

The episode focuses on fallout from an alleged espionage scandal involving NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang, plus UK retail and consumer issues (M&M’s clothing sales, ticket resale regulation, and a Booker Prize publishing boost).
Mike Tompkins, chairman of online sportswear/fashion discount retailer M&M HQ (Hereford). Jane Sydenham, Senior Investment Director at Rathbones. Bob Cubbins, CEO of StubHub International. Lily Jamali, BBC Silicon Valley correspondent. Stephen Witt, American journalist and author of The Thinking Machine (biography of Jensen Huang). Rana Mitter, S.T. Lee Chair in U.S.-Asia Relations at Harvard Kennedy School. Bea Carvallo, head of books at Waterstones.
NVIDIA’s governance and “key man risk” around Huang may worry investors; the US government/FBI is investigating; Congress may force Huang to testify. Ticketing regulation targeting resale profits could push buyers toward fraud/black markets and won’t stop bots unless enforcement improves.
Megaspeed (Singapore/Malaysia-linked chip access) and alleged Chinese spy “Alice Wang”; StubHub’s argument that Ticketmaster blocks ~20 billion bots/month; Booker Prize winner The End of Everything by M. John Harrison.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on NVIDIA's stock decline and future implications.
“Morning, welcome to Wake Up To Money on Tuesday the 10th of November, just gone 5 o 'clock in the morning.”
Insights from StubHub on government crackdowns and potential impacts.
“So, loads for you to have your say on this morning, should you wish to get in touch with us.”
Exploring the impact of the Booker Prize on booksellers.
Mike Tompkins discusses retail trends as Christmas approaches.
“So, you know, some shipments, most of our shipments are three to four items.”
Panel discusses NVIDIA's leadership and its effects on investor confidence.
“And we'll get into maybe more of the sort of European things.”
Update on NVIDIA from reporter Lily Jamali regarding ongoing investigations.
“And Jensen Huang is NVIDIA and NVIDIA is Jensen Huang.”
Discussion on the implications of Jensen Wang's alleged ties to a Chinese spy and government accountability.
“Wong apparently relaying to the president that he had no idea that Alice Wang was believed to be by U.S.”
Exploration of NVIDIA's pivotal role in AI and potential leadership crises.
“Well, let's turn to Stephen Witt and Rana Mitter then.”
Examination of the importance of corporate governance within NVIDIA amidst the current scandal.
“It's running so much through him, and he has so much influence and control, or at least he did until quite recently when this scandal broke.”
Discussion on potential abuses of power and the lack of accountability in corporate leadership, particularly at NVIDIA.
“You don't want a situation where people leading the company abuse power.”
Panelists speculate on the future of Jensen Huang amid allegations and potential congressional scrutiny.
“But I would say that on the Beijing side, they'll be probably reciting a mantra they've been using a lot recently at the leadership level, which is the East is rising, the West is declining.”
Exploration of current issues surrounding ticket reselling, government regulation, and the impact on fans.
“We're going to be talking books and the Booker Prize a little bit later on in the programme.”
Discussion on the challenges faced by the ticketing industry regarding bots and consumer protection.
“Bob Cubbins is the chief executive of StubHub International and says the plans would push fans towards fraudsters instead of helping them.”
Analysis of the implications of imposing price caps on ticket reselling and market behavior.
“I mean, genuine question, is that expensive to do?”
Panelists discuss the complexities of ticketing regulations and their effects on consumers and businesses.
“You could get some of the costs and things back, but you couldn't make a profit on the tickets.”
Learn about the rising costs of attending sports and music events and the ongoing ticket reselling debate.
“Mike, it doesn't sound like it, but I mean, sport or music, Jane, I know you've been dragged by the kids to take them to something recently.”
Discover the shocking case of a civil servant found guilty of holding multiple full-time jobs fraudulently.
“But also there's a piece that's been rolling basically since Labour came into power, which is looking at ticket reselling more broadly, so for music and things like that as well.”
Hear about the announcement of the Booker Prize winner and the significance of the win for the publishing industry.
“Joe Hill was a civil servant for seven years who now works for the independent think tank Restate.”
Explore insights from the head of books at Waterstones on the latest Booker Prize winner and its reception.
“as the winner of the Booker Prize for Fiction was announced last night.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Wake Up to Money, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Will Bain: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing, or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, You can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place.
1:05Visit schwab.com to learn more.
1:17Will Bain: Hello, morning. Welcome to Wake Up To Money. What next then for Jensen Huang and the world's biggest chipmaker, NVIDIA? President Trump says the FBI are involved. Democrats in the House of Representatives say there's questions to answer and investors fled the company's shares to the tune of more than$160 billion yesterday. We'll have all the latest and try and answer what might come next. Also today, the boss of the ticket resaler StubHub International warns us the government plans to try and crack down on ticket touting could backfire. We'll hear from him a little bit later on. And it's one of the publishing industry's biggest nights.
1:51Will Bain: The 2026 Booker Prize winner has been announced. Which is The End of Everything by M. John Harrington. What do awards like that mean for booksellers in the run-up to Christmas? One of the country's biggest will join us a little bit later on on Wake Up To Money. Wake Up To Money with Will Bade. Morning, welcome to Wake Up To Money on Tuesday the 10th of November, just gone 5 o 'clock in the morning. Will with you again this morning, lovely to have your company. As always, first thing, yes, lots to dig into. We're going to have a good look at the very latest from NVIDIA. Obviously, a lot happened since we left you yesterday, including the company's shares falling 4.5%, which when you're valued at more than$4 trillion is a heck of a lot of stock market value.
2:35Will Bain: So we'll dig into what's gone on, but also try and look ahead a little bit about what the future might be for both the company and its boss, Jensen Wang. But plenty of domestic news to get into as well. Bob Cubbins, the boss of StubHub International, talking to us about a kind of ticket-touting bill that's going through Parliament at the moment. Two going on, really. One for sport, one for music. So we'll hear from him about his concerns around that, what it might mean for StubHub International's future in the UK as well. And then, yes, we will be hearing from Waterstones a little bit later on in the programme as M.
3:04Will Bain: John Harrison won the Booker Prize for what's been described as a pretty strange post-apocalyptic novel. but we'll dig into a bit more detail, I suppose, about why, with the kind of slew of prizes that we get this year. Do they make a big difference? What is obviously the biggest time of the year for the book publishing industry in the run up to Christmas? So, loads for you to have your say on this morning, should you wish to get in touch with us. 85058 is the text number to do so. 08085 909693, the WhatsApp, if you prefer to get in touch with us that way. Panel of guests with us for the next hour, as always, as well.
3:39Will Bain: Mike Tompkins back with us the chairman of the online sportswear and fashion discount at M &M it's HQ in Hereford. Morning Mike how are you? Good morning I'm good Will actually I'm pretty good. Yeah how's business going at the moment? Yeah it's really picked up we're sort of running flat-ish from our beginning of the year in August but it's really picked up in the last few weeks I suspect most of that's due to weather because it's been pretty mild so far and it's getting colder at the weekend so um good for boots and jackets really right so that sort of uh cold fog that we've had anybody getting up at the time of the morning i've been getting up the last couple of days or let's be blunt about it the time of night that i've been getting up the last couple of days um driving a bit of sales then are they they are and i always despair when i see someone walking around in shorts in november that that sort of frightens me a bit but um there's always someone at every rugby club everywhere in britain i think who insists on wearing shorts and they just think you can't be comfortable can you but um what else kind of around it mike are you sensing then is there a little bit more confidence from consumers full stop than perhaps we thought um i'm not convinced yet but we'll see you know that christmas is a really important time for most retailers if not all retailers and uh you know we we've just literally on board in over a 000 extra staff in our warehouse um in herefordshire so you know that's the sort of uptake i mean we're we're currently pushing about um 100 000 units a day but that that will double and treble as we get nearer back back friday so it's yeah it's it's starting to be a very busy time for us and uh every hour counts really and yeah i bet i'm balancing all of that on the way and i know you've talked to us before about um supply chain concerns because of what's gone on kind of geopolitically through the year but also as a result the kind of cost of of transport basically of fuel prices for trucks and things like that how big an impact has that had as you kind of do that ramp up yeah that's well it just multiplies so um that's not gone away um we're still you know we're still suffering a bit every business from the ni hike um we've had a couple of other sort of internal uh things we we've launched a bunch of new websites um which will make our export uh but you know our ability to export into europe much easier uh that hasn't gone so well um but we we've got through the teeth you know two months of teething problems so i think we're that's that's very positive where i sit um and lastly our irish business we had to change we used to export to Ireland directly from the UK, but our friends in the EU brought in a new rule, a€3 unit surcharge on every shipment.
6:40So, you know, some shipments, most of our shipments are three to four items. So our shipments would have increased in cost from€9 to€12, and I don't think the consumer can stomach that. So sadly, we've had to move that to be shipped from a Polish warehouse, which obviously doubles the transport time. But so nothing's easy these days. We just keep coming against a new barrier. Fortunately, there wasn't any massive change in the budget.
7:14Will Bain: So fingers crossed. Really interesting. And we'll get into maybe more of the sort of European things. what could be ironed out, because obviously those are things the government have been talking about in the past few weeks with Mike, perhaps a little bit later on in the programme as well. Alongside Mike for the next hour, Jane Sydenham also back with us here on Wake Up To Money. Jane, the Senior Investment Director at Rathbones. Morning, how are you? Good morning. I'm good, thank you. We'll come to NVIDIA in lots more detail, so perhaps hold your powder on that. But the sort of wider, sort of semiconductor-y rally yesterday in the US, is that a fair thing to describe it as?
7:49Yeah, no, it was quite a rally. I mean, you know, there's often when you have sharp falls, there's often bounce backs in the immediate term, just because a lot of traders have kind of got all their books are out of order and they've got to straighten everything up again. We need to see whether or not this is a proper rally or whether it's just that sort of technical correction. So, you know, the confidence has taken a bit of a knock as a result of the midterms. as far as tech is concerned. But, you know, let's see if that extends further today.
8:23Will Bain: And kind of the wider economic backdrop, just talking to Mike about those fuel costs. I mean, one of the things that struck me, and it's kind of sort of been sneakily going on in the background, hasn't it? And we obviously always focus on it a lot more when it's going up quickly. But the price of oil coming down pretty quickly, down another percent and a half, looking at my screen at the moment this morning. So hovering around$91 a barrel. Is that more market conditions than actually fundamentals there, Jane? because presumably not a lot has changed in terms of the fundamentals around the war's ending.
8:52Yes. I mean, we have been here before with the oil prices come down, the market saying, oh, you know, talks about a peace deal, etc. But we've kind of got to see something fundamental or concrete for that to happen. I mean, there's talk about this in Iran as well. so you know maybe this time maybe this time it will happen I mean you know the world economy
9:18Will Bain: really needs it too but let's see yeah interesting and uh anything else you're kind of watching this week I mean we're going to get a lot of UK data aren't we as the week moves on I know we're going to focus a lot today again on kind of just because the Nvidia story's been extraordinary hasn't it and uh and it's dominated business news headlines but we have got kind of again another important week. Yes, I mean, you know, this is kind of heavy reporting part of the year, lots of signals that, you know, give us guidance about how the economy is looking. But I mean, the technology situation is the one that's driving sentiment the most strongly.
9:55So we'll keep a close eye on that.
9:56Will Bain: Yeah, absolutely. As I say, we'll be returning to plenty of domestic matters as we move through the programme today here on Wake Up To Money. But we thought it was worth kind of really dwelling on this extraordinary story that we were bringing yesterday around the the boss of NVIDIA, world's second largest company by market cap, the world's most important chipmaker, right at the centre of everything going on around AI. And Jensen Huang appearing to be caught in, well, potentially some kind of honey trap with a Chinese executive or an executive at a Singaporean company, a customer of NVIDIA's that the US administration certainly thinks, the US intelligence services believe to be a Chinese spy.
10:35Will Bain: We're going to get the latest from Lily Jamali in Silicon Valley shortly. She's standing by to speak to us and can bring us up to date with where we got to yesterday. But let's introduce you to the rest of our panel for the next chunk of Wake Up to Money. Because Stephen Witt is joining us. Stephen's an American journalist and author of The Thinking Machine, a biography of Jensen Huang. He's joining us from Singapore this morning. And Rana Mitter is also with us. Rana is the S.T. Lee Chair in U.S.-Asia Relations at the Harvard Kennedy School. morning both Rana morning from us just before we get into the details and obviously your area of expertise about the sensitivities around this just I just wonder what you kind of made of it when you saw the headlines coming through
11:23Will Bain: struggling with Rana's line there at the moment Jane what was your top take from the week Well, I think, you know, I mean, NVIDIA has just been the poster child for driving forward artificial intelligence. And Jensen Huang is NVIDIA and NVIDIA is Jensen Huang. So that's a real problem for investors. The governance of the company is really going to have to be looked at more closely. A lot of the people on the board have been on the board for a long time. So they're people that he knows really well. There isn't that sense of independence that you see at lots of other companies. So, you know, it doesn't feel very comfortable for investors at this point in time that there are the checks and balances that we would normally have in place.
12:13Will Bain: And in terms of the nuts and bolts of what went on yesterday, down just over 4%, is that right? Which for a company of that size, absolutely enormous fall. That is a big fall when you think of the size of NVIDIA, but not really surprising if investors are worried about, you know, how this is going to play out for the longer term and whether or not he's going to be the driving force. I mean, he's famously demanding, as far as his staff are concerned, he really expects everybody to put in 110%. You know, it's going to be a big change if he's not calling all of the shots going forward. Yeah, well, let's get everybody right up to date with perhaps if you're coming new or you need refreshing on the story.
12:53Will Bain: And also, obviously, what's gone on while we've all been in bed? Someone who I don't think has been to bed for about four or five days at this point is our Silicon Valley reporter, Lily Jamali, who joins us live from there now. Morning from us again, Lily. Why don't you bring people up to date with the latest?
13:17Will Bain: Sorry. Hi, Lily. This is Lily. How are you doing? I'm sorry. Good, good. I was just describing you as someone who hadn't slept for days, and I was worried that finally you had been consumed by it all at some point there. No, I was just saying, bring everybody up to date. So while we've been asleep, what's been the kind of latest, what are the top lines this morning on all of this? Of course. And I'm sorry for that. Yes, the top lines right now are that President Trump has now given more commentary about what has happened. First and foremost, he says that the FBI is looking into all of this, didn't offer any more details, the FBI not offering any more details to the BBC in response to an inquiry.
13:54But really interesting to hear President Trump say that he had actually talked with Mr. Wong on the phone today. Mr. Wong apparently relaying to the president that he had no idea that Alice Wang was believed to be by U.S. intelligence a spy for the Chinese government. He called him an honorable man and said he's basically having a really hard time right now. But there are just increasingly more and more questions mounting about who knew what and when. One of the things I keep coming back to is NVIDIA's statement to me last night where they told me in no uncertain terms that NVIDIA was not aware that Ms.
14:37Wang was an intelligence asset according to the understanding of the U.S. government. And so their line is, well, why didn't the U.S. government relay this to us if this was a concern?
14:50Will Bain: Yeah, and certainly seems to be a lot of debate in the media where you are, Lily, doesn't there, about if and when the president knew it had been suggested that he'd known for a long time when we were talking to you yesterday. As you say, alongside sort of talking about the FBI being involved in some of his interviews with US media overnight. Our time last night, he was kind of saying, oh, no, well, I wasn't actually that sure. And this May date when supposedly he had been at an intelligence briefing, he said it hadn't stuck with him had that happened. And also potentially more investigations circling already, right, as well, Lily, too, because we heard from Hakeem Jeffries, now the Democratic kind of leader in the House of Representatives, obviously a very swelled number of Democrats there saying he thinks there's questions to answer.
15:34I think that if there is going to be accountability, if that is merited here, it's going to likely come from Congress. I know we're all looking to January for this changeover when the Democrats take over. But even right now, when the Congress is still in Republican hands, there are a couple of committees that are devoted to national security of the United States that have asked for Jensen Wong to fly to Washington next week and testify to them behind closed doors. I think there you're going to see the kind of prosecutorial muscle that just, you know, when you talk to when you hear bites, sound bites and audio cuts from the U.S.
16:16president, some of them don't completely add up. So I think what whatever happens, new information is likely to come from those congressional hearings and potentially leaks that come out of them.
16:29Will Bain: And I know you've been up and around NVIDIA HQ and I know what it's like on these stories. you end up doing a lot of broadcasting and not a lot of walking around chatting to people. But have you been able to get a bit of a sense of, I mean, have people been taken as off guard as this as all of us listening have? You know, I donned my most Silicon Valley outfit today. I had the Patagonia fleece on, put the baseball hat on with the sunglasses, tried to blend in the best I could. I've never had so many people flee from me, not since the great financial crisis on Wall Street. It probably was the last time when nobody wanted to talk.
17:05I did get a couple of people to give me a minute outside of NVIDIA headquarters, an employee as well as a few suppliers who were just doing business there. And from what they told me, it actually felt like business as usual. If you can believe that, you know, people are very heads down just trying to do the work, get through the day. I don't think there was a lot of chatter, at least not at the office, about what had happened to Mr. Wong.
17:32Will Bain: Lily, really appreciate you bringing us up to speed with it. As always, Lily Jamali there, our correspondent, grafting hard in her Patagonia fleece out in Silicon Valley there. Well, let's turn to Stephen Witt and Rana Mitter then. Rana Mitter, the STL chair in US-Asia relations at the Harvard Kennedy School. And Stephen Witt, as I mentioned, American journalist and author of The Thinking Machine, a biography of Jensen Wang. Morning both again from us. The same question, I guess, I asked Lily there, both Stephen perhaps first and then Rana. Were you as surprised by this as I think all of our listeners were?
18:03I was certainly surprised that Jensen was involved with this particular woman. I mean, the red flags surrounding Megaspeed were obvious to both investors and people looking at this for over a year. Well, why so?
18:18Will Bain: Because you're in Singapore, Stephen. So you're really well placed to talk to us about this company because they are a Singaporean company. And we were saying yesterday on the program being investigated by the Singapore government, right, as well. Megaspeed had been investigated by the United States government going back to 2024 by the Commerce Department. There were many people who believed that it was essentially a cutout, a way for Chinese AI developers to get access to NVIDIA chips through Malaysia because otherwise there was an export ban that prevented them from getting them. And so that looked like something kind of fishy to a lot of people.
18:52You know, why was NVIDIA's second largest territory, Malaysia, if Malaysia doesn't have a very big AI development program? And I think a lot of people were thinking that China was probably involved in some way. I think what came as an absolute shock, a real surprise, was that Jensen was having a relationship with the CEO of Megaspeed. I think that was a shocker. Honestly, I'm kind of surprised that he could be so foolish. which I mean, there should have been a ton of red flags, both about this company and this woman in particular.
19:26Will Bain: Right. Really interesting. Rainer, how taken off guard were you by all of this? I was very surprised too. In honour of your other reporter, Lily, I should say that. I think I'm wearing a T-shirt at the moment. I hope that's suitable for this interview. Only as long as you've got kind of some kind of gilet with it somewhere, I'm guessing too. Next time around, I'll see what I can hold on. Look, yeah, I think this was an absolutely astonishing story. I was actually speaking to a colleague from, let's say, a major American newspaper today who said that they thought it was the story of the century.
19:56That might be a bit much, I think. On the other hand, the idea that actually you have the combination of what Stevens mentioned, which is this romantic relationship, which I have to say came as a complete surprise. But probably the element which actually is going to attract the most attention, I think, in the next few days, weeks and months, I think, beyond that, which is the question of how much the American government knew about this and why they didn't do more. I mean, the Megaspeed connection, the Malaysian connection with the chips that seem to be placed in this sort of third country, presumably to get to China.
20:27That was fairly well known, I think, to people who have a look at the way in which the US-China tech competition has been happening for a while. but at least as reported in the New York Times. So I'm just sort of reporting what I read there.
20:38Will Bain: And we should say that they had done a lot of the legwork on this, hadn't they? Anna Swanson and others have been the people who had broken a large part of this. I think we have to give a big call out for this is journalism at its most impressive. The New York Times has really broken the story in a big way. Some extra details also for the Financial Times today. I think we should put that in there. But wherever the story comes from, the New York Times has been reporting amongst other things that it appears that US intelligence knew about this for quite some time and essentially, you know, very senior, perhaps, you know, the most senior people in the US government essentially don't seem to have acted on it at this particular point.
21:12Now, that means that as I think, you know, a couple of correspondents certainly said that Congress and this newly democratic Congress is likely to push hard at this for two reasons. One is that there are national security issues. And I think, you know, many people who remember that the Biden administration only two years in the past put some pretty strong export controls on many of these chips and asking why they were lifted. And secondly, good old partisanship. The US is still very divided between Democrats and Republicans, and this will be grist to that particular mill.
21:42Will Bain: Well, the other extraordinary element, just to build on what you're saying, Rana, and Stephen touched on this too, was that Jensen Huang was also one of the people lobbying against all of that, wasn't he? He was lobbying that his firm should be allowed to sell more powerful processors. Again, I'm simplifying a little bit here, but sell its sort of top chips to China. He was actively lobbying the government around that at a time where he kind of knew some of these loopholes potentially. Well, he was whispering that into Trump's ear and he got what he asked for too. I mean, for the most part, he really got a lot of the export restrictions lifted.
22:13I think that's actually why this story is playing out the way it is. If you look at the source, the origins of this intelligence, it comes from inside the White House. Most likely the China hawks in the White House didn't like that Jensen was doing this. And so they showed this information to some reporters to kind of pull Trump back towards the more kind of hawkish side. There's a lot of gears at work here, I would say. But it is, as we say, the congressional testimony is for – the congressional grilling of Jensen is going to be vicious over this one. It could be quite embarrassing.
22:50Will Bain: So those are some of the questions that we'll come to the sensitivities with Rana in a moment. Jane, just jump in at this point. And Stephen, I'm going to bring you in on this as well, because I think you can't overstress this enough. And I think I've talked about this on the program before. So sorry if I'm boring listeners with this one, but an extraordinary graphic, Jane, that Bloomberg posted a month or so ago with NVIDIA kind of in the middle of this web, basically, of where it was buying services, where it was selling services, where it was renting, where it was investing. You cannot overstate how significant this company's place is within the kind of global network of AI already, right?
23:27Yeah. And of course, that's been Jensen Huang's ambition all along is just to make NVIDIA chips so completely central to the way that the artificial intelligence network and infrastructure functions that you can't disentangle it from all of this progress. So it's absolutely pivotal.
23:50Will Bain: And Stephen, that's why this matters too, right? Regardless of, you know, it would be important if it was a company of this size going through this anyway. But it's actually its place in the chain, if you like, too, that makes it even more significant, no? Of course. And on top of that, Jensen really has no replacement at all. I mean, he runs it sort of like how Louis XIV ran Versailles. He's in charge and then there's a whole bunch of people far below him, you know. So if he's forced to be removed from this company, there's no obvious successor. We call that key man risk. And there's key man risk for NVIDIA, but there's actually key man risk in some sense for the whole global economy.
24:26It's running so much through him, and he has so much influence and control, or at least he did until quite recently when this scandal broke.
24:35Will Bain: And Jane, is that your sense as to why the volatility, that perhaps the guys have referred to him as a Trump whisperer as well? perhaps at a time where people have been worried since the midterms about more regulation around things like data centres and all that kind of stuff, that you've got a key kind of a key confidant of the president around AI who may no longer be in their role. Yes, yes. I mean, you know, he, as I say, he's been a he's famously hardworking and drives everything forward. And without him as an individual, it looks more difficult for the company and as you say for for the sector as a whole so it's it really is important stuff and that all matters rana against the backdrop of all of this this race i mean battle really between the united states and china and that's not us editorializing i mean the president president trump himself has talked about it in such terms hasn't he when he's talked about things like ai regulation saying the u.s cannot slow down it has to win in this ai race with china is that what again adds to the kind of sensitivities of all of this it adds to sensitivities not not to forget that president xi and trump should be meeting in shenzhen in basically about two or three weeks time uh there's also some rumors that vladimir putin may join them as well which will make for an interesting family pick as you can imagine but the main issue is that president trump will already be coming in weakened by the midterms because of the huge democratic wins and the chinese will be aware of that this will be another story which essentially makes it look as if the u.s is not in control of the narrative.
26:03Now, there is a sort of very weird silver lining in that there is so much interwovenness between the US and Chinese AI systems and tech systems, much more than it appears on the surface. Big apps like Uber, DoorDash, and so forth actually use a lot of Chinese AI anyway. And therefore, actually, I don't think the Chinese want the US economy or its system to collapse in any sense. But they will, I think, to be honest, the major reaction in Beijing behind the scenes is going to be hilarious laughter. On the surface, it's all denial that, you know, it's nothing to do with us and very poker-faced in the usual, very official way.
26:38Behind the scenes, I think that they will be absolutely howling into their baijiu, the strong liquor that they drink at parties, at this sort of sign of essentially the US system really having lost the plot.
26:51Will Bain: Yeah, they seem to have been doing a lot of that in the last few years, don't they, in the barrooms of Beijing. Mike, come in as the one person, as a chief executive boss in your own business as well. We were touching on this yesterday, actually. Nicola Downing from Tease Wealth was kind of making this point. We have seen park the espionage bit, certainly in big stock market listed companies in the UK and in the US, right, that there are a lot of kind of sort of code of conduct rules around, you know, relationships, relationships within a business relationships certainly with a key customer like here i mean just as someone who lives through that kind of corporate governance stuff every day i mean are you are you sort of sort of eyebrows raised about that yes of course i mean look in this case uh he isn't the first man and he won't be the last man that's had a extramarital affair however um It just doesn't look good.
27:53You know, of course, the espionage thing is something separate and huge. But, yeah, there's a lot more corporate governance. And really, that's right. You don't want a situation where people leading the company abuse power.
28:13Will Bain: Could be seen to have power imbalances. Yeah, exactly. so you know i think it's important um but but there comes a point where some of the regulation can get a little bit overkill in in everything and there's certainly you know in my 40 odd years of business um it's changed it's changed a lot steven to that point and a little bit to what you were chatting about earlier as well are there people then as nvidia begins this internal investigation, are there people who can, I don't know, bluntly, who can say no to Jensen Wang, who can tell Jensen Wang things he doesn't like within NVIDIA? No. I mean, I think that's partially why this happened in the first place, right?
28:57I think there were no real breaks on Jensen. I mean, he was, you know, seen with this woman in public a number of times. And I think if he'd had someone who could say, hey, Jensen, you know, what are you doing? Like, I think maybe this wouldn't have happened. But there's not really anyone like that at NVIDIA. There's no real second in command. There's no real kind of trusted lieutenant of that type. It really is just his show. And I think we see kind of the weaknesses of that now. We've seen the strengths for the past few years. Now we're seeing the weaknesses. I also think it makes it very hard for the board to remove Jensen.
29:32Some of the board members have billions of dollars worth of NVIDIA stock that they personally hold. They can't do things that will make that stock go down. And I think removing Jensen, despite his misdeeds, at this point would cause the stock to crater.
29:47Will Bain: Right. Bit of crystal ball gazing then from you all before you go. Rana, lead us off. Does he survive this? I think he does because he's a key man. But I would say that on the Beijing side, they'll be probably reciting a mantra they've been using a lot recently at the leadership level, which is the East is rising, the West is declining. They will regard this story as further evidence that that particular narrative has some weight to it. Stephen? I think he will survive at least initially. It is the grilling from Congress that's going to be tough. You know, the other thing is Jensen may have broken the law here.
30:23If he was aware that Megaspeed was kind of funneling these chips into mainland China, he may have broken the law. That could be a real challenge for him if he had to plead the fifth before Congress or something like that. So I see that as a looming threat to NVIDIA.
30:40Will Bain: Yeah, and as Lily Jamali was telling us, our correspondent, the FBI not clarifying what it is that they're looking at to us around that. Jane, what's your sense? Yeah, I think he will probably survive because I think it's almost impossible for him not to, given the significance of his position in the AI chain. But there will need to be changes at the board and all of those kinds of things. And having said that, you know, it will depend on whether he has broken the law. And I think that that could be a pretty uncomfortable ride both for him and the company. Mike, some awkward board meetings down the track regardless here.
31:20yeah look i'm sure he will survive initially but um nobody should be above the law i'm afraid um and if he has broken the law that that may be different uh in in 2027 onwards all that still
31:37Will Bain: to be uh discovered much more as we say seems to be coming out on this story almost hourly hope we'll have these guys back on again because i really appreciated you breaking it down for us this morning steven witt american journalist author of the thinking machine a biography of Jensen Huang, well worth a read if you haven't already. We'll be talking Christmas books later. Stephen joining us from Singapore. And Rana Mitter, the ST Lee Chair in US-Asia Relations at the Harvard Kennedy School. Right, as I mentioned, we're going to talk books in the second half of the program. We've got Waterstones coming on about the winner of the Booker Prize.
32:05Will Bain: And we're also going to talk tickets and ticket reselling with StubHub International. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes. Visit your online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made.
32:38This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service.
32:43Will Bain: Innovation has always kept the world moving forward, but it also comes with risk. In a In a world that is as complex and unpredictable as it is exciting, AXA XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your business and power your innovations. AXA XL, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of AXA XL.
33:14Will Bain: Wake up to money with Will Bain. Morning. Welcome back to Wake Up To Money on Tuesday, the 10th of November. Our panel this morning, Mike Tompkins, the chairman of the online sportswear and fashion discount at M &M HQ in Hereford and Jane Sydenham, senior investment director at Rathbones with us this morning. Keep your text coming in on 85058. Appreciate this one in from Roger. We're going to be talking books and the Booker Prize a little bit later on in the programme. Hi, team. I've never bought any item, music, books, gadgets or anything else because of any prize award or any other such thing, says Roger.
33:49Will Bain: So bad news for the organiser of the Booker Prize. But I'm sure plenty of people will buy M. John Harrison's novel that was the winner last night. We'll hear from Waterstones about the difference or otherwise, whether they're in Roger's camp or whether they do see a big boost in sales off the back of awards like that as well. I'm going to turn to the world of ticketing, though. Now, a couple of interesting things going on sort of in parallel with each other at the moment to try and clamp down on ticket reselling, ticket touting around the UK. The boss of one of the world's biggest ticket resale sites has told us fans could face unintended consequences if some of those government plans trying to restrict ticket resale are successful.
34:28Will Bain: Bob Cubbins is the chief executive of StubHub International and says the plans would push fans towards fraudsters instead of helping them. He argues the real problem is bots, the automated software that buys up tickets the moment they go on sale. And the government should first enforce a ban it has on those. And that if a cap on any profit from reselling tickets online was to come in as part of any of this legislation, StubHub International would have to consider whether it stays in the UK. One of the key pieces of regulation that the government has enacted was to make bots illegal. One of the opportunities that the industry has and that we all have, and consumers are going to be the beneficiary of this, is to actually enforce that regulation.
35:08So right now the government's not being particularly aggressive at enforcing that. The primary ticketing players are not being particularly aggressive about preventing bots from operating on their sites. And so I think when you have a situation that operates in normal supply and demand, you sort of understand that marquee events with high demand are going to have higher prices. But I think when you create artificial scarcity, it's not – we don't support that. But we don't support bots and we'd love for both the government and primary to do even a better job of policing that so that those kinds of things don't happen.
35:41Will Bain: Is there realistically a way that we can stop bots buying up tickets for big events? Yeah, I mean, of course. I mean, I think there's two ways. You know, again, we're in a very different place technology-wise in 2026 than we were even a few years ago. So the ability to see what's a bot coming to your site versus what's a person coming to your site, like that is very clear. And I think that's one where we'd love the primary providers, Ticketmaster, others, to do even a better job of really policing and preventing those bots from operating on their site. And we, you know, again, artificial scarcity or the ability to influence, kind of a bad influence on the supply and demand, we feel like really is not beneficial for marketplaces operating successfully.
36:22Will Bain: I mean, genuine question, is that expensive to do? No, of course not. Putting fans first is the other kind of bill that's been kicking around for a long time now in various consultation phases. Is that a confusion in itself, actually, that there's so many bills sort of overlapping, half overlapping with each other potentially? Yeah. Again, I think we want to put fans first, too. So broadly defined, like we're in support of that objective. And we do that in the form of, again, full transparency around price and ticket, you know, what it is. We don't sell spec tickets. So I think that's one of the things that has been an important part of our business model is we don't sell, like, the promise of a ticket.
36:57We only sell tickets that are legitimate tickets to the best of our ability. And, you know, one quick aside is that, you know, you said we're not in a world of paper tickets anymore, which we're all sort of glad for. But, you know, we've not got the ability within the industry to actually validate a ticket with primary. And there's this idea called interoperability that the industry has been kicking around for a while. You know, blockchain has been around for a long time. Now we have AI. Like it seems very straightforward that we should be able to say to a ticket master or somebody else, hey, is this a valid ticket?
37:27We'd like to resell it. And they would say yes or no. Right now, they don't provide us that opportunity. My point is, like, we have all of this regulation that already supports a fair, safe, transparent marketplace. And, you know, look, we're happy to have a discussion about what else needs to be there. But I think the thing that we know, again, it's not a guess, we know that a price cap doesn't make things cheaper.
37:53Will Bain: Because I was going to say, this one has got a cap proposed in it on no profits. You could get some of the costs and things back, but you couldn't make a profit on the tickets. That's right. Could you? What would that mean functionally as a business for StopHub in the UK? I mean, I think it'd be a challenge. You know, we're always kind of in the mode where we have to assess what's the right opportunity for us. You thought you might not be here if there was gaps. No, of course. I mean, we have to assess whether maintaining a business in the UK makes sense. We'd be open to having a discussion with the government about it makes sense.
38:20I think what doesn't make sense is to just arbitrarily put a price cap on because we know the outcome of that is that all of a sudden tickets are more dangerous to buy. We know that price caps don't make tickets cheaper. Price caps make them more dangerous. And the reason is because people are trying to find value for something that they want to sell. If you have a ticket and you can't use it and you want to sell it and there's value associated with that ticket, you're going to go try to find that in social media or some other channel. All of a sudden, those transactions are going to occur in spaces that you don't really want those transactions, the black market.
38:49I could say, hey, I've got a ticket. You could wire me money through some social media platform and then I could completely disappear.
38:57Will Bain: Bob Cummins there, the chief executive of StubHub International. A bit of housekeeping then. So Ticketmaster, we spoke to them. They told us we block up to 20 billion bots a month and invest millions in stopping them. The problem exists because touts can make huge profits on unofficial resale sites by using bots to hoover up tickets. The answer is the government's proposed ban on resale for profit, which would remove that incentive. We won't validate tickets for marketplaces that help touts profit at fans' expense or legitimise sites that ignore artists' resale rules. And a spokesperson for the Department of Culture, Media and Sport, we remain fully committed to stamping out ticket touting for good.
39:37Will Bain: For too long, fans have been ripped off and we're determined to right that wrong. That's why we're bringing forward legislation in this parliament to ensure that our measures are truly effective, enforceable and future proof. Mike, this made me think immediately, actually, of something you were saying before the news about well-meaning regulation can sometimes go too far. Does Bob Cummins potentially have a point here that the actual problem here is that more people want to go to most events, sport, music, whatever it is, than how it can possibly get a ticket. And so you are always going to have these overspill markets one way or another.
40:11Yeah, I think so. And it's interesting that Ticketmaster's view and his view, they're polar opposite. I don't think you can stop it in a way. However, what big retailers like Ticketmaster could do, I guess, and perhaps they do this already, is they can certainly restrict the number of tickets going to an individual name and address. You know, if someone's buying 10 tickets, clearly they may be reselling them. And I don't know. I don't use the service and I don't know enough about it. But I think you can get to the point of if you start overregulating markets, it causes different problems.
41:01Will Bain: Because, Jane, the reason StubHub International, and I've been careful to keep calling them that throughout, are separate to StubHub now is because StubHub, the company in the United States, and anybody perhaps who's been on holiday and maybe gone to see a baseball game or see an American football game perhaps, possibly will have used their site or via GoGo, is that that's perfectly legal, as we saw during the World Cup, to resell ticket prices online on those sites for more than you bought them for, but that the market's regulated. There's protections, right, that you know you're buying a real ticket, for example, or that you've got recompense if your ticket doesn't turn up, all that kind of stuff.
41:37Will Bain: I mean, that's the other track I guess we could go down. Yes, it is. I mean, I think the issue about this is, yes, you want some regulation on this. The difficulty is this is such a complicated market, and I think it's the effects of any changes are kind of quite difficult to work out. I think that's the general problem here. Yeah, absolutely. And also just the cost. I mean, have you guys been to anything? Mike, it doesn't sound like it, but I mean, sport or music, Jane, I know you've been dragged by the kids to take them to something recently. The price of these things, that's the other thing, isn't it?
42:12Will Bain: The cost of getting in to any of these events in the first place is what's kind of also driving this debate now, I think, a bit too. Yeah, I mean, it's just, you know, it is seriously, seriously expensive. And I'm afraid we've kind of backed away several times when we've kind of, oh, yeah, we'll go to something. and then you just look at the prices and say, it's just not worth it. It's crazy money. Mike, anything for you that's been around that? I know you're a big football man. World Cup, did that take your fancy at all? Yeah, I didn't go to the World Cup, but I plan to go to the next Olympics and I've been to quite a few Olympic games and I'm already worrying because it's in LA.
42:51Yeah. The prices are going to be quite horrific. And of course, all the associated transport and accommodation around it um what a surprise it it triples quadruples or whatever so um yeah i i think it look i think what the government are actually coming from a um a sensible approach because they they want tickets available for the masses i guess they all need to talk a bit more to
43:20Will Bain: each other and perhaps they'll find a better resolution as i say a couple of things going on there there's one called the sporting events but which the government's really kind of sort of bringing in in advance of us hosting the Euros across the UK here in 2028, the men's Euros. And it's got a whole bunch of stuff alongside ticket reselling as well about sort of zones where people can and can't be around grounds and all that kind of stuff after the trouble at the last Euros final against Italy, of course. But also there's a piece that's been rolling basically since Labour came into power, which is looking at ticket reselling more broadly, so for music and things like that as well.
43:54Will Bain: So do check out those and check out the Big Boss Interview podcast on our feed now. There's a bit more of Bob Cummins where he goes into more detail about some of the debates that they're having with government around that kind of stuff if you are interested in it, which I can tell some of you are. Some great texts coming in. Tom, been in touch. Morning, pretty sure. Glastonbury have managed to sell all their tickets without a secondary tout market. Yes, we've seen lots of individual artists do that as well. Ed Sheeran, Taylor Swift, people like that in the past few years as well managed to clamp down on that.
44:21Will Bain: All tickets need to be registered against a passport or ID card. Simple, says John from Hale. 85058, if you want to get in touch, 08085-909693 is the WhatsApp. We were talking about a pretty extraordinary story in the first half of the programme in relation to Jensen Huang, weren't we? This one right up there from here in the UK. A civil servant has been found guilty of nine counts of fraud after using remote working and sick notes to hold down five full-time government jobs at the same time. Southwark Crown Court heard that Kashmin Chowdhury, who's 56, lied about his employment status to secure a string of overlapping roles in government departments and public bodies.
44:58Will Bain: He fraudulently earned more than£280 ,000. Our employment correspondent Zoe Conway has been in court for it. In the spring of 2023, Kashim Chowdhury had five government employers, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, the UK Health Security Agency, the Food Standards Agency, the Department for Business and Trade and the Home Office. During this period, he was contracted to work 183 hours a week, more than the number of hours that exist in seven days. He worked entirely from the home he shared with his mother, who had dementia and terminal cancer. Chowdhury tried to cope with his impossible schedule by going on sick leave in 2023 from four of his jobs, but he carried on working at the Home Office.
45:45He told the jury that he'd been suffering from trauma and stress and didn't know what he was doing, but the prosecution argued that he'd been consistently and intentionally dishonest and had exploited the system. A succession of his line managers gave evidence that he'd performed poorly in his jobs. Joe Hill was a civil servant for seven years who now works for the independent think tank Restate. He says the verdict should be a very big wake-up call for the government. I think the biggest lesson that needs to be learned from this case is that the civil service needs to manage its people much, much better.
46:19You know, at a time when the public finances are really constrained, you can't afford to have people who aren't just underperforming in one job. they're underperforming in five of them at the same time. The government says it will use all available avenues to recover the proceeds of Chowdhury's offending. The judge said Kashim Chowdhury faces a very significant custodial sentence. He said he was refusing bail because of the significance of the crime and for Chowdhury's own well-being.
46:44Will Bain: And Zoe has been in court for every day, pretty much, of that trial. So do go and check out her reporting if you want to see. A bit more about that pretty extraordinary case, isn't it? It's on the business pages of the BBC website. Eight minutes to six here on Five Live. It was one of the biggest nights of the year for the publishing industry as the winner of the Booker Prize for Fiction was announced last night. M. John Harrison has become the oldest ever winner at the age of 81. This is what he said he hoped readers would get from his dystopian novel, The End of Everything. It's a grim world and it will keep on being grim and it's weird.
47:19There's something distinctly weird about it. But at the end of things, there may be some kind of, I wouldn't say hope, or closure, but there might be some kind of relief.
47:34Will Bain: I think it gives you a bit of a flavour of what you might be in store for if you're planning to add that one to your bookshelf. Bea Carvallo joins us this morning. Bea's the head of books at Waterstones and was at the awards last night. So thank you very much for braving a very early morning after an awards night. First of all, Bea. Thank you. Good morning. Thanks for having me. What did you make of it then as a novel? It's an incredible novel. It's very strange and surprising. And yeah, I think it's going to do what lots of the absolute best book winners ever do, which is to really surprise readers and draw in a lot of people who might not have otherwise read it, which is a fantastic thing for all of us.
48:12Will Bain: Yes, they have had a few challenging reads. it's fair to say in the last few editions of the well sort of over the last 10 years probably or so haven't there been a few interesting ones within there the sell out thinking of and others among those in there. Does that make them more difficult to sell? No I think readers always look to the Booker Prize as a kind of trusted source of recommendation so we can always be sure for you know a significant uplift for Booker sellers I mean there are some obviously that will resonate better than others and sell kind of more long term to that level. But the last few have been extremely strong for us.
48:50Flesh last year and Orbital the year before as well. We saw an uplift of over 800 % for Orbital in 2024. And Flesh continues to be in our kind of top 10 paperbacks to this day. So I mean, it is always interesting to see the dialogue and the conversation that the winners spark. And And actually sometimes if they produce a bit of debate, then that's quite useful. Reading is always all about word of mouth. So it's book selling. So, you know, people want to have an opinion about what's won a major prize. That's a really useful thing.
49:24Will Bain: Does it help as well? This might sound a bit of a basic question. I say this as someone who my favourite off this list was by far and away the chunkiest doorstopper of the lot that were in there. that all the ones that you mentioned, Orbital and last year's winner as well, and this one, slimmer novels, does that make them easier to sell as well? It can help. I think for Orbital, the fact that, you know, sometimes I think a literary prize winner can feel maybe inaccessible to lots of readers and actually seeing something which is quite slim and very pretty and you think, well, of course I can give that a go.
50:02I can read that in a weekend. So it's helpful. but we've seen some really successful chunky books win the prize as well. And actually, I think that all the books on this list, it was an exceptional shortlist, very, very good for bookshops. There was not a book on that shortlist which would have been a bad winner for us. And I think actually they'll all continue to see that halo effect from the prize. And booksellers were very passionately hand-selling each of them and I look forward to seeing that continue for the long and short books from the list.
50:34Will Bain: Well, I was going to say your book of the year at Waterstones was on the list, wasn't the winner? Was it May We Feed the King? Do the awards like that, when you announced that as Rebecca Perry's novel, as your book of the year, did you see an uptick straight away as well in people going, oh, I wonder whether I'll come and give that a try? And you also have your kind of monthly ones as well, don't you? Presumably the answer to that as a result is that it does steer people towards these books. So, yeah, May We Feed the King by Rebecca Perry won our Waterstones debut fiction prize. and that was something which was announced in July.
51:05It was announced just a week ahead of the long list being announced. So it was already our number one bestseller at the time of the long list announcement. And we were all just so incredibly proud that the book judges had also recognised it on their long list and then subsequently on the short list. So I think, you know, being able to boost the kind of fortunes of a book that we were already so passionate about and selling so well was such a welcome thing. And obviously, I'm very excited that Rebecca was in contention. The book has been our bestseller of the longlist and of the shortlist as well.
51:46And that has been helped along by its longlisting. And it's currently on our book of the year shortlist as well, having won our prize earlier in the year. it's always great when the prize kind of spotlights books that we're already celebrating last year and Andrew Miller was our book of the month at the time of of the shortlist and that was kind of by far our bestseller at the time helped by the fact was in paperback as well and so yeah I mean there's always a really lovely synergy between between the Booker Prize and and our own favourites. What's nice as well is when there are a couple of surprises along the way, which completely changed the fortune of a book.
52:30Flashlight last year, for example, was a book that we hadn't really done that much with before. It was on the long list and it's gone on to be one of our bestsellers. And so that's also great to see.
52:42Will Bain: Jane, interesting, isn't it, that we've talked loads on the programme. I'm sure you've probably been on when we've talked about it, about the rise of book talk and things like that and social media and what that's done for book selling but that actually old-fashioned things like reviews and prizes and things like that still can from what be saying have a big steer a lot of people myself included tend to read you know book reviews at the weekend in the newspaper whether it's online or or hard copy so so they they are really important makes a huge difference to buying um what do you which do you think which would be your bet be out of the uh out of the six on the shortlist and people can see them all on the BBC website that will be the bestseller at Christmas?
53:22Will Bain: Will it be May We Feed the King? So The End of Everything is now absolutely going to be one of our Christmas bestsellers. The winner of the Booker Prize always is. And really looking forward to seeing just how well it does over the following weeks outside of the winner. Yeah, May We Feed the King is going to continue to be huge for us. I'm really excited to keep recommending that. Will anything beat the Gruffalo Granny, though? Oh, I mean, who could beat Granny? She's just absolutely storming out of the gates. We love to see it. The Gruffalo Granny versus Alex Ferguson, the race for Christmas number one that we all need.
53:58Will Bain: Bea, thanks so much for speaking to us this morning. Thank you. Bea Carvalho there, the head of books at Waterstones, speaking to us about the winner of the Booker Prize there, M. John Harrison. And as I say, you can see all of those shortlisted novels on the BBC website. Mike, thanks so much as always this morning. Really appreciate your time. Thank you. Mike Tompkins there, the chairman of the online sports retailer M &M, and Jane Sydenham, senior investment director at Rathbones. Big thanks to all of you as well for listening to us on Wake Up To Money. Wake Up To Money with Will Bain.
54:32Pensions, savings rates, mortgages, they don't make things simple. I want to help people navigate their way through it. I'll take you through how to manage each week's big money issues step by step And I'll answer your questions on everything and anything within reason. So you can maximise keeping the cash in your pockets. The Martin Lewis Podcast. Listen on BBC Sound.
55:01Will Bain: Innovation has always kept the world moving forward, but it also comes with risk. In a world that is as complex and unpredictable as it is exciting, AXA XL is facing into risk. As a leading global insurer, we constantly push the boundaries to protect your business and power your innovations. Axa Excel, facing into risk for a future to be imagined. This advertisement doesn't constitute an offer or solicitation, nor a description of any products or services of Axa Excel.
55:31With the Amex Gold Card, you can earn four times points at U.S. supermarkets. Because the best nights in start with the grocery run that makes it happen. And when meals come with four times points, moments around the table add up to even more. Apply today and find out your welcome offer, which could be as high as 100 ,000 points. Learn more at AmericanExpress.com slash Explore-Gold. Terms and points cap apply.
After Nvidia shares drop, Will Bain hears what the impact of its CEO's affair might be. Elsewhere, Will speaks to the CEO of StubHub about ticket reselling. And as the winner of the Booker Prize for fiction is announced, could it be a boon for booksellers?