The Breakfast Club (Archive)

3 Sep 2025 · 48 min · 18 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

A FilmSpotting “Sacred Cow” archive review of The Breakfast Club (1985) for its 40th anniversary, focusing on why it still resonates: teenage fear, identity, parental failure, bullying, and the film’s cathartic “Saturday reprieve” even though nothing is fully resolved.

Guests

Josh and Adam (FilmSpotting hosts). They also reference an interview with Carl the Janitor actor John Kapelos (via co-producer Golden Joe Dessau) and discuss comments by screenwriter Diablo Cody and actress Ally Sheedy.

Key claims

The movie deconstructs high-school archetypes while taking teens’ concerns seriously; its sustained bullying monologue and layered performances hold up; editing/reaction shots make the single-location detention feel dynamic; the ending is hopeful but debatable (especially Allison’s makeover and Bender/Claire’s flirtation/possible romance).

Notable examples

Allison’s “When you grow up, your heart dies”; Andrew’s bullying confession; Bender’s “life at Johnson” impersonation; Vernon’s isolation and Carl’s “if you were 16” line; the final “second glance” compassion; Allison ripping off the patch at the end.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

The Breakfast Club's Influence and 40th Anniversary

0:00 to 0:30

Discussing the continued relevance of The Breakfast Club and upcoming screenings.

“Most dog food brands don't really want you seeing how their food is made.”

The Breakfast Club's Influence and 40th Anniversary

2:28 to 4:38

Discussing the continued relevance of The Breakfast Club and upcoming screenings.

“Adam, I think we both got news about a new release, an indie release called Pools that I believe is playing right about now at Music Box Theater.”

Sacred Cow Review: Nostalgia and Revisit

4:38 to 7:27

The hosts delve into their personal nostalgia and reflections after rewatching the film.

“I'll just run right out and join the wrestling team.”

Themes and Character Analysis in The Breakfast Club

7:27 to 11:46

Exploration of deep themes and character dynamics in the film.

“I don't know, to get to your question, that watching it as a parent really came into play for me.”

Performance Analysis of The Breakfast Club Cast

11:46 to 14:01

Evaluating the performances of the cast and their impact on the film's success.

“I won't tolerate any losers in this family.”

Character Analysis and Performances

14:01 to 19:44

The hosts dive into the character dynamics and performances of the cast in 'The Breakfast Club'.

“But what these movies all do is they embody the experience in such a way.”

Thematic Depth and Social Interactions

19:44 to 28:00

Discussion on the themes of the film, including social dynamics and character relationships.

“I love the different levels that Nelson brings to this.”

Film Techniques in The Breakfast Club

28:00 to 29:00

Explore how cinematography and editing enhance storytelling.

“And you could just tell that care has been taken in trying to place them within this landscape and alienate them a little bit.”

Interview with John Kapalos

29:00 to 31:20

Insights from Carl the Janitor on the film's lasting impact.

“And it echoes in a way, and we cut to Vernon, and we're not quite sure whether Bender even said it or if this is something that, you know, this is just how Vernon sees these kids.”

Themes of Catharsis and Authenticity

31:20 to 32:50

Discussion on the film's portrayal of teenage angst and authenticity.

“But I think a lot of teen movies might have gone there.”
Show all 18 chapters

Character Analysis: Vice Principal Vernon

32:50 to 34:30

Examining Vernon's role and character development in the film.

“And the difference is that this is a reprieve that you feel is formative.”

Parental Dynamics and Power

34:30 to 37:10

The film's commentary on parental failure and authority figures.

“And this is sort of like when Roger Ebert revisited The Graduate after, I think, 30 years or 35 years.”

The Function of Carl the Janitor

37:10 to 40:00

Understanding Carl's role and thematic significance in the narrative.

“He is treating these kids or relating to them, power, the word you use, the same way that it appears most of their parents relate to them.”

Ally Sheedy's Transformation and Its Impact

40:00 to 42:00

Debating the implications of Allison's character arc and transformation.

“It would have been totally heavy-handed and it would have been unnecessary.”

Exploring Female Characters in The Breakfast Club

42:00 to 46:30

Discussion on the portrayal and transformation of female characters, focusing on Ally Sheedy's role.

“And she mentioned Ghost World, but basically said, it's kind of sad that I can only think of a couple of examples of these kind of strong female characters on screen.”

Reflections on The Breakfast Club's Impact

46:30 to 47:28

Reflecting on the lasting impact of The Breakfast Club and its significance in high school life.

“I think, too, bolster my argument, I'll just say how great is it that her final moment with Andrew is her stealing the patch off his jacket.”

Reflections on The Breakfast Club's Impact

48:50 to 50:31

Reflecting on the lasting impact of The Breakfast Club and its significance in high school life.

“This conversation can serve no purpose anymore.”

Reflections on The Breakfast Club's Impact

51:00 to 51:44

Reflecting on the lasting impact of The Breakfast Club and its significance in high school life.

“With auto pay and a voice line Plus taxes and fees Same day delivery for most internet eligible customers See if it's an option during checkout Okay, laundry stinks, literally.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Most dog food brands don't really want you seeing how their food is made. Just food for dogs is the opposite. They actually invite you in. You can walk into any of their kitchens and see real human-grade ingredients like chicken, beef, carrots, and peas being prepared right in front of you. It's real food made in real kitchens. Nothing is hidden behind labels. And that kind of transparency says a lot. Nothing to hide, everything to love. Go to justfoodfordogs.com and get 50 % off your first order. Amazon Pharmacy presents Painful Thoughts. Of course I see my co-worker in light at the pharmacy.

0:42Can he tell I'm picking up prescription hemorrhoid cream? I'm probably standing weird. Why is he smiling? He knows. He's going to call me hemorrhoid Lloyd tomorrow. I know it. I got to quit my job. Next time, avoid awkward conversations and get fast free delivery with Amazon Pharmacy. Healthcare just got less painful.

1:05Adam Kempenaar:Some people like working twice as hard just to stay right where they are. And in Ohio, we really don't get it. Because to us, owning a home in your 30s, working in tech without the traffic, and still being able to make it to your kid's soccer game sounds pretty good. In fact, Ohio is the second most affordable state to buy a home. Your move. Learn more at yourmoveohio.com.

1:35Adam Kempenaar:Healthcare can feel complicated. That's why Optum uses technology to connect the people and processes that make healthcare easier, more affordable, and more effective. We're making it clearer for you to know exactly what your benefits cover. And to help you better manage your health, we're coordinating care between your doctors and your technology. We believe better, simpler health care is always possible. That's healthy optimism. That's Optum. Visit Optum.com to learn more.

2:08What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today? You're not interested in art? No. Now look, we're going to do this thing. We're going to have a conversation. Hey, FilmSpotters. Josh here with Adam. This weekend, the definitive 80s high school comedy, The Breakfast Club, is back in theaters for its 40th anniversary. 40th anniversary, still influential. Adam, I think we both got news about a new release, an indie release called Pools that I believe is playing right about now at Music Box Theater. Check that for sure. I know they had their premiere there not too long ago. And they described it as being influenced.

2:46It's Chicago made and set and being influenced by John Hughes comedies of the 80s like The Breakfast Club. So, yeah, definitely a movie that is still affecting films and filmmakers many few decades on here. And we wanted to share with you our Sacred Cow review. Now, we did this back for The Breakfast Club's 30th anniversary, which was in 2015. That's right.

3:14Adam Kempenaar:And we're not just busting it out for its 40th. It's also timely because this weekend, September 7th, and on Wednesday, September 10th, commemorating its 40th anniversary, there are going to be special theatrical screenings around the country. If I can find a link with more details about that, we'll post it in the show notes, wherever you're listening to the podcast. You can try to find it there. Otherwise, just Google it, look for it around you. Hopefully it will be playing near you, especially if you haven't seen it in maybe 30 years or so, or maybe somehow you've never seen the Breakfast Club at all.

3:51Adam Kempenaar:Or maybe you're now, you're our age and you have kids who are the age that maybe we were when you saw the film, when we saw the film for the first time, and they can actually experience it for the first time on the big screen. This is your opportunity to see it September 7th, September 10th. Now we're pulling this review, as I said, from the Film Spotting Archives, Adam. And if you want access to these archives all the time, all you have to do is join the Film Spotting family. That's where you'll get those reviews. You'll get top fives and more going back to 2005. So archive access, just one of the benefits you get as a member of the family.

4:33And you can learn more about all of that at filmspottingfamily.com. For now, here, enjoy our Sacred Cow review of The Breakfast Club.

5:08Adam Kempenaar:I'll just run right out and join the wrestling team. Maybe the prep club, too. Student council. No, they wouldn't take you. I'm hurt. Our Sacred Cow selection this time, Adam, is a movie that's maybe not sacred to cinephiles in general, but it certainly is to those of our generation. The Breakfast Club, John Hughes' chamber piece about five high schoolers stuck together for a Saturday of detention, came out in 1985. Yes, 30 years ago. You and I were not quite yet in our teens then, but I know I at least was already fascinated by all things teenager. I'm guessing I didn't actually see the movie until it came out on video most likely, but at that point I did watch it enough times that I could predict most of the lines of dialogue during this revisit.

5:53Judging by your brief review on Letterboxd, your revisit was a blissful trip down memory lane. Five stars. That's as high as it goes on Letterboxd. Word. Were you aware of that? Word. Five stars. Okay. I'm guessing one reason for this lavish rating is because you picked up on a secondary level of wisdom to the movie when watching it now as an adult. One of the things you noted in your review was the truthfulness of an observation made by Allison, the basket case played by Ali Sheedy, who contends that we all become our parents. So what was it like to watch The Breakfast Club now, not as a kid, but as a parent?

6:28And how do you feel about Allison's other observation? When you grow up, your heart dies. Is your heart dead, Adam? Is that five-star rating just a shameless attempt to prove otherwise?

6:39Adam Kempenaar:It might be. You might be on to something that is a little bit melodramatic, but I love that line, and I'll get to why in a moment. First, though, I do hope there's a little bit of magic in the air. Did you catch that when this film opens and you get that opening voiceover that the date is the exact same date we are sitting here to record tonight? Are you kidding me? March 24th. Wow. Of course, it's March 24th, 1984. That's Saturday 31 years ago. So they shot it before it came out, clearly, in 1985. But it's exactly the night. So like I said, hopefully that'll bring something to this discussion.

7:10Adam Kempenaar:And it is for me, forget being able to predict certain lines. This was a unique sacred cow experience. We've always seen the movies first. That's what makes them sacred cows. We're revisiting them. But in this case, I could quote, and to the annoyance of my wife, did quote 80 % of the movie as it was going on. I don't know, to get to your question, that watching it as a parent really came into play for me. My son Holden just turned 13. He's a huge nerd. He would be the Brian here, and he would use that term to describe himself and do it with pride. High school is hard, but I'm fairly constantly worried about my kids already.

7:47Adam Kempenaar:I'm a high dread kind of guy. More significant to me was seeing it as an adult. When I'm not the same age or, as you noted, a little bit younger than these kids, Maybe I can't directly relate to their day-to-day problems. Besides having a different perspective, I was also just more aware of it as a movie, how it's constructed, and hopefully we'll get to that a little bit as well. I think that line from Allison, Ally Sheedy, though, is one of the keys to The Breakfast Club in terms of why it holds up so well 30 years later. It's not just that it was, I think, that I can recall in a way, the first movie to simultaneously establish these high school archetypes while deconstructing them.

8:25Adam Kempenaar:it's how seriously John Hughes takes these kids concerns and how thoroughly he explores them amidst all of this comedy sometimes broad silly comedy he goes to some really dark serious places and he does it as well in Ferris Bueller's day off if you think about Cameron his daddy issues destroying the beloved Ferrari at the end of that movie I always found that tonal shift in Ferris Bueller a little bit cumbersome a little bit hard to overcome because it's such a heavy moment and then it's sort of like, oh, we're back to Ferris Bueller running around backyards and we're just supposed to forget everything Cameron's going to face and everything he's been through.

9:00Adam Kempenaar:But Emilio Estevez's monologue here, about three quarters of the way through this movie, about what he did to get into detention. The bullying. So good. That's even darker than anything with Cameron. That unbroken take that underscores the weight of it, that character isn't just telling a story. He seems to be channeling something deep from within. Anthony Michael Hall's breakdown as well. Hughes is trying, I think, and succeeding at making us laugh, but he's clearly using these characters and this setting to really wrestle with something, wrestling with whether you can overcome your nature, your upbringing, or if you're doomed to become your parents.

9:36Adam Kempenaar:Can you stop your heart from dying? I think that, for me, Josh, is what makes this movie so timeless and universal. Almost everyone, but especially any junior high kid or high school kid, no matter what generation, can relate to that fear, along with everything else the movie is dealing with as far as establishing your identity, retaining your individuality while being part of a group trying to be accepted within that group or culture so yeah this movie really did hit me about the same way it hit me 30 years ago which is something i wasn't expecting because i hadn't seen it since then maybe actually in high school i remember showing it to my now wife because she had never seen it but i was still of that age i was in high school it really did resonate with me was it just recently last week i think with Cinderella, probably.

10:17We talked about children's films for a younger age group, how it's important to respect that audience's intelligence. And the same thing happens for teen audiences, where the filmmakers will often consider, let's just give them the lowest common denominator. The Breakfast Club does not do that. It's very interested in these kids, not as archetypes, as stereotypes, as ways to get some funny jokes out. It's interested in their stories and the universality of their experiences. The bullying thing that you mentioned, Andrew's monologue, is an amazing sustained sequence, especially when you think about in 1985, clearly that was something that educators were aware of.

10:57But it was nowhere near to the degree of attention it gets today in terms of experts coming into our schools and having sessions with kids about being proactive, about keeping this at bay. But the complexity of it, too. Why he does it, the mixture That's what I'm talking about. The awareness of understanding here, well before this was a common thing that people were digging into, of what led to it and how the act was an expression of Andrew responding to how his father treated him. And just the really haunting line that Andrew says, how do you apologize for something like that? There's no way.

11:35It's all because of me and my own man. God, I fucking hate him.

11:43Adam Kempenaar:He's like this mindless machine that I can't even relate to anymore. Andrew, you've got to be number one. I won't tolerate any losers in this family. Your intensity is for shit. Win! Win! Win! You son of a bitch. I mean, what movie would not only acknowledge that the kid is thinking about his action, just move beyond the action. Most teen movies that deal with bullying are centered around the act of bullying itself. And here's something considering the aftermath and considering the sorrow on the part of the offender. And we could talk about the way that the movie gives almost every character in this film a chance to consider who they are in that deep of a manner.

12:33So I think this absolutely stands up. It did for me as well. I didn't go quite as crazy for it as you did. And maybe we can talk about why I backed off a little bit. You were younger either, did you? Oh, all I remember when I watched it is just thinking, yeah, I loved it. And just thinking like, is this what high school is like? You know, it was kind of this, because we were both younger than the people in the story, you're kind of looking at it as a primer a little bit. And so that's why the dialogue would stick in my head. It was almost like you're packing these things so that you'll be ready when you get to high school.

13:07That's what I remember taking it in as at that point. But here, you know, it does just speak across generations and across decades. I would put it up there. A couple of titles that work similarly in the teen genre would be Splendor in the Grass, decades earlier, in terms of just getting at that idea of puppy love, much more focusing on sexuality there.

13:30Adam Kempenaar:Explicitly about sexuality and sexual tension. And that aspect of being a teenager. And then something more recent, Scott Pilgrim versus the world is another movie that I came out of and just thinking, man, that gets it. That manages to get at the heart of what it was like to be a teenager. And these movies, all three of those movies, they don't just get the look right. They don't just get the dialogue right. I might argue that The Breakfast Club does not get the dialogue right in a lot of situations in terms of the phrases they use. But what these movies all do is they embody the experience in such a way.

14:05And this film, Hughes does it primarily for the attention that he gives to the characters and also the cast. I mean, this thing would not work as well as it does without this phenomenal cast. And we can maybe talk about who we think rises to the top. I finally came up with an answer after wrestling with that a little bit myself. Wrestling, is that a cue?

14:25Adam Kempenaar:Are you a big Estevez fan? No, I went another direction. Well, I didn't really think about it in those terms, but I did discover that I did appreciate these performances beyond what I remember as a kid, liking the movie overall and not really judging those performances here being a little more objective or distance from it. I was able to see them as what they are. I think they are all really good, really strong performances. But I want to go back to the opening of the film because all of these kids, this is the first thing I said out loud as Sarah and I were watching the movie. I'm like, all these kids are being driven to school by their parents.

14:59Adam Kempenaar:And yet they seem to me like maybe juniors or seniors. Maybe Brian is the youngest. He might be 15, a sophomore or something. But otherwise, they all seem like they're of driving age, but they're being dropped off by their parents. That seems so weird. Of course, then I thought about it for a minute as that sequence played out. And I realized it's all about parents. It really is. And you see what Hughes is doing. What he accomplishes there is he immediately gives us a window into their psyches. We see where they're coming from. And, for example, we understand the disconnect between Claire and her dad, the academic pressure and demands of Brian's mom, the athletic pressure and demands of Andrew's dad, that blatant disregard of Allison's parent.

15:35Adam Kempenaar:I don't even think we know who it is. They just don't even acknowledge her and drive away. And, of course, the loner Bender, who hilariously walks right in front of the car without stopping. He's the one who comes in by himself, no parent who cares about him. So the whole movie is set up right there, all those dynamics that we need to see. And before we discover them to be a certain type, we get to see them as people and see that baggage that they're carrying with them before they begin any of these interactions or these confrontations with each other. It, of course, sets up the whole trajectory of the story, as I said, but it also gives us some insight that the other characters don't have.

16:08Adam Kempenaar:I think it actually establishes a neat layer of subtext to a lot of those interactions and confrontations that we wouldn't otherwise be aware of. A perfect example is when Bender does his impersonation of what it's like at the Johnson residence. Great scene. The cuts to Anthony Michael Hall and his reaction, you can read it as he's hurt because he's being made fun of. But because we know what the dynamic really is like at home, we as a viewer appreciate that on a different level. We see through it a little bit and we recognize that he's not just hurt at being made fun of. He's actually hurt because he wishes his home life was probably that way and it's not that way at all.

16:48Adam Kempenaar:So there are double layers to a lot of what's going on in this film. And we were talking about how quotable this is. And for me, in fifth grade when I saw this movie, we watched it hundreds of times. I mean, probably not hundreds, but it felt like it. And we did know every single line. So one of the questions I was really wondering as I sat down to watch it now, like I said, at least 20 years since I last saw it, it was could it make me laugh? Could I actually laugh out loud when I know all the lines, I know all the jokes and what's coming? I laughed a lot. I laughed out loud a lot at this movie.

17:19Adam Kempenaar:And it wasn't at the big, broader jokes, the things that did make me laugh a lot as a 9 or 10-year-old. It was the reactions, the expressions on their faces, the overall absurdity of some of those moments, like Bender and Brian, Judd Nelson and Anthony Michael Hall, taking their coats off at the same time. and Ryan acquiesces when Bender kind of shoots him a dirty look like, are you copying me or something? And it's not just that he decides to stop and put his coat back on. That's funny enough. It's that he then rubs his hands together like he's cold and he really wants to put his jacket back on.

17:55Adam Kempenaar:But he feels the need to put on that show is really funny. The look Bender gives him when he does the I'm a walrus bit and he puts the pen on his lip. Those bits for me that I maybe didn't laugh so hard at, like I said, however many years ago, were really funny to me this time. A lot of those are the social cues that the film just nails in how teens walk into a room and it's immediately perhaps, you know, it still happens when you're an adult, of course, but never more so as heightened as when you're a teen. You're immediately staking your place and it captures how that's done through gestures and through looks and those sorts of things.

18:31So Life at Brise, that scene, is perhaps the standout to me. I had three scenes that I want to make sure we talked about. And we got to the first one already. Estevez's confession of bullying. I think that's crucial and I think he's fantastic in it. And I like how Hughes uses the camera there too, as you said, unbroken, but also moving around to include all of them in the conversation. This was much more visually sophisticated than I would have expected in revisiting it. But the other two scenes I wanted to talk about are who I do give my MVP award. Again, not that we need to, but to Judd Nelson.

19:05Yeah. And Life at Bryce, the way that goes from this comic impersonation that's also so bitter. I mean, it's just so clear that the reason this really bothers him is because his home life is not like that, too. And as much fun as he's making of Brian, that he's also just furious because of this other element going on. And then how it transitioned to the impression of life at his house, which is really scary. I mean, Nelson, and we got to talk about this as well, how he treats Claire. Because I think we look at that differently. People in general would look at that differently than they did in 1985.

19:41And he's scary with her, too. But I think that's a very good element of the performance. I love the different levels that Nelson brings to this. Even when he has that early standoff with Vernon and he gets the four or eight extra weeks of detention, there's that moment. I gotcha. Yeah. There's that moment where he turns away and you can see that, OK, most high school comedies would play that up purely for triumph. Right. He's the rebel. He's the rebel. But they hold that one extra beat so that he shows he's pissed at himself for losing self-control. He can't believe he did it. So those are two scenes.

20:14The other one goes to Nelson, too. And it is that early one where it's a sexual harassment slash seduction of Claire. And watching that very early on where he's trying to find out how sexually experienced she is. He's flirting with her at the same time. She's acting repulsed, but also pulling back enough here and there to, I don't want to say toy with him, but to give him the hint that she's still listening. Let's just put it that way. For sure. All right. So in 1985, and as a kid, you know, I'm taking that as, wow, is this guy cool? You know, and you'll hear from women, too. I think I saw it on, it might have been the FilmSpotting Facebook feed.

20:57That's where girls fell in love with John Bender. The bad boy. What's yours? Claire. Claire? Claire. It's a family name. Oh, it's a fat girl's name.

21:09Adam Kempenaar:Oh, thank you. You're welcome. I'm not fat. Well, not a present, but I could see you really pushing maximum density. You see, I'm not sure if you know this, but there are two kinds of fat people. There's fat people that were born to be fat, and there's fat people that were once thin, but they became fat. So when you look at them, you can sort of see that thin person inside. You see, you're going to get married. You're going to squeeze out a few puppies and then...

21:38Oh, obscene finger gestures from such a pristine girl.

Read the full transcript

21:44Adam Kempenaar:I'm not that pristine. Are you a virgin? I'll bet you a million dollars that you are. So you read that scene today where we're much more attuned to things like sexual harassment and it reads very creepily. But I think that's good as well because it speaks to the authenticity. So we could say we could put a politically correct label on this and say, oh, Breakfast Club is so dated because of scenes like that. But I think it speaks to an authenticity, again, of the social cues of how girls and guys, whether it's right or wrong, do interact and how they handle those sorts of interactions. Now, the one place where we might want to talk about does the movie make a misstep is in following through on where does that relationship go by the end of the film?

22:37A, is that believable? And B, is that maybe getting us to root for something that really is unhealthy? I'm still trying to work my way through that because people read the ending differently as well, whether or not Bender and Claire do end up together or was this kind of a one-off flirtation thing.

22:54Adam Kempenaar:Well, let's just go ahead and get to it because I don't want to sidetrack the whole review with it. But for me, it's not as problematic because I do see it as more of a one-off type of thing. I don't think come Monday, Bender and Claire are holding hands with each other, walking down the hall, or he's showing up at her house and angering her father. I see this as a one-time act of kindness and compassion and deciding to call a truce. But that's it. I don't see them embarking on any kind of a relationship with each other. Okay. I wouldn't go quite that far. I don't think they're holding hands on Monday either.

23:24But I think the movie wants you to believe there is a relationship that will continue there. And I think in having us root for that is where we might want to say, okay, I don't know if that's quite so healthy. But that also brings to mind something I thought of after watching this. How did they not make the sequel, The Breakfast Club, Monday morning? And let us know, you know, what really happened to these kids when they showed up that day. I'm totally with you. Nobody even gave each other a second glance. Yeah. I mean, as hopeful as this movie wants to be, if it really stayed true and was as authentic as it is to these kids, that Monday morning would be they don't know each other at all.

23:59Adam Kempenaar:Well, maybe we'll come back to this. It is sort of like before sunrise in a little bit where you wonder six months later what's going to happen. and the key question for 30 years. And that's one of the beauties of this film as well is that we still have that question to ask and ponder and debate because we don't know the answer. But I'm with you, except I would say, Josh, a second glance is exactly what they do and no more. I think we get the second glance. I think there's a little bit of knowing. Where they try to let each other know that they remember Saturday without anyone else seeing. That's exactly right.

24:28Adam Kempenaar:But with Bender, I appreciated him as a young man, as a young kid, because I respected his verbal dexterity and his sort of just rebellious spirit. It probably was. Look, I wasn't growing up watching screwball comedy, so watching someone who was that quick and that witty and able to disarm people the way he was, that was attractive to me at that age. I didn't really see it as a performance in anything deeper than that until watching it this time. I do love his costuming as well. I picked him as one of the top five Halloween costumes I'd wear this past October, but you watch it, it's such a hodgepodge of looks.

25:02Adam Kempenaar:He's grabbing at all these different places to try to form some kind of identity. You've got the flannel before flannel was a look, the boots, those hand glove things he's wearing a little bit. There's some of that kind of biker rebel criminal thing. But there's also a guy wearing that overcoat he's wearing like he's a prep. You know, he really is just grasping at anything. And I think that applies to a lot of the characters here. But you're right in terms of the performance, that sense of anger and resentment, but also pain that underlies everything here. You realize watching it this time that he's overcompensating for everything.

25:38Adam Kempenaar:That confident routine really is just completely an act with him. And what is underlying everything is that fear that everything Andrew says to him at one point is accurate, which is that he really doesn't matter. And that comes through in Nelson's performance. And Claire calls them out on it, too. And that's where I like the Ringwald performance, where she definitely has those strong moments where she gives it back to them and lays bare. She sees through all of that because she's doing similar things. They're all doing similar things. So they all know what they're doing. But who's going to admit to it?

26:09Well, first of all, they're going to call each other out on it.

26:11Adam Kempenaar:This episode is brought to you by Peloton. Break through the busiest time of year with the brand new Peloton Cross Training Tread Plus. powered by Peloton IQ. With real-time guidance and endless ways to move, you can personalize your workouts and train with confidence, helping you reach your goals in less time. Let yourself run, lift, sculpt, push, and go. Explore the new Peloton Cross-Training Tread Plus at OnePeloton.com. Yeah, no, that's exactly right. And I think that as we talk about the look of this film, you mentioned that it was more visually sophisticated than you remember it. Or would have even noticed at that age.

26:46Adam Kempenaar:I think that shot, though, that unbroken take that rotates around the group is probably the only shot that really calls attention to itself in the film. But what I noticed this time, and this is one of those bits on the show here where audio certainly doesn't help us. A video essay would be much more instructive because what I loved is the editing. I really noticed this time how much of the movie is made by the cutting. because it's not visually audacious and it has so many memorable lines of dialogue in it. I think everybody focuses on the writing and they give Hughes all this credit as a screenwriter.

27:20Adam Kempenaar:But all of the relationships, the character dynamics, it's all revealed in the silences, in the looks on their faces, in their reactions. Yeah, reaction shots. Because it really is all about their perceptions of each other. And not only that, how we perceive their perceptions. So as I said before, everything is loaded. So when you cut to a reaction shot, you're really focused on how they're taking that in and what that tells you about how they see themselves, how they see the person who's talking. That is something certainly at age nine or 10 I didn't catch on to, but it's there. It really is in those decisions.

27:54Adam Kempenaar:And think about that. That has to be pretty formally rigorous because you've got pretty much the whole film, five people sitting around each other. and depending on how they shot it and depending how Hughes visualized it maybe storyboarded it or not there was probably a lot of coverage options to cut to so the editor could have gone in a lot of different directions but it's very precise every cut is done for a reason and every cut does have some meaning and that was something as I said that caught me by surprise this time for a movie that primarily takes place within that library it does not feel static at all and when they get out of the library I noticed too that there's some nice framing of individuals or even them as a group within these long institutional halls.

28:37And you could just tell that care has been taken in trying to place them within this landscape and alienate them a little bit. I mean, we don't want to get too carried away in that you're going to put this in and it's going to wow you with its cinematography. But compared to most teen comedies where the cameras just plop down and they go for the gags, it really does have another level going on. In the soundtrack, too, a little bit, there's the moment in particular, I think the same thing happens later on, but the one I'm thinking of is very early on, when Vernon slams the door shut and Bender screams the FU.

29:09And it echoes in a way, and we cut to Vernon, and we're not quite sure whether Bender even said it or if this is something that, you know, this is just how Vernon sees these kids. That's interesting, yeah. And it's amplified. And there's just a little, some nicely clever bits going on like that. For sure. Uh, Carl? What? Can I ask you a question? Sure. How does one become a janitor? You want to be a janitor? No, I just want to know how one becomes a janitor, because Andrew here is very interested in pursuing a career in the custodial arts. Oh, really? You guys think I'm just some untouchable peasant, sir?

29:47Peon, you know? Maybe so. For following a broom around after shitheads like you for the last eight years, I've learned a couple of things. I look through your letters, look through your lockers. I listen to your conversations. You don't know that, but I do. I am the eyes and ears of this institution, my friends.

30:08Adam Kempenaar:Now, I thought it'd be interesting to hear from one of the key figures in the movie. Carl the Janitor, John Kapalos, was available for us to talk to and do an interview with. And obviously, it seemed like a perfect fit for this 30th anniversary review of The Breakfast Club. And even though we couldn't do it, Golden Joe Dessau, our amazing co-producer, was available to conduct the interview. He took some of my questions, worked in a few of his own. And Joe got John Kapalos' take on why he thinks the movie resonated so strongly with audiences in 1985 and why it continues to. I think because it hits on universal truths that are always going to be there in adolescence.

30:48There's fear. There's fear of failure. there's sort of dealing with your parents and all the sort of incumbent issues that, you know, and you walk away from the film going, wait a minute, what just happened here was a sort of a catharsis for these people. And I think that kids continually relate to this movie because it addresses teenage angst and it doesn't talk down to them, period.

31:15Adam Kempenaar:I really responded to the fact that all of their problems don't get solved. And I don't know that I expected that, knowing the movie as well as I did. But I think a lot of teen movies might have gone there. They overcome their differences temporarily. They don't correct themselves or each other. Nobody gets fixed, I think, here watching this movie. They don't absolve each other for their deficiencies and their foibles because, of course, they can't. That's not reality, and I think that gets back to what you were saying in terms of authenticity. This is a reprieve from those lives, but they're going to get back to those lives.

31:46Adam Kempenaar:And to use the word that I think is so appropriate, we heard from Carl the janitor, John Kapilos, it's catharsis. There is a sense of catharsis at the end of this film. And I was thinking about why that final shot, that final frame of Bender with his fist up in the air, why that gives you this sense of triumph when at the end of the day you think nothing much has really changed here. And actually Diablo Cody, the screenwriter, is on the DVD and she talks about it as it's, of course, playing very memorably to the Simple Minds song, Don't You Forget About Me. She says it's just about a Saturday in detention, but you feel like a battle has been won.

32:21Adam Kempenaar:And she's right. You do somehow feel like a battle has been won or at least some kind of blow has been struck. Right. Something something decisive has happened, even if it's not going to change everything forever. Some kind of blow has been struck against conformity, against complacency, falling into those roles and those prior beliefs about each other and ultimately about compassion. And that's what I was hinting at when I said they'll at least give each other that second look. I think that second look is that bit of compassion. So lots of C words there, but catharsis is a big one as well as compassion.

32:50I think the right word is reprieve. I think that's dead on. And the difference is that this is a reprieve that you feel is formative. So if it does not have a practical effect on Monday morning, the hope is it will gradually as they move on with their lives. All right. So let me pump the brakes a little bit on this, all this enthusiasm, and just ask. You're not going to ruin this. You're not going to ruin that. I just have to, you know, one of us has to be a little bit reasonable about The Breakfast Club. Some of the dialogue seems like, I feel like Hughes understands kids much better than maybe he understood how they talked.

33:28Things like, eat my shorts. And, you know, no one in whatever grade I was, sixth or fifth, would say that. You don't think he was being a little bit ironic? No, there's a lot of lines like that. The dance montage, too. I mean, I know, are they high at that point? Is that the excuse we give them? Right.

33:44Adam Kempenaar:Right, which I don't think anybody really reacts to being high that way. Everyone gets manic, like they're on PCP or something. Yeah, and they're doing these routines together. I mean, you know, even as a kid, I thought that was pretty corny. I don't know. I think those lines, Josh, it did occur to me that when he says, eat my shorts, and there were maybe one or two other Bender lines where I thought, I don't think he would say it that way. But those are so compensated for by all of the other really insightful lines. And those pieces of dialogue, like you already touched on, where you get the end of a scene with a line like Andrew recognizing, how do you apologize for that?

34:20Adam Kempenaar:There are too many good lines like that where you just think— But that's why the clunkers stand out. Yeah, maybe. It's like, you know, they're a little more hilarious. It's not enough for me at all. No, it really isn't. Especially when, as I was saying, a couple of other things I like. Paul Gleason as Vice Principal Vernon. He's phenomenal. And this is sort of like when Roger Ebert revisited The Graduate after, I think, 30 years or 35 years. And he was kind of negative on the movie. And he told that story about how when he was a kid, he saw the guy at the pool party giving Benjamin Braddock advice about plastics.

34:50Adam Kempenaar:And he laughed at him like everybody else did in the audience. And now, 30 years later, he thinks, plastics, not a bad idea, right? He has that different perspective being an older man. Well, Paul Gleason as Vernon at that time was nothing but an adversary, an antagonist who didn't understand these kids. He was purely the enemy. But it's not a surprise that Hughes gives him that scene with Carl in the basement of the school. And you get a sense of his own disillusionment with his role and what he's doing there at the school. Why is he even there at the school on a Saturday at all for someone who should be in a loftier position?

35:27Adam Kempenaar:I mean, he's making 30 grand. 31, I think he says. I make$31 ,000 a year. Yeah, it's not about redeeming him. It's not about us ever siding with him against the kids, but it is at least a little bit about getting his perspective. And I think that's enough. Having a little bit of empathy for where he's coming from as well, it makes him a more interesting figure when you have that bit of empathy for him. And I do think that Carl's line to Vernon underscores another key moment in the movie for me, along with Allison's line, which is, listen, Vern, if you were 16, what would you think of you? That's something that he probably hadn't thought of until Carl said that to him, really forced himself to look at it that way and wondered how far he's come and how much he has changed in this process.

36:09Adam Kempenaar:And watching this movie again, when they cut to him in his office and he's isolated in there while they're isolated in that library setting, you are keenly aware of his isolation and his loneliness and a sense that he's being punished as well. He has to sit there, as we said, on this Saturday. That's what his life has amounted to. That probably isn't what he envisioned when he started out, as Carl alludes to in that conversation. All he has really going for him is power or some sense of respect. And the kids don't even give him that. So, of course, imagine how he's then going to behave. But again, I never felt any empathy for Vernon before or recognized any of myself in Vernon.

36:47Adam Kempenaar:And now as I watch it, I realize that there is a lot more to him than that. Well, Gleason makes him more than the butt of the joke, for sure. I mean, he is the literal butt of the joke in many instances. But because of that scene you mentioned, and he's also not just a cardboard villain because his villainy, if you can even use that word, ties into what I think really this movie is spending a lot of time considering, and it's parental failure. He is treating these kids or relating to them, power, the word you use, the same way that it appears most of their parents relate to them. This authoritarian power dynamic, he just puts that into place at school.

37:27That's what they're experiencing at home. And if anything, the movie is this argument that there are more to your kids or the teenage experience than just keeping them in line and making sure they do what they're supposed to do.

37:43Adam Kempenaar:Right. There is at least one more topic I want to get into before we finalize this review. But I thought it would make sense to hear a little bit more from John Kapalos. Of course, Carl, the janitor here in this movie, as I was talking about that conversation in the basement and the relationship between Carl and Vernon. And I wanted Joe to ask him about the fact that he seems to be articulating one of the key elements of the movie, almost given the theme of the movie to bestow on Vernon and the audience. And I wanted his sense of his function as a character in the movie. To me, a lot of what Carl does is kind of underlines, as one would say, the theme of the film, but also underlines the notion that you have dreams, you have aspirations, you have things you want to be, but be prepared because they are going to be crushed.

38:36and you think the detention is difficult and you think that this world that you're in right now is difficult, you know, stay tuned. And there was a monologue that I delivered that told them we're all, they're all going to be like 25, 30 years, like today, right? I told Molly that she's going to have stretch marks from here to Zion. She's going to have five kids, a Ford Suburban. She's going to be drinking too much and her husband's not going to pay attention to her, you know, have fun with that. And I told Michael, he's going to be a big lawyer. He's going to work in a big loop law firm. He's going to make big money and he's going to have a big heart attack and a big funeral at 42.

39:13I told Emilio that he's going to be a failed athlete and he's going to be a gym teacher for the rest of his life and living vicariously through his son, like his father is living through him. And on and on it goes. Judd Nelson, I said, well, you're going to spend five years at Attica, four years in Chino, you know, for armed robbery. And I sort of enumerated this long list of crimes that he's going to commit. And Ali Sheedy, failed loft artist in New York, living off the kindness of strangers, et cetera. So it was a really great thing because in a way that expressed like, hey, you know, you think you've got it tough now?

39:46Stay tuned. And in a way he was sort of senior buzzkill.

39:50Adam Kempenaar:So John goes on to explain that D.D. Allen, the editor, and John Hughes ultimately decided to leave that monologue out of the film. Obviously it's not there. and boy are we grateful, right? I mean, can you imagine if all of that was unloaded on those kids and us as an audience? It would have been totally heavy-handed and it would have been unnecessary. And now that I'm thinking about that smart choice by Dee Dee Allen and I'm thinking of my comments earlier about how sophisticated the editing is in this film, just before I sat down here, I thought, Dee Dee Allen, he mentioned her by name, otherwise I probably would have failed to.

40:23Adam Kempenaar:That sounds really familiar. I'm gonna look her up on IMDb and see what else she has done. And of course, what we see is just a few movies like The Hustler, Bonnie and Clyde, Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon, Reds. Nice. She's done some work. And it certainly was a case where she had the right instinct to lose that monologue. Though it does explain, Josh, why when he says that line about the clock, by the way, is 20 minutes fast, they really react to that. And I noticed watching it this time, they seemed to almost overreact to it, like it was a better little closing jab than it is. Well, it's because that was the kicker to that monologue, which would have been much funnier.

40:59And they also keep a slight variation on that. Bender delivers a little bit of that to Claire. That's true to Claire. So we get a taste of it. That's funny he describes Carl as a buzzkill because he struck me on this watch as being pretty zen, actually. And this model of a guy who maybe didn't end up where, you know, he envisioned, but few people do and take it as it comes. And it's a really good performance. and does serve, for as little screen time as he got, serves a crucial function for the film.

41:27Adam Kempenaar:Okay, well, I told you I had one more area I wanted to get into. I just would be remiss. I think we'd be remiss if we didn't go down this path. You talked about Claire and Bender and that relationship maybe being more problematic, but I'm going to get to another clip here that I want to prompt you with, Josh, a little bit, because back in 2007, I interviewed Ellen Page and Diablo Cody for the movie Juno, and I asked Cody about an Entertainment Weekly article I had read that she was interviewed for, where she referenced Angela Chase from My So-Called Life as a bit of a template for Juno, similar sensibilities.

42:01Adam Kempenaar:And I asked her if she had any others. And she mentioned Ghost World, but basically said, it's kind of sad that I can only think of a couple of examples of these kind of strong female characters on screen. And so then I asked Ellen Page if she could think of any others. And that led her to Ally Sheedy. But Ally Sheedy gets all pretty in the end for the boy. I can't believe that this is like an iconic Breaking Barriers movie. I am sorry for all the lovers at The Breakfast Club. But when I first saw that, I was like traumatized. Really? The unique girl totally changes herself. It's so strange that you brought that up because I discussed that with somebody earlier today, actually.

42:38The whole Ally Shady thing at the end is deeply distressing. And for what? Emilio Estevez? But he's a wrestler. Yeah.

42:47Adam Kempenaar:So I want to know, Josh, did you find it deeply distressing, that transformation that Allison makes at the end of the film? Cody is all over the Breakfast Club 30th anniversary Blu-ray. She's in documentaries. She does love this movie and praises it considerably. But they ask her about this, and she doesn't back down from saying that she sees it as a little bit of a betrayal of that character. Allison's selling out. What do you think? Totally with her. Really? To the point. Oh, come on. To the point that even my 11-year-old self, my 11-year-old self recognized, I can distinctly remember that being a letdown for me as a boy.

43:23Because one of the characters that I probably, I mean, I wasn't like, I would say being an introvert as a kid, I remember feeling connected to the Ally Sheedy character to that degree. There's really no type in that film that I identified with when I was in high school. They're probably just too broad. Nobody really does. But I very much liked her character. Let me put it that way. Me too. I thought she was just, you know, someone who was really cool in that sort of in the background, watching what's going on, probably smarter than maybe even Brian, and doling it out only when it was necessary.

44:02So I really liked Allison. And I remember being like, what is this now? No, this is no good beyond not even just not buying the romantic element of it. But this sort of what they're getting at more is like, this is not her. This is not, you know, doesn't need to happen. So, yeah, I'm with them on that.

44:19Adam Kempenaar:Okay, well, I definitely see the argument for sure, but I didn't see it that way as a kid, and I still don't completely see it that way now. And I think it is worth noting the specific words that Ellen Page used there where she talks about how she can't believe people regarded as some kind of big breaking barriers movie and that Allison's some kind of feminist icon or something. I don't think that's something I would argue, and I've never heard anyone else argue it. So if she was coming to the movie with that weight, expecting it to live up to that, I think the movie probably really would disappoint.

44:51Adam Kempenaar:I suppose, too, I would ask, and I'm legitimately asking. I don't have this answer. Maybe other people will share their opinion. Is something that is not feminist then anti-feminist? Because I don't know that it's the exact same thing. It's beyond that. I mean, it's the makeover. The makeover is never a good idea. No, I agree to an extent. It's just a bad trope. I agree to an extent, but here is my one counter. And this is my genuine response to it. And it was the response when I was a kid. Does Allison really change herself for Andy? Is there a transformation or more of a reveal of who she really might be?

45:30Adam Kempenaar:Because that's how I see it. I think his comment to her is important. The first thing he says to her, actually, the first thing he verbalizes is, I can see your face. He finally sees her at the end of the film rather than who she's been up to this point. A girl, as I saw it and as I see it, literally hiding behind the unkempt hair and bangs and the black eyeliner. So I'd be distressed by it more if that character I ever felt was really comfortable in her own skin and she compromised her identity to win the affection of a boy. But I don't think she compromises her identity because she's still trying to discover it just like everyone else.

46:05Adam Kempenaar:And so, yes, in hindsight, would it be better if she didn't put the blush on her cheeks? Would it be better if maybe she didn't strip down to that pink shirt? Okay, maybe so. But for me, it's more about stripping away than adding. And I think that's exactly what suggested is that a mask has been removed, not added by the makeup. That could very well be what they were going for. But the method they took is hackneyed and problematic. There's no way around that. Well, I don't know that I completely buy that, but I see the argument. I think, too, bolster my argument, I'll just say how great is it that her final moment with Andrew is her stealing the patch off his jacket.

46:40Adam Kempenaar:Just in case we thought, well, she's no longer the basket case. She prettied herself all up. All of her problems have been solved by this little makeover. And now she's like everyone else, just conforming to the way high school is. Nope. She rips off that patch. And I just think that's one of those great little touches that shows how in sync Hughes was with these characters, even after a little bit of misstepping with how that reveal goes down. Unless she's going to put it on her own Letterman jacket. Then the transformation is complete. Maybe that's what was going to happen. That would be fine.

47:07Adam Kempenaar:That would be fine. Okay. There is a lot more I think we could talk about with The Breakfast Club, but wow, I think we've talked enough. So we will go ahead and close out there.

47:28Adam Kempenaar:I'm going to recommend Josh that 10 years from now, we give The Breakfast Club another look, see how we come at that movie for its 50th anniversary, because, you know, I'm sure it came up in that conversation. I didn't re-listen to it. I don't want to re-listen to it. Maybe I will 10 years from now and see how I wrestled with it upon that revisit. But that movie for me was one of the first movies I remember incessantly quoting and, and thinking was not only hilarious, but also profound, you know, and I was, I was like 10, you know, so whatever profound meant at 10, I thought that movie was, it was a peek into the high schooler's life, right?

48:11That's what you were getting.

48:12Adam Kempenaar:Yeah, absolutely. Reminder that you can get full archive access over a thousand episodes going back to 2005. Get them in Spotify, get them in Apple podcasts, whatever player you want. You can get that by being a film spotting family member plus monthly bonus shows, a weekly newsletter. And when we do any event, which we will have some events coming up and we think we You may have another film spotting fest film spotting family members get early access. They get discounts. They get VIP access to things. If that sounds interesting to you, sounds like something you'd want. Well, learn more at film spotting family.com.

48:52Adam Kempenaar:This conversation can serve no purpose anymore. Goodbye.

49:28Adam Kempenaar:Thank you.

49:38Adam Kempenaar:When it comes to your own food, you can walk into a restaurant, see what's being made, and know exactly what you're getting. But with dog food, most brands keep that completely hidden. Just Food for Dogs does the opposite. They've built their entire brand around open kitchens. You can actually walk in and watch them prepare your dog's meals with real human-grade ingredients, like chicken, beef, carrots, and peas, cooked right there in front of you. No mystery, no behind-the-scenes you're not allowed to see. That kind of transparency is rare in the pet food world. And it's a big reason they've become the number one vet-recommended fresh dog food, earning trust from pet parents who want to feel confident in what they're feeding.

50:19Adam Kempenaar:When a brand is willing to show you exactly how your dog's food is made, it says a lot about the care, quality, and standards behind every meal they produce. Nothing to hide. Everything to love. Go to JustFoodForDogs.com and get 50 % off your first order.

50:38Zach, nice vacation spot But without T-Mobile 5G home internet It's scary here

50:45Adam Kempenaar:Don't open it Relax, I ordered T-Mobile 5G home internet With same day delivery Powered by DoorDash Nothing to be afraid of We're saved Get T-Mobile 5G home internet Delivered the same day Powered by DoorDash Just 35 bucks a month With auto pay and a voice line Plus taxes and fees Same day delivery for most internet eligible customers See if it's an option during checkout Okay, laundry stinks, literally. I mean, you could just keep buying new underwear. Not that I've ever done that. Or maybe sort your clothes into piles based on how re-wearable or filthy they are. Or just use Arm & Hammer Deep Clean.

51:23It's made for real-life stinks and stains. So even if you don't do laundry the, quote, right way, Deep Clean will knock it out. I mean, it is from the number one liquid detergent brand that tackles more loads than any other. Come clean with Arm & Hammer Deep Clean. Number one claim based on total wash loads sold. We learned how to love dogs from the dogs that loved us and waited for us to get home from school. They were the dogs that raised us. We returned the love with Pedigree Dog Food. It was good then, and it's better now. Every bowl has 100 % complete nutrition, supporting six health essentials, And now it includes vitamin good bites, a nutrient boost your dog will love.

52:09Pedigree. Good then. Better now.

From the publisher

The definitive '80s high school movie is 40 and back in theaters. Adam and Josh gave it the Sacred Cow treatment back in 2015 for its 30th.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Filmspotting

All 198 episodes
The Breakfast Club (Archive)Filmspotting · 48 min
Listen in VO