1. Podcasts
  2. 1A
  3. Politics: The Midterms At The Dinner Table
1A

17 Nov 2026 · 34m · 15 chapters

Episode artwork

Politics: The Midterms At The Dinner Table

In short

How politically mixed couples and families handle divisive politics during the holidays, especially after the 2024 election and midterms; includes advice from a relationship therapist and a politics-news entrepreneur on building shared “consensus reality.”

Guests and backgrounds

  • Maggie and Laura: a long-married (married 2013; ~50 years together) politically mixed couple in Georgia; Maggie is a lifelong Democrat; Laura is an independent who votes Republican.
  • Alexandra Solomon: licensed clinical psychologist; author of Love Every Day; relationship therapy perspective.
  • Isaac Saul: politics reporter; founder of Tangle News, a newsletter presenting arguments from left, right, and center.

Key claims

  • Political differences map onto values and can threaten feeling seen and understood; avoidant silence can breed resentment.
  • Couples can reduce conflict by agreeing on how to talk (curiosity, not trying to change the other, stop when heated).
  • Tangle News helps by giving a shared set of facts/arguments before disagreements.

Notable examples

  • Maggie and Laura watch different cable news; they sometimes “look it up” together later.
  • Tangle News was boosted by a “Question Everything” episode about a marriage nearly ending over politics.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:20

Maggie and Laura's Political Dynamics

Listen to Maggie and Laura discuss their differing political views.

“back in with Maggie and Laura after the midterm elections to see how they're doing.”
2:07

Maggie and Laura's Political Dynamics

Listen to Maggie and Laura discuss their differing political views.

“Discount cannot be combined with insurance.”
3:00

Challenges in Political Discussions

Maggie and Laura share their struggles and strategies in discussing politics.

“So the last time we spoke, Maggie, you identified as a lifelong Democrat.”
6:40

Reflections on Previous Elections

Maggie and Laura reflect on their thoughts from past elections and their impact.

“I think we mentioned two years ago that we watch different, you know, cable TV and things like, you know, news programs.”
10:00

Voices from the Audience

Hear insights from listeners about political relationships and dating.

“But I do believe because of this vision that I see he has, that things are going to improve.”
13:20

Expert Reactions: Love and Politics

Experts discuss the dynamics of love and politics in relationships.

“You heard us mention it in our conversation with Maggie and Laura.”
14:06

Navigating Political Differences in Relationships

Explore the dynamics of couples who disagree politically and how they manage their conversations.

“They've got their wine on their front porch, and they named that humor is protective.”
16:42

The Unique Challenges of Romantic Partnerships

Learn how frequent interactions influence political discussions in romantic relationships compared to familial ones.

“Why and how are those relationships different than other types of relationships, especially when it comes to navigating political differences?”
19:26

The Importance of Communication in Mixed-Political Couples

Discuss the significance of open communication about political beliefs between partners.

“Macfound.org Welcome back to the 1A Podcast.”
24:10

Understanding Political Affiliation in Relationships

Examine how political beliefs relate to personal values and moral beliefs in relationships.

“I enjoyed it in some ways because when we'd argue, it would force me to take a hard look at exactly what I believed and why, so I could make a strong and accurate case.”
Show all 15 chapters
28:01

Navigating Polarization in Relationships

Learn how political differences impact personal relationships and the challenges faced by couples.

“and wasn't willing to separate out the politics from the person and the relationship.”
29:41

The Impact of Political Views on Relationships

Discover how differing political views can lead to relationship challenges and audience reactions.

“And that episode was called Can Journalism Save a Marriage?”
31:30

Starting Difficult Political Conversations

Explore strategies for initiating discussions about politics in relationships to foster understanding.

“And yeah, it was really rewarding and it grew our audience a lot and it brought in a lot of people, I think, with the intention of engaging in the mission that we're after, which was obviously a really powerful thing.”
34:59

The Future of Consensus Reality in Media

Examine the current state of media and the potential for a shared consensus reality.

“Isaac, one of the reasons you found at Tangle News was because of what you felt was a lack of consensus reality.”
36:36

The Future of Consensus Reality in Media

Examine the current state of media and the potential for a shared consensus reality.

A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 1A, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This episode is sponsored by Carvana, which offers the following message. Carvana Value Tracker lets you see what your car is worth, understand how the value changes, and sell your car when the time's right. Try it now on Carvana.com.

0:20After a historic midterm election for Democrats, politics is on many Americans' minds right now. The holidays are also around the corner, which might mean some uncomfortable dinner table conversations for those with family members on different sides of the political spectrum. What about people in romantic relationships with someone who doesn't share their political views? We spoke to one such couple shortly after the 2024 presidential election. It's just been the most divisive I've ever experienced. And I think that's true from a lot of people I've heard. And we watch different networks for our news.

0:55And Laura hears different things that I hear and, you know, different perspectives. And it's just been real difficult for us to talk about it without fighting. That's Maggie. Her partner is Laura and they're a politically mixed couple in Georgia. They got married in 2013 and their 50th anniversary together is this month. I'm Jen White. You're listening to the 1A podcast. I recently checked back in with Maggie and Laura after the midterm elections to see how they're doing. We'll listen to that conversation and more right after the break. Stay with us.

1:32Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from BetterHelp. Your brain has limited storage, so why is it still holding on to that embarrassing moment from years ago? BetterHelp is an online therapy platform that gives you space to talk about what's taking up too much of yours. BetterHelp is now in network with more than 125 health plans with many co-pays as low as$15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance, you can still get 20 % off your first month. Visit betterhelp.com slash NPR. Cost and coverage may vary. Discount cannot be combined with insurance.

2:11Oh, Kevin, it feels good to be back. It sure does, Casey. And what a time the world is talking about AI and what's going on in Silicon Valley. And we are here with a new show to tell you all about it. That's right, Kevin. On our new show, Machine Gods, twice a week, we'll be bringing you the biggest news in tech and bring you unmatched access to the real titans of this industry. You can find Machine Gods from NPR on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Last November, New Mexico became the first state to launch universal free child care. One year later, many families are still on wait lists.

2:43It's just hard to explain to the families, oh, I'm sorry, we're at full capacity. We don't have a spot. How New Mexico is working to keep this ambitious program alive. Listen now to the Sunday story from the Up First podcast on the NPR app. Welcome back to the 1A podcast. So the last time we spoke, Maggie, you identified as a lifelong Democrat. Laura, you identified as an independent who votes Republican. So I first want to just understand how you both identify now, Maggie. I'm still a Democrat, and that's the way I vote. And voted the last time. Laura, what about you? Well, I would still describe myself the same way.

3:25I'm voting Republican at this time in our lives, but I am not a Republican. I've voted other ways. So you still identify as an independent who right now votes Republican. Yes, I do. So two years ago, your political views diverged most dramatically around then-president-elect Donald Trump. Maggie, where do you think they currently diverge from one another right now? The same. I mean, I'm very pleased with the blue wave that just swept over us. So I'm happy with that. And, you know, I'm very excited to see what happens with the Democrats, what kind of work we can get done. I mean, to be honest with you on that, as I think about it, you know, when I think of the different policies like open borders, I mean, I'm definitely opposed to open borders.

4:17And to be honest, I'm not sure. If I pick out some one thing, what do you think about this? What do you think about that? I'm not really sure where Maggie, but she's just voting Democrat. You're not sure where Maggie stands on specific policy issues. Right, I know that she's a Democrat, so she's likely to stand where the Democrats stand. But just if I pick something like open borders, I just don't know exactly how she feels. We've talked about this many, many times, and I've expressed my thoughts about immigration. And I do believe that our system is broken and it needs to be fixed. I understand there's a need for watching the borders.

5:01And people who have broken the law and have come in to break more laws need to be stopped and dealt with. So I think the system is broken. And it needs to be fixed. Do you, Maggie, feel like you understand Laura's position on specific policy issues? Mostly, yes. And I wish people had the benefit of seeing your faces right now because you're both smiling, which makes me wonder in the last two years how many conversations you've had about your politics and your beliefs, or have you sort of set it aside? No, we haven't set it aside. I wish we could set it aside, but it's in our face all the time.

5:50And we try to do some different things. We enjoy our glass of wine on the screen porch, you know, and we try different things like pick out something you heard today that we could talk about, you know, something you heard on the news or whatever in a conversation with someone else. and we try different things and different ways of talking about it. It's difficult because it's easy to get into an argument and then the whole thing stops. But we're working on it. You're working on it. Luckily, Jen, we both have pretty good senses of humor and so we can laugh at each other when we're not fighting.

6:31I mean, if I say something that she doesn't know the answer to, she gets mad. That's how I see Maggie. Well, often you bring something up. I think we mentioned two years ago that we watch different, you know, cable TV and things like, you know, news programs. So often Laura hears different things that I hear and she'll bring something up and say, did you hear this? And I'll have to say, no, I have not. But I'm interested and I'd like to look it up. And usually, a lot of times, that's the way we end it. You know, we say, I'll look it up and we'll talk about it later. Because often, quite often, we hear different things.

7:17The information environment was something we talked about last time. And someone recommended Tangle News. And it's a newsletter that presents the arguments of various political topics from conservative, liberal, and moderate sides. And we're actually going to speak to the founder of that news site in a bit. But are you finding that there are places where you can have a conversation around at least a shared set of information? Because the last time we spoke, Maggie, you had your sources. Laura, you had your sources. And the two did not intersect at all. We need to go back to that tangle, you know.

7:54Tangle is very helpful. And I don't always read it, but I really enjoy it when I do. It's very helpful. And that would be a really good thing for us to do together, Laura. Yeah, it would, because we get both sides. Exactly. Yeah. I want to turn to the last conversation we had. And we spoke to you shortly before Trump was elected. Well, it was after he was elected, but it was before he took office for his second term. And this is a clip of where we left that conversation right before he stepped into his second presidency. We haven't really, really thought about it. I'm just ready to move forward and be as present.

8:35I think there'll be decisive things that we can look at that he's promising. And it either happened. I mean, do we have more money in our bank account? That's one. I mean, it'll be either it is or it isn't. Well, I don't, you know, it sounds like money, money, money. No, no, no. No, I don't want the whole focus to be money. I mean, I'm concerned about people. So, Laura, I'll come to you first. How do you feel listening back to that and the test you set for yourself about whether or not you thought this would be a successful presidency? First of all, let me say, I don't think money is everything, not for me, us, but it is.

9:21You know, Meg says she's concerned about people. Well, there's a lot of people that having more money makes a difference. I see Donald Trump as a person with a vision. And I've never seen a president that had a vision before. He sees a vision of a peaceful world that people are getting along well, that they are, you know, they're not broke all the time, that they have a good life. Have your financial circumstances improved in the last two years? Well, probably. We've been spending so much lately that, no, I mean, the last few days, it's really been bad. But I do believe because of this vision that I see he has, that things are going to improve.

10:11I just believe that. I believe he knows what he's doing. Maggie, what about you, listening back to that clip? Quite honestly, I think the people have spoken now. People voted. Lots of people voted. And I think the way people feel is known now. And my concern for people is improving. I'm encouraged that we could start working together much better than we have. Laura, how are you feeling about the outcome of the midterm elections? Maggie already said she's quite pleased. The horrors of midterm has happened to in the Obama administration, in the Bush administration, in the Clinton administration.

10:54They've all had horrible midterms and then popped back. But I hope our president, I hope he and like-minded people will start spreading the word about the good things that have happened. Because it's too easy to point to our pocketbooks right now, which to me is temporary. And I just don't think they've done a good job of telling people the great things that are happening. So we've got two years now before the next presidential election. How do you think those two years are going to be for the two of you? Because the lead up to the last presidential election, it was really hard on your relationship.

11:39Maggie? It's definitely going to be interesting. And I really am not sure what to expect. I just hope that the Democrats can continue to work together and learn to work across the aisle. And I feel that that can happen. It really can happen. And Laura's shaking her head, but that's what's going to have to happen. They don't work across the aisle. They work on their side of the aisle. Well, in my mind, they need to learn to if they're not, like you're saying. But they could certainly do more than is happening right now. And we could benefit for coming together. That's Maggie and Laura. They're a politically mixed couple who live in Georgia.

12:29They've been together for almost 50 years. And you can listen to my last conversation with them on our website, the18.org. We're talking about the role politics can play in our intimate relationships, and we're hearing from you. Abby emails, as a lifelong progressive liberal, I don't think I've ever dated anyone who didn't share my political views. The current GOP and MAGA platforms have not demonstrated respect for women or genuine concern for our well-being. While those on the right have traditionally claimed a moral high ground and a commitment to family and religion, I have yet to see that reflected in practice.

13:00It is difficult for me to date someone when I perceive such prevalent hypocrisy. Well, let's add some more voices to the conversation. Alexandra Solomon is a licensed clinical psychologist and the author of Love Every Day. Professor Solomon, it's always great to have you. Welcome back. Great to be with you. Thanks for having me. And also with us is Isaac Saul. He's a politics reporter and founder of Tangle News. You heard us mention it in our conversation with Maggie and Laura. It's a political newsletter. Isaac, welcome to 1A. Thanks for having me. Glad to be here. So, Professor Solomon, we had you on the program the last time we spoke to Maggie and Laura.

13:36So, as a relationship therapist, I'd love to hear your reaction to what you just heard there. I was so glad to hear about Maggie and Laura and how they've been doing over these last couple of years. And what stood out to me was, you know, here they are, 50 years in, trying to figure out how to make this difference work. And it made me think about research that we have from John Gottman, who found that there are three types of very happily married couples, the volatile couples, the validating couples, and the avoiding couples. And I think Maggie and Laura are a volatile couple because what they told us is that they will argue, you know, they'll get into it with each other, but they also laugh a lot.

14:14They've got their wine on their front porch, and they named that humor is protective. So I really, I heard that. And I love this idea of them coming together around a shared news source, because I think if you don't have a shared set of information you're looking at together, it's really hard to have that conversation. So I feel hopeful about them reconnecting with Tangle. Well, and Isaac, it was something we spoke about the last time we had them on the program. And I think I'd heard about Tangle from a This American Life episode, if I'm remembering correctly. And as I was speaking to the two of them, it occurred to me that they kind of retreated to their own corners when it came to their information environment.

14:53So they were each watching different cable news channels, but they never really sat down together to read something. And I thought of Tangle, and we talked about that. So as someone who's created a resource to try to bridge the gap between these separate media ecosystems, why do you think having that bridge is so important? I mean, the reason I started Tangle in the first place is because I realized that the people I used to share space with who disagreed politically could no longer have a conversation over a beer at dinner without ending in a screaming match or believing the other person was totally delusional.

15:34And they didn't become more evil or something in the last 10 years or more judgmental. Their information ecosystems changed in a really profound way. And they started getting stories that were so divorced from the other that they just had no common ground to connect on. So I had this thesis that I could bring people from across the political spectrum under one roof by just making sure there was a wide range of perspectives represented in the content we were producing. So we share arguments from the right and the left and the center explicitly in our content on whatever the big story is we're covering.

16:12And I think just seeing your perspective or your argument represented in a news story like that before you encounter an argument you really disagree with is disarming in a way that allows people to hear the other side and feel like their voice is at least part of the conversation. Professor Solomon, we're approaching the holidays and many people will be visiting family members with whom they disagree politically, maybe in big ways or small ways. But today we're really specifically focusing on romantic relationships, intimate relationships. Why and how are those relationships different than other types of relationships, especially when it comes to navigating political differences?

16:57Yeah. Well, one is just frequency of contact. It's one thing to disagree with your parent or your aunt when you only see them several times a year. Where with a partner, you're going to bed with them each night and waking up with them each morning. but it's more than that. We choose our partner. We don't choose our family. So it's a bit easier to offer grace and acceptance to a family member that we did not choose. And I think when we look at our partner and we see them view the world so differently, that arrow can turn back towards us and lead us to ask ourselves, what have I done here? How have I chosen a person so different from me?

17:32Because political views often map onto values. And what we want so much in our intimate partnerships is to feel seen and heard and understood. And certainly we can do that across difference, but the presence of difference feels threatening. It feels like, wait a minute, can you really see me and get me if we are different? And values, you know, map onto priorities and they inform how we make decisions. And couples have to make a lot of decisions together, how to raise kids, where to live, where to spend time, where to spend money. And so if we're bumping up again and again against those values, differences, political differences, it can just be a grind.

18:11It ends up being a sort of wind at a couple's face. Not impossible, as Maggie and Laura show us, not impossible, but couples have to figure out how to work with the presence of the difference. We have to take a quick break, but when we come back, more from you and our guests. Stay with us.

18:31Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This week on Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, we talked to Brendan Hunt about how his character, Coach Beard, on the hit show Ted Lasso, got his name. It is entirely due to the coincidence of me having had a beard at the time. I was like, Coach Beard? Great, Coach Beard. Great, here we go. And now it's my job. Don't miss our full conversation and the rest of our games. Listen to the Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me podcast in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Happy fall. Yes, the days are getting shorter and colder and the rain can be a drag.

19:05But this is also the perfect time of year to get cozy. LifeKit has lots of ideas so you can embrace the change of seasons with episodes on everything from making soup to exercising outdoors. Listen to the LifeKit podcast in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. This message comes from the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, recognizing extraordinarily creative individuals whose ideas, solutions, and discoveries expand people's expectations of what's possible. Macfound.org Welcome back to the 1A Podcast. We're following up on a conversation we had in 2024 about the role politics plays in our love lives and how politically mixed couples make their relationships work.

19:50We're here with Alexandra Solomon. She's a licensed clinical psychologist and the author of Love Every Day, and Isaac Saul. He's a politics reporter and founder of Tangle News, a political newsletter. We're also hearing from you. Evan writes, My wife and I started as a long-distance relationship in high school. Our ability to communicate and have in-depth conversations about difficult topics, including politics, helped strengthen that bond, and I don't think we would have ultimately ended up marrying if we weren't politically compatible. Our friends are almost the polar opposite with very little political compatibility and largely an avoidance of any tough topics.

20:26I can't imagine living that way and not letting my wife express her thoughts and feelings in an environment where she felt safe to do so. I mean, Professor Solomon, I'm hearing two things in what Evan is saying. One is that, you know, having the ability to communicate around difficult topics is really important. But for those couples who avoid difficult topics, who just really don't want to get into it with one another, is something lost in a relationship when you just avoid the hot spots? I mean, certainly, that's my, you know, I'm a therapist. I want to talk about anything and everything all the time.

21:07So, but, you know, if we go back to Gottman's research, Gottman says, you know, he found a sample of couples that he labeled the avoidant couples, and they just are easygoing. They don't get their feathers ruffled about anything. And for them, intimacy is much more about companionship and a bit more side-by-side connection rather than face-to-face connection. So I do, you know, I think there's something about allowing things to just be as they are versus avoiding. And avoiding means I'm stuffing it down. And that, I think, sows the seeds for long-term resentment and, frankly, long-term health problems.

21:45If there are things that we are actively biting our tongue about and not bringing to our partner, that's different than for some of us who just where politics sort of ebbs and flows and we don't get particularly troubled by any of it. Isaac, I want you to tell us a little bit more about Tangle News. How does it work? I know you present perspectives from on the left, the right, and the center. How does that show up in the newsletter? Yeah, so every day we wade into one of the big divisive topics that is kind of rocking our political world that week. So yesterday we covered the FAA grounding that happened across the country on Friday.

22:25And then we'll explain the story in the most neutral terms possible. So often that's the hardest part is just trying to give the facts in really direct sort of non-emotive language that people can just read and get some background on and understand. And then we go out and we collect a bunch of opinions from across the political spectrum. So we'll have arguments from the far left, the kind of center left, the more moderate left, and then arguments from the far right, the more center right, the more moderate right. And we'll show this big spectrum all the way from the left, all the way to the right, including some views that are sort of maybe heterodox or in the middle.

23:02and if you read the newsletter from the top to the bottom, you'll see this huge spectrum of views presented on whatever that big divisive topic is. And then each day, one person on our staff, often me, but I have other writers on the team now too, will write what we call the my take section, which is just a little personal opinion piece where we got to call some balls and strikes, share our own perspective, integrate our own worldview into the conversation and offer some original analysis for our audience. And, you know, I think what I found is that people are really hungry for this. A lot of Americans feel like they're not getting a multidimensional view on some of the big debates that we're having.

23:43And a lot of Americans are interested in engaging with people that they really disagree with, despite all the conceptions we have about how divided people are, how close-minded people are. There is a real hunger and a real thirst to understand the other side, even when it's people that you really, really disagree with. I think that desire is just really present right now in the country. We heard from Anna, who emails, I had a casual relationship with someone with very different political beliefs. I enjoyed it in some ways because when we'd argue, it would force me to take a hard look at exactly what I believed and why, so I could make a strong and accurate case.

24:18It was an interesting philosophical exercise that ended up reinforcing my beliefs while also opening my mind to understand his side better, even if we ultimately disagreed. Professor Solomon, I think one of the questions, especially in the context of a romantic relationship, is how you can be at peace with the disagreement. I think oftentimes when we go into these conversations, it is with the goal of convincing our partner that we are right. And to be clear, sometimes there are real stakes around that discussion. But is there a space, I suppose, for just allowing the disagreement to be the disagreement in a way that doesn't affect the relationship, especially with lower stakes issues?

25:06Yeah. You know, I was thinking about your last question and thinking about how much of this also ties to privilege. You know, politics sort of sits more closely to our lives and to our actual bodies, you know, based on the amount of privilege that we have. So I imagine those couples who can sort of let the political difference live, are couples more likely who live with quite a bit of privilege where politics is not sort of like the wolf at the door on a daily basis. But yeah, I think that there are, you know, the ways that couples allow a difference to sit is by being very, very careful and purposeful about the how, about how they talk about politics and that there are very clear agreements that both of them hold on to, which are things like agreeing that we are not having this conversation in order to change the other's point of view and having the conversation based on the premise of, you know what, if I was you with your experience, your history, your profession, I probably would see it the way that you see it.

26:04You know, keeping somebody's politics tied to their history, their identity, because we make, none of us make sense outside of our context. So couples who live with this difference are couples who really keep their partner contextualized, keep their beliefs contextualized, not just sort of, you know, a set of ideas, but a person who's holding those ideas. And they come into a conversation with curiosity and they agree to stop if and when it gets heated, you know, because that's also another way of caring for the relationship is not going round and round and round, but saying, I think we've had enough for tonight.

26:39Let's go, you know, make a puzzle. Well, let's go to our inbox. Here's what one of you sent us. When thinking about dating and relationships and political affiliation, I feel like there's been a change where political affiliation isn't seen as something separable from identity or from core values. Rather, I think we realize that it is an exact result of the values we hold most dear. I would find it really difficult to date somebody who didn't share my same political beliefs because that would suggest that they don't share the same morality and values of community and belonging and equity. That echoes some other messages we've received from Ricardo, who says, If you see your political ideology and partisan support as an expression of your morality, and that is how you would want society and the government to treat your neighbor, then it seems natural to gravitate to people who share your moral and ethical beliefs and thus your politics.

27:40And Karen emails, I'm currently separated from my husband of 20 years, partially due to his passionate support of Trump and callous disregard for all the damage he has caused and continues to inflict on anyone and anything that doesn't serve his personal interests. And so in Karen's email there, Professor Solomon, we see someone for whom the stakes felt very high and wasn't willing to separate out the politics from the person and the relationship. And I wonder if you can give us some insight into the circumstances in which that choice becomes the one that feels like the right choice, the safest choice for an individual.

28:25Yeah. I mean, it's one of the most painful parts of this political polarization for me is knowing that there are couples where this has become the final straw or the thing that they just can't figure out how to navigate through. But I think those are the indicators, right? If I'm walking on eggshells, if it feels like my views can't be seen and held in positive regard, if I can't hold you in positive regard. Relationships don't do very well without admiration. You know, the happiest couples are the couples who really admire each other. And if what she's saying is, I couldn't look at him and admire him knowing who he supports and knowing what he is okay with.

29:08And I think in that way, there's a mercy there of letting each other go. If you can't, if the relationship becomes filled with contempt, you know, contempt is an intimacy killer. And it sounds like she just really couldn't hold him in warm regard and feel proud of him and connected to him. And that is equal parts tragic and heartbreaking, as well as perhaps merciful. And that she, you know, I wish her well in her next chapter, certainly. Well, in 2024, Tangle News was highlighted in an episode of Question Everything. That's a podcast from KCRW. And that episode was called Can Journalism Save a Marriage?

29:47And it's about a married couple who almost split up over differing political views. We can argue about our kids. You know, we can argue about the neighborhood, but we usually come to some sort of resolution. This whole thing about Trump, there's no resolution. How did that feel? Frustrating. Because I know my husband. I know what a smart, sensitive, thoughtful person he is. He's very generous. And to have him suddenly be aligned to this person who I found absolutely despicable was very troubling. Isaac, how did that episode change Tangle News? Well, first of all, I mean, we were flooded with new readers and audience members who found themselves in similar situations.

30:44I mean, it was a kind of magical thing to listen to because it was a distillation of a lot of the work that I had done and a lot of the goals that we set out to do, which was really truly to bring people under one roof and to be this kind of big tent media organization. And when Dick and Emily, the couple you just heard, when they popped up and they gave this interview and they shared their story, we were just flooded with similar emails and similar stories from people across the country, not just married couples, but, you know, uncles and nieces and parents and their kids and best friends growing up.

31:21All these people had these really deep, intimate relationships who said that they were losing the ability to communicate with that person, to get along with them. And then they found this news source that sort of offered a shared reality, a jumping off point, a place where it was safe for them to kind of disagree and engage with each other's views without lighting the whole house on fire. And yeah, it was really rewarding and it grew our audience a lot and it brought in a lot of people, I think, with the intention of engaging in the mission that we're after, which was obviously a really powerful thing.

31:58I want to read some of the other messages that we are getting from folks. Camille writes, I conduct research into the ways far-right movements reframe history for political ends. I met and married a British man while I was doing a postdoctoral fellow at Cambridge. We spoke extensively about politics prior to getting married, and we aligned on nearly everything. I sponsored him for a marriage-based green card. He arrived in the U.S. two months before the 2024 presidential election. Trump's win emboldened my spouse to admit that he supported various conservative figures, including Trump, Le Pen, and Farage, for years.

32:31But I knew women wouldn't date him if they knew the truth. We got divorced. Politics in the U.S. is no longer a difference of opinion. It's a life or death set of values. You also heard from Claire who says, I refer to my relationship as a mixed marriage, one Democrat and one Republican. I figure if a Baptist can marry a Jew, it must be possible, right? For many people, those two choices would be equally impossible, maybe even forbidden. To make it possible, a deep respect is essential. And I wanted to read those two messages together because Claire is describing a relationship where it sounds like all the cards were on the table.

33:06And Camille is describing a relationship that was shrouded in lies. There was just not clarity about who her partner was. And so for people who are maybe at the beginning of relationships, Professor Solomon, who are maybe not having some of these conversations about who their partner is and who they're engaged with, how would you suggest starting those discussions, maybe even using a site like Tangle to open the door to some of these conversations before you get deeply entangled with someone? I think it's essential. You know, much the same way, there's lots that we want and need to know about a potential partner.

33:47I think it makes sense to understand politics. You know, so many of these messages have been about the overlap of politics and worldview, politics and values. So it does make sense. And it doesn't need to be a litmus test of I need you to see the world the way that I see you. I love this new research that Pew, the Pew Foundation did that found there's actually more like nine political parties in our country than just two. So we are much less binary than we act like we are. And so to have a conversation about those issues, really, then what you see is less about where the person stands and more how the two of you connect across difference.

34:28Because a difference that can be talked about and met with curiosity in both directions maybe become something that is tolerable and that grows both of you. You know, none of us are going to marry a carbon copy of ourselves, nor should we. But the question really is how? How do you speak across that difference? And I think the sooner you do it, the better. Again, not as a test, but as a way of getting to know each other and knowing how do the two of us connect across this difference. Isaac, one of the reasons you found at Tangle News was because of what you felt was a lack of consensus reality.

35:05And I can't help but wonder whether you think we are moving any closer to a consensus reality in our current media environment, or if we're actually slipping farther away. I'm an optimist, and I do feel like I could make a case in the last couple of years that we've kind of hit rock bottom on how far we can isolate ourselves and sort of hide in our corners without confronting reality. I mean, I think Republicans and the GOP just had a reality check. I think a lot of them were living in bubbles and were being quite delusional about their prospects in the midterm elections and how the country felt about the way they were governing.

35:51And there's no way not to confront that now. And even the president, we hear it from him, he's confronting it. So I'm hopeful that we are moving toward a world where people are stepping back into shared spaces. And I think the ability to sort of live in that self-curated reality is getting harder and harder right now. Well, that's Isaac Saul. He's a politics reporter and founder of Tangle News. It's a political newsletter. And Alexandra Solomon, a licensed clinical psychologist and author of Love Every Day. Professor Solomon, Isaac, thanks for joining us. Today's producer was Haley Blassingate.

36:27This program comes to you from WAMU, part of American University in Washington, distributed by NPR. I'm Jen White. Thanks for listening. And we'll talk again tomorrow. This is 1A.

36:56Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Schwab. At Schwab, you can get everything from self-directed investing to full-service wealth management, all in one place. No matter your investing goal, life stage, amount to invest, or know-how, you can invest your way with Schwab. Two iconic voices, one rare opportunity. I thank you so much for being on our show today. Terry Gross and Paul McCartney. I listen to your show. I listen to NPR all the time. I'm not just blowing smoke here. a live conversation between one of the world's most influential musicians and one of America's most accomplished interviewers.

37:37Monday, November 23rd in New York City, benefiting public media. Tickets and information at whyy.org slash events.

From the publisher
After a historic midterm election for Democrats, politics are on many Americans’ minds right now.

The holidays are right around the corner. That might mean some uncomfortable dinner table conversations for those with family members on different sides of the political spectrum.

But what about those in romantic relationships with someone who doesn’t share their political views? We check in with some 1A listeners who are romantically involved but whose politics couldn’t be more different.

Find more of our programs online. Listen to 1A sponsor-free by signing up for 1A+ at plus.npr.org/the1a.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

More from 1A

All episodes