


The episode explains how revenge-seeking can become psychologically and neurologically “addictive,” why it can feel rewarding in the moment, when it backfires, and how therapy and forgiveness can reduce the urge.
James Kimmel Jr., author of The Science of Revenge and Yale psychiatry lecturer; former lawyer. Alexandra Solomon, licensed clinical psychologist, Northwestern faculty, and host of Reimagining Love.
Revenge is defined as trying to inflict pain on someone perceived to have caused pain; it creates an illusion of control/power. Brain scans link perceived wrongs to the pain network (anterior insula) and reward/addiction circuitry (nucleus accumbens, dorsal striatum, dopamine), with prefrontal inhibition enabling action. Revenge is often confused with “accountability” or “justice,” which can sanctify violence. Forgiveness (even imagined) can deactivate pain/reward craving circuits and restore prefrontal decision-making.
Kimmel’s teenage bullying story (he nearly attacked bullies with a revolver but stopped due to cost). Listener stories include revenge against a sibling escalating to assault, reporting an abusive boss, and withdrawing from a betrayed friendship.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the complexities of revenge and its emotional effects.
“When someone hurts us, we might feel sad, angry, defensive, but sometimes those feelings turn into something more dangerous, a desire for revenge.”
Understand the difference between revenge and accountability in social contexts.
“He's the author of The Science of Revenge, Understanding the World's Deadliest Addiction and How to Overcome It.”
Discuss how emotional pain can drive the desire for revenge.
“That's different from punishing, ultimately, the person who has wronged you, which is revenge.”
James shares his childhood experiences with bullying and revenge.
“And so the action of revenge creates an illusion of control when we feel helplessness.”
Explore the relationship between forgiveness and the desire for revenge.
“And these were costs that I wasn't willing to pay.”
Delve into the brain mechanisms involved in seeking revenge.
“So James, your book actually delves into the neuroscience of revenge-seeking behavior.”
Learn how revenge is perceived as a behavior linked to violence and societal issues.
“It's an actual act to go out and inflict pain upon someone else.”
Hear personal anecdotes about the urge for revenge and its emotional consequences.
“I went through a pretty nasty divorce with my wife, and she did things that almost made it feel more personal than it was.”
Explore how seeking revenge can lead to emotional messes and moral dilemmas.
“Alexandra, let's go to you to talk about when revenge can make us emotionally less healthy.”
Discuss alternatives to revenge and the idea of thriving despite adversity.
“I had a friend, a longtime 30-year friend, who betrayed me in a really terrible way.”
Differentiate between revenge, schadenfreude, and healthy emotional responses.
“And that is a great satisfaction, But it's not revenge satisfaction per se.”
Investigate the psychological factors that drive individuals to seek revenge.
“We got an email from Elizabeth who said, my ex-fiance cheated on me horribly.”
Discover the addictive nature of revenge and its impact on healing.
“I think often people think of, I will feel better once I get revenge on this particular person, but James is saying that it becomes an addiction.”
Explore how trauma shapes our focus and the neurological impact of forgiveness versus revenge.
“narrow and really focused and really ruminative on this one thing.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On 1A, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:07When someone hurts us, we might feel sad, angry, defensive, but sometimes those feelings turn into something more dangerous, a desire for revenge. I believe that revenge is something that has to be done in a timely manner. I like to wait till the right moment has come. And usually that's a long time when the other person has possibly believed or is under the impression that nothing's the matter anymore. And I do believe in getting revenge. I mean, it may be just a push from karma, but I will definitely take all the steps needed to make sure that I make all the wrongs right. I am interested in seeking revenge against my former boss.
0:51She caused me so much pain. I don't know how to get through this. I pray about it because I know revenge is really wrong. Wanting to right a perceived wrong, very normal. But neuroscientists are now finding that revenge-seeking behavior can be addictive. So why does revenge feel good, at least in the moment when you're getting it? And when can it backfire? I'm Celeste Headley, in for Jen White. You're listening to the 1A Podcast. We'll be back with more after this short break. Stay with us.
1:28Let's get into the conversation and meet our guests. Joining us for this discussion is James Kimmel, Jr. He's the author of The Science of Revenge, Understanding the World's Deadliest Addiction and How to Overcome It. He's also a lecturer in psychiatry at the School of Medicine at Yale University. James, welcome. Thank you, Celeste. Happy to be here. Also with us is Alexandra Solomon. She's a licensed clinical psychologist in private practice. She's also on the faculty at Northwestern University and host of the podcast Reimagining Love. It is good to have you back, Alexandra. Thank you, Celeste.
2:01Great to be here. James, you've written the book on this, so can we start with what revenge is? Sure. Revenge is trying to inflict pain upon a person who you perceive has inflicted pain on you or someone you care about. How is that different from, say, accountability, right? Well, accountability is a very different thing, but we tend to use both words together and we use accountability to kind of soften revenge and make it sound like it's a more reasonable activity. But accountability really means taking account. You know, we have accountants in society and what they do is they account for things that have happened in the past, for instance, to your money.
2:46And that's tracking down and making aware of what has occurred. That's different from punishing, ultimately, the person who has wronged you, which is revenge. So they're very different things, but they're, I think, often dangerously used sometimes to mean the same thing or to make revenge-seeking a far more rational, reasonable, and even noble act. So, Professor Solomon, you are a relationship therapist. You heard that listener saying she wanted to get revenge on her boss because her boss had hurt her so much. Where is this line between someone feeling that they need someone to suffer in order for them to feel closure and, I guess, being able to move on?
3:34When is this healthy? When is it unhealthy? Yeah. What I heard so clearly in her comment is that it is at the heart, it is a desire for her to do something with her pain. The pain that we feel in these contexts we're talking about, betrayal, abandonment, disrespect, the pain is so real. And emotional pain is an embodied experience. And we feel that tightness in our chest. We feel our hands trembling. And if we don't know how to move emotions through our bodies, all we're left with is an urge to act, to just do something with all of this energy. And so the action of revenge creates an illusion of control when we feel helplessness.
4:14It creates an illusion of power when we feel powerless. Is there a difference, especially in terms of psychology or psychiatry, in whether the hurt you felt, the pain that you suffered, was unjust? Right, right, right. We heard James use the word perceived, right? Right. It truly is. And there are certainly, we live in a world where there are actual injustices and systemic things that are built in. Absolutely. And so I think the perception or the reality of the injustice can amplify the urgency and amplify the desire. Because you feel like you're doing something on behalf of others. And at the same time, I think a word I'm probably going to come back to again and again in this is self-care.
4:59What is the price that I pay? What is the toll at the end of the day on me? What does my healing need and warrant? James, you talk in your book about how you became interested in this topic decades ago while you were still in school. Can you tell us how you ended up writing a book about revenge? That was a long journey, and it started when I was in high school. I was bullied as a teen in rural central Pennsylvania, and ultimately the bullies staged an attack on my house and shot and killed our dog. And then a couple of weeks later, they staged a second attack and blew up our mailbox. And during that second attack, I was home alone at night when that occurred.
5:42And after, you know, maybe three, four years of this bullying that had occurred and the loss of my dog, you know, with the mailbox went what was left of my self-control. And, you know, living in rural central PA with plenty of guns, I'd been probably shooting guns since I was about eight years old as a hunter and just target practicing. And I grabbed a loaded revolver for my dad's nightstand. And I went off after these guys in the middle of the night and, you know, just driving as fast as I could down a one lane country road until I finally cornered them by one of their barns. And, you know, so the scene was, you know, they're in a pickup truck with three or four heads in their back window and I'm behind them, you know, with my bright beams on.
6:29And they slowly get out of the truck and they're squinting through my headlights to see who had just chased them down. And I knew very clearly at that moment two things. One is they were unarmed. They didn't have anything in their hands and they would have no way of knowing that I had a gun. And I began to open the door and did open the door and started to put my leg through the opening. And then I had at the last second, I had this sort of flash of insight or inspiration that if I went through with what I very much wanted to do to balance the scales and punish these guys and, you know, do what, you know, some of those people at the beginning of this segment were talking about, that I'd never be the same person again.
7:18And, you know, James Kimmel Jr. who entered that farm with a gun would not be the same guy who left, even if I survived the whole thing. I'd have to always identify myself as a murderer. And these were costs that I wasn't willing to pay. And I was able, very fortunately, to see that cost-benefit disparity and very, very quickly go, this isn't for me. And I don't want to go through with this, even though a big part of me did. But we know, you know, from news programs every day that in the same situation, many, many, many other people go through that event. They pull the gun. They go out and they do what they want.
8:03They do what their brains crave. And I've spent the rest of my life trying to understand that, in part, though, out of a continuation of my desire for revenge. But I just thought for my own life that I wanted to legalize that. And there is a way to legalize revenge seeking. You know, we have a justice system for doing that. And so I decided to get into the professional revenge business by becoming a lawyer. Yeah. We have an email from Christopher who says, I want to share this Congolese proverb, to take revenge is often to sacrifice oneself. This idea that the cost to oneself of taking revenge is too high is also in this comment from one of our listeners.
8:47I did seek revenge against my sibling brother. And I did make some rude comments about his wife when I found out some information about her being an alcoholic. All it did was exacerbate bad feelings to the point where my brother actually in our 50s physically assaulted me. He ended up having a permanent record and it was not good for family dynamics. They never really were repaired and we don't speak. We were born in the same year. We grew up very close and that's the way it went. speaking about revenge, probably better to work through it yourself. We're hearing a lot of these comments, Alexandra.
9:33There's also Angela who says, I don't believe in revenge. It isn't noble. Causing someone else to suffer doesn't remove one's own suffering. But I bet as a relationship therapist that you hear about these dynamics a lot. This need to, as James mentioned, balance the scales. Isn't forgiveness, I mean, is the only option, if you're not going to take revenge, is the only other option to just forgive when we've been done a wrong? Forgiveness is tricky. You know, I think forgiveness is something that if we start out saying my only choice is revenge or forgiveness, we're getting really binary. So the middle path starts with validating the pain.
10:13So if I'm working with a client who's struggling with this desire for revenge, the first thing I'm going to do is validate the pain. And I'm going to convey to them that I can be with you near this pain. I think part of what fuels revenge is feeling terribly, terribly alone, that there's nobody around, there's nobody that can carry this with you. And the only thing worse than carrying something big is carrying it alone. So when we can feel near to somebody who is safe and when we can talk about the feelings, when we can talk about the revenge fantasies, you know, therapists say all the time, the urge to do something and talking about doing something is radically different than doing it.
10:46So can our therapy office be a place where we can talk about all those feelings that we might label as dark or ugly or dangerous or bad? Can we talk about them? Because talking about them takes the sting and the urgency out of them. And then through the process of working through the feelings, maybe forgiveness starts to kind of creep in the corner as a possibility that ultimately is less about what the other person deserves and more about our own liberation. Okay. So James, your book actually delves into the neuroscience of revenge-seeking behavior. What is going on in our gray matter when we think about taking revenge or actually act on it?
11:28Sure. So I'd like to start really with what Alexandra was mentioning about the embodiment of pain. And so what we're able to see in brain scans of people who experience a perception of having been wronged, mistreated, victimized, insulted, it is that inside your brain, the pain network, the anterior insula actually activates. So we, you know, we have this brain, very real physical brain experience of pain and the brain doesn't like pain. And so it wants to rebalance itself and restore homeostasis. And it, and it does that by seeking pleasure. And humans have evolved, you know, over eons to derive enormous pleasure from inflicting pain upon the person who wronged them or their proxy.
12:16And that's an important thing to think about with revenge. Revenge isn't only happening when you target the actual person who wronged you. Innumerable times throughout the day and throughout people's lives and throughout history, people will target someone who was not the perpetrator of their wrong because they're either more easily accessed or it's safer to do. And I'll just, as a quick example is having been mistreated, let's say at work by a coworker or your boss, and then not retaliating there because you might lose your job. And so you come home and you pick an unfair fight with your significant other in order to act out your desire for revenge in a way that should, you hope, be safer for you or that the other person will tolerate.
13:03Can I also ask you about the way dopamine plays into this? Because dopamine is part of our reward system, right? This is the feel-good chemical. It's also a neurotransmitter in the brain and hormone in the body, but it's what keeps you pulling the arm on that slot machine, right? How does our reward centers in the brain and in the body interact with the revenge-seeking behavior? Yeah, that's the next step. So once that pain network is activated and the brain begins to seek pleasure, it activates, just as you said, the pleasure and reward circuitry of addiction. And that is the nucleus accumbens and dorsal striatum.
13:44Those are the two areas most commonly associated with and strongly associated with craving and habit formation. And so you get this initial dopamine hit, which is very pleasurable. Then it falls off and that produces the feeling of craving, the desire for revenge, which turns into a motivation for a behavior. This is not an emotion. It's a behavior. It's an actual act to go out and inflict pain upon someone else. That's how that begins to happen. And the last piece of the puzzle is that in addiction, the prefrontal cortex, which is there as your executive function and self-control area of the brain, if that's inhibited or hijacked in any way, then that's the end of the break that would stop you from actually moving from the world of desire and fantasy and into the real world to inflict, you know, forms of violence.
14:38And we know that from public health data and law enforcement data now in behavioral studies, that almost every form of human violence, from bullying and youth violence to street and gang violence, violent extremism, police brutality, terrorism, genocide and war, all of those have at their root as the primary motivation, a perception of a wrong and a desire to retaliate, either at individual or population scale. Let's go back to our inbox here. I went through a pretty nasty divorce with my wife, and she did things that almost made it feel more personal than it was. And I felt the need to seek revenge out over the course of the following weeks and months.
15:21And I, through my faith, chose not to. And now, years and months later, I hear stories of how her life maybe moved in a direction that was not so good, while mine moved in a direction that was great. And now hearing about these things, I actually feel bad, and I regret ever even thinking about trying to seek revenge. And ultimately, I try to help her through her troubles now. So glad I didn't seek out revenge. We are getting lots of messages from you, James says, I had an abusive boss. I reported him to the U.S. Department of Wage and Labor. They found him guilty and got some money back to me.
15:57And Christine emails, a co-worker wrongly accused me of an error he committed himself. There was a big scene. Many layers later, after we'd moved on, I got a call from an old friend in graduate school. The former co-worker was applying for a job and wanted a character reference. She told her friend not to give the character reference, and he didn't get the job. We'll take a short pause here and be back with more in just a moment.
16:25Let's jump back into the conversation. Alexandra, let's go to you to talk about when revenge can make us emotionally less healthy. What are the circumstances under which that's true? I think in most circumstances, revenge makes us less. I'm having a hard time coming up with a case for the other. You know, because ultimately, to put it very simply, we now have two messes on our hands. One is the mess of the horrible thing that happened. And two is the mess that we've now made with our own behavior. And by definition, in order to exact revenge on somebody else, I have to be out of my own integrity.
17:07You know, I have to act like I don't have these hardwired empathy circuits that I have. I have to act like I know better than anybody else what's supposed to happen next. So it's like in order to exact revenge, I have to forget who I am. You know, and I'm drawn back to James' very powerful story of in that moment, even as a teenage boy, he knew if I do this, I'm no longer the person that I am. So there's something very powerful about what if our journey from being hurt to healing is just coming back to who we know ourselves to be, who we all are, which is interconnected, empathic, and ultimately not in charge of other people's journeys, which in some ways, thank goodness.
17:53Part of what fuels revenge is this idea of I have to do it all on my own. I have to make sure they understand. I have to make sure. No, what if all you have to do is come back to your journey? Let's take a listen to another comment from a listener. I had a friend, a longtime 30-year friend, who betrayed me in a really terrible way. It broke my heart and shattered my spirit. And the way I responded when I really wanted revenge was to withdraw from the friendship. I felt that that was the best way to take care of myself. and I grieved the loss of the friendship, but I knew that it was the right thing to do for my mental health and my stability.
18:37I didn't seek revenge because then I would be going down to that gutter level of behavior. So James, you talked about revenge in the form of violence, but what about revenge when the revenge is I'm going to, I myself, my great life is going to be the revenge. I see adopted pets, especially dogs, and the shelters will say they're on their revenge tour, right, when they were abandoned. What about that kind of revenge? Well, that's probably not revenge, right? I mean, revenge is really about inflicting pain upon another person, and so if you're not inflicting pain on someone, then it really doesn't meet that test, and it's not giving you that gratification that we can see in brain imaging when you're wronged and you plan to hurt someone, right, to inflict pain on them.
19:28So, wait, I want to stop for just a second. Positive kinds of revenge or not. Hold on just a second, James, because we have heard a couple listeners talk about how they later saw the other person suffering while they were doing great. Our listeners are clearly associating that with a form of revenge, but you're saying it's not. Yeah, well, that might be more akin to schadenfreude, right? So, that's the joy of experiencing someone else's pain, probably because we are envious of them or maybe we're angry at them either way. But in that type of case, I think that has been described there, they, the person who's enjoying that pain, hasn't been the source of it, hasn't inflicted that pain other than in their imagination, maybe by saying, look, I succeeded in triumph despite your efforts to take me under.
20:14I'm still here and I'm thriving. And that is a great satisfaction, But it's not revenge satisfaction per se. So, Professor Solomon, not everybody automatically seeks revenge, right? I mean, some people are relatively quick to move on. They don't feel a need to sort of get back at people or themselves inflict punishment. And I wonder from a clinician standpoint, if you have somebody for whom revenge is an automatic option, what other issues could be at play here? Yeah, you know, as I talk these through, these aren't judgments, you know, because, again, I think what we're hearing loud and clear, I think what's so important about what you've done by collecting these stories from listeners is really validating how deeply human the urge for revenge is.
21:07I would say, though, that those of us who are more prone to that urge for revenge likely grew up in family systems. I'm always going to go to family systems. In family systems where they were taught explicitly or implicitly that vulnerability is weakness, that admitting that you are sorry or admitting you are wrong is weakness, that tenderness is weakness. and they may struggle with, you know, the heart of my work is relational self-awareness, understanding our role in our relationship dynamics. So people who are prone to revenge may struggle with relational self-awareness. They may struggle to see, this is not about victim blaming, but they may struggle to see the ways in which they also are not perfect in their own lives, certainly in a breakup situation where maybe they had a part in the unhealthy dynamics that led to the breakup.
22:00So maybe struggling to kind of look at how all of this fits within a bigger context. And then folks who are prone to really rigid, narrow thinking, right, wrong, good, bad, either, or, and kind of if this, then this. And in fact, there's research to back up that when people have experienced a kind of transgression that led to a breakup, not everybody had an urge to seek revenge. The ones who are more prone to revenge, A, define themselves as victims, and B, had some particular personality traits that are known in the field as the dark triad. It's like Machiavellianism, which is being self-interested, narcissism, and psychopathy, which is the impulsivity, the struggle with empathy.
22:40So there are some traits that may kind of stack the deck. Interesting you mentioned breakup. We got an email from Elizabeth who said, my ex-fiance cheated on me horribly. My mom, who was cheated on by my dad, had pushed for me to respond in ways she couldn't, when she went through it, break her things, throw her stuff away. I couldn't bring myself to do it. I didn't want to give my now ex and her new partner more justification for their wrongs. In the end, I'm proud of how I handled it. I could have done better still, could have been kinder. But overall, it made getting through the initial breakup easier for both of us.
23:13But James, I have a question from you prompted by a couple other messages from our listeners. Tony writes, Most people, I suspect, have fantasies of revenge but consider the potential harm to themselves psychologically and the risk of legal or other consequences. What happens if a person has enormous power or can escape consequences? Can they not take revenge with impunity? And that's a question that John also wrote about specifically in reference to our current president who has talked before about being a victim and wanting to get revenge. What's the danger here, not just psychologically, but when the person seeking revenge has a lot of power?
23:54The danger then is enormous, right? I mean, having that kind of power, the power to inflict pain across millions of people is a big responsibility. And for someone who's struggling with revenge desires and maybe not controlling them well, and who has said, you know, in their pitch to the public for coming into office, I will be your retribution. I am your retribution. In terms of the neuroscience of revenge, you know, revenge looks like a drug inside your mind. It seems to act that way. Your brain on revenge looks like a brain on drugs in many ways. And so you can see with people who have a large voice and they're able to impact millions of people at once with their words that they can infect other people with their grievances and make millions of people all at once feeling and sharing the same grievance over the same thing and desiring retaliation for the same thing at the same time.
24:57And social networking platforms are extremely dangerous in that context because they allow grievance perpetration to happen at light speed and create an opportunity for retaliation by mean tweets as well as an opportunity to plan real-world retaliatory behavior on their platforms. And the platforms are designed with algorithms to keep feeding that to the people who enjoy it. So you mentioned retribution, and retribution is often mentioned in our courts of justice, right? That's punishing someone because of a criminal act often. And I want to talk about this line between revenge and justice and what makes that line, James, because it almost seems as though justice is just about someone else deciding that a wrong has been committed and exacting punishment.
25:50What is the real line here? I see justice as to revenge and retribution as OxyContin is to heroin. It is a brand name for the same kind of behavior. It's just the legalized form of it, right? So, you know, and I was part of the, I am actually, I'm still a licensed attorney, but I was a litigator. And I was part of that process. Lawyers have the unique singular license in society to prescribe, manufacture, and distribute revenge to the masses in a legalized form that we call justice-seeking. Justice-seeking also means something very different. It has connotations of equity and integrity and fairness, and it's attached to social justice and people like Jesus and the Buddha and Gandhi and Martin Luther King.
26:42But we use it as well to trick ourselves into believing that if we're getting revenge in the name of justice, it's sanctified. So terrorism becomes sanctified. Violence of all forms become sanctified. Violent extremism is sanctified. Injuring and or killing your intimate partner is sanctified because I'm just getting justice. And even there, I go, I'm just getting justice. These are important words that we need to think about because we're mixing them together to our very opposite meanings in order to sanctify some of humanity's worst behaviors. Okay. So Professor Solomon, I wonder if you see some of, in your work, some of what James is talking about, especially in terms of the addictive nature of revenge.
27:32I think often people think of, I will feel better once I get revenge on this particular person, but James is saying that it becomes an addiction. Do you see that in your work? I do. It's that the way in which addiction makes our field of vision really narrow, it's like this myopic process where we're so focused on it. By the way, it's also what trauma has the power to do, right? And the things we're talking about are traumatic experience, you know, and trauma is the impact that a negative experience has inside of our bodies. And so the impact of experiences that are too big and too much is that we get really narrow and really focused and really ruminative on this one thing.
28:12We play it over and over again. And the healing from trauma is about widening out our span of vision, looking again at the beauty in the world, looking again at who we are beyond the painful experience. So I do think there are definitely themes there that are around how addiction makes us narrow, trauma makes us narrow, and healing kind of widens us out and helps us remember our three-dimensionality. And one of you writes, revenge doesn't actually feel good. It may feel better than the pain of being hurt initially, but then you create two things to heal in yourself. And James, in your book, you talked about the fact that imagining yourself forgiving someone can actually blunt that desire, that urge, yearning to exact revenge.
28:59How does that work, especially neurologically? The neuroscience of forgiveness is even more fascinating and amazing to me than the neuroscience of revenge-seeking because it reverses everything that I just said about revenge-seeking. So if you simply imagine forgiving someone, you don't forgive them, you just imagine it internally inside your head, it deactivates that pain network, the anterior insula that I mentioned that is where your grievance is physically focused. The other thing that it does is it It shuts down the pleasure and reward circuitry, the craving circuitry. So you're no longer confronting these intrusive and nagging cravings of how should I get back at and how can I punish the person who roamed me?
29:39And then the last thing that forgiveness does neurologically is it restores and reactivates your prefrontal cortex so you can make good cost benefit decisions. And so these three areas we can see now inside the brain support really the ancient forgiveness teachings of people like Jesus and the Buddha who talked about forgiveness often in spiritual terms and in human life terms. But we can see that in very brain biological terms, they actually have a direct beneficial impact. And the most important thing is forgiving isn't a gift to the person who wronged you. It's a gift to yourself. It's the way you can heal from the traumas of the past.
30:21That's a great place to end our conversation. James Kimmel, Jr., author of The Science of Revenge, Understanding the World's Deadliest Addiction and How to Overcome It. He's also a lecturer in psychiatry at the School of Medicine at Yale University. And Alexandra Solomon, licensed clinical psychologist in private practice, adjunct faculty at Northwestern and host of the podcast Reimagining Love. Thanks so much to both of you. You know, we're on Instagram. You can follow us at The1AShow. Today's producer was Haley Blassingame. This program comes to you from WAMU, part of American University in Washington, distributed by NPR.
30:56I'm Celeste Headley. This is 1A.