1. Podcasts
  2. 1A
  3. What Does Donald Trump’s Tariffs Mean For Michigan? Plus, The Israeli Election
1A

20 Oct 2026 · 44m · 15 chapters

Episode artwork

What Does Donald Trump’s Tariffs Mean For Michigan? Plus, The Israeli Election

In short

The episode connects two elections: U.S. midterms (with a focus on Michigan) and Israel’s national election. On trade, it argues Trump’s tariffs on Canadian goods (50% in August; Canada retaliated in September) are disrupting Michigan’s border economy and raising costs. It claims automotive losses are rising even if finished auto parts are exempt, because cross-border assembly repeatedly moves tariff-exposed materials. Notable examples include tariffs affecting steel, aluminum, dairy, electronics, and even packaging materials; Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer warns “chaotic tariff policy” threatens autos. It cites Detroit Three losses in the past year and a drop in Canada’s U.S. vehicle sales share from about 40% to about 20%, plus a University of Toronto estimate of a 42% decline in Canadian visits to U.S. cities.

Guests

April Baer (host of Stateside, Michigan Public) and Daniel Estrin (NPR international correspondent in Israel), Joshua Leifer (Haaretz columnist; author of Tablets Shattered).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:31

Impact of Tariffs on Michigan's Economy

Discussion on the implications of tariffs imposed on Canadian goods for Michigan's economy.

“Yesterday, we covered the midterm races in Michigan that will affect the rest of the country.”
2:47

Discussion on Trade Tariffs and the Auto Industry

Exploration of how trade tariffs are affecting the automotive industry in Michigan.

“This election season, let the NPR Politics podcast save your time and your sanity.”
3:21

Effects on Household Goods and Prices

Analysis of how tariffs influence everyday goods and consumer prices in Michigan.

“She's the host of the stateside show and podcast right here at Michigan Public.”
4:30

Tariffs and the Midterm Elections

Insight into how tariffs are influencing political campaigns and voter concerns in Michigan.

“And I would say that while auto parts themselves are exempt from the tariffs, those materials that go toward automotive are not.”
5:59

Cross-Border Travel and Tourism Effects

Discussion on how tariffs are impacting cross-border travel and tourism between the U.S. and Canada.

“Well, again, the larger makers of goods have absorbed some of these costs.”
7:22

Public Sentiment on U.S.-Canada Relations

Exploration of how Michiganders feel about the changing relationship with Canada due to tariffs.

“And it was not at all uncommon to just take a little trip across the border to Windsor, spend the day up there.”
10:10

Future Economic Consequences of Tariffs

Speculation on the long-term economic effects of ongoing tariffs on Michigan's economy.

“Not just the way it's affecting their pocketbooks, but just that we have this really friendly neighbor to the north.”
12:06

Transition to Israeli Elections

Introduction to the upcoming Israeli elections and their significance.

“Okay, so one thing that a lot of people have eyes on is crude oil.”
14:20

Analyzing the Stakes of Israel's Upcoming Election

Discussion on the impact of Netanyahu's leadership and the implications of the upcoming Israeli election.

“On October 27th, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faces voters for the first time in four years.”
16:50

Analyzing the Stakes of Israel's Upcoming Election

Discussion on the impact of Netanyahu's leadership and the implications of the upcoming Israeli election.

“It's the first vote since the October 7th Hamas attacks and since the Gaza war.”
Show all 15 chapters
19:25

Analyzing the Stakes of Israel's Upcoming Election

Discussion on the impact of Netanyahu's leadership and the implications of the upcoming Israeli election.

“And you hear that sentiment from a lot of Israelis, and that too is not an exaggeration.”
28:06

Eisenkot vs. Netanyahu: The Israeli Election Dynamics

Explore the contrasting positions of Eisenkot and Netanyahu ahead of the election.

“But this time, because of October 7th, they see him as presiding over Israel's biggest security disaster ever.”
32:25

Voter Sentiments and Security Concerns in Israel

Discuss the emotional responses and security strategies of Israeli voters.

“Let's get back to our discussion about the upcoming Israeli election and what it means for that country, for Israeli democracy, and the rest of the world.”
42:08

Election Dynamics in Israel

Explore the political stakes and corruption charges facing Netanyahu in the Israeli elections.

“Israelis draw drastically different lessons from what has happened here these last few years.”
45:16

Netanyahu's Campaign Strategy

Understand how Netanyahu's alignment with Trump shapes his election strategy.

“And I would say it's a very strong force in the current election.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 1A, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01This week on Up First, the midterms less than 15 days away. President Trump, Vice President J.D. Vance and former President Obama all crisscrossing the country, rallying voters in key races from Michigan to Georgia to North Carolina. Join us every morning as we guide you through the homestretch of this election season up first on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.

0:31Yesterday, we covered the midterm races in Michigan that will affect the rest of the country. Today, we turn to trade. In the decades following the start of the North American Free Trade Agreement in 1994, the U.S. and Canada built strong economic ties across their border. Robust trade for billions of dollars of goods, with most tariffs removed, made Canada a key trading partner for northern border states like Michigan. President Trump has fractured that decades-long economic relationship. Depending on how he and his administration navigate their trade war with our northern neighbor, that relationship may not return in the same way.

1:06In August, the administration imposed 50 % tariffs on Canadian goods, taxing$20 billion of Canadian products like dairy, beverages, cement, and more. Canada hit back in September, matching them dollar for dollar with new tariffs on U.S. dairy, steel, aluminum, agricultural products, and electronics. I'm Jen White, broadcasting from Michigan Public in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and you're listening to the 1A podcast. Today, what have those tariffs meant for Michigan's economy and Michiganders? How would they show up in the midterms? Plus, we'll go to Israel for a look at what's at stake during their national election next week and why it matters here in the U.S.

1:46We'll be back with more after this short break. Stay with us.

1:53Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Mint Mobile. While others have been hiking your bill, Mint Mobile has kept their wireless plans starting at$15 a month. Switch to Mint Mobile and get three months of premium wireless service for$15 a month. Go to mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for a three-month plan required,$15 per month equivalent. New customer offer, first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. Hey, it's Ray from Car Talk. Are you tired of all the depth and thoughtful care that goes into NPR shows?

2:31Want some good old-fashioned goofing around and stumbling to figure out what's going on? Well, I've been taking occasional car questions again. You can hear them by signing up for NPR Plus, along with lots of other bonus content. Just go to plus.npr.org. This election season, let the NPR Politics podcast save your time and your sanity. We'll help you understand key races, which polls you can safely ignore, and what might happen if power shifts in Congress. Our short daily episodes come out every afternoon so you can spend less time scrolling through each chaotic news cycle. Make NPR Politics your hub for midterm election coverage.

3:08Follow our podcast on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome back to the 1A podcast. We're starting our hour by discussing how the U.S.-Canada trade war tariffs are hitting border state economies like Michigan's. Joining in studio is April Baer. She's the host of the stateside show and podcast right here at Michigan Public. April, it's great to have you. It's so nice to be here, Jen. Welcome back to Michigan. Thanks. So, April, let's start with some specific examples that show how important Canada is to Michigan's economy. Sure. Okay, so there are a whole slew of iron and steel products that are probably the first thing that a lot of Michiganders think of.

3:46These are everything from iron tubes for pipelines, steel for railroad ties, right down to aluminum foil, metal screws and bolts, threshers, other types of farm machinery, stoves, timber products, plastic packaging, a lot of clothing and dairy products you might not expect. going down to facial tissue and toilet paper. There are billions and billions of dollars of items that travel between the two countries. And obviously, it's having a big impact for automotive. I want to just play a bit of tape from Michigan's governor, Gretchen Whitmer, speaking in mid-September. The biggest threat to autos in America and in Michigan right now is unfettered, chaotic tariff policy that's coming out of the White House right now.

4:28So the auto industry looms large in Michigan's economy. Absolutely. To this day. And I would say that while auto parts themselves are exempt from the tariffs, those materials that go toward automotive are not. And as I know you know, Jen, there's a highly integrated relationship. Many times when an American-made vehicle is assembled, the chassis and parts are trucked back and forth across the border several times during assembly. So what are those automotive companies, you're talking about Ford, GM, Stellantis, saying about what this all means for their bottom lines? Well, so the Detroit three don't like to talk about this on the record at this moment.

5:09They've been kind of mum. But the corporate profits really tell the story. All three reported billions of dollars in losses in the past year because of the tariffs. And the Canadians are not buying as many American vehicles as they used to. Over the past four or five years, the U.S. share of new vehicle sales in Canada was close to 40 percent. This year, it's down to something like 20 percent. And the industry has already absorbed huge losses due to some other issues, the Trump administration's flip-flops on EV policy. At this point, the Detroit three are absorbing costs. It's only a matter of time before vehicle prices start going up.

5:46Now, everybody's not in the market for a car. So where are Michiganders feeling the economic pinch when it comes to these tariffs, when they're thinking about how they're, you know, buying things for their own households? Where is it showing up most? Well, again, the larger makers of goods have absorbed some of these costs. But you start to see, I mean, there's just any number of ways. I was noticing last year, actually, some of the tariffs were a little higher last year. There have been moving targets. It's you go and you pick up cans of cat and dog food. It's not necessarily that what's in the can costs more, but you better believe the aluminum that forms the can is pushing that price up notable, notable a few cents at a time.

6:30Michigan has a key U.S. Senate race this year between progressive Democrat Abdul El-Sayed and Republican Mike Rogers. How are the tariffs playing a role in the midterms, especially that race? Oh, it's definitely something that candidates have been talking about on the campaign trail. And it plays into the costs of living issues that voters bring up to us all the time. I can tell you, in terms of the Senate campaign, in the early days, Republican candidate Mike Rogers said that, you know, these tariffs would not be as catastrophic. He said Democrats were fear-mongering. He has since flipped. There are TV ads running this week saying we need to end the trade war now.

7:07And Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic candidate, interestingly, hasn't said no to all tariffs. He says he'd be open to what the UAW would support. That's a union that has supported his candidacy. But he says the Trump tariffs need to end like yesterday. You know, it's interesting, April. I grew up in Michigan. I grew up in Detroit. And it was not at all uncommon to just take a little trip across the border to Windsor, spend the day up there. but I'm really curious about what that cross-border travel and tourism looks like now. And you spoke recently with Gordon Orr on Stateside. He's the CEO of Tourism Windsor-Essex-Paley Island.

7:46That's a tourism board for the Canadian side of the border with Detroit. Let's take a listen. A lot of people are staying closer to home and staycations and doing things in their own backyard. I just want our friends in America, certainly in Detroit and Michigan and Ohio, to know that we welcome you with open arms and we're a very welcoming community. And we know the same goes when we travel to your beautiful states and towns. How do Gordon's comments compare to what you're hearing from other people? I mean, it's, I cannot, it's really something really hard to explain to people who maybe are not from Michigan.

8:22I know you understand, but there are families that have ties across the border. You know, maybe one member came down to work and married, you know, from Canadian to American. Likewise, Americans who, you know, have their family had a summer place up in Ontario. They develop friendships, maybe relationships or family ties that way. This relationship goes back so far. And I would say there has been a noticeable difference. Now, when I go over to my favorite, my favorite dumpling place, Shanghai Bistro in Windsor from, you know, across the river from Detroit. It's not a big deal. I mean, people are still relatively chill on a person-to-person basis, but the feelings about where people are spending their money and spending their time are definitely going through a shift right now.

9:10I mean, pull on that thread a little bit, because you're talking not just about, you know, Americans crossing the border into Canada, but how many Canadians are willing to come over to the U.S.? For sure. The University of Toronto had some research that showed a 42 % decline in Canadian visits to American cities. And the city of Windsor spent half a million dollars this year on a summer event series that was trying to get Windsorites to stay where they are, you know, recreate in place. I think the Canadians are pretty fed up with this. And I should say it goes up the ladder, too. I follow Canadian politics and elections, and it's very interesting the way Prime Minister Mark Carney has been, you know, making a few more overtures to China, thinking about lateral relationships for his country in a different way than when it was just North Americans in it together all the way.

10:03I know you hear from a lot of Michiganders on stateside. And what are they saying about this shift in the relationship between the U.S. and Canada? How do they feel about it? Not just the way it's affecting their pocketbooks, but just that we have this really friendly neighbor to the north. And that opened up all kinds of opportunities in terms of travel and tourism. And as you said, you know, making family relationships. How are they feeling about this moment? Not fans. Not fans. And, you know, again, it's the employment factor. It's a little more common for folks from Ontario to come over to Michigan to work.

10:42But there have been there are any number of reasons why Michiganders go to Ontario and other provinces in Canada. And there has been overall a cooling on President Trump's handle handling of economic issues. We hear that from people quite a lot. And I would say, especially across automotive sectors, I don't just mean the vice presidents at the Detroit Three, but people who have any connection with a supplier, with a parts factory, with an ad agency that serves the industry. Everyone is very, very painfully aware of what this has done to the relationship. And we'd love to have the Canadians back.

11:23I will note, though, there are still Republicans like John James, a candidate for governor. His position is a little different than Mike Rogers, and I thought this was so telling. He says he agrees that it's time for the tariffs to end. He says Canada's our friend. But then he goes on, we must negotiate a deal that also works for Michigan. You know, President Trump had a lot of voters in Michigan in 2024. It was not an overall landslide of a victory. But some people still hew to the idea that there might be something behind this, although a lot of industry insiders and just plain folks say, this is nuts, we have to stop.

12:00So briefly, if these tariffs continue for months or even the rest of the current administration, what specifically are you watching to understand their longer-term economic consequences for the state? Okay, so one thing that a lot of people have eyes on is crude oil. It is Michigan's, as a state, largest import from Canada. Crude oil is exempt from the tariffs right now, but everyone's keeping an eye on that. Also, the fact that the automotive tariffs have been subject to some movement up and down. Trump proposed a 50 percent tariff on imports of autos from Canada that could take effect at the start of 2027 if he holds his course.

12:37Well, that's April Baer. She's host of the Stateside Show and podcast right here at Michigan Public. April, thanks. A pleasure, Jen. Coming up, we head overseas. While the U.S. has midterm elections in two weeks, Israel holds its national election next week. We hear what's at stake there and why that election's outcome matters here. That's just ahead.

13:02Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Mint Mobile. While others have been hiking your bill, Mint Mobile has kept their wireless plans starting at$15 a month. Switch to Mint Mobile and get three months of premium wireless service for$15 a month. Go to mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for a three-month plan required,$15 per month equivalent. New customer offer, first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. On the next through line from NPR. I was surprised that this man, every single day, takes a chair and goes to the rubbles and debris of his house.

13:41and he starts to tell stories to his children, to his mother, to his wife. We travel through the past four seasons of Ceasefire in Gaza with NPR's Enes Baba. Hi there, I'm Brittany Luce. And not to brag, but I host a really fabulous podcast. It's called It's Been a Minute. I love making it and I think you'll love listening to it. Over the last year, hundreds of thousands of listeners have been tuning in. And I got to say, if you haven't yet, you're missing out. Listen to the It's Been a Minute podcast from NPR today.

14:19Welcome back to the 1A podcast. Let's turn now to Israel. On October 27th, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faces voters for the first time in four years. They will answer the question, does he deserve a record seventh term as leader based on what's happened during his time in office? That includes the before and after of the October 7th terrorist attacks three years ago, the deadliest day for Jewish people since the Holocaust, where Hamas militants killed nearly 1 ,200 people and took around 250 hostages. Netanyahu then launched a retaliatory war with Hamas in response, devastating Gaza.

14:55Health authorities there say the war has killed more than 74 ,000 people, including 21 ,000 children. And despite a ceasefire agreement, daily missile barrages into Gaza continue. His government's policies are also changing life in the West Bank. More than 275 Palestinian communities have been affected by settler attacks in 2026, nearly as many as the total number of communities affected during all of 2025. That's the highest annual figure recorded since 2006, according to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Netanyahu is also pushing to change the face of Israel's democracy itself, as he relies on the most far-right political coalition in the country's history to govern.

15:38What are the stakes of this election for Israel? And how could the winning coalition shape the country's current military operations around its borders? What might a new Israeli government mean for the country's relationship with the U.S. and the rest of the Middle East? And what could it mean for Netanyahu himself? Let's get into it with our guests. Joining us now from Tel Aviv is Daniel Estrin. He's an international correspondent for NPR in Israel. Daniel, welcome back to the program. Thanks for having me, Jen. Also with us from Tel Aviv is Joshua Leifer. He's a columnist for Haaretz. That's a progressive daily newspaper in Israel.

16:13He's also author of Tablets Shattered, the End of an American Jewish Century and the Future of Jewish Life. Joshua, welcome to 1A. It's great to be on the show. Thanks so much for having me. So as we said, Israel's election takes place next Tuesday, and I'm interested in hearing from both of you broadly speaking, and we'll get into the finer details. But how are Israelis describing the stakes of this election? Daniel? Well, it is not an exaggeration to say that many Israelis will tell you that these are the most pivotal elections in their country's history. They say the stakes are incredibly high.

16:50It's the first vote since the October 7th Hamas attacks and since the Gaza war. And it's a moment of clarity. It's a moment where Israelis are asking themselves, should they hold Netanyahu responsible for the deadliest day in their country's history? Or should they vote Netanyahu again? Should they reelect him in order for him to continue what he's done ever since October 7th, which is to retaliate in war after war across the Middle East? And he's vowing to complete the job now with suggesting another attack in Iran. So October 7th is the date that is shaping these elections. And I mean, the stakes are so high that tens of thousands of Israelis who live abroad, expats, are expected to be flying in to vote.

17:46Joshua, what are you hearing? I'm hearing many of the same things. I think that at the same time, what I would also add is that one of the strange features of the current election cycle is that the polls have been basically static for four months. They generally show neither the Netanyahu block nor the block of his opponents able to cobble together a majority. And what's been so striking about this kind of polling deadlock, and again, we'll see whether that's borne out on voting day itself, is that none of the recent revelations about Netanyahu having been warned, say, by the leader of the UAE, MBZ, or by Egyptian security officials, or by his own security officials about the dangers that preceded October 7th.

18:40none of these revelations have really altered the polls. And so on the one hand, it's sort of strange, almost limbo state where everyone agrees that it's the most existential election for Israel, perhaps in its history, and it is a referendum on the government's handling of October 7th. But in some ways, people seem to have already made up their minds quite some time ago. Of course, there are a few undecideds, but not that many. Daniel, what did Israeli voters tell you about how they might respond personally to the outcome of this election, especially if the coalition they want to win doesn't?

19:25I spoke to an Israeli man today who said that he's voting for the opposition and that if the current coalition, if the current government that is made up of Netanyahu leading a far-right, ultra-nationalist, ultra-Orthodox Jewish religious coalition, if that makeup is re-elected, he says, I'm packing up my bags and leaving. I have nothing to do here anymore. And you hear that sentiment from a lot of Israelis, and that too is not an exaggeration. We've seen in recent years many Israelis, more progressive, liberal, or just people who are fed up with what they see as Israel's radical extremist turn in the past four years.

20:15They have left in droves. There's been a real brain drain. So that is part of why the stakes of this election seem really high. And on the other side, there are voters who believe that Netanyahu is the only person who can keep them safe, who can continue the wars that he has continued and started since October 7th. And so, yeah, these are matters of life and death and survival for many Israelis. Joshua, voters will cast ballots for a party, not a prime minister. Briefly, how does the country's political system translate those votes into the person who becomes prime minister? That's a great question.

20:58I mean, until fairly recently, my answer would be straightforward, which is that usually this is sort of a norm, not a codified law per se, that the party that wins the largest number of seats, so Israel is a parliamentary democracy within the green line, that party is typically given what is called the mandate to form a coalition. And the leader of that party typically becomes the prime minister if they are able to form a coalition. Now, one of the reasons why this is important to say is because what the government will actually be may take some time after the votes are cast because just because a party is the biggest doesn't necessarily mean that it's able to cobble together a coalition.

21:47And so once the votes are counted, then a kind of period, long period, potentially long period of haggling and coalition deal-making will begin. Now, the reason why I say until recently there was a norm that the largest party would end up forming the coalition is that the last time that Netanyahu was deposed in 2021, Naftali Bennett, who is running again, but at the time was the head of a very small right-wing, quasi-moderate right-wing party, became prime minister with a party of only six seats out of 120 in the Knesset. And that prospect has continued to entice, let's say, pretenders to the throne of prime minister who think that there's now a precedent for them to being able to become prime minister, even if their party is not the biggest.

22:43So I think one thing that we should probably prepare to expect is that there'll be quite a bit of uncertainty. Of course, this itself is not certain, but there'll be a fair bit of uncertainty even once the votes are counted. Because the coalitional math, given, at least if where current polling bears out, the coalitional math will be quite complicated. So that makes me wonder, Joshua, are there early partnerships being hinted at? You know, these different groups saying, I could see working with this other party, or I could see working with this other party, or we're not at all interested in working with this group over here?

23:28So the biggest question mark of the current election cycle has to do with the Arab-led parties. They're currently organized into two separate lists. There's the joint list, which is comprised of three parties, the Arab-Jewish Socialist Party, Hadash, the, let's say, Liberal Nationalist Party, Ballad, and another party called Tal. And they're running as one slate. And then there's another party call that goes by, often is known by the acronym in Hebrew of its name, RAM, which isn't a moderate Islamist party, but that has also taken a sort of radical step of having a Jewish centrist politician running as number two on its party list.

24:12Again, these are parliamentary lists. And RAM actually sat in the coalition in 2021 that deposed Netanyahu, an unprecedented move, the first time that an Arab-led party was part of a coalition in Israel. This time around, all of the parties that are, all of the, let's say, as they're known in Israel, Zionist Jewish parties, with the exception of the left-wing Zionists, the Democrats, have vowed not to sit with the Arab-led parties. On the other hand, there's no poll that's shown them able to form a majority or a counter-majority government without support from the Arab-led parties. And so what happens, let's say, if those parties win quite a few number of seats, which they are currently slated to do, potentially combine anywhere between 13 and 16, which could make them second or third largest party or party block, and therefore hard to ignore.

25:11So this remains an open question. I think if I had, you know, so people have spoken about different scenarios. One possible option would be, you know, this gets into, again, the coalitional complexities, would be a minority government in which one or more of the Arab-led party list supports a minority government from the outside. This is something that Gaddy Eisenkot, who is currently Netanyahu's chief challenger. And he leads the center-right party, Yashar. Yes, which means straight as a kind of no BS, straight is the connotation. So that's one possibility and one option. Then there are all other kinds of things.

25:56Avigdor Lieberman, who leads a secular right-wing populist party whose base are Russian-speaking immigrants to Israel, is playing the spoiler in this current race. So he said he won't sit in a minority government, which in theory would deprive Eisenkoth of being prime minister in that scenario. And there's fear that he may try to cobble together his own right-wing, center-right coalition. Another wild card, just to finish, is the ultra-Orthodox parties. So the opposition has also said that they won't sit with the ultra-Orthodox parties because one of the most divisive issues in the wake of October 7th is the mass draft exemption that's been granted to ultra-Orthodox men.

26:44At the same time, there may be deals behind the scenes that we don't know about in which one or maybe two of the ultra-Orthodox parties, and there are two major ones, might also be enticed into an opposition coalition if a deal can be made. So all of which to say, like, there is a lot that could happen that we don't know. Daniel, I want to circle back to Gadi Eisenkot. Again, he leads the center-right party, Yashar, and his name will probably come up quite a bit during this conversation. Tell us a bit more about who he is and his political background. He was the former military chief of staff under Netanyahu.

27:22And he left the scene, but he came back to the public eye. after October 7th, he joined Netanyahu's war cabinet to help lead the war. He quit around a year later. He criticized Netanyahu's handling of the war. And his supporters like him because he seems to be everything that Netanyahu is not. He's not charismatic. He is not a polished politician. He apparently does not speak English very well. And those are things that Netanyahu is very eloquent in English. He is a polished politician, but people who support Eisenkot are sick of Netanyahu, including a lot of former Netanyahu voters. I was at a rally, a stump speech by Eisenkot a few weeks ago in a traditionally conservative Netanyahu stronghold, and I met voters who said, all my life I have voted B-B-B-B-B-B.

28:19That's Benjamin Netanyahu's nickname. But this time, because of October 7th, they see him as presiding over Israel's biggest security disaster ever. They want to switch to Eisenkot. Eisenkot lost his son fighting in the war in Gaza a few months into the war. So he's seen as having personally sacrificed for Israel. And one thing that he is saying is that the first thing that he would do if he were elected prime minister is that he would open an official investigation into what went wrong on October 7th and leading up to it. That is something kind of akin to the 9-11 commission that Israelis really, really demand and that Netanyahu has resisted doing.

29:06And there are, in many ways, Eisenkot is trying to distinguish himself from Netanyahu. He says he wants diplomatic agreements in some of the wars, many of the wars Netanyahu has fought over recent years. but he in many ways is championing a similar security platform that he's saying that it will take a long time for Israel to pull soldiers out of Lebanon and out of Gaza. So there are a lot of questions about what Eisenkut, a prime minister Eisenkut would do that would be different from Netanyahu but he is the main challenger challenging Netanyahu in this race. We got this question from Drew in Georgia who asks, outside of national security, what are the other factors that affect the decisions of Israeli voters?

29:56Is it household economics, anti-corruption, judicial or electoral reform, conscription? And if it's conscription, can you explain that issue? We'll come back to conscription after the break, but very briefly, what are you hearing, Daniel, about other issues that are a factor in this election? You know, I spoke to an Israeli the other day who I think really summed it up in terms of what is on people's minds. And he said, I'm looking into the future, and I'm seeing that the ultra-Orthodox Jewish population is booming in the country. And they generally do not serve in the military. They do not contribute to the workforce as a whole.

30:38They are given exemptions from the military. They are given subsidies so that their young men can study Torah and religious texts. And so this Israeli man I'm speaking to says, I see a future in which I'm going to be, me and my children will be paying Israeli taxes overwhelmingly, contributing to the workforce, sharing an unequal burden and sending my children to the military. And so that really is a central issue for people. They want a different government, not one that Netanyahu allows these exemptions for the military for ultra-Orthodox Jews. Their population is booming. Let's briefly pause here.

31:19We're discussing next Tuesday's Israeli election with Daniel Estrin of NPR and Joshua Leifer of Haaretz. We'll be right back.

31:31Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Mint Mobile. While others have been hiking your bill, Mint Mobile has kept their wireless plans starting at$15 a month. Switch to Mint Mobile and get three months of premium wireless service for$15 a month. Go to mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for a three-month plan required,$15 per month equivalent. New customer offer, first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. Happy fall! Yes, the days are getting shorter and colder, and the rain can be a drag.

32:08But this is also the perfect time of year to get cozy. LifeKit has lots of ideas so you can embrace the change of seasons, with episodes on everything from making soup to exercising outdoors. Listen to the LifeKit podcast in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Let's get back to our discussion about the upcoming Israeli election and what it means for that country, for Israeli democracy, and the rest of the world. We got this from Kit who says, how could people in Israel support Netanyahu because he keeps them safe? It seemed that he did not keep them very safe on October 7th. Joshua, how are Netanyahu and his opponents positioning themselves in terms of their defense strategy for the country?

32:51Netanyahu, you know, the irony of this, of the current situation, is that Netanyahu, until October 7th, was known as one of the most cautious figures on the right. Very reluctant to start wars, very passive, reactive. And what has changed since October 7th is that he has led Israel into a new defense strategy. That is based on a very aggressive offensive approach. We see this in Israel's creation of buffer zones, which are essentially military occupation zones in southern Lebanon, in parts of southern Syria. And of course, in the Gaza Strip, where roughly half of Gaza remains under full Israeli military control.

33:37The argument that the Netanyahu government is making is that the reason why October 7th happened was because Israel was perceived as weak, that its deterrence had been eroded, and that now it needs to show its enemies that it's willing to break all of the rules and attack aggressively and to take territory. You know, of course, this is also a recipe for constant perpetual war and conflict. But in tandem with Netanyahu's and his allies' constant fear-mongering about what an alternative might mean, he has managed to maintain, certainly among his hardcore base, the sense that there's no alternative to him as the guardian of Israel's security.

34:28and in some sense the constant sense of mobilization and threat enables him to maintain that stature. We're seeing this now as the campaign goes on. Every couple of days, Netanyahu makes an announcement at a military base. He says, our enemies in his deep baritone, our enemies are plotting to attack us and we'll respond with an overwhelming show of force. And for a certain segment of the electorate, that's comforting and that's appealing. But are Gotti Eisenkot or any of the other opposition parties offering an alternative strategy? It depends on where and how you look. You know, I think that Gotti Eisenkot, if we were to judge by his historical commitments, who he's voted for in the past, what he did when he was the IDF chief.

35:28I think we can expect from him to be much less defiant of, let's say, American dictates. I think he would probably follow through with the Trump plan for Gaza, something that Netanyahu is currently holding up. I agree that it would require a potentially unfeasible effort on the part of Lebanon to disarm Hezbollah that would create the condition for an Israeli withdrawal. But I think that some kind of eventual agreement or process to reach an agreement with Lebanon is something that Eisenkot would pursue more in earnest. And the same is true for Syria. I don't think it's the case that Eisenkot shares Netanyahu's new security doctrine that what is needed is a constant kind of offense and Israeli military presence beyond its borders.

36:26Where I do think that there is much less potential for change, at least certainly in the immediate term, is when it comes to the Palestinian question. Despite Eisenkot having voted for Yitzhak Rabin and for Shimon Peres and for Eud Barak, all of whom were supportive of the two-state process, Eisenkot, at least in the campaign, has made clear that that's not something he intends to pursue and that he has said he's never supported that, although this is kind of a ritual at this point in Israeli politics where everyone campaigns to the right and then kind of governs less to the right. Of course, as the military, as a former military chief, he was one of the architects and enforcers of the mechanism of occupation management in the West Bank and Gaza.

37:17And that's something that I don't think he's going to deviate in the near term. The last thing I'll say is that I think that when it comes to settler violence, again, I think Eisenhower will be much more receptive to international pressure, whereas Netanyahu, because he's in this populist campaign mode, uses instances of international pressure to then rally his base and show that he's standing up to the rest of the world and that only he can really stick it to the United States or to Europe or to the United Nations. Well, Daniel, you had a piece for the Sunday story from NPR's Up First podcast, and it's about where Israelis stand ahead of this election.

38:02You spoke to many people. I want to highlight a few. Kati Zohar's 23-year-old daughter, Bar, was killed on October 7th at the Nova Musical Festival. At a makeshift memorial, Kati shows you a photo of Bar shortly before she died. And he gave her morphium, so she was very relaxed when she died. This is like two minutes before she took her last breath. Yeah. Lior is a 34-year-old reservist in the Israeli military who led a sniper unit in Gaza and Lebanon. To be honest, in my opinion, I don't have any mercy of people in Gaza. I know what's going on there. I know of the poverty. I know about the lack of water, electricity.

38:48I don't have any mercy on them. And Ari Shahali is a former Israeli intelligence official. He joined him on a visit to a Palestinian family's home in the West Bank. He was told Israeli settlers and soldiers had blocked access to their outdoor bathroom and their sheep. This is nasty. This is evil. I don't believe that we, as a people, became such kind of unhuman behaviors. I'm an Israeli, I'm a proud Israeli, and I'm ashamed to be an Israeli at the same time. Some of you are reporting there for the Sunday story from NPR's Up First podcast. Daniel, what did you take away from these conversations you had with Israelis from all walks of life about the future of the country and whether there is a shared vision for what happens next?

39:50Well, thank you for playing those excerpts. You heard voices filled with pain from all different kinds of perspectives, whether it's a mother who lost her daughter on October 7th. She is angry. She feels that Netanyahu bears the ultimate responsibility for what happened to her daughter and to the country. Netanyahu has not telephoned her to offer his condolences, and she's looking for a new leadership, a new leader who can, what she says, unify the country. You heard from a soldier who is one of around 19 ,000 young Israeli soldiers who have been diagnosed recently with post-traumatic stress disorder or related illnesses because of their service in Gaza and Lebanon and the various wars.

40:43who believes that he and the rest of Israel will have to live on the sword for the rest of their lives because that there will be no other choice. And I think you – one person I spoke to in this reporting who I think summed it up very well is a popular author, Micha Goodman. He's also served in the past as a kind of unofficial advisor to prime ministers. And he said that Israel wants to protect two different reputations and it just simply can't. It wants to be feared in the Middle East and loved in the West. In the Middle East, he says, Israel feels that it lost its deterrence on October 7th and it has to restore the fear of its neighbors.

41:36But everything that Israel did in the past three years to restore fear eroded the love that it wants from the West, the sense that it wants to be seen as an orderly, predictable Western country playing by the rules. And he says, ultimately, Israelis see this zero-sum game between the love of the world and the fear of their neighbors. And so I think these elections really are down to that. Israelis draw drastically different lessons from what has happened here these last few years. They see drastically different visions of what it means to survive. Do they need to be a country that is repairing their relations with the world, a world that's angry and full of rage for the war in Gaza and the destruction and death there?

42:35Or do they need to be a country, as Joshua was saying, perpetually fighting wars beyond their borders? We got this question from Donald who says, what happened to Netanyahu's court case? Does this matter to Israeli voters, or is he like Trump above the country's laws and normal rules? Joshua, really briefly, there have been accusations and charges of corruption against the prime minister. What happens in his political future, his legal future, if he loses this election? Yeah, the trial is still ongoing, and I think it's impossible to understand the dynamics of this election and what also preceded it without understanding that Netanyahu is facing relatively serious corruption charges and has done anything to stay in power so as to avoid having to face the trial.

43:30I would put it this way. The way that Netanyahu understands the stakes for himself of this election is that if he loses and is not prime minister, he might go to jail. and I think that that in part explains his pivot to the far right and his inclusion of parties that never were considered parties that were eligible for coalitions, whether those led by the right or the left, like Itamar Bengvil's Jewish Power Party and of course Bengvil is now a minister of national security. There is talk that in the event of an inconclusive result, There may be a push for a national unity government and that that push might involve some kind of pardon or immunity for Netanyahu.

44:15That's also potentially on the table. We know that Donald Trump, who endorsed Netanyahu yesterday, has also called on Israel's president, who kind of serves in a quasi-ceremonial role. But one of the things the president can do is issue pardons. And according to reporting that my paper Haaretz and others have done, there's been quite a bit of pressure on Israel's president Yitzhak Herzog by President Trump to pardon Netanyahu. So that's also something to keep an eye on. And in some ways, the parallel between Trump and Netanyahu, there are very close ones. And much in the way that no matter what is revealed about Donald Trump, there's a hard core of supporters, maybe 30%, maybe 40 % of the electorate that will stick with him no matter what.

45:03There's also a segment of Israeli voters for whom Netanyahu, you know, I once met someone when I was reporting who said, I'll still vote for him even if he's in jail. And, you know, that dynamic is part of right-wing populism. We see this as a global phenomenon. And I would say it's a very strong force in the current election. Of course, Netanyahu's opponents are running in part on a good governance anti-corruption campaign as well, targeting not only Netanyahu's personal corruption, but also a scandal that we probably don't have time to get into, which involves Netanyahu's closest advisors being on the payroll of the Qatari government to basically run PR for Qatar amid the war.

45:51Yeah, well, that's something we'll likely have to cover in our international news roundup. Daniel, I do want to ask, you talked about Israel's relationship with the West broadly, but in what way is Israel's relationship with the U.S. specifically? on the ballot in this election, very briefly? Oh, it's front and center now since President Trump openly endorsed Netanyahu. And this is Netanyahu's main campaign now. His opponents are saying, don't vote for Netanyahu, vote for us because of October 7th. And now Netanyahu has a new message. And that message is, vote for me because Trump and I are close and Trump wants me.

46:33And if you vote for me, I will, together with Trump, lead a new attack on Iran. I will put away and destroy the nuclear threat that Iran poses forever. I have two years to do that with Trump still in office. And that is his central campaign. And Trump had, for many months, not endorsed anyone in the election. And suddenly he did so on Sunday. And that, I think, is going to be defining Netanyahu's campaign from here on out. We'll be watching the outcome of this election next week. That's Daniel Estrin. He's the international correspondent for NPR in Israel. And you can find his very excellent reporting on the Sunday story from NPR's Up First podcast.

47:20Also with us, Joshua Leifer. He's a columnist for Haaretz and author of Tablets Shattered, the end of an American Jewish century and the future of Jewish life. Daniel, Joshua, thanks to you both. Remember, the 1A podcast is a great way to catch up on anything you might have missed. It's where you'll find our best guests and stories each day. Today's producer was Michael Falero with help from Aileen Humphreys. This program comes to you from WAMU, part of American University in Washington, distributed by NPR. I'm Jen White. Thanks for listening. And we'll talk again tomorrow. This is 1A.

48:13Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Squarespace. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between thinking about photography school and selling your portraits online. It's the difference between giving away cookies for free and running your cookie empire. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between having a movie-reviewing hobby and a movie-reviewing career. Squarespace. Because no matter what you're into, a website makes it real. Use offer code DIFFERENCE for 50 % off select plans. Terms and conditions apply.

48:48Midlife brings a lot of changes. Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast to help you navigate the twists and turns. From health and relationships to creativity and purpose, we can help steer your next chapter. With Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher
In the decades following the signing of the North American Free Trade Agreement, the U.S. and Canada built strong economic ties across their border. That robust partnership — which accounts for billions of dollars of goods — made Canada a key trading partner for northern states, like Michigan.

But that decades-long economic relationship is fractured. Depending on how the Trump administration navigates its trade war with our northern neighbor, that relationship may not return to what many businesses and consumers consider normal.

In August, the administration imposed 50 percent tariffs on Canadian goods, taxing $20 billion of Canadian products like dairy, beverages, cement, and more. Canada hit back in September, matching them dollar-for-dollar with new tariffs on American dairy, steel, aluminum, agricultural product, and electronics.

What have those tariffs meant for Michigan’s economy, especially given Michigan is at the center of the midterm elections?

Plus, in one week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faces voters for the first time in four years. They’ll answer one question: Does he deserve a record seventh term as leader based on his time in office?

After the Oct. 7 terrorist attacks, he launched a three-year-long war with Hamas. He’s maintained Israel’s democracy while relying on the most far-right political coalition in the country’s history.

So, what are the stakes of this election in Israel? And how could the parties that win it shape the country’s current military operations in and around its borders?

Find more of our programs online. Listen to 1A sponsor-free by signing up for 1A+ at plus.npr.org/the1a.

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy

More from 1A

All episodes