Top 5 Movie Bands | Archive

10 Jun 2026 · 38 min · 20 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

FilmSpotting’s “Top 5 Movie Bands | Archive” episode: two hosts debate and rank fictional bands from movies (no biopics; bands/groups only, not solo acts). They also mention off-limits “Pantheon” bands (e.g., Cantina Band, Bigrin Dan and the Modal Nodes, Autobahn).

Guests (hosts)

Josh and another host (Ryan Seacrest appears only as an ad voice; no named guest interviewees in the episode). The discussion is between Josh and his co-host.

Key claims

The list prioritizes whether the band/music works on-screen, not just the movie’s plot. Stillwater (Almost Famous) is rejected because they dislike the band’s music.

Notable examples (top picks)

#1 Soggy Bottom Boys (Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?) #2 Mitch and Mickey (A Mighty Wind) #3 Sweet Sue and Her Society’s Syncopators (Some Like It Hot) and The Twilight Zones (Not Fade Away) #4 Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem (The Muppet Movie) and Brian Slade and Venus and Furs (Velvet Goldmine) #5 Reverend Cleophas James & church choir (Blues Brothers).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Discussing the Movie 'Frank'

0:00 to 0:21

Conversation about the movie that inspired the top five list.

“Apple Vacations, where your story starts.”

Discussing the Movie 'Frank'

1:33 to 2:01

Conversation about the movie that inspired the top five list.

“This summer, stock up on your favorite brands for both you and your home.”

Discussing the Movie 'Frank'

2:55 to 3:58

Conversation about the movie that inspired the top five list.

“And if I didn't have this in front of you, is there any world in which you remember the movie that inspired that top five, Josh?”

Top Five Movie Bands Criteria

3:58 to 4:40

Setting the parameters for selecting fictional movie bands.

“Now, during the flower people period, who was your drummer?”

Number Five: The Blues Brothers

4:40 to 5:54

Discussion about the Blues Brothers and their church choir.

“This top five is inspired by our review earlier in the show of the new film, Frank.”

Exploring Other Notable Bands

5:54 to 7:26

Discussion about notable bands that are excluded from the list.

“This is the scene where Jake, John Belushi, literally sees the light during a church service and he gets inspired to get the band back together.”

Nostalgic Pick: Eddie and the Cruisers

7:26 to 9:23

Personal story about a nostalgic band and its influence.

“And I know everybody here is just waiting for me to list Stillwater.”

Number Four: Dr. Teeth and The Electric Mayhem

9:23 to 14:00

Discussion of Dr. Teeth and their significance in pop culture.

“Talking about a movie, I believe, from 1983.”

Exploring The Muppet Movie's Musical Genius

14:00 to 17:41

Learn about the creativity and challenges of Henson's puppeteers in creating a believable band.

“and a Keith Moon-like drummer known as Animal, who usually had a giant chain wrapped around his neck.”

Fictional Bands in Velvet Goldmine

17:41 to 20:01

Discover how Velvet Goldmine captures the essence of 70s rock through its characters and music.

“I'm glad I caught you on my view screen.”
Show all 20 chapters

Comedy and Music in Some Like It Hot

20:01 to 25:44

Explore the comedic elements of Some Like It Hot and its portrayal of an all-female band.

“But he did, back in his college years, perform a lot, was in a band, had musical aspirations, and obviously they didn't amount to much.”

The Emotional Depth of A Mighty Wind

25:44 to 28:00

Understand the poignant balance of humor and sincerity in A Mighty Wind's portrayal of musical reunions.

“But not far behind for me is Christopher Guest's other musical mock documentary about a memorial concert that brings together a bunch of has-been folk acts.”

Emotional Depth in Christopher Guest Films

28:00 to 29:04

Explore the unexpected emotional reactions elicited by Christopher Guest's films.

“And the big reason why you nailed it, that Mitch and Mickey performance, the whole movie hinges on it.”

The Fabulous Stains: A Cult Classic

29:04 to 30:06

Discuss the cult film 'The Fabulous Stains' and its themes of feminism and identity.

“even beyond waiting for Guffman, which I felt a little bit.”

The Punk Band and Its Authenticity

30:06 to 33:18

Analyze the authenticity of the punk band in 'The Fabulous Stains' and its cultural impact.

“They have a very cynical take on the world.”

The Soggy Bottom Boys and Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?

33:18 to 36:39

Delve into the fictional band Soggy Bottom Boys and their impact in the film 'Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?'.

“Well, I'm prioritizing your picks here in order of what I should see.”

Hedwig and the Angry Inch: A Unique Performance

36:39 to 39:04

Examine the blend of humor and heartbreak in 'Hedwig and the Angry Inch'.

“They probably don't know what you're talking about at the supermarket.”

Honorable Mentions in Movie Bands

39:04 to 40:09

Discuss additional notable fictional bands that didn't make the top list.

“And it's my number one fictional movie band.”

Honorable Mentions in Movie Bands

42:00 to 42:32

Discuss additional notable fictional bands that didn't make the top list.

“anymore goodbye Apple Vacations, where your story starts.”

Honorable Mentions in Movie Bands

43:15 to 43:42

Discuss additional notable fictional bands that didn't make the top list.

“Now through June 23rd, shop for you save days and get great savings on all your favorite personal care essentials and earn four times points.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Adam Kempenaar:This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.

0:04Josh Larsen:Apple Vacations, where your story starts. The Splash into Savings event from Apple Vacations is here. Now through June 25th, save up to$150 on vacation packages, plus instant savings at select resorts in Mexico, the Caribbean, Central America, and top U.S. destinations. Use promo code JUNE26 for these limited-time offers. Start planning today at AppleVacations.com or contact your travel advisor. Apple Vacations, where your story starts.

0:36Josh Larsen:Zach, nice vacation spot, but without T-Mobile 5G home internet, it's scary here. Don't open it.

0:44Adam Kempenaar:Relax. I ordered T-Mobile 5G home internet with same-day delivery, powered by DoorDash. Nothing to be afraid of.

0:50Josh Larsen:We're saved. Get T-Mobile 5G home internet delivered the same day, powered by DoorDash. Just$35 a month with auto pay and a voice line. Plus taxes and fees. Same day delivery for most internet eligible customers. See if it's an option during checkout. And now another appliance triumph from our friends at Grand Appliance. With two dogs, every wash load came out covered in fur. I went into Grand Appliance looking for a fix. And they recommended the Maytag Top Load with Pet Pro Hair Removal System. They had it in stock and installed it days later. And you know what? It really works. Lint rollers are a thing of my past now.

1:27Josh Larsen:Great recommendations from the appliance experts. Shop GrandAppliance.com. GrandAppliance.com. Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Jewel Osco.

1:37Adam Kempenaar:This summer, stock up on your favorite brands for both you and your home. Now through June 23rd, get big deals on everyday essentials from Procter & Gamble. Shop in-store or online for savings on items like Swiffer Power Mop,

1:48Josh Larsen:Febreze Plug Warmer, Herbal Essence Shampoo, Old Spice 2-in-1, Crest Scope Toothpaste, Secret Deodorant Spray, and Head & Shoulder Shampoo. Get these deals before they're gone. Offer ends June 23rd. Restrictions apply. Offers may vary. Visit Jewelosco.com for more details. Film Spotting is presented by Regal Unlimited, the all-you-can-watch movie subscription pass that pays for itself in just two visits. See any standard 2D movie anytime with no blackout dates or restrictions. Sign up now on the Regal app or at the link in our description and use code FILMSPOT26 to receive 15 % off.

2:28Josh Larsen:What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today? You're not interested in art? No. Now look, we're going to do this thing. We're going to have a conversation.

2:37Adam Kempenaar:Hey, FilmSpotters, it's Wednesday. That means it is time to drop something from the archive. And we were inspired by John Carney's Power Ballad, the movie we will discuss on our Friday show. We are going all the way back to 2014 for our top five fictional movie bands. And if I didn't have this in front of you, is there any world in which you remember the movie that inspired that top five, Josh? I don't think I would have.

3:09Josh Larsen:I'm seeing it in the notes here. Yeah, it's Michael Fassbender in a papier-mâché head movie, Frank. Yeah, Frank. I would not have remembered that, but I remember Frank quite fondly. It's a good movie. A weird, weird little movie, but very good.

3:24Adam Kempenaar:Yeah. Didn't make my top five list, as I recall, which I certainly called. I think I may have even convinced you to call the Spinal Tap Memorial list. I know I dug way back into my youth for my number five. I've got a David Chase reference on here that is not The Sopranos. You'll have to find out what that is as we get into our list of the top five fictional movie bands going all the way back to August 2014.

3:58Josh Larsen:Now, during the flower people period, who was your drummer? Stumpy's replacement, Peter James Bond. He also died in mysterious circumstances. We were playing a festival, jazz blues festival. Where was that? Blues jazz, really. Blues jazz festival. misnamed. Was he in the Isle of Lucy? And it was tragic, really. He exploded on stage. Just like that.

4:23Adam Kempenaar:That's David and Nigel, of course, from Rob Reiner's classic comedy This Is Spinal Tap. And this top five, our top five movie bands, of course, is going to be the Spinal Tap memorial list. So, off limits, because it would just be my slam dunk number one, Josh. Who was your co-host when you reviewed Spinal Tap? It's a tragic story, Josh. Might have to save that one for bonus. This top five is inspired by our review earlier in the show of the new film, Frank. And there aren't a whole lot of rules here. We are talking about movie bands that are fictional. That is one restriction, so you're not going to have any biopics.

4:58Adam Kempenaar:And I also did focus on bands, as the title suggests, or groups, not just individual artists. So even though I really like DJ Terrence Howard's character in Hustle & Flow, not eligible for this list. he really is a solo performer. So movie bands, fictional bands, who's your number five?

5:15Josh Larsen:My number five, well, when this list came up, I immediately thought of the Blues Brothers, but I wasn't sure if they met the criteria. They debuted as sort of a fake band on Saturday Night Live and then became something of a real band alongside the movie in a way. So I decided it doesn't quite fit for me, but that was okay because actually my favorite band in the Blues Brothers isn't the Blues Brothers. It's the movie's church choir, headlined by that ringer of a pastor, James Brown. By the day of the Lord cometh as a thief in the night.

6:00Josh Larsen:This is the scene where Jake, John Belushi, literally sees the light during a church service and he gets inspired to get the band back together. It culminates after the church erupts and all the parishioners are dancing. It does culminate in this great group dance number. Even Jake and Elwood join in. They're all dancing down the aisles. The Blues Brothers features a ton of brilliant musical guests, in addition to James. You've got Ray Charles. You've got Aretha Franklin. Makes me think we've got to be getting our Aretha Franklin biopic any day now, don't we? Maybe. The way things have been going.

6:34Josh Larsen:But when I was a kid at least, and I would watch the Blues Brothers over and over on WGN, it was the Reverend Cleophas James and his church choir. They were my favorite band. That was my favorite musical sequence. So they're going to get my number five slot.

6:48Adam Kempenaar:I think it's an inspired choice. A couple other bands we should note that aren't going to be eligible for our list. Because of the Pantheon, the film spotting list of movies that are off limits because we feature them too much or they're just too good. No Cantina Band from Star Wars A New Hope.

7:03Josh Larsen:Which has a name. Yeah, they do. It was a frequently suggested band on Twitter.

7:08Adam Kempenaar:Bigrin Dan and the Modal Nodes. Did you know that was their name? No, I didn't either. And that was surely just made up by somebody, right? That's what fans call it. I don't know the history and the derivation of that name, but they're not eligible. It's in the Pantheon. Also, if you're a big fan of Autobahn from the Big Lebowski, not eligible. I saw that one too. And I know everybody here is just waiting for me to list Stillwater. Uh-huh. Almost famous. Everyone's just - That's not your number one? They're just waiting for me to get to that as my number one, find another reason to talk about that Cameron Crowe movie.

7:39Adam Kempenaar:But here's the thing, Josh. It was very crucial for me, very important, that as I considered my picks, I was really considering the bands and the music and not just the movies that they're in or the personalities of the band members. And I'm sorry, Stillwater, but I don't like the music at all. I don't think they're a good band. Wow. And I think that's appropriate. I think Cameron Crowe - No, it's kind of part of the point. Yeah, he made them appropriately average. Forgettable. They're a middling band. I also don't ever believe for a second that Russell, the guitar player played by Billy Crudup, is anywhere close to the musical genius that it suggested he is, because we certainly don't see it or hear it in the film.

8:16Adam Kempenaar:So Stillwater, not even an honorable mention for me. Wow. Except you just spent a good minute mentioning them.

8:22Josh Larsen:How dare you. That's all right. How dare you. I thought about that as well. You know, in my perfect world, it was going to be a band where they worked as a band and they worked for the movie overall for what the movie was trying to do. They did both of those things.

8:34Adam Kempenaar:So Stillwater might apply.

8:36Josh Larsen:I guess, except but no, because the music, like you had to like the music, too. So not not all of my picks fit that perfect criterion, but that's what I was going for.

8:45Adam Kempenaar:And we should also give a little bit of credit to a couple of websites that recently did similar lists that is all our friends over there shared their favorite fictional movie bands. Each one of the writers there did that. You're going to get some overlap on our list. And also IndieWire, the playlist over there, had 15 great fictional bands and movies. We'll link to those in our show notes if you're curious for more on this topic. There's some good stuff over at both those websites. My number five, a purely nostalgic pick. This movie was a critical and box office flop, though the soundtrack, released later, actually ended up being pretty successful.

9:16Adam Kempenaar:And it was the first movie soundtrack I ever owned, Josh. Eddie and the Cruisers. Wow.

9:30Adam Kempenaar:Talking about a movie, I believe, from 1983. And not only was it the first soundtrack I ever owned, but it did inspire the first band I was ever in. My friend Matt, whose mom babysat me, and my sister Melissa. And he had a couple brothers as well. We used to run around in the summertime doing whatever we wanted, and we loved this movie so much that we decided to start our own band. called Adam and the Cruisers. Oh, come on. And all we did was put on the soundtrack, and then I would basically go up and lip sync the words into a microphone. But Matt, who still is an amazing drummer, and the drummer in my band, and still my best friend, he would actually play the drums, because even at like age eight, he could actually play the drums.

10:10Adam Kempenaar:So he'd play the drums. I'd sit up there and strum a guitar that I didn't know how to play, and I'd lip sync the words to Eddie and the Cruisers. Please tell me there's super eight of that. There is no footage of it. And you know why? Because we only had one performance. it was you're talking like you guys toured the neighborhood no it was billy french's family reunion oh my goodness and i saw the crowd all of maybe 12 people assembled in billy's basement and i got stage fright and i called off the gig that was the i love it so adam and the cruisers didn't have much of a future unfortunately josh but this is a movie you've probably never even seen it you don't know what I'm talking about.

10:49Josh Larsen:I was just going to ask, is it a greater sin to have never seen Eddie and the Cruisers or Roadhouse? Well, it's a movie. What do I need to confess for first? Well, Roadhouse for sure. You need to see that. Yeah, that's a greater sin.

10:59Adam Kempenaar:Because I haven't seen Roadhouse in the last three weeks. You're probably shocked at that. Yeah, I am. Actually, I thought maybe that show would inspire you to finally seek it out. But this is a movie. Maybe this will help get you interested, Josh. It steals heavily or maybe lightly from Citizen Kane. Oh, really? It takes that whole conceit of the reporter going back to try to piece together the life of this enigmatic person. In this case, the lead singer, Eddie, played by Michael Perret. Ellen Barkin plays the journalist, and she goes and basically talks to all the band members, including one of the key members, Tom Beringer.

11:32Adam Kempenaar:And this was my introduction to Tom Beringer as an actor. He had been out in The Big Chill the same year in 83, but I, of course, didn't go see The Big Chill. But Eddie and the Cruisers was on HBO or one of those movie channels all the time. and the movie is about a band from the 60s so there's a lot of flashbacks takes place in new jersey and they're kind of a bruce springsteen meets deon and the belmonts sound and the eventual song that made the soundtrack such a hit and gave the movie a little bit of notoriety was called on the dark side

12:07Adam Kempenaar:surely you have actually heard this song if i played it for you josh and the real band playing the music was called John Cafferty and the Beaver Brown Band. Better name than Eddie and the Cruisers. A little bit better. There is a scene on a rooftop early in the film where Tom Beringer has just joined the band, finding his way, finding his voice. And he's playing, I think, if I'm remembering correctly, he's playing on the dark side very earnestly. And everybody's laughing at him and it's just awful. And Eddie sticks up for him and he sits down at the keyboard and he rocks it up and he shows him exactly how it's done.

12:40Adam Kempenaar:And he talks about the importance and the power of words and music, Josh, words and music. And I was such a sucker at age eight for that romanticizing of words and music that that movie I probably watched a hundred times. Oh, my goodness. Probably saw it a hundred times.

12:55Josh Larsen:Yikes. So there you go. You know, if Citizen Kane was missing anything, it was middling Jersey Rock. I mean, that would have really cemented it as the number one film of all time. A masterpiece. If it somehow had that. Sadly, sadly lacking. Oh, boy. All right. I can't say too much, though. My number four is going to be a nostalgic pick as well, though they still play. And I think they still hold up in current movies. It's Dr. Teeth and The Electric Mayhem. I'm picking them from the Muppet movie. Love it. They also made their TV debut like the Blues Brothers. They were in the 1975 pilot for The Muppet Show.

13:28Josh Larsen:But they really have been in most of the Muppet movies, have gotten a number or a scene or something. On the Vulture website, Alex Susskind wrote a tribute piece in March that detailed their greatest hits. He described them this way. The Mayhem consisted of five members, all loosely based on real-life musicians. Fittingly, Muppet creator Jim Henson voiced the Mayhem's lead singer, Dr. Teeth. The doctor's deep, gravelly tone and colorful vests were a nod to New Orleans legend Dr. John. The rest of the group included guitarist and Valley Girl slash Janis Joplin hybrid Janis, Yeah. Bassist and Beatle Freak Sergeant Floyd Pepper, Zoot, a saxophonist who looked like jazz musician Gatto Barbieri, and a Keith Moon-like drummer known as Animal, who usually had a giant chain wrapped around his neck.

14:11Josh Larsen:The band was occasionally joined by a yellow Afro trumpet player named Lips. The personal favorite in our house is Animal. Of course. We have a drummer. Our younger daughter, she went as Animal last Halloween, I think it was, maybe the Halloween before. She sat on a wagon with a mini drum kit and we pulled her down the street. Smart. It was pretty cool. I gotta say. Now among the movie musical numbers by Dr. Teeth and The Electric Mayhem is a clever one from 1979's The Muppet Movie called Can You Picture That?

14:45Watching them perform there and

14:51Josh Larsen:elsewhere, you realize that Henson's puppeteers, this is what was so wonderful about them, they always seemed determined to create a high degree of difficulty for themselves. They didn't just envision, here's a scene we could do with puppets. It was, let's make this really tough and see if we can pull it off. It's hard enough getting puppets to just stand there and interact. But with Dr. Teeth and the Electric Man, they have to pull off the complicated coordination of creating this convincing puppet band playing together. And you know what?

Read the full transcript

15:19Adam Kempenaar:They do it. They do indeed. My number four pick, probably not much in common with the Muppet band other than the colors. There are plenty of colors in this group and their costumes as well. We're going to move up from the 60s to the 70s and go across the pond. So different than my number five pick, Eddie and the Cruisers, but actually using the same conceit, the band is Brian Slade and Venus and Furs from the Todd Haynes movie, Velvet Gold Mine. And this movie too is based around a journalist writing a story about a character who's disappeared from public life, that character being Brian Slade, played by Jonathan Rhys-Myers.

15:56Adam Kempenaar:Christian Bale is the journalist in this case. And it is very clearly a fictional band, but based on real life, because there's no doubt that Brian Slade is meant to be a stand-in for David Bowie. His Maxwell Demon persona is very clearly a reference to Ziggy Stardust. The relationship he has with Iggy Pop is mirrored in the relationship he has with an American rocker in this film called Kurt Wilde, who's played by Ewan McGregor and really does nail the Iggy Pop physicality on stage. And the movie just gets this music so right. I mean, not only are they playing a lot of those songs that perfectly coincide with the time and these artists, but there are original songs produced as well.

16:39Adam Kempenaar:And it helps when the English musicians in this film who were playing this music featured in these bands are Radiohead's Tom York, Johnny Greenwood, David Gray, Roxy Music's Andy McKay. On the American side, the band Wild Rats, that's Kurt Wild's band. You've got members of the Stooges, Sonic Youth, the Minutemen, Mud Honey. So there's some real verisimilitudes certainly here in this movie with the music and how it's portrayed on screen. And I love Haynes's admiration for this music and also how it brings about this change in the Christian Bale character. As we flash back on his life, there's a great scene where he's playing the music of Brian Slade.

17:19Adam Kempenaar:He puts that album down, Maxwell Demon. You hear that song, the ballad of Maxwell Demon, and then as he has to sneak out of the house wearing the clothes that his parents want him to wear, and then he can take those off when he gets outside the door and be the character that he wants to be, be the persona he wants to be, who is someone a lot closer to Brian Slade. So I do love the music, especially in Velvet Goldmine. It's a movie I haven't seen in ages, and it's probably worth a revisit.

17:45Josh Larsen:One man, and neither does his world. I'm glad I caught you on my view screen. Sailor, you're the grand one. Both of your picks I have not seen. Really? Actually, though I feel much worse about having not seen Velvet Goldmine. Fair enough. Compared to Eddie and the Cruiser, sorry. Okay. My number three pick, I hadn't even known the name of the band until I started putting together this list. It's Sweet Sue and Her Society's Syncopators, the all-female band. Yeah, I can see the look on your face that you hadn't heard of it either. But this is the all-female band from Some Like It Hot. You got it.

18:22Josh Larsen:Now, I have to give credit for this one to Jeff Carpenter, a former English teacher of mine who suggested this on Facebook. Speaking of dead poets recently, here's another English teacher coming through. You're right. It is the Billy Wilder classic from 1959 with Tony Curtis and Jack Lemmon joining in drag this band. Mostly the band is a gag, a way to get Curtis and Lemon in those dresses. They play musicians who are on the run from the mob after having witnessed the St. Valentine's Day massacre. But there's this great scene of the band rehearsing Running Wild while on the train on the way to their next gig.

18:56Adam Kempenaar:Hey, Sheboygan, you too. What was your last job, playing square dances?

19:00Josh Larsen:No, funerals.

19:02Adam Kempenaar:Well, would you mind rejoining the living? Goose it up a little. We'll try.

19:07Josh Larsen:You really get some wonderful comedy in it because Curtis and Lemon, they're trying to fit in both as women and as musicians. And it kind of goes back and forth which one they're more inept at, depending on what's happening. And of course, the scene also offers Marilyn Monroe, whose sugar cane Kowalczyk closes out the song in her ukulele.

19:31Josh Larsen:So Sweet Sue and her syncopators, my number three pick from Some Like It Hot.

19:35Adam Kempenaar:Love it. I don't know how I'm going to top that with my number three, though. This is a film certainly far more underseen than some like it hot. It's not Fade Away, and the band is The Twilight Zones. This is a movie that just came out a couple of years ago around Christmas time. David Chase from The Sopranos, this is his feature film debut as a director, and his autobiographical, another movie like it in The Cruiser, set back in the 60s and in Jersey, Josh. So I should have just tried to construct a whole top five off of 60s New Jersey music movies, But he did, back in his college years, perform a lot, was in a band, had musical aspirations, and obviously they didn't amount to much.

20:10Adam Kempenaar:And that's similar with this band. The Twilight Zones don't make it very far, though they do put up a good fight. The title, Not Fade Away, I know it as a Buddy Holly song because I'm a big Buddy Holly fan, but it was repopularized by the Rolling Stones in 1964. And the Rolling Stones' influence on this movie is huge here. It has a big influence on the main character, Doug. His dad is played by James Gandolfini. Great performance, as expected from Gandolfini. And Doug gets into a band here for the same reason most guys do, which is girls, to try and impress girls. And it works for the most part.

20:42Adam Kempenaar:But one of the things I really appreciated about this film, which is a weird little movie, actually, is the way Chase combines together all these elements in this coming-of-age tale so that you get things that are momentous, like the sexual revolution, Vietnam, Martin Luther King's assassination, JFK's assassination, all mixed together with the Rolling Stones forming, with I Want to Hold Your Hand on Ed Sullivan, on Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club ban. These are all part of this cultural stew, and they all matter. They all have relevance. And actually, I was looking back at my notes. I made the observation that he's making a similar point, I think, to Richard Linklater in Boyhood, where it's really about how these seemingly significant occasions are really no different than the most mundane moments.

21:29Adam Kempenaar:And it opens with a great bit, Josh, where a young Keith Richards meets a young Mick Jagger on a train. And it's the moment where they realize they both have an interest in blues. And, well, that's the moment that made the Rolling Stones and changed popular culture, right? So it's this notion that just these little tiny experiences can have that big of an impact. And that's what the movie really explores. Matt Singer, in that Dissolve piece on fictional bands, picked the Twilight Zones as his favorite. and he said their aspirations greatly exceed their talent and their struggles to get discovered stand in for those of the thousands upon thousands of similar bands who never made it to the big time and whose stories are rarely told on screen.

22:07Adam Kempenaar:The other thing they have going for them is the fact that their music was written by Stephen Van Zandt who cared enough about Not Fade Away's authenticity to put stars John Magero and John Houston through a rock and roll boot camp so that they could credibly sing and play their own instruments on screen which makes Not Fade Away the rare fiction movie with the genuine flavor of a concert doc. Matt's right. They look like they're pulling it off, which, as I said earlier, is really important to me. And the moment where we see them play their song, the song they hope is going to make them stars, it's called The St.

22:36Adam Kempenaar:Valentine's Day Massacre.

22:41It's a really good song.

22:48Adam Kempenaar:It's not good enough to make them into the Rolling Stones, but it's good enough to keep them struggling along as a band that thinks they just might have a shot, which is the curse of having a song that's just that good.

23:01Josh Larsen:Apple Vacations, where your story starts. The Splash Into Savings event from Apple Vacations is here. Now through June 25th, save up to$150 on vacation packages, plus instant savings at select resorts in Mexico, the Caribbean, Central America, and top U.S. destinations. Use promo code JUNE26 for these limited-time offers. Start planning today at applevacations.com or contact your travel advisor. Apple Vacations, where your story starts. And now, another appliance triumph from our friends at Grand Appliance. I want to eat healthier, but get frustrated when produce spoils before I can eat it. So I went to Grand Appliance looking for a fridge that would help.

23:44Josh Larsen:They recommended a Frigidaire Gallery French door with crispers that block dry air and excess moisture to extend the life of fresh food. And wow, it really works. No more wasted food in my house. Expert appliance recommendations for the win. Shop GrandAppliance.com.

24:01Adam Kempenaar:Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Jewel Osco. This summer, stock up on your favorite brands for both you and your home. Now through June 23rd, get big deals on everyday essentials from Procter & Gamble. Shop in-store or online for savings on items like Swiffer Power Mop,

24:14Josh Larsen:Febreze Plug Warmer, Herbal Essence Shampoo, Old Spice 2-in-1, Crest Scope Toothpaste, Secret Deodorant Spray, and Head & Shoulder Shampoo. Get these deals before they're gone. Offer ends June 23rd. Restrictions apply. Offers may vary. Visit Jewelosco.com for more details. The following ad is sponsored by Pets Best Insurance Services. You knew right away. He's perfect. The one for you. Those puppy dog eyes. That cute little button nose. You don't even mind the drool. When you find your perfect match in a dog or cat, the love is unconditional. Your budget, on the other hand, has realistic limits.

24:49Josh Larsen:Help protect your heart and your wallet with Pet Insurance from Pets Best. With plans starting from less than a dollar a day, you can get up to 90 % cash back on eligible vet bills. Pets Best makes it easy to pick a plan that works for you and your bank account. Find the perfect match for your perfect match at PetsBest.com. Pet insurance products offered and administered by Pets Best Insurance Services, LLC, are underwritten by American Pet Insurance Company or Independence American Insurance Company. For terms and conditions, visit www.petsbest.com backslash policy. Products are underwritten by American Pet Insurance Company, Independence American Insurance Company, or MS Transverse Insurance Company and administered by Pets Best Insurance Services, LLC.

25:23Josh Larsen:$1 a day premium based on 2024 average new policyholder data for accident and illness plans pets age 0 to 10. Well, this might be the first top five we've done where I have not seen a single film of yours so far. My number two, I think I'm going to get you with that one too. Oh, boy. All right. We'll see. My number two is Mitch and Mickey from A Mighty Wind. This is Spinal Tap, is deserving of having this list named after it, yes. But not far behind for me is Christopher Guest's other musical mock documentary about a memorial concert that brings together a bunch of has-been folk acts. Among them is Mitch and Mickey, a once-married duo who later divorced, and they've been estranged for years.

26:00Josh Larsen:They're played by Eugene Levy and Catherine O 'Hara. Now, guest films, even the earlier ones, it's a little harder to sense in them, but even the earlier ones, I think, do have an affection for the characters. They're often spoofing. But I feel like Mitch and Mickey are among the most poignant of any of them. Without a doubt. They're still very funny, too, though. It's not that it's made this complete switch to another tone. They just get that balance really well. One of Mitch and Mickey's famous songs was A Kiss at the End of the Rainbow, at the end of which they would share a kiss. So a big part of the suspense for this reunion concert is how that will go.

26:35A Kiss at the End of the Rainbow was written by

26:50Josh Larsen:guest regular Michael McKean and his wife, Annette O'Toole, and it was nominated for a Best Original Song Oscar. So it really works, I think, on its own terms. There's some spoofing going on there, too, about that style of music. But similar to Inside Llewyn Davis, there's also a sincerity to it.

27:05Adam Kempenaar:Well, the songs that Inside Llewyn Davis is making fun of are the same songs that A Mighty Wind is making fun of.

27:11Josh Larsen:Yes, that's a good way to put it.

27:13Adam Kempenaar:In terms of kind of the early days of folk music.

27:14Josh Larsen:Yeah, and that earnestness. The ones that Llewyn Davis hates anyway. Right. The character. Right, that he would say are inauthentic. But you know what? It works for me. It is beautifully performed by Levy and O 'Hara, for sure. and they do manage that fine line between spoofery and sincerity that the entire film really I think

27:32Adam Kempenaar:has I'm shocked I always had you pegged as more of a new main street singers kind of guy they're pretty good too I guess I don't know you very well if you gotta pick Mitch and Mickey well you almost got me with this one but I watched a mighty wind for the first time last night oh you hadn't preparation for the list I'd never seen it even though I had seen all of guests other movies and of course being someone who's into music and who plays instruments I don't have a good explanation for why I never sought this one out. I had seen bits like the performance at the end, but I did kind of love it.

28:01Adam Kempenaar:It's really, really good. And the big reason why you nailed it, that Mitch and Mickey performance, the whole movie hinges on it. I mean, it's setting up from the very beginning. Is Mitch even going to play? And once he does, is he going to be the old Mitch? And are we going to get that kiss? And that moment has to work. And it really, really delivers. But there's some great stuff even after that where it really hit me harder. when we see them looking back on the night and they each have varying takes on what that kiss meant. Because they go separate ways. They do. And their takes on that really, really hit me, actually.

28:35Adam Kempenaar:And I'm not used to having any kind of genuine emotional reaction to a Christopher Guest movie. And I like his movies and I don't think they're as patronizing as a lot of people do when they write them off. I hated For Your Consideration. I don't feel that way about the other movies. But to watch a Christopher Guest movie that has that humor and sure is still mocking in really playful ways, but then have this undercurrent of emotion and just genuine sympathy and empathy for its characters, it really surprised me, actually.

29:01Josh Larsen:No, you're right. I think that level of motion is the next step that it takes, even beyond waiting for Guffman, which I felt a little bit. But here, yeah, it's full force.

29:11Adam Kempenaar:All right, Josh. Do you know a little film from 1982 called Ladies and Gentlemen, The Fabulous Stains? No. All right, I'm four for four. Wow. I'm going with The Fabulous Stains, but you can also throw in their sometimes opening act slash headlining act, The Looters, as well, because they're pretty fantastic. And this is a Lou Adler movie. He also produced The Rocky Horror Picture Show. And I had never even heard of this movie before hearing Laura Dern's interview on WTF with Marc Maron a few months ago. It was her fourth movie, but her first adult role. She's all of 14 or 15, if you can call that being an adult.

29:49Adam Kempenaar:And in the movie, she plays the cousin of Diane Lane, who's the main character of the movie. She's a character named Corinne Burns, and she is the lead singer in The Stains. Her sister plays guitar. Her cousin, played by Laura Dern, as I mentioned, is the bass player. And they're a punk band. Their mother has died of cancer. They have nothing. They have a very cynical take on the world. And they happen to get a chance to go out on the road with this touring band, even though they basically only know one song. This really is a cult movie that deserves to be more widely seen. It's a satire of the music business and the media, with Lane really slyly manipulating television to her advantage to get promotion until it does turn against her.

30:29Adam Kempenaar:It's a movie about the dangers of conformity, and it's also, Josh, a movie very much about feminism and the struggle to assert your identity in a male-dominated world. Corinne's got this mantra that is, I don't put out. We're the stains and we don't put out. There's an obvious sexual connotation to that, but they're also expressing this idea that they're not going to be taken advantage of. They're not going to be what you want them to be and fit into your tidy notions of womanhood. Their best song, and they really only have one other song, is a song they steal from the looters. They perform it at a mall and it's called Join the Professionals.

31:01Adam Kempenaar:And this is a song written obviously from a male perspective. It references the army. You get lines like, yeah, I want to see the world for free, but I won't like the things I see up to, three, four really ain't my style.

31:21Adam Kempenaar:It takes on a completely different meaning when sung from a female perspective. And that scene in a mall where they perform it is really good stuff. I mentioned Lou Adler produced the Rocky Horror Picture Show. And this movie does have that borderline camp feel to it at times. It's silly. It's cheaply made for sure. But as I said, I think it's really smart in the way it tackles some legitimate issues. and there's a real knockout scene with a very young Christine Lottie as Laura Dern's mother, the aunt to Diane Lane. And she goes on TV and the media says, was your daughter always as much of a troublemaker?

31:53Adam Kempenaar:And her reaction is to say, well, yeah, she was. She's always been a nightmare. And then she catches herself and she delivers this really genuinely touching soliloquy where she reflects on the fact that her parents treated her the same way she treated her daughter and how proud she is actually to see those girls up on stage. It's a great scene. And Diane Lane, man, is so good here. One of her early performances, this perfect mixture of hurt, scared little kid and too smart for her own age rebelliousness. I've said too much, but I do have to mention the Looters, that band, the punk band, the Sex Pistols inspired band that she goes on the road with.

32:31Adam Kempenaar:Ray Winstone. Did you know, Josh, that there was a time where he was a young man? i just thought he arrived fully i know me too right like the sexy beast ray winstone is the only ray winstone that's ever been in existence no he was really young once and pretty gorgeous too and he's billy the lead singer of this punk band he's a charismatic presence i'm not sure if he's really doing the singing or not but he certainly has the sneer and the fierce conviction of a punk band and the band of course sounds like the real deal and not a fake movie band because their drummer and guitarist are steve jones and paul cook from the sex pistols their bass player is Paul Simon in from The Clash.

33:06Adam Kempenaar:And that song I mentioned, Join the Professionals, was actually a song those guys wrote in one of their post-Sex Pistols groups. So very authentic playing here and a really smart cult movie that, as I said, I hope more people see.

33:18Josh Larsen:Well, I'm prioritizing your picks here in order of what I should see. So Velvet Goldmine is the first one. And then, ladies and gentlemen, The Fabulous Stains, not fade away after that. I don't know if I'll ever have time for any of the cruisers. I'm going to work on you.

33:33Adam Kempenaar:I'm going to get on the dark side on your iPod.

33:35Josh Larsen:That's after Roadhouse. Fair. All right, number one. It's the Soggy Bottom Boys from Oh Brother, Where Art Thou? In constant sorrow through his days We talked about how these have to be fictional bands, and the Soggy Bottom Boys are fake in two senses. They only exist in the movie, of course, and they aren't even really a band in the movie. Instead, in the Coen Brothers' 2000 farce, which is set in the American South of the 1930s, this is one of the covers that is used by the movie's three escaped convicts, George Clooney, John Turturro, and Tim Blake Nelson, while they're on the run. Now, although they're a fake band, they run into a radio station to perform a song to earn some money, they do manage to record a real hit, Man of Constant Sorrow, which became something of a real-world hit of its own for the best-selling O 'Brother soundtrack.

34:30Josh Larsen:I do love this whole soundtrack, probably because a lot of these blues gospel songs are familiar from my childhood. You are my sunshine, I'll fly away. Now, full credit should be given, of course, to the people behind the music. You said you want to be able to believe that the actors are singing this. I don't think anyone believes George Clovey when he belts out Man of Constant Sorrow. T-Bone Burnett was the producer, and on Man of Constant Sorrow, the voices belonged to Dan Tominsky, Harley Allen, and Pat Enright. Right. In one sense, Oh Brother, Where Art Thou is one of the flimsiest Coen Brothers films.

35:04Josh Larsen:At least, let's say it's one of the most pastichiest. I mean, it's inspired by a lot of bits they're throwing into the mix here. But often I think in their movies, the meat of the matter is in what's going on in the corners or in the details. So in a way, you could argue that this collection of songs which are about suffering and perseverance, about doubt and belief, that's probably what Oh Brother Where Art Thou is really about. So Soggy Bottom Boys, my number one movie band.

35:33Adam Kempenaar:And that song became kind of a hit for a while, didn't I? Oh, yeah. It was everywhere. And I've lamented before, unfortunately, that that's one of the few Cone Brothers movies. I like their work so much. I don't get to rewatch a lot of movies, but I've seen most of their stuff more than once. That's one I've only seen once when it came out in the theater, didn't write about it, didn't talk about it. And when people write in and say, how did you leave it off this top five list and that top five list? I always regret that I haven't seen it again because people love it most of our listeners who write in love it

35:59Josh Larsen:I've probably only seen it once and would like to revisit it as well you know in their filmography I don't rank it as high as a lot of their stuff but I still do appreciate quite a bit and the music is probably the main reason my number one

36:14Adam Kempenaar:I know you have seen Josh I've got three words for you yeah Origin of Love oh that's a good song I've got five more words for you Hedwig and the Angry Inch I mention Original Love because that song is so good in this 2001 film from director and star John Cameron Mitchell, but there may be nothing better actually than the opening credit sequence, the spectacle of Hedwig performing Tear Me Down at a Bilge Waters in Kansas City, while old people immediately scatter for the door.

36:43Josh Larsen:Don't you know me, Kansas City? I'm the new Berlin Wall. Try and tear me down. I was born on the other side.

36:52Adam Kempenaar:I love that opening. And for those of you who are familiar with Hedwig, this is a character who has a botched sex change and starts a band and is a transgender figure, obviously, and develops a relationship with a younger man, Tommy, played by Michael Pitt, who ends up stealing her songs and running off and becoming a big star. The one problem was seeing Hedwig, and I hadn't seen it since 2001, but I was re-watching clips to get ready for this list, And the bad part is then you end up going to, say, the gym or you go to the supermarket and you find yourself out loud singing things like six inches forward, five inches back.

37:29Adam Kempenaar:I got an angry inch. People look at you funny, Josh. Yeah, they do. They probably don't know what you're talking about at the supermarket. No. And because I haven't seen in so long and I know you just caught up with it, I'm actually a little bit more curious to get your reaction than for me to babble about it.

37:43Josh Larsen:No, it was brilliant. And the music is a big part of that. And the Bilgewater scenes, I mean, it's sort of like a Denny's, right? It's this middle brow restaurant, or maybe it's the equivalent of Pizza Ranch. I can picture Hedwig playing at a lot of Iowa Pizza Ranches. But you're right, the reaction of her performance and the disparity between that and the intensity and the commitment to what it is and the people in the audience, the so-called audience, is just so great. But I think Mitchell's performance in those scenes, it's at once wanting to be so entertaining for those people and wanting this to be such a good time with the costumes and the wigs and the music itself and the calisthenics of the act.

38:30Josh Larsen:Yet what he's singing about is just some wrecking stuff, you know, that that that she's gone through in her transformation, in her life. Yeah. When you do pay attention to those lyrics. And there's just a really bittersweet dichotomy between the performance and the subject matter that that does carry through in the whole film.

38:50Adam Kempenaar:Yeah, you nailed it. It's the John Cameron Mitchell performance. It's the music, the intensity, and the emotion of it, and the subtext, and the text of it. The humor and the heartbreak mixed in those songs really is something that makes Hedwig and the Angry Inch special. And it's my number one fictional movie band. And those are our top five fictional movie bands. Josh, what about any honorable mentions?

39:10Josh Larsen:Hedwig is probably my number six. You encouraged me to watch it, so I knew it was going to be on your list. They have the best band name for sure, I think, of any of these that we've talked about. Also in real competition for this list was Sex Bob-omb from Scott Pilgrim and The World.

39:25Adam Kempenaar:Yes, it is a great name. Though not as good even as The Clash at Demonhead, also in Scott Pilgrim.

39:30Josh Larsen:That's true. That's an even better one. Yeah. Another one that couldn't make my list because really I'd be mentioning Back to the Future pretty much for any top five list I would like to, but Marvin Berry and the Starlighters. And then the John Glenn Singers. I thought an inside Llewyn Davis group might make your list, though I know you like Llewyn Davis best. That's the problem. I mean, he's the artistically true one that you want to align with. But the John Glenn singers, that novelty trio behind Please Mr. Kennedy, it's Oscar Isaac, Justin Timberlake, and Adam Driver, I gave them some consideration too.

40:01Adam Kempenaar:Yeah, I could see that. That's a great choice. I also considered the Blues Brothers, Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem from the Muppets, and Sex Bob-omb. But Mitch and Mickey came really close to making my list from A Mighty Win. Others that neither of us have mentioned, but were definitely in contention. The Ruttles, the Eric Idle band, the Beatles ripoff. It's a funny show. See, why didn't you pick that?

40:21Josh Larsen:And then I would have been -

40:22Adam Kempenaar:Five for five.

40:22Josh Larsen:Five for five. I should have gone with the Ruttles. Maybe it's just been too long.

40:25Adam Kempenaar:There was a show a while back where I made a reference to Chase Stadium, the stadium built after the famous revolutionary Chase Stadium, which is a line from the Ruttles. And Josh, not one person on Twitter or email wrote in to tell me I was a hero. It just died. It just died.

40:42Josh Larsen:Well, can the Ruttles, I mean, does it sustain itself? My suspicion with that movie is, does this joke really sustain itself?

40:50Adam Kempenaar:I was going through a real Beatles phase at the time. I don't know what to call the band. They eventually became the swell season, but in the movie once, they were just guy and girl, Markita Erglova and Glenn Hansard. That was hard to leave off the following slowly sequence. The Broken Circle breakdown, the Belgian film that we recently talked about. Whatever that music is they're playing, this mixture of American, Americana, it's bluegrass. It's really good. I enjoyed the music in that film quite a bit. And the Alan Parker movie, The Commitments. I love the music in The Commitments as well. Who are your influences?

41:23Adam Kempenaar:Led Zeppelin. Shanae O 'Connor. Wings. Well, what kind of music are we going to be playing, Jimmy? Soul. Soul. An eclectic list. I know I did at least a little bit of preparation. saw a movie I hadn't seen before for that list and that group ended up making the fabulous stains ended up making my list I love it when homework pays off as I know you do Josh access to the film spotting archive is just one of the benefits of joining the film spotting family you can learn more at film spotting family dot com thanks for listening

41:57Josh Larsen:this conversation can serve no purpose anymore goodbye

42:15Josh Larsen:Apple Vacations, where your story starts. The Splash into Savings event from Apple Vacations is here. Now through June 25th, save up to$150 on vacation packages, plus instant savings at select resorts in Mexico, the Caribbean, Central America, and top U.S. destinations. Use promo code JUNE26 for these limited-time offers. Start planning today at applevacations.com or contact your travel advisor. Apple Vacations, where your story starts. And now, another appliance triumph from our friends at Grand Appliance. With two dogs, every wash load came out covered in fur. I went into Grand Appliance looking for a fix, and they recommended the Maytag Top Load with Pet Pro Hair Removal System.

43:00Josh Larsen:They had it in stock and installed it days later. And you know what? It really works. Lint rollers are a thing of my past now. Great recommendations from the appliance experts. Shop GrandAppliance.com. GrandAppliance.com.

43:14Adam Kempenaar:Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Jewel Osco. Now through June 23rd, shop for you save days and get great savings on all your favorite personal care essentials and earn four times points. Shop in-store or online and save on items like head and shoulder shampoo, Pantene shampoo, Trace-A-Mai conditioner, L 'Oreal hair dye, Trace-A-Mai hairspray, and Aussie Miracle Curls.

43:35Josh Larsen:and earn four times points to use for future savings on groceries or gas. Offer ends June 23rd. Restrictions apply. Offers may vary. Visit JewelOSCO.com for more details. Honestly. Honestly. Honestly, no one wants to think about HIV, but there are things that everyone can do to help prevent it. Things like PrEP. PrEP stands for pre-exposure prophylaxis, and it means routinely taking prescription medicine before you're exposed to HIV to help reduce your chances of getting it. PrEP can be about 99 % effective when taken as prescribed. It doesn't protect against other STIs, though, so be sure to use condoms and other healthy sex practices.

44:08Josh Larsen:Ask a health care provider about all your prevention options and visit findoutaboutprep.com to learn more. Sponsored by Gilead.

From the publisher

From heavy metal volume knobs cranked up to eleven, to the sweet, soulful harmonies of a dynamic rhythm and blues revival, Adam and Josh count down their Top 5 (Fictional) Movie Bands.

Unlock the full archive, Filmspotting Discord, ad‑free + bonus episodes, and more when you ⁠join the Filmspotting Family⁠.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Filmspotting

All 198 episodes
Top 5 Movie BandsFilmspotting · 38 min
Listen in VO