


16 Nov 2026 · 1h 6m · 29 chapters

How Bitcoin sentiment (especially fear/anger/boredom) can be tracked via language on X/Twitter to identify market psychology, contrarian signals, and bear-market “inflection points,” with a focus on why this bear market feels different and how AI narratives are reshaping attention.
Michael Sullivan is a writer and engineer with a long-standing interest in language and etymology. He writes in public, has a background in technical work and fiction, and applies sentiment/linguistic analysis to Bitcoin communities. He tracks sentiment back to ~2016 and analyzes cohorts like OGs, plebs, and traders.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore how fear and emotions impact Bitcoin investment decisions.
“People are trying to manipulate your emotions to make you part with your Bitcoin, potentially.”
Learn about the speaker's journey into sentiment analysis and its relevance to Bitcoin.
“Well, I mean, we're in now, let's just go.”
Discover how language use can reveal shifts in sentiment among Bitcoin investors.
“I had fallen down the rabbit hole in like early 21.”
Hear about the author's books related to Bitcoin and their thematic focus.
“And that's interesting because there's like two big chunks of data.”
Understanding how Twitter is used to track Bitcoin sentiment compared to traditional methods.
“And I guess really like it's just psychology baked into two different avenues.”
Examine the diversity of perspectives within different Bitcoin communities.
“until like they're more despondent, they're more defeated in the words they're choosing.”
Learn about the historical tracking of sentiment and its correlations with Bitcoin prices.
“And the longer you've been around, there's a little less volatility in their emotions.”
Discover the differences in sentiment and behavior between new and long-term Bitcoin investors.
“And that garbage, that data is complete garbage in my opinion, because you get all these accounts that are like, just say whatever they need to say to get the likes.”
Explore methods for visualizing individual sentiment data and its implications for the market.
“and people latch onto different sorts of narratives under these kind of emotional regimes.”
Understand the dynamics between crowd sentiment and market predictions in Bitcoin.
“It's funny because I see this in myself.”
Explore how market manipulation affects Bitcoin sentiment and individual reactions.
“Yeah, I mean, I'm dumb money to some degree too, right?”
Discuss the shifting sentiments among different Bitcoin cohorts amidst market changes.
“what you said earlier, you said, like, there's a lot of fear right now.”
Analyze how the emergence of AI is diverting attention from Bitcoin among long-term holders.
“And they are insanely angry right now compared the other groups.”
Examine the various cohorts in the Bitcoin community and their differing sentiments.
“is that a lot of these folks who want to build have kind of been doing it on more financialized things.”
Explore the lack of conviction among traders and the implications for Bitcoin's future.
“Traders right now are the lowest conviction they've been in many, many years.”
Learn how psychological factors influence short-term holders' perceptions in the Bitcoin market.
“and the things that James has spoken about really eloquently is the idea that people are kind of anchored psychologically to whatever happened before.”
Understand the phases of market sentiment from bear to bull transitions.
“I think we're going to see phases of this.”
Discover how trust issues affect Bitcoin holders' sentiment during market shifts.
“like the hardest period of this bear market to me from the, like when, when cold car got hacked, that was the first big hack we had from this like AI thing.”
Learn why Bitcoiners cling to narratives and the importance of storytelling in cryptocurrency.
“Is Bitcoin really unique in this sense where you can actually gauge sentiment in a very useful way because there's so many people, lunatics online, talking about Bitcoin 24-7?”
Explore the complex emotional dynamics and time relationships of Bitcoin holders.
“Because I completely understand that AI agents might use Bitcoin as money.”
Exploring the relationship between emotions like fear and optimism in market sentiment.
“Not necessarily when it's happening, but like right when they expect it to happen.”
Discussing the volatility of treasury companies in relation to Bitcoin and their investor conviction.
“because you said you're also gauging sentiment on the treasury market side.”
Examining the split between Bitcoin purists and treasury company investors, and their differing convictions.
“I think that these groups are very, very, very convicted.”
Analyzing the effects of BIP-110 discussion on community sentiment and social media engagement.
“like conviction, yeah, it means somebody might be bullish about it, might be in there confident about it, but I think conviction's inherently related to how accurate you think your worldview is.”
Discussing the manipulation of sentiment by hedge funds and the emotional dynamics of Bitcoin investors.
“There's like sentiment warfare is another way that I've phrased this before, where people are trying to manipulate you.”
Speculating on the relationship between price movements and market sentiment in the coming months.
“It's not always malicious or it's not always like you're not always being inundated with it, but it can happen now and again.”
Explore how past market sentiments and patterns influence current Bitcoin investments.
“be like, oh yeah, it would have been so easy to buy there.”
Learn how crowd behavior influences Bitcoin price discussions and expectations.
“And we were going to have this like a long continuation, that desire language I was alluding to before that skyrocketed during that period of time.”
Discuss future market predictions based on sentiment data and analysis.
“Then we enter a bear market, people start entering and talking about these lower ranges.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On What Bitcoin Did, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:02People are trying to manipulate you. People are trying to manipulate your emotions to make you part with your Bitcoin, potentially. I just can't overstate how much fear and anger cloud your judgment. Myself included, I'm not immune from this. It's been a brutal time to hodl, right? But Bitcoin has a really unique way of messing with your psychology. They buy Bitcoin when it feels easy, when they're confident it's going to do well. And if you do that, you drastically underperform DCA. And that's interesting because it kind of is what the average person is doing almost all the time They just buy whenever they feel like it's easy to buy right watching how fearful people are despite the fact that bitcoin still up Like 20 % off the lows is really freaking bullish in my opinion It's like the crowd is overreacting even though we're actually seeing positive price momentum and those are the kind of Voids and deviations that I think have the most signal around this data I'm kind of expecting to see a little bit more of this where we just don't see full crowd buy-in until we probably pass through like the 100k range or something like that and it's like it's cool you know one of the things that i like about this is when everyone comes into bitcoin like okay what can i do in bitcoin like what can i add with my skill set and like sentiment analysis i like i didn't really see anyone doing this in a in a professional way until i saw you sort of crop up like this is your thing right it very much is now and it happens so organically where it was kind of just inspired by my love of language i'd done that for such a long time.
1:22And I was like, oh man, like I, I just followed this natural inclination and curiosity of mine. Eventually I'm like, all right, this is, this is way deeper than I thought initially. And we're just, we're just going to keep doing it. Yeah. Well, I mean, we're in now, let's just go. Um, so why, like, why did you get into this then? What, what brought you to the sentiment side of Bitcoin? So I have a big background. Uh, I was a writer, engineer. I've done lots of like technical stuff, but really have loved language forever. I've done lots of writing stuff. And anybody who's written any kind of like fiction stuff, you'll know that you use language very tactically.
1:52You'll like kind of weave certain words in to convey stories about characters and stuff. And most people have probably noticed that like just regular people, non-fictional people do this kind of thing too. And you can sort of get a vibe from folks over a duration of time. Like if they're shifting comparatively to what language they're using and kind of tell who they're talking to based on what words they're using. It's called like etymology, generally the evolution of language. There's a lot to this. It was always really interesting. And I started exploring this. I specifically looked at a bunch of my own data, first and foremost.
2:20Watched how euphoric I got during the Bitcoin bull market. Watched how depressed I got and kind of like applied this sort of principles and methodologies to other people like Saylor and whatnot. I was like, okay, there's so much more here. And I've just, I love learning. I love sharing things in public. I love writing in public. So I just kept pulling this thread and saw where it took me. And it's been a really, really fortunate trip. That's really cool. So you've written a couple of books. You wrote Blood of the Boudreuse. What's the other book you wrote? The Final Flaw. Very different topics, both kind of like sci-fi-ish, I suppose.
2:55Okay. I've not read either. Give me the... And I'm actually, I've literally, I'm at like 90 % through my most recent book on Kindle. So, so shield me on one of them. Which one should I read? Blood of Bourgeoisie is about Bitcoin. That was like my first thing I got. I had fallen down the rabbit hole in like early 21. I'd finished writing The Final Flaw, which was my first book, which was about like genetic differences and kind of like in a world where we started to get rid of genetic defects. And I had all this inspiration for Bitcoin. I was like, all right, I'm going to dedicate a chunk of my life here to writing a story about Bitcoin.
3:23That's what it is. Essentially like a really thrilling, like intertwined story kind of thing where Bitcoin is the main thing, following an on-chain analysis guy who sort of goes through and does like forensic stuff around Bitcoin and takes you all over the place across the U.S. as the bad guys are kind of murdering folks politically and doing all sorts of other crazy stuff. It's very, very thrilling and exciting and that kind of thing. But I wrapped that up maybe a little over a year ago now and kind of wasn't sure what I was going to do with my life after that, to be honest with you. I feel like I'd already, that was a three-year process.
3:55It was like all I was doing for a few years there and still felt this desire to do more for Bitcoin. And then this kind of thing just came up and I had to pursue it farther. Okay. So when you started looking at sort of Bitcoin sentiment, first of all, what are you tracking? Is this all, is this Bitcoin Twitter to sentiment, really? Yes, primarily. So when I first started doing it, I thought it was going to be podcasts. I love podcasts. I'm a big fan of them. I watch them and listen to them quite a lot. But there's some data differences between them. Like if somebody were to go on a podcast, you'll see me on one and I'll say a bunch of stuff.
4:26And then maybe you don't see me on one for another month. And I'll say a bunch of stuff there. And that's interesting because there's like two big chunks of data. But what's way more interesting is watching how somebody shifts over smaller durations of time. And people are talking and sharing their thoughts on Twitter constantly, like sometimes a few times a day, sometimes way more than that. So you can actually, if you look at Twitter data, you could technically do this with like threads and Noster as well. You can watch how somebody's talking evolves. So that has been way more interesting because then you see the minutiae of how an individual changes over time.
4:57And that's kind of like the core concept that all the other extrapolations of this are built around. Okay. And I've heard you talk about this before, where you have sort of pools of Bitcoiners and they all fit into different pools and you kind of take data from them in different ways. Like how do you set this up and what are you trying to track from these different pools of Bitcoiners? By far, the most interesting thing is Bitcoin broadly. I still just love to see how this entire asset class is thinking and moving and changing. But one thing I think we'll definitely talk about here is just how many subgroups of Bitcoiners there are, how kind of fractured folks have been during this bear market.
5:28And different groups are doing wildly different things. You have all the treasury company folks who are talking about some narratives. You have people that want to like transact with Bitcoin out in a jungle somewhere who talk about totally different things. And they both have different visions for Bitcoin. So kind of seeing like Like how different groups deviate, think, and which ones lock on to specific narratives earlier, which one are feeling different emotions than others during different periods of time has been one of the most interesting bits of this overall. Yeah. And so it's funny when you talk about this, and I've heard you on other podcasts talking about it.
5:57It's obviously nothing to do with like on-chain Bitcoin data, but it has the same kind of vibe. And I guess really like it's just psychology baked into two different avenues. have you seen anything that gives you like actual insight that you think is not available anywhere else yes I'm heavily biased because again it's like this data set that I've been exploring deeply as I kind of mentioned I'm sort of a teacher by heart I love to learn in public I just started this as a natural exploration right away I kind of wanted to see where it would take me and first started exploring kind of like the emotional regimes that were happening like as Bitcoiners were shifting one direction versus the other direction but the more I've done it and the more I've done like actual statistical analysis on the data and seen how it shifted over time I have found there's like very high levels of correlation with specific like prices of Bitcoin like right now there's a lot of fear out there people are really checked out they're bored they're not very convicted in the language that they're using and these things are very frequently coupled with bottoming ranges that has no bearing on what happens in the outside world there could be some wild news item that drops like next week and like we go way down or whatever right but it gives you a pulse because like people kind of are locked on to bitcoin in their own psychological way and sort of your like subconscious kind of seeps out a little bit in the language you're using and you can actually measure that it's kind of weird like but i think an analogy that i like to use here is that people like you've probably had a friend that's fallen in love before and you can kind of tell based on how they're talking that like oh they're really enthusiastic about this new person they're with uh another one would be like somebody's really depressed you can kind of until like they're more despondent, they're more defeated in the words they're choosing.
7:34And you kind of watch people's language shift. And you can do this with like crowds in general. So that's kind of the broad idea of what I'm doing here. And you can see when it shifts at interesting inflection points. So like, for example, looking at people that have been in Bitcoin longer, it's one of the cohorts I like to look at. And a new cohort that I've been really fascinated on is like traders, people making really short-term price predictions around Bitcoin. Because those two groups talk about wildly different things, right? Like people are focused here and now on the price. people have been around a while and are focused more on long-term things.
8:02So like watching how those two groups deviate has been fascinating. I definitely think there's a lot of signal there. Yeah, that's interesting. I do want to get into sort of what sentiment looks like today. But before we do that, just so I have a better idea, how far back have you tracked this data? Across how many different cycles? So the farthest back I've went is around like 2016 or so. There's some nuance here that's very different from OnChain actually in that a lot of people that are in Bitcoin right now were not in Bitcoin in 2015, right? Like there's a shift in the demographics over time.
8:33One of the reasons I really like this cohort, I call them the OGs, like who've been around much longer, is they've been through these cycles. So I've done a lot of this longer term analysis on them in particular because they've actually kind of been through things. And there's similar patterns. That was kind of one of the things I was looking at and studying before I was slightly outspoken with some of the analysis. Like I want to actually see if these patterns held up with some of the older term people, figured out they do generally. There's differences. There's more volatility. Another observation I had kind of related to this is that usually when people first get into Bitcoin, their sentiment is very volatile.
9:04You're super euphoric. I experienced this myself. And the longer you've been around, there's a little less volatility in their emotions. That happens on an individual level. And it also seems to happen in the crowd generally. Like we're very muted comparatively to where Bitcoin was even in like 2022. Yeah. I mean, that's definitely true. And that's why we have in on-chain data world there's like short-term holders like that's why they exist because of that volatility in their emotions um when so when you look at where we're at right now is there anything that is most comparable to and and how do you visualize taking a load of data from twitter how do you visualize that in terms of where we are right now so we are in a very unique place right now um we are one analog that i look at is like 2019 there was a lot of boredom there people were pretty checked out um even comparatively though like back like 2015 there's some similarities there again that data set is not quite as robust so i'm hesitant to say with like a certain amount of accuracy and that was a brutal bear market worse than anything else we've experienced right now however a lot of people that came in recently kind of came in with like mstr or some treasury company at the top and are already with options and are down like 90 so it kind of makes sense that some of these people would have been brutally brutally depressed after all that But to answer the second part of your question, like how do I visualize this?
10:23It's all built around the individual. Like what a lot of traditional sentiment analysis has done is it'll just go out there and scrape Twitter broadly. And that garbage, that data is complete garbage in my opinion, because you get all these accounts that are like, just say whatever they need to say to get the likes. There's bots everywhere. There is hedge funds out there trying to sway public opinion by throwing money at bot farms and influencing people. You can't get around that completely, but what is more interesting is if you track an individual. You can track one person's language over time.
10:53The negative with that is that an individual has life events that go on. Like they might have an election in their country, or they might have a child, and they might check out briefly. So there's a lot of volatility. There's a lot of noise in that singular person's data set. But if you combine that style of individualized data into a big cohort, you kind of do get this raw Bitcoin general sentiment, and it really closely tracks with some of the things that I've personally found. And it pairs up really well with on-chain stuff too. You can really see some of the euphoria, some of the optimism, some of the fear during certain periods of time.
11:26So is the idea here that, you know, individually people can behave irrationally, but as a crowd, as a collective, generally it's, um, you know, it's rational behavior? No, not at all. The crowd is super irrational too. It's just cleaner data. You get a better a feel for what the crowd is doing broadly. The crowd is often wrong. As of like very frequently, you see like high levels of optimism, high levels of excitement around bull markets, right around the time that like strategic Bitcoin reserve narratives get latched onto is like the certainty that this is going to happen. At bottoms, you see a lot more apathy, boredom, fear, and people latch onto different sorts of narratives under these kind of emotional regimes.
12:05So honestly, one of the most useful ways to look at this is kind of as a contrarian indicator, or to look when the crowd might be biased in a certain direction. Because not saying they're wrong, like you could be excited because Bitcoin has optimistic things in its future. That could very well happen. But to better understand where we sit broadly has been probably the most interesting and useful way to use this. So is this almost like the opposite of the efficient market hypothesis? In the sense that you're saying you want to always counter trade the crowd's general opinion? To some degree. like historically, not so I can't say it quite that broadly.
12:40There's a lot of nuance here where for example, I've done a bunch of analysis on all the different emotions I've tracked. Certain ones of them, you definitely want to counter trade when people get super, super excited. I did an analysis recently where I compared DCA to bulk buying Bitcoin when the crowd was excited, had high desire or had high conviction and kind of like saw how that compared because that's exactly what the average person does. They buy Bitcoin when it feels easy, when they're confident it's going to do well. And if you do that, you drastically underperform DCA. And that's interesting because it kind of is what the average person is doing almost all the time.
13:15They just buy whenever they feel like it's easy to buy, right? That was a big learning with all this. And those things in general are kind of things you want to fade, but there's nuance there too, where like conviction, you can be confident that Bitcoin is going up, but you can also be confident Bitcoin is going down. So there's a little bit of like nuance and contextual stuff that you have to understand to accurately use this data. Yeah. It's funny because I see this in myself. When Bitcoin is absolutely ripping and let's say I'm looking at houses that I could potentially buy, the bracket that I'm looking in goes significantly up.
13:44And every time I do that, I almost make a mental note. I'm like, okay, things are getting a bit frothy. I'm never going to trade Bitcoin. I'm not interested. I'm not good at it. That's just not my wheelhouse. So it doesn't really matter to me, but I still get the same psychological reaction that probably everyone gets. So is it just the fact that kind of most people are dumb money? Yeah, I mean, I'm dumb money to some degree too, right? And I was very dumb money, looking back to my data historically, right? Like, there are for sure brilliant folks in the market, especially now. There's like big fish swimming out there taking advantage of stuff.
14:17Especially as I've kind of done more analysis, I know that there's like a lot of manipulation going on. There's certain narratives that'll have like monetary weight thrown behind them to try to get them to trend. And people are susceptible to this. People that I think are brilliant are susceptible to this. If there's a lot of fear and anger out there, it doesn't matter how bullish you are on Bitcoin. There's certain ideas you might spend more time thinking about. To kind of make a personal analogy to this, if you are really angry because something happens to you, you'll start forming stories about why something bad happened.
14:51You'll have different kinds of stories comparatively if you're optimistic, you might have a more positive view of somebody who wrongs you. And this kind of thing happens on an individual level, but it's also kind of happening at the crowd level where like a good example of this a while back was when Saylor sold 32 Bitcoin, everybody was freaking out about it. Like that's the exact kind of narrative that you would see people overreact to when people are angry and they're bored, you know? Bitcoin is a hard asset. It took discipline to build your position and the platform you use for a Bitcoin-backed loan should have the same discipline.
15:19That's Ledin, the lead sponsor of What Bitcoin Did. When the next opportunity comes along, a Ledin loan puts liquidity in your hands without selling what you spent years building. Loans are funded in hours, not days. There's no monthly payments. There's no penalty for repaying early. And all the rates are published upfront. The larger the loan, the lower the rate. Eight years of protecting client assets with a perfect track record and over$11 billion in loans have taught Ledin what really matters. Your Bitcoin stays custodied. It's never let out to generate interest and Ledin doesn't ask you to take its word for it.
15:49Every month, Ledin publishes its open book report with all metrics independently reported. It's proof over promises. Hard assets, higher standards. Check your rate at ledin.io forward slash WBD, which is L-E-D-N dot I-O forward slash WBD. Bitcoin-backed loans involve risk. Do your own research before taking out a loan. APR eligibility and terms apply and may vary by jurisdiction. In the world of Bitcoin, security isn't just a feature. It's the entire foundation. and that's where my new sponsor BitGo come in. For over a decade, BitGo have been the backbone of the entire industry, securing billions of dollars of Bitcoin for major funds, exchanges and institutions.
16:26Following their 2026 public listing on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker BTGO, BitGo are now bringing that exact same enterprise infrastructure to individual Bitcoiners. Self-custody is still the gold standard, but as your stack grows, it's worth thinking about whether diversifying your custody can make sense. BitGo pioneered commercial multi-sig and their cold storage combines distributed keys, offline key generation, and geographically separated vaults. Head to bitgo.com slash Danny to get started with institutional grade custody today. Your Bitcoin secured like an institution's. That's BitGo.
16:58If you're a taxpayer in the US, you need to talk to your CPA about Bitcoin mining before the tax year ends. Mining equipment may qualify for 100 % bonus depreciation. That could mean deducting the full eligible cost in year one, and that's before any of the Bitcoin they mine. With Abundant Mines, you own the miners and keep every single sat they earn. Their team handles the setup, hosting, maintenance and repairs, all for a flat fee, and you keep 100 % of the Bitcoin you mine. And here's what really sets them apart. If one of your machines goes down, their Hashrate Redirect covers you with Hashrate from their own fleet to keep your Bitcoin production going.
17:30To count this year, the equipment generally needs to be placed in service, meaning plugged in and running by December 31st. So you need to move quickly. To find out more and get a free consultation, head over to abundantminds.com forward slash WBD. And What Bitcoin Did listeners will get a free month of hosting with your miner purchase. Check them out at abundantminds.com forward slash WBD. And, you know, when we're talking about sentiment now, what you said earlier, you said, like, there's a lot of fear right now. There's a lot of boredom. I think boredom is the real one. You know, I've been in Bitcoin since 2016 and every bear market sentiment gets bad.
18:05But this one's been particularly interesting to me in that it's not just people getting angry, fighting on Twitter, infighting, which we always have. It's people kind of giving up on Bitcoin a little bit, which I've not really seen before. Is that a novel thing that's happened this cycle? One of the reasons I compared it to 2019 is because we saw similar levels of boredom back during that period of time before the run-up in 2020. It's not a perfect analogy, but there's definitely some similarities out there. One of the things that I feel like makes this one really unique is the AI trade happening right now.
18:36Something that I've seen a lot in the data that has been kind of a unique thing to the OG data set that I track is how much people that have been in Bitcoin longer are more focused on AI, which I found just completely fascinating. I think there's an easy story to tell around why this might be. People that were like an OG to Bitcoin have a tendency to be earlier adopters of technology, right? That's the core reason you were probably an OG in the first place because you've been around it longer, right? You adopted technology earlier. So it makes sense to me that those folks would be the exact same ones who adopted AI earlier.
19:05I feel as though because this totally foundational technological change has been happening, a lot of folks in that group have kind of had some of their energy that was all like funneled towards Bitcoin and moved it over to like AI. I can't say like what they did action wise, like did they sell Bitcoin? I'm not sure to some degree they probably did just based off of where we are at price wise. But I know like a lot of attention has went into AI that would have normally been in Bitcoin at this point in time. Do you think some of that as well is that, you know, if you've been around Bitcoin since 2011, 2012, 2013, you've kind of made it like, you know, no matter what price you bought in, then you've done really, really well.
19:40Do you think that's another reason that we're seeing people check out a little bit? Because it's kind of done for them. Yeah, I think that makes sense to me. Another thing kind of relating to this, one of the cohorts I track is like the Bitcoin plebs, smaller accounts, more retail focused accounts like sat stackers who have generally been around like a cycle or less is kind of the informal definition I have for them. And they are insanely angry right now compared the other groups. The OGs in particular are pretty chill. They're bored for sure, but they're relatively more chill. But I think these people that are relatively newer feel as though they were promised this euphoric bull run, didn't get it.
20:13And then they're seeing all these people that have been around much longer who are like, well, man, I've been around. They feel as though they were owed the thing that the OGs had. And I think that's one of the core underlying reasons for a lot of the anger and a lot of the disjointedness between these groups right now. Yeah, 100%. It's funny. I was speaking to Justin Moon recently, who he's been in Bitcoin a long time um a developer and he ran the uh bit devs in austin for a very long time and so they recently closed down that bit devs because the guys who were running it i think it was um justin and ben the carmen i think were doing it like they basically just have both got super interested in ai didn't want to spend the time doing the bitcoin thing and the interesting thing is what justin was saying is like every couple years you they were getting new people come into these bitcoin meetups and eventually like you kind of hand over the baton to people who have got more enthusiasm, who are newer, who still want to talk about this all the time.
21:04And he was like, this time we just didn't have that. There was no one to hand it off to. And so they end up just, you know, stopping the BitDevs. I think they're doing them occasionally, but really it is kind of stopped. And I think that's a little bit worrying for Bitcoin. Yeah, that is for sure a concern. It's interrelated to the AI thing though too, right? Where like, again, I have a background as an engineer and I'm seeing just a shift in all the engineers I've known. Like a lot of them are out of jobs. Some of them are doing crazy new stuff. Like I'm pretty optimistic about AI in general, but there's like less of a need for this developer thing.
21:33Like the hyper focused developer guy who just like was in the weeds of specific problem. LLMs are better at solving one of those problems now. LLMs are smarter than a lot of developers now. It's a crazy thing to say. I would not have said that a year ago. I don't know that I would have been willing to admit that even like nine months ago, but it's just true today that like a LLM can write better code than an engineer. Now there is, it's not to say that like humans aren't absolutely critical to understanding these complex systems and giving direction to these things, but But that's probably part of the thing at play there, in my personal opinion.
22:03Another thing that's kind of interesting right now, or something I've been paying close attention to, is that a lot of these folks who want to build have kind of been doing it on more financialized things. They're interested in treasury company stuff or finding other more financialized tools. The really builder folks seem to be building in the financialization as opposed to actually free-to-money sort of things, which I don't feel great about, to be honest with you. I mean, the freedom money thing is one of the reasons I got into Bitcoin in the first place. But it is the thing. It's definitely happening right now.
22:34It's definitely happening. And I'm with you. Like, that's the thing that I really care about with Bitcoin. Obviously, number go up is great. But like, if it's not freedom money for everyone or anyone, then I think it's really missed the bar. Okay, can we talk about the different cohorts that you have? So you have OGs. Will you tell me the main ones that you sort of track? Yeah, I have a ton of these. So but the main ones that I found most interesting are the OGs, plebs, traders. I created a few other based off of one of Michael Saylor's definitions between Bitcoin capitalists, fundamentalists, and technologists, as he defined in like the four ideologies of Bitcoin.
23:09That's when I've watched really closely. I've done stuff like seeing American Bitcoiners versus non-American Bitcoiners. I've done stuff like the most optimistic 20 % of Bitcoiners versus the lowest, most pessimistic, and seeing what narratives they're talking about. Those are some of the ones off the top of my head, but really those core ones are the most interesting. And I also have cohorts for like every single treasury company basically too. Okay. So if we go for those core ones of OG, plebs and traders, um, do their sentiment within those groups, do they generally track and are similar? Generally, yes.
23:42So there's specific times when they'll deviate, which is kind of the deviation is where a lot of the fun lives, right? That's like a lot of the analysis ends up being is like, why are they changing? What's shifting between them in general though? Like in a, in a very euphoric time, for example, they're all in alignment. Like during the last bull market, there was high conviction, excitement, desire, like just all of the different emotions that I'm tracking, very tightly coupled. One of the defining characteristics of this bear market is that there was kind of like a fracturing. Different people have kind of like dealt with this bear market in different ways.
24:12Some have gotten siloed into their group more so. And even emotionally, they're different, right? Where the plebs, for example, are more angry. Traders right now are the lowest conviction they've been in many, many years. That's not true across the other groups necessarily. And that's the kind of thing that makes this interesting, makes this have like more value to understanding why these groups differ at all. And I think that's where the fun of the analysis lives again. That's interesting because like when you look at those groups, OGs and plebs, you'd imagine these are people just buying Bitcoin, DCAing, holding for a very long time.
24:46And so like when it comes to, you know, trying to get an edge on the market, maybe don't care as much because they're just in this for a long time. Traders are the ones that you expect at this point where Bitcoin's relatively low compared to where it's been, looking like it's pretty good, probably going to have a breakout at some point relatively soon. You'd expect the conviction there to be growing, but it's actually at the lowest you've ever seen it. Do you think that is, again, the AI trade just taking all the excitement, all the enthusiasm away from Bitcoin? I think to take a slight step back here, to understand the core of what these traders even are, is there are people making price predictions publicly.
25:18They are out there saying, like, I think Bitcoin's going to go to 100K at the end of the year, or they'll say, I think that like this short-term holder cost basis level is going to hold this time. If you're one of these folks and you've been beaten down the last year, you're going to put more like hedging language. You're going to put more conditionals on every single thing you say. So the way I read into that, like conviction is not inherently bearish necessarily, or bullish, low convictions are inherently bearish. It kind of gives a really revealing story when you look at these folks in particular, because it shows that the people that are making all the price predictions all the time just have no confidence in where this thing is going next.
25:53And that's the thing that I find kind of most striking or revealing about this group in particular. And I think that kind of is at the core of something all of us are probably feeling where it does feel like Bitcoin's at an inflection point right now. We're kind of devoid of any strong narrative. That's kind of another sign of a bottom, right? Like there's nothing to latch onto to tell a story about why Bitcoin's going to go up. And I think that's kind of the core underlying reason these traders are less convicted and maybe more confused about what's happening. Yeah, I mean, you telling me that everyone's bearish, everyone's bored is the most bullish thing I think you could possibly tell me.
26:27I would much rather that than the other way around. Like, if you track this, like, is this something you can actually take a bet on? Is, like, would you be confident enough that when you get to this sort of peak apathy, peak boredom, that almost certainly the bottom is in? I mean, nothing is certain, right? Like you can't know about world events. You just can't know if some black swan thing comes in. You can't know if COVID happens, right? Like there's no way I can use this data to know those sorts of things. But to give you probabilistic edges when it comes to like where the crowd is at, I think it can be insanely useful.
26:58Like right now, we're gonna talk more about short-term stuff probably in the near future here, but like watching how fearful people are despite the fact that Bitcoin's still up like 20 % off the lows is really fricking bullish in my opinion. It's like the crowd is overreacting even though we're actually seeing positive price momentum. And those are the kind of voids and deviations that I think have the most signal around this data. Yeah, it's super interesting. So I know that you also look at on-chain data a little bit. You've done a few pieces with Checkmate. You did one recently called disbelief in data with him.
27:31What are you kind of trying to track there when you compare both sentiment with on-chain data? We've seen lots of similar things. I think we share some similar theses. the two paradigms that I've kind of been using to think about the present state of things are the disbelief rally, like people just simply do not believe this, and climbing a wall of worry. Those are two patterns that you've kind of seen as Bitcoin leaves this bull market or bear market phase and enters into a bull market phase. And kind of the commonality among all these things and the things that James has spoken about really eloquently is the idea that people are kind of anchored psychologically to whatever happened before.
28:08This is the underlying reason why short term holders are a useful cohort because people in the last five months of time give you a really accurate idea of like the people that are just bought recently what are they thinking what's their mental state like right and the reason they're useful is because people take a little while to shift like people are still kind of in this bear market mindset they've been beaten down consistently every time they've got hope in the past you can actually see this in my data you see optimism come up as the bitcoin price goes up and you see it crash down again and people get despondent and more angry and more fearful every time, after a long enough duration of this, people are expecting that momentum of negativity to move forward.
28:43They get locked into that negative mindset and they have a harder time shifting or believing in this optimistic future again. And I think that's kind of what you'd expect during this turning point. And I know he's talked about this a lot, but I very much see this happening in the data right now. We could see that change for sure. There's definitely things that could invalidate this in general. If we do truly see a massive flush out again, people get more bored or whatever, but right now I still like despite the negative price action still believe that we are climbing a wall of worry. Recent hardware wallet vulnerabilities have definitely made me rethink my entire security setup as I'm sure it has for a lot of Bitcoiners and the uncomfortable truth is that no single security product can promise there'll never be a problem which is exactly why the design matters.
29:24BitKey is a self-custody hardware wallet that uses three keys created in three separate environments. There's one on your phone, one on the BitKey hardware itself and one on a secure BitKey server. Two of those three keys are required to sign any transaction. So a problem isolated to just one key is never enough to move your Bitcoin. So if you are rethinking your setup right now, as I'm sure a lot of people are, you should really think about the BitKey. The hardware looks great. The app and the user experience is second to none. Backing up and restoring your wallet is seamless and they even have inheritance built in.
29:53So I really don't think you'd be disappointed. So download BitKey today. use the code WBD for 10 % off the second generation BitKey, which is this device right here with the screen. Download the app, download BitKey, use code WBD and get 10 % off. Bitcoiners hate single points of failure, but your phone has three of them. One network, one identifier for life, and one carrier employee who can be taught into handing over your number. And that's where CAPE comes in. CAPE fixes all three. It's the only US carrier running two major networks on one SIM. So if one drops, you're on the other. Your identifier rotates every 24 hours, so to the network, you're a different person every single day.
30:29And the big one, your number only moves with a 24-word phrase that you control, just like a Bitcoin wallet. There's no call center worker, not even CAPE can move it. CAPE provides the same premium, reliable service you'd expect from any other carrier, but designed with privacy and security as its first principles. If you're a Bitcoiner in America, I don't know why you'd use any other carrier. Head over to cape.co forward slash wbd and use code wbd for 33 % off your first six months. That's cape.co forward slash wbd and use code wbd. Every Bitcoiner eventually has to answer one question. If something happened to me, could my family access my Bitcoin?
31:06Would my children inherit what I've spent years stacking? That's why Anchor Watch builds Bitcoin custody solutions designed to protect you and your family against real life accidents, errors, kidnappings, and even death. every solution includes their inheritance protocol designed to help your bitcoin reach the people you intend it for and us-based customers can also add bitcoin insurance backed by lloyds of london whether you're a self-custody expert or want multi-institutional support your bitcoin estate plan should not be an afterthought bitcoin is only generational wealth if it can be passed down so make sure your family can access tomorrow what you've built today anchor watch is your custody your way so visit anchorwatch.com to get started that's anchorwatch.com okay so if like peak bear market is disbelief boredom uh apathy and bull market is like euphoria everyone's getting too excited what comes what's in between like what would you expect to come next from here i'm sort of expecting to see this climbing thing uh this is some analysis i've done looking at how we've exited previous bear markets entered in previous bull markets you kind of expect this like people start to get excited you fall off people are not convinced it's here.
32:18I think we're going to see phases of this. During the 23 bull market early stages, people were still convinced it was a bull. And even though price was going up quite a lot, people were even more fearful, which is crazy if you go back and look at it. And there's always broader world events going on, right? Like on-chain data doesn't have world events, but when you're analyzing human language, there can be an election, there can be some legislative change that makes everybody freak out about something. So that comes up. But as Bitcoin has positive price action in the face of those things, it's like one of the more bullish signals potentially.
32:50So you can kind of watch how the crowd responds to that. They have a more angry or more fearful response to this negative news compared to the last time. Again, to kind of give you one of the things we're seeing right now, like we had a lot of fear out there during the cold card incident, BIP 110, all this period of time. It was really a brutal time for Bitcoin, myself included. We're seeing more fear now than we were back then. Even though the price is 20 % higher, even though we're not seeing any of those negative events, coin the same way. We have had AI hacks and the whole Binance thing, the election result and all those sorts of things.
33:21But if you would have told me that we were going to be up 20 % at the 58K bottom and people would be more scared then, I would have just like not believed you back then. But that's exactly what we're seeing right now. I'm kind of expecting to see a little bit more of this where we just don't see full crowd buy-in until we probably pass through like the 100K range or something like that. Why do you think sentiments got worse, you know, even than what seems to be like the hardest period of this bear market to me from the, like when, when cold car got hacked, that was the first big hack we had from this like AI thing.
33:51Um, it was sort of the bastion of self-custody. It was like the gold standard and that got broken. That shattered a lot of trust. I would have expected that to be complete capitulation in terms of sentiment. I would have as well. Uh, but that's one of the reasons I got back into looking at some of these older ones. Cause I was so curious about this. I, there was across every single pattern, like huge amounts of boredom, like lots of anger, especially around the BIP-110 cold card stuff, man. There was like people just freaking out, yelling at each other constantly, but it's still been rising. And I think it has more to do with the broader Bitcoin price and the broader market position than it does to do with the individual events.
34:26I think people just feel as though they were owed a lot and it's going to take longer. And I think as Bitcoin's climbing and it's still not having like the euphoria that they desire, they kind of lash out and are angry about stuff. To go back to the AI thing again, I think some of these hacks around AI genuinely do cause reason for fear. I think there's good reasons to be fearful right now. Like that's justified. I'm not saying the crowd is wrong just because they're feeling that there's valid reasons to feel this way. But I do think it's also the kind of thing that you would expect during this phase of the market.
34:54We've had a lot of negative news previously, and we've climbed the wall of worry. And until that doesn't happen, I'm going to continue to think that's the position we're in presently. Yeah, that makes sense. And I'm always bullish on Bitcoin. Like I love Bitcoin. and because again, I'm not trading it, like it doesn't really matter to me if I'm bullish when the price is going down. But do you think we managed to get the excitement back in Bitcoin? Because like you say, we have lost that. The AI trade has been sort of the ball of hot money that people have been chasing. It's kind of captured the imagination of a lot of Bitcoiners.
35:25Do you think we get back to the point where Bitcoin's the hot thing? I think that is a certainty. I think that people lose sight of this. I just can't overstate how much fear and anger cloud your judgment. myself included i'm not immune from this it's been a brutal time to hodl right but bitcoin has a really unique way of like messing with your psychology people have asked me if i can apply this methodology to other stocks and stuff and like the truth is i absolutely can do that but bitcoin is so unique in the sense where there is this like nebulous new idea the world doesn't understand that people don't grok that like your average boomer thinks is just a complete hallucination and like AI is going to break tomorrow.
36:06It just, it has a psychology around it. It has a story around it. It's like novel and people just don't understand it. So it has more of this like narrative volatility. It has more sentiment volatility because people are either like really into it or really not into it because of that in particular, like it has a psychological element that most markets do not have, which is what makes studying it in particular, I think so revealing. Is Bitcoin really unique in this sense where you can actually gauge sentiment in a very useful way because there's so many people, lunatics online, talking about Bitcoin 24-7?
36:43Like if you compared that to, you know, Walmart's dot, which is probably a relatively similar market cap to Bitcoin, there's no way you can gauge sentiment on that. No, you could do it with things like AI stocks. You could do it with things like Tesla, these like really tight-knit stock communities. But Bitcoin is so much more robust than that, right? Where we have people that are doing crazy different things that absolutely hate each other with a passion, but still use Bitcoin, right? Like, which to me is like one of the beautiful things about it. Like you can use this network and even like the people building with it in a financialized way are like empowering those who want to use it for freedom tech in Africa, right?
37:15Like I just think that's such a beautiful idea. And you can kind of bundle all these people up and look at them all, right? And I kind of see how they're differing. But it's this diversity of the group. It's like the big tent kind of Bitcoin that I think makes this analysis, like it makes this sort of analysis is just perfect for Bitcoin generally. And I mean, I'm a Bitcoiner, right? Like I love Bitcoin as well. So I've kind of focused here. And then there's so many subgroups where there's been like no shortage of different data to explore. Yeah, it's really interesting. Why do you think as Bitcoiners, and I say this as like collective because it's not something that actually gets me that much, but why do you think we get so attached to things like the narratives around things like stock to flow or the power law or four-year cycles?
37:57Like, why do we need these stories? I think humans are story-driven creatures. Like, I told you my history is as a writer, right? Like, people want a story to latch onto to explain something. Like, stories are a way for humans to compress data and move it into the future. Like, stories have existed being told between cultures to pass down ideas in this, like, highly compressed way that's easy to remember, easy to share. So when somebody tells another person about Bitcoin, they want a story to wrap up all their beliefs about bitcoin as tightly packaged as possible and send it to another person and stories are a way to do that and we evolve these stories because we need new ways to share this thing and they kind of emergent they're not necessarily always driven although some stories are manufactured for sure um but we kind of want these things like i want a new narrative to wrap up or to pop up so i can use it um one of the things i've written about kind of recently is i'm convinced that bitcoiners desperately want the ai narrative to be like a bitcoin narrative understandably.
38:55I think it kind of is to some degree, but I think there's a lot of that right now, but there's enthusiasm about AI and Bitcoiners want there to be enthusiasm about Bitcoin. It's like, how are these things going to become married? I think they will. I have good arguments for why they might be, but I just see that as a desire for people of wanting to find a way to marry these ideas. Not to even give, talk about the validity of that idea, but just to say like, we kind of want stories, right? Like all of us want a story to share why Bitcoin is good. I failed so many times to tell people why Bitcoin is going to be a good thing for them.
39:24They don't find my arguments of why fiat is stealing from us and taking our time compelling enough, apparently. So if I find new stories that resonate with those folks, it gives me new avenues to maybe discuss the orange coin with them. Do you think that with the AI story, we're trying to shoehorn Bitcoin in when it doesn't necessarily fit perfectly? Because I completely understand that AI agents might use Bitcoin as money. If you ask them to use Bitcoin as money, they will. But I don't know if it's a core part of the AI story in a way that some Bitcoiners are trying to sell it? I am very skeptical of the AI agents using sats.
39:59I think it's way more likely to be token or like USDC or stable coins, right? I don't love that. I'd rather it be sats too. Don't get me wrong, find this unlikely that all of these existing institutions are going to dislike why Bitcoin do that. However, I think that there's like, I don't know that AI is like this amazing short-term narrative for Bitcoin, but this technology that allows everybody to build things more quickly, allows like insane amounts of deflation, allows like us to do everything humans have ever wanted more quickly potentially, is super bullish for the most scarce asset that's ever existed, right?
40:32If everything's becoming more abundant, scarcity becomes more valuable. That is not a short-term narrative. That's a very, very, very long-term narrative, but I think it's insanely bullish for Bitcoin. There's like a very natural marriage here, but you have to have a long time horizon. You can't be looking to trade this thing six months from now in order to latch onto that AI narrative, you know? Yeah, no, and that's a narrative I totally believe. But like you say, it's not the most exciting narrative because you're probably talking 20, 30 years in the future, and that's too far off. People need something to grab onto right now.
41:01It's very cool. So what are the things that, while you've been looking at this data, what are the things that have jumped out and surprised you about it? The relationship between emotions and time was maybe one of the most surprising things. I kind of went into this. Yeah, I kind of went into this within an open mind. I didn't know what I was going to find. I kind of considered sentiment to be like fear and greed frames it as there is a binary like good sentiment, bad sentiment. That's not the case, in my opinion. I think fear and greed has massively misled people into thinking about how sentiment works.
41:33I think humans are really complex and different emotions tell different stories and have different relationships with time. So excitement is a very good example of this because when people get really excited, like typically it's about something here and now, like you can be excited about a vacation six months from now, but if there's something tomorrow, if you're like standing in front of the ocean, you've traveled somewhere, like you're freaking pumped. You feel more of this emotion. You typically see excitement pop up in the language, specifically Bitcoiners, like right before they expect an event to happen.
42:03Not necessarily when it's happening, but like right when they expect it to happen. so the presidential election in 2024 was the perfect example of this like right when that happened it was the biggest spike of excitement i have recently that contrast to something like optimism which is a view of the future it's farther off if you use more optimistic language it can be about something here and now but it's kind of like a how i extrapolate what the future is going to look like and those both those emotions have kind of a different relationship with time in a negative way fear and anger are kind of like different sides of the same spectrum where fear is more like hyper-focused here and now.
42:38You get tunnel vision and you're influenced by fear, where anger is more this like slow, persistent emotion. And this was a trip for me. I actually got way more into like human psychology stuff because of this, because I felt as though I needed to like understand it and share it better. And I feel just very fortunate to be doing this work because this is not where I thought it would take me. It's kind of been like, I've loved writing because you get to explore a novel idea and see where it takes you. And that's very much what this has been is just sharing this with Bitcoiners as I'm exploring these things and kind of seeing what learnings arise from it.
43:06That's really cool. So I want to talk to you a little bit about the treasury stuff, because you said you're also gauging sentiment on the treasury market side. When you talk about treasury companies, they're just basically a more volatile Bitcoin. Do you see the same thing in sentiment? Is it just more volatile sentiment? There's more nuance, for sure. So one of the biggest differences, so I'll take a step back here. In general, that is true, that they are generally more volatile. They're smaller groups of people too. They're like more influenced by small things. Like some of these treasury companies can be really based on a single person who is like the leader of that treasury company.
43:42And if that person goes, like I'm talking kind of about the meta planet situation here where a lot of those guys just left and they were kind of the leaders. And now there's just a total checked out vibe across the meta planet community. There's that kind of thing going on. Right. So they're very volatile in that way. They're way riskier, not just from a single man risk, but like from a single influencer risk, I suppose. like that kind of thing happens and it's wild. But in general, they do track Bitcoin pretty closely. But there are differences. There's different times where they'll be separated.
44:09Like for example, overall across all the treasury companies, there's higher levels of conviction through the entirety of the bear market. So Bitcoin treasury investors, MSTR shareholders, Metaplanet, et cetera, et cetera, have generally had higher levels of conviction the entire duration of the bear. That is just recent. That's interesting. It's just recently flipped. And I, again, I found that very interesting too. people have kind of had different opinions on what that might mean. I don't necessarily think it's bearish or bullish, but I do think the idea that treasury companies are going to go away in the short term is completely misguided.
44:42I think that these groups are very, very, very convicted. They believe this deeply. They're not leaving or going anywhere anytime soon. Yeah, no, I totally agree with that. I went to the Bitcoin treasury conference in New York in September, I think it was. And the night before it started, they had like drinks at PubKey and I went and I was hanging out with a few people there. And the level of conviction, I think was definitely higher than if you spoke to Bitcoiners in the same room. And the thing that really stood out to me more than anything though, was I feel like compared to when, say the first came out and started doing this, like compare that to today, I think there's been a real split between the treasury company people and the Bitcoin people.
45:22I almost feel like there's not, The Venn diagram has widened and the group that's in the middle has got much smaller, I think. They sort of straddle both. I don't know if that's something you would agree with. Yeah, not only do I strongly agree that I studied this. This is one of the earlier pieces I did around that four ideologies of Bitcoin that Michael Saylor wrote. I really wanted to see how the differences happened between those different groups, what was different between them. And the conviction was one thing, but there was also like anger among Bitcoiners that are not capitalists, that are not big fans of the treasury trade, there is less conviction.
45:56And to put a more precise cap on what that might mean, like conviction, yeah, it means somebody might be bullish about it, might be in there confident about it, but I think conviction's inherently related to how accurate you think your worldview is. And you can really imagine that if you're more of a fundamentalist Bitcoiner who's like running their own node, like really pro self custody and hates the treasury company thing, the last few months have been brutal for you. And not only has the price been down, you've watched the treasury company thing persist. you've watched cold card happen. And that was brutal.
46:24Like a lot of those folks were, got wrapped up in BIP 110 too. And that was also brutal. Like the very fundamentalist Bitcoiners have had a way worse bear market than those in the treasury companies, even though the treasury companies are down more, their story for viewing the world hasn't changed. That has happened for fundamentalist Bitcoiners. Your view of what Bitcoin is, is how do you shift and evolve over these last like six months or so? Yeah, a hundred percent. Like I don't feel like they've had the same existential crisis i mean especially if you've picked the right treasury companies maybe you've picked some of the bad ones um it's really cool i want to know how you kind of when you look at this data how you pick between what would be like real independent thought that i think would be really valuable data and people that are just sort of the echo the group think you know and like if you use bitp 110 as an example of this like whatever mechanic said you saw a thousand accounts online basically saying the same stuff.
47:15Is there a difference in signal between those two things? I did a lot of research around BIP-110. That was one of the first pieces I really shared where I did crazy deep analysis around and looked at in a couple different ways too, because I think it really showed some of the manipulation that was going on. Normally, I like to look at how the moods are deviating. I like to look at the narratives. But something I found particularly striking in that data was that there was a massive incentive to talk about BIP-110. There was a lot of examples of this, but one was so outstanding to me because normally Lynn Alden replies to somebody and she gets a thousand likes and she's like, I was just blowing up people's replies and ratioing them, right?
47:57She's legendary for that. I found a bunch of examples where Lynn entered into a BIP-110 debate and Mechanic and Luke were ratioing her massively. And you can't read too much into that, but in that one singular example, but I had a lot of examples by it. And I actually ran this numbers on this where I figured out that people that were just a regular Bitcoin influencer, whatever they were doing, if they started talking more about BIP-110, they generally got less engagement. If they talked about it negatively, if they talked about it positively, their engagement went up. So everybody kind of had this like subtle incentive to talk more about BIP-110.
48:33I got a lot of heat for sharing this data, but it was so repeatedly consistent that a lot of these people latched onto Big 110, probably for their own reasons. I don't disagree with them necessarily. I think their hearts were in the right place. They clearly love Bitcoin deeply. But these little algorithmic biases, there very well could be manipulation there to some degree. I'm not explicitly saying that, but it can make a big difference. Humans are dopamine driven, right? If you get a bunch of likes on your thing, you'll probably do more of that thing and kind of sway people in one direction or the other.
49:02And that's always happening out there. There's like sentiment warfare is another way that I've phrased this before, where people are trying to manipulate you. People are trying to manipulate your emotions to make you part with your Bitcoin, potentially. I know that there's some hedge fund folks out there doing some more things behind the scenes. They're not telling you they're doing it, but they're trying to play in this crowd psychology realm and see if they can potentially get an edge or even create an edge. I want to ask you about that. But with the Bit110 stuff, you saw the incentives to talk about it.
49:33And the thing that, from my perspective, like doing the podcast, there was also a disincentive to talk about it negatively. So, like, I covered this, you know, with both sides. I had Mechanicon a couple of times, and I had Shinobion. When I had Shinobion, which was sort of the anti-Bip 110 case, that video got so heavily downvoted so quickly, so many negative comments, that it got, you know, completely taken from the YouTube algorithm, did way worse than it otherwise would have done. similar things happened when I had Rob Hamilton on the show even not talking about Bitp 110 because the Bitp 110 crowd hate Rob Hamilton like they would just go in downvote the show I also think there's probably some some manipulation there I don't know if the robot accounts because I was getting comments on shows like that three seconds after posting the video and stuff but um that that definitely existed both the incentive and the sort of disincentive yeah it 100 % did even to the CEO of Bitcoin it's like anybody can get caught with that stuff yeah that definitely did happen behind the scenes for sure.
50:30And it's hard for me to say definitively, it's if it's bots, I'm convinced that you can probably spend like 10 grand and heavily sway the sentiment around a treasury company, for example, like you can definitely do stuff like this. And it doesn't necessarily take you having bot accounts commenting. You can just make sure you amplify the voices that are against that thing. And they'll talk about that idea more because they'll get more dopamine and they'll feel good because they're getting more narrative traction. They're getting more people behind them. Like you can do subtle things like that to influence people.
50:58And I don't know that I like perfectly answered your previous question around like how you get rid of that and bias in the data. I do a ton of manual cohorting. So this is not a completely automated process. There's a lot of parts that are heavily automated and systematized, but there's a level of like me making sure people are legit. I don't have any aggregator accounts. I don't have any engagement beta accounts. I try to make sure they're real people. That does not mean they're not anonymous. like a ton of them are anonymous, but they're like actual folks consistently posting over a long duration of time who can easily be influenced by whatever news item like the rest of us.
51:31But you kind of want to measure that anyway. It's kind of good to see what people are getting manipulated or if people are watching onto a specific thing, regardless if it's, you don't want to like hide that data because there actually is real stuff that are happening to real folks. Yeah. I just want to go back to something you said a minute ago. You said that you know for a fact that hedge funds are out there trying to manipulate sentiment. How do you know that? what do you know? Tell me. I have to tread carefully on that answer. I know there are groups doing this. I know that you can buy likes and things.
52:01I have had conversations with people who know things that have happened around this. I was not as aware of this until I started doing this work. But I know for a fact this is happening to some degree. I don't necessarily think it's always crazy malicious. I think the more recent example of this that's not the BIP 110 thing, because I don't necessarily think that those people were involved there. Could have been, I don't know for sure. But like MSTR, when there was a lot of shorting that happened, there was an influx of bot accounts and a influx of liking around negative narratives around MSTR.
52:35That's the kind of thing that you would expect to see if a hedge fund was taking a short position and trying to kind of manipulate retail out of it. That's exactly the kind of situation you'd see. I do not have definitive proof on that, but there's a lot of reasons to believe that was the case. And again, I have talked to some folks behind the scenes that have led me to believe that that is absolutely happening. Interesting. I hate that. I do not like that that exists, but I guess that's market. Well, I like, I'm not like this person that perfectly understands a crowd psychology going into this, right?
53:04Like I'm pretty nerdy guy and I really enjoy like the principles of Bitcoin, but there is like this human element to this thing that is just human. You can't like get away from the fact that we're emotionally driven. And the realities of the world are that people are trying to manipulate you out on social media. It's not always malicious or it's not always like you're not always being inundated with it, but it can happen now and again. And I think it's like a good thing to stay savvy to and to have a more defensive perspective on your timeline. Like just because you feel a certain way, like just being, having a slight pause, thinking about why you might feel an emotion, I think can be a valuable thing.
53:41It's actually one of the reasons I found this data most valuable for me is I'm so embedded in this, but recognizing that the crowd is really angry right now, recognizing there's a lot of fear has been a really useful framing for me to understand like, okay, I'm also feeling that, but maybe I shouldn't be too manipulated by it. Maybe I should be a little more immune from it. Maybe I should take a step back and view it as an outsider and see like, this is where the crowd is. Don't let myself get too wrapped up in the present narratives when there's anger or fear going on. Don't be so euphoric or don't be so convinced that the strategic Bitcoin reserve will happen, for example, when everybody's optimistic.
54:13That's kind of the time to fade some of those hyperbole narratives. The 100%. So now, what do you think happens next? What moves first? Does price lead sentiment or does sentiment lead price? I think they're interrelated. I definitely think price leaves narratives. I think that one, that relationship is very frequently true, unless there's some news that absolutely nobody talked about. But even then, there's oftentimes people that are privy to that earlier on. I think that price generally leads, but it's not like there's always a perfectly tight relationship between them. Like I've talked about this a couple of times now, but some of the most interesting periods are when price is like choppy, but the crowd's getting excited or they have higher desire.
54:54So like desire is when I track really closely, it's how much people want something to happen. It's not usually a great sign. It usually means people are like really hoping the outcome that they want is going to play out. So if you see a lot of like choppy price action and the crowd gets more like excited and wanting for this, it can be a pretty bearish signal. Whereas if the price is chopping sideways and people are getting more scared, that can potentially be a very bullish signal because it kind of shows you that people aren't bought into it. Those kinds of deviations are some of the potentially higher signal bits of this.
55:23Like, I think that's just very revealing about where the present crowd sits at any point in time. And so when you're looking at sort of now, the next few months, what are you expecting to happen? Like, if you look, if you compare this to, you know, history, what do you think comes next? I have been recently done a bunch of pieces on the 2023 bull market, that climbing a wall of worry. There was massive amounts of fear during that period of time. Bitcoin was actually trending up into the right and fear was also trending up into the right during that. And that's not what you would expect during, like, if you go back and just look at it, if you look at the broad zoomed out price chart, it's so easy to look back at that period of time be like, oh yeah, it would have been so easy to buy there.
56:05They knew ETFs were coming, right? In hindsight, that seems so obvious, but living through that was not obvious. There was all sorts of reasons and fearful things that the crowd got wrapped up in. Like the ETF thing had failed so many times for the Winklevii twins, like people are just expecting that negativity to happen again. And at that time as well, people were talking about whether it was priced in, whether it be like a sell the news event, like all this stuff was unclear at the time. And once it became clear, price finally broke through like 70K, I believe. Right around that period of time, you saw crazy amounts of excitement, crazy amounts of desire.
56:41People wanted it to come back more. All these emotions I'm talking about. That's when James Check so brilliantly started vocalizing his opinions about chop solidation. That shows up in the sentiment data, too. Not in the exact same way. Again, he has such a unique framework for that. But showing that the crowd was really overly excited here and felt like they were owed more after that. but it was really before that event when people were doubting when the fear was there that it was potentially your better time to buy when it's when there's no fear when it feels easy to buy bitcoin it's like generally a slightly more dangerous time to buy bitcoin um i'm kind of expecting similar patterns but to have a different flavor right i don't think it's going to look exactly the same i don't think like just pattern matching to previous periods of bitcoin or previous technical analyses levels is the perfect framework i think every single one of these paradigms and frameworks will fail over a certain duration of time i think the crowd will become too attached to an idea think that like this style of analysis has to work and then it won't work and it'll prove everybody wrong because they're all off sides and like i think that's bound to happen so i don't want to say precisely what's going to happen but i'm expecting this similar rhyming of the way that happens where like you're leaving the bear people are scared still despite having positivity and then get way too bought in when maybe they should be more uh despondent yeah you know when you i don't think you can use sentiment to track this but when you look at the last cycle it was a slightly disappointing cycle to me at least like it wasn't super euphoric it wasn't very exciting um do you think that's going to be the case going forward we're going to have these diminishing return type type uh scenario or do you think we can have a proper bull market again oh we're first we have a proper bull market over a longer duration of time i don't want to say we're going to have one next year but i uh i let me answer your first question there about like the excitement of 2025 we had a lot of excitement and optimism and conviction and like just all the positive ones around the election period the latter half of that year was way more muted um to the point where like a lot of the signals that i look at like really would not have screamed overheated at all it didn't look like crazy overheated curiously it was actually the beginning of this year uh like very early 2026 where we actually saw more overheated emotion this was after the big price dropped down people thought the bear market or the bull market was going to continue.
58:53And we were going to have this like a long continuation, that desire language I was alluding to before that skyrocketed during that period of time. People really wanted the bull market to continue. And then we crashed down and we immediately went to this like apathetic phase where people are like realizing it's not going to happen. That actually makes sense in some ways, because I think at that time people like, well, that wasn't a proper bull market. You know, it can't be the end. I think that was generally the sort of take. Yeah, exactly. I, I, part of reason I think this is likely to play out, like people are kind of buying in too much to this, like diminishing returns thing, in my opinion.
59:26Um, just watching how assets like gold, um, or silver have responded recently. Like the fact that these older assets can have that much volatility to the upside is super bullish for Bitcoin over the longterm potentially. I, I a hundred percent agree. Um, like, is there anything that we've not touched on that we should have done? I actually, I do have a crazy chart that I could show that I was always a fun one to riff on. Let's do it. Yeah. One crazy chart to finish. Yeah. All right. So this is kind of one of the more like just crazier ones that I've put together here. A lot of the different sentiment stuff we've described so far is like looking at a mood or an emotion over a line, like how the crowd trends that way.
1:00:05But I have this absolute mountain of language data, right? So as I was looking for different ways to visualize this, and this has been one of my favorites by far, and it's very illuminating on like how the crowd is moving and reacting to different stuff um the the first thing that stands out with this one to me is just like the obvious amount of density around the line so what this is measuring is how often different price levels in bitcoin are talked about over time uh you can really see here like the very stark obvious one through the middle at 100k if i were to scroll way up to the top it's way out of view here but you'll see like there's this crazy dense red line at a million where people are very constantly talking about this price level.
1:00:46And then obviously see lots of stuff heating up around the present price all over the place. Lots of different observations here. I've looked at this many different times. One of the more curious ones is the period we were just talking about around after the ETFs were approved and we started having a lot of chatter around the present price levels. There's a lot of density around the tops and people are talking about levels and technical analysis if we're going to break into new areas. You see this really high level of price chatter right around 100k range as we first break through it have resistance initially break through it something very very curious recently is just how much price chatter there's been and i think this is a very natural um relationship or a very natural thing to look at based on our discussion about traders too where the people that are talking about price levels are less convicted and overall looking at the broader crowd because this is the entire group of bitcoiners i have it's not cohorted in any way.
1:01:40It's just a broad one. People in general are talking a lot about price levels and really have been frequently here. There's like more density of price mentions around this period of time. I think that's kind of representative to what you would expect around a really massive inflection point. The other thing I really want to draw your attention to that I find kind of hilarious, to be honest with you, is this period, this area right here. Is this 58K gang? Yeah. Well, there's 58K gang in here, right around this area right there. But it's this idea that But when we are in a bull market, people start talking about like 150k and these other ranges.
1:02:14Then we enter a bear market, people start entering and talking about these lower ranges. And it's so funny because like no one was talking about 40k up here at all. But then when you come over. Yeah, that is interesting. It's literally empty. Yeah, people talk more about these lower levels and that changes and people readjust their thinking. Right now, people are talking way, way, way more about these lower levels and almost not at all about the levels directly above us. And I think that's kind of what you would expect during this time when people are just so worried. And again, you're fearful.
1:02:44You're focused on different things. You're focused on more fearful things when you're fearful. And they're talking a lot more about these lower levels, partly for technical analysis purposes, but also just because people are so like, oh, if we do fall, what are we going to see? That's just showing up in the data here. And you see a lot less of the people talking in a more optimistic manner using higher levels of Bitcoin prices. That's interesting. And like when you look here, so November last year is really when people started talking about 40k as a number. And then it really ramped up maybe, I don't know, February, around then sometime.
1:03:15There was that, there's the guy, I forget his name. I think it's something Cowan, the analyst who was, he kind of drove the 40k narrative. And that gets back to one of the questions I was asking before in terms of like, how do you pick between independent thought, like him coming out saying he thinks it's going to hit 40k is cool. Like he's made his own analysis and he's made that decision. But then because one person says that, and the same would exist with a checkmate or anyone, if they start talking about a level, everyone starts basically just copying that talking point. Like, is that still signal?
1:03:47Oh, yeah. It's just maybe that signal in a positive way. It could be like signal of, okay, the whole crowd is starting to believe that that guy's right. Maybe we fade that. So if you think about this from a perspective of like a market maker who knows where certain people are trading and certain levels that people are locked onto and you have a lot of control over short-term price action and you can bring it a certain direction to pump and get rid of some liquidity you might do that with that knowledge of where the crowd is focused on and if you see those specific levels when the crowd's focused on them you don't necessarily even need to use a price mentioned heat map to do so you can just kind of like see where specific people are positioned and see who these big people are talking about you can kind of potentially do some stuff like that and I think that's one of the reasons that like I think technical analysis in general has had a lot of pain recently because the market has chopped around and really challenged a lot of perspectives, levels and lines that people thought were guaranteed to hold haven't held.
1:04:37A lot of the stories that they use about just like how Bitcoin has to trade have come under tension too. Yeah, it's very cool. Really interesting. I've really enjoyed this, Sully. We should do it again at some point. You need to tell everyone if they're into the sentiment data where they can go and check out your work, your sub stack, all that stuff. Yeah, so the best place to find me is Sentiment Sully on Substack. I read a newsletter called Bitcoin Sentiment Weekly where I share all this analysis, like constantly going deep into the weeds with all these things and just evolving this thinking as I go too.
1:05:07Because there's just a massive, massive amount of data for all sorts of different groups and cohorts like we've discovered here today. And I'm still actively exploring this and seeing how it has different relationships, the price, what it can tell us about where Bitcoin's going and all that kind of stuff. I'm also on Twitter as Sully Michael then over there. And yeah, just appreciate the time today, man. This was a ton of fun. No, thank you. It's been cool. and sentiment bottoms in. Let's go. I'm ready for some price, some price action. You will. All right. Thank you, man. Appreciate the time.
1:05:34Yeah, appreciate you.
“I just can’t overstate how much fear and anger cloud your judgment.” — Michael Sullivan
Michael Sullivan is a writer and Bitcoin sentiment analyst behind Bitcoin Sentiment Weekly. He tracks how Bitcoiners talk online to understand what fear, excitement, conviction and boredom reveal about the market.
In this interview, we discuss why buying Bitcoin when it feels easy can lead to worse results, how our emotions shape the narratives we believe, and whether Bitcoiners are losing faith. We also get into AI pulling attention away from Bitcoin, the divide between Bitcoiners and treasury company investors, and how social media can be used to manipulate sentiment.
Sponsors:
Ledn - Explore Bitcoin-backed loans and get 0.25% off your first loan.
BitGo - Secure your Bitcoin with institutional grade security.
Bitkey - Get 10% off the new Bitkey wallet with code WBD.
AnchorWatch - Insured Bitcoin custody, security & inheritance. Book a consultation: https://www.anchorwatch.com/wbd
Cape - Get 33% off your first six months with code WBD.
Abundant Mines - Bitcoin mining made simple.
FOLLOW:
Danny Knowles: https://x.com/\_DannyKnowles
Michael Sullivan: https://x.com/SullyMichaelvan