Husband testifies about affair with au pair. Alleged killer of UGA student on trial. Plus, no body murders.

0:02Mazda has been named Consumer Reports' safest new car brand. It starts with our approach. Every Mazda comes standard with proactive safety features. So you're more aware of what's around you, more focused on the road ahead, and ready before problems ever start. Mazda. More of what matters most to you. Go to mazdausa.com to learn more. Consumer Reports does not endorse or promote any product. Is your education moving at the speed of the world around you? Grand Canyon University doesn't settle for the status quo, they shatter it. At GCU, they offer industry-driven programs, built to move at the speed of relevance, focusing on practical skills and career readiness for every learner.

0:46With over 132 ,000 students joining in, both on campus and online, GCU is proving that education can be affordable and exceptional. GCU is purpose-driven education. Find your purpose today at gcu.edu. Hey, Jim, who's there? Anybody? You're listening to the Dateline story meeting. Yeah, we got a lot of people here. Winter storms closed courthouses around the country earlier this week, but our producers still have plenty to talk about. The family was in full force at this hearing. They get the police to reopen the case. There might be more here. Welcome to Dateline True Crime Weekly. I'm Lester Holt.

1:27It's January 29th, and here's what's on our docket. In Athens, Georgia, after a law student was murdered 25 years ago, her grieving family teamed up with a podcaster to try and solve her murder. This week, her alleged killer finally heads to trial. He does have a long rap sheet, including assault and multiple probation offenses. In Dateline Roundup, the Crystal Rogers case is back in the news, and allegations of witness intimidation in the case of Utah mom and murder suspect Corey Richens. She alleges the prosecution threatened not just a witness, but the witness's dog as well. Plus, how to solve a murder when there's no body?

2:09We talked to a veteran cold case detective. We're not giving them a pass just because they've been better at disposing of a body. But before all that, we're heading back to Northern Virginia and the trial of the former IRS agent accused of masterminding a double murder so he could run off with the family au pair. Over the past two and a half weeks, a jury in Fairfax County has heard dueling accounts of what happened inside the home of Brendan Banfield on the morning of February 24, 2023, and the violent encounter which ended up with two people dead, Brendan's wife, Christine, and a man by the name of Joseph Ryan.

2:50The prosecution alleges that Brendan, who has pleaded not guilty, lured Joseph Ryan, a complete stranger, to the Banfield home and shot him. Then they say Brendan fatally stabbed his wife. Prosecutors allege it was all part of an elaborate plot to frame Ryan for his wife's murder. Brendan would be the hero of the day. He would show up, kill the guy, kill his wife, pretending that it had been that guy. The defense says that's not true at all. They insist there's no evidence Brendan lured Ryan to the home, that in fact it was Christine who invited Ryan over for a sexual liaison. And when he got there, Ryan attacked her with a knife.

3:32They say Brendan was heroically trying to defend her when he shot Ryan dead. And this week, the jury got to hear from Brendan Banfield himself as he took the stand to tell his story. I think that it's an absurd line of questioning that a plan was made to get rid of my wife. We're joined now by Dateline producer Brad Davis, who has been working on this story. Brad, good to have you here. Great to be here, Lester. Okay, so let's talk about the family au pair. How does she fit into all this? Yeah, Lester. She was the prosecution's star witness and testified on day one of the trial, which was sort of a surprise to have her testify so soon.

4:13Her name is Juliana Perez Magalhães. She's a young Brazilian woman who took care of the Banfield's daughter, Valerie. And prosecutors say she and Brendan were lovers, that they wanted to be together, and according to prosecutors, that's why Brendan came up with this elaborate plan to murder his wife. And she told the jury that she helped Brendan lure Joseph Ryan to the home. Explain how long that went down. That's correct. According to Juliana, she and Brenda did something called catfishing, which is where you pretend to be someone you're not online. The au pair, Juliana, said that they went on a fetish website called FetLife and posed as Christine, using her pictures to invite Ryan over for a sexual liaison.

4:54Then when he got to the house, Brendan and Juliana shot him. The defense said her testimony is not credible, and she's telling the prosecution just what they want to hear in exchange for a more lenient sentence for her own role in the murders. She's pleaded guilty to manslaughter for shooting Joseph Ryan, and she's not supposed to be sentenced until after this trial is over. Okay, so let's talk about the defense. Over the past week, they've said that there just isn't enough evidence for the catfishing theory, and they called a man named Brendan Miller to the stand to talk about that. Who is he?

5:24Brendan Miller was the Fairfax County detective who originally analyzed the electronic devices in this case. He concluded that he couldn't rule out the possibility that Christine was in control of her device when the FetLife account was created. That she, according to him, could have been the one who actually created that profile on the website. How did the prosecution push back on Miller's testimony, given that their whole case hinges on this catfishing theory? Well, when they cross-examined Miller, they got him to admit that there's a lot he doesn't know. Miller said that without a witness or photographic evidence of someone using a device, you can never know 100 percent who's using a device at a particular point in time.

6:03And in this case, when you dug into Christine's phone, Christine's laptop, were you able to put someone concretely behind the screen? At times, yes. But throughout the context of all of the conversations that you saw occurring on Christine's phone, could you conclusively opine as to who was behind the screen? No. So we've all been on pins and needles for the last few days. At the end of last week, we heard that Brendan himself was planning to testify. We don't often see defendants take the stand in criminal trials. How did that come about? There was a conference with the lawyers and the judge outside of the jury's presence, and Brendan's attorney confirmed that he wanted to testify.

6:48But Brendan didn't testify. Jurors were sent home for the weekend, which turned into a four-day weekend because of the massive snowstorm. And he finally took the stand Wednesday afternoon after a morning of technical testimony. Tell us more about what was said. Well, Brendan's attorney started by asking him questions about his life with Christine and their daughter Valerie, you know, before all this happened. How long were you and Christine together? We were together since we were 18. How did you meet? We met freshman year at college at Quinnipiac University. And he talked about, you know, she was a great mom and he loved her so much.

7:26You know, he was really talking about a very, you know, sort of happy family life. Christine loved Valerie very dearly. And Valerie was very attached to her mother. This is, you know, it was tragic, their separation. Did he address his relationship with Juliana, his au pair? Yes. He told the jury that initially it began as a professional relationship as she, you know, began working for the couple. But then it turned into something more. He said that Juliana took the initial steps, sort of flirting with him and texts, and then it got to a point where they were home alone. We were sitting at the island in the kitchen, and she scooted her seat closer to mine a couple times.

8:20At some point, I told her that I was going to go to bed. And when I went upstairs, I went to the left, and she also took a step towards the left with me. And then she came with me into my bedroom. And they began a full, he said it was a full-blown affair. Yeah, and then Brendan dropped a pretty big bomb about his relationship with Christine. Yes, he said that he had had various affairs before his affair with Juliana. I have had affairs previously in that there's nothing that changes in mine and Christine's relationship. Now, was Christine aware of your previous affairs? She was aware of at least two previous affairs.

9:06Okay. And likewise, were you aware of her affairs? Yes, I was also aware that she had affairs. He said that Christine didn't know about the affair with Juliana and that he didn't plan to leave Christine. This was just another affair to him. So unlike the prosecutors argued, he wasn't trying to get rid of his wife. Did you ever create any sort of a plan with Juliana? No, there was no plan. And I think that it's an absurd line of questioning for something that is not serious, that a plan was made to get rid of my wife. That is absolutely crazy. And how did Brendan respond to some of the main evidence from the prosecution?

9:50The fact that Juliana says they made the FedLife account together. He said he didn't know anything about it until after Christine died. He said he never used Christine's devices, nor had Juliana, which contradicts what Juliana said in her testimony. So we'll have to see who the jury believes on that. And what's next at trial? Well, we're taping this Wednesday evening. Brendan will be back on the stand Thursday morning to answer more questions and be on cross-examination, which is really always the test. If you're a defendant testifying, it's how you handle your cross-examination. Okay, a lot at play there.

10:26Brad, thanks very much for the updates. You bet. Coming up, the murder of a University of Georgia law student went unsolved for decades until a podcaster started getting calls from people who knew her.

10:44Relax. Apple Pay is secure by design. When you pay with a physical debit or credit card, you're handing your card number over. With Apple Pay, your card number is never shared with the merchant. Apple Pay uses a device-specific number and unique transaction code to help process your payment instead of your actual card number. Plus, Apple Pay doesn't keep transaction information that can be tied back to you or sell your data to third parties for marketing or advertising purposes. Shop with confidence when you check out with Apple Pay. Terms apply. Summer is the perfect time to rethink what clothes you're reaching for every day.

11:19With the warmer weather, you want lighter fabrics, better materials, pieces that just feel good the moment you put them on and look effortless. That's where Quince comes in. Quince's summer essentials are crafted from fabrics like linen, organic cotton, washable silk, without the luxury markup. And it's not just clothing. With Quince, you can find elevated essentials across home, kitchen, bedding, and beyond. And according to Quince, they work directly with ethical factories, cut out the middlemen. So you're paying for quality, not brand markup. Elevate your summer wardrobe. Go to quince.com slash dateline for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.

12:00Now available in Canada, too. That's quince.com slash dateline for free shipping and 365-day returns. Quince.com slash dateline. Grainger knows when you're a procurement manager for an office park, you're not managing one building. You're managing all of them. And to stay ahead, you need to see through walls and around corners. Lights about to fail, filters ready to clog, HVAC on its last leg. If you wait until something breaks, you're already behind. Count on Grainger for quality products, easy reordering, and 24-7 support. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click grainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.

12:46All right, now we're turning to Athens, Georgia. If you're a college football fan, you probably know it as the home of the Georgia Bulldogs. But 25 years ago, a crime there shattered the community and remained unsolved for decades. On the morning of January 19, 2001, firefighters rushed to the scene of a blaze at an off-campus apartment at the University of Georgia. They made a horrifying discovery in a locked room. The body of 23-year-old law student Tara Louise Baker. She'd been raped, stabbed, and left to die in the fire. Investigators chased down lead after lead, taking a close look at three people in her life.

13:29Her boyfriend, an attorney at the law firm where she worked, and a fellow law student. But the case hit a wall until 2020, when Tara's mother teamed up with a podcaster who began unearthing new leads and new theories. As the web grows, there are some who get caught in the truth, like a poor bug in a spider's web. And that, my friends, is the goal, to finally catch in the web of truth the person responsible for taking Tara's life away from her dear mother and her family. In 2023, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation took a new look at the case. And this week, 25 years after her brutal death, a man by the name of Edric Lamont Faust is standing trial for terrorist murder.

14:15He's pleaded not guilty to multiple charges, including murder, arson, and sexual assault. Here to get us up to speed as the trial gets underway is Dateline producer Dorothy Newell. She's at the courthouse for us. And, Dorothy, I normally wouldn't start an interview with this kind of question, but it's pertinent here. How's the weather down there? Well, they never got the big snow that so many places got hit with, but they did get rain and sub-freezing temperatures. So the ice on the roads and sidewalks is pretty treacherous. Yeah, and I point out, I'm asking that question because some courts were closed because of this big storm that was coming.

14:52Yep, yep. Jury selection was delayed by a day. All right. Before we get into the trial, tell us what you've learned about Tara. Who was she? Her family and friends say that Tara was an exceptional student, always was. Her friends described her as incredibly sweet, warm, hardworking, and kind of wise beyond her years. Her three younger siblings adored her and apparently called her their North Star. Okay, let's turn to the night of the murder. What do we know about Tara's final hours? Well, according to court records, on the evening of January 18th, 2001, Tara was studying at the University of Georgia Law Library with a friend.

15:32Around 7.30 p.m., that friend left and walked home. And later that night, Tara called to make sure she'd gotten home safely. That was kind of Tara's thing. That phone call with her friend, that appears to be the last time anyone close to Tara talked to her. And early on, police believe this wasn't some kind of random attack. Why? Well, first off, her friends have said that Tara was really safety conscious. They couldn't imagine she would have left her door unlocked. But according to court records, investigators found no signs of forced entry. So many people believe the killer was someone Tara knew or at least someone who had a key.

16:11And that's why police focused really hard on people who were close to her. But the early investigation kept hitting dead ends, partly because the killer apparently wiped the apartment clean and set fire to the home, destroying any telltale evidence. I've been following this case for about five years, and I remember someone in law enforcement telling me they probably wouldn't find the killer until he confessed. Okay, so years have passed, decades really. Tell us about this podcast and how that may have changed things. Okay, so here's this guy, Cameron J. Harrelson, who's lived in Athens for many years.

16:47And he's had all kinds of jobs, marketing consultant, wedding officiant. He was even an apprentice funeral director. But in 2020, he launched a podcast called Classic City Crime. As you may know, Classic City is Athens' nickname. And he started with the Tara Baker case. He scored interviews with Tara's family and friends, many of whom had never spoken out publicly. and they were clearly frustrated that this case had gone unsolved for so long. You have had to relive Tara's death over and over again. Yes, yes, and it has worn me down. Cameron and Tara's mom didn't just focus their efforts on Tara's case.

17:24They ended up lobbying for a crucial piece of legislation to help other families. Tell us about that. That's right, Lester. Tara's family, Cameron, and another family, the Coleman's, whose daughter was also murdered, they pushed for legislation that would require law enforcement to review unsolved homicides if victims' families asked them to. And so in 2023, they stood together as the governor signed the law into effect. The Coleman-Baker Act set up and funded a cold case unit within the Georgia Bureau of Investigation. And Tara's mom said she hadn't expected it, but one of the first cases they looked into was Tara's.

18:02They worked the case with local police, the FBI, and other agencies. And in April 2024, they announced they'd made an arrest. Police arrested 48-year-old Edric Lamont Faust and charged him with felony murder. Police said there's no evidence that Baker and Faust were acquainted. Okay, so tell us what do we know about the defendant? Well, for starters, he lived near Tara, but he had no known connection to her. He does have a long rap sheet, including assault, battery, public indecency, and multiple probation offenses. So if the defense says it's not their guy, do they have any alternate theory about who did it?

18:41The defense says that the crime was so brutal and drawn out that it suggests a crime, you know, driven by rage. They also pointed out that the killer took Tara's laptop and documents from a cabinet and did not take her valuable jewelry. And that raises the question, why would Foss do that? So does the defense have anyone in mind as an alternate suspect? Yeah, well, they're pointing their finger at someone investigators looked at early on, Tara's boyfriend. But he took a polygraph at the time and he passed. He also talked to Cameron Jay on the podcast and adamantly denied having anything to do with the murder.

19:15I was fed up with not getting answers and not being talked to like somebody who just lost somebody they absolutely loved. And you had a verified alibi for the night of Kara's murder and the morning of, correct? Yes, sir. So as we're taping this, jury selection is not complete in the case. So where do things stand with that? So it started yesterday afternoon with a big crowd of people that has been winnowed down. They just started, as we're speaking, they've just started a second panel of about a dozen people. So we're waiting. All right. Well, this is one we will definitely be keeping an eye on.

19:52And Dorothy, thanks so much. Thank you, Lester. Up next, it's time for Dateline Roundup, a big update in the case of murdered Kentucky mom, Crystal Rogers, and prosecutors under fire in the case of Utah mom, Corey Richens, plus an inside look at a murder investigation with no body.

20:17Need to pay a friend back for festival tickets or a morning coffee run? Apple Cash makes it simple. Just tap plus in the Messages app to find Apple Cash. No need to jump between apps or search for usernames. It's a private and secure way to send money. Send cash right in the chat with Apple Cash. Apple Cash services are provided by Green Dot Bank. Member FDIC. Terms apply.

20:46This NBA playoffs with FanDuel. You're not just watching the playoffs. You're a part of them. Steve's got the phone, opens FanDuel, and he's going for threes. Be a part of the action on FanDuel. All customers get a profit boost every NBA playoff game day. 21 plus and present in select states. Opt-in required. Bonus issued as non-withdrawable profit boost tokens. Restrictions apply, including any token expiration and max wager amount. See full terms at FanDuel.com slash sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET. Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for$15 a month plan that I've been enjoying.

21:25It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three month plan equivalent to$15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. Default terms at mintmobile.com.

21:52Welcome back. Joining me for this week's Roundup is Dateline producer Rachel White. Rachel, thanks for being with me. Thanks for having me. So our first story, we head to New Jersey for an update in the trial of Paul Canero. He's accused of killing his younger brother and business partner, Keith, along with Keith's wife and kids, then setting their house and his own on fire in an attempt to cover up the crime. He's pleaded not guilty to all 16 charges against him. So, Rachel, it's week three in the trial and prosecutors are still making their case. What's new here? Yeah, so, Lester, recently they have turned their focus to physical evidence.

22:33And seeing that physical evidence that's been preserved for about seven years has made the case feel much more present. So the crime scene detective walked through the evidence recovered from Paul Canero's Ocean Township home and Paul's wife's Porsche after the murders. Prosecutors alleged that the Porsche was the vehicle Paul drove home from the murders. What did they find? The detective showed the jury a backpack that was found in the car, and he said that inside was a gun barrel, a silencer, and a knife. Though in his testimony, he made it clear the knife wasn't confirmed to be the murder weapon.

23:11Outside the home, investigators found a gas can, and prosecutors allege this was the accelerant that Paul Canero used to set his own house on fire. Finally, they moved on to some bloody clothing found in Paul's basement, which has been a key piece of evidence for the prosecution's case. And prosecutors talked about that bloody clothing in their opening statement, and specifically a pair of genes they say belong to Paul Canero. Let's take a listen. Those genes, as well as numerous other items, were sent out for DNA testing. And what you're going to learn is that DNA located on multiple areas of those bloody genes in the defendant's basement came from none other than his niece, Sophia Canero, and in one area from his nephew, Jesse Canero.

23:58So, Rachel, the point the prosecution was making here was, why would Paul Canero have the children's blood on his genes, and why would those genes be in his basement? But the defense pushed back on whether the prosecution could even prove the genes belonged to him. That's right, Lester, and they got into whether the pair of genes were compared to other genes found at the Canero home. This investigator said they were not compared. Okay, well, lots more to come in this trial. Paul Canero, as we said, has denied all of this. Okay, for our next story, we're headed to Kentucky for an update in the case of Crystal Rogers, the mother of five who has been missing from Bardstown since July 2015.

24:40Her body has never been found. Last summer, 10 years after her disappearance, her former boyfriend, Brooks Houck, was convicted of her murder. Rachel, you've been covering this case for some time now. What's the latest on this one? So the news here is that Brooks Houck has filed an appeal with the Kentucky Supreme Court, and his attorneys are asking for an acquittal or a new trial. What's their basis for an appeal? So Houck's attorneys are saying that prosecutors didn't present enough evidence at trial to lead to a conviction, and they're arguing that the prosecutors couldn't prove a murder even took place.

25:15They wrote, quote, with no body, no murder weapon, no idea of where the alleged murder occurred or how it allegedly occurred. The Commonwealth presented a case made up entirely of circumstantial evidence. Now, the jury would obviously disagree that there wasn't enough evidence to convict. So what's next in the appellate process? Well, as we know here at Dateline, the wheels of justice turned slowly. So we don't know yet when the Kentucky Supreme Court will even review the appeal, but we'll report back once we know more. Okay, let's move on. For our final story, we're heading to Utah, where trial preparation is in full swing for Corey Richens.