

Wall Street Week episode “Blue Wave Economic Impacts, European Welfare Woes” covers three main stories: (1) what midterm election results mean for economic policy, (2) Alaska’s “hidden winner” dynamic from high oil prices after the Iran conflict, and (3) Europe’s strained welfare promises as pensions and social spending collide with aging populations and higher defense/infrastructure needs. It also includes a Richmond Fed site visit to a manufacturing plant in Union, South Carolina.
Glenn Hubbard (Columbia Business School; former Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers under George W. Bush); Robert Post (former Yale Law School dean; teaches election integrity); Tom Barkin (Richmond Fed President; visits manufacturing); Anton Hemmerich (European University Institute; welfare state/social policy); Monica Kweiser (OECD social policy head); Chrystia Freeland (mentioned as former Canada Deputy PM/Finance Minister); plus local experts Brett Watson (natural resource economics, University of Anchorage) and Lee Cruz (Alaska Deputy Commissioner of Revenue), and Steve Wachowski (Alaska Oil & Gas Association CEO), and Brian Brunzel (Gestamp U.S. operations).
Voters want “what works” and affordability fixes like electricity, permitting reform, and housing costs; tariffs should be paired with policies that expand participation. Trade adjustment assistance is insufficient; moonshot-style adjustment is needed (land-grant colleges, GI Bill). Alaska’s oil windfall can offset household energy/heating costs via dividends/energy rebates; Alaska’s permanent fund structure and taxes are detailed. In South Carolina, manufacturing is expanding; automation shifts work toward skilled roles, with apprenticeships and school partnerships. In Europe, social spending is ~30% of GDP (and ~70% including education), but aging means fewer contributors; pension reform is politically hard; France’s protests reflect crumbling education infrastructure and fiscal stress.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on how the recent midterm elections may influence economic policies.
“Can Europe still afford what it put in place decades ago?”
Interview with Glenn Hubbard discussing economic growth and voter expectations.
“I think there are two messages, and I don't think the press has really picked up on them.”
Discussion on tariffs, trade, and ensuring economic inclusivity for Americans.
“Do they need to address tariffs and trade?”
Analysis of the implications of debt and social security on future policies.
“That sounds like a big government program.”
Exploration of voter perspectives on capitalism versus socialism in the economy.
“That will set up a negative fiscal loop as the government refinances its debt.”
Insights from Professor Robert Post on the protection of election integrity in 2026.
“despite President Trump's past criticism of the process.”
Discussion on the resilience of state and local governments in managing elections.
“It was astonishing how happy I was that there was no crisis, that people just voted and their votes were reported honestly and fairly as far as I could tell.”
Discussion on how the war in Iran affects oil prices and American consumers.
“The ongoing war in Iran has been deeply unpopular in the U.S.”
Understanding Alaska's economy and its dependence on the petroleum industry.
“President Trump is talking about all the money they're making while people are suffering at the pump.”
Examination of the alarming rise in heating oil prices for Alaskans this winter.
“The other leg of the stool is federal government spending, which has been increasing over the last decade or two.”
Insight into Alaska's sovereign wealth fund and its dividends for residents.
“And we'll see no variation until the next barge arrives in the spring.”
Details about Alaska's oil taxes and their impact on state revenue.
“Each year, every Alaskan gets a dividend from the fund.”
Discussing Alaska's unexpected windfall from increased oil prices amid rising costs.
“So the windfall revenues associated with this oil price shock,$1.3 billion.”
Evaluating the potential for future oil production in Alaska amidst historical declines.
“or even exceed, their increased out-of-pocket costs.”
Challenges related to the lengthy permitting process for oil projects in Alaska.
“Oil production peaked in Alaska in 1988 and has declined for decades.”
How global events affect Alaska's economy and energy independence.
“And then as prices rise, the state derives benefit from that.”
Discussion on the focus of U.S. manufacturing under different administrations.
“Again, I pivot back to the national security argument that, thank God we are energy independent here in Alaska or in America, because one thing we're not talking about is rationing or shortages.”
Explore the historical shifts in American manufacturing and its current state.
“Much of the American economic story has been told in its manufacturing plants, exemplified by Henry Ford's creation of the assembly line in Detroit in 1913.”
Discover how a local plant in South Carolina is adapting with technology and investment.
“In Union, South Carolina, a town of some 8 ,000 people over 500 miles from Henry Ford's Detroit, amidst the hum and clatter of the factory floor, steel and aluminum moved through a seamless production line.”
Learn about the efforts to develop skilled workers in the manufacturing sector.
“And building that kind of workforce increasingly starts outside the plant itself, with local schools and training programs helping feed workers into those technical jobs.”
Gain insights on how local economies differ based on firsthand experiences.
“Barkin oversees the Federal Reserve's fifth district, stretching from Maryland and Washington, D.C.”
Understand the challenges facing manufacturers and shifts in consumer demand.
“then every so often, I have an insight that comes from that about how people are going to deploy AI, whether people are going to start laying people off or start investing in growth.”
Discuss the current mood among businesses and their need for stability.
“We're expecting most of our customers will maintain their market position or maybe even grow a little bit.”
Analyze the impact of Europe's social welfare systems on the economy.
“clashes with some harsh economic realities.”
Explores how aging populations are affecting welfare systems in Europe.
“and what it takes to honor them when the bill comes due.”
Discusses the political difficulties surrounding pension reforms across Europe.
“And so it's going to be a difficult fiscal situation.”
Analyzes how different European countries manage welfare spending.
“I mean, countries like Finland, Sweden, Norway, the Netherlands, they're all spending more than 2 % of GDP on the military.”
Emphasizes the importance of balancing social welfare with economic viability.
“That is not really happening in a majoritarian big country like France.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Wall Street Week, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Tom Barkin: The world is transforming faster than ever, and standing still isn't an option. At Oppenheimer, we're working at the forefront of the innovation economy to invest where progress begins, finding opportunities that build and protect wealth for individuals and institutions that want a seat at the edge of tomorrow. Put the power of Oppenheimer Thinking to work for you. Wealth management, capital markets, investment banking. When you're a business owner interested in expanding to new markets, there's a lot to consider and countless questions to answer before making the call. The most important one being, are you ready?
0:40Tom Barkin: That's where ChachiPT comes in. Give it a goal, add your files, and ask chat to help you map out different scenarios for the future of your business. So when growth is on the table, you've got an expansion plan ready to implement. Get started at ChachiPT.com.
0:55Glenn Hubbard: For big business, AI opened up a world of promise, but that world of promise turned into a world of pain. Cost spiraling, data trapped, security and governance risks multiplying, and ROI out of reach. That's why enterprises turned to Boomi to connect data, apps, and AI, helping them operate securely, efficiently, and at scale. Boomi turns a world of AI pain into a world of AI gain. As Boomi says, we got you. Head to boomi.com. That's B-O-O-M-I dot com.
1:41Tom Barkin: This is Wall Street Week. I'm David Westin bringing you stories of capitalism. Americans are reeling from the high cost of diesel and other fuel in the wake of the Iran conflict. We visit one state where people could break even, or even come out ahead. Plus, we continue our site visits with regional Fed presidents, this time with Richmond's Tom Barkin on his visit to a manufacturing plant in Union, South Carolina. And demonstrations in the streets of Paris showed the stress on the French social welfare system. Can Europe still afford what it put in place decades ago? But we start with the aftermath of the midterm elections this week and what they may mean for the policies or lack of policies on the economic issues that matter to voters.
2:28Tom Barkin: We talked with Glenn Hubbard of the Columbia Business School, who served as chair of the Council of Economic Advisers under President George W. Bush.
2:38Glenn Hubbard: I think there are two messages, and I don't think the press has really picked up on them. The first is that voters want what works. The second is that voters want you to actually look at their problems. I think there's a view that, well, the Democrats won because their ideas are better. Well, they may or may not be, but that's not what the electorate was saying. I think the electorate is just saying, give me something that works. Affordability is an example. But really, we've had decades of big change in the economy. Politicians on both sides of the aisle have nodded, but have not offered solutions.
3:10Glenn Hubbard: And I think voters are sick of it.
3:12Tom Barkin: So if the Democrats turn to you tomorrow and said, OK, what plan should we pursue in the new Congress that would address some of the affordability concerns? What would you suggest they look at?
3:22Glenn Hubbard: Well, let me start 30 ,000 feet and then lay on the plane. So 30 ,000 feet, it ought to be about two things. One is economic growth. It's still the case. Growth makes everything in life easier, makes us better off. But the other is to have a full participation economy. Don't be glib and say, AI will make us better off the same way globalization would or any other technological change. Tell us how we all can participate. Going down to the landing field, how are you going to prepare people for those new jobs? Give the voters some specific ideas. And on affordability, talk about electricity. Talk about permitting reform.
3:58Glenn Hubbard: Go into the housing market and talk about why it costs so much to build particular places. I don't think they're going to do any of that. But I think that's the thing that needs to be done.
4:07Tom Barkin: Do they need to address tariffs and trade? Because I think most Americans heard President Trump talk a lot about tariffs and associated it, whether fairly or not, perhaps fairly, with higher prices.
4:18Glenn Hubbard: I do think they need to address it, but maybe not for the reason people think. Tariffs did raise prices and Americans did bear the burdens of tariffs. Everything your Ecom 101 professor taught you is still true. BUT I THINK WHAT THE PRESIDENT SAW, AND BY THE WAY, JOE BIDEN SAW IT TOO, WAS THAT THE PUBLIC IS CONCERNED ABOUT AMERICA'S COMPETITIVENESS AND STAND IN THE WORLD. SO I THINK ANYBODY WHO SAYS, I WANT TO RENEW TRADE, I WANT TO REDUCE TARIFFS, ALSO HAS TO HAVE IN MIND, HOW AM I GOING TO HELP, AGAIN, MORE AMERICANS COME INTO THIS ECONOMY AND PARTICIPATE IN IT FULLY? SO I DO THINK TARIF REDUCTION IS WHAT PEOPLE HAVE IN MIND, BUT ONLY IF IT'S MARRIED WITH, WELL, HOW ARE YOU REALLY GOING TO HELP?
4:58Tom Barkin: When you talk about including more people in the pie.
5:01Glenn Hubbard: Meaningful work. In other words, making sure that, let's say we say AI has enormous promise for the economy. GDP can grow by a lot more. Productivity is greater. All sounds good on average. But you and I are individual people. There are other individual people that will watch your show. The question in their mind is, am I one of those people? So we need a policy that says everybody's going to be in the boat. It doesn't mean we all get the same thing, but we all are going to get changed opportunities rather than just saying, well, the tech sector will work it out. I think that's cold comfort for a lot of people.
5:34Tom Barkin: Have we ever done that? I mean, there was trade adjustment assistance, as I recall, with the auto industry back in the 80s that didn't really pan out. Well, yes and no.
5:44Glenn Hubbard: So trade adjustments, I have sometimes quipped that it helped four people and a chicken or something. It came about in the 1962 trade bill because I think President Kennedy had the right intuition that you did have to help people adjust. To me, it doesn't matter whether a shock comes from trade or internally. You should always help people adjust. Trade adjustment assistance has worked in some areas, for example, wage insurance programs. So I think rather than calling a trade adjustment assistance, what could we design? Bigger picture, we've done this much larger ways. The most obvious example is land-grant colleges.
6:19Glenn Hubbard: It's an old one. We had an agrarian economy. We wanted to make a manufacturing economy. We democratized education and did just that. The GI Bill after World War II is another example. So I think programs as small as trade adjustment assistance aren't going to fit the bill. You would need somebody who articulates a moonshot, not to build too much on President Kennedy aphorisms, to make that clear to the public.
6:44Tom Barkin: That sounds like a big government program. I'm not sure that the country is ready for that. right now, and I'm not sure we have the money for it. I don't think it's a big government program.
6:52Glenn Hubbard: I think it's a big idea. Remember the land-grant colleges were literally just land grants. It was up to others to raise the funds. I think what's necessary is to change the tune in Washington that we do notice everybody, and we do want everybody to participate in the economy. And a shot across the bow to business leaders, you can help in this regard, or by the way, you too will face the political pressures and regulatory pressures to do so.
7:19Tom Barkin: One of the big issues that I think should have been in the agenda, but I didn't hear anybody talking about it, is the debt and deficit. Because we're going to have to pay for things sooner or later.
7:27Glenn Hubbard: Well, let me give you a crazy optimist take. Because the Social Security trust funds run out in 2032, now those are actually meaningless accounting fictions, but they matter a lot in Washington. Whoever the next president is, he, she, Democrat, Republican, doesn't matter. They will face that, as will currently elected senators. It's going to be on their watch. So I think we're finally at the point where the public has both a right and responsibility to say, David, you're running for office. Tell me what you're going to do about Social Security. Is it taxes? Is it benefits? Is it whatever? So I think we will have progress there.
8:03Glenn Hubbard: The other thing that sadly gives me optimism is that I do think interest rates will be higher for longer. That will set up a negative fiscal loop as the government refinances its debt. And we will have to have a discussion of what we're going to do. We all know it's unpopular. And we all know what we need to do.
8:22Tom Barkin: One of the things that was different, at least in my experience about this election, was that you could say capitalism was on the ballot. We had Democratic Socialists of America candidates coming forward with socialists, a validly socialist platform. Did they make a difference? Was it serious or was that mainly just attention?
8:40Glenn Hubbard: I think it's mainly attention, but there's a deeper story there. I don't think most voters are even thinking at the level of, do I want Adam Smith's capitalism or Karl Marx's socialism? I think what they're thinking is, I want an economic system that works for everybody, and we don't have one. And if somebody wants to come along and call that socialism, I'll at least listen to that man or woman. So I think it's incumbent on both sides to deliver a message in the middle that says, of course, this economic system can work for many more people. And it has. And here's how.
9:11Tom Barkin: Whatever the new Congress does, the definitive results of the midterm elections put to rest concerns about whether they would be accepted, despite President Trump's past criticism of the process. Professor Robert Post is the former dean of the Yale Law School, where he teaches a course on preserving the integrity of the electoral system. So, Professor, there's been a lot of talk and concern about these 2026 midterm elections and whether they would go off without a hitch. In fact, you teach a course on protecting the election in 2026. In retrospect, did it need protection?
9:45Glenn Hubbard: Leading up to the election, there were just enormous worries because we'd seen a lot of initiatives seemingly designed to undercut the election. There was the attempt to cut off mail-in ballots and use the post office for that. There was the attempt to get voter rolls so they could take people off the rolls. There were the various lawsuits, their endless subpoenas to election officials. So it looked at the time before the election that the Trump administration was trying to make people lose faith in the institution of the election, trying to make people not trust the outcome of the election. And because the Trump administration had all the resources of the federal government, which are considerable, there was great fear about how far he would go.
10:30Glenn Hubbard: And of course, when we have somebody who did January 6th, that fear could go in many different directions. That could be really terrible. So there was this apprehension about what would happen on November 3rd. I remember feeling that. It was astonishing how happy I was that there was no crisis, that people just voted and their votes were reported honestly and fairly as far as I could tell. That was amazing. And it was such a relief.
11:01Tom Barkin: Every election is about who gets elected, but it's also about us, who we are, the people who are voting. And I wonder what you think this election tells us about some of our institutions. And start with state and local government who really run and by constitution are supposed to run elections. What did we learn about them?
11:19Glenn Hubbard: Well, we learned that state and local governments are enormously resilient. They were put under pressure by the federal government. And, you know, liberals used to grow up thinking about the federal government as the guarantor. And now we think about the state and local officials as the guarantor. And we see as the great strength of the American elections that they're run by local officials who take great pride in what they do.
11:44Tom Barkin: We're on Bloomberg. And at Bloomberg, we focus on the economy and on business commerce. And obviously, the democratic process is critical for governing the country, first and foremost. But it also, the rule of law is important for contracts, for U.S. treasuries, which are promises to repay. What is the risk to our economy and to our markets, to our businesses, if in fact we really put into question the rule of law?
12:14Glenn Hubbard: I think that's a very deep and inaccurate point. In the first Trump administration, I had tried to get business support to support the rule of law. And what we have seen in this administration is quite beyond anything we saw in the first Trump administration. In the first two years of the second Trump administration, we have seen an executive that really doesn't care about the rule of law. It acts first and then it attempts to explain to a court later. And it has politicized the Justice Department in ways that if I were a business person, I would be terrified.
12:48Tom Barkin: Up next, the cost of gasoline and diesel fuel was one of the things on Americans' minds as they went to the polls this week. But it looks a bit different in the state of Alaska, which is making money off of high fuel prices and even returning part of it to its citizens.
13:11Glenn Hubbard: We believe in starting with your financial goals, not a formula. At Oppenheimer, we put the full strength of our longstanding expertise to work, understanding your life and your ambitions, and designing the precise strategies that build and protect your wealth with confidence across this generation and the next. Put the power of Oppenheimer thinking to work for you. Wealth management, capital markets, investment banking.
13:40Tom Barkin: This is the Bloomberg Tech Minute brought to you by ChatGPT. I'm Carol Masser. Millions of Americans are taking peptides, short strings of amino acids that can act as biological signals for cells. Bloomberg's Annika Inampudi reports peptides may be exploring their next frontier, the brain. People are taking peptides for mental clarity and cognitive benefits and to gain a competitive edge or stave off the effects of aging. Both insulin and semaglutide are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Because importing or selling unapproved peptides for human use is not legal in the U.S., many people turn to online forums for guidance and overseas vendors with questionable credentials to obtain them.
14:20Tom Barkin: Unapproved peptides, which are marketed as research chemicals, have been circulating in what's become a billion-dollar gray market amid the rise of do-it-yourself medicine as people increasingly turn to social media or artificial intelligence for medical help. That's the Bloomberg Tech Minute brought to you by ChachiPT. Get started at ChachiPT.com.
14:47Tom Barkin: This is a story of hidden winners. The ongoing war in Iran has been deeply unpopular in the U.S. Oil prices have surged, hitting Americans in the wallet across the 50 states. But President Trump insists that the conflict will benefit Americans in no small part because of its role as a net petroleum exporter.
15:07Glenn Hubbard: I could just see the fake headlines. President Trump is talking about all the money they're making while people are suffering at the pump. That'll be the headline. But I said, I don't give a damn. I'm going to say it.
15:18Tom Barkin: We'll make it a freaking fortune. Rugged, remote, and sparsely populated, Alaska is often called the last frontier, and its economy is perhaps as unusual as its landscape.
15:32Glenn Hubbard: We liken Alaska's economy to a three-legged stool. One leg of the stool is held up by our petroleum industry. The other leg of the stool is federal government spending, which has been increasing over the last decade or two. And then the third leg of the stool is everything else, our mining, timber, tourism industries. So what we've seen over the last decade or so under declining oil prices is that oil leg has gotten a little shakier as the federal government leg has gotten a little sturdier. So maybe now it's a bit more like a rocking chair than a stool. But the resurgence in oil prices over the last year has brought in both new revenue to the state government, but also pinched consumers.
16:11Tom Barkin: Alaska ranks among the highest states in revenue per resident coming from oil production. But it also spends more on energy per person than any other state. Brett Watson is a professor of natural resource economics at the University of Anchorage, Alaska.
16:26Glenn Hubbard: Now, as we're entering into winter, increasingly people are finding kind of eye-watering prices for home heating fuel oil. Prices are considerable,$10 a gallon, up to$20 a gallon in some places for this heating fuel oil. Essentially, the prices that those communities are seeing right now are going to be locked in for the rest of the winter. And we'll see no variation until the next barge arrives in the spring. So the prices that they're paying today are what they should expect to pay for the rest of the winter.
16:53Tom Barkin: Those higher prices hurt households, and will continue to hurt them through the winter. But unlike most other U.S. consumers, Alaskans will also benefit, both directly and indirectly, because their state is a major oil producer. It's a state that is unique in many ways. Roughly 80 % of its communities cannot be reached by road. And, as we explored two years ago, it's also a state with its own sovereign wealth fund. The United States has over$330 billion in sovereign wealth funds, but the largest one is the one in Alaska.
17:28Glenn Hubbard: This is a very popular topic in Alaska. Every year, it's like, how much is the dividend going to be this year? When are we getting it? Are we getting direct deposit? It's uniquely Alaskan, to be honest with you. It's a way for Alaskans to store their non-renewable resources, especially oil, mining.
17:45Tom Barkin: Each year, every Alaskan gets a dividend from the fund. Lee Cruz is the Deputy Commissioner of Revenue in Alaska.
17:53Glenn Hubbard: So we have both a royalty as well as a production tax. So our royalty is between 12.5 % and 16.6%. That largely depends on where the leases were granted and when they were granted. Out of that, 25 % to 50 % goes to the principal of the permanent fund. And that also depends on the when and where those leases were issued. Half a percent goes into the public school trust fund, and then the rest of it goes to our general fund. Now also we have our production tax, which is essentially a net profits tax. That's a 35 % tax on the oil that's produced and that all goes to our general fund. I'd say the only other thing on top of that is we do have a 9.4 % corporate income tax.
18:34Glenn Hubbard: And so when those corporations are seeing an increase in revenues from the increase in both production and price of oil, we also see that benefit as well. Our spring revenue forecast estimated oil at 75 a barrel. So at 75 a barrel, we also estimate that for every dollar increase that the price per barrel sees, you'll have an additional 45 million in revenues to the state. So this year, compared to the state's forecasted revenue from last December, the state will probably, year to date, has probably brought in another$1.3 billion that were unforecasted. So the windfall revenues associated with this oil price shock,$1.3 billion.
19:13Glenn Hubbard: On a household basis, that's almost$5 ,000 per household.
19:17Tom Barkin: This year, with that increased revenue, the state was able to pay out a dividend of$1 ,000 to every Alaskan, plus an extra$200 energy rebate payment. So that's$5 ,000 perhaps per household of net increased revenue for the state. First of all, what does that mean for the state budget?
19:37Glenn Hubbard: So the state's budget varies pretty considerably with oil prices. because of oil price volatility, the state's budget is also quite volatile. As I said, the state passed a balanced budget on a forecasted oil price last year of$55 a barrel. Obviously, oil prices are considerably higher than that today. And so that's where this windfall amount comes from. Now, the state budgeted what they called a waterfall provision. They said, OK, if we raise an extra$200 million that we didn't expect, let's invest that in our state's education system. If we get another$200 million that we didn't expect, we'll add that to our state's permanent fund dividend distribution this year.
20:15Glenn Hubbard: And so Alaskans, every Alaska man, woman, and child this last October, beginning of October, received another$200 on top of their ordinary permanent fund dividend payment as a so-called energy rebate. And it's likely the case that come January, when the legislature reconvenes, there'll be discussions about potentially adding another energy rebate supplement.
20:35Tom Barkin: Watson estimates higher oil prices caused by the war could cost rural Alaskans thousands of dollars a year, even as they are due to receive increased payments from their permanent fund that may cover, or even exceed, their increased out-of-pocket costs. But they don't hit all Alaska residents equally. Around Anchorage, higher costs to households are roughly offset by the money returned by the government. In more remote areas, they may not be. Your oil price, so it's coming down.
21:05Glenn Hubbard: But your country is making an absolute fortune because of the situation in the Middle East. Alaska is a big beneficiary. Everybody is a benefit. The whole country.
21:17Tom Barkin: President Trump has said when it comes to fuel prices, actually, the United States is going to benefit because we're a net exporter as a country. We can quibble with that one way or the other. But it sounds like maybe that is true for the state of Alaska.
21:30Glenn Hubbard: That's certainly how I would characterize the situation, that the potential windfall for the state in terms of our revenue situation should likely exceed on an average basis the increase in expenditures at a household level. So really, the state has an opportunity to make every citizen of the state whole if the state correctly determines appropriation decisions.
21:53Tom Barkin: But for Alaska, the question is not just whether it can get more per barrel for the oil it produces. There's also the question of whether it can produce more in the future. We will drill, baby, drill. Oil production peaked in Alaska in 1988 and has declined for decades. But there are signs of activity picking up again. And the Trump administration has made it a focus to expand oil and gas production in the state.
22:20Glenn Hubbard: We're not comparable to the Permian Basin where the Bakken plays, right? That's kind of like the fast food of oil and gas. we're very much more fine dining.
22:31Tom Barkin: Steve Wachowski is the president and CEO of the Alaska Oil and Gas Association.
22:36Glenn Hubbard: So the Trans-Alaska Pipeline System, or TAPS, as we call it, is the absolute artery that brings the lifeblood of Alaska's economy and Alaska's private sector to life. And it wasn't that long ago where we saw investment leave Alaska, the TAPS throughput, that means the oil coming down the pipeline was under rapid decline. And at that 2012 study, the federal government said, hey, look, in a low price environment, we could talk about decommissioning the pipeline as early as this year. The impacts of what that would look like for Alaska can't be undersold. I mean, we would be having a much, much harder discussion in this high price environment if the state was driving zero benefit from higher oil prices.
23:22Glenn Hubbard: So what Alaska's leaders did is they looked at our tax structure. They provided some incentives to both develop and keep our legacy fields in Prudhoe Bay online. Again, these are 40, 50-year-old oil fields. We've got a member company called Hillcorp based out of Houston. They've been doing incredible work getting some of these old legacy fields like Milne Point back to their nameplate capacity in production, which is like unheard of. And then we created a tax and a fiscal system that actually incentivized new entrants to come back. So we saw companies like Santos, Repsol come in, invest in PICA.
23:59Glenn Hubbard: We just had First Oil come online this summer, an additional up to 80 ,000 barrels. And so I think you've seen this stable, predictable fiscal system that's durable, right? So the durability there is the state retains some profit at a low price environment. And then as prices rise, the state derives benefit from that. It takes a long time to bring Alaska projects online. So we just can't pivot on a dime. We're unlike the shale place, right? Where we can't, you know, turn a couple of rigs on, throw some fracks in and get an additional 10, 20 ,000 barrels. These are long lead items. I think part and parcel of that, it is absolutely critical that one thing we're talking to them about all the time now is this permitting reform.
24:38Glenn Hubbard: So, you know, you look at a project like Willow, which is one of our most significant new projects coming online. It took over three years, over a thousand days to permit that satellite production facility and their associated processing facility. So the need for permitting reform for tighter deadlines and to have agencies stay on task and not to deal with differing permit strata in each different agency and for it to be combined under one effort is absolutely critical for us to be able to bring that online.
25:09Tom Barkin: For now, Alaska is cashing in on the net effects. While many Alaskans are feeling it daily as they pump their gasoline, statewide, the benefits appear to be outweighing the costs, which means that although most Americans disapprove of the war in Iran, in part because it means less money in their pocket, Alaska might be a quiet winner.
25:32Glenn Hubbard: And you can go back and I can point you to legislative testimony where, you know, I was testifying in front of the Senate, the Alaska State Senate Resources Committee. And the chairman says, we're not celebrating war, but we've been gifted with a high commodity price because of this conflict. And it makes some decisions that we have to make easier. I will have to say, I am a serving member of the Alaska Air National Guard. I have colleagues deployed in the Middle East right now. You'll never see myself or the Alaska Oil and Gas Association celebrate conflict that rises the commodity price. Again, I pivot back to the national security argument that, thank God we are energy independent here in Alaska or in America, because one thing we're not talking about is rationing or shortages.
26:16Glenn Hubbard: There are countries in Asia right now that have had to tune down general aviation schedules and ration fuel. We don't have that problem. I do realize it still means that families do struggle at the pump and to pay for heating oil, but it is an interesting paradox.
26:35Tom Barkin: Coming up, President Trump has made manufacturing in the U.S. a priority, as did President Biden before him. We go on a trip to South Carolina with the Richmond Fed President Tom Barkin to see how manufacturing is holding up in his district.
26:58Tom Barkin: This is the Bloomberg Tech Minute brought to you by Chachi PT. I'm Carol Masser. Millions of Americans are taking peptides, short strings of amino acids that can act as biological signals for cells. Bloomberg's Anika Inampudi reports peptides may be exploring their next frontier, the brain. People are taking peptides for mental clarity and cognitive benefits and to gain a competitive edge or stave off the effects of aging. Both insulin and semaglutide are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Because importing or selling unapproved peptides for human use is not legal in the U.S., many people turn to online forums for guidance and overseas vendors with questionable credentials to obtain them.
27:38Tom Barkin: Unapproved peptides, which are marketed as research chemicals, have been circulating in what's become a billion-dollar gray market amid the rise of do-it-yourself medicine as people increasingly turn to social media or artificial intelligence for medical help. That's the Bloomberg Tech Minute brought to you by ChatGPT. Get started at ChatGPT.com.
27:58Glenn Hubbard: The world of business is constantly evolving. Every day, new challenges, new opportunities, new ways of working. Comcast Business keeps you totally in step with secure AI-backed networking built to power the way modern business gets things done today in more than 100 countries around the world. That's some serious muscle. And get this, Comcast business powers over 90 % of the Fortune 500 and millions of small businesses. Behind it all, network engineers, cybersecurity specialists, support teams, thousands of experts answering your call at 2 a.m. like it's 2 p.m. Always on, always ready. That's a lot of coffee.
28:40Glenn Hubbard: One partner powering how business gets done for companies of every size all around the globe. When you add it all up, no one does business like Comcast business.
28:57Tom Barkin: This is a story about the good old days. Much of the American economic story has been told in its manufacturing plants, exemplified by Henry Ford's creation of the assembly line in Detroit in 1913. But as essential as manufacturing has been to the growth of the American economy through the years, it has changed profoundly over time. The promise of seeing that change firsthand is what brought Richmond Fed President Tom Barkin to a small city in South Carolina, where Bloomberg's Michael McKee joined him.
29:33Glenn Hubbard: In Union, South Carolina, a town of some 8 ,000 people over 500 miles from Henry Ford's Detroit, amidst the hum and clatter of the factory floor, steel and aluminum moved through a seamless production line. What we have is we have automated assembly lines, which take metal stamp parts and put them together into the geometry for our customers. This plant does primarily hoods and doors. Gestamp has been building here in Union for years, and the scale of that investment is easy to see. Brian Brunzel helps oversee the company's U.S. operations. If you look at this facility, you can tell that our business is extremely capital intensive, and we're putting in assets that are here for 30 years.
30:16Glenn Hubbard: So we're planning long-term and committing to Union County. Gestamp's investment comes amid a broader pickup in U.S. manufacturing, with factory activity expanding for 10 straight months. So you're able to obviously spend capital and buy equipment, but you said employees are the hard part. Human resource is really the key to our business. The equipment is going to function. It's going to function as designed, But without the right people to maintain it, to make sure that we have longevity with it, to program it, to operate all the robots you said you saw out there, we're no good. So it's really the core of our business is our people.
30:52Glenn Hubbard: And we're working on new initiatives related to digitalization and those things. But they're not to replace our people. They're just to give our people better tools to manage our business in the future. The union plant currently employs roughly 600 people and shows just how blurred the lines are between manufacturing and technology. Many of the factory's jobs increasingly require specialized technical skills. Are robots or AI going to take more jobs, or how does that play out here? No, in fact, they create more skilled positions, more high-paying jobs, and more opportunity for our employees. The robotics require people to program the robots, to work through the controls.
31:32Glenn Hubbard: You know, we look at digitalization, artificial intelligence as more of a support role for our employees and not something that's going to take their positions. And building that kind of workforce increasingly starts outside the plant itself, with local schools and training programs helping feed workers into those technical jobs. Tell me about the investments you've made in South Carolina and what you have planned for the future. How is it affecting the area? This plant's been through, I think, three or four major expansions with our partnership with our OEM partners. As far as the union area, we're doing some really interesting things.
32:06Glenn Hubbard: First of all, we've got job shattering with the local high schools to give people the opportunity to see what a technical career looks like for them, how that could be very beneficial to them. And then the other thing we're doing is we're starting an apprenticeship program to give people the opportunity to learn, you know, tool and die and maintenance to provide themselves and their family a good living in training right here. And one of the messages when you come into Gestamp is once you're in the door, you can do whatever you want. We'll provide you the opportunity if you show the initiative.
32:34Glenn Hubbard: And you probably talked about that with Tom Barkin. Yeah, he was very interested in how we're developing people. And, you know, Mr. Barkin was very supportive of those things. He had a very good understanding of how a lot of those technical resources and tool and dye and things have left the country, actually. And now we're redeveloping them for our use in this plants. Those connections between a company, its workers, and the community around it are part of what Richmond Fed President Tom Barkin came to Union to see up close. We'll come to your stump. We'll like it if you're hiring a bunch of people and you're not raising prices.
33:10Glenn Hubbard: Because while the data can show what is happening in the economy, Barkin says getting out into his district helps him understand what's behind it. Well, I told my board when I took the job that we have a beautiful 24-story tower in Richmond. right on the interstate. It's literally an ivory tower. And I said, it's just hard to figure out the economy from the tower. And we do get the data. We study the data. You can study it from your office. You can study it from your car. I've just committed myself to being in the market, talking to people about what's actually happening. And I think you learn a lot about what's behind the data.
33:43Glenn Hubbard: So you try to understand the data better. I think you actually do get some insight on turning points before you otherwise would, because you're talking to people who are giving you live information on hiring and firing or on pricing or on input cost pressures or on demand. Barkin oversees the Federal Reserve's fifth district, stretching from Maryland and Washington, D.C. through Virginia and the Carolinas. And depending on where he goes, the economy can look very different. Is it a uniform view across the district? It's definitely not a uniform view across my district. Now, my district has D.C.
34:17Glenn Hubbard: and Maryland in it and it has South and North Carolina in it. In D.C. and Maryland, you've got an economy very tied to government spending. And I'd say that's a much more challenged environment. In the Carolinas, you've got 2 % workforce growth every year, housing's being built, companies are moving here, people are moving here. It's a much more vibrant economy. You've got a lot of manufacturing in your district. How are the manufacturers feeling about tariffs? What are they telling you? very much depends on where you come from. So we see big differences by sector. Pharmaceutical, for example, big investments being made in North Carolina and Virginia based on some of those deals that have been struck in the context of the pharmaceutical tariffs.
34:58Glenn Hubbard: On the other hand, in South Carolina, I talked to a lot of foreign assemblers who may be importing their parts from overseas, but assembling locally and being tariffed on the parts that are coming in from overseas and they don't like it. So really, I'd say weighted average manufacturing in my district is net positive, but big differences based on what impact you're seeing. Now, when you put together the data that you get and then the insights that you get, how far ahead does that help you see the economy? Well, I think what you hear is today, or maybe it was yesterday, what you see in the data might be last month or maybe the month before that.
35:38Glenn Hubbard: And I think seeing the future requires a lot of courage and a lot of synthesis and a lot of insight. I'm not sure you see a ton of the future just from a conversation, but when you have a lot of conversations and you add it up, then every so often, I have an insight that comes from that about how people are going to deploy AI, whether people are going to start laying people off or start investing in growth. So you do your best to figure out the future, but I think it's difficult. I'll tell you two things I do try to ask whenever I'm with somebody. One is, what are your budget assumptions for next year?
36:14Glenn Hubbard: Because if you understand what they're budgeting in terms of headcount or compensation increases or price increases, that tells you something about what's coming. And the second is, do you have any plans in process to lay people off? Because it actually takes a few months to put a layoff plan in process. And if people are starting to think about it, that'll give you at least a couple months head start on what's happening in the jobs market. What did you learn today? We're trying to understand what's happening in the economy. And so we talked a lot about demand, which still seems to be solid. What do you see the economy in the union account?
36:47Glenn Hubbard: The thing I'm particularly trying to push on is, do people still have the ability to pass on their input costs to their customers in terms of prices? And we had a lot of conversation about the ability to do that or not do that. And my sort of base question is, are we in 2016 or are we in 23 or are we in a different year? And I don't think we're in 2023 anymore, but I also don't think we're back in 2016. At Gestamp, that question is playing out in real time, with demand holding up, even as the company adjusts to a changing market. You make auto parts and the automobile industry seems to be seeing declining sales, a bit of a slowdown.
37:28Glenn Hubbard: Are you seeing the same? We see strong sales with some of our core customers. Obviously, there was a big rotation out of battery electric vehicles over the last years. I think some of the automakers need to recover from some of those investments. So I guess to answer your question, there's pockets that are doing really well and there's pockets that are struggling. What about the outlook for sales going forward? I think in the U.S. we see pretty consistently 16 million vehicle sales coming in the future years. We're expecting most of our customers will maintain their market position or maybe even grow a little bit.
38:07Glenn Hubbard: So I think it's going to be strong. But in a business built around long-term investment, changes in the market can take time to absorb. Our customers are very focused on reducing costs right now. They've had a lot of things in the changing environment related to some inflationary topics or tariffs or things like that. So there's a real focus we see on cost. The other thing we see is really a shift back to the internal combustion engine. Two or three years ago, everything was focused on the battery electric vehicle. And now we're shifting back to the internal combustion engine right now. And they're doing new developments and we're seeing new opportunities associated with that.
38:42Glenn Hubbard: How nimble is your company if we suddenly shift back to electric vehicles? I mean, I think we're as agile as anybody in this space. But I mean, you're in the building, you see it. We're very capital intensive. There's a lot of investment in the business we're in. Stability is our friend. If we have a stable environment and we could do that, but switching back very quickly would be difficult, but no more difficult for us than anyone else. Ultimately, the strongest and most important measure of stability is whether customers keep coming back. Our biggest concern about that is keeping the consumer buying cars.
39:17Glenn Hubbard: We need a strong consumer and strong car. Our business works really well when we're selling the amount of cars we're supposed to sell. Our customers are getting the sales they have in the market, and we're making the parts we need. So as long as the cars are competitive and people are able to buy the cars, our business works very well. It is that broader search for stability and certainty that Barkin says he hears from businesses across his district. What's the mood among the business people that you talk to throughout your district? Well, so it's very torqued. And the way I would describe it is their business, by and large, is doing fine.
39:52Glenn Hubbard: When you talk to people about the businesses, earnings are strong, margins are holding up. People feel pretty good about their business, but they don't like the macro environment around it. Uncertainty is something you hear a lot about, a call for stability. Here in Union, the machinery, much like the economy around it, keeps moving. despite no shortage of forces that could slow it down. Years of automation, rising costs, and uncertainty have all tested the sector, and yet the American manufacturing engine keeps humming. For Barkin, understanding that balance is at the heart of the job, and ultimately the choices the Fed has to make.
40:33Tom Barkin: Up next, the streets of Paris erupt as a cherished social welfare system clashes with some harsh economic realities. we look at the costs and the benefits of Europe's approach to public welfare.
41:11Tom Barkin: benefits and to gain a competitive edge or stave off the effects of aging. Both insulin and semaglutide are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Because importing or selling unapproved peptides for human use is not legal in the U.S., many people turn to online forums for guidance and overseas vendors with questionable credentials to obtain them. Unapproved peptides, which are marketed as research chemicals, have been circulating in what's become a billion-dollar gray market amid the rise of do-it-yourself medicine as people increasingly turn to social media or artificial intelligence for medical help.
41:45Tom Barkin: That's the Bloomberg Tech Minute brought to you by ChatGPT. Get started at chatgpt.com.
41:51Glenn Hubbard: The world of business is constantly evolving. Every day, new challenges, new opportunities, new ways of working. Comcast Business keeps you totally in step with secure AI-backed networking built to power the way modern business gets things done today in more than 100 countries around the world. That's some serious muscle. And get this, Comcast business powers over 90 % of the Fortune 500 and millions of small businesses. Behind it all, network engineers, cybersecurity specialists, support teams, thousands of experts answering your call at 2 a.m. like it's 2 p.m. Always on, always ready. That's a lot of coffee.
42:33Glenn Hubbard: One partner powering how business gets done for companies of every size all around the globe. When you add it all up, no one does business like Comcast Business.
42:48Tom Barkin: This is a story about promises, the ones governments make to their people, and what it takes to honor them when the bill comes due. In the wake of World War II, Europe built a robust social welfare system, including pensions, employment support, housing, and education. But as the population ages, people are feeling the repercussions of paying the price for all that's been promised, particularly as other spending priorities, such as defense and tech, become urgent. And when people don't feel they're getting what they were promised, those repercussions can spill into the streets.
43:27Tom Barkin: In mid-September, student protests swept across France, triggered initially by demands for more resources for the country's schools.
43:39Tom Barkin: The youth of France may be dissatisfied with how much is spent on education, and they may be right. But it's not because the country scrimps on social spending overall. France spends nearly a third of its GDP on social protection in a country where 35 % of the population is 55 or older. And France isn't alone. Nine countries in the European Union spend at least a quarter of their GDP on public social spending. And the median age has increased in every EU member state except for Germany and Malta. Anton Hemmerich is a professor at the European University Institute and and his studies focus on the welfare state and social policy.
44:21Glenn Hubbard: I think if you look at the countries of Western Europe, in particular, they spend about 30 % of GDP on social outlays, and that goes from social protection, social insurance, pensions. And if you include education, it's about 70 % of the public purse.
44:40Tom Barkin: The European social welfare system was built in the wake of World War II, when the population was young and growing, and the economy was resurging after the demonstration of the war. Today is a very different story. France has more than 17 million direct pension recipients, a number that is growing faster than the workers that support it. The trends we're seeing are, of course, closely related to population aging. All OECD countries are aging, and European countries perhaps are among the group of faster aging countries. There is more and more pensioners for fewer and fewer contributors. And so it's going to be a difficult fiscal situation.
45:20Tom Barkin: Monica Kweiser is the head of social policy at the OECD. Now, countries are fully aware of that, and they're trying to remedy the situation mostly by looking at pensions. Why pensions? Pensions are a big chunk of social spending, and pensions are relatively easy to manage because it's only about money in and money out. And there's a saying in the United States which says that pensions are the third rail of politics, touch it and you die, which means that politically speaking, it is very, very difficult for political parties, for governments to address pension reform, because the sad truth is even though people should be working longer, the vast majority of people do not want to work longer.
46:03Tom Barkin: And so touching the retirement age is something that is hugely unpopular in all countries. The politics of changing pensions are difficult everywhere. But the need for more money for retirees in Europe comes at a time when it also needs to find resources for other pressing needs. We're seeing mostly in Europe right now, we are really seeing this tension between the necessary increases for defense spending and the needs for social benefits. But not only that, also other investments, for example, public investments in infrastructure. One of the reasons why the youth here in France were protesting is that the education infrastructure is crumbling.
46:44Tom Barkin: So this is a real tension that will be increasing because we know that in almost all countries, we will see increased pension spending. Those countries that invested early in more capital-funded pensions are able to shoulder this burden more easily because they can draw down existing reserves. Those countries that have no reserves, for them it's got much more difficult. But not everyone agrees that there must be a choice between social welfare spending or defense spending.
47:10Glenn Hubbard: There is a bit of a debate going on, which I really dislike in Europe, of sort of, you know, is there a trade-off between warfare and welfare? And really, it's a misguided way of looking at the issues. I mean, again, if you look at sort of, you know, the country comparison across Europe, I mean, countries like Finland, Sweden, Norway, the Netherlands, they're all spending more than 2 % of GDP on the military. It's the countries that have more, let's call them passive welfare states, you know, France, Italy and Spain. They spend far less on defense. You know, there must be a trade-off somewhere, but it, you know, it doesn't stand up to the evidence.
47:50Tom Barkin: And some believe there are ways to address the fiscal pressures from things like pensions if there is the political will to do so. Chrystia Freeland dealt with these issues as Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister of Canada. Isn't there an inherent problem there, an inherent sort of generation rift, as it were, as you get a larger percentage of population who are eligible for pensions and a smaller who are actually in the workforce?
48:15Glenn Hubbard: Well, it's a problem if you fail to do two things. If you fail to move the pension age up as people live longer, and France has tried to do that but failed. But France has a much younger retirement age than the Nordic countries that are doing well fiscally. And it's also a problem if your government hasn't looked ahead and moved beyond a pay-as-you-go pension system because you're counting on young people to pay for old people. It doesn't have to be that way. You can create various kinds of saving systems, which countries like Australia, like Canada, like Denmark have done, that shift the burden of people's pensions away from a pay-as-you-go system.
49:04Tom Barkin: We need definitely reforms of the welfare states, of pension systems in many countries, but we also need to rethink within the companies that employ these older workers. And then I think the very difficult topic will be health care. Those seeking social welfare reforms point to a few smaller European countries where it's already working. The best performing welfare states are all small countries.
49:28Glenn Hubbard: And it's Denmark, the Netherlands, Austria, Switzerland. That is not really happening in a majoritarian big country like France. So French people think about the welfare state not as an intergenerational contract. They equate the welfare state purely with pensions. And, you know, if you look at the comparison, Denmark spends a third on the young, a third on the adult population and a third on the elderly. France spends half of the social budget on the elderly and then, you know, a quarter on the young and a quarter on the adult population.
50:06Tom Barkin: So, yes, there is something to small and big countries. They do receive maybe a good, fairly generous public benefit in a system in a Scandinavian country, but then you have to pay taxes on it. So the government recoups part of the spending by taxing the benefit. And then you take into account the fact that there's obligatory private spending in some countries, which make it mandatory to have private pensions or occupational pensions. And you count all the tax breaks. And then you come to the surprising conclusion that countries like, for example, Denmark and U.S., in total spending, aren't that far away from each other, which is quite an interesting way to look at social spending.
50:45Tom Barkin: So as always, the devil is in the details. And you really have to look at the structure, how these social welfare states function, and how much particularly public, private, and tax systems are involved in giving the overall benefit to the populations. The stakes for reforming the social welfare systems of larger European countries, such as France and Italy, are high. Not just for their people, but for economic growth and the ability to compete in the global economy. What does the social welfare system, taken as a whole in Europe, mean for competitiveness and economic growth in Europe? I think for investors, we see for competitiveness and investors' decisions, there's many other factors that also play a role.
51:26Tom Barkin: the size of the market, the skills of the population, how well they are received in the countries that they invest in, what other benefits they have. So I think reducing it just to a discussion about the social welfare state and the costs is too short because it's also about keeping your workers in good health, offering child care and having an overall package that makes it attractive for workers to contribute, to be productive, and attractive for investors to invest in. In much of Europe, there's a real deficit problem. How much of that do you think is because of the social welfare system?
52:03Glenn Hubbard: It is definitely driven significantly by a poorly thought out and constructed social welfare system. A Canadian politician who I love, the premier of Manitoba, a guy called Wob Canu, likes to say the economic horse needs to pull the social cart. And I think if you are a person, a leader, who believes in a strong social safety net, you need to also believe in fiscal responsibility. And the European countries that are successful in having a well-funded social safety net that isn't pulling the economy down because of creating a debt burden are the ones that have been thoughtful about, yes, building a social safety net, but only building one that the country can afford.
52:55Glenn Hubbard: Countries like France and Italy that have kind of leaned over their skis are facing a really challenging situation. But I would say, David, the United States is not immune. And actually, interestingly, America's fiscal problems actually, ultimately, actually in many ways, resemble Europe's fiscal problems.
53:18Tom Barkin: If the economic horse has to pull the social cart, is politics in the driver's seat? You have to be able to do it politically and sell it. And is that doable at this point?
53:30Glenn Hubbard: Emmanuel Macron has tried very, very hard to grapple with France's outsized spending on seniors. And politically, that has been impossible for him to do. What I worry about, you know, for Europe, maybe for the United States, is usually these deep structural fiscal problems can only be solved when you have a crisis. The reason that Canada has a well-funded pension system is because we had a near-death fiscal experience in the 1990s, and that created the political will to restore our public finances to a sustainable path. If that's what it takes, then we could all be in for a really rough ride.
54:23Tom Barkin: That does it for us here at Wall Street Week. I'm David Weston. See you next week for more stories of capitalism.
54:44Glenn Hubbard: Oh my gosh, you can't be serious. You think making the pick is the hard part? No, it's not. The pick takes like three seconds. You know what's hard? The sweat. The time between locking in and cashing out. Yeah, you have a take. But in the end, it's not about the winners or losers. This is about us, man. whether we're brave enough to sit through it. Don't fight the sweat. Live in it. Because you are an underdog. Underdog. Release your dog. Terms may apply. At Farmers, we go out of our way to keep you in the know. Like by singing everything for emphasis. That and by providing you with coverage on a page in easy-to-understand language so you know what's covered and what's not.
55:28Tom Barkin: No confusing legalese that no one gets. And full transparency. We do have to put a disclaimer at the end of this ad, though. Just being honest. That's what you get when you have farmers. Learn more at farmers.com. Underwritten by farmers, truck or fire insurance, exchanges or affiliate. Products not available in every state.
This week, Columbia Business School professor Glenn Hubbard breaks down the economic implications of the US midterm elections. Meanwhile, rising oil prices are both a burden and a benefit in Alaska. And, we go into the field with Richmond Fed President Tom Barkin to get a closer look at American manufacturing. Plus, Europe’s postwar welfare programs are facing new challenges amid budget crunches and growing youth protests.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.



