1. Podcasts
  2. Express Checkout
  3. The “dessert-ification” of everything.
Express Checkout

29 Oct 2026 · 43m · 16 chapters

Episode artwork

The “dessert-ification” of everything.

In short

“Dessert-ification” of everything—CPG trends where functional/health products are marketed and reformulated to feel like desserts, plus two sweetener-related news items and a debate about “permissible indulgence.”

Guests

None. Episode is hosted by Jenna and Nate (Express Checkout Podcast).

Guest/host backgrounds (from episode context): Jenna and Nate are CPG/food-industry commentators who taste-test new candies and discuss food science and consumer research; they reference surveys they ran (Pogo, plus an intern’s college network).

Key claims

  1. “Desertification” = non-indulgent products marketed as excessively dessert-like (often via flavor worlds and even dessert-like formats).
  2. “Permissible indulgence” is shifting in the GLP-1 era toward intentional, guilt-reduced treats (often via portion control, but definitions are contested).
  3. Stevia is losing favor; consumers may prefer small amounts of real sugar or non-nutritive sweeteners like monk fruit.

Notable examples

  • Skinny dipped dark chocolate peanut butter wafers (3g sugar, 70 calories).
  • Happy Candy lower-sugar, top-9 allergen-free gummy candies at Target.
  • Oobly sweet-protein system for chocolate (with Kosan Ingredients; uses tricotter root fiber for sugar-like texture).
  • Zevia (Stevia soda) raises $20M but faces stevia aversion and competition.
  • Stars and Honey protein bars with dessert flavors; Good Warrior “treat bars” (dessert-format textures).
  • Olipop caramel apple flavor; mochi vitamin gummies.
  • McConnell’s half-pint Costco format; Alex Culture Cups portion-controlled ice cream.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Halloween Episode and Sweet Treats

Discussion about Halloween-themed treats and brands they enjoy.

“oh this is our Halloween episode I am a sexy cat also known as Tony the Tiger um so I'm Tums because my shirt says Tums and I was Tums last year I I love me an antacid uh who doesn't I love me and antacid.”
4:30

Skinny Dipped and Happy Candy Review

Hosts review new low-sugar candy products, their tastes, and textures.

“we are just so curious what will be in Halloween households this year.”
7:35

Innovations in Sugar Alternatives

Exploration of a new sugar replacement system for chocolate by Oobly.

“They have had an alternative sweetener for a bit now and have been making their own chocolate bars with it.”
10:36

Stevia's Rollercoaster Journey

Discussion on the challenges facing Stevia products and brand Zevia.

“They kind of need, I think, to get this mass adoption.”
14:00

Sweetener Preferences Survey Insights

Learn about consumer sweetener preferences through a recent survey comparison.

“So these were all 250 college students who mostly shop at Whole Foods and Sprouts, live in bi-coastal college towns.”
16:08

Desertification of Products Explained

Understand the concept of desertification in food marketing and its implications.

“And we're going to start with desertification.”
19:58

Examples of Desertification in Brands

Explore examples of brands like Stars and Honey and Olipop that embody desertification.

“If you don't like artificial sweetness, you're not going to like it.”
22:48

Good Warrior and New Treat Bars

Discuss PepsiCo's Good Warrior brand and its unique approach to treat bars.

“They desertified in a totally different way, which we thought was really interesting because, again, they launched as beef sticks.”
24:20

Defining Permissible Indulgence

Dive into the evolving concept of permissible indulgence in the food industry.

“Which is basically about giving consumers permission to eat what they want and feel good about it.”
28:05

Permissible Indulgence: Definitions and Examples

Explore the concept of permissible indulgence in snacks and desserts.

“So, like, I don't think we're ever going to see a Nabisco 100 calorie again.”
Show all 16 chapters
29:04

Subcategories of Indulgence

Discussion on the need for subcategories in permissible indulgence.

“I mean, I think if the if the definition of permissible indulgence is that broad, there needs to be different names for it.”
30:58

Trends in Portion Control

Examine trends in portion sizes and their implications for indulgent products.

“But the actual formulation of all of those products is so different that I really don't like putting them in the same category.”
35:00

Impact of GLP-1s on Snacking Habits

Discuss how GLP-1 medications are changing eating and snacking behaviors.

“And like all of this discussion, I think, is really happening because of GLP ones.”
36:38

Natural Ingredients vs. Processed Foods

The shift towards natural ingredients and the perceptions of ultra-processed foods.

“a real cookie, to real ice cream, whatever it is.”
38:40

Consumer Trends and Product Innovations

Discuss emerging consumer trends and innovations in indulgent products.

“And that's why even us who we studied this day in and day out, it still gets kind of confusing because there's so many levels to it.”
42:00

Halloween Candy Recommendations

Discover the best candy options for Halloween.

“but they are this blend between a gummy texture and a marshmallow texture.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Express Checkout, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Welcome back to the Express Checkout Podcast. Hey Jenna. Hi Nate. It's so much fun to be in studio again. Yeah. It's so... The new norm. It's the new norm. And today we're talking about some of my favorite stuff. Candy. Candy. Sweet stuff. So first we're going to be chatting about a few brands that we like that both happen to be sweet, which is wonderful. And then we're going to be talking about two different trends we've been seeing across CPG lately. desertification not to be confused with desertification and permissible indulgence but first what have you tried this week wait crazy for you to not address the elephant in the room oh this is our Halloween episode I am a sexy cat also known as Tony the Tiger um so I'm Tums because my shirt says Tums and I was Tums last year I I love me an antacid uh who doesn't I love me and antacid.

1:01The hat, the hat is part of the Tums costume. What's what causes the need for Tums? Perhaps. So this is a hat from the brand Sunshine Buns, which makes frozen, ready to heat cinnamon buns. It just felt festive. It felt Halloweeny. It felt Tums. It's giving acid reflux in a cute way. And that's where we've landed. So that's the elephant in the room or the cat in the room or the antacid in the room and with that because it's halloweeny that's why we're talking about sweet stuff today but yeah so what i tried this week that i've been liking sweets edition is skinny dipped skinny dipped has a new product they're dark chocolate peanut butter wafers i'm gonna i'm gonna give her a little i'm gonna give her a little crack open uh because it's like kit cat vibes and if you're watching which you should be.

1:59Do you buy the mic? Oh. That sounded so good. That was really satisfying and like little wafer pieces actually just flew everywhere so that's fine. But you can see those good layers of peanut butter in between wafer candy and outside dark chocolate coating. I'm not going to eat it on camera. I'm not ready for that yet. We'll get there one day. We'll get there one day. So this is going to taunt me in front of me for the rest of this episode but But these, if you don't know, skinny dipped are low sugar candies. They have a lot of my favorite candies. They're great. It actually started as like dark chocolate or chocolate covered nuts and almonds.

2:38And now they are like a full candy brand. And these are their newest launch. And they are just my new favorite candy. Like they're so good. Kit Kats are my favorite. Dark chocolate is my favorite. Peanut butter is my favorite. They put them all in one and they're only three grams of sugar and 70 calories. If that's something you care about, it might not be. But if it is, and even if it's not, fabulous new candy. So that's my answer. And there is two grams of protein if you care about that. And that's going to help me hit my macros. But these might be their best product ever. They're so, so good.

3:12They're almost too good, actually. I could eat a lot of them. So this week I tried some Halloween candy a little bit early from a new brand called Happy Candy, which I have right here. If you're crinkly. So this variety pack just launched at Target, which is really cool because this brand basically just launched. They're sold at, I think, Whole Foods. But this is a lower sugar candy free from the top nine allergens. And these are delicious. These are definitely some of the top tier, better for you, lower sugar candies out there. I brought these home this past weekend and my parents tried them.

3:51And my dad was like, I need so many more of these. These are great. They're also a really good texture the first time I tried them They were like a little bit harder than I would have liked but their new formulation is so good Are they like Swedish candy vibe? Yeah, okay. Yeah, but that is a different texture a little bit Swedish candy But like they're very familiar gummy candies and the flavors are really good. I think I Yeah, I think there's some my favorite lower sugar candies out there and there's a lot There's a lot of really good ones these days, too. Yeah. Oh, absolutely. And we'll be talking about some of them today.

4:28But even of the ones that we don't talk about, we are just so curious what will be in Halloween households this year. I think as much as these lower sugar candies are starting to be at least distributed more ubiquitously, I don't think necessarily they'll be what people are giving away for Halloween. I think we'll still see a lot of Three Musketeers. I will be giving away a bunch of Better For You candies. And that's because they sent you them. No. I went to Target to see what their set was, and there was a whole section just of Better For You candies. No way. So Happy Candy, this was sold to Target.

5:01This is where I bought. She sent me a bag, but I ended up buying two more bags of Target. Unreal had a Halloween set. Yes. Joyride had two different Halloween packages as well. Nature's Bounty, which makes yogurt-covered dried fruit balls. Don't give that away for Halloween. That was more for me to snack on. I like those. But there were a lot of better for you leaning candy sets that I mean, most of it was not. But I was very impressed with what they had. And even having a brand new brand like Happy Candy out on shelves having this package. I think that's wonderful. Yeah, it's awesome. This one in particular, I don't think really tastes like better for you candy.

5:41I think it just tastes like really good newer candy. I also have, as you can see up on screen, smooth sweets, which is dates coated in a candy coating, a hard candy shell, which are also pretty good. I am not a fan. I'm not giving them out for Halloween. That would be cruel. That would be so mean. That's like close to being to giving out, you know, like apples for Halloween or something. I like an apple, but. Did you when you were a kid? Yeah, I think it'll be interesting to see if there's ever really like a mass shift from the classic Halloween mixed bag of Three Musketeers and Twix and Reese's into these Better For You candies.

6:21I feel like one, price parity is still an issue, and that's why people probably won't be giving them out. These are more expensive. And the other thing is just, I mean, I don't think people care that much unless it's their kid. So yeah, the parents are preaching about how much they want lower sugar candy, but it's probably because that's what they want to give to their kids. I don't know how much they care about handing it out to strangers' kids on Halloween. So until we have universal empathy and price parity, I don't think it will be, yeah. Interesting. But it'll be interesting, yeah. So, Jenna, I think we should start talking about the news of the week.

7:03And the news of the week is a little sweet. Yes. In fact. So, Oobly, which is a sweet protein startup, they announced a sugar replacement system for chocolate. And they co-developed it with a Dutch chocolate giant, Kosan Ingredients. So, they're pairing their sweet proteins with tricotter root fiber to replace sugar's mouthfeel. and crystalline structure. And I just think this is so cool. Yeah. So Oobly's a really fascinating company. They have had an alternative sweetener for a bit now and have been making their own chocolate bars with it. But now they are partnering with the Stutch Giant and also making their ingredients more available to other candy makers.

7:50What's interesting about them is it's not just a non-nutritive classic sweetener like a stevia or like an aspartame. They use precision fermentation to produce sweet proteins that taste thousands of times sweeter than sugar, wild. They're digested as proteins. So your body doesn't digest them as carbohydrates, therefore lower calorie, no impact on blood glucose or even gut health actually in this case. But they're not really like protein because you use so little of them because they're so sweet that it wouldn't be like a substantial enough amount of protein to make to make it onto the nutrition label.

8:33That being said, it is just a really fascinating company. And I love I love food science. Every time I see like a new ingredient be developed, I get very excited about what that could mean for the industry. A really good way to understand this, actually, if you've ever heard of, you know, those miracle berries, it kind of used to be like a gimmick. These fruits, they're crazy. They're crazy. These fruits that you eat and then they make whatever you have for the next like 30 minutes taste sweet. So people used to try the berry in like a dehydrated form and then eat a lemon and it's like, tastes like lemonade.

9:06This company is actually using those, those kinds of fruits, either like specifically the miracle berry or there are other equatorial fruits that like, we just don't know much about and aren't being like consumed in a major way to make these sweet proteins. So it's really, really interesting to your point about this new news that is especially fascinating and it being developed them developing this new version of the sweetener for chocolate. So because the sweetener is so sweet and they use so, so, so little of it, it doesn't fill up enough of the bulk when they're making chocolate. So first of all, you'd have like a tiny chocolate bar.

9:45Right. But the other piece of it is texturally, it like wouldn't work because sugar off traditional sugar offers a lot of texture and mouthfeel and like crystallization to traditional chocolate, which is why zero sugar chocolate typically sucks. It sucks. It's like chalky. It doesn't have that like really satisfying snap. And so they blended their traditional sweetener with prebiotic fibers, partly to add the bulk that we're looking for in making a chocolate bar. But it also adds some of that structure and mimics the crystal structure of sugar. It's just so interesting to me. So I'm really excited to see, yeah, what they do with this new partnership, but also how this ingredient goes beyond this one partnership and is used in zero sugar chocolate formulations in the future for other companies, too.

10:36They kind of need, I think, to get this mass adoption. I mean, they're working with a group of bimbo. They announced that a few months ago. we've talked about in the newsletter, to sort of get into more products and get more distribution. But they need something that, like, David did for EPG. Yes, totally. They're missing that. Like a platform brand. They're missing a platform brand. They're missing the marketing arm that David has and also, like, a little bit of the controversy, too, kind of. I don't know if they need controversy. We need controversy, but I think a successful new ingredient that's very food science-y that is changing the way we eat is EPG.

11:23And I hope that Oobly can get to that point because they're doing a lot of different things, not just a fat replacer. They're doing these sweet proteins, and this could change how we eat. Yeah. And as we're going to get into, even in the next story and also in future stories, there's already so many mixed opinions and perspectives on sweeteners. Sweeteners are in the you don't need more controversy because sweeteners as a category are incredibly controversial. Whether we're talking about the health impact, whether we're just talking about personal preferences, some people have serious taste aversion to certain sweeteners like the next one we're going to be talking about.

11:59So we need a new hero in sweeteners. Yes. And I think hopefully, I mean, I don't know if this will be it, but I'm excited to see a brand trying. Yeah. Or a food science company trying. So, yeah, on that, I mean, the next story, again, is about one of the most controversial sweeteners, which is Stevia. Oh, my God. Yeah, Stevia. Oh, Stevia. What a crazy sweetener that was just like everywhere, then nowhere, then everywhere again. Yeah. But we're talking specifically about Stevia Soda. And there's a brand called Zevia, which you can guess where that name came from. They just raised a$20 million round.

12:38And they seem to be on the up but also struggling a bit. And that's partially because of Stevia. A lot of people have an aversion to Stevia. Last year, Zevia hired a – they hired bankers to potentially explore a sale of the business. but doesn't seem like they're actually going that direction. And, you know, they have a lot of competition from new soda entrants who are building their sodas around multiple different sweeteners, not just Stevia, because so many people have had such a strong aversion to it. And to be clear, like the$20 million raised, that headline sounds like you're doing really well.

13:14That would be doing really well for a much earlier stage company than Stevia is, one. And two, the terms of this specific deal were very, very favorable. to the investor. So it's not looking like they were super gung-ho about this investment. It looks like they failed to get a buyer and this is the next step. And as part of this next step, GP Investments is trying to do a quote-unquote strategic reset, which they're trying to turn around the brand, basically, which indicates that it wasn't doing so hot. And that strategic reset includes exploring adjacent categories like function. Classic. and they're also attempting a single can strategy like selling single cans for for trial purchases likely instead of just selling multi-packs so yeah i think there is a lot at play here of why they might not be killing it right now part of it is what you said the modern soda category is absolutely booming there are so many new entrants and the other part is that they're shifting sweetener preferences as we've been saying uh stevia yeah peak 2010s i truly like when i think of stevia i think of like mid 2010s oh yeah it was everywhere i think of bi yeah and it was flexed as this like natural alternative as opposed to its artificial counterparts um but now consumers are opting for lower sugar but real sugar options instead so we actually ran our own study earlier this year it was a small sample size i'll get that out of the way we ended up surveying 750 people 500 of them from general population so people who are mostly shopping at Kroger and Safeway of all age groups and we did this through a company called Pogo which leads consumer research and they're awesome and then we also did our own survey with our incredible intern Natalie shout out Natalie who sent our survey to 250 people she knew or had was networked with in through her college network.

15:11So these were all 250 college students who mostly shop at Whole Foods and Sprouts, live in bi-coastal college towns. We asked about their sweetener preferences, and we thought that positioning these two populations kind of against each other would be really telling, and we would see really different preferences. And we actually saw a lot of the same. And what we saw was Stevia ranked eighth among 12 sweetener choices, which is kind of wild. And when given the options of a higher sugar count, so like five grams of sugar in a product from a fruit derived sweetener, like honey or coconut sugar versus zero sugar from something like monk fruit, stevia or artificial sweeteners, both population sets chose slightly higher sugar and nothing non-nutritive.

16:00So the two trends that we've been seeing. One are desertification and permissible indulgence. And we're going to start with desertification. Again, not to be confused with desertification, which is a very real climate problem. We maybe made this one up and maybe were inspired by desertification. But here's where we landed. We still think this is the best term for what we're describing, which is taking a product that isn't actually indulgent at its core, either in its ingredients, its format, whatever it is, like a protein bar, and marketing it as excessively indulgent in flavor. So, Nate, there was some news this week that had us thinking about this.

16:48Martha Stewart's CTO of a new protein bar brand. All right, we got to define CTO right now. So she's joining this AI startup. No. So Martha Stewart is joining Stars and Honey as chief taste officer. So Stars and Honey, collagen protein bar brand known for very, very dessert inspired flavors. And she will also be working with the team to develop new flavors as well. If you haven't come across Stars and Honey, this is truly a beast of a young brand. They only launched in 2023. They've already expanded to Target nationwide and some select Costco. This brand is growing like hotcakes. It grew 300 % in 2025.

17:29And all of their flavors are desserts. I mean, literally, I think on their website, it says like this could be a menu item at a bar or restaurant. Yeah. I mean, the website has incredibly indulgent imagery and descriptions and everything like that. And like that's why like Martha, I think, is such a good addition to this because she's culinary. She is taste. She is indulgence. She is comfort. She is luxury. and that's what this brand is trying to position itself as rather than like a functional bar that you're supposed to have post-workout or to fill a need but they're trying to make it seem more tasty.

18:14Yeah I mean a lot of what they're flexing isn't just we have these cool flavors because a lot of protein brands have indulgent flavors they have their their marketing is more about like we are building this around being culinary we have an in-house culinary team they have 18 chef inspired flavors which is too many they do seasonal flavor drops like they are rooted around flavor there's no denying it and i know yeah you said there are all these very indulgent flavors some of them i want to even just say them because they're like ridiculous to say out loud cherry chocolate waffle cone well it's a protein bar what am i missing here red velvet literally there's one called cake and ice cream.

18:54I see no ice cream. This is a protein. How does it taste like both cake and ice cream while also being a shelf stable, literal protein bar? And yet I want to try it because it sounds so indulgent because the imagery is so indulgent. Yeah. So it's a really interesting one. And the other thing about this, it's a great example of what I was explaining with what consumers are looking for in sweeteners. It's a blend of cane sugar and monk fruit. So it's four grams of real sugar. And there's just a touch of a natural sugar with monk fruit. But that's this great example of like, okay, there is real sugar in this just less.

19:30And it's a blend with a non-nutritive sweetener. We're not relying on the non-nutritive sweetener for the sweetness. So they're a great example of that. But yeah, this brand is fascinating. This is a fascinating brand. I will probably do a deep dive on this brand at some point. but it's a perfect example of of desertification we're just gonna sound like desert and you're gonna know what we mean yeah like i think broadly just like protein bars in general are a perfect example of desertification if you look at the protein bar set nine times out of ten it's some dessert flavor it's some indulgent treat on on the front of pack yeah imagery the the flavor the description protein bars are like the best example of desertification they are I think it's getting more extreme like yeah some people might be listening to this and they're like well yeah like quest bars were like cookies and cream and just but it was simple yes it was it was just a flavor it wasn't building a brand world around it right and that's the difference I think and stars and honey in particular I mean 18 and chef inspired flight was like everything about this brand is less about like hey this is a fitness this is this is a functional product to fill a function to fill a need to fill a fitness need and we're making it taste good so you can actually yeah take take it in because they're usually not that good this is like no this is a lifestyle brand like we're building it around the concept of indulgence totally and desertification also spans beyond protein bars yeah i one example that i've been thinking about is olipop's new caramel apple flavor, which I really like.

21:08If you don't like artificial sweetness, you're not going to like it. But I loved it. It was so good. You should try it. It's delicious. But caramel apples specifically, that wasn't a soda flavor. That's something that Olipop is trying as a seasonal drop that is really dessert-like. And the imagery is obviously very dessert-like. That's one example. Honestly, gummy supplements are a great example of dessertification. Specifically, what I'm thinking about is all these new mochi vitamin gummies. So they're a gummy supplement, but they are mochis. It's a dessert. They're mochi, yeah. They're not literal mochi, but they're gummy vitamins that are coated in that, I guess it's tapioca flour, and they kind of mimic the texture of mochi as you know it.

21:57But the serving size is two. They are a supplement. so that's a really interesting case i'm like what why do we need we don't need this for the absorption the bioavailability of this supplement it has nothing to do with function and it purely has something to do with this perceived i guess yeah indulgence or like treat culture yeah it's really interesting and even sense i know also oh yeah all the i mean you go to bath and body works everything is like a cupcake flavored thing yeah which it's been that way forever but yeah i do I think these are not new trends. They're evolving. And I think Stars and Honey and even Ollie's Mochi is a great example.

22:35Like, it's going beyond just, like, giving it a flavor. It's giving you, like, even more reason to consume it and feel good about it, but still, like, scratching that itch of wanting a dessert. Yeah. Other piece of news that also felt like desertification was news this week, which is PepsiCo's Good Warrior brand, which launched earlier this year with beef sticks. Hold on. They desertified in a totally different way, which we thought was really interesting because, again, they launched as beef sticks. I now associate the brand Good Warrior with beef sticks. Yeah. But they're expanding into protein bars.

23:10But they're not exactly positioning them as protein bars. They're positioning them as basically treat bars. So there are three different SKUs. they're coming out with. One is a cocoa marshmallow bar. There's a cookie dough brownie crisp, and there's a cookies and cream cream, which they're, they're protein bars. They have 15 grams of protein, seven grams of sugar, five grams of fiber. But the difference between these just being like dessert inspired flavors as a usual protein bar might be, they actually are mimicking the format of the dessert that they're describing. So like the cream, which is like two layers of cookie with like a cream filled center it's still in a bar form um but that format and texture is more closely matching that flavor which is we think is another like next evolution of desertification yeah and it this one was like so interesting to me because it was just so interesting to see them not go with a traditional protein bar format and actually match it to the different flavors.

24:11They're each different. It fits really nicely into the next sweet trend that we wanted to talk about. Permissible indulgence. Which is basically about giving consumers permission to eat what they want and feel good about it. And permissible indulgence is an interesting one. Because it's always sort of been a thing. And I think traditionally a lot of it has been tied to diet culture. I think like the Nabisco 100 calorie cookies like was very, very much permissible indulgence, but also very, very much toxic diet culture. And now we're in this GLP-1 era where I think we're switching up what permissible indulgence kind of means and like tacking on another definition to it.

25:02I think the biggest difference now is that GLP-1's food noise is quieter. It's calmer. So I think it's more about now intentional indulgence. Yeah, which is where I like, we've been talking about this and we both agree and disagree about what permissible indulgence means. Because to me, these days, permissible indulgence really means something is actually indulgent in nature. So it's like made with full sugar, it's made with full fat, real butter, whatever it is. And the brand or format is giving you a permission slip reason to indulge in it. So typically, for me these days, what permissible indulgence means is just portion control.

25:47So the Nabisco 100 calorie cookie packs that you're describing that feel very nostalgic in my brain, I wouldn't think of as counting as today's permissible indulgence because they, the cookies are not indulgent. They were diet cookies themselves. Whereas today, what permissible indulgence means to me is the product is actually indulgent, but there's something about it, usually again, portion size, I think, that makes it excusable to eat. And yet, to your point, this is very much something that is tied to GLP-1s and the fact that one in eight people in the U.S. are on a GLP-1 and they are able to have a bite of something that they used to love and felt like was maybe off limits if they have ever been dieting and feel satisfied.

26:37And so that is the difference because those consumers aren't necessarily going to be reaching for a diet product like an Abisco 100 calorie cookie pack because if I'm only going to have one bite anyway, I might as well have the thing I actually want. Yeah, and I think that's like the biggest trend. Like mindless and frequent impulse snacking is down across the board. Hershey's seeing it, Conagra's seeing it. A lot of the big players are seeing it. So it is, so permissible indulgence is going to start leaning and has started leaning more into this where people are like, okay, if I'm going to have a treat, might as well have it be super buttery and sugar and fat and all this, this kind of stuff, because I'm going to have less of it anyways.

27:20So might as well have the real thing. But I do think there are now sort of like three parts of this. I do think there are still some diet culture products that fit into permissible indulgence. And then there's like more indulgent treats that have something added to it that make it also easier to consume. Like Wonder Monday, I think is a good example, which is individual cheesecake with added protein, low sugar, low calorie, low net carbs. I think a lot of the frozen pints are really good example. We've evolved from Halo Top to something that's actually indulgent and probably actually has like cream in it and dairy, but it's higher protein.

28:05It's formulated to be a little better so you can still like eat the pint or feel good about eating the pint um i think and then like yeah i i also think like some of the cleaner candy is is still like permissible don't it's like hall pass for example it's kind of in the name where they're positioning it as such yes it's not like the richest chocolate on the market but they're still giving you the reason to indulge in it yeah But overall, I do think people are indulging less. So, like, I don't think we're ever going to see a Nabisco 100 calorie again. I don't. I think we'll see maybe, like, a better-for-you Oreo a little bit that has some either benefit or is formulated a little bit better.

28:51Like, Nature's or Back to Nature's Oreo, I think, is a good example. But like you feel a little bit better about having that because it's made with better ingredients, but you're not going to have like the whole sleeve. Yeah. I mean, I think if the if the definition of permissible indulgence is that broad, there needs to be different names for it. Because you're describing like three vastly different things to me. Like, I think permissible indulgence where it's a candy-like hall pass that is zero sugar would not be reached for by the same consumer who is looking for one bite of the best thing that they've had or the most nostalgic thing that they've had and they're able to have just one bite and feel satisfied.

29:34they would reach for a Reese's cup instead of a Hall Pass version of a Reese's cup. Because why would I have zero sugar when I'm only going to have one bite anyway? And I want the real nostalgic thing. And I don't like the taste of artificial sweeteners. So I almost want permissible indulgence to have subcategories if we're going to be using it that way, because those are not the same thing to me. And also like adding something to a product. So that's Hall Pass is example of like we're taking away the sugar. adding something to a product also feels a little bit different to me. So, for example, protein pints is one of the things you get.

30:13One of the examples you get. Protein ice cream. More broadly. What is that brand? Nimble? Yeah. So Nimble. N-Y-M-B-L. Only one vowel. It's very good. And Nimble is an example of what I think you're describing, which is full fat, full sugar ice cream that just also has protein in it. And I see why that's like a version of permissible indulgence. But I really don't like that being in the same category as something like Alex Culture Cups, which is permissible indulgence because Alex Culture Cups are single serve ice cream. And it's permissible because it's just a single serve. So these communicate different things to me.

30:56They are both trends for sure. There is a reason for the permission slip, whether it's this thing takes something away, this thing adds something that makes me feel good about it, or this thing is in a smaller size that makes me feel more comfortable with consuming it. But the actual formulation of all of those products is so different that I really don't like putting them in the same category. Yeah, but it is because it's all giving you a different reason that you're allowed to consume that thing and feel good about it. Whether that's a Lexington Bakes where it's a single serve brownie, blondie baked goods that's made with really, really, really good ingredients.

31:42or if it's a hall pass where you can have four Reese's peanut butter cups and feel good about it or their new product, Rowdy. I think the Medici stuff is honestly, a lot of their new products are leaning into the permissible indulgence side because of EPG and how they formulate things. I think more of permissible indulgence will be leaning into premium and microportions. I do think that's really true, but I don't think that that that doesn't mean that a hall pass, a frozen protein ice cream isn't permissible indulgence because it's still giving you the go ahead. Consume all this stuff. Right. Right.

32:27But I do agree with you. We need more terms. We need more terms because these are all describing very different. So I like intentional indulgence. I feel like that sort of intentional indulgence sort of fits like the protein, the additive stuff in a way. I was going to say that intentional indulgence actually fits more the portion controlled things because the intentionality is around I'm going to indulge, but I'm being intentional about the way that I'm consuming it. Great point. But again, these all can be interpreted differently. And honestly, the debate is definitional at this point, which isn't necessarily like the most riveting.

33:02But needless to say, we're having these conversations because we've been seeing so much of this. And I think it is just a really interesting phenomenon. One of the stories this week, too, that we saw this happen in was McConnell's ice cream, which is a 78 year old brand. It's really old. McConnell's ice cream, California based premium, premium ice cream. They make some of my favorite ice cream. It's so good. They just introduced their first ever half pint format. So it's a two pack, or no, sorry, it's a four pack of eight ounce cups or a half of a pint that's being sold exclusively in SoCal Costco locations.

33:39So they're now able to be sold in Costco. I'm really sad that they're not sold in my Costco. But this is very reminiscent of what I was describing earlier, Alex Culture Cups, which the brand Alex, which makes A2 dairy also really premium ice cream. It's really good. Came out with culture cups, which are the single serve a little bit different because they're four ounces. So half half of a pint. And there's a term for that that I don't remember. Half five. So, yeah, Alex culture cups are sorry, not half a quarter pint. Alex culture cups, which are single serving, have been really popular. They instantly sold out upon their launch.

34:19I think the reason that Alex is doing so well as a company is because they came out with this portion-controlled version of their pints. And McConnell probably saw that and was like, how can we do something similar? And they did something similar but different. It's a larger size. It's not a single serve unless you want that to be a single serve. I mean, do what you got to do. I think it is. Totally. A half pint. I love it. But it's still this permissible, indulgence-leaning format of this is less, but we didn't take anything away from it. It is the same premium ice cream that you got in the full pint format, but in a smaller version.

34:54So I thought that was really interesting news for especially for an almost 80 year old brand to do something like that. Yeah. Yeah. A hundred percent. And like all of this discussion, I think, is really happening because of GLP ones. It's like shifting so much of how people eat and how people consume. I mean, currently there's what, like 11 % of U.S. adults are on a GLP-1. At the end of the day, GLP-1s are affecting how we eat. I mean, it's literally affecting how people eat. It's changing their taste buds. It's changing their food impulses. But snacking at the same time is up. Snacking is growing.

35:33So it's not that people don't want a snack. It's just, like we're saying, they want to still indulge without necessarily feeling bad about it. But GLP ones are just going to continue to change how everything is done across these brands. I mean, we're going to see smaller portion sizes amongst a lot of these indulgent products, like true, true, true indulgent products like Alex Ice Cream and McConnell's Ice Cream. And I'm sure more of these brands will start doing it. I mean, I think even a lot of these bigger brands are going to start coming out with more portion control versions of their products.

36:11Yeah. Yeah, and it's also, I mean, GLP-1s are a huge, huge part of this, as we were saying, but it's also, there are a lot of factors that are playing into this. One of them is a lot of fear around artificial ingredients and ultra-processed foods. And so as the rhetoric shifts towards, I want real ingredients, that applies to indulgences as well. Right. So it's not just GLP-1s are influencing how people consume or interact with these sweet products. It's also that the Maha movement and a lot of fear mongering around ultra processed food and artificially sweet products has made people lean away from traditional diet culture products and actually go back into traditional indulgences to a real cookie, to real ice cream, whatever it is.

36:56They feel actually that that is the better for you option. it kind of is too because like if you're if you're if i'm having like let's use lexington bakes for example real flour real real butter real chocolate like real normal ingredients that you'd find in your kitchen that you'd make something like when i have one of those i don't feel the need to necessarily have another one right away where a lot of overly processed food is literally designed to to make you indulge even even more which i i think as we have more just products that are simpler and cleaner sweetener, cleaner sweeteners, natural sweeteners and cleaner ingredients.

37:38We're going to see a lot more of that. Yeah, I think it's, I struggle with it because I agree with that completely and I've experienced that personally, but I also think there's a really fine line where it leans into chem phobia of, I don't want to have these fake ingredients in my products and therefore I'm going to have the full sugar Coca-Cola instead of the Diet Coke because that's better for me because it's real sugar when that is misinformed. So it's a little, it's, it's still tricky for me because that line is still there, but I also hear what you're saying of there's a satisfaction that comes from actually indulging in the thing that you want to indulge in as opposed to having some cop-out diet version of it that is a good thing but yeah and granted a lot of the the diet uh dupe versions are pretty good or getting very good like these healthified junk food products are like getting pretty good like i you know i think especially if like brands like or companies like ublee can get their their sweet proteins into more products or epg can get into more products like if you can make it taste and feel like the real thing or even the indulgent unhealthy thing uh like overly processed thing but make it better people will flock to that and like i mean we we don't have david's numbers but like we're doing pretty well and people seem to be interested in that kind of stuff and hall pass we'll see how that one performs for example but like i think if that performs really well on shelf that is very telling about what people are wanting and willing to consume on like a mass market scale yeah that one that example also confuses me because that's the ultimate diet culture product it's a zero sugar product so it's interesting that's why permissible indulgence can't be the label for all of these things because they're too different and they perform too differently and they respond to cultural impulses too differently.

39:43There's so much. We could go on forever. There's so much nuance to all of this. And that's why even us who we studied this day in and day out, it still gets kind of confusing because there's so many levels to it. The American consumer is so broad and so vast. There's so many different subsets. But I do think permissible indulgence is going to be something we're going to keep hearing over the next year for sure. There's going to be more and more brands trying to dabble in this, whether it's from the premium and microportion side, whether it's from the subtraction-led side, whether it's from the addition-led side.

40:20We're going to see many more products in this world of indulgence from all of these different angles. Yeah, absolutely. I completely agree. And it's exciting to see what innovations come out of that. I mean, if skinny dips and butter dark chocolate wafers are one of them, then I'm happy. but I refuse to see any more 100 calorie cookie packs. I do want those Nabisco crackers back. Those were so good. They were actually kind of good, but I just - They were so satisfying. There's something about like a single serve product that like the whole stick is that it's only 100 calories that makes you so mad.

40:54It's incredibly toxic, but I was very blessed to not have at least a knowingly toxic relationship with food personally. Wow, that makes one of us. Well, I'm happy we had our Halloween episode and could shout all things sweets because, again, one of your favorite things. I love candy. I love candy so, so, so, so, so much. Yes. I do want to shout out a candy. Katja's, Jake Shane's, octopus, sourpuss. Those are addictingly good. And everyone who's tried them has been like, this is the best. So this is a vegan Swedish candy-inspired gummy product. From Germany. From Germany. But it's like Swedish-inspired.

41:42European. Katchas that they made in collaboration with the very famous influencer, Jake Shane, who— The LaBubu. I don't know what you're saying. I'm not an internet culture enough to know what you're saying. Anyway, but they're octopus-shaped gummies that are sour. but they are this blend between a gummy texture and a marshmallow texture. And they're so good. And everyone who I've given them to has been like, this is the best candy I've ever tried. So that's a good one. That's a good Halloween wreck. If you can get your hands on them, cause I think they're sold out, but otherwise have a very happy Halloween.

42:15Merry Halloween, everybody. Thank you for listening. Thank you for watching. If you happen to be watching, you can find us at express checkout.co where we post our newsletter. You can find us on Instagram at express checkout. and we'll catch you on the next one. Bye. Bye.

From the publisher

Happy almost-Halloween! ‘Tis the season for sweets, and we’re celebrating the best way we know how: by overanalyzing how brands are playing into indulgence.

First, we’re sharing news about a fascinating innovation in sweetener science from Oobli and the latest from a forgotten friend in the modern soda aisle, Zevia (and why building a brand around a specific sweetener is risky behavior).

Then, we’re getting into two theories shaping the sweetest brands—“dessertification” and permissible indulgence—both backed by news stories from this week and recent launches.

What’s the spookiest sweet trend to you? Over-exaggerated dessert-themed marketing, portion-controlled indulgences, or function-packed treats?

🎧 Love the show? Subscribe to the Express Checkout podcast wherever you get your podcasts! New episodes drop weekly.

📧 Get the inside scoop Subscribe to Express Checkout, our newsletter packed with consumer insights, trends, and exclusive content straight to your inbox at expresscheckout.co.

🗣️ Let’s connect! Follow us for behind-the-scenes content, quick tips, and more: @expresscheckout

💬 Join the conversation Have a product you’re curious about? DM us your questions or drop them in the comments—your topic could be featured in our next episode! If you have any thoughts/questions/suggestions, feel free to email us at [email protected] :)

⭐ Help us grow If you enjoyed this episode, please rate and review us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. It helps other curious consumers find us!



Get full access to Express Checkout at www.expresscheckout.co/subscribe

More from Express Checkout

All episodes