


Emily St. John Mandel discusses how scientific ideas (especially simulation hypothesis, time travel, and multiverse/parallel-universe concepts) function in her fiction, focusing on her new novel Exit Party. She explains her process for choosing ideas, how she turns “science-fiction tropes” into metaphors for real life (counter lives, doppelgangers, aging as “migrating” between timelines), and why she doesn’t get bogged down in technical accuracy.
Emily St. John Mandel is a Canadian novelist from a small island on Canada’s west coast; she studied contemporary dance, worked for years in a cancer research lab, and is not formally trained in science.
She uses science concepts because they’re interesting and help solve narrative problems (e.g., making time travel work). Parallel universes map to adulthood and to state-level “counter lives.” She emphasizes transience as a source of hope: bad outcomes don’t last forever.
Station of Leaven (pandemic aftermath), Sea of Tranquility (simulation hypothesis + time-travel detective), Exit Party’s opening with a woman at a party where doppelgangers appear and someone disappears, and comparisons to East Germany/Stasi surveillance and Ted Chiang’s prism story.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Emily St. John Mandel discusses the intersection of science and fiction.
“out there that researchers don't have perfect scientific answers for, but that fiction writers have explored in plays and movies and TV shows, and they come to their own interesting answers in their work.”
Mandel explains why she incorporates scientific concepts into her novels.
“Emily, thank you so much for being here.”
The challenges and creative solutions in writing time travel stories.
“I like reading about these ideas kind of, well, I was going to say on the fringes of science, but my understanding is that physicists are more or less evenly split on the question of whether we're living in a multiverse.”
Mandel explores the concept of doppelgangers and their implications.
“And myself for that, I thought, well, what if I added a whole other layer of science fictional weirdness to try to make that work?”
Discussing how metaphorical implications of parallel universes reflect real lives.
“thinking about counter lives and doubling, and that's what got me to this idea of the multiverse.”
Learn how TikTok can facilitate learning about astronomy.
“First, you might discover a video about the Andromeda galaxy.”
Explore how dystopian themes can intersect with hope and transience.
“I was thinking about it when I was reading your book because you sort of, I don't think it's a spoiler to say, you drop us into a fairly dystopian world.”
Discuss the nuances of decision-making and their impacts on lives.
“I mean, my wife wishes I would write a utopia.”
Understand the challenges of writing about parallel universes and choices.
“You also won't always be in a good situation.”
Learn about the importance of revisions and editor feedback in writing.
“Because something I realized with this book is that I had always thought about the counter life in terms of agency and choice.”
Examine how authors balance scientific accuracy with storytelling.
“But I don't think there were any versions where it was like, oh, and then this outrageous science fictional thing happens.”
Discuss how identity may shift across different parallel universes.
“So that was actually kind of liberating.”
Wrap up discussions on themes covered and acknowledge contributors.
“I mean, you probably don't have a podcast in every version.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Unexplainable, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Support for the show comes from TikTok. If you listen to this show, you probably enjoy discovering new things. It is built into the DNA of the show that curiosity is its own reward and that there's always a deeper dive to do. And one place to explore some of the topics we've covered here is TikTok. Whether it's how to forecast volcanic eruptions, strange phenomena that the James Webb Space Telescope picked up near the beginning of time, or a literal deep dive on the ocean's deepest reefs, TikTok has a wealth of fascinating videos just waiting to be discovered. Your next discovery is waiting on TikTok.
0:41Learn more at tiktok.com slash discover more.
0:49As soon as autumn rolls around and you swap your iced lattes for pumpkin spice, that's your signal to start thinking about the holidays. The decor, the gifts, the shopping lists, but more importantly, the holiday treats. Cheesecakes, cookies, is there anything better? And when the recipe calls for cream cheese, there's only one option. Philadelphia, the original cream cheese, made with fresh milk and real cream. This holiday season, whether you're going all out or keeping it simple, make it really Philly good. Find your favorite holiday recipe at creamcheese.com.
1:57out there that researchers don't have perfect scientific answers for, but that fiction writers have explored in plays and movies and TV shows, and they come to their own interesting answers in their work. I think Emily St. John Mandel is a great example of a writer like this.
2:20Emily St. John Mandel: There was something else that I wanted to write about that I'd been thinking about for a very long time. And that was the sense of awe that I feel at this extraordinary world in which we find ourselves. I loved the way that she explored the aftermath of a pandemic in her book Station of Leaven and the simulation hypothesis in her book Sea of Tranquility. So I was really excited to read her new book, Exit Party, which has at its center the idea of parallel universes. And I'm even more excited to have her today in studio to talk about this really heady question of what if there is another world out there that looks kind of like ours, but is in some meaningful way very different.
3:29Emily St. John Mandel: Emily, thank you so much for being here. It's an absolute pleasure. Thanks for having me on the show. We're a science show. You're often writing about really interesting scientific ideas. And I guess my first question for you would just be, why? Like, why do you put these scientific concepts at the heart of the books that you write? Because they're so interesting. I think that's what it is. Like, all I want is everything. You know, it's like, I want to write novels that are beautifully written and have an interesting plot. And over the years, that's pushed me either toward crime, in the case of my first three novels, or The Glass Hotel, which is a white-collar crime story, or in a more speculative direction, which is where you get, you know, this sort of—that kind of gets me to the outskirts of science, I would say.
4:15Emily St. John Mandel: I don't have an educational background in science. I didn't study it in school. I did work for years in a cancer research lab. So I've definitely hung out with scientists. You have a science background. But do I? It's like, you know, I was great with grant budgets. I could not actually tell you the mechanisms by which microRNA 335 impacts breast cancer metastasis. Neither could I. Well, there you go. Okay. And that's why we talk about books. But yeah, you know what? Science is interesting to me. I like reading about it. I like reading about these ideas kind of, well, I was going to say on the fringes of science, but my understanding is that physicists are more or less evenly split on the question of whether we're living in a multiverse.
5:02Emily St. John Mandel: But yeah, you know, my books kind of, they do move towards science sometimes. So walk me through that kind of process of are you scouring like nature or the journal of science or whatever and saying like, ooh, that's an interesting paper? Or where do you start with this? It's really book by book, and it's never come from reading actual scientific articles. So I would say Sea of Tranquility was the first book I wrote that had, I guess, arguably more of a hard sci-fi component because I do have a time-traveling detective in that book. And what that came out of was it was the spring of 2020. The pandemic hit.
5:42Emily St. John Mandel: I was promoting The Glass Hotel on Zoom. And I thought, for my own sanity, it might be nice to be immersed in the grand project of a book. You know, that can be good for you sometimes when everything is chaos, like in the early days of a pandemic. So I've always loved time travel novels just as a reader and a fan. the problem with the time travel narrative though is that that falls apart instantly like you know okay well if you think about it for a second it's like if i walk out of this podcast studio and i'm transported back to 1812 was i not always going to walk out of the time studio and transported back to 1812 and doesn't reality break upon my arrival well maybe everything that happened in 1812 was supposed to happen.
6:29Maybe. But then you have a loop. And it's like,
6:32Emily St. John Mandel: that raises other questions around, I don't know, like immortality. It's like, am I always going round and round in time? Yeah. And like causation gets really complicated and weird. So, you know, we were all a little deranged in early COVID is my memory. I don't know what your experience was. Oh, no, I was totally normal and having a great time. You're gone and mental health. Well, the rest of us were a little undone. And so I just had this feeling of, F it, I'm going to write about a time-traveling detective. I think before then, I'd been worried about being taken seriously as a literary novelist.
7:05Emily St. John Mandel: But I kind of felt like, you know what, I'm going to write whatever I want. Everything's horrible. Let's do this. So I start writing about my time-traveling detective, and then I run into the time-travel narrative problem, the loops and the paradoxes and all the rest of it. And myself for that, I thought, well, what if I added a whole other layer of science fictional weirdness to try to make that work? Enter the simulation hypothesis. Can we summarize what it is? Yeah, sure, sure. It is the hypothesis that all of our reality is a simulation. And something I love about it is you can find really smart people convincingly arguing either side.
7:44Emily St. John Mandel: Sure. For myself, I actually don't know. But I'd come across it. I thought it was a cool idea. And I realized that I could use that to make time travel work. So that's what got me into, you know, that little branch of science for Sea of Tranquility. And then Exit Party. I had an idea about writing about doppelgangers. There's this idea that I've been thinking about for years. The idea of the counter life. Yeah. So that is the life you did not live. where you moved to a different city or took a different job or married a different person, like any of those inflection points. And I thought, I wonder if doppelgangers could be thought of as a sort of embodiment of a counter life.
8:29Emily St. John Mandel: It's another you who has lived a different life in a different version of reality. So that's what kind of got me to the multiverse idea. It was that, but then also thinking, okay, well, I've thought about the counter life of the individual, what is the counter life of the state? And that can be a really interesting thought experiment. There are some very obvious inflection points in our recent history, but every country has them. You know, the election that went a different way or the decision made to go to war or not, a policy that was enacted or not enacted and the fallout from that. And any of those inflection points create a somewhat different country.
9:09Emily St. John Mandel: So, yeah, so it was thinking about counter lives and doubling, and that's what got me to this idea of the multiverse. I think one of the things I find really interesting about the way that you treat these ideas is you're talking about them as like almost like it's a fix to this problem that I've created. Yeah, yeah. They sort of blossom in your book into these really rich metaphors of, okay, yes, it is literally a doppelganger or whatever, but then there are all these other sort of metaphorical connotations that spring out of that. I wonder how, like, do you just sort of sit there and think, oh, this could look like this or like this or like this?
9:52Or does it just kind of emerge in your writing that, oh, this is kind of also a metaphor for the state. It's also kind of a metaphor for something else.
10:00Emily St. John Mandel: I think it's mostly that it emerges. Although I have to say, like, the doubled state state in this book, that felt like more of a conscious decision. Because, you know, the book opens with a woman going to a party and two doppelgangers show up and somebody else disappears. And I realized pretty early on, wait a minute, at some point I am going to have to account for where the doppelgangers came from. So it's like, in that case, it was definitely a fix. But it was also thinking about the double life of a state, you know, the state that you could live in if things had gone in a different direction at some inflection point.
10:34Was there something in sort of parallel universe stories that you were like, oh, this always happens in a parallel universe story and I'm so frustrated by it?
10:42Emily St. John Mandel: Something that interested me as a thought experiment in writing this book is how might the tropes of science fiction map onto actual lives? So like doppelgangers, that's very science fictional. Sure. But we all have counter lives. So imagine those as the embodiment of the counter life. Or later in the novel, there's a conversation about time travel. And what the character says is something to the effect of, I think if you live long enough, you become a time traveler. It's like you're a migrant from another timeline. Okay. Can I just say, I literally have here, there's even one part where your character says, I think if you live long enough, you become a migrant from another timeline.
11:22Yeah.
11:22Emily St. John Mandel: Isn't that interesting? Because there's nothing more science fictional than a time traveler. That is like a definition of a trope, basically. But that is how adulthood works or how time works. You learn to navigate the world as an adult when you're, I don't know, 18 in my case. That was when I started paying rent. And then after a certain point, you look up one day and you realize the world I learned when I was 18. It's really long since gone. And if you're lucky enough to get to live for a while, you know, if you live into your 80s or potentially even older, the world's really gone that you learned.
12:03Emily St. John Mandel: You know, you are kind of a migrant from another timeline. I think this is what I meant when I was saying, you know, you have these sort of metaphorical implications of a parallel universe in your book. Because, yes, technically, at the heart of this book, there is a parallel universe. We enter into a different one. Right. But then throughout the book on sort of both sides of that divide, your characters just seem to be entering parallel universe after parallel universe. There's like, there's the aging that you mentioned, but there's also, they move countries. They do, yeah. Change their lives in these really dramatic ways where you're like, oh, they're going through just a series of little.
12:43Emily St. John Mandel: They're going through a series of lives. Yeah. Which I hadn't connected that with parallel universes, but that's interesting. I am. What I was thinking about there, I don't think this is even so much a product of getting older. I feel like my 10 year old could do this. But you get to a certain point in your life. You look back and you realize you're not really looking back at a life singular. It's really one life after another, isn't it? And I wanted to express that. You know, you're a different person 10 years ago and living a different life. And just, I wanted to follow a character, Ari in this case, from one life into another.
13:23After the break, more with Emily St. John Mandel.
13:34Support for the show comes from TikTok. Being curious is endlessly rewarding. There are few better feelings, in my opinion, than asking a question and then having that question lead you down a rabbit hole. Might even be the beginning of a new set of interests that was not on your radar beforehand. Maybe you're looking up at the night sky one night and you start to wonder what the most distant thing you can see with the naked eye is. One place to start searching for answers to a question like that is TikTok. First, you might discover a video about the Andromeda galaxy. And then, next thing you know, you're learning how to find different stars, or how to identify constellations, or how different astronomical discoveries got made, or how constellations got their names.
14:24You don't need serious equipment to make serious discoveries. Start with a simple question, and suddenly, you're somewhere you never expected to be. Your next discovery is waiting on TikTok. Learn more at tiktok.com slash discover more. At tiktok.com slash discover more.
14:49Life can be messy and complicated, especially during the holidays. One thing that isn't, switching to the Simplicity Plan from Verizon. It's one plan, one price. Just$30 a line per month for you or the whole family. Make the simple choice this season. Switch to Verizon and shop their best holiday deals today. In the world of expense management, SAP Concur is here to help. From cost control slipping to travel chaos, SAP Concur has an integrated travel and expense solution to help you overcome problems like overburdened teams, decisions looming. When travel, expense, and AP are connected with a single AI-supported solution, SAP Concur keeps you ahead of problems.
15:36Visit concur.com to learn more.
15:43I remember damage, then escape, then drift in a stranger's galaxy for a long time. Are you familiar with the Ted Chiang story where there's like people have a prism and they're able at a moment when they make a decision to, like, have this prism that they can look through to see the version of themselves that made a different decision. That's amazing. I was thinking about it when I was reading your book because you sort of, I don't think it's a spoiler to say, you drop us into a fairly dystopian world.
16:21Emily St. John Mandel: I mean, I collapse the United States in the first sentence. So I believe in Going in hard and fast. Yeah. So you start off in this dystopian world. And I was almost expecting, oh, we're going to enter into another world where we make different choices and everything worked out so wonderfully. Yeah. I mean, my wife wishes I would write a utopia. It's come up a few times. No, it's true. I do then present an equally dark vision. I think the key, though, and where I find hope personally in my life, but also in this book, is intransience. So this idea that nothing lasts forever and everything ends.
17:02Emily St. John Mandel: You know, there's such obvious grief and loss attached to that idea. But I think there's also a lot of hope. Because if I look at it through the lens of my personal life, the worst moments of my life did not last forever. You move through them and there's something else after that. Or if you look at it at a larger scale, the worst moments in your country's life don't last forever either. So, you know, in the second universe of the book, The Authoritarian State, I was thinking in terms of modern day surveillance states like China, for example. But I was also thinking about East Germany and the Stasi system of citizen informants.
17:41Emily St. John Mandel: And, you know, here's where transience and hope intersect. A lot of what I know about them I learned in the DDR Museum in Berlin because the Stasi are gone. We make museums about them. So, yeah, they're both fairly dark visions. But on both sides of the book, we are moving through them towards something else. So do you think there are no correct decisions that you can make necessarily? Right. Also, making the wrong decisions does not mean that you will always be in a terrible situation. You won't always be in a terrible situation. You also won't always be in a good situation. That's where the loss comes in.
18:24Emily St. John Mandel: Yeah, and you can second guess all your decisions. But as you were telling me about that short story with the prism, I found myself thinking, okay, but like the decision to go across the street and buy a coffee, like is that the moment when you're hit by the car? And like there's literally every decision has crazy knock-on effects. And so that sort of takes us back into this idea of how do you write a parallel universe book? Did you want it to be sort of it's a cup of coffee and it creates huge effects? Did you want it to be sort of active decision making? How did you sort of go about trying to think through what the fractal parallel universes would look like?
19:06Emily St. John Mandel: You know, I never landed on the inflection points, either for characters or for the state. Because something I realized with this book is that I had always thought about the counter life in terms of agency and choice. You know, you chose to cross the street and get a cup of coffee. You know, or on a larger scale, you chose to marry that person. You chose to take that job. But what about the stuff that just happens to you? Or, you know, just growing up in a different culture makes you a different person. I was thinking about that with the character Ari, where she's someone who, well, she's got this kind of character defect.
19:44Emily St. John Mandel: She's pulled toward criminality. It's like this deep fundamental proclivity that she has. And there's a world where somebody like that just goes toward criminality and becomes a criminal, as she did in a previous part of her life. But what if that same person were growing up in a much more repressive state where the consequences were much worse for breaking the rules? Maybe that interest in criminality pulls a person toward law enforcement. And it was interesting to think of that as almost two sides of the same coin. It sounds almost like we're really interested in the concept of parallel universes, but even more so in doppelgangers.
20:24Yeah. Did you have versions of your drafts where you're writing this and you were like, oh, God, nope, never mind. This has gone terribly awry. That's a really good question.
20:37Emily St. John Mandel: I mean, I ended up rewriting the entire second half of the book. Really? Yeah, after my editors saw it. Editors are really good at spotting problems. I feel like that's at the core of their job. They can read a book and they can tell you that something's wrong. Or they can do it in a very specific way, which not everybody can. It's a real skill. So, yeah, so my editors, after they read the first draft, by first draft, I probably mean like 40th draft. I mean, you know, I do so many rounds of revision and then early readers and my agent reads it. But the first editorial draft, they identified a need for more propulsion and reveals in the second half of the book.
21:19Emily St. John Mandel: So I ended up rewriting the entire second half. So, like, there are definitely kind of dud versions of sections of the book like that. I don't write from an outline. So, you know, those moments do happen. But I don't think there were any versions where it was like, oh, and then this outrageous science fictional thing happens. It was more like versions that needed to be improved. When you're sort of borrowing these scientific concepts, do you feel trapped by the science of it all? Do you feel like you have to stay within certain boundaries? I don't. Which will definitely annoy some readers of sci-fi.
21:59Emily St. John Mandel: But I think there's a really interesting choice that you have to make if you're writing speculative fiction. And that's how far, like how accurate do you want to be or how deep into the weeds do you want to go with your science fictional technology? Like on one end of the spectrum, you've got a guy like Tseshin Liu, the three-body problem. And I really love his work. He gets so granular about those technologies. And, you know, as a layperson, I don't have a, you know, a science degree. But when I first started working on Sea of Tranquility, I guess it was a bit of insecurity on my part. I thought, I want to figure out how the time machine works.
22:38Emily St. John Mandel: So I spent some time reading about current ideas and technologies that I could kind of imagine eventually evolving into time traveling. I was reading about the quantum blockchain. And then after I'd spent a bit of time in that rabbit hole, I realized I don't actually care. Because I had this realization. I was like, wait, this book moves from 1912 into, I don't know, the 2400s, the far future. And if I'm not describing how a car engine works in the 2020 section, why do I care about the mechanics of the time machine? It is literally just transport. And that was kind of liberating, just realizing, you know, I think I care more about the characters.
23:28Emily St. John Mandel: I want to focus on how people respond in these interesting scenarios and putting them in. So that was actually kind of liberating. So honestly, at this point, and like half of your listeners are going to hit stop, the level of scientific detail I'm aiming for is plausible within the context of a literary novel, which is like, that's a low bar. So yeah, I'm just much more interested in the people. But I guess I ask the question in part because for this, for this parallel universe stuff, did you look into some of the physics debates about this? Did you dive into this? A little bit. I read about it a little bit.
24:07Emily St. John Mandel: It's one of those interesting ideas like the simulation hypothesis where you can find smart people on either side. So I feel very unqualified to participate in the debates. Sure. But as a novelist, this is interesting. I can work with this. Well, I do wonder also sometimes if science does kind of, you are forced to say, and this is rooted in fact. And this is rooted in something I can prove and whatever. And I think sometimes the space of science fiction or literary fiction with a scientific tingle. Yeah, yeah. It gives you space to play and think in ways that in a scientific paper you are not necessarily.
24:52Emily St. John Mandel: There's not a ton of space for play in a nature paper. Yeah, you're right. You're right. I think it's an interesting arena to just explore ideas. Who do you think you would be in a parallel universe that looks different from the one we're in now? There's so many of them. I don't know. I have this feeling sometimes like the life that I'm living is somewhat implausible. where, you know, I'm from a tiny island on the west coast of Canada. I actually don't have a high school diploma. It's kind of a long, dumb story. Hippie parents and homeschooling. I studied contemporary dance, and nothing in that CV suggests novelist in New York City.
25:31Emily St. John Mandel: Sure. So it's really easy for me to imagine a parallel world or parallel life where I'm a very different person living a different life in a different country. Do you think that that person enjoys their life as much as? I don't know. It's a really good question. I mean, that person, well, because this question comes down to essentialism, doesn't it? Like how much of you remains you in a different life? If I weren't a writer, I would be a reader. So, you know, I think that person and that hypothetical other life reads a lot and loves stories. But, yeah, I don't know if I'm a writer in every version.
26:17Yeah, what parts of you are essentially you and what parts of you change?
26:23Emily St. John Mandel: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you probably don't have a podcast in every version. But maybe you're interested in science in all of them. I think I'm interested in science in all of them. I would hope that in every universe I get to do this job. It's a great gig. It's a very fun job. Emily St. John Mandel's book is Exit Party. Emily, thank you so much for coming in to talk to me about it. This was so fun. I really enjoyed it.
26:56This episode was produced by Valerie Schenkman and by me, Bird Pinkerton. It was edited by Joanna Solotaroff, our editorial director. The video edit was done by Jacob Reynolds with animation from Kareem Correa. Sam Mutin and Tom Kasparin were our studio engineers. Christian Ayala did the mixing and the sound design for the podcast. Melissa Hirsch checked the facts. Kim Slaughterback did the video copy edit. Noam Hasenfeld does our music. Meredith Hodnot runs the show. And as always, thanks to Brian Resnick for co-creating the show with me and Noam. If you would like to watch this episode as a video, you can check out Unexplainable on Netflix.
27:39If you have thoughts on science fiction, on Exit Party, on topics you'd like us to explore, email us. We are at unexplainable at Vox.com. If you would like to support this show and the journalism that Vox does, we would love it if you would become a member. it's very easy to do just go to vox.com slash members and you will get access to all of Vox's journalism but you'll also know that you are supporting all of Vox's journalism and for those of you who have emailed us to let us know that you signed up because of Unexplainable thank you thank you also to those of you who left us a nice review on your podcast platform of choice or those of you who just told someone in your life about the show you are all the best Unexplainable is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network, and we will be back very soon with another episode about everything that we do not yet know.
28:40All new holiday drinks are now at McDonald's. Like the Frosted Cranberry Splash with Sprite, the Red Bull Frosted Cranberry Energizer, and cookie butter coffees. Tis the season for seasonal drinks at McDonald's.
29:21One plus year versus non-member or club member pricing slash fees. Excludes membership fees. See Walmart Plus terms and Sam's Club terms for more info.
Science has some really weird, wonderful ideas. Some of them are hard to prove in fact, but Emily St. John Mandel does a great job of playing with them in fiction — in works like Station Eleven, Sea of Tranquility, and her newest novel, Exit Party.
Guest: Emily St. John Mandel, author
Watch us on Netflix!
For show transcripts, go to vox.com/unxtranscripts
For more, go to vox.com/unexplainable
And please email us! [email protected]
We read every email.
Support Unexplainable (and get ad-free episodes) by becoming a Vox Member today: vox.com/members
Thank you!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices