

Founder Michael Laniac explains how Millie Pepper was born from a “pepper rabbit hole,” and how the brand is building a new consumer mindset around pepper. He argues pepper is a fruit, flavor depends on freshness/harvest timing, and essential oils fade over time—so Millie works directly with one farm to deliver freshly harvested, single-origin pepper. Strategy includes shifting consumers from “anonymous black orb” to curiosity, using PR (Wall Street Journal, Fast Company, Oprah Daily, Esquire, Food & Bev) plus an email onboarding series and social content. Hooks tested: “pepper is a fruit” and “freshly harvested.”
pepper types from one plant; press initially focused on giftable packaging; “Millie Eats” recipes using pepper daily (e.g., bacon, egg & cheese; ice cream).
Michael Laniac, founder of Millie Pepper; co-founder Roy Chan mentioned; PR agency Isetta and chef partners mentioned.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Kelly introduces Michael and shares her experience with Millie Pepper.
“Welcome back to a new episode of Emerging Brands Podcast with Kelly Bennett.”
Michael discusses his background and how he became interested in pepper.
“So Michael, how did you first start going down the rabbit hole of pepper?”
Michael shares insights on pepper being a fruit and its significance.
“And I started going down this rabbit hole.”
Michael details his professional journey leading to founding Millie Pepper.
“Is it just it created a whole new part of its life cycle that I hadn't known.”
Discussion on the transition from employment to starting his own business.
“up in a position to succeed here, or at least give it a good swing at the bat.”
Michael explains his approach to marketing Millie Pepper amidst competition.
“And that's such a huge piece, I think, personally for myself.”
Discussion on strategies to engage consumers and highlight product freshness.
“And your strategy is very important to me.”
Learn how authentic storytelling and unique product positioning resonate with consumers.
“And so it's really what we can do ourselves to maintain that momentum.”
Discover effective strategies for validating your business idea and understanding market sustainability.
“And so I'm excited to learn about all the peppers too.”
Explore the importance of retail strategies and maintaining product accessibility to consumers.
“And really, like a lot of our plans and like big ideas went out the door, you know, the second we launched.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Emerging Brands Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Welcome to the Emerging Brands podcast. Sharing the stories behind brands you'll want to shop next. I'm your host, Kelly Bennett. I am a New York City-based brand strategist for CPG food and beverage brands. In each episode, I'll take you behind the scenes of founders that are building better for you products and bringing them to market. Also, I talk to brand builders, retailers, industry experts, and tastemakers who help
0:28Michael Laniak: bring those cool products to your shopping cart. You will hear stories of real-life founders, their launch strategies, and practical advice you could use to grow your own brand or simply discover what's next on shelf. And the best part is you could shop all the brands featured on the show. This podcast is brought to you by Glimpse. Glimpse is an AI-powered deduction management tool that disputes and recovers invalid deductions, winning brands thousands of dollars and hundreds of hours back to founders so that they can focus on what really matters most. If you're a brand selling in retail, go to tryglimpse.com backslash trial for 30 days free and let them know I sent you.
1:17Now, let's dive into the new episode. Hi, everyone. Welcome back to a new episode of Emerging Brands Podcast with Kelly Bennett. Today, I have Michael Laniac. He is the founder of Millie Pepper, which I've been using Millie Pepper in my culinary rotation. It's in my kitchen, really fresh, full of flavor. Honestly, I thought I was a nerd about culinary, but I haven't really been thinking much about my pepper choices. So Michael, how did you first start going down the rabbit hole of pepper? What what was happening in the background? And how did this concept first come to be?
1:59Michael Laniak: Yes, well, like you just said, how you really hadn't thought about pepper until now is very much how Millie started. It was really out of the idea of like care and curiosity. Once upon a time, I was a line cook, moonlighting while I was doing, I've always built e-com and websites. And so I was moonlighting as a line cook. And I really learned there to care about the ingredients I use with. And I carried that skill set into my life as a home cook. And I care deeply about the objects that I place around me. I like everything to have a story. And I think that really makes me feel good when I interact with them.
2:36Michael Laniak: And it really tells a little bit about myself as well. I like to share those stories. And so in my kitchen where I have a lot of my tools that I use every day, be it my salts from a small farm in Newfoundland or my olive oil from down the street at Frankie's or some oregano I got in Italy at like a small market in Orbitello to my Japanese kitchen knives. Like everything has their place and like helps me while I cook. And that's like my happy place. And I got to Pepper and I realized like I knew so little about this spice. And yet I use it every single day. It's in every single recipe. And I started going down this rabbit hole.
3:14You know, what is it?
3:16Michael Laniak: Where is it grown? You know, where does it come from? And, you know, soon after that, I had a dinner downtown with my friend Dennis, whose family grows coffee and coca in a farm in Liberia in West Africa. and when the waiter came by and he's like would you like some fresh pepper that guy got a workout we were cracking so much pepper on our dish and we just had a laugh and he's like did you know that pepper is a fruit and I was like I had no idea wait really yes and so it's a fruit just like when we think about like our coffee or olives for olive oil like it grows on a vine all the different pepper types are from a singular plant and this this fruit is then picked and dried or processed in different ways.
4:01Michael Laniak: And that's what gives us our pepper today. And it was like a very real aha moment for me. Okay, this makes sense. Yes, it did. Something that you wouldn't have thought of, though. No, and I think that that's like, that's why I was so excited to continue learning. Is it just it created a whole new part of its life cycle that I hadn't known. And yet we think about these ingredients like our olive oil or our coffee and like we care about like where they're farmed you know is it fair trade or is it single origin or when was the harvest and again this spice that we use every single day we don't and it matters it impacts the flavor the quality when it was harvested it carries essential oils which carry the aroma the flavor the health benefits and those fade over time and so you know for us at Millie like what we really try to do is get as close to the harvest as possible, working directly with one farm and making sure that we always have fresh pepper, which again, is going to be the most flavorable, the most aromatic.
5:04Michael Laniak: And, you know, that's really our goal here is to deliver fresh pepper to our customers. So cool. So you were mentioning that you were working in e-com website and then moonlining as a line book, which is such a great combo. What made you want to make the leap jump or, you know, next chapter in your career as CPG founder? Because it's its own industry, language, lingo, the whole bit. I would just love to hear what helped you make that leap and what encouraged that because so many founders listening are kind of on that cusp of making this leap into CPG. Yeah, it took a long time to get here. And I feel like my career really has set me up in a position to succeed here, or at least give it a good swing at the bat.
5:57Michael Laniak: You know, I've been working for, you know, well over 15 years in direct to consumer. I started on the marketing and e-com side, so really owned channels, focusing on building out the website towards conversion, brand storytelling, representing product, marketing, strategy. And then as my career continued, I started working in other areas of the business in operations, logistics, P &L ownership. And so I've jumped around to a few brands here in New York. I started at Best Made Company, which is a great outdoor gear and apparel business, and then really honed my chops at Away. I was there for about four or five years with actually my now co-founder, Roy Chan.
6:39Michael Laniak: We were developing out the international business. So I was responsible for Canada and the UK and the development of those businesses and then was president at Saba footwear brand before actually making the jump into CPG. I worked for a supplement brand called Primal Harvest where I was their head of marketing and really opened my eyes to the beauty of consumer packaged goods. The subscription model sort of like apparel was always a big piece for me and so it's like no sizes no returns and exchanges like was a very beautiful thing. Yes. And I thought, yes, subscription was a great business, but like a fundamentally different model.
7:23Michael Laniak: And I think the real balance for me was, you know, I'd always work at very brand first businesses, which was like we hung on to every word, every pixel, you know, it was so important how we showed up. And then in CPG, it was it was much more, I'd say, like fast paced business where like our order volumes, our business model was like very efficient and we were just hyper focused on driving you know results there not to say we weren't over here but the brand at least the one that I worked at was like less critical than the success of you know the business and operations and so it was really that piece there that kind of rounded out my experience and you know following those roles like I'd been building businesses like I said for you know over 15 years and I'd always wanted to start something it was it was eating at me every year that I hadn't and it got to a point where you know it's like if now then when and I was in between jobs and I'd already started this like pepper quest in terms of my education and research and the more that I tried to validate the idea and understand if there's something here and it wasn't it wasn't always a business idea it was like it was out of fascination and curiosity, but it got to a point when I did begin validating it from a business perspective, you know, could this be a viable business?
8:48Michael Laniak: Could this be profitable? Is there a market for it? You know, all the boxes continue to check yes. And it got to a point where I needed to make a decision. It was like going to go back into the workforce. Or did I want to give this a shot? And it was sort of this, this time, and you know, there's never the right time. But for me, it felt like a reasonable time to give it a go and take all of that experience and put it towards something that I would build myself. And that's such a huge piece, I think, personally for myself. I turned 41 this year and building other people's brands for so long. and even though my whole career has been working with founders myself, it does feel like another leap and another jump when you go all in of building your own brand and business.
9:39And I think that's why I love founders so much and I love interviewing founders like yourself because it's like this really incredible leap of faith of like, wait, I do have the chops to make this or I like how you said have like at least the best swing at it, right? And knowing like this sweet spot of having so much experience, but then putting that into something you're really genuinely passionate about. I would love to hear about your strategy because knowing your background, having a D2C presence in CPG, not every CPG brand really has that as a viable sales channel opportunity. But I definitely could see how your brand has that.
10:22But I would love to hear how you have been approaching strategy around getting the product out there, helping consumers understand, wait, hold on, my pepper could be better. And just getting people excited about switching out their pepper or trying something that they haven't in the different varieties of peppers that you have, too.
10:44Michael Laniak: Totally. And yeah, it's a great question. And your strategy is very important to me. I like to take things sort of slow and understand the implications of certain decisions. And this is, you know, I'll start by saying this is all wildly new for me. I have never run a business before in the driver's seat. I have never been in food and beverage. And like with that comes kind of naivety that I think can be powerful. Like I haven't been following, you know, potentially like typical playbooks. I have been leaning on like every new hot trend. Like for me, I'm just really going a lot with like my instinct and what feels right and what I've learned.
11:26Michael Laniak: And like for us, there were like some very clear paths to travel. Like, and we actually have some sort of predecessors in a certain way when we think about the challenge that we're trying to solve here. you know the very first piece is you know how do we shift the consumer mindset around pepper like you've been saying like how do we get them to like care or spark some curiosity or conversation around pepper like why should people care and you know when I look at the businesses before us that have done this like we've gone through this as a people with like salt like now we know there's fine and coarse and sea and Himalayan and you know so on and so forth we've done this with coffee we've done this with olive oil graza is like a great example that has had a similar but different challenge in shifting that you know consumer mindset they went from a very broad category and simplified it we're going from no category to establishing it so but like a very similar playbook in a sense and so for us we knew that like the first piece of this equation was to spark conversation around the spice that we use most and begin to have the customer care or think or question around the pepper that they're using.
12:36Michael Laniak: And so in order to do that, we partnered with a PR agency, Isetta, who are great partners. Who's amazing. They are. I love them. Now, they're so nice to work with. And, you know, they really helped us validate our narrative and sort of prepare that conversation in market. So like for us, the first step was creating a spark, a spark of conversation. And we did that through press and tried to drum up as much excitement as we could. And we got great landings in like Wall Street Journal, Fast Company, Oprah Daily, Esquire, Food & Bev. Like, they continue to come, which is awesome. Like there is a, I would say powerful narrative here and it is like a familiar ingredient and it's just about sparking that conversation.
13:20Michael Laniak: And so we've done that today, mostly through press, and we knew that that wasn't going to run forever. And so, you know, the baton was really passed to us to continue that momentum and conversation through our own channels. And so we've built, you know, quite a substantial onboarding series through Millie in terms of email, in terms of educating the consumer around, you know, why pepper, you know, what matters, like the harvest date, the essential oils, you know our single origin approach the different pepper types like you mentioned earlier and really bringing them into the fold about like why they should care as well as organic social and what we've realized is like when we have that narrative in front of people when our product is in front of people and once they've tried it most importantly there is a connection that's made there and so for us our goal is really just getting in front of people with our narrative of in our story and doing it in a way that is, you know, efficient for the business given our size right now.
14:17Michael Laniak: We don't have substantial budgets. And so it's really what we can do ourselves to maintain that momentum. And so far, I think we've done a great job of that. You have. What are some of the hooks that are really resonating with consumers that you're finding? Yeah, well, the one that I said earlier that I'm borrowing from my friend Dennis from that dinner is pepper is a fruit, which I think is just it shifts the mindset immediately, because I think we look at Pepper as this anonymous black orb on a shelf. And for us, it's so much more than that. And the fruit is what holds this story. And also, you know, we really lean a lot on the idea of freshly harvested, which is another one that I think drives a lot of interest and momentum there.
15:01Michael Laniak: And so I'd say right now we're testing out those two that are landing with our consumers. But I know we have a lot more work to do on that front as well. And as far as press, what was the thing that they were really biting at that they found interesting around Millie? Yeah, it's, you know, to be honest, the first wave of press was really around, I think, the beauty of the packaging. That's cool. It is. And, you know, it's a very simplified package. And, you know, our assortment is quite tight. Like we only have our three styles of pepper and then the mills. And so, you know, we were very intentional about that.
15:41Michael Laniak: And we were very intentional about, you know, sort of everything that we put out in market at launch. And so I think it was the fact that, you know, it's a beautiful packaging. It's very giftable. It's solving for a problem right now that we that we didn't know we had, I think, is another one. A lot of like, I didn't know I need this has been a common thread. But now that we've gotten a little deeper, and this is really how we thought it would play out, too, is now we're starting to work with other publications. Like we just have been in contact with food 52 and like they, you know, did a small piece on us.
16:13Michael Laniak: And like, I think starting to shift more now to like the Bon apps of the world and like pepper in use, I think is like the next channel that we'd like to dive into in terms of conversation. And that totally makes sense. I mean, and also thinking so much UGC that you can accumulate. I mean, to your point, you use pepper at least once a day. I mean, I use it breakfast foods, lunch, dinner. Like it's something that I'm always constantly grabbing for. So I just love when a product can be integrated into someone's life on the regular multiple times a day. And so, yeah, I'm excited to see that content too of just all the different ways of using the peppers.
16:59Michael Laniak: We just – I just got back from a photo shoot last week. We're about to launch a new section of the site called Millie Eats. And so really focused on daily use across the three pepper types. We worked with a bunch of local chefs here in New York, as well as upstate and actually around the country who we've been sort of culminating this like great group of folks who stand behind the mission and are excited about what we're building. And so we've all been working together to create some like accessible and sort of unexpected recipes when you think about pepper, you know, everything from a bacon, egg and cheese to ice cream.
17:33Michael Laniak: So I think we're getting very excited about that. And like we certainly, we're learning as we go and we wanna share those learnings with our community. I'm excited. I love all things culinary. And so I'm excited to learn about all the peppers too. A piece of advice that you would share with a founder that is in the early days, you mentioned validating the idea and checking off that list. And that's something that I hear from so many early stage founders. I was mentioning before we hit record. I work with people when they are in the really, really early days. They have an idea that they can't shake.
18:09But one of the biggest pain points that they have is, is this a good idea? Is this something that has legs within the market? And so I would love to hear your advice around validating a concept and some insight on what you did, what you found really helpful, not just asking your friends and family like, hey, do you think this is a good idea? but like what, how you approach this and also based off of your background too, in, in building brands.
18:37Michael Laniak: Yeah, it's, it's a great question. And yeah, I think it's important. Like, you know, half of the people I told this idea to thought it was a great idea and half of them thought I was insane. And I think that's like, it does. And, and you can't let that bother you. Like you're never going to get, you know, everybody on board. But I think for me, the validation I was doing was more on the business side and just really trying to understand, like, from a product cost perspective, you know, from a price point perspective, for the competitive perspective and market, like, what is the potential to have a healthy business?
19:16Michael Laniak: You know, I've worked for a number of businesses, and I was sort of in that era where it was like, all that matters is top line revenue. And we're going to spend as much as we possibly can to drive that regardless of profitability. And like, to me, that isn't really business 101. And so for me, like, I wanted to ensure that we had a healthy business from a bottom line perspective, like we are very lean, we would like to be break even as soon as possible. And like, that's as much as I wanted to know, is like, is there a sustainable business here, regardless of what happens through investment or whatever.
19:51Michael Laniak: It's like, I just want to build something that we can continue to grow responsibly. And so the validation that I did was really much on our cost of goods sold, our supply chain, the, you know, how much is it going to cost to ship to consumers, our overhead, and really just understanding, like, if we sell product, can we, you know, make a dollar at the end of it to keep the business going. And so that was the validation that I did. I didn't pay too much attention to, you know, competition, there really isn't any in the, like, there is not another pepper brand. There are, of course, like great spice brands, when you look at like a diaspora or burlap and barrel.
20:31Michael Laniak: But like, for us, our focus is really on, you know, the pepper category, or subcategory, if you will. And so, you know, I just stayed focused on the numbers, made sure that we had a business model. And then, of course, like the strategy towards launch, but like, Like, you know, I had built out a forecast for launch. We had three versions. We had like a very exciting version, a la Graza. We had a very modest version. And then we kind of had a sad version. And, you know, we ended up right in the middle. And like what I would just say in terms of that, or like the advice I would say, it's like, it's good to have a plan, of course, going into launch.
21:09Michael Laniak: You want to have a plan going into launch. You want to make sure that, you know, you're running the business. You're not scrambling to, you know, plug holes, which is like going to happen naturally. But like, you know, you want to have the confidence that like if you're selling product, the business can maintain. But beyond that, like I just I would not set expectations too high. I would just like be happy with where you are in the business. Like you've just launched a business that is very exciting. You have a product in the world. You build something. And really, like a lot of our plans and like big ideas went out the door, you know, the second we launched.
21:42Michael Laniak: Like, you know, our e-com business, you know, what we thought would be the main driver, in fact, is now retail. And retail has been a tremendous factor in our growth. And so we've had to have the flexibility to shift on the day to day, like how we're supplying our partners, you know, our supply chain, you know, how we're prioritizing product. and we have the nimbleness to do that and we have the flexibility to do that because we didn't have these like set in zone expectations and we just know that if we had a healthy amount of product and we had a strategy which would continue to follow and we had the right attitude and that every product sold we make some sort of dollar then we're okay to continue and so we just made sure the foundation was there to allow for growth and they continue to be flexible along the way.
22:34Such a great way of thinking about it and well put. And I know that many emerging founders listening to this will be like, okay, that was a light bulb moment for them of really helping them take a beat, take a breath, and making sure they have a solid foundation in bringing a product into the market. And to your point too, like that alone is an incredible win. And just also taking their time in building. It does not happen overnight. With that said, I know I have to let you go and get back to building Millie and all the cool things you have going on. But last question, where can people shop Millie Pepper?
23:16Yep.
23:17Michael Laniak: So I think for the complete Millie experience, of course, our website, which is MilliePepper.com. If you're in New York City, we are at Big Night and Jubilee Marketplace, which were two of our first retailers. But we're also we've expanded into over 50 retailers across the country. and we have a section on our site where you can find that. And then we do have a couple larger conversations going on, which I'm very excited about to share in the future. Yes, we'll have to do a part two. We'd love that. Amazing. Well, thank you again for your time, for creating a great product, bringing it to market.
23:49Thank you everyone for listening and I'll see you on the next episode. Bye. This episode was brought to you by Glimpse. As we know, building a brand is not as sexy and glamorous as it looks on social media at times. A lot of those unsexy problems come into play when brands start to scale in retail distribution. Founders are always incredibly excited to see their products on shelves at major retail chains, but they don't realize all the hard work that starts to begin. Retailers and distributors are known for their processes of deducting amounts from invoices. Most of the time, those are totally valid.
24:34Promos, slotting fees, free fills, and all the things that brands agree to to be part of the retail experience. But sometimes those deductions are invalid, costing brands thousands to millions in fees. Actually finding those needles in the haystack though and fighting to win back lost revenue, it's a costly manual and time-consuming issue and that's where Glimpse comes in. Glimpse is an AI powered deduction management tool that disputes and recovers invalid deductions winning brands thousands of dollars and hundreds of hours back to founders so that they can focus on what really matters most, scaling their businesses.
25:22With a team of in-house deduction experts who come from some of the most successful and profitable CPG companies and custom-built AI with 100 % accuracy and precision, you'll recover money that you never should have had leaked in the first place. If you're a brand selling in retail, go to tryglimpse.com backslash trial for 30 days free and let them know I sent you. Thank you again for listening to this episode of the Emerging Brands Podcast. It really means so much to me that you listen to this show, share it with your friends and support it. If you are a CPG food and beverage founder and you're ready to launch a brand, people want to shop, head to withkellybennett.com for the details.
26:15And as always, thank you so much for listening, shopping the brands featured on the show and following brands I'm working with. It means so much. See you on the next episode.
Bringing culinary-grade quality to the everyday kitchen became Michael Laniak's mission when he realized how vastly overlooked standard grocery store pepper really is. As Founder of Milly Pepper, Michael is breathing new life into a staple ingredient by pairing single-origin, regeneratively grown peppercorns with thoughtfully engineered, refillable ceramic mills.
Sourced directly from a fourth-generation farm in the Andean foothills of Ecuador, Milly Pepper's organic black, green, and white varietals are hand-harvested and sealed right at the source. Michael shares how he built a supply chain grounded in agricultural integrity while designing a sleek tool that lets home cooks seamlessly transition from coarse crusts to fine finishings with peak freshness in every grind.
Inside the Episode:
How Michael identified a massive gap in the spice aisle and set out to give single-origin, high-quality pepper the spotlight it deserves.
Michael's transition into entrepreneurship and how his professional background equipped him with the skills to confidently take the leap into the CPG world.
The marketing and brand strategy behind educating consumers, sparking curiosity around single-origin sourcing, and changing how people view a daily pantry staple.
This podcast episode was made possible by Glimpse — the AI-powered deduction management tool helping CPG brands recover lost revenue from invalid retail deductions. With in-house experts and custom-built AI, Glimpse saves founders time, money, and countless hours so they can focus on scaling. Book a call with the Team to get started!