In short
Podcast Episode Notes: Inside OpenAI’s NSFW Growth Plans
Episode Overview
- Podcast Title: WSJ What’s News
- Episode Title: Inside OpenAI’s NSFW Growth Plans
- Date: March 17, 2020
- Host: Luke Vargas
- Guests: Sam Schechner
Episode Description This episode covers significant news events, including geopolitical developments, rising oil prices, and advancements in AI technology. It also delves into OpenAI's controversial plans for an adult-themed chatbot, highlighting the internal debates surrounding this initiative.
Key Headlines
- Israel Airstrikes: Israel claims responsibility for killing Iran's security chief, Ali Larijani, amidst ongoing tensions in the Middle East.
- Oil Prices: Following drone strikes and maritime attacks in the UAE, oil and natural gas prices begin to rise.
- Nvidia's AI Advancements: Nvidia introduced new hardware aimed at enhancing AI model efficiency, predicting a surge in AI chip sales.
- OpenAI's Controversial Plans: Discussion on OpenAI's potential rollout of an adult mode for ChatGPT, with insights from tech reporter Sam Schechner.
Major Discussions
- Geopolitical Developments
- Iran and Israel:
- Israel's Defense Minister confirmed the airstrike on Larijani, who was pivotal in Iran's military strategies.
- Larijani was involved in actions against anti-regime demonstrators.
- Oil Market Reactions:
- Attacks near vital oil trade routes caused concerns and price hikes in oil and gas.
- Nvidia's Technological Innovations
- New Hardware Launch:
- Nvidia's CEO announced new AI chips capable of processing tasks significantly faster than previous models.
- The shift from training to inference in AI is emphasized as a key focus for future developments.
- OpenAI's Adult Mode Strategy
- Background:
- OpenAI is contemplating an adult mode for its chatbot, aiming to cater to adult users just as competitors have.
- The concept has sparked internal debates over ethical implications and potential mental health impacts.
- Concerns Raised:
- Advisors expressed fears over potential negative effects on mental health, including fostering unhealthy emotional dependencies.
- There were strong warnings that the adult mode could inadvertently target minors or create harmful content.
- Internal Management:
- OpenAI formed a Wellbeing and AI Council to address mental health concerns and consult experts from various fields.
- Despite the plan being stalled for now, OpenAI intends to pursue it, ensuring safeguards for minors and avoiding extreme content types.
- Broader Implications
- Cultural and Ethical Dimensions:
- The discussions highlight larger societal questions regarding AI's role in personal relationships and emotional wellbeing.
- OpenAI's challenges reflect the complexities tech companies face in navigating innovation while ensuring user safety.
Conclusion The episode encapsulates a blend of current events and the evolving landscape of technology, particularly in AI. It raises pivotal questions about the intersection of technological capability and ethical responsibility, showcasing OpenAI's proactive measures in addressing potential concerns related to its products.
Additional Notes
- The episode also touched on unrelated topics such as President Trump's statements regarding Cuba and the ongoing situation in the Philippines, providing context on the global political landscape.
- The upcoming visit of Ireland's Prime Minister to the White House and associated investments was briefly mentioned.
Call to Action
- Listeners are encouraged to sign up for the WSJ’s free "What’s News" newsletter for ongoing updates on financial and global news.
---
This summary provides a comprehensive overview of the discussed topics in the podcast, offering insights into both specific news events and broader technological discussions.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOAI and Content Moderation
0:45 to 4:30
Discussion on Instagram's protections for teen accounts and recent news headlines.
“the debate around open AI's not-safe-for-work growth plans.”
OpenAI's Strategic Shift and Adult Features
4:56 to 11:09
Exploration of OpenAI's strategies including adult features and internal debates.
“NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang has unveiled a huge suite of new hardware geared toward running AI models more quickly and efficiently.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Instagram teen accounts. Automatic protections for teens. Instagram teen accounts have built-in content settings now inspired by 13 plus movie ratings and limits for who can contact teens. Plus, teens under 16 can't change these default safety settings without parental approval. So parents can help teens connect safely. Instagram teen accounts. Automatic protections for who can contact teens and the content they can see. Learn more at instagram.com slash teen accounts.
0:33Israel claims to have killed Iran's security chief. We'll get the latest. Plus, NVIDIA signals the dawn of a new age of computing, predicting a doubling in AI chip sales. And we'll go inside the debate around open AI's not-safe-for-work growth plans. Advisors warned that AI-powered erotica could foster these unhealthy emotional dependencies. They were worried that miners could find their way into excess of the chaff that they risk creating a, quote, sexy suicide coach. It's Tuesday, March 17th. I'm Luke Vargas for The Wall Street Journal, and here is the AM edition of What's News, the top headlines and business stories moving your world today.
1:17Israel says it's killed Iran's security chief Ali Larajani in airstrikes last night on Tehran, according to Defense Minister Israel Katz. Lara Jani had emerged as the central figure in Iran's aggressive military response to U.S.-Israeli airstrikes and played a central role in the killings of anti-regime demonstrators in January, according to the U.S. government. Oil and natural gas prices are rising today. That's after an overnight drone strike on a gas field in the United Arab Emirates and an attack today on a tanker off the Emirati coast near a key oil trading hub that lies outside of the Strait of Hormuz.
1:56Meanwhile, the UAE has reopened its airspace after a brief precautionary shutdown earlier today. Nevertheless, British Airways said it's extending a suspension of flights to Dubai and other Mideast destinations until May 31, along with a cancellation of flights to Doha until April 30. Skipping the region altogether, the airline is instead adding more flights directly from London to Bangkok and Singapore.
2:23President Trump has asked China to delay a summit with Xi Jinping in Beijing originally scheduled for this month. Trump cited the war in Iran in explaining the requested one-month pushback. We report that Trump aims to land a trade deal at the summit while Xi is seeking U.S. concessions on Taiwan, potentially including the scrapping of planned arms sales to the island. Cuba has been plunged into darkness with officials reporting a complete disconnection of its power grid. It's Cuba's third nationwide blackout in four months amid a U.S. oil blockade and comes as demonstrators have been using the cover of darkness to voice frustration over dire living conditions.
3:07Speaking at the White House yesterday, President Trump touted the crippling effects of his blockade and predicted that he'd have the honor of taking the island. Taking Cuba in some form, yeah. Taking Cuba. I mean, whether I free it, take it, I think I can do anything I want with it. You want to know the truth. They're a very weakened nation right now. In a pair of judicial updates, a federal judge in Massachusetts has blocked the Trump administration from paring down the list of recommended vaccines for kids, saying that the government improperly bypassed the technical knowledge and expertise of a vaccine advisory panel overhauled by Health Secretary Robert F.
3:47Kennedy Jr. An HHS spokesman said the department looks forward to the judge's decision being overturned. And the Supreme Court has agreed to hear arguments on the Trump administration's push to end legal protections for Haitian and Syrian immigrants. Arguments are set for the last week of April, with a likely decision this summer expected to also affect immigrants from 11 other countries that the administration has moved to expel from the federal Temporary Protected Status Program. Coming up, an exclusive look at OpenAI's strategy to beat out competitors, including controversial plans for a chatbot with adult features.
4:23That and the rest of the day's news after the break.
4:29This podcast is brought to you by ReliaQuest. Cyber criminals are constantly attacking. They want your data. They want your identity. They want your innovation. ReliaQuest's AI detects, contains, and eliminates cyber threats faster. It helps your security teams move faster at the work that matters most to protect the business now and delivers insights to help them predict what's next. ReliaQuest. AI-powered cybersecurity. Learn more at ReliaQuest.com. That's R-E-L-I-A-Q-U-E-S-T dot com.
5:03NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang has unveiled a huge suite of new hardware geared toward running AI models more quickly and efficiently. At the company's annual developers event, Huang said the business of AI is now moving away from training to inference, where models answer users, and that requires better chips. To meet that demand, NVIDIA has built new server racks able to compute 350 times faster than its second-to-last generation of GPUs. So we believe that this is the future. This is where AI wants to go. Huang also said NVIDIA expects to sell$1 trillion worth of its Blackwell and Rubin chips by the end of 2027, a doubling of its previous guidance.
5:45Meanwhile, we're exclusively reporting that OpenAI is finalizing plans for a major strategy pivot in order to focus on dominating the coding and enterprise markets. Journal tech reporter Berber Jin says OpenAI has been facing a tremendous amount of pressure from Anthropic, which has been the go-to platform for software developers and businesses looking to integrate AI into their workflows. This is a really interesting moment for OpenAI because last year the company was essentially releasing a new product almost on a monthly cadence. They announced a new hardware device that they were developing with Johnny Ive.
6:21They announced Sora, which was their standalone social media and video generator app. They were working on new features inside ChatGPT, including e-commerce and a potential social network. So it was really a kind of spread out strategy that left some employees confused about the strategic direction of the company. And this also interestingly comes as the company is preparing for a public listing. And what you're seeing now is executives really try to instill an added degree of discipline into the business and to essentially reorient the company around winning a few key business segments. Well, another way OpenAI is looking to make a profit is by catering to adult audiences.
7:05Journal tech reporter Sam Schechner says the company has been weighing the rollout of an adult mode. And he's here to discuss what that would entail and why it's been delayed. Sam, several of OpenAI's competitors have adult features, chief among them XAI's Grok, but also Meta in some form. So why then did talk of open AI pushing into this space elicit, as you report, a freakout among its advisors earlier this year? Well, they floated this idea last year. And, you know, Sam Altman tweeted about it. He said the company wants to treat adult users like adults. And the plan has sparked vigorous debate inside the company.
7:43And there's some people who say, you know what, we shouldn't be in the business of censoring content. If people want to have spicy conversations with a chatbot, who are we to say no? That's one side of the argument. The other side, though, looks at some of the mental health impacts of chatbots. Already, there's research showing that extremely heavy users can have some poor impact on their mental health. It can have them withdraw from real human connections. They can have unhealthy emotional dependence. And the concern internally was that this could supercharge that, hijack the brain's emotional romantic circuitry to get you even more attached to your chatbot.
8:26And how is OpenAI addressing that concern? So OpenAI, you know, as part of their response to some of the mental health issues that have been laid at its feet, created something called their Wellbeing and AI Council. They brought in experts with backgrounds in things like psychology and cognitive neuroscience, also human-computer interaction. And the plan was to basically consult with them on what they're doing to try to come up with what would be best for users. And this group expressed some of those same concerns that we heard internally. And at a meeting in January when the company told this group, this council, that they were moving ahead, advisors, according to our sources, were unanimous and furious.
9:12They warned that AI-powered erotica could foster these unhealthy emotional dependencies, that they were worried that minors could find their way into access to chats. That was a major concern. One of the council members actually warned OpenAI that they thought that they risked creating a, quote, sexy suicide coach. So, Sam, for the time being, at least, adult mode is delayed, and yet OpenAI has made it clear it does plan to release it eventually. Do we have a sense of what that could look like now that there has been such a big airing of concerns about the effect of this content? Well, they have said that they're working on other priorities.
9:50But our understanding is that they are also working on trying to make sure that minors can't get access to this mode. They're trying to improve the age prediction algorithm that they use to detect when they think a user is under 18. They, first of all, are only talking about text. They're not going to get into video generation like some of the other platforms out there when it comes to explicit content. A spokeswoman for the company described it as smut, not pornography. They also have certain types of explicit content that they were just going to rule out altogether. So while you could potentially have chatbot sex with ChatGPT, they are aiming to rule out scenarios involving non-consensual sex or child abuse.
10:36Sam, if there's anyone just listening to this interview and scratching their head and say, why are the two of them talking about AI chatbot sex? I think there's a reason you reported on this. This is something that is getting at some of the bigger debates likely to come up in tech and in society over the coming years. I really think that this is one of the many cutting edges of these questions that we're facing about how to deal with all of the impacts, positive and negative, that we're going to see from AI on not just our economy, our political systems, but also us as individual people. What do we want from these tools?
11:15And even inside a company like OpenAI, where all those people are obviously incentivized to want the success of their company, there's not a single point of view. And I think we all want to get a little bit of a look inside the machine, like what is happening and how are these companies approaching the difficult questions that we're going to see more and more in the future. I've been speaking to Wall Street Journal tech reporter Sam Schechner. Sam, thank you as always. As always, a pleasure. Thanks for having me. And finally, it's St. Patrick's Day today. And per tradition, that means a White House visit by Ireland's prime minister.
11:51Gifts are a staple of the visit, but correspondent Natalie Andrews says the prime minister is expected to go big this year, bearing a$6.1 billion investment pledge designed to create American jobs and boost manufacturing. The investments being announced include$5 billion over five years from a sustainable paper packaging company called Smurfett Westrock, a billion dollars from Kingspan, which is an insulation and building company, and then$100 million in investments from a nutrition company called Glambia. Last year, Trump threw a wrench in the historically strong relationship, claiming that Ireland was taking advantage of the U.S.
12:29shortly before announcing his Liberation Day tariffs. and a year on trade tensions are likely to remain in focus. Dublin's tech industry and pharmaceutical industry is booming. And this is something that Donald Trump has brought up, especially in the pharmaceutical lane. He's spent the last year trying to lower drug prices in the U.S. and lamenting about how other countries have better deals. He also wants investment in pharmaceuticals in the U.S. And so it is a delicate balance. Donald Trump brings up drug prices in his effort to lower them all the time. And it's likely something he'll bring up again if he starts talking about trade.
13:04And that's it for What's News for this Tuesday morning. Additional sound in this episode was from Reuters. Today's show was produced by Hattie Moyer and Daniel Bach. Our supervising producer is Sandra Killhoff. And I'm Luke Vargas for The Wall Street Journal. We will be back tonight with a new show. Until then, thanks for listening.
13:28The spirit of innovation is deeply ingrained in America, and Google is helping Americans innovate in ways both big and small. The National Cancer Institute used Google AI to develop Nancy, an app that helps cancer researchers collaborate, identify patterns, recommend research, and accelerate scientific discovery. This is a new era of American innovation. Learn more at g.co slash American Innovation.
From the publisher
A.M. Edition for Mar. 17. Israel says it killed Iran’s security chief, Ali Larijani, in airstrikes last night on Tehran, according to defense minister Israel Katz. Oil and natural gas prices are rising after an overnight drone strike and an attack today on a tanker off the Emirati coast. Plus, Nvidia has unveiled a suite of new hardware geared toward running AI models more quickly and efficiently. And WSJ’s Sam Schechner on why OpenAI has been weighing the rollout of a controversial “adult mode” of ChatGPT. Luke Vargas hosts.
Sign up for the WSJ’s free What’s News newsletter.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
