1. Podcasts
  2. Conversations with Coleman
  3. Do Great Men Actually Matter? With Jared Diamond
Conversations with Coleman

19 Oct 2026 · 45m · 17 chapters

Episode artwork

Do Great Men Actually Matter? With Jared Diamond

In short

Whether “great men” (leaders, dictators, coaches) actually matter, argued using “natural experiments” rather than biographies. Diamond claims biographies are compelling but can’t prove causation; he instead compares outcomes when leaders die naturally or when borders create near-identical conditions.

Guest background

Jared Diamond is a scientist and geographer, a UCLA professor for nearly six decades, and author of Guns, Germs, and Steel (Pulitzer Prize). He grew up during WWII and has personal family ties to Nazi persecution; he also lived/worked in Chile and Indonesia under leaders associated with major atrocities.

Key claims

Leaders can matter, especially in war and when they persuade followers to do unwanted but beneficial actions. Natural experiments can quantify leadership effects; coaches are measurable because sports outcomes are frequent and comparable.

Notable examples

Hitler (distinctive risk-taking and deception), Churchill (rejecting Hitler’s deal over Gibraltar/Malta; tank diversion to Suez), Roosevelt and de Gaulle (mobilizing reluctant populations), Stalin (massive harms and wartime effects), Mao (post-death economic surge), JFK (Cuban Missile Crisis leadership), Lincoln (likely effects on Reconstruction/Jim Crow), Lee Kuan Yew (benign autocrat), Thatcher (Falklands), and sports coaching (Argentina’s penalty errors; John Wooden; Warriors’ Mark Jackson vs Steve Kerr).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:06

Exploring the Question of Leadership

Jared discusses the different approaches to studying leadership.

“Year-end giving doesn't have to mean making every charitable decision by December 31st.”
3:21

Personal Experiences Shaping Views on Leaders

Jared shares personal history that influenced his views on leadership.

“It deals with questions that I personally think about all the time.”
5:30

Did Hitler Make a Difference?

Jared analyzes Hitler's impact on history and leadership.

“I worked in Indonesia just after Suharto had finished killing 2 million Indonesians.”
8:08

Genocide and Historical Context

The discussion extends to genocides and their historical significance.

“But there we have the appeal and the weakness of the biographic method.”
10:40

Conversations with Holocaust Deniers

Jared recounts his conversations with Holocaust deniers in Germany.

“But there was no genocide that killed people by industrial scale means.”
12:29

The Role of Churchill in World War II

Discussion on Churchill's crucial role during the early war stages.

“And when I was with German friends who were playing a speech of Hitler that they had recorded, I didn't argue with that because I wanted to understand what Germans thought and said without my objections.”
14:02

The Impact of Leadership in Wartime

Explore how leaders shape outcomes in war compared to peace, focusing on historical figures.

“Hitler said, I will not invade Gibraltar or Malta.”
24:38

Evaluating Historical Leaders: Mussolini and Stalin

Analyze the legacies of Mussolini and Stalin, their policies, and their impacts on society.

“The classic line about Mussolini is, yeah, he was a fascist, but at least he made the trains run on time.”
28:00

Stalin's Speech and Its Impact

Explore how Stalin's speech during the German invasion shaped public perception.

“Hitler's Germany that included an agreement about Poland that let Hitler invade Poland.”
29:40

Mao's Leadership and Economic Change

Discuss the economic transformations in China following Mao's death.

“And that is buttressed not just by biography, but by natural experiments.”
Show all 17 chapters
30:50

JFK's Influence on the Cuban Missile Crisis

Analyze JFK's role during the Cuban Missile Crisis and its aftermath.

“Do you think that anything material or important in American history, in particular, say the Vietnam War, would have been different if JFK had not been assassinated?”
32:40

Lincoln's Assassination and Reconstruction

Consider the implications of Lincoln's assassination on American history.

“If he doesn't get assassinated at the theater, does reconstruction take a different shape?”
34:20

Lee Kuan Yew: The Benign Dictator

Examine Lee Kuan Yew's governance and its impact on Singapore.

“And yes, Lee Kuan Yew is an outstanding example.”
36:20

Margaret Thatcher's Controversial Legacy

Discuss Margaret Thatcher's policies and their lasting effects on Britain.

“he was able to accomplish things that a free-for-all democracy would not have accomplished.”
38:00

Lessons from Sports Coaching

Learn how sports coaching serves as a model for leadership analysis.

“But when the Falkland War broke out, when Argentina invaded the Falklands, the leaders of Britain were disinclined, were afraid to do something.”
41:30

Case Study: Golden State Warriors Coaching Change

Investigate the impact of coaching changes on the Golden State Warriors' performance.

“That's what happens if you don't read my book.”
42:04

The Impact of Coaches on Team Performance

Explore how coaching changes can dramatically influence a sports team's success.

“The Golden State Warriors were, to oversimplify it, they were bad for a long time.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Conversations with Coleman, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Coleman Hughes: Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile, with a message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just$15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three-month plan, equivalent to$15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com. Welcome to another episode of Conversations with Coleman.

0:33Coleman Hughes: My guest today is Jared Diamond. Jared is a scientist, geographer, and best-selling author who spent nearly six decades as a professor at UCLA. He's best known for his 1997 book, Guns, Germs, and Steel, which won a Pulitzer Prize. Jared has a new book called Prophets, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings. That's prophets spelled both ways, once with an F and once with a PH. This book tries to answer a deceptively simple question, do leaders matter? Normally, we try to answer that question by studying leaders, looking at, for instance, presidential biographies. But the problem with that approach is that biographies create a tunnel vision on the leader and his or her life story and therefore tend to exaggerate their impact.

1:21Coleman Hughes: So instead, Jared decided to tackle this question like a scientist, by looking at natural experiments, for instance, cases where a leader suddenly dies. This leads to questions like, would American history be different if Lincoln had survived? What about JFK? How much impact did leaders like Winston Churchill or Lee Kuan Yew have on their respective countries? Along the way, Jared also talks about what it was like to hang out with Nazi apologists as a Jew in post-war Germany. And finally, we talk about whether coaches matter in professional sports. So without further ado, Jared Diamond.

2:06Coleman Hughes: Year-end giving doesn't have to mean making every charitable decision by December 31st. With a donor-advised fund from Jewish Communal Fund, you can make a charitable contribution now, receive the available tax benefits for 2026, and decide which IRS-qualified charities to support over time. For more than 50 years, JCF has helped individuals and families approach philanthropy with greater intention, combining financial expertise, flexibility, and highly personalized service. And unlike a commercial DAF, when you have a question, you'll find real, knowledgeable people ready to help, Often the same people you've come to know and trust over the years.

2:47Coleman Hughes: Open a JCF fund with as little as$5 ,000. Make your year-end contribution by December 31st. Visit jcfny.org slash get started to open your fund today. Jewish Communal Fund. Smart. Impactful giving. Okay, Jared Diamond, thank you so much for coming on my show. Thank you for being with me and inviting me. So your new book is called Prophets, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings. Prophets spelled both ways. It's a fascinating book. It deals with questions that I personally think about all the time. I'm a big reader of biographies, especially presidential biographies. I am a huge fan of basketball, and that will come up in our conversation.

3:34Coleman Hughes: I often think to myself how much coaches matter versus players. And so these are all questions I spend free time thinking about, and your book is like an arrow shot directly at that interest of mine. So I had a great time reading it. And before we get into the specific case studies of when leadership matters, why leaders arise when they do, and how much impact they have, can you tell me what sparked your interest in this particular question?

4:09Jared Diamond: My interest in leaders was sparked ultimately by me being born in 1937, which meant that I grew up in World War II in the shadow of Hitler. Every day, my father had the battle maps posted on the wall of my bedroom so I could see the shifts in the European theater and the Pacific theater. The last of my family in Europe were eliminated by Hitler. I married into a Polish family. My wife's mother survived Auschwitz. My wife's father's father did not survive Auschwitz. And would it have been different if Hitler had died in 1930? You can argue it either way. Biographies of Hitler have argued it either way.

4:59Jared Diamond: Most biographies of Hitler have argued that he made a difference because he was a very distinctive person. But A.J.P. Taylor, the famous British historian, writing a biography of Hitler, using the same facts of Hitler's life, concluded that Hitler was a normal German politician and that he didn't make any difference. So my life has been living under the shadow of this question, did leaders make a difference? And then on top of that, I lived in Chile just before Pinochet. I worked in Indonesia just after Suharto had finished killing 2 million Indonesians. And so the question of leaders, do leaders make a difference, has always been over me.

5:45Coleman Hughes: So let's start there then with World War II. The two leaders that people, I think, well, I mean, actually all four of the big ones, Hitler, Churchill, FDR, and Stalin, you can and have analyzed. But let's start with Hitler and then maybe go to Churchill. So in your studied opinion, did Hitler make a difference to a Germany's decision to go to war, to expand the war to Poland, to carry out the final solution? Or was that all the inevitable result of systemic forces that went back decades?

6:28Jared Diamond: In my studied opinion, Hitler did make a difference, although A.J.P. Taylor, looking at the same facts, concluded that Hitler did not make a difference. Why did I conclude that Hitler did make a difference? He was a very distinctive person in several respects. He was a mesmerizing speaker, possibly the most mesmerizing speaker, unfortunately, of the 20th century in politics. He was a great deceiver, manipulator of people. He's notorious for having deceived Neville Chamberlain at Munich at the time, Munich agreements. But Hitler also deceived German politicians, German generals, German business leaders.

7:12Jared Diamond: Hitler deceived his fellow Nazis. He was a brilliant deceiver. He was a risk taker. He thought that his life was going to be short, and so he wanted to do it quickly. He took big risks, which first he succeeded with. He risked sending German troops into the Rhine land when there was no German border protection. His generals were ready to throw him out if that didn't work. His generals were ready to throw him out at the time of the Munich Agreement, which seemed like a big risk. So those risks paid off. But when he refused to pull the German army back, surrounded a Stalingrad, or when he risked the Battle of the Bulge, those risks did not work.

8:01Jared Diamond: So Hitler was a very distinctive person. And so I think, based on biographies, that he made a difference. But there we have the appeal and the weakness of the biographic method. Biographies are gripping. I love to read them. But unfortunately, they can't bring proof. And that's why I turned eventually to the method of natural experiments, which is not such sexy reading, but which can do statistics and bring more convincing results on the average.

8:32Coleman Hughes: Yeah, I tend to agree with you about Hitler, especially because obviously it is a standard part of the teaching of World War II that the Treaty of Versailles was part of what caused resentment among the German people and created the opportunity for a politician to tap into that genuine resentment and leverage it towards whatever goal he wanted. but the facts of World War II are so anomalous, including the genocide of the Jews, whereas you can think of many examples from history where a state suffers from a bad deal, similar to the Treaty of Versailles, maybe not in specifics, but in the psychology of resentment that it would lead to in the population, yet you don't often see systematic genocides of millions of people.

9:27Coleman Hughes: And so that alone would suggest to me, combined with the unique factors of Hitler's charisma, which he pointed out, a charisma that can now be seen. I don't know if you've seen the AI videos of Hitler translated into English, but in the same tone. So now if you don't speak German, you can sort of see the level of charisma that he had. So combined, I would tend to agree with you about Hitler.

9:52Jared Diamond: I agree with you. I would add to that that I lived in Germany. I'm fluent in German. My German friends, without knowing that I was Jewish, played for me recordings of Hitler's speeches. So I experienced secondhand Hitler. On top of that, I agree with you that the Treaty of Versailles and the 1923 hyperinflation that destroyed Germany's middle class made it likely that the goal of any German leader would be to reverse the Treaty of Versailles. But there were German leaders like Streisand. Of course they tried to reverse the Treaty of Versailles, but they tried to do it peacefully, not necessarily by war.

10:36Jared Diamond: On top of that, you're right that there have been genocides that killed lots of people. But there was no genocide that killed people by industrial scale means. When Suharto killed two million Indonesians, it was with clubs and sticks, not in this efficient way with gas.

10:55Coleman Hughes: So you mentioned in passing in the book that when living in Germany, you spoke with Holocaust deniers. And I'm curious what those conversations were like, because what does a Holocaust denier say to someone who's had family in the Holocaust?

11:13Jared Diamond: I'll tell you a memorable conversation. In Germany, I didn't tell people that I was, when I was living in Germany, I didn't tell people that I was Jewish because I wanted to hear what they had to say, frankly. One evening, I'm a pianist. I was visiting my German cellist, an elderly woman, in her apartment with her husband. And we were playing a Strauss cellist and Otter. And then her husband, after we played music, her husband began talking. And somehow, spontaneously, he brought up the question of the Holocaust. And he said, the Holocaust, the biggest—this is in German—the biggest lie ever told.

11:53Jared Diamond: They say that six million Jews were killed. Well, today, there are six million Jews in Europe. Do you mean to say that that people multiplied so fast in German? They reproduced so quickly that six million of them were killed, and today there are already another six million of them. That's my conversation with a German Holocaust denier.

12:26Coleman Hughes: What do you say back to that?

12:28Jared Diamond: Oh, I did not argue with him because I wanted to hear what he had to say. And when I was with German friends who were playing a speech of Hitler that they had recorded, I didn't argue with that because I wanted to understand what Germans thought and said without my objections.

12:55Coleman Hughes: I see, yeah. So let's talk about Churchill. I recently saw a video of one of Churchill's most famous, maybe his most famous biographer, Andrew Roberts, speculating what would have happened in World War II if Churchill had not become prime minister. If England had made some sort of peace with Hitler and Hitler was able to focus all of his forces in the East. what do you think uh how important do you think churchill was to the result of world war ii

13:32Jared Diamond: crucial at so many stages and let's start start with the first stage with when hit when churchill had just been appointed prime minister this was the week of dunkirk and so the british war cabinet But five people met. On the war cabinet was Lord Halifax, the foreign minister. And Hitler had offered England a deal. Hitler said, I will not invade Gibraltar or Malta. And I will promise not to invade you if you will allow me a free hand in Europe. To us, it's unbelievable. But Lord Halifax and the rest, Lord Halifax was especially in favor of accepting Hitler's proposal. And the other members of the war cabinet were initially going to go along with Lord Halifax.

14:30Jared Diamond: Churchill asked Lord Halifax to join him for a stroll in the garden. They had a conversation with the garden, in the garden, when Churchill argued against it. The meeting of the War Cabinet went on for four days, but it took Churchill four days to convince Lord Halifax and his own War Cabinet not to make a deal with Hitler, giving Hitler Gibraltar and Malta. In retrospect, we know that that would have been a disaster for England, cutting off the Mediterranean. And if England had suffered a disaster, the United States would not have had a toehold in Europe. Hitler would have had his entire force to apply against Russia.

15:12Jared Diamond: So the result probably would be that Hitler would have been left in command of the European continent. That's my reading. But that was just the first thing that Churchill did. He did so many other things. He took the risk of sending 200 tanks around Africa to Suez, tanks that were crucial in maintaining the British position in North Africa. Again and again, sometimes he made mistakes, but usually he made wise decisions, partly because of his own military background and partly because he had read enormously and he had thought a lot about war and about peace.

15:49Coleman Hughes: Is it the case that in times of war, the specific leader you have matters much more than in times of peace?

15:58Jared Diamond: Yes. Yes, in times of war, the leader makes more difference than in times of peace because in times of war, even a democratic leader is granted more power. Roosevelt and Churchill were granted more power by their parliaments and Congress in time of war. So on the one hand, leaders are given more power in times of war. On the other hand, dictators in war are less unlikely to seek an end to the war because they suspect that they're going to get killed, as in fact happened to Mussolini and happened to Gaddafi. So, yes, it is true that leaders have more power in wartime than in peacetime.

16:47Coleman Hughes: Can you talk about how your method of study in this book, which was natural experiments, is different than the typical method of determining whether a leader was important?

17:00Jared Diamond: It's completely different. The typical method, history comes from the humanities. It doesn't come from the discipline of history. It doesn't come from the physical sciences. And so the typical method, which I love, is the biographic method, and it's great reading. But it does not let you draw objective conclusions, and it doesn't let you do statistics. The method of natural experiments, there are so many disciplines. There are disciplines where we can do experiments in the laboratory manipulating things. We change a test tube, and we maintain a test tube as a control. That's possible and great for physics, chemistry, and molecular biology.

17:43Jared Diamond: But in other fields, one can't do manipulative experiments. In astronomy, we can't turn stars on and off. In geology, we can't melt and then we freeze glaciers. In my work on birds, I'm not permitted to exterminate bird populations and then bring them back again. We have to find another method, and that method is the method of natural experiments. That method is that stars do disappear and they come back again. glaciers do melt and they freeze again. Bird populations do die out without jar and diamond killing them. So in many fields, in epidemiology and medicine, we learn by seeing what happens when nature does or doesn't do something, and we can make that comparison.

18:33Jared Diamond: That's the method of natural experiments, which is the only method available to us in geology, astronomy, epidemiology, and much of field biology.

18:45Coleman Hughes: My favorite natural experiments often come from the placement of an arbitrary political border between two populations. One was, I mean, one really interesting study that was looking at the effect of slavery on the economy of the United States studied the border between Ohio and Kentucky and looked at the land immediately on either side of the Ohio River on that border because the soil was very similar, the people were very similar. Really, the only difference was that one was a slave state and one was a free state. And so it offers an opportunity for someone looking back to say, well, what was the effect of slavery on all kinds of downstream aspects of society?

19:31Coleman Hughes: And so in the case of political leaders, you're mainly looking at assassinations, is that right, as the natural experiment?

19:40Jared Diamond: It's much broader than that. The first of, historically, the first of these natural experiments carried out on leaders was not assassinations, but it was said natural deaths. Leaders sometimes die natural deaths. They die of heart disease or cancer. Prime Minister Harold Holt of Australia drowned in the ocean. The prime minister of Iceland was burnt to death in a fire. another fell off a horse. But most prime ministers do not fall off horses or get burnt in a fire. They survive. And so you can compare. You look at all the leaders since World War II, and when the study was done, there were about 212 to look at, and 57 of them had died natural deaths, and the other 155 had not died natural deaths.

20:27Jared Diamond: You can compare and look at whether the economy got better or worse or stayed the same when a leader died a natural death, and whether war broke out or didn't break out when a leader died a natural death. That's the method of natural experiments. And the border example that you mentioned, it's a great example because there are other border examples. Yes, there's the border between slave and non-slave states, but there's the border between East Germany and West Germany. There's the border between South and North Korea. I just returned from Korea, where I was invited by the Korean Ministry of Unification in South Korea, which is trying to establish a rapport with North Korea.

21:09Jared Diamond: But the border, the Koreans were one people until inviting 1945, and the geography of the North and South is pretty much the same. And yet that border has made like a 50-fold difference in standard of living. So yeah, borders are a great natural experiment.

21:26Coleman Hughes: Yeah. So what about FDR? Is the fact that FDR died and Truman took over at all helpful in assessing the legacy of FDR and his importance to the outcome of World War II? Yes.

21:44Jared Diamond: FDR is doubly useful for understanding the role of leaders. One can ask, under what circumstances does a leader have the biggest effect? And look, the leader has a bigger effect when the leader has more power, et cetera, et cetera. But also, a leader can have the biggest effect when the leader gets his or her followers to do something that they did not want to do. And the two prime examples of that are that the American people in the 1930s did not want to prepare for World War II, but Roosevelt got the American people against their will to prepare for World War II, thank God. And another example, Charles de Gaulle in 1958, there was no way that the French wanted to abandon their colony of Algeria, which was basically a state of France.

22:39Jared Diamond: But de Gaulle recognized that the French were losing and could never win the civil war in Algeria. So de Gaulle cunningly gradually got the French people step by step to give up their insistence on holding on to Algeria. So, in short, one way that a leader can make a big difference is by getting people to do something that they don't want to do but that is good for them. And Roosevelt did that.

23:08Coleman Hughes: Year-end giving doesn't have to mean making every charitable decision by December 31st. With a donor-advised fund from Jewish Communal Fund, you can make a charitable contribution now, receive the available tax benefits for 2026, and decide which IRS-qualified charities to support over time. For more than 50 years, JCF has helped individuals and families approach philanthropy with greater intention, combining financial expertise, flexibility, and highly personalized service. And unlike a commercial DAF, when you have a question, you'll find real, knowledgeable people ready to help, often the same people you've come to know and trust over the years.

23:49Coleman Hughes: Open a JCF fund with as little as$5 ,000. Make your year-end contribution by December 31st. Visit jcfny.org slash get started to open your fund today. Jewish Communal Fund. Smart. Impactful giving.

24:06Jared Diamond: Traditional home security only alerts you after a break-in, and that's too late. SimpliSafe is changing that.

24:13Coleman Hughes: Stop. This is SimpliSafe. Police are on the way.

24:15Jared Diamond: We don't just alert. We help stop crime before it starts. Plans starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 60 % off your new system with professional monitoring at SimpliSafe.com slash Spotify.

24:28Coleman Hughes: SimpliSafe, ahead of crime in real time. Outdoor deterrence plans start at$49.99 a month. Visit SimpliSafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information. Okay, tell me about Mussolini. The classic line about Mussolini is, yeah, he was a fascist, but at least he made the trains run on time. Hey, did he make the trains run on time? And tell me about his wider impact.

24:52Jared Diamond: Sure. Italy is the foreign country in which I've spent the most time, and the Italian language is the language that I've spent the most time speaking in the last decade. I've taught at Italy's social science university in Rome for the last 15 years. So, yeah, I have some understanding of Italy. Yes, Mussolini did make the trains run on time. He did it by some rather strong measures, such as killing railroad employees who contributed to the trains not running that time. The other thing that—the second thing that Italians are most pleased about Mussolini is that he drained the marshes near Rome, and he made them productive, and he got rid of malaria.

25:37Jared Diamond: So Mussolini had achievements. The reason that Mussolini came to power was that the Italian democratic government after World War I had broken down and was not balancing the budget and was not satisfying Italians. So Mussolini, like Hitler, came to power deceptively and then he established a dictatorship. Today, my understanding is that the prime minister of Italy today, Maloney, she's regarded as being in a neo-fascist party. She doesn't speak openly of Mussolini, but she doesn't speak of condemning Mussolini. And there are Italians, there still are Italians today, who are sympathetic with Mussolini.

26:29Coleman Hughes: what about stalin i mean would the soviet union be different if and i guess you can extend that question to would russia be any different today if it hadn't been stalin to take control of the party in in the late 20s if it had been say trotsky or someone like that again with the

26:48Jared Diamond: biographic method who knows but i one can make an make an argument and i would agree that that Stalin, like Hitler and Mussolini, was a leader who made a difference, both for the good and for the bad. Without Stalin, there would not have been 35 million Ukrainians who starved to death as a result of government policy in the 1930s. Without Stalin, the Russian army would not have been undermined by trials, including the execution of Marshal Tukhachevsky, the highest ranking general in the Russian army. And the result was that when Russia invaded Finland in 1939, tiny Finland, the Finns held off the Russian army for half a year because Stalin had so undermined the Russian army.

27:41Jared Diamond: Those are negative effects of Stalin, but positive effects of Stalin when Hitler invaded Russia on June 21, 1941. Stalin had a big problem because Stalin's government had an alliance with Hitler's Germany that included an agreement about Poland that let Hitler invade Poland. And so when Germany invaded Russia, that looked bad for Stalin. Russian people were prepared to denounce Stalin for having made this possible. But Stalin gave a speech. Again, Russian is one of my languages. I read Stalin's first radio speech after the German invasion of Russia. It was a brilliant speech of refuting charges.

28:42Jared Diamond: If anybody accuses you of doing something, read Stalin's speech because it's brilliant. Stalin began by stating the charge in the strongest terms possible. Isn't it true that you made an alliance with Hitler and made it possible for Hitler to invade us? And Stalin's response was, kineshten yet? Of course not. And then Stalin refuted it. Then he went on to the next charge. But isn't it true that, again, stated in the clearest form possible? Again, Stalin's response, conjecture of cure? Of course not. So Stalin stated the complaints against him in the most convincing form possible, but he then refuted them one after another.

29:25Jared Diamond: That was a great achievement of Stalin.

29:30Coleman Hughes: What about Mao Zedong? That seems like one of the clearest cases where the death of a leader just transformed a country overnight. Is that right? That is true.

29:40Jared Diamond: And that is buttressed not just by biography, but by natural experiments. We can look at the different leaders of China in the last 50 years, and the economy has gone up and down, and other things have gone up and down. And upon the death of Mao, So within a few years of the death of Mao, the Chinese economy soared. And so one could say at least coincident with Mao's death, things got better in China.

30:18Coleman Hughes: But there's an easy causal story to tell there too, right? About essentially the end of a communist or a command economy, right? If not a communist political system entirely, right?

30:34Jared Diamond: Yes, that fact, that numerical fact can be fleshed out with facts. And yes, the prevalent view is that Mao was bad for the Chinese economy and for many other features of China. But natural experiments, namely comparing the ups and downs with different Chinese leaders, allow us to put a number on it.

30:57Coleman Hughes: Do you think that anything material or important in American history, in particular, say the Vietnam War, would have been different if JFK had not been assassinated? Right.

31:12Jared Diamond: The clearest effect of JFK leaving aside the Vietnam War, the clearest achievement of JFK was the Cuban Missile Crisis. So I was alive and I heard the presidential speech at a dinner when JFK announced the Cuban Missile Crisis. And for six days, we were closer to nuclear war than we ever have, than the world has ever been in history. After the missile crisis, we learned, in fact, how close we were. There was a moment when a Russian submarine commander wanted to launch a nuclear missile. He was overpowered by his own crew. JFK handled that brilliantly. It was an outstanding example of how a leader can guide discussion.

32:02Jared Diamond: JFK made a point of walking out of the room periodically and allowing his advisors to have a discussion among themselves so that his presence would not inhibit them. And so they could say whatever they want and then eventually would come back to the room. And that allowed his advisors to come up with all sorts of ideas, including ideas, particularly Bobby Kennedy's idea, that produced a successful end to the Cuban Missile Crisis. So I would say that in retrospect, that perhaps is the biggest decisive single achievement of JFK. The Vietnam War, who knows? We don't have the controlled experiment.

32:42Coleman Hughes: What about Abraham Lincoln? If he doesn't get assassinated at the theater, does reconstruction take a different shape? Do the next 100 years of Jim Crow in the South take a different shape? Very likely.

33:00Jared Diamond: Again, we don't have the controlled experiments, so I can't prove it. But by the biographic method, Lincoln was a very skilled politician. politician, like de Gaulle and like Roosevelt. He got people to do things that they did not want to do. And my guess is that if Lincoln had not been assassinated, the period after the Civil War would not have been as unhappy a period as it was at least for the remainder of Lincoln's term in morphous.

33:36Coleman Hughes: The case of Lee Kuan Yew is an interesting one for, especially for an American to think about because it's so deeply in our political DNA to dislike the idea of a dictator and to doubt the idea that it's possible to have a benign autocrat. But the case of Lee Kuan Yew, I mean, you know, I don't know much about him, but I know anytime I talk to someone from Singapore, they have almost only good things to say about what he did for the country. So I guess two questions here. One, is there such a thing as a benign dictator? And was Lee Kuan Yew that?

34:19Jared Diamond: Yes, of course, there are benign dictators, just as there are benign democratic presidents and there are evil democratic presidents. And yes, Lee Kuan Yew is an outstanding example. Lee Kuan Yew was the founding prime minister of Singapore. Singapore did not seek independence. Singapore was expelled from Malaysia. And when Singapore became independent, Singapore had big problems, a tiny statelet, risk of invasion by Indonesia and by Malaysia, no armed forces of its own, ethnic polarization between Chinese and Malays. Lee Kuan Yew trained as an economist. He recognized that if he let anybody open their mouth and say anything that they wanted, then Singapore would quickly be occupied by Indonesia and Malaysia.

35:12Jared Diamond: A free-for-all democracy was not going to work in Singapore. He had the trappings of a democracy. In some respects, Singapore was democratic. He was very successful in that Singapore rather quickly became a first world state. But I visited Singapore for the first time in 1979, a decade or so after its independence. And it was a joke that people said in Singapore, not only does the government tell you not to have standing water in your apartment, which breeds mosquitoes, which produce malaria, that's a good idea. But the government also tells you floss your teeth. The government intervened in detail into the lives of citizens.

36:02Jared Diamond: One can argue that certainly the result is that Singapore is a prosperous, still peaceful country today. Thanks to Lee Kuan Yew, who was nominally democratic but had the trappings of a benign dictator, he was able to accomplish things that a free-for-all democracy would not have accomplished. And he stepped down voluntarily of the major leaders of the world since World War II. Interestingly, there were only two who stepped down voluntarily, Nelson Mandela and Lee Kuan Yew. All others were voted out of office or they died. Evidently, once you have succeeded in high office and have gotten a good impression of yourself, good opinion of yourself, you are not likely to change that opinion and step down, except in the case of Lee Kuan Yew and Nelson Mandela.

37:03Coleman Hughes: I believe there was Jerry Rawlings of Ghana might be a third example with an asterisk, because he was a dictator and then he was elected and then he chose not to run, but he could have, he kind of chose to turn Ghana into a democracy. So in spirit, similar, but maybe not technically quite the same. And people in Ghana similarly speak of him similarly as Lee Konyu in some ways. I want to ask you about Margaret Thatcher. How impactful was she?

37:35Jared Diamond: Margaret Thatcher, again, the biographic method. But I believe a strong argument can be made that she made a difference. British people today are divided between those who admire what she did and who hate what she did. But virtually everybody agrees that she made a difference. She came after a series of prime ministers who were waffling and indecisive and didn't take strong positions. But when the Falkland War broke out, when Argentina invaded the Falklands, the leaders of Britain were disinclined, were afraid to do something. Margaret Thatcher took a strong point of view, and it was a risk. She sent out a British fleet, a tiny British fleet, all the way across the Atlantic Ocean.

38:29Jared Diamond: big risk, and they prevailed in the Falkland War, although we could have lost. Again, Margaret Thatcher came down strongly against exaggerated demands on the part of British unions. She had the courage to do it. There were people who hated her for it, and she had gone too far, but it was necessary. So I would say, and I'd say most, virtually all British people would say, Margaret Thatcher made a difference, whether for good or for bad.

38:59Coleman Hughes: So the final thing I want to ask you about is the case of sports coaches. And in the book, you know, obviously we're talking about politics and religious leaders in the book, which we haven't covered here. But you defend sports coaches as a particularly useful example of how to study this phenomenon, even though sports is the realm of entertainment rather than the movers and shakers of all of human life. Why are sports coaches such a good example? And can you tell me about the UCLA basketball coach that you chose to analyze in this book?

39:35Jared Diamond: Sure. Sports is a wonderful case to analyze, particularly for professors in business schools, because sports are so transparent compared to business. In business, results may or may not be announced, the executive may and may not be a public figure. Whereas in sports, a game is played every week or twice a week, and there's a league of 25 teams all with the same number of players doing the same things. There are neat comparisons that you never get in the business world. So business school leaders trying to understand whether a business executive, a CEO, makes a difference, have worked out their methods, especially by looking at sports coaches.

40:20Jared Diamond: An example is the great coach of my basketball team, John Wooden. But I want to give you one example. Because the coach of the Argentinian soccer team had not read my book at the time of the recent World Cup, Argentina lost that game against Spain. And if the coach had read my book, the coach would have known that the most important things that a soccer or football player, a coach can do is not teaching his players to dribble, which they know anyway, but getting them not to commit errors or penalties or fumbles. and the reason that Argentina lost was that all the yellow cards were against Argentina.

41:07Jared Diamond: None were against Spain because the Argentinian coach hadn't taught his players not to behave. Yes, the Argentinian coach, if he had been able to read my book, would have learned that the most important thing that he could have taught his players was not to incur penalties. but since he did incur penalties, Argentina got a red card and lost the game against Spain. That's what happens if you don't read my book.

41:35Coleman Hughes: Well, my fans will not be making that mistake. Before I let you go, I want to ask, have you looked at the case of the Golden State Warriors' decision to change coaches from Mark Jackson to Steve Kerr?

41:48Jared Diamond: No, I have not looked at that case and I would defer to your opinion on it.

41:54Coleman Hughes: So I implore you to look at this because it's such an interesting question for the set of analytical tools you're using in this book. The Golden State Warriors were, to oversimplify it, they were bad for a long time. Then they hired this coach, Mark Jackson. They became better than average, but not amazing. In the third year of Mark Jackson, they had a bad playoff result. So the owners fired Mark Jackson and the players almost mutinied. They signed a letter testifying to their faith in this coach that the coach was not the problem with the team. They fired the coach anyway. They ignored the letter.

42:35Coleman Hughes: They hired Steve Kerr. Immediately became basically the best team in the league. the following year the second year of Steve Kerr Steve Kerr gets a gets a like a surgery he has a horrible health issue so he is missing in action for the entire first half of the season and then he comes back only in the second half of the season right so in the first half of the season the Warriors go on had to have the best record any NBA team has ever had right and in the second half of the season, the same result. That season is the best season of basketball that's ever been played by an NBA team, better than Michael Jordan's 90s Bulls.

43:19Coleman Hughes: And so there are various questions. A, like, did Steve Kerr improve the team over Mark Jackson? If the answer to that is yes, it means that all the players who knew the most had bad judgment, actually, and the owners actually had the correct judgment, which is interesting in itself. If it's not the case, then that's also interesting because it's an example of like a false signal. And then there's this other natural experiment of if he was the secret, then why did it still work the second year when he was gone for half of the season? Maybe it's the case that like a sports coach can like set the strategy and set it and forget it and can leave the room and his impact is still felt.

44:04Coleman Hughes: In any case, it's a really rich example for you to look at.

44:10Jared Diamond: It's a great example. My first thought is that coaches make a difference, but they're not 100 % of the explanation. They're 30 % of the explanation. And so in your case, in that first half of the year, maybe something else happened. A coach is not omnipotent, but good coaches like John Wooden. So John Wooden didn't do well for the first 14 years, and then he did well thereafter. Interestingly, my university, UCLA, we fired all of our basketball coaches since John Wooden, although their winning records have been 60 or 70 percent, with which any university other of them in UCLA would have been thrilled, but we expect everybody to be equal to John Wooden, and that's impossible.

44:56Jared Diamond: So we fired coach after coach with the result that UCLA is now$150 million of debt in its athletic department because of him having to buy out all these contracts. Again, my chancellor should have read my book.

45:09Coleman Hughes: All right. Thank you so much, Jared Diamond. Everyone should go purchase the book. It's Profits, Profits, Coaches, and Kings. Thank you so much, Jared. Hey, Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now, I don't know if you've heard, but Mint's premium wireless is$15 a month. But I'd like to offer one other perk. We have no stores. That means no small talk.

45:34Jared Diamond: Crazy weather we're having. No, it's not. It's just weather. It is an introvert's dream.

45:39Coleman Hughes: Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three-month plan,$15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See MintMobile.com.

From the publisher

Did any single man change the course of the 20th century? Jared Diamond, the Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies, says the biographies can’t answer that, but the data can. He walks us through Winston Churchill’s dayslong fight to keep Britain in the war, Lee Kuan Yew’s Singapore, John F. Kennedy’s brinkmanship in Cuba, and Joseph Stalin’s response to Adolf Hitler’s invasion. Then he explains why basketball coaches are the best laboratory we have for measuring what a leader really changes.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Conversations with Coleman

All episodes