1. Podcasts
  2. Filmspotting
  3. Double Indemnity
Filmspotting

4 Nov 2026 · 32m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

Double Indemnity | Archive

In short

FilmSpotters Archive’s Noirvember kickoff review of Billy Wilder’s 1944 Double Indemnity, focusing on how the film’s “perfect crime” plot, Stanwyck’s performance, and Wilder/Chandler’s structure build a noir about obsession and moral “love” between Walter Neff and Barton Keyes.

Guests/backgrounds

No specific guests are interviewed in the excerpt. Hosts are Josh and Adam (FilmSpotters). A listener letter from Albert Malafront is read; Mariah Gates is referenced as having discussed the film earlier.

Key claims

Phyllis Dietrichson (Barbara Stanwyck) is “peak” femme fatale—sinister, cold, and psychologically layered (not just seductive). The film’s real heart is Neff’s relationship with Keyes, not the romance with Phyllis. Wilder’s shadow imagery and repeated blocking (tall vs. short, big vs. little man) underscore Neff’s doom.

Notable examples

the opening crutch shadow silhouette; the murder scene where Wilder holds on Stanwyck’s blank stare; echoed compositions (Phyllis watching Neff and her husband sign papers; later Neff “pinched” between investigators); the anklet-to-stairs editing transition.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

4:30

Plot Overview of Double Indemnity

A breakdown of the film's plot and key characters is provided.

“of double indemnity see what i mean walter sure i got good eyesight You mean you want him to have the policy without him knowing it.”
6:40

Character Analysis: Barbara Stanwyck's Phyllis Dietrichson

Discussion on Stanwyck's portrayal of Phyllis and her impact as a femme fatale.

“Josh, Double Indemnity is one of my all-time favorite films.”
12:50

Narrative Style and Filmmaking Techniques

Exploration of the film's narrative techniques and visual storytelling elements.

“more exchanges where you understand really her motivation and her psychology and where she was starting from and hoping to get to, you realize that she is, I'll use a word I've used previously in the show.”
14:00

Exploring Visual Storytelling in Double Indemnity

Analysis of key visual elements and shots in the film.

“and even in Neff's recordings to this, you know, that he's giving to the Edward G.”
23:04

Character Relationships and Themes in Double Indemnity

A deep dive into the character dynamics and themes of the film.

“My favorite single visual moment, though, in this film is a transition.”
28:04

Walter Neff: The Average Man

Explore Walter Neff's character traits and the significance of his stature.

“He says at one point, I thought you were smarter, Walter.”
30:04

The Decision to Commit Crime

Discuss Walter's motivations behind committing the crime in the film.

“Hold tight to that cheap cigar of yours, Keyes.”
31:36

The Dynamic Between Neff and Phyllis

Analyze the relationship dynamics between Walter Neff and Phyllis Dietrichson.

“To try to pull this off is essentially cheating on keys, whether as a, you know, a romantic partner or a colleague.”
34:27

Phyllis and the Role of Femmes Fatales

Examine the portrayal of Phyllis in the context of film noir and femme fatales.

“The only other film like this in our marathon is meet John Doe.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Filmspotting, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Josh Larsen: This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. O, O, O, O 'Reilly. Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on? Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE certified master technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today. O, O, O, O 'Reilly. Auto Parts

1:00Josh Larsen: Get worse with Kyle Pruitt on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. From shocking betrayals to carefully planned murders, the Black Effect's new original podcast series, Bloodline Crimes, hosted by me, Morgan Wood,

1:15Adam Kempenaar: explores the darkest and bizarre cases where family became the most dangerous threat of all.

1:22Josh Larsen: Listen to the Black Effect's Bloodline Crimes every Thursday, starting October 8th, From the Black Effects Podcast Network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Michael Lewis here to tell you about my new book, Blockers, which gives you an inside look at the Trump administration and the public servants who stood in its way. These were people who were securing our most sensitive data, keeping the public safe from all sorts of threats, and engaged in life-saving scientific research until they were told they no longer belonged. And the question to me is, if they can't survive in our government, then what does it say about us?

2:03Josh Larsen: Get Blockers now only at blockers.fm.

2:12Josh Larsen: What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today? You're not interested in art? No. Now look, we're going to do this thing. We're going to have a conversation.

2:21Adam Kempenaar: Hey, FilmSpotters. It is Wednesday Archive Drop Time. And as we are now into November, or as some call it, I think maybe even our friend and colleague Mariah Gates technically coined it, Noirvember. We're going with that. We're going to share this month, Josh. Sam had a great idea. Let's just share over the course of November, every episode will be a noir film, a neo-noir review. And maybe we'll get to our top five neo-noirs that we did several years ago. So we're going to go in chronological order, beginning with 1944 and Billy Wilder's Double Indemnity, which unlike The Shining, which we still don't know whether or not we've put into our pantheon, that's a refocused joke that will make more sense later.

3:09Adam Kempenaar: I do believe we put double indemnity in the Pantheon. Officially, it certainly belongs there. And that's the one we're kicking things off with.

3:17Josh Larsen: I mean, you might want to double check that, but it does sound right to me. We reviewed this together at least. And maybe for sure it went in then in 2022, because that's when we did our Barbara Stanwyck marathon. What a great marathon. Baby face, Stella Dallas, the Lady Eve, meet John Doe, ball of fire. And then yeah, double indemnity. which was, I don't think it was, it wouldn't have been the first time I saw it. Was it, Josh? I think it was actually.

3:45Adam Kempenaar: I think that was a big blind spot for you.

3:47Josh Larsen: Yeah. This will be answered in the review. It will be. People are about to hear, of course.

3:51Adam Kempenaar: It will be ahead of you. We remind you that access to the Film Spotting Archive, over 1 ,100 episodes, counting all the bonus episodes. Actually, if you count everything, it's well over 1 ,200 or maybe 1 ,300 episodes. That's just one of the benefits of joining the Film Spotting family. you're really supporting the show keeping us doing what we're doing you get bonus shows a weekly newsletter early access to event tickets and a whole lot more speaking of that we think we may have details soon on an event in a major u.s city it's a tease but if you're a family member you will get early access to that so here from september 2022 is our sacred cow review of double indemnity see what i mean walter sure i got good eyesight

4:35Josh Larsen: You mean you want him to have the policy without him knowing it. And that means without the insurance company knowing that he doesn't know it. That's the set-up, isn't it?

4:43Adam Kempenaar: Is there anything wrong with it?

4:44Josh Larsen: No, I think it's lovely. Then if some dark, wet night that crown block did fall on him.

4:48Adam Kempenaar: What crown block?

4:49Josh Larsen: Only sometimes it can't quite make it on its own. It has to have a little help.

4:52Adam Kempenaar: I don't know what you're talking about.

4:54Josh Larsen: Of course it doesn't have to be a crown block. It can be a car backing over and we could fall out of the upstairs window. Any little thing like that just so it's a morgue job.

5:00Adam Kempenaar: Are you crazy?

5:02Josh Larsen: Not that crazy. Goodbye, Mr. Diedrichson.

5:06Adam Kempenaar: What's the matter?

5:08Josh Larsen: Look, baby, you can't get away with it. Fred McMurray and Barbara Stanwyck there in 1944's Double Indemnity, directed by Billy Wilder, written by Wilder and Raymond Chandler, based on a story by James and Kane. How about all of that? It's the sixth and final film in our Summer of Stanwyck marathon. Stanwyck keeping things steamy. Adam, even as we get into fall here and summer falls behind us, still pretty steamy thanks to Stanwyck. Double Indemnity, it turns out, kind of a perfect bookend for this marathon. We began with 1933's notorious pre-code Babyface. That does have Stan Wick in femme fatale mode.

5:44Josh Larsen: She's playing a determined social climber, Lily Powers, who seduces and then disposes of one man after another. Here she is, just a little over a decade later, as one of film noir's preeminent femme fatales, Phyllis Dietrichsen. Seducing men, knocking off her husband, kind of come full circle here.

6:03Adam Kempenaar: A quick plot summary for the double indemnity uninitiated. We meet Mick Murray's insurance salesman, Walter Neff, at the beginning of the film, confessing to a crime, not to the police, but via dictaphone to his superior at the Pacific All-Risk Insurance Company. It's claims manager Barton Keyes, who's played wonderfully by Edward G. Robinson. In flashbacks, we see Mick Murray's introduction to Stanwyck's Phyllis, a woman who has, it appears, grown tired of life with her wealthy but controlling husband and his grown daughter by a first marriage. Against Walter's better judgment, he and Phyllis are soon setting out to commit the perfect crime, getting the husband to unwittingly purchase a life insurance policy that will pay out big when he dies and doubly big if he dies the right way.

6:46Adam Kempenaar: Josh, Double Indemnity is one of my all-time favorite films. You had never seen it before this week. And while I am truly desperate to know what you thought of it, I'm going to give the floor for a moment to listener Albert Malafront, who wrote us this. I felt compelled to write in because you are covering my favorite movie of all time on this week's show, Double Indemnity. I could go on and on about everything from Wilder's direction, visual delights like that incredible opening shot of the mysterious man in crutches advancing towards the camera, Or how about the amazing Edward G. Robinson supporting performance?

7:19Adam Kempenaar: But seeing that this is a Stanwyck marathon, I'd love to hear this question discussed. Is Barbara's Phyllis Dietrichson the greatest femme fatale ever? Mariah Gates beat me to this when she was on the show a couple weeks ago, but she describes Dietrichson as peak femme fatale, and I couldn't agree more. Despite knowing, at the start, the doomed inevitability of how this story is going to unfold, I find the central seduction with Neff more engrossing, heartbreaking and sexy than any other film of this era. I completely believe why Neff gets wrapped up in it the way that he does. And it really is because Stanwyck is an absolute force.

7:51Adam Kempenaar: I love Doir, but nothing in the genre comes close to this in terms of passion and chemistry. So we'd love to hear your thoughts regarding how she ranks as a femme fatale. Is she indeed peak femme fatale? Also another burning question. Why is this not in the Pantheon? Take it away, Josh. Tell me, please, whether or not you agree with Mariah and with Albert. and tell me if you, if not agree with me, that it's one of the best films ever made. Do you at least maybe now understand where I'm coming from?

8:22Josh Larsen: Oh, for sure. I mean, let's put it in the pantheon. Loved this. It was fantastic. I do want to table Albert's main question here about the femme fatale ranking and how that relationship plays out in the movie, because it might be one of the areas I possibly have a critique, But I don't want to start with that because I loved this so much. Let's stick to Stanwyck, though. No surprise. The main reason I probably did love this. What a thrill, once again, to watch her go to work and assert her dominance. What an entrance. I mean, at this point, moviegoers had likely been accustomed to knowing what they were going to get from a Stanwyck performance.

9:07Josh Larsen: And this does not disappoint when Neff shows up at her door to renew her husband's auto policy. And Phyllis answers the door wearing nothing but a towel. Right. And it's even trumped because that's maybe an expected thing with a femme fatale character. Sure. But then when she comes down the stairs after changing, I like how she's still buttoning her blouse. Love it. You know, it's just like you could have taken 10 more seconds. Right. Phyllis. then more of the physicality that stanwick always brings to her performances she sits in that chair in the parlor with the slinkiness i mean there are things going on between her and that chair that we shouldn't be witnessing i don't know how she does it because she's not really moving it's just how she sinks into it so that the chair is caressing her as as neff watches and um you know There's more to the performance than that.

10:02Josh Larsen: However, I do think once the murder plot kicks in, we get to see additional layers. This is, that's the sort of stuff that as good as it is, and as few actresses could do it that well, you feel like Stan what could probably do in her sleep, but we get more layers as the movie proceeds. And the one scene I do want to highlight is the murder scene. Actually, they're driving, right? She's driving her husband. So they're both in the front seat and Neff is hiding in the back seat. and he rises up, Neff rises up from behind to choke her husband, played by Tom Powers. Wilder cuts to a close-up for this of Phyllis, of Stanwyck, as the deed is being done, holds it for a couple seconds, and what she gives us there is an expression that is eerily blank, which is disturbing, because you want to see some level of emotion, distress, concern, even if it's amoral.

10:55Josh Larsen: It's just like, are we going to get caught? She doesn't give us that, But somehow, and I'd have to watch it a number of times to see what it exactly is, you sense some deep-seated terror going on in there, which is different than surface-level panic about getting caught, those other things I'm talking about. And so I think Stanwyck is doing the sort of work that, in the context of this marathon particularly, we probably expected, but giving us even more than that in her portrayal of Phyllis Dietrichson.

11:24Adam Kempenaar: she's remarkable and this is a film filled with remarkable elements i don't know that stanwick's performance as phyllis is the thing that elevates this film but it's all of those component parts working together wilder and the writing here with chandler they know just what they're after and they get it from stanwick they get it i think from mcmurray as well and i'm going to talk more about that scene, Josh, the murder scene a bit later when we get to our awards. But that blank stare you touch on, that's where I think you can probably put Stanwyck up there as peak femme fatale in that there is a coldness to her and there's an edge to her that she doesn't really soften.

12:15Adam Kempenaar: It's as if Stanwyck understands that Phyllis, no matter how good of an actress she is. And she puts on a performance. There are times, right? Oh, I hate him, Walter. He's so mean to me. He abuses me. She puts on a performance in the way she comes on to Walter and how much she claims to love him. But it's almost as if Stanwyck understands that Phyllis in her soul refuses to be a victim and she cannot play that part. And when that murder happens, I'll unpack it a little bit more later. But when that murder happens, when other scenes happen between her and Walter, more exchanges where you understand really her motivation and her psychology and where she was starting from and hoping to get to, you realize that she is, I'll use a word I've used previously in the show.

13:06Adam Kempenaar: There is a sinister quality to her that I think does make Phyllis stand out from even other femme fidels. Yeah, sinister is exactly the right word.

13:17Josh Larsen: The revelations you get to her character, but they're not, you know, there's wiggle room too. There's enough of a question to wonder, because you hear about these things, her past, her relationship with her now husband's ex-wife as the nurse to her. You hear those third hand. And so you start to wonder, as Neff does. How deep does the sinister quality go in this woman? And how deep am I? And will I ever be able to get out? So it's a great word to describe this character. Wilder and Chandler, you know, in the screenplay here, I would say this is more of a noir in terms of the plot and the language.

13:57Josh Larsen: The language is such a delight. The exchanges between the two of them. and even in Neff's recordings to this, you know, that he's giving to the Edward G. Robinson character, the narration of that just has an incredible, he's storytelling, you know, in a way that fits the character, but also just makes it so fun to listen to. It's essentially a voiceover and sometimes those can be leaned on too heavily. It is leaned on here. It's the entire structure of the movie, but I think the writing does that well. It's maybe not so much a noir for me visually, Although, as Albert mentioned, the opening credits are fantastic with this silhouette figure and the crutches coming at you menacingly.

14:38Josh Larsen: And you don't know, if you haven't seen it before, what that means, what is going on. And in terms of the filmmaking, I do want to call out two echoing shots that worked really well for me. And the one comes fairly early on where it's Phyllis, it's Neff, and it's Phyllis' husband. At this point, Neff is getting him to sign the insurance papers that are part of their con, part of their scam. And we see Phyllis in the background of the shot, framed in the foreground are Neff and her husband. And she's just watching. It speaks to what you were talking about, Adam. In retrospect, when you first watch it, you sense like it's a point of suspense.

15:18Josh Larsen: Are they going to get him to sign the papers, right? But in retrospect, it's such a sinister shot because she's slightly higher than the two of them as well in the frame. And then this is echoed later on here with a shot of Neff. This is in the insurance offices. Neff is in the background this time, in the middle, placed between a witness and the Edward G. Robinson character, the insurance investigator. And he, at this point, is getting pinched, where she was in a powerful position before. At this point, we see he's getting pinched by those two figures. So just a little bit of filmmaking. I don't know how intentional it was to mirror those two.

15:56Josh Larsen: Probably was, knowing Wilder, but was just so effective to me. So even though this is not maybe the noir-iest looking of noirs in a lot of ways, I do think there are some crucial decisions like that, which jump right out at you.

16:11Adam Kempenaar: No, you nailed it. The slinkiness of the way she's positioned in the chair, the way that dynamic changes when she's in that chair at the end of the film and they're having a different type of exchange. The imbalance of people standing and sitting, the imbalance of people who are tall and people who are not. I am going to talk more about this in a second. It all matters. It is all intentional in this film. And I do want to go back to that opening credit shadow that Albert mentioned and that you mentioned as well, Josh. First time I watched Double Indemnity wasn't something that even stood out to me.

16:50Adam Kempenaar: I just sort of took it for granted as an opening credit sequence. And it was only actually as I started to unpack more and more what this film really to me is about and the themes and ideas that Wilder is exploring, did I realize how intentional even that was, that it's not just a little bit of creative license to have a more dramatic opening, to do something that's a little bit more expressionistic like you'd expect from noir. No, there is even in that opening something intentional. There's something in terms of the mood and even an idea that Wilder is just planting. He's planting the seed for it right there.

17:29Adam Kempenaar: And I'm going to get to that. I'm going to get to what I think that seed is. But the shadow shot itself is something on this viewing I never noticed before how much Wilder goes back to it. and there's a part of me that wants to acknowledge that well it's noir and even if it's not as dark or as bleak or as stark in terms of the black and white in the shadows as a lot of others this is california after all right i mean that's also one of the elements wilders exploring here is it's gorgeous sunny california but behind these closed doors all these sinister things are are taking place, but there's a veneer that everything is even and good and cheery.

18:14Adam Kempenaar: And every time Walter walks out that door of the house, as he leaves, that same shadow figure that opens the film is there on the wall and gets imprinted on the wall. It's very deliberate to me, Josh, that it's as if every moment he comes into that house and he leaves, he's getting himself closer and closer to being that that imposing, scary, almost zombie like doomed figure. And Wilder says, I'm going to make sure that the lighting is set up a certain way so that every time he exits that door, that shadow is cast large on the wall behind him.

18:58Josh Larsen: Well, and it's also the sense he is the shadow, but the shadow's pursuing him, right? Just like in that opening credits, it's pursuing us. It's coming towards the camera at us. And so in those echoing shots you're talking about, it's coming after him, which is what fairly soon into the movie we realize is happening here. Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on. Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE certified master technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you.

19:37Josh Larsen: Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today.

19:47Josh Larsen: There are thousands of podcasts that can tell you how to better yourself. Get Worse with Kyle Pru is not one of those podcasts. So if you're interested in getting thinner, going to therapy, starting peptides, setting boundaries, taking supplements, making your better, getting closure, then I would humbly recommend other podcasts.

20:04Adam Kempenaar: But if you're interested in blackmail, love bombing, cloning yourself, or getting revenge, then we've got a little something something for a dastardly individual like you. Take a listen to some of the incredible advice we've given so far.

20:16Josh Larsen: Fake a back injury. Get the spray tan. Up your alcohol consumption. Only women should be allowed to have guns. Kill them. Kill them. Kill them. Listen, it's already over. I'm all about lying if it's something that really happened.

20:30Adam Kempenaar: The next time a bear is running at you, you just calmly stop what you're doing. You look the bear in the eye and you say, this isn't you.

20:37Josh Larsen: Do not preserve relationships. You don't need them. You only need one thing, and that's the Get Worse podcast. Listen to Get Worse with Kyle Pru on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Malcolm Gladwell here. As a child growing up in rural Canada, I was always puzzled by America's peculiar problem with gun violence. The murder rate in the U.S. is nearly three times higher than Canada's, and five times higher than the murder rate in the U.K. and much of Western Europe. Why? What's so different about the United States? In my new book, The American Way of Killing, The Invention of an Epidemic, I speak to the doctors who worked miracles on gunshot victims, re-examine the strangely important story of a 17th century English knight, and parse out the grammar of the Second Amendment with a linguist and travel to a shooting range in North Carolina, all in an attempt to understand where this problem came from and why Americans so often misdiagnose the nature of the violence that plagues their streets.

21:43Josh Larsen: But this book really isn't about guns. It's about why a country has never quite understood its own problem and why you can't fix what you refuse to see. Get the American way of killing at pushkin.fm slash audiobooks or at Audible, Spotify or wherever audiobooks are sold.

22:03Adam Kempenaar: They shared the same name, the same home, the same DNA, the same blood. But behind closed doors, blood isn't always thicker than water and family loyalty can turn deadly. From shocking betrayals to carefully planned murders, the Black of X new original podcast series, Bloodline Crimes, hosted by me, Morgan Wood, explores the darkest and bizarre cases where family became the most dangerous threat of all.

22:32Josh Larsen: Because sometimes the person you should fear most is not a stranger, but rather someone sitting at the dinner table with you. Real cases. Real families. Real killers. This is Bloodline Crimes. Listen to the Black Effect's Bloodline Crimes every Thursday, starting October 8th, from the Black Effect Podcast Network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

23:04Adam Kempenaar: My favorite single visual moment, though, in this film is a transition. And it goes back to the anklet. And this here, again, is just pure, wilder, directing genius. The moment when he sees her, elevation again. There's a discrepancy. He's looking up at her. She's up high. She's in an exalted position at that point. But she's hidden. The camera is even obscured. We see that she's wearing a towel, but we can't get a glimpse of her full body, just like Walter can't. You want to see it, just like Walter does, right? And then when she comes down, the fact that we see the anklet first, we see the legs first, and she is still, as you noted, buttoning up her shirt.

23:50Adam Kempenaar: She could have waited. She chose not to. Very intentional to further get her hooks and the imagination going for Walter. But how about the moment, Josh, when he says in his narration something like, I couldn't stop thinking about that anklet. And we cut back to the leg, the anklet going down the stairs. And for a split second, you think he's remembering it. It's like a flashback in his head of the thing he's talking about, except it's not. It's her coming down the stairs again the next time he shows up at the house. Just a beautiful bit of editing there and connecting those two scenes. But for me, why this film is among my all time favorites, it's so many of these things we've talked about.

24:36It's the performance by Stanwyck.

24:39Adam Kempenaar: It's the noir dialogue and the delivery. It's the Sunset Boulevard approach in terms of the structure, which I think is really bold. Starting with that fatalism, we know where it's going to go. We know how this ends up and it's bad. It's not about That it's about how we got there and why and the surprises along the way, because as much as Albert talked about the relationship between Phyllis and Walter, for me, the real genius of this movie is that. wilder pulls a fast one on the audience he's got a character who says that he committed this murder and he did this whole thing for money and for a girl and it turns out he didn't really do it at all for money and a girl those were elements but that's not really why he did it and not only that it's a film noir where he's got this relationship with this sultry woman but what's the real love story here.

25:38Adam Kempenaar: This is a love story between two men. This is about the relationship. Fundamentally, double indemnity is about the relationship between Walter Neff and Barton Keyes, the only real love of Walter's life and the larger philosophical implications of that relationship. Why does he do it as he says to her in one key scene and he's starting to grab her so tight as he's saying it that she even says Walter you're hurting me he's not getting turned on by her he's not even getting turned on by the thought of committing the crime itself he's getting turned on by what it will mean if he can pull this off that Walter Neff 35 years old or whatever he says no visible scars The plainest, boringest, blandest, everyday guy who nobody pays any attention to and doesn't remember when he walks through the door and walks out the door.

26:42Adam Kempenaar: He's eminently forgettable. He is going to make his mark. He is going to pull off something unthinkable. He's going to make this crime work and he's going to get paid out. It's going to be perfect, as he says, right down the line. Well, the only way to do that is to fool Keys and fooling Keys is the thing the movie sets up as the true impossibility. So their relationship and the way that he constantly he even says at one point sarcastically because Keys has just taken him down a peg. He says, I love you, too. But he actually says, I love you, too. Every time he lights the cigar for him, he lights the cigar for him.

27:23Adam Kempenaar: And that's Neff's way of saying, I love you too. And at the end, of course, that's mirrored and reversed by keys lighting his cigarette. But it's about that relationship. And as I said, that larger idea of Walter Neff setting out to do something that ambitious, misguided and immoral, but that ambitious. And that's where all the stuff with the height comes into, right? That looming shadow figure getting closer and closer and larger and larger. And all the talk about the little man. Barton Keyes, a little man with another little man inside him that's the conscience, right? And Walter's this tall guy.

28:05Adam Kempenaar: And what does he even say to him? He says at one point, I thought you were smarter, Walter. You're just taller. And Wilder plays with this in other ways, Josh. even at the at the mart the grocery store where they meet and have their clandestine conversations what happens in one scene a woman interrupts their conversation because she asks him to grab something off the top shelf and she even says i love it she even says i don't know why they put the things i want just out of my reach this is this is life that's that's not just a throwaway moment this is like the things you want are always just out of your reach and guess what Walter's tall enough to grab him.

28:42Adam Kempenaar: Walter's tall enough to grab him. And even he says to him later too about his insurance sales reports. He says, you're high man on the board. There's throughout this film, you can catalog again and again, all the references to big man, little man, tall, short, but that idea of being a big man by doing something and accomplishing something that But an average person can't. And it's built into every aspect, every fiber of who Walter Neff is. You know, he's that forgettable. He's that ignorable. Josh, so much so that even though he's hiding himself, he's obscuring himself. Nobody on the train notices anything about him.

29:24Adam Kempenaar: And even the guy who interacts with him later only has a faint sense of maybe we've met before and otherwise walks right out. It's so ingrained into every aspect of who Walter is. The very reason why he's committing this crime altogether is tied inextricably to who he is as a man.

29:44Josh Larsen: You thought you had a coal, didn't you? All wrapped up in tissue paper with pink ribbons around it. It was perfect. Except it wasn't because you made one mistake. Just one little mistake. When it came to picking the killer, you picked the wrong guy. you want to know who killed Dietrichson? Hold tight to that cheap cigar of yours, Keyes. I killed Dietrichson. Me, Walter Neff. Insurance salesman. 35 years old, unmarried, no visible scars. Until a while ago, that is. Well, the decisive factor for him, for Walter Neff, in actually going through with this, he says as much at one point. I think he tells Keys this when he's recording his story is because he'd always wondered if he could get away with it.

30:38Josh Larsen: Can you beat the house? And yeah, it's yes, it's her. It's the money. But he he rejects those two initially. Right. He sets them aside. He tells her you're crazy. This won't work. What is it that pulls him back in? In a lot of ways, it's not her. it's this thing he's always had which speaks to your comments about his relationship with keys this wondering it would there be a way to get one over on keys and could i do it and that's why he actually he actually tries it so so yeah it makes sense to frame the movie in that way and you know how far you want to take it in terms of a romantic loving relationship or not yeah you're not no okay Because if you did, it would be interesting, you know, in a way doing this, especially with her, would be cheating on keys, if you put it in those terms, right?

31:35Josh Larsen: Sure. To try to pull this off is essentially cheating on keys, whether as a, you know, a romantic partner or a colleague. So, all right. So since it's interesting that the emphasis for you is on those two, because I think that is an incredibly rich relationship that the movie is clearly interested in. The amount of scenes they give to those two and those lines that they repeat to each other and come back and forth. And if there's one thing that did hold me back a little bit is not about Stanwyck being a femme fatale, but who her partner was in the femme fatale department. I think McMurray is good here.

32:15Josh Larsen: I think he's quite good and captures a lot of those qualities you were just describing, this every man who's going to reach a little bit further than he probably should, despite his stature. But when Albert said in his comment about nothing in the genre comes close to this in terms of passion and chemistry, I just wanted a little bit more of that. Adam, I thought a little bit more of that would have nudged Double Indemnity for me to the level where it is for you, as much as I did really admire it. A little more heat between the two of them. I think McMurray lacks a certain darkness that in some other noir relationships we see.

32:55Josh Larsen: but this connects us to the Stanwyck marathon. Here's a curious thing I've noticed about her and watching all of these films together. She is so sly. She's so whip smart, always ahead of her male co-stars. They're playing catch up. They're almost too busy trying to play catch up to flirt on her level. And that's okay in some of these films. But when you're talking about a noir, a steamy noir like this, you need there to be a portion of the entrapment where they're on the same level. And I think McMurray's Neff for me talks tough. He tries to be in charge. He throws baby around a lot and mostly in a way that is a command rather than a term of endearment.

33:43Josh Larsen: But I don't know that he's equipped for the joust here. That doesn't undermine the film in any way. This is a case of where it's not even a flaw to the movie, but it's an area where if there had been maybe just one more seduction scene where I felt like he was seducing her a little bit too or keeping up with her, then the movie would have been elevated even more. So I don't even want to call this a flaw because I think the relationship works for the way the film wants it to. And maybe it works this way because the priority for Wilder and others is on Robinson and McMurray rather than McMurray and Stanwyck.

34:16Josh Larsen: That could be it. But for me, and especially thinking about this in terms of femme fatales in the film noir, that's the one thing where where I just was looking for a tiny bit more.

34:26Adam Kempenaar: well i'll say this everybody i know their first response to double indemnity is that fred mcmurray just isn't quite up to the challenge he's a little too boring he's a little too blind whatever it is a little too normal you can't do it give yourself some more viewings josh and i'm going to save any more thoughts about fred mcmurray's performance for our awards here okay yeah we can talk a little

34:48Josh Larsen: bit more about this uh this stanwick thing with her male co-stars too i think that'll probably

34:53Adam Kempenaar: come up in the awards as well but let me just state that that is what it's tied up in for me it's tied up in the fact that this film really ultimately is not at all about the heat between those two characters she's just another nudge she's just another nudge in something sure that that walter has his his mind set on she's the spark she lights the flame and she has to light the flame and i have to believe that that the dynamic between them is is such that he can't he can't overlook that flame and that it's it's it's hot that's what i'm looking for yeah and i i think it's hot enough and i think that that that jousting between them is is there but in the context of a stanwick marathon there is a little bit of a contradiction for me in the fact that i think she is absolutely peak femme fatale and at the same time i think that this movie does put her on the side a little bit because that emphasis on Neff and keys.

35:53Adam Kempenaar: This is Mick Murray's movie. The only other film like this in our marathon is meet John Doe. And you talked about that with Michael and I had the same feeling if we had to do it all over again, I'm glad I saw meet John Doe, but we probably should have swapped it out for another film where she was the star and the main character. She's definitely sidelined in that movie, especially that's noticeable when her character has the most interesting potential and the most interesting arc and i think is the the ripest for exploration of what that movie wants to talk about but it's gary cooper's movie it's john doe's movie right similarly this is walter neff's movie and and his and keys i think but she's so good and so striking and so memorable that she does elevate phyllis dietrichson into one of the all-time great femme fatales, if not the greatest.

36:47Josh Larsen: Now, about those policies, Mr. Diedrickson, I hate to take up your time.

36:50Adam Kempenaar: Oh, that's all right. If you wait till I put something on, I'll be right down. Nettie, show Mr. Neff into the living room.

36:58Josh Larsen: Reminder that access to the Film Spotting Archive is just one of the benefits of joining the Film Spotting family. You also get bonus shows, a weekly newsletter, early access to events, and more. If you'd like to join the family, just head on over to filmspottingfamily.com.

37:12Adam Kempenaar: This conversation can serve no purpose anymore. Goodbye.

37:28Wait!

37:29Adam Kempenaar: I came in for two things! How is this$47?

37:33Josh Larsen: Alright, we're gonna need a plan here. Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25. Oh, that's actually really simple. Safe balance banking. One less thing to figure out. Learn more at bofa.com slash simple banking. Terms and conditions apply Bank of America and a member FDIC.

37:57Adam Kempenaar: With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers. You can get things done. Whether you're leading a big project, planning an elaborate trip, or trying to balance work and life, ChatGPT can help. Give it a goal, plus things like files, notes, or project plans, develop a trip itinerary with daily updates, or create a prioritized schedule so you can spend less energy sorting out the details and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life. Get started at ChatGPT.com.

38:25Josh Larsen: This war amongst us has got to end. The Hulu original phenomenon, All's Fair returns. You got one shot to make this right. I'm not saying I hate you, but I would unplug your life support to charge my phone. From executive producer Ryan Murphy. I will not stop, and I will win. Let's give these girls a show. This is gonna be a good time. The Hulu Original Series All's Fair. Now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply. Whether you run a small office or a factory of 500, For businesses of all sizes, connection is everything. That's why T-Mobile is reinventing business internet with Super Broadband.

39:09Josh Larsen: Powered by America's fastest 5G internet and integrated with Starlink, Super Broadband is built from the ground up and the sky down, reaching every zip code in the U.S., even in the most remote locations. Like this solar farm. Whether it's the boardroom or the emergency room. All of our systems and our systems. With Super Broadband, your critical data states online, even through disruptions. T-Mobile now delivers Super Broadband, a new era of business internet. Visit SuperBroadband.com to learn more. Vastest 5G network based on analysis by Okula Speed Test Intelligence Data 2H 2025. Speeds vary due to local network characteristics and management.

39:51Josh Larsen: Satellite requires hardware installation and clear view of the sky. A 36-month commitment.

From the publisher

What better way to kick off Noir-vember than with a Sacred Cow review of arguably the greatest noir ever made, Billy Wilder's 1944 classic Double Indemnity. Originally reviewed in 2022 as part of the Barbara Stanwyck Marathon. 

Unlock the full archive, Filmspotting Discord, ad‑free + bonus episodes, and more when you ⁠join the Filmspotting Family⁠. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Filmspotting

All episodes