In short
Podcast Summary: Up First - The Families Hiding from ICE
Episode Overview The episode titled "The Families Hiding from ICE" sheds light on the emotional and psychological challenges faced by undocumented families in the U.S. due to the heightened immigration enforcement under the Trump administration. Through the lens of the experiences of families, particularly focusing on one mother's journey, the episode articulates the fear and anxiety surrounding potential separation and deportation.
Key Themes and Discussions
Impact of Immigration Policies
- Increased Fear: The episode discusses how the Trump administration's immigration policies have instilled fear among undocumented immigrants, leading many to self-deport or go into hiding.
- Family Dynamics: The fear of deportation impacts familial relationships, leading to anxiety and conflict, particularly in households with mixed immigration status.
Personal Stories and Experiences
- Maryland Family: The narrative revolves around a Maryland mother, referred to as Em, from Guatemala, and her husband, who are both undocumented. They grapple with the decision of self-deportation, highlighting the tension between wanting to keep their children safe and the reality of their undocumented status.
- Em's children, born in the U.S., experience anxiety and panic due to the threat of family separation.
- The family's summer was described as the "summer of nothing," spent largely indoors in fear of ICE raids.
Emergency Guardianship
- Preparing for the Unexpected: The episode delves into the concept of emergency guardianship, where undocumented parents prepare for the possibility of being detained by ICE by designating trusted friends or neighbors as guardians for their children.
- This process offers a semblance of security, providing families with a plan in an unpredictable situation.
- Legal experts stress the importance of having formal agreements rather than informal arrangements to protect the children’s welfare.
Community Support
- Network of Care: The episode underscores how communities come together to support undocumented families.
- Parents express relief in knowing that their children will be cared for by friends in case of deportation.
- The concept of community solidarity is highlighted, emphasizing the emotional relief provided by having a plan in place.
Legal Perspective
- Immigration Rights: The discussion includes insights from legal experts about the rights of undocumented families and the rules regarding ICE operations in schools and community spaces.
Key Takeaways
- Psychological Toll: The fear of detention and deportation takes a significant psychological toll on the children and families involved, leading to anxiety and mental health challenges.
- Legal Preparedness: Emergency guardianship arrangements are becoming increasingly common among undocumented families, reflecting an adaptive response to the fear of sudden family separation.
- Community Resilience: Despite the oppressive climate, there is a profound sense of community resilience and solidarity among families facing these challenges.
Conclusion This episode of NPR's Up First poignantly captures the complexities of life for undocumented families in the U.S., illustrating their struggles, fears, and the strategies they employ to cope with the uncertainty brought about by strict immigration policies. Through Em's story and the broader discussion of emergency guardianship, the episode reveals the human side of immigration enforcement and the importance of community support in navigating these challenges.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00I'm Aisha Roscoe and this is a Sunday Story where we go beyond the headlines of the day to bring you one big story. The Trump administration's immigration policies have upended daily life for undocumented immigrants across the country. Some have self-deported. Others have gone into hiding, afraid to leave their homes. Many are still torn about what makes sense for their families in the face of an uncertain future. Over the past year, NPR's immigration correspondent Jasmine Garst has been following the ups and downs of some of the people navigating this moment. She sat down with host B.A. Parker on the Code Switch podcast to talk about her reporting, and we wanted to share some of it with you.
0:48We start with Jasmine's story of a Maryland mom who's taking unusual steps to keep her kids safe. My mom told me it's going to be okay. I worry that something will happen to her, like something will get her. We'll be right back.
1:30This message comes from Charles Schwab. When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices, like full-service wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on Think or Swim. Visit schwab.com to learn more. This message comes from Comcast. Comcast operates the nation's largest converged network, reaching 64 million homes and businesses. With$80 billion invested to expand broadband infrastructure in the U.S., Comcast is actively supporting the goal of bringing broadband to everyone. Learn more about how Comcast is bringing high-speed internet to communities across the country at comcastcorporation.com.
2:11This message comes from Progressive Insurance and the Name Your Price tool. It helps you find car insurance options in your budget. Try it today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states. We're back with a Sunday story and an episode about the difficult choices facing undocumented migrants and their families. Here's NPR's immigration reporter Jasmine Garst. The kids say this summer was the summer of nothing, but it was boring as hell. Nothing happened, nothing at all. We didn't go anywhere.
2:49One mother in Maryland told me she quietly lost her mind this summer.
3:00We spent it locked down, she says. We didn't go out. The weather was bad the day I drove down there to the southern part of the state where rivers and creeks crisscrossed the land. It was late August, hurricane season. And Tropical Storm Aaron had led to coastal flooding warnings up and down the mid-Atlantic. I kept kind of eyeing the water nervously every time I crossed a bridge. I was going to check in with a family I wrote about earlier this year for a story about self-deportation. Now, self-deportation is one of the centerpieces of the Trump administration's immigration policy. The message from the government has been, take your kids with you.
3:42They can always come back as adults. But back when we first met last winter, this mother in Maryland told me very firmly she would under no circumstances self-deport with her children. My children were born here, she says. They are American citizens. This mother asked that I refer to her as M. M and her husband live in a pretty rural area of Maryland, and they are both from Guatemala. They're also both undocumented. Em's husband desperately wants to self-deport. He is really out there in the world every day working as a landscaper, and he's quite worried about being detained and taken to a detention center.
4:29And he says she just doesn't understand that it's not the same for her. She works from home making piñatas and party favors for quinceañeras, weddings, birthdays. The couple fights about this constantly. The kids see it and it gives them bad anxiety. Back in the winter, when we first met, her youngest daughter, her seven-year-old, first initial L, had a cold. She kept having to be sent home from school. The real reason was because she was having panic attacks. I feel frustrated sometimes. I was just feeling sad. My mom told me it's going to be okay. I worry too something will happen to her, like something will get her.
5:23After we met that one time, Em and I stayed in touch. She would send me WhatsApp messages almost every day, you know, pictures of her pinatas and stuff your tia sends you on WhatsApp, you know, a daily blessing, softly lit images of flowers or kittens or kittens inside flowers with some motivational quote. And I'd ask about the kids. How is everyone doing? Has the family made any decisions? And then, around the beginning of summer, radio silence. After a few weeks of not hearing anything from Em, I reached out. I could tell my messages hadn't even gone through. I started to wonder if maybe Em or her husband got arrested, deported, or maybe they finally agreed to leave to self-deport.
6:14It was strange that I hadn't heard from her, but this has sort of become a constant in my life as an immigration reporter. For the last few months, on a regular basis, I will have an extraordinarily intimate conversation with a complete stranger. Or someone will find my phone number and call me from inside a detention center, and they will tell me their worst fear, their desperation. They will ask me what I know as if I know. And then that person will just vanish. It's like my WhatsApp is filled with ghosts. So yeah, over the summer, when I stopped hearing from them, I decided to go check in on this family.
6:59As I drove to Southern Maryland in the storm, I was really unsure of what I was going to find. But as I approached the driveway, Someone drew the curtain and these four faces like pressed up against the window. And it was Em and the kids. And they immediately bolted out, smiling and running to say hello. Even though she was wearing not platform shoes. She was wearing wedges, which was kind of hilarious. Because people running and jogging in heels is very funny to me. Just happy to see you. Yeah. She looked the same, even though she's lost a lot of weight. She says her stomach hurts a lot. Son los nervios.
7:47She's still got these very reddy cheeks, and she laughs at everything. She has an infectious, raspy laughter. She's always dressed really cute. You know, she reminds me of a little, like, Fran Drescher. Sometimes it throws me off. Like, she'll be talking about how she had to hide in her house all summer, and it really affected her psychologically. And then...
8:18Once we were inside the house, Em apologized for going silent. She explained that her phone broke earlier this summer, and she just couldn't afford to buy a new one. The party planning business, it's not going very well. She says people, Latino immigrants in particular, aren't doing a lot of celebrating lately. Em's husband still wants to go back to Guatemala. Earlier this summer, he was at work at a landscaping job when ICE agents showed up. He went to his car to lay low, and he sent Em a message on Facebook. They're here. Em's seven-year-old, Elle, explains. One day, when they were working, ice came there.
9:08How did you know about that? Because our dad sent us a message. And how did that make you feel? Sad. And so she didn't eat at all that day.
9:29My bones hurt from the anxiety. We locked ourselves in. I was scared. And that event sent the family into a sort of lockdown for the entire summer. Hence, the summer of nothing. The family was stuck indoors in their small trailer home for three whole summer months. With four children, ages 1 to 12. As Em and I talk, her youngest boy has climbed on top of the laundry machine and is throwing out about a hundred, give or take, plastic Easter eggs onto the floor.
10:10The baby she's rocking is, unbeknownst to her, pointing a very large bottle of glue at me, like directly at my face. and then her seven-year-old walks in holding an upside-down cat. Oh my god, the cat.
10:31She held a strand of her hair and in true M style made a joke. I didn't have these white hairs last time we met, did I? It's not all jokes. The eldest kid, Kay, says this summer was actually incredibly boring. Nothing happened. Nothing at all. Boring, because we didn't go anywhere. Kay is 12, and you can really, like, hear her adolescence simmering. This summer, she was selected to go to a STEM summer camp for kids who are interested in science. Her parents pulled her out. They told her the family had to hunker down. All summer activities were canceled.
11:25My husband had to explain to them, Em says, you are U.S. citizens, but we are not. If we take you to the aquarium, to the pool, we could get detained. We could get deported. Without looking at her mom, Kay says, she's excited about school starting again. But I was filled with questions like, what if immigration agents come for me while my kids are in school or as I'm picking them up? And can immigration agents go into the school? Can they ask my kids about our legal status? I heard concerns like this from a lot of parents. Oh, can they? I actually reached out to Ilora Mukherjee to ask about this.
12:14She's a professor of law at Columbia Law School and also the director of the Immigration Rights Clinic at the school. And what did Mukherjee say? There are no confirmed reports of ICE raids or ICE enforcements inside of schools. Mukherjee says she understands the fear, though, because almost as soon as President Trump took office in January, these previously designated locations like schools and churches and hospitals were deemed no longer off limits for immigration enforcement. But she clarifies that agents, and this is really important, agents need a warrant to go into a school. Parents and children cannot be asked about their immigration status by the school.
13:00However, just a few weeks ago in Chicago, A teacher, you might have seen this, Parker, was chased by armed immigration officers into the preschool she works at. DHS said they weren't targeting the school itself, but you can see how the lines for many parents and students feel blurry. So back to Em. Her kids started school in the fall, like kids all over the country. And then a few days later, I got this audio message from her. She had a phone again.
13:42She's standing about a block away from the school bus stop. The sheriff's department is there. She has to pick the kids up, but she's scared.
13:55About an hour later, they get another out-of-breath message. They made it home.
14:07I froze, she says. She grabbed the kids and they ran back home. It's okay now, she repeats. It's okay. Nothing happened. And then she laughs and says, I got as cold as a cucumber, though. I got as cold as a cucumber, though.
14:27That first week of school, Emsa, she did what a lot of parents across America did.
14:35She caught up on her sleep. And then she did something a lot of parents never consider doing. She reached out to a friend who is an American citizen and started the paperwork to give emergency guardianship in case she or her husband get picked up by ICE.
14:57When we come back, host B.A. Parker talks to Jasmine about the process of emergency guardianship and what it means for families either giving up or taking over the responsibilities of parenting.
15:13This message comes from Superhuman, the AI productivity suite that gives you superpowers everywhere you work. With Grammarly, Mail, and Coda coming together, you get proactive help across your workflow so you can outsmart the chaos. Experience AI that proactively helps you go from to-do to done faster. Unleash your superhuman potential today. Learn more at superhuman.com slash podcast. That's superhuman.com slash podcast. This message comes from Fisher Investments. Senior Vice President Michael Hosmar reflects on one of their core values. We want to empower our clients with knowledge. In fact, Fisher is built on that idea.
15:56It comes straight from our founder, Ken Fisher, who believes the more our clients understand about the plan we've built for them, the more comfortable they will be with their personal financial situation. Learn more at fisherinvestments.com. Investing in securities involves the risk of loss. This message comes from Amnesty International. When the world is breaking apart, but you refuse to look away, Amnesty International is the place to start. Donate today to defend human rights, and your gift will be matched at amnestyusa.org slash podcast. We're back with a Sunday story and a conversation between Code Switch host B.A.
16:35Parker and NPR's Jasmine Garst about emergency guardianship. Okay, Jasmine, can you talk to us about what emergency guardianship looks like? I mean, to me, it seems like an impossible place to be in. Like you're caught between wanting to be with your kids and wanting what's best for your kids, but also knowing that you might have to leave them behind if you're targeted by immigration enforcement, you know? Yeah, it's a rock and a hard place for many, many families. You know, the parents I spoke to who did this process of giving someone else emergency guardianship power told me it did make them feel some sort of security, like a sense of control in a world that they feel has gone out of control.
17:28And it also, they also told me it felt like, okay, like some of my neighbors really are watching out for me. The way one parent said it to me was, I'm not happy, but I'm relieved. Does that make sense? Yeah. It's not great, but it, you know, that's one less thing to worry about if there is something to worry about. Yeah. And a lot of parents describe that sense of like, my community does care about me or my friend, my neighbor cares about me. So at the end of the summer, I was working on a totally separate story. in Washington, D.C., and I met a woman who confided in me that she had gotten that call, that she had signed on to be an emergency guardian.
18:19I went to her home, this very lovely house in an upper-middle-class D.C. neighborhood. She says the phone rang one day, and it was her son's best friend's father. She tells me this story. She offers me some freshly baked cookies, some milk. Would you like oat milk or milk milk? Milk milk. Okay. This is like an American-American woman. Okay. Yes, it was very like a different world. She was extremely sweet and hospitable. She asked if we not use her name. I mean, she is American. She's an American citizen, but she wants to protect the man who called her that day, her son's best friend's father. He's Honduran.
19:07So is his wife. They're undocumented. They've been in the U.S. for some 25 years. And they spent the last month or so hiding in their homes. We're not even going to work right now, he says. There's been a heavy ICE presence in D.C. for the last month or so. You might have seen some of the videos, arrests throughout the city, delivery workers being arrested. And the Honduran father says there are literally checkpoints on both sides of his street. Our neighborhood is surrounded, he says. And, you know, you might get past a checkpoint once, but twice. So the only person who goes in and out of that house is their 17-year-old son.
19:56who's their only child. He was born in the U.S. He's a citizen. He goes to high school every morning. His parents stay behind, just hunkering down. And they recently sat down with him and asked, if we get deported, what do you want to do?
20:16Well, and he responded, I don't know Honduras. I've never been. And then he mentions his best friend, the one who the family has known since the boys were in pre-K together. We need to ask them for help, he said. So they called the American mom, the one I'm sitting with having cookies and milk. And when the families met, the Honduran dad laid it out super clearly. We could get detained any minute now. And if we do, I want to ask you if you would be the temporary guardian of our son.
21:00Don't feel pressured, he told them. We understand this is an enormous request. We are putting our son's life in your hands. He is 17. He needs to finish high school. We want him to go to college. He will need guidance. You know, my husband and I just looked at each other and we were like, yes, of course. Right? Like, not even, not a question, not a moment's hesitation. It's not something we entered into lightly. We love them. I find myself seeing people on the street laughing and having fun and asking myself, like, how is that even possible? Just as an American, I am deeply sad and sorry that this is a conversation that we even need to have.
21:49And yet, I really do hold out hope for the possibility that in the long run, it does serve to bring people closer together if we let it. But is this happening more and more? How common is this kind of arrangement? I am hearing a lot about this. I mean, it's not clear how many families have arranged this because it's not people aren't going public with it. Yeah, fair. But I've been hearing a lot about it and I've been hearing a lot about it from families. I've been hearing a lot about it from lawyers. Lawyers I spoke to say they've seen an increase in recent months. I spoke to Ginger Miranda. She's president of the Central Florida Hispanic Bar Association.
22:36What we're advising is, you know, to be prepared. And lately, what they've been doing is they've been holding a lot of emergency guardianship and power of attorney classes across the state. And what they recommend is that people do not make verbal or informal kind of handshake agreements. Make concrete plans through a lawyer, they say. Like having it all legally sorted out. Yeah, she described it almost like a will. Like this is something you don't want to think could happen, but it could. So have the paperwork drawn out. Don't go and tell your cousin, hey, take the kids. It's a smart precaution.
23:15Yeah. There's a reality, which attorney Ginger Miranda says, which is if you do not prepare, the consequences can be really serious. Remember, if a parent is detained, those children are left vulnerable. Sometimes they're left at school. No one's there to pick them up. And without the proper legal documents in place, you know, the children could end up in foster care. Which is exactly the scenario this Honduran family is afraid of. Their son ending up in foster care. So they all went and signed the paperwork to give the U.S. citizen family emergency guardianship.
23:56The American mom says she has told nobody. She does not want to put the Honduran parents at risk. My mom does not know. My husband's mother does not know. Instead, they try to keep the mood in the house light. We try to keep it a little lighter around the dinner table and watch amusing and really sweet television like The Great British Baking Show.
24:29Did you get to speak to the Honduran mother? I wanted to. I really wanted to, and she just couldn't. Her husband apologized for her. He explained very graciously that she didn't want to be rude. It just, this broke her.
Read the full transcript
24:55She has chest pains, headaches. She isn't doing well. And me, the father says, I always knew this time would come. And I asked what he meant. And he said, this country is for no one. It's for Americans, the white ones. He says he's grateful beyond words to the American family for their help. If it comes to it, his son will be safe. And yet...
25:35Do you really think this is what we wanted, he says? To abandon our child in another country? Do you think this was the plan? Who would want this, he says? Nobody.
25:55That was NPR correspondent Jasmine Garst and Code Switch co-host B.A. Parker. You can hear more of Jasmine's reporting on immigrant families on NPR's Code Switch podcast. This episode of Code Switch was produced by Javier Lopez. It was edited by Leah Dinella. The engineer was Kwesi Lee. And a special thanks to Courtney Stein. Jenny Schmidt, Thomas Coltrane, and Andrew Mambo worked on this episode of The Sunday Story. Our team also includes Justine Yan and Liana Simstrom. Irene Noguchi is our executive producer. I'm Aisha Roscoe, and Up First will be back tomorrow with all the news you need to start your week.
26:39Until then, have a great rest of your weekend.
26:51This message comes from GiveWell. When you give to a nonprofit, how do you measure success? What is the real impact on people's lives? GiveWell researches the highest impact opportunities around the world. Over 150 ,000 donors have confidently used GiveWell's research, collectively saving an estimated 300 ,000 lives. Make a tax-deductible donation at givewell.org. First-time donors can have their donation matched up to$100 as long as matching funds last. Select podcast and NPR at checkout. This message comes from PACA. Everyone's got that one hoodie they practically live in. But the PACA hoodie?
27:29It's on another level. Softer than cashmere, warmer than wool, and still breathable, this alpaca fiber hoodie goes from airport to mountain trail to couch without missing a beat. Right now, grab a pack of hoodie and score a free pair of Alpaca Cruise socks. Moisture-wicking, odor-resistant, and guaranteed for life. Level up your hoodie game at go.pakaapparel.com slash NPR. Code NPR.
From the publisher
Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices
NPR Privacy Policy

