1. Podcasts
  2. Filmspotting
  3. Top 5 of 1991
Filmspotting

14 Oct 2026 · 28m · 11 chapters

Episode artwork

Top 5 of 1991 | Archive

In short

Film Spotting’s “Top 5 of 1991” archive/year-by-year countdown (from May 2014), debating art vs downloads and revisiting standout 1991 films; includes a brief mention of “Movie Manimals” (Tusk) as an alternate archive Halloween/horror tie-in.

Guests/hosts

Josh Larson and Adam Kempinar (co-hosts). No other guests appear in this episode’s main discussion; it references Michael Phillips and producer Sam only as prior contributors to other archive segments.

Key claims

1991 was a “rich” year with major dramas and landmark genre films; Terminator 2 and Silence of the Lambs hold up due to visual/tonal choices; The Fisher King is Gilliam’s “grand slam” balancing fantasy with grounded reality; Barton Fink’s overt symbolism is challenging but rewarding.

Notable examples

Boys in the Hood (Cuba Gooding Jr., John Singleton); Terminator 2; Beauty and the Beast (Belle’s independence); The Silence of the Lambs (Hannibal Lecter, Clarice POV); The Fisher King (Jeff Bridges, Robin Williams); Delicatessen; My Own Private Idaho; Barton Fink (John Turturro, Coens).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Reflecting on 1991's Films

Discussion about the significance of 1991 in film and the top five list.

“And I mean, the ones that you have that I don't, and I think this is probably rare.”
3:21

The Countdown Begins

Kickoff of their countdown of top films from 1991, starting with personal reflections.

“Not an anniversary, so we must have had another very good reason to tie it into that year.”
5:03

Boys in the Hood Discussion

In-depth analysis of 'Boys in the Hood' as a significant film from 1991.

“But because of our Sacred Cow discussion of My Own Private Idaho from 1991, we thought it was only appropriate that we'd share our five favorite films from that year.”
6:50

Terminator 2 and Its Impact

Discussion on 'Terminator 2: Judgment Day' and its legacy in action cinema.

“Boys really made this a matter of the heart and head, I think.”
10:46

Beauty and the Beast Analysis

Exploration of 'Beauty and the Beast' as a defining animated film of 1991.

“And for reasons I'll get into a little later in my list.”
12:42

The Silence of the Lambs and Its Terror

Examining 'The Silence of the Lambs' and the character of Hannibal Lecter.

“Probably my number 16 or 17 movie of 91.”
14:00

The Terrifying Impact of Hannibal Lecter

Explore how Hannibal Lecter is portrayed as a uniquely terrifying character.

“For me, that is more terrifying than Schwarzenegger or Robert Patrick in the Terminator films.”
15:40

Rebellious Teens and Movie Choices

Hear a personal story about the rebellious act of watching Silence of the Lambs.

“So Debbie and I are going on a date to see Silence of the Lambs, right?”
17:48

Terminator 2: A Landmark Film

Delve into the qualities that make Terminator 2 an action movie landmark.

“Even Captain America, the Winter Soldier, which I liked quite a bit, in the end gives into one of these deadening climaxes of endless fights and huge explosions.”
22:58

The Fisher King: A Redemption Tale

Discuss the themes of redemption in The Fisher King and its unique storytelling.

“He's sort of like one of these all or nothing major league hitters in a lot of ways.”
Show all 11 chapters
24:26

Art vs. Entertainment in Barton Fink

Analyze the themes of artistic ambition and existential struggles in Barton Fink.

“about art versus entertainment, how about the struggle at the core of this movie, the playwright turned screenwriter John Turturro in the Coen Brothers film, Barton Fink.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Filmspotting, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Adam Kempenaar: This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.

0:08Josh Larsen: What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today? You're not interested in art? No. Now look, we're going to do this thing. We're going to have a conversation.

0:17Adam Kempenaar: Hey, film spotters, archive drop time. Josh, we're going back. Can it really be? 35 years to 1991 now before we take a brief look at our list and set them up a little bit I do have to give you some bad news what you don't know is that producer Sam gave me the option of this or another potential top 5 from the archive that he was tying into Halloween and horror and that was top 5 movie animals you're never going to allow that that that i feel like that was if you were ever going to loosen up

1:00Josh Larsen: the grip a little bit uh-huh it was it was starting you were you were starting to have like a more relaxed life and then michael phillips and i without your approval had too much fun five top five movie animals and it was just the clamps came down went off the rails yeah never again

1:21Adam Kempenaar: now in fairness in fairness and i could be wrong i i could be wrong you tell me with a clear head josh be yeah be unbiased do you think top five movie animals would get more downloads than the

1:37Josh Larsen: top five movies of 1991 well it's not all about the downloads sometimes it's about the art uh-huh okay and you make those choices you do yeah chosen we've chosen commerce over art yeah

1:53Adam Kempenaar: i did archive i definitely did apparently so all right that's fine okay top five films of 1991 we will not belabor this too much but i'm looking over our list here really quickly looks like a pretty darn good year so good in fact that we have a bunch of films and only one no two crossover between us. Okay. I'll take that.

2:17Josh Larsen: Great year. And I mean, the ones that you have that I don't, and I think this is probably rare. I would happily have all of those on my list and feel like it was respectable and movies that I really love. So yeah, 91, man, what a year.

2:36Adam Kempenaar: Yeah. Well, we hope you enjoy this look back at our top five films of 91. Remember that access to the Film Spotting Archive and top fives like this. And yes, Movie Manimals. Josh, get it ready. When we come out of this, we'll have it ready. What show number is Movie Manimals so they can look it up easily?

2:55Josh Larsen: You think I know that off the top of my head?

2:58Adam Kempenaar: Well, that's what Google is for, Josh. All right. We'll make it easier on them.

3:02Josh Larsen: You know, Adam, the number of shows that have done Movie Manimals, it's going to be endless. Oh, I know. It won't be the first result. How am I going to find our show?

3:12Adam Kempenaar: Mm-hmm. Access to the Film Spotting Archive is just one of the benefits of joining the Film Spotting Family. Learn more at filmspottingfamily.com. This list is from May 2014. Not an anniversary, so we must have had another very good reason to tie it into that year. One of our annual year-by-year lists at that point. Enjoy. You see, it's basic dog psychology.

3:36Josh Larsen: If you scare them and get them peeing down their leg, they submit.

3:41Adam Kempenaar: Yet if you project weakness, you draw aggression. That's how people get hurt.

3:46Josh Larsen: You see, fear causes hesitation. And hesitation will cause your worst fears to come true. So it's simple. You project strength to avoid conflict.

3:59Adam Kempenaar: Peace through superior firepower. You're listening to this very special Keanu Reeves-infused edition of Film Spotting with Josh Larson. I'm Adam Kempinar. Patrick Swayze there as Bodie in Catherine Bigelow's Point Break. My number one film of 1991. Actually not. My number five, probably. If it was really 1991, but it's not. I am an FBI agent. I know you are, Josh. I know you are. One of the memorable lines, among many, from that film, Point Break. And truly, if we were reflecting back on these films as we saw them, I was 15 years old in 1991. You were 16, 17. Yeah, probably 16. So, you know, we probably didn't have the refined taste, Josh, that we have now.

4:42Adam Kempenaar: But Point Break would have been in my top five. Not going to make my top five now as we get back to our year-by-year countdowns. We started at 2004, the year before film spotting began. We've been counting back. We'd actually stopped at 93. Yeah, I had people quite concerned about this. Sure, that we skipped 92. That we skipped 92. Just pretended it didn't happen. We'll get back to that at some point. But because of our Sacred Cow discussion of My Own Private Idaho from 1991, we thought it was only appropriate that we'd share our five favorite films from that year. Josh, what is your number five?

5:12Josh Larsen: Well, it was a really rich year, first of all. I mean, looking back at this, and I must have seen an awful lot of movies in 1991 for whatever reason, because only a handful of the significant titles in My Own Private Idaho was one of them are movies I hadn't seen before. So that was good. I felt like I'd done a decent amount of homework as far as that goes. My number five is Boys in the Hood, which I did see in 91. It was this out-of-nowhere blast from writer-director John Singleton. Singleton, he came directly out of a USC film program to write and direct this drama, which is about a promising African-American teen, played by Cuba Gooding Jr., who's trying to balance family, friendships, schooling, and just plain old adolescence, really, in this gang-infested neighborhood of South Central Los Angeles.

5:56Josh Larsen: Boys in the Hood had a huge impact on the film scene when it came out. I mean, Singleton was nominated for Best Director by the Oscars, which made him the youngest ever and the first African-American for that honor. It was also selected for the 1991 Cannes Film Festival and took in$60 million that year, which is huge for this type of movie at that time. Now, 91 actually saw three significant dramas from African-American directors. We had Singleton's Boys, there was New Jack City from Mario Van Peebles, and then Straight Out of Brooklyn from Maddie Rich, another low-budget effort. And these led to a wave of hood films in the 90s.

6:32Josh Larsen: You had Menace to Society. We got Juice, Fresh, Friday are a couple of those. What I think made Boys in the Hood distinctive was maybe the thoughtfulness that it brought to this story of trying to survive as a kid in a place where crime has become so integrated into the community. Boys really made this a matter of the heart and head, I think. as much as it was a matter of performing the right action or taking the right action to get out of these situations or to resolve these things. So really heady film, my number five film for 1991.

7:06Adam Kempenaar: Why don't y 'all take a look at that sign up there? See what it says? Cash for your home? You know what that is? It's a billboard.

7:16Josh Larsen: What are y 'all, Amos and Andy? Are you stepping and he's fetching? I'm talking about the message, what it stands for. It's called gentrification. It's what happens when the property value of a certain area is brought down.

7:30Adam Kempenaar: Huh? You listening? Yeah. They bring the property value down. They can buy the land at a lower price. Then they move all the people out, raise the property value, and sell it at a profit. Now what we need to do is we need to keep everything in our neighborhood, everything black. It's an honorable mention for me. It is a really good film. My number three of 1991, if it was 1991. You really put this together.

7:53Josh Larsen: Oh, I gave some thought to it.

7:55Adam Kempenaar: As it is now, Josh, just an honorable mention. But it's always true of these lists to an extent that you're counting down the top five films of a given year as you remember them, not necessarily the same thing as just an overall top five. If we were going to do this right, we would both spend about three weeks picking from our top 10 or 12 initial films from this list. And we'd rewatch all of them and reevaluate all of them. For sure. That just can't happen here as we're doing a weekly show. It especially becomes true, though, the further back we go in time because they aren't as fresh in our memories necessarily.

8:29Adam Kempenaar: Nor were they movies that either of us probably reviewed unless we've had a reason to revisit them. As we said, we were teenagers in 1991. so I wasn't writing reviews anyway for my student newspaper in high school at the time. I wasn't really thinking critically about these films. It's hard to go back and I haven't seen a lot of these 91 films that stood out to me that were on my short list recently. So it was a tough list to put together. I always consider for these year-by-year countdowns the five films I can't live without that have to be salvaged for all time, though I'm going to immediately render that criterion completely worthless because Irene Jacob from The Double Life of Veronique, sorry, gone, been discarded for eternity in favor of Edward Furlong.

9:12Adam Kempenaar: You're not here to kill me. I figured that part out for myself. So what's the deal? My mission is to protect you. My number five, Terminator 2. Understandable. Judgment Day. I was 15 that summer when it came out. I remember going to see that movie with a couple friends, seeing it on the big screen, and just being so charged up by that movie. as we walked out. And I've caught up with just parts of it over the years. I've never sat down and watched the movie from start to finish, probably since that summer of 91, unfortunately. But it does always seem to hold up. And it's made many top five lists over the years, so I really don't have a whole lot more to say about it.

9:49Adam Kempenaar: But top five dream sequences, mother-son movies, time travel movies, it's been an honorable mention many times as well. I was a big fan of the first Terminator movie, and Schwarzenegger's T-800 was already such a great screen villain. And I love that line from Reese in Terminator 1 where he says it can't be bargained with, it can't be reasoned with, it doesn't feel pity or remorse or fear, and it absolutely will not stop ever until you are dead. Well, Terminator 2 gives us that same thing, just a better model, that same lack of empathy and that objective, but even better and more efficient at killing.

10:21Adam Kempenaar: And there are great action sequences to this movie that don't feel dated at all and characters who aren't just there to serve a function for the plot, but are conflicted and dramatic and evolve over the course of the movie. So for me, it still stands up, even though, as I said, I haven't had a chance to view it in its entirety. It stands up with Die Hard and some of those other movies from the mid to late 80s and early 90s as all time great action films.

10:43Josh Larsen: Yeah, it is. It does hold up. I've watched it more recently. And for reasons I'll get into a little later in my list. Another one that I can say for sure holds up because I just rewatched it this weekend is my number four. And that's Beauty and the Beast. the real reason this Disney film is on my list though is because my daughters and I recently took this Disney princess quiz I don't know if you've done this Adam tells you tells you which Disney princess you would be well based on you still don't know me very well do you Josh the questions and your answers I got Belle so had to pick Beauty and the Beast ah Belle good morning I've come to

11:16Adam Kempenaar: return the book I borrowed finished already oh I couldn't put it down have you got anything new

11:21Josh Larsen: Belle's key to this film, I think, how they've envisioned this character, especially in the whole Disney princess debate, you know, about how they may or may not serve as role models for girls. I don't think that's the only way you should look at Disney films, but I think it's an important way. And as far as Beauty and the Beast goes, I really appreciate how Belle's independence and her refusal to bow to conventional romance is established right in that amusing opening number where she sings about this longing for more than this provincial life. And that's juxtaposed in the same song with the buffoonish Gaston's cocksure plan to marry her.

11:54Josh Larsen: The animators throughout this movie are very sure to give her a sense of skeptical intelligence. Even when she's imprisoned by the beast, she senses something more than his gruffness, isn't afraid to challenge his bravado. Later, after he does transform into the human prince, we get one of my favorite little details. She looks at him with this squinting eye and raised eyebrows if she's not quite sure she believes what she's saying. And I also like to think that maybe she's lamenting the disappearance of the big hairy beast, because I know a lot of people prefer the beast to that Kendall Prince at the end.

12:25Josh Larsen: There's a lot more, though, to like about Beauty and the Beast beyond Belle. There are really some standout animation sequences, including that ballroom dance scene that's an early experiment in computer animation. The beast himself is a wonderful character, even when he's prowling on all fours and they make him very animalistic. His eyes hint at this longing for his lost humanity. and there's also this undercurrent of a ghostly sadness to the film that recalls Jean Cocteau's 1946 Beauty and the Beast so I appreciate that about it this movie really did confirm Disney's return to relevance by being one of the best films in 1991 oh sorry I was just staring off

13:02Adam Kempenaar: into the distance thinking about you as a Disney princess I sort of missed that you were done there you should take it do it with Sophie sometime yeah that does highlight though a key difference between us in terms of, and we've talked about this before, our difference in appreciation for animated movies because I remember seeing Beauty and the Beast the year it came out, 1991. I remember really liking it. Probably my number 16 or 17 movie of 91. Did you see that with your high school buddies right after T2? It was a double feature that night. If only. If only. For my number four, I go back to that Terminator quote I just referenced a little bit ago about not being able to bargain with and reason with these killing machines.

13:41Adam Kempenaar: That applies to the villain from my number four pick, Hannibal Lecter, from Jonathan Demme's The Silence of the Lambs. It's actually what makes that character so disturbing and scary, I think, far more than the T-800 or the T-1000 later, that he doesn't just want to kill you. He probably wants to eat you or at least have some fun torturing you along the way. For me, that is more terrifying than Schwarzenegger or Robert Patrick in the Terminator films. And I'm not sure there's a more terrifying figure that's ever been on screen than Hannibal Lecter, as far as I'm concerned. And that's where Jonathan Demme and his use of point of view shots throughout his entire filmography really comes into play and is really effective in this film because it puts you in Clarice's position, looking into that glass box he's imprisoned in.

14:26Adam Kempenaar: And when he moves, when he comes closer to the glass, he's moving towards you. And I, as a viewer, want to actually physically back up that introduction to him, that point of view camera. We see him first from Clarice's point of view. He's just standing still in the dead center of that box and he's looking right at us. Just that him standing there is creepy enough. The way his eyes light up when he says, Jack Crawford sent a trainee to me, he's just spinning with possibilities what he can do with poor Clarice. And so far with Terminator 2 and Silence of the Lambs, I'm going with kind of conventional genre picks here, an action movie and here a serial killer film.

15:05Adam Kempenaar: But I'm as susceptible to those serial killer detective thrillers as anybody else. And I just think the combination of Demi's visual approach with Lecter's unique qualities as a villain. And he's the last person in the world you ever want to spend any time with. And the person you could find yourself not wanting to pry yourself away from because the conversation would be so stimulating. That cat and mouse game between him and Jodie Foster is something I really appreciate about that film. In addition to the scares and the thrills along the way.

15:33Josh Larsen: You want a story about seeing these films back in 91. And this will probably be somewhat of a confession. I don't think I've ever talked to my parents about this. So Debbie and I are going on a date to see Silence of the Lambs, right? going into the theater, 9.30 show, parents are coming out of the 7 show or whatever it was. And they were, you know, they were fine with us going to movies. Not like they were restrictive at all. But for whatever reason, as creepy as this film was, this shows you the impact it had on people. They run into us in the parking lot and are like, you're not going to that movie.

16:04Josh Larsen: Wow. You guys go do something else. You're not going to that movie. But you went. We're rebellious teens. Okay, we'll go do something else. Get in the car, wait for them to pull out of the parking lot, get out of the car, go to the movie. Nice. Because, yeah, that was my version of acting out, Adam. Love it. My number three, Terminator 2, Judgment Day. No shame in making this a top five film from 1991. It does hold up, as I've seen it recently. Might be Arnold Schwarzenegger's best movie. You'd probably say Predator, I know, from our list last week. I wouldn't go quite that far, but it's number two.

16:36Josh Larsen: Okay. Or maybe just behind The Running Man. Okay. It could be James Cameron's best movie, though Aliens is probably definitely in the running there. It's up there. But either way, it's an action movie landmark. I mean, it's inventive, it's propulsive, it's big but never bludgeoning. It doesn't mistake chaos for excitement, which is what a lot of contemporary action movies do these days. And you're right. Cameron and screenwriter William Wisher Jr. had this great idea of turning Schwarzenegger into the good guy this time around. and that just worked wonderfully in terms of reinventing that character but using some of the same qualities some of the same things that made the original terminator so fascinated and this advanced cyborg the t-1000 that you get from icy robert patrick just an ingenious creation i did name him as one of my top five movie robots last year and i talked about how patrick's performance plus all the new cgi technology that enabled it is probably the hallmark of this franchise for me

17:31Adam Kempenaar: He's a good looking boy.

17:33Josh Larsen: Do you mind if I keep this picture?

17:35Adam Kempenaar: No, go on. There was a guy here this morning looking for him too.

17:38Josh Larsen: Yeah, a big guy on a bike. Does that got something to do with this?

17:46No.

17:46Josh Larsen: I wouldn't worry about him. Now going back to that action, I think one thing that stands out compared to what we get today frequently is how judicious Cameron is in doling it out and choosing when to lay it on heavy, when to back off, when to allow the suspense to build. Even Captain America, the Winter Soldier, which I liked quite a bit, in the end gives into one of these deadening climaxes of endless fights and huge explosions. While T2 manages a finale that's not only in proportion with the rest of the film, but really somewhat poetic, too.

18:18Adam Kempenaar: My number three is The Fisher King, the movie that made me love Terry Gilliam as a director and also kind of ruined him for me, maybe, because it has all the anarchic spirit and visual flights of fancy you get with Gilliam and expect from him, but with a fairly conventional narrative, actually. And that through line, I guess, is what really keeps that movie together for me and really draws me to it. It is a redemption tale times two, and what's better than redemption when it feels earned, as it does for both of these characters, Jeff Bridges and Robin Williams. if you're not familiar with the Fisher King Bridges plays a shock jock and his flippant words on air that he really wasn't even thinking about one morning prompt a madman to go shoot up a restaurant and then later as he's dealing with the aftermath of this and trying to figure out kind of who he is and what he wants to be and what kind of person he is Bridges character meets Robin Williams character a homeless man on the street who has these visions of chasing the Holy Grail and fighting against the Red Knight.

19:20Adam Kempenaar: And this may be the last time, perhaps the only time, I didn't look at his entire list of films, that Robin Williams and all that manic energy had been employed to good effect. But it is here. I'm the janitor of God. I know.

19:36Josh Larsen: Yeah. Hey, I know how you feel. I mean, they came to me about a year ago. I was sitting on the john, having one of those really satisfying bowel movements.

19:47Adam Kempenaar: You know, those ones that border on mystical where you're like...

19:53Adam Kempenaar: You know, there's a lot of standout sequences in The Fisher King for me, but that Grand Central Station one, I think everyone probably looks to justifiably when Williams is following the woman he's in love with, Amanda Plummer, and it turns into this symphony where everyone is dancing. And if you like Jeff Bridges, he's great here. He's charming and tortured at the same time as he often is. And there's a little bit of crossover with this movie and the Williams character with my own private Idaho, Josh, in that the Williams character takes refuge. His name's Perry. He hides in these fantasies whenever his past is dredged up, whenever he's overloaded emotionally, just like Mike, the River Phoenix character in Idaho.

20:31Adam Kempenaar: Anytime things get a little too heavy for him and he really starts thinking about the past, he falls prey to that narcolepsy and just has to shut himself down. A little bit of that in Fisher King as well, but I love that film. It's my number three.

20:42Josh Larsen: My number two is an homage, really, to Gilliam, an obvious one in a lot of ways, especially his brand of inventive insanity. So much that, Gilliam lent his name to the marketing for it. It's Delicatessen, which was sold in the U.S. as Terry Gilliam Presents Delicatessen. This is a French film from co-directors Jean-Pierre Jeunet and Marc Caro. Jeunet would go on to make Amelie. And it's just this wonderfully odd little movie. It's set in a post-apocalyptic apartment building where the landlord is a cannibal butcher. But things are so desperate here that the neighbors don't really seem to mind.

21:15Josh Larsen: Despite all of this, there's a life-affirming sense of whimsy to the film that mostly characterizes it. It has a visual creativity that gets some of that across. There's certainly affection for its oddball characters, and it's a very communal film. Rather than rooted in one person or their story, you get a sense of what's going on in this entire apartment building, which is kind of cool. So take away the cannibalism really. And it's not all that different from Amelie. Well, you know how I am with whimsy.

21:44Adam Kempenaar: So delicatessen, haven't seen it. Haven't seen it. Though I did really like Amelie. So there's really no excuse. And it is one among a handful of movies I really hope to catch up with before forming my list and just wasn't able to do it. Good pick. My number two is the film we discussed at length in the first segment of the show. It is Gus Van Sant's My Own Private Idaho. And if up to now, my five, four, and three picks have all been essential as pieces of entertainment with artistic touches and flourishes that make them worthy of a top five list. This one I think is essential as a piece of art, as a film of its time that is also timeless.

22:19Adam Kempenaar: And unlike any other film of that year or any other year, you think about how you can find relatives of even the Fisher King, but especially Terminator 2 and Silence of the Lambs in other films, in similar movies. I'm just not sure you can do that. As much as there are elements combined from different genres, as we mentioned in our review, the road movie, the Western, whatever, there is something about my own private Idaho to me that feels sometimes familiar, but the totality of it is a truly unique vision. It's my number two. All right.

22:46Josh Larsen: You already stole Mind Thunder for my number one. Actually, it is The Fisher King. I was wild about this movie when it came out in 91, and I think I've seen it probably twice since then. And yeah, it's just, it's a magical experience. And you're right about Gilliam, the way you described, I think I'm probably a little more forgiving of some of his other stuff than you are, but I definitely can see and understand and often feel that same sort of resistance to the manic nature of his films. He's sort of like one of these all or nothing major league hitters in a lot of ways. You know, he always swings for the fences and especially with the creative ambition of these projects.

23:22Josh Larsen: And he's just as likely to strike out as he is to hit home run. For me, The Fisher King, it's his grand slam. It just all does come together. Maybe it is due to that script, which is by Richard LaGravines, who did a lot of good work in the 90s. For me, though, with The Fisher King, the hectic nature that can overwhelm Gilliam's films, it pauses for a certain poignancy that feels new in some ways to his work. And you can feel it both in the visuals and in the performances of this film. The visions of Red Knight that you talked about that Williams' character has, those are really haunting images that Gilliam provides.

23:58Josh Larsen: And both Bridges and Williams are very effective at humanizing what are extreme characters when you think about it. But the way they bring them to life and the way Williams' energy, as you talked about, is used, it is spot on. I mean, overall, I think there's a rooting in reality here that none of Gilliam's other films really have. And somehow doing that makes the flights of fancy that he takes all the more magical. So Fisher King, my best movie of 91.

24:24Adam Kempenaar: Obviously a great pick. My number one as we speak about creative ambition here, and as I was talking about art versus entertainment, how about the struggle at the core of this movie, the playwright turned screenwriter John Turturro in the Coen Brothers film, Barton Fink. It's my number four, currently my number four Coen Brothers movie as I rank them on Letterboxd. And that's a tough list to crack. Yes, it is. I like a lot of those films. But yeah, it's top five worthy as you consider all their films for me. Another one that's made a handful of top five lists over the years here. So I actually want to go to some comments from the critic Mike D 'Angelo.

24:57Adam Kempenaar: In 2009, when A Serious Man came out, he did a feature for the A.V. Club called Scenic Routes, where he focused on a specific scene from Barton Fink. And he talks about the symbolism of the movie, how Joel and Ethan Cohn put the movie symbols right in the audience's face rather than, as Mike says, subtly deploy them in the margins or confine them to dream sequences. He says not only does that constitute a sort of respect, but it allows them to tackle real emotion, in this case loneliness and longing, without feeling exposed as they can and inevitably do claim that it was just a giggle to them.

25:27Adam Kempenaar: And that really did strike a chord with me because I think that blatant use of symbolism throughout Barton Fink is what can make the movie seem challenging and difficult on an initial viewing, but only more rewarding when you see it on repeated viewings. And it's another one like My Own Private Idaho that's a depressing movie at times, but so starkly and absurdly funny at times that it balances that out. And D 'Angelo, it's funny, his inspiration to write that piece was that he was having a conversation with a couple other colleagues at Toronto where they had just seen A Serious Man and he wasn't as warm to that Coen Brothers film as they were.

26:04Adam Kempenaar: He just thought that they handled the same subject matter better in Barton Fink. and realized that they could have called Barton Fink a serious man, which is undoubtedly true because part of that character's problem is his pretentiousness, how he views himself as more serious, as better than everyone around him in Hollywood, including the characters he writes, which is really a key flaw. For me, another one is Inside Llewyn Davis. When we talked about that movie, I couldn't help but think about that film riffing on that same type of Barton Fink character, where you've got a character there who's a folk musician, and he's got this real focus on being a professional, just as Barton Fink does, but they're both failures, and they're both artists with high art aspirations, but working within sort of low art slash popular mediums.

26:47Adam Kempenaar: So this is a subject the Coen brothers keep going back to, for me, in really interesting ways. I like a serious fan, but I like Inside Llewyn Davis and Barton Fink even more, and it's my number one.

26:57Josh Larsen: I don't guess this means much to you. Hell yeah, I could tell you some stories. And that's the point, that we all have stories.

27:04Adam Kempenaar: The hopes and dreams of the common man are as noble as those of any king. It's the stuff of life. Why shouldn't it be the stuff of theater? Okay. As promised, Josh, do you have it? Do you have the number?

27:16Josh Larsen: Episode 507, top five movie manimals, which Michael Phillips and I paired with, yikes, Tusk. Tusk? Do you remember Tusk?

27:26Adam Kempenaar: Wow, I do. And I love, I love knowing that I was gone and Michael Phillips had to sit in for me and review Tusk. Yeah. Kevin Smith. Uh, it was a Kevin Smith thing. Yes. Taking one for the team. Wow. Michael, well done. We remind you that if you're interested in learning more about becoming a film spotting family member, you can get all that info and learn about the benefits at film spotting family.com. Thanks for listening. This conversation can serve no purpose anymore. Goodbye.

From the publisher

The 1991 movie year turns 35 this year. T2, Barton Fink, Boys in the Hood. In 2014, Adam and Josh looked back a mere 23 years for their Top 5 of '91.

 

 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Filmspotting

All episodes