


28 Oct 2026 · 42m · 11 chapters

The episode explains “weaponized incompetence” (doing tasks badly on purpose so others take over) and “weaponized passivity” (stepping back so completely that someone else must take ownership), plus “weaponized irritability” (complying but making the task unpleasant so people stop asking). It argues these behaviors keep a “vacuum” of labor that someone else fills, often tied to gendered expectations and “mental load” dynamics.
Margaret Ables and Amy Wilson (hosts). No other guests appear as interviewees; Astrid is referenced via her Substack “Ask Astrid,” and Sam Kelly is referenced via “Notice and Do.”
Jared Samberg coined “strategic incompetence” (WSJ, 2007); the terms spread widely during the pandemic/TikTok. Passivity can be harder to challenge because it looks like indifference.
a temp worker asked to obtain $300 petty cash; a spouse struggling with an unfamiliar washer; Elizabeth Holmes scenes from “The Dropout” (eggs, “I don’t care about money”); “Fair Play” card loophole (“I don’t care”); beach lunch decisions; women carrying sheets on vacation; “notice and do” vs irritability (slamming pots).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the origins and implications of weaponized incompetence.
“Today, we're talking about one thing that I think I know exactly what it is, and one thing that was completely new to me researching this episode.”
Sharing personal experiences and examples of strategic incompetence at work.
“But it actually started, as so many things we talk about do, in the business world.”
Exploring how gender roles manifest in weaponized incompetence and passivity.
“Like, I'm just going to go home, eat the one hour that I've worked for you and sign up with a different tendency tomorrow and start again.”
Introduction to the concept of weaponized passivity and its implications.
“So that's weaponized incompetence and our kids do it.”
Explore the concept of weaponized passivity through examples and personal anecdotes.
“Again, I'm not giving away any of the crazy twists, but she just with her doe eyes says, I don't care about money.”
Discuss the importance of equitable contribution in household tasks and the impact of annoyance.
“And I have asked the question on the podcast.”
Analyze how societal norms shape the distribution of tasks between genders in households.
“The number of times I find myself in a situation in 2026 where the men are relaxing and the women are working and I almost like I'm in it before I realize it.”
Explore the dynamics of household responsibilities and passivity in relationships.
“And I do think that I can, in the realm of garbage, be like magically the garbage makes it to the curb on Wednesday mornings.”
Discuss strategies to address and challenge passivity and caretaking in family dynamics.
“You are at least a week late on putting up those spooky decorations.”
Exploring the concept of weaponized passivity in family dynamics and decision-making.
“Then came Thanksgiving and my mother had, you know, of course, done the 50 steps and made the cream white onions.”
Encouraging listeners to share the episode and engage with the show on social media.
“I'm going to put the link to Astrid on Substack.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On What Fresh Hell: Parenting, Relationships, and Making Life Better, with Two Funny Moms, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Heidi Rose: This year, set up your holiday gifting with a little extra magic. The perfect shoes from Designer Shoe Warehouse. DSW's got holiday gifts and stocking stuffers for everyone on your list. And tis the season for a little self-gifting, too. Whether you bake all day, dance all night, carol all over town, or tiptoe under the mistletoe, DSW is your Designer Shoe wonderland for comfy slippers, joyful party shoes, statement boots, and more. Shop in-store or visit DSW.com. DSW. Let us surprise you.
0:32We were making sourdough and learning the phrase weaponized incompetence. What fresh hell. Laughing in the face of motherhood.
0:41Heidi Rose: This is an episode about petty cash. With Margaret Ables. And Amy Wilson. Don't invite me to parties. A podcast that solves today's parenting dilemmas. So you don't have to. I'm not the washer whisperer any more than you.
1:02Hello, everyone, and welcome to What Fresh Hell? Laughing in the face of motherhood.
1:05Heidi Rose: This is Margaret. And this is Amy. Today, we're talking about one thing that I think I know exactly what it is, and one thing that was completely new to me researching this episode. That is weaponized incompetence and weaponized passivity. Ooh, I'm very familiar with the first, like you, and not as familiar with the second. Here we go. We're going to learn about this. Yes. And this is something that is in our kids, in our partners, in our co-workers, in ourselves, and in some very surprised guests. You're going to love my references, the examples I have for you today. What do you hear them? I'm fired up and ready to go, Amy.
1:41Heidi Rose: So weaponizing competence, it was really during the pandemic I found out going back to who coined this term. Where did it come from? It exploded during the pandemic. But it actually started, as so many things we talk about do, in the business world. Oh. Isn't that interesting? Like things are worthy of consideration and I think publication when they happen at work. Jared Samberg in 2007 wrote an article for the Wall Street Journal where he circled what he called strategic incompetence in the workplace. Okay. And the examples in the article were all the guys at work who pretend not to know how to change the toner ink.
2:16Heidi Rose: It just was all bosses in this article. Like, I get, you know, a happy work week because I pretend not to know how to do any of that stuff. And I have an example of this. I was temping. I was working for somebody whose, you know, assistant was gone on our honeymoon, I think. And he was leaving on a business trip. I had been working there for like seven minutes. And he calls me into his office like, I need this. I need this. And I need$300 in petty cash. Oldie locks alert. Back in my day, you needed to get cash to spend on a trip because I don't know. I don't know why. This was a long time ago.
2:46You couldn't tap your phones against stuff. You couldn't beep and boop. Right. You couldn't beep and boop. You could spend your own money and then get reimbursed. But there was also petty cash that was like, I'm going to be taking cabs and stuff and I'm not fronting the company money. Yeah, that's what it was. Plenty of places didn't take a credit card. Right. A cab didn't take a credit card back in the day. Let me tell you about a world, youngs, where calves, you had to pay with something called cash.
3:10Heidi Rose: This is an episode about petty cash. So anyway, I just got there. You need to do this. You need to do that. And you need to get me$300 from petty cash and I need it by 1130. So I go back to my desk. I've just got there. Right. You're like, sir, I'm an aspiring actress. You're laying quite a lot at my feet. I have one job, get the petty cash. But like I'm sitting by myself in a like group of open plan desks, but there's nobody around, you know, phones ringing and nobody answering them. And I'm like, what, what am I going to do? I'm going to wait for somebody to happen by a woman. I'm going to give this guy$300 cash.
3:42Right. Right. I'm going to the ATM. I'm going to the ATM so I don't get in trouble. So it got to be about 11 and I know he's leaving at 1130.
3:50Heidi Rose: So I have to be like, knock, knock, knock. Um, hi, sir. Um, I know you want me to get petty cash. Like, where do I go to do that? He blew up at me. You know, I don't have time for this. And I was so upset. And as I'm going to the other floor that I realized he doesn't know how to get petty cash. This is stuff he just hands off and doesn't think about. And he's furious that I don't know, but he's really furious because he can't tell me because he doesn't even know. So I think that's a little bit of weaponized incompetence. I have to just take a quick side road to be like that happened to me like three times at temp jobs.
4:21And whenever anyone would yell at me, I would just get in the elevator and go home. I'd be like, goodbye. You don't seem to understand the economics of this situation. Like, I'm just going to go home, eat the one hour that I've worked for you and sign up with a different tendency tomorrow and start again. Right, right. Exactly. I don't make enough for you to be yelling at me.
4:42Heidi Rose: Yeah. Even at my young people-pleasing age that I was in, I could see like, oh, this guy would suck to work for a good thing I don't. Right. And by the way, it's going to take you an hour to realize I've left and you're going to miss your flight. So I hope you have a good day, you idiot. Hope this was worth it for you, dopo. So this was strategic incompetence and it happened at work. And then in 2021, during the pandemic, a little unclear who called it this first weaponized incompetence. And it was all over on TikTok as we were all stuck home with everybody we lived with. We were making sourdough and learning the phrase weaponized incompetence.
5:17Heidi Rose: Yes. Doing something badly on purpose so that you never have to do it again. Like not rinsing the dishes and putting them in the dishwasher and they come out all crusty. Now she won't make me love the dishwasher ever again. Your kid, your spouse, whoever it is. And not to get all it's the patriarchy all the way down. But I think in the petty cash example and in many examples, it's an unpleasant task. But there's also a certain air of it's a task that's beneath me to figure out. Yes. And it's a task that women are naturally better at. We know these things. The women here know where the petty cash is.
5:53That's part of it, too. Thinking about the yelling guy. I've always thought about it as like you don't want to do it and therefore you act like you can't figure it out. But I'm also seeing more that there's a role in it that's like this is women's work. This is lowly work. Right. And therefore I can't be bothered with it even more than I can't figure it out, although it's manifested and I can't figure it out.
6:19Heidi Rose: And yes, and sometimes it's, I mean, I think it's all there, but I think sometimes it's unintentional. I just was on vacation with my spouse. We're visiting people and we need to do some laundry. We were in Europe, so it was an unfamiliar washer and dryer. And so he said, can you help me with the washer? Because I am magically better at figuring out a washer that neither of us have seen before. Yes. Than him. You know what I mean? And like he thought that and I thought that. I'm like, oh, let me go figure this out. I'm not the washer whisperer any more than you. But we've existed in this world where everybody assumes that I am.
6:52Heidi Rose: I'm naturally more capable of figuring out appliances. I want to go back and clarify that when I say it's kind of beneath me, I don't think that's a conscious choice. It's like it's not usually category of things that my advanced brain can't come down to. Not talking about your husband in the washer, but the thing of like, I couldn't possibly figure out how to get out a dustpan and broom and get rid of garbage because that's a different kind of person's job than mine. Right. And then we get into women just see mess better. You're just better at this. You just like things a certain way. Right. All those excuses that kind of come up in this.
7:32Heidi Rose: So that's weaponized incompetence and our kids do it. And I just saw a reel today. Got to bring it up. Elizabeth Holmes and you can see everything. Guys, if you haven't seen it, what a ride. What a ride. It's so good. And this woman is explaining how Elizabeth Holmes, I'm going to try not to give anything in the movie away, but there is a scene where she's beating eggs to scramble them. And she's doing it in a rather lackluster way and somebody else takes over. And this person was like, that's the perfect example of weaponized incompetence. And it's funny because most people see that scene very differently as a controlling person taking over a task that was being done just fine.
8:08Heidi Rose: But I did think that was interesting that this woman was interpreting it as a female, expressing like, oh, I just can't stir the eggs right. So you'll just take over and do it because you just know how to do it better. You just know how to do it better. Yeah. Yeah. I'm also going to say that as I love to point, point, point my finger outwards, I definitely do this. I don't feed the cats in our house to the point where like if everyone's away, I have a moral debate about whether or not it's okay to let cats starve for an evening because I am, I think, more sensitive. And I have one kid who I would say we're more sensitive to smells and grossness than other people in the family.
8:47But it is a little bit like I can't do that. It is outside of my realm. Similarly garbage. I feel that I have a lower grossness threshold than other people in my household. But that's just a definition that I've probably created. Like, I'm sure no one likes to put their hands in the sink where lettuce and pieces of spaghetti are floating around. But I'm like, I can't. I can't. It's too gross. For me, I literally cannot. But you can because you're braver and have a less good sense of smell. I actually, as I'm saying that out loud, I believe that to be true. But like Elizabeth Holmes, you believe what you're saying to be true, even though it's demonstrably false?
9:28I'm internally delusional, I think is what I'm saying. But yes, I definitely am weaponizedly incompetent at feeding the cats, sticking my hand in a sink of dirty water and taking the garbage out.
9:40Heidi Rose: And the reason it's weaponized, like the weaponized part of this, just to underline that, is that means you're like, oh, I can't. I'm so bad at this. I'm so bad at scrambling eggs or whatever. Right. Means the other person has to do it. Right. I'm especially sensitive to the grossness of food floating in water. I mean, that's insane when I say it out loud. Like, nobody likes to do that. Right. So that's weaponized incompetence. And you're right. We all do this. I'm like that when, you know, there's a flat tire. You know, me, just a little lady who doesn't know how to do things. See me when a rat's in the house, Amy.
10:13Heidi Rose: Ooh. But now, new and improved, there's weaponized passivity. I loved this idea. Hit me. I mean, I think I can get it from context clues, but tell me. We're going to be talking a lot about a substack by Ask Astrid. Astrid is a communications researcher at the University of Vienna, and she has a great substack called Ask Astrid. So I'm going to link to this. So she talks about this idea. This is her idea of weaponized passivity, or at least she's calling it that way. So there's weaponized incompetence. She sets that up and then she's like, there's also weaponized passivity and we don't talk about it enough as a separate thing.
10:47Heidi Rose: She defines it as the act of stepping back so completely that someone else has no choice but to step forward. Oh, I get it. Yeah. And it's not like I'm so grossed up by weird smells. I can't do it. It's I don't care what's for dinner. I'm easy. I'll eat whatever. I'll go wherever for vacation. Right. I don't care what you get my mom for Christmas. I don't care. It's fine. I don't care what you get my mom for Christmas. Right. Or I don't care if we get my mom something. That's more like it, right? Like, oh, I don't care. And it's like, well, who's going to get blamed when your mom doesn't have a Christmas present on the tree?
11:21Or like, who's going to feel the stab in their heart if you see the mom's face on Christmas and your husband is happily drinking eggnog and you're taking the emotional blow that he's not even aware of? That's right.
11:34Heidi Rose: So it's the, I'm easy. This is the, I go with the flow. You know, we need to find a place that will take a table for 14 in the next half hour. Where is that going to be? I'll do whatever. It is couched in the language of generosity and cooperation. Yes. And it is not really either of those things. It's disengagement is a virtue. This is Astrid's quote. I'm like, that's it. And also, I think it also plays into the kinkeeping idea that we've talked about. It sure does. The thing of like, oh, she's so extra. But making the holidays at your house warm and memorable and cozy and filled with core memories is the very important work of building families.
12:23And for everyone else to sit around and be like, oh, there she goes again with her crazy Christmas decorating, it undercuts the value of the work. And it's like, okay, hey, will you all want to sit in bare room and stare at each other any crackers on Christmas morning? I don't think you're going to be happy. Right. You're not neutral. You're just happy that someone else is doing it. And you're then taking this extra step of goofing on the person doing it.
12:52Heidi Rose: Yes. Because the thing is, like that holiday, that family trip, those things will still happen. With the partner who goes with the flow just sort of showing up, right, to put on old Navy pajamas that somebody else thought to order two months ago and didn't do any of the work to make it happen, but they still get to benefit from it. Can I throw some Astrid quotes at you here? Hit me. The fiance who doesn't care about the wedding still gets married. The person who doesn't care where their child goes to school still benefits from the selection of a good one. The person who doesn't care what's for dinner still gets to eat dinner, right?
13:23Heidi Rose: This is assuming, like, I don't care about this stuff, assuming that it is still going to actually happen. And I do think there's an aspect where my husband, for example, does care a lot less and did probably spend a lot of Christmases with like just getting on a plane the day before and going home. Now, his mother was then doing the kinkeeping or his father was doing the kinkeeping. But I don't think he's pretending not to care. But it's the whole picture that makes it complicated. Right. Interesting, Amy. Interesting. All right. Let's take a break. When we come back, we're going to talk about what made Astrid on Substack see this so clearly.
14:03While summer may be starting to feel like a distant memory, the effects of all of the sun and salty waves might be lingering. And you might be thinking, my hair could really use a reset. That's why I'm glad I've been taking Nutrafol. It means my hair health never takes a day off. Nutrafol is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement brand. And it's the number one hair growth supplement brand personally used by dermatologists and also the hosts of this podcast. And now the Nutrafol Women's Formula has been upgraded to its most advanced version yet. It's 100 % vegan, biotin-free, and comes in a smaller capsule size to make your daily routine easier.
14:48Whether you're just starting your hair health journey or you've been taking Nutrafol for years, this update means you can now get their most advanced support yet. Right Right now, Nutrafol is offering our listeners$10 off your first month subscription and free shipping when you visit Nutrafol.com and enter promo code laughing. That's Nutrafol.com spelled N-U-T-R-A-F-O-L dot com promo code laughing. Beam Minerals is a line of plant-based liquid minerals and electrolytes designed to help replenish all the minerals your body needs every day. I take a half a cap full of electrolyze and micro boost daily.
15:31I just put them in a glass of water. I don't even need one of Amy's smoothies.
15:35Heidi Rose: I like the morning smoothie. I put everything in the morning smoothie. It works for me. Beams electrolyze provides maximum support for cellular nutrition and electrolyte replenishment and micro boost delivers a full spectrum of trace minerals, electrolytes, micronutrients, amino acids, and B vitamins. The liquid format makes it easier for your body to absorb them. Guys, I'm busy. I'm recording a podcast during the day. I'm heading out to teach at night. Taking Beam in the morning means I'm feeling more energized throughout the day. Head to beamminerals.com slash whatfreshhell and use code whatfreshhell for 20 % off your first order.
16:12Heidi Rose: That's beamminerals.com slash whatfreshhell. Use code whatfreshhell. Give Beam Minerals a try and discover why mineral replenishment could be the missing piece in your wellness routine. This is Tamsen Fidel from The Tamsen Show. Fall in New York City is my favorite time of year. Crisp mornings, that excuse to layer up, walking around the city without melting. And once that shift happens, I genuinely don't want anything on my feet except Bombas. Their new suede moccasins have been my go-to for the second it cools down. Cushy soles, shearling lining, water-resistant suede. And I have to remember, comfort this good is technically allowed outside the house.
16:48Heidi Rose: When I'm traveling, I reach straight for their compression socks. they help with the fatigue from being on the plane so much, and I feel so much better landing when I have a pair on. My sock drawer is filled with Bombas now, so I have merino wool for the cold mornings, sweat wicking pairs for workouts, and a few dressier ones for whatever fall wedding season throws at me. My favorite part though, for every item you buy, Bombas donates an essential clothing item to someone phasing housing insecurity. One purchased, one donated, over 200 million donations and counting. Head over to Bombas.com slash audio and use audio for 20 % off your first purchase.
17:22Heidi Rose: That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash audio. Code audio at checkout. I got one more Elizabeth Holmes example for you because like anybody who has seen, you can see everything. That's all I'm thinking about. So there's another point in the movie. Again, I'm not giving away any of the crazy twists, but she just with her doe eyes says, I don't care about money. I don't. I don't care about money. That's definitely weaponized passivity. Like she doesn't care about money because she has to give away any money she has to the people that she's wronged. So she's like me not know about money. I just don't care.
17:58Heidi Rose: And not only is she absolving herself of responsibility, she's also giving herself this moral high ground. Yes. Like silly you that cares about money. I don't. She's in like a nine million dollar house saying this. It's the peak of I'm better than you because you have to dirty your hands with things like bills. See also me moving to the suburbs as like a reformed thinking I'm a big rebel without a clue chick and being like, look at these losers on the PTA with their clipboards doing stuff. Right. And it's like, wait, my kids go to a lovely school with a lot of amazing speakers and activities and fun after school stuff and fun in school stuff and a nutrition committee and a garden.
18:39and they get to learn about and grow things and eat stuff out of, all because of the work of people who I originally was like, what dorks.
18:47Heidi Rose: Right. That's so well said. You're right. Yeah. I'm a very horrible person. So Astrid says in this substack that what made her realize this as she was looking at Eve Rodsky's book Fair Play. We've had Eve Rodsky on the show. We talk about it all the time. It's wonderful. And you have this system of cards. It makes it physical, like who handles the birthday presents in our house. I have that card in front of me who handles when the car breaks down, you have that in front of you. And then you can't argue with the number of cards. That's the point. One person's probably going to have 20 cards in front of them.
19:18Heidi Rose: The other person's going to have four. Oh, the inequity is very visible. It's a smart thing. It is very smart. But Astrid said she's going through this. And there is something in the book where it says, if a card is important to only one of you, place it in front of the person who values it. Like decorating the house for Christmas. It doesn't, I don't care. You do whatever, babe. I don't care. that card is going to get placed in front of you. But then she says that's a loophole in this game because if you don't want to have very many cards in front of you, all you have to do is say that you don't care about anything.
19:48Heidi Rose: Yes. And you don't get the cards in front of you. Yeah. I think it's also fair to say having the house festooned from pillar to post with Merriman and Whimsy is important to me. And therefore, this Saturday, everyone in the family is helping me with what's important to me. Because guess what? I spend a lot of time helping you all with things that are not important to me. That's a really good point. I don't care about your Pokemon cards that I help you organize. I don't care about your American Girl doll that I have created a system of organization for the teacups about. Evan knows. And so I think that I would just cast a slightly gimlet eye towards if you don't care, you get out of helping.
20:30Because that I have found I'm really pushing back on in my household. Right. If you're going to eat the dinner, you're going to help me cut up the vegetables and set the table because you do care about the dinner going into your belly. So I don't care if we have fancy food or not. I do care and you need to support my care because I support the things you care about. Yeah, exactly.
20:53Heidi Rose: And then there's also weaponized irritability, which I wanted to talk about this weaponized passivity more. But that's also a thing, which is like, I'll do it, but I'll slam the pots and pans around so much and then be so cranky for the rest of the day. You'll have regretted asking me and you won't ask the next time. This with my children is a huge area of struggle for me. And I have asked the question on the podcast. I have talked to my husband about it. I get obsessed with like, not only are you going to clean out the garage for four hours, but you're not going to have a puss on your face the whole time you're doing it.
21:25And I still struggle with this. Do I care if you do it like my jolly Snow White elf singing a merry tune the whole time? And I believe as my children have entered their teenagedom, I have kind of had to let go a little bit of the part of like, you have to do it with a smile, like as long as you do it. But I also don't think while I'm working hard, I should actually have to listen to you banging the pots and pans. You don't have to be in a good mood about it, but you can't be in a disruptively bad mood about it is I think where I've come out. I think you're right.
22:00Heidi Rose: Sam Kelly, who created the notice and do method, I asked her how we got kids to buy in and she's like, you don't. You live in a house and you notice and do. This is what we're going to do in this house, which I found refreshing. But I do think the weaponized irritability, you're right. Who cares if they like it as long as it isn't successful in that you're just going to clean out the garage by yourself the next time because it wasn't worth it. Or you're really going to annoy me the whole time. If you're going to make it less pleasant, I think if we can get to like neutrality, I'm fine. But if you are making it actively less pleasant for me, not OK.
22:32Heidi Rose: So all three of these strategies, they don't exist in isolation. They can be switched in and out by the people we live with and ourselves, depending on what the situation calls for. But they all kind of in different ways create a vacuum that somebody else has to fill. Yes. I need an amen button for this episode. Can you get an amen? I mean, you can get a million of them on this episode. Astrid's pretty smart, so I'm going to explain it the way she says it. Incompetence, you know, weaponized incompetence, uses action to disqualify yourself from having to do it in the future. Passivity uses indifference to opt out of ownership.
23:08Heidi Rose: And irritability uses compliance to make asking costly. I see what she's saying. It's three ways of doing the same thing. This is not my problem, but it's somebody's problem, which means it's yours. I also want to say one more thing about indifference. It doesn't always play out. So indifference becomes, I don't care, I'm so laid back, but not that, but not the thing you want. And it's like, tell me you want something or give it over to me. My sister has a role with her husband. If you give it to me, you're not allowed to make any notes. Like your voice, you have no veto, you have no voice. This is not an example about my sister, but I think about this, Like, tag your it means I live with any results.
23:50If I want to be involved, I have to work. And so you're not allowed to come home after being like, I don't care at all about Christmas decorations, and then come home and be like, why'd you put the tree there? It looks dumb. The tree looks better by the piano. You're not allowed, because I do think that sometimes passive indifference is passive aggression in some ways. And it's like, oh, look at me. I'm so laid back. I don't care. Oh, I can't believe you did dinner that way. That's not how we do it in my house, you know, and that is the world's most frustrating version.
24:23Heidi Rose: Yeah. This is so societally baked in, right? The number of times I find myself in a situation in 2026 where the men are relaxing and the women are working and I almost like I'm in it before I realize it. You know what I mean? I'm like, why are the two or three women taking the wine glasses out to the other room? Like, what? Why are we doing this? And it's just because, like, it's the water that we swim in. I've gotten into the full crone phase of my life where I have no problem shouting at a party. Why are only the women working? And it happens in my house sometimes, too. I have one daughter. Often she has a friend or friends over.
24:57It's time to clear the table. Because what happens? The boys start wrestling and fighting and the girls keep working. I'm talking about the teens clearing the table suddenly are throwing bread rolls at each other and cracking up and the girls are still working. And I'm just constantly screaming, why are girls working and boys are not working?
25:16Heidi Rose: Because we're socialized. Don't invite me to parties. I'm quoting Astrid here. Women are socialized to maintain their families and their homes, regardless of whether anybody else participates or how much they participate. We are trained to anticipate needs to notice and do. And men, she says, are trained towards something closer to what she calls confident inattention. This is at home. At work, they're not confidently inattentive. I mean, maybe the petty cash guy was. But you can pay attention to what needs to be paid attention to. But when I'm at home, good. They got it. I have a perfect example of this.
25:49I was on a weekend away with some women. And the person who owned the house was there, but we weren't really interacting with them. We came down in the morning, all three of us carrying what in our hands, Amy, on the last day when we were moving out? Your sheets. You stripped your beds. Your sheets. Exactly. And she started laughing. And she's like, ah, women, they carry their sheets down in the morning. Like she was saying that it's just incredibly noticeable to her that it's just like a vacation house where she's very generous and always like, hey, you should come up with some friends and you should do this and you should do that.
26:25And immediately she said, here are the women carrying the sheets down in the morning because they understand that they've slept in a bed that needs to be turned over. And so they're going to launder the sheets. and that not just men, but young people too. She's like, I always notice that women of a certain age always come down the last morning carrying their sheets every single time. You could set the clock by it. And we were kind of talking about like, have men not gotten the message? Are the women doing it? And the men just never think about how the bed, they just think the elves come and change over the beds.
26:58And I now find myself making a note, like always tell my kids if they stay at someone's house, strip the beds in the morning. That's what you do. But it was exactly an example of this passivity versus action by men and women or young people and older people.
27:15Heidi Rose: This isn't one bad partner at a time. This is societal stuff that we're all learning to undo. I always go back to Alison Damager and her research that each couple that she interviewed about mental load stuff, if it was a man and woman together, the story would be the man's just like easygoing and laid back because that's how he is. And the woman is just really organized and get stuff done because that's how she is. That each couple thought they had this unique breakdown of things where she just likes to get things done a certain way. And so she does most of it. Everybody thought they're the only one doing it that way when everybody does it that way because it's a construct.
27:51I think that men in the realm of home can be a little bit like like magically the sheets get done. And I do think that I can, in the realm of garbage, be like magically the garbage makes it to the curb on Wednesday mornings. Like I think it's important to make the distinction and certainly driving the car when it starts making a weird knocking noise, I just turn the music up and keep driving, you know, and my husband would say like, why wasn't that an alarm bell for you? Or like, why didn't you mention that the tire light's been on for the last 50 ,000 miles? Or why did you leave the gas on empty and just leave it in the driveway?
28:33Because I am passive in certain realms and active in other realms.
28:37Heidi Rose: The example in my house, we have this thing called a mill, which I love. It composts food. It turns it into sort of like coffee grounds while you're sleeping. So you can have this compost thing in your house and you only have to dump it out once in a while. But I have no idea how to do it. I'm a lady with teeny tiny arms who couldn't possibly lift, you know, the bucket of stuff and dump it in a box. We like mail it somewhere. It also sounds pretty gross. I don't want to deal with that. It's coffee grounds, so it's not terrible. But somebody was asking us recently, like, oh, is it easy to work with?
29:05Heidi Rose: I'm like, yeah, it's easy. You just send it in. And my husband was like, really? It's easy? Because he's the one who's dealing with like coffee grounds everywhere you have to clean it. I mean, it's not terrible, but it's, I was like, yeah, it magically just goes away when it's almost full. And I think what sneaks in is like anger and resentment. My husband famously said, because I delivered my first son in under an hour from the time I realized it was in labor until the time I was holding him. I heard my husband on the phone talking to his mom and was like, yeah, it was quick and easy. And I was like, yeah, that's a phrase you should never say again.
29:38But for him, it was quick and easy. It took 45 minutes. He did not experience any of the physical stuff. And he does laugh and recognize that that was an incredibly dorky thing to say because I goof on him for every five minutes for the rest of our life. You have a podcast just so you can bring that up every once in a while. Exactly. We started this podcast so I could talk about my husband saying my birth was quick and easy forever. But I do think the neutrality of it is helpful to keep in mind because what immediately comes in is must be nice to think that the elves do the sheets and must be nice to think that the elves also fill your car with gas and stop it from exploding because you haven't changed the oil in 10 years.
30:18Heidi Rose: All right, we're gonna make this better. When we come back, we have strategies for addressing this. You all know I am not a lotions and potions type. I want my skincare to be simple, clean, and effective. So let me tell you about my latest secret, Osea. It's clean, seaweed-powered skincare from the sea. Osea has been providing award-winning, best-selling skincare for 30 years. Their clinically tested products have quickly become my new go-to for everyday skincare. At night, I'm using the Dream Bio Retinol Body Serum. I put it on right after I get out of the shower. And the lavender scent is perfect to put me in the right headspace to go to sleep.
31:03It's fast absorbing and deeply moisturizing with none of that greasy feel. It's lightweight, silky and will leave your skin glowing. Infused with vitamins, minerals and antioxidants, Osea products make a difference after just one use. Guys, I really love it. Go to OseaMalibu.com and get 10 % off your first order with code FRESH. That's O-S-E-A, Malibu.com, code FRESH. Dealing with the education system can feel like an uphill battle. For mothers navigating the unique complexities of raising neurodivergent kids in the special education system, the struggle is tenfold.
31:46Heidi Rose: That's why we want to tell you about Zero Reject. It's an investigative podcast from the nonprofit Understood.org. In it, education journalist and author Anya Kamenetz examines what families go through to secure free and appropriate education for neurodivergent children. We actually did a fresh take with Anya a few years ago about her book, The Stolen Year, about how COVID affected kids' education. It was a great interview. You'll hear the unfiltered truth of the special education system and gain the knowledge you need to advocate for your child's legal rights. I've been listening to Zero Reject, and whether or not you have a child with a disability, it is essential listening for anyone with a kid in the American education system.
32:28To listen, search for Zero Reject in your podcast app.
32:31Heidi Rose: That's Zero Reject.
32:41And now, your guide to fall for moms. From the What Fresh Health Podcast. Let's move, people. It's Halloween. You are at least a week late on putting up those spooky decorations. And if you don't get started carving those pumpkins this weekend, you might as well put an I Ruined Halloween sign up on your front lawn. And where are you on that all family minions costume you guys talked about in July? The Spirit Halloween store isn't coming to you, friend. Is that an inflatable turkey on your lawn? How embarrassing. Thanksgiving has been over for two days. Okay, you got home from a six hour drive yesterday.
33:14It's December now. You need to get your seasonal decor game moving here. What do you mean you forgot the holiday concert was Thursday? Well, the grandparents were counting on you to remind them that was coming up.
33:23Heidi Rose: And that gift list isn't getting any shorter, so you need to hustle if that's all going to get done. This is the time of year the core memories are being made for every single member of your family. And we need some whimsy. Stat! For God's sake, Mama, relax. No one likes it when you get so stressed around the holidays. This is supposed to be fun, and you kind of bomb everyone out when you get all uptight at this time of year, okay? find your jolly, would you? This has been your guide to fall for moms from the What Fresh Hell podcast.
33:55Heidi Rose: So this is again, ask Astrid on Substack. She makes the point that passivity is hard, can be hard to challenge and push against because she says it doesn't have a visible surface, like weaponized incompetence. It's like, uh-uh, you don't get away with this. You're going to have to wash these dishes and run the dishes again, sorry, because I'm not going to accept that, you know, nobody knows how to load the dishwasher except me. But weaponized passivity, there's nothing there to circle. And so it makes it a little harder to get started in addressing this. Yep. But you should, because we live in a world where this stuff becomes like we're uniquely qualified to know where the Christmas decorations are or to care about it.
34:36Heidi Rose: And the default setting is we do it and all the partner who hasn't done it in the past has to do like the status quo is them not participating. If they choose not to opt in, then they get to continue opting out. Yes. And why wouldn't they? Right. Like that's what I realized when I was working on Happy to Help. Nobody around you is a bad person for being very happy to have you continue to handle everything because it's working great, but it's hard work to change it, but it's worthwhile to underline it. For sure. And I think it's very important to underline to kids as well. I do think in my marriage, because I am so chaotic as a human person, our gender roles are somewhat reversed.
35:17Like my husband is much more in charge of managing me, is often like, do we have enough food to eat dinners this week? You know, we don't break down as much as many couples I know because I don't fit the mold of like the get her done kind of wife who's always like, OK, now the camp forms. My husband tends to be a little bit better at saying, OK, we need to register our kid for camp because it's six months out. And that let me set a reminder that we need to do the medical forms. But the biggest solution that I have found to all of these issues is we do keep a Google Doc. We got married in our late 30s.
35:57So I think we had an advantage in that we were used to running homes by ourselves. And I think sometimes the transition from that into a household takes a lot longer and probably sets people more in their roles, basically giving voice to like, these are the 10 projects who's doing what and why.
36:16Heidi Rose: One of the things that can really come into play with this passivity is that there can be things, a partner cannot care about what you're bringing to the beach for lunch, but that work still has to happen. There still has to be lunch. And so I think one way to sort of underline this is that it's one thing to say you don't care about something that doesn't need to happen, but we need to care about what's for lunch and the bills and what you're getting for your mom for Christmas. Like those are things, when you're saying you don't care about it, that doesn't mean it doesn't have to happen. You're just protecting yourself.
36:51Heidi Rose: You're drawing a ring around yourself from having to care about it. That's different from something that you can both agree. Should we do holiday cards this year? I don't care. I don't care either. Then don't do the holiday cards. Right. Or I guess I don't care if we do holiday cards. I do. They're really important to me. I love seeing them. I love opening ones everybody sends. Then you get them. But then as you say, if it's really important to us and it's work for the family and it's, you know, 200 cards or whatever, then the person who doesn't care still gets to spend a night in front of the TV putting stamps on the envelopes because it really matters to the other person.
37:24I'm going to give another example that I think gets into like a subtler version of this. We're going to the beach, family beach day, right? I am extremely lazy. I'm like, all right, let's go to the beach. I'll grab a towel and a swimsuit. And that's all I want to think about to go to the beach. And then people are like, what are we going to eat at the beach? And I'm like, I don't care. We'll go to the beach shack and get chicken fingers. Yeah, well, that's a good answer if there's food there. It works for me. But then other people in the family are like, I don't actually like to eat fried chicken fingers and French fries that cost$75.
37:57And so I don't want that option. And I can be a little bit like, oh, yeah, now we got to stop and get wraps. And I don't remember. I think stating all of the pieces that are important to you and why is another aspect of this. Because let's say I'm with my sister's family and they're like, we don't want to pay$75. All right. Do you guys want to stop at the store and just get stuff for you guys? Or should we go in together? What parts of this is important to you? I've had this with people in the family who are like, but why would you go to the airport and spend$150 on absolutely disgusting pizza?
38:34And my answer is because I'm lazy and that's how I prefer to do it. I prefer to outsource food to the airport when we get there. I think that having the full conversation sometimes it's like what gets lost in translation is you're being uptight about lunch. You're being gross about lunch. You see what I'm saying? Right. I feel like you drive me crazy at the holidays. I want everything perfect at the holidays is not as useful a conversation as let's break down the 20 things we do at the holidays and see which ones are still important to us. Because I think when you stay at like you're a crazy holiday person and it drives me crazy, you can't have an effective conversation that way.
39:15Heidi Rose: I think sometimes there are things that I would accept as, I don't really care about that. You do it like a new carpet. We need a new carpet for the hallway. The runner is stained. We're gonna have to rip it up and get a new one. What one should we get? I don't care. You decide. Okay, I don't really care either. Right. Just stop and think about that. I also don't really care. But it has to happen to just kind of notice those things around the edges for ourselves to not be so quickly like, okay, I'm it. Now I have to spend. Now I have to go to the carpet store. Well, maybe we both go to the carpet store.
39:42Heidi Rose: Or maybe I speak up and say, I also don't really care, but we do need a new runner for the carpet before we have the Christmas party. That you can just take a moment, you know, when somebody does hand something to you and be like, is it that I really care about this? And it's only because of my caring that has to happen? Or is it a thankless task that still has to happen? Noticing that default of you have to do annoying busy work because you quote unquote care about it. And maybe it's like, I also don't care about the rug. I'll get this one. But the next thing we both don't care about, you can take care of.
40:14Right. Because you're just saying out loud what's actually going on. One of the things that I find myself saying sometimes to my teenagers is not caring is not interesting. Like not caring, you don't win. You're not cooler for not caring. You're not more interesting for not caring. Are you sure you don't care or are you just trying to be someone who doesn't care? And I think really noticing is the key thing of like, I'm noticing that the girls cleaned up, even though boys and girls made the mess. I'm just noticing that and saying it out loud. And it's not like because you boys are lazy and dumb and girls and patriarchy.
40:53It can just be, here's what I'm noticing.
40:56Heidi Rose: And then you can also kind of push back when somebody says like, they're easy. They go with the flow. They're low maintenance. You know, particularly when it's not somebody that you're in a familial relationship with. You can say like, well, really? You're low K. That's interesting. Who's doing the work so you get to be low K? If you get to go with the flow, who made the flow? I think that there's room for that. And you capture this really well and happy to help. On the flip side, Amy's just so good at everything. Amy's just so competent. Amy's just a control freak or a type A person. And really breaking that down a little bit as where does that labor show up in your life?
41:33What is the labor that you can do without? I'm open to hear that. I've told this story before about my grandmother telling my mother when she was making her first Thanksgiving and explaining what was going to be on the list that my grandmother said, you're not having cream white onions? It just doesn't seem like it's Thanksgiving without creamed white onions. It's like 1950s recipe. 32-step recipe is my understanding. It's like pearl onions and you make a cream sauce and cream white onions. Then came Thanksgiving and my mother had, you know, of course, done the 50 steps and made the cream white onions.
42:08And my father passed them to my grandmother, who, of course, announced, no, thank you. I don't like cream white onions. Are we doing things in crazy town to make people happy because we're not even thinking about what we're doing? We're just riding the bus. We're passengers on the bus to crazy town. I think we can stop the bus and be like, passengers, eyes up front. We're having a meeting.
42:28Heidi Rose: That's a good point. Do we want to go to crazy town? Do we all want to go to crazy town? Like, how, what are we actually doing? We're not just sitting there looking out the window, letting the breeze hit our faces and riding the bus to crazy town. And sometimes, like, that would be weaponized passivity, right? To muse a little like, oh, it just doesn't seem like Halloween without the three giant skeletons outside. And I am the kind of person who's like, oh, better go get the three giant skeletons and put them out before they wake up tomorrow. I am that person. But I've learned to be, what if they are just musing?
43:01Heidi Rose: What if your grandmother's just like, oh, she wasn't really thinking, I'm going to make her go to the store and get these weird ingredients and make this complicated recipe. And it wasn't like a gotcha game. It just was something she said. And she certainly was going to make them herself. But she wasn't really thinking about, you know, somebody else like taking on that labor. I don't think. She just said it. Yeah, when I was planning my wedding, my mother-in-law to be at one point was like, I love yellow for bridesmaid dresses. I went into a three-day tailspin being like, yellow? We're getting married in December.
43:32Who wears yellow? I don't want yellow. I look terrible in yellow. And I finally sat my husband down three days in and he was like, I guarantee you my mother has never thought about that again. She just muses out loud about things. And right, like, are you picking up stuff on the bus to crazy town that nobody was even trying to hand you? Great point. I'm going to put the link to Astrid on Substack.
43:55Heidi Rose: Oh, for sure. I'm going to read that. This was great. It's really scholarly and so smart. Give me so much to think about. So I'm going to end with a quote from her. Most tasks that sustain a shared life turn out not to require rare talents. Wow. That's an amazing sentence. Yeah. Amazing. I loved this episode, Amy. Great job. Thank you so much. I'll put the link to that and our fresh takes with Alison Damager and with Eve Rodsky, whose book Fair Play really is a useful way to get started on this if you need to start having this conversation with the people you live with. And will you do us a favor?
44:29I love this episode. I bet you heard stuff in this episode that you liked. Share it on social media. Hit the share button, put on your Facebook page and say, are you listening to this podcast? I love it. They have great advice, great topics. Just share it somewhere on social media. It really helps us to find new listeners and we'd appreciate it oh so much. We really would. Thanks for listening. Thanks for helping us spread the word about the show. Don't be like, I don't know how to share it on social media. I'm just a tiny baby. I don't care about sharing it on social media. All right, guys, thanks for listening.
45:02We'll talk to you next time. Thanks, everybody.
45:11Thank you to Osea for sponsoring the show. Go to OseaMalibu.com and get 10 % off your first order with code FRESH. That's O-S-E-A Malibu dot com code FRESH.
There are several sneaky ways for the people we work with, or live with, to get away with participating less in the work that needs to happen. "Weaponized incompetence" became TikTok-famous during the pandemic, and most of us became more aware when that was being deployed.
A recent Substack post by Ask Astrid suggested that "weaponized passivity" may be a subtler but equally effective opt-out option. When someone says "I don't care what we have for dinner, I'll eat whatever," are they being generous, low-key, and collaborative? Or are they declaring themselves "not it," knowing dinner will still be served (by you) and they'll still get to eat?
We discuss:
How to spot weaponized incompetence, weaponized passivity, and weaponized irritability
How gender roles and socialization teach women to anticipate the needs of the domestic sphere, while rewarding men for being hands-off and largely inattentive
Practical ways to challenge these patterns, including recognizing that “not caring” doesn't mean something doesn't need to get done
How these dynamics show up with our kids, our teenagers... and yes, sometimes, ourselves
We loved Ask Astrid's Substack on this topic and refer to it heavily in this episode. Read for yourself: Meet weaponized passivity: incompetence's quieter sibling
Here are links to some of the other resources mentioned in the episode:
Maggie Zhou for Refinery29: Why Is ‘Weaponized Incompetence’ Blowing Up On TikTok? Because Too Many Of Us Do It
Fresh Take: Allison Daminger, WHAT'S ON HER MIND- The Mental Workload of Family Life
Changing the Invisible Workload (with guest Eve Rodsky)
Celestial Sylvia on FB: Weaponized incompetence in "You Can See Everything"
What Fresh Hell is co-hosted by Amy Wilson and Margaret Ables.
We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website:
https://www.whatfreshhellpodcast.com/p/promo-codes/
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices