


The 1A Podcast discusses Pope Leo XIV’s rise to the papacy and the early themes of his pontificate, focusing on his American identity, his Augustinian background, and his priorities: AI ethics, migration and human dignity, Catholic social teaching, and how he handles church governance issues like synodality and abuse.
Daniel Burke, NPR senior editor of Religion and Spirituality; Scott Detrow, co-host of All Things Considered; Dr. Tia Noel Pratt, sociologist/religion scholar at Villanova and author of Black and Catholic; Father Philip Leray, Boston College philosophy professor.
Prevost’s election surprised cardinals who assumed an American pope would align with U.S. politics; Trump’s social-media AI “pope” image reportedly offended cardinals. Leo’s style is “leveler” and more measured than Pope Francis’ “bulldozer.” His papacy emphasizes Catholic social doctrine—human dignity—connecting AI, migrants, peace/war, and the common good.
800,000 people at Champs-Élysées; Leo’s multilingual first address (Italian/Spanish/Latin); Peru mission shaping lay empowerment; AI encyclical “Magnifica Humanitas” and Vatican AI summit; a Philadelphia case where Prevost reportedly agreed to defrock an abusive Augustinian priest.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploration of Robert Prevost's background and ascent to become Pope Leo XIV.
“An estimated 800 ,000 people packed the Champs -Élysées to see him, and his beloved Chicago White Sox went from woeful to winners and made the World Series playoffs.”
Discussion about the live announcement of Pope Leo XIV and the atmosphere at the event.
“Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns.”
Insights into the historical significance and reactions to the election of an American pope.
“So, Scott and Daniel, that must have been quite a moment to witness in St.”
Analysis of the factors leading to Prevost's election as Pope and the cardinals' considerations.
“Yeah, I mean, but even with that lack of alignment between the president and the now pope, there was no way to really predict how that relationship was going to play out.”
Details on the conclave process and the sentiments surrounding Prevost's potential papacy.
“But it wasn't as if he was a very visible figure, Daniel.”
Discussion of Pope Leo XIV's positions on immigration, AI, and global conflicts.
“This week on Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, we talk with David Byrne about the early fashion advice he got from Lou Reed.”
Learn where to find the podcast ThruLine.
“Listen to ThruLine in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.”
Explore Pope Leo XIV's stances on immigration and AI morality.
“Since becoming pope last year, Leo has spoken out on a wide array of issues, including immigration, the morality of artificial intelligence, and global conflicts, including the Iran War.”
Hear diverse listener perspectives on Pope Leo's influence.
“That's Pope Leo speaking to journalists mid-flight in April.”
Understand the contrasting styles of Pope Leo and Pope Francis.
“Now, Pope Leo has been Pope for a little over a year now.”
Discuss the main themes shaping Pope Leo's leadership so far.
“Well, and what are the main themes of his papacy to date, Daniel?”
Learn how growing up in Chicago influenced Pope Leo's values.
“The period of time he's growing up in the 1950s and 60s, we talked to a cardinal, Colonel Greger, who grew up in Chicago as well.”
Explore the impact of Vatican II on modern Catholicism.
“Daniel, how did that approach align with where the Catholic Church was or where it wanted to go as he ascended to the papacy?”
Examine the challenges faced by Pope Leo in promoting inclusivity.
“He brings in lay people to address some of the big issues facing the church.”
Discuss the role of women in Pope Leo's education and ministry.
“Kit writes, I'm not religious, but I like what Pope Leo stands for regarding human rights, the environment, treatment of migrants, et cetera.”
Learn about the significance of the Augustinian order in shaping Pope Leo.
“He sees them as friends and colleagues and people that he can turn to when he needs something done quickly.”
Explore the formative experiences that shaped Pope Leo XIV's worldview.
“And he talks about meeting the Spanish friar who was working with inner-city Latinos in Chicago.”
Introduction to a break for sponsor messages.
“She's a sociologist at Villanova who joins us from Rome.”
A discussion with experts on Pope Leo's challenges and priorities.
“Tia Noel Pratt is a sociologist and religion scholar.”
Examining Pope Leo's views on artificial intelligence and its implications.
“And so elevating that and elevating this core principle of the church's social doctrine of human dignity is something that we've seen and how he is making his mark even in this first year and a few months.”
Discussion on Pope Leo's focus on systemic racism and clergy abuse in the church.
“And I think those are the two largest models that we have now, aside from the Chinese.”
Interviewer reflects on personal history and questions for Pope Leo about systemic racism.
“Well, Daniel, I'm going to come back to you because there's another issue we haven't discussed yet, and that's the widespread sexual abuse in the Catholic Church by priests.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On 1A, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Robert Prevost: We the people make a free press possible. Together we hold power to account with reporting for the public, funded by the public. It takes all of us to protect the future of public media. Make your gift now at donate.npr.org.
0:25It's been a busy and successful summer for Robert Prevost, one of Chicago's most distinguished citizens. His essay on artificial intelligence was released in paperback to enthusiastic reviews, blurred by one prominent commentator as, quote, beautifully written, hugely significant, speaks truth to power. His three-city tour of France exceeded all expectations, drawing huge crowds. An estimated 800 ,000 people packed the Champs -Élysées to see him, and his beloved Chicago White Sox went from woeful to winners and made the World Series playoffs. Prévost, of course, is better known these days by another name, Pope Leo XIV, the first-ever American head of the Catholic Church.
1:13On May 8, 2025, white smoke poured from the Sistine Chapel chimney, and the bells rang out in St. Peter's Square, announcing that a new pope had been chosen. Shortly afterwards, Pope Leo stepped onto the Laja and addressed the crowd first in Italian.
1:36He starts there with, peace be with you all. Leo spoke in Italian, Spanish, and Latin, not in English, but there was no disguising that a taboo had been broken. For the first time, the Pope was an American, an Augustinian priest, and missionary who grew up in a Chicago suburb and attended church on the south side. NPR's senior editor of Religion and Spirituality, Daniel Burke, and All Things Considered co-host Scott Detrow were in the square for this remarkable moment, and it inspired them to write a book, American Pope, Leo XIV's Road from the South Side of Chicago to Vatican City. I'm Jen White.
2:11You're listening to the 1A Podcast. Today, we sit with them and discuss how Pope Leo made it to the papacy and what kind of pope he's turning out to be. That's right after this.
2:25Robert Prevost: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message Which comes from HomeServe. A burst pipe. A dead water heater. The AC calling it quits. Who do you call? HomeServe is an easy way to handle unexpected home repairs. With plans covering stuff basic homeowner's insurance usually won't. Instead of scrambling for a contractor, you make one call to get the repair process started. Join the millions of customers who trust HomeServe right now. Go to homeserve.com slash podcast for 50 % less your first year. Savings compared to renewal price. Boyd in Florida. Midlife brings a lot of changes.
3:05Robert Prevost: Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter. With Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
3:26Robert Prevost: This election season, you can streamline your news intake with Up First. Our team of reporters and editors works overnight, so you can start every morning with three stories you need to know. In short episodes, 12, 14 minutes long to save you time and your sanity. Follow Up First on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Let's welcome Daniel Burke and Scott Detrow, authors of American Pope, Leo the 14th's Road from the south side of Chicago to Vatican City. They join us in studio today. Daniel, Scott, welcome. Great to be here. Thanks so much for having us. So, Scott and Daniel, that must have been quite a moment to witness in St.
4:05Peter's Square. In fact, Scott, I think we have some tape of you doing the live play-by-play. Habemus Papa. We have a Pope, Habemus Papa.
4:18Robert Prevost: Robert Francis.
4:23Oh, my goodness. The Pope is from Chicago. What was going on in your mind at the moment? I mean, I knew that at minimum I was going to have to be translating Latin in real time on a live broadcast. So I was kind of amped up to begin with. The environment around us was electric. The roars that you heard when the white smoke first emerged from the chimney were the loudest roars I have heard in my life. And I've gotten a chance to go to like World Series games. This was something I never heard before. So it was so exciting. And then in the middle of that to hear this announcement that the pope was, as I said, somebody who grew up on the south side of Chicago, an American citizen for the first time in church history.
5:06It was just stunning. I could not believe the words that I was saying into the microphone. And the interesting thing that we quickly realized as we began to dig into who this guy was is that if you look at his resume, if you look at his qualifications, he's kind of the perfect person to head the Catholic Church. But the fact that he was an American citizen really clouded a lot of people's judgment, including Prevost. Cardinal Prevost, right before the conclave, sends a note to one of his close friends saying, I'm sleeping well at night. They're not going to elect an American. That friend relays the story to a nun that they both know really well.
5:41And Sister Therese responds, oops, he forgot about the Holy Spirit. I mean, well, Daniel, explain a little bit more about why it was unlikely that an American pope would be chosen. Yeah. So the thinking for generations has been that since America is so powerful politically around the world, militarily, that it would be a mistake to elect an American pope who would also kind of give spiritual power to that kind of environment. The assumption there is that the pope, American pope, and the American president would be aligned, and that's not quite what we've seen, have we? We've seen them battle, not quite battle, battle of words, over the Iran war, over artificial intelligence, over the detention of migrants in his home city of Chicago.
6:26So it's really interesting that we have this moment, we have an American pope, we have an American president, obviously, but they're not aligned in the way that people feared going into the conclave at all. Yeah, I mean, but even with that lack of alignment between the president and the now pope, there was no way to really predict how that relationship was going to play out. And so I'm curious, Scott, whether or not the reelection of President Trump specifically played a role. I wondered that. And I think in a little bit of the ways, it certainly was in the cardinal's minds going into the conclave.
7:00They denied it afterwards. One cardinal said, I didn't really see the, in a very dry way, I didn't see the conclave as a continuation of last year's election. But the fact is Trump was so front and center in the world at that point in time. You have to remember this is about three or four months into the second Trump administration. Tariffs are changing minute by minute, roiling the world economy. And this is the point where he's threatening to leave NATO. And right before the conclave, he posts this picture on social media, this AI picture of Trump as the Pope saying, like, I should be elected Pope.
7:31That deeply offended the cardinals going to the conclave. That was something everybody was talking about in Rome two or three days before the conclave began. And it kind of hung over things. Once the conclave began and in those meetings, you know, based on our reporting, in those meetings where the cardinals were talking about the future of the church, it's not like they were talking about the Trump administration and the United States. They were talking about a whole range of things. And the thing – I think the idea of a counterbalance, somebody who had a different moral framework of the world than the American president was appealing.
8:02But I think by and large what drove Prévost's election was that on one hand he was somebody who was a close ally of Pope Francis. Pope Francis had appointed 80 percent of the cardinals who were voting in the conclave. So the people who wanted to continue Francis' goal of the church had their guy. but also a lot of the detractors of Francis who didn't really like his governing style, who wanted a more steady leader, a more methodical leader. They saw Prevost as somebody who fit that model of leadership and would have a tonal and a structural change to the church, and that appealed to them as well.
8:34So he very quickly, after the first ballot, becomes the consensus candidate, and by mid-afternoon the next day, he's the pope. But it wasn't as if he was a very visible figure, Daniel. How much did they know about him before they chose him? Not much at all. Well, one of the most well-known cardinals in the United States, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, formerly of New York, said he didn't know him at all. And so he gets to, Cardinal Dolan gets to Rome and he says, I quickly, he hears the rumors about Prevost, they're circulating, and he says, I got to meet this guy. I think because he had been in Peru for 20 years, he'd been kind of off people's radar.
9:09He was there as a missionary for most of the 1990s. He was there as a bishop from 2015 to 2023. And his meetings with Pope Francis were not, you know, broadcast. There were not big pictures of this. These were quiet Saturday morning meetings. Scott kind of jokingly calls them Pope school, but it does seem like they were talking about geopolitics and how the church can kind of interplay with these various countries where they name bishops. Can I just add one quick thing to that? I think one image that really gets the point across of how Prevost is a high-level cardinal before the conclave, but not quite on people's radar and not thought of in the same way, is that all of the American cardinals who came over from the United States, they're all together at the big North American seminary near Rome.
9:50And as they get ready to go to the conclave, there's this glossy social media video that they shot. It's like slow motion. They're all walking out together. They're posing for pictures. And it's like, it's the American cardinals going to the conclave. And then Dolan, in the interview, he says, in retrospect, we forgot one. You know, Robert Prevost, the American cardinal who becomes pope, is not included in that big social media montage that they post. because he was staying with Latin American cardinals. Well, he lived in Rome. He was staying in his apartment. But he was, by and large, talking to the Latin American cardinals and kind of gathering with them before the conclave began.
10:21Now, there were two other cardinals in the mix to be the next pope. What did they represent as the bishops or the cardinals were trying to figure out what does the future of the church look like? Well, Cardinal Pierolline, Pietro Pierolline, was the secretary of state under Pope Francis for a long time. He represented continuity in a kind of way. but he was a career diplomat. He'd never been a pastor, and some of his sermons before in the lead-up to the conclave really fell flat with people. So he didn't really make a deep impression. The other one for the conservatives was Peter Erdo of Hungary.
10:55They really liked his traditionalist view on a lot of theological matters. It turned out that he didn't have nearly as much support, though, as he needed to get the election. As Scott said, 80 % of the cardinal electors were appointed by Francis, and so they fit with more his theological pastoral style than Erdos. So, yeah. Sorry, go ahead. The first night, they have the first ballot, the first night of the conclave, which is hours late because the cardinal giving the sermon, which is supposed to be a 15-minute sermon, talks for more than an hour. So we're out in the square freaking out and thinking, oh my gosh, this is so delayed.
11:31There's no smoke. Did they elect a pope on the first ballot? This would be monumental. What happened? It was just an old man talking for more than an hour. But that first ballot comes out, and the three of them are clumped together. Everyone realizes the other two contenders really have already hit their hard ceiling. Everybody goes to bed that night thinking, wow, Robert Prevost might be the pope. And we learned that the next morning, sitting in not the Sistine Chapel but the other chapel where they gather to pray beforehand, Prevost thinks hard about this, realizes this might come to me. And almost by accident, he's looking around.
12:05He's thinking, should I be Pope Augustine? What should my name be? Because he was an Augustinian. And his eyes catch the seal on the floor of the chapel, and he sees the seal of Pope Leo XIII. And he realizes, I could be Pope Leo because Pope Leo was close to the Augustinians, but also, as I'm sure we'll talk about, really said a lot about humanity and the dignity of workers in a time of great social upheaval. Let's pause here for a quick break. But coming up, new reporting from Daniel and Scott on the Pope's early years in Chicago, as well as his time as a missionary in Peru. and how those experiences continue to influence his worldview.
12:45Robert Prevost: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from HomeServe. A burst pipe, a dead water heater, the AC calling it quits. Who do you call? HomeServe is an easy way to handle unexpected home repairs, with plans covering stuff basic homeowner's insurance usually won't. Instead of scrambling for a contractor, you make one call to get the repair process started. Join the millions of customers who trust HomeServe right now. Go to homeserve.com slash podcast for 50 % less your first year. Savings compared to renewal price. Boyd in Florida. This week on Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, we talk with David Byrne about the early fashion advice he got from Lou Reed.
13:29Robert Prevost: I had really hairy arms at that point. He said, you should never wear short sleeves. Body shamed you. Don't miss our full conversation and the rest of our games. Listen to the Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Before Bernie Sanders or AOC, a man named Michael Harrington tried to market socialism to the American public. Tens of millions of Americans were poor, miserable, in body and in spirit. On NPR's ThruLine, how the founder of the DSA created a modern political movement. Listen to ThruLine in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Back now to our discussion of Pope Leo XIV.
14:14Since becoming pope last year, Leo has spoken out on a wide array of issues, including immigration, the morality of artificial intelligence, and global conflicts, including the Iran War. Perspectives that have sometimes put him at odds with his fellow American, President Trump. Here's Leo aboard the papal plane in April.
14:32Robert Prevost: I have no fear, neither the Trump administration, nor speaking out loudly about the message in the gospel. And that's what I believe. I am called to do what the church is called to do. We're not politicians. We're not looking to make foreign policy, as he calls it, with the same perspective that he might understand it. But I do believe that the message of the gospel, the blessing of the peacemakers, is the message of the war needs to hear to him. That's Pope Leo speaking to journalists mid-flight in April. A new biography, American Pope, explores his life before he was in the public eye and the President's Truth social feed.
15:09We're here with the authors, NPR's Scott Detrow and Daniel Burke, and we're hearing from you.
15:15Robert Prevost: I am born and raised in Chicago, and I now live in a tiny town in Vermont. I'm a recovering Catholic, and I was so happy that when Leo became Pope, I really almost considered going back to church, you know, and I, he's a Bears fan, he's a Sox fan, it was wonderful, and I was like, yeah, maybe, maybe I'll try this again, and as I was thinking about that, I drove past my local parish, and they had a big old anti-abortion sign out there, we had local elections for women's reproductive rights, and they had a big vote no, and I was like, oh, right. I'm a non-Catholic Christian, and I'm very impressed with Pope Leo.
16:00Robert Prevost: His message about the poor and taking care of the poor resonates deeply with me as a Christian. My home parish in Charlotte, North Carolina, is very supportive of Pope Leo. Ironically, I think that I named my son after him, as his name is Leo. I think that, honestly, he's doing a great job as Pope. He's really balancing the modern age with the church doctrine and really allowing people to feel more comfortable with the Catholic Church. Thank you, Margaret in Vermont, Dale in Delphi, Indiana, and Rachel in Fort Mills, South Carolina. Now, Pope Leo has been Pope for a little over a year now. Scott, how do you think he differs from his predecessor, Pope Francis, both in style and substance?
16:48I think the style is what is more front of mind to me. One of the quotes that a cardinal told us as we were reporting this book, a Peruvian cardinal, said that you have to think about the two men this way. They have a lot of the same goals, but Pope Francis was a bulldozer. He was clearing the road. He was trying to get the debris out of the way to make a path forward. And Pope Leo is a leveler. He is meticulously plotting the path, taking a longer time to do it, but trying to make it so it is a straight path that lasts a longer period of time. I think Pope Leo is a lot more diplomatic than Pope Francis.
17:25Pope Francis, his admirers loved him for it. His detractors rolled their eyes for it, but he would say what he thought. He would be combative. He would pick a fight. He would kind of make an abrupt term if he wanted to see a change. He would float big theological changes to the church in press conferences and in off-the-cuff remarks. And I think a lot of people saw the passion and the power of that. I think Pope Leo is a lot more careful the way that we heard him speaking in response to President Trump. It was so measured. He was saying, I'm not getting into politics. I'm just speaking the gospel.
17:57I think that when you talk about potential changes to the church, I think Leo is mindful that different people in different parts of the world all have different priorities and different timelines that they're comfortable with. And he's going to try—we have seen throughout his life that he tries to bring as many people along with him as possible, even if that means moving more slowly to keep everybody on board. Well, and what are the main themes of his papacy to date, Daniel? Especially when you think about the fact that depending on where you're practicing Catholicism in the world, the expectations of what the church is and what it should do can be very different.
18:32Yes, and he has a lot of experience in that. Hands-on, firsthand experience. He was, of course, a missionary in Peru, but he was also the head of the Augustinian order, which meant that he visited communities around the world. He visited 40 countries, and that put him in touch with local realities. What does the church in Nigeria think of this issue? What does the church in the Philippines think about that issue? I think it was actually a good indication of how he was good at relating to people that later came up in the conclave from around the world and understanding their needs and concerns.
19:02But I think one of the things that Leo—the main thing, obviously, artificial intelligence. He mentioned it as soon as he was elected. I'm taking the name Leo in part because I want to address artificial intelligence, just as the previous Leo had addressed the Industrial Revolution. I think he's continuing Pope Francis' care for the environment, making that a top priority for the church, and really migrants. He's looking at the migrant crisis not only in the United States but in Europe. He went to the Canary Islands in Spain where a lot of migrants have come through. He said a mask for them. He said, we really need to respect the dignity of people who are coming to their borders.
19:38It's okay to have an immigration policy. It's okay to have those borders, but we cannot treat the people who come across those borders in the way that they have been treating. We've seen him do that in Spain. We've seen him do it in France. We've seen him do it in a number of different countries around the world. I'm really interested in hearing, Scott, how you think his time growing up in Chicago shaped both his faith and the way he's approaching his papacy. The period of time he's growing up in the 1950s and 60s, we talked to a cardinal, Colonel Greger, who grew up in Chicago as well. He's the first black American cardinal, and he said you have to think about the parishes in the south side of Chicago were the focal point of the entire community even for non-Catholics.
20:25It was kind of like I live in this church's zone. I live in that church's zone. If you go a few blocks over, he said you might as well be entering a different world. And the centerpiece, the center point of the Prevost family's life is St. Mary of the Assumption Church. It is right on the Chicago border. You cross the street. You're in the suburb of Dalton where he grew up. And they did everything there. He went to school there. They would have dances. They would have parties. They would have festivals there. His mother took him to church several times a week. And he's seeing the way that his parents engage in this community.
20:55They are focal points of this parish. They are organizing so many things in the way that you see him as an adult later. His mother is, we're finding in news clippings in the parish bulletins, she's organizing a polio vaccine drive. She's organizing a food pantry. She single-handedly creates the school library. The school didn't have a library. She was a librarian. So she's bringing books in, setting them up in a room in the basement, setting up a card catalog, helping kids learn how it is. So he sees from his parents something that is something he's talked repeatedly about no matter what level of authority he's in, that to him religion is about prayer and it's about going to church.
21:32But it's also about being out in the world helping other people. He saw his parents do that. He saw all the other parents around him do that. And that left a big impression on him. Well, if that is how his faith was shaped, it's both about understanding the theology, but also serving the community, ministering in a very active way. Daniel, how did that approach align with where the Catholic Church was or where it wanted to go as he ascended to the papacy? Yeah. So I think with the advent of Vatican II, which is this big church meeting in the mid-1960s, what it does is, what it tries to do is take some of the power from the hierarchy and give it to the laity, give it to lay people.
22:16It wound up developing a little bit more in Latin America than in the United States, which is interesting. So in 1985, Robert Prevost is in Rome. He's studying to get a degree in canon law. But there's this accident in Peru where Augustinians have started a mission. And one of the victims of this accident was the canon lawyer who was supposed to help them set up this new diocese in Peru. So all of a sudden, Robert Prevost, who's on this path up to the church hierarchy, gets sent to Peru, this northern diocese, very, very remote. And there he learns this new model of being a church, in part because they had so few priests.
22:52They really empowered laypeople. They started these little communities, local groups, where they put women in charge of the liturgy or youth ministry or all kinds of things. And they really banded together. And what they saw was this model really works. We have to take the church out of the building and bring it to the people, particularly in places like Peru where people are spread out across deserts and mountains and things like that. And then we saw him bring that up later throughout his career. And I think we're seeing a little bit of that with the Catholic Church now that he's pope. He's really consultative.
23:24He brings in lay people to address some of the big issues facing the church. And this is something that he learned in Latin America in the 1980s. Is there resistance, though, to that approach, Scott? Because, I mean, there can also be a very hierarchical structure to religious institutions. Indeed. Perhaps maybe the most hierarchical structure in the world is the Catholic Church historically. Yeah, this actually became one of the big fault lines in Pope Francis's papacy. Pope Francis was really into this idea. The church term is synodality. It basically means consulting. You know, the pope has ultimate authority, can be infallible if he wants to be.
23:59But Pope Francis said, no, this is not the approach. I need to bring people on board. So first he begins consulting bishops from around the world. And then for the very first time, he's the first pope to have a synod where lay people, where non-bishops are included and involved, where women are included, which in the Catholic Church is at times a remarkable step, even though the rest of the world is often saying, Yes, that's half the population. Perhaps they should be at the table. But Francis goes all in on that. Cardinal Prevost is all in on that as well. He's constantly talking about how that is the approach that he sees as well.
24:30A lot of cardinals, a lot of detractors of Pope Francis do not like that approach. They want a top-down order. They think it gets too watered down and it loses the essence of Catholicism. So there were some major theological struggles on that fact. And in fact, one of Prevost's close friends throughout his life, one of the smartest people in Prevost's orbit, somebody who in high school and college and seminary, they always competed with each other. He ends up on the opposite side of that church fight, and he is leading the effort to try and stop Pope Francis's synods. And that creates a real painful tension point in Prevost's life with somebody who he'd known from age 13.
25:06Kit writes, I'm not religious, but I like what Pope Leo stands for regarding human rights, the environment, treatment of migrants, et cetera. I also like Pope Francis as a breath of fresh air after Benedict. In 1978, Robert Pravost attended Catholic Theological Union in Hyde Park. You describe it as, quote, a hotbed of post-Vatican II experimentation. Coursework included a how-to-say mass class that was taught by Sister Kathleen Hughes. And there was a well-established ministry to sex workers as well. And an editorial in the student newspaper said, and nearly everyone agreed, that women should be ordained.
25:41And Daniel, this is a low bar, but when you say Prevost didn't need to be taught how to work with women like some other priests in the book, what were the biggest impacts you saw on him during this period of life when he was still learning? It's such a remarkable period because like this seminary came to life reading through like the student papers of the time. You know, somebody writes an op-ed saying, can all the students please stop smoking cigarettes? I get allergic and I have to sit on the floor. So they're all – they're sitting there. They're smoking. They're arguing with each other about theology.
26:12They're having parties. Pope Leo's order at one point. They had an animal house that just came out and they had a toga party one night. So these are people who are thrilled to be learning about theology, thrilled to be learning how to minister to people but also just really loving the academic side of things. But yeah, there are lots of women in classes with them even though it's technically a seminary. And this whole group of remarkable, brilliant, passionate sisters are teaching his classes, and he really learns from them, including how to say Mass. And I think, you know, you add on the strong presence that his mother led in his life, and you see that how repeatedly from that point forward as a priest, he is always the first call he makes is to a laywoman to help him out with one project or another.
26:57He is somebody who in a way that, you know, I think we were trying to figure out He might be the first pope to be taught by a woman in the history of the Catholic Church because, you know, they all grew up in seminaries in all-male environments. And that's different. And that is a step toward the modern world that you can see the way that, you know, he has close relationships. He has a lot of friends in his life who are women who he talks to and he confides in. And again, many priests historically, you know, Pope John XXIII, who is this big historic pope, has diary entries in books that have been published saying that it's important to stay away from women in any form of temptation, you know.
27:34But Robert Priebus doesn't see that. He sees them as friends and colleagues and people that he can turn to when he needs something done quickly. Well, he was also really shaped by being a part of the Augustinian order, Daniel. And what drew him to that order specifically? It's a couple of things. Number one, his two brothers went to an Augustinian high school in Chicago, so he was familiar with the order. His mother was the librarian at that school for a time. His father would bring around guests, interesting people that he worked with, to the table. And he talks about meeting the Spanish friar who was working with inner-city Latinos in Chicago.
28:07It kind of plants the seed early. But one of the things we know is that he was heavily recruited by the religious orders, almost like college football coaches. We got to get this Bobby Prevost, you know, because he was seen as so spiritual. His parents were so Catholic and he was just such a prized commodity. He winds up with the Augustinians. He goes to a high school from the age of 13 until he's, he lives in Augustinian communities from 13 until like 2015 until he's a bishop in Chiclayo. So this is formed almost everything about him. You know, how he prays, how they take care of each other when they're sick.
28:40They really are a community of brothers that forms how he sees the world. It builds into this idea that the consensus is how we do things. It's not a top-down order. It's very egalitarian in contrast to other orders. And so I think they share power with each other. That's just something that he's used to. In the Vatican now, he lives with several Augustinians who help him out. So it just shows how close he is to the order. He introduced himself on the loggia on the first day, May 8, 2025, as a son of St. Augustine, which just goes to show how deeply indebted he seems to be to St. Augustine. Well, Scott, I'm also really interested in hearing how he views himself as a citizen of the world, because we talk about him being an American citizen, but he is also Peruvian.
29:26He's a naturalized Peruvian citizen. So how does he hold those identities within himself as he's in the papacy? Yeah, that's a really important point. And, you know, it's funny. We've all seen the memes that rocketed around Chicago. Yes. I was in Chicago when it was announced, and it was quite a time. The funniest thing was when we were in Peru reporting, you see those same memes but with Peruvian culture. They claim Pope Leo just as much as America does. Like all of the memes of the Pope drinking Malort in Chicago, you see that with Inca Cola, the popular soda in Peru. And I thought that said so much because people in so many different parts of the world feel so close to him.
30:06He is a Peruvian citizen. He is an American citizen. And the fact that he didn't speak English until the second day of his papacy and not in that introduction to the world, I think underscores he wants to be seen as a pope for the world, not as an American pope. Doug in Mansfield, Massachusetts, writes, I'm a Unitarian Universalist. To me, Pope Leo's message with regard to President Trump is to simply preach the gospel. No politics. I believe that Jesus would be a fan. And Margaret writes, Leo is intelligent and not afraid to speak up. As a lifelong Presbyterian, I admire him so much that I'm even thinking of becoming Catholic.
30:39Well, we have to take another quick break, but still ahead, we'll hear from a Catholic priest who's studying the ethical implications of AI and the author of Black and Catholic. She's a sociologist at Villanova who joins us from Rome. Stay with us.
30:56Robert Prevost: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from HomeServe. A burst pipe, a dead water heater, the AC calling it quits. Who do you call? HomeServe is an easy way to handle unexpected home repairs, with plans covering stuff basic homeowner's insurance usually won't. Instead of scrambling for a contractor, you make one call to get the repair process started. Join the millions of customers who trust HomeServe right now. Go to homeserve.com slash podcast for 50 % less your first year. Savings compared to renewal price. Boyd in Florida. Let's get back to Pope Leo XIV and add two new voices.
31:38Dr. Tia Noel Pratt is a sociologist and religion scholar. She holds many roles at Pope Leo's alma mater, Villanova University, including special assistant to the vice president for mission and ministry. She's the author of Black and Catholic, Racism, Identity, and Religion. And she joins us from Rome. Dr. Pratt, welcome to 1A. Thank you for having me. And also with us, Father Philip Leray. He's a Catholic priest and professor of philosophy at Boston College. Father Leray, welcome. Thank you, Jen. Good to see you again. Good to see you. We should mention here we were in New Hampshire recently together on a panel about AI.
32:12So, Dr. Pratt, you work at Villanova. The Pope studied there. How would you assess your fellow Villanova's first year or so as pontiff? I would say this first year or so has been illuminating and what we heard previously about the Holy Father taking his time. And that's what we've seen. We've seen him take his time to elevate the issues that are of concern for him and concern for the papacy, as was already mentioned, you know, migration, the poor, immigration, AI. These are things that he has taken his time to let us know are of concern for him and that will be priorities in this papacy. Father Leray, what's your assessment?
33:04well first of all if i may i want to congratulate scott and daniel as you know i lived in rome for 30 years and the uh research that they have done and the uh accuracy with which they describe the events in rome is is is outstanding i i congratulate both of you i think it was uh it's it's a great book. Thank you so much. As both Scott and Daniel said, right from the beginning, Pope Leo speaks about the digital revolution. And that's why he took his name, Leo, to do for today what Pope Leo the 13th did for his time. And his first encyclical was about the social doctrine of the church in relationship to artificial intelligence.
33:48And I think that we're going to see more and more of that because it is a central issue of our time and it is changing society and even people to a significant degree. And I think that the Pope is recognized as a universal moral authority and moral leader, even for those that disagree with his positions, leading us and guiding us in order to use this technology well. Well, we reached out to Father James Martin. He's editor-at-large of the Jesuit magazine, America. And we asked him about the biggest challenges facing the Catholic Church in the next 20 years.
34:27Robert Prevost: Certainly recovering from the sex abuse crisis and taking steps to make sure those kinds of crimes never happen again. Second, a certain polarization, particularly in the West, in places like the United States, which really threatens to divide the church. But I think Leo has done wonderful work in trying to bring the two wings of the church together. and certainly looking at the challenges of the growing church in the global south, which is really the new sort of center of the church. So all those things, I think, make being Pope kind of a tough job. Dr. Pratt, where do you most clearly see Pope Leo putting his mark on the papacy so far?
35:11So far, we can see that that first speech from the loggia, We saw outlined migration, human dignity, artificial intelligence. We saw those themes again in the first encyclical Magnifica Humanitas. And these are places where he is putting his mark. You know, the name, taking the name Leo, harkens back to Pope Leo XIII. So that tells us that Catholic social teaching is going to be a major point in this papacy and that Catholic social teaching is often regarded as the best kept secret in the church. But what we can see is that it's not going to be a secret anymore. And the themes of human dignity and the common good, there is a lot about artificial intelligence and magnifica humanitas, but there's also a lot about human dignity.
36:11And there's a thread through there with AI, with migration, with peace, and war that we've seen him talk about. And so elevating that and elevating this core principle of the church's social doctrine of human dignity is something that we've seen and how he is making his mark even in this first year and a few months. Well, Father Luray, those issues are hotbed topics globally. And we heard Pope Leo earlier say, you know, I'm not a politician. But at a time when politics are so divisive and where things like immigration, artificial intelligence, there's not a lot of agreement, or at least through a policy lens, there's very different approaches to how to manage those things.
37:01I mean, how difficult is it for him to really just stay in the role as a religious leader without it bleeding over into politics? I think he leaves that to the politicians. Look at the example he gave us in France. Very difficult to visit France, which is very secularized. And even though everywhere you look, you see signs of the heritage of the Catholic Church, it's not very popular as it has been in the past. For example, he went to the UNESCO and Macron was there and the head of the UNESCO was there. And he did speak about artificial intelligence, but he does it from the perspective of a pontiff, not from the perspective of the technology.
37:52He's aware of the intricacies of the technology, but he's not a CEO of an AI company. He's not a programmer. He's not a technologist. He's a pope. And so I think Tia mentioned this. What he tries to do is list the principles of the vision the Catholic Church has of the human person vis-a-vis artificial intelligence. And that is what he's writing about now. Well, on May 25th, Pope Leo spoke at the Vatican about his lengthy encyclical that is at least in part about the potential risks of AI, weighing in on one of the most complex and challenging issues of our time.
38:33Robert Prevost: Artificial intelligence needs to be disarmed. The word is strong, I know. but deliberately chosen because this moment needs words capable of attracting attention, awakening consciences, and indicating paths forward for humanity. Let's not fear artificial intelligence, but constantly keep the question of the human in play. We cannot be careless with their most powerful technical instruments. Father Loray, help us better understand the Pope's concerns about artificial intelligence and its potential impact on humanity. It's been in the news, Jen, over the past couple of weeks in a huge way, especially on Meet the Press.
39:23And what Pope Leo is trying to do is balance the tension between embracing the technology and using it to its fullest extent, even at the cost of substituting human beings, and rejecting the technology, like usually we call these Luddites, those who reject new technology because of the effects that they can have on society. And the Pope says in the encyclical, both of these concerns, you can't ban the technology, you can't ignore the technology, but at the same time, we have to be aware of the risks. And they have been voiced by many people, most recently by Bill Gates, Elon Musk, and the rest.
40:13It went viral, the fact that artificial intelligence, if it is not controlled and used properly, could even mean the extinction of the human race. So let's hope that doesn't happen. We mentioned that Pope Leo is seen as a moral authority on this issue and others. But when we think about the development of AI, control of that technology is really held in just a handful of people, a very concentrated group of technocrats. And so how well is he able to leverage that moral authority and really catch the ear and attention of the people who are developing this technology? Is he doing that in any practical way?
41:01I believe so. The fact that he had the co-founder of Anthropic, Christopher Ola, at the presentation of the encyclical speaks volumes of his intention. And that is to have people understand the encyclical on the social doctrine of the church and AI is not just for Catholics, it's for everyone. Many people in Silicon Valley were a little, shall we say, disappointed because of the length of the document. You mentioned this yourself. It's a long document. And it is clothed in words typical of the Vatican. And, you know, as a priest, I'm quite used to that. But I think that someone, you know, who lives in Palo Alto, for example, and works at Cisco probably would not be able to understand much of the encyclical.
41:54But I must say, and we talked about this in New Hampshire, the Catholic Church has had a good rapport with the different AI companies, especially OpenAI and Anthropic. And I think those are the two largest models that we have now, aside from the Chinese. And I think that Pope Leo wants to continue to encourage that, have people come to Rome. We just organized, as you know, a summit in the Vatican on September 9th and 10th, and we brought together entrepreneurs, politicians, philanthropists, theologians, scholars, all kinds of people to talk about artificial intelligence inside the Vatican. And I think that we're going to continue doing that.
42:44We heard from Eudoxia, who writes, I'm a black Catholic, and I am so glad to see Pope Leo as the head of the church, as I feel that he will continue the work begun by Pope Francis in a way that would gladden the heart of Jesus. Unfortunately, I don't see a lot of the spirit of Pope Francis and Pope Leo reflected in our local parishes. Dr. Pratt, much of your scholarly work has focused on systemic racism in the church. Do you see that as an issue Pope Leo will address? I see it as an issue that he will address because he's already addressed it. He's addressed it in paragraph 176 of Magnifica Humanitas when talking about slavery, when asking for pardon because of the church's role in slavery.
43:34And as a U.S.-born pope, this is something that would already have been on his radar. We wouldn't have needed those around him to place it on his radar. And systemic racism was also part of the final document on the Senate on synodality. And we know that when he was still Cardinal Provost, that he was involved in the Senate as well. So, yes, so this is something that I would expect to see continued conversation about as his papacy continues. Well, Daniel, I'm going to come back to you because there's another issue we haven't discussed yet, and that's the widespread sexual abuse in the Catholic Church by priests.
44:20What is Pope Leo doing for survivors? How is he dealing with that issue? Yeah, so we talked about community before and how big of a value that is for Augustinians. and there were times when that value was really tested. And one of those times was the clergy sex abuse crisis in the early 2000s. At the time, he was the head of the Augustinian order. So all of these cases eventually reached his desk. And there's one in particular that's kind of indicative of how he handled things. There was a priest in Philadelphia, a leader, who said that there's a friar, an Augustinian, who had done some things that were criminal and needed to be removed from the community, which is a tough thing to do, actually, to remove them from the community.
44:59They call Robert Prevost in Rome and they say, we need to get rid of this guy, unfortunately. And he hesitates. He says, do we really need to do that? I'm not really clear on the problem here. You have to remember he'd spent a lot of time in Peru. He'd spent a lot of time in Italy where it wasn't seen as much of a problem, though. It clearly was still a problem. So what the priest told me, he says, Prevost says, okay, let me think about this. I'll put down the phone. He spends a couple of days thinking about it. And the priest says it's almost like he took a crash course during that time in how to handle clergy sex abuse.
45:33He agreed that the priest needed to be defrocked. He didn't stand in the way. And he issued clear guidelines to the order. This is how we need to handle these cases. So I think as Pope, he has his eyes wide open to this issue. He has dealt with it since 2000. He has dealt with it pretty clearly. And he's not the kind of guy who's going to sweep things under the rug. Well, you didn't get a chance to interview Pope Leo for your book. And Scott, I've got to ask, if you had a chance to speak to him, what would you ask him? So many questions. We tried many times, and at a certain point, we had our bullet list of questions.
46:08But to go back to something you were talking about a moment ago, one of the things that I would love to know what he truly thinks and feels about it, when you talk about systemic racism and you talk about that, the fact that generations of his family were black, were a mixed race, and that by and large that was forgotten by the time that his mother's family moves to Chicago in the very first wave of the Great Migration. She's born in Chicago in 1911. Her parents were listed as black in census records in New Orleans. From Chicago on, they're listed as white. But this was a deep part of his history.
46:39There were enslaved people in his family. There were enslavers in his family. There were people in his family who were slaves. They were freed. They purchased slaves themselves. So when he, as a pope, apologizes for the church role in slavery, that is personal to his family. And I would love to know what he has thought about that as he has learned more information. And I would love to know what his mother said to him about that part of her family history as a child. Well, questions I would love answers to as well. That's Scott Detrow. He's co-host of All Things Considered. Also with us, Daniel Burke, NPR's Senior Editor of Religion and Spirituality.
47:10Their new book, American Pope, is out this week. Also with us, Father Philip Luray. He's a Catholic priest and professor of philosophy at Boston College. And Dr. Tia Noel Pratt, a sociologist and religion scholar who holds many roles at Pope Leo's alma mater, Villanova University. She's the author of Black and Catholic Racism, Identity, and Religion. Thanks to you all. Thanks so much. Our text is the fastest way to connect with us. You can sign up to our text service at the1a.org. Just go to the Talk to 1A tab. We had a lot of help with this show. Today's producers were Chris Turpin, Deanna Ferreiro, and Aileen Humphreys, with help from Avery Jessa Chapnick.
47:47And this program comes to you from WAMU, part of American University in Washington, distributed by NPR. I'm Jen White. Todd Zwillick is with you tomorrow for the Friday News Roundup. Hope you tune in. Thanks for listening. And we'll talk more soon. This is 1A.
48:21Robert Prevost: Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. Opera singer Gabriela Di Lacio always loved Mozart, Beethoven, Vivaldi. But then she discovered she didn't know the works of thousands of female composers. It's not about taking people off the list. It's putting more people on the list. Tracking down the women missing from music. That's on the TED Radio Hour podcast. Listen on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. This election season, let the NPR Politics podcast save your time and your sanity. We'll help you understand key races, which polls you can safely ignore, and what might happen if power shifts in Congress.
49:02Robert Prevost: Our short daily episodes come out every afternoon so you can spend less time scrolling through each chaotic news cycle. Make NPR Politics your hub for midterm election coverage. Follow our podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.