

Episode title: Listener Questions #56 (Daniel Whiteson & Kelly Wienersmith)
Listener Q&A across three themes: (1) why quarks have fractional electric charges and what charge patterns imply, (2) whether skin exfoliation could accelerate cellular aging via telomeres, and (3) whether AI data centers in space are physically/economically feasible, focusing on heat dissipation.
No guest interviewees. Hosts are Daniel Whiteson (particle physics; dark chocolate/aliens) and Kelly Wienersmith (parasitologist; space books).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts introduce the episode and the concept of listener questions.
“The weird charges of particles feel like a clue.”
Daniel and Kelly discuss the implications of turning down Nobel Prize projects.
“Daniel, my question for you is, so you and I...”
Listener Scott asks about fractional charges on quarks and their implications.
“This podcast is not just me hanging out with Kelly a few times a week, though that's why it's a lot of fun.”
Daniel explains the nature of fractional charges and their significance.
“I guess my first question I have here is that, like, is the fraction arbitrary?”
Daniel discusses patterns in the charges of particles and their importance.
“Take every number and divide it by 72 or 11 billion or whatever.”
Explore the intricate relationship between particle charges and the universe's structure.
“And that's why you get like chemistry and balance and all sorts of exciting stuff, because the proton and the electron balance each other in charges so you can get neutral stuff.”
A listener expresses gratitude for the detailed explanation of particle charges.
“All right, Scott, let's see if Daniel's answer was a swing and maybe a miss, but I'm guessing that Daniel knocked that one home.”
An in-depth discussion about the effects of exfoliation on skin health.
“We're answering questions from listeners.”
Learn about telomeres and their role in cell aging and cancer prevention.
“But actually, for our conversation, that's not really what's important.”
Explore how telomerase affects cell replication and its implications for health.
“We're not doing the hospice analogy anymore.”
Discover the regeneration rates of skin and gut cells and their implications.
“And I went through a bunch of like dermatology websites for different like university hospital systems, and none of them mentioned this as a risk.”
Learn about the complexities of cooling systems for data centers in space.
“And eventually, just space is so filled with garbage, nobody can even go out there.”
Discover how heat loss occurs in space and the function of radiators.
“But the way you can prevent that here on Earth is like, well, put your hot coffee in a thermos.”
Get insights into the massive scale and weight of potential space data centers.
“It's a very common unit, football field.”
Explore the environmental costs associated with launching data centers into space.
“You need like power systems, storage, thermal systems, all this other stuff.”
Examine the future prospects and economic arguments for space data centers.
“that's true today, but AI use is going to go exponential, right?”
Discuss the idea of constructing space infrastructure using lunar materials.
“to sort of get the ball started on this stuff?”
Learn how to connect with Daniel and Kelly's community.
“And you can find our website, www.danielandkelly.org, where you'll also find an invitation to join our Discord, where everybody comes and talks about the amazing universe.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Daniel and Kelly’s Extraordinary Universe, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. This is Jacob Goldstein from What's Your Problem. Running a business is hard enough. Don't make it harder with a dozen apps that don't talk to each other. One for sales, another for inventory, a separate one for accounting. That's software overload. Odoo is the all-in-one platform that replaces them all. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR. fully integrated, easy to use, and built to grow with your business. Thousands have already made the switch. Why not you? Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's odoo.com. Morning, Carmen. Hey, Garb. Morning.
0:42Quick question. Just one second. Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything. Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account? Oh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them work IQ. Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023? Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. Picture a holiday morning. You're toasting a warm breakfast bagel piled high with cream cheese. Now, picture that bagel with 19 grams of protein.
1:20That's hero bread. From Hawaiian rolls to decadent pastries, Hero Bread baked goods have 0-5 grams net carbs and 11-26 grams of fiber per serving. No compromises, just flavor. Try it for yourself. Go to Hero.co now for 10 % off your order with code IHEART. That's H-E-R-O dot C-O code IHEART. I hope I don't have to cancel again tonight. Chronic migraine means 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting 4 hours or more. Botox, on a botulinum toxin A, prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine. It is not approved for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. Botox, the number one prescribed branded chronic migraine preventive treatment, prevents, on average, 8 to 9 headache days a month versus 6 to 7 for placebo.
2:03Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS Lou Gehrig's disease, myasthenia gravis or Lambert-Eaton syndrome and medications including botulinum toxins as these may increase the risk of serious side effects.
2:36Ask your doctor. Visit BotoxChronicMigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.
2:49The weird charges of particles feel like a clue. What are the patterns telling you? Skin exfoliation is heralded as a win, but will it result in old-looking skin? Is there anything worse? Not here in Southern California. That's a crime. See, that's why I like Virginia. Where you can age in peace. That's right. You stepped in that one, man. Should we send a data center into space or would it just blow up in the billionaire's face? Whatever questions keep you up at night, Daniel and Kelly's answers will make it right. Welcome to Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe of Listener Questions, episode number 56.
3:3656, not a prime. Can't be prime because it's even. That's right.
3:55Daniel, my question for you is, so you and I... Are we not doing intros? Oh, yeah. No. Okay. We do need to do that. Thanks. Let me introduce my co-host. This is Kelly Wienersmith. She's a parasitologist who writes books about space, and she often forgets to introduce herself. Hello, and I'm introducing my co-host, Daniel Whiteson. And he's all about particle physics and aliens and dark chocolate, not white chocolates. And yeah, I do often forget to introduce myself because let's get to the good part, man. So here's my question for you. So we've established that you have turned down a lot of Nobel Prize winning projects.
4:31Sorry for like pouring some more lemon in that wound. That's fine. I'm good with it. Yeah. And so now I'm going back and I'm thinking about all the different things that you and I have talked about that we were like, oh, that's not a good idea. like space-based solar panels and data centers in space. And I guess what I'm wondering is, do you think the people who are pitching space-based data centers and solar panels are going to win the Nobel Prize now because you came out against it? You know, there's a difference between like, could this ever work and do I want to spend my life on this? Because, you know, you got like one career and one shot.
5:07And I do believe in taking big risks. and swinging for a home run scientifically. But, you know, you got to hedge your bets a little bit. Back when I was a student, I was taking smaller risks, you know, because you only have one project and it's your whole career. And if it fizzles out, then you're dead. Whereas now I'm a senior tenured academic and I can, you know, swing and miss as many times as I need to. So I think for young people, it's a different calculus. You know, what are you going to spend your life? And what are you going to bank your whole career on when your whole career is just the one project you're doing, you know?
5:43But yeah, now I'm all about crazy projects. Let's do it. Let's win some Nobel prizes. Finally. Tenure is awesome. Being an adult, like sure, you can't eat as much ice cream. A glass of wine gives you a headache the next day. But there's some freedom that comes with it. There is. And there's also freedom to ask questions and to wonder about the universe. And that's what our listeners are doing. And they write to us with their questions when they can't figure them out. And we love, love, love hearing from y 'all because we love answering your questions. This podcast is not just me hanging out with Kelly a few times a week, though that's why it's a lot of fun.
6:18It's also about making sure you understand the universe. And so we're going to go directly to you with your questions. And today we're starting with a really fun question about particles from Scott. Hi, Daniel. This is Scott. I'd love to know your thoughts on what's up with the fractional charges on quarks. It seems to me they imply that whatever gives the electron and positron their charges can't be fundamental. And do you suppose that there's an underlying principle that requires any combination of particles to end up with an integer charge? Thanks for taking my question. Ooh, this is a great question.
6:58I guess my first question I have here is that, like, is the fraction arbitrary? Like, could you have made it a whole number by just keeping the ratio of the charges between the particles the same? Does that make sense? It does absolutely make sense. And the answer is yes. There's nothing inherently fractional about our charges. So let's remind ourselves what the charges are. The electron has charge minus one, and that's just a definition. We just decided to call the electron negative. We could have made it positive, and we decided to call it negative one because the electron was the first particle we discovered, and we could have made it negative seven or one third or whatever, right?
7:42It's just a definition. That's sort of like how charge is defined. What is fixed by physics are the relationships between the charges. So, for example, the electron has charge minus one and so does the muon. I have an important question for you. If aliens discovered the electron, what arbitrary charge do you think they would give it? Do you think they'd make the same choice as humans? Almost certainly not, because it depends on what you discover first, you know. And we happen to discover the electron first. It's kind of easier because they boil off of atoms and they appeared in cathode rays. And that's why J.J.
8:16Thompson was able to find them. But who knows what things aliens will find. Maybe they'll be studying radioactivity and they'll find alpha particles first or something else. You know, they'll discover photons beforehand. Who knows? So, yeah, it just depends on their history. Okay. Well, I just had to give you the alien question back. Could you do that to all of our guests? So muons and taus have the same charge as electrons. Whatever you set electrons, muons and taus have to have the same because that's what we see in nature. Like if you shoot them into a magnetic field, they bend the same way.
8:47They have the same charge. So electron, muon, and tau all have negative charge. Now neutrinos have no charge. And that's not a definition. There's no choices there. It's just zero. Because if you shoot neutrinos through a magnetic field, they don't bend at all, right? They don't interact with electric fields or magnetic fields. So that's just a zero. There's no choices there. So aliens would also have zero for their neutrino charge. Is that right? That's assuming the whole structure of quantum field theory and charges and forces, you know, which is a lot of assumptions. But yes, if they get that far, then they have to give neutrinos a zero charge.
9:22Okay, got it. Now, once you give the electron the charge of minus one, the proton is a charge of plus one. All right, the relationship between the proton and the electron charge is equal and opposite. Right? And so if you had made the electron negative seven, the proton would be positive seven. And the neutron is charged zero. So that's where we start. We have positive charged protons and negative charged electrons. That's really nice because then you can build things like neutral hydrogen, right? And it seems like all cozy and good. And about 100 years ago, people felt like, oh, wow, we found the basic constituents of matter.
9:55It was. But then we discovered that actually the protons are made of other stuff. There's little things inside the proton. These are the quarks. And there's three quarks inside the proton, which means you get some kind of ugly math going on here now, because if you want to make a proton out of three things, you got to have thirds. So the proton is made out of two up quarks, each of which are charged two thirds and a down quark, which is charged minus one third. So two thirds plus two thirds minus one third. That's one. And a neutron is up, down, down, which is two thirds minus one third minus one third.
10:31that's zero. So it all works out, but now you have these quarks with these fractional charges. I think this is what Scott is asking about because the up quark has this charge of plus two thirds and the down quark has a charge of minus one third. And you know, there are variations on the up quark, the charm and the top that are similar to like the way the electron has the muon and tau, the up has the charm and the top. They're also plus two thirds and the down has its two cousins that are also minus one third. So the table of fundamental particles is a little ugly. The neutrinos are zero, the electron and muon and tau are minus one, and the quarks are like these two-thirds and one-third.
11:07But you were totally right from the beginning. We could have avoided this. So if we had called the electron charge minus three from the beginning, then the up quark would have a charge of two, and the down quark would have a charge of minus one, and you wouldn't have any fractional charges at all. And it would be nice and clean. But it wouldn't change the physics at all, right? That's just a definition. And, you know, some people find fractional charges weird and uncomfortable because we start out hearing about plus and minus one. And so it seems strange, but there's nothing weird about it, right?
11:40It's just a definition. Take every number and divide it by 72 or 11 billion or whatever. The physics doesn't change. All right. So then the next part of the question, does it tell us anything about substructure now that we've established that aliens would also divide by three, whatever they ended up calling the electron? Yeah. So it seems like a big clue, but I don't think the fact that the charges have fractions actually says anything. It just tells us about what we decided first and, you know, essentially what the base charge is. Because you can get rid of the fractions and really change nothing in your understanding.
12:13But there are some interesting patterns here. And I think it's the patterns of the charges that are really interesting clues. So, for example, the difference between the electron and the neutrino is charge one. And that's really important because that's what allows them to participate in the weak force. So, for example, a W boson, which has a charge, so it's a force-carrying particle, but it has an electric charge, it can decay into an electron and a neutrino because the W is charged minus one and the electron is charged minus one and the neutrino is zero, so charge is conserved. And that's really cool.
12:45And if that gap wasn't exactly the same charge as the W, you couldn't do that. So that's what allows the weak force to interact with these particles, which is really important. The really cool thing is you have exactly the same charge difference between the up and the down. The difference between the up, two-thirds, and the down, minus one-third, is also exactly one unit. It's the same unit as the difference between the electron and the neutrino. That's really cool. That's really interesting, right? That is the reason that the proton and neutron have a difference of one charge. It's because you flip an up to a down and you change your charge by unit one.
13:21So that's where the one comes from. It's this difference between the electron and the neutrino, the difference between the up and the down. And so both of these are crucial to let the weak force interact with these particles. And to me, the interesting thing is like, why do these things have the same patterns, right? And by same patterns, do you mean sets of three? I mean that there's this unit charge difference, this difference of one between the up and the down and between the electron and neutrino. All right. You see that thing in both sets of particles. And that's the reason why the proton and electron have exactly the same and opposite charge, right?
13:58The proton charge comes from the difference between the up and the down. And the electron charge comes from the difference between the electron and the neutrino, which is one. And that's why you get like chemistry and balance and all sorts of exciting stuff, because the proton and the electron balance each other in charges so you can get neutral stuff. And so people have wondered for a long time, like, is this a coincidence? because, you know, we have the quarks and we have the electrons. Those are different particles. Could you have a theory where, like, those are different numbers and they don't work out in a universe where, like, you know, you don't get neutral hydrogen and chemistry and all that good stuff?
14:34And, you know, the answer to that is complicated. It turns out that if you have a theory where those two things don't match or, like, the proton charge is a little bit different from the electron charge, then you get awkward numbers in your calculations and infinities And so it feels like maybe that doesn't work. But we don't really know what the relationship is. It's not like we have an explanation. I think this is what Scott is leaning towards. Like, is it possible that the electron and the quarks are made of something smaller? And what we're looking at, these patterns, these similarities between the electron and the quark, which are unexplained, are like emergent phenomenon from some smaller bits.
15:13You know, instead of having all of these 12 particles that we're talking about, six quarks and six leptons, maybe we only have a couple of basic bits, squiglions that you put together in different ways to make the electron or the quark. And that's why these patterns of charges emerge. It could be, right? And so we have some clues there. We have clues about the patterns of the particles that tell us like, hmm, all this unexplained structure might come from something deeper, but we don't know yet. It certainly could be, but we don't have any ideas. We do have some clues as like where these thirds come from.
15:49The quarks appear three times as often in these loop cancellations, these virtual particles, because they have three different colors. Remember quarks feel the strong force, and so there's a red, a green, and a blue version. Those are really different quarks. And so when you do these calculations to see if things add up and balance, then the quarks appear three times as often. So you have to have a factor of a third to make it all cancel. And so for to have a consistent quantum field theory, you do need to have the quarks have a one-third charge relationship with the electron. And that gives you the proton, which balances perfectly, and it's all consistent.
16:24That doesn't mean that you can't possibly build a quantum field theory with different charges. It's just that's not the universe we're in, and we don't quite know why. Has anybody tried to think through that experiment from beginning to end? Like, what are some other charges that might work, and how would that change things? Yeah, and it's really connected to grand unified theories. People try to build like a theory that brings all the forces together into one force or also include gravity in the theory of everything. So there are theories that are like higher level structure that explain all of this stuff.
16:54But a lot of those theories don't work to have other mathematical problems. So this is really at the cutting edge of like trying to understand the bigger picture of these patterns. And I think it's important to remember this in like the larger historical context of how we've understood the world. We started out discovering a few elements, which is incredible because it means that like the complexity of the world is explained in terms of simplicity underneath. A few elements can make everything. And then we're like, oh, actually, this turns out there's a lot of elements. And wow, it's really complicated, actually.
17:25But then it turns out the complexity of the elements is explained in terms of a few particles, proton, neutron, electron. Yay, simplicity returns. Oops, no, it turns out there's other particles, pions, caons, mesons, ahedrons. It's crazy. Oh, I'm glad that you said all of those. That added a lot. It wasn't cognitively complicated or anything. You up, lurkis californiensis. That was the point there. That was the point. I was trying to express how cognitively complicated it is. I see. I see. But then again, we found the solution. We're like, oh, actually, all that zoo of particles can be explained in terms of just three quarks up, down, and strange.
17:58Yay, simplicity reigns again. And then we found more quarks. And we had all the other quarks, the charm, the top, the bottom, all the other leptons and neutrinos. And so now it's complexity again. And probably that complexity can be explained in terms of simplicity at another level, the squiglions down below. Just two of them maybe explain all of this. You hope. And if we ever do find that, probably we'll then find a bunch more squiggly ons, which don't make sense. And we'll have to explain those in terms of simplicity down below. So this is pendulum that swings back and forth, you know, finding a few little bits that explain everything we see, then discovering there are more bits actually is complicated and then explaining that again.
18:37And so right now we're at the phase where we found all of these quarks. We don't understand why there's so much complexity, these patterns, these fractional charges, everything. or hoping that these are clues that lead us to understand the universe deeper down. So you're hoping, but you're not 100 % sure the pendulum's going to swing back. Oh, no, you never know, right? It could just keep swinging getting more and more complicated. And there doesn't have to be an explanation down below. That's just sort of the pattern we've seen before. And so we're extrapolating, we're hoping, we're using it as an argument to say, give us$100 billion so we can reveal the nature of reality down deep.
19:09But, you know, you'd certainly never know. It's research, so it's exploration. It's a swing and maybe a miss. All right, Scott, let's see if Daniel's answer was a swing and maybe a miss, but I'm guessing that Daniel knocked that one home. Hi, Daniel and Kelly. Thank you so much for answering my question. Wow, that was so much more complete an answer than I had ever hoped for. For starters, I can't believe that it never really occurred to me how important it is that the difference between the charges of the up and down quarks is one and that the difference between the charges of the electron and the neutrino is also one.
19:46Your final comments about how the pendulum has swung back and forth between simplicity and complexity are very thought-provoking. So, the squiglions may still be out there. Thanks again, Scott.
20:12We'll be right back.
20:30Morning team. I found a way to improve the plan. Check slide four. Get help with complex tasks with Copilot Cowork. Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. At GMC, ignorance is the furthest thing from bliss. Bliss is research, testing, testing the testing, until it results in not just one truck, but a whole lineup. The 2026 GMC Sierra lineup. featuring the Sierra 1500, the Sierra Heavy Duty, and the Sierra EV. Because true bliss is removing every shadow from every doubt. We are professional grade. Visit GMC.com to learn more. Tis the season for exclusive offers at Simon Malls and premium outlets. Join Simon Plus for free at SimonPlus.com to unlock members-only savings from the brands at the top of everyone's wish list.
21:20Use Simon Plus at Simon Center's close to home, during your travels and at ShopSimon.com, where shopping never sleeps. This year, get gifts for them, plus a little something back for you. Join for free today at SimonPlus.com. Participation in benefits subject to rewards program terms. See SimonPlus.com for details. Having peace of mind for your home and connected life is more important than ever. That's why Xfinity Shield has built-in Wi-Fi features like Xfinity Cybersecure, which provides protection against online threats and risky sites for every device. Plus, you can lock in one Wi-Fi price for five years.
21:54Guaranteed. It's added peace of mind so you can stream more of your favorite podcasts on iHeartRadio. Get it now at Xfinity.com slash Shield. Xfinity. Imagine that. Restrictions apply. Not available in all areas. Five-year guarantee with select plans only. Xfinity gateway required.
22:20All right, we're back. We're answering questions from listeners. And today we're hearing about skin health. And if you want to look at your youngest, most Southern California you, what should you do? That's what Natalie wants to know. How many skin peels do you need to get? All right, let's hear the question. Hi, Daniel and Kelly. This is Natalie. I'm a long-time listener and I'm super excited to have my question answered on the podcast. So what I'm wondering about is exfoliation. I see various skin exfoliating products advertised as being good for your skin's health. As I understand it, the idea is that exfoliants remove the top layer of dead cells from your skin, and this prompts the living cells underneath to divide and make fresh layers.
23:03The idea seems to be that the newer cells are healthier, maybe because they've had less time to sustain damage. But I've also heard that DNA in, at least most, cells can only be replicated a finite number of times because there are telomeres at the ends getting shorter with each replication. Eventually the telomeres run out, and then each time a cell divides, important DNA information is lost. So is it actually a good idea to try to make your skin cells divide more quickly? Do exfoliants give you a temporary boost in skin freshness at the cost of hastening you toward the ultimate fate of old, genetically damaged skin?
23:40Or am I misunderstanding one or both of these processes? Thanks so much. Can't wait to hear what you have to say. All right. This was a fun question with lots of parts. So let's start with exfoliating. What is that? Yeah. So exfoliating, I think like at its core is just trying to remove the outer layer of like dead skin cells to reveal a fresher you underneath. The real you. I guess. Yeah. I don't know. I feel like my dead skin cells that are sticking to my face are still the real me, but but maybe I don't want them. And so there's a couple different ways to exfoliate. You can like, you know, get those soaps that have sugar scrubs and you can like physically remove and scrub off the outer dead layer to reveal newer cells underneath.
24:25There's also chemical exfoliants, and these work in a lot of different ways. We're not going to go through all of them. But one of the ways that I read about, they essentially, the dead skin is stuck to the rest of your face with like oils and stuff. And this like dissolves away the oil so the other dead skin cells can kind of come off. Things like retinol are supposed to actually like absorb into the deeper layers of your skin and stimulate the growth of new cells. And so exfoliating isn't always supposed to result in new cells, but it is supposed to take off the layer of dead cells and reveal the younger cells underneath.
24:59But some exfoliants do have this added claim that they stimulate the growth of new cells quicker than you would otherwise have them growing. I see. But is it good or bad for you? I mean, on one hand, we're talking about does it look good? On the other hand, I'm wondering, like, is this going to give you skin cancer or like weird rashes or whatever? Like which direction are we talking about? Yeah, right. So first I'm going to go ahead and do my usual disclaimer. I am not a medical doctor, so I'm going to tell you what I found. But if you have any questions about what you want to do with your face skin, you should talk to your dermatologist, your face doctor, your face doctor.
25:32And so exfoliation can be harmful. Like so, for example, if you're rubbing your skin too hard to try to get those layers off, you can cause irritation or breakouts and stuff like that. But Natalie specifically wanted to know if making your skin cells replicate faster can hit the limit of cell replication and essentially prematurely age you. So here's what's going on there. Your chromosomes have these ends that are sequences of DNA that are short and they repeat a lot. And when we had Venki Ramakrishnan on the show, he was talking about how genetic information and your chromosomes change over time.
26:11and we were talking about how these telomeres shorten. And the analogy that we used was, say you have a truck that's paving a road, but it can't go off of that road. Every time it paves the road, it hits the end of the road before it's done paving it. And so the road gets shorter every time the truck goes and paves it. Does that make sense? So every time your cell replicates, it replicates up until a certain point and then it loses it because it doesn't replicate like a little bit of the end of the chromosome that has purposefully been put there as excess so it can get lost. Does that make sense?
26:48This is like a internal biological clock that's counting down to your death. Okay, so let's dig into that statement. So there are correlations between what they think of as like your biological age and the length of your telomeres. But telomeres can also break down and get shorter for other reasons, like if you're exposed to oxidative stress or if you're exposed to just like stressors in general. So the length of your telomeres can be an indication of how many times your cell has replicated or how much of like a couple of different kinds of stress you've experienced in your life. Does that make sense?
27:26Does stress include things like being exposed to gooey, sticky, unpleasant, non-California weather? No, actually, that moisture probably refreshes your skin and makes you look younger. This is not medical advice. So there's a correlation between telomere length and things like aging. But there's actually a debate right now about how useful telomere length is as a predictor of like your biological age and, you know, I guess how close you are to to death. So so there's a debate about how useful that is. But actually, for our conversation, that's not really what's important. What matters is that when you run out of telomeres, your cell does what's called senescing, which is to say your body is like, you know what?
28:13You're old. I'm not using you anymore. And so it makes it stop replicating. And so it's not. I know. I think I think the listener imagined that at some point you start like eating into the first gene on the end of the chromosome. But I think what's actually happening is they're just like, OK, we're not replicating this cell anymore. It's gone through too many rounds of replication. The road is too short. Let's just stop paving it. That's right. Yes. Not worth paving anymore. A little hospice for the cell. Oh, oh. Oh, bring it flowers. Come by on its birthday. Otherwise, pretend it doesn't exist.
28:46Oh, no. OK. This has gotten too dark. I am backing us out. We're not doing the hospice analogy anymore. So part of why it's important to have this process where you say, OK, we're not going to replicate the cell anymore is that, you know, cancer is essentially a disease where the cells keep replicating. And so these telomeres, we think, are one way that our body prevents cells from becoming cancerous. If they could replicate and replicate and replicate with no stop, then you might end up with a lot more cells replicating and causing cancer. And in fact, there's variability in how long people's telomeres are.
29:22And there's some correlation where families or people who tend to have longer telomeres are at slightly increased risks of certain kinds of cancer. And we think that's because the brakes are just not as active on those cells. Does that make sense? Yeah. Okay. But so our cancer cells, in some cases, are able to induce what's called telomerase. And telomerase is an enzyme that essentially sticks those sequences back on. It like takes the brakes off. And so when you have like, you know, sperm cells replicating, for example, telomerase is on because you don't want those cells to replicate and get shorter.
30:01You want to make sure that when, you know, a baby starts, its telomeres are, you know, as long as yours were when you started your life. And you don't want to start it off with short telomeres. So our body has ways of expanding our telomeres after replication, and they do that by turning on this enzyme called telomerase. Does that make sense? Yeah. Okay. So cancer cells tend to turn telomerase on so that they can keep replicating. So this is a case where one of our body systems for trying to stop cancer fails because the cell finds a way to turn telomerase back on. And anyway, they have found some evidence of telomerase acting in skin cells.
30:38So if you get your skin cells to replicate a little more, they are less likely to suffer the negative implications of that replication than some other cells in your body, which might not have telomerase turned on to the same extent. Does that make sense? Additionally, I did some research and your skin cells on average turn over every 30 days. Really? But your small and large intestine epithelial cells, so the cells on like the inside lining, they turn over every like four days. Oh. So there are cells in your body that are like regenerating and replicating much faster than your skin cells. And we don't worry about those.
31:21And there was a study done not too long ago that looked at differences in telomere lengths between cells of different types. And so like your blood cells have short telomeres. The cells in your testes have like weirdly long telomeres, but skin cells are like somewhere in the middle. So these cells are meant to replicate a lot. They've got slightly longer telomeres. Telomerase is turned on a little bit to sometimes add some of those lost genetic pieces back. And so my guess would be that if you are exfoliating and to some extent speeding up the rate at which your skin cells on your face replicate, you are probably not going to end up with old people face much earlier.
32:08That is my hope. But again, talk to a dermatologist. And I went through a bunch of like dermatology websites for different like university hospital systems, and none of them mentioned this as a risk. And so I think, I think you'll be okay. All right. Well, let's send that explanation off to Natalie and see how it makes her face feel. Well, thanks for that really feral answer that really did hit all of the points I was wondering about. I didn't know before that telomeres could be regenerated. Although I was pretty sure there must be some way cells to divide without eating up the telomeres because otherwise babies would start the telomere sort of in appearance.
32:52And I didn't even think about intestines and stomach lining, but I'm really glad to know that I'm not going to have old guts long before my skin passes its prime. Thanks so much.
33:13So, everyone on board? Yeah, I think so. You can't see it, but everyone in this room is nodding. They all agree the launch plan's perfect, but Julie has an idea how it can be even better. So she asks Copilot Cowork to help her overnight. Hey, Copilot, gather the past three months of retail sales reports, surface key insights, and build a deck outlining a partner strategy by tomorrow morning. Morning team, I found a way to improve the plan. Check slide four. Get help with complex tasks with Copilot Cowork. Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. Buick knows confidence changes how you move through the world.
33:46That's why Buick designs SUVs with striking style and was named the most dependable mass market brand by J.D. Power. From the head-turning Buick and Vista to the seven-passenger enclave, experience the Buick SUV lineup at Buick.com. Buick, exceptional by design. Buick received the fewest reported problems in its segment in the J.D. Power 2025-2026 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Studies based on 2022-2023 models. For J.D. Power 2026 award information, visit J.D. Power.com slash awards. Tis the season for exclusive offers at Simon Malls and premium outlets. Join Simon Plus for free at SimonPlus.com to unlock members-only savings from the brands at the top of everyone's wish lists.
34:25Use Simon Plus at Simon Centers close to home during your travels and at ShopSimon.com, where shopping never sleeps. This year, get gifts for them, plus a little something back for you. Join for free today at SimonPlus.com. Participation in benefits subject to rewards program terms. See SimonPlus.com for details. Having peace of mind for your home and connected life is more important than ever. That's why Xfinity Shield has built-in Wi-Fi features like Xfinity Cybersecure, which provides protection against online threats and risky sites for every device. Plus, you can lock in one Wi-Fi price for five years.
34:59Guaranteed. It's added peace of mind so you can stream more of your favorite podcasts on iHeartRadio. Get it now at Xfinity.com slash Shield. Xfinity. Imagine that. Restrictions apply. Not available in all areas. Five-year guarantee with select plans only. Xfinity Gateway required.
35:24All right, and our last question of the day is from Wade, and it's about data centers in space. D'day, Daniel and Kelly. Thank you for taking this question. The AI data center in space idea is wholly debated and controversial. Some parts aren't really about rational or logical argument, like whether it's financially justified. there's plenty of super wealthy people that will blow their fortunes on vanity or ego projects, but one key consideration that does seem irrevocably beholden to the laws of physics is heat dissipation. Yet, surprisingly, there doesn't seem to be any agreement on this. There's lots of future tech will solve it thinking that seems magical or wishful, but also a lot of you can't call things in space, everyone knows that sort of logical fallacies.
36:06So, perhaps you could tackle the question from first principles. It seems like it's a simple matter of basic material science, conduction and thermal mass, geometry, surface area, electromagnetism, radiation, and rockonomics, cost per payload gram. Can we at least put some bounds on the problem? For example, what's the minimum amount of weight we'd have to toss into orbit to power and cool a gigawatt of compute, which is roughly one typical AI data center today? And how much carbon dioxide equivalent would that put into our atmosphere, even with our most efficient rockets today? Thank you. Love the podcast.
36:41Looking forward to your answer. Oh, I love this question. So you and I did an episode where we talked about data centers in space and like we put on our skeptic hats and talked a little bit about why we thought that like from a physics perspective, this was going to be tough. But man, this is a great question about the economics and like props to you for digging in. When I read this question, I was like, oh, that could be a lot of work. But I see you did it. So go Daniel. Yeah. Well, the guy who asked this question works at Google on data center sustainability. And so I think, you know, he's quite interested and wanted some details.
37:16And so I read a few papers, some guys at JPL did some calculations. So, you know, we all have a few minutes. So let's get into it and try to tackle this hot topic of whether we're going to put our hot data centers into space. Awesome. And for a reminder, why is this an issue at all? When you ask chat GPT, where did I leave my keys? It goes off and it runs a bunch of calculations. And those calculations run on computers. And computers involve using power and moving electrons around. And anytime you do that, thanks to thermodynamics, it generates heat. Any activity at all generates waste heat. And that waste heat's got to go somewhere.
37:59when your computer is really crunching on something, it gets hot and the fan blows that heat away. Really fancy data centers have like water to keep the computers cool. If you didn't have all that, they would overheat, the chips would melt, they would stop working. So computers, when they compute, they get hot. And that's why we often quote computational power in terms of energy. And so he talks about a gigawatt of compute. That's why he's talking about it that way because that's a way to measure How much compute do you have? How much power are you using in order to run this compute? And it's important to have the space to put these computers and like the water or the air or whatever to keep them cool.
38:39If you want to keep them running, otherwise you're going to have to find your keys on your own. And is this why there are some communities that don't want data centers? They suck up energy, they require a lot of water and they take up a lot of space. Are those some of the main arguments? Yeah, they use water and also they're loud, you know, like there's this hum from the fans or whatever. And so I don't think it's pleasant to live near a data center. Also, I think you can raise electricity rates. Not expert on any of that, but I don't think it's fun to live near a data center. Yeah. And so some people have been talking about like, let's put them in space because that seems really cool.
39:14And one of the world's most famous billionaires is a big proponent of this idea, big space booster. And, you know, there are some pros. Let's start with the pros. Why would you want to put this in space? Well, like if it's in space, it doesn't have to be next to anybody's bedroom, right? And little Timmy doesn't have to grow up next to a massive data center humming all night long. And so, you know, there's plenty of room in space. Let's just build it out there. Nobody wants to be in space anyway. It's not taking up land. That's definitely a pro, right? The other pro is that there's plenty of sunlight in space, right?
39:48Solar power on Earth is great, but it's limited because there are clouds. Sometimes you're on the part of the Earth that's not pointed towards the sun. We call that nighttime, and it's hard to get solar power at night. But if you're in space, you can always see the sun. And so you can get power all the time. There are no clouds. It's 24-hour sunlight, right? And so those are the pros of having your data center in space. But let's talk about the cons, right? Cons are space is hard. Everything in space is hard, right? It's very, very difficult. Putting stuff into space is hard. You've got to launch it from the surface of the Earth.
40:26That's expensive. It sometimes blows up. Fixing stuff in space is hard. You've got to, like, send a robot or a person. And it's far away and hard to get to. And dangerous. And dangerous. There's a lot of radiation in space. Here on Earth, we're protected by the blanket of our atmosphere and our magnetic field that bends away charged particles and absorbs a lot of radiation. Out in space, you're protected by none of that. And so there's just like particles whizzing through all the time that can hurt you, but they can also hurt computers, right? Particles depositing energy in computers can change bits from zeros to ones or ones to zeros.
41:01These are bit flips, and we have to worry about that. And data centers have like redundancy and error checking to make sure that this doesn't affect ChatGPT's answers about where your keys are. And if you put your stuff in space, you need a lot more of that, either mass in terms of shielding, like, you know, layers of lead between space and your computers, which is expensive and heavy, or some more fancy air correction and redundancy. So it's hard, right? And it's going to be harder in space. Another con is that it's further away, right? I need my keys now, man. I don't want to wait 7.2 milliseconds for the answer to get here from space.
41:39You're a busy, tenured professor. Exactly, right? You know, I have naps to take, people. That's right. And so, you know, it just takes longer to get your answer if your computers are further away. There's also the risk of, like, collisions. You put tons and tons of satellites up there. Some of them are going to bump into each other. You're going to lose control of them. You're going to create debris. And this can create this runaway effect where you have more debris, which bumps into more stuff. And eventually, just space is so filled with garbage, nobody can even go out there. So there's all these cons.
42:09We haven't even talked about the main one yet. which, you know, Wade has asked about. The other con before we get to the heat question is that solar power in space is not just like free and easy, right? You have to build solar arrays. You have to keep them running. You have to protect them from radiation. You have to maintain them, right? Here on Earth, you have to maintain your solar power. There's not as much dust in space as there is here, but there is dust and there's other stuff, radiation, et cetera. So there's a lot of things that you're going to have to solve before building your data center in space makes any sense at all.
42:43But the one people have mostly focused on is the cooling one. And this is the one that sounds easy. It sounds like, wow, I want my computer to be cold. Why not put it in space? Space is cold, right? It's like a huge natural freezer. So the best place to run your compute. It's actually the opposite. The physics is the inverse because space is cold. That's true. But the vacuum of space is an insulator. So you're surrounded by coldness, but you're deeply insulated from that coldness, right? It's like you're wearing a massive, massive, the best jacket ever that's protecting you from that coldness.
43:21So it's not actually easy to cool things down in space. Why is it an insulator? Is it just because there's no particles to like pull your heat away? Or yeah, why is it like that? Yeah, exactly. There are two ways you can lose heat. One is just by radiating it away, just by glowing heat away. Because everything in the universe that has a temperature, me, you, the sun, hot piece of metal, glows. And it glows at a frequency and at a power that depends on its temperature. And so you just lose heat by glowing things away. But down here on Earth, that's not your major way of losing heat. The major way of losing heat is you're standing in a breeze, right?
43:59And the air around you is bouncing off of you and your particles are bouncing off of it. You're sharing heat, right? And so you are losing heat to the air and then the wind blows that hot air away and you got to warm up the next layer of air and then the wind blows that away. So you're constantly losing energy to the particles around you in the same way that Like if you put cold milk into hot coffee, right, then those two things are going to equilibrate in temperature. The hot coffee is going to lose some heat to the milk, not by radiating it away with photons, you know, but just by bouncing off of each other, reaching equilibrium.
44:34And so a hot thing next to a cold thing, if there's heat conduction, is going to lose some of that heat. But the way you can prevent that here on Earth is like, well, put your hot coffee in a thermos. What is a thermos? It surrounds your coffee with vacuum, right? It's like a vacuum flask because then there are no particles to exchange that heat. And so a thermos is like, put your coffee in space. If you put your coffee into space, it would stay hot for a long time. You could sip it toastily a day later. It would still be really hot. That's the whole principle of a thermos. So now you have your data center out in space, wrapped in an amazing thermos or a super duper jacket that prevents any of this very effective heat loss that you get from air or water or, you know, just being around cold stuff with which you can exchange heat.
45:23You can't do that with the vacuum. There's nothing there to exchange with. So now you're out in space. You have to lose heat somehow. The only way to do it is to radiate that heat away. All right, cool. So you build a big radiator, right? And the radiator is very simple, right? It's just a big thing which radiates away energy, like a, you know, huge sheet of metal. You get the heat from your computer using water or whatever inside your system in space. You transport that heat to your radiator. You run this hot water that you need to cool down through a bunch of pipes, and it will radiate out into space.
46:04And the cool thing is that the hotter it is, the more it radiates. So the first principles calculation says that you radiate power per area by temperature to the fourth. So if you can like double the temperature of your water, you're radiating a lot more. It's not just radiating twice as much. Okay, so how much can you radiate? Well, if you have like a megawatt of computer, that requires 2 ,400 square meters of radiating surface. Wow. Yes, not a small amount. All right, so how many like football fields can you give me like, yeah, help me visualize that. It's a very common unit, football field.
46:43So let me just do the conversion for you. So that's like half of a football field for a megawatt of compute, right? Okay. And a megawatt is small. He was asking about a gigawatt, right, which is a thousand times more. And already we're talking about half a football field. But, you know, that's at 300K. If you go to 400K, depending on temperature of the fourth, gives you a much smaller surface. You only need 750 square meters at 400K. Okay. So you can run the radiator hot. You need a smaller surface. But, you know, you need this surface and you've got to build it and it can be heavy. So, for example, the ISS up in space right now is putting out like 70 kilowatts of heat.
47:23It needs to radiate away its heat, right? Like the ISS, they have this heat problem already. They're in space, but they're too hot. They got to get rid of their heat. And their radiators weigh six tons. Wow. Just to radiate 70 kilowatts. The other problem is you build these radiators, you put them out there, you want them to lose heat. the sun turns them into solar power, right? The sun is delivering more than a kilowatt per square meter all the time. And so if you don't want to just like be heating up, then you need your radiators to be like in shade. So you need this complicated arrangement.
47:57We have like solar panels absorbing energy to make power. And then in the shade of those solar panels, you want your radiators to be giving off heat. So it becomes a big complicated problem. And Wade was asking, like, well, what are the numbers here? How big would this thing have to be? And so imagine we have a gigawatt of computing space, like a big data center, to figure out where are Daniel's keys. A big problem. Yeah, a big problem, right? We definitely need next generation technology to solve this. And, you know, how much would you have to build? So I found a paper from JPL that gives some estimates that lets us convert from energy use to like kilograms.
48:37And it suggests that it's like 17 kilograms per kilowatt for solar power generation. So if you need a gigawatt of solar power, that's 17 ,000 tons of solar power generating equipment. 17 ,000 tons. 17 ,000 tons, yes. Wow. And you need a similar amount for radiators, a little bit less, 13 kilograms per kilowatt of radiators. So you need like 13 ,000 tons of radiators, right? So we're up to 30 ,000 tons. Yes. And the solar power is like almost six square kilometers of solar power. And the radiators are like two square kilometers of radiators, right? But hey, space is big. This thing must be tiny compared to Jupiter, you know?
49:25And then there's the other stuff. You need like power systems, storage, thermal systems, all this other stuff. Roughly double it, said this paper from JPL. So now we're up to like 60 ,000 tons for our one gigawatt space data center. And, you know, that's roughly current technology. There are smart people. There are good engineers. There are improvements possible. Lightweight radiators, really thin solar panels. Maybe you get this down to 10 ,000 tons with good engineering. Let's be generous. Okay. So still, that's 10 ,000 tons. You've got to launch up into the atmosphere, into space, right? And currently, launching like, you know, the best thing you can from SpaceX can launch like 150 tons, right?
50:10And notice the difference there. We were talking about thousands of tons before. Now we're talking about just tons. Okay. So 150 tons is impressive, right? Yeah. But launching 150 tons is a single launch that uses 20 kilograms of carbon equivalent. So a 30 ,000 ton system costs a million metric tons of CO2. Wow. Yeah. So a million metric tons of CO2. How does that compare to like, I don't know, how many metric tons of CO2 our cars put out each year? Well, you know, the world emits like almost 40 billion metric tons of CO2 every year. So this is not a big fraction of that. But this is one data center that probably they would prefer to be a lot more than one gigawatt.
50:58So multiply this by, you know, the many data centers and the more gigawatts. Yeah. It's not trivial, right? And so this thing, basically the answer to this question is this thing is going to be big. This thing is going to be heavy. engineering can make it less big and less heavy, but you can't avoid the bigness and heaviness. And big and heavy means expensive to launch and use a lot of CO2 to get up there. So it's not trivial, but these are economic arguments, right? And a guy I think like Phil Metzger would probably argue, and I'm not going to speak for him, but I've seen him make similar arguments that like, that's true today, but AI use is going to go exponential, right?
51:37We're going to need more and more and more of this stuff. And we're going to figure out how to make this cheaper. And if AI use goes exponential and our need for data centers goes insane, then we're going to be limited on Earth. And so the economics of space will eventually be attractive. I think he's projecting out into the future and saying like, not today, not tomorrow, not in 10 years, but eventually, if current trends continue, it's inevitable that space will be cheaper despite all of these costs. So, you know, that's me trying to steel man the other side of this argument. Yeah, which I think is a good thing that we try to do.
52:14And yeah, I guess it's worth also keeping in mind, if you're interested in environmental questions, that having these data centers on Earth results in a lot of other Earth-based problems as well that you need to weigh against data centers in space. Yeah, exactly. So, you know, we don't know today what the economics are going to be like tomorrow, what engineers will come up with tomorrow. but I think it's a little glid to be like, data centers in space make obvious sense. Like they might in the future, they don't today. Okay. And so what do you think about, isn't Google sending up a satellite to sort of get the ball started on this stuff?
52:47What do you think of that plan? I think that SpaceX already has, haven't they? Oh, I don't know. I think they have prototypes up there. I'm not sure on the details, yeah. You know, I'm in favor of research. Maybe they'll come up with some amazing way to do this, really lightweight and really cheap, and we can get those data centers away from Timmy's head while he's sleeping, you know? I think that'd be great if you can do it cheaply. I also think we should figure out how to build space infrastructure in space rather than building it here and launching it. Like, that makes a lot more sense to me.
53:19Like, build this stuff out of moon stuff, put it on the moon, then you have it on the moon. You never have to launch it off of Earth. That sounds hard, I know. But that seems like where you want to get eventually, because that's going to solve a lot of these problems. You know, you have the materials already in space. And also, if you have a space economy and space colonies, then you need this data center for people in space. You don't have latency issues. And so, you know, eventually, dot, dot, dot, dot, dot, a bunch of magic engineering. I can see how this might one day make sense. What do you think?
53:51Check out A City on Mars by Zach and Kelly Wienersmith for my thoughts on why. It's going to be a little bit more complicated than Daniel just pitched. I mean, the moon is like I think we did a whole episode on why the moon is a harsh environment to work in. Yeah. You know, you've got all those radiation problems that you talked about earlier. That's messing up your equipment. The dirt on the surface of the moon is like super fine and super jagged and super abrasive. Like it was already like messing up the equipment that the Apollo astronauts had when they like tried to rub it off. The moon is more like Virginia than California.
54:21I hear you. Oh, my goodness. I can't believe we're here again. I'm not saying it's going to be easy, obviously. I'm just saying that, you know, it might make sense one day if, as I think you said in your book, you do the work and you do the studies and you try to figure out how to make this possible rather than just, you know, try to dot, dot, dot yourself there without a lot of thought. Yes, fair enough. OK. And thank you again for the comments you gave me on the book. You caught us in a lot of mistakes. You read it carefully. Much appreciated. It was a lot of fun. All right, let's send this answer back to Wade and see if we have scratched his itch.
54:55Thanks, Daniel and Kelly. Those numbers were a bit surprising to me. Big, but not as big as I would have guessed. Hundreds of launches per space data center sounds like a lot, and it is, I suppose. But then again, in 2025, Wikipedia tells me there were 317 successful rocket launches into low Earth orbit. That's crazy. Thanks again for tackling the question, and keep up the good work. Thank you so much to everybody who shares your curiosity with us and sends us your questions. We really appreciate you trusting us with those questions. Until next time. Thanks, everyone.
55:36Thanks, everybody, for listening. Please go and do us a favor and rate the show on whatever podcast app you're using. It really helps people find us. Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe is edited by the amazing Matt Kesselman. He really is a wizard. You can also find us online on Blue Sky, Instagram, and XDNKUniverse. Come engage with us. You can email us at questions at danielandkelly.org. We really do want to hear from you. And you can find our website, www.danielandkelly.org, where you'll also find an invitation to join our Discord, where everybody comes and talks about the amazing universe.
56:15And we also have the most amazing moderators. This is an iHeart Podcast. Thanks for joining us. Morning, Carmen. Hey, Barb. Morning. Quick question. Just one second. Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything. Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account? Oh, uh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them work IQ. Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023? Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot.
56:53Work lives on. The Hoover Dam wasn't built in a day. And the GMC Sierra lineup wasn't built overnight. Like every American achievement, building the Sierra 1500, heavy duty, and EV was the result of dedication. A dedication to mastering the art of engineering. That's what this country has done for 250 years. And what GMC has done for over 100. We are professional grade. Visit GMC.com to learn more. Assembled in Flint and Hamtramck, Michigan, in Fort Wayne, Indiana, of U.S. and globally sourced parts. Tis the season for exclusive offers at Simon Malls and premium outlets. Join Simon Plus for free at SimonPlus.com to unlock members-only savings from the brands at the top of everyone's wish lists.
57:37Use Simon Plus at Simon Centers close to home during your travels and at ShopSimon.com, where shopping never sleeps. This year, get gifts for them, plus a little something back for you. Join for free today at simonplus.com. Participation and benefits subject to rewards program terms. See simonplus.com for details. This is Jacob Goldstein from What's Your Problem? Running a business is hard enough. Don't make it harder with a dozen apps that don't talk to each other. One for sales, another for inventory, a separate one for accounting. That's software overload. Odoo is the all-in-one platform that replaces them all.
58:13CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR Fully integrated, easy to use And built to grow with your business Thousands have already made the switch Why not you? Try Odoo for free at odoo.com That's odoo.com This is an iHeart Podcast Guaranteed Human
Daniel and Kelly answer questions about the significance of fractional charges in quarks, whether exfoliating will shorten the telomere length of your skin cells, and how much it will cost to cool data centers in space.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.