


FinTech Recap from Money 2020 (Las Vegas) covering AI agents in banking, shrinking charter timelines, tokenized deposits vs stablecoins, and the OCC’s “irrefutable” debanking report.
Alex Johnson (host; FinTech Takes newsletter creator) and Jason Mikula (Fintech Business Weekly). No other guests named.
Alex is a fintech newsletter creator and podcast host focused on fintech trends and regulation. Jason is a fintech industry analyst who writes recaps and commentary on financial technology business and policy.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion about experiences and observations from the Money 2020 conference.
“This is FinTech Takes, the podcast keeping you in the loop on all the latest FinTech trends, news, and ideas.”
Exploration of the concerns banks have regarding AI agents accessing their systems.
“But when it's getting down to the thermostat is in Celsius, of course, when it's getting down to like 18 in the house, like that's too cold.”
Conversation on how banks are reacting to AI agents and potential reputational risks.
“So they can see information, but we will not allow them to take action.”
Discussion of the opportunities AI presents for fintech companies and back-office applications.
“It's funny, I went to a dinner with a bunch of kind of bank and sort of payment type folks and actually sat right next to the guy who leads AI for large parts of JPMorgan Chase.”
Final thoughts on the future role and management of AI agents in banking.
“The risks that you're talking about, one could almost call them something like a reputational risk.”
Discussion on the use of AI agents in banking, focusing on regulatory challenges and opportunities.
“I will add one more different note, and then we can move on to the next one.”
Analysis of the current landscape of bank charters and the implications of obtaining a national trust bank charter.
“Next topic at the show was charters and the window of getting charters and the question of should I be getting a national bank charter or a national trust bank charter or should I be maybe considering a different route?”
Overview of the latest discussions on stablecoins and the new regulations affecting payment stablecoin issuers.
“I mean, there's kind of like a shadow hanging over getting this charter and using it for things other than what Congress intended to.”
Discussion on the implications of chartering and regulatory scrutiny.
“a lot of this might end up getting unwound or changed or applied more scrutiny.”
Exploration of the latest developments in stablecoins and SoFi's new product.
“Last topic, and I'll just zoom through this one because I want to move on, is there was obviously a lot of stable coin tokenized deposit talk at the show.”
Analysis of how consumers view tokenization and the practicality of crypto products.
“We saw Connexus from JPMorgan Chase add another public blockchain that it's now capable of supporting.”
Critical review of the OCC's report on debanking and its implications.
“I mean, I've looked more in targeting LADAM, not domestic US consumers, but these apps really seem to go out of their way to make it look like it is dollars.”
Exploring the implications of debanking and its political context.
“Or should we let the free market operate and those institutions that have the risk appetite and the compliance infrastructure to manage those risks decide if they want to serve a segment?”
Discussing whether debanking is a material problem and examining anecdotes.
“I would say the answer, well, so my thing is no, to start with.”
Sharing a personal story about banking difficulties related to crypto transactions.
“So I'm like, oh, maybe this is Operation 2.0, false positive situation where I'm getting throttled or debanked because I'm involved in crypto, even though this isn't even real involvement.”
Learn about Wise's recent regulatory issues and how they affect users.
“And Wise's own policy had a carve out if you're the employee or the service provider of a crypto firm, which is what this was.”
Explore the implications of Operation Chokepoint 2.0 on fintech companies.
“So it's like, they did probably a data migration at some point and botched the address.”
Discuss the groundbreaking lawsuit by Ernan against Maryland's tipping statute.
“Usually it's overdone because it's like a reaction to not doing as much before.”
Analyze the ethical concerns and business outcomes of tipping in fintech.
“Tipping, as listeners probably know, is my favorite thing in fintech.”
Exploring the inappropriate nature of tipping in fintech services.
“It's not someone delivering food to your table.”
Discussion on the CFPB's confusing stance on superintelligence and AI.
“And in fact, I had a different topic that quite frankly was a more calm topic for my can't let it go.”
A critique of the CFPB's handling of language and policy communication.
“It's crazy because it's like the CFPB put out a statement that they're not doing anything on this, but they wanted to be on record as not doing it, but using the proper language to use.”
Finding humor in the bureaucratic errors of the CFPB.
“I mean, it's like at least we can get a chuckle out of it.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Fintech Takes, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Alex Johnson: This episode is brought to you by Increase. Increase offers API-first banking for ambitious technology companies. Coast, Gusto, and Ramp rely on Increase to process more than$500 billion annualized. If you're building the next great financial product and need a bank that gets it, visit increase.com. Hello, and welcome back to the FinTech Takes podcast. Today is another episode of FinTech Recap with Jason Mikula. Jason and I just got back from Las Vegas and the last ever Money 2020 at the Venetian where we left it all out there on the carpeted hallways. So Jason and I talk a little bit about what we saw and heard at the show, everything from AI agents to the narrowly shrinking window of getting a bank charter to the growth of tokenized deposits and new products being launched in that space to compete with stable coins.
1:02Alex Johnson: We also spend quite a bit of time talking about debanking since the OCC put out a new report ostensibly proving the size and scale of the debanking problem in the U.S. And Jason and I talk about just how little that report actually proves and discuss, I think in a pretty nuanced way, how big and how real the actual problem of debanking is. And then finally, because we are who we are and we care about the things we care about, we spent a little time talking about the Ehrnan lawsuit against the state of Maryland over Maryland's law banning EWA providers, including Ehrnan, from being able to solicit tips from their customers, which is a topic that if you know anything about me, you'll know I had some very strong feelings about.
1:51Alex Johnson: That also was my rant at the end of the episode. Great discussion with Jason, as always, and I really hope you enjoy another episode of FinTech Recap.
2:05Alex Johnson: This is FinTech Takes, the podcast keeping you in the loop on all the latest FinTech trends, news, and ideas. I'm Alex Johnson, creator of the FinTech Takes newsletter, your host and self-confessed FinTech nerd. Let's go. Okay, fresh off his sojourn to Las Vegas, we have Jason Mikula of Fintech Business Weekly. Jason, how are you? I'm doing pretty well. I detoxed from Las Vegas in Barcelona in a small town outside of Barcelona for a wedding, which was very fun. And I will say I was practicing my Spanish and it is markedly better after my time in Oaxaca. Very, very nice. There's no substitute for immersion, as they say.
2:55Alex Johnson: I detoxed from Las Vegas by going to San Francisco, which I'm not sure was exactly the right place to go for detoxing from too much sort of fintech. just like going to San Francisco, I was actually always blown away whenever I go to SF because truly like that place is just, it's like Twitter in real life almost. Like every ad on every bus stop and at the airport and everything you walk by is like tech, AI, or surprisingly like a lot of fintech. Like the number of like fintech billboards and stuff in San Francisco is honestly kind of shocking. And so I didn't get out of the fintech bubble, but I at least changed the type of bubble I was in.
3:39That does not surprise me. I think I've been back once since I lived in San Francisco and that was 2014 to 2016. And even then it was like, yeah, living inside Twitter, everything was a, whatever the cool startup of the day was, or like VC related, like everybody on the Muni, like every hoodie. I actually did not care for it. I need a little bit more diversity in sort of like my day-to-day life.
4:03Alex Johnson: I had that same feeling. I was just it was way too much like sort of IRL group think just everywhere. Like every coffee shop was every person was in every chair and every laptop was open and AI was open running on every laptop. I mean, it was just like a caricature of real life tech Twitter just playing out in real life. So beautiful city. I love to visit for non sort of fintech reasons. But yeah, it definitely definitely kept me in the bubble. So I'm happy to be back in Montana where it is. We were joking that it's getting cold in various locations and sort of like approaching winter slightly.
4:43Alex Johnson: Are you turn on the heat or keep the heat low to keep the AC bill down? I crapped probably before I went to Vegas. It had been off since whatever, May. But when it's getting down to the thermostat is in Celsius, of course, when it's getting down to like 18 in the house, like that's too cold. I need like 20. No, that's very fair. I sort of have to fight my like emerging dad instincts to keep the thermostat off or as low as possible with like just the desire to be comfortable, especially as it gets a little colder. We don't have snow on the ground right now, but I expect by Halloween we will. Jason, since we just saw each other in Vegas, didn't actually get to spend a ton of time together, Literally, you did do me the courtesy of coming to my three-on-three basketball tournament.
5:32Alex Johnson: So it was great to see you there. I thought maybe we could start by catching up on some Money 2020 takeaways. Yeah, absolutely. You wrote an excellent recap and seemed to actually ingest and synthesize and analyze what happened. So if you want to run us through it, we can do kind of like a quick fire on what was the various hot topics, if there was more than one. I would love to. I would love to. There weren't that many more than one. It was pretty concentrated, which I'm guessing you can probably guess why. But the first topic, of course, was, as we have in the outline, agents, agents, agents, agents everywhere and not a bit of liability to be had.
6:12Alex Johnson: There was a lot of, I would say, anxiety around AI and AI agents in particular. I think this is probably the hangover of Muse and Instinct and Dots and Duet and all the different personal agents that are sort of now being built in this template. It was interesting to be at an event where it was immediately after these products have like exploded onto the scene. And so everyone I talked to was very much trying to figure out, okay, how do we get ahead of AI agents? Now they're here and they're out there and they're already interacting with our systems and our customers are using them and our stock price is dipping because analysts are projecting what agents are going to do to our business model and just all this stuff.
7:05Alex Johnson: And so there was a lot of anxiety. There had been, I think, the week before Money 2020, a series of earnings calls where basically all the big bank CEOs had said, we're not going to allow banks to or agents to get inside our system. We will allow them to use read access via something like a plaid, which obviously, if you're Chase, you've sort of wrestled plaid into a position that you're comfortable with. So they can see information, but we will not allow them to take action. Jamie Dimon said that if customers, you know, instruct agents to take actions on their behalf, that they're taking on the liability of anything that happens.
7:46Alex Johnson: So banks are already sort of disclaiming liability. They are doing their best, I think, to try to block these agents. However, there was also a story from Axios about banks already reporting anonymously in this Axios story that agents are already inside their systems. They're in some cases going rogue and taking actions that they don't think their customers authorized. So everyone was very sort of freaked out by it on the bank side. On the fintech side, whether it was Plaid and Perplexity who had a main stage session at Money 2020 or any number of the other companies that were there, people who were talking about stuff.
8:25Alex Johnson: on the fintech AI side, it was, hey, let's go. Let's enable this. Let's move faster. Let's empower agents to do all of these things. And so, I don't know, Jason, I spent most of my time and money 2020 trying to sort of suss out what was actually true. And I'd be curious to get your take on this. From what I could tell, it did seem like it was true that agents are already accessing bank systems with their customers' credentials and trying to do stuff. I couldn't really get a sense of how prevalent that behavior was, but it did seem in talking to folks like they are already seeing this activity.
9:02Alex Johnson: They're already seeing some evidence that it's happening. I would hazard a guess it's still on a relatively small scale. I mean, I don't know about you, but Muse and Instinct and others still haven't permeated themselves too deeply into my non-tech, non-fintech side of my life. Like family and friends for the most part still aren't using these tools. So I don't think it's happening at a massive scale, but it does seem to be happening. I also think that banks probably believe rightly that AI agents are still making a lot of mistakes and still screw stuff up all the time. It's funny, I went to a dinner with a bunch of kind of bank and sort of payment type folks and actually sat right next to the guy who leads AI for large parts of JPMorgan Chase.
9:48Alex Johnson: and he was saying one of the things he wishes people would discuss more publicly about AI is just how much it still makes mistakes and screws stuff up and just kind of like we're not nearly as far as we sometimes like to pretend in terms of AI being reliable. And so I think there's a legitimate fear on the part of banks that they maybe will have these agents inside screwing stuff up. And I think, you know, banks experience their lived experience recently with things like scams have been that even if you are legally covered because, hey, our terms of service said you're not allowed to do this and you violated the terms of service and, you know, anything bad happens, it's on you.
10:31Alex Johnson: It's not on us. We've seen how that doesn't totally always work and that like Elizabeth Warren will still send you mean letters and you'll still have to answer questions from the New York Times when they write stories about your customers getting screwed on, you know, whatever happens. I feel like banks understand that like technical liability versus like liability in the court of public opinion are not exactly the same thing. So they seem a little freaked out by that. So again, I think it's understandable why they're blocking agents. But I guess the two things I was sort of left with are one, can banks technically block AI agents if they are coming from the customer's browser or the customer's device and have their credentials?
11:14Alex Johnson: Like, is that technically a feasible thing to do for the long term? And then two, will blocking AI agents eventually become a competitive disadvantage if there are other banks that allow AI agents to come in and transact on behalf of their customers? So what do you think about those questions? And what did you hear about sort of AI and agent anxiety at the show? The risks that you're talking about, one could almost call them something like a reputational risk. Sure, sure. I'm just throwing that out there. No, but you and I are both the geriatric millennial late early adopters. Yes. And so I have been increasingly playing around with some of these tools, including, yes, giving my instinct bot a separate credit card number that I can like turn on or off or change the CVV code if I need to.
12:10It is very impressive, if not slightly frightening, like how capable they are. I mean, I was, well, I was departing SFO on my way to Barcelona. I had a connection. Polaris Lounge, very nice. And I was like, oh man, I have all this extra luggage because I was like bringing various things for various people. And I was like, instinct, can you find me a car service that will like meet me at international arrivals? like the guy with a sign holding, you know, with my name who can help me with the luggage. And it went out, found a service, created an account. Nice. Watched my email to get the two FA codes into my email to verify the email, booked the car, and it would have been great except the flight showed up too early and there was no line at immigration.
13:00I don't have to do that horrible European entry-exit system because I'm a European resident, so I didn't have to deal with that. I arrived before my car. So in theory, it worked great, except it didn't work. And I just ended up taking a taxi. But I've also tested this with some of my burner fintech banking apps. I will not name anybody. But I was like, oh, yeah, can you log into XYZ Neobank and check my balance? And like, it could do it. So, I mean, I think the themes I heard were very consistent with what you're saying. Like, definitely, well, I would say there's a bifurcation. Like, big bank freak out for all the reasons you spelled out.
13:43Yep. And a sense of either excitement or opportunity, particularly in the business banking space. So, your Mercury's ramps, etc. of, hey, if this is how our business customers, or I guess Mercury also has a personal offering, if this is how our customers want to interface with our services, we need to figure out how to support this and not sort of run the Jamie Dimon playbook of like block, delay, sue. I will add one more different note, and then we can move on to the next one. We've been talking about consumer agents. But a lot of what I've been chatting with folks about is using agents within sort of like the back office or within the systems of the bank.
14:35Sure. Particularly when it comes to areas like BSA, AML. The folks I've talked to are generally quite excited. The hesitation or the caution is around things like model risk management. How do I explain this to my bank examiners? If I do something now, will there be a different lens in two years when a bank examiner is looking back at what I did in 2026? These are both sort of AI agent topics, but they're very, very different, I think, in their implications and sort of how different stakeholders in the ecosystem are viewing like opportunity versus risk.
15:16Alex Johnson: Yeah, I think that's really well said. And one point I'll just add and then we'll move to the next one is on the regulatory front, this came up numerous times, somewhat kind of unprompted in conversations I was having with folks at the show. everyone was sort of blown away by how little regulatory sort of guidance or anything around AI is happening right now. And I guess you could sort of bucket that around just sort of a general deregulatory agenda plus a, as long as we call it super intelligence, we're all for AI sort of stance that the administration currently has. And so it seems as if like the desire is just don't get in the way of any AI thing.
15:59Alex Johnson: Don't slow anything down around AI, but even from like fintech companies or banks that wanted to be aggressive with AI, I had talked to numerous people who were like, yeah, it would be nice if we could be aggressive with an understanding of what's going to get us in trouble and what's not going to get us in trouble. And there's just no guidance. There's nothing. I mean, you mentioned model risk management. They updated the model risk management guidance and they de-scoped generative AI and LLM. So like, Like, it's just not in there. And so like, if you were to ask your regulator, like, hey, how should we be thinking about using this new and by far most important and most sort of constantly discussed and constantly asked about technology inside our bank, either for back office purposes and or for customer facing purposes?
16:49Alex Johnson: My understanding right now, at least at a federal level, is you discourage to get like shrugs, which is like a crazy, crazy thing to say. And I do think to your point, you know, two years from now, you're going to be having a very different set of conversations with regulators. And you better at least have a cogent story to be able to tell them, not just like, well, we didn't know what the guidance was, so we just did a bunch of stuff. Like, that was another flavor of anxiety I was getting at the show. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, we'll put a pin in it here. And we also have made a category error because it's not AI, it's SI, but we can leave that for another show.
17:23Alex Johnson: Yes, well, and I think you're going to dip back to that at the very end of our podcast, so we'll save it for that. Next topic at the show was charters and the window of getting charters and the question of should I be getting a national bank charter or a national trust bank charter or should I be maybe considering a different route? Apparently Mission Lane got a credit card bank charter, which Jason, I'm going to be totally honest with you, I didn't even know that was an option. So good for them, I guess, for flipping through the catalog all the way to the end and finding one that, you know, suits their purpose, I suppose.
18:03Alex Johnson: But the charter conversation was definitely very active. I had two things I wanted to bounce off you on this one. One was, what's the window of time for getting a bank charter? And I was really curious about this because I had numerous conversations with folks where they were essentially telling me, you have something like six to nine months, roughly speaking. And the math was basically that even if you get a conditional approval under this administration, typically a conditional approval lasts for a year, which is how long you have to get all of your capital and all the other things you're required to do based on the conditions that are set out in the conditional approval.
18:45Alex Johnson: and if that conditional approval year-long window overshoots the end of the administration and new regulators coming in, it's not a guarantee that you're going to get final approval. Now, depending on how sort of mainstream it is that you're doing, you might still feel good about getting it, but it's not a guarantee. And so particularly for novel charters or novel types of businesses, it does seem like kind of everyone to the lifeboats before the ship goes down is sort of the mentality that I was sort of picking up a bit. And the other question that was sort of coming up was this question around national trust bank charters, which we've talked about before.
19:26Alex Johnson: You've written extensively on. I've written a little bit about it. Our friend Kia Hazlitt has written about it as well. It's really interesting because Ramp was the company most recently, I think while the show was happening, that announced that they were going to be getting a national trust bank charter. And it's funny, despite having learned a bunch about National Trust Bank charters and despite the ICBA suing the OCC over the sort of repurposing of National Trust Bank charters, I'll be completely honest with you and say I don't really understand what the fuss is about National Trust Bank charters.
19:59Alex Johnson: And what I mean by that is I do think it is a strange repurposing of the charter type. So I think the ICBA in a sort of general sense has a point about like, this isn't really what these were meant for. However, having said that, I'm not sure what you get by doing this. Like when Ramp announced they had applied for one, they were like, yeah, we're going to use this to custody the assets that we have for our investment account that we offer to our business customers and for some of the crypto stablecoin stuff that we do, even though they don't issue their own stablecoin. And I was kind of looking at that and going, uh-huh, like, sure, that's great that you're now cutting out the custody partner that you had before.
20:41Alex Johnson: That'll save you a couple bips. Like, yeah, sure. And I was kind of trying to figure out like, beyond that, which doesn't seem all that compelling to me, what is it that you're getting out of a National Trust Bank charter? Or to maybe put it in the opposite lens from an ICBA perspective, what is it that you're worried these companies are going to do with this charter? Like what business are they going to take away from you by having this charter? And honestly, like as I look at it, it's a charter type that allows you to duck having to become a bank holding company, which if you want a charter, but you don't want to be a bank holding company, which is a very common feeling.
21:19Alex Johnson: It allows you to do that. you could duck being a bank holding company by getting a ILC, but then you have to get pulled into weird preemption fights that you might want to skip. And so like, it allows you to avoid that. So that's something I suppose it's theoretically, and I stress theoretically very hard here because nothing is a guarantee when it comes to this, but theoretically it opens up a path to getting a Fedmaster account, maybe. So I guess, Jason, like a question I have is it doesn't seem like the most useful charter to have and yet it does feel like maybe solely because of the optionality it provides.
21:58Alex Johnson: Everyone is like, well, the OCC is giving them out. We might as well grab one. Like, what's your take on this? I also struggle, even though I've read and written a lot about this, sometimes I struggle to like fully understand what all the business models potentially are, particularly, as you pointed out, would I want to be constructing a business model around a trust bank charter, doing something that is non-fiduciary when there is a real risk that the ICBA or someone else comes along and that suit is successful? I mean, there's kind of like a shadow hanging over getting this charter and using it for things other than what Congress intended to.
22:43Alex Johnson: Well, the OCC end of the next administration could just change their mind and regulate you differently with that charter type too. Yeah, I mean, right, exactly. I mean, I think my core understanding, and I hope I'm not wrong in this because if I am, it'll be embarrassing, would be something along the lines of, or at least what the ICBA type world seems to be afraid of, or I think they're afraid of is, okay, I get this National Trust Bank charter. This allows me to have a pathway to becoming licensed under Genius when all that stuff is finalized. So now I can issue stablecoins. I'm going to hold my own collateral backing those stablecoins, which is largely short-term treasuries.
23:26So I'm holding those via my National Trust Bank. I'm issuing stablecoins. This starts to look a lot like narrow banking, right? Like you can't do lending on the trust charter, but you're holding this collateral. You're collecting the interest, the regulated stablecoin issuer. So you're prohibited from passing along that interest, at least directly. There are various mechanisms to do it indirectly.
23:48Alex Johnson: It starts to look a lot like banking without the lending piece. I mean, and that's bad for community banks who argue that like it crowds them out from doing the work that banks are supposed to do, which is maturity transformation and putting deposits to work and blah, blah, blah. Like, I get all of that. But I guess my counterpoint is, couldn't you just do everything you just described and have a bank partner for like the small little parts of what you're like? I mean, in the alternate world where you're not getting that charter, doesn't the fact that we allow payment stable coins in the US genius past?
24:26Alex Johnson: I mean, narrow banking is here, whether we want it to be or not. And I don't really see the national trust bank charter is fundamentally changing that reality all that much unless I'm missing something. I mean, I guess this is definitely me thinking on my feet. If I were a ramp or any of these other firms doing this, what did we see unfold from 2020 to 2023, 2024? I mean, actually, I just saw a tweet about this today. It was from a customer perspective, somebody complaining that their Mercury account was being migrated from choice to column. And then later, that account could be migrated from column to Mercury's own bank.
25:05And so I think having control of if it is a fundamental piece of the business you're operating, not having that dependency on a third party, a regulated third party who could get into trouble due to other partners that they're supporting, or just decide, hey, like, we don't want to be in this business anymore. We're offboarding you per the terms of our contract. If the business model and the features and services you're providing are mission-critical dependent on having this thing, recent history demonstrates why you don't want to depend on a third party for that capability.
25:43Alex Johnson: Yeah, no, I think that's absolutely true. Although, again, like, it goes back to, like, using Ramp as an example. is custody of assets critical to ramps business like my understanding is no i mean like it'll be interesting right because now that ramp has applied for this national trust bank charter they'll probably get it i would hazard a guess and um you know i would think that's step one to like maybe they issue their own ramp stable coin and then the stable coin becomes more central to the way that they process payments between their customers and like i could see a path for it becoming a bigger part of their business.
26:18Alex Johnson: And so maybe it's is simply just, you know, we want a little more control of our infrastructure and be less dependent on third parties. We want the optionality of just having this thing. And so it's the whole thing is just kind of like this very funny fight over a relatively narrow, small thing, but it's almost like more what it symbolizes about the way that the market is changing. And I, I feel like it's, it's that larger symbolic change that the ICBA is more pissed about and suing over than the narrow threat that like these actual charters pose to the community banks that they represent. What do you think on the charter window question?
26:58So I think my understanding is generally comparable with what you're saying. So, I mean, if we look at what has been the timeline from application to conditional approval, that kind of feels like it depends on who you know. It does. It does. but let's call it roughly six months. And then to your point, from conditional approval to final approval, I think it may depend on charter type actually, but let's call that 12 months. So that means - Yeah, 12 to 18 felt like the window roughly, yeah. That means if you're filing your initial application today, you've got 18 months. If you haven't started the work to prepare that application, like it's probably about now or never.
27:45Alex Johnson: No, that was the feeling I had was talking to folks. They were like, you have very little time, which for the Claroses of the world is great. More business coming in. And I think the thing that's funny about it is when we get to the other side of it, a lot of this might end up getting unwound or changed or applied more scrutiny. And then the consulting firms that helped you get the charter can help you get out of trouble with the charter that you have. So it's like, you know, I think that it's funny. We're going to talk later about like the whip sign of regulatory stuff. But the lawyers and the consulting firms do fantastic, regardless of what happens.
28:24Alex Johnson: They call that job security. That's right. I think that's right. Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. So so I think that's interesting. Last topic, and I'll just zoom through this one because I want to move on, is there was obviously a lot of stable coin tokenized deposit talk at the show. It was interesting because timing-wise, the OCC just finalized its rules for payment stablecoin issuers under the Genius Act in the U.S. The yield prohibition that we mentioned before stays intact. However, the loophole for affiliates and third parties like Coinbase remains open. So despite Brian Armstrong's histrionics throughout the whole process of Genius and Clarity, that loophole remains open.
29:03Alex Johnson: So if they want to provide incentives for USDC or I guess OUSD, which is the new stablecoin that Coinbase is participating in, they can do that. As you mentioned before, there's also a million different options for indirect other tricky ways through DeFi to offer things that look like yield that I don't think there's any way from a rulemaking or regulatory perspective that you could really stop those. I trust, Jason, you also saw that SoFi launched right after this happened the first tokenized savings account by a bank in the U.S. called SoFi Earn or SOFI, which I wrote about it. it's kind of funny because it mostly just seems like marketing.
29:45Alex Johnson: Because if I have a SoFi savings account, TradFi style, it's stored in a ledger. And I can convert that in the app to SoFi stablecoin if I want. If I use SoFi earn, it is stored in a different ledger that is tokenized, I guess, whatever we mean when we say that. It pays a higher APY than the TradFi savings account. And with one click of a button, I can transfer it into SoFi's stablecoin. So it doesn't really functionally seem to be new or interesting or valuable in any way, shape or form. It does seem like a way that SoFi is trying to ironically sort of weaponize the fear that banks had about stablecoins offering yield pulling deposits out of the banking system.
30:34Alex Johnson: This is sort of the inverse. And in fact, in the press release, Anthony Noto, the CEO of SoFi, basically said, it's a real shame that all of those people holding stablecoins out there don't get paid any yield. That's wrong. And someone should do something about that. And so that's why we made SoFi earn. I don't know if there's actually as big or valuable a customer acquisition opportunity to take deposits out of crypto and stable coins and bring them into the banking environment. I think in the same way that banks fears about that were a little overblown. I think if I was Coinbase or Circle or whomever, I don't know that I would worry that much about this.
31:12Alex Johnson: But it is interesting to see a bank sort of invert the threat there. and overall I guess my sense coming out of the show was that stablecoins and tokenized deposits are increasingly fighting over the same area of land right stablecoins are becoming sort of more like payments infrastructure they're introducing features like privacy zones that are designed to like obscure transactions on the blockchain so that corporate clients can use them more comfortably without having all their transactions available for anyone to see And at the same time, tokenized deposits are becoming more like stablecoins, more open, more interoperable.
31:54Alex Johnson: We saw Connexus from JPMorgan Chase add another public blockchain that it's now capable of supporting. So you're seeing tokenized deposits kind of migrate more towards the stablecoin end of the spectrum and trying to open up new use cases for tokenized deposits. So I don't know, overall, it feels like both banks and crypto companies are sort of now on more level playing field to sort of fight over all these different use cases, which used to be TradFi use cases. And I now I guess they're now tokenized use cases. Any hot takes on stablecoins and tokenized deposits that you got from the show? I have two quick hot takes, and then we can move on to something else.
32:34I read the SoFi announcement, which I guess was not actually from the show, but I was kind of scratching my head, particularly when it's describing users, SoFi users, members holding SOFI's, the tokenized deposit. And it says, and I'm quoting the press release, when members are ready to put those funds to work, they can convert SOFI one-to-one to SOFI USD, then use the SOFI USD to buy crypto directly in the SOFI app or move money over blockchain rails 24-7. Like, who's doing this? if you're i have to imagine if you're a serious like a real serious crypto person sure i don't think you're probably using sofi maybe i'm wrong i haven't kept up with their quarterly earnings if they're reporting out data on that it feels even just from that verbal description like an insane ux situation that anyone who is like that attuned to like blockchain, crypto, stablecoins, banking.
33:38Like, I feel like this is not what they're doing.
33:41Alex Johnson: They're probably yield farming in DeFi. I think that's absolutely true. And they stressed in the press release, like, it's a tokenized deposit, so it has FDIC insurance and all that kind of stuff. But the reality is, you know, people who are comfortable operating in the crypto ecosystem, they don't care about that. Now, they may, if there's some event that happens and suddenly they can't access their stable coins, like that might become a more salient benefit. But I don't think it is right now. And I think you're right, like, oh, good, now I have to make one extra hop to get back to the crypto trading I was doing by going through SoFi USD first.
34:17Alex Johnson: Like, why do I want to do that? Like, I would prefer to just hold it in circle on Coinbase, get paid by Coinbase in yield, and then immediately be able to take my USDC and go do, you know, yield farming or crypto trading or whatever I'm going to do. Also, it's not entirely immediately clear to me why SoFi could not just have them hold a regular bank deposit and then instantly issue a SoFi USD or crypto without that intermediate step. They can do that. They can do that. That's a thing you can do. Like you could have a SoFi checking account or a SoFi savings account, not SoFi, but just a regular SoFi savings account.
35:01Alex Johnson: And in the app, you can, yeah, dollars. And then you can buy with your dollars SoFi USD or other crypto in the SoFi app. So like it doesn't, there is no advantage to it. I was looking, I kept studying the mechanics being like, I'm not a moron. No, no, no, no, no. This is much more of a press release than it is like a product, I would say. And on SoFi, like one thing Anthony Noto is really good at is keeping retail traders excited about all the innovative things SoFi is doing. And this felt more like speaking to retail investors than it did like our members are demanding this. It's for the SoFi bros and gals on X.
35:42And I mean, I guess that your last comments there transitioned to my second point, which is normal people don't care if it's tokenized, if it's not tokenized, if it's blockchain, if it's stablecoin, they care, is my money safe? Which historically speaking, crypto world has not always been the best about. And does it like, can I use it? Does it allow me to do what I need to do? And so I do tend to agree that at least in the SoFi case, it's more of a sort of publicity stunt aimed at a retail investor base. And then in a more general matter, it's like most of the consumer offerings I've seen built on stable coins actively try to obfuscate the fact that they're built on stable coins.
36:32Yes. I mean, I've looked more in targeting LADAM, not domestic US consumers, but these apps really seem to go out of their way to make it look like it is dollars. And maybe there's like a FAQ or a footer somewhere that explains, actually, this is EUSD, which is backed by USDT and USDC derivatives in these DeFi pools. because normal people don't understand that and again, don't care as long as their money is safe and they can use it to do what they need to do.
37:07Alex Johnson: Yeah, I totally agree. I mean, the salient point of SoFi Earn is that it pays 4.4%, which is a marketing expense that they are paying right now to try to pull deposits out of the crypto stablecoin universe inside SoFi's balance sheet, which is a fine marketing gambit to try, like go for it. But beyond that 4.4%, I didn't see any compelling reason why. And to your point, like just saying tokenization, I don't think crypto people are going to be impressed by that. And certainly non-crypto people won't even know what it means. Should we talk about our next item? Yes, one that you specifically have gotten yourself some personal experience on.
37:51Alex Johnson: I'd love to talk about this. We'll see how much we can fit in. So prior to Money 2020, I was sitting in Mexico City, excitedly reading the Office of the Comptroller of the Currencies' much-anticipated report on debanking. I think the OCC most have fired their graphic designers because the aesthetics were a little rough. Yes, they were. But I did note that Comptroller Gould, in comments that were in the press release, and I believe also in a post on X, said that the report, quote, provides irrefutable evidence that the nation's largest banks have denied, debanked, and discriminated against customers and lawful businesses.
38:41And before I proceed, I read the report more than once, and I do not think it does what Comptroller Gould is presenting that it did. The report does provide anecdotes about so-called debanking, but there was zero quantitative data that speaks to the scope, nature, or causes of debanking. This report was actually called for in Trump's Executive Order 14331, which describes attempts to define politicized or unlawful debanking. And this is like a long definition, so I will not read it all. But as acts by, I'm paraphrasing, acts by banks, savings associations, credit unions to directly or indirectly adversely restrict access to or change the terms of banking products, loans, based on a customer's political or religious beliefs or on the basis of the customer's or potential customer's lawful business activities that the service provider disagrees with or disfavors for political reasons.
39:51So a couple of thoughts here. One, as Adam Levitan points out, I will plug his post-time credit slips again because it was excellent and much shorter and easier to read than mine. There is no such thing as unlawful debanking currently defined in law. So I mean, despite this EO, that really is not a concept that actually exists in statute or in regulation. One, two, the very first sentence of the report, which is titled Guaranteeing Fair Banking for All Americans, reads, quote, quote, under President Trump's leadership, the United States government is committed to restoring fair access to financial services, which is a fundamental principle of the U.S.
40:44banking system. Listen, this document can only be interpreted as a political and frankly, an explicitly partisan document. If there was actual quantitative evidence in here, like, I would be able to take it seriously, but there isn't. Looking at the anecdotes provided at face value, there do appear to be cases where financial institutions, although again, as pointed out in Professor Levitin's post, most of the anecdotes were coming from like ISOs, independent sales organizations, and payment processors, not necessarily banks. But the anecdotes in the report did speak to entities from both the left and the right.
41:31But there really was no claim of illegal behavior by any bank whatsoever. No example of viewpoint discrimination by an actual bank. Those were the payment processors or the ISOs. Zooming out, I think it's easy to get distracted by how, frankly, ridiculous the report is. But I think the report demonstrates, I don't think it demonstrates that at an industry-wide scale, this is a real problem. The US has about 8 ,500 banks and credit unions, plus numerous fintechs. Should all of them be required to serve customers in cannabis, adult entertainment, firearms, crypto, oil? Or should we let the free market operate and those institutions that have the risk appetite and the compliance infrastructure to manage those risks decide if they want to serve a segment?
42:30And a bank or a credit union that's like, hey, I'm small-town bank and trust in Bozeman. I bank ranchers and mom-and-pop stores. I don't have the infrastructure to serve businesses. crypto exchanges or what have you. So I do think that in a political lens, I think that this is an interesting evolution of the debanking debate. I know that you have followed this as closely as I have with, you know, Operation Choke Point 2.0, which was sort of this alleged coordinated effort by Biden-era regulators to discourage banks from working with crypto-related firms. Memorably, A16Z's Mark Andreessen had something of a meltdown on the Joe Rogan podcast where he falsely described the Chopra era CFPB as terrorizing fintechs and crypto in order to protect big banks, which I don't think Rohit Chopra...
43:30Alex Johnson: No one has ever accused Rohit Chopra of trying to protect big banks. I don't think so. This report focused primarily on religious and political ideology. actually it doesn't have the word crypto at all it does mention digital assets in passing but does not provide a single data point nor even a single anecdote about a person or business debanked because of their affiliation with crypto so it's like there's a wider context to this whole thing I made a joke about reputational risk earlier so we've seen current bank regulators particularly Michelle Bowman at the Fed discourage or actually move to eliminate and prohibit the use of reputational risk in bank supervision.
44:18We've seen direction from the federal banking regulators to focus more narrowly on material financial, quantifiable financial risks. And then, you know, there's also been a whole host of efforts from the current regulatory apparatus, dare I say, to debank undocumented immigrants. So suggesting use of ITIN by itself should indicate higher risk. Suggesting undocumented immigrants pose a higher credit risk because I guess they could get deported and be unable to make their payments or not be able to work anymore. The floating of a requirement for FIs to collect citizenship information, which the ICBA was it was ICBA, right?
45:06Yeah, was opposed to and was, you know, fairly quickly walked back. Meanwhile, on the other side of the aisle, Democratic lawmakers, particularly Elizabeth Warren on Senate banking, as well as consumer advocates, have sort of adopted that same language, the debanking language, to talk about issues that they care about, like EWS and check systems, so-called do not bank lists, overdrafts, and how overdrafts often precipitate, typically consumer having their account closed, or broadly discriminating against a class of consumer based on something like a last name. In the LA area, for example, Armenians or people with Armenian surnames have been discriminated against because of perception that they may pose a higher fraud or financial crime risk.
45:56So, like, my question to you is, like, are you convinced that debanking is a real problem? Like, there are anecdotes, sure, and I have my own anecdote, which we can get to. But like, have you seen anything that convinces you that like this is an actual real material problem? And if so, does the current administration and current regulators actions actually do anything to address it?
46:24Alex Johnson: This episode is brought to you by Increase. Increase offers API first banking for ambitious technology companies. Companies like Coast, Gusto, and Ramp rely on Increase technology to process more than$500 billion annualized in payments, card transactions, and loans. The founder of Increase was Stripe's first employee, and he's built a team of industry veterans who understand technology and banking better than anyone. If you're building the next great financial product and need a bank that's designed for your needs, see for yourself at Increase.com. Yeah, great question. There's a lot there. I would say the answer, well, so my thing is no, to start with.
47:09Alex Johnson: I don't believe that it's a problem worthy of this level of sustained attention. I will admit to being a little surprised at how they're kind of just a dog with a bone with this topic. Like they just won't let it go. Like I kind of thought that what was going to happen in the first like year was going to be, well, all right, Mark Andreessen made a big fuss about this. It kind of became a thing. The House Republicans on the Financial Services Committee wrote a report about it. They dug into it. The OCC did this initial thing. And I kind of just assumed that like that would be enough to sort of satisfy the desire to dig into this.
47:49Alex Johnson: And then we just sort of like move on because I don't really think, and this report sort of continues to make me believe this, there just doesn't really seem to be a there there. And to your point, the way we were talking about this keeps kind of evolving, right? So we went from a question of, all right, did Biden-era regulators inappropriately use tools like reputation risk to discourage banks systematically from not working with categories of businesses or I suppose individuals that they did not like for political reasons. We've talked about that version of debanking and I've kind of debunked that based on the data that's available and the reporting that's been done on that.
48:34Alex Johnson: I think to the degree that you believe that happened at all, it's pretty easy to contextualize it against the fact that crypto had melted down at the time and was a very unsafe industry to work with. And you could understand regulators sort of cautioning to banks about working with that industry. I always think that kind of gets left out of the crypto debanking story or Operation Chokepoint 2.0 or whatever you want to call it. And I think to the degree that you would come away from that version of debanking with any conclusion at all, I actually think the Trump administration came to the right conclusion and said, you know what?
49:09Alex Johnson: Reputation risk has gotten a little squishy and a little easy to sort of be repurposed or broadly used or broadly applied. and really regulators have no business telling banks how to assess reputation risk when they're not the ones managing their own reputation and it's just not a good bit of criteria for supervising banks and we should just get rid of it. I actually think that's pretty reasonable and I think to the degree that you have concerns about what happened under the Biden administration to the crypto ecosystem, the elimination of reputation risk, I think pretty much addresses all of those sort of mainstream or reasonable concerns that you could have.
49:50Alex Johnson: So I kind of thought it was over at that point, to be totally honest with you. And then we keep getting debanking brought up and we keep looking into it. And I had the same read that you had and that Adam Levitin had. You read the report and the only real anecdotes that you see, first of all, there are none relating to crypto, which I think is kind of crazy. Like if Operation Chokepoint 2.0 happened and the big banks were like in a conspiracy with Biden era regulators to stop crypto companies and crypto individuals from having bank accounts, wouldn't that be like the number one category of anecdotes that would have been cataloged in that report?
50:26Alex Johnson: You would kind of think so. And it was not at all. So that was strange. And to your point, all of the sort of examples that were shared specifically around banks, none of it is illegal, right? I mean, like in this country, banks are able to decide who they want to work with and who they don't want to work with. And the only limitations on that really relate specifically to fair lending laws, which is its own sort of separate category. But when we're talking about just having a bank account or not having a bank account, you know, to your point, if that small little bank in Bozeman that works with ranchers and mom and pop shops doesn't want to work with a crypto exchange because they have no idea of what crypto is and they have no idea how to bank it safely.
51:08Alex Johnson: that's very reasonable. And the answer to that is simply, we have 8 ,500 banks and credit unions and numerous, numerous fintech and crypto companies. You can get services from other providers and that tends to be what happens. I will also say, just as a point of emphasis, because I find it really honestly bizarre and it kind of speaks to your point about political motivations. Why is it that we're only looking at the top nine banks? Like if we really care about debanking and scrubbing debanking out of every single part of the ecosystem, wouldn't we want to look at all banks and credit unions? Like, why are the OCC, why is it only looking at the top nine banks?
51:47Alex Johnson: And is it possible, Jason, that the top nine banks are a target because they also have gotten themselves into the crosshairs with other things relating to the Trump administration, like debanking the president or his businesses, quote-unquote, and those lawsuits have gone nowhere, or things they're doing on fair lending and sort of DEI sort of initiatives that the Trump administration doesn't like. Like, it seems very odd and politically motivated for the OCC to narrow its focus only to the top nine banks, when in fact, I'm sure you could find things that look to them like debanking if you looked at regional banks or community banks or credit unions.
52:29Alex Johnson: Like, Why is the NCUA not involved in this initiative? So I do find it to be a strange, politically motivated, and honestly not very compelling report that is coming from a single agency that for whatever reason is just very hung up on it. Whereas pretty much everyone else from a bank regulatory perspective seems to have sort of done lip service to this topic right when the administration has changed over and they got their new jobs. And then they all kind of moved on because I think the sense more broadly in the regulatory community is there's just really nothing here. Yeah. I mean, I mentioned anecdotes in my anecdotes, so I will tell it quickly, which is by the time this comes out, it will happen last week.
53:12For my Dutch company to accept payments from the US, I use Wise, which I opened my personal account when I moved to the UK in 2019, 2018. And then when I moved to the Netherlands and set up my company, I opened a business account. So I was like, hey, I need to be able to, I want to make it easy. And this was, you know, pre-stable coins. They didn't even exist yet. I want to make it easy for, you know, my clients, who are pretty much all in the US, to pay me. So actually, fun fact, when I opened that account, it was based at Evolve Bank & Trust.
53:56but that's neither here nor there for this story used it no problem for the last six years clients pay me into wise i wise is the ux to be honest is like janky because it was set up specifically for remittances right um even before this incident like i'm not leaving a bunch of money in wise because uh i am just not comfortable doing that and so typically i would uh you know when I was doing my bookkeeping, you know, every week or a couple of weeks, move those funds into my Dutch business bank account from Wise. So from dollars into euros in my Dutch bank account, easy. I was going to do my bookkeeping last week.
54:37And I'm like, okay, this is for this invoice, like move this much money, big red air, like cannot process like Like the maximum amount permitted per month is the equivalent of X thousand pounds. And I'm like, well, I've definitely sent more than that before. Like this is like a new thing or like something's going on here. And you know, Jason, once my Spidey sense is tingling, like it's a problem. And so initially I'm like, oh, like I did have a client that is in the crypto space pay me for like recently, you know, at the beginning of the month for some work I'm doing with them. And Y is actually in their T's and C's, I don't know when they implemented this, but in their T's and C's specifically says you cannot use Y's for like buying cryptocurrency, depositing the sale of cryptocurrency, NFTs, blah, blah, blah, blah.
55:37And I'm like, yeah, but I didn't do that. But the name of that, like the company account that that came from, like, if you're doing a name match, like would name match the MSB entity, same as if you were getting a deposit of like cryptocurrency funds, or the sale of cryptocurrency funds. So I'm like, oh, maybe this is Operation 2.0, false positive situation where I'm getting throttled or debanked because I'm involved in crypto, even though this isn't even real involvement. And Wise's own policy had a carve out if you're the employee or the service provider of a crypto firm, which is what this was.
56:20And so I'm like, okay, call customer service. like they understandably can't that won't actually say anything can't actually say anything um i'm like okay i'm gonna send them the purchase order the uh contract and the invoice that like this was like for professional services consulting etc not the you know not a crypto transaction didn't acknowledge that they even received it and so i continued digging and it turns out it's not just me and potentially may or may not be related to that crypto company. I actually don't know at this point, but complaints on, you know, Twitter, Reddit, where all good reporting comes from at this point.
57:05A material number of EU, specifically EU-based businesses, had this exact same hard cap implemented sometime in the past week, 10 days or so, and only found out when they hit the cap. So fortunately, I don't keep much money in Wise. And I also don't have a ton of expenses with my business, apart from Treasure Island bills. So it's like, I'm not in a catastrophic position where I'm in trouble because my money's locked up in Wise until the next month starts and I can get up to the limit out again. But there are people, and I spoke with some of these people, where like, I have a VAT tax bill due, I have payroll, like I have to pay my lease payment.
57:54So like very real consequences from this seemingly arbitrary cap imposed for opaque reasons. For folks who've followed my work or particularly, you know, folks who are in Europe, although this has come up in Wives' chartering application, I mean, they have a pretty long track record of quite serious A &L problems. Their primary regulator in the European Union is the National Bank of Belgium. And there was a 2022 action that was not public that became public because Wise failed to meet the deadline to remediate all the problems in the prior actions. that new action that became public just last month in September specified a deadline to fix this stuff of January 2027.
58:48So it really feels like WISE is rushing to clean up the trash fire that it's let burn out of control for the past however many years, four, five, six years. Sure, sure.
58:58Alex Johnson: Yeah. Including, sorry, this is not I can't let it go, but it might as well be. including like I go and log in to like try to see like is there anything I need to upload or anything I can do on my on my personal account which I opened when I lived in the UK the address I don't live there anymore so the address I actually lived at was 10 Rhodesia Road ground floor flat because it's the UK and addresses are weird the address that shows just says ground and then London and the postcode. So it's like, they did probably a data migration at some point and botched the address. And then it's like, oh, okay.
59:42They actually froze my personal account too and said, you need to upload address information. Like, okay, I can do that. But then when you go to find and upload address information, you can't change the country of residence. And I'm like, well, I can prove where I live, but your UX is broken. it won't let me change the country of residence to the netherlands and you're asking me to hit agree and then upload a document which like this is not the right address so it's not going to work last piece on this before while i'm poking around in there i see that there are other uh other elements that you uh potentially would need to complete including your residence status so like a residence permit, your source of wealth, and the account purpose.
1:00:33But none of those flows actually work. When you click on it, it just says, we don't need this. So it really looks like they are rushing to try to fix a problem that has surely been brewing for quite a long time.
1:00:48Alex Johnson: That's fascinating. I mean, you're right that they've been, I think, pretty clearly late in like fixing these problems and the remediation is always like painful and to your point, like rushed, messy. Usually it's overdone because it's like a reaction to not doing as much before. So that doesn't really shock me. I mean, it also is kind of funny timing because they just got denied for a bank charter in the US based on some of these problems. And so, you know, it is the timing is kind of ironic. But I guess my question for you, Jason, is are you now are you a believer in Operation Chokepoint 2.0?
1:01:24Alex Johnson: Are you like, are you part of the army that's going to fight this now? No, I still don't believe it because as I said, it's like, it's anecdotal, but what is that anecdote? And I guess, I mean, there's probably room for debate here, but it's like, okay, Wise grew incredibly quickly by offering what for consumers and businesses was an easier process. You know, I would have loved to go sign up for an account at ING or ABN AMRO. They told me that my visa was only five years, so they couldn't open me a business account. So it's like, okay, if your business model is we're going to grow by taking more risk than other players in the market are willing to take, then you also need to build the corresponding controls and processes to do that in a way that's not going to get you in trouble.
1:02:12Wise has absolutely and clearly not been able to do that. And so now, Wise's VC investors and exec leadership got rich on the IPO. Wise is trading at an$11 billion valuation, last I checked. And who is getting penalized for the decisions that they made two, three, four, five years ago? The customers who, frankly, rightly or wrongly are having their accounts throttled, forcibly closed, or frozen. Particularly on the business side, it's like if you have built a business where that is a key part of your workflow, or if you're a consumer who comes to depend on that for remittances, it's one thing to give 30 days notice, 60 days notice.
1:03:01This was zero notice. Yay on. if they had told me 45 days ago so that I could start changing the payment information on my outstanding invoices to go to a new account, I'd be annoyed. But I understand better than the average person. Probably one of the more catastrophic user experience, customer service disasters I've seen recently. I would be very curious to understand the scale. Like hundreds, like thousands of accounts, don't know. But I will end my rant there because I know we have one more that we want to get to.
1:03:38Alex Johnson: We do. We do. So our last topic, and we can go quickly through it, but I think it's I mean, we have to do this. We have to. Yeah, we have to do this one. We have to. You wrote about it. I wrote about it. It's the best. Ernan is suing the attorney general and the head of financial services regulation in the state of Maryland, the great state of Maryland, over a statute that was passed in Maryland earlier this year that, among other things, abans earned wage access providers from soliciting tips. Tipping, as listeners probably know, is my favorite thing in fintech. Jason, I think you're right there with me.
1:04:20Alex Johnson: And this is fantastic because, among other things, and this is just amazing, Ernan is making the argument in its lawsuit that, again, among other things, the state of Maryland is violating the company's First Amendment rights and the First Amendment rights of its customers by restricting the state of Maryland. their ability to ask for and their customers' ability to give tips. You know, honestly, like, this is why lawyers get paid the big bucks, because that is quite the argument to make. It is, as far as I can tell, completely novel. I don't think anyone has ever tried to make this argument before.
1:05:03Alex Johnson: It's wild. I think it may not quite work out quite as well as they hope it will, just at least in some respects because especially the earning as a company has the free speech rights to ask for tips seems a little strange to me. Again, not a lawyer, so I can't really judge the chances that this lawsuit is going to have. But it's a wild and novel swing to protect a business model that I have some feelings about. I'm going to pause before I share my feelings, which will take us right into Can't Let It Go because I do have a rant about this. But before we do, Jason, add to an opine on the legal argument that's being made here.
1:05:47Alex Johnson: I am also notably not a attorney. You're closer to not being not an attorney than I am. So go ahead and cook for a minute. So I think the piece about the Maryland law that is very interesting and I think set up what Ernan's doing here is not only did it say like you can't do tips. I mean, it literally said, you know, you cannot ask for tips and compelled Ernan to disclose in, you know, in its UX and its app that it was not allowed to ask for tips. So it was both prohibiting some speech and compelling other speech. Yeah. I mean, to your point about companies enjoying the First Amendment, Companies are people, as we learned in Citizens United.
1:06:37So I have to assume that that is not going to be a problem, a deal breaker for Ernan's case. I mean, I did ask around with some of my actual lawyer friends and like, the arguments are actually pretty good. That's what I heard too. In Ernan's favor. There's a second set of reasoning around due process, which we do not need to go into. in Ernan's lawsuit against Maryland as well. It seems entirely possible, if not likely, that Ernan will prevail. But as you pointed out in your piece, and I was actually unaware of this information, that when Dave scrapped tipping, its business actually did better.
1:07:21Am I understanding that right?
1:07:22Alex Johnson: That's right, yeah. So Dave in 2024 got rid of tipping. Dave, similar business. and, you know, does these sort of small sort of loans. And they were asking for tipping. They were getting a lot of heat from regulators, particularly the FTC over, not just the fact that they asked for tips, but they were pretty manipulative. Like dark patterns. Starving kids. Starving kids. Yeah, like if you tip, we'll give a portion of your tips to help feed kids in some third world country. And there was literally a picture of like kids with like a plate with food on it. And then if you lowered the amount of the tips, some of the food would get taken off the plate, pretty like bad stuff.
1:08:06Alex Johnson: Um, so Dave, uh, for various reasons got rid of tipping. Um, what was fascinating is they moved to just a flat fee. So it's a 5 % fee of the amount that they're lending you a minimum fee of$5 cap of$15. And what was funny was in the first full year where they introduced this just simple, straightforward, mandatory fee, Dave's revenue grew 60%. Its average revenue per user jumped 36%. It's adjusted EBITDA more than doubled. And at a 41 % margin, Dave also critically saw no adverse selection, no hit to conversion rate or retention rate when it made the fee mandatory. And in fact, credit performance on these loans actually improved and made it to all-time lows.
1:08:57Alex Johnson: Now, some of that improvement was a changeover from the old model to the new model, so you shouldn't expect that level of growth to continue. But what's crazy about it is they made more money, and according to them and everything I've seen, their customers were fine with it. In fact, a lot of them prefer knowing what the price of the thing is. And this brings me to my rant about this really quickly, which is, it is so embarrassing to ask for tips if you're a fintech company. It is so, so embarrassing. And quite frankly, it's embarrassing to argue on First Amendment grounds that you should be allowed to ask your customers for tips.
1:09:35Alex Johnson: I don't really care about the legal strength of that argument. Like, that's interesting. But the reality is, like, this is so embarrassing. It makes me embarrassed to work in fintech. When I talk to people in my non-fintech life, and I'm like, hey, did you know that there are these apps that you can work with where they'll ask you for tips. They look at me like I've lost my mind, which is the actual right reaction to have because it's not someone driving you in an Uber. It's not someone delivering food to your table. It's not a massage that you get. Like this isn't a human delivered service where you are not tipping the company, but are rather tipping the individual, which tipping culture and the reason we tip and the fact that we have low mandatory minimum wages and all that other stuff.
1:10:21Alex Johnson: That's all a different kettle of fish that we can get into. But the reality is none of those reasons apply to a privately held fintech company that has raised$190 million in venture capital funding asking its customers for tips. They should not be doing it. It's embarrassing. And as Dave illustrates, it's also bad business. I just can't with tipping in fintech. It is complete horseshit and it needs to go away. And I really don't like this lawsuit. We are on fire today. We're both worked up. We really are. And in fact, I had a different topic that quite frankly was a more calm topic for my can't let it go.
1:11:03Alex Johnson: So I'm going to just substitute in what I just did for my can't let because I'll never, ever, ever, ever be able to let go of tipping in fintech. Drives me out of my mind. Jason, you have a good can't let it go to wrap us up. This apparently was from, I think, October 9th, but it just came across my desk earlier today, which is why I'm bringing it up. It is a page on the CFPB's website about superintelligence at the CFPB. And the subhead says CFPB has no SIU's cases to report. So I guess evidently the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is dedicated to advancing the use of superintelligence and related technologies in a responsible, safe, and secure manner.
1:11:54To facilitate this, they have designated their chief information officer to also hold the role of Chief Super Intelligence Officer, CSIO, not at all confusing, and to spearhead their continued use of SI at the CFPB, which that's internally inconsistent because it says they're not using it, but whatever. And then I guess the reason this is happening, well, there's a lot of reasons, but the specific reason this is happening is because of an OMB memo accelerating federal use of AI
1:12:34I'm dying inside accelerating federal use of AI not SI through innovation governance and public trust so I don't know if somebody did like a control F or like clawed like find and replace they're not very good at it they're not very good at it
1:12:51Alex Johnson: What are we doing here? It's crazy because it's like the CFPB put out a statement that they're not doing anything on this, but they wanted to be on record as not doing it, but using the proper language to use. There's actually a six-page memo linked, and the memo refers to it as AI, so they didn't even fix the memo before they posted it. Yeah, I mean, it's the sycophantic nature of adopting the right language combined with the incompetence of not being able to adopt the right language all the way through is pretty startling. And, you know, it obviously ties back to corruption because everything does.
1:13:34Alex Johnson: But, like, look up stories about people buying up domain names for.si and you'll sort of see the sort of hellscape that we're trapped in. But it's nice to see that the CFPB that's been reduced to the size of like three people and their dog coming into the office every day still found the time to put this thing into the world that absolutely does not need to exist and was done badly. Incredible stuff. Just all the way around. 10 out of 10. No notes. It's awesome. I mean, it's like at least we can get a chuckle out of it. And I guess that's something in 2026. well we will I'm going to see you in DC though right yes I'll be there yeah so AFC Policy Summit you and I will both be there I was just looking at the agenda it's me you and Kia moderating sessions back to back to back so there'll be a lot of policy nerd topics so if anyone is anyone going to be in DC for that make sure to find us absolutely well until then stay warm in Montana I will do my best stay warm in the Netherlands ones.
1:14:47Alex Johnson: Thank you for listening to this episode of FinTech Takes. Stay up to date with emerging companies and the latest FinTech trends by subscribing wherever you get your podcasts. And if you love FinTech Takes, please tell a friend.
Welcome back to Fintech Recap. I'm Alex Johnson, joined as always by my partner in recapping, Jason Mikula.
We kick things off with the big takeaways from Money20/20, where AI agents were everywhere, and so was the anxiety about what they're already doing inside banks. Big banks want to block them, while fintech companies see opportunity. Will blocking agents eventually become a competitive disadvantage?
Then, it’s our charter watch. In the narrowing window to secure approval under the current administration, we discuss what fintech companies may stand to gain from national trust bank charters. (We also dig into SoFi’s new tokenized deposit, SOFIE, which pays 4.4% APY and converts into SoFiUSD – in part to ask who it’s for!)
Next, bank to debanking we go. The OCC says its new report on the nine largest banks provides “irrefutable evidence.” We read it, and we’re unconvinced.
Finally, EarnIn sued Maryland over a law prohibiting earned wage access providers from soliciting tips, prompting my entirely predictable rant about tipping in financial services (which also conveniently serves as my Can't Let It Go!). As for Jason, he discovered that the CFPB has appointed a Chief Superintelligence Officer, despite having no superintelligence use cases to report.
---
This episode is brought to you by Increase.
Increase offers API-first banking for ambitious technology companies. Companies like Coast, Gusto, and Ramp rely on Increase technology to process more than $500B annualized in payments, card transactions, and loans. Learn more at https://increase.com/
---
Sign up for Alex’s Fintech Takes newsletter for the latest insightful analysis on fintech trends, along with a heaping pile of pop culture references and copious footnotes. Every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday: https://workweek.com/brand/fintech-takes/
And for more exclusive insider content, don’t forget to check out my YouTube page.
---
Follow Alex:
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJgfH47QEwbQmkQlz1V9rQA/videos
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/alexhjohnson
X: https://www.twitter.com/AlexH_Johnson
---
Follow Jason:
Newsletter: https://fintechbusinessweekly.substack.com/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jasonmikula/