


How U.S. ambassadors and embassies handle crises and protect American citizens abroad, using a current example: a U.S. Embassy in Qatar warning Americans to shelter in place amid fears of Iranian retaliation after Trump ordered strikes on three Iranian nuclear sites. The panel also discusses soft power, U.S. global standing, and the impact of staffing/cuts to State Department, USAID, and Voice of America.
Ambassador Susan Ziada (U.S. ambassador to Qatar, 2011–2014; career Foreign Service; served in Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Bahrain). Ambassador Gordon Gray (ambassador to Tunisia, 2009–2012; 30+ years Foreign Service; taught Gulf/Arab affairs at GWU). Ambassador Ryan Crocker (served six times as U.S. ambassador, including Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Syria, Kuwait, Lebanon; now RAND diplomacy/security chair; former Middle East Broadcasting Networks board chair).
Ambassadors are the president’s voice and crisis leaders; they activate citizen-safety networks and coordinate with host governments. Crisis communication relies on embassy country teams/emergency action committees and registered citizen outreach. Ambassadors advise but don’t make policy; they must report “unvarnished” facts. Vacant ambassador posts (Baghdad, Jordan, Riyadh/Saudi Arabia) harm U.S. interests. Cutting development and public diplomacy weakens U.S. soft power and creates openings for rivals’ narratives.
Tunisia during the Arab Spring (Bouazizi’s self-immolation Dec 17, 2010; Ben Ali fled Jan 14, 2011). Afghanistan/Iraq negotiations: opening the Afghanistan embassy after the Taliban and arranging passage of armor/tanks to fight al-Qaeda via “coercive diplomacy.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discover how ambassadors respond to crises like the Israel-Iran conflict.
“We'll be back with the conversation in just a moment.”
Understand how ambassadors convey crucial information during emergencies.
“So we are, as I just mentioned at the beginning of the hour, of course, everyone is following the Israel-Iran conflict closely, including the shaky ceasefire that took hold yesterday.”
Explore how relationships influence ambassadors’ effectiveness in crisis management.
“So as we talk about the evolving situation that's happening in Qatar right now, as I mentioned, the embassy has issued a warning to Americans to shelter in place.”
Examine how U.S. relations are affected by political leadership changes.
“We'll be back with more of our conversation in just a moment.”
Learn about the balance ambassadors must strike between truth and policy implementation.
“relationships have changed during Trump's second term?”
Learn about the essential responsibilities and functions of ambassadors in diplomacy.
“But again, it's very important to note that ambassadors don't make policy.”
Explore the differences between diplomats and ambassadors and their roles in embassies.
“It sounded like you were starting to answer this.”
Discuss the challenges facing the U.S. Foreign Service amidst changing global dynamics.
“The three of us, Susan Gordon and I, speak Arabic.”
Hear about the U.S. representation in Tunisia during the Arab Spring and its implications.
“As we're just like in the backdrop of it, we're talking about the importance of diplomacy, foreign service ambassadors.”
Learn about significant negotiations and the concept of coercive diplomacy in conflict resolution.
“Ambassador Crocker, I imagine given the numerous countries that you served in, you probably negotiated many high stakes situations.”
Examine the effectiveness of politically appointed ambassadors compared to career diplomats.
“diplomacy that I imagine you still think needs to be polite and truthful, but diplomatic and weighing the severity of the situation and conveying that appropriately.”
Discuss the significance of consistent messaging and unity among diplomats.
“Let's get back to the conversation and turn to current events.”
Analyze the consequences of budget cuts to USAID on U.S. diplomatic efforts.
“Washington takes that information plus their own policy priorities, comes up with a strategy, and the strategy is therefore for us to implement.”
Explore how reductions in soft power could allow other nations to expand their influence.
“interests and to further our own national security, we have eliminated one of those three.”
Explore the importance of U.S. communication in the context of global narratives.
“but also with our public diplomacy efforts, such as the virtual elimination of Voice of America.”
Discuss the impact of reduced American presence in global media and its implications.
“Ambassador Crocker, can I just ask you a follow-up to what Ambassador Gray is talking about?”
Understand how information shapes narratives and its significance in U.S. foreign policy.
“that includes Iran and Russia broadcasting in Arabic, filling the airwaves that we vacated.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On 1A, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:07Earlier this week, the U.S. Embassy in Qatar issued a warning to American citizens to quote, shelter in place until further notice. Qatar is home to the largest U.S. military base in the Middle East. The alert came amid growing fears of Iranian retaliation against U.S. troops and personnel overseas after President Trump ordered strikes on three Iranian nuclear sites. When global news breaks, especially emergencies, embassies and the ambassadors leading them play a crucial role. They're on the ground, serving as the top representatives of the U.S. government. Ambassadors also protect U.S. citizens abroad.
0:45So what does that work look like today? How do embassies and ambassadors help preserve America's so-called soft power? And what's their role during moments of crises? I'm Nyla Boodoo in for Jen White. And for this installment of our Ask a Series, we ask an ambassador, or in this case, a panel of ambassadors, about the work they do. You're listening to the 1A Podcast. We'll be back with the conversation in just a moment. Stay with us.
1:16Let's meet our guests. Joining us in studio is Ambassador Susan Ziada. She's the former U.S. ambassador to Qatar from 2011 to 2014, a career foreign service officer who also served in Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and Bahrain. Hi, Ambassador Ziada. Thank you for being here with us. Thank you for having me. Joining us from Delaware, Ambassador Gordon Gray was the ambassador to Tunisia from 2009 to 2012. He also served for more than three decades in the Foreign Service, including in Egypt, Canada, Jordan, Iraq, and Pakistan. He's now the Kuwait Professor of Gulf and Arabian Affairs at the Elliott School of International Affairs at George Washington University.
1:54Hi, Ambassador Gray. Hi, thank you for inviting me to be on the show. And joining us from Washington State, Ambassador Ryan Crocker, who served as U.S. ambassador six times in Afghanistan from 2011 to 2012, Iraq from 2007 to 2009, Pakistan from 2004 to 2007, Syria from 1998 to 2001, Kuwait from 1994 to 1997, and Lebanon from 1990 to 1993. He is now the Distinguished Chair in Diplomacy and Security at RAND and Chairman of the Board of the Middle East Broadcasting Networks. Ambassador Crocker, thank you for your time as well this morning. Thank you. So we are, as I just mentioned at the beginning of the hour, of course, everyone is following the Israel-Iran conflict closely, including the shaky ceasefire that took hold yesterday.
2:45Even as both sides are claiming the other, we're continuing the attacks. Countries across the Middle East, of course, are worried about further escalation and a wider regional war. Can I just start by asking all of you, Ambassador Crocker, can I start with you? What role do ambassadors play in moments like this? An ambassador is the president's personal representative in a given country, meaning he is the voice, he or she is the voice of the United States to that country. That is one category of issues. conducting relations with a given country, particularly in a crisis. Another very important function of an ambassador is the safety and well-being of American citizens in her or his country.
3:34We are your 9-11. When you're traveling abroad, if something happens, you can call an embassy anytime, day or night. And if an emergency situation develops, as we've seen in the Middle East, we are on alert, activating our citizens network to do everything we can to keep our people safe. So it's a big job and it cannot be done by long distance. You have to have that woman or man on the ground to make these things happen. Ambassador Gray, we actually got a question from Margaret in Chicago who was asking how do ambassadors convey crucial information during an emergency like what Ambassador Crocker was just talking about.
4:16There are several ways to do that. For long-term residents of a foreign country, U.S. residents, they're encouraged to register with the embassy so that the embassy can reach out to them by text, by email in times of crisis along the lines that Ambassador Crocker was describing. information's posted on the embassy website. That's for instantaneous transmission of information. It's also important for ambassadors to hold town hall meetings with different constituencies in the American community in terms of crisis, both to answer their questions and to reassure them and to let them know that their voices and their concerns are being heard.
5:15Ambassador Ziada, as we think about the role of an ambassador in a crisis, is there anything else that you think it's important for us to know to give us sort of an inside look into what happens during a situation like this? Well, I think it's important to know that the ambassador's leadership of his country team inside the mission, his leadership in terms of his or her relations with the host government, the ambassador's reach back to Washington to report and also to find out information that could have bearing on the trajectory of events in the region, and also So the ambassador's role in disseminating information within the embassy and within the greater American community, as both ambassadors Crocker and Gray describe, is paramount in this situation.
6:12The communication and the confidence that the American community within the embassy and within the host country receive by seeing that steps are taken and are clearly communicated is perhaps one of the most important characteristics or skill sets that an ambassador must have. So as we talk about the evolving situation that's happening in Qatar right now, as I mentioned, the embassy has issued a warning to Americans to shelter in place. Ambassador Ziada, what considerations go into a decision like that? Well, usually that would come out of a meeting of the country team or the emergency action committee.
6:58This is a gathering of heads of the various agencies and section heads within an embassy. to deliberate the information at hand, what we know, how specific it is, how timely it is. And of course, when we have that level of granularity that gives us a certainty, the importance of communicating that not just within the embassy, but to the American community at large. And in this case, it's pretty clear that information was communicated directly from the U.S. to Qatar and also from the Iranians to Qatar. And in this case, having that shared relationship from the embassy to the host government to make sure that all information is being shared is critically important.
7:52And so the step was taken to share all of that information with the Americans because, as Ambassador Crocker said, the paramount importance of protecting our American citizens in the host country. Ambassador Gray, as we're talking about current events in the Middle East, I wonder what insight you have into what Ambassador Ziada is talking about in terms of relationships with host countries. If you can give us insight into what that looks like now across the Middle East in terms of ambassadors and their relationships in diplomatic channels, maybe even if I'm just kind of curious what that host relationship looks like, if it depends on how much that country's relationship to the United States is strong.
8:36It certainly depends on the strength, the breadth, and the history of the bilateral relationship. But it also depends on the personal relationships that an ambassador can establish in the country. And I think this is what Ambassador Ziada was just getting at. So it's really important to have both. I would like to note, though, unfortunately, there are several ambassadorships that are vacant in many countries, including key countries across the Middle East and North Africa. Which vacancies are most concerning to you right now, Ambassador Gray? Well, the two that come to my mind most immediately are we do not have a confirmed ambassador in Baghdad.
9:42We do not have a confirmed ambassador in Jordan. And I'm not aware that we have a confirmed ambassador in Riyadh, in Saudi Arabia. those are three pretty important countries to the United States. They're very important countries in the Middle East and not having ambassadors there is detrimental to promoting U.S. interests and protecting U.S. citizens. Let's head to a quick break here. We'll be back with more of our conversation in just a moment. Stay with us.
10:27Let's get back to the conversation with this question we got from one of you in Texas. What is the reputation of the U.S. in the eyes of other countries? Ambassador Crocker? The U.S. is the world's leader. That is, I think, beyond dispute whether a country views us as an ally, a neutral, or an adversary. We are taken very seriously because we are the world's strongest power. um sometimes that uh perception uh leads to misconceptions of what we can actually do or what we will do and of course it's up to an ambassador and his or her country team to uh make clear what the uh exercise of power will actually look like and that again comes down to the point that Ambassador Ziada made earlier, the importance of relationships.
11:22You know, crisis leadership doesn't start in a crisis, whether it's with the host country or with your American citizen community or with your own embassy team. You've got to build those relationships from the day you arrive in country. And that means it's personal. Right. Yeah. As we think about relationships, Ambassador Gray, can I just fold in a similar question that we got from Michigan asking about what the standing of the U.S. abroad is, how that's changed since President Trump has come to power for his second term? How has that affected relationships from the ambassador's standpoint? Well, from an ambassador's standpoint, you take an oath to defend the Constitution, and implicit in that oath is that you will faithfully carry out whatever the policies are of the government.
12:19So it's your responsibility to do that, whether you agree or disagree with them personally. Now, that being said, it's also incumbent upon any responsible ambassador to give his or her best advice to Washington, D.C., even if that best advice is not always welcomed. Ambassador Ziadro, what's your perspective on how you think maybe U.S. standing, U.S. relationships have changed during Trump's second term? And as Ambassador Gray is talking about advice, I wonder what advice you would offer to current ambassadors who are navigating this? Well, I think the importance of the role of the ambassador is to be honest, to be faithful, and to report what they see.
13:15It may not always be welcome, as Ambassador Gray stated. On the other hand, to have Washington needs the full scope of information. They need to know the whole range of issues at hand and to be able to adjust their policy accordingly. Now, they may dismiss it out of hand, but to be faithful to upholding the Constitution and doing your job, it seems to me that one has to report faithfully in terms of what is happening on the ground. Ambassador Crocker, I imagine there's a lot of diplomacy involved in doing that, in reporting faithfully up through the channels, what's happening? There is. But again, it is a requirement, as my colleagues have laid out, that an ambassador speak truth to power, that an ambassador present an unvarnished set of impressions, of facts, that that's why she or he is there, to be able to sense the conditions in a country, the mood, likely reactions.
14:25But again, it's very important to note that ambassadors don't make policy. They advise on policy and they implement it. And we do so regardless of what administration is in power. I was an ambassador six times, three times for Republican administrations, three times for Democratic administrations. It doesn't matter which party holds the White House. An ambassador is the representative of the president and serves that president to the best of her, his ability. Robin in Detroit left us a message with our app, 1A Vox Pop. Ambassador Gray, can I put this to you? It sounded like you were starting to answer this.
15:02And Robin's wondering, what exactly is the difference between an ambassador and a diplomat? Well, any embassy is staffed with not just foreign service officers, but also with representatives from other agencies as well. The ambassador is the only person who is nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate to serve as the leadership, as the leader of the diplomatic mission in any given country. But there are many people working at the embassy are diplomats. There are career foreign service officers who are engaged in diplomatic work, be it political reporting, be it commercial advocacy, be it protecting U.S.
15:58citizens. There each embassy has a senior defense official who is, in effect, a military diplomat because he or she is responsible for maintaining a good relationship with the host country military. So that's basically the difference is the ambassador is the head of the mission, the leader of the mission, and is nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. Ambassador Crocker, as we're talking about the Foreign Service, this broader term to describe diplomats that represent the U.S. and its interests abroad, we know last year the Foreign Service marked its 100th anniversary. And according to the American Foreign Service Association, there are around 15 ,000 foreign service officers worldwide.
16:50As we look at the changes that have happened in the past couple of months with the pipeline of civil servants, I just want to ask you about when you're talking about the idea of the foreign service, what you think the state of that is now in America. Never has America needed its foreign service more than it does right now. President Trump has shaken the world's tree, whether that is in the Middle East, as we've just seen with Iran, whether that is in Europe vis-a-vis NATO, Russia, China. There is a great deal of motion, and that is when the Foreign Service is its most essential. All Foreign Service officers are professionally fluent in at least one language.
17:35One foreign language. The three of us, Susan Gordon and I, speak Arabic. We have years of experience on the ground. We know the cultures, we know the players, we know the issues. So this is a time when, with the impact of the Trump administration's many changes in our global priorities and our actions, when the Foreign Service is at its most essential. Yet we have seen a budget submitted that is going to dramatically cut the level of spending in the State Department and for the Foreign Service. We have seen a suspension of the intake of new Foreign Service officers. We don't know when that will be resumed.
18:22Also, the Foreign Service exam is no longer being given. We hope that's a temporary pause. But at a time when the Foreign Service, I think, is at its most vital for American interests, we're seeing cuts rather than efforts to expand it. Ambassador Gray, you were ambassador to Tunisia in 2010 when the Arab Spring began. As we're just like in the backdrop of it, we're talking about the importance of diplomacy, foreign service ambassadors. Can you just share what your experience was like representing the U.S. during that time? Certainly, it was actually a very, certainly an interesting time, but also an inspirational time.
19:08The revolution in Tunisia happened very quickly. Muhammad Bouazizi set himself on fire on Friday, December 17, 2010, and a mere four weeks later, January 14, 2011, Ben Ali fled into exile in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. The challenges were several. One was at the top of our list, protecting the U.S. community. We had a voluntary departure of staff and American citizens to make sure that they felt comfortable. But it was also very important to show the Tunisian people that we supported their transition from an authoritarian regime to whatever democratic future they chose. And we were able to do that with a wide range of tools of statecraft, economic, political, public diplomacy.
20:29Ambassador Crocker, I imagine given the numerous countries that you served in, you probably negotiated many high stakes situations. Is there one that comes to mind that you can share with us? I was the lead negotiator in both Afghanistan and Iraq for broad-ranging strategic framework agreements that bound our two countries closer together in every aspect of our relationship, economic as well as security, informational, cultural, and so forth. These were enormous challenges involving representatives from many different agencies. But the episode I remember the most clearly was after the fall of the Taliban when I opened our embassy in Afghanistan.
21:14We had to negotiate the passage of armor from an Afghan faction to join a fight against al-Qaeda up in the remote northeastern mountains of Afghanistan. And that required the application of coercive diplomacy. A tribal leader was determined to block the passage of those tanks because a rival faction possessed them. And in the middle of the night, with a team of diplomats who were all bearded and heavily armed, we sat down with our Afghan counterparts and made clear that those tanks were going through either with the permission of the tribal leader or without it. And if it was without, we would use whatever force is necessary.
22:06It's called coercive diplomacy. It's not coercion outright, but it is making an interlocutor aware that coercion is an option and it worked. Imagine Ambassador Crocker that it can be coercive diplomacy that I imagine you still think needs to be polite and truthful, but diplomatic and weighing the severity of the situation and conveying that appropriately. Yes, the harder the message, the more level the tone needs to be. We got an email from Lionel who said that ambassadors are sometimes selected from political allies without diplomatic experience. Ambassador Ziad, can I ask, Lionel wants to know how well do such people perform compared to diplomatic professionals?
22:51Well, it's a wide range of performance, to be quite honest. Many of them come from positions in industry or previous government positions. We've had a number of governors, for example, previous governors who have been appointed ambassador, and they have tremendous leadership and managerial talent that they can bring to the table. Some of them from industry, the same thing. So it really depends on how much experience they have and how well they listen to folks who have more experience in the embassy to be able to round out their experience. Let's take a quick pause here. We'll be back with more of our Ask an Ambassador in just a moment.
23:37Stay with us.
23:43Let's get back to the conversation and turn to current events. President Trump spoke from the NATO summit in The Hague. He said Russian President Vladimir Putin called him to offer help with settling the situation in Iran. No, I consider him a person that's, I think, been misguided. I'm very surprised, actually. I thought we would have had that settled. I've settled four of them in the meantime. But he did call up and he said, you know, he's close to Iran. He'd like to help us get a settlement. I said, no, no, you help me get a settlement with you, with Russia. Ambassador Gray, what's your reaction to the president's statement there about Vladimir Putin?
24:23Well, I'm pleased to see that the president is very clear-eyed about Putin and what Putin needs to do. And as far as U.S. interests are concerned, what Putin needs to do is stop meddling in the Middle East and withdraw his troops from the unprovoked invasion of Ukraine. Ambassador Zeta, as we talk about the president's statements, I wonder how important it is from a diplomatic standpoint to have everyone on the same page. Well, we serve at the pleasure of the president. And our job, as Ambassador Crocker pointed out earlier, is to implement the policies as set by the administration and, of course, led by the president.
25:12So it doesn't matter whether it's a Democratic or a Republican administration. Our job is to, as I said earlier, to report faithfully, to give the sense on the ground. Washington takes that information plus their own policy priorities, comes up with a strategy, and the strategy is therefore for us to implement. And that's what we do regardless of who is in the White House. We got a lot of questions about USAID. Workers at the U.S. Agency for International Development, many of whom are Foreign Service officers, numbered about 5 ,000 until recently. But this year, sweeping cutbacks began. In early June, Secretary of State Marco Rubio directed U.S.
25:55embassies worldwide to dismiss all remaining USAID staffers. Can I just first hear what work you all did as ambassadors in implementing U.S. foreign aid and assistance? Ambassador Crocker, what's your reaction to the dismantling of USAID? It is a major blow self-inflicted to our ability to project national power overseas. There are three elements of power, defense, diplomacy, and development. the three Ds that we classically employ, the weight depending on the situation in a given country, to further U.S. interests and to further our own national security, we have eliminated one of those three.
26:39And that is going to, I think, overall weaken the United States globally for the foreseeable future. In Afghanistan, for example, our development projects were very closely tied to our security goals. The AID mission director worked, extremely worked for me, but he also worked very closely with the commander of U.S. forces to ensure that our development objectives were synced up with our security objectives. It is a fundamental pillar of that triad. And we have weakened it, almost eliminated it. And that is unfortunate. I think we're going to have to build it back. Ambassador Gray, can I ask you specifically, since you served in Tunisia, we got a text that asked, how have cutbacks to soft power hobbled diplomacy, especially in Africa?
27:30If the U.S. is not practicing soft diplomacy, is this an opportunity for China and perhaps India to have greater influence in the region? Well, it's absolutely an opportunity for other countries, be China or India or others, to come in. You know, nature abhors a vacuum, and we're going to see that happen with the elimination of both the development programs that Ambassador Crocker was describing, but also with our public diplomacy efforts, such as the virtual elimination of Voice of America. I think it was very telling that shortly after the Israeli-Iranian war began, the Trump administration brought back from administrative leave 75 Farsi speakers working for the Voice of America because they realized the United States needs to tell its own story in its own words.
28:45but in the language of its audience. And if absent that, we're going to, you're going to have others telling the narrative, and that does not support U.S. interests or U.S. values. Ambassador Crocker, can I just ask you a follow-up to what Ambassador Gray is talking about? We also got this text from someone in Virginia who mentioned the staff reductions at State, the closure of Voice of America and USAID and asks, what tools do diplomats, American diplomats have left to leverage soft power? Well, we still have a lot of power, soft and hard. But Gordon's point on the elimination or the dramatic reduction in the American voice overseas, I think, is particularly relevant.
29:36I'm the chairman of the board of Middle East Broadcasting Networks. Susan Ziada is a member of that board. We broadcast in Arabic as a private U.S. government grantee in Arabic to about 35 million people. We've had to cut our staff by 90 % and our transmissions accordingly. So at a critical time in the Middle East, our ability to communicate American perspectives and American views to a multi-million listener audience has been severely reduced. And as Gordon says, others are ready to fill that vacuum with misinformation and disinformation that includes Iran and Russia broadcasting in Arabic, filling the airwaves that we vacated.
30:25This is not a time to have America's voice go silent. And Mr. Ziadah, can I just ask you to provide us a perspective on what that media landscape looks like now as we think about sort of the modern way that people are consuming information, the amount of the vast amounts of mis - and disinformation out there. If you can give us a sense, how important is it to have what Ambassador Crocker is talking about in terms of an American perspective? Well, I think information is the coin of the realm. Information is what shapes the narrative. It's not just to inform, although first and foremost, But it also is how you bring people on board, how you make them understand what our objectives are in the region, why we're there, and what we're doing.
31:12And it seems to me that for many people, they get their social media, they get from TV. You would be surprised how many people listen to radio in the Middle East. It's still a common way of people communicating and hearing, particularly in some of the more remote regions. And so not to have those platforms is extremely damaging to U.S. interests in the region because it denies us the ability to project our rationales, our strategy, why we're there, what we're doing, in ways that are very important to our allies and to people of the region to have a better understanding of what we are doing. Well, we'll leave the conversation there.
32:01Ambassadors Ryan Crocker, Susan Ziada, and Gordon Gray, thank you all for joining us today. Today's producer was Avery Jessa Chapnick. This program comes to you from WAMU, part of American University in Washington, distributed by NPR. I'm Naila Boodoo, in for Jen White. Let's talk more soon. This is One It.