

Wake Up To Money (BBC 5 Live) covers: Labour’s win in the Holborn and St Pancras by-election; Tesco forecasting a less “boozy” Christmas due to health trends and weight-loss drugs; Conservative economic pledges (inheritance tax on family homes; employer NI cut for 21–24s); BT’s rescue purchase of TalkTalk and the CMA investigation; potential UK tariffs on Chinese EVs and the “Made in Europe” trade-off; OpenAI’s revenue shortfall and wider AI stock concerns; AI’s impact on UK independent music; and possible UK tax rises on bingo gaming machines.
Jack Fenwick (political commentator/journalist). Charlie Blakemore (CEO, Intercity Technology; cybersecurity, comms, managed IT). Leah Ramwell (Head of Tailored Investment Solutions, Canaccord Wealth). Shelley Horne (economist, S&W). G. Davey (CEO, Association of Independent Music). Dominic Mansour (CEO, Buzz Bingo). Nicole Garrett (CEO, Bingo Association).
Labour win was “comfortable” but Greens’ vote share fell; housing and “Zionism is racism” controversy hurt Greens. Low/no alcohol growth tied to health/GLP-1 drugs. BT-TalkTalk deal justified as preventing service loss; CMA to assess competition. EV tariffs could reach 45% but risk EU/China relations; AI revenue downgrade ($70B to ~$50B annualised) hits tech sentiment. Music groups fear “AI slop” overwhelming Spotify playlists; summit aims shared rights principles. Bingo leaders warn a tax rise (speculated 20% to 40%) could make one-third of clubs loss-making; machines likened to “popcorn,” up to half of Buzz Bingo revenue.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
An in-depth discussion on the implications of Labour's by-election win.
“Welcome to Wake Up To Money on Friday the 9th of October.”
Discussion on changing consumer behaviors and trends for the upcoming Christmas season.
“That was a weird way I said that, wasn't it?”
Overview of key policies and speeches from the recent Conservative conference.
“Are you stocking up on the Noseco and the zero alcohol lager?”
Discussing the importance of youth employment in stimulating economic growth.
“Do you think that would get you potentially hiring more younger people?”
Analyzing the contrasting views of Conservative and Labour parties on economic growth.
“But Labour said, well, the Tories failed, completely failed at every turn, was their phrase, to grow the economy during their 14 years in power.”
Exploring BT's acquisition of TalkTalk and its implications for the broadband market.
“OK, let's talk about one of the other big stories this week.”
Examining the balance between market consolidation and its effects on consumers.
“I think that we were expecting to see consolidation in the broadband market for quite a while.”
Discussing the government's involvement in facilitating telecom mergers for public interest.
“Shalyan, the Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy, says that they could make changes to the Enterprise Act if it helps get the deal past regulators.”
Analyzing the growth of Chinese electric vehicles in the UK market and its implications.
“Sales doubled to almost 200 ,000 last year.”
Exploring the implications of potential tariffs on Chinese cars and UK-China relations.
“Shelley, it's a very difficult line to walk, isn't it?”
Discussion on the complexities of UK trade relationships with China and the EU amidst changing tariffs.
“who are currently, though, levying tariffs on this type of car.”
Hosts introduce new guests and acknowledge previous guest's contributions.
Listeners share personal stories about changing alcohol habits during holidays.
“or your move towards low alcohol Beth says, as an 80s child, I've experienced the heavy nights out drinking in my 20s, followed by wine o 'clock in my 30s.”
Discussion on OpenAI's revised revenue projections and impacts on tech stocks.
“Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made.”
Exploration of the dual effects of AI on the music industry, including challenges and opportunities.
“Now let's talk about a story that's making the front page of the FT this morning.”
Insights from independent music representatives on AI's effects and potential benefits.
“You represent the UK's independent music industry.”
Learn about the different types of AI and their potential benefits for the music sector.
“Because this is not, you know, people aren't getting together at this summit to just say, right, it all needs to stop, put the brakes on, scrap AI, are they?”
Discover how bingo halls are adapting to economic pressures and changing demographics.
“joining me in the studio ahead of that summit in Manchester.”
Understand the financial implications of tax changes on bingo operators and their revenue models.
“But most bingo halls offer visitors the chance to play traditional bingo.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Wake Up to Money, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:29Syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes. Visit your online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell or attain any specific investment or service.
1:07Wake Up To Money from BBC5 Live.
1:10Felicity Hannah: Hello, welcome to Wake Up To Money. Labour has won the Holborn and St Pancras by-election. We will get the very latest. Then there's a big AI number to discuss. But this time it's not growth, it's not investment. OpenAI may be$20 billion less profitable than investors thought. We will hear why that's hitting other tech stocks. And speaking of tech stocks, creatives from around the country are gathered in Manchester for an AI summit this week. It's definitely a scary place to be as a young songwriter and just musician in general, to be seeing how the landscape is shifting around it. We will hear what they want to change to protect their work and...
1:47Yellow 31, red 20.
1:50Felicity Hannah: We will hear from the boss of one of the UK's biggest bingo chains on why tax changes could hit their business. Wake Up To Money with Felicity Hanna. Very good morning. Welcome to Wake Up To Money on Friday the 9th of October. It's four minutes past five. Let's get straight into the breaking news that Labour has won that by-election. Camden Council leader Sigal Abdiwali received 12 ,292 votes. Green leader Zach Polanski came in second with 8 ,928. That, of course, is the seat that became vacant after the former Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, announced he was standing down to focus on a role in international affairs.
2:32Felicity Hannah: Let's speak to Jack Fenwick, no doubt one of the people who's been staying up all night, Jack. Indeed, I have been staying up all night. We've been at the count for several hours. We're not at the count anymore because it closes up shop quite quickly after the declaration happens. But yeah, there's been many hours of talking on the telly and radio for me over the evening and the morning. Well, we're grateful that you're joining us on Wake Up To Money. So talk us through the result then. Is this a resounding win for Labour? I wouldn't say it's a resounding win for Labour. It was comfortable, but their share of the vote did go down compared to the votes at the general election in this constituency two years ago.
3:13Remember, Andy Burnham himself returned to Westminster with a by-election victory in Makerfield. And that was very much seen as evidence that he was able to beat reform in Makerfield to Labour's right. The test here was always going to be whether his Labour Party was able to beat the Green Party to their left. They have shown that they can do that this evening. But there are still doubts about whether the party is as popular as it was two years ago when it got that stonking victory at the general election. I think in truth, it was always going to be a bit of a tall order for the Greens to win this particular seat.
3:48It has been a safe Labour seat for decades. We know that the Greens had a big bounce in the polls when Zach Polanski first became leader just over a year ago. But that has dipped in recent months. And that's a trend that's continued since Andy Burnham became prime minister. It felt right from when voting closed, like those around Zach Polanski were not sounding confident. and at about half past two this morning, they did give us that concession saying that they were going to lose this election. Now they're saying it's still evidence that they are catching Labour up, but certainly they'll be disappointed with this result.
4:25Felicity Hannah: I mean, Zach Polanski was very keen to point out that they've considerably increased their vote share. I suppose when you come second, you always have to try and make the numbers sound as good as possible. Yeah, and they have considerably increased their vote share. Yeah, that is undoubted, although that is slightly nuanced, because when the Greens fought this constituency in the general election two years ago, they came third, and there was another candidate who had quite similar views to the Green Party and was an independent who came second, and he agreed to not stand in this by-election in order to give the Greens a better chance of winning.
5:03So there are some interesting numbers when you're trying to compare that result two years ago with this one here. I mean, the Greens try to turn this into an election really about the issue of housing, particularly trying to pick out a point of difference between them and Labour, talking a lot about rent controls, for example. In the last few days of the campaign, it was dominated by that motion passed by Green Party members saying that Zionism is racism. That proved incredibly controversial within the party. I'm told that the issue of anti-Semitism was coming up on the doorstep over the last couple of days.
5:36that Zach Polanski has spoken to the media for the first time since the Green Party conference ended this morning. He's not quite come down one way or the other on whether he actually agrees with that motion or not. I'm sure he will be hoping that takes some of the fire out of it. The danger for him is that by not coming down on one side or the other, he might annoy both bits of his party. He says he's insistent he's going to stay on as leader, but I think there are still difficult questions to come for him.
6:02Felicity Hannah: And Sigal Abdiwali, who has won the seat for Labour, a former Camden council leader, so someone who's already well known on the Labour side. Yeah, she's been leading the council for the last few months and has been a councillor for longer than that. She is somebody who is a former refugee, came to the UK as a child and very much was using her backstory as part of her campaign, saying that she is evidence of what somebody in modern day Britain can achieve. Now, she gave us a bit of policy when she had her speech after her victory was announced. She said that she would be pushing Andy Burnham on issues such as rough sleeping, on issues such as public ownership of water companies.
6:43They were the two things that she spoke a lot about both during the campaign and this evening as well. I mean, it didn't sound like she's going to be somebody who's going to try and cause problems for Andy Burnham. I think she was largely singing from the same hymn sheet as him throughout this campaign. And I think this by-election will be seen in the context of the so-called Burnham bounce, this idea that Labour have gone up in the polls a bit since he became the Prime Minister.
7:08Felicity Hannah: Jack, I don't know if we're letting you go on to do more telly and radio, have a coffee or go to bed, but we'll let you crack on with whatever it is. Thank you so much for joining us. Thank you. Thank you. Jack Fenwick there, bringing us up to speed on the news that Labour has won the Holborn and St Pancras by election. By election? That was a weird way I said that, wasn't it? Right, let's get on with wake up to money. I don't want to drop the Christmas word too early, but I have and I am. The Tesco chief executive yesterday told journalists and investors that Brits are on track for a marginally less boozy Christmas.
7:40Felicity Hannah: He said weight loss drugs and people wanting healthier lifestyles means there'll be strong growth in low and no alcohol drinks this year. So I want to hear from you on everything, as always, but particularly on that. Are you stocking up on the Noseco and the zero alcohol lager? Are you dreaming of a clear headed Christmas? or is Christmas the time when you sort of worry about it less? Save all that for January and just kick back with a drink or two. Get in touch and let me know. You can text me on 85058. You can send me a WhatsApp message on 08085 909693. And if you're on social media, use the hashtag WakeUpToMoney.
8:15Felicity Hannah: I'll keep an eye on that. Joining me this morning throughout the programme, I've got Charlie Blakemore, Chief Executive of Intercity Technology based in Birmingham, working in cybersecurity, comms and managed IT services. Morning, Charlie. Good morning, Felicity. We're also joined by Leah Ramwell, Head of Tailored Investment Solutions at Canaccord Wealth. Morning, Leah. Morning, Felicity. And rounding off our Friday panel is Shelley Horne, economist at the business advisory firm S &W. Good morning, Shelley. Hi, Ron. Great to have you all with us. I suppose we'll start off before we get into the very, very busy week that was.
8:50Felicity Hannah: zero alcohol drinks, low and no alcohol drinks. Charlie, you a fan? Yeah, I think times have shifted a lot now. I think I certainly see a younger generation that are more attuned to well-being and health and fitness. So I think and having, you know, options is great. And I think, you know, you've seen the decline of pubs now. I think it's a generational shift. And I think that this will, in my view, this will offer more choice and more opportunity for people to socialise, you know, as they want to. So yeah, I think it's a good thing. Leah, it's interesting, isn't it? Younger people do seem to be turning towards alternatives when they socialise, quite, quite often coffee shops and even hot chocolate.
9:36Felicity Hannah: And there is a sort of healthier trend. Absolutely. We're definitely seeing that. And you're seeing that reflected for several years now in the numbers of the companies selling the alcoholic drinks. Acheleon, what do you think? Do you think Christmas on the noseco, is it something that works for you? Well, I think it's definitely, you know, these weight loss drugs are definitely changing the way in which we sort of consume and the way we live. And we're seeing that in the composition of the inflation basket and, you know, and sort of what people are investing in going forward. So it's definitely a change in consumer preferences.
10:10Felicity Hannah: James on social media says, this will be my third Christmas off the booze. Non-alcoholic lager now superb, but the absence of any nice zero alcohol wines is sorely missed. We will get into a few of those shortly. Mark says, I shall be having a couple of glasses of champagne for the first time in four years. So I'm going to throw the stats. My experience has been that low alcohol beer is now pretty good. Non-alcoholic wine remains utterly vile like liquid chemical jam. Okay, Mark feels strongly. Let me know your thoughts. It's 85058. But we're also going to look back at a busy week. Political conference season came to an end.
10:47Felicity Hannah: It was the Conservatives laying out their plans for the economy and beyond in Birmingham this week. Kenny Badenock, the leader, gave her keynote speech, pledging to scrap inheritance tax on family homes, while also allowing couples to leave£1 million tax free. Passing on your home to your family is one of the most human instincts of all. So, conference, the next Conservative government will legislate so nobody will ever pay inheritance tax on their family home. I mean, people cheer that at some conferences. They always cheer the leaders' suggestions and comments, Shelley. But it is going to be a popular idea with the Conservative Party and perhaps with their base.
11:36Felicity Hannah: But what do you think? What do you make of that? Because tax changes like that can have a really, really significant, wider, sometimes unforeseen impact, can't they? I was wondering if perhaps if the Conservatives were in power and went ahead with that policy, would you see more, I don't know, perhaps older people upsizing the family home instead of downsizing? It's really interesting, isn't it? Because I think it very much was a sort of fact-right speech, very much based on home ownership and whether that was, you know, passing on the family home free of inheritance tax around sort of abolishing stamp duty or not bringing in the proposed mansion tax.
12:11But as you say, they have sort of competing effects. So, you know, reforming or abolishing stamp duty might encourage people to downsize. But at the same time, allowing somebody to pass on their family home tax free might actually encourage them to upsize as it's a great way to sort of shield you know shield assets and and pass on more wealth to to the younger generations you've got very much those competing effects there
12:32Felicity Hannah: yes i mean there were a few different um pledges coming out in birmingham weren't there um kemi badenock said that uh the differences between her party and the labour government go to the very core of what kind of country we want to be charlie from a business perspective what did you make of what kemi badenock had to say yeah i think it's a good thing on balance i think it's it's one of aspiration to uh for for people to you know um grow and and develop their sort of uh their property and their and their family life um without the fear of it being lost you know there's a lot of tax being paid throughout people's lives and i think that this is a good thing i think there's always though two sides isn't there and you've got to look at is it affordable and what could that mean elsewhere is it a priority for you as a as a business uh you know somebody running a business no i wouldn't say it's a priority i think the one thing i would say though is that you know it's um for me it will probably drive more aspiration for people who want to succeed in business because that could offer them a you know a a more uh sort of affordable and and sort of tax efficient way of investing in their properties, etc.
13:49So it's one of aspiration, which I think for business is good. Generally, though, will it impact business? I don't think so.
13:57Felicity Hannah: What about that pledge to halve the rate of employer national insurance on earnings for people aged between 21 and 24? Do you think that would get you potentially hiring more younger people? Absolutely. And I think that's a really good move. I think the cost of employment in recent years has gone up. I think that, you know, generally, I think margins are being squeezed now because of the cost of employment. And anything to really help business in this environment, I think will be great. You know, I was at the West Midlands Growth Summit yesterday, and there's, there is real optimism that we can come out of this quite challenging period now in business and sort of, and grow again.
14:38But it relies on confidence. And I think that, The more opportunity for optimism in the business community will help that. And definitely for younger employees, we've got to make it more affordable for companies to take on and develop young people, for sure.
14:58Felicity Hannah: Leah, it's a tricky one, isn't it? Because Kim Vadenhock said that growing the economy will be the central organising principle of the next Conservative government. But Labour said, well, the Tories failed, completely failed at every turn, was their phrase, to grow the economy during their 14 years in power. But it's not proving an easy job for the Labour government either. There's this kind of elusive issue of growth, which is the answer to all our problems. But lack of it seems to be the cause of a lot of our problems. Absolutely. And I think we've heard very little so far from the Labour Party on plans for growth.
15:31They're focusing on different levers to pull and, you know, different priorities. You know, and I think we can see vastly different approaches to trying to stimulate economies. This isn't just a UK specific problem.
15:46Felicity Hannah: You know, I think the government is going to have to look at how to stimulate that growth going forward. OK, let's talk about one of the other big stories this week. the UK's biggest broadband provider, BT, agreed to buy rival operator TalkTalk to save the company from collapse. BT's chief executive, Alison Kirkby, spoke to Will Bain earlier this week. This is an exceptional situation. It's unprecedented. You know, there was going to be two and a half million customers, including vulnerable households and key emergency services might have lost their services if TalkTalk had failed, which it was on track to do.
16:24Felicity Hannah: So BT stepped in as we were the only viable option. This deal has not been without criticism, though. Rival bidder Virgin Media's chief executive, Lutz Schuller, called the deal a stitch up, masked as a rescue deal in the public interest. The competition regulator at the CMA says it's going to investigate and it will report back to the culture secretary, Lisa Nandy, by the 19th of October. It's a really tricky one, Leah, isn't it? TalkTalk have been struggling for a while, ever since they suffered that big cyber attack in 2015. They've accrued quite considerable debts of 1.5 billion. This is a company that's been in difficulties.
17:05Felicity Hannah: Yes. And I think the immediate priority there really had to be to keep essential services running without disruption. But there's a really fine line that needs to be treaded between that immediate priority and managing that immediate financial stress, but also thinking about the long term best interests of the market dynamic and consumers going forward. You know, and if you have consolidation in an industry, you know, permanently, you know, that that can impact consumers in terms of, you know, higher prices, less choice. So that's a fine line to walk and one that we're seeing repeated across conversations in other markets as well.
17:48Felicity Hannah: Shelley, and why would BT see this as a good deal? Yeah, I think, you know, Leah's right. I think that we were expecting to see consolidation in the broadband market for quite a while. And TalkTalk has been struggling, like TalkTalk's been on the market for a while. I think there are a number of reasons why I think maybe BT hadn't looked at this before, and not least actually a couple of weeks ago, the CMA was not positive towards Nextfibre's acquisition of Natomia. So I think the Competition and Markets Authority has always been concerned about too much market power being held by sort of, you know, a particular telco at that wholesale level.
18:23And that perhaps put BT off from sort of looking more at talk to before because it didn't think the deal would go through. Obviously, this time around, it's in quite a different position. So the CMA will be using the failing firm defence. So to look at the counterfactual, which is actually if BT hadn't stepped in, talk-talk wouldn't exist. It wouldn't provide competition in the market. So it's quite a lower bar to get the CMA to approve this deal. And also, obviously, there's been a public interest intervention notice put in place by the government. So I think BT is looking at it now saying, well, actually, this is easier.
18:53Before, we probably wouldn't have got it through the competition authority. It would have been very tough. Now, actually, it's a lot easier. And we are seeing consolidation in the broadband markets. There's an awful lot of licensed operators. that. I think last time I looked, there were over 120 operators that were sort of under the code, under the electronic communication code, who were able to provide this sort of fiber. And there were just basically too many operators out there for what the market can sustain. So we know there's going to be consolidation. And BT is the largest provider at the moment.
19:21So from its point of view, I'm sure it would like to sort of reduce the level of competition and have reduced its cost as a result, whether it will just sell through or whether the CMA will put in place some sort of remedy. At the extreme, it could require BT to run Talk Talkers as a totally separate business. I don't think it would do that. But it's quite likely that it will put some remedy in or off what will put sort of further regulations in to ensure that sort of BT can't use its additional
19:48Felicity Hannah: market power to sort of too much extent. Charlie, that's an interesting point, isn't it? One of the main arguments against this deal being that BT Openreach dominates the market already. How important is competition for customers? It's really important. And I think this is one that will be carefully monitored in terms of going forward. But I think this was, you know, a sort of a continuity of service and customer protection move really first off. And I think there's going to be some stabilisation needed of the business before any sort of, you know, competition sort of impacts, I think. I think going forward, though, I think this is the careful bit, is now how do we maintain competition in a very more increased, consolidated environment and maintain innovation and, you know, sort of economic improvements to the platforms for customers?
20:45So I think this will be watched carefully, but I think this is a rescue at the first point and then move forward with a more sort of, you know, making sure there's more competition and innovation is not stifled for customers.
20:59Felicity Hannah: Shalyan, the Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy, says that they could make changes to the Enterprise Act if it helps get the deal past regulators. Do you think that it's likely the government played a hand in getting this deal over the line? Definitely. You know, the government, I think, put in place, I think, a public interest intervention notice, where it makes it very clear that, you know, it would like the CMA to look at this quickly. So there's a very short timetable for the CMA to look at this, which I think has been another sort of complaint by many of the operators compared to sort of previous deals that the CMA's looked at.
21:29So, yeah, the government's been very clear that it wants this deal to go ahead. But it's not doing it, let's be clear, because it wants to strengthen BT's market power. It's doing it because it's genuinely, I think, concerned. It's a sort of critical national infrastructure and it supplies, you know, hospitals, education, the emergency services. And I think the government is genuinely worried if it does become a sort of disorderly liquidation process, what would happen there? So it's looking to sort of manage this more carefully.
21:55Felicity Hannah: Thank you very much. Let's talk about EVs, those sort of Chinese made, in particular, electric vehicles becoming more and more popular here in the UK. Sales doubled to almost 200 ,000 last year. Yeah, there's huge, huge growth in brands like BYD, Jayquist. That's according to data from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders released last week. I spoke with Robert Forrester of Virtu Motors last week, and here was his explanation as to why that's happening. The market is very strong, 10 months of growth. It's the Chinese brands who are actually powering this growth in the new car market, because we're the only major economy in the world without tariffs on Chinese brands.
22:37Felicity Hannah: But now, could that be going to change? We've heard reports this week that the government is considering whether to impose tariffs on Chinese car imports to align itself with the EU. The UK, of course, wants to be included in the trading blocs made in Europe scheme that would remove key trading barriers for British goods. And to do that, one of the things the EU might want is for the UK to impose tariffs, which if they match to the EU's tariffs, could be as high as 45 percent. They've got a 10 % duty and then they've got up to 35%, depending on the different manufacturers. Charlie, these vehicles are absolutely everywhere, aren't they?
23:15Felicity Hannah: Have you noticed the increase? I notice the tunes that a lot of them play when they're sort of bingling about the streets. They've all got quite soothing music. There's a real increase in it. It's, you know, it's very visible. And again, it's similar to the last sort of conversation, really. It's about, you know, competition and about, for me, a very level playing field. And I think that tariffs is one way of making that sort of, you know, enabling competition to be to be on that level playing field. I think part of the issue is that, you know, there's the Chinese markets at manufacturing gets, you know, it's talks of support from from the state.
23:57so you know I think getting a getting a manufacturing balance and making sure that you know for me I still believe we should have we should be making more in the UK and encouraging that now there's a journey to do that of course but you know it's also got to be affordable for the end user so there's a real balance here but I genuinely think that you know it competition needs to be on a level playing field. And it will have long-term effects if the market continues to grow and consumers continue to buy Chinese EV cars because, you know, it will squeeze others out, European and UK. So UK-made cars.
24:38So we've got to, you know, this has got to be balanced and it's got to be looked at so that it does give fair market conditions for everybody.
24:46Felicity Hannah: Leah, that's an important point, isn't it? That this is a tricky line for the government to tread, particularly when it wants people to make that shift to electric vehicles. And very, very often those Chinese vehicles are the cheapest on the market. Absolutely. And, you know, consumer choice is important. It's particularly an issue for our European neighbours. And, you know, the government's clearly signalling they want an improved relationship with Europe, closeness with Europe. And this is a real issue in Europe, which still relies heavily on manufacturing in the auto industry for many jobs.
25:22So, you know, the UK government has to walk that line very carefully between, you know, maintaining the best and most popular choices for consumers. And I think last month, the most registered car in the UK was a Chinese electric vehicle. So, you know, this is a very popular series of vehicles. So they need to make sure that UK consumers are not losing out on choice and on pricing, particularly important with fuel prices, diesel prices where they are, you know, electric vehicles becoming more popular, but also not souring relations with European neighbours. It's a difficult line to walk.
26:03Felicity Hannah: Shelley, it's a very difficult line to walk, isn't it? But then the EU says that a lot of these vehicles, these Chinese vehicles, they're so cheap because they say the industry has had unfair state subsidies distorting global markets and subsidies that have come right up through the supply chain from the battery development, right to the point where the cars reach our shores. you're right and the eu has imposed tariffs through what is known as its foreign subsidy rules so it does assess whether there's been dumping and dumping is where you sell state subsidized cars below the true cost of production in order to sort of wipe out local competition and i think that's what the uk is going to have to do here is do that similar assessment and say are they sort of legitimately low priced and that might be because there's vertical integration in the supply chain so a lot of the chinese car manufacturers also have um interest in the battery supply chain which sort of makes it makes it cheaper than to produce is because there's economies of scale they've got huge volumes of cars so are they able to sort of produce each one more cheaply is it due to sort of lower domestic labor costs r &d costs and all of those sort of legitimate reasons why why the price might be low or is it down to state subsidies and if it is down to state subsidies and they are being sort of as I said price below that true cost of production absent state subsidies then there's a reason a rational reason for the UK to come in and under our own subsidy rules to be able to impose a tariff on those cars.
27:23Felicity Hannah: There's another difficult line to walk as well, though, isn't there? And that's the line between UK and China relations. Yeah, that is difficult. They are an important trading partner. We, in fact, sell vehicles. Some of our car manufacturers do sell vehicles into China as well, Shelley. And kind of maintaining good relationships might be quite difficult if we suddenly whack 35 plus, 45 % tariffs on those vehicles because China already faces 100 % tariff over in the States. So the UK is an important market. You are right. I think we're one of only a few sort of major economies who are currently, though, levying tariffs on this type of car.
28:04Just that 10 % import duty. Yeah, we have the 10%. We don't have the additional, I guess, distortion tariffs, the foreign subsidy type tariffs. I think we're one of only a few major markets that don't do that. So you could argue that actually by doing that, we would just be sort of where others are. And I think, you know, it's tough in this country because we are trying to build a closer relationship with China. But at the same time, the EU is looking to change its own procurement rules so that it procures more and subsidizes more manufacturing made within the EU. So we're being squeezed out of the EU at the moment because of those rules.
28:38And we do need to trade with China. So how do you sort of, I guess, you know, keep that relationship with the EU, try and remain within their within their market so that we can benefit some of that production in the EU whilst also being able to trade with China?
28:51Felicity Hannah: Charlie, how important do you think being in that made in Europe scheme is for the UK businesses? I think it's really important access to markets for business now has always been and is increasingly more important. And I think, you know, we're feeling and seeing now a more an approach that the UK is trying to get back closer to Europe because of the access to that market. It's really important across all sectors. And as said before, you know, it's not just Europe. It's a global picture now. And there's been such a lot of changes, geopolitical changes. And the US has changed how it trades with the rest of the world.
29:32So keeping avenues open for fair trade, but it is really important for the UK. And it is a fine line here in terms of, you know, sort of opening channels for opportunities for businesses globally, but also maintaining our own focus on productivity and making sure that we stay competitive across all sectors to be able to provide goods and services that are of real quality that are also affordable. So I think, you know, that competition is important. And I think we've got to focus on both aspects, opening the market, but remaining really high levels of productivity and being competitive.
30:16Felicity Hannah: I don't think I've ever heard the words fine line to tread used so much in a chat on Wake Up To Money. right it is 5.32 Charlie Blakemore Chief Executive of Intercity Technology Leah Ramwell Head of Tailored Investment Solutions at Canaccord Wealth stick around drink some tea lots more to talk about but Shelley and this is where we let you crack on with your Friday thank you so much for being with us on Wake Up To Money very much thank you Shelley and Horne there economist at the business advisory firm S &W quite a few of you getting in touch with your Christmas low and no alcohol stories or your move towards low alcohol Beth says, as an 80s child, I've experienced the heavy nights out drinking in my 20s, followed by wine o 'clock in my 30s.
30:58Felicity Hannah: Now I'm in my 40s. I'm happily and healthily sober. Given you mentioned Christmas, I do confess to having a snowball with a glassy cherry in homage to my youth. Beth, thank you for that.
31:21All seafood is wild caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes. Visit your online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made.
32:03This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell or attain any specific investment or service.
32:11Wake Up To Money with Felicity Hanna.
32:14Felicity Hannah: Good morning. If you're just joining us, welcome to Wake Up To Money. Welcome to Friday. day. We're talking about Tesco saying that it's expecting a less boozy Christmas this year. People are a bit more conscious about their health. Some people are using weight loss drugs, so they don't want to drink in the way that they otherwise might. So I'm asking you this morning, are you planning for a less drinky, maybe a much healthier Christmas this year? And what's driving you with that? I want you to get in touch with me this morning. You can text me on 85058. You can send me a WhatsApp message on 08085 909693 and you can use the hashtag wake up to money on social media.
32:53Felicity Hannah: A lot of you have already been in touch. One person who says Felicity hardly the time to be talking about Christmas drinking habits on October the 9th. I know I'm sorry I realise it's early for a mention of the Christmas word but the supermarkets are getting ready for it aren't they and I'm interested to hear if you're changing your drinking habits. Howell in Cardiff says over the last couple of years, my 50 plus old friends and I have reduced our alcohol intake to our regular Friday night outside by alternating between standard and alcohol free beer. This allows us to enjoy time together in our favourite pubs, wake up refreshed the next day, which is why we go out not to get drunk.
33:29Felicity Hannah: For me, the introduction of a zero version of a well-known stout beer, I know the one you mean, has been a game changer. I prefer it to the standard version. Thank you. And Sean on social media says my mum makes half and half Guinness and Guinness zeros to keep herself sober. So yes, probably I'll be doing that. Keep your thoughts coming. 85058. Now let's talk about a story that's making the front page of the FT this morning. The news that OpenAI has said that its annualised revenue is about$20 billion less than the company has previously signalled. So Previously, it had been looking at about$70 billion.
34:10Felicity Hannah: Now they're saying about$50 billion on an annualised basis at the end of September. Still with me throughout the programme is Leah Bramwell, Head of Tailored Investment Solutions at Canaccord Wealth. Leah, this is pretty significant, isn't it? And actually, it's not just OpenAI that's felt the impact of these reports. Shares in tech companies more widely took a bit of a hit. Yeah, they did. We saw the NASDAQ falling. We saw the semiconductor index more widely falling. So a revival of the concerns that we saw coming out over the summer, that the capital expenditure that we're seeing many of these AI companies undertaking is harder to justify if those revenues don't come through.
34:56Felicity Hannah: Now, also, and some breaking news, actually, the AI data centre company Firmus says it's scrapped its plans for what would have been one of Australia's biggest ever stock market listings. Robert, this is the business that's backed by NVIDIA. But it says that due to recent market volatility and prevailing market conditions, going public at the moment would not be in the company or the shareholders' best interests. Leah, does it start to make you wonder if the AI boom is reaching a point where investors are starting to question whether some of these businesses are worth what they're asking? Yeah, I don't think that's a new phenomenon, to be honest.
35:35I think there's been question marks over valuation in this space for quite some time. The challenge is that many of these companies are backed by strong earnings. So, you know, your traditional valuation metrics don't look too out of line compared to previous episodes where we've seen technology stocks getting very expensive. So, you know, I think that the firmness deal that the valuation was high. I think it was on track to become Australia's largest ever IPO. You know, there may just not have been quite enough appetite for that level of valuation in the market at this time.
36:17Felicity Hannah: Also with us still is Charlie Blakemore from Intercity Technology, which works in cybersecurity, communications, managed IT services. Charlie, very curious to get your view on this and whether these two announcements coming so close together say something more widely about the tech landscape. Yeah, I think the key to this is just really the cost of investment to keep up with the advancing technologies within AI. And I think the operating costs are getting higher and investments in infrastructure and talent are huge cost burdens. And I think, you know, this could indicate that going forward that subscription models and the cost of using AI for the consumer potentially could go up.
37:07because I think, you know, the investment to stay ahead of the competition in AI, you know, requires huge capital investment in data centres, you know, infrastructure development and specialised sort of chips, etc. So there's a huge cost to being in this market. And I think now they're going to be looking at, you know, what is the future return on this, I'm sure.
37:32Felicity Hannah: Now that is one side of the whole AI discussion, isn't it? The other side is about perhaps some of the ethics of AI, what it's feeding itself on, what it's gathering its information from. And hundreds of delegates from across the UK's creative industries are gathering in Manchester today for the Creative Industries AI Summit. It's been convened by the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, who's hoping a consensus can be reached on the use of AI content and how things work in terms of creative ownership as we all start to use more AI. I say all, I know you're all going to start texting in now to say that you don't, but clearly a lot more people do.
38:12Felicity Hannah: This summit is part of a three-day festival in Salford called Beyond the Music and Wake Up to Money's Jennifer Lynham spoke to attendees yesterday and ask them how AI is affecting them. Competing with AI is going to be an interesting, you know, people can take my voice off of my songs and they can just use it as and when they please. So I think some more restrictions around it are definitely needed. I think as a reviewer of live music, the big danger is AI being used by, you know, maybe less worthwhile journalists or, you know, people in the industry to use AI to write reviews. I think especially with songwriting, younger artists are relying heavily on AI to write lyrics, to write melodies.
38:56It's just like ruining the independence of writing music at the moment as people just relying on it heavily. The music industry has been impacted by AI for a long time. Auto-tune is a form of AI. And yet that doesn't seem quite as bad as generative AI where people are generating pieces of work from other people's work and labour without their consent. and the music industry hasn't really found a way to protect the copyrights and the human rights and the moral rights of musicians.
39:23Felicity Hannah: So that was attendees at the Creative Industries, at the Beyond the Music Festival in Salford, talking about AI. And joining me to talk about it is G. Davey, Chief Executive at the Association of Independent Music, joining me in the studio, which is always an absolute pleasure. G, good morning. Good morning. Thank you very much for being with us. What are your members then? You represent the UK's independent music industry. Are they worried about AI and what are they worried about? Yeah, there's certainly concerns about AI in the independent music sector, but also quite a lot of positivity about how that could really help to boost independent music and independent artists.
40:03So it's really a double-edged sword.
40:05Felicity Hannah: So give us then, give us some examples of the concerns and some examples of the reasons for optimism. Sure. So, you know, much of the music business revenues are now coming from digital music, have been for a long time. And, for example, a lot of my members are very concerned and already having great difficulty battling what we call AI slop, which is poor quality AI generated music on digital music platforms. so for a lot of them they get revenues from things like algorithmically driven playlists on Spotify for example and they're seeing things like some of those playlists such as for instrumental or jazz music being increasingly overwhelmed by poor quality AI generated music and that's a very important area for particularly emerging artists to find revenue streams so those artists are now not just competing with other real human artists, but also now competing with a great deal of AI music.
41:08And it really kind of saturates the market and means that revenues are affected.
41:12Felicity Hannah: And do you think it is costing some of those performers genuine money? Oh, it genuinely is, yeah, already, yeah. Is there an argument, though, that if you're a real human being singing a real song about your real experience, you should be able to connect with the fans in multiple other ways, through social media, through your events, through your gigs, through getting out there and promoting your stuff. And that's something that AI can't compete with. No, absolutely. That human connection is absolutely vital and I think we'll run through. But as I say, around 70 % of the music business, the way that artists actually get returns on their creativity is driven by digital platforms.
41:51And yeah, if there's so much of an overwhelm of AI-generated music, it's incredibly hard for real human artists with that connection to break through and just be seen.
42:01Felicity Hannah: What are some of the benefits then? Because this is not, you know, people aren't getting together at this summit to just say, right, it all needs to stop, put the brakes on, scrap AI, are they? There must be some positive conversations happening. Yeah, and arguably, even more so for my constituency, who are all small to medium-sized enterprises in music, you know, everyone from household names such as Beggars and 4AD to local Manchester labels like Scruff of the Neck and NQ. So, you know, there is some optimism there. I suppose it's more really on the business tools that could be helpful, cutting down admin, helping understand metadata, working through digital music analytics, things like that.
42:42One of my members, Absolute Music, have actually built their own analytics engine called Anthology. So, you know, there is quite wide use of AI in that regard and some positivity as to how that can boost businesses.
42:58Felicity Hannah: Can you have it both ways? Because some people will be listening and thinking, well, hang on, I work in admin. It just sounds like you're taking money away from me. Yeah, AI is, you know, like any technology, it's a term that's used very generically. But in fact, there's very, very different kinds of AI. You know, the concerns really come from generative AI largely. But then again, there's also assistive AI, if you like, tools that help with creativity, tools that help with business. So I suppose it depends on what type of AI we're talking about. But I always find that people use AI like they use the word the internet.
43:34And the internet isn't all one thing. It's everything from emails to everything else that we use the internet for. So, yeah, I don't think we can talk about AI as one thing. I think we've got to separate when we're talking about generative AI, which is producing creative output, to assistive tools.
43:49Felicity Hannah: And agentic AI where it starts to go off and do things for you, potentially promote bands for you around the UK. OK, organisers today say they want to align on a shared rights and integrity first position for AI. What does that mean? And is it likely to happen? Well, I think there's an awful lot of aligned thinking across the not just the music sector, the creative sectors more generally. And I suppose what we want to do is come together, really flesh out some of the things that we're all talking about all the time around this and present outwardly publicly. our aligned thinking so I've I've very strong hopes for today's summit.
44:30Felicity Hannah: Okay so what I mean do you think that you'll arrive at an industry position at the close of this summit or is it just such a huge discussion and a huge debate? Yeah it's a huge area and actually a lot of it is very much out of control out of the control of businesses like the music industry but what I would hope is that we come out with some high-level principles that really tell the story of how the music business is thinking about AI. Well, thank you so much for joining us bright and early ahead of what is clearly going to be a very, very busy day, G. Yeah, I'm happy to. Thank you. G. Davey there, Chief Executive at the Association of Independent Music, joining me in the studio ahead of that summit in Manchester.
45:11Felicity Hannah: Let me see. Somebody who doesn't give their name has messaged to say the AI bubble will burst when the price of licence renewal increases. It's basic business. Create dependency, then ramp up the cost. Keep your thoughts coming on that and on everything that we're talking about this morning, including this very familiar sound to many of us.
45:32Felicity Hannah: Oh yes, eyes down. Bingo is a familiar sound for a lot of people, a familiar sound actually to an increasingly young crowd as well. But bingo hall operators are warning that a third of their venues could close if the Chancellor increases taxes on gaming machines in the budget later this month. Now you might think, well, hang on, these are bingo halls, not gaming machine centres. But most bingo halls offer visitors the chance to play traditional bingo. But alongside that, they often have some of these gaming machines. And speculation has been growing in recent weeks that the Chancellor could raise taxes on those machines from 20 % to 40 % in his budget to raise more revenue from adult gaming centres and the high street shops that are filled with them.
46:20Felicity Hannah: The government says it won't comment on speculation about the budget. Expect us to say that a lot more in the next few days and weeks. But the bingo industry says that it would be hard for it to make money and that many bingo halls would go out of business. Here's Nicole Garrett, who's chief executive of the Bingo Association. Machines is an important secondary income for bingo clubs. It helps us keep clubs viable and also keeps bingo affordable for many people that enjoy it. Even after the bingo duty cut, 27 % of bingo clubs are loss making, even today. So we do need to invest to make sure we can safeguard ourselves for the future.
46:55Felicity Hannah: And it's just another tax increase that could undermine that. Well, Dominic Mansour is chief executive of Buzz Bingo, Britain's largest bingo operator with 76 clubs across the country. Joins us now, Dominic, good morning. Good morning, Felicity. Thank you so much for being with us. I suppose we're going to talk about these potential taxes, these mooted taxes. We're going to talk about the impact. But first of all, just tell me how bingo is doing at the moment in the UK. Because I think there's the sort of traditional view of bingo, which is, you know, perhaps an older generation kind of heading along drinking cup of tea and getting out their dabbers.
47:30Felicity Hannah: And actually, there's the reality, which is quite a vibrant industry. Well, yeah, you're absolutely right. In fact, over the last few years, bingo has been in decline. But in the last couple of years, It's had a real resurgence. We've noticed a lot more younger customers coming in since COVID, people looking for, you know, an affordable, friendly community place to hang out. OK, so that's the kind of the good sell for bingo. But let's talk about these gaming machines. Tell me what proportion of your revenue is generated by those rather than by traditional bingo. Yeah, I mean, I'll get to that in two sets.
48:08I mean, think of bingo clubs like cinemas. Machines are our popcorn. So, you know, a critical part of the revenue stream in a cinema is the popcorn for us. Machines represent up to half of our total revenue coming through the retail estate.
48:25Felicity Hannah: OK, so is the trade body right then that it would potentially drive a lot of your kinds of businesses out of business if the tax on those machines was doubled to 40%. Yep, be under no illusion. We don't even, I wouldn't even want to talk about the 40%, to be honest with you. I'm worried at 5%. And at just a 5 % increase in tax would put one third of all of our clubs to loss making. And that would be pretty much unsustainable for a business who, you know, we employ 2 ,200 people across the country from Plymouth all the way to Aberdeen. So it would be really, really tough for us. You know, we've invested about£30 million into our estate in the last couple of years.
49:09We're planning to increase that if we can. And when government abolished bingo duty last year, we felt that we had a real support and a real tailwind behind us.
49:20Felicity Hannah: So you have had a major tax break from the government. We've also had a massive tax hit at the same time in the remote gaming duty that was nearly doubled last year. So, yeah, we got some support. And off the back of that, we've invested a huge amount of money into, you know, our clubs, into painters and decorators and carpet fitters and so on. And that's really helping, you know, local service people across the country. Is there a problem, though, with your argument here, which is that when you talk about bingo, you are talking about a sociable, relatively low cost activity that people can come together and do.
49:59Felicity Hannah: But when you talk about those gaming machines, you are talking about something that the government has chosen to hit with what a lot of people would call a syntax because those can be quite harmful. I'm just looking now at a report from the Social Market Foundation that says one in four casino game users on machines are gambling at risky or harmful levels. And that 43 % of the general public back increasing taxes on slot machines in high street betting shops. I appreciate that you might be offering different kinds of gaming machines, but these are a more problematic area than people getting together to have fun and hear about two fat ladies.
50:38I mean, a couple of things. One, bingo is a membership model. So that means that we have an ability, if somebody does show any signs of harm, we have an ability to stop them visiting any bingo club in the country, which is a real nice safety net. but 99 % of our customer admissions happen around the hours of a bingo game. So what does that tell you? What it tells you is people come in to play bingo, to socialise, to have a bit of fun and in the intervals or before and after the game of bingo they might put, in our case, between£8 and£10 into a slot machine.
51:13Felicity Hannah: That can be a lot of money though for some people, particularly people who are looking for affordable ways to go and spend time with their friends. And bingo is an affordable, that's an affordable night out. In fact, we offer some of the best value, you know, F &B across the country. So yes, you know, but we do it in a safe, protected environment. You know, like I say, the general managers know most of our customers on a first name basis. When they come in, they say, you know, hello to them one by one, and they welcome them in and out as they leave at the end of the session as well. Do you agree that taxes should be used to support some positive sectors and to encourage people away from sectors that might be more harmful.
51:53Felicity Hannah: So you've had that major tax break from the government in that bingo duty was abolished in April. And that's because I'm sure perhaps they recognise the sort of the value of what you provide there. However, there is still this concern about those gaming machines. And so they have to potentially face higher taxes. Is it not an argument that you should be moving away from those and more towards the positive community bingo game? I think you're absolutely right. I think we should be talking about the positive community environment. This is about protecting jobs. It's about protecting investment into local communities across the country.
52:28I think, you know, one of the great things about a bingo venue is it's safe, it's warm, or, you know, amusingly nowadays, it's cool in the summer. So we offer an environment which is, you know, ticks all of those boxes, you know, in an affordable fashion.
52:45Felicity Hannah: Dominic Mansour, Chief Executive of Buzz Bingo. Thank you so much for joining us very bright and early on Wake Up to Money. Thanks for having me. Thank you. And I'm sure that it will be a busy evening at a lot of bingo halls as well. Thank you so much, not just to Dominic, but to Leah Bramwell from Canaccord Wealth, to Charlie Blakemore, Chief Executive of Intercity Technology. Thank you very much for being with us throughout the programme today. Thank you for all your messages. Let's have one more. Archie and Vanessa says, as the old joke goes, I read somewhere alcohol is bad for your health, so I gave up reading.
53:18Felicity Hannah: Okay, thank you, Archie. The old ones are the best, aren't they? Thanks for all your messages. That's it for Wake Up To Money.
53:43about being the captain of the club. I just wanted to play for it. Portugal have given me me two words like two football. Search The Wayne Rooney Show on BBC Sounds and subscribe now. That way, when my new series Can You Beat Wayne Rooney comes out, you'll be the first to get every episode as soon as they're released.
54:04Innovation has always kept the world moving forward, but it also comes with risk. As technology and AI evolve, AXA XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your data and network from cyber risks.
54:22Felicity Hannah: AXA XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation nor a description of any products or services of AXA XL. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing Or perhaps you pick up a few farm-fresh trades while you peruse You can even get help from a dedicated advisor That's full-service wealth management Mix, match and change your mind whenever you want Because at Schwab, you can invest your way No matter your goals or appetite for investing Schwab has everything you need all in one place Visit schwab.com to learn more
Felicity Hannah looks at the week's biggest business stories with her expert panel.
We'll also hear from the body that represents independent musicians about what the impact of AI could be on the creative industries.
As the price of oil rises once again, we'll see what that means for markets and find out why questions are asked about Open AI's projected profits.
And, we'll hear from the boss of the UK's biggest bingo chain about the difficulty businesses like theirs are facing.