Best of: How to Be in "High Magic, Low Effort" Mode This Holiday Season

24 Dec 2025 · 48 min · 22 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Holiday “high magic, low effort” parenting—how to reduce the seasonal workload while keeping the fun, especially as kids age and expectations rise.

Guests

Margaret Ables and Amy Wilson, hosts of What Fresh Hell (motherhood-focused podcast). Margaret has performed as “Mrs. Santa” in the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade and worked as a Santa/elf performer; Amy is a “kinkeeper” type who manages family logistics and shares listener-sourced strategies.

Key claims

Lean into “magic” with boundaries (lean in, but don’t overdo). Acknowledge grief and seasonal dread instead of forcing cheer. Choose a few high-leverage traditions, set limits, and invite help (including kids) rather than silently carrying everything. Social media can create guilt; skip or simplify.

Notable examples

Selling unused dresses on Depop; renting a school gym for post-Thanksgiving kid energy; “top three Christmas things” lists (e.g., Muppet Christmas Carol, Christmas Eve dance party); limiting December extras (no dentist/doctor, fewer activities); “open the best gift last” sticker trick; pepper cookies rage vs store-bought cookies.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Opening Thoughts on Holiday Magic

0:00 to 0:32

The hosts reflect on their recent experiences and the concept of holiday magic.

“You survived the Miami weekend, nailed the speech, and maxed out your credit card in the name of friendship.”

Struggling with Holiday Expectations

1:12 to 2:40

The hosts discuss their holiday goals of less doing and more magic amidst changing family dynamics.

“Today, we're talking about our holiday goals, which are?”

Personal Reflections on Holiday Joy

2:40 to 4:55

They share personal experiences with holiday traditions and the pressure of keeping them alive.

“You know, that used to be my job in my younger years.”

Navigating Loss During the Holidays

4:55 to 6:52

The conversation shifts to dealing with grief and loss during the holiday season.

“And I think that it comes up really hard around the holidays.”

Kin Keeping and The Burden of Magic

6:52 to 9:09

They discuss the role of kin keepers and the struggle of wanting others to help during the holiday rush.

“you know, my husband has been traveling for work a ton.”

Listener Advice on Holiday Stress

9:09 to 10:01

The hosts share advice from listeners on managing holiday stress and expectations.

“music, it carries me along a little bit.”

Creative Solutions for Holiday Celebrations

10:01 to 12:10

They discuss various creative strategies to celebrate holidays without overwhelming pressure.

“And we have chosen to do things a different way.”

Finding Joy in Simple Traditions

12:10 to 14:00

The hosts emphasize the importance of identifying and focusing on simple, meaningful traditions.

“I mean, we're gonna have like two dozen kids between the ages of two and 21 staying at various houses.”

Holiday Traditions and What Matters

14:00 to 16:01

Learn how to prioritize meaningful holiday traditions with your kids.

“And my mother spent hours making cream white onions and passed them to my grandmother who said, oh, I don't really like them.”

Holiday Traditions and What Matters

16:16 to 17:36

Learn how to prioritize meaningful holiday traditions with your kids.

“Well, I'm coming in hot to say it is worth taking care of your skin.”
Show all 22 chapters

Holiday Traditions and What Matters

17:39 to 18:18

Learn how to prioritize meaningful holiday traditions with your kids.

“When I log into the Monarch Core app, all the info is there, right at my fingertips.”

Managing Holiday Expectations

18:18 to 20:58

Understand the importance of setting realistic holiday expectations with kids.

“She says, I try to remember that some things will just be better once the kids are older.”

Holiday Activities and Family Dynamics

20:58 to 24:05

Discuss the balance of family traditions and the pressure of holiday activities.

“And this is, I go back to that suggestion of talking to your kids.”

Navigating Holiday Stress

24:05 to 28:01

Explore how to handle the stress of holiday expectations and activities.

“I have like the opposite thing, an opportunity being presented to me right now for Christmas, which is in Brooklyn.”

Navigating Holiday Expectations

28:01 to 30:23

Learn how to manage holiday festivities with kids and set realistic expectations.

“Sounds like it will be fun, but really it's cold, wet, crowded, and often the kids are too tired and overstimulated.”

Navigating Holiday Expectations

30:24 to 31:15

Learn how to manage holiday festivities with kids and set realistic expectations.

“because Quaker's coming in hot with morning nutrition, 100 % whole grain oats, and a good source of fiber to fuel the rhythm of your morning and kickstart your day.”

Anticipating Holiday Surprises

31:25 to 42:03

Delve into the humorous and unexpected moments families face during the holidays.

“And now, eight things that will happen to you this holiday season from the What Fresh L podcast.”

Redefining Holiday Magic and Family Values

42:03 to 45:35

Explore how to balance holiday traditions with family values and personal joy.

“As a family, we're going to thank these people.”

Making Memories vs. Holiday Stress

45:36 to 48:08

Discuss the importance of prioritizing memorable experiences over stressful traditions.

“And everybody's merry and you're absolutely miserable.”

Creating Joyful Holiday Memories

48:09 to 48:58

Understand the significance of shared memories in creating a joyful holiday atmosphere.

“We've done for people's birthdays and stuff like people write stories about the person.”

Making Memories vs. Holiday Stress

48:59 to 49:45

Discuss the importance of prioritizing memorable experiences over stressful traditions.

“Make the high value magic, the high leverage magic.”

Making Memories vs. Holiday Stress

49:48 to 49:59

Discuss the importance of prioritizing memorable experiences over stressful traditions.

“you sign up or we'll put the link in the show notes for this episode.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00You survived the Miami weekend, nailed the speech, and maxed out your credit card in the name of friendship. Now you've got one hangover, four pastel dresses, and zero reasons to wear them again. Sell them on Depop. Just snap a few photos and we'll take care of the rest. And you at least get some of your dignity, money, back. Someone on Depop wants what you've got. Start selling now. Depop. Where taste recognizes taste. you're like I want the magic but I don't want to make the magic your dream is real what fresh hell laughing in the face of motherhood I would show up and I'd sing a few songs I had like a set show and then I'd be like and here he is and he'd come in with Margaret Ables and Amy Wilson somebody gonna be screaming and crying and hiding between your legs and being like I don't like that Santa yes that will happen a podcast that solves today's parenting dilemmas so you don't have to had I checked with my family, it was a priority to nobody that I make these incredibly complicated cookies.

1:03And then I was mad nobody wanted them. Hello, everyone, and welcome to What Fresh Hell laughing in the face of motherhood. This is Margaret. And this is Amy. Today, we're talking about our holiday goals, which are? We have two. Less doing, more magic. Yeah, I love this. And I think, you know, this has been thematic for us in a ton of ways. And I think it's really interesting as our kids start to get older and their relationship with Christmas changes, that I'm finding the pushback or my push to kind of scale everything down. It's challenging. Like, although they are kind of aging out of some of the magic of Christmas, they don't want less.

1:52That's for sure. I mean, they're not like, let's tone it all down, you know? It's not happening. I want to start with something one of our listeners, Tiffany, said. She said, I am a make magic girl. I enjoy doing the things I do pick and choose, though. And I thought, well, that's interesting. Are you, because I'm not sure I know the answer, are you a make magic girl? Are you into Christmas? 10 ,000%. I mean, I am a, I love Christmas. I love the magic of it. I loved it as a kid. I still love it as an adult. My nephew was just here and saying, well, when does Christmas really start? And I said, okay, this is not, he said, do you have an opinion on that?

2:30I said, I don't have an opinion. I have a fact. Christmas starts the moment Santa appears in the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade. That is the beginning of the Christmas season. You know, that used to be my job in my younger years. One of my many acting jobs was being Mrs. Santa, not in the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, but at different malls around the United States. I would show up and I'd sing a few songs. I had like a set show and then I'd be like, and here he is. And he'd come in and it was one of my favorite acting jobs ever. I worked as an elf at the World Trade Center. That tells you a little bit how long ago this was for a real beard Santa.

3:06And I can't say I loved it. It paid really well. It was like 500 bucks a day that gig. It was such a good gig. Which right for an out of work actor back then was a lot of money. I could write an essay about it except for that David Sedaris has already written the what do you call it formative essay on being a Christmas elf, but yeah, he got a whole career out of it. 90 % of the job is keeping children from assaulting Santa. Like, it's funny, like you're basically a Secret Service agent, dressed in a merry way, because kids, sweet, you know, gigantic 12 year old kids would take a running leap from like 10 feet away to leap upon Santa's lap.

3:47And Santa was, he was a real beard Santa. He was an older gentleman. And he was a human being. He couldn't handle the beard was real. Everything, everything was real. And so was his bad hip. And yeah, exactly. He could not handle the leaping children. So make magic. Am I a make magic girl? I'm gonna ask myself that. And the answer is sometimes. Definitely when my kids were little, I really dug it. This year, I am not feeling it. For many reasons, I am not really feeling it this year. And I'm like Hodor and the people at the door are like, when you have your kids lists, I really want to get started in my shopping or here's my kids list so you can get started in your shopping.

4:28And I'm like, go away. I don't I don't want to do it this year. But I do. I mean, it's also the only thing that will save me. Yeah, I am similar. I had a long talk with my sister yesterday, who I think is feeling this times 10. And what we came to is lean in with boundaries, basically. I think sometimes this time of year can obviously, for a lot of reasons, be depressing and kind of remind you of what's not there. We've both lost parents. And I think that it comes up really hard around the holidays. and there's a lot that can feel bad. And I don't think it's smart to try to be in denial about that and be like, what?

5:12I'm just a merry elf. There's nothing wrong. It's okay to say like, this is a time of year where I really miss my mom, miss my dad. Those are very real feelings. But I think sometimes there's a temptation and especially when we feel like the merrymakers and put upon in those ways to kind of cut off our nose to spite our own face, truly. You know, that like, I'm going to show everyone how miserable I am by being a Grinch. And I think that that instinct, because, and I think we've talked about this with birthdays, I think it can become a little bit like, I have a huge tendency to do this on my birthday.

5:51I know my husband's going to mess it up. I know he doesn't have enough prepared. So rather than say anything about that or do any guidance, I'm going to sit back. Like, who's the guy in Lord of the Rings who like my precious, my precious Gollum, like Gollum, I'm going to stroke the orb of how everyone has failed me. I feel like it's a little different that, you know, we talked about being kin keepers earlier this year, a term that was new to me at the time, but I certainly know what it is. And I am the kinkeeper. I'm the tree decorator, present spreadsheet keeper. And I don't feel like doing it this year.

6:29And it isn't necessarily that I want to like, make sure everybody has a lame holiday season. It's that I want somebody else to do it this year. I want somebody else to keep me instead of being the kinkeeper this year. But it's probably not going to happen. So you need to like figure out how to get going, get some hot chocolate or something and get moving. I think we often have the advice, and I think it can feel like another job and frustrating to invite people into the kin keeping with us and to kind of give voice to that, to say, hey, for whatever reason, I'm really struggling this time of year.

7:02you know, my husband has been traveling for work a ton. And I was kind of like you in grades, you don't even see that I'm doing this all by myself. And I kind of had to check myself at a certain point. And I sat my kids down and I said, Listen, I need more help. As you know, dad's off in the great beyond. So I really need you all to pitch in and be my helpers, because I'm struggling to get everything done. And I feel like my kids, it doesn't mean that they suddenly like don elf hats and are like, well, I will do everything and it'll be fun. But leave it to me. I think it's fine to invite people in, you know, my sister and I had a really frank conversation and said, like, let's do gift exchanges.

7:50And let's lean in on what the present lists really look like? And who can we take off of them? And how can we do it less? You know, we were originally kind of like, let's just forget it and just forget about gifts this year. And after a week, I think that both of us kind of felt like that's going to feel depressing. But the instinct is coming from a real place. So like, can we find a solution? Well, so we asked our listeners. Oh, I know they're going to solve it for us. They are. There's some really good level setting advice in this episode. So we asked our listeners on our Facebook group and page, you can find them both at WhatFreshHellCast or just searching WhatFreshHellPodcast on Facebook.

8:29We asked, how do you resist the urge to do all the things for and with your family members during the holidays? Which is funny. For us, it's like, how do you get the urge to do any of the things is what we've been talking about so far. But this is how do you resist the urge to do everything, feel bad when you're falling short? How do you lessen the burden while retaining the magic? because yeah, I want the magic. I don't want the burden. That's what we're all about. And I will say before we dive into our brilliant listeners, that I think that sometimes we feel this very strongly before the season begins.

9:05It's like seasonal dread in a way. And then I sometimes find that like once I get the lit candy canes up and I'm playing the music, it carries me along a little bit. Uh-huh. I think you're right. Well, Lisa had some advice that I think is maybe worthwhile for me. Lisa says she lessens her time around the people who do all the things. And she sticks to two or three traditions, makes it more special than doing all the things and cramming it in. Huge. This is something that I'm working on as I get into like the college season of my life is just, as you say, like putting that slip of paper, taking that extra breath when I'm involved in conversations that are like, Like, well, my child with their 12 APs and eight varsity letters and 19, you know, buildings that they've built are.

9:54And that feeling comes up of like, why are you attacking me? And why are you this way? And why are you stabbing me in the face and trying to kind of say that's the way they've chosen to do things. And we have chosen to do things a different way. And both of those things are actually fine. Yes, that's right. The person who has all of her Christmas shopping done already, except for your kid, and she's asked, you know, three times for the list and a list that you are somehow responsible for preparing in today's world, that that's, you can feel anxiety from that, which is not intentional. That is just somebody doing it differently than you do it.

10:33Right. And you can say, I don't have that. Cassie says, the day after Thanksgiving and the day after Christmas are our days we look forward to. We don't schedule anything on those days with people outside of our household. The day after Christmas is my favorite day of the whole year to just wear pajamas all day, snack to our heart's content, and enjoy gifts. Yeah, I kind of feel like nobody expects you to do anything else the day after Christmas. Maybe it's like pile in the car and go see Aunt Martha, but I feel like everybody just stays home the day after Christmas. I mean, the day after Christmas is my sister's birthday, so we're just rolling right into birthday celebrations.

11:09Oh, you roll right into that. I will say this is not a tip for everyone, but this is how we do it. And it works for me. Your mileage may vary, as they used to say on the internet back in the day. The day after Thanksgiving, I find that I often have 20 people still hanging around at my house who need something to do. And you know, we decorate the whole house for Christmas because I got 20 people. I got 40 hands. I'm like, let's go. We're turning on Christmas music and the kids are generally really into it and it's free labor for me and it's a fun activity and we get a big tray of bagels and hot cocoa and turn on the music and let's all decorate the house.

11:49It's kind of a trick on my part because I'm just forcing people to put up decorations in my house and then by that day, it's all done. I don't know. And it's like, okay, we're rolling right from one thing to the next. I like it. That's a great idea. We have both sides of our family this year are gathering in the same town because my husband and I are from the same town. Anyway, we're and big families. I mean, we're gonna have like two dozen kids between the ages of two and 21 staying at various houses. And that day after Thanksgiving, that weekend is like now what that can get a little long. I feel like after Christmas, you're playing with your new toys.

12:25Now come decorate my house for free. That's my answer. Right? Today after Thanksgiving, if you're not going to Best Buy at 5am, then what are you doing all day. So my husband, smart idea, he called up a local grade school and we're renting their gym for a couple of hours for not very much money. And we're going to let those kids descend and run around, which I think will buy us some peace, some peace before and after. Yeah, especially on the Northeast, it's often cold. And so you can't really do the like, all right, here's a football, everyone go play in the yard. Michelle, I love this idea. And a lot of listeners had different versions that she and her kids talk about the top three most important Christmas things to do.

13:06You ask your kids what they are. Everybody has their three. Maybe you don't do everybody's all three, but if somebody's appears on more than one list, you do. So she asked her kids for the top three Christmas things, and two of them were Watch Muppet Christmas Carol. Okay, I think I can arrange that pretty easily. Okay, yes. And to do a Christmas Eve dance party. Michelle says, we started this in Christmas 2020 because it was depressing because they weren't going to see anybody. They wanted to make it fun. So they had a Christmas Eve dance party. And now her kids are like, OK, number one, we're definitely doing our Christmas Eve dance party.

13:38And number two, we're watching a movie. I love this idea, too, because I think that we sometimes as the magic makers and the kinkeepers are like, oh, then we've got to have the screening of Rudolph. And then I've got to make that crab soup that I make. And then I've got to, you know, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I've got to do the special box that I wrap with new pajamas and packs of hot cocoa. That's a now thing that we've done. And I really like the idea of asking your kids, because I think there can be times where we're, this is the famous story that I've told many times that my grandmother told my mother, how could you have Thanksgiving without cream white onions?

14:16And my mother spent hours making cream white onions and passed them to my grandmother who said, oh, I don't really like them. Right. And it's like, right, you just think that there should be cream white onions on the table because you used to have them in 1911 on the table, you know? And I really like this idea of focusing in or in like, what are the things that are important? And we do a funny, they started during the pandemic too, this area, they have a dam that has like a little driving area around it. And there's drive-through, light-up, you know, silly things, like a light-up elf throwing presents and stuff.

14:49My kids still love it and they're teenagers, you know, but it's like that's part of our tradition. There's a restaurant we go to and like that's what we do. Yeah. And what it is, it isn't roasting chestnuts one by one, right? It's like driving them to see these lights. I think I can manage that. Okay, we'll be back with even more ways to do less and make more merry. Amy, when you take Nutrafol every day and you know that I do, every day can be a good hair day. So many good hair days around here, Margaret. Killing it. Nutrafol is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement brand.

15:23And it's the number one hair growth supplement brand personally used by dermatologists. Nutrafol supports hair health from within, working over time to deliver results you can see and feel. Nutrafol's hair growth supplements are peer-reviewed, NSF certified for sport and clinically tested. Nutrafol offers multiple formulas for men and women tailored to different life stages and lifestyle factors. so you get support that's actually right for you. Let your hair be one less thing to worry about. See visibly thicker, stronger, faster-growing hair in three to six months with Nutrafol. For a limited time, Nutrafol is offering our listeners$10 off your first month subscription and free shipping when you visit Nutrafol.com and enter promo code LAUGHING.

16:07That's Nutrafol.com, spelled N-U-T-R-A-F-O-L.com, promo code LAUGHING. Well, I'm coming in hot to say it is worth taking care of your skin. It's worth finding the right products to keep your skin smooth and hydrated. Let me tell you, I have tried many products, and time after time, I come back to Osea. Amy, same. Osea just sent us their anti-aging body balm to try. It combines the lasting hydration of a lotion with the firming power of a serum, leaving my skin smoother, firmer, and beautifully supple. Osea's body balm is clinically tested and designed to deliver visible results you can see and feel.

16:48Since using this product, I really have noticed firmer and smoother skin, backs of my hands, knees, elbows. It really helps. Get a spring-worthy glow with clean, clinically tested skincare from Osea. And right now, we have a special discount just for our listeners. Get 10 % off your first order site-wide with code FRESH at oseamalibu.com. That's 10 % off your first order site-wide with code FRESH at OSEAMALIBU.COM. It's way more fun to plan a summer vacation when you know exactly how you're going to afford it. That's why Margaret and I both love MonarchCore. MonarchCore is the personal finance app that tracks everything.

17:29Accounts, investments, savings goals, and spending. Right now, you can get your first year of MonarchCore for half off. Just$50 with the promo code FRESH. Monarch Core takes the mental load of your finances way down. When I log into the Monarch Core app, all the info is there, right at my fingertips. Most apps only tell you what you've already spent. Monarch Core helps you set goals and map out big purchases, like that summer vacation. Or you can even ask Monarch Core's AI assistant about your finances. How much did I spend on that vacation last summer? Or can I spend this much on this year's vacation without touching my savings?

18:06Use code FRESH at Monarch.com to get your first year of Monarch Corps half off at just$50. That's 50 % off your first year at Monarch.com with the code FRESH. This is another Amy. She has some very good advice. She says, I try to remember that some things will just be better once the kids are older. This is not the year to decorate a gingerbread house because they're too little. There is time for the complicated stuff and that time may be next year. I so second, third and fourth this and having kids who are grown someone was asking the other day about picky eaters on the Facebook group. And I thought I had the pickiest eaters in the world and Amy had older kids and would say I don't know they just grew out of it.

18:53I'm like, no, no, no. Tell me how tell me when tell me what date they stopped just eating a roll at Thanksgiving. And the reality is now I don't remember. But now my kids, I mean, I just put stuff on the table and they eat it, you know, and are there kids who don't still love salad? There are. And are there kids who there are certain things they will not eat? There are. But I do think that the making a gingerbread house is merry. If it's not, it's great to acknowledge that, you know? Right. Or leave it for next year or leave it for not this year. Although I will say Target and Trader Joe's both make gingerbread houses where everything's like pre-cut.

19:36I mean, they are easy. Like a five-year-old can do this with a little bit of advice. So it's like you're guaranteed to succeed if you get one of those gingerbread houses. It doesn't have to be ready for good housekeeping. Yeah. Although someone just gave us a Halloween-themed one very nicely. They came over for something and brought a Halloween-themed gingerbread house. A Halloween gingerbread house. And the amount of guilt I felt not assembling that Halloween gingerbread house, it crushed me. And then I finally just put it in the closet. And I was like, well, maybe we'll do it later. Or maybe one cold day in February, we'll make it.

20:08But we just didn't get to it. I'm sorry. Well, you have to be aware of that stuff, too, I think, right? Like my kids and their cousins used to get very complicated Lego things when they were really too young to put them together. And so it turned into watch my father-in-law put them together. And then somebody would bump it, you know, two hours into the process. And there'd be wretched sobbing because it fell apart. It's like, why are we getting a six-year-old a 7 ,000-piece Lego set? So they can watch their grandfather put it together. This doesn't seem like making Christmas bright. And while he like, yeah, says bad words.

20:43Exactly. Anna says, it's okay if everything isn't every year. Most years we decorate cookies, but sometimes we don't. We often do the zoo light tour, but sometimes we don't. You can do it next year if this year isn't the year. Make your absolutely must-do list very short. I love this. And this is, I go back to that suggestion of talking to your kids. I mean, I think that I sometimes feel, it's a famous story in my family where I had my grandmother and her sister both lived into their 90s. And when I was in high school, they were in their 90s. And I would go every Sunday as a high schooler and drive over and pick them up and take them to church and then take them to IHOP afterwards and then drive them home.

21:31It was like my good deed. I was like, polish up my halo. I'm going straight to heaven. Every Sunday, I'm taking grandma and Mary to church and IHOP. And then at some point, my grandmother said to my mother, oh, sweet Meg, she just loves IHOP. Like she didn't want to go. Like I was dragging them to the IHOP basically. And I think that you have to watch that you're not dragging people to the IHOP thinking you're doing such a good deed, you know? This was good advice I hadn't really considered. Tiffany says she tries to stay off social media more in December to avoid the feeling I should be doing all the things.

22:06We have plenty of fun things we already do. I don't want to feel the need to do more because of what others are sharing. I think this is definitely true. I mean, I live in New York City. And so you see people like, we're at the Rockettes. We're at the Nutcracker. Here we are. And then you think like, oh, shoot, I need to figure out a day for us to go to the Nutcracker. I mean, maybe, maybe next year, right? Maybe never. Maybe nobody really wants to go in your house. But if you look at social media, you feel like you have to be have all your kids in their matching tartan plaid outfits in front of the tree.

22:36Yeah. And then I think that sometimes when you do something, we my mother in law, and I took my daughter to the Nutcracker when she was maybe seven or eight. She was in the tartan plaid with the bow and the like big skirt. You're there for the gram. We were so there for the gram. We were taking pictures in front of the fountain at Lincoln Center and we went and we had a great time. And I do think maybe we went in 2019. And so then it was 2020 and there was no Nutcracker, whatever happened. But then it starts to, it can easily feel like now we go to the Nutcracker every year. Oh, we have to go to the Nutcracker.

23:12And my husband and I used to love in Los Angeles. They have a sing-along Messiah. They do Handel's Messiah with a beautiful chorale, but then you sing along with the big choruses. And we loved it. And then we moved to New York and, oh, well, what are we going to do about our sing-along Messiah? That's our tradition. We went to one in the city and it was genuinely not as fun. It just wasn't, I don't know, they didn't do it as well. For us, it wasn't the same. And the next year we're like, okay, we found ourselves sort of like painfully buying another round of tickets to the bad singalong messiah.

23:49And then we thought, we could just not go. We could just not go to the messiah. What about that concept? But it's funny how weirdly your brain is like must slog through the messiah singalong because it's what we do. I have like the opposite thing, an opportunity being presented to me right now for Christmas, which is in Brooklyn. There's a neighborhood in Brooklyn called Diker Heights where people just go ham with the Christmas decorations. I've never been. I've only heard about it. It's like that jingle all the way movie come to real life. And it's one of these things like, oh, it's bucket list.

24:25You have to go. You have to see the lights in Diker Heights, which for people who weren't from New York City, it's like an hour and 20 minutes from my apartment. You have to see the sights in North Carolina. Fly to Omaha to see the lights. Right. Like, okay, maybe I'd do that. So it's like, oh, yeah, I'll do that. Anyway, there's this fun, like, it's called Grab Your Group and Go. And I love it. And it's in New York, like, grab your group and go. We're going to go to this museum. We're going to go to this show. And so they're like, we're doing it. We have a bus. We're going to Diker Heights. There will be cocktails served on the bus.

24:53Grab your women friends. We are going to Diker Heights. And now it's like being handed to me. All I have to do is show up and get on the bus. That's your dream. You're like, I want the magic, but I don't want to make the magic. Your dream is real. I don't want to make the magic. Right. Right. But now I'm like, do I want to go? So I'm going. I'm telling you guys, I'm going because I know if I do, I'm going to come back like, you have to go see these lights. And right, I'm being given a very easy opportunity to go if I want to. And I think that's also a good question, because I do find myself and I think it is lingering from the pandemic a little bit.

25:23I don't want to. I don't want to. You know, I mean, we're doing our live shows and stuff. And it is, it's much harder to get an audience to come out to stuff. It's interesting, because I just think that people have fallen in love with their sofas. God bless them. Their sofas are comfy and there's good stuff on TV. I get it. But I think the flip side of you don't have to go to the Nutcracker every year is watch the story of I don't want to do anything. Like, are you just falling out of the habit of would it be fun to all pile in the car and put on the horrible Christmas. This light show that we go to has a radio station that plays Christmas music, but it's like Backstreet Boys singing some song that's called Don't Miss Me Santa.

Read the full transcript

26:13I mean, it's torture, basically. But it is fun. And so I think you have to balance those two things. We need a new album. There was that Christmas covers album. It was from the 80s with Run DMC and Whitney Houston and stuff. And they're still playing that song. Like it's a great album. Do you hear what I hear? That was Whitney. Right. And they still play those like eight songs every year because we don't have a new one. We need like a Billie Eilish. I think we might be old. No offense. But I think there are like when I turn on like the Christmas station, it's a lot of Carrie Underwood. And I just think.

26:49Right. Right. This is sacrilege. Where is Nat King Cole? I like the oldies. Nobody's had. I mean, Mariah's got the market covered with. all I want for Christmas is you. No one else has been able to break that market. It might just be that might just be all I need. Maybe I just need to put that on and get in that holiday spirit. Yeah, I like I really like here's an insider tip. Josh Groban has a great Christmas album. I love it. I mean, I love his voice, but he's got a really good one. Anyway, like you're right getting myself on this bus to go look at these Christmas lights. I'm sure it will be like a laugh and a half and I'll come back.

27:23Glad I went just like when you go to any show or museum or whatever. Like, I'm glad I did that. No, it's like going to the gym. You have to push through a little bit and that it doesn't seem right because there's also sunken cost fallacy where you think, well, I have to go and be miserable the whole time because I bought tickets. You don't have to go. Right. But watch that story that is I'm already I already took my bra off. Like, you'd be happy going to take. I just want to stay. I'm going to call. I'm going to be your phone a friend and call you and be like, you have to go. You have to go get on the bus.

27:53Are you on the bus? Hannah says you have to be careful of what you think you should be doing. She says for her family, zoo lights, hell no. It sounds like it will be fun. This is Hannah talking. Sounds like it will be fun, but really it's cold, wet, crowded, and often the kids are too tired and overstimulated. It comes down to focusing less on what is supposed to be fun and being honest about what will actually feel festive and not sweaty and yelling at each other. I mean, you're going to have some of that, by the way. If you have kids under 10, you're going to have sweaty and non-festive moments during the holidays.

28:27Well, that's it. Like this bus to Diker Heights to look at the lights, there's no four-year-olds on this bus. You know, it's all like ladies with cocktails. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And I do think if you have multiple kids, I mean, I had three very closely spaced. My kids are 18 months apart. The probability of three of them having a great time was pretty much zero for four years. You know, you had to kind of take some pain to do any of it. Was somebody going to be screaming and crying and hiding between your legs and being like, I don't like that Santa? Yes, that will happen. 100%. 100 % chance.

29:02Jessica has really good advice. She says, I try to cut down on the other stuff. No doctor's appointments or dentist appointments in December. We don't do extracurriculars in December when we can. I try to take as much of the other stuff off our plates. Yeah, because it's true that when you have older kids, you also have like midterm exams. I mean, and the Christmas concert. Concerts, right. And the other concert. You really don't need to add a lot of activities. Like you're going to be sitting there through the like beard so white, snow so white, whatever, like Christmas concert. and if you've got three kids like I do, you're going to three of them and then you've got a lot of studying and reviewing and fine and midterms and that's right.

29:50It's already, it's funny. I have a couple of people who I've been meaning to catch up with and I'm like, well, I guess now I have to do it in January. Like I certainly am not going to catch up with them in December. Yeah. It's already the can we push season. Yeah. Let's talk about that. I remember joking mid-August that I I was like, well, Happy New Year, everyone, because it does like back to school slides right into Halloween, slides right into Thanksgiving, Christmas, holidays, and it's New Year's. Yeah. Okay, we'll be back with even more ideas for less doing and more magic.

30:24Do you hear that? Sounds like breakfast is ready. because Quaker's coming in hot with morning nutrition, 100 % whole grain oats, and a good source of fiber to fuel the rhythm of your morning and kickstart your day. And that sounds absolutely delicious. Fuel to start whatever's next. Quaker, official sponsor of FIFA World Cup 26. I, oh, let's go! Study and play. Come together on a Windows 11 PC. And for a limited time, college students get the best of both worlds. Get the Unreal College deal. Everything you need to study and play with select Windows 11 PCs. Eligible students get a year of Microsoft 365 Premium and a year of Xbox Game Pass Ultimate with a custom color Xbox wireless controller.

31:15Learn more at windows.com slash student offer. While supplies last, ends June 30th. Terms at aka.ms slash college PC.

31:25And now, eight things that will happen to you this holiday season from the What Fresh L podcast. Number eight, your suggestion that your kids should add books to their holiday list because they might not be as exciting right away, but will yield deeper and more meaningful results in the long run was ignored again. Number seven, your child's performance of Snowy Day on the bassoon is somehow once again dead last on the holiday concert schedule. You'll be sitting through every other grades program before it starts, no matter what grade they happen to be in. We don't know how that's possible, but it is.

32:04Number six, you forgot to move Elf on the shelf, even though you spent two hours on Pinterest yesterday looking at cute ideas. Number five, your spouse has done all of his Christmas shopping in 25 minutes. You won't know who he has forgotten until it is too late. It is you who will be in trouble. Number four, your demand of only one big item per holiday list was interpreted very loosely by your offspring. Number three, when anyone describes how magical their holiday was, you will mutter under your breath, that was me. It was me all along. Number two, you will read your child's wish list and realize that somehow they think you make$25 million.

32:44a year. Number one, you will promise yourself that this year there is absolutely no reason to overdo it. No reason to overpurchase, over nog, over everything. And you will overdo it anyway. This has been eight things that will happen to you this holiday season. From the What Fresh Hell podcast. Amy, I like this idea from Elizabeth. We focus on our immediate family during the holidays and put are major travel to see families at other times of the year that are more conducive to travel and having a fun time summer and be not already packed with crazy school events. Also summer. I mean, this goes back to what I was saying before about in Pennsylvania in November on a, you know, rainy morning in the 40s, you need to figure out somewhere for all these kids to go.

33:38They can't just go in the yard. Or maybe they can if you're a thousand hours outside kind of family. But yes, might get some resistance. So anyway, but yeah, it's bad weather. Yeah, yeah. So yeah, it's these things are easier in the summer when you're not also supposed to be at the other person's house and the other person's house and the party. Yeah, but this also makes me think that one of the things we haven't discussed in this how we're making decisions and the decision tree, is that there are a lot of expectations that other people have at this season. So it's not just you saying, we have to watch Rudolph because that's our tradition.

34:13It's also often everyone in your extended family saying, well, we have to be together, we have to see you during this season. And those boundaries, and this is a whole discussion that we've had on a bunch of other episodes, you have to really talk those things through, I think, because, you know, people saying, well, you have to this and you have to that. It's not always just as easy as saying, like, we've set our boundaries and no, and we're just doing immediate family, you can definitely do that. But I mean, I know for our family, we try to alternate with what my husband's family or my family every year.

34:57And that's what works for us. And then, you know, on one side, we have two separate families. So it's like, okay, who's seeing who when and keeping things balanced. And then if you have large extended families, as we do, the gift thing gets very quickly out of control. And it becomes kind of, as you've said, like the great gift card exchange, like here's your best by and exchange, here's your cheesecake factory or whatever. And the kind of, I think it's worth having conversations about different people's needs and working from your place of maximum generosity that sometimes it's easy to kind of demonize the other people in that story and like, oh, that person always wants this and we need to set our boundaries, which I'm not, it sounds like I'm making fun of, but like, I just think everybody does have different needs, you know, and these are people's parents, you know, who've had always spent their time with their kids at the holidays.

36:01And you can absolutely make any choices you want. But I think it's worth just a discussion about what the expectations are, and whether or not those expectations can be reasonably met. This gets really hard. I mean, I remember so well when the kids were very little, right? Like the new baby at Christmas, the nativity child that's in your arms that's going from this one's house to that one's house and whoever's house you're not at, they're asking you when you're getting there and the house that you are at, they're saying you're leaving already. It can be really extra stressful to be letting somebody down.

36:39Like, what do you mean you're leaving and whoever is on her way over to see the baby. And it can be hard to be in a series of situations where you're letting somebody down, even though you're really trying your best. But that doesn't mean you shouldn't do what's best for you. And with young kids, there's so many expectations around, they're gonna love this, they're gonna love it. And spoiler alert, they're gonna cry. They're not gonna love it. My grandmother, she's coming up a lot today on the podcast. She famously crocheted my brother and worked on it for months, a Santa Claus, and it had bells.

37:16It was like a kind of stretchy Santa, and it had bells on the hands. And she must have worked on it for months. And it really was objectively an amazing piece of craft work. And it was presented on Christmas morning. And my brother was, of course, terrified of it, to the degree that he cried the whole time. And then when she tried to leave, when she left for the night, chased her down the street being like, you forgot this. He really didn't want it in the house. He was terrified of it. And I think lots of people are good at handling those situations. And lots of people are, you know, we told it as a funny story, but sometimes people get their feelings hurt about things.

37:54And they're the expectation. I mean, my famously, we had a Christmas where my parents had bought the grandchildren bicycles, you know, and it was the big like this is the year you're old enough for bikes. So here are two or three bikes under the Christmas tree that you know, I'm sure were expensive. And the kids came down and there were also Pokemon cards with the bicycles. That was like another thing under the tree. And they practically pushed the bikes out of the way to get to the Pokemon cards. And that's all they cared about. They didn't, their eyes did not linger for a second on these bikes.

38:27And I think all you can do with those situations is talk in advance and say, I know my kid would love the full set of this set of books, but understand that their Christmas reaction is not going to be as great as if you bought them 9 ,000 Hershey bars wrapped up or whatever. Key ring nonsense, yeah. Yeah, or whatever cushy or flippy toy that they, you know. Squishmallow of the day. Like they will actually read these books for five years and they will add a tremendous amount of value to their lives. But are you OK with the fact that on Christmas morning, if you want the, you know, jack in the box joy of seeing them grab something and hug it and run around, then get them a Squishmallow.

39:18That's what you should get them. I do think that giving visibility on the overall experience is important. This is funny. I hadn't really thought about this. But like in our own family, there was a year that a beautiful handcrafted rocking horse with somebody's name on it was given as the like, they're gonna love it gift. Reader, they did not love it. You know, they wanted to play with the Star Wars thing. They moved right on to the Star Wars Legos. Right. That was not. And so when the same people who have come up with like the love this crochet Santa and they don't are now hounding you for please just tell me what they actually want.

39:58And you're like, stop bothering me. It does come out of the I just want them to be happy. Right. And I think the whole time of the year is a good time for maximum generosity in terms of those things. And, you know, that's right. The grandma who's maybe calling you in October to be like, well, what do they want? What do they want? You're like, are you kidding me? I am still sewing a Raggedy Ann costume. Right, right, right. Right. They've had the experience of they want to just make it joyful. And I think you can also work with your kids on this. And this is something as your kids get older, you can have the meeting on Christmas Eve and say, listen, tomorrow's going to be really exciting.

40:42You're going to get a lot of exciting things that you want, and some things that you don't want, and some things that you aren't as excited about now, but you'll be excited about later. You have one job on Christmas, which is making everyone who's gone out of their way to get you something feel good about that effort. That's your job. You're going to receive a lot and you have one thing to give, which is your joy, even if you don't feel it in the exact moment. Now, you can't really do that with like a three-year-old who's getting the rocking horse. That's people have to understand. And some people, for the record, definitely don't and will be really, really mad.

41:18Emily says one way to make things easier is to try deciding once and keep notes, she says, so you can adjust over the years and let muscle memory take over. So I do have a Christmas spreadsheet that I use every year. Yeah, and you just start over and erase everything that was in column B and you're starting over, but you have your list already. You're not going to forget somebody. And of course, living in New York, you have different, everybody's got like, oh, I have to think of the woman who colors my hair, right? and the, you know, my kid's karate teacher, what am I going to get for them? In New York, that's even more because you have the people who work in apartment buildings and things.

41:53So I have a long list of those people, but I have it ready to go. And that's the kind of thing that you can outsource to your kids. This needs to happen. As a family, we're going to thank these people. Here you go. Here's a pen, get writing. Get here, pick up a pen, start writing. Yeah, Yeah, absolutely. Maybe that's about really spreading out the less work, more magic. I mean, kids are excited about doing the magic part, right? About the like leaving out the cookies with their toddler cousin. That part's exciting. It's a little less exciting to get them excited about writing tip envelopes for their baseball coach.

42:32but that makes it better for you. And I think it's always okay for older kids. I mean, to see that there is work, that it feels magic, but it's not, it's not actually magic. There's a lot of hard work involved and appreciation that has to go into it, which can be hard for kids to detach from that. I think that, you know, we've talked a lot about that. I feel like this is one thing I've really changed my mind about by doing the podcast is like, what are our family values. Really having that conversation, knowing what you value, and then kind of running stuff past that list. Like, well, my family value is that family comes first, but we have eight kids in 23 sports, so we never see each other.

43:14Okay, that's in conflict with our family values. Are we making that decision in a short term? Like, just actually thinking things through and not letting life kind of carry you along. And I think that it's really worth doing that. I'm really going to do that after this conversation is sit down with my family and say, what do we want this Christmas to look like? And then for yourself saying, what do I want Christmas to look like? Do I want it to look like everybody's happy but me? Do I want it to look like the SNL skit, I got a robe, you know? Or is it worth saying to my family, I'm going to make all these cookies, I'm going to organize the decorations.

43:51I'm going to do all of these things. But I'd love you all, and say it in front of your spouse, like I'd love you all to really think about how you can make it great for me or whatever. Like having these conversations, I think that's where a lot of the rub comes in is sort of skipping the part where we say, what if we could really think about what this looks like? Cassie says make sure you're doing the highest leverage things and I have the perfect example of this couple Christmases ago there is a kind of cookie from the part of Pennsylvania where I'm from it's called a pepper cookie and I've looked at it I think it's really actually like from my area maybe I'll find a good recipe for you I'll put the link in the show notes because it's amazing it's kind of like having a chai tea flavored cookie it does have a little bit of pepper in it It has like 24 ingredients.

44:42And I decided that I was going to make Christmas bright one year by making these pepper cookies, which require sifting flour and adding approximately 7 ,000 things, right? In my mother-in-law's house, by the way. So I do this, I make these incredibly complicated cookies, and they're cooling. And then another relative walks in with a bag of these pepper cookies purchased at the local bakery. Well, guess which ones everybody ate, right? Well, I seized with rage that nobody wanted to eat the pepper cookies that I spent two hours making because the ones from the bakery were better because they know how to make them.

45:18That was not a high leverage activity for me. Nobody cared about it but me. Everybody was happy to eat the ones from the bakery. You know, had I checked with my family, it was a priority to nobody that I make these incredibly complicated cookies. And then I was mad nobody wanted them. Yeah, the definite lane that you're looking to avoid is everybody's having fun but you. And everybody's merry and you're absolutely miserable. They're reading those pepper cookies instead of my pepper cookies that I work so hard on. Yeah. And I think that, you know, we've talked about this. It's a very difficult balance.

45:55And I don't like it when it becomes like, well, just do less, mom. You're putting it all on yourself, mom. That's not true. Drew, you're the kinkeeper. You are being looked to to create all of this wonder. But our only locus of control is figuring out what our limits and our joyfulness comes from. I was just thinking during the pandemic, we went ice skating at Rockefeller Center under the tree, the five of us. And now we've been doing it every year. And it's incredibly expensive. It's really expensive. And that's one that's worth sitting down and saying, where are we enjoying this on a level of 1 to 10?

46:33Because if we do this, we're going to cut out some other stuff. Because driving through the belly of the beast lights probably costs$25. And going to Rockefeller Center probably costs$500. So are we making the right choices? But if you skip the conversation, you're never going to know. I have one more really practical one before we wrap up. Put a sticker on the best wrapped present and open it last. This is like the one thing that has ruined Christmas many times at our house. So that if you know you're getting your kids, you know, socks, underwear, some school supplies, and an iPod, iPod, what am I, 9 million, and a laptop or whatever, the big thing they want.

47:16Put a sticker on the laptop, know where the laptop is, hide it behind the tree. In your building. And make sure that gets opened last. Because we've often had the Christmas where like one kid's last gift is, you know, a new guitar, and the other kid's last gift is underwear or socks. And it leaves us with a bad feeling. Put a sticker, save the best gift for last. My takeaway, I'm going to go with what Michelle says. She says, I ask myself, what do I want my kids to remember about the holidays growing up and try to focus my attention there? And it makes me think when you're talking about the ice skating at Rockefeller Center.

47:51I mean, your kids will have that memory and they'll love it. And so maybe it's worth leaning into. And maybe it's like, okay, but they'll have that memory. We've done it. We don't need to keep doing it. We've checked that box. Or they might say it's the most important thing in their Christmas season for all three of them. And then you say, OK, I guess we're going to do it. But you check. You make sure. Yeah, because you don't. It's always surprising. We've done for people's birthdays and stuff like people write stories about the person. It's like a little birthday book with a lot of stories. And everyone who's had one done always says how surprising it is.

48:26What the thing. We did one for my dad and one of the nieces said, whenever we went, he would be setting up the volleyball net when we got there. Like he always remembered he was always trying to make it fun for us. He said, I have no memory of ever doing that. I don't. And like, that's where I think it's so great to have these conversations and say, what is fun? What is magic? And you definitely don't want your own memories of the holiday to be like Christmas stinks. Everyone has fun with me. That's right. That's right. Make more magic. Yeah, make the right magic. Make the high value magic, the high leverage magic.

49:06Work magic-er, not harder. There you go, Amy. You have indeed solved it. Do you subscribe to our newsletter about once a month? You subscribe to it. Yeah, so do I. I do. I subscribe. I love to hear what we're up to. Well, I mean, if you want to know what we're up to, what book events I might have coming up, what Fresh Health Live shows we might have coming up, where else you can find us, we send it once a month. We're not going to hound you. It's the perfect way to find out, oh, you know what else we put in there? Things that we're watching and reading and things. It's not, you won't hear it on the podcast.

49:41You only get it in the newsletter. And here's how you get it. You go to whatfreshhealthpodcast.com. There's a link in the sidebar. you sign up or we'll put the link in the show notes for this episode. Get the newsletter once a month and then you'll never have to like wonder if the Facebook algorithm is showing you that cool episode with the great guest or not. Love it. Everyone go subscribe. And with that, happy holidays. Go make magic, everyone. Leverage that high value magic. And we'll talk to you next week. So long.

50:43Thank you. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law.

From the publisher

For the holidays, we’re re-running some of our very favorite holiday-themed episodes! It's hard not to feel like we've got to be doing ALL the things at the holidays, especially when social media tells us we should be. Here are some tips for taking perspective at the holidays and operating in "high magic, low effort" mode. We discuss:

pre-gaming with your (older) kids about the preferred responses to less-preferred gifts

starting with what family members really do love most about the holidays (their answers will surprise you)

why you don't have to go the Nutcracker, or lights at the zoo, or Aunt Martha's house, this year, let alone every year

Rosie Colosi for Today Parents: ⁠⁠Moms are challenging the idea that they are the sole keepers of holiday ‘magic’⁠⁠

SNL's "Christmas Morning" sketch: ⁠https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FOVCtUdaMCU⁠

⁠Read all of our listeners' great advice on the original Facebook thread⁠... and here, as promised, is Amy's recipe for the⁠ Italian pepper cookies⁠ that seem to be unique to northeast Pennsylvania...

Italian Pepper Cookies (makes about 72 cookies, more if they’re small)

1/2 cup Crisco 

2 cups of milk or water (or more if needed) If dough is really sticky you can add a little bit more of milk

1/2 lb. raisins 

1 cup cocoa

2 1/2 cups sugar

4 tbsp. baking powder

7 cups of flour (add more if needed)

1 1/2 tsps. cinnamon

1 1/2 tsps. cloves (not whole)

1 1/2 tsp. vanilla

1 1/2 tsps. black pepper (if you don't want them too spicy, you can cut back on the pepper, I never do though)

Optional, you can add nuts or I've seen people add chocolate chips too. We aren't big nut eaters, so I've never made them with nuts.

Preheat oven to 375

Cream sugar and Crisco together in a bowl 

In a different bowl, sift together all the dry ingredients. Add sifted dry ingredients to creamed sugar and Crisco alternately with milk.

Mix well. It will be very sticky, it's easier to work with your hands. I usually coat my hands with some Pam to be able to work the dough. Add your raisins and mix it up more. 

Using your hands, take enough dough to roll a small ball (my mom likes them big, I like them smaller) Place cookie balls on your cookie trays (I usually fit around 16 on a tray, all depends on the size of your cookie balls) 

Bake in oven for 8-10 minutes.

Icing:

2 cups confectioner's sugar

1 to 2 tablespoons milk

1/2 teaspoon butter

splash vanilla

For icing: Mix together all ingredients, adding milk until achieving creamy consistency, not stiff.

When cookies are slightly cooled, top with icing.

Sign up for the What Fresh Hell newsletter! Once a month you’ll get our favorite recent episodes, plus links to other things to read and watch and listen to, and upcoming special events: ⁠http://eepurl.com/h8ze3z⁠

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website:

⁠https://www.whatfreshhellpodcast.com/p/promo-codes/⁠

Get 50% Off Monarch Money, the all-in-one financial tool at ⁠www.monarchmoney.com/FRESH

Ready to raise money-smart kids? Start now with your first month FREE at acornsearly.com/FRESH!

What Fresh Hell is co-hosted by Margaret Ables and Amy Wilson.

Christmas, Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, Santa, Elf on the Shelf, gift exchange, holiday, holiday shopping, holiday gifts, mom friends, funny moms, parenting advice, parenting experts, parenting tips, mothers, families, parenting skills, parenting strategies, parenting styles, busy moms, self-help for moms, manage kid’s behavior, teenager, toddler, holiday recipes
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from What Fresh Hell: Parenting, Relationships, and Making Life Better, with Two Funny Moms

All 197 episodes
Best of: How to Be in "High Magic, Low Effort" Mode This Holiday SeasonWhat Fresh Hell: Parenting, Relationships, and Making Life Better, with Two Funny Moms · 48 min
Listen in VO