

Listener Questions #55 from Daniel and Kelly’s Extraordinary Universe. The episode answers three main science questions: how oil forms and how much oil exists; how parasites adapt to new hosts, including hybrids and invasive species; and whether tying knots marks the “birth of technology.”
Kelly Wienersmith (studies parasites and space) and Daniel (particle physicist who also sails).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts introduce the segment focusing on listener questions.
“Do dinosaurs really turn into underground crude oil?”
Discussion begins with a listener question about fossil fuels and oil formation.
“I study parasites and space, and I don't know where I'd be without technology.”
Hosts explain the complex process of how oil forms from organic matter.
“So Tommaso is probably sitting in a cafe, eating an incredible pastry, sipping a delicious coffee and wondering about what's going on under the soil.”
Discussion on the economics of oil extraction and the challenges involved.
“And then you need a bunch of other stuff to happen.”
Explore the complexities of predicting undiscovered oil deposits and the economic implications.
“When the price of oil goes down, people shut that stuff down.”
Discuss factors influencing our reliance on oil and potential technological advancements.
“Because if energy becomes really, really cheap, if tomorrow somebody invents fusion and it's easy to build and run and energy becomes basically free, then we're not going to drill any more oil, right?”
Answering a listener question about parasites and their interaction with hybrid species.
“November is Pancreatic Cancer Awareness Month.”
Discuss the complexities of species definitions and hybridization in nature.
“So, Kelly, are there always parasites munching on everything or does it take them a while to figure it out?”
Exploring how species movement leads to parasite spillover in ecosystems.
“Folks should go back and listen to that one.”
Examining the ecological effects of cane toads in Australia and their associated parasites.
“But we also use that term to refer to alien parasites being able to infect the native host population.”
Explore how parasites interact with native host populations and the complexities involved.
“I would guess, and actually I didn't research this, but I would guess that some of the native parasites have probably jumped into the toads.”
Discuss the importance of funding scientific research to understand parasites better.
“All right, Joe, I hope that answers your question.”
Delve into the history of tool use and the concept of technology through knot tying.
“Our last question for today is from Lauren, and it is about the origins of technology.”
Explore the intricate world of knots and their implications in technology and engineering.
“and they like find water and find food and built, you know, crude technology.”
Discuss the evolution of technology from basic tools to complex engineering through rope making.
“Because as you pointed out, rope is a complicated thing to make even before you get to knots.”
Engage with listener questions and insights about technology and knot tying.
“I don't know, archaeologists, sociologists, anthropologists, write in and let us know what you think about this question, since maybe you actually know something.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Daniel and Kelly’s Extraordinary Universe, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. This is Jacob Goldstein from What's Your Problem. Running a business is hard enough. Don't make it harder with a dozen apps that don't talk to each other. One for sales, another for inventory, a separate one for accounting. That's software overload. Odoo is the all-in-one platform that replaces them all. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR. fully integrated, easy to use, and built to grow with your business. Thousands have already made the switch. Why not you? Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's odoo.com. Morning, Carmen. Hey, Garb. Morning.
0:42Quick question. Just one second. Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything. Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account? Oh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them WorkIQ. Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023? Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. This is Osvaloshin from Tech Stuff. For many kids and teens, math class is a source of stress. And a lot of that stress comes from learning at the wrong pace.
1:20That's why I want to tell you about Brilliant. Brilliant is the online math tutor that's visual and interactive. It helps students actually understand math step by step and gives them guidance when they need it. Brilliant was built by experts from MIT and Harvard and is trusted by millions of teachers and parents. Sign up at brilliant.org slash tutor and get 20 % off for back to school. That's brilliant.org slash tutor. That sound? That's the National Squash League. Pro teams, the world's best players, and rally so fast you'll forget to breathe. Season 4 is in full swing, and every match streams free on YouTube.
2:01Big hits, bigger rivalries, and a front row seat from wherever you are. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport.
2:24Do dinosaurs really turn into underground crude oil? And how much could be extract without too much toil? When a new host comes to town, how long before parasites chow down? Our ancestors used rocks and sticks to solve problems, which is cool, but was combining them together with knots the very first tool. Whatever questions keep you up at night, Daniel and Kelly's answers will make it right. Welcome to Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe of Listener Questions, episode number 55. 55. Also not prime. Also not prime.
3:17Hello, I'm Kelly Wienersmith. I study parasites and space, and I don't know where I'd be without technology. Hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist who likes to think about aliens and to sail, which means I do know a lot of nuts. Whoa, you know how to sail? I do not sail. I live here near the ocean. Of course I know how to sail. It's the best thing to do on the water. Dude, I lived in Santa Barbara for two years, and I didn't try to surf once. Slivery near the ocean doesn't mean anything. Well, where's the coolest place you've sailed to? Oh, I once sailed all around the coast of Denmark over a summer with some friends.
3:55Yeah, we would sail and then we would stop in our harbor. We would fish and eat dinner. It was really nice. You know, every time I talk to you, it's like there's some new country you have a passport to that I didn't know about or some additional language that you speak or some like incredible adventure you've been on. that is like a revelation to me. You have a pretty cool life. I'm just kind of old. And so, you know, I've been around. Dude, being old is not necessarily correlated with lots of awesome experiences. That's true. So at dinner the other night, I revealed to Hazel, when we were talking about the Nobel Prize in physics, that I refused an invitation to go visit the experiment in Antarctica.
4:31And she was like, what? You could have gone to Antarctica? And you said, no, I want to go to Antarctica. And Trina's like, I want to go to Antarctica. And I was like, you guys are crazy. Antarctica is terrible. I have no desire to go to Antarctica. Right. Right. Exactly. I was like, they probably don't have kombucha in Antarctica. You know, like, why would you even go? I think there's a flavor of exoticism to it that they imagined. I'm not sure. It's cold. It's miserable, right? I always remember how you guys described how space is like a worse version of Antarctica and nobody wants to go to Antarctica.
5:08That's right. And that really resonated with me. But now I realize Katrina or Hazel might have been like, actually, I do want to go to Antarctica. What are you talking about? So, different strokes. I mean, thankfully, there are lots of different kinds of people on this planet who enjoy different kinds of experiences. Our friend Scott Solomon has been on the show multiple times. He led a group of, I think, Rice alumni to Antarctica. Incredible. And as part of the trip, they jumped in the water. No. Yes. Oh, I'm getting cold just thinking about it. I, every time I see him, I'm like, I think you might be nuts.
5:41Because I think about that experience. And I was like, you're a person who did that. Why? But anyway, he's also a wonderful human being. He's much more of an adventurer than I am. So what do you do? Yes, and he's got a great book called Becoming Martian, which you should check out. Absolutely. Yep. Love that book. All right. But today we're not talking about Mars or Antarctica or Daniel's weird family. We're answering questions from listeners. And the first question comes from Tommaso. From Austria. Hello, Daniel and Kelly. This is Tomaso from Austria. I have a question about fossil fuels, and in particular, I was wondering whether we know how much oil there is under the crust of Earth, and how we could get an estimate for that.
6:21Also, how does oil form? How do pressure and heat transform dead microorganisms like plankton and algae into oil? I happen to recall the absence of oxygen is crucial. Otherwise, it is that microorganisms would decay. But what does decay mean in this sense? How does the presence of oxygen change the picture? And how much do we know about the process leading to the formation of fossil fuels in general? Thank you very much. And keep up the good work. All right. So Tommaso is probably sitting in a cafe, eating an incredible pastry, sipping a delicious coffee and wondering about what's going on under the soil.
6:58That sounds pretty awesome, actually. But okay, so how does oil get under the soil in the first place? How is oil made? Yeah, exactly. This is really cool. And I held my nose and learned a little bit of chemistry to understand how this all happens. Because, you know, actually, sometimes chemistry is interesting. I know. What? It's true. It's very off-brand for me. So the popular conception is like dinosaurs died and got squeezed into oil, but it's a little bit more complicated than that. You know, you have organic matter like plants and animals and little microscopic marine organisms, and they do turn into oil, but it's complicated.
7:40Like normally when stuff dies and doesn't turn into oil, you have this process. You know, like stuff dies and is filled with all sorts of useful materials for the rest of life on Earth. You've got proteins, fats, sugars, carbon, all sorts of resources. And typically you have like bacteria and fungi break it apart and use it for metabolism. This is what you call rotting, right? It's like why if you forget your yogurt in the back of the fridge for six months or whatever and you open it up, it's colorful and there's stuff growing on it because it's resources and eventually something will eat it and microbes can eat everything.
8:15And Katrina's excited and the rest of us are grossed out. That's right. And so this is what decay means at the molecular level, right? It's not like the atoms have disappeared. You've got the same carbon and oxygen and whatever, but these micros are doing chemistry on it. So you have big complex organic molecules that were in the living thing, you know, the raccoon that died or the fern that passed away. And it gets chemically transformed into simpler substances. And normally when you die and you're in the atmosphere and there's lots of oxygen, then most of that carbon ends up as carbon dioxide because oxygen-fueled pathways are very efficient and very powerful.
8:54And so typically you get like organic carbon plus oxygen turns into like carbon dioxide and water and energy. And so if you have a lot of oxygen around, it's not a great place for preserving carbon or organic material, right? Because it tends to get reprocessed and reused and recirculated back into the environment. So there's this carbon cycle and carbon like exists in organisms and then they die and their carbon gets released with the help of oxygen. That's the normal thing that happens. Okay. Okay. Got it. And if anybody wants a more geologist specific answer to that question, we had my friend Callan Bentley, a geologist on the show on one of our first listener question episodes to talk about that.
9:35But I'm loving this chemistry version. Thanks for taking one for the team. Yeah. And so you don't get oil when there's oxygen around, right? But if you don't have oxygen around, you have anaerobic microbes, microbes that don't require oxygen. And they can still decompose material just like other chemical pathways. So if you don't have oxygen, it doesn't mean nothing decays. It's just a different pathway. Maybe it's less complete, right? And so if you bury organic molecules, for example, and then there's no oxygen available, then you can use anaerobic processes to break it down. Okay. All right.
10:11And so that gives you the opportunity to create some oil. So what happens is you have like microscopic organisms maybe living near the surface of a lake or whatever. They die. They sink. They reach the bottom. There's some sediment there that accumulates on top of them. Now you have an oxygen-poor environment. All right. And it's buried deeper and deeper because you have this sediment laid down. And that's the raw material from which crude oil can eventually form. So you need those dead organisms and you need an oxygen-poor environment. And then you need a bunch of other stuff to happen. So this first gets transformed into an intermediate step called kerrigan, which is complex chemistry.
10:50I was trying to read and honestly my eyes glared over and I couldn't even understand it. But it turns into these complex, insoluble mixture of large organic molecules. That's what kerrigan is. And then to go from kerrigan to oil, you need the right temperature and the right pressure. As stuff gets buried, it gets deeper into the earth, which weirdly is hotter, right? We think of like, oh, the earth is cold, but it's only cold in the very top surface. As you dig deeper into the earth, it's warmer because it's hot down there because of the pressure and you're closer to the center, et cetera. And that helps drive chemical reactions, which breaks down some of those complex organics into smaller hydrocarbons.
11:32And crude oil is just liquid hydrocarbons. Hydrocarbons are things with a carbon backbone and hydrogens on them. So if it's in this right window of temperature, like between 60 and 120 C, then it breaks down and you get crude oil. If it's too hot, then it breaks down. You get like natural gas and it cracks it off and maybe even drives off all the hydrocarbons. You just get graphite. If it's too cold, then it doesn't break down enough. So you've got to die. You've got to fall to the bottom somewhere. You've got to get covered in sediment. And then you have to have the right temperature to get broken down into crude oil.
12:08And this takes a long time. Is it mostly dinosaurs? It's not mostly dinosaurs, actually. I know. So it's mostly tiny marine animals and plants. The plants tend to mostly turn into coal because it starts with a different stuff and you end up in a different environment. And so the things that turn into oil are mostly like little marine animals, microscopic marine animals from the past. Thank you for powering my car, Zooplankton. Exactly. And pressure matters also, but it's not as important. And like the typical popular explanation, like it's crushed under the pressure is a little bit too simplistic.
12:48So that's making oil. But like if you just make oil, it's a liquid. It'll like drip down through holes in rock to, you know, deep, deep within the planet. We'll never see it. In order for it to be an oil field that we can recover, it's got to accidentally trickle down into like a bowl. So you need like some source rock where this is happening that makes the oil. and then you need like a porous reservoir to hold it. So you need like another kind of rock that has gaps in it the oil can fill and something underneath it the oil cannot go through. Got it. So you need this like all this stuff to randomly happen for the oil to be there and extractable.
13:27A lot of the oil that was made on the earth is like so deep down or mixed in with stuff we'll never be able to extract it from. Tommaso asks, like, how much oil could we ever get? You know, there's no single meaningful number for how much oil is under the Earth's crust. There's like a vast, vast amount of oil in the Earth that we'll never be able to extract. And what's extractable is kind of like an economic question. When the price of oil goes up, it's feasible to extract more complicated, more expensive to extract oil and sell it. When the price of oil goes down, people shut that stuff down.
14:05And so have we found all of the big pockets of oil because we know what to look for? Or is this process like so hard to predict where it happened or where it could happen that like there could be giant deposits we've just never even seen? Can we predict where this stuff is going to be? If you could predict where undiscovered oil was, you would be a trillionaire. Like it's a trillion dollar problem. The oil companies spend a lot of money. They hire a lot of mathematicians and modelers to try to understand this. It's an inference problem. You have sparse measurements. You have a little bit of geological knowledge.
14:38You have physical models for where stuff might happen. But not only do we now have a lot of data, also we don't understand all these processes. And it's kind of chaotic, which means it's sensitive to really small changes. So it's very, very hard to predict where should you drill. If you knew how to do that, then you could make a trillion dollars. And that's not even an exaggeration. Like it's a huge economy, right? And they spend billions on research and billions on exploration. Because when they find it, it's worth trillions. Okay. Right? And so there's enormous amounts of oil dispersed through sedimentary rock.
15:11But a lot of it is, like, not very concentrated, inaccessible, energetically and economically unattractive. You know, how much actually exists is, you know, is unknown. But it's vast. Like, much greater than the amount of oil we've extracted. But most of it we will never be able to extract and don't want to extract because it would just be ridiculously expensive and useless. Is there an answer for the question of like how many more years are we likely to have all the oil that we'd need for the stuff that we use oil for? Or is that question too difficult because who knows when like we're going to have more solar panels or more wind and maybe we won't want oil or yeah.
15:53What do you think? It depends on how expensive energy is. Because if energy becomes really, really cheap, if tomorrow somebody invents fusion and it's easy to build and run and energy becomes basically free, then we're not going to drill any more oil, right? We're not going to have any. It's not going to be economically feasible. If, on the other hand, everything else breaks, we go into a nuclear winter as we have no solar power or something, then oil is going to be even more important. And then we will extract more. So, like, how much we need depends on the prices of so many other things and technology.
16:24or somebody invents some new technology that can extract oil from really deep in the earth. So it depends on too many factors to make any predictions, really. Got it. Okay, well, let's send this question back to Tommaso and see what he's got to say. Hope the pressure's not too great. Hello, Daniel and Kelly. Well, thanks so much for taking the time to dig into my question. Keep up the great work. Ciao.
16:57So, everyone on board? Yeah, I think so. You can't see it, but everyone in this room is nodding. They all agree the launch plan's perfect, but Julie has an idea how it can be even better, so she asks Copilot Cowork to help her overnight. Hey, Copilot, gather the past three months of retail sales reports, surface key insights, and build a deck outlining a partner strategy by tomorrow morning. Morning, team. I found a way to improve the plan. Check slide four. Get help with complex tasks with Copilot Cowork. Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. That sound? That's pro squash. Some of the fastest rallies in sport played inches from the crowd.
17:37The National Squash League is back in full swing for Season 4. The sport is heading to the 2028 Olympics for the first time, and you can see it up close right now in a city near you. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport.
18:20Carr, Feifei Lee, Palmer Lockheed, because I wanted to understand what the most consequential builders believe, what they fear, and where they think this is all headed. Silicon Valley is always saying the cliche thing about the way to predict the future is to create it. Well, yeah, it's up to us. But when you say us, who's us? Is it 400 people that you know in Silicon Valley? Is it me down here in New Orleans? They're brilliant, controversial, and they're already shaping the future. The question is, whose imagination do we want to live in? This is going to determine the fate of nations and economies and the future of humanity.
19:00Listen to The Builders on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
19:12November is Pancreatic Cancer Awareness Month. and I want to tell you about My Brother David, a podcast that documents my brother's journey with this disease. It's important to let people know what my experience is. I think quite often the experience of pancreatic cancer patients goes under the radar, not to callous about it, but just because we die so fast. I think it's important to share this story and hopefully give some more understanding to what pancreatic cancer patients go through. My brother David tells the unflinchingly real story of the last year of my brother's life. Let's change the pancreatic cancer narrative and turn sympathy into survival.
19:57Listen to My Brother David on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
20:18Next up, we've got a question from Joe from Florida. We love getting questions from Joe. Joe's a longtime listener, so let's hear what Joe has to say. Hi, Daniel and Kelly. Joe here from Florida. I recently discovered stertlefish, which are hybrids of an American paddlefish and a Russian sturgeon. And besides not really knowing how that happened in the first place, I did have a question, to Kelly's delight, about parasites. Now, understanding the complex life history of many parasites, my question was, how long does it take for a parasite to, quote, figure out how to engage with a new species, especially one that's a hybrid?
20:58Look forward to the response. Hope it's not too gross. And thanks again, guys. So, Kelly, are there always parasites munching on everything or does it take them a while to figure it out? Well, it can be a little complicated. All right. So Joe wanted to know about hybrids of American paddlefish and Russian sturgeon. But he gave me an out where I could talk about their parasites instead. And so I'm putting off the first part of his question because it turns out it depends on like ploidies and this complicated genomic stuff. And actually, I want to get a guest on the show to talk about ploidies because this is like something I don't really know much about.
21:30So what we're going to say is it is surprising that these two fish can hybridize because they come from different families. And so if you're me in your head, you're going kingdom, phylum, order, family, genus, species. So usually, you know, if we're getting hybridization, it's often between species in the same genus. They're kind of closely related. Maybe they didn't even split that long ago. But here, they're different families. They split a long time ago, but somehow they're still able to reproduce. Isn't that sort of the definition of species, though? So how is it possible for things that are not the same species to reproduce if being the same species means you can reproduce?
22:08You should listen to What Makes a Species, our interview with Scott Egan, where he pretty much is like, this is complicated. We do our best to define species, but nature doesn't really care that we would like to have more like strict categories for these things. Sometimes hybridization happens anyway. Right. And there's even some example of like a circular definition. species were like, anyway, it's complicated. Yeah, ring species. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. Great interview with Scott. Folks should go back and listen to that one. But the other part of Joe's question is essentially, how long is it going to take for parasites to recognize this new creature, this hybrid, as something that they could infect?
22:51And to give a quick answer to that before getting into what I think is an even more sort of interesting, bigger question, So I looked for papers where folks had looked at hybrids between two different fish species and then what happened with their parasites. And the answer seems to be that the parasites recognize the hybrid almost immediately. And the hybrids and this is this is an example because you found an example in nature doesn't mean that you understand the phenomenon at all. But in the two examples that I found, the hybrid could be infected by the parasites from both of the parent species.
23:28Whoa. What a gift. Yeah, that's right. So they were immediately recognized by more parasites than either initial parent species would have been recognized by, which is a bad situation to find yourself in. Although they had fewer of each parasite, they could still be recognized. OK, but to me, a more maybe interesting way of getting at this question is an unfortunate natural experiment that we are doing over and over and over again, which is to say we are moving species from their home ranges to different parts of the globe and they bring their parasites with them. And when they bring their parasites with them, those parasites have the opportunity to then infect the native hosts in the new range.
24:14So they're alien parasites that now have a chance to, yay, to possibly infect all of the parasites in the host range. We call this parasite spillover, which is a little bit unfortunate. I think this is the second time in as many listener questions episodes where a biology term has been used to describe two things where it probably would have been better to have different terms. People often refer to spillover as situations where parasites from wild animals end up in human populations. But we also use that term to refer to alien parasites being able to infect the native host population. So this does happen.
24:55For example, in the United Kingdom, there are parapox viruses like think of this as a squirrel pox, a pox upon your squirrel house. And invasive gray squirrels brought this virus to the United Kingdom where it ends up being worse for the native red squirrels. So in this case, the virus can recognize the red squirrels as a host and the red squirrels are not as well prepared to fight back. Their immune systems are just not really tuned to the presence of this virus. And so the native red squirrels are getting knocked out by this virus. That's not a big deal for the gray squirrels that brought it over.
25:33I'm definitely on the side of the red squirrels in this one. Yeah, I'm on the side of the red squirrels, too. Yeah, you always got to pick a side. Oh, yeah, absolutely. We learned that in the syphilis episode. So, but spill overs don't always happen. For example, we introduced cane toads into Australia. Daniel, did you ever see that documentary with the like loads and loads and loads of cane toads in Australia where the roads were getting slippery because there were so many cane toads on the roads? Or was this just like a formative moment for ecologists? No, for sure. And like the main should use like rabbits to eat them.
26:07And the mansion should use something to eat the rabbits. And then eventually they had to choose like apes or something. I don't know. I think, you know, maybe some of that story is not quite right. But but you're so gentle in your fact checking, Kelly. I love it. So are you, though. You're always, every once in a while afterwards, I'll be like, wait a minute. Like later that night, I'll be like, Daniel was saying I was wrong earlier today. He was so nice about it. I didn't realize. All right. So that's Daniel's distorted memory of some video he saw in second grade. Tell us the real story. Well, I'm not going to go into like the long history of what we did after the cane toads were introduced.
26:40But what I'm going to say is that cane toads are a problem because they produce a toxin that in their native range makes them unpalatable for things that would want to eat them. But now you plop them down in Australia and there's a bunch of stuff that, you know, don't know to avoid them because they don't have any evolutionary history with them that taught them that these toads are toxic and they'll kill you. So pets would try to eat the toads and then they would die, for example. And a lot of native species as well would try to eat the toads and then they would die. And so the toads didn't really have a lot of predators in the area because they had this amazing defense.
27:14But the toads also brought with them a lungworm, like a parasite that lives in their lung. We've talked about this lungworm parasite in the past. This is not rat lungworm. This is something different. I don't like it. I also don't like any parasites in lungs. But it turns out that this parasite was not able to jump into the native frog and toad populations. We don't know why, but it looks like it has stayed with just the cane toads. So the good news is that this lung parasite is controlling the toad population to some extent. Obviously, the toads are still out of control, but maybe it could have been even worse without the parasite.
27:52So thank your local lungworm. Wait, the toads are still out of control like today? I mean, they're still there. Like if you're driving around Australia, you'd have to watch out for the toads? I don't think that they are as thick as they used to be. I would guess, and actually I didn't research this, but I would guess that some of the native parasites have probably jumped into the toads. And it's thick with toads. It makes me think of Australia as a piece of toast and somebody's spreading toads across it like a thick layer of marmite. Or is it Vegemite they eat down there? They eat Vegemite. Yeah, I think.
28:20Yeah, that's something. Vegitoad. Oh, gross. Okay. But so what I wanted to know when I started to research this question, and I think I knew the answer beforehand, but I figured I'd look for it anyway. But do we have a framework to predict when a parasite should be able to jump into a native host population? So like if you were to take a nematode and plop it down in Utah and you knew which hosts were available in Utah, could you predict which one of the native hosts were going to pick up that parasite? Or is biology too complicated? Yeah. All right. Done. Biology is too complicated. There are some things we think matter.
28:59As a person who studies animal behavior, I'm happy to say that behavior matters. So the first thing is, do the native hosts engage in behaviors that would cause them to encounter this parasite at all in the first place? And so that depends on knowing where the risky areas are for the parasites, what the native hosts are doing in the area. So behavior matters. And then if a parasite manages to encounter a native host, is the host immune system prepared to attack that parasite or is the parasite able to even recognize that as a suitable host? And we don't have a great framework for when that's going to happen.
29:34So like some parasites are generalists, which is to say like Toxoplasma gondii can infect almost any mammal. So if you plopped Toxoplasma gondii down in front of a mammal it's never seen before, there's a pretty good chance that it can infect it because that generalist is just good at mammals across the board. Okay. But for my PhD, I studied a brain infecting parasite of California killifish, and you don't find this parasite in any of the other fish in the salt marsh. So if you plopped that parasite in a population that had maybe another fish in the same genus, it's possible it could infect that.
30:13But if it was anything farther out than like the genus level, I would guess that it probably can't infect it because this is a specialist parasite that is pretty tuned into one kind of host. So that's a little helpful from a predictive standpoint. But some parasites also have complicated life cycles. We had a whole episode on parasite life cycles. And so some parasites need to go from, for example, snail to fish to bird and then back to snail again. And so when you bring them to a new environment, they need to replace all of those hosts. And so you might be more likely to not see those parasites come from one area to another because now they don't just need to find one new host.
30:52They need to find an entire life cycle that they can fit into. And the probability of that happening is a little bit lower. Does that make sense? Yeah, fascinating. Though, you know, a lot of this seems like you're extrapolating from one system to another. You're making educated guesses based on your experience. But in reality, these systems are very complicated and like they hinge on little details, don't they? So what would you say like your confidence is in any of these predictions? It depends because it's biology. So, you know, I would say I would feel pretty confident that if you took the parasite that I studied for my PhD and you tried to infect a bass, you know, like this infects killifish.
31:31If you tried to infect a bass, I'd say zero chance that's going to happen, you know. But if you tried to infect another killifish in the same genus, I think there's some chance that it could make it up to the brain and it could do its thing in the brain. So, yeah, I think for each instance, it depends on knowing something about, you know, how broad the range of hosts that parasite can use, what else the parasite requires. So I don't think it's possible to have an across-the-board prediction system because a lot of it does depend on the details of the system. Yeah. All right. All right. All right, Joe, I hope that answers your question.
32:07We have hybridized your question with our answer, and we hope that it isn't a parasite in your mind. Amazing. A plus, Daniel. Thank you, as always, for that diverse response. I was particularly surprised that, at least from a parasite susceptibility standpoint, being a hybrid is the worst of both worlds. It doesn't delight me that parasites are quite so good at what they do, though I'm not dealing with a layer of cane toads strewn across our landscape. In such case, I might have a different perspective. On that point, Daniel got the W for being the most gross, so kudos on that. It's actually impressive our interconnected world doesn't have more pestering parasites plundering people.
32:48To me, it's one more reason why we should be funding scientists across all fields, because knowing these things, especially in the biological world of it's complicated and it depends, is way better than getting caught off guard with an unexpected lungworm paying a visit. Looking forward to that upcoming discussion on stertlefish, and cheers to you both.
33:16Morning, Carmen. Good job. Morning. Quick question. Just one second. Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything. Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account? Oh, uh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them work IQ. Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023? Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on.
33:48That sound? That's the National Squash League. Pro teams, the world's best players, and rallies so fast you'll forget to breathe. Season 4 is in full swing, and every match streams free on YouTube. Big hits, bigger rivalries, and a front row seat from wherever you are. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport. If there's a million times more digital intelligence than there is biological intelligence, it's hard to imagine humans being in control in that scenario. I'm Walter Isaacson, host of the new podcast, The Builders.
34:28Right now, we're living through an AI arms race. So I went directly to the people shaping that future. Elon Musk, Dario Amadei, Alex Carr, Feifei Lee, Palmer Luckey. Because I wanted to understand what the most consequential builders believe, what they fear, and where they think this is all headed. Silicon Valley is always saying the cliche thing about the way to predict the future is to create it. Well, yeah, it's up to us. But when you say us, who's us? Is it 400 people that you know in Silicon Valley? Is it me down here in New Orleans? They're brilliant, controversial, and they're already shaping the future.
35:09The question is, whose imagination do we want to live in? This is going to determine the fate of nations and economies and the future of humanity. Listen to The Builders on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
35:30November is Pancreatic Cancer Awareness Month, and I want to tell you about My Brother David, a podcast that documents my brother's journey with this disease. It's important to let people know what my experience is. I think quite often the experience of pancreatic cancer patients goes under the radar, not to callous about it, but just because we die so fast. I think it's important to share this story and hopefully give some more understanding to what pancreatic cancer patients go through. My brother David tells the unflinchingly real story of the last year of my brother's life. Let's change the pancreatic cancer narrative and turn sympathy into survival.
36:16Listen to My Brother David on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
36:37Our last question for today is from Lauren, and it is about the origins of technology. Hi, Daniel and Kelly. I tie a lot of knots, even made a profession of it for a while. And I explained to people that while rocks and sticks were obviously the first tools humans picked up, the real revolution came about when someone decided to tie a rock to a stick using some sort of fiber. I call this the birth of technology. Am I fooling myself? What do you think? So I love this question. And I have questions about this question. Like, what profession is it where you tie knots? Like, is that being a sailor?
37:15Is that being like a professional knot demonstrator? What is the deal with it? What about if you're, maybe if you teach people how to like climb rocks? What are professional rock climbers called? There's like a cool - You mean, is there some scientific name for it? Oh, that's not what I'm asking. Maybe it is. All right. Yeah, I don't know. Maybe he does climbing or does tours with climbers. So really fascinating question and a great excuse to like dig into the history here, you know, and think about what do we mean by tools or what do we mean by technology? Right. Like if you just pick up a rock, you can use it to do stuff.
37:53Or if you pick up a stick, you can use it to do stuff. Right. Right. But that's using something that already exists. And what he's asking about is like combining stuff to create something that didn't exist before. And I think he suggested that that's like the birth of technology. But what if you like sharpen the stick or hit the rock in such a way to like sharpen it so now you can do something new with it? Does that become technology? Yeah. It's a fascinating question. Like, is there a big difference between combining objects and just adapting objects? And of course, you know, the answer is going to be it's subtle, but it's fun to think about anyway.
38:30And so let's go all the way back and think about like just tool use before we even think about technology, like just using tools. And the thing that always blows my mind is that tool use is not unique to humans, right? Chimpanzees use sticks to like stick in the termite hole, pull them out and slurp on them. They use stones to crack nuts. Sea otters, like crows use tools. Even some insects, I think, use tools. Crows are amazing the way they use tools. So clever. They'll, like, bend metal wires so that they can stick it down a tube to pick something up that has a loop, and they need to, like, get it up through the— It's, like, the problem-solving and the tool creation is just like, wow, crows are smart.
39:12In that tiny little brain, right? Yeah. Really incredible. Yeah. And the thing that I love is that we've been using tools since before we were humans, right? Homo sapiens are like 100 ,000, 200 ,000 years old, but we have evidence of stone tools that go back more than a million years. Wow. Holy cow. So before we were humans, the tools are older than humanity, right? There was a person walking across the earth using some like handheld axe a million years ago that they had intentionally sharpened for this use. Wow. You know, to kill a creature or to skin a creature or butcher a creature or butcher another human or whatever.
39:52Like what was it like to be that person? Anyway, they probably thought it was some pretty fancy technology. Yeah. And fill out cannibalism on your DKU bingo card. I feel like you tangentially referenced it. It's close enough. I'm giving it to us. There you go. There you go. And so like, you know, to reference what you mentioned, like even modifying a tool is not uniquely human, you know, because pre-humans modified stones. And, you know, there are some animals like will strip leaves off of sticks before they use them and shape materials for a purpose. As you mentioned, like crows will like bend a piece of metal.
40:23But when you do something like tie things together, then I think maybe there is a threshold you're crossing there because you're not just like finding something useful. and maybe optimizing it a little bit, you're combining objects to do something that have really a very different functional system. You know, like your stone is hard and sharp. Your stick gives you reach and leverage. So now your stick is doing something that it just really wasn't doing before. And just to be clear, you and I are talking about how we feel like technology should be defined. You haven't gone through the history of technology literature to see how folks.
41:00Okay, got it. So this is our gut feeling. Yeah, these are just our non-expert thoughts about this on a Friday morning. Yes. Okay. Well, and they asked us. So here's what we say. Okay, cool. But I think it's really fascinating, the knot portion of this, right? It's not just combining tools. You have a stick and you have a rock and you combine them into an axe, which feels different than just your original hand axe or your stick. But the knots themselves are kind of sophisticated technology. Like, first of all, rope. Rope is not easy, right? No. You can't just like find rope around. You have to find fiber around from plants or maybe from animals.
41:41Select it, process it, twist it, combine it, right? So rope is like complicated. I know from my research in watching Naked and Afraid, this TV show, that - Okay. Have you never seen this show? No. They drop people in a random location and they're literally naked and they have to survive for 21 days. and they like find water and find food and built, you know, crude technology. It's bizarre and amazing. Okay. Especially, it's amazing because why do people do it? There's no prize. All you get at the end is like an iced coffee and a cheeseburger and a congratulations. Holy cow. But still, and these people suffer.
42:19Oh my God, the mosquito bites, let me tell you. Anyway, back to rope making, it's complicated. And beyond ropes, knots themselves are complicated. You're taking something which is a straight string and now you're changing its topology. You're just like arranging it in a way that it'll do this thing where it won't slip, you know, or two strings come together to make one. And why that happens is fascinating. And it's like a whole region of mathematics called knot theory, exploring like what arrangements will make a knot, what behavior various arrangements have. Can you predict it? Can you derive knots?
42:59Can you, you know, it's a fascinating area. is very mathematical, right? Because these things are about patterns and organization and solutions. I once sat in on a knot theory class for a few sessions until I realized, wow, I do not have the mathematics to handle this. I am not prepared. Oh, I would not be prepared either. Yeah. So now you have stones, the sticks, and other basic elements, but the knots really help you do something new, which is like reliably bind things together. So now the kind of things you can make is much more complicated. You have axes, but also spears and nets and traps and clothing and shelters and boats.
43:39And like once you can combine things, you can really do zillions of mechanical things you couldn't before. Rigging and pulleys and like think about all the elements of a sailboat that require connecting things and combining different materials. Yeah. Nobody's finding something like a sailboat in nature, right? Yeah, no, probably not. Yeah. And it's funny how foundational strings are. I was thinking about how like in freshman physics, we have the concept of a string, like a physics string is an essential element of many, many problems. You have like, you know, a pulley on a string or a weight is hanging from a ceiling or something.
44:18And we use it as this sort of like ideal way to transmit a force. That's how we treat it in freshman physics problems. But that's really what it's doing. It's like take a force and transmit it from here to there and maybe even bend it around a corner. It's really incredible as a concept, you know, like inventing a string is like, you know, a deep thing. And so what you can do then is create lots of different kinds of technology. And so Lauren is asking, like, is this the birth of technology? And I think that's, you know, it's a powerful moment. It's maybe a pivot point in our history. I would say that's a little too strong to call it like the birth of technology.
44:57Before that, we still had technology, like making stone tools required some planning and training. You had to like teach other people how to pick a rock and choose one that you could turn into an axe and learn how to flake it so that you got a sharp point, right? And similarly with sticks, like I'm sure people had spears made just out of sticks and they could sharpen them, et cetera. So before we combine things together, I would say that that's still technology. And so I don't think archaeologists would define technology as like beginning with tying stuff together. So I've got a question for you.
45:32So did it go like stone stick rope? Because as you pointed out, rope is a complicated thing to make even before you get to knots. And so I guess I'm wondering, do you need technology to make ropes? Like what do you need to make ropes? Yeah, well, you need some basic technology to make ropes. I think it's helpful to have something you can cut with, right? So you can select the fibers. And more advanced stuff like spinning fibers together, right, like going from wool to yarn requires some sort of fancy spinners. But I think that's more complicated because you're assembling like really short fibers into longer ones.
46:10But if you start with already longer fibers, you know, vines or other plant fibers, then I think it's probably not necessary. So I think it depends on the complexity of the rope. So I would guess that, you know, archaeologists who I didn't consult in this answer would say that it's an important conceptual leap because now you're doing more engineering and less using. Instead of like, I need something which does solve this problem, which does this thing. Let me go in and look for that thing. Instead, you're thinking, how do I put together the elements I find in nature so I can do that thing? So you're combining specialized parts to get your tool rather than just looking for a natural axe.
46:54And this is the foundation of engineering. This underlies every complex machine we have. And so in that sense, the idea of a knot, which pulls things together, combines two primitive things into something more complicated, is a deep idea and a powerful moment. And so I don't know if it's the birth of technology, but I agree with Lauren that it's a huge transition in our ability to create a more complex set of tools than we had before. Can we so you started by saying that tools are not the same thing as technology. Can I push you a little farther on that? Like, yeah, what is technology then? Like, is that rock technology?
47:34I mean, they're very closely related, obviously, like a tool is a specific thing you use to do a task. Right. You need to turn a screw and you get a screwdriver. That's the tool for the jobs. Technology, I would say, is more like the application of some tool or scientific concept to build some system. And I would include in that what we mentioned earlier, like training, like the transmission of knowledge from one generation to another, the knowledge of how to build the tool. So it's more like the social apparatus around the tool than just the tool itself. So like a crow teaching the daughter crow how to bend the metal wire, that's technology?
48:20Because I feel like that's culture. Yeah, I think it's all connected. I think that culture is part of technology. Okay. Right. And, you know, you're creating new capabilities in the next generation by teaching them how to build this tool. I don't know, archaeologists, sociologists, anthropologists, write in and let us know what you think about this question, since maybe you actually know something. And, Lauren, what do you think about this answer? And what is your job, Lauren? How do you get paid to tie an off, Lauren? Daniel and Kelly, thank you so much for your answer. It was quite interesting.
48:57I agree that creating tools from rocks and sticks and also making the string itself were technological in nature, but I still maintain that the combining of the elements is an order of magnitude different. It is possible to make money tying knots. I tied knots in gold and silver and made jewelry. It's quite a change from tying them in string, but it was a lot of fun. All right. Thank you, everybody, for going on this journey with us. We had a lot of fun. We appreciate that you share your curiosity and your questions with us. You can send us those questions at questions at danielandkelly.org. I am on a bit of a question hiatus until 2027 because I have so many amazing questions from y 'all that I still need to answer.
49:43I need a little bit of time to catch up, but send questions to Daniel. Please do. And I look forward to hearing from you at a later date. Thanks.
49:58Thanks, everybody, for listening. Please go and do us a favor and rate the show on whatever podcast app you're using. It really helps people find us. Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe is edited by the amazing Matt Kesselman. He really is a wizard. You can also find us online on Blue Sky, Instagram, and XDNKUniverse. Come engage with us. You can email us at questions at danielandkelly.org. We really do want to hear from you. And you can find our website, www.danielandkelly.org, where you'll also find an invitation to join our Discord, where everybody comes and talks about the amazing universe.
50:38And we also have the most amazing moderators. This is an iHeart Podcast. Thanks for joining us.
50:48Wait, I came in for two things. How is this$47? All right, we're going to need a plan here. Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25. Oh, that's actually really simple. Safe Balance Banking. One less thing to figure out. Learn more at bofa.com slash simple banking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC. Morning, Carmen. Hey, Carmen. Morning. Quick question. Just one second. Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything.
51:27Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account? Oh, uh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them work IQ. Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023? Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on.
51:49That sound? That's the National Squash League. Pro teams, the world's best players, and rallies so fast you'll forget to breathe. Season 4 is in full swing, and every match streams free on YouTube. Big hits, bigger rivalries, and a front row seat from wherever you are. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport. Grainger knows if you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while sourcing critical supplies across the operation. Too much inventory?
52:28Costs climb. Too little? Production slows. Grainger's$2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it, so you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click grainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.
53:13started at chatgpt.com. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
Daniel and Kelly answer listener questions about how much oil is left underground, how parasites recognize "new" hosts, and when to date the birth of technology.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.