1. Podcasts
  2. Waveform: The MKBHD Podcast
  3. Apple Homeview, Microsoft Surface Ultra, and Fitbit Edge. It's TECHtober.
Waveform: The MKBHD Podcast

16 Oct 2026 · 1h 32m · 26 chapters

Episode artwork

Apple Homeview, Microsoft Surface Ultra, and Fitbit Edge. It's TECHtober.

In short

The episode is a “TECHtober” roundup focused on Apple’s HomeView smart home hub, Microsoft’s Surface Ultra laptop, and Fitbit’s new Edge wearable. Hosts and guests discuss Apple’s HomeView as a 7-inch LCD display/speaker hub ($299) with tabletop and wall-mount variants, emphasizing the wall version’s extra mounting costs and reduced speaker setup.

Key claims

HomeView’s multi-user facial recognition (up to six people) is the standout feature, while the device’s limited app ecosystem (Safari-only web, no app store) makes it feel like a “half computer, half ambient hub.” Notable examples include recipe “tap-to-display” requiring Safari, CarPlay-style media support (Spotify via AirPlay; non-Apple apps via CarPlay), and the fast-paced, anxiety-inducing HomeView commercial where the family uses it for everything. Guests also criticize design choices (large black bezels, power/USB-C cabling approach, and “feels cheaper” materials) and discuss Apple Home collection smart home partners (LG/Schneider) plus HomePod Mini 2 updates.

Guests

Marquez, Andrew, David (hosts); Mariah and Ellis (producer desk). Backgrounds aren’t specified beyond their roles as podcast hosts/producers.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:18

Techtober Kickoff

Discussion about the various tech products being revealed during TechTober.

“And it's Techtober, which means, wow, we've got a lot to talk about.”
2:46

Windows Update Troubles

Marquez shares his frustrating experience with Windows updates and connectivity issues.

“We got to see Microsoft Surface Ultra laptop with RTX Spark, a new Fitbit with a screen.”
6:56

Apple HomeView Event Overview

Overview of Apple's latest home event, focusing on the new HomeView product and features.

“Well, on the complete other side of the fence, Apple had an event this week, and they added a new first-generation device to their ecosystem and then a whole bunch of other things around it.”
10:44

Deep Dive into HomeView Features

Exploring the functionalities and implications of the new HomeView device.

“I remember we got a breather for Pixel 2 that had like an iPad on the wall.”
14:00

Apple HomeView Design and Features

Explore the design elements and functionalities of the Apple HomeView.

“A different person walks up, asks for something, gives them their answers, they walk away.”
21:08

Audio Components and Commercial Discussion

Analyze the audio setup of the HomeView and critique its promotional commercial.

“So it's like kind of a few things stapled together and CarPlay gets stapled in there too.”
28:00

Apple Homeview Commercial Analysis

The hosts dissect the new Apple Homeview commercial, noting its chaotic presentation and messaging issues.

“It does sound really good, in my opinion, to be fair.”
30:00

Commercial Features and Family Dynamics

Discussion on the features showcased in the commercial and how the family dynamics portrayed appear unrealistic and stressful.

“It's like, okay, the simplest thing you could possibly make.”
34:00

Apple's Position in Smart Home Market

The hosts discuss Apple's entry into the smart home sector and its integration with existing Apple products.

“And it just so happens that if they put a thing in your home, it has to integrate with your iPhone.”
36:40

Overview of New Smart Home Devices

A detailed walkthrough of Apple's new smart home devices partnered with LG, highlighting features and pricing.

“And when you use these things, the main kind of headline feature is that you can tap your iPhone to it to set it up really quickly.”
Show all 26 chapters
42:00

Smart Home Security Options

Discussing smart home security devices and their features.

“It's like the phone you expect to be super secure, so I guess maybe.”
43:50

Apple HomePod Mini 2 Features

Exploring the new features of the HomePod Mini 2 and Siri AI.

“Like they just updated the health app and it's so modern.”
46:00

Apple's Audio Innovations

Discussion on how Apple integrates their speakers with Mac and gaming.

“In my briefing, for some reason, they were playing Angry Birds on the Mac.”
48:40

The Evolution of Siri AI

Examining the developments and limitations of Siri AI in new products.

“During Black Friday, they do kind of throw.”
51:20

Apple's New Product Launches

Overview of Apple's new product launches and their market positioning.

“So it's possible that it will roll out to HomePod by the time HomeView is out.”
54:20

Smart Home Cost Considerations

Discussing the high costs associated with smart home devices.

“because it is less Apple-like by definition.”
55:36

Teasing Upcoming Discussions

Setting the stage for future topics about Microsoft and Fitbit.

56:00

Apple HomePod Mini and Surround Sound Setup

Discussing the setup and benefits of an Apple surround sound system using HomePod minis.

“The surround sound thing is kind of cool.”
57:08

Trivia Time: Predecessor to Bixby

The hosts engage in trivia about Samsung's voice assistant that preceded Bixby.

“So last week when I was researching the Samsung Mega, a smartphone, I learned about a thing on the Mega that I had never heard of.”
1:01:20

Microsoft Surface Laptop Ultra Review

In-depth discussion about the features and specifications of the Surface Laptop Ultra.

“They've dropped a new product that I'm very curious about, and I actually want to hear your guys' thoughts on how we should review this, but Surface Laptop Ultra.”
1:09:08

Comparing Creative Workflows in Tech

Examining how new technology products cater to creative workflows and AI needs.

“Look at how much faster premiere and after effects are looking how much faster final cut is look how much faster it is to render to like render this 3d scene or to edit a ton of photos or all this stuff.”
1:10:02

AI and Creative Workflows

Discussion on the impact of AI on creative tools and workflows.

“One of the examples they gave in this event was they're like, oh, here's the Surface Laptop Ultra running GitHub Copilot.”
1:13:44

Windows Search Functionality Update

Exploring the new Windows search experience and its improvements.

“a new Fitbit that is I just want to preview this what if the Fitbit air but with a screen huh now you're thinking before.”
1:17:36

Review of Fitbit Edge

In-depth discussion about the features and confusion surrounding the Fitbit Edge.

“Lastly, though, I wanted to cover what David mentioned before, the Fitbit Edge, which is a cool but kind of confusing product.”
1:24:01

Wearing Tech at Weddings

The hosts discuss the appropriateness of wearing tech gadgets like smartwatches at weddings.

“but was anybody in here on team no Apple Watch allowed at the wedding?”
1:27:31

Trivia and Tech History

A lighthearted trivia session where the hosts reminisce about tech history and their experiences.

“waiting to see if I get the trivia questions right.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Waveform: The MKBHD Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This episode is brought to you by On Investing, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. Each week hosts Liz Ann Saunders, Schwab's chief investment strategist, and Colin Martin, head of fixed income research and strategy for the Schwab Center for Financial Research. Bring your fresh insights on what's happening in the markets and why, and what the implications might be for your portfolio. Join Colin and Liz Ann as they explore questions like, how do you evaluate corporate bonds that look interesting? And what sectors are on the move right now. Download the latest episodes and subscribe at schwab.com slash on investing or wherever you get your podcasts.

0:33Marques Brownlee: Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. Your work is scattered. A thread here, a DM there, docs everywhere. And now it's not just your team hunting for context, your AI agents need it too. Jira taps Atlassian's teamwork graph to bring the context together across Jira, Confluence, Slack, GitHub, and more. It makes it easy to share with the agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot, assign them work directly, or connect your agents through MCP. The result? Less token waste, more accuracy, and more time moving work forward. Learn more at jira.com. That's spelled J-I-R-A dot com.

1:09Marques Brownlee: Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is Amex Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. flexible controls for when priorities shift support around the clock all backed by american express so you can stay focused on what matters most built to simplify designed to scale this is amex corporate get started at go.amex slash amex corporate terms apply

1:42Marques Brownlee: there is this moment which had such an opportunity positive where it was like wait my wife just said see you tonight hey siri what is the thing that we're doing tonight and it's like you have a date with your wife of like ice skating lessons and instead of being like oh nice thanks siri he's like oh yeah we gotta talk i'm like i'm like what

2:08Marques Brownlee: yeah what is up people of the internet welcome back to another episode of the waveform podcast we're your hosts i'm marquez i'm andrew and i'm david we got Mariah and Ellis at the producer desk this week. And it's Techtober, which means, wow, we've got a lot to talk about.

2:22Andrew Edwards: Wait, I made a sound for this.

2:28Marques Brownlee: For Techtober. That feels how I've felt for the past couple days. So I think that's a good sound. Anyway, this week, because we have to make sure we don't fast forward too far ahead, what do we have? We have Apple Home View. They had their home event this week and all the things that came with it, including their new first-gen HomeView product. We got to see Microsoft Surface Ultra laptop with RTX Spark, a new Fitbit with a screen. It's a lot. But first, did they even test this?

2:58Andrew Edwards: I'm back. I'm ready to get yelled at because I don't know how to do stuff. People loved your last one. I know. I'd agree with you. This one, man. So, okay. So lately I've been dabbling in the dark arts, and by that I mean I've been using a Windows computer at home for some personal projects, you know? I'm so sorry. Wait, before you continue, is that a pixel light bar on your shirt? It's close. It's got some - No, it's got too many colors. No, only the black bar. Oh, right, they have red on it, so I forgot. The light bar has red. It's the dot, it doesn't matter. The glow bar. I'm just making a dumb joke.

3:32Andrew Edwards: You can continue with your Windows. Thank you. All right, so I'm using Windows, right? Yeah. And what happens when you use Windows? Windows updates. You know, it just, you open your computer You're going to be like, hold on, blah, blah, blah. So Windows, this time it was like, I'm updating right now. Like you have 10 minutes to wrap up your stuff. And then this is happening. And I was like, okay, I can accept this. Even that happens. Windows updates. The computer comes back online. I try to resume what I'm doing. And I'm not connected to the internet. And I'm like, oh, I guess this was a serious enough update.

4:00Andrew Edwards: Like it must have forgotten my Wi-Fi password. Any number of things, right? So I'm sort of new to Windows. So I'm like, how do you connect to the Wi-Fi? a second. You go to that little cluster of tools at the bottom right corner. You click it. And then I don't see Wi-Fi. It's just not an option. I'm like, okay, I must have not really known how to use Windows properly. I'm new to this, whatever. So I open settings, go to the network tab, right? Nothing about Wi-Fi in there either. So then I'm like, okay, okay, okay. I must not be understanding something like this is a professional operating system, written by one of the biggest companies in the world.

4:38Andrew Edwards: So I search Wi-Fi in the settings. No result. At this point, I'm actively questioning whether Wi-Fi exists or if I just imagined it my whole life up until this point. And so I do a little bit more digging. Lo and behold, the update that I had given to my computer uninstalled the network adapter. So there's like a wireless antenna directly connected to the motherboard that needs a driver, even though it's directly connected. This is a laptop. Yeah. It uninstalled the built-in, the driver for the built-in network adapter. And so when Windows diagnoses this as the problem, it goes, here's the link to download it from the internet.

5:24Andrew Edwards: And I'm like, well, that doesn't help me. Luckily, eventually I read it around the computer. There was like an old version of the network adapter driver in the device manager. It was like a surreal Kafka-esque experience, first being gaslit into questioning whether Wi-Fi exists and then being told, it's okay, dude, just click on this webpage and you can get back on the internet. Yeah, this happened on my old Surface Book 2, I remember it uninstalled the network driver. Yeah. And I had to use a USB-C to Ethernet dongle to get internet so that I could reinstall the network driver. It was just...

6:01Andrew Edwards: I, yeah. it seems bad other than that Windows has been actually it's not bad how dare you guys I'm just kidding I don't I don't dislike Windows I just dislike when it updates when you're doing important things and then I don't hate Windows and just hate all the that happens on it I just hate using it but I don't hate it

6:23Marques Brownlee: I just hate looking at it I just hate no I don't hate looking at it I actually think it's fairly aesthetic I do I like the square I like the way it looks the bloatware you like all the bloatware

6:32Andrew Edwards: I do not love the bloatware. The nice part about the bloatware is that everything is backwards compatible to infinity. The bloatware is backwards compatible? Yeah. No, it's just like the reason it's so bloated is because there's some random program written in 1993 that Windows, for some reason, is like, no, we still support all the graphics drivers. Anyway, that's my did they even test this? Thanks, Microsoft, for a good story.

6:56Marques Brownlee: Well, on the complete other side of the fence, Apple had an event this week, and they added a new first-generation device to their ecosystem and then a whole bunch of other things around it. So it's the home event. It was actually not really an event. It was like a hands-on experience in New York, I guess. I don't know if there's one in California, too. Probably not. There's a New York one. Just Tribeca, yeah. We all walked in, and everyone's like, welcome home. And we're like, oh, I see what you're doing. It's a home event. Yeah. So they announced their new products, which is the new HomeView, which is an in-home display and speaker computer combo thing.

7:35Marques Brownlee: We'll talk about that. They also announced a partnership with LG and Schneider Electronics for a bunch of smart home products like a doorbell and a thermostat and security cameras, things like that. And they also dropped a new Apple TV 4K and a new HomePod Mini 2. now I think all those other things are a little bit less interesting in the home view itself but the home view I have so many thoughts on I did my impressions video I also have a lot of thoughts on the commercial yeah I think it was really strange and really bad actually I agree uh but I don't know where to start where do we start with what it is because some people might not even have seen this true fair okay so in the smart home you guys might have seen like other people have smart home products when you visited their homes before, they need like a little hub, like a screen that you can control all of it from, like a Nest Hub Max or an Echo Show or something like that.

8:28Marques Brownlee: Apple has not had one of those. So that's what HomeView is. It is a seven inch square LCD with these big black bezels. And it sits on this sort of metal base that has extra speakers in it. It's$299,$300. And there are two versions of it, one that sits on the base, or one that mounts to the wall. The one that sits on the base has just like a USB type C port in the back, which I was actually fairly happy to see that. Really? You could just like plug it in wherever you want. I have a thought on that also, that idea. Fair. But then, yeah, the wall mounted one is the same price. It doesn't come with the base.

9:01Marques Brownlee: So it doesn't come with that woofer, that deep speaker that would be in the base. And it also doesn't come with any mounting hardware. You have to buy that as well separately. How much is that one though? Because you don't get that stuff. So there's a$60 USB-C one. There is a$80 AC adapter version, and there's a$130 power over Ethernet version. So based on what sort of wiring setup you have. $130. Yeah. Based on the wiring setup you have, you're going to be spending some extra money just to mount it to the wall. Yeah. And it doesn't have as many speakers. And it doesn't have as many colors, by the way.

9:32Marques Brownlee: That one only comes in silver or gray. Yeah. Did you say they're the same price, too? Sorry. They're the same price. The same price. The same price is insane because you get a big speaker when you have the one that sits on your tabletop. Yeah, the woofer. So they did make a big point about how the one on the wall has those full range drivers tuned specifically for on-wall use. I don't know if they are physically different, if they like point backwards or something. But they did talk about that every single time I brought it up. But I'm pretty sure it's going to sound worse because it doesn't have a driver, that big woofer driver.

10:04Marques Brownlee: I also generally don't want music just coming out of my walls. That sounds like some poltergeists. There's a whole group, and we can talk more about the market for this in a second, but there's a lot, not a lot. There's some amount of people that have an iPad on their wall to do this sort of stuff. Yeah, right. And there's an Apple Home app, and so they just glue the iPad to the wall or however they want to attach it to the wall, get some power to it so it doesn't die, or maybe just take it off and charge it once in a while, and that's been their home hub until this point. This is generally like bespoke, like designer homes that they will like show off in L.A.

10:39or something and sell to multimillionaires. Like 10 years ago. Like 10 years ago. I feel like it's not really. I remember we got a breather for Pixel 2 that had like an iPad on the wall. And even then it was like, this doesn't feel high tech. This somehow feels 15 years old already. Yeah. And like, I think there but there are people who want to do it. And giving a version of that makes sense. but to charge the same amount with like 50 less material and then also be like here's the mounts you guys need yeah and it costs more like that should have that should be the difference just include the amount it should be at least a hundred dollars cheaper yeah or the 60 amount should come with it yeah like right for free and then like even that i don't think is a an equal yeah because but it's a large speaker in the bottom and we had we both had briefings the speaker i think sounded pretty good when it was on the tabletop.

11:26It had a lot of good sound. I don't know. It sounded great, in my opinion. A lot better than the Nest Hub Mini. Google doesn't even sell the Nest Hub Max anymore,

11:33Marques Brownlee: so it's kind of hard to compare. You used to be able to get them for like$229 from the Google store. Yeah. I've been thinking about the pricing a lot. I typically don't say that a decision a company this big makes is totally pointless and stupid. There has to be some reason for it, and I've been trying to think of it, and I think it's probably some version of like price steering where if they're the same price people will get the one that lives on the table because that's the one most people should get where if the one on the wall was a hundred bucks cheaper then a bunch of people who probably shouldn't be getting the one on the wall are going to see that it's a hundred bucks cheaper and are going to try to get the one on the wall like or rig it in like a weird way because it is just usbc in the back right because the amount is essentially a mount that plugs into with a little usbc port right and the difference in prices between the first two at least were essentially if you expect for the USB-C wire to run down your wall or if you want AC power, which I'm assuming is coded or whatever correctly to be safe inside of a wall and it tells you to get it professionally installed.

12:36Marques Brownlee: Yeah, yeah. So I think you probably could just plug a USB-C in the back of it. Yeah, I think so. And get it to do something because you can order it with no mount. Yeah, maybe you just put some super glue on it. Just to the wall? Just super glue it straight to the wall. Put the USB Type-C cord in there. I don't know. I haven't seen the back of the - I live in an apartment and the walls are made of concrete. So I'm not drilling into that concrete. You're not feeding a cord through the wall. We need the third party manufacturers to rise up and make something so they can mount it to the wall. Yeah, hopefully some cheaper options.

13:07Marques Brownlee: But anyway, yeah. So the idea is the product lives in your home and it can do all of the smart home stuff. It can control your lights and all the smart home stuff you have attached. You can view your security cameras. You can set timers. You can ask Siri things. You can play music. You can even open Safari links and view recipes and things like that. So it does the stuff it's supposed to do. And then its interesting feature, I think it's the headlining feature, is the multi-user switching, like fast multi-user switching. And we'll get to the video in a second. But basically the idea is you walk up to it and it uses facial recognition to know that it's you.

13:42Marques Brownlee: and then it can give you some extra personal context like your messages, your calendar, or you ask Siri, what was that recipe that Joe texted me? And it can actually tell you because it knows it's you. And then when you walk away, it goes back to just being not personal. And it can do this for up to six different people. So one person walks up, asks for something, walks away. A different person walks up, asks for something, gives them their answers, they walk away. As long as you have an iPhone or an iPad with an Apple account, it will be able to be set up to have you included as one of the users in the home.

14:15Marques Brownlee: Cool. I don't know what took them so long. I was actually hoping they would do this for the iPad like 10 years ago, like having multi-user support.

14:22Andrew Edwards: Oh, yeah, multi-user.

14:23Marques Brownlee: But they still don't. But, you know, we have it on Macs. Now we have it on this thing. It's fast. It works with just that selfie camera. It's a 12 megapixel center stage camera. It's not full face ID. But the idea is you probably don't need full face ID. In your house. At least this is their logic. This is a device where if it's in your house, you're expecting that pretty much anyone who comes up to it is expected to come up to it it's not like you're in public and so that selfie camera with facial recognition combined with the fact that it's looking to see if your ios device was recently on and unlocked in the area then it's probably you do we just talk about the video i don't know if i a lot of stuff i don't know if i buy the yeah let's do let's finish design and everything yeah i want to talk about a lot more of this first i don't buy the the if you unlock something nearby because i feel like the point of this is to be that i don't need to go to my phone for some things so like the area is more of like the house building the house okay yeah cool um the design itself i'll give credit for one thing is that we didn't see a totally accurate leak of this going up to it we saw a million things close but not exactly i think it looks cheaper than i was expecting i agree with I think I was expecting, I kept hearing HomePod mini cut in half, which is one way smaller than this.

15:41And I expected the fabric around it. I think because I'm used to Nest Hub. I'm used to HomePod. I think the fabric makes it a little bit nicer. I agree with you. Maybe in a kitchen with food, they don't want it to get all grimy. Yeah, that's what I mean. It's a good point.

15:58Marques Brownlee: I kind of wonder about that. Like all the others in this category that I'm picturing do kind of feel a little bit more homey. Yeah. White bezels, fabric on the speaker, like softer plastic type materials. This is like sharp cornered metal. Yeah. And like an aluminum base with it like a sort of aluminum can feeling look. I don't know if that feels cheaper to me as much as it feels like less home friendly. It's just an unusual design. It is a little bit cuter with like the square aspect ratio. I love that part. I actually think I like that part. You don't like the square? No, I don't. Tim also hates the square.

16:32I like the squircle a lot, actually. I think how it's set up is nice. Something about the base just feels, maybe it feels cheap, maybe it just feels cheap because, like you said, it doesn't feel homey. But that just feels so, that feels like it should be in an Apple event video in the background, not in my kitchen. I feel like white bezels would have made it feel like it blends into your home more. I mean, bezels are, they just look huge.

16:55Marques Brownlee: I agree. So it's a nice little screen. It's an LCD with true tone. I think that did a good job of adapting, but I've had so much beef with this. You remember the iMac? Yeah. You remember the iMac with the white bezels? And they didn't offer any black bezels for it, and their reasoning for that was, in all the commercials, it was like in the kitchen, in the living room, and they were like, your walls are white. You probably want white bezels so it blends in more nicely. And I was like, I guess. I'm not putting an iMac in there, but you chose this, so all right, you better keep that same energy.

17:24Marques Brownlee: Now here's the home thing, and it's big black bezels and i'm like what happened to that energy probably to hide the camera i guess but i guess but now you're not hiding any of the best it's massive bezel i think that also contributes to it looking a little bit cheap um that i could see that that with the giant like metal base which is really big black bezels in a kitchen with like smudging is going to look terrible yeah for a while yeah so another thing i found very interesting is like there's only a set of apps on it and that's it there's no like app store or anything it has a bunch of apple apps that are all optimized you can only use safari you can't use your browser of choice that's kind of weird right and then they have all of these features that only work if you use a very select set of apple apps which just felt like something that apple would have done a number of years ago but it feels like like the first home pod that only worked with apple music yeah they have this feature that they flash around a lot where if you bring if you have a recipe open on your phone you can just tap your phone to it and then it shows the recipe on the display and a much richer format that looks a lot nicer and whatever i guess it uses like a most recipe websites use json apparently there's a format standardized yeah and apparently it can index that and then use it to show it on the display whatever but you have to be using safari on your phone when you tap it and it's like this feels so apple no but it feels like apple like a number of years ago that's sorry that's what i mean like the apple yeah we know it's funny because when i saw people first of all the reddit thread for our video i don't think i've ever seen our apple more like i don't get this product at all and a big thing is the apps yeah at first i wasn't that worried about it because i feel like nest hub doesn't really have like i never downloaded apps on nest hub it just is like the kind of things i wanted to play music i wanted to do my home controls whatever Yeah.

19:19At least my Nest Hub Mini.

19:20Marques Brownlee: I don't forget the tablet. I have the Nest Hub Max. I've been using it for years. It's not that good of a product. It sucks. But it does have a YouTube app, and I can play stuff on Spotify. I guess that's the thing. I never downloaded those, but it had Spotify and YouTube on it already. Can this play YouTube videos? It's only in browser? So YouTube videos are only in browser. It's Safari. The other thing that they kept bringing up was the CarPlay framework. So the same way that your car screen can show content from apps that support CarPlay, you will be able to show content on those same apps, CarPlay-supported apps, on the HomeView.

19:58Marques Brownlee: So when I was asking about Spotify specifically, basically the idea is there is no Spotify app on the HomeView. But you can AirPlay like Spotify to the HomeView, and it'll show up the same way it would on CarPlay. So SoundCloud will work. Spotify will work. Your Pocket Cast will work. non-Apple apps will work if they support CarPlay. Yeah. It's not like a new home framework. It's CarPlay. And by the way, I asked them, what OS is this running? Is there a name for this? And they said it's HomeView Software. Yeah, they've never named it. And I said, is it HomeView OS? They said, it's HomeView Software.

20:33Marques Brownlee: And then they smiled at me. I found that so odd. Because I checked many places for the OS name. The fine print, the newsroom, the website itself. I cannot find any. They've got to be running one of their OSes. It's combining a couple of things from several of their OSes. And I almost want to feel like, okay, it's just iOS, but like with some launcher or something or whatever. WatchOS? But like there is watchOS. When you change the clocks and the watch faces, I keep saying watch faces, but it's just watchOS watch faces, right? And then when you go through and you have that like home screen with your apps and the widgets, that's just iOS right there.

21:08Marques Brownlee: That's your iPhone screen right there. Yeah. So it's like kind of a few things stapled together and CarPlay gets stapled in there too. And that's something I wanted to bring up was that this product feels strange because it feels a little bit like a computer and a little bit like a home display. Because in some ways they're like, oh, you've got Safari. You can like bring up these like in the ad that we'll talk about. All of the people in the ad, like they're kind of using it like a computer. They're like touching it and they're doing this. They're spinning it around. They're touching it way too much.

21:36They're spinning it way too much. Spinning it a lot. and so it's almost like it's like a kitchen computer but at the same time it's so limited because it's like only got the Apple apps that are approved to be on there. There's no app store or anything like that. So it's like half computer, half sort of ambient computing device,

21:55Marques Brownlee: half Siri AI device. I tried to think about it as like what does this end up being in like a month when the novelty factor wears off? Because I've had a lot of this home stuff for a while and I'm like what do I at this point now do with my reasonably advanced smart home hub. I do basically three or four things. I listen to music once in a while. I'll ask for a timer once in a while. Every morning I ask it for like my routine slash news. So it tells me the weather, the traffic for my commute and the news. Sounds like something Siri would do. And I think I asked like for sports scores and random other general knowledge stuff and that's about it, right?

22:30Marques Brownlee: So let's say this is gonna have to do the same stuff. This is just Siri performing those tasks instead of Google. It can still give me the sports scores. It can still tell me, you know, what I'm asking from online information. It can still set timers. And then all the other stuff is just kind of like extra. Like, I don't, I have my phone with me. That's the only reason it unlocks. Like, I don't need to ask it about my messages or my calendar very often or like take a FaceTime call on it. I don't think I'm going to be doing that stuff as much. I could see in a kitchen, a FaceTime call maybe like if you're cooking, I could, the one thing I do like is like, uh, if you're in the kitchen or something and like your smart doorbell rings to see who's at the door, because it could just be like, Oh, that's just a FedEx person who has to ring the doorbell and walk away.

23:13I don't need to like, yeah, that's not a good one. Clean up. So like that, which a lot of this is stuff that like Google has been doing for a long time. Exactly. And I mean, this so much feels like, uh, we realized where it's 100 % catching up. Cause then they had to partner with LG to just be like, do you see nest and rings list? Make all of those and make them a hundred dollars more expensive. Um, but like, yeah, I think it's at the end of the day, and one of the reasons the commercial hits so poorly is they're trying to do too much in a little amount of time when this is a thing you interact with five to six times a day.

23:45Yeah. And that adds up throughout the years. Yeah. And it very much is mostly when you're cooking or like maybe in some part of your home. I also felt that the LED display felt a little bit cheap. Sorry, LCD display. LCD, yeah. Felt a little bit cheap. It was very blue kind of casting. Interesting. It had true tone. so maybe that was off on that. It does have true tone. Yeah, I like how dark it gets. It gets to 0.3 nits. One of my favorite features of my Nest Hub Mini is that at nighttime, I can almost not even see the clock because it's so dim, which is really good at like late at night. It gets up to 500 nits, which is not like crazy bright, but you're not gonna be in direct sunlight so it doesn't really matter.

24:27Not available in the EU because Siri AI is still not available in the EU, which is crazy. But they are working on trying to get that approved, obviously. Yeah. So, yeah. I was going to say, my gripe with the plug in the back is, I think so many other companies have already done this so much better, is the bottom should be slightly hollowed out with a USB-C port there and a little gap for the plug to come out flush on the bottom. Because then you can put it against the wall. then you can the way they have it set up in the commercial which I have is like drilled into a hole and then you have this like extra three inches that you need for the cable to make a turn it looks off or just like pull right out so like when it's stuck in the bottom it is then secured in there and it's not showing as much so like that again made it feel kind of cheap that as well yeah yeah for$300 rock okay we got to talk about the

25:26Andrew Edwards: commercial I'm so sorry before we move on. I've been reading about the speaker layout in here, and I think I have some ideas as to why the price might not be raised. Interesting. Because it's a really interesting configuration of speakers, actually. It's one downward-facing driver. So that's a driver that fires sound directly at the table. And then it's two of these things called passive radiators, which are effectively membranes on springs that are not attached to any drivers. And the whole air pressure inside the base. And then that air pressure actually is what moves those passive radiators.

26:04Andrew Edwards: And that is a way of getting around needing to drill sort of like a throat in the speaker, which helps tune it. There's a bunch of speaker design. Watch my video actually about cabinet size on the studio channel if you want to learn more. Anyway, it seems like the way they design this is almost like the base is this weird like hybrid non-traditional subwoofer because Because you're not going to get my I haven't heard it. I haven't seen it. But my guess is it's tuned somewhere around 100 and 150 hertz as a crossover. So like only real bass is going to come out of the bass. No pun intended. So realistically, also, it's Apple.

26:44Andrew Edwards: So all these things are going to be computationally tuned all the time. Anyway, what I'm trying to say is it seems like there's not very many audio components inside this bass. um yeah it seems like it's mostly passive components a really well-tuned chamber one driver facing down possibly a wave guide and then just being computationally controlled by the head where they're relying on the classic apple force-canceling drivers which is what they've been putting in everything lately to produce the full the full range i just feel like in terms of materials the base and the hinge and everything on it should that's true more expensive than the one that doesn't have the material.

27:24These are the guys that sold$600 wheels. Yeah, and$1 ,000 stand for your... I just thought we were past that era of Apple, you know? They've made a lot of things that are good value in the last couple of years.

27:36Andrew Edwards: That's true, that's true. But I was surprised when you look at this... When you look at this base, it makes you think of like some of the older HomePod stuff where when you took it off they'd have like a million bajillion speakers firing in all directions. But I think if you were to open this up, it would be... Yeah, right. It would be like mostly empty space. I don't know yet. Well, I'll wait for the iFixit teardown, but I think it's mostly a cabinet. Anyway, I'm sorry to interrupt. I just feel like I finally got to the conclusion of reading it. It does sound really good, in my opinion, to be fair.

28:03Yeah, there is that if you like want a smart home display that is also a good speaker,

28:08Marques Brownlee: like it's, you know, when I'm thinking about the other like the competition of like the Nest Hub and the Echo Show and stuff like that, none of them have particularly good speakers. They're all supposed to be pretty inexpensive like just to just get a display that can just do the basic stuff in the home yeah and they've certainly it's apple they've certainly like leaned towards the premium look and feel with the metal and all that but i think at the end of the day they do have to make it pretty inexpensively so i'm not shocked that it's not like 15 different drivers in here or something yeah yeah okay let's talk about the commercial okay the commercial i just want to say you can go watch it on youtube it's three minutes long it's like the way they introduce this product to the world and I think it breaks several really long-standing rules that you would think Apple would have about commercials yeah one of them is yeah like a commercial especially for a first-gen product is supposed to basically instruct you especially as a reviewer of how they see this being used in the world yeah and the family that like goes through their morning with this product and has a bunch of different users and stuff.

29:13Marques Brownlee: I think the idea was to showcase the multi-user support really cleverly. But a lot of the other stuff was like, not how I think most people will use this. So I kind of disagreed with that. It also didn't paint a picture of like, I wanna be like this family. No. It was not like a positive, usually you're like, oh wow, this person has the iPhone Duo and it looks like they're getting so much done. Wow, that's so cool. I want the product so I can be like that. this commercial didn't have any of the oh i want the product so i can be like that it didn't have that and i just want to clarify for you so in case people take that wrong it's not that we don't understand that families can be chaotic it's we understand that families can be chaotic and you can just speak to each other in that scenario and not all basically have an intermediate little screen on the table let me let me summarize the video so okay so it's like a four or five person family home right they have this kitchen island that they have the home view on and they're drilled in drilled in the middle that's crazy just drilled in the middle of the cabinet just yeah you gotta plug it in they drill it in anyway uh they do it is successful in showing that it can be used for everything that you might need to use it for because they basically go through all these scenarios where the son walks in he's like i want some fresh toast and the dad's like fine how do I make French toast?

30:34And then he beams it to the thing. It's like, okay, the simplest thing you could possibly make. Literally, yeah. It's like two ingredients, but okay. Anyway, it's French and it's toast. And then notably not French, which is another part of the ad. I would argue that might be the only thing that I would like, in that scenario, I was like, yeah, that is what I ask. I just ask it random questions. Yeah, so they go through a lot of different scenarios where they're beaming recipes over, they're asking Siri AI if French toast is actually French, the daughter walks up to it and it beams to her face so it switches to her messages so she can talk to her boyfriend and then when the son tries to walk over to it he can't read her messages it does a good job of showing off all the features but it is so fast paced and it is so like chaotic and anxiety inducing like gems it just feels like okay your turn what do you need now talk to the home pod not the home view okay your turn what do you need now talk to the home view Like they don't really engage with each other.

31:31Marques Brownlee: They're just like, for every problem, I will go to the home view. There's also something super unrealistic about this ad, which is that everyone in order to set up their account on this and for it to recognize their face must have an iPhone or an iPad with their account on it and nearby and recently unlocked. Yeah. And so in this ad, at no point does anyone at any point have an iPhone in their hands or near them. and that's fine I guess but like these are you know 15 year old kids or whatever like they're texting on the family home display for some reason like I don't understand texting her like secret boyfriend on the thing in front of everybody because they all keep picking it up and like spinning it around which is crazy yeah I don't know okay I think the main faux pas here is that the entire ad just feels really anxious like it moves really fast it spins around it's like really fast paced there's like tense music and at the end the husband and wife are like the kids leave and the husband like oh good morning and then they just leave they don't embrace there's no like there's no like that was my last welcome home yeah none of them like they were gonna divorce to be honest that's what that's the vibe i did all of the they did actually i think the thing was like we have a checklist of all the features we need to demo and they managed to get every single one in the video.

32:51Marques Brownlee: And also every single one of them, the resolution was like kind of negative. Like there was one where the like grandparents called on FaceTime and they were like, we don't like your beard. Like what's going on? We shouldn't be calling you right now. I'll call you back later in the car. And then they just like hang up. They're like, that was weird. I didn't want to, I don't want to call you right now. And then there was like the like find my keys moment where it was like, oh, it's in your pocket the whole time. Like you idiot. Like, why would you use that product to do that? And then there was the texting thing, which was like the kid was like, I want to like spy on my sister's text.

33:26Marques Brownlee: So I look over and that was like kind of a weird feeling. And then we're going to watch them. And then we're going to watch them on the doorbell. And at the end, there's this moment which had such an opportunity positive where it was like, wait, my wife just said, see you tonight. Hey, Siri, what is the thing that we're doing tonight? And it's like, you have a date with your wife of like ice skating lessons. And instead of being like, oh, nice. Thanks, Siri. He's like, oh, weird. We got to talk. I'm like, what? That was so negative. I just didn't. I felt like it was a very stressful watch. So this exists because Apple, when they make a new product, they need that product to integrate with everything else they have ever made.

34:05And it just so happens that if they put a thing in your home, it has to integrate with your iPhone. It has to integrate with your Apple TV. It has to integrate with your new security cameras.

34:14Marques Brownlee: It has to integrate with like so many things at once. Oh, even there was a moment where they had to demo that it plays music. So briefly, the little annoying kid was like, play this song. And it plays the song loud for like three seconds. And the mom's like, cut that off. Like, no, we don't need it. You're late for class right now. Everyone is annoyed and stressed at everything that is happening out of the home view. Like the grandparents calling. They're like, oh, God, I hate that there's a display that my grandparents can call me in the kitchen. Oh, God. I hate that my son can randomly play annoying music in the morning.

34:46Oh, God. I have to make French toast. Like, everything they're annoyed about. It was weird. It was so weird. It was so strange. In my eyes, it was like, we have to make a commercial that shows everything this can do, and if we did it and how people would normally use it, which is two to three times a day with hours in between, it would be really boring. Yeah. So they're like, how do we get all, what's the scenario we can do all of it in? I feel like I could come up with like a... Well, exactly what you said. Do the same thing with a family trying a bunch of stuff in the morning, but make them not hate each other.

35:17Yeah, it was like high anxiety. They were all annoyed. It was like, oh, modern family. I think they're like poking fun at the sister being smarter than the brother. And it's not actually French. You can do that when not every other thing is negative. Also, they drilled a hole in their camera, which is crazy.

35:35Marques Brownlee: Who among us, you know? They did drill a hole in the center of their kitchen island. Yeah, okay. So this HomeView integrates with a bunch of new smart home stuff. Notably, Apple never really got heavy into the smartphone home game, right? Like they made Apple Home. They made all these things. They have HomeKit, which has always been their smart home software. But they never really made a lot of first party stuff. And then they got excited about Matter because Matter allowed, you know, all these other third parties. What's the matter with Matter? smart home protocol uh that allows all of these third parties to sort of integrate together work well together cool but they did eventually realize like oh we're getting our lunch eaten by google and amazon and if we just made our own quote unquote first party stuff which they still didn't do uh we could really win this space we could really lean into the smart space so they announced a new thing called the apple home collection which is a partnership between apple and LG and Schneider Electric.

36:39There's a bunch of stuff. There's a bunch of cameras. There are temperature sensors. There's thermostats. And when you use these things, the main kind of headline feature is that you can tap your iPhone to it to set it up really quickly. Whether or not that solves the problem of the smart home in which doing a smart home is a ton of logic and is just very complicated and confusing, I'm not sure. I have found this sometimes very hard to set up. They announced a ton of different devices. They're all really expensive, like very expensive. Some of them do have some unique features that I haven't really seen on other smart home devices before.

37:15So we can just go through them. There's an LG indoor camera, which is plug-in, so it plugs into the wall,$200, but it can tilt up and down remotely. It articulates. It articulates, which is kind of cool, I guess. It's kind of a weird setup. It kind of looks like the Pixar lamp in the sense that it's like... A little bit. Yeah, the hinges are all very obvious. There are like there have been smart home things that like spin and then have their own tilt. But yeah, this is like. And then there's the Amazon that just sold the drone that flies. You have the drone. So one cool thing about this camera is that when you're not using it, it tilts down, which I found cool.

37:55Marques Brownlee: When you get home, it goes, oh, all right. You don't need to like monitor the inside anymore. It makes it so nobody feels like something could just be watching them without their knowledge. I think that's kind of cool. Especially with LG. There's an outdoor camera that's$300. That's a plug-in. There's a$400 floodlight camera. The colors on both of these I have a big problem with. What's up with the aluminum again? It's not even the aluminum. So it's black or aluminum, but the base on all of the... Or silver, sorry. Yeah, the base is black on both of them. Black base. Unless you have the modern farmhouse or the LA carved into the hill full matte black home, this does not match with your siding like most people have siding that is a light color and to just have this giant black brick on it now yeah feels really weird it feels like this super high tech thing on your house that's probably this feels like a 2011 aesthetic yeah this is this is like the movies that were predicting the future like you have the futuristic home yeah yeah you know maybe maybe what we're learning is apple is good at designing really modern feeling devices but the home design is a different type of design that they're not good at.

39:05Marques Brownlee: Yeah, I could see that. Like the home stuff, because this kind of, this dips into the headphone world too. I'm going so into the weeds, but like all these headphones, every pair of noise canceling headphones we've ever seen is like lightweight plastic. You're going to wear it for six straight hours. It's like super, super cheap feeling. Except for the home. And then Apple comes along and they're like metal. Yeah, we're doing all metal. And it's like, okay, I guess it's not terrible, but it is really heavy. It is heavy. Vision Pro comes along. like every other metal like heavy like every other vr headset is like plastic and lightweight and the home is kind of different too it's like fabric light yeah like plastic and then they come along and they're like how about metal how about sharp corners and like drilled speaker holes and like all this stuff yeah and maybe they're just not good at this yet they got it half right with the home pod mini and the home pod and those look so nice i think that's why i'm so surprised that home view looks so different yeah and actually it looks more like all these lg products right i was going to say like the base of the home view looks similar to the lg cameras and floodlights brutal i don't uh yeah four hundred dollars for a single floodlight is also insane um but i guess if you can afford a home maybe you can afford this i live in a cellar so there's an lg video doorbell that is wired um that's 250 dollars it has two cameras notably that i found very cool that's clever um there's a main camera that's 2.5k resolution that points like directly at you and then there's one that points down.

40:27So if you get a package, you can switch to the package view, I guess.

40:30Marques Brownlee: I'm curious how well this works because a lot of other doorbell cameras have a single camera and they just make it an ultra wide so you can see the person and you can see the package. And then if you get one of those notifications where someone delivers a package, you can see the video of the person putting the package down. How does it work for this one? It seems like you can manually switch between looking at the out camera and the down camera. Yeah. But yeah, I don't know. Is this better that it's two cameras? Is the down camera underneath it? Yeah, it is. Straight down. Because it is kind of strange that it is cylindrical.

40:59And now a cylinder is going on your flat wall outside and looks kind of strange. This, again, is kind of weird. At least this one is silver, although there is a black one. There is a black one. Or it's silver with black on top. Not that bad. But this wouldn't really fit on a lot of houses either. Yeah. Because this brushed metal and house siding or brick, this on brick would look so strange. It would look really out of place. Yeah. In my hands-on event, they showed it on the home view, so you could see both the main camera and the one facing down. One facing down is FHD, and you could really tell.

41:35Clearly, it doesn't really matter. It's just a package, but whatever. Okay, there is an LG Smart Deadbolt lock, which is$350. Damn, that's crazy. It uses UWD technology, so if you walk up to it and you have your iPhone in your pocket, it should automatically unlock. That's actually awesome. Yeah. I love that. They have that in a lot of products, though. It's not really new. I steal your iPhone. I also can steal everything in your house.

42:01Marques Brownlee: It's like the phone you expect to be super secure, so I guess maybe. But they have everything. They have all the options. They have a touchpad on it as well with a number keypad, and then they also have a hidden key lock area. True. So that's great. And I think like that's not way more expensive than competing options. So I think that's not too bad. My deadbolt was not. I'm pretty sure my deadbolt is like definitely not. No, we're near that. No, I mean, it's like under a hundred bucks or like a hundred bucks. So you can give guest users access to this, which is also pretty nice. And it works with the doorbell.

42:36So if someone rings your doorbell, you can then just quickly like accept and then it unlocks, which is kind of nice. uh they have a 40 lg temperature sensor a 200 lg smart thermostat that looks very similar to the um nest everything is just like 20 more expensive than you expect yeah the nest looks a little bit better though in my opinion because it's domed but this is not domed this is like flat yeah which is kind of weird that's the schneider electric one there's the schneider electric one which is really ugly uh which is 200 but i guess if you're already in the schneider ecosystem both smart home thermostats though will adapt to the temperature based on if someone is at home so that's kind of nice like if you're not home it probably won't you know do that yeah i'm sure a lot of everything is except for maybe the like if you bring the doorbell i'm assuming apple will do a good job of in the thing bring the doorbell probably have a button to unlock it that's the only thing you said so far that's not part of every single yeah i need to remind the the audience that I live in a cellar for the third time today,

43:37Marques Brownlee: I have not used any of these types of products. I, this is all fairly standard functionality wise. It's just a little more expensive and a little more metallic. Yeah. I think, you know, what's kind of hard about it though, is that it's all like grouped into Apple home and Apple home is still very outdated. Like they just updated the health app and it's so modern. It's so nice and it's beautiful. That was the most overdue. Now that the whole map is over, You really need to do that with the Home app. Yeah, I agree. Like, really, really. Yeah. As Shrek would say. So, HomePod Mini 2. Also a new product.

44:11Barely. Barely. Five new colors. Well, five colors. White, blue, green, pink, and black. I think they call it midnight, but it's black. Well, I don't know. It's black. It's like dark, dark, dark blue. Anyway.

44:21Marques Brownlee: I hate that. When you pair it to an Apple TV 4K, you can set four of them up for surround sound, or you can pair them with regular HomePods. Don't do that. Which I forgot they still sell. Can you set up four home views for surround sound? Unfortunately, probably. Siri AI is coming in a future software update. Oh, my. Wait. You know what? Isn't that the whole new thing with this HomePod? Yeah. Okay. Yeah, man. So, wait, wait, wait, wait. Okay, wait. I want to get this straight. So, the old HomePod mini is not getting the new Siri AI. No. The new HomePod mini, the only thing new about it is the slightly new top screen and that it will be getting Siri AI.

44:59Marques Brownlee: Yeah. But it doesn't actually have it yet. I don't really know why they couldn't do this on the previous one. The previous HomePod mini had that glowing kind of top screen that would like glow when you would touch it. Now it does that too. But it's slightly different. Slightly different. A couple more colors so it can match your album art. It matches the album art. That's it. And then also they have new ambient modes so you can like have rain playing and stuff. Funny enough, like when you play rain and stuff, it also dances with color, which I hope you can turn off because if I'm playing rain it's probably usually because I'm trying to go to sleep and I don't want it just glowing on my wall all the time.

45:36Zero nits please. It does now also listen for smoke and carbon monoxide alarms and will send notification to your phone if it hears it which I think is very good.

45:46Marques Brownlee: It didn't do that before? Interesting because I thought your phone would do that already. Well but it's when you're not home. Oh I see. Like I get my Google Home alerts me if it hears glass breaking or a monoxide alarm or a fire alarm. Other new feature is they can also be speakers for your Mac now. I saw that. I think that's hilarious. In my briefing, for some reason, they were playing Angry Birds on the Mac. I also saw that. What? Wait, this setup, Ellis, I think you'd get a kick out of this. They just had an iMac and a HomePod mini on either side. Yeah, they had two HomePod. So you can have$300 of speakers.

46:20Marques Brownlee: Yeah. Both of them are a Siri smart speaker, and they're the setup. $300 of speakers for your iMac. But the whole thing's wireless though, right? Like you don't need to plug the HomePod mini. No, it is wireless. And they said they both plug into the wall still. Yeah. They said they re-architected the AirPlay, whatever, for specifically for connecting them to a Mac. I don't know what that means. I don't know how much truth is in that. Maybe so you can hear the birds' footsteps. I didn't even know Angry Birds was on the Mac. I mean, when Apple does gaming demos, it's always like, cut the rope. yeah that's their gaming demo it's literally a beer app if you are spending the gun app who is this person?

47:04Marques Brownlee: I have an iMac already but I don't want to use the built in speakers in the iMac which are fine I want$300 of better speakers I'm going to choose two HomePod minis as my speakers it's strange I've never thought to do that before the Pro Display or Studio Display XTR does not have speakers, right? So... The studio display does have speakers. The Pro Display did not have speakers. The Pro Display did not have speakers. If you buy a Pro Display XTR and then two HomePod Minis for your speakers, I need to know that singular person out there.

47:42Andrew Edwards: It has to be about volume. Two HomePod Minis must be able to get louder. I was thinking about for that price, you could get one of my favorite cheap studio monitors, the JBL 305 Mark II.

47:55Marques Brownlee: You can get a lot of speaker for$300. That's a$100 speaker.

47:58Andrew Edwards: You get two of them for$200. You get the audio interface and the cables for the rest. But the problem is that speaker doesn't get very loud. Like, it sounds really good, but turned up all the way. It's not what I would describe it. So I wonder if two HomePod minis cooking together.

48:10Marques Brownlee: I think Apple's argument would be ease of setup and just like, you have, this is so many of Apple's unexplainable products is like, well, you have a bunch of extra money and this is easy. Yeah. Like, that's the real target demographic. How much could a speaker cost, Michael? $10? You have a bunch of extra money and this is easy. So what? Okay. I guess I have an iMac and I want better speakers. I have a bunch of extra money and they make speakers. So I guess I'm getting HomePods, huh? Like that's, I guess that's it.

48:37Andrew Edwards: Maybe if you get like a free HomePod with something and then you get another free HomePod later, you're like, oh, now. But they got a match. During Black Friday, they do kind of throw.

48:46Marques Brownlee: So wait, you can have four of them? You can have a pink iMac and two pink HomePod minis. But like you could have surround sound. Yeah, you can. Four of them?

48:54Andrew Edwards: Why four? Because you got a lot of money. They got to surround you. But why not five? Like the standard surround sound. That's an odd number. We don't do it yet. We only do pairs here. Only pairs. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. The Siri AI coming later thing I found insane. I feel like Apple is dropping so many products in Q3 and 4 of this year that they had to release them now, even though Siri AI is not ready yet for it. Which, by the way, you shouldn't release something that you say has Siri AI features when Siri AI is not ready because you already played that card. And it really didn't go well for you.

49:36Andrew Edwards: That was Apple Intelligence. It was a different thing. Oh, right, right. Don't worry about that. That's a good point. It was Apple Intelligence. It was not Siri AI. Can I ask a dumb question? It's probably not dumb. I bet you it's not that bad. What is the difference?

49:46Marques Brownlee: Of what? All the AI. The Siri? Siri AI. Well, the Siri, the context stuff of it being able to pull information from your personal context is like that big new thing. It's so great. So a lot of their demos will be like, what was that French toast recipe that Jen texted me? And then it'll pull it from your text and it will find it. And that's the thing that the old Siri couldn't do. And that is, for some people, very helpful. Legitimately helpful. But so like, can the speaker do the same thing? Like, what are we doing? Not yet. it can be play play that album that uh my friend texted me about yeah or uh yeah something like what was that podcast and then it can just play it directly from apple like it is that those features work well uh apple tv had one that i thought was funny which is like a lot of their demos i think are a little unrealistic and this one is also slightly unrealistic but it was like um what was that show that bob told me to watch play that yeah and then it just opened up ted lasso season one episode one zero zero zero and i was like all right i guess that's probably what i would have done sure yeah but uh yeah that's that's what it's supposed to be helpful it has to be an apple tv show how many products have they promised this like these ai would be on and then they haven't launched yet well they're promising it for everything so it's on the iphone it's on ios it's in beta still right i think uh maybe not so it's still not like actually rolled out yet it is it's on the iphone okay it's on home view it's coming with home view that's why It's even more confused that HomePod Mini doesn't have it.

51:20Well, okay. HomePod Mini comes out October 30th. HomeView comes out in November. Yeah. So it's possible that it will roll out to HomePod by the time HomeView is out. It's in beta on our iPhones.

51:31Marques Brownlee: Yeah. So, yeah. Yeah. I can't believe Siri is still in beta. I know. Okay. Apple uses the beta tag for the products that they are the least confident in being good yet. Remember the Apple Watch feature where it's like listening to you all the time? Oh, yeah. That one's in beta. That's not even in beta yet, right? Well, when it comes out, they said when it does come out, it'll be in beta. When it comes out, it'll be in beta. It'll be in beta. Yeah. You're like, all right, I see what you're doing. Yeah. Okay, last product. They have a new Apple TV 4K. A lot of people have been waiting for this. Faster performance.

51:59It can act as a home hub for smart home monitoring and stuff. It plugs into all of this stuff. It has far-filled microphones, so you can control it just from the brick or whatever it is. The remote has Find My Support with precision finding, and you can chime it. And the cool thing is if you just buy the new remote, it will work with the old Apple TVs. So you can still find the remote even if you pair with the old Apple TVs. That's great. But it's$300. It costs the same as a Home View, which is way more expensive than the old Apple TVs were. What was the last 4K? $399 better come with like a year of Apple TVs.

52:35$299. $299, sorry. Still, point of sense. It's very expensive. That's wild. I could buy a whole TV for that price. I could buy two TVs What are you going to watch on it Mariah when there's no Apple TV 4K so true everything's expensive that's sort of the takeaway that I had was like everything feels a little half baked like they're just trying to make the ecosystems work together because that's what Apple does but like a lot of the scenarios that they introduced were like I would never do that but they had to do it because if they didn't do it it would feel under baked but then for some reason they doubled the price on like everything.

53:14I feel like for years we've watched every single other company scramble to try and build the ecosystem that Apple has. And for one time we got to watch Apple scramble with an ecosystem thing and be like, here's a bunch of stuff and look, we've got the ecosystem. Which is kind of crazy because what they usually do is just wait a few years and then introduce a better version. But this time I feel like they waited a few years and then everyone's like, they waited a few years and then like looked at their calendar and were like,

53:38Marques Brownlee: oh, we were supposed to do that. LG fixed this for us. Yeah. The home stuff to me was interesting because Apple makes a very finite number of products and they want to have a very high quality first party option for a bunch of stuff that they do not make. A doorbell, a thermostat, a camera, like all this stuff. And I guess in theory, they could have spent a couple more years like making their own Apple thing. They probably will. Maybe, yeah, maybe at some point. They'll also be metal and expensive. But like instead partnering with the Go2s, which I guess Schneider Electric is one of them. LG is also, I guess, in there.

54:13Marques Brownlee: allowed them to get to market more quickly with some stuff because they're experienced at making that already. But it feels less Apple-like because it is less Apple-like by definition. Yeah, it's interesting. So Home View comes out, pre-order now available November 13th. The Apple Home Collection, I think you can pre-order now as well. The Apple TV 4K comes out November 13th as well. And the HomePod Mini 2 comes out October 30th. Sweet. so that's kind of the roundup of that$350 deadbolt that's yeah sorry i keep looking all the numbers next to each other and like that's almost as much as the floodlights yeah which feels like it needs to do so much more but yeah i don't know$200 for one indoor camera is insane to me that also is for one it like moves around i guess but like yeah the deadbolt is like i have to spin i have I guess it's been a physical lock that I'm not even providing.

55:09Marques Brownlee: Yeah. Somewhere out there, somebody's starting their first smart home, and they're like, can I get one of everything? Can I get a home view? Yeah. A doorbell, an outside camera, an inside camera. I wonder what that bill would be. And they just spent literally$1 ,000. $1 ,000. $1 ,500. Yeah. Which, shout out to them. I guess if you own a home, look, you're spending$1.8 million on a home or whatever. Whatever homes cost these days. How much do the homes cost? $10. $10. Okay, we gotta take a break. We got a lot to talk about. We got Microsoft. We got more Microsoft. We got Bose. We got stuff. Bose?

55:45It said Bose here, right? No. Oh, I said that was bass. Why did I say Bose? Anyway, we don't got that. We got Fitbit again. Let's go. Trivia.

55:55Andrew Edwards: Okay, hear me out. Smooth. I went to the press release. The surround sound thing is kind of cool. For what? Because It sounded good. Well, it's because if you get... Okay, so you spend$300 Apple TV 4K, right? Uh-huh. Then you spend$100 on a HomePod mini. No,$150. Oh, my God. Okay, you spend$150. Then you spend$450 more on three more HomePod minis, right? The fact that you can just plug them all in, put them in your room, And then the Apple TV can sense their location and automatically calibrate the surround sound. That's a hard thing. Like you can't really buy that. And that's still a$900 surround sound setup, which like is not the cheapest one.

56:50Andrew Edwards: But it's also very far from the most expensive. Ellis, I'm glad you like them so much. We will set up the new audio room in the new office. No, no. If we do, for some reason, we are lucky enough to get four HomePod mini review units and an Apple TV 4K. I will be setting this up. Alright, let's do trivia. I'm feeling that today. So last week when I was researching the Samsung Mega, a smartphone, I learned about a thing on the Mega that I had never heard of. This was a predecessor of Bixby, a voice assistant on a bunch of Samsung Galaxy phones from the time. It was discontinued and replaced by Bixby.

57:29Andrew Edwards: What was it called? wait so the predecessor to Bixby yes the voice assistant on Samsung phones before Bixby it was in fact on the Samsung Mega the hilarious big small phone we talked about last week before I destroyed

57:45Marques Brownlee: and it's Samsung specific not Android it is Samsung specific that's correct that I should know I feel like as soon as you guys see the name you're gonna be like oh yeah okay good that's a good hint alright well we'll think about it answers will be at the end like usual we'll be right back

58:10Marques Brownlee: support for the show comes from shopify starting a business requires you to be resourceful and the more you flex that muscle the more you see opportunities for growth for example launching your business with black friday approaching means you can take advantage of the extra online traffic shopify is there to help you make it all happen shopify is a platform for a record-breaking reliable holiday selling season for businesses at every stage. Their pre-built website themes and AI site builder make it easy to launch a beautiful professional looking store and you don't even need to touch a line of code to do it.

58:39Marques Brownlee: They also have a mobile app that lets you run your store from anywhere. So their e-commerce expert sidekick can help you manage almost any business task with a single prompt, including holiday discounts with Shopify. You can easily sell everywhere. People shop online in person across social media, and even in AI chats. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to shopify.com slash waveform to start your free trial. That's shopify.com slash waveform. Go to shopify.com slash waveform today to hear your first. Support for the show comes from Framer. The future of website building is one that seamlessly blends all of your tools that we have available.

59:16Marques Brownlee: And you should use a platform that has it all and stays useful even after you launch. That's what Framer is. Framer is the AI website builder that helps creators, teams, and businesses ship production-ready sites faster than ever while getting every detail right. You're able to prompt, inspect, edit, and publish in one place at a whole new pace. On Framer, agents and humans work in tandem, so agents bring speed and scale, while people bring taste and judgment and control. And that's what all takes place in the same workspace, where the real site is designed, managed, reviewed, and published. Everyone's ideas land on the canvas, stay editable, and can be published when the team is ready.

59:52Marques Brownlee: Framer is an enterprise-level solution. Thousands of businesses, from early-stage startups to Fortune 500s, are choosing to build their websites in Framer, where changes take minutes instead of days. Learn how you can get more out of your site from a Framer specialist or get started building for free today at framer.com slash wave for 30 % off a Framer Pro annual plan. That's framer.com slash wave. Rules and restrictions may apply. Support for the show comes from Pipedrive. Sales teams spend up to 50 % of their time on admin work rather than selling and building relationships and closing deals.

1:00:24Marques Brownlee: They can really use a tool that covers all the admin stuff. That way sales teams can actually focus on the work they were hired to do. That's where Pipedrive comes in. It's an intelligent AI-powered sales CRM loved by growing sales teams. Their new meeting intelligence feature, like an AI note taker, are built right into the CRM. Pipedrive automatically pulls deal history, email records, and previous conversations. You can walk into a call already briefed. During meetings, PipeDrive's AI note taker records and takes notes so you can stay in the conversation. Then it turns those notes into accurate auto-drafted CRM updates ready for you to review and approve.

1:00:56Marques Brownlee: The end result? Less admin, more selling. Switch to a CRM built by salespeople for salespeople and join the over 100 ,000 companies already using PipeDrive. Our link gets you an exclusive 30-day free trial instead of the usual 14-day trial, so no credit card or payment needed, just head to pipedrive.com slash waveform to get started. That's pipedrive.com slash waveform, and you can be up and running in minutes. All right, welcome back. Let's talk about Microsoft. They've dropped a new product that I'm very curious about, and I actually want to hear your guys' thoughts on how we should review this, but Surface Laptop Ultra.

1:01:31Marques Brownlee: I've been a fan of Surface Laptop Sneaky for a while now. I've been making beautiful matte black laptops running windows for a while and the newest one is our most powerful laptop yet it's rtx spark can we retire that phase from everyone well i guess it's typically the most powerful one yet but this one is like significantly yeah because we've had all this apple silicon remember m1 comes out and like they leave intel in the dust like the the jump between intel macbook pros and apple silicon macbook pros was legendary and we've been thinking about it ever since and like people are thinking about M6, but also like still have M1s, right?

1:02:07Marques Brownlee: Amazing jump. Unified memory, the whole architecture, beautiful. Windows World has still been sort of like kind of trying to figure out what to do with that. Like, do they do, because we've had all these, what are they called? Like ARM chips, all these ARM chips. And we're like, is that the answer? Or is it just going to be like, we should make our own version of Apple Silicon? RTX Spark comes out and NVIDIA is like, here's essentially not the same thing, but a very similar architecture, unified memory, and dramatically more powerful and more headroom and more speed. And that is what's showing up in these new super high-end laptops.

1:02:40Marques Brownlee: And AI. And AI, of course. I mean, if you look at any of the literature, there's a lot of local AI in there too. This is built for local AI and 3D graphics. Yes. But 3D graphics also in Windows land includes gaming, includes like 3D rendering and like ray tracing and all those sorts of things and like a creative workflow. So there's other things that this could be good at. anyway i'm spinning around the point which is that there is a new super super premium surface laptop it's called the surface laptop ultra it starts at is this right two thousand six hundred dollars yes and goes way way way way up there's a lot of different types of people who would be interested in this um but we also notably we're recording this in the middle of october right and we all are expecting at the end of october to get that like halloween time apple event where we get a new super high-end touchscreen macbook pro and i do feel like these are the same product on each side of the fence right that the new most powerful version yet and it's matte black hopefully and a touchscreen and just like their absolute most premium offering for either creative workflows or local ai or whatever else you plan on doing with this high-end hardware there's a silver one too by the way they're not all i'll never get it i'll never get it but the matte black one looks so sick There's also this magnetic USB Type-C port on the side.

1:03:55Marques Brownlee: So you probably know all these MacBook Pros, we've had this little MagSafe thing now, which is not a USB Type-C port. So you kind of are, I guess, theoretically doing MagSafe instead of a USB Type-C port. Yeah, you can still charge via USB-C, but - Exactly. But they threw MagSafe on the side there, which is kind of cool. This one, they've put a magnetic USB Type-C connector on the side. So if you want to use the magnetic power connector, it's great. If you don't use it, fine. It's just a USB type C port. Yeah, yeah. Well, and Surfaces have always had that kind of proprietary weird like. Surface Connect port.

1:04:30Yeah. It's almost looked like a PCIe slot like thing that magnetically taps it and pops off really easy. Yeah. I'm interested to see how easy this will, like MagSafe is there because it pops off really easy. So if you kick a wire with a laptop on a desk, it doesn't fly off. Yeah. The way this works is it's just a USB C port with really thick sides that have magnets on it. so it feels like if you pull it horizontally it probably will snap off pretty easy but in some other directions i'm wondering if it yeah will actually pop out because the usbc port still goes in pretty far yeah all of the videos that i saw were only it like kind of like pivoting in on an x-axis it had like a little mechanism they did for demos and it had an extremely specific way it still snapped it's tugged out up i don't really know how it's gonna work um would like to see it very very interested in seeing it they made a big deal about the fact that it's the most ports ever on a surface laptop um they have a usba they have an sd card reader they have three usbc ports including the magnetic one yes they have a headphone jack and hdmi hdmi port full size

1:05:35Marques Brownlee: pretty good pretty good and then all the rtx spark excitement too yeah which is like this is a super super powerful chip it has a ton of onboard integrated memory which is shared between the gpu and the cpu uh it will get the same power or i guess 99 of the power on battery versus plugged in which is not always true in windows land but that is true for these and they're claiming 15 hours of local video playback and 12 hours of active web usage efficient good battery life with these big bright screens these touchscreen like huge for i think there's a 4k screen option for this right 3270 by 2180 up 220 hertz so not quite 4k but close and there's also another uh equivalent in windows land which is the asus pro art p16 they're also doing an rtx spark laptop that's super super super high-end and it'll do the same stuff it's it's like five six thousand dollars you can get you can get a seven thousand dollar one with a terabyte of storage and like a 4k super high-res touchscreen super bright super powerful it's going to be awesome so they're doing these super high-end laptops and we're going to have this macro pro to compare it to very soon And I'm just excited to see how close the RTX Spark version gets or maybe even surpasses because you see the GPU numbers.

1:06:46I was going to say, can I read you the two processors you can purchase? Please. There's the NVIDIA RTX Spark N1X with 5 ,120-core GPU and 18-core CPU. That is available in a 24 or 32 gigabytes of unified memory version. Or there's the NVIDIA RTX Spark N1X with 6 ,144-core GPU and 20-core CPU. and that's available. I believe that you can go up to 128 gigs. Yeah, very funny. So I need to somehow figure out how to compare

1:07:13Marques Brownlee: the like 80 core GPU on MacBook Pro with the 6 ,144 core GPU on RTX Spark. I don't know what I'm going to do there, but we'll figure it out. Funny enough, you cannot in the pre-order page get the higher processor. You can only get in 32 gigs of memory in platinum. You have to go matte black to get the 4864 128. Yeah, Apple did that with the MacBook Pro. as well really i think it only came with they color gated the high end silly i think so yeah yeah with the m3 with the m3 max i believe they color gated it that's really funny uh something i do like about this laptop a lot is that it's very repairable and upgradable so you can it has internal wayfinding published repair guides replacement parts available upgradable storage so you can you can upgrade the storage yourself which is really nice um yeah that's just that's really nice to see overall generally these uh comparisons to m5 macbook pro is this to m5 max compared to m5 macbook m5 pro macbook pro uh 2.1 times faster to first time token time to first time to first token i don't even know what that means 4.3x faster image generation 6.2x faster video generation yeah wow you can you can see who these are targeted at oh yeah they're I mean, built for AI and image generation.

1:08:31Time to first token, oh my God. I don't even know what that means. But yeah, I think we went over a bunch of the specs. Most of them, like the cheapest one is 24 gigabytes unified memory, 512 SSD. That's that like$2 ,500 one, right? And then you can go up to one terabyte, two terabytes to get into the like almost$6 ,000 version.

1:08:51Marques Brownlee: Yeah, they're ridiculously expensive. One thing in this event, or are you guys done? Do you have anything else about Surface Ultra? ultra i not really i've always really liked their laptops i think they're sick i think this is sick i don't really give a damn about local ais or anything so this is too much i mean i think it'll be a sick computer but i don't see me ever spending that kind of money for it yeah because a big part of this and reviewing these obviously is where this comes in is who is this for yeah and did i talk about this last time when we were thinking about we have the m5 ultra mac studio and the M6 Mac mini, like three or four years ago, all the ads from Mac mini and Mac studio were creative workflows.

1:09:32Marques Brownlee: Yeah. Look at how much faster premiere and after effects are looking how much faster final cut is look how much faster it is to render to like render this 3d scene or to edit a ton of photos or all this stuff. There's a lot of creative workflows in their examples. Yeah. And people always give to YouTubers because it'd be like, all you ever do to benchmark is like export videos like that's not the only use case but it's like well that's one of the reasons people are buying these things like that's what it's for now if you go to m5 ultra mac studios website or if you go to m6 mac mini's website a lot of it is time to first token time to generate images time to generate videos all the stuff like compiling and all the stuff that you do yeah in ai land is much more center focus for these products because that's now who it's primarily for it's obviously still really good for creative stuff but that's also true about a lot of these the surface ultra the pro art the pro art they a lot of the pro art line for a long time has been like the nicest screens and the nicest creative tools yeah so it's still probably targeted for that but again you see yeah pro it's in the name it's pro art but it's gonna have a lot of ai token generation benchmarks too because that's what these chips are great at and that's what the the buyers these buyers are making a purchase decision based on how much money they think it will make them back they're thinking should i spend the extra 800 to get the 128 gigs of internal memory so i can run the larger model so i can have that model work more to make me more money later yeah that's the purchases and they're making yeah so when we're buying these laptops and we're not doing that local ai stuff doesn't mean anything to us but there are some of those people who are trying to Bytes laptops.

1:11:12One of the examples they gave in this event was they're like, oh, here's the Surface Laptop Ultra running GitHub Copilot. And then he's like, and now I'm just going to alt tab to like, I'm mastering this movie in DaVinci Resolve. And then he's like, alt tabs again. He's like, and I'm playing Gears of War the entire time. This is the experience of being a freelance creative. You're doing all these things at the exact same time. Yeah. Which is, I mean, that's impressive. It's just very funny that it's just like, I'm going to do some AI coding and then master this film and now I'm going to play Gears of 4.

1:11:44Marques Brownlee: Yeah, it is crazy capable how good these machines are. Some of the demos that these companies give us, I make fun of Apple all the time for these. They'll be like, and here's my Final Cut timeline. It's like a three minute video with a bunch of clips and they're like, I'd like to add a LUT to all of my clips and I'll just spam just a bunch of things and they'll be like, and now I'll export it and now I'm done and now it's got captions and now I'm moving on and I'm like, nobody edits like that but sure, it's like a general fast way of demoing how powerful and how quick something works yeah yeah so i can extrapolate my own workflows based on their insane demos yeah yeah you want to talk about the search functionality yeah there's one other thing in here which is just like a new update to the windows search experience that i found which i mentioned previously when ella said he was having all his network problems but it seems like windows is adding a much better search function within their like taskbar search which is essentially what we've been talking about in a lot of other things which is like a search feature that just understands you better, can deal with typos and synonyms and makes finding files and settings and everything on your laptop so much easier, including inline previews of docs and photos and videos and quick actions inside the like dialogue on the taskbar, which seems like something Windows has needed forever.

1:12:59Thank God. I know. It's just like now I can be like, why is my sound driver not working anymore? Or like, why can't I get the Wi-Fi? You can run commands and stuff. I just feel like it has always been a pain in the neck to try and find things on a Windows computer, even as an experienced Windows user. And having this will make everyone's lives easier. If it works. It was a nice demo. We'll see how it actually works in the end. I mean, it can't get worse. Everything in this world can get worse. we've been doing this podcast for 300 episodes and we've seen a lot of things get worse closer to 400 so yeah I just wanted to shout that out I'm excited to try that and see if it actually works as well and I'm very excited for that actually it used to be a society well after the break we're going to talk about a new Fitbit that is I just want to preview this what if the Fitbit air but with a screen

1:13:56Marques Brownlee: huh now you're thinking before. Now you're thinking. Now we'll, okay, I'm interested. Now I'm thinking with local AI. I'm excited to get there. We need to hire people with bright ideas like this. Yeah, that's right. But first.

1:14:13Andrew Edwards: All right, we've been talking about computationally intense Windows products, specifically hardware. I want to talk about what at the time I assume must have been an insanely graphically intense piece of software, MS Paint. Yes. Nice. A classic, right? Classic. MS Paint actually comes from a predecessor called PC Paint, which originally was built to complement what piece of computer hardware? Complement? Complement. Oh, wow. PC Paint. It's a complement of piece of hardware? I can't find a lot of info on PC Paint. It seems like it's effectively MS Paint. like they just sort of bought it, rebadged it, and republished it.

1:15:00Andrew Edwards: So it came out after MS Paint? No, it came out before MS Paint. When Microsoft was like, we need this to complement a piece of hardware we're making, they just picked it up. Okay. Do we need to name the exact name of the piece of hardware or just like what it is? Just what it is. What it is. Oh, really?

1:15:16Marques Brownlee: What it is. What it is. It's definitely an Etch-a-Sketch. Cool. Okay. Okay. I just get it. It's before my time off. Etch-a-Sketch. But I'll make a really good guess, I promise. Okay. We'll be right back.

1:15:40Marques Brownlee: Support for the show comes from Jira by Atlassian. So AI is only as useful as the context it has to work from. But when that context is scattered across tools like threads and DMs, that means your team and your AI agents end up flying kind of blind. That's the problem Jira solves. What's the gold tied to your project? what got decided last week in Slack. Atlassian's teamwork graph pulls all of these pieces together from Jira, Confluence, Slack, GitHub, and more, so nothing falls through the cracks. With Jira, you can actually share that context with the AI agents you already use, like Claude, Cursor, and GitHub Copilot, assign them work directly, or connect your agents through MCP.

1:16:16Marques Brownlee: Spend less time digging through endless links and DMs, less time chasing down what got decided and by who, and more time actually shipping. Learn more at jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot com. Support for the show comes from Google Gemini. You know that moment when curiosity strikes? You're exploring a new city with a family and a sculpture catches your daughter's eye. What is that? Who made it? With Gemini, you can snap a picture and get a fully interactive breakdown of its history, architecture, and even hidden secrets. Gemini is built for moments like that. Whether you're learning something new, solving a problem, or looking for your next favorite thing, Google Gemini is here to help.

1:16:58Download Gemini, Google's AI app, or visit gemini.google.com to learn more.

1:17:06Andrew Edwards: Purchase new carpet from The Home Depot and get it installed for free right now. Shop the stylish choices and simple pricing of carpet from Home Decorators Collection, Traffic Master, or LifeProof with PetProof technology. and see for yourself why nobody beats our prices. Enjoy new carpet with free installation right now at The Home Depot. Offer valid October 15th through November 1st, 2026. Exclusions apply. For licenses, see homedepot.com slash license numbers. All right, we're back. Lastly, though, I wanted to cover what David mentioned before, the Fitbit Edge, which is a cool but kind of confusing product.

1:17:43And I think the only reason it's confusing is because how everyone's titling all the articles about it, which is we all know Google acquired Fitbit a few years ago. Google and Fitbit have made it nothing short of extremely confusing by keeping both of the names and continually going back and forth. It reminds me of Google Home and Nest where I still don't know if I'm supposed to call things a Nest thing or a Google thing or if it's in the Nest app or the Google app. It's all very confusing. Because they change it every other month. It really feels like it. So they just announced the Fitbit Edge which a lot of people are calling the Fitbit Air with a screen.

1:18:14But you have to use Google Health, not the Fitbit app. yeah i don't even know that part i well they got rid of the fitbit app okay so fitbit app is gone yeah everything's in google health now so i'm confused why people are calling a fitbit with a screen because that's what a fitbit is that's what a fitbit always was um in 2013 they had the fitbit force which was just a rubber bracelet with a little tiny screen that could show things like step count yeah and like since then we have just seen that generally fitbits are these watches in quotes that are just a tall skinny screen that show fitness metrics on it right yeah so that's what this is and i think in that sense this is actually pretty cool it does slot in between the pixel watch and the fitbit air yeah it's 179 it is a much smaller screen a much smaller form factor it is updated because the fitbit charge 6 is i believe the last fitbit we really got which was in 2023 and this looks way nicer than that and it's almost the same price so i'm assuming it's got all the new updated sensors and everything 1.34 inch amoled display seven day battery life 100 charge in 90 minutes or five minutes for one day of battery life 1.35 grams side button gps and all the fun fitness tracking stuff you'd expect out of a fitbit i'm assuming probably still a garbage app like the uh oh wait no because it doesn't because it can show things update it to make it less broken okay so gotta note that cool um but so like yeah my really fast take on this is i actually i think it's kind of cool i wouldn't want it but this is a new this is a modernized fitbit that fits in the lineup much better fits hearing it called the fitbit air with a screen reminds me of how white claws started making non-alcoholic seltzers like you are now just making the thing you originally based your weird thing off of.

1:20:05Yeah. So does this one show like notifications and stuff? Yeah. Okay. This is, I think they basically said this is the Fitbit error if you want the notifications and some of the updates you would have on a screen without having a full-blown watch screen on it. This is my ideal watch. I think this actually looks kind of nicer than the Pixel Watch. 100 % by the seven day battery life.

1:20:28Marques Brownlee: That's pretty good. Yeah, it has real watch faces. Wow. Yeah, it's a whole... I think it's interesting. Why are they selling the Pixel Watch? Why would I spend$400 on a Pixel Watch when this fits my wrist better? How many days of battery life does the Pixel Watch have? Less, but it's a much bigger screen. Pixel Watch 5 is 40 hours with always... It's like every regular Apple Watch. 72 hours with battery saver mode on the Pixel Watch. This is so much better. It's funny that this is about the same amount of battery life as the Fitbit Air, but that's probably because it's got a bigger form factor to fit a larger battery in with the screen.

1:21:01But like this isn't that big. This is kind of nice. This is great. I would genuinely buy this. This looks like a good product. You should. Yeah. It's$179. I also want to note that the band team has been cooking. Yeah.

1:21:13Marques Brownlee: I was going to say the bands, there is a lot of good bands for this. Ever since the Fitbit Air came out, which had a couple of bands and they all sucked, these ones are actually pretty good looking and they have some like fancy ones. Like they have like a, I don't even know what you call it, like a Milanese kind of thing. Metal Lynx. Yeah. Metal Link band. They also released two new bands for the Fitbit Air with the Fitbit Edge. And those look great, too. So that's been good to see because I have been, you know, this thing has gotten real dirty. Metal mesh band is what they're called. Metal mesh.

1:21:47It looks, I mean, I saw photos of it on some people and it looked really nice. Yeah. I don't know how I feel about that. That one feels like you should have a watch attached to it. Well, it kind of just feels like a fashion bracelet. Like a thick fashion bracelet. I mean, I know nothing about fashion.

1:22:02Marques Brownlee: Is that Fitbit Edge is going to have Google Maps coming soon. Wow. It does have its own GPS, which is great. It's okay. Question. Dedicated GPS in this seven day battery life. Garmin freaking no screen. Yeah. No dedicated GPS. I mean,$400. It's kind of surprising. Very surprising. I wonder how much it's used. It's probably just in active workouts that require GPS tracking. Minus like. Yeah, but still. I guess maybe Google Maps will be able to use it too. This says dedicated GPS? It's not just when it's connected to your phone? It says GPS on it. It says GPS in the specs. I don't really know when it's used or how often it's on.

1:22:38Marques Brownlee: It has Galileo too. It's there. That's crazy. Wait, in? He's in the... Dog. It comes with the man himself. Anyway, yeah, wow. Okay. This seems good. I think it's awesome. I think just... This is mostly me just ranting about stop calling it a Fitbit error of the screen because that's just what a Fitbit Air is a Fitbit without a screen. Yeah. Fair enough. I do think it's cool that they offer now like multiple screen shapes and sizes. But yeah, seven day battery life with better bands, half the price of a Pixel watch. I feel like for people that want the screen but want the Fitbit Air, this is a really good in-between.

1:23:15I do kind of like wish there was a version that was like the current Fitbit Air but with this screen of the Fitbit Force from 2013, which is literally just like... Essentially, yeah, what? five different enough for like five characters yeah like maybe be able to i really like this

1:23:31Marques Brownlee: little this little oled yeah a little black bezels this little oled just like give me a couple things step counter time it's a good lineup if you look at it from air edge pixel watch they're cooking can i ask a dumb question it's probably not we're talking about asking dumb questions uh are the other fitbit products ios compatible yeah with the google health app yeah okay cool because this one is as well. I was just curious. I want to throw back to an older version of the podcast which I don't remember but was anybody in here on team no Apple Watch allowed at the wedding? We were all here. Oh wait like said you shouldn't wear one?

1:24:09Marques Brownlee: Yeah. Yeah that was because you went to the Met Gala wearing one. Well I was obviously on team like wear the Apple Watch at my wedding. That's fine.

1:24:15Andrew Edwards: I thought didn't you weren't you the one who was like no no mind. Wow thrower under the bed. Was anybody fully against that? I think there was two I think the Met Gala and this were separate episodes because the wedding was about a tweet that was like popping off. Oh, that's right. There was some guy who was like, don't you dare. Yeah. No, I was anti. I was anti it at the wedding because I was thinking it was going to feel outdated. And the whole point of weddings is to feel out of time.

1:24:40Marques Brownlee: Okay. Can I ask you then? Yeah. How do you feel about the Fitbit Edge dressed up with a nice metal band at that same wedding? It's still got a screen on. You got to say yes, David. Why? Let us just wear what we want. Oh, yeah. Okay. I wore the Fitbit Air to the wedding I went to last weekend. I think you should be allowed to wear anything you want. That's close. It was hidden underneath. Just add a little OLED on there and then. Yeah you're good. It's the same thing. It was hidden underneath my cuff length. They should make a cover for the top of them that just has a fake analog of hands and then you can just cover it up.

1:25:13Andrew Edwards: This is like when people are talking to their pets and like okay you can have a little salami. It's like okay you can have a little smartwatch. You're not giving your pets salami? I don't have any pets. I have the freaking maps that won't go into traps. I don't know. I forgot what team I was on, but I think at that point we were doing that fitness competition and I had to wear it. I didn't have to. But in order to win the fitness competition, I had to wear the Apple Watch and I crushed my rings that night. So it was worth it.

1:25:39Marques Brownlee: Yeah. Okay. No, I'm fully on team. Where would you have? Where are your kicks? It's a time capsule. It's a time capsule. If you take the photo on a 5D, is that dating the photo? because it's taken with a camera of the time. I think everything is of the time. No, it's because emails come on that thing. That's the reason. Emails will show up in 30 years when I'm looking back at these photos. Email weddings.

1:26:01Andrew Edwards: No, no, no. I'm saying the reason the Apple Watch at the wedding is a bad thing is because you're going to get an email. Weddings are an email-free space. If we've culturally agreed that any space is an email-free space, it's weddings. I would even argue you could send an email at a funeral and it would be more appropriate.

1:26:20Marques Brownlee: I think do not disturb is all you need. I should have the Apple Watch on and it's on do not disturb. But I get to track my calories for the dancing. I get to, all the other stuff is still there. I think that should be fair game. I think at a wedding, if they're the people getting married and they ask you to do something, you should probably just listen to them.

1:26:36Andrew Edwards: What would you do if the person officiating your wedding was wearing an Apple Watch? And reading the script off of their Apple Watch?

1:26:44Marques Brownlee: Scrolling on the little side. That would be a little much. Hang on. I don't know where the line is. I just know that everything in the wedding photos is a sign of the times, from the outfits we're wearing, to the phones, to the grandma holding their phone like this, taking pictures. That's a sign of the times, like the watch I'm wearing. It is very common for officiants to say, please put your phones away. I hear that all the time, and I always see phones anyway. You got to call them out then. I know. Grandma. It's always the grandma. I don't want to call out the grandma. You got to. She's taking the pictures.

1:27:14Marques Brownlee: You got to call out the grandma. Grandma, fingers in front of that lens. You'll never learn if you don't keep calling them out. Let her have this one. she doesn't have that many more weddings to go to. That's fair enough. Yeah, it's just a fun question. But yeah, I think Fitbit is, the edge is kind of far. Yeah, I'm on the edge of my seat waiting to see if this is good. I'm also on the edge of my seat waiting to see if I get the trivia questions right. I'm not going to get them right. Neither am I. I don't need to guess on a lot. I'm excited I have a guess. The second one? Yes. I'm sorry, guys.

1:27:43Andrew Edwards: This is your fault because you didn't know what Chumby was. Yeah, that's my fault. He's that guy from Pawn Stars. Yeah. Before there was Bixby, there was what? Did you say it's the guy from Pawn Stars? Craziest s*** you've ever said. That's Chum Lee, okay? Put some respect on his name. That was a deep cut. That's crazy. That's the cut. S***. Oh.

1:28:14The dead silence of trivia, and then you're just going to have to bleep that is going to be really funny.

1:28:20Andrew Edwards: What do we got, fellas? This is either really dumb or really smart.

1:28:28Marques Brownlee: Okay, who wants to go first? I wrote the Samsung AI Assistant because I don't know what it is. Well, that is different than David's answer. What did you write, David? Oh my God, it was. I don't think it is, but... I wrote Samsung Assistant. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I wrote Dex. Why would it be called Dex? It's not Dex.

1:28:43Andrew Edwards: I don't know. That's another thing. Dex is the thing. I know it's another thing, but this is way before, so I was like, maybe that's where it came from. That's true. No, it was called S-Voice.

1:28:51Marques Brownlee: Oh, I knew that. I did know that. Me too. I knew that. No, it's because Siri, it was such an obvious copy. S-Voice, Samsung Voice, Siri, it's all on the same. Damn, I knew that. I should have known that considering I contributed. That's a good question. I should have gotten that. It should have been called Galaxy Brain. I appreciate that. No, I remember that. Galaxy Brain would be a sick name for that. I remember the little logo, too, for the button with the S on it. Damn.

1:29:14Andrew Edwards: Yeah. I should have gotten that. Before I read the next question, quick update on the score. Mariah, can you put it on your computer? Quick update on the score. Marquez, you got 10 points, meaning you're right behind Andrew at 11 points. David is still somehow lapping everyone at 16 points.

1:29:35Marques Brownlee: We're catching him, though.

1:29:36Andrew Edwards: I'm going to stroll in Latifi over here. Now, quick correction. I read the question the first time I accidentally said PC Paint, what I meant was PC Paint Brush. Not that that matters to any of you guys, just a different program. PC Paint Brush was the thing that came before Microsoft Paint. However, they're all in the same fork of one another. Anyway, MS Paint, also known previously as PC Paint Brush, was released, here I'll give you a little more hint, as part of the driver package for what piece of hardware for Windows computers? Hardware? Hardware for Windows computers. What would you... What would be really exciting?

1:30:23Andrew Edwards: I just got a brand new blank. Now I can use MS Paint.

1:30:27Marques Brownlee: Let me try something.

1:30:28Andrew Edwards: Can it be a category?

1:30:29Marques Brownlee: Let me try...

1:30:30Andrew Edwards: You can be pretty vague with this one. Okay.

1:30:33Marques Brownlee: I'm just trying. This is a shot in the dark. Shot in the dark. But you're to blame. If the thing that I erased was the right answer. or I'm going to be pretty mad though. I feel so bad. All right.

1:30:46Andrew Edwards: Wow, I'll put different things. That's what I wrote. That's what I was. That was my other guess, but now I have a third guess too. David, what did you put? Drawing tablet. Unfortunately, drawing tablet is not correct. I'm sure someone's going to be like, actually, they did release a drawing tablet. So please let me know and then I'll give them the point. Marquez? I wrote mouse and crossed it out and wrote stylus. I'm so sorry. And Andrew, would you please? The best part about trivia now is based on who Ellis calls on first. I wrote mouse. Mouse is correct. I also wrote that before all of your hints.

1:31:19So when they invented the mouse, they released that software.

1:31:22Andrew Edwards: It's not exactly that simple, and who invented the mouse is a little bit of a convoluted. It was one of those people were sort of racing towards it at the same time. However, there was a company called Mouse Systems that bought some simple art software and then bundled it with their stuff and then released a windows driver for their mouse microsoft was like why are we not making a mouse too so they because they never made mouse one they also developed got to start somewhere microsoft they licensed the art software they bundled it it made too much sense i'm sorry guys the vibes of pc pain pressure is so good i didn't i wrote mouse in all caps next week i'm just going to start making stuff up again we got to go back to Trivia's Rootsman, where I just start...

1:32:06Andrew Edwards: Which is these as a real tech company. Yeah. Chumbie would have been an excellent candidate for that. There's a chance Mariah cuts the entire Chumbie section, and people have no idea what I'm talking about when I say Chumbie. Equally funny.

1:32:20Marques Brownlee: Incredible. Who wants to read us out? It's still October. By the time you listen to this, Techtober is still cruising along. So, thank you for watching and listening to this week's episode. Get subscribed, if you haven't already, to be first in line to wash your dishes to next week's episode because it's still going to be fire. Otherwise, catch you soon. Peace. Bye. There's so much stuff next week as well. We're produced by Mariah Zank and Alice Rovin and part of the Fox Media Podcast Network and our intro, outro music was created by Vain. So, bingo. Let's go. There's the bingo button. Bingo. Let's go.

1:33:10Andrew Edwards: guys what is this called as far as i could tell this was one of the first home dashboard sort of ecosystem screen things that was ever made and when the home view came out i saw a bunch of people on twitter being like damn we we had this in 2006 can i did not have this first of all it I thought it was a ham at first. A ham. Like a ham. Excuse me. For audio listeners, can you please describe what you're looking at? I think ham, like tech ham with a loosely. Leather ham. Have you ever played that game, the DS game where you draw stuff? Yeah. What's it called? Scribblenauts. Yeah. It sort of has a Scribblenauts-esque interface.

1:33:50Andrew Edwards: I love Scribblenauts. But picture that on a ham. Yeah. The two screens. One has Pandora and one has something called Facemaker. Yeah, so it's like an old home hub kind of thing, but it kind of just looks like a stuffed leather purse upside down, and there's a screen in the middle.

1:34:05Marques Brownlee: I definitely have never heard of this, but I will do my best guess. 100%.

1:34:08Andrew Edwards: Marquez, damn it. This is the one where I was just like.

1:34:11Marques Brownlee: I didn't own a home in 2006.

1:34:13Andrew Edwards: I know, but you were reviewing TV remotes. I thought this might have made it across your desk. 06? I assumed one of you would be like, oh, I totally remember that. I have no idea. You want a different question? Can I guess who made it? Sure. Myspace. No. It's called the Chumby. Yeah. The Chumby? No, I've never get that. Mariah, I'll let you decide if you want to keep that catastrophe of a true-to-to-question. Damn, I was really hoping one of you would be like, Oh, yeah. The Chumby. You remember the Chumby? Purchase new carpet from the Home Depot and get it installed for free right now. Shop the stylish choices and simple pricing of carpet from Home Decorators Collection, traffic master or life proof with pet proof technology and see for yourself why nobody beats our prices enjoy new carpet with free installation right now at the home depot offer valid october 15th through november 1st 2026 exclusions apply for licenses see homedepot.com slash license numbers your heart can tell you a lot about your health apple watch series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off.

1:35:25And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.

From the publisher

Gadgets, gadgets and more gadgets. TECHtober is heating up and we have Marques, Andrew and David talking about the Apple Homeview and other smart home products, the Microsoft Surface Ultra, and the Fitbit Edge.

Links:

MKBHD: Homeview Impressions

Microsoft: Introducing Surface Ultra

9to5Google: Fitbit Edge

This episode brought to you by:

Charles Schwab: https://www.schwab.com/oninvesting

Shopify: https://www.shopify.com/waveform

Framer: https://www.framer.com/wave

Jira: https://www.jira.com

Pipedrive: https://www.pipedrive.com/waveform

Follow us on socials:

Marques: https://www.threads.net/@mkbhd

Andrew: https://www.threads.net/@andrew_manganelli

David: https://www.threads.net/@davidimel

Adam: https://www.threads.net/@parmesanpapi17

Ellis: https://twitter.com/EllisRovin

Waveform Threads: https://www.threads.net/@waveformpodcast

Waveform Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/waveformpodcast/?hl=en

Waveform TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@waveformpodcast

Join the Discord:

https://discord.gg/mkbhd

Intro/Outro music by 20syl:

https://bit.ly/2S53xlC

Waveform is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Waveform: The MKBHD Podcast

All episodes