

AI agents and cybersecurity risks, plus related UK money/energy policy news. The show discusses how “agents” (AI systems that can take multi-step actions with user permissions) are spreading—especially Meta’s Muse—alongside warnings about vulnerabilities that can shut down websites globally (critical PHP flaws). It also covers UK energy bills, including a proposal to remove gas standing charges, and broader energy/offshore drilling and budget business-red-tape themes.
Harriet Kelsall, founder of Harriet Kelsall Bespoke Jewellery Showroom Studios (Hertfordshire/London/Cambridge); Victoria Scholar, head of investment at Interactive Investor; Charlotte Wilson, head of UK enterprise at Check Point cybersecurity firm; Andrew Sissons, economist and director at Nesta; Tabitha Goldstub, tech entrepreneur, founder of Like an AI, formerly head of the UK government’s AI Council.
AI agents will quickly reshape workflows; trust and human oversight remain crucial; Meta’s Muse adoption is fast but privacy trust is damaged by major fines; shared internet infrastructure makes cyber incidents systemic; standing charges could be shifted to unit rates to help lower gas users.
Harriet uses AI to summarize emails and draft jewellery website descriptions with human approval; a colleague automates email-to-calendar tasks; a “busy mum” uses an agent to build a weekly shopping basket; Charlotte explains PHP vulnerabilities (CVE score 9.2) and emergency patching/monitoring; Nesta analysis suggests typical households save ~£20/year if standing charges are reduced/removed; Muse users reportedly use it mainly for shopping and purchase decisions.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on how AI is becoming integrated into everyday life and tasks.
“It's Thursday morning, the 22nd of October.”
Interview with Harriet Kelsall discussing her use of AI in her jewelry business.
“I'm okay thank you We are talking to you and not some AI agent that's acting on your behalf to come on Wake Up To Money this morning.”
Exploration of how AI agents can improve efficiency but raise trust issues.
“So just on that, because the idea I have of an agent is what you've hinted at there is These apps that many of us are using actually just going away and making decisions and acting for us.”
Discussion on personal uses of AI agents in everyday tasks like shopping and scheduling.
“That concept of without the human checking it.”
Audience interaction about concerns surrounding AI agents and privacy issues.
“Is it the world of shopping in any kind of way?”
Preview of topics to be discussed including cybersecurity and energy news.
“I mean, Facebook, Meta have just been fined$25 billion in the US for privacy issues, lying to users about how they're using their data.”
Discussion on the approval of the Jackdaw gas field and its implications for the controversial Rosebank oil field.
“All plays into similar conversations, doesn't it?”
Insights into the upcoming budget and potential impacts on small businesses in the UK.
“But obviously energy security is a big focus for the government at the moment, at a time when the oil price has been elevated around the world and we're very dependent on external imports for our energy.”
Listeners' views on AI agents and their implications for privacy and technology trust.
“They sort of quote a treasury source talking about the sludge that is choking firms.”
Discussion on critical cybersecurity flaws discovered in PHP affecting many websites worldwide.
“And us delegating parts of our lives to these AI agents and how much we trust them.”
Discussion on the implications of AI agents and technology in daily life.
“but we know criminals have tried to exploit it.”
Guests share their experiences and concerns about AI agents and the need for control.
“This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of Axa XL.”
Analysis of current oil prices, factors influencing them, and potential future changes.
“You know, I think we've all got to be quite careful with everything.”
Examination of standing charges in energy bills and proposed changes to improve fairness.
“And if it's going to be a politically charged straight for a long time, then businesses will have to look for other ways to transport oil and keep prices low.”
Discussing the government's role in supporting low-income households during the energy crisis.
“And actually, there are households that have low incomes and high gas use for various reasons.”
Exploring how heat pumps can help households transition away from gas and reduce costs.
“The Teesside Traveller has been in touch saying, I use AI to help with my YouTube titles, descriptions and thumbnails.”
Examining the use of AI agents in managing tasks and their potential to enhance teamwork.
“He reckons billions of people will be using it in the years to come, potentially generating more revenue than the average meta user as well, the way this stuff works.”
Discussing the trust challenges surrounding AI and data privacy, particularly with companies like Meta.
“And as AI advances, we have to probably make those choices for ourselves, our teams, our families each week, because we're going to be faced with new skills that these agents have.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Wake Up to Money, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing, or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, You can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place.
1:05Visit schwab.com to learn more. Wake Up To Money from BBC5 Live. Hello, welcome to Wake Up To Money. We're talking tech this morning and how it is impacting our lives in many, many different ways. A global shutdown of websites has been triggered after artificial intelligence uncovered critical cybersecurity flaws in software that powers much of the Internet. Sounds big, doesn't it? Well, it's had a big impact. We'll get the very latest on that. Explain what it is all about. Meanwhile, Meta, that owns Facebook and Instagram and WhatsApp, of course, has seen millions of people in North America sign up for its artificial intelligence agent, Muse.
1:50The company's had a big fine for privacy issues as well, spending fortunes on artificial intelligence. So we've got lots to get into about how all that is impacting us. Are you using digital assistants, automated and trusting them to do your work? And fresh off giving the green light to Jack Dor, the gas field in the North Sea, Prime Minister Andy Burnham is planning to change how some of our bills are set. to look at whether we can remove standing charges from gas bills. Wake Up To Money with Sean Farrington. Good morning. Wake Up To Money on BBC Five Live. It's Thursday morning, the 22nd of October.
2:31It's just after five o 'clock. Thank you for being with us this morning. 85058, get that number in your phone. Pop us a message over the course of the show. Join in our chat. interested to know like for years we've been now talking about how people have been using artificial intelligence in their lives were you one of the first to download chat gpt when that became an app were you one of the first to click on that button on your whatsapp app or your facebook app that enabled you to tap into meta's ai use well over in the united states and canada Meta has been talking more about this AI agent that it has launched, that autonomously acts on behalf of users.
3:16You obviously have to give it permissions and your credentials to be able to do some of that stuff. But Facebook's saying it's been downloaded by 10 million customers in the last six weeks alone, one of the most downloaded apps in North America. so a hint of what may well be on its way for us in the UK at some point soon if you're not already using this stuff already so we're going to be chatting about AI agents, what they all are how you use them a little bit later got Harriet Kelsall on the show this morning founder of Harriet Kelsall Bespoke Jewellery Showroom Studios in Hertfordshire, London, Cambridge morning to you Harriet Good morning, how are you doing?
3:57I'm okay thank you We are talking to you and not some AI agent that's acting on your behalf to come on Wake Up To Money this morning. Well, I think so, but maybe you'll never know. That's the problem, isn't it? That's the problem. Trust. Are you more widely, Harriet, less for your broadcast moments? Do you use AI agents at all in your personal life at work? Yes. Yeah, I've been working quite a lot with AI for quite a long time now. Probably, I think it's actually nearly two years. I think I first looked at ChatGPT. I was working out a minute ago, but I think it was nearly four years ago that I first looked at that prompt three and a half, four years ago.
4:33But yeah, we've been looking at all of that. So recently, for the first time, I linked ChatGPT to my email, which was kind of terrifying. But I've not I'm not brave enough to actually let it perform tasks on its own on there. so what I do is I sort of have my my sort of toe maybe a couple of toes in there so I'll say to it things like can you summarize my emails which ones do I still need to action which ones are the most high priority for me to look at and then it will give me that summary but I want to write the actual emails and do the sending and deleting and moving things into folders myself so I've not quite gone the whole hog at this point because I don't quite trust it to do those kinds of things without me knowing but I often I often find myself thinking should I should I make that change but I'm definitely not ready for it but we're also using agents for all kinds of other things so we've been exploring them for quite a lot of the repetitive work behind the scenes so for example we might be entering quite a lot of repetitive information into different spreadsheets to maybe analyze some of the data that we're looking at, or we might be looking at how we are pricing our jewellery using our own rules.
5:53And so we've been beginning to code some agents that others can then use within the business to help with those kinds of tasks, which has been absolutely fascinating. So just on that, because the idea I have of an agent is what you've hinted at there is These apps that many of us are using actually just going away and making decisions and acting for us. Is that what you mean when you talk about an agent? So if you've got an agent within the business that effectively somebody will just sign off on a given moment, go away and do this work, but make some business decisions or admin decisions along the way.
6:32it can be programmed like that but i don't think most people are using it in that way at this point some definitely are one of the boards i'm on some people are using it like that but um i think most of us are using it differently so for example one of the agents i'm working on gives you a prompt and it says you know what what uh what kind of jewelry are you trying to describe today because it's it's helping with the uh information that we're putting about the jewelry on our website, helping make sure that we haven't made grammatical errors, that we've said all the things, excuse me, that we need to say about the metal type and the gemstones and the weight.
7:09And then it will, you'll put in a few key pieces, excuse me, of information, and then it will actually word up the perfect web description for you. And that can spool it directly into our back end of our website. But we're not getting it to actually enable it and put it straight on the website yet without your sort of approval so it's almost like having a colleague at the moment rather than delegating a task to somebody exactly exactly but one of the businesses i use is doing that because they tested it manually for um i think it was a few weeks maybe more than a month and they found that the ai was making so many less decisions than the people so so many less mistakes than the people who were doing that had been making that they've they've automated it and it goes straight through to their website without a human checking it.
7:59So, yeah, it's quite easy to make that change when you've got confidence, I think. Without the human checking it. I mean, we've got Victoria Scholler with us as well, head of investment at Interactive Investor. Hi, Victoria. Morning. That concept of without the human checking it. One boss I was chatting to the other week saying to me how they thought the world of agents is just going to change everything when we all get used to this. We're hearing Harriet putting two of her toes into this when she one day eventually fully commits the whole foot into letting an AI act on her behalf. How does then that change how you look at, you know, you look at businesses, different sectors every single day, Victoria?
8:45Can that just sort of turn them all up on their head? Yeah, I mean, I think it's hard to argue that AI agents aren't going to be a major role in terms of future workflows and our personal lives as well. You know, it just helps to speed up tasks and it creates so much more efficiency for businesses and requires a lot of the need for that sort of manual labor that you're talking about there. And yeah, I've heard of lots of examples of people using AI agents to automate a lot of kind of the analysis of financial markets. But also for personal use as well. You know, I was talking to a colleague just last week who's a busy mom.
9:33And she was saying that she got all of her emails from the school and just said, put everything I need to know into my calendar for the next few months. put all my meetings in there and it's just saved her hours of reading. And I think that we're just kind of starting out on this process and I'm sure given how quickly we've seen chat GPT and AI kind of develop throughout our economies and around the world, I'm sure that this will be a very fast-moving technology and we'll soon think of it as very much normal. Harriet, given that you've maybe made the leap that not so many people have made in the world of AI with their chatbots on their phone, but clearly an increasing number of people are, where you've given your sort of login credentials for your email to your AI chatbot that you have and allowed it to at least have a look at something else and use those credentials, but you're not allowing it to act yet.
10:31What's the closest part of your sort of personal life, do you reckon, where you are not far off being able to trust an AI chat bot to do something for you? Is it the world of shopping in any kind of way? Having a bot just look at what it is you're buying month by month and then just going ahead and doing it so you don't have to worry about 90 % of your big shop? Yeah, I don't really shop like that myself, but my good friend Indira who works with us, she was telling me she's a busy mum, she's got two kids, she just routinely goes into her her ai agent and gets and says right we want you know this many meals this week we're not eating this that and this and we love these foods and and she gets her whole shop put directly into her shopping basket and it gives her menu choices she says yes no yes no and then it puts all of her shop straight into her basket she maybe adds a few and presses go.
11:34I mean, I suppose she's not actually saying to it directly, here's my credit card details, go do the whole thing. She is actually double checking it at the end, but I bet some people aren't. I think that's quite a sensible way to use it. I mean, that must save her hours and hours every week. And I love the idea of using it for the school calendar. I'm definitely going to steal that one because putting my daughter's school, you know, which day is this trip and all of that straight into my calendar sounds absolutely brilliant. Well, yeah, I've been trying to find a way lately of somehow getting all of my different calendars, whether it's the school one, the family one, the personal one, the work one, all to somehow talk to each other so that just on one place I can see everything that is going on alongside your to-do list.
12:21So, yeah, we can all go away and explore that and do a bit of home-home work and see if we can come back to it. 85058, are you using any of this stuff? Apologies to Mary, who's messaged and said, good morning, Sean, I feel as though I've woken up on another planet. Tech horrors. Somebody else saying the most worrying part of AI is how people are becoming less capable of making independent decisions. I know it's that time of year, Halloween around the corner, but this is a reality that will last longer than just the next few days. So 85058, where are you dipping your toe in a little bit more? You know, not that long ago, we'd speak to the likes of Harriet and be fascinated that she might have merely downloaded the likes of ChatGPT.
13:05Now people are talking about AI agents. John says people are mental if they're giving their login credentials to AI agents. I work with this stuff. It's unsafe. Don't be lazy, says John. Let me know what you are up to, what your warnings are. We'll be talking about some of the concerns around this as well later, of course. I mean, Facebook, Meta have just been fined$25 billion in the US for privacy issues, lying to users about how they're using their data. And yet at the same time, millions of people are downloading their AI agent app in North America. So let us know. 85058, quarter past five.
13:43It's Wake Up To Money. Wake Up To Money with Sean Farrington. Right, we're going to be talking very shortly about the huge news of there's websites all around the world that have been shut down because of a trigger over cyber security flaws. All plays into similar conversations, doesn't it? Let's take a step away and look at a few other things that are knocking around in the newspapers this morning. We are getting ever closer to the budget. We've had that announcement. It got confirmed yesterday. I mean, listening to Wake Up To Money for a while now, you've heard strong hints that the Jackdaw gas field was going to be approved for use and will be providing gas to the UK within days and in time for the winter period.
14:35Victoria, interesting to see in the front of the Guardian this morning, a few other places as well, picking up on where the conversation goes next. So we chatted a lot about the gas field yesterday. Now people are turning their attentions to this massive Rosebank oil field in the North Sea. The Guardian saying that the Energy Secretary, Miata Van Bulla, minded to reject the Rosebank oil field. So it does seem, in front of the Times saying, Jackdaw approval, the gas field, isn't a green light for more offshore drilling. it does seem that it's not necessarily automatic, that this is full steam ahead as Donald Trump would like us to be.
15:14No, it looks as though there are hurdles ahead for this giant Rosebank oil field, at least according to Guardian sources. And we know that these projects are quite controversial already. But obviously energy security is a big focus for the government at the moment, at a time when the oil price has been elevated around the world and we're very dependent on external imports for our energy. We know that it's been very expensive for filling up your tank of petrol and diesel at the forecourt. And so the knock-on impact of the Iran war and this year's energy shock has real implications for consumers, businesses and the inflationary backdrop as well.
16:02So this is going to be a hot topic, I think. and I don't necessarily think that Jackdaw paves the way for Rosebank's approval. Yeah, and what is particularly highlighted here is the approval of Rosebank and oil field would be hard to justify, say, these sources one of the times, on climate grounds and the government clearly feeling like the Jackdaw gas field approval is easier to approve on climate grounds. So we will watch that one and debate it, no doubt, with close interest. Harriet, you may well be interested, as many people running businesses around the country will be interested in, what the Chancellor is going to do in the budget next Wednesday.
16:46And he's been speaking to The Times. The headline on the front of The Times, Harriet, I'll cut cost of business to boost the UK. Budget will help bloody-minded entrepreneurs. Oh, my goodness. What's a bloody-minded entrepreneur? I'm not sure what that is. But I'm not sure I'd quite identify as one of those. But I'm very glad to hear that he's talking about helping businesses because we really do need that. It's a real struggle at the moment for all businesses in the UK trying to run small businesses. There are so few things that actually help the smaller business compared to the larger business and make the playing field a bit more level.
17:29And there's all kinds of issues for us. I mean, I've been talking about retail business rates being such a big problem, and I keep hoping there's going to be something about that coming up, because that's a real, really difficult area for us on the high street. So, yeah, let's hope he changes things. This will be fascinating, won't it? Because we often hear the words that businesses want to hear in a run up to a budget, or hear some words at least, and then you get it and everybody has to make their conclusions on the back of that. So let me tell you a bit more about what he's been telling the Times.
18:01He said, I want to be a chancellor who backs business in Britain making a profit. And those entrepreneurs who, in the end, are the ones who challenge the status quo, come up with innovative ideas and are trying, some of them through sheer bloody mindedness, to keep going through these sorts of pressures. They sort of quote a treasury source talking about the sludge that is choking firms. reporting requirements likely to be abolished for many smaller enterprises would things like that so it seems like there's a bit of a focus on reducing some red tape do you have to do a lot of reporting as a small business?
18:37Not absolutely no so I wouldn't say that's my biggest problem I think we've got much bigger problems with rising employment costs alongside all of the other costs that we have investing in training and investing in growth so employing and developing people can be challenging and also as I say the business rates on independent on independent businesses could really be helped and made level by the fact that we have to pay on the high street even though footfall is is very low and so many people shop away from the high street it's actually based on rental values rather than actual sales so high street premises carry a really heavy burden on it while you know online businesses don't have to worry about that so those kinds of things would help um so i'm not sure i'd say that we have to report loads obviously we have to you know fill in our bits and pieces at company's house and um and all and do our vat returns like everyone else but i wouldn't say that was my biggest problem at all no and and it is interesting there's a quote in there where he says he's acutely aware of businesses concerns over over employment costs employment law regulation tax inputs, supply chains, rising minimum wage for younger workers in particular, he added.
19:46So he's acutely aware. We will see what that means when it comes to the budget next Wednesday. 85058, do keep your messages coming in. We've had plenty on our AI agent chat already. We'll be getting into it more before the end of the show with somebody who has been head of the government's AI council, tech entrepreneur themselves. So they really understand how all of this works. If you've got questions, get them to us, 85058, because there does seem to be some concerns. Dave in Birmingham in Brom says, what are we doing handing over our brains to tech monsters which rule our lives? Beth saying, I don't even trust Alexa, never mind AI.
20:27The more prevalent it's becoming, the more I'm stepping away from technology. Tony says, Sean, I found the built-in AI on my iPhone unnervingly accurate, imaginative and helpful over a range of personal decisions, says Tony, who also flags that he's 78 years old. And Richard says, what are these people who use AI agents to run their lives doing with all their spare time? Doom scrolling on social media? Well, that is one test, isn't it, Richard, about how useful this stuff actually is. And for workers as well, something we've talked about on Wake Up To Money a lot, you might as well have these tools.
21:06Does it actually create the space for you to do more of the stuff you and your business really want to be doing? Another saying, my boss overuses AI, does not check what it does, and therefore she sends it out, which makes it not helpful to move us forward or be more effective. Quite often this happens. I ask co-pilot to review and complete those papers. However, without AI, I could not do my work anymore. It saves me time to create documents, presentations, analysis and research. That person says, I'd like to stay anonymous. My boss might be listening. Any boss worth their salt should be listening to Wake Up To Money.
21:42Keep them coming. 85058. I can see more messages coming through about the use of AI. And agents is our topic today in particular. And us delegating parts of our lives to these AI agents and how much we trust them. Meanwhile, you see these headlines of a global shutdown of websites triggered. after artificial intelligence has uncovered critical cybersecurity flaws in software which powers much of the internet. So two crucial vulnerabilities were found in the programming language PHP, which most of us might not have paid any attention to before yesterday evening, this morning, but now it is part of those headlines about what vulnerabilities that means for websites and businesses around the world.
22:30It's used by an estimated 70 % of all sites and applications online. Governments are urging organisations to install emergency fixes, warning hackers could exploit the vulnerabilities to steal data, take control of servers or deface websites. Security agencies say systems that cannot be patched immediately may need to be taken offline to reduce the risk of attack. Comes, of course, just days after that Google Cloud outage disrupted banks, businesses and court services in the UK. Let's speak to Charlotte Wilson, who's head of UK enterprise at the cybersecurity firm Checkpoint. Charlotte, good morning.
23:09Good morning. People hearing this, just before we get into what it's all about, Charlotte, we're talking about AI agents and how that might be becoming more prevalent and at the same time seeing how there are so many vulnerabilities out there as well. Do you detect that there's an increased nervousness amongst people when it comes to technology at the moment? I don't think it's an increased nervousness. I almost think it's the other way. I think it's a decrease in nervousness. I think we, as some of your callers mentioned, we give so much of our lives out to AI and we're so more heavily reliant on digital connectivity that I almost think it's the other way around.
23:51I think we're almost less nervous and we have almost become desensitised when something happens. So I almost think it's the other way around. Desensitised, that could well be the word, judging by the way we're having to think about some of this this morning. So, Charlotte, let's explain what this is, because this is a brand new thing. Again, it seems for us to be getting our head around. Certainly so many websites around the world needing to shut if they can't resolve anything. So what exactly has happened here? Yeah, so this is a really technical one. So a lot of people didn't necessarily cover this greatly because it's in our mind something that quite technical people talk about.
24:31But effectively, if you think of all of the Internet like a big shopping center and you've got loads and loads of different shops and banks and governments and hospitals all on that Internet as shops, many of those organizations use the same technology to set up their shop front, which is their website. And this technology they use is something called PHP. and there was found two major security vulnerabilities in that technology which meant that criminals could if they wanted to break in and take over those web servers so the the thing that holds the front end of that shop they could take them over without using a password so get into them and start taking information away and that vulnerability that was found There's something called a CVE, which is a critical vulnerability exploit, means I can get in, and the score that it has is normally out of 10, and that vulnerability was a 9.2 out of 10.
25:33So you can see it was quite a serious vulnerability. That's good. Well, actually, having numbers out of 10 is a good way of judging some of this stuff because we hear about these things every day. Do you have an equivalent number for that Google Cloud outage a couple of days ago, Charlotte, which seemed to sort of create a few problems in the morning and then it disappeared by the afternoon and the next day everything was back in place. When people hear the two things happening within the same week, are these vastly different concerns? They are different things. So the Google outage was a power problem.
26:07So that was the power went off in one of the big data centres. And this is a software problem. But I think what it highlights is that so many companies share the same infrastructure, whether that's the big cloud infrastructures like the Googles of the world, where there's only really three or four really big ones in the world, and we're all reliant on the same. And often they share the same software as well. So if there's a vulnerability in the infrastructure or in the software, our over-reliance on digital services are impacted. And it doesn't hit one company. It hits all of those shopfronts, all the 75%, as you said earlier, using this technology and this version of it.
26:50So on this PHP issue, which if people wake up this morning and they open up the BBC News site and they'll see the main headline being about oil fields and gas fields and Jack Doran Rosebank. And the second story on the website this morning is that website taken down worldwide as critical cybersecurity update is issued. So if you have a business or you have logins on these websites that maybe are being impacted, what should be the first thing you're doing today? So the very first thing I would do if I ran a company would be to understand where do you use PHP? So someone in your organisation, in your IT department should be able to understand where are you using this software?
27:40and then install the emergency fixes because there has been some emergency patches released to fix this problem or temporarily patch this issue. And then I would monitor ongoing because we know that there have been attempts. So we haven't got anybody yet almost put their hand up and said we have been breached by this, but we know criminals have tried to exploit it. So then I would be monitoring from now on in. Charlotte, thank you so much for your time this morning to explain a bit of that for us and give us scores out of 10 for some of these things that people may well be concerned about. Charlotte Wilson, head of UK enterprise at the cybersecurity firm Checkpoint 85058.
28:23Do keep your messages coming in about all of this, AI agents, use of technology. Some saying you've got to keep up with the times, others saying, blimey, this is making me back away. We'll go through a few more of those, and we're going to talk much more about AI agents, how exactly these may well be used. What is it that Facebook and Instagram and WhatsApp are up to, where in the United States, the company that owns those, Meta, has launched an app. And in the past six weeks, millions of people have been downloading it, using it. It's a glimpse into what Mark Zuckerberg thinks is the future of how we're using technology.
29:03That's for sure. Or is it what you want to be seeing?
29:34might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Innovation has always kept the world moving forward, but it also comes with risk. As technology and AI evolve, AXA XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your data and network from cyber risks. AXA XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of Axa XL.
30:12Wake Up To Money with Sean Farrington. Good morning. Wake Up To Money on BBC 5 Live. Thank you for being with us, 85058. You want to join in the chat about artificial intelligence and agents. That's particularly our focus this morning. But let us know whether you are convinced by all of this or not. we have had Peter in Battersea getting in touch saying I often use the free AI to help me learn about mixing and mastering for music it regularly makes errors on general issues it often asks me to upload a photo I've already sent I'm convinced this is to get me to upgrade and pay it's not accurate at present so needs checking that's a fascinating part of it all as well isn't it as you start to use this stuff more and more and then all of a sudden it says oh you've used up all your tokens or all your ability to change a photo for today, come back tomorrow or upgrade.
31:08Are you being persuaded to do some of that? Are you finding value in doing some of that as well? Another saying, you have to keep up with the times. We aren't in the 80s anymore. Times have changed with technology. Just stay in control. Don't let it dictate everything you do. AI is only going to get more prevalent in our lives. And Martin and Ipswich has been in touch. He says, I'm blind and chat GPT has helped me sort things in an accessible way. It can look at tables, it can look at inaccessible charts, all sorts of things. I also use it to help me overcome inaccessible websites. And the fun part of ChatGPT, I'm a creative writer, I'm blind, and ChatGPT fills out the bits and pieces I cannot see.
31:46So I'll write the general, what the characters are doing, what the setting is, and ChatGPT can fill out all the colour that I can't see, describe the places, describe facial expressions, that sort of thing. It's really, really good for certain things, but I have ultimate control. Fascinating. Got that word control coming up. Thank you so much to Martin. Thank you to everybody who's been in touch. Keep your messages coming. Have you tried an AI agent yet? Is there a part of your world where you have given your logins for something to the AI and said, hey, crack on without me. Go and buy me an outfit for the weekend.
32:21Get me some presents lined up for Christmas. Something maybe less risky. Just sort some Halloween tats. See what arrives a few days later. to 85058 if you've used one to actually make a decision on your behalf. Are you getting closer to that? Harriet Kelsall has been with us this morning, founder of Harriet Kelsall, Bespoke Jewelry. Harriet, that word control coming up interestingly there. Is that what it's all about? Well, I'm not sure it's all about control. I think there's a lot going on with AI that people don't even realise is happening. So, you know, you don't have to use a chatbot to be benefiting from AI.
33:02I mean, it's in your spam filters. It's doing your traffic predictions on the map apps. And, you know, it's finding water leaks. It's helping traffic flow through junctions. There's lots of medical stuff. I used it recently because I had a mole I was worried about. And I took a photo of it and analyzed it and said, oh, we'll just check in two weeks. But that looks fine. you know it saves a lot of a lot of time and a lot of problem is it about control I'm not sure I think I think we do need to be careful the person that wrote in saying there's lots of mistakes absolutely there are and you have to be very careful about the actual information it's finding if you're trying to use it say I used it a while back to give me some information about one of the royal crowns the gemstones in it just to help speed me up and it was completely wrong it just got the wrong crown.
33:53So you do have to keep your brain switched on and not just rely on everything it's saying. But I think when it comes to control, for me, I'm still using those safeguards and making sure that I press the button and don't make it do things automatically within my own life. But I definitely will be going that way with business because if I can help my business by getting the legacy systems to talk to each other that don't talk to each other using AI automatically, I'll definitely be doing that. You know, so I think it's when you want that control and when you don't need that control and just making sure that you really keep your wits about you, about also not letting some kind of problem in, you know, linking AI and then leaking customer data or something terrible like that.
34:40You know, I think we've all got to be quite careful with everything. So much going on there. And I sort of feel like I have to be on tent hooks a little bit. Whenever we talk about financial investments on Wake Up To Money and what people might do with the money, we're always at pains to remind people that, you know, things can go up, things can go down, all of that kind of stuff. And I feel like we're in that world with AI a little bit where we might talk about, you know, how we're using stuff and just need to remind people that there are, you know, certain ways and things to go about. When you mentioned in there, Harriet, about checking a mole that you had.
35:13Now, everybody will sort of know that the thing to say off the back of that is, if you have concerns, you go to your GP and you get involved in the system and use the medical services that are there. But I'm just interested, when you were using something like that, was that just a general chatbot you were using and trusting, completely separate from any healthcare system? No, it was a health app. I should have said that. I do believe the NHS are sometimes using this kind of AI to help assess photographs of suspicious moles as well. But the doctor end rather than your end. Yeah, but this was a sort of medical app, a sort of part of a medical insurance type of an app that my partner has.
35:56But it did say, you know, obviously if you're worried, you know, do go to the GP, but it would give you that first, you know, should I go right now? Is this a really definite problem or is it something I should just keep an eye on? And it was absolutely right because it did go away a few days later. So it stopped a lot of time being wasted in that case. Really interesting. But, yeah, I mean, I do. You've got to obviously keep your wits about you. I'm not suggesting you just do that. No, that's why I asked. And that makes sense, particularly as we've heard on this show, you might be a jewellery boss, but you're clearly immersed in the world of technology and everything that comes with it as well.
36:29So it's really interesting to hear how you approach this stuff. 85058, are you doing a bit of this? Let me know your thoughts. I've got Victoria Scholar with me as well, Head of Investment at Interactive Investor. Victoria, we mentioned a little bit earlier the chat about gas fields and oil fields in the North Sea and where has that gone? Let's take the conversation on a little bit and look at where generally the cost of stuff is at the moment, the cost of a barrel of Brent crude, still up at$110 a barrel. What's been going on with the oil price lately? Are we just accepting these days that it's this astronomically high historically?
37:10It does feel as though having Brent crude above$100 a barrel is the new normal, at least for now. And we've seen that there's obviously been this huge surge in the oil price this year. There's been some easing lately off the highs, but there's still that geopolitical risk premium baked into the oil price. We saw that Middle East oil exports were back up to pre-war levels, and that's because companies are using alternative routes instead of the Strait of Hormuz. We saw that shipments from the Gulf hit 24.6 million barrels a day, so that's topping pre-war levels last week, the highest since mid-February.
37:52So that's helped to ease some fears around a major supply shortage. So there are kind of less immediate concerns about the Middle East, I'd say. Just when you mention that, when you say about the Strait of Hormones, you just reminded me, Victoria, about headlines we saw a day or two ago where the boss at HSBC was talking about the Strait of Hormones potentially being redundant in five years, being replaced by new routes. Well, that's the thing. Businesses have to adapt, don't they? And we've seen that companies have been rerouting via other paths. And if it's going to be a politically charged straight for a long time, then businesses will have to look for other ways to transport oil and keep prices low.
38:39Because as it stands, with the oil price where it is, it's unsustainable for many, many businesses out there. We've seen that reflected in our domestic economy with that surge in inflation that we've seen this year. And that's a phenomenon that we've seen across economies in many parts of the world. Well, just as part of all of this, whether it's high oil price filtering through into higher prices that people are seeing for the goods they buy, their energy bills at home. We're talking about approvals of gas fields in the North Sea and will there be approvals of oil fields in the North Sea? Andy Burnham's been talking about how the decision to approve that gas field, at the very least, he says, would allow the government to increase investment in renewables and also, interestingly, do more to help people with bills.
39:27So there could be a change coming to how our gas bills are set. Here's what Burnham had to say at Prime Minister's questions yesterday. I can tell the House today that I have asked the Chancellor and the Energy Secretary to look at whether we can remove standing charges from gas bills and to report back to this house at the earliest opportunity. So standing charges are fixed daily fees that cover the cost of connecting to a supply. Households have to pay them even when energy isn't being used. You'll have noticed it if you keep a close eye on your bills and maybe wondered as you try and reduce your energy usage what on earth you can do about that bit of the bill.
40:07Well, research firm Nesta has suggested the standard charge could be moved to the unit rate. So people then would pay for what they use. Andrew Sissons oversaw Nesta's analysis, joins us now as an economist and director there. Morning, Andrew. Good morning. Just explain why the standing charge is there to begin with. Because people might not like it on a bill, but that concept of you need to be connected to a supply every day. so you pay for that. There's a bit of logic in that, isn't there? Yeah, there is. And both our gas and electricity bills historically have had the stunning charge. I guess it covers a lot of the fixed costs of the system, particularly the network and some of the operating costs for companies who supply us with gas and electricity.
40:53But it obviously creates this sort of difficult situation where every morning you wake up and before you've even used any energy, you've got 30p on the metre for gas and more for electricity. Hence the move is something that Labour wants to do for some time, look at whether they can reduce those stunning charges and hopefully, in the case of gas, get rid of it altogether. So how would this work? Because there may be some concern from others that if you have high energy usage, that this is only going to increase your costs overall. Citizens are always worried about people on lower incomes who have high energy usage.
41:30Actually, this could be penalising them. yeah so what what this would do is it would move all of the spending charge onto the unit rate so you'd pay a little bit more for each unit of gas but save a lot each day what it would do in general is help lower users of gas which tend to be lower income households people in in smaller homes and it would tend to mean households larger households with with lodgy gas use paying a little more but actually the overall effect is that the majority of households would save money and the a typical household would be just over£20 a year better off. And actually, there are households that have low incomes and high gas use for various reasons.
42:09But actually, those are households that need lots of support anyway. And so what we'd be saying is, yes, you should do this, government, because it makes the system fairer. But at the same time, you need to provide extra support, especially this winter, to make sure that bills fall for low income households in particular. So this isn't just a measure in isolation. and the government has been doing things to reduce bills in the ramp but actually it does generally make the system fairer and benefit those on low incomes on the whole. One of the things that you've looked at is as well is how it might impact people's approach to whether they use gas and electricity too.
42:44Yeah so we're obviously in heading into another very painful energy crisis this winter and it's caused by our over-reliance on gas and oil and actually the best way to deal with that and stop this happening again is to help people stop using gas altogether which is now very possible through technologies like heat pumps um the key factor which you need a fair bit of money for to you know to be able to get involved and see any benefits of that you do but there are support from the government and the key thing is that changes like this help to make the saving from switching to something like a heat pump much larger and that helps to um obviously for people to pay that back quicker but also to bring in options like finance which mean you don't have to pay up front.
43:23So being able to make the incentives much larger and the savings you can make from clean technologies much larger, it obviously benefits households in the short term where they can switch. It also means that as a whole we can move away from using so much gas and being so reliant on it. But electricity is a lot more expensive than gas. It is. It's currently about 3.3 times more expensive, but your typical heat pump, it uses about four times less electricity. Heat pump aside, though, if people were just looking to make that move with just an electric boiler or something like that, that didn't have that large investment, it's still a long way off everybody being able to afford a heat pump at some point.
44:04Just merely moving people towards using more electricity in the short term. Couldn't that actually increase their costs? Yeah, we have to be careful. So using direct electric heating can be a lot more expensive. It tends to be an expensive form of heating. It's also plenty of people have that and do need help under electric heating. But yeah, having sort of more efficient electric technologies like heat pumps is really important. That's obviously not something that's going to happen overnight, but it's something that many other countries have got moving on really quickly and that the UK needs to get moving on quickly.
44:34And this measure would help to get that started. And it does make a difference because at a national level, if we can start to use less gas, it starts to help bring down prices and reduce the kind of economic exposure we have to these ongoing gas shocks. Just finally then, just to almost explain this a little bit, are you sort of saying that the whole heat pump concept is a necessity for this argument of moving away from gas and towards electricity to actually be a strong argument that will reduce the cost for many people? the heat pump is the key yes it is um but it's key to um how britain can kind of rebuild its energy security in the longer term as well we've been this is the kind of the second big shock in four years and ultimately um it comes about because britain is kind of uniquely relevant on gas um and so helping people to move away from that in the long term is going to be a really key step to making sure it doesn't happen again and again there may be support from the government for households this winter but that that you know if we keep having to do that again and again it's it's not particularly sustainable it's much better uh to help us move away and help also also look at measures to uh save some energy go heating working well uh this winter such that we're not having to sort of um as households and as the government shell out large amounts of money each time we have a problem like this andrew sittens from nesta thank you very much for your time this morning Thank you very much for all of your messages about artificial intelligence and about what you might be using it for, how you feel about it all.
46:10The Teesside Traveller has been in touch saying, I use AI to help with my YouTube titles, descriptions and thumbnails. It gives me a great starting point. I then edit them to exactly what I need. Saves me loads of time. Well, Teesside Traveller, at what point would you just give your logins and tell that AI, You know what? You know how I work. Just go and make those titles up yourself and publish them. You don't even need to check with me. Would you delegate parts of your life to artificial intelligence if you felt like it knew you enough? Mark Zuckerberg of Meta, of course, Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram, has been talking about how more than 10 million people in the US and Canada have set up accounts for its Muse AI agent in just a six week period.
46:54He reckons billions of people will be using it in the years to come, potentially generating more revenue than the average meta user as well, the way this stuff works. So the Facebook and Instagram's owners push comes as OpenAI, which is ChatGPT, Anthropic, which is Claude, Google, which is Gemini, all compete to build systems that can do more than just answer questions and advise you, as it has the Teesside Traveller. It can actually carry out multi-step tasks to help businesses automate their operations. We've heard Harriet talk about that on the show today as well. We've got Tabitha Goldstub with us, who is a tech entrepreneur, founder of Like an AI, and formerly head of the government's AI Council, to talk to us about just this.
47:41Tabitha, good morning. How do AI agents fit into your world, Tabitha? gosh i uh i've started to use ai agents for things that i don't want to do myself so unlike the teeside traveler i quite like writing the titles um the bits i don't enjoy doing like my expenses uh i've been using agents for those bits the boring bits and i think culturally that's what we should be focusing on uh the bits we would rather not have to do in our days so what happens Let's talk us through how you're using an AI agent. You are completely delegating that task of expense management yourself. How does that work compared to what you would have had to do beforehand?
48:27I think a good example is at work where we're all sitting in a room. We're all constantly sharing news to each other ourselves. What if you can have an agent that actually understands what you're looking for online, brings you back the information that you were looking for, and shares it amongst your team? And I think the thing I'm really focused on is not AI agents for us as people individually optimizing us all the time one-to-one-to-one but actually how it can strengthen teamwork um and and how it can strengthen teamwork at work rather than just leaving us all as individuals who are who are walking around feeling uh i think more isolated rather than more connected to each other can you explain to us a bit about this muse that may well be coming to the uk at some point soon although when i had a bit of a search around this morning it doesn't look like there's any kind of launch date imminently but just explain what these users in the United States and Canada are doing with Muse.
49:30So we're seeing over 10 million people have used Muse they are mainly shopping which I thought was strange I like shopping but I can imagine what we're seeing is when you look on the the forums they're using it to you know they're saying these are the things that I would like to buy today, new ski suit, new summer clothes, and they're trusting the agent to go and make those purchases for them. The thing here really is trust. You saw in the earnings yesterday that the revenues are up$64 billion. And then on the same day, we see fines of nearly half the company's profit at$25 billion for past issues.
50:20Behaviours, yeah. Lying to customers is what the trial in America said, wasn't it? Effectively, lying to customers about how they were using the data that was linked to the Cambridge Analytica saga that people might be wanting to have a little search and read around if you remember that one. But yeah, it's remarkable, isn't it? At the same time as the biggest ever fine Facebook and Meta has ever received lands, they're talking about, hey, we've created an agent that will do things for you. So that trust, do you think it's there? I don't think it's there. And I think that we're seeing we're seeing fines like this too late.
51:04You know, if you think about Cambridge Analytica being 2019, we're now seeing New Mexico coming and saying, actually, we refuse to settle. We refuse to shield the company's liability from the fact that people were lied to. And so I'm hoping that a fine as significant as representing nearly half the company's profits, which, of course, they will refuse. And, you know, and there's risk that it gets reduced, but will start to ensure that Meta doesn't keep its move fast and break things. but actually starts thinking about, OK, how are we going to be trustworthy? Not how are we going to gain trust, but genuinely be more trustworthy in this environment.
51:45Just to put Meta's point on that trial, I think the head lawyer at Meta said in a statement that at its core, this lawsuit seeks to impose a tax on speech to enforce new rules for what people can say online. So that's part of Meta's response to all of that. So, Tabitha, let's sort of focus on agents then and where they go next. To people who've been getting in touch this morning saying we're utterly bonkers to be giving away our personal information, our login details to the world of AI. Are we bonkers to do that? I think the thing that I remind myself every single day is AI is not a force of nature.
52:29It's a series of choices, and we have to make those choices every single day as an individual. And as AI advances, we have to probably make those choices for ourselves, our teams, our families each week, because we're going to be faced with new skills that these agents have. And so the opportunity for us in Britain, I think, is to ensure that we take advantage of the amazing pieces of technology, but say no where we don't want AI to be doing things. So I wonder whether, yes, shopping is the big usage in America, but what is the big uses that we should be using for in Britain? We need a common language for the things we're excited about automating and what we aren't.
53:16So, for example, I would love it if my kids' teachers were able to spend more time teaching and less time marking rather than my child having a personalized AI tutor. And I think those are the kinds of decisions that we can make with our feet. And the reason why Meta talks about its earning results is because it matters what we decide to use this technology for. and so we have to really close that gap between using the technology for what we've been told by these eight billionaire bosses to actually using it for what we think is is is going to help with our with our lives tabitha thank you for laying that out i can't believe you're sort of hoping for the end of the little smiley face and a great work comment handwritten by a teacher maybe the the ai can help them do that so you still get that feeling as you're flicking through that that spelling test book at the end of the day.
54:10Tabitha Goldstorpe there, who is founder of Like an AI, formerly head of the government's AI Council. Blimey, thank you for all of your messages about the world of AI. It's not Wake Up to AI yet, as one said. But that is it from Wake Up to Money. Wake Up to Money from BBC Five Live. That's it from Wake Up to Money. You can download the podcast every Monday to Friday, so please make sure you subscribe. We'd also love it if you left us a review when you do. Get in touch, keep the conversation going any time as well on social media. Use the hashtag WakeUpToMoney. The Football Daily Podcast with Rick Edwards and Lloyd Griffith.
54:50We are here and we're back twice a week, every Thursday and Sunday. We are going to try and tackle all of the big stories in football throughout the season. Everyone's talking at the moment about, oh, you've got to invest in gold. So I think you just melt it all down. Then you give each of the teams a little bit of gold. There you go. Yeah, I mean, the big revelation for me there is that you think those trophies are made out of gold. Yeah. Silverware. Yeah, silverware. The Football Daily Podcast with Rick Edwards and Lloyd Griffith. Listen on BBC Sounds.
55:23Innovation has always kept the world moving forward, but it also comes with risk. As technology and AI evolve, AXA XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your data and network from cyber risks. Axel XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of Axel XL.
Sean Farrington explores what scrapping standing charges on gas bills could mean for households. We also look at why websites worldwide were taken down to address critical cyber-security vulnerabilities in in a crucial programming language. And, over in the US, Meta has received millions of sign-ups for its AI agent. We get the lowdown on how these digital assistants actually work.