In short
Instagram engagement “truth” and quick-win marketing tactics, plus a brief dinner/dessert aside.
Guests
Daniel Murray, host/creator at The Marketing Millennials (Instagram-focused marketing); Jay Schwedelson, host of Do This, Not That and subjectline.com.
Key claims
Use Instagram’s “Try Reel” button to test reels with a test audience before posting to your feed; review analytics like three-second hook retention and where viewers drop off, then iterate and repurpose learnings elsewhere. On reposting: the head of Instagram says reposting/sharing doesn’t increase circulation to more people, but Jay argues story/DM activity matters and can drive engagement and dialogue.
Notable examples
testing hooks via Try Reel; using trending music on reels instead of static grid posts; starting a story with a poll/question to boost interactions before sharing a post.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VODinner Specials Debate
0:45 to 2:03
Jay and Daniel discuss their preferences regarding restaurant specials.
“And we're going to be talking about some really awesome quick win things on social media and in different areas.”
Instagram Engagement Tactics
2:03 to 5:07
Exploring quick win tactics for improving Instagram engagement.
“We're going to go through a series of different quick win things that I think are not on everyone's radar, whether it's social media or email or whatever it is.”
Debunking Instagram Myths
5:07 to 7:25
Discussion on the effectiveness of sharing posts on Instagram stories.
“We'll do other episodes on a bunch of other tricks and tactics and stuff.”
Engagement Strategies on Instagram
7:25 to 9:21
Suggestions for increasing engagement through stories and posts.
“a little bit misleading because I get what he's saying.”
Dessert Menu Preferences
9:21 to 11:16
Jay and Daniel share their thoughts on ordering dessert at restaurants.
“Before we wrap up this episode, back to the dinner thing.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:07Jay Schwedelson:Welcome to a new special series called The Bathroom Break. That extra 10 minutes, you either have to listen to marketing tips or use the bathroom or both. But I don't recommend both, but that's your choice.
0:19Daniel Murray:This collab is going to be super fun. We have Daniel Murray from the Marketing Millennials and me, Jay Schwedelson, from the Do This Not That podcast and subjectline.com. each episode in the series, we are going to go over quick tips about different marketing topics. And if you want to be in the bathroom, fine, just don't tell us about it. Thanks for checking it out. We are back for another episode of The Bathroom Break. I'm Jay Schwettlson from Do This, Not That. I am here with the legend, Daniel Murray from The Marketing Millennials. And we're going to be talking about some really awesome quick win things on social media and in different areas.
0:52Daniel Murray:But before we get to that, Daniel, I'm curious about something. I went out to dinner the other night and the waiter comes over and tells us the specials at the restaurant. And first of all, right out of the gate, it was something gross. And I'm like, I don't want this thing, but the waiter was going through like on and on about every sauce and every dot that was going to be in this special. I feel like when you go to a restaurant, you're a specials guy. Like you would order the special over something that you see on the menu. Are you locked in on the specials at the restaurant? Or do you go with like whatever you think their number one thing is at the restaurant?
1:24Jay Schwedelson:I'm not a special guy because three years ago I saw a TikTok of the chef talking about how the specials are just food they're trying to get rid of. Really? Yeah, and especially like fish. It's like fish they're trying to get rid of. And they say never order the fish at the restaurant special because it's old fish that they're trying to get rid of and they're trying to do a creative plate for it. So I'm not a special guy. I'll go for the most popular thing on the Maddie. Wow. I didn't know that.
1:53Daniel Murray:It freaks me out. That's the most useful thing I've ever shared on this podcast. By far. All right. Well, now let's get into actually useful stuff. We're going to go through a series of different quick win things that I think are not on everyone's radar, whether it's social media or email or whatever it is. So Daniel, you do stuff on Instagram that I need to learn from. So what's a quick win tactic that you're doing right now that everybody should know about?
2:18Jay Schwedelson:The one thing that Instagram launched months ago, but people are underusing is the trial reel button. So if you're a creator or a brand, this is the perfect opportunity, especially if you're trying to test into what's working or what not, hooks that are working, hooks that aren't working. You can go create a reel. When you're going to go post, there's a button that says trial reel. And what trial reel does is it sends it not to your followers. So it goes to a test audience to see if it works. That is similar to what you have on Instagram to see if this post has legs or not. And if it does have legs, it's a perfect opportunity to either share it with, use a button after that says post live to your feed or what you could do too is now redo the post later on your feed and say, because you know it works.
3:20Jay Schwedelson:So two reasons why this is important. One is a lot of people don't want to test new things on their feed before putting it live. So this is a great way to test to see, is my hook good? Do people care about what my messaging are not saying? And also if you're trying to be a creator or build your personal brand and you're scared about the first couple of posts, this is a good way to get your cringe factor out and just try a bunch of things and see, does the algorithm like this or not? Back in the day, you would have to just post and get zero likes and deal with it. And now Instagram gives you the opportunity to just send it out to a test audience.
4:01Daniel Murray:So you run it for, would you say, 24 hours?
4:05Jay Schwedelson:You run it for as long as you want. But Instagram has a curve that after a few hours that you'll know if it's doing anything. So like after like an hour or two, if your post is started, they have great analytics that show, okay, the post is starting to die. Or is it at a curve that's more like starting off that's better than your other post? They also have now, which I do look at a lot of the three second hook, like how many people are watching past three seconds. And compared to your other posts and your average, like how many people. So it also teaches you like, is my hook bad on this post or not?
4:46Jay Schwedelson:Or where people are dying off on the video? Do I need to speed up the middle? Or is my CTA, are people not watching at the end? Do I need a better CTA? So analytics on Instagram teach you so much about your video. And then you can take these learnings and post it on other places. And that's what people don't do. So I think that's one thing people are underestimating.
5:06Daniel Murray:You know, let's stay on Instagram for a minute. We'll do other episodes on a bunch of other tricks and tactics and stuff. I want to stay on Instagram because I saw something this week. Adam Masseri, the head of Instagram, came out and he said this. And I actually don't believe him, even though he said it, the head of Instagram. He said that it is a myth that let's say you post something on your company page, your personal page on Instagram, and then you share it to your own story. Okay. or if you repost it hit the repost button that little thing with the circle arrows whatever and or you repost it neither putting it on your story or you actually reposting it does anything to increase the circulation of the post that you did i think that makes no sense what do you i'll tell
5:55Jay Schwedelson:you why i think what he's saying is it's not gonna go see push it to more unfollowers so what what it will do if you post on your story you could get more views because it's counting story views as well but if you if you repost it it's not going to have a better opportunity to hit the algorithm to get it to more people because when you're posting on instagram another metric you should look at is how many how is that like what's the percentage of unfollowers to followers So if it's only hitting, like it was hitting 95 % of followers and like 5 % of non-followers, that means that it's not sharing it out to like the bigger algorithm.
6:36Jay Schwedelson:If you start getting more of a percentage and reels is the best way to get to non-followers. Like if you do a static on-grid post, you'll see that it's mostly followers that it hits, it doesn't get on-followers. So what I've been doing too is like a standard grid post. I'd be just doing an image. Instead of putting it on an image, I'll put it as a reel, as a static image. Because if you put music behind it that is trending and it gets attention in the feed, it has more of an opportunity to go viral. Sometimes it won't do as good as the grid post because it's not hitting the algorithm. but you have a better opportunity to get it to more unfollowers if he posts a reel from what I'm seeing.
7:24Yeah.
7:24Daniel Murray:My only issue with him making that statement, and I'll tell you why I feel like it's a little bit misleading because I get what he's saying. I get what you're saying, right? The algorithm is not going to pick it up, but you know, for a lot of people that they look at their stories more than they even look at their feed. Right. And then when you put something on your story, I reshare posts to my story when somebody likes it, right. Uh, likes a story, you get a notification as the person that posted it, that put it on the story. You get a little whatever. It goes into your kind of messaging, if you will.
7:53Daniel Murray:And then all of a sudden, you have a direct dialogue out of nowhere with that person who interacted with your story, right?
8:01Jay Schwedelson:I don't think he's saying it's bad not to. I think people have a misnomer. Like, if I do this, it will increase my chances of getting in the - Viral. I think 80 % of activity on Instagram happens in story and dms yeah like right so it is your goal for instagram is to get someone to press the repost button and share it to their story and that's what you really want or in their in the dms because that will increase the chances of circulating if you shared on your story it just hints to some people but i sometimes i would look at the analytics because i don't share it to my story that much but i would look at an analytics how many people are actually viewing a post that you put in in on your story like if that goes down versus doing a regular story post because i've heard also that the best thing to do the first thing to do of the day is to do an engagement story to like a poll or a question or something to get people to start interacting with your story and then add it in there because now you have activity in your story and people, it's noticing.
9:13Jay Schwedelson:So before you post it, do something that gets interactions on your story and then share it to your story so you get more and more people seeing. Oh, I got you.
9:22Daniel Murray:I got you. All right. I'm screwing it all up. All right. Before we wrap up this episode, back to the dinner thing. Are you a, all right, now it's the end of the meal. It's in way too long and now they bring out the dessert menu. Are you one of these people that are like, oh, I always have to order dessert. We always have to look at the dessert menu. Are you an instant, no, we're good?
9:41Jay Schwedelson:No, we're good. If I want dessert, I want to usually go somewhere else. Unless the only time I would ever be that, if that place is known for that thing, and I'm going to the restaurant for that thing, I will get dessert. Or it's someone's birthday. Those are the two caveats. But if someone's at let's see dessert, I want to get out of the restaurant as fast as possible. I don't want to be there for three hours and eat dinner.
10:09Daniel Murray:I agree. That whole dessert thing is like an extra half an hour of like nonsense. It's like, let's get on with it.
10:16Jay Schwedelson:Who cares? They also scare you when they say, do you want to order dessert now? Because it takes 20 minutes. I'm like, no. It's a good tactic, though. It's a good tactic.
10:25Daniel Murray:It's absolutely not. Well, all right. We crushed another episode here. Go follow the Marky Millennials. Leave Daniel a review and do this, not that podcast. We'll see you at the next one.
10:38Daniel Murray:Daniel, come on, man. I got to get back to work. Get out of there. All right. While he's still in there, this is Jay. Check out my podcast, Do This, Not That for marketers. Each week, we share really quick tips on stuff that can improve your marketing and hope you give it a try. Oh, here's Daniel. He's finally out.
10:55Jay Schwedelson:Back from my bathroom break. This is Daniel. Go follow the Market Millet podcast, but also tune into this series. It's once a week, the bathroom break. We talk about marking tips that we just spew out and it could be anything from email, subject line to any marking tips in the world. We'll talk about it. Just give us a shout on LinkedIn and tell us what you want to hear. Peace out. Later.
From the publisher
Most restaurant specials aren't what you think they are, and somehow that's the most useful thing Jay Schwedelson and Daniel Murray have ever shared on this show. Between the fish warning and the Instagram algorithm reality check, this Bathroom Break episode packs in more practical social media clarity than most hour-long marketing podcasts manage to pull off.
ㅤ
Follow Daniel on LinkedIn and check out The Marketing Millennials podcast for sharp, no-fluff marketing insights. Subscribe to Ari Murray’s newsletter at gotomillions.co for sharp, actionable marketing insights.
ㅤ
Best Moments:
(01:10) Never order the fish special - a TikTok chef blew Daniel's mind and now it's your problem too
(02:18) Instagram's trial reel feature is criminally underused and it's the safest way to test content without tanking your feed
(04:30) Three-second hook analytics on Instagram tell you exactly where your video is losing people
(05:15) The head of Instagram says reposting to your story doesn't boost reach - Jay pushes back, and he's not wrong
(08:15) 80% of Instagram activity happens in Stories and DMs, so that's where your real goal should be
(09:22) The engagement story trick - warm up your audience before you post to maximize story views
ㅤ
Check out Jay’s YOUTUBE Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@schwedelson
Check out Jay’s TIKTOK: https://www.tiktok.com/@schwedelson
Check Out Jay's INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/jayschwedelson/
ㅤ
Pre-order Jay Schwedelson’s new book, Stupider People Have Done It (out April 21, 2026). All net proceeds are donated to The V Foundation for Cancer Research—let’s kick cancer’s butt: https://www.amazon.com/Stupider-People-Have-Done-Marketing/dp/1637635206




