

Britain’s “earned settlement” and Labour Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood’s reforms to indefinite leave to remain (ILR), debating who the UK wants long-term, how policy balances “keeping people out” vs attracting workers, and why public perceptions (e.g., small boats) don’t match actual migration patterns.
Sam Blewett, Politico UK political correspondent; Madeleine Sumption, deputy chair of the Migration Advisory Committee and director of the Migration Observatory (Oxford University), author of What is Migration Policy for?; Sojan Joseph, Labour MP for Ashford in Kent, former NHS nurse who moved to the UK in 2001.
ILR criteria reward English-speaking, higher-earning, low-benefit claimants; faster settlement for “highest talent” (e.g., after three years) is expected to follow Migration Advisory Committee advice; voters prefer skilled, English-speaking, “warm” refugees (women/children) and often dislike bankers; economists focus on fiscal contribution and employment, not “shortages.”
COVID-era short-term visas for HGV drivers and turkey-killers; historical “suspicious description” French refugees; surveys where “applying for citizenship” changes perceived economic impact; care workers’ low pay and retention risks; “unicorn immigrant” described as a nurse/care worker speaking perfect English, earning above a threshold, and not claiming benefits.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the ongoing immigration policy issues and recent reforms.
“Like many who came before her, Mahmood was told it wasn't enough.”
Exploration of what characteristics define an ideal immigrant in the UK.
“So this week on Westminster Insider, I'll find out who is Britain's perfect immigrant.”
A look back at the history of UK immigration policies and their evolution.
“way, which maybe isn't entirely working to everyone's liking.”
Analysis of the current challenges and contradictions in UK's immigration system.
“tech bros, your AI geniuses and things like that.”
Insights into how public opinion shapes views on different types of immigrants.
“because they basically really clearly lay out exactly who we want in the country.”
Discussion on the characteristics and expectations of refugees from the public's perspective.
“You know, how much is it a question of, well, we have a worker shortage in this particular industry.”
Exploration of the characteristics and perceptions of the ideal immigrant in the UK.
“People want to be helping the most vulnerable.”
Labour MP Sojan Joseph shares his personal experience of immigrating to the UK.
“I'm here with Sojan Joseph, the Labour MP for Ashford in Kent.”
Discussion about the policies affecting immigrants, focusing on contributions and benefits.
“they took me to the bank, opened the bank account, and it was completely, you know, a different feeling to what you hear in the news these days.”
Analysis of how voters view immigrants, including their preferences and contradictions.
“that you need to be someone who is contributing.”
Exploring the complex and often contradictory opinions surrounding immigration in the UK.
“I've been kind of going through, you know, exactly what voters want, because we kind of know what the Home Office wants of immigrants.”
Explore how public perception shapes the narrative around immigrants in the UK.
“but they don't want bankers and they really love NHS workers.”
Discussion of the characteristics that define the 'perfect' immigrant according to various stakeholders.
“That's not something that many nurses achieve.”
How political narratives and public sentiment influence immigration policy in the UK.
“the eyes of the british public they like this idealized version of themselves like as you just described about Sgt.”
An examination of the complexities surrounding asylum seekers and public perceptions of them.
“that they're not being completely tough on immigration is still, I think, because it's such a politically charged issue in the UK, kind of nervous political territory for some people, within the Labour Party.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Westminster Insider, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:16Hello and welcome to Westminster Insider. I'm Sascha O'Sullivan. Go on, name a single more controversial policy than immigration. For decades, we've barely stopped arguing about who gets to come to the UK, who gets to stay here and how they arrive here. Last week, Shibana Mahmood, the Home Secretary, unveiled her much-awaited reforms to indefinite leave to remain. Mr Speaker, today the government publishes a policy called earned settlement. Like many who came before her, Mahmood was told it wasn't enough. Labour's Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, has given up on her promise to stop low-paid migrants settling permanently in Britain after just five years.
1:03What and who we want from our immigration system has changed countless times over the years. Mahmood's plans are just the latest twist in a long-running tale of politicians promising to reduce overall immigration numbers, struggling to do so because of the acute economic trade-offs, and then finding it impossible to explain those trade-offs to the country. Mahmood is raising the bar for retaining indefinite leave to remain in the hope she can ensure the people who come here and stay here will truly contribute to the country. The period someone must live in this country before they settle is determined by the contribution they have made.
1:38But does her wish list of who she wants coming to the country align with who voters want and who economists say we need? People are confused. When you see somebody on the street, they think, oh, this person may have arrived on a boat. But this person was brought in by our country to work here. The perfect refugee is someone who's very vulnerable now, but after arriving in the UK is suddenly not going to be vulnerable anymore and is going to launch themselves into the labour market and do really well. So this week on Westminster Insider, I'll find out who is Britain's perfect immigrant.
2:21So today I have with me Sam Blewett, who is Politico's UK political correspondent. Hi, Sam. Pleasure to be here. And of course, I've got Patrick Baker, my trusty co-host. Now, Sam, how much of the immigration policy is designed to keep people out as well as say what kind of person we want here? Yeah, I think it's a huge balance between those two things, right? The Home Office, at least, wants to keep out those who have criminal records that they maybe have claimed benefits in the past. But totally, now we have moved largely to outside the EU system of immigration. It's now almost like this planned economy where we need committees to come up with to identify where the shortages are and then to try and issue short-term visas and then attract those workers over here.
3:08So yeah, that kind of weird planned economy way, which maybe isn't entirely working to everyone's liking. And I actually did a bit of fun history research on the immigration system. It actually dates back to the French Revolution. Basically, there were a bunch of French refugees trying to come to the UK and there was an undersecretary in the Foreign Office who said, The majority of these people are of suspicious description and are very likely either to do mischief of their own accord or to be fit tools of those who may be desirous of creating confusion. So basically, you know, we don't want anyone who's creating confusion or encouraging confusion.
3:44We don't want the mischievous French, basically. That's what that's saying. It wasn't until the kind of 1900s when eventually it was changed to keep out undesirable immigrants, including anyone who was a lunatic or an idiot. Politically correct terms, those? Over the years, we've kind of incentivized and disincentivized different types of people from coming to the UK. How much has that changed? Yeah, I think if you look back into recent political history, we've seen a real kind of whack-a-mole approach. So, for example, if you remember during, just as we were kind of in the middle of the pandemic, we suddenly needed a whole load of lorry drivers.
4:19So we issued short-term visas for HGV drivers. We needed people to come and kill turkeys for Christmas. And these, again, were like short term visas for people that we needed really a moment's notice. And obviously, there wasn't a huge amount of take up. We weren't promising that much in exchange. Then on the other side, you've got people who we want who are like millionaires. We've got an investor scheme visa that was launched in 2020. We've got schemes that try and entice people here based on their talent and their skills. So it seems as if we're still in this kind of quite muddled mentality when it comes to immigrants.
4:55We don't quite know who it is we're really looking for. Yeah. And the immigration system is really designed not just to say who we want here, but how long we want them here. Sam, Shabana's changes to indefinite leave to remain, what did they tell us about who we want living here long term? Yeah, I mean, looking at the criteria, I think to an extent, the Home Office wants an idealised version of ourselves, right? These migrants would speak English to a decent level, more or less like ourselves. They would be high earners, quite high rollers in some instances, particularly for those who would get settlement even quicker.
5:31And maybe they would work in desirable, fancy jobs or healthcare sector. So they are the sort of do-gooders of society. I think that's lots of things that we might aspire to. But also, the idea is putting quite high burden on these people. So they can't commit any kind of crime. It used to be like, you could get away with a little bit. And you can't claim benefits whatsoever if you're going to get a settlement. So I don't know. I think that's quite a criteria which would be hard for a lot of Brits to abide by themselves. And it's so interesting because on one hand, you've got care workers who are some of the lowest paid workers in the UK.
6:06And then you've got these people right at the top that we want to be moving here. So for example, your kind of tech bros, your AI geniuses and things like that. Yeah, right. And I think that's a confusing picture because I don't know how what voters clearly their hearts are with the healthcare workers, maybe less so with the bankers, right? And actually, I think quite interestingly, as part of Shabana's reforms, those who make a considered the highest talent group can settle within after three years, right? And I think we hear that an important Migration Advisory Committee report is coming on Tuesday, right?
6:41Yeah, that's right. So we're expecting the Migration Advisory committee who are an independent body but advise the Home Office to put out their recommendations next Tuesday on exactly who should have that kind of faster route to indefinite leave to remain. So it'll be three years instead of five. And those are those top talented people who maybe aren't the three of us, but maybe it could be. Now, I wanted to find out, I wanted to bring together the kind of Venn diagrams of what we want from immigration, what the Home Office wants, which Sam has just told us, what voters want, which we've kind of started to allude to, and what economists want, which is maybe those super clever tech people.
7:21I spoke to Madeleine Sumption, who's deputy chair of the Migration Advisory Committee, director of the Migration Observatory at Oxford University, and literally wrote a book on what we want from immigrants. It's called, What is Migration Policy for? In other words, she's the perfect person to answer the question of who is Britain's perfect immigrant.
7:45The Home Office ILR reforms are really interesting because they basically really clearly lay out exactly who we want in the country. Yeah, that's right. So the basic idea of this reform is you've got some people who will be on a faster path towards permanent status. Some people will be on a slower path. So I think that's a very helpful way of looking at the list. And basically on the one side, on the group of people that the government wants to reward in its policies, effectively people who are working and if they're working, particularly people with higher earnings. Now, there is then an exception for people who have low earnings because they're working in the public sector.
8:30So then there's teachers, for example, nurses, care workers, and also people with what the home of schools are British connections. So most obviously that would be people who are married to a British citizen. So those are the groups of people who would sort of get positive points, as it were, in the settlement policy. And there's also the requirement that you have to be not on benefits for five years. So it's basically saying we don't want people who come to the country, we want people who contribute to the country, not take from it. Yes, absolutely. So that's another big one. And there's a little bit of tension sometimes because some of the groups of people who are more likely to receive benefits in the future would be those with low earnings.
9:11But that includes some of the public sector workers. And especially if they have children, many of them could actually be entitled to quite a lot in the way of in-work benefits, even if they're still working. But then on the other hand, you've got the sort of the contribution to this public services, people really value care workers. And so that was a sort of debate. And it seems like in the final policy, it was the contribution side won out over the low earnings and likely future benefits received. You know, how much is it a question of, well, we have a worker shortage in this particular industry.
9:43And so we need to have an exception for care workers? Well, it's so it's very tricky. I try to avoid using the word need in immigration policy because there aren't really they're usually not needs right we have wants we you know we can think about the impact and it's um i think needs sort of suggest there's a kind of mathematical um you know reality to it and there's the government has no choice the government does have a choice it's just the different choices are difficult right and so um in the case of care workers this is a largely publicly funded industry and um it's not funded very well and so the paying conditions are miserable.
10:22And that's one reason it's been difficult to attract British people into the industry. It's a reason that once care workers get permanent status, it might be difficult to retain them in the industry because they will leave for the same reason that the British people do. What do voters want? You know, when you look at the polling and talk to people, what do they say? This kind of immigrant I'm okay with and this kind of person I'm not quite sure about? Yeah, so there's quite a lot of research on this. And broadly speaking, there are some characteristics that tend to come out again and again as more favourable.
10:55So poll respondents would prioritise people, for example, who are highly skilled, people who speak English, sometimes certain nationalities, people who come from majority white countries, for example, people often, poll respondents will often prefer women and children. That's especially, we see that quite clearly when it comes to refugees and people who are not Muslim. They also like, I think that they put a fair amount of emphasis on the sort of social and cultural side of things and not just the economic side. So for example, people like the idea that someone might be applying for citizenship and sort of becoming part of society.
11:37And how do voters kind of generally feel about the kind of earnings question because you know they they don't want people who who use the state they want people who's going to contribute to the country but for example they really don't want bankers in the country so they want high earners but not so high they work in the city yeah so there is in general if you ask you know would you prefer skilled migration or less skilled migration people will say skilled migration but then actually a lot of if you ask about specific occupations you would you like to see more or fewer of this this group or that group admitted, it's not necessarily the high paid ones that qualify.
12:15So you will then get more of a preference for, for example, nurses and care workers who don't tend to earn a lot. Bankers, it was interesting, my colleagues did a survey a couple of years ago and asked about occupations. And I wonder whether the word bankers was putting people off because it has these associations of, you know, bankers bonuses and all of that stuff, sort of greedy fat cats, etc, etc. So I thought, well, maybe this is, maybe this is good. Let's not call them bankers, right? the you know the office of national statistics would call them financial analysts so we'll call them that so we anyway no one was fooled they still they didn't want them um so um so yes and i think there's an interesting dynamic here which is that people um i think poll respondents struggle to disentangle the economic impact of a person coming in for a particular job and whether they think that they're a nice person and so we see these interesting results for example there was this great survey where people asked about the hypothetical Nigerian building contractor who was coming to the UK.
13:12And they asked you, how likely is it this person has a positive economic impact? And they were much more likely to say that they thought he had a positive economic impact if they were also told that he was applying for British citizenship, which is actually completely irrelevant, his economic impact. I mean, you know, maybe some small things at the margin. But I think so when people feel warmly towards a person, they're more likely to believe that they have an economic impact or positive economic impact, even if actually, you know, economists would not necessarily say that was the case. And what about the kind of question of refugees?
13:44Because I think that's an interesting one. And actually, you know, a lot of the time when people think about who a migrant is, they actually think of asylum seekers rather than people who are coming over on international student visas or to work in the city or things like that. What kind of refugee do ordinary people want? People want to be helping the most vulnerable. So we get this a lot in the debate about small boats, for example, that you've got these young, fit men getting onto boats, when actually the UK could be welcoming people, women, for example, who were just less willing or less able to make that dangerous journey.
14:20But once people arrive, they also want refugees to be able to support themselves and to be reasonably self-sufficient, even if they're never going to be massively high earners. And so we have a tension between those things, because actually one of the groups that do worst in the labor market is female refugees. We see really, really low employment rates, for example. And if people are working, they tend to be on very low earnings, whereas actually people who come, the men who come on small boats, they don't do brilliantly in the labor market, but they do less badly. And so I think you've got this tension where people, the perfect refugee is someone who's very vulnerable now, but is going to, you know, after arriving in the UK is suddenly not going to be vulnerable anymore and is going to sort of launch themselves into the labor market and do really well.
15:09So there's this incredibly narrow work as a banker. Yes, certainly not work as a banker. So there's a sort of narrow intersection. There's an academic who talks about the idea of promising victimhood, right? So they're victims now, but they have promise for the future of sort of integrating and supporting themselves. And it's interesting because I've been basically thinking about this episode and I've been trying to put a Venn diagram in my head of like who is the perfect immigrant. And on the one side, you've got the Home Office and they want people who speak English, who are highly paid or who work in, you know, public services and maybe have some kind of British connection.
15:46Like that's the kind of standard of who the Home Office wants. Right. And then on the other side, I think the Vosys question really confuses it because you've got they want, I guess, ideally they would want a highly paid lorry driver who is a woman. who doesn't claim benefits, speaks perfect English, and maybe came from a majority white country? Would that square? Yeah. I mean, the lorry drivers is interesting because these things kind of come and go as well. I think in COVID there was a lot of focus around lorry drivers. I would be interested, you know, if you did a more recent survey, I wonder whether that would still be the case.
16:28I mean, I think the... So maybe a highly paid nurse. Probably nurses. I mean, I think doctors and nurses also tend to come up pretty high. I think nurses, you know, in terms of like who would maximize most of those, you know, most of those characteristics that in polls people tend to favor, you know, sort of Spanish nurse might might tickle the boxes. But yes, it's very it's quite dependent on exactly how people ask these questions. And to swap to the kind of less emotional side of it, which is what economists want from immigration, you know, they're probably just looking at it maybe from a perspective of like a pure perspective of who contributes most to the economy.
17:09Did they just pretty much want rich, skilled people? More or less. Yeah. So I think from an economic perspective, certainly if you look at public finances, it's very clear you get really stark differences. Basically, the more likely someone is to be employed and the higher their earnings, the more they will contribute to public finances over time. If people have lower earnings, then from an economic perspective, there may be still a fair amount of benefit if the visa is temporary. and so people from an economic perspective people with with fewer rights people on temporary visa who don't have access to any welfare benefits for example would have more a more positive fiscal impact obviously this can kind of take you to an extreme right you get to like you know the united arab emirates where the large majority of the population are migrants with very few rights not many people would look at that society in the uk and be like a great that's what the uk should should be like.
18:09And what about the kind of worker shortages question in economist views? You know, it's something that we talk about. We talked about it with the seasonal workers. We talked about it with care. It comes up all the time of, you know, it's actually very helpful having people move to the country and kind of fill these gaps, lorry drivers during the pandemic. Is that something that economists actually like? A lot of them don't. I think, yeah, the shortage is really interesting because I think politically it's a really compelling pitch right we have this idea that there are people that we need if you look at it sort of in the data it's actually very difficult even to work out where the shortages are by the time if you do identify a shortage you know some of them may have disappeared by the time the immigration system cranks into action in order to admit people the data are never that good anyway and and there isn't I think that the key thing is that there's no optimal number we can't work out what the deficit is you know what does the right number of raspberries for the UK to produce?
19:08I don't know. Right. And so you, you know, the economists tend not to have a view about how big a particular sector should be. And so it's basically impossible to calculate, well, we need X number of workers in order to produce how many tons of raspberries. You can't build too much of your immigration policy around that before things start to fall apart. And if we were to kind of pull together everything that we've talked about from the kind of home office, home office perspective, voters perspective, economist who's the kind of unicorn perfect immigrant for UK it is probably a nurse um a sort of nice female um uh contributing to to public services I would imagine yeah would tend to be one of the ones that come out um top in those sort of you know survey experiments that a nurse who owns earns over 50k and doesn't ever claim benefits um yeah I guess if you're a very senior nurse.
20:02I mean, the doctors also do pretty well in some of those surveys in the public's imagination. Madeline helped us put together a kind of perfect immigrant. So I wanted to find one who worked in Westminster. Yeah, who is the perfect migrant? I think maybe I am a perfect one. After the break, Labour MP Sojan Joseph will talk me through how politicians can possibly square all of the circles of what people want from immigration. Stay with us.
20:46Welcome back. I'm here with Sojan Joseph, the Labour MP for Ashford in Kent. Sojan, can you tell me about when you moved to the UK? I moved to UK in the year 2001. So it will be 25 years this month. It was hard. I was in my mid-20s when I moved. Unmarried, no girlfriend. So leaving parents behind, siblings behind. In November, dark winter, coming from Kerala, south of India, which is always sunny place, coming to dark, arrived in Heathrow around four o 'clock in the afternoon. And my employer came and picked me up, drove me to Dorset, Dorchester, that's where the work was, my accommodation was.
21:42So driving through narrow country lines in dark was a bit scary. Oh yeah, I can imagine. And that was at a time when there was lots of immigration into the UK. Did you feel welcome when you arrived? I did actually. So immigration was not this level, what we're experiencing these days in early 2000. And you were coming with a proper job. You have your accommodation all being agreed before you arrive. As I said, my employer picked me up from the airport. Nice car. So in the morning, when I met with all the rest of the team, they took me to the bank, opened the bank account, and it was completely, you know, a different feeling to what you hear in the news these days.
22:37That sounds like, honestly, an incredibly nice experience of moving to the UK. I mean, when I moved here, I think I got on the Piccadilly line and that was a bit of a shock. Not like Australia. Yeah. So your first job was in the care sector? Yes, I was recruited. I was brought in. I always say I never came here. I was brought in to work as a nurse here. So I only worked in the health profession in the last 24 years until I got elected as an MP. That's the only job I did, and I started working the day after I arrived. You're kind of like the perfect immigrant, I guess. Well, if that's what everybody warned, yeah, who is the perfect migrant?
23:21I think maybe I am a perfect one. If you kind of look at the ILR reforms that Shibana Mahmood has set up, who do you think they're designed to bring to the UK or to incentivize to come to the UK? See, I've gone through this whole process, ILR, me and my family going through this. So I just use my own experience. So I arrived on a work permit that was for two years. And then your employer decide, oh, he's a good guy. We can extend his work permit. So I got another two years. So this is when I was in Kendan Medway NHS Trust. In those days, you leave four years. That was the qualifying period for your ILR.
24:04And then you stay another year, you are eligible to apply for British citizenship. So I gone through that process. Yeah, I was I was happy to accept the rules and regulations at that time. But what we what Shabana is putting, I think she's looking to something similar. that you need to be someone who is contributing. If you are brought in or came to UK to work as a care worker, you should be working. And the country should value their contribution as well. I think that's what Shabana is looking at as well. You contribute to the country, and you get some help from the country. So it's a give and take.
24:47And can I ask, you seem to be fully supportive of Shabana Mahmood's measures, But what do you say to some of your Labour colleagues who are maybe a little bit squeamish about some of the measures that she's introducing? They say that it prioritises maybe the economic contribution over some of the other elements that need to be considered. I was generally in support of when the White Paper was published. I was in support of that. But my concern as I chair the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Adult Social Care, my concern was some of the changes that was proposed in the White Paper initially, that you may lose some of those workforce that's been working here for the last five or six years.
25:33We already spend money on those people. We train them what we need to retain them. If not, in two, three years' time, we will be looking to other countries to recruit more people. We don't want to be in that situation. So I was arguing the case that we need to make sure that those care workers who are already here should be given the ILR as they were expecting in five years' time so we can retain those workforce. but any rules, any changes should be for anyone who's coming from now on. And the kind of care workers exception, do you think that's largely on the basis of an economic argument, i.e.
26:15that we need them in the workforce? Like is it, you know, that we've paid for them, we've trained them, we've done all of these things and we need them or want them to fill these gaps in the workforce or is it more about the kind of idea that they're contributing to our kind of public good? So I mean, NHS and our health system has relied on overseas workers for many, many years. This is not anything new. This has not just happened after COVID. I know we're calling it Boris wave. It did not happen. This has been happening for many, many years. I was a bit surprised to hear from Kami Bertonok the other day about the NHS over with too many migrant workers.
26:52Yes, we are heavily relying on overseas workers. that's because we are not producing enough domestic workers. Why are we not producing enough domestic workers? This job is not attractable to domestic workforce. We're not paying enough. The pay hasn't caught up with it. I mean, I was an NHS worker for almost 23 years. I recruited thousands of people here. And you always struggle to recruit people into those jobs. And every time you hear that, I would rather go and work in a supermarket than working in a care home or a hospital ward. The job is a very challenging job. It's not an easy job. So we have to pay them.
27:33Unfortunately, we are politicizing, over-politicizing this to get to appealing to the public. I've been kind of going through, you know, exactly what voters want, because we kind of know what the Home Office wants of immigrants. economists basically just want people who are highly skilled and highly paid who contribute to the economy and don't cost us anything. Voters are really an interesting bag in terms of who they want to be coming to the country because they want someone who's highly paid, but they don't want bankers and they really love NHS workers. They want someone who doesn't take benefits.
28:10But again, they hate bankers who are least likely to go on benefits. They really like lorry drivers, for example, these kind of workforces where it seems that people are coming to fill shortages. And when you kind of look at the refugee side of things, they want people who are going to come over here and work, as you say, but they want women and children who are much less likely to be able to get a job because they'll need more support, at least in their first few years. I mean, how do you square all the circles of those contradictions, you know? Interesting. You're absolutely right. People are confused.
28:47When you see somebody on the street, they think, oh, this person may have arrived on a boat. But this person was brought in by our country to work here. I agree that people are concerned genuinely. I mean, we do have a shortage occupation list. So we published that. Where are the shortages? Who are the people country need? I agree that that's how we should be. And people should be brought on based on that. I kind of put together, you know, who is the unicorn immigrant? And I'm going to read it out to you. So if you put together the Venn diagrams, what the Home Office wants, what voters want, and what economists want.
29:29You end up with someone who earns over 50K, who doesn't claim benefits, who is a care worker or works in the health service or some kind of nurse and who speaks perfect English. That's basically you. You might have lost a couple of points for being a politician. And you're not a woman. So there we go. You're not quite there. To earn$50 ,000 in a health service, you have to be, I think you have to be a band aid these days. That's not something that many nurses achieve. So it is unrealistic that to get that$50 ,000. So$25 ,000 is a reasonable amount. How does it feel, though, to kind of fit the perfect criteria for what people want in an immigrant?
30:16Again, I think it is the way we use the migration for politics. That's why people think that. If we say that, you know, this is our hourly rate, we're bringing these people to work in a care home. If we don't bring them, we don't have enough people to look after our people, the people's perception will change.
30:44thanks to sojan josa for his time i'm back here in the studio with politico sam blewitt and pat baker sam is immigration policy purely a numbers game or is it about encouraging specific types of people to come to the uk i think it's it's not a numbers game in many ways is it um particularly in the eyes of the british public they like this idealized version of themselves like as you just described about Sgt. I mean, it's a fantastic story that everyone would love to aspire to. But perceptions is really important here too, right? When we talk about numbers, when we think about how public feels where net migration is at any moment in time, it's very often coloured by how many small boats they're seeing, right?
31:26So I think, you know, if you ask them to plot that on a map at any point in time, if it's a summer, they're likely to probably think net migration is far higher than it is because we've seen a wave of unauthorized crossing. So yeah, these things are entirely muddled. And I think that makes the government's job getting to grips with that issue that is a huge salient in the public mind. So, so, so difficult because, yeah, you can bring down that migration all you want, I think, as long as you see those kind of images splashed on the front of newspapers or circulating on social media and, you know, pushed by people like Nigel Farage and others on the right of the immigration debate, it's going to have a high salience for people.
32:04And it's so interesting because I think voters also wildly underestimate how many people are actually coming to the country. It's why David Cameron's whole like tens of thousands shtick was so clever. Because if you tell people, you know, like we got immigration down by 50 percent, it's down to 250 ,000. They're like, there's 250 ,000 people coming into like they're genuinely shocked. Whereas if, you know, Cameron's thing of being like, we can get it down to the tens of thousands, it kept it kind of vague. and tens of thousands was something that people could kind of be okay with in their minds.
32:35I thought that was a really interesting way of like selling it. And weirdly, Britain might be on track for that in the next figures. It's not confirmed yet, but it could well be under 100 ,000. So finally hitting that. Yeah, there was a really interesting interview after Shibana Mahmood's reform. She went on the Today programme and she said, we'll debate whether that number is too high or too low. So there was maybe a suggestion that it might end up being too low. That's really interesting. And I guess that talks to an extent to the economy's demand and the desire to drive growth. But I also wonder where that goes with the EU debate.
33:10You know, Andy Burnham has sort of opened that debate about, you know, going back into Europe and freedom of movement. And I think he started to make a really interesting point during that. I think it was in the same Sunday Times interview where he mentioned the F word, freedom of movement. He started talking about, well, it is such a tricky, loaded term. at times in the Brexit debate. But he talked about how migration has changed after Brexit. So he kind of, I think, was like alluding to like perhaps this idea that when we were in the EU, like younger workers would come here for a certain period of time and then eventually at some point head back to the countries.
33:49But he talks more about how that was revolving door migration. But then now we've been attracting non-EU workers. I think the idea is they probably come here to settle for longer. So I think that's, you know, some of this pathways to settlement stuff that Siobhan Ammoud has announced is trying to address that as well, I think. Yeah. And to your point about perception, I mean, Labour MPs I've spoken to are really squeamish about reopening the freedom of movement debate, but also any sense that they're not being completely tough on immigration is still, I think, because it's such a politically charged issue in the UK, kind of nervous political territory for some people, within the Labour Party.
34:27And to your point about perception, again, I mean, there was a poll that Sky News had in August, which showed that the public's concern over small boat crossings has barely changed, despite the fact that numbers have come down. And I just think that really underlines the fact that, in a way, this is so much more than about the numbers. This is about how people feel in their communities, about the pressure that they're sensing on public services when it comes to immigration. So I think that's something to constantly bear in mind when we're thinking about what do people really want from immigration is they're not necessarily completely attached to what the facts on the ground are.
34:58And I guess to that point, you know, how much of immigration policy is tainted by how voters view illegal immigration? There was a poll in 2023, and I suspect the numbers haven't changed wildly since then, which was that when you said the word migrant to someone, they don't think of people like Sojourn, who's working in the health system. 65 % of people were thinking of purely asylum seekers. You know, it's complicated because at times this country puts asylum seekers on a pedestal and, you know, greatly loves opening their doors to them. We saw in the Ukraine scheme where people literally invited, sponsored Ukrainians to come live with them.
35:34I think that was like a hugely successful asylum pathway. But then you see the kind of irregular migration of people coming over small boats. And then that just changes the conversation massively because it feels there's no buy-in from the public. and there's no sense of control over it.
35:56It is now on to our favourite part of the show, maybe Pat's favourite bit of the show. Best bit of the week, actually. Which is the odd cast, Sam. It's basically we choose a weird and wonderful story every week and we pitch it to you in three words or less and you have to choose which one you want to hear more of. How exciting. Yeah. Pat, do you want to go first? Sure. Greg's hotel room. Intriguing. Okay, Sasha. King says no. That's mysterious, and I'm not sure what it is, but I think I need to hear about any Greg's-related content. I'm sorry, yeah. So apparently a luxury hotel in Newcastle has teamed up with Greg's to open a luxury hotel suite that is completely Greg's-themed.
36:45so all the clothes and you know you wear like a dressing gown that says Greg's on it slippers that say Greg's and then you can ring a bell and they'll bring you a sausage roll I mean it sounds incredibly luxury is there like a fridge stacked with steak bakes how expensive is this place I think it's a five star hotel wow steak bakes everywhere you look is that the thing the steak bakes is that your favourite I like the bean and cheese one sure that's Andy Burnham's favourite as well so I think they've probably got that I've actually never had anything from Greg's apart from a sausage roll you what I've had a sausage roll Look past the sausage rolls.
37:16Look, I just love a sausage roll. So you can see this picture here of what the room looks like. It's that blue. Oh, it's very blue. Yeah. It looks a bit like what Donald Trump's done to the Oval Office, I guess. But very blue. With the Greg's theme. So Donald, if you're listening. Okay, that's it for this week. We'll be back next Friday. And remember to check out the Politico EU YouTube channel for our bonus content, including Pat speaking with journalist Jonathan Friedland about everything you need to know about the Israeli elections. And Politico has a new app. It's free to download and brings you all of our reporting from London and around the world in one place along with the newsletters you love, alerts on the stories that matter to your work of course and all of our podcasts including your favourite one, this one.
38:03So please do check that out. And thank you to our guests Madeline Sumption and Sojan Joseph. Westminster Insider is produced by John Rogers. See you next week. See ya.
Shabana Mahmood is the latest home secretary to try to reform Britain’s complex immigration policy.
Her latest proposals on so-called ‘indefinite leave to remain’ are designed to assess migrants based on the extent of their contribution to the country — by taking account of their skills, salary and what kind of job they are able to fill.
As MPs in the Commons consider Mahmood’s plans, this week on Westminster Insider host Sascha O’Sullivan tries to find out who Britain really sees as its ‘perfect’ immigrant, reflecting on the very different perspectives of the Home Office, voters and economists.
Sascha is joined by Madeleine Sumption, director of the Migration Observatory at Oxford University and interim chair of the Migration Advisor Committee, which advises the Home Office.
Keralan-born Labour MP Sojan Joseph tells Sascha his story of coming to the UK to work as a care worker, and reflects on how he tried to navigate British society amid its various and often contradictory demands for the ‘perfect’ immigrant.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices