1. Podcasts
  2. Westminster Insider
  3. Stockpiling Britain: Does Westminster know something we don’t?
Westminster Insider

20 Nov 2026 · 48m · 20 chapters

Episode artwork

Stockpiling Britain: Does Westminster know something we don’t?

In short

The UK government’s “Be Ready” campaign urging households to stockpile essentials (food, water, medicines, power/heat and information tools) amid risks like supply-chain disruption, extreme weather, cyber attacks, and infrastructure vulnerabilities. The episode asks whether Westminster knows something the public doesn’t, and argues the issue is partly communication and preparedness culture.

Guests and backgrounds

  • David Reid, Conservative shadow minister for defence, security and resilience.
  • Alistair Carmichael, MP for Orkney and Shetland (island communities; logistics vulnerability).
  • Baroness Tracy Paul, House of Lords Resilience Commission author; focuses on national resilience and supply-chain risk.
  • Dan Jarvis, UK government Minister of State for Security; leads resilience/security response; interviewed in the National Situation Centre.
  • Dan Bloom, Politico political editor (studio).

Key claims

  • Stockpiling is practical for “everyday emergencies,” not panic.
  • UK is vulnerable due to fragile just-in-time systems and lost institutional memory.
  • Government messaging needs more context; transparency/candour is debated.
  • UK depends heavily on imported medicines (especially from China).

Notable examples

  • Water supply stress from drought/depleted reservoirs.
  • Cyber attacks causing fridge/freezer failures.
  • Finland’s “resilience culture” and nine months’ food storage.
  • 2004 post-Madrid bombings pamphlets and a satirical “government stockpiling” website that the Cabinet Office shut down.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:30

Exploring the Need for Stockpiling

Discussion on the government's campaign encouraging citizens to prepare for emergencies and the underlying threats.

“It's no secret that Russia is very interested in what there is on the seabed.”
2:42

The Stockpiling Mindset

A conversation about personal stockpiling habits and the rationale behind the government's campaign.

“So in the last few weeks, obviously, we've had a government campaign telling us all to get ready.”
7:26

Supermarket Stockpiling Expedition

A practical exploration of what items to stockpile for emergencies and the rationale behind them.

“ready and resilient for whatever might come.”
14:00

Government's Stockpiling Campaign

Discussion on the government's campaign to encourage stockpiling supplies and its communication issues.

“But do you think they do at least deserve credit for putting it on the national agenda?”
15:00

The Need for Context and Communication

Exploration of the importance of providing context to the public regarding stockpiling for emergencies.

“There's actually just more of a comms issue that needs to be improved.”
16:05

Stockpiling in Remote Communities

Insights from MP Alistair Carmichael on the necessity of stockpiling in remote constituencies like Orkney and Shetland.

“Finally, the one thing we didn't get was any alcohol.”
17:47

Risks and Vulnerabilities in Supply Chains

Discussion on the vulnerabilities of supply chains and the impact on communities in crises.

“Come the zombie apocalypse, I think absolutely a stalk of hobnobs is going to be absolutely critical.”
20:51

Lessons from Finland on Resilience

Comparison of UK preparedness to Finland's resilience practices and the culture of preparedness.

“but you know it's no secret that Russia is very interested in what there is on the seabed and you know it does leave you at moments of geopolitical tension feeling that little bit more exposed.”
23:26

Calls for Government Accountability

Discussion on the need for more transparency and urgency from the UK government regarding preparedness.

“And that's from young children who understand what they should do through to senior business leaders who will understand their role.”
24:41

Show and Tell: Preparedness Debate

Hosts discuss their stockpiled items and the importance of being prepared for crises.

“Baroness, well, thank you so much for being on Westminster Insider.”
Show all 20 chapters
25:57

Interview with Security Minister Dan Jarvis

An interview with Dan Jarvis on the government's stockpiling strategy and crisis management.

“Next up is my interview with the government's security minister, Dan Jarvis.”
28:00

The Importance of Preparedness

Discussion on the role of data in informing government decisions and personal stockpiling.

“where we're fusing together different data sets to inform judgments that ministers will make in another part of the building.”
29:56

Public Engagement and Campaign Awareness

Exploration of public engagement in the Be Ready campaign and perceptions of its seriousness.

“I suppose, is do you worry that perhaps some of the messaging from some of your cabinet minister colleagues has been perhaps trivialising what is obviously supposed to be quite a serious campaign?”
31:15

Government Transparency and Risk Communication

A conversation on government transparency regarding national risks and public preparedness.

“record, the conversations that we're having nationally about the nature of the world that we're living in, I think there is a lot of conversation about the different threats that we face.”
33:59

Challenges in Government Resilience Strategy

Discussion on the need for a cohesive government approach to national resilience.

“The public expect government to make sure that collectively we are resilient and that we are prepared.”
36:01

The Peaceful Joy of Chicken Keeping

Personal reflections on the relaxing nature of keeping chickens amid a busy life.

“So we absolutely do need that whole of government response.”
36:56

Threats and Public Safety Concerns

Discussion on various national threats and the government's response to keep the public safe.

“It's something that I've done for a long time and hopefully will continue to do in the future.”
42:03

Understanding Stockpiling in Westminster

Explore the complacency in Westminster regarding potential threats and stockpiling.

“They're preparing for how to fight in the Arctic.”
44:09

The Need for a Cultural Shift

Discuss the need for a dramatic external shock to shift public and government mindset.

“both the civil service need a shock and the public need a shock?”
45:17

Weird News Stories: Kamikaze Drones and Garden Bunkers

Hosts share and discuss unique news stories, including a Boeing bunker.

“And apparently his wife was like, we don't need that in the garden.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Westminster Insider, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Music

0:16David Reed: Be ready. That, in case you haven't heard it yet, is the current message from the government to all of us.

0:23Patrick Baker: Be ready by just having some everyday essentials indoors. It's not about panicking, is it? It's just about being prepared.

0:31David Reed: It's the name of a new campaign encouraging us to stockpile food and water and prepare for emergencies, whether that's power cuts, disruption to our energy grid or breakdowns in supply chains that keep our supermarket shelves stocked. Because as recent events have shown, the interconnected just-in-time world we live in can be remarkably vulnerable. To be honest, I don't blame the housing secretary for stocking up on Sauvignon Blanc. If Russia attacks with these guys in charge, we'll all need a drink. But when you suddenly hear politicians telling you to stockpile, it's hard not to wonder, do they know something we don't?

1:12David Reed: So, this week on Westminster Insider, we're going from the supermarket all the way to the Situation Room to dig a little bit deeper into what's really going on here. speaking to the politicians trying to convince Britain to change its mindset when it comes to emergencies. The world has changed so rapidly over the last couple of years. It's no secret that Russia is very interested in what there is on the seabed. We also want to speak to those warning the government itself that it needs to do a lot more. We were very, very shocked to learn that we do not make any medicines here in the UK. And we'll speak to the security minister with the unenviable job of getting Britain ready for the next crisis, whenever that may be.

1:56Patrick Baker: Lots of things. Keep me awake at night.

1:58David Reed: From Politico, I'm Patrick Baker, and this week on Westminster Insider, we're asking why Westminster wants you to stockpile.

2:20David Reed: Black Friday scores, door boosters too. More than a few. Grab a big bed too, lay your head mattresses too. Sheets that are new. Save that Wayfair. Save on these chairs. Find just your style. It makes you smile. Here's a quick plug. Area rose free shipping while Wayfair is how. Wayfair. The season will win the season.

2:37Patrick Baker: Wayfair, Wayfair, Wayfair, Wayfair, Wayfair.

2:41David Reed: Hi, Sasha. How are you doing?

2:43Patrick Baker: I'm doing very well, thanks. Got my stockpile ready. You got it ready? I know you do too.

2:47David Reed: You knew that question was coming. Yes. So in the last few weeks, obviously, we've had a government campaign telling us all to get ready. And I feel like anecdotally, some of my friends have completely ignored that message. Some are a little bit more attentive. Some have been doing it for a while. So my first thing I really want to know from you is, are you a stockpiler?

3:05Patrick Baker: I'm not a natural stockpiler. Although potentially some people who have had the burden of living with me would disagree with that. Are you a hoarder? I'm not a hoarder. I'm paranoid about running out of loo roll. I basically hate going to shops to buy loo roll. But my ultimate, I think, stockpiling hack is, I can't say with a straight face, but I'm going to make the case for it. Saucison, so the kind of French cured meat, it lasts for months. It's a good protein source. Once you open it, it will last like a week or two opened. It doesn't require a refrigerator. you can eat it raw, you can cook it, you can do whatever you want with it.

3:49Patrick Baker: If you've got access to a gas stove, you can make a nice little kind of saucisson carbonara. There's just so many options available.

3:57David Reed: I love it. And it doesn't at all scream liberal metropolitan elite. So we're coming at this episode in a context where we're hearing more about cyber attacks around the world, the rise of AI, increased threats from Russia. Do you think Westminster is now taking the threats to the UK more seriously?

4:13Patrick Baker: I think they are. And the kind of Be Ready campaign was launched back in October before Labour Party conference. And there was a kind of spate of silliness about it. You know, Angela Rayner saying that she was going to stockpile Sauvignon Blanc and mascara. But I think that there has been a real pivot from the government to make sure that people take this more seriously. You know, I remember when Storm Buelo and Storm Austin hit a few weeks ago. Andy Burnham came out and said, look, this is why we're doing this Be Ready campaign. It's not necessarily about Russia, you know, kind of starting war with us.

4:47Patrick Baker: It is just about sensible measures that people can take. And I think, you know, historically, again, like we've really struggled to take some of the resilient stuff seriously. So I don't know if you remember Pat back in 2023, Oliver Dowden tried to do this and he did a big speech telling people to stockpile. And he was totally ribbed for it, you know, and he was just saying, you should have some water, you should have all of these bits and pieces. And it was kind of funny, because on the day that that campaign was meant to go formal, Rishi Sunak called the election. Yeah, absolutely.

5:18David Reed: So it got completely buried. Yeah, I think it's interesting to think about the government's obviously launched this campaign, they want to raise awareness of it. But at the same time, it's coming at a point where Andy Burnham is clearly trying to inject a bit of positivity, a bit of optimism in the country. So it makes sense that you don't want to overload people with a sense of dystopian threats and danger on the horizon. I spoke to one MP who told me that there was a bit of a contradiction in saying we might have a war in a thousand days, but also hope again. It does bring home that sense that, you know, they're a little bit confused about the messaging.

5:50David Reed: Do you think there has been almost a strategy of deliberate ambiguity around this? They kind of want people to take it seriously, but at the same time, they don't want to overstate the threats that we're facing.

6:01Patrick Baker: I think they definitely don't want people to panic. But as you say, that can lead to people saying, well, why are you telling us to stockpile then? And again, I kind of went back through government attempts to do this historically. And there was very, I mean, it wasn't funny, but the response to it was funny. So in 2004, in the wake of the Madrid bombings, the UK government sent out pamphlets to everyone's home, 25 million households. It cost 8 million quid, just telling them to have a kind of stash of food and goods and things like that. And there was some university kid called Tom Scott who set up a website basically taking the piss out of the government's attempt to get people to stockpile.

6:43Patrick Baker: And he signed it. He made it look like a government website. And he signed it on behalf of his majesty's department, or it would have been her majesty's department, of vague paranoia at the time. But what's better about it is the cabinet office actually rang up this kid. They gave him a call and they said, you have to take the website down.

7:01David Reed: Wow.

7:01Patrick Baker: Yeah.

7:02David Reed: Incredible. Yeah, and that really, I think, underpins this whole thing, doesn't it? It's like, on the one hand, you want people to take it seriously. On the other hand, you don't want to scare them. And I think it leaves a lot of the public thinking, what's going on? Does Westminster know something that we don't? So to try and get under the surface of what's really going on in Westminster, I wanted to spend this episode roaming around the Westminster bubble, speaking to parliamentarians who've been banging the drum about the need for Britons to become a bit more ready and resilient for whatever might come.

7:29David Reed: The first person I spoke to was the Conservative's shadow minister for defence, security and resilience, a man called David Reid. He's been pretty supportive of the government's Be Ready campaign so far, but he does think it needs to go further. So he kindly agreed to meet me outside a supermarket in Pimlico to buy a few emergency essentials.

7:52David Reed: Hi, David, Patrick. So we're going to spend an unspecified amount, but enough to keep me safe for three days let's do it let's go for it get my basket okay so first thing here we are so first thing big bottle of water yeah i would say probably going sort of supermarket own brand cheapest option five liters i should imagine okay so a couple of those so if we could just explain obviously we understand that water is important for human survival but what's the sort of underlying threat that could really expose our water system to to some jeopardy yeah so we're seeing this at the moment so um with all the droughts that we've had over the summer some of the water companies because they haven't haven't built um reservoirs they're now really depleted and i'm feeling it's in the southwest at the moment right um so if those um if that water supply goes off then you need the ability to be able to um drink obviously but also maybe to prepare food to wash um if you've got pets and animals to be able to um to give them to give them hydration as well okay well yeah Can't argue.

8:51David Reed: Seems like a very sensible place to start. So where are we going next, David? So now I want to start thinking about non-perishable foods. Beans, glorious beans. Excellent. Good multi-buy on there. Perfect. Okay. So that's a good start. Yeah. So just talk us through that. So obviously that's been one of the kind of icons of the non-perishables, baked beans. But why are non-perishable items so important in an emergency? So these are brilliant. So if your gas or electricity went down, and you didn't have the ability to heat or cook food, you still need sustenance in some way. Beans are just a good staple where you don't need to do any of those things.

9:31David Reed: You can literally open the can. It's not going to be delicious, but you will have to eat the food cold. But it is a source of energy and it's something easy that you could have on your shelf. I like rice pudding cold. I wonder if you could get that in a can. Other food sources here. So I think tuna is a brilliant one. High protein, lots of energy. Spam, that really kind of evokes World War II rides, doesn't it? Yeah, it really does, yeah. We're not at that level. And it's on offer, no, but I think let's go for it. Not sure I'm eating that, even in an apocalypse. This is going to have to go on your shelf now.

10:03David Reed: Yeah. Okay, brilliant. Let's get some biscuits in. This is easy to have in. And again, you can go through that. Buzzing for some hobnobs. This is where hobnobs we are gambling. So here we are in a slightly chilly section where the milk is and other sort of perishable items. We've seen around Europe recently cyber attacks that have led fridges to going to something like 50 degrees, items just disintegrating. So it's no surprise that obviously when you're thinking about what you'd go for in emergency, these areas aren't on the list. Yeah, definitely not. Look, I think fridges are a fairly new thing that people have in their houses.

10:42David Reed: So my dad was born in 1942 in Plymouth during the Blitz and the concept of having a fridge in your house, it just wasn't even there. People would keep stuff outside if it was cold enough and that society was way more resilient than we are now. I think our search for a torch, there's one down there, this section around heat and warmth. If you have the ability to get a torch, get some batteries to be able to have some light if electricity goes off and then also the ability to be able to keep yourself warm so things like blankets or making sure that you've got warm clothes or if it's in the summer making sure that you have an ability to cool yourself okay um i think that's the next area that you want to be focusing on but it doesn't look like the supermarket has it just while we're on this aisle this obviously happened during covid everyone rushed out to get loo roll yes there is loo roll we can confirm very good so i think it's probably best to get some if sewage systems go down uh if you can't have the ability to actually flush your toilet having the ability to be able to go to the loo in some way and maybe sort of thinking through how you do that Yeah.

11:46David Reed: Right, we've got most of our stuff now. It's a bit of a workout, I will say. It's going to be a tough job getting up my flat stairs, but anyway. But this is a good start. And there's another area that we haven't focused on, because I knew that we wouldn't be able to get it in the super market, which is around how we get information from either the governments or other providers. Because if electricity networks go off, then mobile phone companies then have an inability to be able to provide those services. You might not even be able to charge your phone up. So having a normal wind-up radio or a battery radio is massively important so that you can still get information from the government if they need to provide anything.

12:34David Reed: So there will be people out there who look at all this current messaging about resilience and government campaigns and perhaps hear you talking about it and go, well, the Tory party were in government for 14 years. Did they leave us a country that was unprepared for the challenges that the world might pose to us? What would you say to that? I think the world has changed so rapidly over the last couple of years that it would have been difficult for any government to see what was coming down the track. And I think if we look at the world that we've lived under for the last, what, first six years since the end of the Cold War, we've been used to supply chains working to being able to just get things that we need at the click of a button because the world's been safer and it's been underpinned by American security guarantees that world is changing rapidly now war's broken out in multiple regions we've seen we've seen mass cyber attacks and we're also seen extreme weather events happening because of climate change.

13:37So we've seen this in the

13:39David Reed: defence space as well and we talk about defence spending but this has been multiple governments over a long period of time that haven't thought about this stuff and we've sort of lost the institutional memory of how to do it which for me is really worrying and that's why we need to get real very quickly about some of the threats we face and do it in a cross-party way where the messaging is quite consistent. People have been critical of the current government's campaign for saying that perhaps they didn't explain why they were doing it, that these warnings about the need to stockpile, for many people, I think, felt a bit random and like they came out of nowhere.

14:14David Reed: But do you think they do at least deserve credit for putting it on the national agenda? Yeah, definitely. And look, I've worked very closely with Dan Jarvis, he's the security minister. And I've said well done for launching this campaign but the politics comes from how it's done and how we do the strategic communications to inform people of some of the issues we face and my big challenge has been that we've asked people to go out and prepare and struck up our food and water and medicine but we're not given the additional context of why we need to do that and if you don't give the context people get scared very quickly so when people sort of say they look at Westminster and And they go, do politicians, do ministers, do they know something we don't?

14:58David Reed: That's actually, in your view, not the case. There's actually just more of a comms issue that needs to be improved. I think from my own experiences, the state understands a lot and the wider public don't understand because that information hasn't been shared. I think some of our near neighbours, I was out in Germany last week, they've become a lot better at declassifying some of this information and having a proper conversation with the population so that everyone's more informed. We're speaking to Dan Jarvis for this episode a little later on. What would be some of the things you'd want us to put to him?

15:29David Reed: What do you think are some of the important things for him to consider as next steps? Obviously, he's a big part of the Be Ready campaign, but what more do you want to see from the government now? So really simply, I want them to start the national conversation properly. So we've produced a booklet in my team. Here it is. Yep, so we've produced it here. There it is. Yeah. In all its glory. so we want this to go out to every household it's exactly what our near neighbors have done so those in Denmark and the Netherlands so people have the context of what they need to prepare and it's not a case of then you have to log on to a website and look at the information yourself this is coming through your door and you get to see the information the same as everyone else up and down the country so that's the first step the second is to give the context so when we are attacked or if there's a natural weather event that maybe hits our water or electricity, talk about it openly and link it to the prepare campaign of why we need to be more resilient.

16:23David Reed: Finally, the one thing we didn't get was any alcohol. Angela Rayner said she would want Sauvignon Blanc in a crisis. What would you choose? I think it would be dependent on seasons. If it was really cold, I'd want a bit of whiskey to warm my cockles. Right, let's go back in. We forgot the real essentials there. Well, David, Thank you so much for taking me shopping. It's been brilliant. Lovely being with you. Cheers. So got quite a good haul there, other than the spam, obviously. We've just dropped David off in Parliament behind me. I'm now going to speak to another MP whose constituency is so remote that stockpiling isn't just the latest fad from a government campaign, but a way of life.

17:03David Reed: Come with me. So delighted to be joined by Alistair Carmichael, who, given your constituency, obviously you know a thing or two about the need to stockpile. Could you just tell our listeners which constituency you represent? Okay, I represent Orkney and Shetland, so the island groups to the north of Scotland. And yes, Luke, you know, we're talking about keeping supplies in the cupboard and what you do when things that we kind of take for granted in urban communities are not there. Now, living in an island community, that's not as unusual an experience for us. And obviously, the government recently launched its Be Ready campaign, which I'm sure you know all about.

17:47David Reed: I've been out and about shopping. I'm very impressed. All sorts of goodies. Come the zombie apocalypse, I think absolutely a stalk of hobnobs is going to be absolutely critical. Truly, truly key. But do you perhaps look at that campaign and think, well, my constituents are already used to having to do this kind of thing. How do you say it? We really do, you know. Not to overstate it, but yeah, I think everybody's got some dry pasta, maybe tinned foods. Probably not bottled water. That might be a sort of less common one. And things like people will have candles and maybe paraffin lamps and that sort of thing in the cupboard.

18:35David Reed: We don't take for granted the continuation of public services and even the availability of food. Because this is something that I think we need to confront now and take seriously. We have such an over-reliance on supermarkets for our weekly shop. And they don't store food. They have this just-in-time distribution system where basically your next day's food is on the motorway coming towards you. Shetland, Orkney, all island communities are in microcosm what the rest of the United Kingdom is. So it's not that unusual for us not to have a ferry coming in for a few days at a time. You have two or three days of a bad storm, but even after that, the sea state remains really bad.

19:35David Reed: So, you know, ships don't necessarily get in to dock. And you see it, empty supermarket shelves. And, you know, if you don't produce your own food, then you are vulnerable to that. A few years ago, actually, we very nearly lost Christmas. We had a bad storm about 10 days out from Christmas and the supermarket shelves were stripped bare. Are you perhaps more alive to some of the threats that we often hear talked about, whether that's undersea cables, cyber attacks, those kind of things? We live with the reality of this. Undersea cables is an interesting example because actually I think that's not sufficiently resilient and we do need to be doing more to protect the resilience of our infrastructure like that.

20:30David Reed: Because I don't believe that any mainland community would tolerate being left without digital connectivity in the way that we have been twice last year alone, where undersea cables have been broken by accident, apparently by fishing crawlers. but you know it's no secret that Russia is very interested in what there is on the seabed and you know it does leave you at moments of geopolitical tension feeling that little bit more exposed. For all this talk of individuals stockpiling and being ready what can the government do to keep us safe? Just this week as fate would have it the House of Lords Resilience Commission has released a report and it accuses the government of being underprepared and complacent in the face of what it calls catastrophic risks.

21:28David Reed: One of the authors of that report who sat on the commission is Baroness Tracy Paul and she works out of Milbank House right behind me. So I'm off to speak to her to dig into what she's found out about the UK's vulnerabilities. Was there anything during the course of putting this report together that really shocked you about the state of Britain? As a committee, we were very, very shocked to learn that we do not make any medicines here in the UK and that we are completely dependent, as is most of Europe, for China, for most of the medication that we use on a daily basis here in the UK. There's obviously climate change, there's cyber attacks, there's Russian activity.

22:05David Reed: There's all sorts of possible threats. Is there one specific one that perhaps keeps you up at night? I suppose I have a particular interest in cyber. And so it's something that I feel closer to than some of the other subject matters. I know other members of the committee are very concerned about flooding and about climate change. I just think that we don't understand how our supply chains work and how vulnerable we can be to very small parts of the economy going wrong. As part of your research, you went to Finland. Could you tell us a bit more about what you learned there? What did that tell you about how the UK compares to a country like that?

22:45David Reed: Yeah, so we met a number of people whose job it is to make certain that Finland is prepared for any incident. They're very keen to stress to us they have an 800 mile border with Russia, which is a very, very different scenario to the one that we face. And it would be naive of us to think that we should do everything that they're doing in Finland here and that it would translate because it wouldn't. But what it really came across is that resilience is a culture and it is a muscle. And every person understands what they should do if there was any kind of event, a risk event. And that's from young children who understand what they should do through to senior business leaders who will understand their role.

23:35David Reed: and we met people who talked about their food supply and how they maintain nine months' worth of storage. So they've got nine months' worth of food resilience. They talked about how everybody in Finland knows how to use an axe and shoot. So not all of it translates here, but there was something very special about their approach and I think we've got a lot to learn. The report was quite critical of the government overall and accuses it of a lack of candour. Are you calling for more transparency from government about the risks? Yes, definitely. And I think that the feeling from the committee was that there's not enough urgency, there's not enough momentum, and that it's too siloed.

24:19David Reed: We didn't get that sense that there was a proper coordination across the top of government, which is why we called for a cabinet minister with responsibility and a permanent secretary with responsibility and a statement from the Prime Minister on an annual basis because we want to inject some urgency and some sense of coordination into the kind of process. Baroness, well, thank you so much for being on Westminster Insider. Thank you.

24:52David Reed: Sasha, it's show and tell day at school. So what do you think of my stash here?

24:55Patrick Baker: Do you feel more prepared, Pat?

24:57David Reed: I feel so prepared. I'm hiding behind a huge tin of baked beans here. Yeah, we've got some Spam.

25:03Patrick Baker: Have you ever eaten Spam?

25:05David Reed: I've never eaten Spam, to be honest.

25:07Patrick Baker: Are you going to eat some right now?

25:09David Reed: I'm not going to eat some right now.

25:10Patrick Baker: If you were a professional, you would eat some on camera.

25:12David Reed: Producer John wants us to eat it on camera, but that is not going to happen, I'm afraid. I feel like I'm going to vomit, actually. Right.

25:21Patrick Baker: The big water is good. I actually think the water is the thing that we will probably miss the most. You know, we all have a bit of food in our pantries that we could snack on for three days. But what would you do if you didn't have any water?

25:33David Reed: I can already imagine having a row with my partner about sort of using half of that water on a shower that I didn't need or whatever. You know what I mean?

25:39Patrick Baker: Yeah, this is not water for showering, Pat. This is water for drinking. Sure. Yeah.

25:42David Reed: OK. It's all well and good going and buying all this stuff and filling up our cupboards. But I guess what we really want to know is when the next crisis hits, is the government, is the UK really prepared? So in part two, I'm going to speak to the government security minister, Dan Jarvis, to ask him that question.

26:05David Reed: Welcome back to Westminster Insider. Next up is my interview with the government's security minister, Dan Jarvis. And I was joined by Politico's political editor, Dan Bloom. So here we are in the National Situation Centre in the heart of Whitehall. We've just heard we're the first podcast to ever be given an interview in here, which is great news. Dan, can we just describe to our listeners who perhaps aren't watching on YouTube what they could potentially see in this room? Yeah, we're not allowed to show you anything that is right of this pillar that I'm standing next to. But basically, we're in 70 Whitehall.

26:36David Reed: It's the cabinet office building that's connected to Downing Street. And we've walked past the brass plaque that says State of Vigilance Heightened. We've walked past the Movember Bake Sale and Henry VIII's Tudor Tennis Court. Amazing. And we're now in actually quite a small kind of office room with a lot of tech kind of hidden away that we're not allowed to talk about. and kind of maps on the wall that we're not allowed to talk about either. In fact, on the screens that we're also not allowed to show you, they've put up a really anodyne map of the traffic network that you could get anywhere pretty much via Google, probably because we are standing here.

27:13David Reed: There are banks of desks here with very plain screensavers where data analysts would sit during a national emergency and kind of feed the response. and there's a conference room over there with the thickest glass door I have ever seen. So clearly it's soundproof, but you can still see who's in there. Hey Dan, how are you? How are you doing? Hello, Patrick. I'm going to move off our mark. So great to be joined by the Minister of State for Security, Dan Jarvis. Thank you for being on Westminster Insider. My pleasure. First question, we're obviously in the National Situation Centre right now. When people at home having stockpiled would be opening their bottles of water or tinned food in a crisis, what would be happening in this room and where would you be?

27:55Patrick Baker: Well, I would probably be not very far away from here. So this essentially would be a nerve centre where we're fusing together different data sets to inform judgments that ministers will make in another part of the building. So the people who work here do really important work. They provide valuable time-sensitive information and that enables my ministerial colleagues, maybe the Prime Minister, whoever it might be, and myself to make decisions depending on the circumstances that we find ourselves in.

28:24David Reed: Tell us a little bit about your personal stockpiling. What have you got at home to survive 72 hours?

28:30Patrick Baker: It may not come as a huge surprise to you to know that I am quite well prepared. Maybe it's as a consequence of my previous time in the army, although I think the roots of my desire to be prepared go back much longer than that. So I was a Boy Scout. The motto of the scouting movement is be prepared. So I think it is within my DNA to make sure that I am as prepared as I possibly can be.

28:56David Reed: Do you have something special for yourself as well? So our colleague Sasha has some saucisson, you know, ready to, that's the treat if it really gets bad.

29:03Patrick Baker: I think there's nothing wrong with having a treat. And you'll be aware that some of my colleagues have let us know what their particular treats were. And that's helpful in a way, because those are the kind of conversations that the public are having in the supermarkets or wherever they are about the Be Ready campaign. So I think it's a good and helpful thing that people are having a lighthearted conversation about it. But I'm really pleased at the extent to which the public has engaged with the campaign. The latest figures show that there is very high levels of awareness of it. So I think that's a good thing.

29:33Patrick Baker: And I'm really pleased with the way it's going.

29:34David Reed: go on, what's yours? What's your treat? PM has his Twiglets.

29:40Patrick Baker: Well, I don't have anything at the moment. Perhaps I should sort of take this away as something that I need to include in the kind of treat box. But I've got the water, I've got the approachable food, and I've got the torch, and I've got the radio.

29:52David Reed: I noticed you obviously didn't mention any Sauvignon Blanc. And the serious point to that, I suppose, is do you worry that perhaps some of the messaging from some of your cabinet minister colleagues has been perhaps trivialising what is obviously supposed to be quite a serious campaign?

30:07Patrick Baker: So as you will understand, as a security minister, there is lots of things that I worry about at any one time. That isn't one of them. I think it's quite helpful in terms of promoting the conversation. I think it's quite helpful in terms of focusing people's minds about what they would do in their own households. And that's the essence of this campaign. So I'm entirely relaxed that people are having a conversation about serving en blanc or whatever it might be. My job, though, is to make sure that we've got that resilience across our nation. And that local household preparedness is a really important part of that.

30:42David Reed: There was a House of Lords report from the Resilience Committee, which I'm sure you've seen this week. And one of the things it pointed to was that there is a lack of perhaps candor from the government about really laying out what the risks are. And I suppose if people are wondering, is there something that we don't know in government, if the public are concerned about that? Is that because the government hasn't actually been clear enough about what the risks are to the country right now?

31:04Patrick Baker: I don't accept the premise around transparency. We've published the National Risk Register, which is a long list of all the different risks that we deal with in government. If you look at the things that I've said in Parliament on the record, the conversations that we're having nationally about the nature of the world that we're living in, I think there is a lot of conversation about the different threats that we face. Fundamentally though in the first instance, Be Ready is about the everyday emergencies that people are experiencing in their everyday lives. We are approaching winter, we've already had some quite challenging conditions as we had throughout the course of the summer with the wildfires as well.

31:46Patrick Baker: So in the first instance I think it is really helpful to be focusing people's minds at a local level on the simple steps that they can take in their households to prepare themselves for everyday emergencies like extreme weather, like wildfires, like flooding. That's the purpose of the campaign at this particular moment.

32:03David Reed: And the report mentioned catastrophic risks, which is obviously quite punchy language. Would you use language like that at the moment?

32:10Patrick Baker: Well, I think the National Risk Register is a good place to go to, to look at the different risks that we face. But ultimately, it's our job in government to make sure that as a country, we are as resilient as possible and that we are as best prepared to face the risks, the threats, the challenges that undoubtedly we face. The world is a dangerous place. You know, I've been dealing with matters relating to national security for a long time and there are a range of different threats that we face. It's the job of government to make sure that we are best prepared to guard against those risks and those threats.

32:40David Reed: It's a conundrum, isn't it? Because there's so much that you can't tell us and therefore is the public taking it seriously enough because they don't know the full extent of the risks, right? So we've got undersea cables, cyber attacks, fridges being switched off, natural disasters, like you say. Which of those things kind of keeps you awake at night? What do you as a human being, as Dan Jarvis, have a sort of fear about?

33:06Patrick Baker: Lots of things keep me awake at night. That is the kind of the nature of the role. And it's not a role for the faint hearted. There is a breadth of risk and threat that we face as a nation, but we face those alongside our allies. I've just recently returned from Norway, where I was talking with Scandinavian partners about the work that they do to ensure that they are as resilient as possible. And I think there's quite a lot that we can learn from them and from other partners in Europe. In truth, there is a bit of catch up that we're playing here in the United Kingdom. And there is a bit of balance to be struck, because we absolutely don't want to alarm the public.

33:43Patrick Baker: But we do want the public to be alert, we want the public to be prepared and we want our society to be resilient. The polling shows that there is an overwhelming desire from the public to be receiving the kind of information that we've put out through the Be Ready campaign. The public expect government to make sure that collectively we are resilient and that we are prepared. And the Be Ready campaign is an important step in that endeavour.

34:08David Reed: Is Westminster taking it seriously enough though? Because you're standing here very serious but a lot of it you know we've been cracking jokes your colleagues have cracked jokes like we said.

34:17Patrick Baker: I think when I talk to colleagues in parliament both in the commons and in the lords they are genuinely interested to know what we're doing as a nation to be as resilient and as prepared as we possibly can. You know people look to Norway to Sweden to Finland to the Dutch and they see the important work that they're doing so I think there is a general sense of the importance of this work. I hope that it's not remotely political you know this is something that we want to work collaboratively across different political parties on. But I also want to be ambitious. I want the United Kingdom to be the most resilient nation that it can possibly be.

34:52Patrick Baker: We've taken a number of steps recently that previous governments weren't prepared or able to do. There's more to do, but we're making good progress.

35:00David Reed: One thing that people have told us repeatedly as we've been making this podcast is that actually there should be a separate cabinet role for resilience. You've obviously got a lot on. Is that something you would actually welcome?

35:12Patrick Baker: Well, ultimately, these are judgments for the Prime Minister, not for me. But I hope people get a sense of how seriously I take matters relating to resilience. It's an important part of my portfolio here in the Cabinet Office. But I also think it makes good sense to configure in the way that we have, with the Security Minister also being in the Home Office and in the Cabinet Office, drawing together that response from government. And if you look at the work that we've been doing recently, the Home Defence Programme, the investment in pandemic preparedness, I think people will see that this is a government who takes this seriously and is working to ensure that as a nation we are as resilient as we possibly can be.

35:50David Reed: I've got two more questions for you, then we'll let you go. The first one is we have picked up some concern in Whitehall that there isn't enough of a whole of government approach about this, given what you've just been saying. Would you share that?

36:00Patrick Baker: I wouldn't share that, no, not least if you look at the work that we're doing through the Home Defence Programme that draws together all of the different government departments, all of whom are working collaboratively to update the departmental crisis books, the kind of war books as we sometimes refer to them. So we absolutely do need that whole of government response. We need a wider societal resilience embedded in communities right around the country. It's my job to deliver that with partners and that's what we're going to do.

36:27David Reed: Lastly, Pat might have one newsy one, but a birdie told me once that you keep chickens at home. You still do that and have you got eggs as your secret supply?

36:39Patrick Baker: I've always found it incredibly relaxing to keep chickens, not least when you have a reasonably busy and demanding job. There's something very peaceful about them. So it's something that I've enjoyed doing, that my kids have enjoyed doing for a number of years, but it's not a recent thing. It's something that I've done for a long time and hopefully will continue to do in the future.

36:59David Reed: How many chickens? A never dwindling number, sadly. Very last question, if I could. We've been hearing lots of outages in America, Microsoft outage and planes grounded. Do you sort of watch the news through your fingers at times? I mean, and do you think that perhaps those threats could be coming here very soon?

37:18Patrick Baker: I think it's important that the public should be reassured that we have got some extraordinarily dedicated professionals working across national security to keep the public safe, who work around the clock to make sure that we are as resilient as possible. When things happen in the way that you've described, we make sure that our response is as quick and proportionate as it possibly can be. But we shouldn't shy away from the fact that the world is a difficult and dangerous place and is our job to make sure that we are best prepared to respond to a range of different threats and challenges that we face.

37:50David Reed: We're honoured to be the first podcast ever allowed into the National Situation Centre. So thank you so much for having us, Dan.

37:56Patrick Baker: You're very welcome. Thank you.

38:03David Reed: Right, I'm now safely back in the studio with Sasha, of course, and Dan Bloom is here as well. So that was Dan Jarvis and he's still got his chickens. Sasha, have you got any chickens?

38:13Patrick Baker: I don't have any chickens. I would love some chickens, to be honest. I think they're pretty cute. I liked what he was saying about how it's quite peaceful. Sounds quite useful.

38:21David Reed: Dan, have you... I've got a cat, so it's probably best that I don't have any chickens because I wouldn't have them for long. Okay. And obviously everyone that's coming on this podcast is telling us about what they've stockpiled, what they've got. Have you got anything in the cupboards that we should know about? It's actually my stockpile is really bad at the moment. I have this same problem in COVID in 2020 when I was like a just-in-time kind of guy and I had really nothing. I had like a few meals in the freezer and that's it. The weirdest stockpile I ever did was a 16 kilogram bag of flour under my bed in 2020.

38:54David Reed: Do you remember the great flour shortage of 2020 when all the people who ended up working from home started making their own bread? Sour day. Yeah, bored out of their skulls.

39:04Patrick Baker: I will note Dan's never brought bread into the office.

39:06David Reed: Well, I stopped because I gained a stone. Well, Dan Jarvis there was interesting, wasn't he? I mean, he doesn't particularly go off message. And we felt that perhaps there was something significant in the fact that the government had put up Dan Jarvis, one of their trusted communicators when it comes to national security. Yeah, I think all credit to Dan Jarvis. You will have heard there that he is very careful with his messaging. And perhaps that is why he is the minister of resilience and telling everyone not to panic, but also please to stockpile things in your house. and the interesting thing there for me is behind the scenes here there is you know a lot of nervousness that the messaging is coming across the right way that it's not being treated in a trivial way and there was definitely some discomfort in government not just about you know for example Angela Rayner joking about having Sauvignon Blanc in her stockpile but the ownership of the message as well you know should it be owned by the Ministry of Defence or indeed the Cabinet office, which is where we were, which is where Dan Jarvis is, and where this message is meant to be owned.

40:11David Reed: So there's a lot of sensitivity around that. And I thought it was interesting that Dan Jarvis went bent over backwards to say, don't worry, I'm not annoyed at you, Angela. He didn't say Angela, but you get the idea. All of these sort of jokey comments are helpful because they get the message out there. And that is true to a certain extent, but they're just trying to walk this really fine line. Yeah. And one thing that really also stood out for me was when we asked Dan Jarvis about the fact that this campaign needs to be a whole of government approach. And he gave quite an on message response to that saying, yes, of course, you know, we need to be joined up and all the rest of it.

40:47David Reed: But we have been hearing some concerns from people in Whitehall that actually, you know, this isn't a joined up government messaging campaign at the moment, and it really needs to be if it's going to really succeed. It was interesting that that report called for a cabinet minister for resilience, where, you know, Dan Jarvis's job is like, what he was talking to us about and about 10 other things, all of which are critical to the security of the country. So there's this argument that you need someone going out there and beating the drum the whole time. But I mean, I don't know. I kind of feel like the public doesn't really give a crap whether there is a whole of government messaging.

41:23David Reed: The public either hears the messaging or doesn't. And if the public is hearing the messaging, that's great for the government. If the public isn't, that's not great for the government. And ultimately, it doesn't really matter what systems are behind that for me. And it might take a while, but it does feel as if culturally, psychologically, people are slowly shifting their mindsets to be more aligned with Finland and other countries that have been on a war footing for a long time. So I remember, it was interesting that Dan Jarvis said, we're playing catch up a little bit with these Nordic countries.

41:54David Reed: The thing about the Nordics is they're close to that sort of very contested Arctic region where Russia is kind of making movements towards that. And of course, they're closer to Russia. And I remember going with Yvette Cooper, who was foreign secretary at the time, to a visit to one of our big bases in Norway, where British troops, the number of them has increased in recent years, and it's still increasing. They're preparing for how to fight in the Arctic. And she was standing there and her counterpart, Espen Barthade, I hope I've pronounced that right, was sort of literally pointing at a map and saying, you know, if Russia comes for us, this is the bit of water that they'll come through and this is how they'll get us.

42:35David Reed: And that just instantly made everything seem much more real than it does for us, even though we're an island nation. And, you know, in theory, we could be quite vulnerable.

42:44Patrick Baker: Pat, you've now spent a couple of weeks not only buying a stockpile, but talking to people about stockpiling. Do you have a sense now of why exactly Westminster wants us to do this?

42:54David Reed: I think Westminster really wants us to engage with this. But I would say that from the conversations that I've had with people, the one thing that really came through was this sense of complacency that Westminster has. And I don't mean that in the sense of you've got people sitting around going, the threat from Russia isn't important, or the threat of cyber attacks isn't important. There are lots of people saying that it is, lots of politicians, ministers who are worried about this kind of thing. But I think the system as a whole, whether that's Whitehall, civil servants, they're so focused on other domestic priorities.

43:26David Reed: We've got a new prime Minister who wants to bring an agenda of optimism, hope and change. They're so focused on that, that actually to galvanise the whole government across departments to be on a war footing in the same way that countries like Finland or Estonia are, I think it's going to take more than just a campaign. It's going to take more than some government comms. And so I think there is this residual complacency, and we see it all the time in Westminster, but actually you kind of can't escape the feeling that it's going to take a big external shock, perhaps like COVID, something quite dramatic to really focus minds in Westminster and Whitehall on the problems that could be stored up ahead for us.

44:08Patrick Baker: So you think we kind of need a bit of a shock, to be honest, both the civil service need a shock and the public need a shock?

44:14David Reed: I think that's right. And I think the government be ready campaign deserves some credit, I think. Personally, I think the fact that we're all talking about it, that it's entered the national consciousness is part of the plan. And that is, I think, you know, everyone I spoke to, regardless of their political persuasion, was full of praise for the government in doing that. And they haven't panicked people, there haven't been shortages on the shelves, really, as far as we've seen. But at the same time, I think, how do you encourage that step change in thinking that cultural shift that we need to see?

44:49David Reed: And I think that remains a bit of an open question. And I think it may well be that there needs to be some kind of dramatic external shock for people to really get the message.

45:02David Reed: Aside from all that doom and gloom, it's now time for the odd cast, my favourite bit of the week. This, Dan, to spring this on you, is where Sasha and I each choose a story from the news that caught our attention for being profoundly weird. We kind of pitch it to you in three words, and then you have to choose which one you want to hear more about so this week we have a doomsday theme

45:23Patrick Baker: Sasha please take it away kamikaze drone launcher intriguing mine is I just like saying the word

45:31David Reed: kamikaze to be honest it's a great word mine is Boeing garden bunker right well I'm biased because I've seen the story about the kamikaze drone launcher so I want to know about the Boeing

45:44Patrick Baker: garden aren't they fun though it looks like there's like things in the tennis no no no seriously on you know on a tennis court where the tennis balls come out it's just like drones spitting out of a machine like that sorry i have well over your three-word sell yeah fun is one word for it

45:58David Reed: um no this was a great story i saw where basically a man in the midlands um as is their want perhaps in that part of the world he saw a a hull or a you know the the shell of a boeing 747 for sale on eBay or something like that, I think, and basically decided to buy it and put it in his garden to create a kind of underground bunker. And apparently his wife was like, we don't need that in the garden. And it is absolutely massive. And I assumed this was perhaps for like an end of the world style nuclear bunker, but apparently he just wants to have a pool table down there and somewhere to chill out.

46:35David Reed: That is a rusty bunker. And aren't the kind of frames of aircraft famously actually quite thin? so that it can, you know, fly. Yeah, and this is something that used to take people to Tenerife apparently in 2013. So it's nice to think next time you're in an airplane, you could be sitting in someone's future living room. Okay, that's all for this week. Thank you so much for joining us. Please do remember to check out all of our bonus content on YouTube. My colleague Emilio Casalicchio joined Sasha to talk about the latest response to the welfare review that was going on in Parliament this week and all the rows and dissent that could be brewing around that.

47:13David Reed: Thank you to our guests from this week, David Reid, Alistair Carmichael, Baroness Tracy Paul, Dan Jarvis, and of course, Dan Bloom here in the studio. Westminster Insider is produced by John Rogers, and we will see you next time.

48:10David Reed: We'll be right back. with her right there.

From the publisher

A ‘Black Sky event’ — a major blackout that could knock out communications, disrupt food supplies and bring everyday life to a standstill — is among the scenarios emergency planners worry about.

Now the government's new ‘Be Ready’ campaign is urging Britons to stockpile food, water and other essentials.

But why are politicians suddenly so keen for us to prepare for the worst?

This week, host Patrick Baker meets the MPs who think the government isn't going far enough.

He hits the supermarket with Conservative Shadow Minister for Defence, Security and Resilience David Reed to put together a 72-hour emergency kit — and find out what threats have him worried.

Liberal Democrat MP and Shetland islander Alistair Carmichael, Chair of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee, explains what the rest of Britain can learn from life on a remote island, where power cuts and disrupted supplies are familiar hazards.

Baroness Tracey Paul discusses a new House of Lords report warning of ‘potentially catastrophic risks’ and accusing the Government of complacency.

And, in a podcast first, Patrick gets rare access to the Government's National Situation Centre inside the Cabinet Office. There, alongside POLITICO's Dan Bloom, the minister responsible for resilience Dan Jarvis explains why Britain needs to learn from its Nordic neighbours — and why he's not bothered by Cabinet ministers joking about stockpiling sauvignon blanc.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Westminster Insider

All episodes