1. Podcasts
  2. Conversations with Coleman
  3. Mark Manson: Self-Help for People Who Hate Self-Help
Conversations with Coleman

2 Nov 2026 · 1h 21m · 29 chapters

Episode artwork

Mark Manson: Self-Help for People Who Hate Self-Help

In short

Mark Manson critiques conventional “self-help,” arguing that many modern mental-health ideas are rebranded ancient philosophy. He explains his “self-help for people who hate self-help” approach: stop chasing happiness, expect suffering, manage anxiety by reducing optionality, and pursue meaning/purpose instead of feeling good. He also discusses paradox of choice, stoicism’s resurgence, and dating across political differences.

Guest backgrounds

Mark Manson is a three-time New York Times best-selling author. His books have sold 20+ million copies worldwide; he’s best known for The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck. He previously worked as a dating/relationship coach and blogger, including writing Model (attracting women through honesty). He has drawn on Buddhism, Nietzsche, Kant, and existentialism.

Key claims

Happiness is overrated and largely baseline/genetic; emotions like anxiety and depression can be functional. Anxiety is tied to modern information overload and excessive choice (Kierkegaard’s “present age”). Conventional self-help often offers “band-aids” (e.g., affirmations) rather than core agency/responsibility.

Notable examples

“Fuck yes or no” decision rule; pickup artistry as often formulaic/inauthentic; war as an “anxiety-free” emergency; veterans returning home feeling less clarity; dating/politics first-date dilemma.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Making Decisions in Life

A humorous take on the decisions we make in life, from bad purchases to good choices.

“Sometimes you make questionable ones, like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall because the electronics store employee was a little too good at their job.”
1:45

The Journey to Writing

Mark Manson shares his journey and motivation for writing 'The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck'.

1:59

Philosophy and Happiness

Discussion on how ancient philosophy relates to modern mental health concepts.

“Year-end is the most important time for charitable giving.”
3:00

Critique of Self-Help

Mark discusses the shortcomings of conventional self-help advice and the rise of stoicism.

“So I read The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck when I was an undergrad, probably a freshman.”
4:52

The 'Fuck Yes or No' Principle

Mark explains the principle of making decisions based on genuine desire rather than social pressure.

“I kind of wanted to just disrupt the self-help market very intentionally.”
7:01

From Dating Coach to Author

Mark discusses his evolution from a dating coach to a bestselling author and his thoughts on pickup artistry.

“Not attractive enough or not not not confident enough not secure enough.”
9:35

Authenticity in Attraction

The importance of honesty and authenticity in dating and relationships is explored.

“Like, I don't, I don't really want to deal with it.”
12:00

The Reality of Pickup Artists

Mark shares insights about the pickup artist community and the misconceptions surrounding it.

“And I think a lot of those guys experienced that had kind of the fallout from that and then moved on.”
14:01

Understanding the Pickup Artist Subculture

Explore the misconceptions and reality of the pickup artist community and its origins.

“is, you know, I used to deal with a lot of guys from that world.”
17:00

The Mark Manson Approach to Self-Help

Learn about Mark Manson's unique approach to self-help that challenges conventional wisdom.

“i i would say my audience it tends to be uh more educated people more skeptical people um I Get a lot of people who Who were never interested in it?”
Show all 29 chapters
19:33

The Science Behind Affirmations and Happiness

Discover the research on affirmations and how they impact different individuals' self-perception.

“But it is interesting if you look at research on things like affirmations.”
21:27

Genetics and Happiness

Examine the role of genetics in determining baseline happiness and emotional responses.

“Who's who's who's always saying and Perkins, you know, like, he's just like, happy, happy all the time.”
22:42

Rethinking Happiness

Understand why the pursuit of constant happiness may not be beneficial and the value of negative emotions.

24:03

Anxiety in Context: A Double-Edged Sword

Delve into the complex nature of anxiety and how it can be both a problem and a functional emotion.

“But it's also if something is going wrong in your life, like it is likely that if you wait long enough, you'll kind of return to baseline.”
28:00

Understanding Anxiety in the Modern Age

Explore the complexities of anxiety as a prevalent emotion in today's society.

“It is a, I think, a hidden side effect or a hidden tax of introducing opportunity into people's lives.”
38:13

Philosophical Adaptation to Modern Choices

Discuss the need for a philosophy that suits the modern individual's choices and challenges.

“Whereas we live in an individualist culture where a lot of people don't, you know, live near their grandparents.”
42:04

Exploring Buddhism's Influence on Philosophy

Learn about the speaker's journey into Buddhism and its impact on their worldview.

“and Buddhism when I was younger and then very, I would say when I got older, very inspired by existentialism.”
43:41

Personal Journey Through Religion and Spirituality

Discover the speaker's transition from Christianity to Buddhism and the quest for understanding through psychedelics.

“Got into Buddhism as a teenager So I grew up in the Bible Belt, so I got a lot of Jesus growing up and it's funny because you know when I was young I was kind of resentful of that.”
46:26

The Reality of Suffering in Buddhism

Understand how Buddhism addresses suffering and the misconceptions about achieving bliss.

“I was reading a lot of kind of conventional self-help wisdom.”
48:32

The Evolutionary Perspective on Happiness

Explore how evolutionary psychology shapes our understanding of happiness and dissatisfaction.

“I mean, obviously you can go, there's actually a list on Wikipedia of the people confirmed to have the most offspring in the history of humanity.”
52:42

Existentialism and the Search for Meaning

Examine existentialism's core tenets and the importance of creating personal meaning and responsibility.

“So this raises the point of like, okay, what is a good life then?”
56:00

Navigating Political Conversations on Dates

Learn how to handle political discussions during dating situations.

“responsibility for our own lives and and our responsibility to make our own choices And it is those narratives, all of those excuses that generate the most amount of suffering.”
57:50

Delaying Political Discussions

Discover the strategy of postponing political dialogues until a connection is formed.

“I should preface this by saying I have not been single in 15 years.”
1:01:08

Nietzsche and the Need for Personal Responsibility

Explore Nietzsche's views on personal agency in a modern context.

“I feel like he doesn't get such a good rap these days.”
1:04:53

Kant's Moral Framework and Responsibility

Understand Kant's perspective on personal accountability as a moral obligation.

“kant i love kant that's interesting that's so interesting which is funny because like The other like I would not predict that Nietzsche just shit all over Kant.”
1:08:10

The Relevance of News in Personal Philosophy

Analyze the significance of news consumption in light of personal values and attention.

“I'm curious how politics, what politics flow from, from your, um, personal philosophy.”
1:10:02

The Impact of News Consumption

Explore how news often misdirects attention from local issues to global outrage.

“And then I think there's probably a broader philosophical argument as well.”
1:13:34

Reflections on Will Smith and the Oscars Incident

Mark Manson discusses his insights on Will Smith's behavior and personal struggles.

“Okay, two more questions before I let you go.”
1:17:50

Mark Manson's New Venture: Purpose AI

Learn about Manson's AI company aimed at challenging users for personal growth.

A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Conversations with Coleman, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Life is all about making decisions. Sometimes you make questionable ones, like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall because the electronics store employee was a little too good at their job. Then, sometimes you make great ones, like protecting your home and auto with Progressive. You get customized coverage options, so you can be sure you have the right coverage. Get your quote today at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers, not available in all states.

0:30Coleman Hughes: Welcome to another episode of Conversations with Coleman. My guest today is Mark Manson. Mark is a three-time New York Times best-selling author, best known for The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck, a book that I read in college and loved. His books have sold over 20 million copies worldwide. Now, I hesitate to call Mark a self-help author because he is so substantive compared to most of the slop that gets marketed as self-help. But in this episode, we discuss whether much of what we now call mental health is really an ancient philosophical problem, how to live a good life, that we've re-described in the language of therapy.

1:08Coleman Hughes: We explore the shortcomings of conventional self-help, the revival of stoicism as popularized by writers like Ryan Holiday, who has also been on this show. We talk about the paradox of choice. We talk about whether happiness is really the right goal to pursue in life. We also discuss Mark's early involvement in pickup artistry. We talk about what he's learned from Buddhism, Nietzsche, and Kant. And finally, we talk about how to approach dating across the political aisle. I was really impressed by Mark, and I think you will be too. If your life feels messed up or out of order, Mark is the kind of guy that can actually set you straight.

1:45Coleman Hughes: So without further ado, Mark Manson.

1:55This episode is brought to you by Jewish Communal Fund. Year-end is the most important time for charitable giving. With the JCF Donor Advised Fund, you can set aside funds for charity now, receive the available tax benefits, and decide where and when to give over time. JCF combines financial expertise with highly personalized service to help you approach your philanthropy with confidence and purpose. Open a fund with as little as$5 ,000, then recommend grants to IRS-qualified charities supporting the causes and communities that matter to you. And when you have a question, you can speak directly with knowledgeable JCF team members who understand philanthropy and take the time to understand your goals.

2:43Make this the year you give more strategically. Open your JCF fund by December 31st at jcfny.org slash get started. Jewish Communal Fund. Smart, impactful giving.

3:00Coleman Hughes: Okay, Mark Manson, thanks so much for coming on my show. Thanks for having me. It's good to be here. So I read The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck when I was an undergrad, probably a freshman. that's probably about 10 years ago, which I think is when it came out. And I remember it being really useful. It really appealed to me. I told a lot of my friends about it. The one thing I remember from it 10 years after was you had this phrase, fuck yes or no. Yeah. And what that meant is if it's not a fuck yes, right? Somebody comes to you with an opportunity, if an idea, if it's not a fuck yes, it's a no.

3:39Coleman Hughes: And that was really helpful for me because I, I was someone and still am someone who's in the habit of wanting to say yes to people that come to me with asks. Right. And, you know, as you get more successful in your career and meet more people, the number of asks increase. And the ability to sort of like stay in your framework about, you know, just to not react and to think about what are my goals? Does this really excite me? Or am I saying this out of a social programming to please those around me and to not be negative and to not be a naysayer and all that. And that was really helpful to me.

4:26Coleman Hughes: And I used that. And I still think about that to this day. Talk to me a little bit about what went into writing that book. And we're going to get into everything else you're doing now and what you did before. We're going to try to do a comprehensive interview on Mark Manson. Sure. Right. Okay. So, But let's start with that book. What was the original inspiration for that? The original inspiration was really... I kind of wanted to just disrupt the self-help market very intentionally. I grew up consuming a lot of self-help content from the 90s. My parents were very into it. So I was exposed to Oprah and Tony Robbins growing up.

5:12And I read all the books. I read Dale Carnegie and Think and Grow Rich. And by the time I was kind of in my mid-20s, like a lot of the advice was useful. But I think like most millennials, I was kind of a little bit disenchanted with the world. And I realized that a lot of the advice was kind of empty and very superficial. And even though I had like achieved a lot of my goals and dreams, it didn't make me happier. It didn't make me feel more fulfilled. It didn't make me feel like my life was fuller or more meaningful. And so it kind of set me down this path of reinvestigating a lot of the philosophy that I hadn't really paid attention to since I had been in college.

5:58and I started discovering like just such a much deeper reservoir of ideas around like what is happiness, what is fulfillment, what is the role of suffering in life, is it inevitable and I was very inspired by a lot of Buddhism, a lot of Stoicism, a lot of Aristotle and and I at the time I was blogging pretty regularly. I was I started out as a dating and relationship relationships coach and blogger and uh i imagine we'll come back to that later on but i started to note i started to kind of write more general life advice because what i had discovered through years of coaching people through dating relationship issues is that there's not really such a thing as a dating or relationship issue like every issue is a personal issue right like if you can't Get people to call you back.

6:56It's not because you're not texting the right thing. It's because you are showing up as a person who was just Not attractive enough or not not not confident enough not secure enough. You're not communicating well enough So I started writing about these kind of broader topics and I started taking a lot of control like intentional contrarian takes, you know killing a lot of self-help sacred cows So like happiness is overrated, right? There are plenty of great reasons to do things that don't necessarily make you happy. You shouldn't always think positive. Sometimes you have to think about the downsides or the negatives of a situation.

7:34You have to consider drawbacks. Failure and embarrassment are a completely normal part of life. You shouldn't try to be immune to those things. You should just try to get good at managing them and handling them when they do happen. And it was funny because it clearly struck a chord in the culture because my website and my blog at the time, this was pretty sub-stack. I mean, it just blew up and became pretty massive. And so pretty soon agents and editors started reaching out to me about doing a book. And I met my agent that way. She just cold emailed me. And I guess the rest is history.

8:17Coleman Hughes: um so you mentioned that you started first as a relationship coach and you had a book called model about attracting women through honesty yeah now i'm i'm i'm i don't know if i actually ever knew about this book when i was in college but i know it would have been really appealing to me because obviously i was trying to date and i you know there's this whole trend of pickup artistry at the time. And, you know, I want to hear your thoughts on that. You know, at the time I was totally turned off by pickup artistry because it felt formulaic. I knew the moment, you know, if I ever tried to do it, I would just feel false.

8:57Coleman Hughes: Right. And what's the point of getting a woman to like you if you feel false internally the whole time? Yeah. Surely not every guy has the same circuitry that they do feel false maybe some people it just doesn't matter how you how you get what you want to get but if you get it you just feel the same i was never that way so the idea of leaning into honesty and having that be the source of your attraction which does work yeah um would have been really appealing to me uh what what did was that book a reaction to the pickup artistry trend it was 100 so I when I started writing and publishing online the the first kind of content that started to get traction was I mean back then you start by writing what you know right so in at the time I was a single guy in my 20s just kind of like stumbling through a bunch of relationships and so I started writing about those experiences and some of the girls I was dating and some of the the parties that I was going to and I attracted a lot of young men from that crowd and those men started asking me a lot of questions and and I would give them my best answer and then they would immediately reply with like well that's not what the pickup artists say the pickup artists say that I should be you know wearing a top hat and doing a magic trick and Nagging her and uh, and like all this kind of ridiculous theory and so I I actually my career really started almost by like deprogramming a lot of those guys like I would take a lot of men who were in that community were very dissatisfied with it and And kind of pitch to them like hey man, there's a better way to do this Like you don't have to memorize lines and like pretend like you're somebody you're not and And that's how I That career basically got off the ground and then I reached a point after a few years where I looked around I was like, I don't want to be a dating coach for the rest of my life.

11:07I want to like pivot into something else And so that book was really intended as kind of a final statement Before I left that industry the idea was to publish it and then just be done with it and move on and anybody who ever asked me anything, I would just say it's in the book. Like, I don't, I don't really want to deal with it. Um, to my surprise, that book ended up having a lot of staying power because the pickup artist stuff really kind of fell out of fashion. I think, I think most men of my generation started to experience and learn the things that you just described, right? It's like, if you are performing to earn the affection of women, And they're not, they don't really like you.

11:51They like the performance. Yeah. Right. So it's like.

11:53Coleman Hughes: And your soul knows the difference. It absolutely. Right. So it's like, even if you get the girl, you're not going to be satisfied. And I think a lot of those guys experienced that had kind of the fallout from that and then moved on. And in the book, you know, that book models, like it really kind of became the alternative. I think what I didn't understand at the time was that there were Millions of young guys out there like you right who did want to improve their dating life But they didn't want to do it in a way that felt scummy or disingenuous or inauthentic to themselves And so eventually that book really tapped into that market in a way that I Kind of surprised me and it like it still sells well today It's actually it's gotten a little bit of a re it's resurfaced a little bit with Gen Z And I think it's because Gen Z is kind of Gen Z men are going through their own kind of version of What the millennial guys went through with pickup artist stuff.

12:58They're doing it with the manosphere

12:59Coleman Hughes: Yeah, I mean the one thing that I would be tempted to say in defense of pickup artistry and And this is not, this is kind of me shooting from the hip because I've never tried it. But for a certain kind of guy that struggles to get, even get in the door, right? To have the courage to approach. Yeah. To have a script for how to do it seems like it could be powerful. As long as you understand the script is just to get you to the conversation where, okay, she's paying attention to you. Now be yourself, be honest. Right. Be bold in your honesty. Don't be afraid to be polarizing in your honesty. I think that's a crucial Message that falls out of your work But ultimately if you are honest You will either get honestly rejected and it'll suck.

13:50Coleman Hughes: Yeah, and that's okay or you will get Honestly what you want and it will feel amazing. Yeah, it'll feel that much better. Yeah, it's funny because back in those days is, you know, I used to deal with a lot of guys from that world. And I met a lot of the coaches in that industry, guys who did seminars and wrote books. And it's funny, I used to always tell people, I'm like, the pickup artist guys, they were not this like group of psychopathic, nefarious masterminds, like, you know, secretly meeting and and trying to figure out new ways to manipulate women it i said it's like 90 of them are just really clueless and they don't they don't know better and there's nothing available to them that's actually like trying to teach them you know in many cases some basic social skills uh and so first of all they don't have like the background of social socialization to understand what is like weird and what's not weird.

15:00And then second of all, it's like nobody's actually taking their problem seriously enough to try to teach them how to approach a woman, how to flirt with her, how to ask her out, except for these guys who are kind of creepy and weird, right? So they just kind of fall into that subculture. But 90 % of them genuinely like had good intentions. They just, it was more ignorance than anything.

15:28Coleman Hughes: So I, I share with you the distaste for conventional self-help. I think actually I've only in like, you know, years of doing this podcast had like two self-help people on ever. You're the second. I think the first was Ryan Holiday. Yeah. Who's popularized stoicism. You know, I grew up hearing about affirmations, right? look in the mirror and say, I am amazing. I am capable. I am confident. And for whatever reason, that just made me laugh. Yeah. If I stand in the mirror and say that I don't believe myself, I feel if I have to say these things to myself, then you're not it. Then I'm not it. Right.

16:12Coleman Hughes: If I were it, I wouldn't have to say, you know, I'm not like Tinkerbell where I have to just, everyone has to believe in me for me to fly. I either have it or I don't. I feel it or I don't. I'm doing it or I'm not doing it. And so to have a self-help message shorn of all that bullshit was really, really useful for people. I mean, I'm curious, are there, like, how would you describe your audience? Who is the type of person that needs the Mark Manson version of self-help, which is really like non-self-help self-help and are there people that just really the affirmations work and it's just like they're not your audience but you're happy for them and for yeah for the version of self-help that they use i i jokingly call what i do self-help for people who hate self-help um i i would say my audience it tends to be uh more educated people more skeptical people um I Get a lot of people who Who were never interested in it?

17:22It's similar to the dating thing again, right? It's like back then it was guys who wanted to improve their dating life, but they didn't want to do all the scummy weird stuff It's similar now where it's like people who want to learn and understand how to be happier how to be more fulfilled how to have better relationships, but They don't want to Do all the cheesy self-help stuff that that is conventional wisdom So it's that's kind of the demographic It's interesting. I do actually also attract a lot of I call them the woo-woo people You know the the people manifesting the manifesting people the people who think that the universe has a plan for them that You know that they They have their their Vision board and their gratitude journal and all those things There's like a pretty sizable contingent of those people.

18:18It's funny That surprised me for a long time But what I've found is that a lot of people who are into that stuff they are pretty like I Think they're so open that they don't really take it personally when I when I kind of shit all over it They don't get offended or defensive. They're just like oh, that's cool. Like, you know, I like it in their bar, I guess they're kind of like their bar for evidence is really just like, does it make me feel good? And if it does, they keep doing it. It's funny. A lot of that stuff originated in the early and mid 20th century when, you know, so like for most of the history of psychology, people didn't study what makes you feel good.

19:06They mostly just studied what made people feel awful. They studied depression and PTSD and different psychiatric disorders and things of that nature. It really wasn't until like the 80s and 90s that research even started on what makes people happier, what makes them more productive, what makes them thrive. And a lot of the good research didn't start to even get published probably until like the 2000s or even early 2010s. So it really is kind of my generation of self-help authors. we kind of are the first generation of authors that have access to an evidence-based uh i guess literature of what is good advice and what is useful for people so it's i don't hold it too much against like kind of the old school woo woo stuff um i think they were doing doing the best with what they knew.

20:04But it is interesting if you look at research on things like affirmations. Affirmations is a really interesting one because what they find is that it's essentially people who already feel good about themselves, an affirmation will make them feel better. And people who don't feel good about themselves, it will make them feel worse. And you see this with a lot of those sorts of practices. Manifestation, it's similar. It's like if you're already a high agency person manifesting will uh actually make you more likely to take action on things if you're a low agency person then it manifesting will make you less likely to take action on things you see this sort of thing show up it's a lot of these techniques are they don't they're like win more techniques it's like if you're already somebody who's probably going to do it they might just help you do it slightly faster or or do it a little bit more efficiently at the margins the problem with that obviously is that most of the people who struggle with these things um are not going to do it anyway and they don't feel that way anyway and um and it's it's so you're you're kind of just taking people who don't feel good about themselves and training them in ways you're really just giving them a lot of like short-term fixes um to kind of band-aid over the problem and and not actually address the core issue what do you do with some

21:32Coleman Hughes: of the research that finds that you know people's happiness range is to a large extent genetic meaning you know based on the genetics you have you're basically like you're you're some people are just never going to be, you know, the like the guy from Parks and Recreation. Yeah. Who's who's who's always saying and Perkins, you know, like, he's just like, happy, happy all the time. Like some people just it's never in the cards for you. You're not going to be that happy, right? Most of us are somewhere in that middle range. Some of us have very unlucky genetics where just the slightest tug sends you into a deep depression, or you you basically have major depressions cycling in and out of them your whole life and some people are just happy no matter what golden retriever energy um like what where along that spectrum are people most uh helped by your message and how do you sort of see that interacting with with with the the possibility of like getting much better yeah I mean the fact that happiness is so what you're describing is is there's this concept of kind of baseline happiness which is it's like a center of gravity if you go if you ask people day in day out to rate how happy they are from 1 to 10 generally everybody's gonna fall between 6 and 8 like 95 % of the time and then what happens and that the that baseline happiness is is mostly genetically determined so if you're like a six every day that's probably just how you're wired up some people are like an eight every day that's how they're wired up what changes is like as good things and bad things happen in your environment you kind of fluctuate up and down but that center of gravity is always the center of gravity this is one of the reasons why i i just preach that happiness is overrated and not something that people should be worrying too much about because it is a lot of it is outside of your control a lot of it there's a lot of ironies around happiness in that the many of the things that we instinctually do to feel happier actually make us less happy so it's one of these kind of backwards law things where you it's by letting go of the need to be happy that you actually make space for the happiness to emerge in your life.

24:03But it's also if something is going wrong in your life, like it is likely that if you wait long enough, you'll kind of return to baseline. It's interesting too. I do think this whole idea that we should all be happier as much as possible. It is a very recent idea. And I, I actually question how valuable it is. Because I do actually think if you look at all of the quote unquote negative emotions, like they all serve a very important function. Like we evolved our full palette of emotions for very good reasons. So somebody who's more depressive, for instance, people who struggle with depression, they tend to be more observant.

24:53They tend to be more realistic. um they tend to uh catch problems earlier uh or predict problems earlier than people who are much happier than them right and so if you think about like a human you know humans uh spending hundreds of thousands of years in tribes like it's probably good to have a depressive person in the tribe who's always kind of like calling out like well i don't know guys did you think about this, right? Like it's, it, it, it is functional in the right environment. And I think it's the same. You can make the same argument for people who are predisposed to anxiety. Anxiety is actually a very functional emotion when it's placed in the right situation or the right environment.

25:39So what I generally tell people is like, A, stop worrying about happiness. And then B, Like whatever the emotion you're struggling with whether it's anger or anxiety or sadness or whatever Like think more about the environments that you're placing yourself in because it's You you can you can leverage a lot of those predispositions to your advantage depending on what you're doing

26:04Coleman Hughes: one of the paradoxes of Life and happiness is that you can sometimes be at your most anxiety-free in terrible situations. And the classic one is war. You ask anyone who's been to war and they say, you know, it was horrible. I lost some of my best friends. It was somehow though one of the most meaningful experiences of my life. Afghanistan, Iraq, whatever it is, being in an emergency situation, even if it's a long emergency, like a one-year emergency, which is basically what it is to be in combat it's just like one long emergency is a strangely anxiety-less situation because you only have one problem right right and anxiety the feeling of anxiety at least for me it's like this morass of having lots of small problems that i don't have clear answers to and i don't know what's right and i second and third guess myself whereas when I'm in an emergency and and the you know the one that that was important in my biography was my mother dying in that situation I had no anxiety because I had one problem right and this is I think also why a lot of veterans when they transition back to normal life when they're not getting shot at perversely they're not necessarily happier yeah and it's not because they're warmongers that just like liked shooting and liked violence and like death It's because now they have a thousand small problems rather than one big problem.

27:44Coleman Hughes: There's a clarity that's lost like it's Have you seen the movie hurt locker? Yeah, like the end of that movie I Thought was so powerful, you know where he goes through all the stuff he goes through in Iraq and Then he comes home and he's clearly very bored with his like in a supermarket And he's standing in a supermarket and he's like staring at like a hundred boxes of cereal and you can just see on his face that he's just like What the fuck am I doing here? Like what is this for? Like why right it is It's interesting. I think In many it makes sense that anxiety is kind of the core Problematic emotion of our age There's an interesting distinction between fear and anxiety which I think you just touched upon you know fear is when there is something very Tangible and observable right?

28:40It's like There's a guy pointing a gun at me or there's a lion in the grass who's gonna attack me or My mother is having a medical emergency and I need to get her to the hospital like fear is extremely Clarifying because there's only one thing to pay attention to and there's only one thing to react to and so fear like in it either mobilizes us or it it mobilizes us either towards it or it mobilizes us away from it right it's the fight or flight anxiety it's this kind of ephemeral it is this worrying about potentiality that doesn't necessarily exist it is thinking and imagining all of the potential scenarios that could happen but there isn't necessarily any evidence that they are happening And so in a way, anxiety, I think first of all, it is exacerbated by introducing optionality into people's lives.

29:39It is a, I think, a hidden side effect or a hidden tax of introducing opportunity into people's lives. But it is also immobilizing. Like it is disempowering, right? Because it's like if the thing you're afraid of is all of this, all of these imaginary outcomes that you don't actually know if they're going to happen or not, like what can you actually do? Right. Like you just you kind of become paralyzed and in like lost in your own head. And and so it people kind of assume that anxiety and fear are kind of the same thing, but it's like the actual outcomes of experiencing those two things are often polar opposite of each other.

30:22Coleman Hughes: So you said anxiety is appropriately the, the, um, like the scourge of our age, something like that. Why is that the case? Is it because, is it because, um, like a perverse side effect of capitalism and innovation and wealth creation, which is generally an awesome thing, has created a paradox of choice for everyone all the time. I mean, I, I, I noticed this, like I've gotten, I've gone through one or two phases in the past five years where I just don't have a phone for some reason. Cause like I lost it or, you know, and I'm waiting to get it back from somewhere and I've just got like two days with no phone.

30:58Right.

30:59Coleman Hughes: And I'm just sitting there at, you know, the diner by myself eating and you know, I'm not, I'm actually not bored. Yeah. But if I had a phone and you told me I can't look at it, that would drive me crazy. Yeah. Right. But because I don't have one, I'm, it's just like the old world. Like we all got along with our imaginations talking to people it's a certain calmness right um is so why is anxiety the the feeling of this age it's funny we just i just did a a podcast episode on kierkegaard and it blew my mind because first of all for people who don't know kierkegaard he coined the term Anxiety and he coined it.

31:42I did not know that he coined it specifically to describe What he called? the he called it the present age, but he was basically saying it was Emerging as as a side effect of our modern age and it and it's ironic It's really funny because at the time it was this was the 1840s. He pointed to the The printing press and the publishing industry at the time there was Printing had become extremely cheap. So there was just this like surplus of newspapers and magazines like pretty much Kind of analogous to the internet and that like anybody with a little bit of extra money could go print a magazine Call it put a name on it that sounded really official and credible and then like hand it out pass it around and And people didn't know the difference like so there was a lot of disinformation going on there was a lot of like gossip like politics was really really ugly at the time and and this really freaked Kierkegaard out and he made the argument that as information proliferates a few things happen to us psychologically one is it becomes far more difficult for us to determine what is actually meaningful and what is not right and So it's like when you are exposed to dozens and dozens of ideas every single day It's extremely difficult to filter like what is signal and what's just noise and it's it's very mentally taxing on each individual The second thing that he pointed out is that it creates this humans don't Like he intuited this I think a hundred years before psychology But he realized that like humans don't actually we're not able to process more than a certain number of individuals Right, like there's a thing called a Dunbar number which basically says that you can really only hold in your head so many relations a few dozen relationships at any given time.

33:34Anybody beyond that is just like you just kind of see them as part of a group or, you know, the public or whatever. And so he noticed that a lot of people were becoming like burdened by this idea of public opinion or what the public would think of them if they said or did this thing. and Kierkegaard was like, dude, the public is like, that's not a real thing. Like these are individuals and they all have their own ideas and they all have their own perspectives. And then the other thing he pointed out is the paradox, like the optionality piece of it, right? Like the more paths you lay in front of somebody, the more you agonize over which one to take.

34:17And the more you grieve the ones not taken, right? Right. It's in a world where like you grew up, I don't know, in a small farming town and 1900. You have like maybe two life options in front of you. You take one. Maybe you wonder sometimes what the other one would have been like, but you you just kind of get on with it. And and ironically, those people tend to be like the most satisfied with their lives. It's people who have the most opportunity, the most optionality. Part of that is education. They know the most. They're exposed to the most information. Because they can imagine so many other possible versions of themselves and so many other possible paths they could potentially take in their lives, it tortures them.

35:08Because to choose one in and of itself is exponentially more difficult. And then once you've made that choice, you are just tortured for years of like, well, maybe this was the wrong choice. Maybe I should have moved to Chicago instead of New York. Maybe I should have gone back, done grad school. Maybe I should have started a podcast, right? It's just there's this constant kind of gnawing at you. and That that abundance of potentialities to worry about those Possible futures or possible paths that pass that don't exist That is anxiety, right? Like that is worrying about things that could exist, but they don't and so he predicted it back in the 1840s I think we are we are living that prediction out on steroids today And I you know, there's a lot of hand-wringing and a lot of politics around, you know mental health crisis mental health of young people I think There probably is there probably are interventions at the margins that can be useful or helpful, but I personally think a lot of this is just It's the tax of abundance It's a tax of being well-educated people in a first world country with lots of opportunities in front of us.

36:35You're going to agonize over your choices a lot more. This episode is brought to you by Jewish Communal Fund. Year-end is the most important time for charitable giving. With the JCF Donor Advised Fund, you can set aside funds for charity now, receive the available tax benefits, and decide where and when to give over time. JCF combines financial expertise with highly personalized service to help you approach your philanthropy with confidence and purpose. Open a fund with as little as$5 ,000, then recommend grants to IRS-qualified charities supporting the causes and communities that matter to you.

37:16And when you have a question, you can speak directly with knowledgeable JCF team members who understand philanthropy and take the time to understand your goals. Make this the year you give more strategically. Open your JCF fund by December 31st at jcfny.org slash get started. Jewish Communal Fund. Smart, impactful giving.

37:42Coleman Hughes: Life is all about making decisions. Sometimes you make questionable ones, like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall because the electronic store employee was a little too good at their job. Then sometimes you make great ones like protecting your home and auto with Progressive. You get customized coverage options so you can be sure you have the right coverage. Get your quote today at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers not available in all states. so what i mean do we need a philosophy or religion that's like adapted to this new environment because all of the you know i guess kierkegaard you say was was ahead of his time but most of the idea systems we've inherited belonged to a world that was very different that had low optionality where most people's life paths were set, where people experienced like real problems far more often than we do, disease, death, um, war displacement, um, where people were more likely to live in communities that had a set value system that was handed to them without much choice.

38:56Coleman Hughes: Whereas we live in an individualist culture where a lot of people don't, you know, live near their grandparents. That's like a proxy for how culture has changed. And so you have a choice over the most fundamental thing, which is who to be. Yeah. You can choose your religion. You can choose no religion. You can choose from a set of quasi-religious political identities. You have an endless buffet of options of who to be when you scroll through entertainment and TikTok. I mean, at some level each reel and each tiktok you see is an option of how you could be right a way you a way in which you could be different um so i mean is is one way of describing what you're what you're doing like trying to create a philosophy that's like well adapted to the current environment as opposed to and and i guess a different way of asking that is like how much value do you find in Ancient philosophies are they are they obsolete or are they rather like a fount of wisdom?

39:58Yeah It's funny. We have a we have a running joke on my podcast that If you ever do you ever watch South Park? Mm-hmm. Do you remember the episode the symptoms Simpsons did it? I don't remember that It's a pretty old one, but there was an episode of South Park where it's like every plot point Somebody would be like oh the Simpsons did that, you know It was like a running joke through the episode that it's like every idea the South Park guys had it's like oh the Simpsons already did that so we have a running joke on my podcast that that everything everything we kind of quote unquote discover or figure out that's correct through like psychological research it's like oh Aristotle was right like He nailed most I would say most of like modern positive psychology Aristotle kind of nailed most of it already um even like if you look at stuff like habit formation goal setting um it the stuff about happiness like the the difference between like you know uh pursuing uh pursuing peak experiences versus pursuing like meaning and purpose like all that stuff is just bread and butter aristotle it's all in the nicomachean ethics um i i think the sto i think i don't think it's a coincidence that stoicism has had such a resurgence.

41:16I think it is a particularly well-suited philosophy for this age and that it does seem to be, it's not the only philosophy that does this, but it's such a core piece of stoicism is kind of that sitting with uncomfortable things and thinking very hard about what is worth your attention and time and what is not, Choosing your your actions very consciously and intentionally but you didn't really get to your philosophy through stoicism.

41:48Coleman Hughes: Did you? No, I see how people could easily easily confuse your philosophy for straight stoicism. Yeah, I often get I Often get compared to Ryan and called a stoic, bro but it's I know my my background is more Buddhism and Buddhism when I was younger and then very, I would say when I got older, very inspired by existentialism. I want to go dive into both of those because Buddhism, I have some experience with Buddhism. When I was younger, I went on several meditation, silent meditation retreats and it was a direct, probably right around the same time I was reading your book. I was looking for solutions for my anxiety right and I I came across meditation it just it didn't work for a long time and then one day it clicked and I had such a profound experience of anxiety relief I was like I'm just going to do as much as this as much of this as possible um which is why by the way I have a lot of sympathy for people that just do whatever works right right because at the end of the day, if you are, you know, people, you can be critical of the doctrine of Alcoholics Anonymous, but if it got you sober, keep doing it, man.

43:11Coleman Hughes: Like, who cares? So I kept doing meditation and getting into Buddhism, and I found that its diagnosis of the human condition was really in line with actually evolutionary psychology, which I always Yeah liked as well. And so I had Robert Wright on this show who had this book why Buddhism is true. Yeah, where he makes that point What what was your introduction to Buddhism and how did it influence your philosophy? I Got into Buddhism as a teenager So I grew up in the Bible Belt, so I got a lot of Jesus growing up and it's funny because you know when I was young I was kind of resentful of that. I mean, parents made me go to church all the time.

44:00It was just everything, social life ran through the church, and I was not a big fan. I would say as I've gotten older, especially kind of in the last five or ten years, I've come to appreciate a lot of Christianity and notice its subtle influences in my own life. But at the time, I was very just felt very disenfranchised, frustrated. I decided I was atheist when I was like 13 or 14 and just kind of was done with it. I didn't want to have anything to do with it. Also, when I was a teenager, I started taking a lot of drugs recreationally. And I, there was one weekend I took a ton of psychedelics and had a non-dual kind of a ego dissolution, like a non-dual awareness and I came out of that and I was like okay what the fuck was that uh I don't know what that was was that religious was that spiritual like did I see God did I was I one with the universe like there's got to be somebody that can kind of talk about this or help me like process this understand it and so that that pretty quickly led me to the eastern religions and eastern spirituality and buddhism was kind of the first thing that seemed to have some sort of description of what i had experienced that made any sense and and so that was that was my pathway into into buddhism and meditation and i was really into it for a while and i really admire the philosophy a lot it made a lot like the four noble truths Made a ton of sense to me it I like the fact that it was really just built around principles rather than Myths or you know commandments like as the Bible mostly is You know there's kind of this understanding in Buddhism of like hey these are the right ways to live but you're gonna fuck it up So, you know just do your best It you know life is a practice It's something everything is something you have to come back to and like refocus and try again so all of that stuff felt very appealing and very intuitive to me and Coming it's funny because a lot of that boot like the eastern spirituality stuff at the same time I was reading a lot of kind of conventional self-help wisdom.

46:29There was a big overlap of those two worlds in the 90s and 2000s and And it was funny because as somebody who was reading Buddhism very seriously and intellectually and then going and reading something like, you know, the untethered soul or Eckhart Tolle or something like that and kind of getting this fluffy woo woo version of Buddhism that, you know, hey, you can achieve bliss, right? You just have to be still and enjoy the present moment. Like I just kind of looked at him like that's not Buddhism, man. Like Buddhism is kind of it's hardcore. Like it's it's like life is suffering and there's nothing you can do to get away from it Everything you become attached to is another form of suffering including the attachment to Trying to achieve bliss so you don't experience suffering like that is just another form of suffering And so there Some of the early chapters of soul art are very Buddhist in that It's I don't want to say it's fatalist but it really is kind of the foundation of look guys no matter what you do you're going to struggle uh there is no such thing as a life without struggle and i think there are a lot of people kind of hold on to this childish notion that there is a certain configuration of actions or choices that they can make in their life that they will not have to struggle anymore or they will not have to be in pain anymore or they will not have to be disappointed anymore and that's just not the case and i think it's much more useful to kind of conceptualize growth not as going from sad to happy or from in pain to pleasure but more of like going from a problem that is not manageable or you don't you don't want to have to a problem that you is very manageable and you are grateful for having because the problems are always going to be there like that's the buddhist component of it yeah and and you can come at that from the other side of the coin which is evolutionary psychology if you ask you know if you ask about

48:43Coleman Hughes: the process of natural selection that created us and what kind of psychology it would have created given the selection pressures of our ancestors, the guy who is happy all the time is not motivated to do the things that will lead to the greatest number of children. I mean, obviously you can go, there's actually a list on Wikipedia of the people confirmed to have the most offspring in the history of humanity. And everyone knows Genghis Khan. I actually think Genghis Khan is technically not at the top of the list. There are others, but if you look at them, none of them seem like people that were blissful all of the time.

49:27Coleman Hughes: Many of them were quite, quite brutal, probably unsatisfied much of the time followed by sort of peaks of happiness and pleasure while they were fathering a thousand children or whatever and and you know victory and war and all that stuff but if that's if that's the basic process that shaped our psychology what you would expect is that we are created to be momentarily satisfied by pursuing things that in our ancestral past would have led to reproduction whether that's got a got a big bag of money i got the girl whatever it is and then that we are programmed for that to fade extremely quickly yeah and then worse than that we are programmed to forget how quickly that faded and pursue the next success as if the next success is going to be permanent with with a vigor and intensity as if we are going to be achieving heaven on earth only for that to evaporate immediately.

50:25Coleman Hughes: So we are on this hedonic treadmill is, is, is one way of describing it. You know, we're, we're, we're basically, we're basically on a losing game. We're in a losing game, right? And the, the, the terms of the game are set by our own psychology. And once you realize that, what kind of practice can you do in order to maybe live a somewhat more satisfying life? Again, it's kind of a paradox because like, yeah, it's funny. I want to come back to that, that one to 10 scale thing and how we're all generally we're all around sevens. Like if you ask yourself, what is a seven? It's mildly dissatisfied, right?

51:07Like you're not so dissatisfied that you give up and you're like, screw it. It's not worth it. But you're dissatisfied enough that you're going to keep working. and whereas yeah if somebody was just blissed out 24 7 like that guy's lying food right like he's just he's not gonna he's not gonna do it he's not gonna worry about things he's not gonna think about the future he's not gonna prepare for worst case scenarios right so totally with you there i mean this kind of comes back to why happiness i think is just kind of the wrong question I think it's it is Happiness so what you were just describing like kind of the evolutionary view of psychology or or well-being is is that emotions are feedback pain is feedback, right?

51:55Dissatisfaction that is feedback that is that is Million millions of years of our biology telling us like hey, you're you're unhappy about something That's because you need to change your behavior You need to do something different to increase your fitness in your environment your chances of survival and reproduction Happiness is also a form of evolutionary feedback. Happiness is when nature is telling you. Hey, you're doing a great job Don't fuck it up right like keep doing that so it's there's nothing like necessarily cosmically important about happiness. It's just another tool in nature's tool bag to nudge us into the right behaviors that are going to benefit us, benefit our kids, our grandkids, all of our offspring.

52:42So this raises the point of like, okay, what is a good life then? And I personally believe, this is kind of where the existentialism comes in. I personally believe that the proper thing to optimize for is not necessarily happiness it is purpose and meaning it's like feeling because you can go through a really you just use the example of war like you can go through a harrowing experience an extremely difficult experience and you may not have enjoyed it but you can come out the other end feeling that it was incredibly meaningful and profound and a huge part of your identity, your legacy, the way other people know you, something that you are proud to say you lived and experienced.

53:28And it's less about the feeling of the experience and it's more about the perceived value of the experience. And I think what a lot of people, especially people who come to self-help, especially people who feel kind of lost and aimless, they think their problem is that they just need to feel better. But really, it's they need to do things that feel more valuable. And if you do things that feel more valuable, the happiness will kind of happen as a side effect because you will be more satisfied with all of the efforts that you've been putting out into the world.

54:06Coleman Hughes: What is existentialism and how has that contributed to your philosophy? So existentialism is, it's kind of the starting point is nihilism, which is that there is no objective higher meaning in life. There's no preordained, you know, God or this is what you're supposed to do. It's basically the idea that you are, it is incumbent on each one of us to create the meaning in our lives ourselves. and probably the biggest single core concept that comes from that stems from that is that if we are all if it is on all of us to create our own meaning in our own lives there is a massive amount of responsibility for ourselves that comes right you you have to choose what matters you have to choose how you're going to use your time and your energy you have to choose what you're going to pursue what you're going to ignore what you're going to say no to and that that responsibility is is terrifying right like it's it it brings anxiety with it and so people because of that people avoid taking that responsibility and so they find all sorts of kind of psychological maneuvers and ways to avoid accepting that responsibility it's like oh it's i can't i can't decide that you know my parents would be so upset with me or like no i can't i can't even think about that you know my friends they would never talk to me again or uh or no you know it's in this economy right like that's never that's never gonna work so why even try like we we come up with all of these excuses and narratives that justify our willingness to kind of forfeit responsibility for our own lives and and our responsibility to make our own choices And it is those narratives, all of those excuses that generate the most amount of suffering.

56:13And I think it's, I would argue that a lot of self-help material, it doesn't really empower, like the core issue is that lack of empowerment, that lack of responsibility. Most conventional self-help and life advice it focuses on giving people better excuses And not giving them agency

56:39Coleman Hughes: So one of the most common questions I get from my audience and I Literally can't think of a person better than you to answer this for me is You know I'm a guy Whose politics are not liberal. I'm trying to date in new york city and I have no idea what to do on the first date when politics somehow comes up into the conversation. Do I not say anything? And she's going to think I'm a Trump supporter and God forbid you are a Trump supporter or maybe you're not, but you could easily be mistaken for one because of some of your opinions. Do I just lay it all out there on the table and just get 50 dates in a row walking out on me?

57:22Like what the hell am I supposed to do to manage the fact?

57:27Coleman Hughes: And by the way, this is not just like an individual issue. This is a systemic issue in the sense that young men and young women are further apart politically today than they were in the past. And politics has taken on more, to use a bad word here, existential stakes, or at least it has seemed to. So what is your advice to a person in that situation? I should preface this by saying I have not been single in 15 years. Yeah I but I sympathize um okay the The by the book answer what I say in in my dating book And I do think in principle this is the correct answer which is It's better to polarize early and get the rejection immediately than like waste everybody's time I think the complication here with that is that And and this this isn't just true with politics I think it's true with a lot of things these days What I am observing is that what has started happening in the last few years is that people are starting to filter in dating Based on very superficial things They're almost looking for reasons to disqualify somebody on the first or second date and And they're not giving that grace of like, okay, well, we disagree about this, but I really like him and, you know, I'm really having a good time and, you know, maybe he's not such a bad guy.

59:01So I don't, I think a lot of it would come down to how virulent are her opinions, like how intractable are her opinions around this? Like, is she liberal, but like kind of open-minded or, you know, not necessarily going to get up and walk out? I mean, if a woman's going to get up and walk out over something like that, like she's kind of doing you a favor anyway. But I think that the fear or the concern would be if there's a woman who's maybe she doesn't like it, but it's not a deal breaker for her. scaring her off too soon when if you spent more time getting to know each other um maybe it does go somewhere um so yeah i if i was a single guy and i was in that situation

59:55Coleman Hughes: i would delay the question as long as possible that's been my advice as well yeah delay it delay it because you know what I've noticed is if if she likes you by the third date she will receive whatever your opinion is in a favorable charitable light yes if she's a reasonable person yeah so like literally it will and this is true of all of us right it's like when you when you hear someone from hear something from the wrong messenger or a messenger you don't trust it elicits a different psychological reaction than if you've already figured out you like somebody and now you you're going to give them some rope you're going to you know you're going to give them some leeway and you're going to consider what they have to say so if if it's possible to delay those delay the conversation until you've learned other things about each other yeah but once you have that conversation be yourself don't hide what you think um i love the i love the uh expression which i I think I heard from like AA people say what you mean, but don't say it mean.

1:01:01Coleman Hughes: Yeah. You know, that's a great heuristic to have in your mind in actually any conversation. Yeah. Especially politics. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. Have you taken anything from Nietzsche? Yeah, I've read tons of Nietzsche. Big fan. He's kind of, you know. I feel like he doesn't get such a good rap these days. You know, he's an interesting one because he was very over the top. And I think a lot of the things that he wrote and said haven't aged super well. But it's... Uber well. Uber well. Nice. But it's interesting reading him today because in my opinion, it's a very uneven reading. Like you'll read four or five pages that are just kind of ridiculous.

1:01:54and he's like ranting about somebody he hated in the 19th century. And then you'll have one page of just like incredible profunity. You know, everything I described earlier about the responsibility piece, like I was basically just, that was all Sartre. And I think Sartre kind of expressed it in a more clean way that is probably more psychologically accurate. But I think these ideas, like those ideas originate in Nietzsche. Nietzsche's big thing was that if you do live in a modern world where there is no fixed source of meaning and purpose, if there's no God, if God is dead, right, it is incumbent on each one of us to learn how to choose for ourselves and like build ourselves up piece by piece through our choices and our actions.

1:02:51And if you fail to do that, and Nietzsche was very uncharitable in his views around this, but he believed that if you failed to do that, then you were a coward and you deserved. You were basically going to become enslaved to the people who were capable of doing that. Not enslaved literally, but like mentally enslaved, right? Your opinions would be based on other people's. Your decisions would be based on other people's. So in his mind, it was the same thing as slavery. so he he had no patience or charity for people who chose not to do that or were incapable of doing it but he i do think he and that that's part of what gives him such a bad rap but i i do think he was probably the first one who correctly pointed out that that it isn't is now incumbent on people that you have to do that like this is not an option back then it was the 19th century but i'd say definitely in the 21st century like this is no longer an option i mean even if you are raised christian grow up christian or grow up religious whatever religion you are um it is at some point you have to consciously make the choice to continue to be that religion right it's not i think centuries ago it was just taken for it was unimaginable that you wouldn't follow the same religion you grew up with or that your parents followed but today it's like absolutely something it's always an option for everybody it's on the table so if stoicism kind of predicted a lot of the solutions to today's issues and problems I think existentialism really predicted the problems themselves like the existentialist philosophers were the ones who pointed out they saw what was happening with the media environment and they saw what was happening with industrialization modernization and they're like hey this is where this is all headed right like people are only going to become more anxious more more more loss there's gonna be more group think there's gonna be more like individual responsibility on each of us we're gonna become more fragmented um and i think it's yeah it's it's important to to pay attention have you taken anything from

1:04:59Coleman Hughes: kant i love kant that's interesting that's so interesting which is funny because like The other like I would not predict that Nietzsche just shit all over Kant. Mm-hmm. I Love Kant's The thing I love about Kant is

1:05:22So I I spoke incorrectly I said Nietzsche's is probably you know the first to kind of call out the personal I think Nietzsche called out the personal responsibility in terms of hey this is the way the world works and and either you figure out how to create yourself or you're you're gonna you know you're not gonna survive um kant really saw personal responsibility and agency as like a moral imperative um I don't I think he some of his ethical conclusions, you know, he was very inflexible in his moral framework and he famously Tried to defend some pretty like ridiculous conclusions that came from his moral framework But I I do think there's an elegance and a beauty in that at the end of the day, you know his the starting point of of his ethical system was that the scarcest and most important thing in the known universe is is human consciousness it is and so everything else should flow from the protection and promotion of human consciousness and whether he went right or you know wherever he missteps like that's fine but I think that as a starting place I think that is just such a beautiful and elegant place to start like bedrock assumption to build your moral framework on top of and i think the the responsibility piece which is a huge component of my work you know he was he was the first one to say that personal accountability it is not it's not something that you should do you know aristotle and the stoics said you should do it it's a virtue it's good to do it um kant was like no this is it is your duty to do it and if you fail to do it that is a moral failing to yourself and to the world um because and there's this beautiful symmetry to to his views as well which i love which is that you know with nietzsche he was like if you fail to take responsibility for your own life and create yourself you're just you're screwing yourself over and you know I'll pour you history will forget about you but Kant was like not only are you screwing yourself over you are screwing the world over too because you are not becoming the best version of yourself like not only do you have a moral duty to become the best version of yourself for yourself you have the moral duty to become the best version of yourself for the world.

1:08:09And yeah, I just love that.

1:08:13Coleman Hughes: Yeah. I'm curious how politics, what politics flow from, from your, um, personal philosophy. And I don't mean left, right. I mean, like what level of engagement with politics at all is implied by your philosophy? Because it could, I could easily see, and it might even assume that, you know, I think this Mark Manson guy is really wise. I'm listening to what he's saying. It's working in my life. Politics in the news seems just completely outside of my control. Why should I even pay attention to it? And I have, I know some very smart people like Brian Kaplan, the economist, brilliant guy. And he says, look, the news is usually not even the most important thing going on in the world that day yeah it's just what will attract eyeballs that day yeah so people are under this naive assumption that you know if if i to be a good citizen i need to be reading the news every day i need to be watching the news every day to stay informed well stay informed of what stay informed of whatever story is most basically rage baiting to one side or the other which is a tiny slice of everything that's gone on on planet earth and the surrounding planets today yeah so given like you're in a way your whole philosophy is like anchored around you don't have that many fucks to give you don't have that much attention you don't have that much caring you need to really discriminate in terms of what you care about.

1:09:50Coleman Hughes: Is the news worth caring about in your worldview for a normal average person? I would say not much. Part of that is just the nature of news media today, I think, in particular. And then I think there's probably a broader philosophical argument as well. The piece today is that, as you pointed out, like news is very much optimized for rage baiting it's right optimized for clicks it's it's not even optimized to inform i mean there's there's some surveys out there that show that people in some cases the more news people consume the less informed they are about certain things um i also think there's something kind of more philosophically i there's there's something to be said about information that remains valuable over a long period of time like time in and of itself can be a kind of a filtration mechanism of what matters and what's worth paying attention to uh i i would guess i i don't know if anybody's researched this but i would guess like probably like 80 90 of what is in the news doesn't really matter beyond that week or that month and it doesn't matter for the vast majority of people.

1:11:11So I think, and given how global and international our awareness is these days, I think there's something to be said. I think there's something to be said that we're probably thinking too globally as individuals. We should think a little bit more locally. Like, don't get me wrong. It's terrible some of the things that happen on the other side of the world and I guess it's worth knowing in the abstract but it's not affecting my day-to-day life for the most part and and that's that that can sound very cold whereas like there are plenty of things that are happening in my city in My community that I have no awareness of because they don't rise to the level of rage bait On the algorithms that the global news does and so I think most people are over indexed on global affairs and Under-indexed on local affairs.

1:12:09Coleman Hughes: There is a way in which Caring about something abstract and far away can be a convenient excuse to care less about the things in your immediate vicinity that you could control Yep And I avoidance of responsibility, right? Yeah Yeah. And I do think there's a little bit of a fallacy that we often make in that we assume that like there are some things that our behavior on the micro level in aggregate can affect the macro level. But there are a lot of things that can't. And I think there's a lot of people don't think about that translation between the micro and the macro. They assume like, okay, if this is a macro problem, then I need to behave in a way that fixes it on the micro level.

1:13:02Right. It's like, it's like paper straws. Like if you actually go look at the statistics around it, it's pure signaling. It's like pure vanity. There's a lot of that that goes on and it's just misplaced. If you, if you look at attention as a resource, it's just misplaced resources. Right. And I think if you view attention as a resource, you would say that news media is an incredible disruptor of a scarce resource.

1:13:34Coleman Hughes: Okay, two more questions before I let you go. You spent two and a half years helping Will Smith, one of my favorite celebrities of all time, understand and narrate his own psychology in the form of a memoir. did the oscars slap cause you to reevaluate any any of that did it come as a surprise to you or were you like i know this guy as well as anyone i know the depths of his mind that's that didn't surprise me i can explain that it's funny because so i was watching the oscars with some family and friends and when it happened everybody thought it was a bit yeah they thought i remember yeah i was watching it live they thought it was an act and and as soon as the They showed his face.

1:14:21Mm-hmm. I told everybody I was like this is real. Mm-hmm like he really hit him and My wife was like no, it's an act there. There's gonna be a punchline and I was like no no no He's really pissed. He's really pissed. I actually wrote a piece about this so that to answer your question Sadly, no, I was not surprised but that doesn't mean I Love will wills an amazing guy it was It was such a blessing to be able to work with him for those two years. And I don't think the Oscar slap does not cloud my perception of who he is. And I don't think it should cloud other people's. Ironically, people, if they read the book, I think they would understand a little bit more.

1:15:08It's one of the big things we talked about in that book. I mean, it's one of the first things that he and I dug into when we started working together is he grew up in a in with a abusive alcoholic father Who would come home and just beat the shit out of his mom in front of him and his siblings and he was the oldest child and so he felt from a very young age he felt like a immense responsibility to protect his mom and it that That experience is kind of you know, it's kind of the template of how he is seen the world or all of his relationships in the world and so one of his deepest insecurities is the women in his life um and we talk about that quite like extensively throughout the book with his mother with the women that he's dated with um his grandmother like it's just it's it's his achilles heel in a lot of ways also in the book we talk quite a bit about when he was younger, he had a propensity for throwing punches in very inappropriate situations.

1:16:12And it's a habit that he learned to stop doing by the time he became famous or kind of shortly after he became really famous. And it never really cost him anything, but it's kind of sad and ironic that, you know, in the end, it kind of came back. It came back out. I think part of it too is just, and this is something that we talked a little bit about in the book. I really wish we explored more, is that his PR image was so polished. Like he was from like 1995 to 2011 or 2016, like there was not a single flaw on his public image.

1:17:04Coleman Hughes: I remember there was a family guy clip about that where he was like rapping in the studio and it's just so clean It's like about so kids can go get school supplies and it's just like kind of like cringely clean. Yes. Yeah Everybody loved him. Yeah, everybody loved him and and they hit him and his team were extremely aware of that and I think You know, it's the the the more perfect you are in the public image the harder the fall when it does happen um and so i i think in in the end like if you think about i don't know if like charles barkley slapped chris rock right like everybody would probably be laughing about it and be like oh that's chuck being classic charles yeah exactly right but it's because it's will it's just so shocking and and so disappointing to so many people yeah okay final question you co-founded a company called purpose ai and uh you're you're it seems like you're trying to put your old self out of business in a way with this company explain what this company does i'm hedging against myself yeah um so when when chat gbt came out um i'd say within the first year i started running into a lot of people in my personal life who were using it as a therapist a coach you know going to it for for life advice and i was like wow that's really interesting and they were telling me they're like i'm actually getting really good advice from it and and so i started messing around with it and it does give some good advice and like it can be very useful um but as we all know chat gpt likes to kiss your ass likes to tell you everything every idea you have is great and you know every decision you made is brilliant and all those things and uh and i realized from like a personal growth perspective that's really problematic right like growth really does hinge on your ability to question assumptions re-evaluate previous beliefs face failures and mistakes head on and admit the failure and if you have an ai that is just constantly you know sucking up to you and validating everything you already think and believe about yourself in many ways that becomes antithetical to personal growth.

1:19:29So I, I, I met my co-founder and my co-founder has been building AI products for 10 years and he and I were talking about it and, um, and he, he was like, well, you know, I think, I think we could build something that actually challenges people. Um, you know, I, but I, I would need your help to kind of craft the language and check and make, You know evaluate the answers and you know help the engineers kind of figure out what's What's actually useful and what's what's sick of fancy, right? And so we launched we started the company last year we launched in December And it's been growing really quickly and I really do think You know the the struggle in my industry has always been the things that Do work don't really scale very well like the things that work are primarily it's like one-to-one therapy and coaching it's um highly personalized advice it's uh communities um those are all things that are extremely different difficult to scale to lots and lots of people or and or to do it economically uh in a way that like people have access to and then on the flip side the things that do scale like instagram posts and um and a lot like books and um you know tv shows and whatever They're not that impactful like in terms of just the power of their individual intervention like they're not There's not a whole lot of juice in the squeeze and so I realized that I think AI Can potentially be the thing that that threads the needle in both of those it can be extremely personalized and useful and It can scale economically to millions of people for extremely low cost so I was like yeah let's do it let's see where this goes

1:21:16Coleman Hughes: alright Mark Manson thanks so much for coming on the show thanks man

1:21:25Progressive's accident response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident the only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them so Progressive is here to help when you can't so get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's accident response. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Limited availability in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions.

From the publisher

Mark Manson is the author of The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck and a former dating coach whose argument cuts against most of the self-help genre: Happiness is the wrong thing to chase. In conversation with Coleman Hughes, he explains why people should aim for purpose and meaning instead, and why he thinks affirmations and manifesting tend to most benefit those who already feel good about themselves. They get into Søren Kierkegaard, how pickup artistry gave way to the manosphere, and when to bring up politics on a first date. Manson also talks about the two-and-a-half years he spent helping Will Smith write his memoir.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Conversations with Coleman

All episodes