SPECIAL SERIES ==> How to Use Clicks to Win at Segmentation <== | BATHROOM Break #104 COLLAB: The Marketing Millennials + Do This, Not That

20 Apr 2026 · 11 min · 4 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

How to turn email click-throughs into higher-value segmentation using retargeting, CRM tagging, and click-quality filters.

Guests

Jay Schwedelson (Do This, Not That; subjectline.com) and Daniel Murray (Marketing Millennials). Both discuss practical email/marketing tactics; Jay also shares caffeine-to-chamomile tea routine as a personal aside.

Key claims

Most clickers won’t convert, so clicks should trigger segmentation. Segment clickers into their own database, then run retargeting/remarketing on social and display ads. Tag clicks in the CRM by content type and offer type to power segmented campaigns. Exclude bot clicks and unsubscribe clicks from click-through rate reporting; filter for ICP.

Notable examples

“2–3 a.m.” email sends to estimate bot-click inflation; using an invisible above-the-fold link to measure real engagement; removing unsubscribe-link clicks from CTR.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Morning Beverage Routines

0:45 to 2:55

Discussion about morning beverage choices and routines.

“And before we jump in, I want to ask you a question because I don't really know the answer to this.”

Maximizing Click-Throughs

2:55 to 5:21

Strategies for improving click-through rates and segmentation.

“episode so let's jump into it um we're gonna be talking about some quick win tactics i want to talk about clicks for a second.”

Understanding Click Data

5:21 to 9:09

Insights on analyzing click data and avoiding common pitfalls.

“And I also think to just like misnomers is, cause I is make sure you're optimizing for clicks on actual good CTAs.”

Ordering Coffee Anxiety

9:09 to 10:33

Light-hearted conversation about the stress of ordering coffee.

“There needs to be like a phobia for that.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:07Jay Schwedelson:Welcome to a new special series called The Bathroom Break. That extra 10 minutes, you either have to listen to marketing tips or use the bathroom or both.

0:16Daniel Murray:But I don't recommend both, but that's your choice. This collab is going to be super fun. We have Daniel Murray from the Marketing Millennials and me, Jay Schwedelson, from the Do This Not That podcast and subjectline.com. each episode in the series, we are going to go over quick tips about different marketing topics. And if you want to be in the bathroom, fine, just don't tell us about it. Thanks for checking it out.

0:39Jay Schwedelson:We are back with another bathroom break. I'm here with the Jay Shwedelson of Do This Not That podcast. And before we jump in, I want to ask you a question because I don't really know the answer to this. So what is your beverage of choice in the morning? And is it hot or cold? And do you have a routine with your beverage in the morning or is it something different every day?

1:06Daniel Murray:Well, this is very odd that you asked me that. You probably don't know this, but I usually, I have drank a lot of coffee, an extreme amount of coffee, like my whole adult life. And then I felt like really jittery, right? So I'm now on week seven. I gave up all caffeine, all caffeine seven weeks ago. So I've had no coffee, no nothing with caffeine. And so my new favorite drink of choice is chamomile tea. I hope all my college buddies hear this and I get shredded because when you go in somewhere and you go, can I have a small chamomile tea? I should go and just basically kick my own ass i've done that once where everybody's owning alcohol and i was like could i

1:52Jay Schwedelson:get a like water with lemon please yeah yeah hot water and lemon and everybody looked at me like

1:58Daniel Murray:what are you doing why are you we're all drinking hot water with lemon oh yeah i'm on that train also i am i am i'm like eliminating everything for people who don't know jay used to like when

2:10Jay Schwedelson:I used to see my conferences. He used to be on his fifth Celsius by 10 a.m. So this is a big change.

2:18Daniel Murray:This is a big change. I didn't get any headaches or anything. And the weirdest thing is I thought when I cut out caffeine, I was going to have no energy and I fall asleep at my desk. I feel exactly the same. I'm still out of control. So yeah, chamomile tea. What are you? What is your drink of choice i always have to have a coffee in the morning like but i do i i would say it's

2:41Jay Schwedelson:more of a routine than uh like i like it as a routine thing after 12 i don't drink any caffeine so like it has to be like at an 8 8 a.m and then i will i only have one and it's done so well speaking

2:54Daniel Murray:of one and done you'll probably be listeners be one and done with listening to us after this episode so let's jump into it um we're gonna be talking about some quick win tactics i want to talk about clicks for a second. So I'm going to get right into it. I think everybody is sleeping on what they are doing with click-throughs. What do I mean by that? So let's say you send out emails. Could be a promotional email, business, consumer, nonprofit, doesn't matter. Could be a newsletter email. It doesn't matter how big or small your brand is. What do you do? Oh, you get some opens, you get some clicks, you get some customers, you get some downloads, whatever.

3:26Daniel Murray:But the majority of people who click on your email, they're not going to convert, right? Whatever it is, they're not going to convert. So, you know, maybe somewhere you have in your scoring methodology and some sort of automation tool that you give a couple extra, you know, points to a contact in your database that they clicked on an email, but that's not even close to enough. Here are some of the things that you should be thinking about doing with people that click through on your emails. Number one, you should be segmenting out anyone that clicked on your emails into its own little database.

3:57Daniel Murray:and then you should be running retargeting and remarketing programs across all of social media, all your display ads, just with your click-through contacts, because they're way more engaged than just taking to your entire database and remarketing to them. And you could run remarketing and retargeting campaigns to your click activity at like, like for dollars, for actual no money whatsoever. And then the other thing I don't think that people are doing with their clicks is tagging them in their CRM and in their databases. What do I mean by that? Everybody's always trying to find out more information about people that click.

4:37Daniel Murray:I mean, people that are in their database, people that are, you know, whatever your database is made up of. Whatever the topic is that the person clicked on, right? It's an HR software and they clicked on hiring stuff. You know, it's a consumer thing about sneakers and they clicked on hiking. Okay. You want to have tags associated with all the different content types and all the different offer types of those clicks in your messaging. And then you want to add those tags in your CRM or in your email tool or whatever your marketing tool is. Because then when you go to do a segmented campaign, you can pull on those tags that you've assigned to those click-throughs.

5:12Daniel Murray:And you're sleeping on the best way to segment your database. So your clicks have a lot more value than just actually people clicking through. I like that.

5:21Jay Schwedelson:And I also think to just like misnomers is, cause I is make sure you're optimizing for clicks on actual good CTAs. I think you, because you can have clicks on your database that are of stupid links that are irrelevant to your, to what you're offering. So you could even go deeper and say they clicked on a ebook link. They clicked on a, um, a product link. They clicked on this. And also retargeting, you could do retargeting in ways with your lifecycle stuff. So you could do it with email retargeting. You could also not only push it to meta, you could push it to other channels that you're trying to remarket.

6:07So I like that technique of like thinking about clicks as a way to segment highly engaged people in your database.

6:21Jay Schwedelson:And but yeah, tag them. People make the mistake of not tagging because there's so many BS clicks that happen. So you want real clicks in your database that to be able to retarget.

6:35Daniel Murray:Yeah, I'll give you one simple hack that all the email deliverability people out there will hate me for, but I don't really care. Here's a newsflash for everybody. You have bot clicks in your tracking reports. I don't care what platform you use to send out your email. You have bot clicks, clicks that aren't real. Your clicks are inflated. That is the nature of the internet. If you want a real quick way to figure out the inflation of your click activity in your marketing metrics, what you want to do, and it's fine. Life will go on. Take one of your emails, send it out at like two or three in the morning.

7:10Daniel Murray:Okay? And you're like, why would I ever do that? And then isolate out the click-through activity that happens in the first 30 minutes. Here's the deal. You're not that popular at two or three in the morning. Your brand's not that popular, right? So any clicks that you're seeing in the first 30 minutes or two or three in the morning, those are bot clicks. And you can actually take that and say that's your baseline for how inflated your overall metrics are. and then you could actually get to what is my real click-through rate although some of you just want

7:38Jay Schwedelson:the vanity metrics you want to be really high what i do too is i put an invisible link above like above the fold and see how many people are clicking yeah that's what people do too and this is the problem like because you can we've gave the tip sometimes which is smart but also can inflate your kicks if you put the link in your logo to your offer it will inflate the clicks on your email. So if you put like another link above the logo that's hidden, you could see how many, because only computers are going to be able to see that link and not a regular person. Yeah.

8:15Daniel Murray:I mean, that's a hundred percent a cleaner way to do it. And the last thing I'll tell you on clicks, which you'll be shocked how many people do this, make sure your unsubscribe link click is not factored into your click-through rate. You would be shocked about how many companies do not actually discount the unsubscribe link from their click activity. You can't be like, we got a great click-through rate. We also have a high unsubscribe rate. Hmm, that's weird.

8:39Jay Schwedelson:And I think the last thing I would add is make sure you also have a filter of like ICP in the click report, because sometimes you'll have good clicks of people who are just like stragglers clicking and they're just interested. So take that and also make sure you look at the list and clean it for ICP because you can run it through an enrichment software and stuff like that too, to get more information and then push it to, to any ad platform out there. Totally.

9:09Daniel Murray:So let me, so back to the beginning here, are you like some sort of like a dude, like when you go to Starbucks, do you have like an order that's like, hi, I want a caramel macchiata, three pumps, no pumps, two things of Stevia and hold the cream. Or do you have like

9:24Jay Schwedelson:the most complicated order of all time are you an embarrassment but i do i did actually to be honest i was in the airport the other day and like i think starboard's trained me i felt like scared to go order like at the desk so i i went i was what saw it and i took out my app and mobile ordered it so i didn't have to talk to anybody because i'm i get so nervous like if i want to add one stevia i get like oh my goodness i add one little stevia to it it's it's getting crazy So I went mobile ordered.

9:55Daniel Murray:Were you scared of the barista? Yeah, I was scared of the barista. There needs to be like a phobia for that. Like, you know, barista phobia. Wow. Who knew? Wow. Meanwhile, you put out like this monster podcast. You talk to people all day long and you won't talk to the barista.

10:12Jay Schwedelson:Sometimes I just don't want to deal with people like knowing exactly what my order is every single time. And if I want to try something new, I'm like, I don't want to mess this up. So I want to go slowly. and look through the options. I feel rushed when I'm up there.

10:26Daniel Murray:And that's what I don't like. We'll keep it chill for you. Well, once again, we've crushed another episode. Everybody, leave Daniel a review. Follow the Market Millennials. Do this, not that. And keep it real. Daniel, come on, man. I got to get back to work. Get out of there. While he's still in there, this is Jay. Check out my podcast, Do This, Not That for marketers. Each week, we share really quick tips on stuff that can improve your marketing. and hope you give it a try. Oh, here's Daniel. He's finally out.

10:55Jay Schwedelson:Back from my bathroom break. This is Daniel. Go follow the Mark and Millie podcast, but also tune into this series. It's once a week, the bathroom break. We talk about marking tips that we just spew out and it could be anything from email, subject line to any marking tips in the world. We'll talk about it. Just give us a shout on LinkedIn and tell us what you want to hear.

11:16Daniel Murray:Peace out.

11:17Jay Schwedelson:Later.

From the publisher

Most marketers glance at their click data and move on. But Jay Schwedelson and Daniel Murray think that's a massive missed opportunity hiding in plain sight. This Bathroom Break gets into the underrated power of click-through segmentation, bot inflation you probably don't know you have, and why your unsubscribe link might be quietly wrecking your metrics. Oh, and Jay gave up caffeine seven weeks ago. Chamomile tea era, officially.

ㅤ

Follow Daniel on LinkedIn and check out The Marketing Millennials podcast for sharp, no-fluff marketing insights. Subscribe to Ari Murray’s newsletter at gotomillions.co for sharp, actionable marketing insights.

ㅤ

Best Moments:

(03:00) Why your click data is worth way more than you're treating it

(04:00) How to build retargeting audiences from email clicks for almost nothing

(06:45) The two or three in the morning trick that reveals your real click-through rate

(07:40) Using an invisible link above the fold to catch bot clicks before they skew your data

(08:26) The surprisingly common mistake of counting unsubscribe clicks in your CTR

(08:45) Why filtering clicks by ICP before retargeting makes everything sharper

ㅤ

Check out Jay’s YOUTUBE Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@schwedelson

Check out Jay’s TIKTOK: https://www.tiktok.com/@schwedelson

Check Out Jay's INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/jayschwedelson/

ㅤ

Pre-order Jay Schwedelson’s new book, Stupider People Have Done It (out June 9, 2026). All net proceeds are donated to The V Foundation for Cancer Research—let’s kick cancer’s butt: https://www.amazon.com/Stupider-People-Have-Done-Marketing/dp/1637635206

More from Do This, NOT That: Marketing Tips with Jay Schwedelson

All 462 episodes
SPECIAL SERIES ==> How to Use Clicks to Win at Segmentation <==Do This, NOT That: Marketing Tips with Jay Schwedelson · 11 min
Listen in VO