Musk on the Moon

25:22Stop being an A-hole to your B-hole. Drop the toilet paper. Available on Amazon and major retailers nationwide. Dude wipes. Best clean. Pants down. Hey, Donald. Really flying on that treadmill. I'm trying to run as fast as T-Mobile 5G home internet, Zach. Well, you better pick it up because now T-Mobile has the fastest 5G home internet according to Ookla Speedtest. Really? How's this? T-Mobile's faster than that bud and it's still just 35 bucks a month. Speed up! No! Plus they've got a five year price guarantee. Come on! Faster! How can I go any faster? Channel the speed of T-Mobile 5G home internet.

26:01Think 100 meter dash fast. Think drag racing fast. Think speed skating fast. Now let's bump up your speed a notch. Hey! Whoa! Whoa! That's too fast! You'll be alright, just walk it off. Get on the fast track. T-Mobile now has the fastest 5G home internet. And it still starts at just$35 a month with auto pay and a voice line. Plus a five-year price guarantee. Plus taxes and fees. Fastest according to Uglow Speed Test Intelligence. Date of second half, 2025. All rights reserved. Guaranteed for monthly price of 5G internet data on eligible plans. Find exclusions and details at T-Mobile.com. Organic Valley Protein Plus Ultra-Filtered Milk is pasture-raised from cows that might take more steps than most people.

26:42That's a plus. And it has 50 % more protein and 50 % less sugar than regular milk. That's a big plus. And the fact that it didn't make a pun about moving? Also a plus. Organic Valley Protein Plus Ultra-Filtered Milk. Protein plus pasture-raised. Learn more at organicvalley.com. Let's talk about modern home shopping. It's sort of become a fun side hobby, right? Scrolling listings at night, dreaming about kitchens you've never seen, or backyards you haven't even stepped foot in. All from the comforts of pretty much anywhere. Redfin knows a lot of people like you want to own, but are stuck in this browsing mode loop.

27:25That's where Redfin flips the script. With listings that update within minutes, and tours you can book right from the Redfin app, you can see your dream home the moment it appears. Now, liking a listing is easy, but actually landing it, that's where Redfin comes in. Redfin has over 2 ,200 agents with local expertise. And Redfin agents close twice as many deals as other agents. That means they want to help you win, not just window shop. Redfin is built to help you go from just looking to wait. This could actually be home. So become the newest neighbor on the block. Visit redfin.com to start finding and start owning.

28:05That's redfin.com.

28:17All right, we're back and we are talking about Musk's lunar ambitions. Musk is now heading to the moon instead of Mars, or at least he's going to the moon first. He still plans on going to Mars. I noted in the last segment that I'm actually kind of excited because going to the moon first gives us some time to learn some good skills and practice with some technology. before we go to Mars, which is a much more like dangerous, far away place. Whether or not we'll make the most of this opportunity remains to be seen because it seems like Musk does sort of want to rush through things. But we could learn from this.

28:53Yeah, one of the big arguments in your book essentially is that we're not ready to go to Mars and we need to fill in a lot more steps to get there. And experiments on the moon and in near Earth are part of those steps. So in that sense, hey, maybe Musk read your book and he's listening to your advice. I doubt it. Highly doubt it. But, you know, if so, that'd be great. So the moon does have some pros, and this is what Musk is pointing out. He's pointing out that, you know, the moon is, celestially speaking, pretty close. It's 385 ,000 kilometers away and pretty much always the same distance away.

29:30That's pretty nice. Yeah, it's always available, right, year-round. Yeah, and so you can get resupply ships there quickly. you can get medical advice almost in live time, whereas Mars is so far away that there's a three to 22 minute communication delay, depending on how far away Mars is from Earth at the time. And that also means that you can like control robots from Earth in like pretty much live time. That's pretty great. In fact, I think about the surface of the moon sort of the same way I think about Antarctica, because like you can get to Antarctica, but you can't get there like this afternoon.

30:06Yeah. You know, there's like a few planes and a few boats. Like it takes a couple of days. And if you're in Antarctica and you need to get home like ASAP, you can't like be home for emergency surgery that evening. Right. It's a lot of planning. Right. And so in the same way, like, yeah, you can get there. It's just not easy. With the Apollo 13 crew, like things went wrong and they were able to like get help and turn around and get back in time and everyone survived. Right. And then in Antarctica, there was like a woman who figured out that she had breast cancer. She was a doctor and she was able to like do a biopsy.

30:41She realized she had breast cancer and she ended up getting like saved by a rescue mission that was able to come like towards the end of the season. Right. Do you know this story? Yeah, this is amazing. This is Jerry Nielsen. And she did a biopsy on herself in Antarctica and started treating herself with chemotherapy. She was then evacuated. But they couldn't get her out very easily because you can reach Antarctica much more easily during some parts of the year than others. And so they sent a plane several weeks ahead of schedule in this crazy weather to bring her back. And they were able to evacuate her back to the U.S.

31:18for surgery. Yeah. So like it's difficult, but you have some options. Whereas like for Mars, you're just 100 % out of luck. Although there was that one Russian surgeon who did his own appendectomy in Antarctica because he couldn't get out on time. Like that is pretty hardcore. I would just be dead. Anyway, all right. So the moon also has some cool stuff like silicon, aluminum, magnesium, iron, titanium, things that might be helpful for building stuff like solar panels. There's also helium-3 on the moon, isn't there? Yeah. Hooray. You don't sound excited about that. Why not, Kelly? Everybody talks about helium-3 as a fusion fuel.

32:00Yes. And maybe one day helium-3 will be a helpful fusion fuel on the moon. I don't think it's worth digging through tons of regolith on the moon to collect helium-3 for nuclear reactors that we aren't quite using yet. Or don't know how to build. Or don't know how to build. But some people disagree with me. And quick primer there, helium-3 is a fuel for fusion. Fusion is not a technology we've made to work here on the surface of the Earth with all of our infrastructure. We might one day get it to work and we might one day be able to do it on the moon. But helium-3-based fusion, although it has some advantages, is also harder to get to work.

32:40So we're talking about an extra hard version of fusion that we haven't made work here on Earth yet. Even when we're doing the easy version. Yeah. Yeah. The moon also has lava tubes. And lava tubes are kind of cool because when you're underground, that protects you from space radiation. It also protects you from impacts from, like, you know, space debris that might fall onto the surface of the moon and could maybe puncture your habitat. and temperature swings are a little bit less extreme in lava tubes. And speaking of those temperature extremes, let's go ahead and jump to the cons because the moon has a lot of them.

33:16I love how you put lava tubes as a positive, like lava tubes. Like who wants to live in a lava tube? That doesn't sound like cozy or appealing or attractive to me at all. So like the fact that you have to put it in the pro category just tells you like there's not a whole lot of pros in that category. No, no. I mean, I think it would be cool to go in a lunar lava tube to, like, explore once. But I wouldn't want to live there, no. I mean, I don't even like going in caves. I'm claustrophobic. I went in a cave once and I was like, I need to get out of here. And then once you read the story by the guy who, like, crawled into the cave the wrong direction and got stuck upside down.

33:56Oh, no, stop. Yeah, no. You don't want to see that story. Moving on, moving on. So the temperature at the lunar equator swings from negative 130 degrees Celsius to positive 120 degrees Celsius. Wait, by the fundamental theorem of calculus, that means at some moment it must be room temperature. Yes. Yes, there is a moment where you'll be like, oh, that's comfortable before you either freeze to death or like overheat to death. Nice. Yes. So, right, it could kill you in either direction, which is lovely. The daytimes last the equivalent of two weeks here on Earth, and the nighttimes also last the equivalent of two weeks.

34:36Why is that, two weeks? Is that because the moon is tidally locked to the Earth? Probably. How about you explain that, physicist friend of mine? So the reason a day lasts for two weeks on the moon is that the moon takes four weeks to orbit the Earth, and it's tidally locked to the Earth. And so what that means is that it essentially takes four weeks for the moon to spin relative to the sun. And so that's why a day lasts for two weeks because relative to the sun, the moon spins once every four weeks because it's connected to the Earth and it takes four weeks to orbit the Earth. Excellent. That's a long time, though, to be at negative 130 degrees Celsius.

35:16Yes. Or at positive 120 degrees Celsius. It's a long time to be at either of those temperatures. Sounds real bad. Another thing that sounds real bad is that if you are trying to create a self-sustaining settlement, then you are going to need carbon and nitrogen and phosphorus. And the surface of the moon is low on all of those things. Why do you need nitrogen and phosphorus? I don't, like, buy those at the store every day. Well, that's because Earth has plenty of those things. And plants suck those things up. And you get those from plants. And if you want to grow plants, which you probably do because we like eating those things, you're going to need to bring tons of that stuff with you to create your self-sustaining settlement.

36:01And right now, probably the most concentrated source of carbon on the moon are the 96 bags of feces, vomit and urine that were left behind by the Apollo astronauts on the surface of the moon. But those belong to NASA. Oh, so you can't use them as fertilizer. No, you are not supposed to grow tomatoes in Neil Armstrong's long lost bowel movements. Wait, so we need fertilizer to grow any food on the moon, which means we need to bring all that fertilizer with us? Yes, or you could import it. You could import it. You could put it on a rocket or you could find it somewhere else in space and bring it from there to the moon.

36:43But the moon ain't got it. Like, you know, there's there's some ammonia in the water at the poles, which we're going to talk about. Ammonia has nitrogen. And so you can get some nitrogen, but it's not going to be enough to create a self-sustaining settlement. It's not going to be enough to make up for the fact that you're going to need to grow a whole lot of plants to support people. So in the spirit of steel manning Musk's plan, has he elaborated or even hinted on how he's going to solve any of these problems? No, not as far as I've seen, but let's go ahead and dig into a few more of the things that are going to make living on the moon difficult, and then we'll get into some of the plan that he has elaborated on so far.

37:24All right. First of all, I want to note that those temperature swings are going to be bad for equipment as well as people. So building factories on the moon is going to be difficult. Another thing that's going to make building on the moon difficult is going to be that regolith. So just like on Mars, the moon has jagged regolith, But on the moon, it also tends to cling. So the solar wind makes it electrostatic and it also makes it sort of levitate a little bit. And it sticks to stuff. And one, the stuff it sticks to gets a little bit darker. So it tends to absorb heat and make things overheat a little bit.

37:58We think that one of the Soviet rovers, Lunakod, overheated because it got some regolith on top of its solar panels. And then everything overheated. And it's super abrasive. And so the astronauts would complain that if they got it on, like, they had these little watches that also had their, like, instructions for stuff they were supposed to do for the day. And if they wiped the regolith off of it, it scratched it so they could no longer read what was written on their watches. And so that's also going to be bad for equipment. Also bad for humans. There's concern that if you breathe it in, it's going to scratch your lungs and cause stone grinder's disease, which essentially means you get scars in your lungs until you can't breathe anymore.

38:38Bad. Bad. the moon has pretty much no atmosphere we call it an exosphere it's like essentially a negligible atmosphere although physicists would be like it still exists bah physicists well there is a distinction there an atmosphere is dense enough that the particles interact they bounce off each other etc an exosphere the particles are there but they're such low density that they basically never interact with each other. Okay. All right. There you go. So they're there, but they're sort of negligible from the perspective of human health. You can't breathe out there for sure. And there's no protection from cosmic rays.

39:17Absolutely. Yes. Right. Yeah. So you are getting hit by all the radiation space has to offer. The moon has one sixth of Earth's gravity. So your bones and your muscles are probably degrading, which over time could be a big problem. But again, We don't really understand that very well. And the moon has water, but not much. Not much. And that water is very concentrated. So, like, yes, there is technically some water all over the surface tied up in that regolith, that dirt that's all over the surface. But technically, concrete also has some water in it. And concrete is wetter than regolith. Concrete doesn't seem very wet to me.

39:58That's right. That's right. Right. So you're probably not going to want to be extracting water from the regolith. Yeah. But at the poles, you have these areas where there are craters. And on the rims of the craters, you could set up solar panels. And that's great because you might remember that at the equator, you've got this two-week stretch of darkness in the middle of the night. So that's probably not a great place for solar panels. But if you are at the poles, over 80 % of the time, you get sunlight at the poles, especially if you're up on these rims. So that's good for solar panels. And then inside of the craters, you get these areas that are permanently dark and there's water inside of those permanently dark craters.

40:38That water has some stuff in it like methane, hydrogen sulfide and ammonia. Are those good or bad? Well, you don't want to drink those, but there's some carbon in there and some nitrogen in there. So those are things that you could extract and use. There's not going to be enough to sustain like a million person settlements with the carbon and the nitrogen in there. But, you know, you could you could still use some of it. But once you extract it, then now you've got water to drink or you could break it up and you've got some oxygen to breathe at that point. But there's not a lot of water in there.

41:10So, like, have you ever heard of Sardis Lake in Mississippi? No. No. Yeah. No one has. Because this is like a tiny lake that's not worth knowing about. Oh, what if we have listeners who live next to Sardis Lake and now you're insulting them? OK, well, I'm sorry to people who enjoy Sardis Lake. Like I hear there's bass there and I like bass a lot, but this is a human made lake that most people haven't heard of because it's nowhere near as big as, for example, the Great Lakes. And the amount of water that's estimated to be in all of the craters is 10 percent of the water that's estimated to be in this lake that most of us haven't heard of.

41:46So I see the point. Yes. So it's not a lot of water. So you're saying if you took all the water on the moon and put it somewhere in Michigan, it would be smaller than a lake nobody's ever heard of, except for the wonderful people who live next to it. Yeah, it's Mississippi. But I may have – I used the wrong abbreviation in our outline, Mississippi. But anyway, yes, that's the point I was trying to make. Right. Okay. So there's not a whole lot of water on the moon. Not a whole lot of water on the moon. And these craters of eternal darkness, which is what we call these craters that have the water, they make up 0.1 % of the lunar surface.

42:25So a very small percent. And those peaks, those rims where you can put your solar panel, we call these the peaks of eternal light, which is overselling it a little bit because they've got light like 80 % of the time. But they are one 100 billionth of the lunar surface. So about two tennis courts. And these are the best places on the moon because you've got water in the best places for solar panels. And the reason you want to know that is because this is probably where Musk is going to want to go. And I was watching a Chinese news channel and what they were talking about was, hey, this is where we want to go.

43:03Do we have to worry about Musk going there now, too? And this is also where NASA wants to go. And so now you have this very small surface area that is where everybody wants to go. And, you know, this program that I was watching was saying, like, was part of this new space race. And so, you know, now we've got this new space race and everybody trying to go to the same places on the moon. And that is a little bit concerning to me in particular. All right. So there are a few places where you can get solar power 80 percent of the time. How does that reconcile with your physicist's explanation for why the moon is in darkness for two weeks at a time?

43:40Oh, yeah. Okay, great question. So if you are at the equator, you get two weeks of night and then two weeks of daytime. But at the poles, the moon has a different tilt than you get with the Earth. And so the sun sort of glances off of it in a slightly different way. And, you know, and on Earth, you get like different day lengths at the poles than you get at the equator. And these rims also lift you up off the surface a little bit. And so you've got solar panels up on poles, up on top of the rims. And in that way, you can catch the sunlight as it glances off of the poles about 80 percent of the time.

44:17All right. So solar power is tricky. There's only a few places you really want to do it. Fusion is maybe impractical even here on Earth. What about good old nuclear power? We know how to do that. We've been doing it for decades. Can't we build small modular reactors and send them to the moon? Yeah, sure. Those portable nuclear reactors would be helpful on the moon as well. We don't quite have those ready to go to the moon yet to power like factories like Musk is talking about. But people are working on stuff like that and that would be helpful. And so I guess the question is, do we imagine that we could have a lunar city that would be self-sustaining in 10 years?

44:56I think 10 years is really optimistic because like, I mean, when you are talking about temperature changes that are like 250 degrees Celsius, I mean, the amount at which metal like expands and contracts at those temperature swings and like, you know, how difficult it is to get lubricants that don't like boil off at that high temperature or like freeze at that low temperature. There's just a lot of engineering challenges when you're working at those sorts of temperature swings. I think we're not going to overcome all of those challenges in 10 years. But, you know, we could start building something in 10 years and that would be kind of fun.

45:33All right. It does seem like this is a hard problem. But remember, SpaceX has done amazing things. What do you think is the best way to attack each of these problems? Like, what is our best case scenario? Like for nuclear power, we said small modular reactors that might be possible. What about the other challenges? What's the best case scenario for each one? All right. Well, so first I'll note that like Starship was built so that you can move a lot of mass fairly cheap. Right. And so they could get things like carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, stuff that they need to the moon. It would be expensive, but they are maybe in a good position to move a lot of mass to the moon to make it more habitable.

46:14I mean, Musk talks about like daily launches or multiple launches a day, like really getting a pipeline up to the moon. Yeah, right. Okay. And if that happens, you could get some mass there. Again, I do think that would still be expensive, but let's assume that that can happen. So, all right. You could build factories in lava tubes and that would protect you from the radiation, which, you know, you and I recently had a whole episode about how radiation is not just dangerous for human bodies, but also bad for our equipment. So you're definitely going to need to protect yourself from radiation. And does lava tubes also solve the temperature problem?

46:50if you're not on the surface, is it more reasonable? Yes, it is more reasonable. Yes, that results in milder temperature swings if you're underground. And it solves a lot of the regolith problem because as the lava went through, it fused the regolith. And so now you don't have a lot of dust that's going to be getting into your equipment and stuff like that. You still have the problem of needing to figure out how you like lower everything into the lava tube. You know, like we're not super experienced with moving around on the surface of the moon. And now we're like lunar spelunking. But like, I don't know, that's kind of a cool problem to solve.

47:27And so working in the lava tubes could be, you know, cool. And like, if you could even like fuse the inside of a lava tube and put an airlock in there, like maybe you could create an environment where you could walk around without spacesuits if you could, you know, create a pressurized environment inside of part of a lava tube. Maybe. Yeah. All right. Well, I don't want to go into a cave here on Earth. So caves on the moon don't sound very cozy, but they do sound better than the surface, I'll admit. Yeah. There are braver people out there than you and me, Daniel. So yeah, that's right. That's right.

48:02Low bar. Exactly. Well, what about the water problem? I mean, the solar system is filled with water. There's huge chunks of ice just out there. Certainly, we don't need to launch water from the surface of the Earth climbing up the gravity well, do we? Nope, that's true. And a lot of the asteroid mining community has been excited about collecting water from asteroids and figuring out how to extract it from asteroids and then, you know, selling it maybe to the International Space Station or maybe they could sell it to the lunar SpaceX facility. And so water could come from other locations in space rather than pulling it out of our gravity well.

48:36That seems pretty cool. I mean, people buy like Fiji water because it seems like exotic. Now like asteroid water? Like, yeah, I'd pay 10 bucks for a bottle of asteroid water. Yes. Yeah. I mean, that could be a possibility. But again, that's not something we're going to like figure out in the next few years. Agreed. Okay. That's right. So yeah, I mean, you could have a portable nuclear reactor that powers your factory inside of a lava tube. I can technically see solutions to all of these problems. Not in the next 10 years. But yes, I could see a path forward. Again, not in 10 years. All right. Well, on that positive note, let's take a break and come back and talk about Musk's other dreams for AI satellites.

49:30this is Rob Gronkowski from dudes on dudes with Gronk and Jules and talk about a perfect partnership I'm here to tell you about protecting your end zone with dude wipes if you're still wiping with toilet paper you need to listen up dude wipes are a wet extra large flushable wipe that leave nothing behind in your behind. Because they are wet and we all know wetter cleans better. Unlike dry wiping with toilet paper, dude wipes clear instead of smear. Goodbye dingleberries, goodbye itch and irritation. Plus, if you take gronk size grumpies, or as I like to call them, gronkies, baby wipes won't do.

50:11You need extra big dude wipes to handle the job. And they come in different scents and pack sizes, including a single-use on-the-go pack that you can take wherever you go for that home field advantage. So don't fumble the ball with toilet paper. Stop being an a-hole to your b-hole and start using Dude Wipes, available on Amazon and major retailers nationwide. Dude Wipes, best clean, pants down.

50:42Zach, nice vacation spot, but without T-Mobile 5G home internet, I feel so cut off. It's scary. Relax. Just breathe in the woodsy-woodsiness. Zah! Don't open it. It's a monster. I just know it. Buddy, it's just our DoorDash driver delivering our T-Mobile 5G home internet. Here you go, guys. Thanks. Look, Donald, now you can get the fastest 5G home internet with same-day delivery powered by DoorDash. And it's easy to set up. See? Nothing to be afraid of. We're saved. It's scary how easy it is. Get T-Mobile 5G home internet delivered the same day. Powered by DoorDash. Just$35 a month with auto pay and a voice line.

51:27Plus taxes and fees. Same day delivery for most internet eligible customers. See if it's an option during checkout. Fastest according to Ookla Speed Test based on Speed Test intelligence data second half 2025. All rights reserved. Organic Valley Protein Plus Ultra Filtered Milk is pasture raised. from cows that might take more steps than most people. That's a plus. And it has 50 % more protein and 50 % less sugar than regular milk. That's a big plus. And the fact that I didn't make a pun about moving, also a plus. Organic Valley protein plus ultra-filtered milk. Protein plus pasture raised. Learn more at organicvalley.com.

52:11Let's talk about modern home shopping. It's sort of become a fun side hobby, right? Scrolling listings at night, dreaming about kitchens you've never seen, or backyards you haven't even stepped foot in, all from the comforts of pretty much anywhere. Redfin knows a lot of people like you want to own, but are stuck in this browsing mode loop. That's where Redfin flips the script. With listings that update within minutes and tours you can book right from the Redfin app, you can see your dream home the moment it appears. Now, liking a listing is easy, but actually landing it, that's where Redfin comes in.

52:47Redfin has over 2 ,200 agents with local expertise. And Redfin agents close twice as many deals as other agents. That means they want to help you win, not just window shop. Redfin is built to help you go from just looking to wait. This could actually be home. So become the newest neighbor on the block. Visit Redfin.com to start finding and start owning. That's redfin.com.

53:23All right, we're back. Daniel, I want to start with a question to you. What is an AI satellite? Why do you want an AI satellite? I think when he says AI satellite, he's thinking about all the data centers we're building to power AI. because AI essentially is deep neural networks and neural networks are basically linear algebra, which rely on matrix multiplication, which means multiplying a bunch of numbers by another bunch of numbers. And that's much faster if you do them in parallel rather than doing them one at a time. And there are special chips, GPUs, which were invented for calculating very quickly how to draw blood on your screen for your video games.

54:06And along the way, invented hardware technology to very quickly do matrix multiplication because you also need that for graphics on your video game. And then AI companies realized, oh, that's also the same technology we need to do with the linear algebra inside of our neural networks. So now GPUs are basically AI chips. Even though they were invented for video games, they found this other use. And I think now the market is just swamped by people using them for AI. So they shouldn't be called GPUs anymore. They should be called like AIPUs or something. I don't know. And so I think when he says AI satellites, he's thinking data centers in space in order to power AI.

54:46OK. All right. So, yeah. So Musk has an AI company called XAI, which was recently acquired by SpaceX. I love that when Musk buys his own company with his own company, it feels like a scam. Yes, it feels weird. But anyway, he owns the world, so he gets to do what he wants. And so he's done that. These data centers, as I understand it, and you probably know more, are getting like huge. Like hasn't – didn't Microsoft buy Three Mile Island so they could use that nuclear power plant to run their data center? Absolutely. The thing that limits AI right now seems to be the available GPUs. Like the more GPUs you throw at these things, the more powerful they get.

55:28There's this scaling behavior where it just seems like going bigger means smarter. So everybody's trying to go bigger than everybody else. And there's a huge market now for these GPUs and for memory also in these chips, which is why like computers are getting expensive and memory is very expensive and GPUs are hard to find because it's like one company in the world, NVIDIA, that knows how to make cutting edge GPUs. Must be a good time to work at NVIDIA. Yes. Must be a good time to own NVIDIA stock. Yeah, right. Right. Right. Okay. So why space? Like why move that all to space? Because that's got to be really expensive to do.

56:08Why not just keep doing that here? Yeah. So we build these things in massive data centers here on the earth, and they take a lot of water to cool these computers because computers use electricity. And when you do calculations, they heat up. And so you got to cool them. So we use a lot of water to cool them. They draw a lot of power. They take a lot of space. There's environmental impact. Real estate is expensive. And so recently, Musk has been talking a lot about data centers in space. And people have been talking about this for years, but mostly it was scoffed at. And now people are taking it more seriously.

56:42And so let me try to steel man the arguments for data centers in space. Why do people want to do that at all? Well, number one, there's power up there, right? If you have solar panels, then those solar panels see the sun much more often, like there's no clouds in space. right? If you are far enough from the earth's surface, then you can always be in sunshine. So solar panels can power you. There's more power in space. So there's that. The other issue is environmental impact. Some people argue like, why should we cover the surface of the earth in data centers? We should just put those out in space.

57:18Also because there's like infinite real estate out there, right? You don't need to take up land that somebody was going to use to build houses. It just fills space with data centers. Space is really big and there's plenty of room up there. And so, you know, in terms of like scalability, that's definitely an advantage. You can flip some of the cons and try to make them pros. Like one of the cons is it's hard to get up there. So anyone who's ever like run a computing system knows you got to reboot the stuff. You got to repair the stuff. You got to get in there sometimes physically to fix things.

57:50And that's harder to do out in space. Remember when we fixed the Hubble, we had to launch the shuttle with astronauts to do a spacewalk to fix the Hubble. It was a huge pain. So now you're talking about maintaining a data center in space. But these guys flip it and they say, ooh, that makes it less susceptible to terrorists, for example, right? So it's like data sovereignty. You're out there in space. You own these computers where the law is fuzzy, as you've often said, Kelly. And so like if my data is out in space, then I don't have to worry about like the U.S. administration trying to subpoena it, right, because it's not in their jurisdiction.

58:29Maybe my lawyers say. What do you think about that argument? The face you're making tells me you're not persuaded. I mean, I think you're still supposed to register your satellite. when you launch something, it is the responsibility, I believe, of somebody because if your satellite smashes into something, they need to know who would get sued. And so I think someone is still responsible for it. And there is a nation that would be responsible for paying the bill if you don't pay the bill. And so I'm pretty sure that you're not in a legal gray area if you're out there. I'm not sure that that holds up.

59:11I think the strongest argument is that eventually we're going to have space industry and we want to build stuff for space. And if you do that, it makes sense to build it in space. The idea is if you need the stuff for space, then why build it on the surface of the Earth and then launch it? So if you need, for example, data centers on the moon, build them in space, have them in space. Don't build them on the Earth and try to operate them from the moon or then launch them. And so if you have some sort of self-sustaining space economy, then I do think there are arguments for building data centers out in space using materials you already have out in space, assuming you have people living out there in space who can maintain them and support them and all this kind of stuff.

59:52But it's a bit of a bootstrapping issue. And I think part of that argument is because Earth's gravity well is so hard to get out of that if you were making the satellites, for example, on the moon, it would be much easier to get them out into orbit. Exactly. Relative to Earth. Even if they bring launch costs down, right? Building huge data centers in space would be very expensive. But it is possible to build them in space for use in space eventually. Okay. So it sounds like Musk's plan is to build AI satellites on the moon and then use what he's calling a mass driver to shoot them out into space.

1:00:33Yeah. Which is interesting because he's a big Heinlein fan. And this sounds very Moon is a Harsh Mistress-like where they used a mass driver to shoot rocks using an AI towards the Earth. But anyway, maybe I'm projecting too much. But anyway, so. Well, mass drivers are cool because on the surface of the moon, gravity is much less. And so you don't need like chemical rocket technology to escape the moon's gravity. You just need like a big gun. And so a mass driver is just like, you know, electromagnetic rail or, you know, even a or even like a centrifuge, you know, that spins up and then throws things into space.

1:01:17That's pretty cool. Now that you've done a pretty good job of emphasizing all the positives. Let's go ahead and give it the Kelly treatment and talk about some of the negatives of doing this on the moon. Yeah, so there are challenges to data centers in space. Number one is cooling. There's a lot of misunderstanding about how this works. People think of space as cold. And so, ooh, isn't cooling just free out in space? The problem is space is an insulator, right? It's a vacuum. The thing you have in your thermos, for example, that keeps your coffee hot or your beverages cold is a vacuum gap between the beverage and the rest of the planet because it's hard for heat to go across a vacuum.

1:02:01And that means if you have something hot out in space, there's no air to blow across it to get heated up to carry that heat away. You can cool down in space, but there's only one way to do it, which is to radiate that heat away. So remember, everything that's out there that has a temperature glows, and that means that it's cooling. It's giving off energy. That also happens down here on Earth. You have like a hot piece of metal. It's red hot. It's glowing. It's giving off that energy. It's going to cool down. But here on Earth, we have two ways to do it, convection and radiation. Out in space, you only have radiation.

1:02:33So you need to build big radiators out in space or bring a bunch of water to run across your chips, but you already are short on water. So cooling is going to be extra hard in space, not extra easy. That's number one. That's number one. Then there's the question of the radiation. Our data centers here on Earth run under the protection of our magnetic shield, right? The magnetic field of the Earth deflects a lot of cosmic rays and the atmosphere, which protects us from cosmic rays. Even still, data centers, as we talked about on a recent episode, have to correct for bit flips from cosmic rays. I had dinner the other night with a guy who runs the data centers for NVIDIA, and they have all this cool technology to correct for bit flips, which is frustrating to me because when they delete those bit flips, they're deleting physics information that could teach us about the universe.

1:03:22Calm down, calm down. I know. But somebody's got to generate that image of puppies playing poker or whatever. Anyway, this is harder out in space because you have no protection, and radiation is bad for computers. And what you're doing is running computers in space. And so you need extra hardcore chips, which we have not developed, or you need shielding, which means, again, more mass. So this is harder to do in space than it is here on Earth. It's a more important, more challenging problem. And then, of course, the biggest one is maintenance, right? Something always breaks. You build something at scale, it needs a whole team of people to keep it running.

1:04:00Nothing, even like the Golden Gate Bridge, just stands there and works, right? It needs constant maintenance. Everything does, which means you need a team of people up there all the time or launching up there all the time. And it's much further away. Imagine you were in charge of maintaining a computer on a table in Antarctica. It would be really hard to do if you could never go there and fix it or if it was hard to get there. And so this thing is going to be down all the time and there are going to be people trying to fix it all the time. And maybe we could get better at building computers that didn't need so much maintenance, but we're definitely not there yet.

1:04:35Well, and what about maintaining those giant solar panels? Yeah, exactly, right? Solar panels also are sensitive to radiation. So those things are going to get destroyed. They need to get replaced or they need to be more robust. Another disadvantage is it's further away. And so maybe if you don't care about latency, then it's not a big deal. But if you want like fast turnaround times to your calculation, you want to press the button and get the answer instantly, then you don't want to put your data center far away because that adds latency to your calculation. I don't want to wait for my puppy playing poker.

1:05:11And in terms of environmental issues, if you're building the stuff here on Earth and then launching it, like launching things into space is not great for the environment. So I don't actually know what Musk's plan is. Do you think that his plan is to build these things on the moon or would that be just like way too complicated to do? No, I think his plan is to build things on the moon. That makes a lot more sense, but it assumes that we have the capacity to do this on the moon. But yeah, it's a lot cheaper if you build these things essentially in space for use in space. Building them on the surface and then launching them makes very little sense to me.

1:05:46But even still, you have to face the issues of maintenance, of radiation, of cooling. These are all solvable problems, but it makes it expensive and laborious. And I don't think they have been solved yet. But, you know, SpaceX is an amazing company and they catch rockets with chopsticks. So let's not put anything past them. All right. Well, we will have to keep an eye on this as the years and the decades pass and see what they do. And, you know, in the meantime, if you're interested in more information on what it's like to live and work in space, A City on Mars is a pretty great book to check out to learn more about that.

1:06:20As is Becoming Martian by our friend Scott Solomon. Which came out today, which is February 17th. You won't be hearing this on February 17th, but you should definitely check out Becoming Martian. And you should check out the prior two episodes on which Scott Solomon was a guest. And so while we think there are challenges to building a self-sustaining colony on the moon, it's not impossible and it is worth pushing. But we should be realistic about when it's going to happen. Yes, and we should try to do it ethically. And I will try not to be too much of a wet blanket at this point. So we'll end the show now.

1:06:51Have a nice day!

1:07:00Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe is produced by iHeartRadio. We would love to hear from you. We really would. We want to know what questions you have about this extraordinary universe. We want to know your thoughts on recent shows, suggestions for future shows. If you contact us, we will get back to you. We really mean it. We answer every message. Email us at questions at danielandkelly.org. Or you can find us on social media. We have accounts on X, Instagram, Blue Sky, and on all of those platforms, you can find us at D &K Universe. Don't be shy. Write to us. Okay, laundry stinks. Literally.

1:07:41I mean, you could just keep buying new underwear. Not that I've ever done that. Or maybe sort your clothes into piles based on how re-wearable or filthy they are. Or just use Arm & Hammer Deep Clean. It's made for real-life stings and stains. So even if you don't do laundry the, quote, right way, Deep Clean will knock it out. I mean, it is from the number one liquid detergent brand that tackles more loads than any other. Come clean with Arm & Hammer Deep Clean. Number one claim based on total wash loads sold. 250 years ago, America made a promise of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

1:08:21Since 1903, Harley-Davidson has been living it out on the open road at the next exit ramp with old friends, new ones, and the next generation of riders. Because the best part of any promise is keeping it. Harley-Davidson Motorcycles. Ride.

1:08:43Here's the truth. You could literally be adored by everyone and then come home and still get completely ignored by your own cat. It's classic cat behavior. But new Sheba Premium Puree is a lickable treat that changes all that. They're protein-rich, made with bone broth, and have the smooth, creamy texture cats go crazy for, especially when it's hand-fed. Yeah, it's more than a treat. It's a fast pass to favorite human status. So feed your cat Sheba and go from totally ignored to truly adored in just 12 days, guaranteed, or your money back. Learn more at Sheba.com. Organic Valley Protein Plus Ultra-Filtered Milk is pasture-raised from cows that might take more steps than most people.

1:09:26That's a plus. And it has 50 % more protein and 50 % less sugar than regular milk. That's a big plus. And the fact that I didn't make a pun about moving, also a plus. Organic Valley Protein Plus Ultra-Filtered Milk. Protein plus pasture-raised. Learn more at OrganicValley.com. This is an iHeart Podcast Guaranteed Human