

PR strategy for emerging CPG brands, including how to craft “sticky” founder/brand stories, avoid common pitch mistakes, and use founder-led thought leadership plus an affordable PR support model called “Office Hours.”
Caroline McKay, founder of Caro, a boutique PR firm focused on CPG, design, and hospitality intersections. She’s worked with brands including Equinox Hotels, Rocco (the Super Smart Fridge), and Felia.
Best PR stories come from founder vulnerability and clear “why”/what problem you’re solving. Launching too fast (e.g., in two weeks) without strategy wastes effort and doesn’t create thought leadership. Founder-led media works only if the founder is comfortable; otherwise, use other spokespeople. Avoid generic, marketing-style pitches; editors want personalized, relevant outreach.
pitching editors after reading their work; bucketing pitches by outlet coverage; gift-guide timing; Office Hours built on Circle with pitch reviews, guides, monthly group sessions, and expert series; affiliate coverage as a “don’t get left out” PR channel.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discover the role of PR in building emerging brands with expert Caroline McKay.
“Welcome back to a new episode of Emerging Brands Podcast with Kelly Bennett.”
Understand how a founder's story can enhance their brand's PR strategy.
“We focus on CBG design and hospitality and kind of where they all intersect.”
Identify pitfalls that emerging brands often encounter in their PR efforts.
“I love how you broke that down and already my wheels are spinning.”
Explore the pros and cons of a founder-led branding strategy in PR.
“We have so many of our clients that are like, I shared this across the board with kind of everyone we work with, our sales team, et cetera.”
Learn about the 'office hours' service designed for brands needing PR guidance.
“And we've also had the opposite where they're like, this is a big part of my story.”
Learn how emerging brand founders can pinpoint market gaps and create solutions.
“What was that gap that you saw in the market?”
Explore the importance of tailored pitches and strategic outreach to media.
“And they, they have, they really want to do something.”
Discover how changing media consumption affects PR strategies and brand stories.
“in front of to see what does that retailer really care about?”
Gain insights into adapting PR strategies to fit the needs of emerging brands.
“And I think something we think about a lot just as a firm and I'm always like posing this question to my team is like, how are people actually consuming media right now?”
Learn how personal engagement and quick responses can drive brand success.
“And the feedback we get is because we're really present.”
Reflect on the insights shared and the importance of community support.
“Well, Caroline, thank you again for coming on the show.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Emerging Brands Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Caroline McKay: Welcome to the Emerging Brands podcast. Sharing the stories behind brands you'll want to shop next. I'm your host, Kelly Bennett. I am a New York City-based brand strategist for CPG Food and Beverage Brands. In each episode, I'll take you behind the scenes of founders that are building better-for-you products and bringing them to market. Also, I talk to brand builders, retailers, industry experts, and tastemakers who help bring those cool products to your shopping cart. You will hear stories of real-life founders, their launch strategies, and practical advice you could use to grow your own brand or simply discover what's next on shelf.
0:42Caroline McKay: And the best part is you could shop all the brands featured on the show. Now, let's dive into the new episode. Hi, everyone. Welcome back to a new episode of Emerging Brands Podcast with Kelly Bennett. Today, you're in for a special treat. I have an industry expert on the show today, and we're going to dive into the world of PR. It's such an incredible tool of building an emerging brand, though there's a lot of things that brands are doing that they don't even realize that is hurting their chances of getting picked up for press. But there's really great solutions for PR, especially for emerging brands.
1:25Caroline McKay: So today I have on Caroline McKay. She is the founder of Caro. And Caroline, we've been messaging over the years. You have booked some amazing clients on the podcast. I love who you work with. And I'm just so happy to finally have you on the show as well. Thank you so much for letting me join, Kelly. I'm really excited to talk with you. So let's dive into what is Caro. So Caro is a boutique public relations firm. We focus on CBG design and hospitality and kind of where they all intersect. And so we've worked We've worked with everyone from Equinox Hotels, Rocco the Super Smart Fridge, Felia. So kind of a mix of brands.
2:13But I just love what I do. So I'm super excited to share it with you guys.
2:18Caroline McKay: Yes. And something that you were mentioning before I hit record was you love brands that have an amazing story that you feel is, say, sticky for PR, something that is buzzy and that could really resonate. Could you kick things off with just explaining what exactly that means? Because I think for a lot of emerging brand founders, they personally could feel like they have a great story, but does that mean that their brand overall has a good story that would fit for PR? Just to break that down a little bit so that people can have some really good context for the conversation we're going to dive into.
3:01Yeah, no, a hundred percent. I mean, I think what's really interesting is like, I've always find that like the best stories come from some place of vulnerability, right? So whether it's your, why did you do this? Like really getting to like, as a founder, why did you do this? And then like, what were you trying to solve for? What are you trying to change? You know, I think, and even if you're just like, I saw this category growing and I thought I could do better than anything in it. And I wanted to do that for X reasons. And it doesn't have to be like, I think some people get really, you know, they're like, I need this like revolutionary story.
3:36Right. Really just getting to the crux of like, why are you here? Why are you showing up in the market? You know, why does that matter to you? And it can be like, you know, the real true reasons for anything. And I feel like, you know, for us, we've had founders from kind of like every different, you know, coming in from so many different careers, walks of life, et cetera, why they did something. And I think that's really
4:02Caroline McKay: interesting from like a founder's point of view that can kind of like bleed into like the brand story as well. So it's really like, what do you like kind of asking yourself the question of like, why did I put this product into the market? And then that also helps create the story for the brand itself, along with like your kind of thought leadership narrative. So it's a pretty like interesting way to just like be asking yourselves kind of a certain set of questions that really just help kind of get to the bottom of that essentially. I love how you broke that down and already my wheels are spinning.
4:36Caroline McKay: So what is something that you see as a big, I don't want to say biggest mistake that saying that, you know, someone's doing something in a terrible way, but you don't know what you don't know. Just years in the trenches and in the field and just seeing so many pitches, I'm sure, over your career. What are some maybe red flags or things that you're seeing that are just like, oh man, I wish they didn't do that themselves. Or if they just had taken a beat and thought about this a little bit more, they could have gotten more press or they could have gotten, you know, picked up by more publications or more media outlets.
5:16Caroline McKay: I would just love to hear from you just the things that whenever you see you're like man I wish I wish they didn't do that no 100 % and what I will say what like to preface this is that most of these things are fixable like you know people are learning people are growing like that is understandable and I think that's totally fine and we are willing to work with anyone at any stage they're at in terms of you know whether there's been mistakes made or not one thing I'll say is just like a lot of people go in and they're just so excited, right? They're like, I've put my heart and soul into this and I'm like a hundred percent, but you also have to like kind of really sit down and like carve out a strategy for what you're really thinking of doing here.
5:56So that's one thing that we're really insistent on. People come to us and they're like, I want to launch something in two weeks. And I'm like, we can't work with you then because we need the time to really understand where's your brand now. And also where do you want it to go and how can we set you up for success, you know, to build you towards that. Because if you're just kind of getting in there and you're just throwing a bunch of stuff at the wall, you're just like seeing what's actually sticking. It's not really telling you much. It's not telling you anything about your customer. It's not telling you anything about like, it's not leading you to thought leadership opportunities that can help your growth and the growth of your brand.
6:33It's really just like, you know, oh, we just, we just put it out there that we launched. We put a press release on the wire. And then you're like, yeah, that's, it's not hurting you, but it's definitely not pushing you in the direction you want to go. So that's what we always think about. So it's really like bucketing out kind of like, what are your goals in this year? What are your goals in five years? How do you see the brand growing? And also those will change a million times over, but it's as you progress that you're able to really like, at least be getting to the point where you're ready for kind of that next stage of PR slash comms, you know, because a lot of founders, when they start out, no one knows who they are.
7:12And then you're like, wow, this name is everywhere. It's like, that doesn't just like happen because they put something into the world. I mean, they've really built, they've done a lot of world building. They've done a lot of community building. They have something to say. That's what kind of builds that. The second thing I'll say is that the, the kind of like rush on things is really challenging too. So it's like, you know, again, it's like, you've put three years into this. Why does it need to launch in two weeks? If that's not setting you up for success, it's kind of like, of course you're excited.
7:46Everyone's excited. Love that. It's the best feeling in the world, but it's also like, give yourself the time to do it right when it comes to marketing and comms and also everything. Cause like that doesn't give any of your, you know, any one time and like runway to really like set you up for success. So just like making sure you're kind of like thinking about like, here's time for strategy and then time for, you know, executing on that strategy and really giving like the key players that you're working with enough to really be able to make that happen for you.
8:17Caroline McKay: A thousand percent. And this is also why I'm so bullish on brand strategy, because I like to explain to people like you need to have a strategy that you could hand off to every single next person in your brand from your designer to your product formulator to your publicist to a manufacturer like everyone needs to be able to follow your strategy and without doing that work it's so hard and especially with PR too like if you don't have that foundation to work from, it's so challenging to get buzz around a brand. A hundred percent. And I'm sure you deal with this too, but I feel like when it's coming, you know, people, when they know your vision, when they really, any, exactly what you said, even your manufacturer, everyone, like if they know like where this is going, what you're looking to do, the way that that will be absorbed into their work is, it's such a game changer in terms of like, So we've had so many of, because they haven't gone through this brand strategy and we do kind of a PR strategy.
9:26We have so many of our clients that are like, I shared this across the board with kind of everyone we work with, our sales team, et cetera. And it's just like the tweak of messaging, et cetera. It's like, it can make such a big difference for people. And so I think that's just a hundred percent hear you on that. And I think it's just not something that people do all the time.
9:45Caroline McKay: And this is why I have the podcast to bring on experts like yourself to remind people how important. Something else that I know you've seen become trendy over the last few years in particular is more of this founder-led strategy for CPG in particular. And I would love to hear your take of when that is a good fit for PR or when that maybe doesn't work for PR or just how to go about it. Because I know so many emerging brand founders kind of loop on that too. Like they don't want to make it about them, but they know that they could help leverage it. I would just love to hear your perspective on that.
10:28A hundred percent. And we've had, we've worked with clients where the founder's like, I don't want my name on any of this. I don't want to be searchable, nothing. And we've also had the opposite where they're like, this is a big part of my story. There's a very personal attachment to it, et cetera. So I think there's like kind of two factors here. I think when you're thinking about you as a person have to be interested in doing that. If you're like, I'm scared to talk to people on camera, I don't feel comfortable with this, I don't feel comfortable sharing my story, etc. It's probably not an approach for you, because, you know, of course, a lot of that can be, you know, taught with media training, etc.
11:07But you also have to really want to do that. And if it's kind of for you to do that, then like, that's just not the best use of your time. And so it's either finding, you know, someone in the brand, a few people in the brand that can talk to certain things just so that the thought leadership of the brand and the category is growing. It can just be quotes. It doesn't always have to be super forward facing things. And then or you can just tell your PR person, hey, these are things I'm open to, you know, email interviews, et cetera. I'm not interested in being on podcasts. I can't be on camera. And people can work around that.
11:39you know what I'll say with CPG is I understand the want to have a founder facing brand in the sense where I think in our country like the food industry in general there's been a lot of kind of smoke and mirrors with it people feel very like duped by certain things so when they know someone is behind something the level of trust can increase a lot you know that's a great point like we probably think about our favorite brands and we probably know the name of the founder or have a sense of who they are. And the reason for that is because we have a level of trust that that just is inherent when you think you know somebody, even if you don't know them personally.
12:19And that there's someone that you could be like, hey, I had an issue with my latest shipment of X and you feel like the founder's hearing you. And I think that can be extremely positive if that happens. But it also depends on the strategy of where you want the brand to grow. That can also be quite stressful that your name is fully tied in case it gets bought, et cetera. So depending on, it's just kind of asking yourself those questions and making sure that you're kind of comfortable with that. As a strategy, you're willing to like be involved in the social media videos, et cetera, and kind of baking that in.
13:01Sorry, my dog just popped right up there.
13:03Caroline McKay: Oh, what a cutie dog. something that I would love to hear your perspective on it because I know that you created a solution called office hours for brands who aren't ready yet for that retainer commitment of a full-on PR team right because they're in that middle stage of like they need to do all the things to get the brand off the ground they're probably bootstrapping maybe raising a friends and family round to create the product. And this is in particular of CPG, food, beverage, lifestyle products. But they know that they need that buzz. So they're starting to post on social or organic social is so important.
13:47Caroline McKay: But then there is that next layer of working with a publicist or having the advisement of a publicist that really does help cut through the noise too. So I would love if you could walk us through how office hours work. What was that gap that you saw in the market? And what is really the experience like so that, again, so many emerging brand founders listen to this show and they're in this kind of gray area, right? And so if you could break that down, that would be awesome. No, 100%. Yeah. So basically, I've had my own firm for six years, which has been amazing. Congrats. Thank you. But one thing that like kind of kept coming up was that we kept, I, I'm always, as a person, I'm always like, if someone emails me and they're like, I'd love to talk to you about your services or even if they're like, I'm a little stuck on something, I'm always, I will always get on a call with them.
14:46I have no problem with that at all. And we've had a lot of people that have come to us and they're like, my budget is very low, but I really want to work with you guys. And I'm like, I would love to work with you, but it's just like, I have a team. I have my overhead that like, unfortunately I can't take on that much. If it's, it ends up being a loss on my end. So I was like really trying to find a solution for that because I was like, it's really unfair that it's either you're spending, you know, seven to 10 K a month, or are you getting nothing at all? Like there's gotta be some way in between where it's like, and so I really broke down.
15:24I was like, what are, when we think about our clients, like, what are we offering, you know, in terms of strategy, in terms of like getting FaceTime with them, et cetera. And then what are we offering in terms of like actual execution on the services? And so I kind of broke it down and I was like, it would be great to create a place where founders could also speak to each other, but they basically have like a publicist in their pocket.
15:52Caroline McKay: So we built it on circle. And basically what it is, is a community of founders and us who they can DM us asking us questions. We have, you know, all these guides on there on like how to write a pitch, who to think about pitching, you know, we do monthly group office hours where they, we all come together and they, we answer any questions that are coming up for people. And then we do an expert series every month as well, where we bring someone in from another part of marketing, um, to help answer just more like general marketing questions. Um, and that's really helpful for people too. And honestly, I've learned so much in terms of just like so many cool experts that have been in our, you know, peripheral that we just haven't ever sat down with and fully got into it.
16:40Um, which I'm sure you've kind of experienced with, you know, the podcast, which is honestly,
16:44Caroline McKay: it's one of the reasons why I love having the podcast to hear from people like yourself and just honestly learn from your expertise. It's, it's honestly the best because I feel like it also helps you advise on, you know, for, for our full-time retainer clients when they're looking for affiliate or they're looking for someone for strategy. It's just nice to have that person for them and really understand what they do. But basically what we've created is an environment where the founders can take it into their own hands and they have to execute, but we can help them find an email for someone. We will read over their pitches.
17:21We'll make sure that they're good to send. We'll tell them how to do the research to find the right people to reach out to. And we always do an initial call to understand, as we talked about, just kind of like, what's your strategy? Like, what are you trying to do with this? Like, does this make sense for you at this time, et cetera. And this just helps them like build this foundation that brings them up to a place where then they could probably hire someone on a full-time retainer for PR. Um, but they're just not quite there yet. And they, they have, they really want to do something. They don't want to just be left in the dust, but they just can't afford the larger retainer.
17:59Um, so it's been great.
18:01Caroline McKay: I think it's such a smart solution because you also hear founders who are eager to reach out to press, but they're just finding random editors, emails and kind of pitching everyone and anyone under the sun, the same pitch. And that's to me, like one of the biggest no-nos that I've learned over the years. So could you explain again, like why that is such a no and how office hours helps reframe that so that when you're pitching, you're doing it in a much more strategic way too. Definitely. So I think the biggest thing is with the people don't understand is like editors want to hear from people who've read their work and understand what they cover.
18:48And so, you know, for, and I also think the approach that a lot of people take when they are founders, just from my experience, reading initial pitch emails, is they, it sounds like a marketing email. They're like, you know, they're like, no, hi, how are you? It's just jumping into like, this is my brand, you know? And it's like, and it's so delicious. Yeah. And it's like, yeah, it is. But I think it's like, just understanding that a lot of what PR is, is personal relationships.
19:21Caroline McKay: So it's saying, hi, how are you? I've read this article that you wrote. I was really inspired by it. I wanted to introduce you to my brand. This is why if you're open to speaking, I'd be happy to get on a call with you or meeting you for coffee, treat you to lunch, really just like finding like X amount of people that you really want to connect with and like finding ways to connect with them and really get in front of them. Cause that will take you further, right? What could have been something that you were just in a roundup could then turn into a full feature. You know, of course, when you have big news, like it is okay to, you know, send any, you know, send a pitch to a lot of people to share that news, but it's also about bucketing it out saying like 20 of these people, I'm going to send this to, because this is exactly what they cover.
20:11This is, and then I want 20 of these people to maybe be interested in a feature on me, which is a different type of pitch. And then I want this 20 to think about me for thought leadership opportunities, which is a different type of pitch.
20:24Caroline McKay: Right. So it's really, you know, we always ask like, what are you really looking for from this? You know, and some people come in and they're like, well, I want sales. I'm like, okay, well, PR is not technically the window to that. So let's think about where we can get you, where it's like creates more aware brand awareness that then could potentially lead to that. Exactly. And I feel like this is in the same vein of when emerging founders are really excited and they start listing out 10 different reasons why someone should buy their product. It's vegan, it's organic, we're sustainable. And it's like you have to read the room and knowing who you're in front of to see what does that retailer really care about?
21:07Caroline McKay: What does that particular consumer really care about? Possible investor really care about? And I feel like it's very much in the same vein as far as media like some writers will cover more of the female founder led or founded niche or the sustainability or sourcing or a new hero ingredient and just learning who you're talking to to not reinvent the wheel of your brand but knowing what to then pitch with or lean into, right? I think that's a big thing I've seen over the years, founders overlook. A hundred percent. And I think that's just also like, even just like with communication and when you're thinking about it, understanding when you're entering a conversation, like what are, you know, what is the person that you're meeting up with actually want to hear about from you?
22:00What's interesting to them? Also putting in questions on them, you know, what are you writing about? What's been interesting to you? How can I fit into that? because that'll help you, you know, find your, you know, window with someone. If you come in, like you said, and you're just like, here's why we're great. It's like, yeah.
22:17Caroline McKay: Okay. Here's why my product is delicious. Yeah. Right. Instead of being like, Hey, I love your work. What do you have coming up? You know, I'd love to obviously only pitch you stuff that makes sense for what you've got going on. Uh, I don't want to waste any of your time. So tell me what you, what topics you're interested in or like if there's anything that I can be like helpful to you for and then the conversation kind of kind of evolved from there I mean we even do it with our when we think about gift guides because it's such an overwhelming time of year and I know a lot of founders will probably be interested in that but it's we email you know a big list of people but we also we're like the email is not here's all our brands the email is hi I know we're coming up on that time.
23:03We don't want to be one of those firms that bombards you. So curious, when is a good time for us to start pitching you so that we're not pitching you too early or too late? And also that gives it the best chance for the brands that we do work with, because we're listening to the guidelines these editors are putting in place. We're respecting their time and we'll get more responses to that email than if we sent 50 gift guide emails from now to December, you know, so.
23:31Caroline McKay: Such a great point. Such a great point. For office hours, how does it work to get started or to join? What does that entail? Yeah. So they can just, you know, anyone can just shoot us an email and we can send you the link to join or it's right on our website. You can just go under. I'll link it in the show notes for sure. Thank you. You can just go in that section of office hours and sign up right there. But if you email us, we do have some just like pricing for we're still like growing it so you know we're we're giving people uh pricing who are like you know kind of founding members essentially so if anyone's in the show once is interested they should definitely email me it's a really sweet deal i will say that is there anything that's exciting to you that uh journalists are currently covering or just things that you see happening in the industry that you're personally excited about that is catching your attention?
24:29Yeah, it's a great question. I mean, I think there's just a lot of, there's a lot of change right now in PR. And I think, you know, it would both be like very scary, but also like really stimulating in terms of just trying to figure out, you know, what's, you know, what's becoming the thing that people really care about. And I think something we think about a lot just as a firm and I'm always like posing this question to my team is like, how are people actually consuming media right now? Right. Right. Of course, for SEO, et cetera, you, you do want to be in the roundups. You want to be doing that.
25:03That's a baseline, but what are people reading that's making them buy stuff? Who, you know, who should we really be going after? How can a brand like tell their bigger story in a way that's actually like resonating with people if they're not someone that's like down to read a full article. Right. So we've been really excited about, obviously podcasts for sure, but really excited about, you know, Substack in the last, you know, two years and just seeing the growth of that and also seeing so many writers that we've worked with for years create their own platforms and be able to touch on topics that mean a lot to them, which is really exciting.
25:41And I think it's been, we've seen a lot of publications go very small in size internally, but then there's a big freelancer network too. So it's a little different than it used to be where you're just talking to, you know, a handful of editors at one publication. It's a little bit of that, but it's also knowing the freelancers, where they contribute, what they might be interested in hearing about. So it's a really fun time. And then one that's also like big right now is affiliate, just the growth of that. And that would be probably big for a lot of people who are listening to the show in terms of just, you know, making sure you're on it, you know, making sure your commissions are 10 to 15%, really, you know, getting onboarded with all the publications you need to be.
26:28And the reason I say that is because I think a lot of founders are hesitant about it. But I'm like, you never want to be left out of something for that reason. You always want to make sure that you can at least like play in that sandbox. because it's, it's, you'll, you'll not know that that's happening. And then like another brand that has it will get included over you, but that's, that's not going through us. So we don't know why you'll be getting less press. So it's just like, make sure you're in it, make sure you're doing it. There's very inexpensive ways to do it. And, you know, I think it's also like when you're factoring in pricing, et cetera, when you're initially pricing your product, just something to consider.
27:12That's a great tip.
27:14Caroline McKay: Any other piece of advice for an emerging brand founder as they make that next step to say, join office hours or just start investing in their own PR? Yeah. I mean, my biggest piece of advice is always just like, find people that align with your vision. Find people that are really excited about what you're doing when you're looking for a PR team, anything with marketing, just anyone you're working with. I think if you find people that love what you're doing and they're excited about it, they will do a great job for you. And I think a lot of people used to really go after big agencies because they felt like, oh, I want to be at an agency that has brands at like XXX.
27:57But so many people have now been reverting to smaller agencies like us. And the feedback we get is because we're really present. We really care where they message us. We're responding very quickly. And we just are, I'm personally just excited about all these brands. I'm on all the calls. I'm very involved. So I think it's just like finding people like that, that will really hustle for you the way that you're hustling for your own brand. And I think that's where you really like find success. Um, if that's helpful.
28:27Caroline McKay: Well said, well said. And what is your website again? I'm going to link it, but just for anyone listening? Yeah. So it's www.buycaro.co. Amazing. Well, Caroline, thank you again for coming on the show. Thank you for sending incredible brands to the Emerging Brands podcast. I always appreciate it. And for sharing your insights today, I know so many emerging brand founders will find this conversation super helpful. Hopefully join office hours and really leverage the insights that you are making so much more affordable. So thank you for all the work you're doing. Thank you so much, Kelly. It's such an honor to be on here.
29:06Caroline McKay: You're so welcome. Thank you everyone for listening and I'll see you in the next episode. Bye. Thank you again for listening to this episode of the Emerging Brands podcast. It really means so much to me that you listen to this show, share it with your friends and support it. If you are a CPG food and beverage founder and you're ready to launch brand people want to shop, head to withkellybennett.com for the details. And as always, thank you so much for listening, shopping the brands featured on the show and following brands I'm working with. It means so much. See you on the next episode.
This week on the Emerging Brands Podcast, I talk with Caroline McKay, founder of Caro, a PR agency bringing an insider understanding of how brands build cultural staying power. Formerly the Communications Manager for Soho House's North American properties, Caroline founded Caro to work with design-forward brands that have a story worth telling, from hospitality to home goods. Clients include standout consumer brands like Rocco, Equinox Hotels, Figlia, Jolie, and more.
Caroline's latest offering, Office Hours, is a flexible monthly PR membership for founders who aren't ready for a full-scope retainer. It fills the gap between full-service PR agencies and DIY approaches, giving founders communication tools, real-time guidance, and direct access to PR experts, all without the agency price tag.
Breaking down PR for emerging brands
What makes a brand really stand out to media
How to start your brand's PR strategy with Caro's Office Hours
Caroline's PR advice for emerging founders
Connect with Caro here!