


The episode examines Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s efforts to reshape the U.S. military: rolling back diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives; making major personnel changes; overhauling military education (including banning books); and pushing a “warrior ethos” focused on “lethality.” It contrasts past reforms—like ending Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell (2011), allowing women in combat roles (2016), and integrating the military—with Hegseth’s “anti-woke” agenda, which critics say is driven by culture-war rhetoric and religious/political beliefs rather than evidence. Guests argue his claims about lowered standards lack support; examples cited include women meeting the same Ranger School standards and passing. They also discuss Project Meridian (120-day future-warfare research) and partnerships with universities (including Liberty and Hillsdale) plus ending tenure for civilian faculty.
Tom Bowman (NPR Pentagon reporter); Jasper Craven (investigative reporter, author of God Forgives, Brothers Don’t); Sue Fulton (Women in Service Coalition executive director, West Point class of 1980); Amy McGrath (retired Marine Corps Lt. Col., former candidate for U.S. Senate/House); Peter Fever (Duke professor, civil-military relations expert).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the evolution of the U.S. military and recent reforms.
“military attracts, educates, and trains some of the best and brightest across the U.S.”
Analysis of Secretary Hegseth's plans and their implications for the military.
“Secretary Hegseth doubled down on his new vision for the U.S.”
Discussion on Hegseth's approach to military leadership and education.
“And I want to dig into two specific areas now, Hegseth's vision of who should be in the military and new rules for military education.”
Sue Fulton shares her background as a pioneer for women in the military.
“She's executive director of the Women in Service Coalition, and she graduated from West Point in 1980, the first class to include women.”
Amy McGrath introduces her experience as a Marine Corps officer and political candidate.
“And on the line from Ohio is Amy McGrath.”
Discussion on the experiences and fears of female veterans in today's military.
“We heard from Jana in Nebraska who says, I'm a retired member of the Air Force, a female veteran who reached the highest enlisted rank.”
Analysis of demographic shifts and leadership removals within the military.
“What does the officer corps look like in this moment, nearly two years into Hexeth's leadership?”
Exploring the unusual nature of recent military leadership shifts.
“It could be I think this woman got the job because of her gender.”
Sue shares her experiences as a woman in the first class with female cadets.
“Sue, you are a graduate, as we said, of the historic West Point class of 1980, the first class to include women.”
Amy McGrath critiques the narrative of military lethality and strength under Hegseth.
“Ultimately, it's going to be a problem for retention, even if it takes months or a year or two to actually see those numbers reported.”
Discussion on how leadership changes affect morale and advice given in the military.
“But look at it from the perspective of our national security.”
Sue discusses the current experiences of veterans and the significance of women in the military.
“It's very dangerous when you have a general or an admiral holding back.”
Tom explains the evolution and importance of diversity in military recruitment.
“The first thing I would say is lethality is an aspect of what the military needs because the goal of the military isn't death.”
Discussion on the current and future prospects for women in service.
“Well, clearly, you know, over the years, the military has wanted to bring in more women officers, more black officers.”
Hear about the discouraging experiences of women in the military regarding career advancement and challenges faced in their service.
“She's a Black West Point graduate and a U.S.”
Discussion on Secretary Hegseth's new educational initiatives for military officers and their implications.
“The only thing we did not predict is that she would actually survive all of this.”
Explore the impact of cultural and educational reforms in military schools as dictated by the Pentagon.
“As part of this push, these schools are also banning hundreds of books.”
Discusses how midterm elections may affect military leadership and policies.
“The military are going to follow lawful orders, even lawful but awful orders.”
Explores key topics reporters are following regarding the Pentagon and military policies.
“Well, does the Guard head into the streets?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On 1A, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab with its original podcast On Investing. Each week, you'll get thoughtful, in-depth analysis of both the stock and the bond markets. Listen today and subscribe at schwab.com slash oninvesting or wherever you get your podcasts.
0:24The U.S. military attracts, educates, and trains some of the best and brightest across the U.S. The Pentagon is a big, complex, and bureaucratic machine. It moves slowly, but it has evolved over time, reflecting changes in our society and politics. From the integration of the military in the late 1940s to women finally being admitted to military academies in the mid-1970s. And you raise your right hand and you swear loyalty to the United States Army and to the United States, and you officially become a new cadet at West Point. Later, the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell in 2011, which officially allowed LGBTQ people to openly serve in the military.
1:11So this morning, I am proud to sign a law that will bring an end to Don't Ask, Don't Tell.
1:22Then women were allowed to fill combat roles officially in 2016. As long as they qualify and meet the standards, women will now be able to contribute to our mission in ways they could not before. Now, some new changes. Secretary of Defense Pete Hexath is on a mission to change what he calls a woke and weak military. He says he wants to bring back a warrior ethos and lethality to the military. His strategy, rolling back diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives, high-level firings and overhauling military education, including by banning books. He's been explicit about the Pentagon he envisions, using vulgarities and slurs to make his point.
2:01We are no longer the woke department or the weak department. Simple translation of that. No fatties, no trannies, no beardos, no weirdos, no wimps, no radicals. Just warriors. I'm Jen White. You're listening to the 1A Podcast. What do Hexeth's reforms mean for service members, cadets, military families, and the next generation of recruits? What will the U.S. military look like in the next 10, 20, or 30 years for the people in its ranks? We get into it right after this.
2:38Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from BetterHelp. BetterHelp is in-network with more than 125 health plans with an average copay for eligible members of just$23 per session. Don't have eligible insurance? You can still get 10 % off your first month. Visit BetterHelp.com slash NPR to explore your payment options. That's BetterHelp.com slash NPR. American journalist Austin Tice vanished in Syria over a decade ago. For years, we've been searching for him. And now we finally have some answers. This is the prison that Austin was in. Oh my God.
3:19We found Austin's file. Listen to Where is Austin Tice from NPR's Embedded and BBC Radio 4 on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. This fall, there are a lot of movies and TV shows on tap for you to see. And we're as excited for all of it to arrive as you are. On Pop Culture Happy Hour, we've got a guide to what's worth keeping on your radar. Listen via the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Let's start off the conversation with Tom Bowman. He's NPR's longtime Pentagon reporter, and he joins us in studio. Tom, welcome back. Good to be here. And on the line from New York is Jasper Craven.
3:59He's an investigative reporter and the author of God Forgives, Brothers Don't, the Long March of Military Education and the Making of American Manhood. Jasper, welcome to 1A. Thanks for having me. Now, in his recent State of the Force address in Quantico, Virginia, Secretary Hegseth doubled down on his new vision for the U.S. military, first presented a year ago. Tom, you've covered many speeches, many plans by Secretaries of the Defense over the years. What stood out to you in this address? Well, again, he's sort of banging the same drum. He's been talking about this for many years. He wrote a book, War on Warriors.
4:33He said the standards have been lowered. You know, DEI has been a real problem. He's hinting that the former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, who he got rid of, C.Q. Brown, and Lisa Franchetti, the first woman to run the Navy, got the jobs because of race or gender. And again, now he's looking at the service academies, trying to get rid of tenure for civilian faculty members. He wants to have more military officers at these service academies. And also he's looking at taking over, taking a greater role in how chaplains are selected, really pushing for more evangelical chaplains. Liberty University is now a big place where a lot of these chaplains are coming from.
5:23So he's pushing a lot of changes in the military. Were his claims about the military supported by evidence or by what other service members said? No, of course not. I mean C.Q. Brown, he was a highly decorated officer, very, very, you know, held in high regard. And, you know, he got rid of the Army's top general, Randy George, well-respected by both parties on Capitol Hill. And also he keeps talking about the standards who have been lowered. And I know he sent some of his people down to Fort Benning to look at ranger school. More than 190 women have made it through ranger school got the coveted ranger tab They thought the standards had been lowered and lo and behold they found that no Both men and women have to meet the same standard to become a ranger.
6:08So a lot of this is just It's hard to say what's why he's doing this. I mean, he just has a feeling that the military is is woke Is not up to standards i've been embedding with troops and marines and soldiers for 20 years I never saw anything like that out in the field. Jasper, one way to understand Secretary Hegseth's approach might be to examine his use of biblical language and imagery. Help us understand how his religious beliefs intersect with the changes he's implementing within the U.S. Armed Forces. Absolutely. Well, you know, Hegseth grew up in a religious household, but, you know, also engaged in secular education.
6:48He arrives at Princeton University in 2000. And, you know, soon after the 9-11 attacks occur not far away in New York City, and, you know, by his own description in his memoirs, that was a real clarifying moment for him that really sort of calcified, fortified his religious beliefs. And so you can see very early on, young Hegseth in his early 20s, writing columns in the Princeton Tori, writing letters to the editor in the student paper, in which his worldview is very much this sort of polarized fight against the Muslim world. And this is something that, of course, strengthens in deployments to Guantanamo Bay, Iraq, and Afghanistan.
7:35You later see in his writings, you know, a sort of strange jealousy almost for the zeal, the religious zeal that ISIS fighters, he calls out, sort of have in the battle. And he believes that part of the sort of weakness of American military forces is that they aren't driven in that same spiritual way. And so this is clearly him trying to inject that into the force because he believes it will increase motivation and lethality. Tom, what are your sources telling you about the way Hegseth's message and approach to reshaping the armed forces is being received by rank and file members? You know, it's hard to say.
8:24A lot of them are not going to speak openly. And I'm not sure if they're really taking it to heart. I mean, a lot of these younger soldiers and Marines, let's say, they just they're doing their job. Some of them might be, you know, pretty religious. Some of them just really don't care. Apparently, you know, it's like 400 ,000 troops just have no religious affiliation. So a lot of them probably just goes right over their head. They don't really care about it. They're looking at their first sergeant as far as I listen to that person and maybe not to the secretary of defense. But I do know there's a real sense of fear with those still in the military, the higher ranks, trying to keep their heads down, trying to get through this.
9:04And they're troubled. You know, retired people I talk with are really troubled by what they see. Jasper, what have you found and heard in your reporting? Yeah, I mean, I think I'm hearing some of the same things, Tom, is I think quietly, you know, many people are really worried about Hegseth's behavior, think it could really damage and politicize the force moving forward. And, you know, I mean, one thing that people bring up to me a lot is this sort of these efforts to elevate the soldier above the civilian, which, you know, is very dangerous and is a sort of signature of authoritarian governments.
9:45You know, I mean, civilian leadership is paramount to a democracy. And while Hegseth is a civilian. You know, his rhetoric often, you know, shows disdain for civilians and sort of, you know, basically describes the military as this sort of like supremacist organization that, you know, holds American ideals closer than any other. So I think there's just, you know, especially when you see, you know, increasing domestic militarization and, you know, the use of National Guard forces in American streets. I think there's just a lot of worry in the force about sort of domestic blowback. Tom, and when we think about the changes Secretary Hegseth is making, do any of those changes align with longer-term criticisms of military structure, things that people thought needed to be changed?
10:43You know, I'm not so sure about that. And I haven't heard anybody, you know, on the record or off the record, say things had to change. I think, again, from what I've seen covering the military now for more than two decades, things are actually going pretty well. You know, recruitment was up, but it wasn't because of Trump. It was because of changes the army made, beefing up their recruiters and the messaging and so forth. From what I could see, the military was doing quite well before Trump and Hegseth came in. Well, one of the changes Secretary Hegseth announced is the creation of Project Meridian to research future warfare, which is supposed to last for 120 days and end with a public report.
11:29Jasper, what stands out to you about the way Hegseth is thinking about the future of fighting for the U.S.? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you know, Hegseth very clearly has picked the two military contractors that are his favorites, those being Palmer Luckey's Andurl and Elon Musk. I mean, you can sort of add Palantir into that as well. But SpaceX, Palantir, Andurl, these are the sort of Trump administration's preferred military contractors. And so they are getting, you know, massive amounts of money to develop AI technology. at the same time, Hegseth is sort of emphasizing the strength benefits of joining the force for recruits.
12:10So it's sort of a one-two selling point here. Well, that's Jasper Craven. He's an investigative reporter and the author of God Forgives, Brothers Don't, the Long March of Military Education and the Making of American Manhood. Jasper, thanks for speaking with us. Thank you. And NPR Pentagon reporter Tom Bowman is sticking with us. We reached out to the Pentagon on to join the conversation but did not hear back, the invitation stands. We are hearing from you. We got this message from Nancy in Washington, D.C. About Pete Hegseth's anti-woke policy. It's absurd, ridiculous. He's taking us back to the dark ages, and it will leave us with a military of white macho men who want nothing more than to show their power over everybody else.
12:59More from you and our guests in just a moment.
13:29Head to a DSW store or DSW.com today for shoes that get you at prices that get your budget. DSW, let us surprise you. This week on Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, we talk with David Byrne about the early fashion advice he got from Lou Reed. I had really hairy arms at that point. He said, you should never wear short sleeves. Body shamed you. Don't miss our full conversation and the rest of our games. Listen to the Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Opera singer Gabriela Di Lacio always loved Mozart, Beethoven, Vivaldi. But then she discovered she didn't know the works of thousands of female composers.
14:13It's not about taking people off the list. It's putting more people on the list. Tracking down the women missing from music. That's on the TED Radio Hour podcast. Listen on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Back now to Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth's reshaping of the U.S. military. And I want to dig into two specific areas now, Hegseth's vision of who should be in the military and new rules for military education. So let's start with who the Defense Secretary wants in the military and why by adding some new voices to the conversation. Sue Fulton joins us in studio. She's executive director of the Women in Service Coalition, and she graduated from West Point in 1980, the first class to include women.
14:58Sue, welcome to the program. Thank you for having me. And on the line from Ohio is Amy McGrath. She's a retired U.S. Marine Corps lieutenant colonel. Amy founded the Super PAC Democratic Majority Action, and she's run for both the U.S. House and Senate from her home state of Kentucky. This year, she ran to replace Republican Senator Mitch McConnell. She lost the Democratic primary in May. Amy, it's great to have you. Good to be with you. We heard from Jana in Nebraska who says, I'm a retired member of the Air Force, a female veteran who reached the highest enlisted rank. I earned my keep every step of the way, and I wonder if I had been serving in this current environment if I would ever have been given a chance to succeed.
15:37They say they're getting rid of DEI to focus on merit-based promotions. All I see is an excuse for discrimination and the elimination of anyone who is not white and male. I worry for the future of our military with the loss of so much skill, talent, and expertise in our ranks. Meantime, we've seen a lot of reporting on high-profile firings of women and Black men in senior leadership positions. What does the officer corps look like in this moment, nearly two years into Hexeth's leadership? Well, again, I'm not sure. You mean as far as the demographics of the officer corps? I'm not sure if it's changed all that much, but clearly he's gotten rid of a lot of high-profile black officers, women officers, and also officers, you know, white men that apparently disagree with him on certain issues.
16:25So he's looking for people that will agree with him, apparently. I mean, that's a real problem. Or he's getting rid of people that had links to former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Mark Milley, who Trump didn't like and Hegseth didn't like. They had an investigation into him, and I'm told that's kind of gone to the purgatory. That's not going anywhere. So it really is a jumble of reasons. It could be I think this woman got the job because of her gender. This black officer got it obviously because of his race. Or this guy was close to General Mark Milley, and I don't like him anymore.
17:00So I think we're seeing that it's across the board reasons for getting rid of them. Has it changed demographics all that much? I'm not really sure. I don't have those stats. Well, and I want to tap into your decades of experience covering the Pentagon when a new Secretary of Defense is installed. Do you usually see this kind of shift in the upper ranks of the military? Absolutely not. No, no, no. I mean, a lot of times the chairman of the Joint Chiefs will serve for four years. It's highly unusual to remove one chairman as soon as you come in. And also, again, he's removed the first woman to run the Navy.
17:36She had been in not all that long to get rid of her. And also, you know, others, again, I keep saying this, who either he thought were, you know, too close to like a General Milley or someone else he doesn't agree with. So it's highly unusual. I've never seen anything like this. Here's the other thing, Jen. He also is reaching down into the colonel level, pulling them off the promotion list. That is almost unprecedented for something like that to happen. These people are carefully vetted. It takes months, and the services take this very seriously. So to reach down and pull these people off, again, some of them black officers, some of them women, I've never seen that.
18:18And people I talk with have never seen that either. Sue, you are a graduate, as we said, of the historic West Point class of 1980, the first class to include women. What was your experience as a woman at West Point then? Yeah, so that's 50 years ago this year that women first attended the academies. And, you know, my experience was challenging, of course. But, I mean, here's the thing. Women have had to fight for every opportunity in the military. And the military has allowed those opportunities not because it's some kind of feminist organization, but because they need us. They need them. They needed women to fill out the ranks.
19:01They found that women were better at some jobs. Their recruiting has gone up and down over the years. And when we go to war, they need everybody. You know, also as a member of the LGBT community, I would point out that whenever we're at war, discharges of – whenever we were at war, discharges of people for homosexuality drop dramatically because they need people. You know, I just want to reflect on – you talked about what is the composition of the officer corps, and it changes slowly because, you know, the process of retirement takes a long time. But we did a review of 2026 promotion lists. Eight of 201 senior military nominations this year were women.
19:52That's 4%. That's the lowest in 25 years. And there were at least 45 officers were removed from promotion lists. And most of those, most of them were women or people of color or both, obviously. So we're seeing women are being sent the message that we don't want UN leadership. And that's a real problem. It's a problem for morale. Ultimately, it's going to be a problem for retention, even if it takes months or a year or two to actually see those numbers reported. Amy, you graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy in 1997. As a fighter pilot, you flew 89 combat missions in Iraq and Afghanistan. You were the first female Marine to fly a combat mission in an FAA-18 fighter jet.
20:42When you hear the Secretary's language about the military being too woke, too weak, that he wants to bring back strength, you know, warrior ethos, lethality to the military, how did you and other women on the surface enforce lethality? I mean, we all think this is absurd. First of all, the idea that you would bring back lethality. Think about it. The U.S. military has never, never had a problem with lethality. We were always able to target when we needed to. And this idea of bringing back a warrior ethos, we've never had a problem with that either. And what he's doing here is firing the actual warriors who have experience, in which he does not.
21:33And so, you know, I try to take it back from just the attacks on women and minorities. Those are really serious. But look at it from the perspective of our national security. What Pete Hextheth is doing as Secretary of Defense, Secretary of War, whatever you want to call it, he is not focused on the right things. He is focused on culture wars and not focused on the things that matter, like our alliances, like winning the wars or not starting a strategically terrible war that this president has started and that he was integral at beginning. And so I feel like those are the types of things that he's focused on.
22:21I also feel like when you fire senior military leaders, you don't just cut a bunch of experience at the very top. You create a culture of fear. The most dangerous thing you can do in the military is create a culture where generals and admirals tell the president what he wants to hear instead of what he needs to hear. And I think more and more we're seeing that to the detriment of our entire national security. Well, Tom, I see you nodding there and around this question of consistency in leadership, but also a willingness to push back. What does that mean for U.S. national security? I think, you know, listen, the people I talk with, the retired community and active officers, there's a real sense of fear, a sense of, you know, maybe I don't want to give unvarnished military advice to this secretary or this president.
23:18And I think Amy's right. It's very dangerous when you have a general or an admiral holding back. Maybe I don't give my best military advice. That is very dangerous. Sue, since you left the Army in 1986, you've been an advocate for all veterans, including women and those who are LGBTQ+. What are you hearing from rank-and-file members about their current experience? They're looking for – look, their current experience at the lower levels, I will say that those mid-level commanders continue to carry forward the values, you know, the military core values, honor and integrity, personal courage and selfless service.
23:59But they're looking forward saying, is there a career here for me given the messages that are being sent? And it's heartbreaking. I've been an advocate because I hate to see the military waste talent. I mean, you asked what do women bring to lethality. The first thing I would say is lethality is an aspect of what the military needs because the goal of the military isn't death. It's victory. And that's a different framework, but that's not the frame we're hearing. And what do women bring? Men, on average, not every man versus every woman, men on average have stronger upper body strength, greater physical power.
24:42Research shows that among the military population, women are better at stress regulation, observation and attention to detail, multitasking under stress, clear communication. those are critical in every single role in the military. That's why some surveys have shown women or some research has shown women are better pilots. They're better scouts. So it's just a waste of talent. One of you shared this. I was in the U.S. Navy while Donald Trump was dodging the draft and I'm appalled at what Pete Hexeth is doing. Being gay, I officially would have been ineligible to be in the military, but it didn't work that way.
25:17Being closeted was mostly forced by society at that time. Since I was in the military, huge progress has been made, but Hegseth and Trump are in the process of reversing it. And we got this message from Robert, who says, I served in the U.S. Army from 1965 to 1970 and taught at West Point. Hegseth is ruining the U.S. armed forces with his policies. Now, Secretary Hegseth says he's building a military that is colorblind, gender neutral, and merit-based. Those are his words. The War Department, as you know, is colorblind, gender neutral, and merit-based. The ideological clowns are out. The patriotic cowboys are in with testosterone testing on top.
26:01Now, Hexeth's language there implies that previously promotions were not based on merit. Sue, what can you tell us about what it takes to be promoted in the service? Yeah, they look at all of your reviews. They often, at the higher levels, they know these people and they talk about their leadership skills and they focus on what they're able to do, not who they are. You know, I think people look at, oh, there's an increase in women over time. Yes, because it's only been about 30 years that women were allowed in all, you know, on the ships. It's only been 10 years since women were allowed in combat arms.
26:42It takes time. It takes 25 years to grow a general or admiral. So women are just becoming eligible in many cases for some of these leadership roles. So it may be new, but it's earned. And the senior, the general officers who determine who is selected are focused on the benefit to the military. Tom, what role have diversity, equity, and inclusion programs played in the U.S. military? Well, clearly, you know, over the years, the military has wanted to bring in more women officers, more black officers. It's like a police force. It should marry your city, right? You want to have people that look like the United States.
27:21United States has obviously black women, men, black men. So you want to bring them up and cultivate them in the military. And that's been done for decades now. And it's important to know, too, we were talking about, you know, recruiting and retention. You know, women tend to make a better recruit because they tend to have higher test scores, have fewer brushes with the law. And you're seeing more and more women, for example, going into the Army and going into the Air Force. So one of the questions is getting rid of women officers, you know, not promoting them could have a chilling effect on, let's say, a young woman.
28:00Should I go into the Army or not? Well, let's hear from Kathy Joseph. She's a Black West Point graduate and a U.S. Army veteran.
28:32afraid to challenge mistreatment or speak up for fear of jeopardizing their careers and their livelihood. That's Kathy Joseph. She graduated from West Point in 2003. Sue, you're now the executive director of the Women in Service Coalition. What are you hearing from women about their, not just their current experience, but their potential future in service? Oh, it's very discouraging. You know, many, especially the high performers, this is the real problem. It's the high performers who are looking to say, not, hey, I just want to get through my career and retire as an 05 lieutenant colonel. It's the high performers who are like, I have seen – I've had this experience.
29:16I have the capacity to do more. I'm crushing everything in my assignment. And now they're looking to say, but there's a ceiling, a new ceiling for me as a black woman or as a woman period. And so what we're trying to do is get this information because they can't say these things publicly, to your point. Having people call in and many of them can't be fully identified because they don't dare. It'll affect them in their current jobs. But it's very discouraging. I will say that we do also hear from some who are like, I'm going to stick it out. In some cases, you know, I talked to a black woman who's like, look, I'm mid-career and the economy's not great either.
30:04So I'm miserable right now, but I'm not confident that I'm going to be able to get a great job on the outside. If I could quickly add, this is anecdotal, but I'm hearing a lot of lieutenant colonels and colonels that are deciding to retire saying, I don't want to deal with this anymore. And that's very troubling. Well, we have to say goodbye for now to Sue Fulton, Executive Director of the Women in Service Coalition, and Amy McGrath, a retired Marine Corps Lieutenant Colonel. Thanks to you both. Tom Bowman stays with us and we hear from a new voice right after a quick break.
30:37Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This election season, let the NPR Politics podcast save your time and your sanity. We'll help you understand key races, which polls you can safely ignore, and what might happen if power shifts in Congress. Our short daily episodes come out every afternoon so you can spend less time scrolling through each chaotic news cycle. Make NPR Politics your hub for midterm election coverage. Follow our podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. This week on Shortwave, Krista Pike's botched execution was no surprise to medical experts.
31:11The only thing we did not predict is that she would actually survive all of this. Lethal injection is often portrayed as the most humane way to execute people. Because it looks medical and it looks like it's not too brutal, but looks are deceiving. What really happens on Shortwave, the science podcast from NPR. We're talking about Defense Secretary Pete Hexeth's plans for the military. And now let's bring in Peter Fever. He's a professor of political science and public policy at Duke and a former special advisor on the National Security Council. He's a leading expert on civil-military relations.
31:47Peter, welcome to the program. Good to be here. So I want us to focus in on schools because Secretary Hegseth announced an overhaul of military education, including a new partnership with five universities to train officers. It's Liberty University, Louisiana State University, Tuskegee, Mississippi State University, and Hillsdale College. Now, Liberty and Hillsdale are Christian universities. Tuskegee is a historically black university. And these new partnerships come months after he ended partnerships with some Ivy League schools and other top universities, alleging they taught, quote, the enemy's wicked ideologies.
32:23Peter, what impact do these moves have on the education of the officer corps? Well, you want to recruit from all walks of life into the U.S. military. and you want a broad accession pool and you want to recruit the very best that you can get into the service. So it's a little bit mystifying that he would narrow the accession pool. I understand broadening it. I understand, for instance, you could probably get a lot of recruits from LSU, Mississippi State. These are places where you could generate large numbers, but every recruit that joins the military is also bringing personal connections into the military.
33:10And that's where the recruits from the elite schools are most valuable. It's not that the military themselves are different, but they bring different personal networks. And that gives a wider swath of America with skin in the game. 20 years ago, as Tom will remember, we were trying very hard to keep the military ROTC programs on elite campuses. Precisely, that was a cause of conservatives who were worried that the elite was losing their skin in the game. And now we seem to be doing that work for them and cutting off elite schools from the military. That's a mistake. Yeah. I mean, take us back 20 years.
33:51Right. I think that's right. I mean, you know, for a long time during the Vietnam War, Harvard, I think, pulled their ROTC program. But now you're right. I mean, it's in Peter's right to have these elite universities is key for networking. A friend of mine, by the way, he's an Afghan American. He's at the Kennedy School. And he was telling me he's meeting people from all around the world, military officers. And it's key for any serving officer to go to a place like Harvard, let's say the Kennedy School, and make these connections with people all over the world, fellow officers, political people.
34:25And that's key going forward because this particular military officer may be a foreign area officer, let's say, in an embassy somewhere. And to know the political people, to know the military people is really key for national security. Those relationships matter. Correct. There are five military academies in the U.S., including West Point and the Naval Academy. And these are highly prestigious institutions that produce many of the military's top leadership. So in another move, Hexeth ordered a halt to tenure for civilian professors at these institutions, saying faculty should focus on lethality.
35:01And Tom, you alluded to this earlier, but how could that affect the kind of education that will form future military leadership? Well, right. I mean, you know, clearly a tenured professor, let's say teaching foreign affairs, could be an expert, could be a former ambassador that has a lot more experience than, let's say, you bring in a captain or a major or lieutenant colonel that basically has a basic knowledge of foreign affairs. So you're not helping the officer corps by bringing in just a younger military officer with really no experience. So I'm not sure exactly why he's doing that. Why bringing a military officer as opposed to a civilian, who may also be a veteran, is going to make the military more lethal?
35:44He hasn't really explained it that well. And frankly, Secretary Hagseth has not had a press conference since May 5th. So we can't ask him these questions because he hasn't had a press conference. And again, we reached out to the Pentagon to participate in this conversation. They didn't respond. Peter, why has it historically been important to have civilian presence at these military academies? Why does it matter beyond the reasons that Tom just laid out there? Well, I want to footstomp something that Tom said. We are training the military to be militarily effective. And as they progress, what matters is what happens above the neck rather than below the neck.
36:32A senior military officer in an elite unit told me, I'm getting paid now for what I do above the neck, not what I do below the neck. We need to outthink the adversary. And you outthink the adversary if your officers and your senior enlisted are better at critical thinking. And these are precisely the skills that the U.S. used to pride itself as being better than any of the other militaries in the world at cultivating. But that requires a commitment to critical thinking in the educational system. And if you are shrinking the types of people who are allowed to teach the military students, you're probably not cultivating that critical thinking.
37:21Well, it's important to note that the Pentagon also runs a school system of 160 schools serving students from pre-K through high school. They educate some 66 ,000 children of U.S. troops around the world. And Hackseth wants to reorient these schools towards what he calls patriotic values and a classical education. As part of this push, these schools are also banning hundreds of books. They prohibited Women's History Month, Black History Month, and the Pride flag. Peter, tell us more about these changes. Well, some of it is the culture war dynamic that you just outlined. A rejection of what is called identitarianism, where everyone is labeled into specific groups and then that becomes their only identity and their only defining feature.
38:09Not all of these changes are bad. A celebration of the classical education system, lots of schools are exploring that. My own kids went to a classical educated school, and that can actually cultivate the very critical thinking that we were just talking about. It's also important to recognize that these are services provided to our men and women who are serving, in most cases, in many cases, serving abroad, who need access to American education that the department is providing for them. They want the best education for their kids that they can get. And so providing a range of choice, ones that emphasize classical education by itself, that would not be problematic.
38:55If it becomes politicized, if it becomes part of the culture war agenda, then I think it's going to have a more negative impact. Are schools or students in that system pushing back or reacting to the shift? There's a range of response. Some, of course, don't like it, and some are reacting also to the larger policy changes that they see. But pervading all of this, if you only have two minutes to talk about civil-military relations, you should emphasize that we have created a low-information environment around civil-military relations. Tom referred to this. Is all of the firings that Secretary Heggs has done, are they all legitimate?
39:43We don't know because he hasn't given us access to the reasoning behind it. Are these policy changes in the schools? Do they make sense? We don't know because he hasn't been asked the tough questions. Congress has not done the job of pulling into the public light and exposing for transparency. What are we doing and why are we doing it? And in that low information environment, you have a culture of fear, a culture of uncertainty. and then that will produce pushback from people who don't know what's going on and are worried. And so there have been some protests on some basis. Well, that fear is showing up in our comments among our listeners, Tom.
40:25We got this from Stacey who says, I'm extremely concerned that this administration is going to use Pete Hegseth's military to remain in power come November 2028. And that's something that we're seeing from several people who are concerned that this reshaping is really about gaining more control over a military that will be willing to follow orders that are unconstitutional. What are you hearing? Well, I wouldn't worry about the military trying to keep President Trump in power. One of the concerns out there is during the election, they could send the National Guard into polling places. That would create a chilling effect, I think, on a lot of people.
41:02Why is the Guard here? Let's say, you know, I'm Hispanic and I'm a citizen. Maybe I don't want to go to vote because ICE may show up and just, you know, drag me off into a van. I do know there's a person I know who's an Afghan veteran. He worked with the U.S. military and he has a green card. He's been stopped twice at the same gas station outside of Boston. But he has a green card. But they're just profiling. I think that's a concern. and having the guard go to the polling places. So we're all keeping an eye on that because that could happen. But keeping the military, keeping him in power, I just don't see that happening.
41:43That would be an illegal order, and I don't think they would do it. Maybe Peter has a view on that. Peter, chime in here. Well, I'll say this is one area where Democrats in the House and Senate have been very active. And so they've been wargaming these scenarios and are unlikely to be caught flat footed if a illegal or questionable order is given. I agree with Tom. The military are going to follow lawful orders, even lawful but awful orders. But that's that's not likely to lead to a scenario where the military interrupts the election and the election process. The military do not want to do that.
42:28The military want to stay far away from culture wars and far away from partisan wars. They would like to focus on the mission. Well, I think the big picture question that's on a lot of people's mind is whether these changes, whether it's in the educational system or it's clearing out the ranks of officers or it's just reframing what the purpose of the military is for with this focus on lethality, whether that will be a fundamental change that will affect the way the U.S. military looks 10, 20, 30 years on. Tom? Well, it's hard to say. I was talking to a retired Army general who said, you know, with all the firings, removing people, reaching into the colonel's list and pulling them off, this officer, retired officer, said it's going to take two generations to fix this problem.
43:19So there's a concern about that. Also, you know, should the Democrats take the House and maybe the Senate, but looks like they'll likely take the House, that could have a break in some of these suggestions or recommendations from Secretary Hegseth, including, you know, not having tenured civilians at the service academies and so forth. And I think he'll be asked to explain why you're removing some of these generals and admirals and also why you're reaching into the ranks of the colonels and pulling them off the list. I talked to one guy on the Hill who said, you know, we're not getting a lot of information at all from the Pentagon.
43:59That could change if the Democrats take the House. He said, I hope we don't have to use our subpoena power. Peter, your thoughts, I mean, how much of an impact could the midterms have on how Secretary Hegseth moves forward? Well, as soon as the House reassembles or returns, I should say, there's a privileged resolution on the impeachment of Secretary Hagseth that they'll have to vote for. And if the chambers change political party, then there will be a lot more pressure on the administration to get us out of this low information environment. There is a risk, though, and that is that the Democrats could overcorrect and swing the pendulum hard in the other direction.
44:47And if they seek to try to fire everybody who was at all connected with Secretary Hegseth in the way that Hegseth has fired folks who were connected to Milley, that pendulum will swing wildly. And that could make it even more damaging, long lasting for the military. I will agree with Tom on this. I think Secretary Hegseth already has been a very consequential secretary, probably the most consequential secretary since Secretary McNamara. He's done more changes and pushed the administration in more new directions than previous secretaries, and it's going to take a while for an equilibrium to return.
45:29So, Tom, what are you following in your reporting leading up to the midterms and beyond? Well, does the Guard head into the streets? That's one of the things I'm looking at as a Pentagon reporter. And also, Secretary Hegseth is doing a review of women in ground combat. They're sending their people out and doing investigation at Army bases all around the country. That report is scheduled to come out by the end of the year. And there's a concern among women advocates that they may, you know, stop having women in ground combat jobs, armor, infantry, and artillery. So I'm keeping an eye on that. Well, that's Tom Bowman.
46:06He's a reporter for NPR's National Desk. He's been covering the Pentagon for over two decades. Also with us, Peter Fever. He's a professor of political science and public policy at Duke. Tom, Peter, thanks to you both. You're welcome. Today's producer was Deanna Ferreiro with help from Aileen Humphreys. This program comes to you from WAMU, part of American University in Washington, distributed by NPR. I'm Jen White. Thanks for listening. And we'll talk again tomorrow. This is 1A.
47:23Hi, it's Terry Gross. Ladies and gentlemen, I can say that now because this administration thinks there's only two genders, and I'm both of them. That's actor and drag king Murray Hill. In the series Somebody Somewhere, he played the host of a queer cabaret, which is something he's done plenty of in real life, too. Listen on the NPR app or wherever you listen to Fresh Air.