1. Podcasts
  2. Conversations with Coleman
  3. Is Anger a Virtue?
Conversations with Coleman

9 Nov 2026 · 1h 9m · 24 chapters

In short

The episode argues that war is inherently chaotic and should be a last resort, while defending “righteous anger” as a virtue and discussing autonomous humanoid robots for defense.

Guests and backgrounds

Mike LeBlanc, former Marine (8 years active duty; three Middle East tours including Afghanistan in 2011–2012 and 2014; Iraq during the rise of ISIS; later a major). He’s an entrepreneur in humanoid robotics, previously building security robots (a “skinny Alexa” form factor; nearly 1,000 robots deployed across nine countries). He’s also promoting a book on the virtues of anger.

Key claims

War is “hell” and a contest of wills, not chess; policymakers often have “weak stomachs” for war’s reality. Robots won’t change who bears responsibility for lethal decisions; they mainly shift the chain of command. Critics fear “Terminator” outcomes, but he argues robots are less dangerous than existing weapons and that morality debates already exist for decades.

Notable examples

Lubyanka prison interrogation premise of the film Confession (Ben Shapiro; directed by Václav Marhul; starring Rob Lowe, James Franco, Cody Smith-McPhee, Nick Nolte). He cites a 2016 Dallas police robot bomb use case and Star Trek’s “simulated war” episode as illustrations of war’s moral reality.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:05

Introduction to Mike LeBlanc

Introducing guest Mike LeBlanc, a former Marine with unique perspectives.

“I'm not sure that we've been in a good war since World War II.”
1:30

Mike LeBlanc's Backstory

Mike shares his upbringing, military journey, and influences on his views.

“That many times is how you should be responding to your own poor behavior.”
3:38

Deployment Experiences and Perspectives

Mike discusses his military deployments and their impact on his worldview.

“So my dad, house painter, my mom, teacher in my school district.”
6:16

Reflections on War and Policy

A critical examination of the U.S. military actions in Iraq and Afghanistan.

“Um, And there was also some, the beginning of ISIS, you were in Iraq for that, right?”
7:42

On the Nature of War

Discussion on the moral complexities and historical context of warfare.

“I think, well, I don't think we should have gone to Afghanistan in the first place.”
9:30

Autonomous Robots in Warfare

Exploring the role and implications of autonomous robots in military settings.

“it was interesting because I think to me, I'm not sure that we've been in a good war since World War two.”
11:23

The Future of Humanoid Robots

Mike explains his work in developing humanoid robots and their applications.

“are you talking about being more and more indiscriminate in the killing and being less sensitive to the distinction between civilians and combatants?”
14:01

Introduction to Humanoid Robots in Security

Learn about the development and deployment of humanoid robots for security and their applications.

“And you had done humanoids for security purposes, right?”
15:12

Government Contracts and Robotics Research

Explore the role of government funding in advancing humanoid robotics and military applications.

“And so we went and just started scooping up a ton of those research contracts.”
17:49

Ethics of Robot Soldiers in Warfare

Discuss the ethical implications and public perception of using robots in combat scenarios.

“And it's like, we've crossed these lines long before.”
Show all 24 chapters
19:55

The Nature of War and Robot Integration

Analyze how the introduction of robots changes the dynamics of warfare and military strategies.

“May seem like it's obvious, but what that means is war is not like chess.”
23:21

Global Perspectives on Autonomous Warfare

Understand the varying attitudes towards robots and warfare across different cultures and nations.

“And infrastructure does a great deal more than I think people give it credit for.”
28:01

Challenges of Robot Navigation

Exploring the complexities robots face in navigating varied terrains.

“So take me through the practical complexities of getting a robot to be able to maneuver over complex and varied terrains.”
29:27

The Impact of Large Language Models

Discussing how advancements in AI can enhance robot capabilities.

“that they have right now that make them still worse than humans?”
31:23

Data's Role in Robotic Learning

Understanding the importance of data in training robots to perform tasks.

“writing as we could with real world data of what a robot needs, right?”
32:58

Ethics of Robots in Warfare

Examining the ethical implications of robots making decisions in combat.

“To your right is grandma and to your left is, and you know, and one of the grandmas is Asian and one of the grandmas is Puerto Rican and who is it going to choose and what ethics are we going to program into it?”
36:56

Chaos of War and Responsibility

Debating the chaotic nature of war and the complexities of accountability.

“Somebody is going to be setting the mission of what, what this robot is supposed to carry out.”
42:00

The Complexity of Warfare and its Realities

Exploration of the harsh realities of war and its implications.

“Yeah, so they'd look at a computer attack and they're like, oh no.”
45:00

The Virtue of Anger: A Philosophical Discussion

Discussion on the overlooked virtues of anger, referencing Aristotle and modern culture.

“All right, let's pivot to your other super popular thesis, which is that anger is good.”
52:58

Navigating Anger in Personal Relationships

Personal anecdotes on using targeted anger effectively in relationships.

“And I told him, like, have you tried injecting a little anger into your voice when you're talking to her about this.”
56:01

Parenting and Boundaries: The Role of Anger

Explore how establishing boundaries in parenting is linked to using anger effectively.

“what we were going to let him do and not do, right?”
57:50

Discipline Strategies in Child Rearing

Discuss various disciplinary methods and their impact on child behavior and understanding.

“It was when anger and punishment seem arbitrary, unfair, and unrelated to having done a wrong action that you get resentment and psychological hangup.”
1:01:17

Masculine Virtues and Societal Changes

Analyze the shift from masculine to feminine virtues in society and its implications.

“Is that because I'm overtired and I'm being a baby right now?”
1:06:36

The Importance of Anger in Modern Life

Understand the necessity of embracing anger for personal growth and societal engagement.

“You read the stories and you're like, kids are so cruel and this is horrible.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Conversations with Coleman, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Coleman Hughes: What would you refuse to confess even if your state demanded it? That's the premise of Confession, a new film written by Ben Shapiro and set in Stalin's Moscow. The movie tells a story of a former literature professor who was arrested and interrogated inside Lubyanka prison by his former student. The movie, directed by Václav Marhul, forces us to reckon with what we might do when faced with unthinkable choices. The former literature professor is played by one of my personal favorite actors, Rob Lowe, who gives an absolutely chilling performance. The rest of the cast is just as impressive. James Franco, Cody Smith-McPhee, and Nick Nolte.

0:41Coleman Hughes: In total, that's five Academy Award nominees in the cast. So if you're a fan of period dramas or great acting or just plain old good movies, make sure you watch Confession, which premieres live on Wednesday, November 11th, only on Daily Wire. Subscribe at dailywire.com to watch. Should we have left Afghanistan? Much sooner than we did. Did you think that at the time you were deployed there? Absolutely. I'm not sure that we've been in a good war since World War II. Let's get into the role of autonomous robots. How and why did you get into the business of creating these entities? Something like$74 million of government research contracts have gone behind our robot.

1:23People are thinking that we're creating the new Terminator and that things are going to turn out like Terminator.

1:28Coleman Hughes: Let's pivot to your other super popular thesis, which is that anger is good. You should be angry. That many times is how you should be responding to your own poor behavior.

1:44Coleman Hughes: What would you refuse to confess even if your state demanded it? That's the premise of Confession, a new film written by Ben Shapiro and set in Stalin's Moscow. The movie tells a story of a former literature professor who was arrested and interrogated inside Lubyanka prison by his former student. The movie, directed by Václav Marhul, forces us to reckon with what we might do when faced with unthinkable choices. The former literature professor is played by one of my personal favorite actors, Rob Lowe, who gives an absolutely chilling performance. The rest of the cast is just as impressive. James Franco, Cody Smith-McPhee, and Nick Nolte.

2:25Coleman Hughes: In total, that's five Academy Award nominees in the cast. So if you're a fan of period dramas or great acting or just plain old good movies, make sure you watch Confession, which premieres live on Wednesday, November 11th, only on Daily Wire. Subscribe at dailywire.com to watch. Okay, Mike LeBlanc, thanks so much for coming on my show. Thank you. So you are a former Marine who is pro-anger and pro-killer robots. So I have to imagine everyone loves you. You never get any criticism. That's exactly right. I just walk through the world beloved everywhere I go. The Bob Marley of entrepreneurs, right?

3:05Coleman Hughes: Yes. I want to get to anger and killer robots and all of that. And you have a book coming out about the virtues of anger in some sense. Before we get to that, give me a little of your backstory. You grew up in Ohio, right? How do you make it to the Marines? What is it like to be deployed in the Middle East? And how does that connect to your twin projects now of humanoid robots and controversial defenses of an unpopular emotion? You know, the whole story is just so serendipitous. So my dad, house painter, my mom, teacher in my school district. So my mom grew up within one mile radius of where our house was.

3:51So that was an interesting way to be brought up. But I really didn't want to leave and was kind of nervous about leaving until I had a teacher in my high school who said, you should really look into this college called St. John's College, where they all read the great books and you translate ancient Greek. And so that became, that was the only school that I applied to. And once I got in there, that kind of opened up this world of Thucydides and Plato and Aristotle. and I think as you read those books, war starts to make a lot of sense as I was looking at myself and going, fit young guys went to war.

4:34That's kind of what you did throughout history and I'm sitting there, we had a war in Iraq at the time that I knew nothing about, didn't even know that we had a war going on and I was like, I think I heard something about that, right? You're so removed from it and so I ended up looking that up And I go, sure enough, there's a war going on. And, uh, and that's, that's where I decided, I think I need to really look into this.

5:00Coleman Hughes: And so from then take me to, um, the Middle East, how many years before you get deployed, what are your deployments and how does that influence your worldview? So I, yeah, I ended up getting into the Marine Corps. It's a very, it was a very strange movement because I'm coming from such an outsider's angle. I just didn't really grow up with a lot of people that went to the military. It was just kind of outside. My parents were really broken up about me going. None of my family and friends supported it. Just one of my professors. But outside of that, everybody was like, this is bad. So getting into the Marine Corps is all of a sudden a really interesting place because there are a lot of people that they're fourth generation Marine Corps or fourth generation military of some kind.

5:43So that kind of opened up this new warrior culture to me in a way that you get to see it's, it's always been around me, but you go, Oh, I, I just hadn't noticed it until, until you're there. And, and so during that time, you know, I did eight years active duty. So that was, that was three tours to the Middle East. Um, that was, you know, two of them to Afghanistan combat tours, kind of like what people picture out of that, out of that era. I was in the Afghans, uh, 2011, 2012, and then 2014.

6:16Coleman Hughes: Got it. Yeah. Um, And there was also some, the beginning of ISIS, you were in Iraq for that, right? Yeah. Yeah. So that was the interesting one because I had just met my wife before I deployed there. And so we were dating and I'm going, there's nothing going on. I was going to Bahrain. And so I'm like, it's going to be really relaxed. The guy stays in a Marriott. It's going to be really, really chill. And as soon as I fly over there, they start launching all of these beheading videos and everybody's sending them to her. and we took command of Iraq in that conflict my unit did. So that was, I was a bit more senior at that point.

6:55I got out when I was a major. So that was much more approving drone strikes and things like that.

7:02Coleman Hughes: You wrote that your time in the Middle East gave you a distrust of abstractions. Yeah. Explain that. You know, I think that had been budding in me for a long time. But it's interesting. When you're taking out a problem conceptually, it can start to feel very easy to move them around like Lego blocks and just go, well, logically, this must follow this and this must be true of this. And when you get on the ground, you end up finding that it's all the particulars that matter so much. Should we have left Afghanistan much sooner than we did? Yeah. Sooner. I think, well, I don't think we should have gone to Afghanistan in the first place.

7:47but did you think that at the time you the times you were deployed there absolutely yeah i've i've thought that forever i almost didn't join the marine corps because i that was when i started reading about the wars and i said these look like really bad wars this iraq and afghanistan both like a mess the the standard back then was iraq was the mistake and afghanistan was the good war neither of them were good wars they were they were really silly uh misdirected wars i think And, you know, I even called up, there's a guy, Ralph Peters, who I was reading at the time. He was like a columnist. He wrote a bunch of books on this.

8:22And I found my way to a phone call with this guy. I just emailed every newspaper that he wrote for to get a call with him. And I said, you're against this war, but you're a Lieutenant Colonel in it. How does that work? Should I still join the Marine Corps? And he said, you know, the nation, the nation always needs a very sharp sword. I disagree with how we wield that sword, but you need to make sure that there's an integrity to the to the sword itself and and that was that was the whole way that i went went through the military was thinking that's what i'm a part of i don't i don't appreciate the way that our military is used and tasked uh definitely yeah don't don't think anything highly about those those wars but you do want an integrity to the

9:05Coleman Hughes: force itself that's interesting that you were able to compartmentalize like that because i think most people that didn't support the war wouldn't have volunteered. And that's such an association in people's mind that the notion that you could still be a part of it and say, well, we're here. Our leaders have chosen this war. You know, I might as well make the best of it and do the best job I can, even though I don't support it. That's a very unusual position. Yeah, it was, it was interesting because I think to me, I'm not sure that we've been in a good war since World War two. Like I really look, I mean, Korea.

9:40I would argue Korea. There's an argument for Korea, but then, then again, the way that we fought it, uh, you know, for that to be still quagmired, right. That you have a North and South Korea with this big DMZ manned on both sides. That's, that's not a good ending. It's just still hasn't ended. Like we're, we're going to keep

9:58Coleman Hughes: that war open for the alternative though, was the whole thing would have been like North Korea, if we hadn't intervened. So I would say on the menu of options, we forced a better outcome, though a highly imperfect one. It could be. It's not bad for what it is. But I wonder, I think that a lot of times our policymakers just have, their stomachs are too weak for the business that they're in. And I mean, war is hell, right? I mean, General Sherman, war is hell. It is a terrible, terrible place. That's why you shouldn't wield it lightly. You shouldn't say, I just want to go tweak something in this other country.

10:35Like this, it's a big line to cross. But once you cross it, you should be so committed that it is just all out warfare on the other country. There should be no compromises in how you're going to win that. And I'm not sure that we drove Korea that way. I think that there were, I mean, there were so many issues. korea is very interesting to to read about and learn about but yeah i i think that we didn't use all the tools that we had uh had in our arsenal at the time well so i mean macarthur was wanting

11:10Coleman Hughes: to drop a nuke on china yeah and i think that was one of if not the main reason truman dismissed him and um so i mean when you talk about using all the tools the the obvious objection to that is are you talking about being more and more indiscriminate in the killing and being less sensitive to the distinction between civilians and combatants? What do you mean by that? Yeah, I think all of those are issues that get discussed in these rooms and that should get discussed in these rooms. But really, I mean, the only reason that you go to war is to break the

11:53a good way to break their will, right? You're not going to break anybody's will playing chess. Like people don't.

11:59Coleman Hughes: Did you see the six-hour game between Magnus and Nepo years ago? Or nine-hour game, whatever it was. But like war, that's the interesting thing is, you know, you should try to, like kids, use your words, right, before you get to all of these things. But once war actually opens up, that's when it's, everything's on the table then. And you're finally just saying, this is important enough that I'm going to do whatever it is that I can do to stop it. That could have all kinds of discussions about breaking the enemy's will, but that can be property damage, that can be infrastructure, that can be cyber attacks.

12:41That has been, I mean, you see that Truman, you know, Truman certainly dropped a bomb and killed lots of civilians. there's there's just no moral absolutes in these things it's war is an absolutely horrible place

12:54Coleman Hughes: so let's get into the role of autonomous robots i mean i i'm going to avoid saying killer robots for the rest of this conversation uh because that's just a cartoonish um phrase but that is what we're talking about right we're talking about humanoid robots that can wield a gun a machine gun, wield any tool that a human soldier would wield and be on the front lines in a war, you know, shooting enemy combatants, enemy robots, doing anything that a normal human soldier would do. How and why did you get into the business of creating these entities? It was interesting. Humanoids started to just become useful with LLMs.

13:45So you started to see this opening of robotics that all robots were starting to get better. And all of a sudden, the human form factor is a very interesting one because we have a world that's built for humans. So that became obvious for a lot of people. And so a lot of companies rushed to it. We were one of those companies that started up during that time. And you had done humanoids for security purposes, right? I'd done a different form factor of robot for security before. Explain that. What do you mean by form factor? It looked like a big, skinny Alexa. like an Amazon Echo. But it was five feet tall.

14:18And that one would move around corporate office spaces looking for open doors and things like that. But that had given me some experience about what it is to get robots out. We had almost a thousand robots out at that company. So, and they were nine countries. You just learn a lot about what it is to put hardware out in the world. And so we started doing that with humanoids for auto manufacturing for, you know, the dream is to build cities, to build things on the moon, build things on Mars. That's the sort of dream of where to go. But as soon as we did that, we realized the Department of Defense was asking for all these humanoid.

14:57They had all these humanoid research projects, and no one serious was going after them. No one that had real funding was going after any of these research grants. And so we said, well, of course we're not opposed to that. The other countries are going to do this. We need to have this technology in. And so we went and just started scooping up a ton of those research contracts. So I think to date, we have something like$74 million of government research contracts have gone behind our robot. But that's just sort of made us a leader in the space. But it's not really the goal. It's more like being an American citizen where you say, I want to work.

15:37I hope the economy is great and there are jobs. But if there's a war, I'm also happy to suit up and hold a rifle.

15:44Coleman Hughes: So is part of this the fact that other humanoid robot companies feel squeamish about the prospect of creating robot soldiers? They wouldn't want to be involved in such an enterprise. And so the lane is open for someone who says, here's the case for why we need this. They're going to be created anyway. We want to have them at least as good or better than China does. so I'm going to take that lane. And along with that, I imagine comes a certain number of arrows flung your way for being the evil inventor of soldier robots or at least on the frontier of that. What is the most common criticism that gets lodged your way?

16:28Oh, well, absolutely. People are thinking that we're creating the new Terminator and that things are going to turn out like Terminator. That's the basic feel of these things. And I think that the reason that other companies are squeamish about it in a way that we are not is that they just haven't seen the realities of combat, right? Having gone to war, having been a Marine for all this time, I, again, have real particulars to look at in this. And, you know, the thought that a human-shaped robot holding a rifle is going to be more dangerous than a 2 ,000-pound JDAM bomb is absurd, right? And when you picture, I mean, carpet bombing, when you picture landmines, when you picture all of the tools that are real tools in war, this is not close to kind of the scary things that are out there.

17:26So to me, if it's a useful tool for our soldiers to use, and if it's one that can be walking point in a patrol and step on an IED before, you know, somebody's son does, it's just as clear as the day that that's the obvious thing to do. But I think that a lot of these conversations happen in tweed jackets with elbow pads. And, you know, people just get this sense where they're like, do we know what we're doing here? And it's like, we've crossed these lines long before. So the morality that's being discussed about a lot of autonomous systems is already done in weapons and has been done for 50 years.

18:06But it feels new because it's a new form factor.

18:10Coleman Hughes: Yeah, I think what it is must be that because it's shaped like a human, it enters the uncanny valley in our psychology where we have no problem with a robot that looked like a Roomba and explodes on contact with the enemy. In fact, we've done that. We celebrated it, I think, rightly back in 2016 when there was that shooter in Dallas who shot five cops and then barricaded himself in a school or something. And they had no way of getting to him without endangering more cops. So they sent a robot in there and blew him up with some C4. Exactly. I thought that was brilliant. And I think it was like the first US police use of a robot for that use case.

18:53Coleman Hughes: But if that robot were shaped like a human and had killed that same guy in the same way, there would be wall-to-wall coverage. We would see international organizations probably condemning it, citing, you know, human rights charters and all kinds of things. But really what it is, is a psychological hangup we have around a robot that looks sort of like us. Yes. And we anthropomorphize these machines and start going, now you're stealing a job. Whereas it's like, well, we've created fully autonomous lines. That takes lots of different jobs. You know, but when it's in a human form factor, it does. I think it just opens up a new new part of people's feelings on all of this.

19:34Whereas, you know, a, yeah, dropping a massive bomb on something doesn't feel human. It feels like, well, yeah, we know what bombs are. That's out there, of course. But as soon as you have something that's, you know, we picture that it's going to be making decisions like a human and that it could go rogue and it's going to be plotting against us. I think that's where imaginations go a little wild.

19:55Coleman Hughes: So if you imagine mass-producing robot soldiers, and this is in light of something you said before, which I agree with, and I think I've talked to John Spencer about this, although not, or I've heard him say this, which is war is a contest of wills. What does that actually mean? That's a very deep statement. May seem like it's obvious, but what that means is war is not like chess. Chess is like, if I'm better than you, I'm just going to beat you. I'm going to wipe the floor with you. doesn't really matter how badly I want to win or how badly you want to win. I'm just intellectually better than you at chess.

20:30Coleman Hughes: I'm going to win. If I'm much better at MMA than you, right? I'm just going to win, you know, 99 times out of 100, probably 100 times out of 100. It doesn't really matter how badly I want to win or what cost I'm willing to incur. War is not like that. War is about who cries uncle first, who is willing to suffer more. It's very rarely the case that one army is killing every member of another army. Almost never. It's, we're going to fight each other until one of us decides the cost is intolerable to us. And this is why it's so, it's so common for very weak armies to defeat the strongest armies in the world, whether it be Vietnam or the American Revolution, right?

21:13Coleman Hughes: So given that calculus for what war actually is, how do robots change that calculus? Because once you have thousands of robot fighters on one side or both sides, the cost to the political entity deciding on the war lowers, right? Because no one is crying over one dead robot soldier, whereas a whole family will be crying over every single dead American soldier. How does that change the decision theory of war? I think that a lot of people, there's like a scene in one of the new Star Wars. I've never seen the movie, but I see the clips on YouTube that people send me. But it's like a robot, you know, droid army versus another droid army, and they're all running over the hills.

22:01If that were the beginning of a war, there'd be some economic damage to be like, man, we broke a lot of robots right there. But it's going to continue until somebody says, we need to have these robots hurt humans, right? We are not going to break the enemy's will. Nobody's going to quit if it's just a manufacturing race. And we go, this is getting pretty expensive to make all of these robots. Like it has to get to that point. That's what war does. You know, to your point, there's not a fourth quarter buzzer that goes off and you go, who's ahead? All right, that's the winner. It's picture if you played a basketball game until one of the teams gave up, right?

22:37Coleman Hughes: The scoreboard was irrelevant. Yeah, the scoreboard's irrelevant. And it's like, who's feeling higher in it? Yeah. And you just keep going until one team goes, I'm finally out. That's very long. Or if you ran a marathon that's not 26 miles, it's just, we'll see who gives up first. Somebody's going to pass out and the other person will be the victor. That's what war is. And so I think when you're in that kind of contest, it may have robot-on-robot skirmishes. There may be portions of it that are like that. But if the idea is to break the enemy's will, there's going to have to be suffering. The robots will be sent after human targets.

23:16They'll have to be sent after humans or infrastructure. Hopefully military targets.

23:19Coleman Hughes: Infrastructure targets. Yeah. And infrastructure does a great deal more than I think people give it credit for. You know, it was like we're at war with Iran and you started seeing news stories. Did you see there was like a little window where there was no water in like Minnesota or something? Or they'd, and everybody was like, Iran went after the water. That to us, that's enough to break the American will of war, right? If we have contaminated water and we're like, I'm not interested anymore. If Afghanistan had been able to shut off our power in a couple states, we would have said, we need to get to a resolution on this.

23:53Because there's not much will there, even though we're much stronger.

23:57Coleman Hughes: Right. In America, especially in modern America, we're very used to our conveniences. um we don't our expectations are very high we are you know western europe would be the same we have beyond first world expectations at this point this wasn't always the case obviously um but many parts of the world don't and i want to read uh this is from i think a time magazine article in which you were quoted throughout um and and this is actually not you this is scout ai This is Otis from Scout AI, which is, maybe you can explain briefly what that is. So they have autonomous, almost like an ATV. It's smaller than an ATV, but something that'll carry military supplies.

24:44Coleman Hughes: Got it. So he said, the future will be, quote, massive unmanned system on unmanned system, sorry, massive unmanned system on unmanned system warfare. And then there's a clear winner and you have a surrender of a nation. So which is not really what you're saying, right? No. That's because pitting unmanned systems on humans would be, quote, so catastrophic that no nation is going to want to subject their people to that. At which point, depending on whom you believe, humanity may be relishing in a Pax Automata, meaning we'll all be at peace because of this mutually assured destruction, or we'll be staring down AI Armageddon.

25:23Coleman Hughes: Now, when I read that in preparation for this, I thought, well, it really depends on the country, because you have countries like Iran, where the regime is willing, at the blink of an eye, to sacrifice, actually to kill 20 ,000, 30 ,000 of its own citizens, and to suffer much more than that in service of their revolutionary ideology. Whereas, if one American soldier dies, that's a big deal to us. If one Israeli soldier dies, that's a big deal to Israel. If one Palestinian dies, that is not a big deal to Hamas, for instance. So how does, you know, if we picture a world where ultimately any state with a little bit of wealth can get their hands on humanoid robots, How do we expect an Iran to behave, to use them differently maybe than an America would?

26:20Well, I think that's the big point. When I hear quotes like that, I always think, oh, that's somebody that's never been to war. And I often think that's somebody who hasn't traveled outside of the kind of four-season cities around the world because life is not treated as precious all around the world. And so when you give these technologies to different countries, it's scary for them to have guns. it's really scary for them to have nukes. It's scary for them to have robots, bombs, C4, anything. Because that's what we've been seeing in the Middle East is a lot of people that are living in times that look straight out of a biblical scene, but that can have all of these real missiles and real guns and all of these armaments that are of the modern era.

27:08That's just a scary combination forever. And so I don't think that robots are something new in that as much as they just continue what is always fearful. The nice thing about some of these robots is that the complex manufacturing of them, the complex AI systems to make them really good, is going to be hard and expensive and kind of controlled by, I mean, China and the US is what it's looking like are going to be the major producers of them. But that's, you know, as these get into other countries' hands, you need to be ready with your own. And that's where anything that we do on our side, you know, we can, I mean, it's the same as trash going into the ocean, right?

27:48We can talk about this until we're blue in the face. But until China does something about it, it's not going to have an effect on what's actually going on with climate or anything. That's kind of the same in all these war technologies.

28:01Coleman Hughes: Right. Right. So take me through the practical complexities of getting a robot to be able to maneuver over complex and varied terrains. And maybe in your answer, you can tell me how I think two of your robots have been deployed in Ukraine already at the front line. But if I'm imagining what a soldier may have to encounter, he may have to walk on a typical road and then a gravel road with bumps and then a puddle that has a two-foot pothole, but it's an invisible pothole because the water's covering it. And it's the evening, so you can't see anything and you fall two feet in the puddle. Human soldier has no problem with that.

28:46Coleman Hughes: You just get up and then all your buddies around you see to avoid that area. and then there's a you have to walk over a destroyed building that is just debris and concrete and you have to you know none of these things are super challenging for a human but when you you know i think we've learned for a long time in robotics the things that seem easy to us are often the hardest in robots and the things that are hardest for us are often the easiest for robots like calculus and chess, right? Yes. So how far have your robots gotten in terms of being able to navigate the complex terrain like a human would?

29:26Coleman Hughes: What are the limits that they have right now that make them still worse than humans? And do you think all of those limits will be transcended and like over what timeline? Yeah. So I think really what LLMs did when you saw a chat GPT come out and you saw a Claude come out and all of these things was that had been available to us for a little while as kind of an experiment that people always wondered, you know, if I ask a question like, what is the weather going to be tomorrow? And I run on a normal computer, it'll come up with an answer. If I throw a ton of compute at that, if I had a ton of computers working together, would it actually make it a better answer?

30:03You know, and I always think about this in terms of like books are a good example. So, you know, if I asked you, to, I don't know, build a cabinet, a lot of the books on the shelf are going to be irrelevant. So you could pick them all off and you go, I'm not going to use that. I'm not going to use that. You finally get to like the cabinet building book and you go, oh, here we go. I've got instructions and I use it. And that was, that was one theory about how all knowledge would work is even if you gave many more books, you'd still arrive at the same answer because there's really just that one book on building cabinets.

30:36But as it turns out, this was the experiment of OpenAI was, let's actually see if we gave somebody seemingly infinite time to read every single book, could they come up with a better way of building the cabinet? And it turns out that they can, right when you throw all that data at it. So that unlock, the reason that that's so big in robotics is because we now go, all right, that's the path is if we throw a ton of compute and a ton of data. So a bunch of people reading and a bunch of books together, we can all of a sudden get new things out of robots than we've ever gotten before. And, you know, so that's what all of these companies are in a competition to do.

31:18The difference is with large language models, we have a lot of language and the internet had already compiled as much of human speaking and writing as we could with real world data of what a robot needs, right? There's not a lot of data of a camera that's looking down at a glass and deciding how to pick it up. There's not a lot of that. And so that's been the major gap. Much less data that would show

31:44Coleman Hughes: how humans do those things. Yes. Well, and so then you go, okay, if we need some kind of data that's going to make sense to a robot picking up a glass, there are all these different ways to do it. One is to use remote controls on a robot and direct the robot to pick it up and do that over and over again, right? That's called tele-opping. And there are people just brute forcing the problem by doing that over and over and over again. When you give all of those episodes into a computer with a ton of compute, all of these GPUs, it can run over that and say, all right, I think I know how to do this now.

32:22And if you put a glass in a different spot, I think I'll still be able to pick it up. And so it's all kind of iterating on that same idea. You can build it in a simulation like a video game. You can build it like we do mostly, which is a video, somebody wearing like a GoPro on their head. But whatever that data is in, it's ultimately an iteration of, do we have enough, right? Have we put enough sugar in these cookies? Do the kids like them? Okay, no, put a little more sugar in the next batch. It's really figuring that out over and over again. And so that's the largest blocker to robots being able to navigate the world like humans, is how much data do we have and how much have we refined that data?

33:00so today our robot is is capable of walking for very long periods of time uh it can go up and down stairs uh reliably it can you know we have we have a whole video of it walking across marbles of it walking in banana peels of you know of all these different things uh but it just gets better

33:21Coleman Hughes: and better as it goes so i remember you know maybe 10 years ago the conversation about self-driving cars, especially among podcast philosophy bro types like myself, was, you know, what is the car going to do in the case of a trolley problem scenario between, you know, you can't go straight anymore because there's a baby there. To your right is grandma and to your left is, and you know, and one of the grandmas is Asian and one of the grandmas is Puerto Rican and who is it going to choose and what ethics are we going to program into it? And, you know, I'm not actually sure this, you know, to your earlier point on how abstraction can miss the point of real world practicalities.

34:09Coleman Hughes: I'm not sure how often this situation actually arises. The self-driving is so good that I think it just very rarely does get into accidents. And in those split second scenarios, are they usually that complicated or is it like swerve and hit? It's really a choice between the driver safety and the thing you're going to hit, right? It usually doesn't require a PhD in moral philosophy, in other words, to solve such problems. But there's a lot of conversation with soldier robots about what kind of decisions is it going to make. These are the kind of decisions I don't have to tell you that actually soldiers do have to make in times of war.

34:58Coleman Hughes: You know, and there are judgment calls. You know, all over the Middle East, we have seen the use of, for instance, child soldiers. We've seen child soldiers, child lookouts in Gaza. There were child, you know, suicide bombers in Afghanistan.

35:18Coleman Hughes: what kinds of decisions in the gray areas of war can we expect robots to make? Who is going to be programming those decisions? And according to what moral code are they going to be looking to the United Nations? Are they going to be looking to U.S. law? Have you thought about that? Well, I mean, this is what I spend a ton of time thinking about. Because I think this has been an age-old question of whose agency is it in war? when, when a soldier goes out, the charge of light brigade, this great example, right? Tennyson poem of this, you know, this army is given terrible orders, terrible misdirected orders that were a mistake, but they're still carrying it out, you know, in, in full fulfillment.

36:01And they, they don't get to make the decisions. They don't get to make the call about who they're going after, but they're going to do it to the best of their ability. That's, that's just, you know, twas ever thus, right? And I mean, in Henry V, he's got a great soliloquy of it all resting on the king that he says, no matter what these soldiers go out and do, they put under my name because I was the one that started the war. And we have that issue today of when a 19-year-old from Arkansas is on the battlefield. Is it him that's deciding to kill that person? Or was it the president? Or was it the person, the teams of lawyers that wrote the rules of engagement and the law of armed conflict and, or his particular commander, you know, it's, it's always a question about who, who actually did this.

36:47And so robots, robots don't change this in any, in any significant way in my mind. It's, it's just a very similar question that, that has always been there. Somebody is going to be setting the mission of what, what this robot is supposed to carry out.

37:00Coleman Hughes: Well, I guess it, it, it, it doesn't change it in the sense that you can have the debate about whether the president or the head of the Pentagon or the general or the colonel or the lieutenant or the soldier was responsible for this particular incident. But when the robot is the last end of that chain, you can't really say the robot was responsible, right? I don't really think you can say the 19-year-old is either. And that's kind of my point is, you know, in war, in an actual combat scenario, I mean, everything is crazy, right? You picture, we see videos of school shootings and things like that.

37:37We'll picture that where every person in the school has a gun. That's the kind of chaos that you're in. Killing is, it's not a judicial system. It's not a court sitting there and going, you know, do I think that that guy really deserves it? I haven't seen him shoot. I know that he has a gun and he's not. It's, you know, everybody's just all out. And, you know, we have courts for big deliberate decision making. That's just not what goes on in war ever. And so, you know, the thought that a machine is going to do that worse, to me, doesn't really make sense than a 19-year-old that's deprived of sleep, that is, you know, far away from home, scared for his life, right?

38:18And willing to do anything to keep things away.

38:19Coleman Hughes: Yeah, robots have the benefit of not being scared for their lives, right? Yeah, there's really interesting asymmetry there, right? Everybody kind of knows the, you know, what is it? I'd rather be judged by 12 than carried by 6. A robot doesn't have that, right? Where they think, yeah, I just need to shoot these things away from me. It doesn't really matter, right? If a person goes into clear a house, when I'm going into clear a building, I'm thinking, I need to come out of this alive. That's job number one. And so you're going to default to, you know, I'm going to shoot every combatant. Anything that looks like a threat, yeah.

38:50And if there's one that looks like a threat, just to be safe. Yeah. A robot's the opposite, right? It's go in there. You want to make sure that you don't shoot before, you know, and you're like, I want to be absolutely sure before I do, because otherwise we just lose a robot. It's no big deal. So I think there are interesting asymmetries, but really none of this is going to come up in a major way because when it's World War III and there are 5 ,000 people dying every day, nobody's going to be going, what did the robot decide to do? And at what point did it decide to do that? We have machines that do this already and that have been doing similar things for a very long time.

39:30We don't think a lot about—A heat-seeking missile is a great example of something that we fire. The machine decides where it's going to go. It looks for the most dense IR, and it goes toward that. That's very similar to what a robot is going to be. You know, the Ukrainians are already using this. They'll have drones that are, of course, going to get their signals jammed because the enemy is not just going to let them have clear communication with it. And so you just have to send it in directionally and go, I hope you find a target. And you're targeting things that you can't even see. So this kind of thing is already happening all over the battlefield, and this happened for a long time.

40:09But again, I think it's when you get to that human shape, it just starts to make you a little bit uneasy. I mean, for me too, I was first starting to think, what are we doing here in defense? And then I had to start getting real and going, wait a second, we do this already. It's just not in this shape. Yeah.

40:28Coleman Hughes: Well, I'm detecting from everything you're saying, if I were to describe maybe your worldview, it's like people have this delusional sense of how ordered war is. It's really chaos. It's really hell. And it's always been that way. And it always will be that way by definition. Given that that's a fact that we can't change, how should we be innovating in our own interest? Is that basically - Given my worldview, we should all be working on diplomacy and trying to avoid wars in every way. This was the key. This was the last part I forgot to say, which is given that that's true, we should have fewer wars.

41:14Coleman Hughes: Yes. and we should only fight wars when we're close to 100 % sure that on the same page that it's in our interest, because it's going to be ugly by definition, despite all of these fancy and nice-sounding rules that we write for ourselves and that international bodies that have no teeth write. And you can see that in every war that's ever been fought, including the ones currently being fought. This was great. My dad sent me this Star Trek episode, like the original TV series. And they had come upon these planets where two civilizations had been at war for 500 years. But because there was so much infrastructure damage, they stopped having the actual wars and they would just do computer simulations.

41:59And then the citizens would go to an extermination chamber or something and voluntarily die. For whoever won the... Yeah, so they'd look at a computer attack and they're like, oh no. oh, you know, thousands of people died or whatever it is. And those people have to go report. And so, you know, Kirk's team is hit in the war. End up doing it in the computer and he won't give his guys up. But it was such a fascinating episode to watch because they had tried to make war so clean and simulated. They tried to take away all of the scary bad parts of it. And Kirk's point at the end is, that's why you've had war for 500 years.

42:36And so he forces them to have an actual war. He says, I won't give my people up. And now you're going to have real attacks on each other. And he said, once you see how much suffering there is in a real war, you're not going to want to do it again. So he says, I encourage you to go make peace. And I thought, what a great episode of Star Trek. But that is the major point, is that that's what war is here for. It's here as an absolute last resort. And I think that people that haven't been a part of it, people that don't know many, many soldiers or sailors or Marines, people that just don't have a sense of that reality are much quicker to pull the trigger on.

43:15We should put troops there. We should go get involved. We should send drones there. We should, you know, we should have some kind of mission. Whereas when you really know that war is hell, right? And that's, that's not just like a tagline. That's, you really know that you're, you're going there for almost nothing. There's, there's almost nothing that can, that can push you to war. And that's why you know that you're very likely to be in a good one by the time you do it because there just were no other options.

43:40Coleman Hughes: What would you refuse to confess even if your state demanded it? That's the premise of Confession, a new film written by Ben Shapiro and set in Stalin's Moscow. The movie tells a story of a former literature professor who was arrested and interrogated inside Lubyanka prison by his former student. The movie, directed by Václav Marhul, forces us to reckon with what we might do when faced with unthinkable choices. The former literature professor is played by one of my personal favorite actors, Rob Lowe, who gives an absolutely chilling performance. The rest of the cast is just as impressive. James Franco, Cody Smith-McPhee, and Nick Nolte.

44:21Coleman Hughes: In total, that's five Academy Award nominees in the cast. So if you're a fan of period dramas or great acting or or just plain old good movies, make sure you watch Confession, which premieres live on Wednesday, November 11th, only on Daily Wire. Subscribe at dailywire.com to watch. This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just$15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song, like all I want. Right. Okay, we can afford that. You know what? Forget the music budget. We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch.

45:11Coleman Hughes: All right, let's pivot to your other super popular thesis, which is that anger is good. I'm vastly oversimplifying, of course. But when did you first start to develop this idea that there are virtues to anger that are now overlooked? or proper use cases of anger that are not really supposed to be discussed or encouraged. And yeah, just give your take on that. You know, for a guy that doesn't promote college, those college years did a lot for me. But again, you know, reading through the Greeks, that was where you first see Aristotle says that anger is a virtue. And it's a virtue because if you're too angry or angry at the wrong things, right?

45:57when you're like smacking your toaster or like, you know, punching your computer. That's like too far angry one direction. But he also says you cannot be angry enough as a situation calls for, right? If somebody like walked up and, you know, pushed my wife and I was like, huh, come on, let's keep moving. That's also not the right response. So he has anger as a virtue is kind of the middle spot of that. And that was really interesting for me the first time that I learned it because I thought, yeah, we all know Jerry Springer. we all know overreactions, road rage and how ugly it looks, but that underreaction, that's a bad look too.

46:33And so, so there really is this degree to get it right. And I think that Plato really builds this out much more when, when he says that there are three parts of the soul. So the normal, you know, people break up the soul into lots of different ways, but we all have this experience of kind of the angel on a shoulder on one shoulder and the devil on another, right? It's like the Looney Tunes version where the angel is saying, we should probably head to bed tonight. And the devil is saying, no, let's go have another drink. Like the night is young. We all know that kind of debate that goes on. And we all know that the devil wins a lot of those debates, right?

47:10It's very easy to give into temptation and pleasure and all these short-term things. But Socrates had a third part in that debate. So he had the angel, which he said was the mind, and he represents with the little man. He had the devil, which his was a crazy part, a many-headed beast, like a hydra, that every time you cut off one head, two grow back in its place, and that's kind of the desires. But he had this third part, this anger, that he cast as a lion. And his basic setup of the soul is, if you want to have harmony in your life, you can't have just tyranny of the mind over the appetites. You can't just let your appetites run free, you need to have an alliance between this anger, this righteous anger, and your mind to be able to work against your appetites.

48:01And so that, you know, another way of looking at that is thinking about shame, right? Shame as a tool. And when are you angry with yourself, right? I shouldn't have done that. That's a good response. That shouldn't be time to go take a bubble bath. That should be, well, what did you do wrong, right? You probably should be angry with yourself. And that's kind of the idea behind what if anger is the answer.

48:24Coleman Hughes: So there's two things I've observed about anger in modern culture. One is that it is completely discouraged among children, at least in our lifetimes. I don't know how it was talked about in our parents' or grandparents' lifetimes. But the basic sense is you should never get angry. Anger is always bad, especially for boys, but I think probably for young girls as well. But then, the one exception to that for teens and young adults is a point of view from the far left which says anger in politics is good because the system is so corrupt and racist and terrible and sexist that anger is the proper emotion to feel when you think about how terrible our society is.

49:14Coleman Hughes: and how important it is for us to tear structures down and replace them with our left-wing versions. Yeah. What do you make of both of those versions, both of those kind of observations? I think that was like clearest. I think that these times were around each other. It was kind of the Paul Ryan Republicans. You remember it was that time when it got like really wonkish and the Republicans didn't want to be angry about anything, even though there would be terrible things happening in the country and they'd go like, we need comprehensive solutions, you know? And then you had on the left, you had like Occupy Wall Street, which was like the world's biggest tantrum without any directive of like what needed to change.

50:00So those were like the fully formed positions. It was just like, I want to stay out of it. I don't think we should do anything about it. We just need to be nice about this and let it happen to us. or I'm just screaming and crying and somebody should do something. I don't know who or what, but please. Those, I think, were the worst of what it looks like. And, you know, both of those need to get more directive if they're going to move into the center of, you can't just sit back. I mean, immigration, right, has become this big issue that is talked about by both sides of the party now. Forever it wasn't discussed, right?

50:37As soon as it would come up, It was racist to discuss it or, you know, people just looked at immigration as this thing that they said, we need comprehensive reform and kind of left it at that. But that's a big problem when you don't know, you know, millions of people by whoever's count, but millions of people coming into your country that you don't know. That's an issue. And it's one that you should get angry about, but maybe not one that you should put on a bunch of masks and take to the streets, you know, in military uniforms either. You know, so I think that's a lot of these issues is they need somebody that does get angry about the right things, but anger doesn't give you freedom to just do whatever you want either, right?

51:17And that's the middle ground that we've been missing. I suspect that in many ways we're actually, as a country, starting to smack that into shape. It seems like over the past 10, 15 years, we've been moving in the right direction of, you know, people trying things and then going, we didn't like that, but something does need to be done. And you kind of even back out.

51:38Coleman Hughes: Yeah. I've always been a very calm person, apparently since I was very little. And that disposition has stayed with me, but there have been moments in my adult life where targeted anger has been useful with friends and relationships to enforce a boundary. And I think, I don't know if it's partly because of cultural programming or just personal wiring, but that's always been, it's like never been my first instinct. It's never my first instinct to get angry that a boundary has been crossed because my first instinct would be to have like a calm conversation about it. But what I found is that sometimes people don't understand that you're serious unless they hear some anger in your voice.

52:31Coleman Hughes: And especially if they trust you and like you and you have a good relationship in general, allowing a little bit of anger into your conversation just like switches on a light like, oh, okay, this is important to him. And that's all that needs to happen. and then the problem gets resolved. And obviously, there's a certain paradox there because anger is almost always involuntary. It's almost always synonymous with a loss of control, right? But if you're controlled and you're intentionally putting a little bit of anger into this and you titrate it and you're not drunk, you're perfectly sober, and you're doing this because rationally you know it's the best way to achieve a result that is actually a good result, and you can sort of turn it off right when it's no longer necessary, then it actually is a virtue.

53:25Coleman Hughes: And there was, you know, I think one reason I know this is because another friend had a similar situation with a girlfriend where he was like, I really don't, I've had so many conversations with her about this thing, and it's such a great relationship, and she's so great, but like there's this one thing that's just really... And I told him, like, have you tried injecting a little anger into your voice when you're talking to her about this. And the reason I gave him this advice is because I knew him so well that I know he's not an angry guy. And I know that he was having every single one of these conversations was super calm, super rational, which is how he is.

54:02Coleman Hughes: And I said, try being a little angry. And he came back to me a month later. He said, you know, I tried it and it freaking worked. The problem went away and we're in a better place now. It's amazing because we avoid conflict at all costs. And I, I mean, this is how I was raised. I was raised by a very nice family. Like, you know, my parents just did everything right. My childhood was so wonderful. And I have a large family that all of us kids feel that way all grown up. So I was kind of raised to be this sensitive new age male. That that was the idea. You don't get angry about things. When somebody's angry, that's them having a moment.

54:38It's like, okay, let's help them through this. You know, hurt people, hurt people and that kind of thing. but this was learning this in the greeks that sort of awakened in me that i i said no this is a real response and it's it's a right response to a lot of things it will it will fix a lot of problems to get angry with them and just like you're saying people people take that signal i now have you know i've got three little kids seven-year-old eight-year-old nine-year-old and if you know i see all these other parents that don't get angry with their kids and their kid will be doing something that is so obnoxious, right?

55:14You'll watch a parent, the kid is just smacking him over the head with, you know, whatever plastic golf club or whatever they have. And the parent is just sitting there calmly thinking, I'm doing the Lord's work. I'm being patient and my kid is going to be free and creative.

55:28Coleman Hughes: You know about gentle parenting? No. Oh, dude, you got to look into this. Just Google it. I mean, it's this trend and philosophy of always reasoning with your kids as if they are a rational adult with a high IQ all the time, no matter what they're doing. Yeah, we'll call that plan B. Yeah, it is the craziest thing I've ever heard about. It's crazy. And that's why, I mean, you know, I see it actually. So even in our parenting, right? My son is the oldest. He's the nine-year-old. He, we were still kind of feeling out what we were going to let him do and not do, right? So he'd like come over to my computer.

56:06I'd be working on my computer and I'd have my coffee next to it. And he'd come up, you know, as a baby and be like grabbing onto it. And I'd be having these debates in my head where I was like, I don't want him to feel afraid of the computer, you know, because I want him to someday use computers, but also my coffee's right there and I have dangerous. So I'd have these little moral debates before I'd finally go like, okay, I've got to trick him into playing with a toy. Those all kind of develop a case law in your family that by our third kid, right, my youngest, Ellie. by the time she would come over near a computer, it was just like knock her on her butt away from the computer, right?

56:41But because of that, I can see in the two of them especially, like my son has just more timidity around what call are we going to make about something? Whereas, you know, my youngest, she walks through it like it's a fully developed world. She knows exactly what's allowed, exactly what's not. And that allows her to either sneak what shouldn't be done and she'll, you know we'll find little candy wrappers up in her up in her room or something but she knows that it's bad it that's where the freedom comes from is from these distinct boundaries and and that's that's why most of the time like you know like you said and this is a big portion of the book is that boundaries are protected by anger that's that's who goes on the wall that's socrates's first in in political society the first place that he puts this anger is in the guardians they're the people that need to defend the city from people that are trying to attack it And I think that's, you know, you can see that in nations just like you can see that in people's kids, that when you just let them do whatever they want and you're reasonable about it and try to have discussions and, you know, go sit on the thinking step and think about what you did wrong, that's just never going to compare to the kind of drop and give me 20 type approach that you can take.

57:56Coleman Hughes: What I found with most well-adjusted adults who had parents that either got angry, punished them, or corporally punished them, is that if the parent punished you when you did something that you identify as being wrong, those kids, those adults almost never have resentment of that punishment, even if it was spanking, even if it was corporal, within reason. It was when anger and punishment seem arbitrary, unfair, and unrelated to having done a wrong action that you get resentment and psychological hangup. Yeah, I think that's hugely what you see. I mean, you see that across dog trainers, horses.

58:43It's been long documented that when you give indiscriminate rewards and punishments, they're just very confused. And you end up with these kind of crazy horses that come out of it. and my wife is Asian. I'm a Marine. So we always say, we play bad cop, bad cop. But that is like, we have very clear sense of discipline in the house. I mean, to the point, a good example, people always say about our kids, oh, they're so good at going to sleep. They go, you guys are so lucky your kids go to sleep. And my wife, she always gets angry about this, that she's like, I'm not lucky, right? We trained our kids to be this way.

59:20We educated them to be good at sleeping. And a lot of that was when the kids go up there and they scream and cry in their room, since they were, I don't know, nine months, very, very early on, maybe, maybe 12 months, I would, I would go to them and I'd explain to them, you know, civilized people get to sleep in beds and animals sleep outside. And if you're going to act like an animal, you're going to be outside of the house. You don't get all the comforts of civilization if you don't live up to that basic law. And so it's always been the same escalation of the first thing, the lights get all the lights get shut off no nightlight then the door gets closed then they get moved into the downstairs and then they get moved outside and you know i would do that i'm sure that my outside like what if it's raining outside i'd put them right right outside the door and i'd stand next to the door and i'd wait for them to be done and they'd finally be done crying and i'd open up the door and they'd start crying again and i'd go not yet i'd go get control and close it again and but you know my my neighbors surely think that i'm a psychopath right and somebody's probably calling child protective services right now.

1:00:23But that kind of escalation, you don't have to do it a lot because the kid understands that you're serious. But that's the hard work of figuring out how to exact punishments on these things. What actually is an offense and what are we going to do about it? What are we willing to do about it? Those are hard judgments that my wife and I have talked about ad nauseum over the years of exactly what's right for this. Today, now we have a pool in our backyard, 10 laps is the default punishment for anything. That the kids do something wrong, go swim 10 laps. And it's, which is nice because it's a state change.

1:01:00You know, they have to get in the water. It's also, we like them to be safe in the water. So it's good for them. But it's hard to come up with those things with all the particulars that you have. It's hard to exact punishments. Judgment is very difficult, but that's going to be the best education for your kids when you can say, you're making me angry. Is that because I'm overtired and I'm being a baby right now? Or are you doing something that is crossing a line? Are you doing something that is unwanted behavior that nobody else is going to accept from you? And in those cases, you should absolutely take that anger as a signal and say, yeah, that should make me change my behavior.

1:01:39Coleman Hughes: I think a lot of the burdens of parenting used to be communal as well. They used to be outsourced to the community. So you lived in a community of like-minded people. Like most parents would punish their kids for the same kinds of things in the same kinds of ways. And so when they went to school on Monday, they said, oh yeah, I got in trouble. Dad made me do this. No one would say, well, oh wow, that's my, well, my parent gentle parents me. And then that creates a potential difference where you say, oh shit, my dad's a hard ass. Maybe I'm being abused in some way, right? Whereas I think a lot of things used to be enforced more communally.

1:02:18Coleman Hughes: And that makes it way psychologically easier for kids to feel normal, I suppose. Yeah. I want to finish on one thing that you wrote on a blog on your website. You wrote a letter to your son. and this has to do with your philosophy of anger, but also with the lessons you learned from being a soldier. And you said, I learned these three rules. One, accept indisputable facts quickly, no matter how bad. Two, locate, close with, and destroy the enemy, whoever or whatever the enemy is. And three, be a happy warrior and fight with optimism. So these seem to me traditionally masculine virtues or values, right?

1:03:09And I was, I don't know if you've read Helen Andrews' essay

1:03:14Coleman Hughes: on the feminization of society. No. Well, she just talks about how American and Western cultures in general have leaned away from the masculine virtues toward the feminine virtues, which I think is true. And then there's a separate question of who that benefits and who it harms and whether it's better on the whole. But, you know, if you talk to anyone who grew up in America in the 70s, it was like, yeah, you're going to get bullied in school and there's no anti-bullying center to go to. It's just, yeah, we all got bullied and bullied. But then, you know, when I grew up, But bullying was this whole, there's a whole institutions to prevent and identify bullying and to deal with it.

1:03:59Coleman Hughes: And I'm like, that's an aspect of, you know, I grew up playing dodgeball. Dodgeball's freaking illegal now. That blows my mind. I didn't know that. Did you know that? Dodgeball's illegal in like the whole country. Yeah. Okay, but it's like, I enjoyed playing dodgeball as a kid, but I was above average athletic. Yeah. I honestly, I never really had considered that if you're scrawny, not athletic, that dodgeball was basically just like, shit, I'm just going to get pegged for like an hour straight. And I'm not going to be able to do anything about it. And it's going to be a little painful and probably even more humiliating.

1:04:38Coleman Hughes: and so the feminine virtue of caring about the most vulnerable and changing the rule set to protect the most vulnerable um is uh is increasingly how society has moved towards and that's a good thing for many people um i think it's good that there's more attention to bullying um but it is it is notable and so someone that comes into that status quo and says here let's remember the masculine virtues, I would assume that's going to ruffle some feathers, but also resonate with a lot of people at the same time. Do you think that that's part of the reason for you writing this book on anger and for pushing your message is to rediscover virtues that society has moved away from?

1:05:30That for me is really the whole push because I saw this in myself that I'd been and raised with all of these gentler virtues of thinking, you look out for the person that's getting pegged in dodgeball. And I mean, just being emotionally intelligent and looking out for people, which I think is a great default and foundation, but it's not the full story. And for me, I had to learn that through learning to translate ancient Greek and reading a lot of books and then going to the military. It took years for that education to really come to light. and I really wanted to put something together that to me, I wanted to be short.

1:06:09You know, you could read my book in like under four hours. So it's like a flight. I read a lot of books on flights. And I thought I want something that my kids can look at when they're 20 years old and we're raising them to be very nice little kids, but they're going to have this other part that I'm hoping to capture all of what the Marine Corps and the ancient Greeks had put together in saying there's another side of the story here where, you know, bullying, there's some bullying that's just bad and toxic. You read the stories and you're like, kids are so cruel and this is horrible. There's also absolutely a case where there's not enough bullying, right?

1:06:47And we see this a lot with like, you know, only children where people are like, they just haven't had the edges knocked off them really, right? I grew up with all of my older cousins. I was the youngest out of my younger cousins and the younger brother. and you know just having that having siblings having cousins that are constantly going like why are you wearing that you know why did you your voice sounds funny when you did that and why did you do that nobody does that close the door when you're going to the bathroom right all of these small little things are they're they're sculpting you right and so if if somebody's doing that in in a terrible way you know and they're duct taping you to a flagpole whatever goes on, right?

1:07:28Those are all way overkill. But there is, you want these things in society of people pushing back on you, just like you want anger in certain cases when it's at the right person for the right period of time in the right way. And I think that that's, in our society, it's a big unlock to living a rich life because it can be so easy to think, we don't need those barbarian virtues anymore. We're past all that. We've grown past that. that was what people used to have to do. And we still love watching Game of Thrones because we go in that time, I would have been killing everybody, you know, but in today's society, we're, we're very civilized.

1:08:05We have nice things. Everybody should just be, should just be nice. And that's, that's not the path to a good marriage. That's not the path to raising good kids, to, you know, making a good product that you can stand behind at your company, to, to holding up your duty in things to, I just, I don't see that as living a serious life. And so today we need that extra push to just think about these things. And that's where the hope is, not to have somebody read my book and then go, I'm forever changed and go and be pissed off at all their friends. But the idea is to give a framework and an argument for here's where this might fit in and here's what it might lead to if you develop these things and hopefully plant a seed in people that they go forward and start saying like, yeah, I'm not gonna back away from that conflict.

1:08:52I am going to get a little more involved in this. And I'm going to live a little more warlike. I'm going to be a bit harder version of myself.

1:09:00Coleman Hughes: All right. Mike LeBlanc, thank you so much for coming on my podcast. Plug your book one more time and point people to your website. Yeah, so my book is What If Anger Is The Answer? You can find out all about me on officialmikeleblanc.com. And I should have social media standing up. I don't think I have them yet, but I think they're coming. All right. Thanks, Mike. Thank you. Observe. The North American Dad. 50s. Great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on Carvana. An offer appears in minutes. Remarkable. He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, Dang, that's a good offer. The highest form of approval.

1:09:41No haggling. No hassle. No one called him boss. He's still on the couch. Astonishing.

1:09:49Coleman Hughes: Sell your car today on Carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply.

From the publisher

Mike LeBlanc is a former Marine and entrepreneur whose company builds humanoid robots. His new book, What If Anger Is the Answer?, argues that anger is the forgotten virtue we’ve been missing. He joins Coleman Hughes to make the case for getting angry, drawing on the Greek philosophy he studied at St. John’s College and eight years in the Marine Corps, including two combat tours in Afghanistan. That experience also shapes his view of war: It’s hell; it should be a last resort, but if we’re going to do it, we better do it right. He also brings the argument closer to home, with his take on what gentle parenting gets wrong.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Conversations with Coleman

All episodes