1. Podcasts
  2. Wake Up to Money
  3. Marked absent
Wake Up to Money

2 Oct 2026 · 54m · 21 chapters

In short

Wake Up To Money (BBC 5 Live) episode covering UK fuel/diesel price spikes driven by refinery shortages; predicted further energy price-cap rises; Labour PM Andy Burnham’s policy signals (state pension “double lock,” public ownership of water); renewed debate about rejoining the EU; and separate headline segments on Manchester City’s Premier League financial-rule conviction and on AI being used to remove school-photo watermarks.

Guests (backgrounds)

Ian Hoskins, owner of My Pub Group (Liverpool hospitality). Anna MacDonald, Investment Strategy Director at Hargreaves Lansdowne. George Lagarias, Chief Economist at Mazars. Paul Gilroy Casey, barrister specializing in sports law (Nine Chambers/ Littleton Chambers). Victoria Welton, school and wedding photographer based in Somerset.

Key claims

Diesel is a refined-product problem (refinery capacity), not mainly crude supply; energy bills could rise further (price cap forecast +16% Q1); Burnham’s “double lock” would start in April 2030; water bill would repeal Thatcher’s ban on public water ownership; Brexit increases friction and hurts sectors like hospitality.

Notable examples

Diesel at ~£2/litre; Man City facing appeal and potential points deductions; AI watermark removal for school photo proofs; Palantir NHS contract renewal discussion.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:02

Fuel Prices and Economic Impact

Discussion about rising fuel prices and their implications on the economy and consumers.

“Welcome to Wake Up To Money on Friday the 2nd of October.”
4:22

Diesel Reserves and Global Supply Chain

Exploration of diesel supply issues and the effects on prices in various sectors.

“That is an all time high and it's actually dominating a lot of the front pages this morning.”
6:41

Refinery Issues and Costs

Analysis of refinery problems contributing to high diesel prices and their broader effects.

“And I was noting that a Democrat candidate in the US said last week, even if you don't pump diesel, diesel pumps you.”
8:11

Energy Costs and Business Implications

Discussion on rising energy costs and their significant impact on businesses, especially in hospitality.

“But I mean, fuel, whether it be diesel or petrol, affects everybody.”
11:09

Consumer Behavior and Energy Usage

Exploration of consumer behavior regarding energy usage and the ongoing energy crisis.

“Of course, I should always say when we talk about the price cap, it's very much a cap for the typical dual fuel household.”
14:00

Rising Costs and Consumer Behavior

Understanding how rising costs affect consumer choices and behavior.

“in your variable costs, which are, you know, which are huge.”
15:01

Economic Dependence on Oil

Exploring the impact of oil prices on the economy and inflation.

“George, I mean, this is what we mean when we talk about the world economy running on oil, isn't it?”
18:01

Political Ramifications of Inflation

Discussing how inflation affects political stability and government perception.

“as PM and perhaps trying to sound a bit more upbeat than maybe some of those concerns suggest.”
18:51

Triple Lock and Pension Reforms

Analyzing proposed changes to pension systems and their fiscal implications.

“That promise will take the state pension to a record high.”
22:41

Water Industry and Public Ownership

Debating the public ownership of water companies and its significance.

“But I think it shows that there is an element of the UK being slightly more rewarded this week for taking some what would potentially be long term decisions around reducing our long term liabilities.”
Show all 21 chapters
26:31

Brexit's Economic Impact

Evaluating the long-term economic effects of Brexit and the potential for reversal.

“said we should be open to potentially rejoining the EU.”
28:00

The Impact of Brexit on the UK Economy

Discussion on Brexit's implications for trade, hospitality, and the economy.

“Even if Europeans, who would be weary because they would say, okay, what happens if there is another government that wants Brexit?”
32:50

Listener Reactions and Energy Bills

Listener feedback on Brexit and rising energy costs in the UK.

“But that has been an absolutely fascinating discussion in the first half of Wake Up To Money.”
34:48

Manchester City's Legal Troubles

Analysis of Manchester City's legal issues regarding financial misconduct.

“Want to hear your thoughts on that, on all of it, and on this, the story that has dominated the headlines front and back pages of the newspapers this week.”
38:12

Potential Consequences for Manchester City

Discussion on the implications of Manchester City's appeal and penalties.

“The tributaries that feed off the mainstream here are beyond comprehension.”
42:00

Understanding Manchester City's Financial Situation

The discussion revolves around the uncertainty of actions regarding Manchester City's financial breaches.

“They normally do it every season, but they can take action mid-season if, in fact, the circumstances dictate that it's appropriate.”
42:28

Fan Reactions and Long-term Implications

Ian Hoskins shares his bewilderment as a Liverpool fan regarding the implications of Manchester City's situation.

“Thank you very much for being with us on Wake Up To Money this morning.”
43:48

Brexit Perspectives from the Audience

Listeners express contrasting views on Brexit's impact on the UK economy and society.

“I'm sure, I'm very sure that we will keep talking about this on Wake Up To Money and very, very much on Five Live as the story develops.”
45:00

The Role of Palantir in Public Services

Discussion on Palantir's controversial role in the UK government and its implications for public services.

“It's on the front page of the FT this morning that the UK government is reportedly looking for a British alternative to the US Software and Defence Group, which has become really quite controversial for a lot of people.”
47:11

AI Controversy in School Photography

Victoria Welton discusses the emerging issue of parents using AI to remove watermarks from school photographs.

“If another company can do it based in the UK, that would be fantastic.”
49:59

Business Models of School Photographers

Victoria explains the economics of school photography and the challenges posed by digital theft.

“Do you think that they realise that they're potentially violating somebody's copyright?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Wake Up to Money, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30and spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes. Visit your online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell or attain any specific investment or service.

1:07Wake Up To Money from BBC5 Live. Hello, welcome to Wake Up To Money. It is Friday. The weekend is in sight. It's been a pretty hectic week, hasn't it? We've seen more pressure at the pumps, with fuel prices reaching record highs. I used to do like, I think, 90 to 95 a full tank and now I'm paying almost 110. And the US says it's time Europe releases its reserves. We've also heard the Prime Minister set out his vision for the country. I will make a break with the direction of the past 40 years and put Britain on a new path. And we found out Man City was found guilty of breaking the Premier League's financial rules it has until today to appeal.

1:47Plus, the latest controversy relating to AI, this time school photos, and the battle to stop parents dodging the cost by getting artificial intelligence to take off the watermarks. Wake Up To Money with Felicity Hanna. Very good morning to you. Welcome to Wake Up To Money on Friday the 2nd of October. It's just coming up to five minutes past five. There's a lot to talk about. So with us to do exactly that is Ian Hoskins, owner of My Pub Group in Liverpool. Morning, Ian. Good morning, Fliss. Anna MacDonald, investment strategy at Hargreaves Lansdowne. Hello, Anna. Hello. And completing our Friday panel, George Lagarias, Chief Economist at the consultancy for Vismazas.

2:27Good morning. Good morning. Now, I feel like we're a particularly cool group here on Wake Up To Money. The Economist, the Investment Strategy Director, maybe, OK, maybe the pub owner. I feel like our school photos might not have been the coolest in the crop. Anna, what about you? No, but they are quite cute, aren't they, to look back on. And I've got one of my daughter's ones on my desk right now, actually, and she's got a very sweet, goofy little smile. So I quite like it. And this is a good point, isn't it, Ian? They're kind of meant to be a little bit gawky. I think I burnt all mine because I knocked my two front teeth out when I was five or six.

3:06So toothy smiles, toothless smiles were not great. But yeah, they're like passport photos, aren't they? They never, ever look good. No, no. But everybody wants to see them. That's the thing. George, do they have those in Greece school photos? That sort of, you know, everybody lined up? They do. And unfortunately, I had her, so I just, you know, kept them out of sight, not to remember it. Well, I would like to hear from you this morning. Get in touch. Do you buy school photos? It's a shame. I'm sure a lot of you will now be sending me pictures of your school photos. It doesn't work beautifully for radio.

3:38So instead, tell me if you buy them for your children, what you think about the cost. Maybe you're a photographer. Are you seeing parents using AI to kind of cheat the system, strip off the watermark, save themselves the money? Is it a problem you're dealing with? Maybe you're in another sector, but you're seeing your customers find a way to reduce their costs or even cheat your costs by using AI. Get in touch and let me know. You can text me on 85058. You can send me a WhatsApp message on 08085 909693. And if you're on social media, use the hashtag wake up to money and I will keep an eye on that.

4:14But let's get straight into another important story for anyone who's got to fill up before work this morning. Average diesel prices remaining on the brink of two pounds a litre this morning, according to the RAC. That is an all time high and it's actually dominating a lot of the front pages this morning. We know that last week, President Donald Trump threatened to ban diesel exports from the US. He's trying to reduce record prices at the pump for Americans and, of course, for farmers in America, anybody using diesel to get the harvest in or for truckers. He's also called on Europe to release some of their diesel reserves to help bring down the cost here in Europe.

4:58And the UK is also in talks with European partners about doing exactly that. George, what does that mean? What difference would releasing diesel reserves on this side of the world make? Right now, a lot. Diesel prices have been soaring. So, you know, releasing reserves might alleviate some of the pressure. Having said that, the problem right now is not oil. OK, it's exactly that. It's diesel. It's the refined product that's a problem. Right now, there aren't enough refineries to process oil. Oil is actually going through. A lot of it is going through. Not as much as pre-war, but a lot of it is going through.

5:44There are just enough refineries to do the job. So releasing the reserves might help alleviate the pressure. Anna, it's interesting, isn't it? The refinery pressure, that's kind of been the second beat in this whole conflict. We've seen more disruption in the Middle East, disrupting refineries. And then, of course, in the existing conflict that we've seen, the Russian war in Ukraine, we've seen Russian refineries being disrupted by Ukraine. So there's kind of a bit of a perfect storm. Yes, indeed. And I think that it's not going to be just diesel because we also know that some other refined products such as fertilisers are important.

6:28and when we come into sowing crops in the northern hemisphere. So it's just layer upon layer of things that can cause further inflation and further disruption. And I was noting that a Democrat candidate in the US said last week, even if you don't pump diesel, diesel pumps you. And that's really in reference to the fact that diesel costs are vital to so many transport systems and getting things around each country. So truckers, everyone uses diesel. So it's not just if you don't have a diesel car that you're kind of safe from it. It affects us all. Ian, are you noticing diesel pumping you? Is it pumping up your costs?

7:15Well, supply chain is obviously always a worry when you're kind of at the front end in hospitality there. things like fresh fruits vegetables um meat um these are the things that generally you can't lock down prices um with your suppliers they are at the mercy of of of the world order and unfortunately it isn't just about the harvesting of the crops it is about the delivery you know so the supply uh and the delivery um which you know still i mean we do i'd say probably maybe about 25 % of our deliveries come on much more eco-friendly vehicles, either electric vehicles or hybrid vehicles and stuff.

8:00So I think it wouldn't have been as bad as potentially sort of five or 10 years ago. So I think, you know, some places that have thought ahead in terms of the bigger picture probably aren't as affected in terms of supply chains. But I mean, fuel, whether it be diesel or petrol, affects everybody. And as you say, it's not just filling up the pumps. It's everything that you spend is affected by that cost. Getting lots of people getting in touch already, talking about the UK's ability to refine. Nathan in Aberdeen says, if we had the infrastructure, we could refine crude and lower costs at a local level, but we can't do that anymore.

8:36Today, the UK imports over 50 % of its refined diesel. Compare that to 2002, when we had nine fully operational refineries and we're a completely energy independent net exporter. And who else? We've got Al in Aberdeenshire who says, why are we not discussing the government allowing the closure of Grangemouth when discussing diesel prices? Crazy green targets, the will to offshore UK emissions and a political blindness to Scotland have caused this. Grangemouth used to provide a significant quantity of UK diesel supply. Keep your thoughts coming this morning on this, on what you're seeing in your sector as well.

9:13George, do you think that what we're seeing makes the likelihood of North Sea drilling become more of a reality? Or is that less likely to happen because it's not a squeeze on oil as much at the moment? It is that refinery squeeze. Well, yes. So having said that, I don't know how governments react to some things. You know, sometimes it's the optics, sometimes it's the long term concerns. But right now, the problem we have is definitely more one of refining than it is of oil. Bloomberg suggests that, I saw an article yesterday, that 80 % of pre-war oil is going through or moves one way or another.

9:52Okay, everybody's scared. The price to get it out is higher because there might be attacks from Iran, but something is moving. Okay, it's not completely blocked. It's not the oil, it's refineries. Russian refineries are out of commission. A lot of these, Gulf refineries, a lot of them are out of commission. and in 2020 we closed down a lot of refineries because there was an oversupply back then. So refining margins, as they call them, they're at their all-time highs and that's why we're paying so much at the pump. We've had another message from someone who doesn't give their name who says, our tanks run on diesel.

10:27If our reserves are used, we become vulnerable. Which just shows the complexity of the situation. Shall we talk about a different kind of energy now? Another thing that might be pushing up costs for people or is very, very likely to be, Cornwall Insights, which is the consultancy that forecasts the energy price cap and does a pretty good job of it. It's predicted that after the 4 % increase that kicked in this week, we could see the price cap on energy bills for homes rise another 16 % for the first quarter of next year. Now, that would take annual bills for a typical dual fuel household to£1 ,999.

11:06£399. It'll be the largest rise since January 2023. Of course, I should always say when we talk about the price cap, it's very much a cap for the typical dual fuel household. If you use more, you pay more. If you use less, you'd pay less. Our Big Boss interview this week was with EDF's boss, Simone Rossi, and our business editor, Simon Jack. Ask what advice he'd have for people worried about their bills. We are all concerned about the fact that we're actually walking into a second significant energy crisis after the one we've experienced just four years ago. However, I'd like to distinguish two things in the bills that you mentioned, Simon.

11:46There are two components, electricity and gas. If you take the electricity component in the quarter four of this year that we are getting into right now, the price of electricity is still slightly lower than at the beginning of the year, like minus 4%. The gas price, however, has increased by 25%. So I'd like to say the first message is that if you can choose between using a little more electricity or a little more gas for your energy needs, privilege electricity, which is holding off much better to the pressure of the geopolitical situation. It's all very, very doomy, gloomy, worrying, isn't it?

12:27And Andy Burnham this week said the UK is facing an energy crisis, but refused to say if people will be offered more than the temporary VAT cut to help with rising energy bills. I suspect it's something people will be watching very, very closely for in the budget. Ian, where do energy costs rank in your overall business costs? What are you seeing? Oh, yeah. It's the monkey on my back. And it always feels like it, you know, for businesses and businesses such as ours, it always feels like this news always hits you as you're going into winter. You've got the long six months ahead where you've got to be really, really careful.

13:04I mean, you know, like domestic consumers, you can lock in prices. The difference with business contracts, there are mechanisms where they can rise within your agreed unit rate as well. So it doesn't give you sometimes the comfort that you might do if you've locked in prices, as you would with a domestic contract. So it is really, really hard because, you know, I mean, for businesses such as ours, there's absolutely no way that you want to go out to somewhere, a restaurant or a pub or a bar, where you're sat in the freezing cold, you're using energy all the time to cook, to heat the equipment.

13:44It's very, very, you know, the lighting. And essentially, you know, you cut back and you cut back. You know, there's a lot of places that obviously don't open at the start of the week because it isn't just about the staff that you pay or the hourly rate. You know, the energy costs now are front and centre in your variable costs, which are, you know, which are huge. And in some instances, it can be more than you rent. Yeah, we've had a message from Sue who says, I quite like this Sue, Sue in Portsmouth bought a ski suit at a car boot sale years ago. Best investment I ever made, wear it at home now, November to March.

14:19But Ian, I suppose, you know, people kind of going out, particularly as it gets closer to Christmas, people want to be out, you know, in their fancy little dresses. Maybe not the men so much, but you know, people don't want to be feeling chilly. while they're at the room looking good. No, it's about being cosy, isn't it, in pubs and stuff and you want to keep coming out of the cold and stuff. So unfortunately, you can't really, it's really, really tough because as you say, at home, you can put another jumper on, you can do whatever, but your venue being cold actually drives people away. It's one of those things where people sometimes say, you know, turn your heating off an hour before you close because you want people to leave when it starts to feel cold and stuff.

14:58Is that what they're doing? It is really, really tough. Right. George, I mean, this is what we mean when we talk about the world economy running on oil, isn't it? I mean, you know, it feeds in. Energy costs feed into almost every cost that we see. Yes. So it's your total supply chains. You know, it's your cars, it's your trucks, it's your clothes. Everything runs on oil. I mean, even, you know, remember, oil is necessary to create plastic. Okay, so everything is, and the question here is not what's happening now. The question is, have we reached the stage where this will last for, say, another 6 to 12 months, even if the debacle in Hormuz ends tomorrow?

15:50And we're getting there. We're getting there. The disruption is now bigger than the war itself. Okay, because think about it also in inflation terms. As you negotiate with your employer, which a lot of people did over the summer, and if you're expecting inflation, say, of 5 % or 7%, and your employer says, okay, your salary will rise by 2%, the answer is, well, I'm losing money, so I'll look for another job or at least get me what I think inflation will be. And some employers will buckle and then they will raise prices, even if the product is not directly related to oil. And that's how you begin a vicious circle of inflation.

16:34And we're getting there. Yeah, I don't think we're quite there yet, though. I mean, in terms of the labour market, for example, is not what we call as tight, as in there are more vacancies than there were in 2022 when we saw the really big gas price. spike when the we had uh putin's invasion of ukraine so i think i think the the bank of england and other central banks are obviously hyper aware of of that effect that george has just described happening but i think we have a few a few different situations situations now but obviously it is a it is a big risk that those those inflation um factors start to drive even things like wage increases.

17:21I mean, it's a very difficult situation. And we know that politically, when we look back, high inflation is really, really bad for the government in situ, because people see how difficult it is. And I think when we look back, historically, we can see high inflation in the UK, for example, can lead to political disruption, because people are just really unhappy about having to pay those extra high prices. Yes, and even when they're caused by global events, it puts a lot of pressure on domestic governments, doesn't it? And we've been seeing Andy Burnham this week at the Labour Party conference in Liverpool delivering his first speech as PM and perhaps trying to sound a bit more upbeat than maybe some of those concerns suggest.

18:11His speech went down a storm in the room. In the days since then, of course, people like us have been poring over what was said, what it might mean going forward. And among the big talking points, there were some very big talking points, weren't there? The triple lock, a new National Care Service leasehold reform. We've heard that many times. Brexit, water. Panel, what shall we tackle first? Shall we talk about the triple lock? Because since that was introduced in 2011, it is a policy that's seen the state pension rise by the highest of three. So the highest of inflation, average earnings or two and a half percent.

18:43Prime Minister said he's looking to change that. We promised in our manifesto to keep the triple lock unchanged throughout this Parliament. I will honour that promise. I will honour that promise. And I'll do more. I'll do more. That promise will take the state pension to a record high. From there, in April 2030, we will adjust it. The state pension will continue to rise every year at least by prices or 2.5%. And it will hold its value relative to earnings over time so that pensioners will always share in the rising prosperity of the nation. Well, 85058, I always want to hear your views on that.

19:41But George, a double lock, essentially, rather than a triple lock. How much of a difference could that make to the government's fiscal position? How much cash is that likely to make available? OK, so first of all, we need to understand that a lot of this doesn't come to pass until 2030. So he'd need to get reelected to enact it. So keep that in mind, because that means a lot of what we heard right now are just pledges. Now, the basic idea is to use that reform to fund national health care. The problem is that the gains from this, the earnings from this are backloaded. So in the beginning, it won't make as much as it would make, say, in 20, 25 years.

20:28Meanwhile, he wants to reform health care today. So he'd need to find the money somewhere. And since he committed not to borrow more, which makes absolute sense, by the way, if you see the state of the bond markets, especially these days, we're very near a global bond crisis, that means essentially taxes. And that is, you know, where most of the criticism has focused. If you don't borrow to fund this because you can, that means essentially this was also pledged to eventually raise taxes. And, you know, that's a consideration, especially in terms of financial planning. Anna, that's a good point, isn't it?

21:11There's some pretty worrying borrowing levels for governments around the world at the moment, but really pinching here in the UK. um yes um i would however point to to something which is um it's i agree that borrowing costs have risen a lot in the uk but i just thought it would be worthwhile reflecting that we are talking here about very long-term borrowing commitments when we if we move from a triple lock to a double lock so if we just move to it being the higher of 2.5 percent or price increases And when we're thinking about those long term borrowing needs of of the UK government, I think actually that the market in a strange way has slightly rewarded these ideas of of thinking about long term spending commitments, because it's not just about what you're spending and what you in the next year or two.

22:13It's about how willing investors are to lend to you over the long term. And what we have seen is that borrowing costs, they've gone up across the globe. This is a global issue, what we're seeing with oil prices and gas prices and all the refined products prices that we've just been talking about. But across the world, since the last sort of potential resolution in the Middle East, the UK borrowing cost is up 0.7 percent. The US is up nearly 1 % and France is up well over that 1.4%. These are all really sharp moves. But I think it shows that there is an element of the UK being slightly more rewarded this week for taking some what would potentially be long term decisions around reducing our long term liabilities.

23:02So I think whilst it's all still pretty uncomfortable, there is an element of reward. On the triple lock itself, what we would say is that, you know, when we do our own research, we have something called the savings and resilience barometer. And we do that annually. And whilst many everyday needs are covered by the state pension, what our survey shows is that only about 43 % of households are actually on track to have a more comfortable requirement where they can maintain their current standards of living. So we're already in a situation where the best way to prepare for your retirement is to start early and start investing in your pension as early as you can, because then you've got the luxury of time to be able to get those investment returns and have a more comfortable pension.

23:57Yes, that is. I mean, that is perhaps one of the swimming below the surface issues that's definitely becoming an increasing concern. Let's talk about something else that went down very, very well in the room when that speech was happening. One of the loudest cheers reserved for a statement of intent on the water industry. The centrepiece of that bill will be this, the repeal of Margaret Thatcher's ideological ban on public ownership of water companies. Oh, he gets them going, doesn't he? But yes, opening the door to public ownership then of our water companies. Ian, as a business owner, how frustrating do you find looking at the state of some of those kind of vital services like the water industry?

24:50Yeah, from a business perspective, you know, increasingly water is taking up a much, much bigger chunk of your overall outgoings for utilities. Seems, you know, there's always, always really, really heavy increases. as far as I'm aware you know again the rules for business and domestic supply are very very different but yeah I just think that it's such a potent issue water it feels like for everybody it's the one thing that you know people have got over the fact that you've got to pay for it but increasingly it's so expensive for people you know you do all the the economies we do all the savings you take baths less you have showers you know don't put the tap on when you brush your teeth but increasingly water is is is you know in terms of utilities even though they're all rising really really you know at such a fast rate unfortunately um water there there's something evocative you know gas and electric we've always had to pay for i think water it just really riles people up the wrong way and i do think that this is a really popular um direction of the government is going to go in because we're quite lucky in the North West where I am.

26:09It's not like the issues that are having with Thames Water and some of the other water companies, but it does feel that this would be a popular move for Burnham and you heard the response in the room there as well. I mean, it's starting to feel like wake up to no money this morning, isn't it, with water bills, fuel bills, cost of diesel. Shall we lighten things up and talk about Brexit? because Andy Burnham also reopened pretty much every door on the Brexit debate, said we should be open to potentially rejoining the EU. It divides listeners. It always does. Somebody who doesn't give their name messaged in while we were talking about the bond markets to say people think it's bad here.

26:50France is in a much worse position and we're thinking of going back to the European Union. And then that sort of shocked emoji face. George, the economic impact of Brexit then, have we seen it and could we undo it? And is there political appetite for that? Okay, so the question is, can you undo a divorce? You can remarry, but it's not quite the same thing. Economically speaking, we have seen below trend growth and a lot more friction. so you know an element of inflation especially when it comes to trading with with a continent also there have been impacts in specific sectors like hospitality or education okay where the impact is is much bigger having said that you can't go back not you not not in the uk i mean in general.

27:48One cannot go back to this. The UK before Brexit had the preeminent position and it sort of dictated financial policy across the union. Even if Europeans, who would be weary because they would say, okay, what happens if there is another government that wants Brexit? We can't keep doing this. Even if they were willing to take the UK back with open arms, It's very difficult to imagine that they would give the UK back its sort of preeminent position in dictating the financial policy and financial services policy for the union. So the UK would have to start at a different level. And there would be the open question of joining the euro itself because every new country now that joins the EU is also required to consider joining the euro.

28:43So there are these considerations. And as one of your viewers said it, who would you be negotiating with? Possibly an AFD coalition in Germany or a National Front coalition in France? So the situation is different across the channel too. I'm not saying, I think the best idea generally is to make sure that there is as less friction in trade as it is humanly possible. And joining a union is a political question rather than an economic one. Anna, what do you make of the reopening of the discussion? well I suppose if we're going to look at it from a market point of view and an economic point of view um there's not really much that we can there are no no concrete proposals that we can we can talk about or that we can price as it were different options which have very different implications um so I think the focus needs to remain now on on maintaining stability and as George says, a more amicable and positive frame of mind on both sides is obviously going to be quite a good thing.

29:59But there is so much yet that we don't know about any potential any potential rapprochement that we can't really we can't really make a sort of call about whether it would be a good thing for our economy or not. Ian, would it be a good thing for your economy? Would it make a difference to you? Has Brexit had any impact on the pub business? Yes, it has. Yeah. I mean, obviously, the hospitality industry in the UK was based on a European model, you know, of Barcelona and all those Paris, great European cities, outside drinking, late night dining. um so i mean certainly in liverpool where we're based um remember when brexit happened we had the european festival of business actually happening right at that point and it just felt like it was a huge huge wrench um liverpool was was reimagined um from all the investment that came from europe in the in the 90s and 2000s um and you know quite frankly the business model you know we were learning from what Europe did in the hospitality industry.

31:10I remember there was a, we had two French architects, I remember that were at the top of their game, that wanted to learn English. And they came over and worked as kitchen porters for the summer. And, you know, there was all these types of arrangements there, you know, and kind of vice versa. And it did feel like it was a real wrench. You know, we had a lot of people that returned to Europe, particularly that was tied in with the pandemic as well. So people left and they never returned. The skills were really hard to replace. And ultimately, I think it has been bad for tourism, for trade, certainly for prices, even supply chain things like fresh fruits.

31:47We're seeing stuff arrive and it actually barely lasts days now where before it was coming direct from Europe, I think stuff gets stored a lot more before with these interruptions and within the supply chain stuff. And I would be hugely, you know, however it works out, clearly it's not going to be a feet first, jumping back into bed. But I think, you know, that associate membership that Canada potentially looking at, that's something along those lines where we start to see frictionalist trade, full alignment. You know, as George said, the political question is something completely different. But I think a move towards then, I mean, we've certainly, the mood music definitely seems to have changed in the last 18 months.

32:32I think people are realising that in terms of prosperity and stuff, we've got to look towards Europe. We can't just be ignoring our closest neighbours. You're talking about not jumping back into bed. George is talking about remarrying after divorce. Who hurt you two? Right, we are going to go late to the news now. But that has been an absolutely fascinating discussion in the first half of Wake Up To Money. Thank you so much, Ian Hoskins, Hoskins, owner of MarPub Group in Liverpool. Thank you, Anna MacDonald, Investment Strategy Director at Hargreaves Lansdowne. Stick around, drink some tea, lots more to talk about.

33:05George, this is where we let you crack on with your Friday. Thank you so much for being with us again on Wake Up To Money. Thank you very much. Have a nice day. Thank you. And you, George Lagarias there, Chief Economist at the Consultancy for this Mazars. Oh, loads of you getting in touch on lots of different stories. Let's really, really quickly have one from Mike on X who says, Hi, Felicity Panel. Diesel has been£199.99 a litre at my local for about three weeks now. I've also seen it at£2.01 a litre in Brum. It's probably a lot more in motorway service stations. Yes, yes, it is. The RAC figures show that the average motorway service area diesel right now is£2.16.78, so just below£2.17.

33:44And I've definitely seen it higher than that. Wake Up To Money with Felicity Hanna. Good morning. If you're just joining us on Wake Up To Money, then welcome and welcome to Friday and welcome to. You'll feel like we're kind of back in 2016. We're having a big discussion about Brexit because, well, because Andy Burnham sort of reopened the door to that conversation again at the Labour conference this week. As you would expect, Wake Up To Money listeners have views. One person who doesn't give their name says, stuff Europe. We must never go back and be ruled by oligarchs. Anne says the government would do better to address why the Brexit vote was made in the first place and focus on agriculture and fishing and energy ahead because it's needed, isn't it?

34:25And somebody else says Labour promised to reduce energy bills by£300, or was it£400, in the run-up to the general election. Most of us said it wouldn't happen. It didn't happen. Energy bills have increased significantly. Keep your thoughts coming this morning. 85058 if you want to drop me a text on WhatsApp. It's 08085 909693. If you're on social media, use the hashtag WakeUpToMoney. Want to hear your thoughts on that, on all of it, and on this, the story that has dominated the headlines front and back pages of the newspapers this week. The enormous news that Manchester City had been found guilty of more than 100 charges relating to breaches of the Premier League's financial rules.

35:08City have repeatedly denied guilt. They've signalled that they intend to lodge an appeal. We know that today is the deadline for that. It's expected the club is going to say that key sponsorship deals were funded by the Abu Dhabi government rather than the club's owners. Now, the fallout, it goes beyond football, doesn't it? HMRC has been urged by the Treasury Committee to scrutinise any tax implications of the case, and it's potentially affecting financial services as well. Let's talk to Paul Gilroy Casey, who's barrister at Nine Chambers in Manchester and Littleton Chambers in London. Paul, you're a specialist in sports law.

35:45I bet everyone you know has been cornering you this week to ask about this. Good morning. Good morning. It's been very busy. What do you make then of, I mean, we can't litigate this, can we? I'm going to ask you what you make of City's proposed defence, but obviously we will have to see what appeal they lodge. We will have to see what the outcome of that is. but it is interesting. They are kind of coming out quite robustly. Extremely. I don't know if you heard the statement made by the chief executive in the wake of the verdict. I think he made a statement this week. It was actually a video that was leaked.

36:25It was a video to staff to reassure them about the position in the light of the commission's determination. But yes, they're absolutely adamant. And I think it's important, as you've already said, it's important we acknowledge that there is an appeal process going to take place. And even beyond that, it's likely, in my opinion, that the club will take the matter further. So they won't simply rely on the Premier League process. I think we're going to see the High Court involved. And how will an appeal work, though? When might we find out the outcome of that? The answer to that question is very much affected by the inordinate amount of time it's taken for this hearing, rather this verdict to come out.

37:12This matter was heard in September 2024. Now, the Premier League rules say it's a matter of 12 weeks to determine an appeal, usually. I can't see that happening. It should be capable of being dealt with in 12 weeks because the issues are much smaller on an appeal because you have points of appeal rather than having a full rehearing of the whole case. Now, looking at the Times business pages headline this morning, I've mentioned HMRC has been urged to take a look at this. Times reporting that BDO could potentially face an inquiry because they audited Man City. Now, BDO has told the Times it's bound by confidentiality and it can't comment.

37:54But when you look at this story, it's potentially going to potentially involve HMRC. It's potentially going to cause BDO a headache. It's even actually caused a headache for the prime minister this week because of some of his comments. I mean, the fallout, if this appeal fails, could be absolutely enormous. The tributaries that feed off the mainstream here are beyond comprehension. You've mentioned a few of them. There are others. What happens to compensation claims against the club arising from this if the verdict stands? What about the liability of individuals? All of the individuals who are involved in this would be deemed to be participants under the FA rules.

38:38That means the FA could take action. There could be insurance implications. Absolutely vast topic. We could talk about it all day. We could talk about it all day. But presumably the Premier League, I mean, the whole situation is kind of unbelievable, really, isn't it? Because this is the Premier League's golden goose and they're the ones that have spearheaded this investigation. I assume that they're going to want to get this over with quickly. You would think so. They've spent an absolute fortune on this in terms of general resources and in particular legal costs. And they are in a very difficult, unusual situation because they are the regulator.

39:18So they are the prosecutor. But they're also effectively the club, the overall association that this football club is a constituent member of. And effectively, the club is contributing to the pot that enables the Premier League to conduct its functions, including this. What are, and I know there's been a huge amount of speculation. In fact, I was on drive when this story broke last Friday. So I know the speculation has been going on a while, but what are the possible penalties here? Well, the rules actually say, they're stipulated in the Premier League rules. They specify a full range of sanctions.

40:00It starts with a reprimand. It goes all the way through to the most serious consequences. But the most important paragraph in the rule says, something like, this is the gist of it, such other penalty as the Commission deems fit. So Pandora's box opens and the full range of penalties are available. We're looking at points deductions almost certainly, probably points deductions that would definitely condemn City to relegation, rather than saying you're relegated, saying here's a 75 point deduction. We could be talking about points deductions that apply in different seasons. I've heard commentators saying that the panel can't expel City.

40:43We have to go to a vote of the Premier League clubs. I'm not entirely convinced about that because of the provision I've mentioned, which gives the Commission power to do pretty much anything it deems appropriate to meet the justice of the case. If the appeal fails, and we just don't know what's going to happen next, do we? But if the appeal fails, what do you think could be worse for City in this situation? Whatever penalties they get hit with or the potential fallout, the risk of other clubs suing, the risk of sponsorship being affected? Sponsorship massively affected, although the further complication there is the very case itself involved allegations concerning the sponsorship.

41:35the sponsorship that came from Abu Dhabi and Abu Dhabi-related companies. There could even be a total meltdown situation whereby the owners and directors test is looked at, either by the Premier League, the Football Association or the independent football regulator. Each of them can take action mid-season. They normally do it every season, but they can take action mid-season if, in fact, the circumstances dictate that it's appropriate. The only question would be, would they take action now? Would they take action after the appeal fails, if it fails? Or would they wait to see what further challenges come in from Manchester City to challenge this entire process?

42:24Paul Gilroy, so much we don't know, but you've made it so much clearer for us. Thank you very much for being with us on Wake Up To Money this morning. Pleasure. Paul Gilroy Casey there, barrister at Nine Chambers in Manchester and Littleton Chambers in London. Still with me is Ian Hoskins, owner of Mar Pub Group in Liverpool. Ian, this is a financial story. This is a football story. This is a business story. This is also a fan story for the Man City fans and other clubs. You're a Liverpool fan. What's your reaction? Bewilderment, really. of how this has happened. And just listening, you know, you get a sense sometimes of what the fallout is.

43:07But even just listening to that then, you think, God, where does this end and where do the repercussions end? And the credibility for top clubs that have, you know, this complex financing structure behind them, it's just completely bewildering. And, you know, for the, I almost hate to say it, the club that sits at the top currently of our Premier League table, you know, is imminently faced with relegation because of, you know, I mean, it's a scandal of the highest order. It's just bewildering. And potentially looking back at a decade of football and saying, and then they woke up and it was all a dream.

43:49Take back the cups, yeah. I'm sure, I'm very sure that we will keep talking about this on Wake Up To Money and very, very much on Five Live as the story develops. Speaking of stories developing, loads of you contacting us about Brexit. And as always, some completely different views. Paul in Liverpool says, morning, Brexit has been a complete and utter failure. I've always believed in safety in numbers, leaving left us exposed and weaker. Can't think of any benefits. Candy says Brexit has been a disaster for this country. Can anyone point to a positive benefit? It's reduced our GDP, our influence in Europe and the wider world and made us poorer financially and culturally.

44:26And somebody else who doesn't give their name says people voted for Brexit for various reasons, some of which had nothing to do with the economy and everything to do with sovereignty. That hasn't changed. Labour keeps bragging we're the fastest growing economy in the G7, which hardly supports the argument that Brexit has damaged the UK so heavily. Either we're doing well or we're doing badly. It can't change according to the argument. Thank you very much for your thoughts. There is still time, another 10 minutes. Keep your thoughts coming, 85058. Now, also still with me this morning, Anna MacDonald, Investment Strategy Director at Hargreaves Lansdowne.

44:59Anna, I want to talk about Palantir. It's on the front page of the FT this morning that the UK government is reportedly looking for a British alternative to the US Software and Defence Group, which has become really quite controversial for a lot of people. It provides services to the NHS and the Ministry of Defence. How key is it to our public services? And are there British companies that could provide alternative services? Well, Palantir won the contract in 2023 from NHS England, and that would have been part of a process of looking for different companies that could perform these services for the NHS.

45:45And the point of it is to make the NHS work more efficiently and effectively. Now, it would be lovely if we had had a British provider of this and then we could have kept those revenues in the UK. However, there just wasn't the availability of a company that could be quite so effective. So, yes, there were some UK companies considered, but they didn't win the contract. So presumably that would have been on an effectiveness and efficiency basis. So as far as I understand it, no decisions have yet been taken around whether this contract will be renewed next year. So I think we do need to have a competitive process around this.

46:40And if there are companies that can then perform and they are British, that's all well and good. But we need to make sure that we are using the best kind of technologies at the best price in order to deliver really good tax efficient services for the NHS, which is just an enormous, enormous beast, as it were, that you need to manage. It's one of the biggest employers in the world. It's it's it's it's an incredible organization. And so far, it seems like the efficiencies are starting to be brought by the use of Palantir's system. If another company can do it based in the UK, that would be fantastic.

47:25But it's not yet become apparent which company that would be. Thank you very much indeed. OK, let's talk about the latest and perhaps a more unusual little known AI controversy that has flashed into the spotlight. School photographers have noticed a new trend among parents, which is using artificial intelligence tools to remove watermarks from digital proofs instead of them paying for the photographs. I have actually seen parents in my school WhatsApp groups talking about exactly this. It is stealing someone's work. That doesn't stop parents sharing what many simply see as a handy money saving tip when times are tight.

48:04Let's talk to Victoria Welton, who's a school and wedding photographer based in Somerset. Victoria, good morning. Good morning, Felicity. Are you hearing about parents doing this? I actually belong to a group of photographers who are volume photographers who are aware of digital theft and copyright infringement. And as a result of this, we're getting more and more posts in this group stating that these parents are doing this because there are other groups. this is this is the thing about Facebook there are groups where where people are going in and saying can you remove this watermark for me and then all of a sudden people are starting to realize that AI can do it for them we've had to change how you approach this in the past haven't I remember when um when my children were very very little they would bring home a pack of photographs and then you'd pay if you wanted to keep them but then people of course started using their fantastic phone cameras to just take the photo of the photo.

49:03So then it became coming home with a watermark. And now if parents are getting around that by using AI, do you perhaps have to stop sending home beautiful copies of the photographs? Maybe send rubbishy photocopies? That's a good question. I do digital because I think it's just more convenient for the parents. I mean, we're all living in a digital age now where the parents can go online and have a look. And luckily, I use a really good platform called Picks for Schools where the parent can sign in to see the picture, but it's very protected from AI. There's a moving bar that goes up and down the image.

49:43There's a big copyright protection legal notice underneath. And if you try and screenshot it, it also does another warning at you. So the parents can still see the image, but not the full image at any one time, if that makes sense. Do you think parents realise when they're doing it? As I say, the parents I've seen talking about this, that they're talking about it like a money saving tip. Do you think that they realise that they're potentially violating somebody's copyright? it? I think maybe some people do, but I think the majority probably don't understand that this is actually the livelihood of a photographer.

50:18You know, they're not going out there and just charging£20 or whatever it is for a download and just pocketing that money. You know, if they are offering digital downloads, they are not able to make any further money from that image. So the parent can take that photograph and use it wherever they want to, whether it be on a print, on a mouse mat, a mug, whatever it might be. And then that's theirs to do what they will with. But at the end of the day, when I go into schools, I'm not charging the school. I only make money if parents purchase an image. How does it work? Does the school just simply make you available to parents?

50:57Or does the school take a bit of what you make from it? I've always wondered how the sort of business behind the scenes work. yeah so I offer various packages to schools and it's up to them which one they take some of them we agree a commission so they get a percentage of the income that I make from the images that are sold other schools I provide them a benefit you know a support service where I either photograph their nativity and they the parents can then purchase downloads for a couple of pounds and all that profit goes to the school's PTA. That's what I do with a number of the schools where I work.

51:36And that's the benefit of being an independent. If I work for a larger firm, then I couldn't call my shots, excuse the pun, and decide what I want to do to help those schools. And I do help all the schools where I live. I make sure that I'm available to them to do benefit. I mean, I photograph things like their colour runs. And again, the parents purchase some downloads and the profits again go to the school. So I'm very aware that a lot of these schools need support with their financial situations in the form of their PTAs because they're always trying to raise funds. And I try and support that where I can.

52:11Now, no one could listen to this and think that you've got an easy job. Making 60 kids smile beautifully in a morning, I'm sure, is unimaginably difficult. But we've had a message on Blue Sky from somebody whose username is Mr. Snowdes, who says, I hope you're going to touch on the scandal that is massively overpriced firms having the contract sewn up for years, certainly in my area. And I think that a lot of people do feel this. Perhaps some parents who are doing this feel like they're fighting back against what can be really, really high prices. I mean, I know some firms do charge a lot of money for a digital download.

52:50You know, I'm a small business owner. I'm not a multinational corporation. I've invested thousands of pounds in equipment. I have overheads like any other business. And I think I'm entitled to charge for my time, my expertise and the product I'm creating for somebody who can keep something, not just like a cup of coffee for five, 10 minutes, that that image will stay with them for years and years and years. My mum still puts my school photographs up, you know, and you can probably see dinosaurs in the background. That's how old it is. But at the end of the day, I still go to our house. I see that school photograph and it's lasted since, you know, for 40 years.

53:26I'm keeping all of mine just to have my revenge on my children when they bring home romantic partners. Briefly then, if you can, because we're almost at the end of the programme, do you think that school photographers are going to have to change how they manage this to stop this from happening? I think they're going to have to tighten up what they do. I know that there are some platforms still who don't offer the level of security that the one I use does. And, you know, it may very well that we land up going back to these small, tiny digital, sorry, small proof cards where the image is tiny and they go home with the parents.

54:00That may have to come back in. I mean, I'd rather not print off loads of paper. Yes. Victoria Welton, thank you so much for joining us, a school and wedding photographer based in Somerset. Thank you very much indeed. Ian Hoskins from Marr Pub Group in Liverpool. Thank you. Anna MacDonald from Hargreaves, Lansdowne. Thank you. One more message. Joe says the PM should stay out of the Man City situation. What does he know? He's an Everton fan. That's it for Wake Up To Money. This is the football story of the century. It's pandemonium. It's ecstasy. It's an authoritarian regime. For the past 15 years, English football has been dominated by Manchester City.

54:34They are champions again, but not only that. They've won it four years running and no one's done that. Ever. Then the Premier League dropped a bombshell. The Premier League has charged Manchester City with more than 100 breaches of its financial rules following a four-year investigation. Somebody turned up at the Etihad Stadium and effectively served papers. Hear in-depth analysis and explanation on Football on Triumph. The Manchester City Charges. Listen on BBC Sounds.

55:24com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range, self-directed investing, or perhaps you pick up a few farm-fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management.

55:54Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more.

From the publisher

Felicity Hannah looks at how AI tools are putting school photography businesses at risk. Elsewhere, we dig into a week of political announcements and pressure at the pumps with our expert panel. And today marks the last day Manchester City can appeal against its more than 100 charges of breaching Premier League financial rules.

More from Wake Up to Money

All episodes