1. Podcasts
  2. What Fresh Hell: Parenting, Relationships, and Making Life Better, with Two Funny Moms
  3. When Kids Hate Transitions

In short

Kids who struggle with transitions (leaving preferred activities, drop-offs, switching tasks) and how to respond using the “iceberg” model: visible behavior is only the top; underlying emotions/anxiety/needs drive it.

Guest backgrounds

Margaret Ables and Amy Wilson are the hosts of What Fresh Hell? They discuss parenting dilemmas. They also cite experts: Dr. Siggy Cohen (emotions validated/contained; behaviors monitored/mentored), Dr. Michael Rosenthal (Child Mind; ADHD/autism/anxiety/OCD/sensory processing explanations), Dr. Michael Sweeney (CBT for anxious kids; anticipation), and Claire Lerner (child guidance; plan conversations during calm times). They reference Dr. Ross Greene (Explosive Child; lagging skills).

Key claims

Validate and contain emotions while mentoring behavior; transitions stink for everyone; outsized, persistent difficulty may warrant a pediatrician conversation; “lagging skills” approach reduces blame.

Notable examples

Kicking during leaving; Game Boy/Minecraft “dance” of negotiating; crying at Kid-o-rama jump time; autism “cognitive inflexibility” with predictability; ADHD reward-center difficulty switching tasks; OCD mid-task interruption; using visual schedules/time timers, two-choice scripts, and bedtime planning.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Understanding Kids and Transitions

Discussing how transitions affect kids and sharing listener experiences.

“75 % of women who seek menopause care don't receive it.”
1:02

Understanding Kids and Transitions

Discussing how transitions affect kids and sharing listener experiences.

“Today, we're talking about kids and transitions and kids who hate transitions, which is all kids, but some kids really hate them.”
4:03

Behavior as Communication

Exploring the concept that behavior reflects communication and emotions in children.

“But the second piece of that is not therefore all behavior is OK.”
7:28

Challenges of Transitions for Different Kids

Identifying signs of transition difficulties and discussing potential solutions.

“You got that one kid that tacks a little more this way.”
10:37

Deeper Insights into Transition Difficulties

Analyzing why some kids struggle with transitions and how to address their needs.

“to go to karate on Wednesdays, cries, but it's only about karate.”
14:00

Understanding Kids' Interests

Explore how extreme interests in children can affect communication and transitions.

“And so that must be how it feels to be a kid that has an extreme interest.”
14:49

Transitioning to Break

A brief transition before discussing more about kids and transitions.

“Okay, let's take a break and we'll be right back and talk even more about transitions.”
18:38

Challenges of Transitions for Kids

Discuss various factors that make transitions difficult for children, especially those on the autism spectrum.

“He suggests that kids with autism can have cognitive inflexibility.”
23:50

Lagging Skills and Behavioral Challenges

Understanding how lagging skills in children contribute to difficulties with transitions.

“They're not crying when it's time to go to class in college.”
27:09

Addressing Anxiety and Uncertainty

Explore how anxiety and uncertainty affect children during transitions and how to support them.

“This is a skill that they need some help with.”
Show all 17 chapters
28:00

The Anxiety of Travel Transitions

Explore the physical and emotional reactions to travel transitions, even when excited.

“We've gone on big trips somewhere out of the country.”
32:12

Gentle Parenting Attempts vs. Realities

Humorous contrasts between gentle parenting strategies and real-life scenarios.

“You can choose to put your shoes on yourself.”
33:24

Strategies for Easing Transitions for Kids

Learn effective strategies from a therapist to help children cope with transitions.

“Michael Sweeney is a cognitive behavioral therapist who works with anxious kids.”
36:53

Involving Kids in Transition Strategies

Discuss ways to involve children in creating strategies for smoother transitions.

“Hey, I love going to the park, but I hate that last five minutes where I'm screaming and you guys were in a terrible mood and blah, blah, blah.”
42:01

Understanding Child Autonomy and Control

Explore how giving children choices can help manage their anxieties during transitions.

“You can't have pizza and run around the house because that's the rule here.”
44:11

The Impact of Poor Transition Management

Learn about the consequences of failing to give children adequate transition warnings.

“And once you establish that, I had something come up a couple weeks ago that I forgot we had dinner plans.”
45:56

Book Recommendation: Explosive Child

Discover a book that addresses challenging child behaviors and promotes understanding.

“I mean, I think the very important work they do is sort of like no kid is beyond help.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On What Fresh Hell: Parenting, Relationships, and Making Life Better, with Two Funny Moms, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:0075 % of women who seek menopause care don't receive it. The lying awake at 3 a.m. wondering what's happening to your body ends now. Midi is virtual care built for women in perimenopause and menopause with clinicians who specialize in women's health. Plus, it's covered by most major insurances. Getting started is easy. You can book your first visit with a clinician right away. Midlife needs Midi. Visit joinmidi.com to book your first visit today. That's joinmidi.com. Insurance coverage varies. Check with your plan for coverage. Do not knock on the door to ask me where the pepper is.

0:36Amy Wilson: What fresh hell. Laughing in the face of motherhood. My body's reaction is chased by bear. With Margaret Ables. And Amy Wilson. Game Boy, am I 100 years old? A podcast that solves today's parenting dilemmas. So you don't have to. I will get us to Helsinki.

1:01Amy Wilson: Hello, everyone, and welcome to What Fresh Hell? Laughing in the face of motherhood. This is Margaret. And this is Amy. Today, we're talking about kids and transitions and kids who hate transitions, which is all kids, but some kids really hate them. So we're going to talk about that today. And some moms, many moms as well. Yes. We have sort of two mailbags today. One is the episode idea, and one is a more general mailbag. So shall we start with the... Let's hit it. A double mailbag. We love to see it. Double mailbag. Missy came on Facebook to say, I come on Facebook for two reasons, to browse Facebook Marketplace and to see what's happening in the Web Freshel podcast group.

1:35Love it. Yeah. She said, I'm listening to the transitions episode. I treasure the fact that you both are a few steps ahead of me in parenting. I savor your wisdom and find myself encouraged by the ways you speak to me from the future. As you talk today about the transition to college, it made me think about my own transition, setting my first to kindergarten in 2021 and now my last in 2026. There were tears from Missy sending off my first and there were not tears sending off my last. Both responses, I have decided, are acceptable and they are not a one-to-one comparison. I just wanted to share the ways that you really reach me today and that you regularly do.

2:12Please don't stop doing what you're doing. You're making many of our worlds a brighter place.

2:16Amy Wilson: Thank you, Missy. Thanks, Missy. And I hope you find every treasure you're seeking on Facebook Marketplace. That's right. Maybe some of my stuff. I've been giving away some of my kids' art supplies and stuff. Okay, so you might be buying from Amy herself. Right, if you walk to my apartment and get them. Yes, you can have all our old art supplies. Anyway, today's topic is also a mailbag, also from Facebook, also about the transitions episode. Nicole said, well, the transitions episode was great for me, but the title had my hopes up regarding the subject matter. My four-year-old has a very difficult time with transitions.

2:48He gets extremely anxious, acts like a loon, and I feel so bad for him. I really need some advice. This is anything from daycare drop-off, someone coming to visit, time to leave wherever we are. Anyone have advice? Could we get an episode on transitions for the littles, pretty please? And you said, yes, we can. Yes, we can. We can, we shall, we will. Here it is. Yeah, it's a topic. And I wanted to underline at the top that what Nicole says, she says something that's very important that comes into play here, and that's the iceberg. We talk about the iceberg a lot, but in case you're a new listener, the idea of the behavior, the thing that you're seeing, the crying when it's time to leave, is the part of the iceberg you can see above the surface.

3:27But what's underneath the surface is much larger and probably more mysterious. And you need to get curious about that in order to address the little part you can see. And more likely to sink your boat. Yes, exactly. So she's already understanding. I'd have this explained to me. Maybe Nicole has had it explained to her, but she knows this already, that the behavior is a signal. Something's up and getting curious about what's underneath will probably help you address the behavior more effectively, more compassionately. But it's better for everybody when your kid doesn't cry every time you have to leave somewhere, including the kid.

4:01So it's worth figuring this out.

4:03Amy Wilson: So behavior is communication. But the second piece of that is not therefore all behavior is OK. And I was just talking to Dr. Siggy Cohen about this behavior. is communication, but you can address and change the behavior while still hearing the communication. It's holding both of those ideas because I think sometimes we think, I'm so glad you're showing me how you feel is the end of the sentence. I understand, Amy, that you are really sad to be leaving Play-O-Rama. I love it there. But we don't kick mommy in the face no matter how upset you feel. It's a two-part solution. We've started to maybe tack a little side to there's an important reason for this.

4:48The reason that he's kicking me or she's kicking me, there's a reason. And so it must be tolerated in order to understand their developing emotional self. Like, okay, you can understand the developing emotional self, but also you can't kick mommy.

5:01Amy Wilson: I think you're right. I'm going to just lay a little Dr. Siggy Cohen on you because I thought this parameter was super useful. Emotions need to be validated and contained. Behaviors need to be monitored and mentored. So your behaviors, yes, you feel angry. You feel this huge amount of anger that we need to get in control of. And your behavior that I'm seeing, you're kicking me in the face. We need to change that behavior. Emotions need to be validated and contained. Behaviors need to be monitored and mentored. I was like, that makes sense to me. It makes total sense. And this was this is a very recent episode, by the way.

5:41So if you're listening to this, you'll find it in our feed. We'll link to it also. Yeah, she was excellent. Excellent. And I also wanted to say that transitions are hard for everybody. There is nobody who wants to stop doing a preferred activity to begin a non-preferred activity, including everybody listening. Right. Like

5:55Amy Wilson: that stinks. You've queued up Real Housewives. You've got your cup of cocoa. You're all snuggled under your blanket and your husband walks in and says, what are you doing? It's back to school night we have to go right now. That's a transition. Yes. And that, of course, I do think sometimes it helps to say, what is this in our life? Because it's right. Transitions stink. Right. Transitions stink. Nobody likes them. Just now I was sitting with my morning tea watching TikToks and looking at the clock and thinking, I have to go record the show with Amy. It's not that I hate the activity. It's just I'm really enjoying my snug as a bug on the couch.

6:32Amy Wilson: Preferred activity. I'm doing my preferred activity. It's okay. This is also kind of a preferred activity, but it's not the same. Right. It's something I think to address because it's easier for literally everybody when transitions are easier, but it isn't a danger sign that your kid cries sometimes, right? It's the reaction. It's the level of reaction where your mileage may vary. True. And transitions tend to be harder for kids on the autism spectrum, kids with ADD, ADHD. It's not a sign of concern that your kid has trouble with transitions, but a kid who has constant and outsized trouble with transitions might be something you want to talk to your pediatrician about and say, I'm really noticing of my three kids, one of them, every time there's a transition, it's super hard because it's just access to more resources that might be able to help.

7:27That's right. And anybody who has more than one kid will have one kid who particularly struggles with transitions or cold bathwater or whatever it is. You got that one kid that tacks a little more this way. Let's talk about the ways that this can manifest. What are we even talking about when we say trouble with transitions? And then I do want to break down the different icebergs because they actually have different manifestations and different reasons. But trouble with transitions is, you know, resistance, whining, just avoiding, just not coming when you call, not acknowledging that the transition is underway.

7:56Maybe actively hiding when you're trying to leave a place. I've dealt with it. Maybe actively hiding. Negotiation. This might be something an older kid is more likely to do. Five more minutes. Can we please? Right, that kind of thing. Sometimes meltdowns. And a lot of these are evidence of emotional overwhelm. The kid is not giving you a hard time. The kid is having a hard time. Yep. But just to go back to what you were saying before, some can be what the kid has learned will work. that if you say it's time to put the Game Boy away. Game Boy, am I 100 years old?

8:29Amy Wilson: Yeah, you're 9 ,000 years old. Methuselah. It's time to put the fax machine away now, guys. Minecraft. I'll go with Minecraft because that's a perennial. Yeah, we're still doing it. We're still doing Minecraft. Time to put Minecraft away. If they learn that if they whine long enough and say, please, please, please long enough, that you'll give them 10 more minutes and then 10 more minutes. They're going to keep it up. They'll keep it up. And why wouldn't they? That just becomes part of the dance. That just becomes the choreography of how this goes every time. There's another thing that can be especially infuriating about transitions, which is they may have been extremely reluctant to come to Happy Play Jump.

9:07Amy Wilson: That took a lot of and now they're at Happy Play Jump and now they're going to be resistant to leave Happy Play Jump. It's not logical. And that part I have found extremely frustrating. Yeah. And also, I think for certain kids, there's a great TikTok. I'll see if I can track it down, although I don't even know how to search for it. But it's like when you hang out with your cousins, it's a bunch of boys all walk in a room. They're like, hey, hey, what's up? Super awkward. Super awkward. You're kind of basically with strangers for, yeah, at first. And then it cuts to them like in a giant pile tackling each other and cracking up.

9:41Amy Wilson: And the mom says it's time to go. And they're like, what? And I think that's right. It takes a while to warm up to a situation. And then when you're in it and warm, now you're going to pull me out. And that I see more for my kids who struggle with transitions. It takes them a long time to get into it. Like a birthday, the first half hour of the birthday party might be awkward standing around or crying or not wanting to be there. And then it's like just when they get going, it's time to go, which is frustrating for us all. I think that there's a little bit of detective work there, too. if your kid cries when they get to the, what is it called?

10:16Kid-o-rama, I believe you called it. This wonderful. Super fun jump kid time, yes. Super fun jump kid time. If your kid cries when they get there and then cries when they leave, then you're like, okay, I have a kid who has problems with transitions. There you go. And which is both bad news and good news. It's useful information. Let's put it that way. It's the transition. It's not the activity. But on the other hand, if you have a kid who only really doesn't want to go to karate on Wednesdays, cries, but it's only about karate. and then is also super unhappy while they're there. Like that's a different situation that needs a different focus.

10:46Amy Wilson: Different information and may not just be as simple as they don't want to go to karate. It might be who knows what's going on. Right. But get curious about that. But what you know for sure is if it's insistent, consistent and persistent about one thing, that's different than leaving and also going. And it might be like there's a weird smell in the karate lobby. You just you got to you got to figure out what the problem is and not just go to like, all right, we'll quit karate. Right. You can guess and guess and it will really surprise you. Let's talk about the things that can be what the iceberg is for kids that can't handle transitions, because interestingly, the different reasons have different motivations that cause the difficulty, which I had never really thought about.

11:30Yeah, I knew this, that kids in the autism spectrum, kids with ADHD would have difficulty, but the reasons they have difficulty, at least according to Dr. Michael Rosenthal of Child Mind, are different reasons, different underpinnings. So let's talk about kids with ADHD. Let's start with that one. Kids with ADHD have greater emotional lability, which just means like big swings, big sudden swings. They have a harder time controlling their emotions. And so this comes into play, I think, with what I was saying before, like nobody likes a transition, but a kid with ADHD might be more likely to absolutely go boneless and fall apart over it.

12:06Right. Because they have more emotional ability. They have a little bit less ability. It's a flatter trajectory in the ability to control their emotions. Yep. It makes sense. And the other thing is that kids with ADHD have been found to have fewer neurons in their reward centers. Like it's harder to make the reward center of your brain light up when you have ADHD, unless it's a preferred activity. And then you're very lit up, but it makes it harder to switch tasks because I guess the neurons, there are fewer of them and or they come on more slowly. So that might make a kid slow to warm up and really hard to switch.

12:42When you're really down that rabbit hole of something you love, it can be really hard to put it aside.

12:46Amy Wilson: Yeah. And I do think that kids on that spectrum, ADHD, autism, they are deep. They go deep on things. They go deep on topics. They go deep on emotions. And they just it's like if you're in a shallower place, it's easier to move out of it. If you're way deep down, it's like I have to come all the way back up. Like I'm no scientist and no doctor, but I know it when I see it. It goes so deep on things that it's not the same as a kid who's playing in a puddle and has to move to another puddle. It's like you're at the bottom of the ocean and you have to come all the way up and then go somewhere else.

13:23That is such a good point. And thinking about this for myself, when I was working on my book, I had to explain to my loved ones, I'm not here. Do not knock on the door to ask me where the pepper is. I'm writing. I'm deeply, and it takes you a while to get into that place. Yes. And then if you're like, knock, knock, knock, hey, do you want any soup? You know, like, don't do that because. I do not want soup. Right. I want to be at the deep end of the ocean. Right. And I would look at them with wild eyes and they didn't get it. And it's okay. Nobody's a bad person. You have to understand that I'm not up here listening to music.

13:53I have to work really hard to get to this place of concentration and like squeeze out this pound of flesh every day. Don't interrupt me. And so that must be how it feels to be a kid that has an extreme interest.

14:04Amy Wilson: My husband, who is not not on this spectrum, he is an engineer and has like a beautiful mind palace where he goes to do his engineering stuff. And there are times where I call him and I'm like, do you know that our tax bill is due and we have to do it on the dentist and the kids who's taking the orthodontist? And I'll say to him, are you in the rabbit hole? And he's like, yes. And I say, we'll talk about it later. Yeah, because I know when he's deep in his mind palace in like the back corner of some library trying to figure out an engineering problem. He's in red brain. Like there's nobody home, Mrs.

14:38Amy Wilson: Torrance. This is not the time to talk to him about orthodontic appointments. You got to come all the way up to the surface, take off your oxygen tank, take off your helmet. What? Pepper? And it's frustrating. No good. Okay, let's take a break and we'll be right back and talk even more about transitions. Margaret, I am so glad that my family discovered Yoto, a screen-free audio player for kids ages 3 to 12 that brings stories, music, learning, and imagination together in one simple device. Such a good idea. Kids just pop in an audio card and take the lead themselves. No cameras, no microphones, no ads, just their own imagination running the show.

15:16Amy Wilson: With more than 1 ,300 audio cards, including stories in Spanish and French, there's something for every age and interest. Let me tell you something. Yoto keeps my six-year-old niece and two-year-old nephew engaged together in a screen-free way long enough to let my brother and sister-in-law make dinner, clean up, or maybe just sit down for a second. The reason Yoto became such a big part of kids' routines isn't just because it's screen-free. It's because the kids genuinely love it. If you're looking for a gift they'll actually use and enjoy, head to yotoplay.com. That's Y-O-T-O. And use our code FRESH to save 10 % off all eligible items.

15:56Amy Wilson: Add a little more imagination and a little less screen time to your family's day with Yoto. Thank you, Yoto, for sponsoring this episode. You know, it's my favorite time of year when I can indulge in my favorite thing in the world, sweater weather. And helping me with my sweater addiction has been Quince, where I head to find elevated everyday essentials that go with everything I already own. As the weather gets colder, Quince has everything you need to round out your wardrobe. From warm, responsibly sourced down jackets to cozy cashmere scarves and gloves. I just bought the alpaca wool chunky knit cardigan and let me tell you, cozy.

16:38Amy Wilson: I'm not taking it off until spring, guys. Everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80 % less than similar brands. They work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen. So you're paying for quality, not brand markup. And it's not just apparel. Quince brings that same approach to everything they make, from hotel quality bedding and bath to kitchen essentials and thoughtfully designed furniture. Find the fall pieces you'll reach for most at Quince. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to Quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the UK, too.

17:17Amy Wilson: And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was what fresh hell. It's the best way to support our show. Friends, my fall look is not complete without my new Zenni sunglasses. I am wearing them everywhere. Zenni is an online eyewear shop with stylish prescription glasses, sunglasses, and customizable lens options at prices that make it easy to own more than one pair, all starting at, listen up, under$30. Just go to zenni.com, pick a frame, enter your prescription, and customize your lenses, all from the comfort of your couch. And if you've never bought glasses online, Zenni has a virtual try-on feature.

17:58Amy Wilson: Loved it. I could see exactly how the frames looked on my face before I ordered. And can confirm, my sunglasses look just as good on me in real life as they did virtually. That scratched-up pair has done its job. Upgrade today with Zenni. Go to zenni.com slash podcast and use code podcast15 for 15 % off your first order plus free shipping on all U.S. orders over$65. The styles sell out, so don't sit on it. That's Z-E-N-N-I dot com slash podcast promo code podcast15. Okay, so let's talk about kids in the autism spectrum and why they might have difficulty with transitions. This is neuropsych Dr.

18:44Michael Rosenthal of ChildMind. He suggests that kids with autism can have cognitive inflexibility. He says for kids with autism, the world is very confusing and overwhelming. And so they adapt by having this need for predictability and sameness, controlling what you can control. I'm going to wear the blue shirt today, and I'm also going to wear the blue shirt tomorrow because the world is a crazy place, but I'm going to wear my blue shirt. So changing activities or doing something unexpected. I'm having a lot of fun at the bouncy castle, and now we have to leave. The rug is being pulled out from underneath them in a way that's profoundly unsettling.

19:21Amy Wilson: I read a long time ago in a book this metaphor that really struck with me about, imagine I'm trying to get Amy to go to the movies with me. Approach number one, Amy is sitting in the park reading Catcher in the Rye, J.D. Salinger. I walk up to her, slap the book out of her hand, grab her by the hand and say, we're going to the movies. It's going to be so fun. It's going to be so much better than the stupid book you're reading. Amy's reaction is going to be like, whoa, I'm in the middle. I want to do my thing. If I go into the park and I see Amy reading her J.D. Salinger book and I pull out Franny and Zoe, another J.D.

19:56Amy Wilson: Salinger book, and I sit next to her. I'm now in the world with her. And then after a while of talking, we both like J.D. Salinger. We should go see the movie version of this book going into her space and bringing her out to mine. You're not going to do that 400 times a day when it's time to put your shoes on. Right. But I found the metaphorical version of it kind of helpful in terms of can I go into this child's world, spend a little bit of time there, and then shift their entrance to something in my world, I might be more successful than just slapping the book out of their hands. At least having a little bit of compassion about how hard it would be to stop doing that.

20:38And in the case of a person on the autism spectrum that they read for two hours every day on the bench, and that's what they do, and you're asking them to do something completely unpredictable and different is a big ask.

20:50Amy Wilson: And I think there might be a way with any child, neurotypical or non, to they're playing bunnies. Maybe it's time for the bunnies to go to the grocery store, like just trying to find a little bit of connection to their worlds, I think can be helpful. Kids with anxiety. And this is all a soup, right? I don't want somebody listening to be like, okay, does my kid have ADHD? These are the ways it might show up. Not that we're going to diagnose, But this is different reasons for different kids. Kids who have anxiety. It's the stimuli connected to the transition. It's time to go to school can just cause this, you know, feeling of panic, this rush of adrenaline.

21:28It's the idea that I have to make the transition at all causes stimuli that is itself something I have to resist.

21:34Amy Wilson: And the opposite of anxiety can feel like control. And therefore, I have control over this environment. Now I'm being dragged to another environment where I don't know what kind of control I'll have. Scary. Mm-hmm. And OCD, this is something that Child Mind brought up, in particular, if you have a kid with OCD, asking them to stop what they're doing mid-task could be like tilt. That's not allowed. I can't do this. Right. As a person with OCD, if you're like, I need to touch this thing 10 times and then Amy comes along halfway through when I'm at three, like that's a different level of anxiety.

22:10Amy Wilson: That's iceberg stuff. You're not seeing what's going on for me in that story. No, no. You're just seeing the reaction. I'm like, whoa, why is this so hard? Right. But there's an iceberg. There are kids who have sensory processing disorder and are just a little more tuned up. I had a kid like this. I am a person like this. Yeah, it's just like things affect you. You're a little more jumpy, maybe. And then I think, yes, sometimes you have a kid with control issues who's kind of cranky, who runs the house and who gets the way when they resist everything. And you can also, for all of this, can have a kid who has zero diagnoses for whom transitions are particularly difficult.

22:46That's right. Sometimes it's just a season, too. I wanted to make sure to underline that. Like if you have a kid who's crying every day at drop off when they're three, it doesn't necessarily mean you need to take them for a neuropsych evaluation. It doesn't necessarily mean they're going to be still crying at Thanksgiving. You can have kids who have this problem for a time in their lives as they cycle between periods of regulation and dysregulation. There can be no reason. So anyway, we've come up with all the reasons it could be. And it could just be give it another couple of weeks. Yeah.

23:17Amy Wilson: Or it could just be this is part of this kid's personality that they struggle with transitions. I had a kid who in pre preschool, like their three year old report card was like struggles with transitions. And my sister-in-law, who's an early child educator, laughed. And she was like, you'll be reading that on their high school transcript, too. And it's true. Struggling with transitions tends to be something that stays with us. And yet it improves, right? Like having had kids who really struggle with transitions, they're out in the world now. They're not rolling around on the floor in 11th grade when you're like, it's time to go here.

23:50Amy Wilson: They're not crying when it's time to go to class in college. Right. They might be grumping around, though. Like they're still communicating it to me. so the book the explosive child by dr ross green you and i are both big fans of his work nicole's original message on facebook saying my kid has trouble with transitions leanne said you should look at this book the explosive child i thought oh that's interesting right we should look at that anyway their whole sort of dynamic and we did have somebody from dr ross green's group on the show so i'm going to link to that in the show notes also our interview with dr stacy haynes basically the idea of kids do well when they can and they're not giving you a hard time they're having a hard time is from Dr.

24:28Ross Green. And so even the most difficult child, the explosive child, there's reasons for that behavior. So what they propose is that kids can have what they call lagging skills. They're not absent skills. They're lagging skills. They're maybe behind their peers on this stuff. And that if you understand what the lagging skill is, then you'll be able to address why they're misbehaving. So there's an assessment of lagging skills and unsolved problems. I'll link to it in the show notes. You can take it for your kid if your kid has, you know, big struggles with this. The first lagging skill on their entire list of 30 things is difficulty handling transitions.

25:07Like that's where it starts. That tracks. That's a big lagging skill. Right. And it leads to unsolved problems, which is what they call crying when it's time to leave, crying when it's time to put your shoes on. That's just, that's an unsolved problem. And they present it as your kid has a lagging skill. They're not good of transitions yet, yet. They have to learn that skill and then they'll be better at it. It just really helps, I think, to sort of approach it that way, that they have a skill that they need more help with.

25:34Amy Wilson: I think this can seem a little tweet tweet, like nobody's got a problem. We're all just, you know, not there yet. But it's super important. Kids who have any kind of behavior problem, it can become a snowball very quickly. Like, why are you always giving me a hard time? Why are you the only one who can't get their shoes on in the morning? These kind of problems, if we only see the problem, and I'm speaking to myself here, it becomes a problem between you and the child. And then it becomes more of a problem as the child feels like I'm always in trouble and I'm always doing bad and I'm always doing wrong and my anxiety is going up and now I'm getting more freaked out about transitions.

26:17Amy Wilson: That it's really worth tapping on this thing of what's underneath the behavior and what what can we get at? Because you are an awesome kid who is having a hard time with this thing. And we all feel this way when we're trying to get out the door to church and like our mother-in-law is going to be there. And we, if we're late, we're going to get judged, whatever, not speaking from experience, but then it becomes a problem between you and your kid so quickly. And it's not your fault. Right. It just helps reframe this. It doesn't mean, I think it's a lagging skill, doesn't mean you never do anything about it, right?

26:52Like your kid, your kid has ARFID. Like it isn't like, oh, well, like, okay, no, it's a lagging skill. It's a, it's something I'm a problem with. We're going to work on it. We're going to address it. This isn't absolving your kid or you of responsibility to address this a little bit. It just frames it as they are not out to ruin your morning every morning. Right. This is a skill that they need some help with. No, because we're doing monitoring and mentoring of behavior. Well, the good news is I have lots of stuff that works to make transitions easier for everybody. Hooray! I wanted to remind everybody, we did an episode on uncertainty recently, dealing with uncertainty.

27:31And there was a lot of research in that about our amygdalas equate uncertainty with danger. Yes, sometimes uncertainty is, I don't know what's around that corner. Like our brains treat, I don't know what's going to happen next as dangerous. Of course, it isn't always dangerous, but our amygdalas don't know that. And so kids who are resistant to new situations, I don't want to go because what's going to happen? They're struggling with the uncertainty.

27:56Amy Wilson: Right. And again, this feels familiar to me probably three times since I've had kids. We've gone on big trips somewhere out of the country. And my reaction the day of is always like, how could a human being do this? put stuff in bags with passports and get on a plane to a place they've never been before. We went to Finland this summer for my sister-in-law's wedding. And it just feels like, what is Finland? And my body's reaction is chased by bear. And I'm excited about the trip. And I know we're going to have a good time. But the physical reaction in my body is like nausea. Like I'm about to go perform at Madison Square Garden.

28:34Amy Wilson: And I don't know my lyrics. Like that level of anxiety is existing in my body. And somebody saying to me, it's going to be fun, is not going to turn that chase by bear anxiety off. Right. And that's really interesting because I know like using this example, this is a trip you're excited about. You had certainly done a lot of talking about it and preparing and talking to your whole family. What is it going to be like? It's going to be amazing. Really looking forward to it. And yet when the time comes, we're leaving in 15 minutes, there's still that feeling. Right. Right. And we're not going to compete on a mountain repelling mission.

29:08Amy Wilson: We're going to sit around and drink long drinks at a wedding. It's not there's nothing objectively scary about it. But the hugeness of the transition makes it feel physically terrifying as if I was going to sign up for a parachuting contest. Yeah. And I guess you're an adult who can have some sort of like, ooh, this is happening. I'm really feeling this anxiety that the trip is now here. Yes. You can have a little bit of perspective on that, that a child is probably less able to do. Right. All right. When we come back, I have lots of ideas and tips from lots of people on how to make transitions easier for kids and us.

29:44Hooray.

29:46Amy Wilson: Beam Minerals is a line of plant-based liquid minerals and electrolytes designed to help replenish all the minerals your body needs every day. I take a half a cap full of electrolyze and micro boost daily. I just put them in a glass of water. I don't even need one of Amy's smoothies. I like the morning smoothie. I put everything in the morning smoothie. It works for me. Beams electrolyze provides maximum support for cellular nutrition and electrolyte replenishment and micro boost delivers a full spectrum of trace minerals, electrolytes, micronutrients, amino acids, and B vitamins. The liquid format makes it easier for your body to absorb them.

30:24Guys, I'm busy.

30:25Amy Wilson: I'm recording a podcast during the day. I'm heading out to teach at night. Taking Beam in the morning means I'm feeling more energized throughout the day. Head to beamminerals.com slash whatfreshhell and use code whatfreshhell for 20 % off your first order. That's beamminerals.com slash whatfreshhell. Use code whatfreshhell. Give Beam Minerals a try and discover why mineral replenishment could be the missing piece in your wellness routine. While summer may be starting to feel like a distant memory, the effects of all of the sun and salty waves might be lingering. And you might be thinking, my hair could really use a reset.

31:05Amy Wilson: That's why I'm glad I've been taking Nutrafol. It means my hair health never takes a day off. Nutrafol is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement brand, and it's the number one hair growth supplement brand personally used by dermatologists and also the hosts of this podcast. And now the Nutrafol Women's Formula has been upgraded to its most advanced version yet. It's 100 % vegan, biotin-free, and comes in a smaller capsule size to make your daily routine easier. Whether you're just starting your hair health journey or you've been taking Nutrafol for years, this update means you can now get their most advanced support yet.

31:46Amy Wilson: Right now, Nutrafol is offering our listeners$10 off your first month's subscription and free shipping when you visit Nutrafol.com and enter promo code laughing. That's Nutrafol.com spelled N-U-T-R-A-F-O-L.com promo code laughing.

32:12Amy Wilson: And now, gentle parenting attempts versus gentle parenting realities. From the What Fresh Out podcast. Attempt. You can choose to put your shoes on yourself. Or you can choose for mom to help you. Reality. We're late. We are so late. Just grab whatever foot covering you can find. Just shove them on your feet while we drive. Attempt. As you can see, I've made this color-coded chart so you can see what the day holds and what we can all expect. Reality. I have no idea what's for dinner. Go play Roblox for an hour. I'll figure something out. Attempt. I love how you are expressing your frustration.

32:54I see that you feel upset that the light isn't changing fast enough. That is so upsetting. And you are heard.

33:04Amy Wilson: Reality. Mommy is just going to turn the music up louder if you keep crying. Mommy also had a very stressful day and wishes you could understand that she cannot control traffic lights with her mind. This has been Gentle Parenting Attempts vs. Gentle Parenting Realities from the What Fresh Hell podcast. Dr. Michael Sweeney is a cognitive behavioral therapist who works with anxious kids. I have had the opportunity to hear him speak, to meet him in person. And he's incredible. And his approach for this, for a kid who has a hard time with transitions, is anticipation. He says that you, as the parent, should approach, first of all, calmly, like calmly and gently, like try to keep your energy calm even when you were supposed to leave five minutes ago.

33:51Approach calmly and anticipate what you're going to say. Say, in a minute, we're going to want to talk about what's for breakfast. And then wait a minute. And then say, so what's for breakfast? We have this. that just that extra step of like, I'm not asking you yet, but in a minute, I'm going to ask you what you want for breakfast. Just couching it that way can make kids who are always have the chased by a bear feeling to know what's going to happen next. Right.

34:17Amy Wilson: Yeah. It's like, think about jumping off a cliff versus having a ramp down or a stairway down. You're trying to put a stairway in for them. Right. So they don't feel shoved or forced to jump. Yes. They know what's going to happen next, you're going to ask them what they want for breakfast. And he would also say, I mean, having talked with him about the situation, I had a kid who was always such a struggle to find out what they wanted for breakfast in the morning. Transitions were hard. And it was like, why are you asking your kid what they want for breakfast? If transitions are hard, just hand them something.

34:47And you know what? That was a great idea. It worked really, really well for me. Sometimes fewer choices for a kid who can't handle transitions is the answer.

34:56Amy Wilson: I go back to my friend, the whiteboard that I talked about constantly when my kids were younger. And we're still using it. I put what's for dinner every night. I have a kid who's very dinner anxious, wants to know that dinner is going to be something good that they like and is not weird. You know, it's not going to be like high spring rolls with shrimp. Like he wants to know it's going to be spaghetti and meatballs. And then we did do New Food Wednesdays. So every Wednesday, we tried a new food. New Food Wednesdays was okay because that was only Wednesday. just building a lot of visual. And if you have a kid on the spectrum, you know, like visual schedules, they can look up at the wall.

35:37Amy Wilson: Okay, we're going to put our shoes on, then we're going to this, then we're going to this. Being able to reference something that is written down is very helpful. The certainty, it provides certainty. And the time timer, I'm going to link to that in the show notes too. It's a timer that counts down where you can see the time going away. Because for kids, like time, especially with digital clocks and stuff, it's so, Didn't you have an hourglass? I have an hourglass. Yeah, I do. I have an hourglass too. I was a Pomodoro one. Pomodoro is like a productivity method, but I had a 25-minute timer and a five-minute timer, both of which were useful, right?

36:10Like we have to get this done. That visual, this is how much time you have left. And then it's the hourglass telling them. It's not you reminding them for the third time. It helps. Not only is it like it removes it so there's a standard that you're not imposing, but it's also certainty. Like I don't when I'm little, I don't understand what five minutes means, but something about like it's this chunk of red or that chunk of red and it just got smaller. It really helps. Sometimes you can make that time timer say it has less time left than you do. Right. Because I had a kid who was like, look at all that red time left.

36:42That's forever. That's one of my shoes. That's the tiniest sliver. Exactly. You know, you can make the time timer smaller when you do. Great point.

36:49Amy Wilson: Like whatever fixes you put in, kids will circumvent. But I think also involving kids in these solutions, even for a pretty young age, can be pretty good. Hey, I love going to the park, but I hate that last five minutes where I'm screaming and you guys were in a terrible mood and blah, blah, blah. What can we do? Let's start setting a timer for 15 minutes when we're going to leave the park. And then this is what we agreed to. It just helps to have something to go back to. Remember, we had a system for this versus we're going to have the conversation while we're in the park. Claire Lerner, who's a child expert, she talks about having this conversation.

37:29Obviously, you can't have it while they're crying at the Jumpy Castle. But she says that it's that bedtime cuddling moment is a great time to do this because they're calm and they also don't want you to leave. So they'll be willing to have a conversation with you to delay bedtime five more minutes. Smart. So that's the time to say, hey, remain back at the park. As you said, like make a collaborative. Like that's just so hard when you really don't want to go. And then you're upset and then mom's upset and we're both upset. And she's like, gee, what should we do about it? That bedtime's a good time to talk about it.

38:02And one fix she suggests is in putting it in place now in this situation, not trying to rule it out in the moment, is to offer extra time for a preferred activity. like we end up being 10 minutes late for school every day and that's stressful and so here's what we're going to do if we get to school on time i'm going to let you stay up 10 minutes later i'm going to let you play 10 more minutes of your game or whatever but if we're late then it's going to go the other way and you're going to lose time give them preferred activity this could work for like an older kid who read who really does staying up later is a very preferred activity i was going

38:35Amy Wilson: to say little kids can be hard yeah and they may not connect it the other thing is the emotionality of the moment, they don't remember. So I've definitely had with kids, wow, you really went to 11 this morning when it was time to put on your backpack. What the heck? And they're like, they just don't relate to that moment anymore. And so you can sometimes solve it in the moment. And the next morning we're back at crazy town. And so that can be frustrating. And I think that's where systems have to go into because I had one kid one time, it was my nephew. I was like, you're my helper tonight. I'm taking four kids to the fair and I need you to be my helper.

39:15Amy Wilson: And he was like the worst behaved of all of them and running around and running off. And I was like, you were supposed to be my helper. He's like, yeah, I know. Sorry about that. You know, and it's like you can't always just work it out ahead of time. You know, it can be complicated. Right. You got to try a bunch of things. Yes. There's a really good point that you want to have a plan. Right. And I think the plan should include validating your kid saying, you know, oh, I see how upset you are. So they don't have to turn it up to make sure that you see how upset they are. Let them know. You get it.

39:45I really see you really, oh, I don't want to leave Sophia's house. I'm having so much fun. I see how upset you are. Then you explain the plan. We're going to do this. But your plan doesn't have to include them agreeing to it first. Great point. Or being fine with it first. That's where I think we can sort of get in a trap of overnegotiating. You You don't have to get them to agree that, OK, it is time to leave Sophia's house.

40:07Amy Wilson: Definitely not. This is where you get into negotiation and you're lost. And I also think you can have rules around this. I had a kid who was famous for in front of friends. Oh, Amy's going to come over later tonight. And I'm like, OK, so the rule is you are not allowed to ask me about plans in front of other people. That has to become the rule. and then in the moment when it happens I can kind of give a look and they recognize oh I broke the rule of asking in front of friends you have to have these conversations outside of the moment yes and then you have to have the rule yes that's the rule so no unfortunately I would have been happy to have Jessica stay I mean you'd say this about the kid around but like I said no because that was the rule if you had waited and asked me then maybe Jessica could have stayed late tonight or stayed over but this is the rule going back to this idea if you say five more minutes and then at the end of five minutes, the time timer is done and that's the end of the activity.

41:05If you negotiate and you extend, then you're just setting that up as what happens next. Step seven is you get 10 more minutes. Someone said you teach a dog to sit by saying sit once. It was my dog trainer. Yes. Kiz Robinson, who trained my kids and me with marshmallow. Right. And they're like, sit, marshmallow, sit, sit, sit, sit. And that's when she said that, like, don't do that because then she's going to think that's the command. You say it once and you wait. Yeah. Oh, this is another good one from Claire Lerner. I hadn't heard it put this way before. Two great choices. Time to leave the playground and your kid doesn't want to.

41:37You say, hey, I know it's really hard to leave the playground because you're having so much fun, but we have to go home. This is a have to. It's time for dinner. Your sister needs dinner, whatever. Right. You have two great choices. If you want to be in charge of your own body, you can climb into the car seat and you can buckle yourself in all by yourself. Or if you want, you can have mommy help you and I can be your helper. Those are two great choices. Which one do you want? Giving that kid a little marketing. We love it. Some autonomy. Right. Two great choices. You have two great choices. You can't have pizza and run around the house because that's the rule here.

42:10So you have two great choices. You can sit down with me and eat your pizza, or you can give me your pizza and go run around, and I'll have it here when you want to come and sit back down and eat. Those are two great choices. And then the kid can pick one and save face and go run around.

42:24Amy Wilson: Kids who are anxious actually want less control. They want to feel like you're in control. And it can feel like this ramping up of emotionality around something, it's easier to give in. But the kid is in contrast to what they're doing. They are asking you for control a lot of the time. They are asking you to take over those overwhelming emotions, to take over that overwhelming fear. In a similar way, when I am anxious about traveling, my husband is amazing at saying, I've got all the passports. I'm taking it from here. I will get us there. You just get in the car. I will get us to Helsinki. I have everything taken care of.

43:10Amy Wilson: He knows that that tells my amygdala, like, calm down, like husband is in control and you can just kind of revert to baby mode and relax. And I think kids are often asking us for exactly that experience, but they ask for it by saying, I don't want you to be in control. And it's you got to really be in your own head and be able to say, I got this. Yeah, I had forgotten all about this anticipation in a minute. I'm going to be talking to you about what you want to have for breakfast. I can't believe I forgot that like that was so helpful to me to try that. I'm totally going to do it and not just with the kids either.

43:52Like in a minute, I'm going to want to talk to you about what time you're getting home tonight, whatever. Like when I'm writing, you know, in five minutes, I'm going to come up and I'm going to ask you if you know where the pepper is. Just a little bit of that reassurance and that control. I need you to transition, but here it comes. It's not here yet, but it's going to be here. It can be magical.

44:12Amy Wilson: And once you establish that, I had something come up a couple weeks ago that I forgot we had dinner plans. And my kids were deep in homework and doing other things. And I literally had to yell, oh, my gosh, we have dinner plans. I completely forgot. Everyone shut off everything. Get in the car. We're 20 minutes late because I completely forgot. It was not great. Everybody was furious. Smoke coming out of their ears. I was supposed to be doing my homework. I was supposed I had my own plans and you've pulled us out into this other place. And I was able to acknowledge this went badly because I made a mistake.

44:48Amy Wilson: I forgot. I did not give you a heads up. I did not give you a warning because the reality is you're not always in your own busy life going to remember, Amy, it's five minutes until we have to leave. You're not always going to remember to do it. But when you set it as the baseline, everything feels more in control. When you think of the iceberg as being made of anxiety, what are you doing to work against that anxiety? Well, we solved it. We solved it, guys. No more trouble with transitions. For any of us, for any of us. This was great. Explosive Child, it will link to it. That's a great book for kids who are struggling with these kind of behaviors.

45:29Right. The lagging skills and unsolved problems. You can take that assessment on behalf of your child and it's eye opening.

45:37Amy Wilson: Super helpful book. I've never loved the title because it feels like reading it would be insulting to your kid. Like explosive is kind of a tough term, but it really just gets into like those jack in the box behaviors where you're trying to do one thing and your kid's having a completely different experience and there's a ton of conflict around it. I mean, I think the very important work they do is sort of like no kid is beyond help. Correct. Kids do well if they can. And it isn't like this kid is just beyond help. That's not true. But you're right. Like it sort of makes it sound like this is only for the most extreme cases.

46:10And really, there's a lot in there. No, you don't have to be at an extreme case to like this book. If you enjoyed this episode, please tell your friends about it. Share it by just tapping on the share button and wherever you're listening right now. Go to our Facebook group or Instagram and share the reels we'll have from this episode. Leave us a rating and a review if you haven't yet. That's how we find new listeners. So thank you. That would be great.

46:32Amy Wilson: Transition yourself over to a podcast app and give us a review. To a non-preferred activity. That's right. To a non-preferred activity reviewing podcasts. That's right. Thank you so much, everyone, for listening, and we will talk to you next time. Thanks, everybody.

From the publisher

Why do some kids completely fall apart when it’s time to leave the playground, get ready for school, or switch activities? We dive into why transitions are particularly difficult for some kids and what parents can do to make them easier.

Here's what we discuss in this episode:

how anxiety, ADHD, autism, and OCD can cause unique issues with transitions

reframing a child’s behavior as a "signal" to help parents focus on the underlying problem

how parents can validate emotions while still setting clear boundaries

practical strategies for helping kids transition, including verbal "previews," visual schedules and timers, and predictable routines

Here are links to some of the resources mentioned in the episode:

Our Fresh Take with Dr. Siggie Cohen

Our Fresh Take with Dr. Stacy Haynes

Katherine Martinelli for the Child Mind Institute: Why Do Kids Have Trouble With Transitions?

Claire Lerner for Psychology Today: The Trouble With Transitions

Kristine Cain for Building Bright Futures blog: Why Some Children Struggle More with Transitions Than Others

Lerner Child Development: The Trouble With Transitions: Why They Are So Hard For Some Kids And How To Help

Houston Family Therapy Associates: Why Kids Resist Transitions (and How to Help)

Lerner Child Development: How "Two-Great Choices" Prevents Power Struggles

Dr. Michael Sweeney

Visual timer for kids

Hourglass timer

Assessment of Lagging Skills and Unsolved Problems

What Fresh Hell is co-hosted by Amy Wilson and Margaret Ables.

We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website:

⁠⁠https://www.whatfreshhellpodcast.com/p/promo-codes/
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from What Fresh Hell: Parenting, Relationships, and Making Life Better, with Two Funny Moms

All episodes