

A “Wake Up To Money” episode focused on Halloween spending and how households and businesses are coping with the cost of living, alongside major news: the Binance crypto heist, the UK budget’s impact on living standards and hospitality, AI spending by US tech firms, and new UK workplace-rights rules for unions and harassment protections.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on how Halloween affects spending in the hospitality sector.
“Joining us is Freddie Cahoon, investment director at JM Finn.”
Breaking news about a major security breach affecting Binance.
“Are you going big for Halloween this weekend?”
Experts discuss the broader implications of the Binance hack on the crypto market.
“The crypto exchange, Binance, which is the world's biggest, as we've said, says about half of those assets that have been affected have been frozen with the help of other platforms.”
Experts analyze the recent budget and its implications for the hospitality industry.
“But crypto, I think it's an interesting sector.”
Discussion on the historical context of living standards in relation to the current economic situation.
“We find ourselves in the 9 % of hospitality venues that are on the hook for every single penny.”
Discussion on the Chancellor's recent budget measures and their effectiveness.
“Opposition parties pointed out that there was one big item missing from the budget, the country's welfare bill on course to reach£431 billion by 2032.”
Analysis of changing consumer behavior and spending habits amid economic pressure.
“is probably not going to be enough, as we've seen, to restore people's disposable incomes.”
Examining the implications of rising welfare bills on economic growth.
“But that question of welfare, the scale of the UK's welfare spending does look huge on paper, doesn't it?”
Overview of recent performances of major tech companies and the role of AI.
“the budget until six o 'clock, couldn't we?”
Discussion on how AI can improve efficiency in hospitality without job losses.
“All I hope AI does is allows our managers in the venues to be more efficient, to allow them spend more time with the guests, more time on the experience and more time with their staff.”
Listeners share their opinions on recent budget changes and their impacts.
“Linda, this is where we let you crack on with your Friday.”
Discussion on listener thoughts regarding Halloween spending and its implications.
“If you're just joining us, then welcome to Wake Up To Money.”
Exploration of recent changes to workers' rights and union access in workplaces.
“And Nick in Wokingham says, Healy was constrained by£3 trillion of national debt.”
Debate between union representatives and employers on the impact of unions.
“I mean, there's absolutely loads to talk about.”
Explore the dynamics of trade unions and their impact on workers' rights.
“Nicola, I'm going to let you respond to that.”
Discuss the new obligations on employers regarding workplace harassment.
“I have to interrupt because there's a huge amount that we need to get through and we just won't if we spend all our time on this.”
Learn how farms adapt to challenges and create new revenue opportunities.
“Thank you all very much indeed for your views on that this morning.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Wake Up to Money, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing, or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, You can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place.
1:05Visit schwab.com to learn more. Wake Up To Money from BBC5 Live.
1:13Felicity Hannah: Hello, welcome to Wake Up To Money, potentially the largest hack in history. Binance and the$6.3 billion crypto heist. we will tell you everything you need to know. And then another big number,$500 billion. That is how much Google's parent company dropped in value yesterday as investors get the AI jitters. Then after a busy budget week, a lot of people might be planning to have a drink this weekend.
1:44Felicity Hannah: That's actually the sound of John Healy downing a pint in a Westminster pub following his speech in the House of Commons. We will bring the latest analysis on the budget, what it means for you, what it means for business. And it's Halloween this weekend. So how about some smashing pumpkins? And I don't mean the band. Wake Up To Money with Felicity Hanna. Very good morning to you. Welcome to Wake Up To Money. Welcome to Friday. It's the 30th of October. It's four minutes past five. It's going to be a busy one. Let's say hello straight away to our expert panel this morning. I'm joined by Louise McLean, director at Signature Group, which has more than 20 venues in Scotland, including pubs, restaurants, hotels.
2:24Felicity Hannah: Louise, good morning. Good morning. Joining us is Freddie Cahoon, investment director at JM Finn. Morning, Freddie. Morning, Fless. And Linda Yu, economist at Oxford University and London Business School. Hello. Hi, morning. I feel like I always try to bring some energy to wake up to money, but I'm properly excited this weekend because we're talking Halloween at the end of the programme. And I really, really enjoy that. And Louise, I was wondering about you because Halloween coming on a Saturday, that's got to be good for a lot of hospitality this year. That's got to be the kind of thing that gets a lot of people out, having a drink, dressed up, feeling a sense of occasion.
2:59Felicity Hannah: Yes. Anything that brings people out, I am all for. I was actually out last night and there was lots of vampires and witches wandering around Edinburgh. So it's not so much Halloween, it's Halloweek. Halloweek. I love it. I love it. And as someone who used to be a goth in Edinburgh, I think I looked that way all the time years and years ago. Freddie, it's a good point, isn't it? Halloween, events like that, they can really, really increase how people spend at a time of year when, you know, let's face it, kind of a windy, rainy October is not necessarily getting people flooding to the shops. Yeah, absolutely.
3:35And also London was incredibly busy last night. There are lots of Halloween costumes around the West End and further out too. And, you know, I think people don't need another excuse to spend more money in today's world. And, you know, Halloween is always a very special, special time, particularly for the kids. And I know my kids are very excited about it.
3:53Felicity Hannah: Well, are you having a Halloweek? Are you going big for Halloween this weekend? Are you decorating your house? Are you, I don't know, filling up with sweets ready for Freddie's kids to come knocking at the door? Get in touch. Let me know. You can text me on 85058. You can send me a WhatsApp message on 08085 909693. And if you're on social media, use the hashtag WakeUpToMoney. And I will keep an eye on that. Charlie has already been in touch on social media to say that they're out of tea lights, which made him think that IKEA sales of them must soar at this time of the year. That's his tuppence, he says.
4:27Felicity Hannah: And Rachel says, one of my near neighbours has out a huge cobweb and spider on her house. Those have been everywhere this year, actually. I've seen an absolute plague of those giant spiders. Get in touch. Let me know your Halloween spending. You are also allowed to get in touch with your thoughts on this week's budget, on the big news of the week. But let's start with the big news of the morning, which is that the world's largest crypto trading exchange, Binance, has suffered a major security breach. Analysts say it could be the biggest ever cryptocurrency heist. The company has suspended transactions.
5:02Felicity Hannah: It does say that users' funds are safe and that no one will be out of pocket. One unconfirmed report suggests that North Korean hackers could be responsible. Let's get the latest on this. Here's our North American technology correspondent, Lily Jumaoli. Binance estimates that hackers targeted approximately$6.3 billion worth of cryptocurrency, adding that it has worked with partners to freeze affected assets, as much as$3 billion so far. It said an initial investigation suggested the incident may have stemmed from the compromised laptop of one of its engineers, with an outside attacker possibly using it to submit unauthorized transactions.
5:42Like Binance, the digital stablecoin firms Tether and Circle said they too had blocked customers from pulling billions of dollars from their accounts. Binance said it continued to investigate and that users would not have to bear the cost of any losses.
5:56Felicity Hannah: North America technology correspondent Lily Jamali there. Freddie, I mean, this is big news, breaking news happening overnight. The crypto exchange, Binance, which is the world's biggest, as we've said, says about half of those assets that have been affected have been frozen with the help of other platforms. And it says it will cover all losses. But if you look at the news article on BBC website on this, early checks show the incident may have involved an engineer's laptop that had been compromised. I mean, this is a really, really extraordinarily large event. Yeah, absolutely. And to put it into context, you know, Binance look after$140 billion of assets.
6:38So, you know, it's not an insignificant figure at all when looking at the total amount of assets on the platform. I mean, this is an IT department's nightmare. This is the one way that, you know, IT teams just don't want to get hacked is on an employee's laptop. When they're out of the office, for example, it's the sort of highest risk exposure you could have. And as you said, it's a breaking story. But, you know, these trading platforms, particularly around crypto, are the number one targets for hackers. And, you know, this rather sort of strange name of this attacker's group, apparently called Trader Traitor, tells you everything about the type of people trying to get into these platforms.
7:18Felicity Hannah: Linda, Bitcoin dropped by more than 4 % following this news. The price of other major cryptocurrencies, including Ethereum and Solana, also fell sharply. Do you think that this has the scope to spill out more widely, to have an effect beyond the crypto world? I think it probably will remind everybody how cybersecurity is a real vulnerability. So I say that because you might recall a couple of weeks ago, there was a website vulnerability, something called PHP, which caused the government's cyber institute to actually alert charities and actually smaller organizations who may not have the same monitoring as larger ones that there was this to patch basically because they were potentially at risk.
8:07So I think it does remind us that this is one of the hardest areas. But crypto, I think it's an interesting sector. Do I think it will affect crypto's popularity? I think that has always been much harder to call. I think some have always thought that crypto, for instance, you mentioned, you know, Bitcoin is more secure because it's secured on blockchain. Obviously, trading platforms are a different kind of thing. So I think those who are reluctant will be just as reluctant. Those who are fans probably, I don't know that this will have a lasting impact.
8:44Felicity Hannah: Well, 85058, if you want to share your views on that, maybe if you're somebody who's been affected by that hack, get in touch. Let me know your thoughts. But let's start our budget look back with a bit more lighthearted than normal, maybe. Let's talk about pubs and a little taste of Wednesday evening.
9:12Felicity Hannah: I mean it's cheerful if nothing else that was the sound of John Healy downing a pint in one on Wednesday evening celebrating delivering his first budget as recorded by down the pub by his exchequer secretary Dan Tomlinson the beer he chose naturally chancellor's choice not everybody in the pub industry has been welcoming that. In fact, some of the front pages this morning are some fairly scathing publicans because, of course, in the budget, Mr Healy increased alcohol duty in line with inflation, which adds around two pence to the tax on a pint of beer. The business rates relief threshold was raised to£18 ,000 from£12 ,000.
9:56Felicity Hannah: Remember, of course, that in his first week as Prime Minister Andy Burnham reassured pubs, The cavalry was coming, announcing a 20 % cut to their business rates from next year. He described that as a first step to supporting the hospitality industry. Louise, director at Signature Group, do you feel supported? Oh, good Lord, no. I haven't felt supported in about, gosh, certainly since before the pandemic. No, no, no. There is no cavalry. There is no support is coming. And I think the sector have realised that now. I think we were very, very hopeful that Andy Burnham was going to deliver support for the sector.
10:38And we were incredibly disappointed with the budget. And seeing the Chancellor downing a pint was just tone deaf.
10:49Felicity Hannah: He did, of course, do some things to support smaller scale brewers. There was some positive action for the industry more specifically in the budget. And I suppose, does it hurt your sector to see the Chancellor clearly a bloke who enjoys a pint? Anyone that enjoys a pint, I absolutely herald. But it was really, really disappointing. Business rates, it needs an entire overhaul. We don't just need a threshold raised or reduced. The entire methodology needs looked at. It will support a very, very small group of people. We needed the VAT cut. And I think we had been very loud about how much we needed the VAT cut and what benefit that could give to the sector.
11:43And with minimum wage rising. You know, some people in our, certainly in our team now, will now be in Scotland, remember it's slightly different. Some of our team will now be in the higher rate tax bracket.
11:58Felicity Hannah: Okay, what about the help that was there? So from April next year, the rateable value threshold for small business rates relief in England, and I appreciate that, that's England, is going up to 18 ,000. So there'll be about 3 ,500 pubs, about one in 10 in England, will be exempt then from paying business rates altogether. Nobody can deny that is a good measure. Because I suppose my question is, how far would you want the Chancellor to go to support your sector? Because Chancellors could always do more, couldn't they? But they can't actually afford to always do more. Correct. And I think that's the main point.
12:38Let's be honest. This is about affordability and what the country can afford. Just to put it into context, our smallest pub, our rateable value is 51 ,000 is the threshold in Scotland. And our smallest pub is 58. So we're, and that is literally our smallest venue. So from 18 to 58, it must be very, very, very small, small venues that are seeing this rate relief. And as you say, it's a very, very small, small number. I mean, our rate bill as a business is 1.8, 1.6 million is what we pay in rates. We get not one penny relief. We find ourselves in the 9 % of hospitality venues that are on the hook for every single penny.
13:28And that's crushing.
13:31Felicity Hannah: Would you serve the Chancellor if he walked into one of your venues and asked for a pint of his favourite tipple? Of course I would, as long as he was well behaved, as long as he was not intoxicated and was polite to our staff. Of course I would. OK, well, let's talk about the budget more widely. Thank you so much for your insights there. But it was pitched as a breathing space budget for household finances. I know the leader of the opposition called it more of a breathing space budget for the Chancellor because perhaps it wasn't as massive as people had expected or potentially hoped. But the Chancellor said he hoped that the measures he outlined would address the cost of living and ease pressures.
14:12Felicity Hannah: He said that the government couldn't remove those pressures completely. And yesterday, of course, the Independent Institute for Fiscal Studies warned the next decade could be the worst for growth in household incomes on record. The chief of the country's official fiscal watchdog, the Office for Budget Responsibility, described the economic outlook as a pretty grim picture. Now, to put today's stalled living standards into historical perspective, Olly Dalbertson, Rob Dalbertson from my team, has been looking at how living standards have changed over time. Strikes, power cuts and inflation approaching 27%.
14:51The 1970s brought economic turmoil and drastic action from Prime Minister Edward Heath. We are limiting the use of electricity by almost all factories, shops and offices to three days a week. By the mid-80s, inflation was down to 4 % and rising wages gave many households more to spend on cars, foreign holidays and household appliances.
15:16Felicity Hannah: It's just perfect. Can we afford it? Everyone's going to be so jealous. The new advanced high-powered compact cleaners from Hoover. Despite recession in the early 90s, the longer-term rise in living standards continued. Home ownership in Britain climbed from around 50 % in 1980 to 68 % in 1991. Then, in 2008, the pattern broke. Meltdown on the markets as Wall Street is left reeling from some of the biggest blows in its history. Thousands of Lehman Brothers staff here and in the US are likely to lose their jobs. Wages stagnated Productivity growth weakened And years of austerity followed Then, Covid disrupted supply chains And Russia's invasion of Ukraine drove up food and energy prices Inflation topped out at 11 % in 2022 Squeezing household budgets even more And just as the British people helped support our banks 20 years ago It is our banks that will help give families breathing space today Breathing space now while taking the long-term action to get costs down for good.
16:34Real incomes for working-age families in Britain roughly doubled in the four decades before the 2008 crash. At the much slower pace of growth since then, another doubling would take around 140 years. For many families, the expectation of becoming significantly better off than their parents now feels much less certain.
16:56Felicity Hannah: Olly Dalbert-Anson there with some quite exciting music. Opposition parties pointed out that there was one big item missing from the budget, the country's welfare bill on course to reach£431 billion by 2032. But yesterday, the Chancellor told the BBC there would be a reduction in benefits. There will be a reduction in the benefits bill. will do that in a Labour way. And we will do that because it is simply not good for Britain or progressive to have a bigger and bigger benefits bill. Well, the Treasury disputed that the Chancellor had committed to reducing it before the next election. And Downing Street has said the government is not setting a target or a timetable for when the welfare bill will fall.
17:41Felicity Hannah: And of course, we've got a couple of reviews coming before the end of the year that might shape some views on things like PIP. Linda what did you make listening to my colleague Ollie's sort of summary there of changing living standards what did you make of what the Chancellor outlined for households and how households are likely to be feeling? I think they're going to continue to feel squeezed because the measure of essentially disposable income how much money people have left in their pockets at the end of the month that that i think is is the kind of the concrete version of the standard of living so just to give you um just a sense of um what it means um in real terms um money terms so if we just use simple numbers before the global financial crisis um it was around probably between two and two and a half percent is how much your um per your income on average would have grown.
18:43If you just take a round number like two, 70 divided by two means your income doubles every 35 years, which is roughly speaking what he mentioned in his package. Now that is a less than half a percent. So let's just use 1 % for mathematical ease. That means that your income would double in 70 years. So he mentioned there are over 100 years, which is probably more accurate, but just to give you a sense of how much it's actually dropped. So basically within your lifetime, your income could double versus, you know, a couple of times. So what did the Chancellor do? I think the cost of living measures that he did announce, there were actually something like 98 different measures that appeared in the Treasury scorecard, either to raise taxes, because that is the fiscal rule.
19:27If you want to spend something, you need to raise taxes to pay for it within and preserve a headroom to meet that rule. I mean, 98 measures, Fliss, most of which are around a billion. So these are not major, but they could make a real impact. So for instance, the VAT cut on electricity bills that will be extended to July that takes 50 quid off of the annual price cap on energy, which has increased and is going to increase more in January because of energy prices globally. But these cost of living support, I think, is probably not going to be enough, as we've seen, to restore people's disposable incomes.
20:11And the challenge to the Chancellor is, because he is constrained, they do need a growth plan with a spending review behind it to really take a decision on where can they invest to grow the economy, because that's the only thing that's really going to get people's disposable incomes up. But that does require investment. And we didn't get that in this budget. It just, I think, came slightly too soon, given that they still need to set out their 10-year growth strategy.
20:43Felicity Hannah: Freddie, we've had Linda's review. We've had the view from Louise as well. How would you mark the Chancellor's homework this week? Well, I think the first thing that they wanted to avoid was anything related to the Liz Trust mini budget. So they had to show... It looms large, doesn't it? Yeah, it still does, unfortunately. They had to show fiscal responsibility and they are in a bit of a straight jacket. So ultimately, they have done a lot of tinkering around the sides and have made a lot of positive noise about trying to help people through what's going to be a very difficult winter. But it is going to be small scale, ultimately, and people will still feel the pinch.
21:25Not only do we have the energy price cap increasing in January by quite a considerable amount. You know, you then have the impacts of ongoing inflation on how you actually feel overall with regards to when you look at your earnings. Inflation is going to touch nearly 4 % next year. And then, of course, you've got the fiscal drag effect as well of frozen personal allowance on your earnings. And then also those people earning a bit more get dragged into higher rates of tax as well. So your take home pay is going to be feeling as if it's sort of flatlining, I would have thought, as we go through next year and even into 2028.
22:04So it's a tough backdrop for people.
22:07Felicity Hannah: Louise, do you see how people are feeling reflected in how much they're spending when they do come out? I mean, do you see people sort of dropping off and socialising in your venues less or are they perhaps spending differently when they're there? Both, actually. Yes, people are going out less. We know that when the trips out are in decline. as a hospitality operator what we have to do is make sure that when customers are coming out they're choosing our venues. Going out is not, it doesn't matter if you've got vouchers or whatever you know going out is no longer cheap I guess you know it is a treat and what we're seeing is that when people are going out they're going out out so that when people are coming out their spend is good, their dwell time is increasing.
22:57People almost are like, you know what, I'm out? I'm going to really enjoy myself, which is great, but it does make trips. Out of home experiences are in decline and that's just due to affordability.
23:12Felicity Hannah: Well, is that you? Are you going out-out when you do go out or are you staying in more when you used to go out? 85058. Get your thoughts out this morning. Share them with me. Linda, we're going to have to move on. There's so much to talk about before the news. But that question of welfare, the scale of the UK's welfare spending does look huge on paper, doesn't it? What does a big benefits bill mean for our growth? It continues to be not in. Well, I'll just give you the figure. So, yes, 100 billion increase in the welfare bill is substantial. And I think that is what the fiscal watchdog is pointing out.
23:50the government needs to take a harder look at what is the tax base that's needed to finance public spending. Because the pressures on the welfare bills, as well as on pensions, it is related to, for instance, an aging population. It's also related to decisions around very well trodden, I would say, arguments around how you support people. And the issue is that public spending is consistently above 40 % of GDP national output, but the tax take is consistently below 40 % of GDP. So if you look at the figures, generally speaking, about a 3 % budget deficit is not, it's pretty normal across major economies.
24:44We don't actually reach that until 2028, 2029 and then you have the welfare bill which is going to increase substantially by 2030 2031 so if you have a structural gap between the amount of taxes that you're taking in and you're spending then you need to look at both sides of the coin and government in this is hard probably needs to look at why the tax system is so complicated the ifs the institute of fiscal studies has pointed this out. The International Monetary Fund, which says we have the most transparent fiscal rules and budget deficit controls, has still pointed out that the tax system could use simplification.
25:26So the expectation is if you're able to look at, if you can simplify, remove cliff edges, can you actually increase taxes? And if you can't, you need to work out how much you can spend.
25:39Felicity Hannah: Was it a budget for growth, Freddie? It was a budget for a bit of growth, but with the caveat that there's a lot outside of the Chancellor's control, such as energy costs, the sort of crimping growth at the same time and the cost of doing business is increasing each year. And that's the problem. Okay, we're going to have, we could talk about the budget until six o 'clock, couldn't we? And then into breakfast. But we do also need to talk about what's been a very, very big week for US tech companies. We had Alphabet, Microsoft, Amazon, all posting results this week. And I find them really interesting because I think that they tell a story about where we are as a society with this changing kind of industry going on.
26:24Felicity Hannah: Google owner Alphabet saw almost half a trillion dollars, half a trillion dollars, wiped off its total value after sharing results that disappointed investors and saying it was increasing its spending. Microsoft had pretty decent results. But of course, we know that it's currently trying to make thousands and thousands of layoffs. Amazon shares fell around 5 % in after hours trading after weaker than expected sales. Freddie, there's just an awful lot going on. And at the centre of all of it is AI. Yes, it is. As we come towards the end of this week, I would say it hasn't been a particularly good week for those people who've got a lot of exposure to technology companies.
27:08As you say, they're generally weaker this week. And that figure you mentioned about Alphabet has to be put into context with regards to how much the business has grown over the last few years due to AI. So there is a rebasing of expectations, I think, across a number of these companies. And they're all doing different things. But as you say, at the heart of it still is this huge investment in AI. And I think what the market is trying to work out and doesn't quite understand yet is all of this investment actually going to yield a decent return.
27:40Felicity Hannah: Louise, is your business using AI at any point? Can you see the benefit of all this spending on AI from the big tech firms? I love AI. And yes, as a business, we are using it increasingly and it is a benefit. What I do love about it is that it is not going to take away a single, there's going to be no reduction in headcount. All I hope AI does is allows our managers in the venues to be more efficient, to allow them spend more time with the guests, more time on the experience and more time with their staff. It will make us more efficient. And people are scared of the word efficiency. It sounds like, you know, firing people.
28:23Yeah. But for us, if I can just reduce some of the administrative burden that we have to do for compliance or for legislation and allow these general managers to really be focusing on the guest, then hospitality will be the winner.
28:42Felicity Hannah: Linda, Freddie makes a good point about Alphabet's growth over recent years and its AI powered growth. But half a trillion dollars, still quite a lot of money, isn't it? I mean, is AI now, when it comes to the global economy, almost too big to fail? If it does, you know, if the jitters catch on, is it going to take us all with it? That is a concern. So, yes, it's actually it's a record loss, half a trillion dollars from Alphabet's market share. And actually, what's interesting is it's a slight cannibalization of its own model, because if you look on, if you go search from Google now, you can click on AI mode.
29:20And so that's what they offer to use AI to help direct your searches. But that's actually eating into profits, which is its core business, which is to sell advertising when you do a search. So I think this was almost expected, but somehow not expected. And I think the other thing that really affected Alphabet is that they have committed to something like in excess of a trillion dollars for data center purchases. So the part of AI that I think a lot of people are worried has created a bubble is around adjacent things like putting a lot of debt into building data centers, because when you do a search, it creates data and AI powered searches are just increasing exponentially.
30:06and things like Gen.ai, actually the unstructured data is just more than what you would use data normally for. And so that is one of the things that economists really worry about when there's a bubble, because when that bursts, what are the consequences for related companies and also the financial sector? And I think this is going to be part of the volatility we're going to continue to because most people, I think, continue to be excited by AI, but also worried you don't really know how all of these things are being financed.
30:42Felicity Hannah: Excited but worried. Probably the state of humanity over every technological development in our history. Thank you so much, Louise McLean from Signature Group, Freddie Cahoon from JM Finn. Stick around, lots more to talk about, including Smashing Pumpkins. Linda, this is where we let you crack on with your Friday. Thank you so much for being with us on Wake Up To Money. Absolute pleasure. Thank you, Linda Yu there, economist at Oxford University and London Business School. Let's just get a few of your messages in because, as always, you've got loads of thoughts, many of them very, very thoughtful.
31:10Felicity Hannah: Big Gaz says, morning, Fliss, just on the budget. I just hate the patronising cashback elements, like somehow we're all in this together and our pain is felt. We aren't on our own. I listened to an interview with an older lady on Radio 4 who said she was going to try the whole winter without using gas and had stocked up on warm gear. We just normalised this. It's not at all normal. Anthony in Liverpool says, it sounds to me the Chancellor is trying to help independent establishments with the rates changes, not large chains, i.e. entrepreneurs, not shareholders and investment houses. Sounds good to me.
31:41Felicity Hannah: And Dave says, save us hit again. Keep your thoughts coming. 8-5. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalise on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes. Visit your online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might've made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell or attain any specific investment or service.
32:19Innovation has always kept the world moving forward, but it also comes with risk. As technology and AI evolve, Axa XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your data and network from cyber risks. Axa XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation
32:43Felicity Hannah: nor a description of any products or services of Axa XL.
32:51Felicity Hannah: 058. Wake up to money with Felicity Hanna. Good morning. If you're just joining us, then welcome to Wake Up To Money. We're asking for your views this morning on quite a broad range of topics. I want to know your Halloween spending ahead of Saturday's big day, big event, whether you've been out spending money on decorations and sweets and pumpkins. And we'll be talking to a pumpkin farmer just before six o 'clock. But you've also been sharing your views on the budget, on the week that was, on your thoughts as to sort of why we're potentially not growing, not seeing living standards improving as a nation.
33:32Felicity Hannah: John in Woodbridge says, good morning. I think part of the problem was that from the mid-90s, we became complacent, enjoying cheap borrowing, food, and having high rates of pay. I think this led to a drop in productivity, as we all assumed that if we didn't knuckle down, we'd always get employment elsewhere. Other developing countries then overtook us, providing more competitive industries, resulting in job losses and pay stagnation. To put it in a nutshell, we all got a little lazy. And Nick in Wokingham says, Healy was constrained by£3 trillion of national debt. He was never going to do the Tory thing slash public spending and give tax cuts.
34:05Felicity Hannah: Any significant economic growth will only come from rejoining the EU Customs Union, etc. Thank you for that. And a few quick Halloween messages as well. One person says, My cul-de-sac will have over 300 kids tomorrow night. it's chaos and then some Halloween cynics I'm going to say among our listeners Liz says Halloween has become utterly ridiculous many families saying how tight their finances are at the moment but they spend a lot of money on Halloween clothing and parties my friend refers to trick or treat as begging with menaces and somebody else says I will do nothing whatsoever to celebrate Halloween I will not be Americanized I find it quite distasteful that people claim they cannot afford to eat but can afford to spend money on frivolous celebrations I welcome all of you on Halloween.
34:51Felicity Hannah: I quite like Halloween, so I'm here to hear your positive Halloween spending stories as well. 85058, if you want to text me on WhatsApp, you can message me on 08085 909693. Very curious to hear your thoughts about this as well, because since the government's new Workers' Rights Act was passed in 2025, there's been a staggered rollout of new measures. From today, some of those now kick in. For example, unions will get new powers to access workplaces. That comes after day one statutory sick pay rights and tighter rules around zero hours contracts were already introduced earlier this year. Let's talk to some people at the heart of this.
35:33Felicity Hannah: I've got Rachel Watkin, Managing Director of the Tiny Box Company, which is an online gift packaging e-commerce firm with about 100 employees. Rachel, good morning. Good morning. Good morning. And joining us for this conversation as well, Nicola Smith, Director of Policy at the Trade Unions Congress, which represents more than 5.3 million working people through 47 member unions. Good morning. Good morning. I mean, there's absolutely loads to talk about. Nicola, just explain what's changing today, particularly for unions with this workplace access. Well, today, a new process is coming into place where unions will have a right to meet with workers in workplaces across the country or communicate with them digitally.
36:19And the presumption will be that unions will be able to meet with workers in this way, although exactly how they do it will depend on the type of access request that the union thinks is right. But it's not something to be trepidatious about or particularly to be concerned about. I think it's an important new opportunity for simply for unions to talk to people in workplaces about what they do, about what the benefits of joining a trade union might be, to do that in a sensible way that's consistent with existing practice in that workplace. and then for people in the workplace to decide if they would like to join a trade union or not.
37:07Felicity Hannah: Rachel, sorry, no, please conclude. Happy to hear from Rachel. Rachel, are you trepidatious? Are you concerned? Have you been preparing for these changes? I think it's an absolute employer nightmare. And the reason I think that is because the unions have the right to come in and recruit staff that would otherwise be perfectly happy and content, you know, especially around where we live. Unemployment is low. If people don't like to work for us, they just go and find another job. But what this could potentially do is instill false promises, instill false ideas of better pay and better contracts and everything.
37:50When if better pay was available collectively because of the free markets, they would just go and work somewhere else. So, you know, already the burden has been put on employers massively. The cost of employing somebody over 25 since 2020, since Covid, has gone up by 51 percent due to the minimum wage increases, due to the employer national insurance. And now the unions are saying collectively, oh, we can get you better salaries and better working conditions. when we had the unions in the 1970s there wasn't minimum pay there wasn't the the contractual obligations that there are now so it's a different situation but with the same
38:39Felicity Hannah: policies coming back by the unions Nicola what would you say to employers like Rachel who are feeling that this is you know perhaps a bit a bit too much well I suppose the first thing I'd say is that it's completely the choice of individuals in an organisation, whether or not they want to join a trade union once they've heard from the union in the workplace. We know that actually a third of workers who aren't a member of a trade union at the moment wouldn't know how to join one. And we know that actually, but when you ask people, would they prefer to see their pay set by unions negotiating with their employer collectively on their behalf rather than individual pay setting.
39:24Most people say that they would. But one thing there that I really wanted to come back on was this idea that if people are happy in a workplace, they wouldn't benefit from trade union representation. I've got a different view. Actually, every workplace that has employees has to manage change, has to improve productivity, wants to think about how best to provide training, wants to do everything it can to make sure it's complying well with employment rights and treating its employees well. And actually, all the evidence from the UK and also internationally is if you have a structured approach to do that via trade union recognition, you can do it much better.
40:08You can identify problems that you may not know about because your employees will feel more comfortable talking to one of their other colleagues. And after all, the union rep in their workplace will just be somebody you already employ. It will be a volunteer who is a colleague of one of your employees. It can help resolve things early. It can improve representation. It can mean that employees have a structured route for a voice. And we know that that improves productivity. So this is absolutely not about creating problems where they do not exist. It's about enabling more people to understand how they can have a structured route if they choose to voice in a workplace and if they do to use an established route for bringing those benefits of collective representation at work that at the moment not enough people and organisations benefit from.
40:55Rachel? So what I would say to that is if my understanding is correct if I had 21 employees only 2.1 of them would need to be recruited by the union in order for them to then have collective benefits because it's only 10 % of your employees. I have 15 days to respond to any requests made by the union. It doesn't matter that I'm in Christmas period which is my busiest time and this is all on my cost. I have to fund the time, I have to allow the union in when they request and I then have to pay the staff whilst they are talking to the union representatives. Do you know that the average business that has under 49 employees at the moment makes£58 ,000?
41:43Sorry, the median is£58 ,000. And that's normally the boss's salary. So where is this money coming from when the costs of employment have gone up, as I said, by over 50 % since 2020. Yeah, I want to know where the money's coming from to pay for that. And surely a better route would be to encourage employers to not be replacing staff with AI and to make better prospects for businesses, rather than putting more legislation on them to just encourage them to reduce employment. It's going to have the opposite effect.
42:21Felicity Hannah: Nicola, I'm going to let you respond to that. And then I want to talk about some of the other rights that come in today, I feel like otherwise we could just we could tennis back and forth between the two of you until six o 'clock. Again, again, you know, I think it's really important to get this in perspective. As and when unions request access to a workplace, they're doing that because they want to speak to workers in the workplace about the benefits of joining trade unions. If the workers in the workplace don't want to join trade unions, then the union will move on and work with a different workplace.
42:57So in terms of the amount of time we're talking about, we're talking about an agreed process of regular access using usual means that would be in place across that workplace to meet with or discuss with or to share information with people in the workplace. If a request is made, yes, there is a need to reply to it. But, you know, that can be as simple as replying to say, yes, no problem. What about coming along for a meeting at lunchtime next week? you know if you have a regular teams meeting with people in the workplace a union representative could join that teams meeting for half an hour to talk about the benefits of joining a trade union and then people could decide whether or not they wanted to find out more information about it so I think it's important not to be too concerned about the amount of time that this is going to take or about how much time indeed the union would want to invest if there wasn't actually any interest in the workplace from employees in joining the union.
43:54And I also think on this point about giving people collective benefits, the right would be for individuals to decide whether or not to join a trade union. And if a sufficiently large number do join a trade union and they want to make a request to be recognised for collective bargaining, yes, there's a different framework in place around that to enable trade union recognition. But crucially, the power from trade union recognition comes from the workers representing everybody in the workplace. There's a lot.
44:25Felicity Hannah: I have to interrupt because there's a huge amount that we need to get through and we just won't if we spend all our time on this. But I'll put the other side of the argument to you from John in Woodbridge, who's texted in to say, quote, it's completely up to the employee if they want to join a trade union. That may be the case. But as a postman in the 90s, you'd be looked down upon if you weren't part of it. Thank you, as always, to everybody who's messaging in. But Nicola, I'm partly interrupting you because I want you to outline as well some of the other measures coming into force this morning, placing more responsibility on employers for addressing all sorts of different kinds of harassments, including sexual harassment.
45:01Well, yes, there is a new duty coming in today as well, which will require employers to take reasonable steps to ensure that their workers have protection if they experience harassment at work. And again, this is something that many good employers already have in place. It absolutely isn't a requirement on employers to prevent any harassment that their staff might experience from patients, from customers. The legislation recognises that that isn't realistic, that any employer could do that. But what it does say is that you have to have an approach in place to make sure that if such harassment does occur, as unfortunately we know it can do for workers often in retail or in care, but there is support available for them, but you've got a clear plan for what you might do, which could include, you know, action barring certain customers from the premises in future support that you could offer to the employee.
46:06Felicity Hannah: Rachel, I suppose if you've got 100 employees, but you're an online e-commerce company, then perhaps that sort of concern about third party harassment is slightly lessened for you. But is that something that you've had to think about? It's absolutely something we've had to think about. We've had to train every single employee in the business on sexual harassment over the last few months. And again, a huge cost to the business. But surely a useful thing to do for all your workers. Yeah, yeah. As I said, don't get me wrong. I'm not saying that that's a bad thing. All I'm saying is that it is more red tape for businesses to deal with.
46:45But yes, beneficial. And of course, we have to deal with it. A lot of customers phone up. We have customers on the premises. We have suppliers. And it is actually something that is constantly on our radar, probably being a female led business. I'm probably more sensitive to it. So that particular piece of legislation I don't think is necessarily a bad thing. It was just the burden again on business owners.
47:12Felicity Hannah: Let's bring in another female head of a business, Louise McLean, director at Signature Group, which has 20 hospitality venues in Scotland like pubs, restaurants, hotels. Louise, this sexual harassment, third-party harassment, I suppose is perhaps more of an issue for you where you do have a number, many of your employees directly facing the public. You're absolutely correct. We are definitely susceptible to harassment in the same way that there are other sectors. And yes, we do sexual harassment training. My mum is 75 years old and she works for us in one of our venues. And she also has had to have sexual harassment training, which is a conversation I never ever want to repeat.
47:58And that's not to trivialise what is the sexual harassment training. It is really, really essential. What we accepted or what I accepted as the norm in the 90s when I joined this sector is no longer acceptable. But I think we've always had a duty of care to our employees. I like to think that we are, in fact, I don't even like to think, I know we are a really good employer and we will do whatever we need to protect our employees from harm. And the easiest thing to do is say to a customer or anyone that's behaving badly, that's not acceptable.
48:36Felicity Hannah: Get out. Rachel, I suppose that that's your view on this as well, which is that a lot of employers do want to keep their staff well and happy and protected and that perhaps formalising that will make that the case across more workplaces? Absolutely. You know, we're the same. We've told customers to leave. I've phoned up customers and said, please don't ever come back and use us. But yes, any good employee would have had this in place from the get go. But yes, I do think it's important legislation for businesses or business owners that are perhaps slightly less ethical. and I could just come in on that I mean it just it just shows the benefits that legislation of this sort can bring because of course if you can address harassment in a way that means that a staff member feels supported you are much less likely to see bigger impacts for that employee potentially avoid any sort of long-term period of sick leave and you're also going to improve productivity in the business if everybody else there sees that you treat your staff well but you deal with these problems properly when they happen and that you've got your employees well being in mind.
49:47So, you know, it's I'm really glad to see this coming in today and also to hear that so many employers who are already doing this sort of important work don't really have anything to be concerned about other than the fact that there's now a level playing field being set, which will be preventing people who don't take this approach from competing unfairly with them.
50:03Felicity Hannah: Nicola Smith, Director of Policy at TUC, Rachel Watkin, Managing Director of the Tiny Box Company, Louise McLean from Signature Group. Thank you all very much indeed for your views on that this morning. Now, I cannot believe that we haven't clipped Smashing Pumpkins for this next item. It is Halloween on Saturday. Pumpkin picking has become a major money spinner for many, many farms across the UK in recent years. But this year, Stormbulo forced many of them to cancel events at a weekend that would have potentially been one of the peak weekends, the weekend before Halloween. Instead of raking in cash, they've been issuing customer refunds.
50:40Felicity Hannah: So some of them hoping to cash in in other ways. Instead of pumpkin picking, Brockvish's Farm in Northumberland is launching its first ever pumpkin smash day this weekend. Let's talk to its owner, Harry Dickinson. Harry, good morning. Good morning. OK, what's going on? Exactly as you said, we lost one of our weekend days. So we only do pumpkin picking for 21 days of the year. and the team thought it'd be a good idea to try and recover that day and do something called Pumpkin Smash. At the end of every season, we plough what pumpkins are left back into the soil, which is all part of good, responsible farming.
51:22So they're going to be destroyed anyway and we thought we'd try and make some fun out of it.
51:26Felicity Hannah: Okay, so is this on Sunday? Is this next week? This is Sunday coming, Sunday the 1st. Okay, who is smashing pumpkins? Is it going to be fields full of kids or is it parents who are sick of this? Grownups can come and do it as well. We sadly can't say bring your own weapons. I think that'd be irresponsible. But no, we're creating sort of lots of fun activities to do it. And there are a few pumpkin farms around the country that do it. And we've spoken to one or two of them to understand how it works and what works. And yeah, it'll be a big learning experience. Is it going to make up for the trade that you lost during Stormbulo?
52:08No, it won't. We've been doing pumpkin picking for about eight, nine years now. And this is a bit of a test. I think we've probably sold 25, 30 percent of our tickets. But it's very much a viable event for us. We're obviously putting on a big team to do it. And if it is a success, then we'll roll it on from year to year. but it won't go anywhere near replacing what we lost but it'll be, yes, a good experience hopefully.
52:38Felicity Hannah: I'm always in awe of how kind of agile, nimble farmers can be in terms of generating new revenue and farming tourism as much as anything else. I want to bring in Freddie Cahoon here, Investment Director at JM Finn. Freddie, this is the kind of agility that so many small and medium-sized businesses are having to consider. Yeah, absolutely. You've got to spread your portfolio of sort of entertainment and also sort of, you know, the more sort of serious part to your business. But certainly around where I live, I know many farms are doing some events over this weekend. And even sort of you bring in fireworks early to the season as well.
53:19So I think there are a few fireworks shows going on as well. But, yeah, you've got to have lots of side hustles going on, I think.
53:25Felicity Hannah: Harry, you've got to have lots of side hustles. Clearly you do, even when things are going wrong. But how busy is tomorrow likely to be? Has everyone picked their pumpkins now? Or is it actually going to be absolutely back-to-back cars and pumpkins and kids trundling them off? No, tomorrow will be chock-a-block as well. Everyone likes to. So I think people probably just tend to pick one or two going into the carving. And then you see sort of the huge wheelbarrows you will see at the beginning of October when everyone's doing their displays and the like. But yeah, we will hopefully, if the weather behaves itself, we'll be in for a sort of busy last day.
54:05Felicity Hannah: And what are you doing beyond sort of selling pumpkins? Are there other money spinning events happening at you? Is it also a fiver to go bob for apples? No, we do. So we're a family business. We're always dreaming up new ideas of things to do. So we did last year, we launched tulip picking in the spring. So we planted, well, this year we're planting about 400 ,000 tulip bulbs, which will invite people to come and see in the spring. So every year we're trying to add fun things for people to do. It's sort of the nature of a farm shop. You want to sort of have farm led experiences for all the family.
54:49Felicity Hannah: Yes. And thank you so much. I never have to thank farmers for being with us on Wake Up to Money. You're always already awake. Harry Dickinson from Brockbush's Farm in Northumberland ahead of that pumpkin smashing event. Thank you so much. Louise McLean from Signature Group. Thank you, as always, for your insights. Freddie Cahoon from JM Finn. Thank you for yours. One last spending thing. Paul says, I've spent a massive£5.50 on two pairs of Halloween socks. That's it for Wake Up To Money. The Football Daily Podcast with Rick Edwards and Lloyd Griffith. We are here and we're back twice a week, every Thursday and Sunday.
55:21we are going to try and tackle all of the big stories in football throughout the season. Everyone's talking at the moment about, oh, you've got to invest in gold, so I think you just melt it all down. Then you give each of the teams a little bit of gold. There you go. Yeah, I mean, the big revelation for me there is that you think the trophies are made out of gold. Yeah. Silverware. Yeah, silverware. The Football Daily Podcast with Rick Edwards and Lloyd Griffith. Listen on BBC Sounds.
56:16www.xrx.com of AXA XL.
With Halloween approaching, Felicity Hannah reflects on whether businesses or markets were spooked by the Chancellor's Budget. Elsewhere, new employment rights legislation comes into effect, and a pumpkin farmer adapts his trade following Storm Boelo. We all know about pumpkin picking, but what about pumpkin smashing?