


An “Archive” Halloween re-review of William Friedkin’s 1973 The Exorcist, framed as a “sacred cow” test—whether a universally acclaimed classic still holds up. The hosts debate what makes it scary/disturbing, how much the film’s shock moments (Regan’s vomiting, self-harm, head spinning) drive the experience, and whether the movie’s faith themes land as depth or “shallow seriousness.” They also discuss Friedkin’s view that it wasn’t made to scare, and a behind-the-scenes dispute with William Peter Blatty over a cut line in the exorcism.
Josh and Adam (the episode is a two-host conversation; no separate guest interviewees). Adam recounts interviewing Friedkin at a Chicago Public Library event for his memoir The Friedkin Connection.
Josh dislikes the shock moments as cheap and jarringly staged; he prefers quieter psychological/disturbing elements (Karras’s dream sequence, guilt themes). Adam says the film’s real terror is Chris McNeil’s helpless maternal distress, and praises Friedkin’s documentary-like pacing and cinematography.
the Iraq opening with Pazuzu and hostile dogs; the surgery/brain-scan needle scene; Karras’s subway dream; the “guilt” motif; the removed Blatty line about “the girl is us.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion about Halloween and the significance of revisiting classic films.
“What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today?”
Explaining the concept of Sacred Cow reviews for acclaimed films.
“Movies that are widely acclaimed, beloved classic films, usually beloved by us as well.”
Hosts discuss their ratings and personal feelings about classic films.
“I have liked, liked to love every single movie we have given the sacred cow treatment.”
Hosts debate their favorite horror films and discuss their views on A Nightmare on Elm Street.
“all of these movies are good to great as they quote unquote should be, or I'm a terrible critic or both.”
Discussion on personal experiences with The Exorcist and its impact over time.
“In the history of the Sacred Cow reviews, you've given, because at least one just popped into my head.”
Insights from a documentary about The Exorcist 2, examining its creative intentions.
“I've gotten a bit wiser, though I do, I think my root difficulties, which I won't go into now, largely remain the same.”
Discussion about an interview with director William Friedkin regarding The Exorcist.
“So the audiences just weren't ready for his movie.”
Hosts compare their personal experiences and fears related to The Exorcist.
“that he would scare people or that he was deliberately trying to scare people?”
Discussion of the effectiveness of scares in The Exorcist and critical analysis of the film's approach.
“But more importantly, how much do you think being scared plays a role in your overall enjoyment of the film?”
A discussion on the film's reliance on shock moments and their narrative impact.
“interesting question you posed to him, those can in many ways be easy.”
Exploring the emotional core of the film through the mother's perspective.
“Again, it's no longer just seeing her scary face and her eyes and those kind of things.”
Analyzing the film's documentary-like scenes and their impact on horror.
“How about that amazing opening to this film where it all takes place in Iraq and it really sets this whole tone for the fact that this evil they're dealing with is something that has gone on since the beginning of time.”
A discussion on the psychological elements and disturbing aspects of the film.
“But let me get to a couple of things I did like, because I think you're right that the scenes with Miller as Father Karras and his mother, who is suffering from old age and the implication is mental illness herself.”
Discussion of the film's psychological horror elements and key scenes.
“I do think that dream sequence that Father Karras has is one of the creepiest moments in the movie.”
Analysis of how guilt influences characters within the film's narrative.
“I would go back even to—you want to talk about great shots?”
Exploration of faith, evidence, and the supernatural themes in the film.
“And we see them even at one point have a conversation about that.”
Debate on the importance of shocking scenes and their narrative implications.
“And I'm fascinated by that watching this film in addition to being kind of horrified by it.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Filmspotting, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Adam Kempenaar: This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Chicago talks a lot. Hold on, let me step over here. People are talking too much. We debate about food, deep dish, tavern style, who's got the best beef. We yell across rooms, across blocks, across generations. Yes, nice earrings, Grammy. And now we're doing it on our phones, too. Video calls from the L train, group chats that never shut up. Neighbors texting you the score before your TV catches up. Come on! Get a load of this guy. Ketchup on a dog. Yeah, we've got thoughts. Too loud? In Chicago, you're gonna hear it. Because nothing here gets built without conversation.
0:40Adam Kempenaar: Nothing moves without connection. So if you think you know AT &T, it might be time to rethink that. Because their network has improved, like, a lot. So Chicago can keep speaking its mind with AT &T Wireless and AT &T Fiber. Chicago won't stop talking. Our improved network backs it up. AT &T. Connecting changes everything. AT &T Fiber. Limited availability in select areas.
1:08Josh Larsen: What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today? You're not interested in art? No. Now look, we're going to do this thing. We're going to have a conversation.
1:17Adam Kempenaar: It is Halloween week. Josh, where does Halloween rank for you among the holidays? You big Halloween guy? Yeah.
1:25Josh Larsen: Love Halloween. Always have. But I mean, I'm sappy. I really get into the Christmas cozy season, Advent, all of that. It's going to be hard to topple it. But Halloween, I mean, since I used to dress up as Indiana Jones every year and go out trick-or-treating, it's a big one. Always has been.
1:47Adam Kempenaar: Well, we are honoring Halloween with this archive drop this week, going all the way back into the archive. Can you believe it? To 2013 on this show, we discussed the fourth film in our contemporary Korean auteurs marathon, Nahung Jin's The Chaser from 2008. But the main review in honor of Halloween that year was our discussion of 1973's The Exorcist. So two things I want to bring up. One, and I may be off on a couple of the details here, so this is where you can also jump in and correct me. This is a sacred cow review, as we call them. Movies that are widely acclaimed, beloved classic films, usually beloved by us as well.
2:33Adam Kempenaar: And that's why we're revisiting them to see if they are indeed sacred cows or false idols. we have probably i don't know how many we had done in 2013 but by now in 2026 we've done 60 to 80 probably of these at least 60 i would say i do know for a fact that if you just go by a simple rating the simple letterboxd rating of three to five stars for me three to five stars. Do you like it? Did I give it the heart or not? Yeah. I have liked, liked to love every single movie we have given the sacred cow treatment. So either all those, except for one. Now that means either all of these movies are good to great as they quote unquote should be, or I'm a terrible critic or both.
3:31Adam Kempenaar: Okay. and you know take take a take door one two or three love that construct yeah now the one the one that got a negative review and i stand by it is the movie that never should have beaten halloween in our recent movie death match it is yeah i mean i don't know why you're even bringing this up i think it's your i think it's your favorite horror movie a nightmare on elm street Nightmare on Elm Street. So here's where I'm going. Am I correct? Is it a Blair Witch or is it Nightmare that you put as your favorite horror movie? Nightmare's one, Blair Witch is two. Okay, so there you go. So here's my point.
4:09Adam Kempenaar: Here's where I'm going. Your favorite horror movie of all time. I think I know where you're going. You know where I'm going, is A Nightmare on Elm Street. And it's the only Sacred Cow movie I've ever given a negative review to. In the history of the Sacred Cow reviews, you've given, because at least one just popped into my head. I know that and I'm not going to say it because I don't want to get listeners against you you've given at least two movies maybe three well I'll say it yeah 12 angry men oh no we've never discussed it Josh we've never discussed it it just came up in bonus content I never discussed it okay well yeah no it's uh but it's it's uh from it's sort of from that period close so anyway it's it's beloved way more than 12 angry men to kill a mockingbird you're thinking
4:58Josh Larsen: about kill a mockingbird to kill a mockingbird by these okay i reject your entire construct no shame in your critics going against the uh the the consensus when did i say that when did i say
5:09Adam Kempenaar: that wasn't a that was a construct i thought that that's what you set this up with go ahead well that's why i admitted i'm potentially a terrible critic this is a long way around to
5:20Josh Larsen: saying that I don't like The Exorcist.
5:23Adam Kempenaar: To be clear, I'm not suggesting critics shouldn't go against the grain. I'm bemoaning the fact that I never do, in fact. Gotcha. Okay. Okay. Wait,
5:32Josh Larsen: what was yours? Oh, Nightmare. Okay. It was Nightmare.
5:34Adam Kempenaar: So I know that there are at least two movies you've gone against the grain. Yes. And one of them is my favorite horror movie of all time, The Exorcist.
5:44Josh Larsen: Yes. Yes. That's just kind of weird. So The Exorcist has been a journey for me. And I'm looking as you were recounting all that history through one nice thing about Letterboxd is you can see like movies you've had a long history with. What does it look like? You're right. Not the first time I saw it. The first time I logged, it was for this Sacred Cow Review, 2013. Oh, you're going to love this. If you're already, if you're already a little distressed, I gave it two and a half stars, but I did give it a heart.
6:14Adam Kempenaar: Oh, gosh, you know how much I enjoy that.
6:18Josh Larsen: So revisited it about five years later, 2019. No. So yeah, six years later, same rating, still trying to struggle with it. 2022, went back again, got a little bump at him, got a little bump. Ooh, the devil wants you to struggle, Josh.
6:37Adam Kempenaar: That's the point.
6:38Josh Larsen: Yes, exactly. I'm up to three out of five. So all of that to say, let my objections that the listeners are about to hear take them with a bit, like the tiniest grain of salt. You've gotten wiser over the years. I've gotten a bit wiser, though I do, I think my root difficulties, which I won't go into now, largely remain the same. I'm sure those are expressed in this review.
7:07Adam Kempenaar: Okay. We will hear that in a second. The other thing I wanted to say was simply, I recently caught up with on Amazon Prime, Borman and the Devil, the documentary about John Borman and the making of The Exorcist 2, The Heretic. And it's really good and fascinating. I've never seen The Heretic, The Exorcist 2, though now that I've watched the documentary, I effectively have. And if you haven't caught up with it yet, you should. John Borman, still alive, still very much lucid, talking from his home somewhere, I think in Wicklow, actually, Ireland, where I visited when I visited Ireland back when I was a student studying abroad in London.
7:48Adam Kempenaar: And the most interesting part might be, Josh, that he doesn't seem to fully understand that he made a terrible film. He still is clinging to this notion that the audiences just weren't ready for what he made because they were coming in wanting to see a pure Exorcist sequel, and he didn't give them that. So the audiences just weren't ready for his movie. And what the doc shows you is that what he made was an incredibly fascinating film with a lot of artistic intention behind it. And it deserves some respect for that. But then when you also see the finished product on the screen, it's not that the audience thought it should have been The Exorcist 2.
8:41Adam Kempenaar: There's more going on than that. So that's also really a matter that you have to consider. There's a bunch of stuff in there about audience expectation and matters that you can really wrestle with that the movie poses.
8:57Josh Larsen: Hey, some of us stubbornly cling to our opinions for many, many years, Adam.
9:03Adam Kempenaar: Yeah, maybe. And I went to your website, LarsonOnFilm.com, and not surprised. You often like sequels more. Five stars for The Heretic. I wish. I wish. We'll see if I get to that someday. At long last, here is from 2013. Here is that Sacred Cow review of William Friedkin's The Exorcist. Is there someone inside you? Sometimes. Who is it? I don't know. Is it Captain Howdy?
9:37Josh Larsen: I don't know.
9:39Adam Kempenaar: If I ask him to tell me, will you let him answer? No. Why not? I'm afraid. If he talks to me, I think he'll leave you. Do you want him to leave you? Yes. I'm speaking to the person inside of Regan now. If you are there, you two are hypnotized. I must answer all my questions. Come forward. And answer me now. Josh, as you know, back in April, I had the opportunity to interview Exorcist director William Friedkin at a Chicago Public Library event to promote his memoir, The Friedkin Connection. In the chapter on The Exorcist, Friedkin is unequivocal when it comes to the topic of how to label The Exorcist.
10:30Adam Kempenaar: He does not want you to call it a horror movie. No? No. Keeping that in mind, as I was setting up a question for him about The Exorcist, I acknowledge that he doesn't think of the movie as a quote-unquote horror film, but I was curious if he conceived any of the scenes with the notion of trying to scare anyone? Did that ever cross his mind that he would scare people or that he was deliberately trying to scare people? His answer, quick, to the point, not at all. He said he knew the material was disturbing. It was based on the actual case of a possession that took place in Silver Spring, Maryland in 1949, but he was never out to frighten anyone.
11:04Adam Kempenaar: He was more concerned, Friedkin said, with exploring the mysteries of faith. Well, Friedkin may not have been trying to scare anyone, but he did succeed in scaring a lot of people, including me. I've long contended that The Exorcist is the scariest movie I've ever seen, still traumatized from just hearing Mercedes McCambridge's demonic voice from the living room. As I was in my bedroom, my parents were watching it in the other room on TV. Over the years, Josh, I'd seen parts of The Exorcist, but could never really force myself to sit down and watch it, because every time I saw poor Reagan McNeil's face, I got terrified.
11:37Adam Kempenaar: All I wanted to do was run upstairs and cuddle with my parents. I was so scared as a young kid.
11:41Josh Larsen: This was all based on overhearing it from the next room. Yeah, overhearing it.
11:44Adam Kempenaar: And then occasionally over the years, I would see it on TV. I'd be flipping channels and it would be on. Got it. And I'd see parts from it and it would absolutely terrify me. So when I finally sat down and watched it as an adult in its entirety, it still freaked me out. I was in my early 20s. I rewatched it in anticipation of that interview with Friedkin. And guess what? It still kind of scared me. So, Josh, on the third viewing, setting up this sacred cow discussion, I can report that it never really freaked me out. I never got this time that visceral kind of scare where you're kind of pulling up the covers around you or you're getting chills or you have to pause the movie.
12:20Adam Kempenaar: Now, mind you, I did watch this film laying next to my wife, so she was there to protect me. I wasn't down in the basement alone. It might have been a different experience, but I never had that kind of freak out moment watching it this third time that I had as a child or a really lame adult where you just respond to the voice, the eyes, everything about poor Reagan's face and her behavior. I'm curious, Josh, how much The Exorcist scared you when you saw it originally and whether it scared you this time. But more importantly, how much do you think being scared plays a role in your overall enjoyment of the film?
12:53Josh Larsen: Well, we had very different viewing experiences of this movie, actually. I don't remember the very first time I saw it in its entirety. I may, as a matter of fact, have not seen it in its entirety until the re-release, which I think was about 98 or so. I certainly remember seeing snippets of it. It had such a reputation, even if, you know, being born after it originally came out, you were still aware of it and it would be on TV, as you said. So certainly aware of it. I can't remember sitting down and engaging with it until I was actually an adult. And as a matter of fact, pretty much working as a critic as well.
13:27Josh Larsen: So that's how I first came upon it. And, you know, this question of did it scare me? In a sense, it's the most fair question to ask of a horror movie. And, you know, Friedkin can call it what he wants. He made it. But in my mind, it's a horror movie. it's at once the most fair question to ask of a horror movie and the most unfair question because it's so personal right the sort of things that's going to scare one person will not scare another that is no measure at all of the artfulness of a movie at least to that degree but on another level it's the most fair because scares that are just out to scare and that's why that's such an interesting question you posed to him, those can in many ways be easy.
14:10Josh Larsen: And if I have a problem with The Exorcist is that it ultimately strikes me as a cheap and easy film when it comes to those scares completely. And this was my initial impression of it when I saw it. And it was even furthered this second viewing that I recently gave it second full viewing, at least in that this is a film that seems completely disconnected from anything except for wanting to shock its audience. And so for Friedkin to say that he didn't even really set out to do that, that's a huge disconnect for me from the filmmaker's point of view and goals to what I experienced, at least as a viewer.
14:52Josh Larsen: And the moments here that everyone remembers, the reason it got those reactions, the reason it has the reputation, are its shock moments. And so the question for me when I watch a movie like this is what is the movie most excited about? Despite what Friedkin or any of the people involved in making it might say, what do I sense in my gut? Is it the shock moments themselves or is it the way the shock moments serve the larger story? And in a sense, this is the same question we often ask in regards to special effects or something like a soundtrack even. and we got into this a little bit on a recent show about movie themes, is are these elements simply there for the sake of themselves?
15:32Josh Larsen: And if they are, in my experience, they will often take me out of the narrative. And specifically getting to The Exorcist, I think that the moments with Regan, whether she's spewing vomit or stabbing herself or spinning her head around, those are very much at another visual and tonal volume level than anything else in the film, which I agree feels separate from a horror film, those other parts of the movie. These are also the least well-crafted moments, I would argue. They're not foreshadowed. They're jarringly staged and edited. And a very odd thing I noticed this second viewing, they're very abruptly abandoned.
16:09Josh Larsen: So we cut away from them to these expository or narrative moments on a couple of occasions. I think of the one where something awful is happening. And before that action even finishes in any way, we get this shot of the priest, Damian Karras, played by Jason Miller, jogging. Now, this happens repeatedly, so there's probably some intentionality behind it. Yeah, no doubt. But for me, it just set these moments so far apart from the film. And again, because of its reputation, it became the film's reason for being. And that doesn't give me much as a viewer.
16:39Adam Kempenaar: Yeah, we had completely different experiences with this film over the course of me now seeing it three different times. That's not at all how I see The Exorcist. I agree that those scenes are shocking and they are jarring, but I would say that I think you're right. It's quite by design. And I think ultimately what was most interesting to me this time, as I said, Josh, that it didn't really scare me. That's not entirely true. There were aspects of it that frightened me, but you know what they are? And I think this just speaks to how we evolve or how we get older and the things that frighten us.
17:10Adam Kempenaar: Again, it's no longer just seeing her scary face and her eyes and those kind of things. For me, the real terrifying part of The Exorcist now was watching the mother, was watching Ellen Burstyn as Chris McNeil, the actress, dealing with her daughter and going through this scenario where she has to basically sit there and be helpless as something takes hold of her child that she cannot find an answer to.
17:39Josh Larsen: We still think the temporal lobe. Oh, what are you talking about for Christ's sakes? Did you see her or not?
17:46Adam Kempenaar: she's acting like she's out of her mind psychotic like a split personality or and just think about how as a parent nothing could be more disturbing or troubling or scary than that that's what really stuck out to me this time that's what bothered me is watching that mom and that predicament as she tried to figure this out and was willing to do anything to try to figure
18:07Josh Larsen: out what was wrong with her daughter that was really effective okay and and i agree that is an interesting entry point for a film that certainly you would appreciate after you become a parent but But again, I think it's representative of what this movie is interested in. And it's in these sadistic elements. Because even take that character, for example. What is the scene we get of her that's going to communicate this feeling of distress that she has? Because I would argue that would be a way this movie. Well, think about the defining one, at least for me, when I watch it again. It's the surgery scene early on where the doctors subject Reg into a brain scan that involves having a needle injected into her neck.
18:45Josh Larsen: During surgery, this movie is so sadistic. It not only makes us watch that scene for no real purpose, but it makes us watch the mother watch that scene. So it's doubly sadistic, and it has this sensibility of being more interested in the blood spurting out of that needle and across the surgery sheets than it really is in Burstyn's reaction or response to that. We see her freak out from behind the window because, again, that cranks it up for us. But does this movie really explore Burson's character at all? I found on this viewing it didn't. Part of that is because Burson is so hysterical in this film.
19:23Josh Larsen: There are ranges, notes of hysteria she hits almost from the beginning. Because she's a really good actress, you mean? No. Well, she is. Notes of one emotion, which is, I think she is a very good actress. I mean, I'm not writing her entire career off here. But in this film, it is different notes of one emotion that just get increasingly heightened until, for me, it didn't engender any sympathy for me, for her.
19:47Adam Kempenaar: I think that there's no doubt if you're not on board with the film, which you clearly weren't, then you're going to see moments like that involving the trip to the doctor's office and think that Friedkin really is just trying to up the shock factor. But what is all the emphasis in that scene? What are we shown? I think it's all about her reaction. I think it's all about her reaction. And I think, Josh, it's all about the emphasis on the horror that this girl is experiencing and us having to watch it, too. And I think that one of the big strengths of this film, and I especially noticed it this time around, is that Friedkin, who got his start as a documentary filmmaker, I think there are a lot of elements to this film.
20:21Adam Kempenaar: This is where it really stands out from a lot of conventional horror movies. The reason it's so scary in a way, the reason it really starts hitting you, I think, in that last half of the film is that Friedkin takes such care in not setting up a lot of traditional frights in that first hour of the movie. It really isn't until about the hour, 10 minute mark of this film that the really gross stuff that The Exorcist is known for starts. He spends that first hour and 10 minutes setting up all these storylines and these characters. The way we meet Father Karras and his relationship with his mother, Chris and her job, Chris McNeil.
20:52Adam Kempenaar: Those are really good scenes between Karras and his mother. We even meet the lieutenant or the cop, the detective, Kinderman, and probably spend more time with him than we really need to. Just crafting these relationships. Father Marin. How about that amazing opening to this film where it all takes place in Iraq and it really sets this whole tone for the fact that this evil they're dealing with is something that has gone on since the beginning of time. I love that opening and a lesser filmmaker might have taken the studio's notes and cut that out as they wanted Friedkin to do but I just love the fact that a lot of this is shot very matter of factly.
21:25Adam Kempenaar: If you took out Josh that trip to the doctor if you took out those scenes from this movie didn't tell someone it was part of the exorcism and they'd never seen it before and just put it on a screen, I think you could very easily convince them that they were watching a documentary about what mental illness and trying to figure out what caused some of these problems, these unexplainable abnormalities, what that trip to the doctor would be like. This could be a document showing you that. That's what it feels like in those scenes. So I think the authenticity of that and getting that blood spurt and seeing that needle, that's crucial.
21:58Adam Kempenaar: Friedkin isn't someone who's just doing that to push buttons. He's doing it because it adds to the overall horror of this tale of this girl and what she's going through. Chicago talks a lot. Hold on. Let me step over here. People are talking too much. We debate about food, deep dish, tavern style. Who's got the best beef? We yell across rooms, across blocks, across generations. Yes, nice earrings, Grammy. And now we're doing it on our phones, too. Video calls from the L train, group chats that never shut up. Neighbors texting you the score before your TV catches up. Come on! Get a load of this guy.
22:33Adam Kempenaar: Ketchup. On a dog. Yeah, we've got thoughts. Too loud? In Chicago, you're gonna hear it. Because nothing here gets built without conversation. Nothing moves without connection. So, if you think you know AT &T, it might be time to rethink that. Because their network has improved, like, a lot. So Chicago can keep speaking its mind with AT &T Wireless and AT &T Fiber. Chicago won't stop talking. Our improved network backs it up. AT &T, connecting changes everything. AT &T Fiber, limited availability in select areas. Shortly before 6 o 'clock a.m. on November 13th, 1991, Annette's mother and her two young sons found her unresponsive inside their apartment.
23:16Adam Kempenaar: Investigators ruled the case a homicide. Over the years, detectives continued searching for answers, but the case eventually went cold. This is Hunter Gilmore, host of Hunting for Answers, a true crime podcast. Shedding light on the silent epidemic of missing and murdered Black women and girls, bringing attention to stories that equally deserve to be told and to the questions that still remain. As the years passed, detectives continued working the case. But more than three decades after Annette's death, no one has been held accountable. Annette's mother, Freda Scott, spent years hoping to see her daughter's case song.
23:51Adam Kempenaar: She never saw that day come. Annette Jones' case remains unsolved.
24:23Adam Kempenaar: The Black Effect's new original podcast series, Bloodline Crimes, hosted by me, Morgan Wood, explores the darkest and bizarre cases where family became the most dangerous threat of all. Because sometimes the person you should fear most is not a stranger, but rather someone sitting at the dinner table with you. Real cases. Real families. Real killers. This is Bloodline Crimes. Listen to the Black Effect's Bloodline Crimes every Thursday, starting October 8th, from the Black Effect Podcast Network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
25:08Adam Kempenaar: Malcolm Gladwell here. As a child growing up in rural Canada, I was always puzzled by America's peculiar problem with gun violence. The murder rate in the U.S. is nearly three times higher than Canada's and five times higher than the murder rate in the UK and much of Western Europe. Why? What's so different about the United States? In my new book, The American Way of Killing, The Invention of an Epidemic, I speak to the doctors who worked miracles on gunshot victims, reexamine the strangely important story of a 17th century English knight, and parse out the grammar of the Second Amendment with a linguist and travel to a shooting range in North Carolina, all in an attempt to understand where this problem came from and why Americans so often misdiagnose the nature of the violence that plagues their streets.
25:59Adam Kempenaar: But this book really isn't about guns.
26:02Josh Larsen: It's about why a country has never quite understood its own problem and why you can't fix what you refuse to see. Get The American Way of Killing at pushkin.fm slash audiobooks or at Audible, Spotify, or wherever audiobooks are sold. You look at that surgery scene. I mean, I didn't do this, but I bet if you go back and just give it screen time, how much screen time is emphasized on the physical gore and awfulness of what the girl is being subjected to and the screen time to Burstyn's reaction, which is why you originally brought it up as being a strong point of the film, I guarantee you very little time is spent on Burstyn Because, again, it's the shock things that this movie is most interested in.
26:49Josh Larsen: But let me get to a couple of things I did like, because I think you're right that the scenes with Miller as Father Karras and his mother, who is suffering from old age and the implication is mental illness herself. I think those are good. Those are really strong. And I generally do appreciate a horror film that builds in the way this movie does. It takes its time to set atmosphere. I actually think this could have used a little more of that so that wasn't so jarring when we do get to the big scenes, how those would work a little better with the opening part. I also think, and this is why those scenes don't work for me, because they are so haphazard in a way, because Friedkin has a lot of nice camera work in the other half of this movie, the more subdued half of this movie.
27:31Josh Larsen: Some great tracking shots, some good camera pans. I think of the one where there's a shot of the priest entering the church and we're up above. There's a blurry statue in the right foreground of the scene. And then he's kind of entering in the left background and he's in focus, comes down the aisle. There are just some nice touches in there. And here's where this movie is scary for me in a way that I'll give it credit for. And maybe scary isn't the right word. Maybe disturbing is the better word. Because I actually would not count The Exorcist as among one of the more scary horror films. not just because I don't like it in general, but just for the way it works.
28:06Josh Larsen: I do think that dream sequence that Father Karras has is one of the creepiest moments in the movie. It's very brief, and I actually had forgotten about it until I watched it again. His mom in the subway, right? His mom coming out of the subway station looking kind of confused, and he's yelling at her. And there are some quick shots in there, too, of a necklace, the fighting dogs, which we see in that opening you talked about. I think also later there's a very effective insert shot that does take place in the famous bedroom where Karis comes back into the room and he sees his mother sitting there on the bed.
28:37Josh Larsen: That's the sort of psychological stuff that is so much more effective in my mind than having the girl spew vomit again or something else outrageous like that, which seems like it comes from a different movie.
28:50Adam Kempenaar: The fact is that you may be right in saying those are the most famous aspects of The Exorcist, but that's not what I think of when I think of The Exorcist. I think of the moments you're talking about. I think of those more subdued moments. That's what really appeals to me.
29:02Josh Larsen: So there's only two of them, I guess, is my point. I'm holding these out as an example of what I—
29:07Adam Kempenaar: No, I think there's a ton of quiet, interesting moments like that that stand out that aren't just those— That are disturbing, too? Yeah, yeah. I think disturbing, too. I would go back even to—you want to talk about great shots? My favorite shot in the film, just a single moment of cinematography comes in that Iraq sequence where we see Father Marin as he discovers the Pazuzu statue. And that's where we see the dogs that are being hostile off in the distance as if the statue is sort of urging them on. But there's this amazing Friedkin shot where he kind of elides space and time a little bit. And we actually see Father Marin sort of on an equal plane with the Pazuzu statue and the suns between them.
29:42Adam Kempenaar: There's a nice shot. There's a lot of great shots like that. There's another great shot, you're talking about how careful he is with the camera, where Reagan is in another room as her mom is on the phone calling her father. And the way the camera tracks out of that room till eventually we're back with Reagan kind of hiding behind the door as her mom is making this really terrible phone call. And there, Ellen Burstyn's pretty hysterical and maybe didn't need to be quite so hysterical in that moment. But what really stuck out to me, especially this third time seeing it, Josh, is how big of a factor and how many times the word guilt comes up over and over again.
30:16Adam Kempenaar: And I think that has to do with some of the larger questions of faith that are being explored in the movie a little bit. But I also think it maybe just gets to what I ultimately do like about this film, Josh, in the way I talked about that sort of documentary style, the way I think he tampers down the horror by making it seem like you really are almost watching a movie where you're just in the kitchen with this family in Georgetown, seeing how they live. But then all these horrible things start to happen. You see how everything unravels. And so one of the ways it's grounded is in this notion of guilt.
30:49Adam Kempenaar: It makes it seem, Josh, almost as if even though this is supernatural, and we think that maybe this possession is just coming out of nowhere, Friedkin doesn't let us just chalk it up to that. There's a point, for example, where one of the doctors says to Chris, they've kind of given been up. They don't really have any more tests to run. They think maybe, you know what, something else is going on here. But he does say that this sort of split personality thing that he's trying to chalk this up to, he says it starts with a conflict or a guilt. And if you go back and watch the movie, and especially that scene I mentioned where the mom's on the phone talking to the father and we see Regan kind of hiding in the room as clearly her parents went through some kind of split.
31:30Adam Kempenaar: And we see them even at one point have a conversation about that. That clearly is sort of weighing on her mind, I think, is maybe what role that she had in that and her mom's happiness and her ultimate happiness. So that's there sort of just in the background. But then think about Father Karras, how much guilt plays a factor in his life with his relationship with his mom and how he feels as if he didn't properly take care of her. At one point when we meet him early on too, Josh, he of course points out that he feels like a fraud as a priest, that he thinks he lost his faith. He feels guilty about that.
32:01Adam Kempenaar: And later we even find out that Reagan's guilty of a crime. She may have had something to do with someone's death. So I could go on and on. Actually, there are a ton of examples of this. And I just think that what that does is it, again, sort of grounds this movie in the sense that, you know what, this didn't just come out of nowhere. This is kind of this bubbling up of resentment, this bubbling up of fear, of trauma, of guilt in people's lives. It eventually manifests itself in something horrific like this.
32:27Josh Larsen: I think Karis is a very fascinating character, actually. I don't think the movie cares a bit about Burstyn's character or Reagan at all. I just don't. I don't get that from it. But especially how Jason Miller plays him too, the undertone he brings to the performance, I think it's very good and I think there's a lot there. That said, the whole faith thing is a bit of a red herring to me because the movie just gives us dollops where it seems like it wants to put that out there so that we have something to kind of grasp onto and take this more seriously than a horror exploitation film that it really is.
33:04Josh Larsen: It gives us the line. Karis even says how he's, I think I've lost my faith. I mean, how on the nose can you get it? It's a little bit like To the Wonder, a weakness of that film where we have Javier Bardem's priest who's going through a similar thing and he keeps talking about it on the soundtrack. We don't need that. And we don't really need it here unless it was woven in a little bit more subtly. Instead, it's just kind of thrown out there as this is what the theme is going to be. And I feel like the film is a little bit the phrase Pauline Kael used for this is that it's a shallow seriousness.
33:36Josh Larsen: And I kind of get that sense to this picture is that it knows it's dealing with these religious elements. It uses iconography, rights, imagery for easy associations, but not really compelling implications to me. I cast you out, unclean spirit.
33:54Adam Kempenaar: Show her up your ass. In the name of our Lord Jesus Christ. It is he who commands you. He who flung you from the heights of heaven and the depths of hell. Be God. Be God. This creature of God. Be God. In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. by this sign of the Holy Cross of our Lord Jesus Christ, who lives and reigns with the Father and the Holy Spirit. Damien! I think it's very compelling, not just obviously as a movie that had that immediate kind of frightened response to it, but it is a movie that over the years, as I've seen it again and again, I see different elements in it.
34:46Adam Kempenaar: Whether or not they have to do with faith is kind of irrelevant, Josh. For me, I see things like the guilt that comes in. I see things like this time I noticed the whole aspect where I think the movie is largely dealing with, again, this notion of the unknown and trying to, as we take control of our lives, trying to be able to come up with a scientific explanation for everything. And then you're faced with something in modern life that can't be explained and how that then causes a conflict that can't be matched.
35:15Josh Larsen: You know what explores that in a really interesting way? A film from this year, Beyond the Hills, actually. Christian Munju film.
35:20Adam Kempenaar: Yeah, you're exactly right. It does. But I guess I saw some of those elements in this movie as well. For example, the Kinderman character, he says at one point something like, probable, not for certain. You know, there's that emphasis on things being probable, but it isn't necessarily the way it absolutely happened. And she even says, the Chris McNeil character to Father Akaris at one point, tell me for a fact that she isn't possessed. Tell me for a fact that that's my daughter up there and this is all just some made-up thing in her head. That idea is reinforced again and again. And obviously it's reinforced in those scenes with the medical professionals where they think they have some kind of obvious explanation and they really don't.
36:00Adam Kempenaar: So I think ultimately, Josh, even though I do see what you're saying, I could see how someone like Pauline Kael would say there's kind of a shallow seriousness to the film. But I guess when you try to take the whole film in, and you certainly see it in those scenes with the medical professionals as they're trying to come up with their diagnoses, and they think that there's some rational, sensible explanation and scientific explanation for everything that's going on. But I think that, again, just gets back, Josh, to this sense the movie has. Maybe it's not so much about religious faith in particular.
36:27Adam Kempenaar: I think it's a manifestation of faith where, of course, what faith is is believing in something even if you don't have any evidence to back it up. And what we see in this movie is sort of a flip side of that, where we have tons of evidence to back up that there's something really wrong with this girl, but you still can't explain it. There's still a lack of faith in what's actually happening to her as you seek some kind of explanation. So I feel like the movie as a whole is this larger kind of exploration of guilt in dealing with the conflict that happens when something in their lives in this modern age we live in where we think everything can be explained away when something clashes with that that can't be explained.
37:04Adam Kempenaar: I think that's fascinating. And I'm fascinated by that watching this film in addition to being kind of horrified by it.
37:09Josh Larsen: So let me ask you then, these threads that resonate with you, how do they work hand in hand or better yet, how are they enriched by the shock moments that the movie is famous for? Because I don't think you can just set those aside and say, well, that's not really what the movie is about. And I can understand if you found more interesting things in the film. Yet those are the dominant elements of this movie in terms of tone and just where they're positioned in the narrative. And this is a sacred cow. So in the enduring reputation. So I'm just wondering how those work for you in concert with these other things.
37:46Josh Larsen: Or are they separate in your mind?
37:47Adam Kempenaar: No, I think they work because, as I said, I think they reflect a larger sense of the true horror of what is happening to Reagan. it wouldn't be enough if it was just sort of ugly and sort of disturbing i think it really needs to be and actually we're going to get into this a little bit more when we talk about the chaser here in a minute and there is a connection i think between the two films a little bit i think we need to see those kind of truly shocking things to really understand the sort of depth of depravity that's happening to her but this also gets to the the conflict josh i think is interesting and i wonder how you kind of feel about this you may not be aware of it at all but there's been for a long time, I think they've now gotten over, but there was a conflict for a long time between Friedkin and William Peter Blatty, who of course wrote the book and wrote the screenplay.
38:31Adam Kempenaar: He was someone who was much more a man of faith and had a little bit of a crisis of faith, but went through this process and wrote the book and the screenplay and has now come out the other side of that. But he hated Friedkin because Friedkin, among other things, cut out a key scene that eventually played in the director's cut or an extended cut later, Friedkin finally decided, okay, you know what? This bothered Bill Blatty for so long. I'll go ahead and put this back in. And the scene, Josh, is a scene in the middle of the exorcism where what we get in the cut we both watch, the original theatrical cut, is just them taking a break.
39:07Adam Kempenaar: And they're on the stairs. And we see Max von Sydow as Father Marin and Father Karras. And they're sort of facing opposite ways. And they're just having this respite before they go back in to wrestle with this devil. In the cut Blatty really wanted, they have an exchange where pretty much Max von Sydow's character puts it right on the nose. He says, the girl is not the target of what the demon's trying to do. The girl is us, every one of us in this house. And the purpose is to make us feel vile, bestial, rotten, and corrupt so that even if there were a God, he could not possibly love us. That was a Blatty line that, as I said, he was really attached to because for him, that was the whole film.
39:46Adam Kempenaar: That's what the whole film was about. I like the lines too, but I love that Friedkin just thought, I've already shown that and I'm going to show that. I don't need to actually put that right on the nose. That vileness, that rottenness, that corruption, that comes through in those shocking moments. And I think we didn't need a character to underline that, how that challenges the people in that house, how it challenges the viewer to question your own faith. Do you believe that something like this could really happen? I think that Friedkin was actually smart to kind of take that back a little bit and cut that out because he shows us.
40:20Adam Kempenaar: And I think that's why those
40:20Josh Larsen: shocking scenes are important. Yeah, but there's a line between where the movie goes in those scenes. And I completely agree. You don't want that spelled out in a line of dialogue. I mean, that's going to do the opposite. You're not making a movie then, right? You're just delivering a speech. But to the degree of vileness or whatever you want to call it that we see on screen, sometimes that can become so dominant that it loses any other implications and it becomes solely, solely about what's being depicted. And metaphors, allusions, those sorts of things get blasted outside because the soul point becomes that awfulness in that exact moment.
41:09Adam Kempenaar: We remind you that access to the Film Spotting Archive is just one of the benefits of being a Film Spotting family member, along with bonus shows, a weekly newsletter, Discord access, and much more. To join, please visit filmspottingfamily.com. Thanks for listening, everyone. This conversation can serve no purpose anymore. Goodbye.
41:57Adam Kempenaar: Develop a trip itinerary with daily updates or create a prioritized schedule so you can spend less energy sorting out the details and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life. Get started at ChatGPT.com. Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on. Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan.
42:20Josh Larsen: The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE-certified master technicians. and if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today.
42:33Adam Kempenaar: Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Auto Parts.
For Halloween week, we're going deep into the Archive for Adam and Josh's 2013 Sacred Cow review of William Friedkin's The Exorcist.
Unlock the full archive, Filmspotting Discord, ad‑free + bonus episodes, and more when you join the Filmspotting Family.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.