El Chapo: Cocaine kingpin

16 Jan 2024 · 51 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Good Bad Billionaire - Episode Summary: El Chapo: Cocaine Kingpin

Podcast Overview Podcast Title: Good Bad Billionaire Hosts: Simon Jack and Zing Tsjeng Description: This podcast explores the lives of billionaires, highlighting their methods of wealth accumulation, philanthropy, and ethical considerations, inviting listeners to form their own opinions on whether these individuals are "good," "bad," or just typical billionaires.

Episode Focus Episode Title: El Chapo: Cocaine Kingpin Episode Description: The episode delves into the life of Joaquín Archivaldo Guzmán Loera, popularly known as El Chapo, examining his rise to power as a drug lord, his criminal innovations, and his eventual imprisonment.

Key Points

Early Life

  • Birth and Upbringing:
  • Born in 1957 in La Tuna, Sinaloa, Mexico.
  • Grew up in a family involved in farming, hinting at early exposure to drug cultivation.
  • Initial Ventures:
  • Started by selling oranges at a young age, exhibiting an entrepreneurial spirit.
  • Entered drug trade by cultivating marijuana, drawn by higher profitability compared to legal crops.

Rise in the Drug Trade

  • Professionalization of Drug Trafficking:
  • Worked under Miguel Angel Felix Gallardo, who established the Guadalajara cartel, teaching El Chapo the operational tactics of drug trafficking.
  • Innovation:
  • Pioneered the use of cross-border tunnels for smuggling drugs into the U.S., marking a significant advancement in drug trafficking logistics.
  • Propensity for Violence:
  • Known for extreme violence, reportedly killing over 2,000 individuals to secure power and maintain control.

Notable Operations and Escapes

  • Drug Smuggling Operations:
  • Developed methods for transporting various drugs, including cocaine, heroin, and methamphetamine.
  • Introduced innovative smuggling techniques, including the use of submarines and drones.
  • Prison Escapes:
  • Escaped from prison twice, utilizing his tunneling expertise.

Crimes and Conviction

  • Violent Reputation:
  • Engaged in brutal acts, including torture and murder, to assert dominance in the drug trade.
  • Legal Consequences:
  • Arrested multiple times; eventually extradited to the U.S. where he was sentenced to life plus 30 years for drug trafficking and related crimes.

Judgement of El Chapo Wealth

  • Estimated wealth reached over $1 billion at his peak, making him one of the wealthiest drug traffickers but comparatively low on the overall billionaire list (noted as 701 on Forbes).

Rags to Riches

  • Life Journey: Transitioned from a poor rural upbringing to becoming a billionaire drug lord. This path is both tragic and indicative of the limited legitimate opportunities available in his region.

Villainy

  • Score: An unprecedented 11 out of 10, surpassing all previous evaluations due to his direct involvement in extensive violence and drug-related deaths.

Philanthropy

  • Critique: While he contributed financially to the local economy, no documented charitable initiatives exist. His reputation as a "Robin Hood" figure was more about self-promotion than actual philanthropy. Given the rampant violence and suffering resulting from his actions, he received a score of -10.

Power

  • Influence: Operated with significant power within Mexico, able to evade law enforcement and corrupt officials. Score given: 8 out of 10.

Legacy

  • Cultural Impact: Renowned as a notorious figure and subject of various media portrayals. His legacy is marred by violence, further perpetuating the mythology surrounding drug trafficking in popular culture. Score given: 6 out of 10.

Final Judgment

  • Conclusion: El Chapo is characterized as a "bad billionaire," reflecting the destructive impact of his actions on society and individuals involved in the drug trade.

Listener Engagement

  • Feedback Invitation: Listeners are encouraged to share their views on the episode and the portrayal of El Chapo by contacting the show through provided email and messaging options.

Episode Production

  • Produced by: Hannah Hufford and Mark Ward
  • Editor: James Cook
  • Production Company: BBC Audio

This podcast episode offers a compelling examination of one of the most infamous figures in the drug trade, blending biographical details with societal implications, sparking critical thought on the nature of wealth accumulation and morality in the pursuit of power.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30Don't say. SAP Concur helps your business move forward faster. Learn more at concur.com. Vanity Fair calls BritBox a delicious streamer. Kaleida says everyone should be watching. Catch Britain's next best series with BritBox. Stream acclaim new originals like Code of Silence. You read lips, right? And Linley, based on the best-selling mystery series. Say hi, Linley. Take it from here. And don't miss the new season of Karen Pirie, coming this October. You don't look lip, please. I'll take that as a compliment. See it differently when you stream the best of British TV with BritBox. Watch with a free trial today.

1:08The spirits of Buttonhouse are back to haunt your screens. And now, your ears as a podcast. As once more, we go Inside Ghosts. You're insane. Tish-tosh. The fifth and final series is here. And we'll be following our favourite phantoms and the spooky stories that unfold episode by episode. I met the elephant man. What was he like? Rather boring, couldn't see the fact. I'm Nathan Bryan and join me for ghostly gossip with the stars from the show. What the bally heck is going on? And take an exclusive peekaboo behind the scenes. Beat that. Inside Ghosts. Listen on BBC Sounds. BBC Sounds. Music, radio, podcasts.

2:00Welcome to Good, Bad, Billionaire, the podcast where we pick a billionaire and find out how they made their money. And then we judge them. Are they good, bad or just another billionaire? I'm Zing Zing and I'm a journalist, author and podcaster. And I'm Simon Jack and I'm the BBC's business editor. And today we are discussing a real piece of work. Joaquin Archivado Guzman Luera, better known as El Chapo. Yeah, one of the most prolific, violent and powerful drug lords in the world, currently in the place he least wanted to be, in a US prison. He's claimed to have killed over 2 ,000 people and he pioneered the use of tunnels to smuggle drugs under the US-Mexico border.

2:45And we should say that this is an episode which contains murder, violence, sexual assaults, drugs. So if it's not for you, we have other billionaires, but it's a very interesting story. It is, because other than tunnels, he was also quite the enterprising businessman. I mean, he used everything from submarines, drones, chilli cans, fish, cars, 90-year-old drug mules to take every single kind of drug you can think of into the US. Cocaine, marijuana, heroin, fentanyl, everything and anything. And he controversially entered the Forbes billionaire list in 2009. He was also not immune to audacious displays of wealth.

3:22So someone who testified against him in court said he had houses at every single beach, ranches in every single state. For context, Mexico has 31, so that's quite a lot of states. A lot of states, a lot of mansions. And even when he was locked away in high security jails in Mexico, he enjoyed regular visits from sex workers. He threw parties for favoured inmates and he would have booze, lobster, filet mignon. This is a man with expensive tastes and even prison couldn't hold him down. He escaped twice from jail. But he can't spend his money now, however much he's actually got left. It's kind of hard to tell because they don't file annual reports, these people.

3:57He is in high security US federal prison and he will be for the rest of his life unless he finds a way to dig another tunnel out. Yeah, and his nickname El Chapo means shorty. Well earned, just under five foot six. And I've seen a little bit of video footage of him. He may be five foot six. I find him absolutely terrifying. and I'm really hoping he's not listening because I don't fancy being tortured and killed myself. Do they have podcasts in maximum security jail? That's the question. Let's keep our fingers crossed. So we are going to tell the story of Al Chappell from a zero to his first million and then on to a billion and then we're going to judge him.

4:33Although, to be honest, I think there's going to be pretty clear cut. He's obviously a baddie. Spoiler alert, he's a bad one.

4:45he was born in 1957 in a tiny town of latuna in the sierra madre mountain range in the north western mexican state of sinaloa so he's one of seven siblings born to a couple called emilio and maria who earned their living from farming and i'm going to put that in quotes because his father was officially a cattle rancher but almost certainly as many people were in that region was really an opium poppy farmer. And similar to in Asia, they've got that place called the Golden Triangle. They've got a Golden Triangle in Mexico where the states of Sinaloa, Durango and Chihuahua meet. It borders New Mexico and Texas in the US, which is geographically very important.

5:24It's very important, especially if you're a drug smuggler, because even for decades before El Chapo was born, these drug cartels were growing marijuana and opium poppies because it being mountainous, it's very inaccessible. and therefore had very few police or armies around. And it's got form, this area, this Golden Triangle, established by pharmacists in the 1910s, as early as that, because they used to carry tins of raw opium across the borders to Southern California. So by the time Old Chapo is born, right, drug trafficking is essentially well established in his neighbourhood. I mean, it's virtually a state-controlled industry.

5:59So he's really born at the right time in the right place. And one of the points he'll make later on to this day is that if you wanted to make a decent living. There weren't that many options. No, I mean, it's a tough, difficult place to be born and to grow up. He starts exhibiting an enterprising spirit from a young age. He would support his family by selling oranges to peasant farmers for a few pesos. And he loved flaunting money, right? So his younger sister, Bernardo, says that he would wear fake gold jewellery when visiting family members. And his mum has a great story about him where she says he used to pretend that little coloured bits of paper was money and then he would count them up into little pals and tell her to take care of it for him.

6:38Yeah, and then recount them. And so much of this story has been captured in movies, hasn't it? There's a kind of... Some of this feels like cliché, but actually it's almost impossible to imagine some of this stuff is real because it's been kind of fictionalised so often. Exactly. I mean, if you've watched Narcos Mexico on Netflix, El Chapo features pretty heavily in it. Yeah. Well, El Chapo's father was said to be violent. He was certainly lazy, a drinker and a womaniser. and El Chapo got a bit of both of his parents. I mean, so he's a womaniser, much like his dad, but he works hard like his mother and he's remained a bit of a mother's boy all throughout his life.

7:14I mean, he caused their relationship perfect. She remains loyal to him to this day, even though he's been convicted. She's still trying to visit him in prison. Yeah, it's sweet. If you could put it that way, sure. Well, he left school at around the age of eight, apparently not uncommon to this day in that area. He'd only have occasional lessons from travelling teachers anyway. And some people say he's actually functionally illiterate. But, you know, there are examples here and there of, you know, rudimentary handwriting. Yeah. So he starts his career, as many did in that area, picking marijuana.

7:46It paid around 2 ,000 pesos a day. Quick conversion, that's about$11.50, about£9 a day, which is roughly four times more than you get when you harvest sugar cane, which is legal. So really, the illegitimate drug trade paid off far more than the legit trade in that region anyway. Yeah. So he worked on his father's farm at first, but he soon became fed up working for him. He had a pretty fractious relationship with his dad, by all accounts. And by the age of 15, he was out of the family home, cultivating weed for himself. And in a sense, you know, this is his first business, if you want to put it that way.

8:18Yeah. So it's 1972. So at that time, there was massive demand in the US for marijuana. It was the hippie boom in the US. Everyone was smoking weed there. And also there was a closure of this pipeline of drugs from Europe, which again was immortalised in the film The French Connection. Exactly. And it's called The French Connection because that's when heroin is smuggled from Indochina through Turkey to France and then via there to North America. And around this time, the diminutive Mr Guzman gets the name El Chapo, slang for shorty. He's five foot six, as we've already said. But while he's growing up, there's also the backdrop of America and its war on drugs, which is going on.

8:59So obviously, the American authorities have cottoned on to the fact that all these illegal drugs are coming in over the border from Mexico. And in 69, Nixon, who's then president, orders searches of every single vehicle entering from Mexico into the US. And in 71, he declares an official war on drugs and creates a new agency in 73, the DEA, the Drug Enforcement Administration. In response to US pressure, the Mexican state begins to assert itself in the mountains. Right. So it flies in helicopters. It sprays drug crops, kind of aerial defoliation spray, which kills them effectively. and even it starts descending on villages.

9:38So in one night in 1975, the army helicopters get to a village very close to El Chapo's and it attacks women and opens fire on preteen boys when they can't even find any men involved directly in the drug trafficking business. And El Chapo had his own run-ins with the Mexican soldiers, right? So his sister claims they once beat him in front of his own mother. Yeah, so the young El Chapo decides to leave La Tuna to seek his fortune higher up the drug food chain. So he moves to a small town about 70 miles, long journey through the mountains, he's leaving it behind. And here he hooks up with five brothers, the Beltran Liver brothers.

10:16They're young, they're ambitious drug traders, and they become his collaborators in the following decades. Now, some people say that El Chapo and the brothers may have worked as hit men. It's hard to verify, but they remain at this stage pretty low level criminals. Right. So El Chapo kind of sets down roots. he meets and marries his first wife here in 1977. They'll have three kids, his first three of at least 12 kids in total. And his wife is also the first of at least three wives, probably four, each of whom he marries without divorcing the last one, which is kind of an interesting way of going about it.

10:50But in his early 20s, he starts getting itchy feet again. He moves to the state capital, which is a big city, and this is where he'll make his first big moves. And in all our billionaires, there are some key meetings with people we've talked about in other ones. And one of the key people he meets in the late 1970s is a guy called Hector Palmer, also known as El Guero. There's a lot of L's in this. There's the blue one, this means the fair-haired one. Hitman turned cocaine smuggler working for the Guadalajara cartel. So this cartel ultimately ladders up into a former cop, a guy called Miguel Angel Felix Gallardo.

11:26And this guy is the so-called boss of bosses. And he was doing something different here. He was professionalising the criminal drugs trade and becoming in the process its most powerful figure, the kingpin, if you like. So he was using things like safe houses, secret ranches, hidden phone lines. You know, he was creating new smuggling routes. He was really kind of making the drug trade a lot more, I guess, formalised. Yeah, more professional. And El Chapo works under him. And at this point, he's moving from the fringes, the low levels, right into the centre of organised crime, which is getting more organised.

12:01And El Chappell was in charge of planning and executing trafficking routes from Mexico into the US. And it's here that we start hearing about his lust for blood, to put it bluntly. There are reports that if the smugglers' shipments weren't on time, he would just shoot them in the head. And this is new territory, I think, in this series, because this is the first time we've actually talked about our billionaires directly killing people. We've done Victor Boot, who was an arms dealer and scored very highly on the villainy. but this is a different order. Oh, definitely. And I think that, you know, as we'll see in his story, that kind of lust for blood, it doesn't go away.

12:37It just gets even worse when the stakes get higher. It gets incredibly bloody. So in 1984, the Mexican military in Sinaloa sort of launched an increased crackdown. So they up sticks and move to the central Mexican region of Zacatecas, which becomes the new centre of the marijuana trade. And here he meets another El. He meets El Azul, the blue one, who's from a village that is very near El Chapel. So they've got that in common. And this guy has a 500 acre marijuana farm. He was involved in the heroin trade and he kind of takes El Chapel under his wing. So the guy finds a business mentor, if you want to put it that way.

13:13And there's something, there's an interesting shift going on in the drugs trade at the demand end of it. because in the late 70s, which was marijuana demand in the US, it's gone into the kind of Studio 54 disco era and cocaine overtakes weed as the drug of choice, if you like, for young Americans. I actually have an amazing fact about Studio 54 that just illustrates how much cocaine just took over in New York. So apparently at the end of every night, Studio 54 dropped a prop in the club of a moon with a spoonful of coke going up its nose. Really? As a kind of ta-da moment. But I think that just goes to show, you know, this is the moment where weed and the hippie era kind of crossed over into the kind of disco loving kind of Coke field Studio 54 party era.

13:59But the interesting thing about cocaine is it's not produced in Mexico. So Mexico assumes a different role in the food chain, if you like, here. It's produced in Colombia and it was previously shipped into the US via the Caribbean or just straight up smuggled on commercial flights. But those routes were being shut down. and the increased demand for more and more coke meant that it was getting harder to smuggle so they needed a new route in. And the best way to do that is on a land route which is so the Mexican border presents itself as the perfect place to get drugs into the US and there were already, as we know, marijuana and heroin had been crossing and this becomes the key route for cocaine as well.

14:38So Colombian gangsters start flying drugs into Mexico and their new partners, the Mexican gangs, are being paid to transport it across the border to operatives in the US. And this became known as the Mexican trampoline. You bounced it into the US. Yeah, exactly. And the thing about cocaine, and we talk about this as a commodity, as a product, it's easier to smuggle than weed. It doesn't smell like weed does. It is more valuable in smaller quantities. And also the markup on it, the profit margin is vast because it gets made by the kilo and sold by the gram. And I was trying to think with my business head on whether I could think of anything which has a higher profit margin than this.

15:16And actually, I came up with coffee. Because coffee actually, the reason there's so many coffee bars, because the margin, the markup on that is enormous. But as my friend who I called and said, listen, we're doing a programme about drugs, what's the profit margin of this compared to coffee? He said, the problem with coffee is you have to have, if you're Starbucks, you have to have the rent, the staff, you know, all of that kind of stuff. Whereas cocaine, you don't have any of those issues to deal with. Oh, interesting. I mean, both coffee and cocaine grown in Colombia. Exactly. They've got some cash crops out there.

15:46And so the trickle of cocaine from Mexico into the US becomes a flood. From 1960 to 1970, the authorities seized less than 30 kilos of cocaine. In 1985 alone, they seized five tonnes. And by 1989, it was 15 tonnes. And that's only what they seed. There's a lot of looking the other way that goes on, as we'll see. At this point, the DEA start kind of becoming a real force, right? And it's due to a guy called Kiki Camarena. You might know him if you've watched Narcos Mexico. He plays a really big part in the show. So he's Mexican-born, but an American citizen, and he's a DEA agent. And in 1984, he gives Mexican law enforcement a huge tip-off.

16:26They raid a massive 2 ,500-acre weed plantation, which is run by the Guadalajara Cotel. And it's thought it was generating an estimated$8 billion a year in revenue. So the cartels sought revenge on Kiki Camarena. And in 85, Camarena and his pilot are kidnapped by the corrupt Mexican officials who are in the boss of bosses pay. And a month later, their bodies are found. And this is the tough part. I mean, he had been horrifically tortured for two days. It said there was a doctor present to keep him conscious and alive in order to prolong his suffering. Oh, this is a very, very dirty business, isn't it?

17:06And Camarena basically becomes a bit of a hero, like a martyr. And he helps legitimise the DEA as a serious agency. And because they've done this to a DEA agent, the US and Mexican law enforcement have to respond, right? So they hunt down the leaders of the Guadalajara cartel. Yeah. And the boss, Gallardo, goes into hiding. He uses political connections to protect him and helps him to evade authorities for another four years. But because there's so much heat on them, they can't really control the Mexican drugs trade like they used to. So he holds a meeting with all the biggest drug traffickers.

17:41And this is going to be the making of El Chapo, right? Gallardo says, let's split Mexico into separate narco states. We'll call them plazas. I'll be the top guy. But all the plazas will have your own independence. So it gives them all their little fiefdoms. And someone has wittily suggested this is actually quite a good business practice. It's a bit like what Bernard Arnault. does with LVMH, one of the richest men in the world. He basically makes them all entrepreneurial little kind of empires within an empire. Right. So they all feel motivated to keep the profits rolling in. So all these different gangs are given their own kind of LVMH sub-brand.

18:18No, I mean, their own different drugs plaza. And this pushes the drugs business back into the shadows. It keeps the eyes of the authorities away. And crucially for our chapel, this is a big opportunity. Yeah, because he then can become sort of a head honcho of his own little cartel. So he, alongside Hector Palmer, he becomes leader of the newly formed Sinaloa cartel. It's not all smooth sailing because, you know, he's entering what you could call a competitive market. So when they started, they only had 25 guys in their employment. Not a lot. Yeah, and there were lots of rival cartels to compete with.

18:53You've got the Tijuana cartel who were going to come on to become Sinaloa's biggest rival. And it's impossible to say how much El Chappell was earning at this point. But, you know, it's fair to conclude that after he sets up his own cartel and starts controlling the movement of drugs and benefits from those profit margins, he would have easily been a millionaire. I mean, that's one of the things, you know, we like to try and be as factual as we can. But like I say, these guys don't file any reports or 10K filings or whatever with the Securities and Exchange Commission. But I think it's fair to say when you're sitting on something which is moving that much and is that profitable.

19:26Yes, he's easily a millionaire by then.

19:33Something mysterious plagues County Mayo on the west coast of Ireland and its legendary Gaelic football team. I believe in the curse. Yeah, I think it's real. Is it just superstition? Or could there be more to it? Sometimes I think there's something sinister going on. What do we need to do to win an All-Ileland final for Mayo? Listen to the curious tale of the Mayo curse on Amazing Sports Stories from the BBC World Service. Search for Amazing Sports Stories wherever you get your BBC podcasts. In business, they say you can have better, cheaper or faster, but you only get to pick two. What if you could have all three at the same time?

20:12That's exactly what Cohere, Thomson Reuters, and Specialized Bikes have since they upgraded to the next generation of the cloud. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure OCI is the blazing fast platform for your infrastructure, database, application development, and AI needs, where you can run any workload in a high availability, consistently high performance environment, and spend less than you would with other clouds. How is it faster? OCI's block storage gives you more operations per second. Cheaper? OCI costs up to 50 % less for computing, 70 % less for storage, and 80 % less for networking. Better? In test after test, OCI customers report lower latency and higher bandwidth versus other clouds.

20:57This is the cloud built for AI and all your biggest workloads. Right now, with zero commitment, try OCI for free. Head to oracle.com slash strategic. That's oracle.com slash strategic. Hey, Ryan, that was a fast trip. It was like you teleported. Yeah, just got in. I'll get all my expenses logged, I promise. Oh, no, you're okay. SAP Concur uses advanced AI, so your expense report will practically write itself. Quite the breakthrough. It's like we've been teleported into the future. All right. So, just curious, would you give us written permission to convert your matter into energy patterns and reassemble you at, say, random travel destinations?

21:32Margaret, are you building a teleporter? No. Yes. SAP Concur helps your business move forward faster. Learn more at concur.com. AI is now a must for companies and the executives in charge of steering them. But the path to implementation is not so clear. Which function or scenario or the use case do I start with that gives me the most value? I'm Chip Kranixl, host of Resilient Edge, a business vitality podcast paid and presented by Deloitte. Our latest episode has the answers to all these questions and more. Available now, wherever you listen to podcasts.

22:16And he's also coming up with innovative ways of moving the product in business speak. He was a real innovator. And in fact, some of it was by necessity because the Sinaloa cartel hasn't got the best geographical place for drug smuggling. It was just a small section of the US-Mexico border. So you didn't have a very long border. So they had to make what they had work better. Yeah, there were only two lanes of traffic that went from their area across into the US. So not exactly prime smuggling territory. And this is where he comes up with his perhaps the invention he's most famous for. Tunnels. tunnels will become very important to our chapel.

22:56So this is how the first tunnel works, right? And this tunnel is going to bring in a ton of money. He sets up in the border town between the US and Mexico, a place called Agua Prieta, and he sends a lawyer to work there who then buys a plot of land just outside town, above market value in cash, so nobody starts asking questions, and he builds a ranch house there. Meanwhile, across the border in the US, in the town of Douglas, Arizona, he buys a construction firm called Douglas Readymix, which had a warehouse about 200 feet north of his new home. And then he hires an architect to design a tunnel to build between these two locations.

23:33And this is the first cross-border narco tunnel in history. Yeah, and apparently a tap installed in the ranch house. It's actually a secret lever which has a hydraulic system, opens a hidden trapdoor underneath a pool table, which leads directly to the tunnel. And this tunnel is pretty big. I mean, it's five foot high by four feet. It had sections to store up to five tonnes of cocaine. And it runs directly beneath the fortifications along the US-Mexico border and emerges into, ta-da, the Douglas, Arizona warehouse. Yeah. And before long, the tunnel became the primary route for moving cocaine into the US.

Read the full transcript

24:12And federal agents have called these tunnels super tunnels because they have everything. They have electric lights, they have ventilation. Some of them even had elevators. So when the cocaine gets across the border and into the warehouse in Arizona, it then gets loaded into cars and trucks and driven out to Phoenix and whatever, where it was cut up and distributed across the USA. So they've kind of taken the border out of the equation here. They don't need to worry about it. And in fact, estimates say that between 88 and 91, El Chapo smuggles 35 tonnes of cocaine into Arizona alone. But it wasn't just the tunnel.

24:43That wasn't the only means of transport. On the Mexican side, the Sinaloa cartel built their own airstrip about 100 miles south of the border. And that's where the Colombians would fly in with their planes filled with cocaine. And meanwhile, he's trying to give himself a bit of room to manoeuvre, right? So he's cultivating these relationships with corrupt Mexican security officials. is he's paying them off to make sure they turn a blind eye to all the smuggling. And this is where the profit margins in drugs comes into play, because between where it's produced and where it's, you know, there's a lot of margin in there.

25:16And you need that for the dealers and the payoffs and the security and the weapons. So it's a good job there are such big profit margins, because everyone wants to take a slice, including corrupt officials and police. And don't forget the tunnels. But because of them, he could move drugs into the US in bigger quantities, faster and cheaper. And then in 1990, he meets a 27-year-old Colombian, a drug trafficker known as Chupita or Lollipop, and he makes an even better deal to import all this cocaine. Yeah, because Mexican smugglers had been charging, where this is written down, I don't know, but had been charging 37 % for moving Colombian cocaine.

25:53But El Chapo wants 40%, but he says he can move it faster and safer. So 3 % difference. It's quite a lot if you're talking in, you know, the millions. I suppose it is. I mean, it's a bit like anything. If you can do it in bulk, you get a slightly better deal. And El Chapo earned those margins, right? So he demonstrated he could move 4 ,000 kilos in a week while other traffickers took a month. So he got a new nickname, El Rapido. El Rapido, El Rapido. And actually, when Lollipop spoke as a witness at El Chapo's trial in 2018, he revealed astonishing profits. He claimed that between 1990 and 1996, El Chapo made as much as$640 million just from his cocaine, lollipops cocaine.

26:35And that's only part of the business empire, right? So El Chapo is well on his way to becoming a billionaire. And by 1990, as well as the tunnel, which he became famous for, the cartel also was using things like ships, fishing vessels, speedboats, even submarines. This is a lot of drugs. I mean, according to one former federal prosecutor, El Chapo was the go-to guy. when the US started shutting down ports of entry in the Atlantic and the Pacific, drugs had to go through Mexico. And if it went through Mexico, it had to go through El Chapo. Yeah, and by this point, the boss of bosses, Mr Gallardo, has been arrested.

27:10So El Chapo is now fully in control. And he makes himself an even better deal. So rather than being paid by the Colombians to smuggle the drugs, he buys their cocaine and sells it on in the US himself and keeps a much bigger slice of the profits. So he's not just a delivery guy now. He's an actual trader of it. He's buying and selling himself. It's kind of slightly reminiscent of, you know, Amazon creating its own products based on the products that are selling well on Amazon. Yes, that's true. And like I say, so talking about the margins again, rough numbers, we think. A kilo of cocaine, which was selling for$3 ,000, about£2 ,500 in Colombia, would be worth$10 ,000 in Mexico and then$30 ,000 in the US.

27:56And once you cut it up and sell it by the gram, it could make over£100 ,000. So you're talking a markup of£3 ,000 to£100 ,000 per kilo, which is a huge profit margin. And that means a lot of money is coming in. So he's got to find ways to launder that money. And we should just sort of probably take a moment to discuss what we mean by money laundering. Because, you know, if you take sackfuls of money into the local bank and start depositing it, people's eyebrows get raised pretty quickly. And so much of this reminds me of Breaking Bad as well, doesn't it? You'll remember that Walter White in Breaking Bad buys a car wash, which you have to pay in cash.

28:33So all these people are paying cash. There's cash going over the till. and then you just filter that cash bit by bit into the legal proceeds and you deposit that money in the local bank and it seems much more legitimate. So that's one way of money laundering. So El Chapo was using this method called structuring, which means depositing amounts smaller than£10 ,000 to avoid the bank tellers having to report it to the authorities. Anyway, the money's rolling in and he starts to enjoy spending it. So his former pilot, who testified during his trial, said that when he first met Mr Guzman in 1986, he didn't have a jet.

29:09In the 90s, he already had four jets. He had houses on every beach, he had a ranch in every state. And he bought loyalty. His henchmen were given gifts like diamond studded Rolexes, expensive cars. He paid close associates like Martinez, who testified against him, a million dollars in cash every December. Can you imagine a million dollars in cash? This reminds me a little bit of the scenes in Scarface when he starts spending all his money. And in fact, there's a scene in Scarface where you see Al Pacino with a little zoo. Yeah, I mean, this is his house in Acapulco, which he built for$10 million.

29:45He had a zoo with a little train riding around that you could see the lions and tigers and panthers. I mean, it's wild. And funnily enough, it's quite interesting to know how he's treated by his own people. And he sort of has a bit of a reputation as a Robin Hood figure. So taking from the rich, the arrogant gringos and giving a living to the hardworking Latino poor, which is an interesting way of looking at it. It's also a good way to buy yourself a bit of protection and breathing room, right? Because no one wants to dob in the guy who's seen as Robin Hood. Yeah. But I mean, you know, we have a category for philanthropy.

30:20And I'm not sure whether that counts as philanthropy, because journalists who've looked into this have struggled to identify anything like a school or a hospital or anything like that funded by him. So it seems more like he was big into the business of marketing himself as much as anything else. So he's making tons of money and whenever money is being made, there is competition to be had. And at this point, the war between the cartels begins to get really bloody. So after Gallardo, the boss of bosses, is arrested in 89, this turf war breaks out between the Sinaloa cartel and their rivals, the Tijuana cartel.

30:55The Tijuana cartel actually behead the wife of El Chapo's partner, Hector Palmer, and send him her head in a box. Yeah, oh, it's pretty grim stuff. And they do not stop there. So weeks later, they actually murder Hector Palmer's children, a five-year-old son, four-year-old daughter. Well, the Sinaloa cartel hits back. The tit-for-tat violence over the next four years sees a series of assassinations, car bombings. At one point, El Chapo's men indiscriminately opened fire in a discotheque. And the thing about this tit-for-tat war is that, unfortunately, it doesn't end until the big boss is killed.

31:32But when this turf war broke out, none of the big bosses ever got killed. But they did make a serious error while attempting to assassinate El Chapo. And it's this error in 1993 that completely changes the game for them. Yeah, one of the most senior priests in the Mexican Catholic Church, a cardinal, is shot dead in the airport. And it's thought that the assassins thought the cardinal who was getting into this fancy car was, in fact, El Chapo. And obviously, the fallout from this murder is huge. There's a huge political uproar because the Mexican government is finally forced to crack down on the drug gangs in a big way to demonstrate to the public they're doing something about this.

32:09And so they put a big bounty on his head. His face is in the newspapers. It's on TV screens. he's becoming famous now around the world. And he's no longer anonymous, so he flees Mexico, but within weeks is arrested in Guatemala and extradited back to Mexico. And there he is sentenced to 20 years on charges of conspiracy, drug trafficking and bribery. I think it's so interesting this, it says something about Mexico and the role of the Catholic Church in Mexico, that all this was going on. You kill a cardinal, that's not OK. Yeah, kill a cardinal, we're coming after you. But I actually think El Chappell kind of viewed the stint behind bars as a sort of sabbatical from work.

32:45Yeah, because as we know, with his tunnelling expertise, he's a master. He could probably have got out of here at any time he wanted. But because the heat is on at the moment and he's in the public eye, this is quite a good place to lay low for a bit. Yeah, and Martinez and Hector Palmer still keep running things on the outside. You know, he's got money to bribe the guards, so he's got regular visits from sex workies. He's even got deliveries of Viagra coming in. And so if you're a notorious criminal, you can actually live a pretty good life inside. But while he is inside the US authorities, and that's the one he fears the most, they're starting to put together a case against him.

33:21And in 1995, he's indicted in San Diego for money laundering and conspiracy to import cocaine. So that same year, El Chapo is transferred to a maximum security prison in Mexico, where he still enjoys, you know, privileges. You know, he pays a cook$1 ,500 a month to prepare lobster for him. You know, he's paying money to everyone to turn a blind eye. But 2000 brings a very different kind of turning point. Yeah, because Mexico elects Vicente Fox for the first time. I remember this happening actually in 2000 because a lot of people said it was amazing because it was the first time in 70 years that a party that wasn't the pre, the Institutional Revolutionary Party, who had been in power for 70 years up to that point, there was actually a calm transfer of power, which no one was expecting actually.

34:08And Fox has cast himself as this anti-corruption reformer. So El Chapo starts getting a bit nervous, right? Maybe this guy's going to extradite him to the US and that would be the worst thing possible for him. So at this point, he decides escape is the right option. So in January 2001, he hides in the laundry cart, but people say he could have walked out the door because he was helped by so many corrupt officials, some of whom are eventually imprisoned for their role in this escape. And he becomes Mexico's most wanted man. But, you know, you can use this term loosely because by all accounts, he was able to just kind of walk around at well.

34:41Apparently, he visited his mum back in Latuna. Well, I think that people are so terrified of him. Who's going to go and turn him in? I mean, you know, I mean, I hope he's not listening right now because, you know, I don't fancy being tortured and killed myself. I mean, he even feels free enough to marry an 18 year old beauty queen in a lavish ceremony. And he just walks into things like restaurants with a posse of bodyguards. He then takes everyone's mobile phone off them. I'd hand mine over it in a heartbeat. So he could sit down, eat his favourite meal without being tipped off to the authorities.

35:12And then on leaving, he gives everyone their phone back and pays for everyone's meal. I still don't think I would have had the most relaxing evening meal there, would you? No, I think I would have excused myself to the bathroom and climbed out of the window. Yes. So he's out and he's back in control of the Mexican drug strain. And he's even expanding into other drugs too. So in the noughties, crystal meth usage explodes in America and his two sons, Ovidio and Joaquin Jr., begin smuggling chemicals from Argentina to experiment with producing meth. And Ovidio will later again help his father keep up with the times, changing tastes of the drug public.

35:47He starts manufacturing cheap versions of fentanyl for the cartel to flood the American market. And again, the markup is wild. So$800 of chemicals can be turned into fentanyl pills or powder, and it could sell for as much as$640 ,000 on the market. That's an astonishing markup. And I think it's kind of a moment to reflect on the fact that, you know, we've said before, you don't get rich without giving people what they need, want or enjoy. I'm not sure which category fentanyl and cocaine falls into, but the point is there's enormous demand for this. The US public is fuelling this trade, and it's thought that between 2006 to 2016, the money spent by Americans on cannabis, cocaine, heroin and crystal meth was around$120 to$140 billion a year.

36:38To compare that, the US spend on alcohol in 2017 was 158 billion. So this is a massive market. Right. It's a huge industry. And, you know, no tax, no government's getting any money off it. It's all underground. So there's no regulation. And El Chappell becomes the biggest player in essentially the biggest black market sector going. But the violence continues and is getting more intense. And actually, the president Vicente Fonks, his new regime has not stemmed the bloodshed. And so we have a new president in Mexico. He launches Mexico's own war on drugs, sends six and a half thousand troops into his own home state.

37:17And the cost of the drug war to Mexico is huge. So the government is blowing$54 billion on security and defense. And it's done so since 2007. And critics say this influx of cash has created corruption on every level. And it's statistics like this that kind of inform the debate about legalisation. Sometimes people saying if you did legalise it, you could tax it, you could regulate it. The cost has also been a human one, right? So since 2007, around 200 ,000 people have been murdered in Mexico. And, you know, El Chapo is not immune to this tragedy either. So he fell out with the Beltran Labour brothers who thought that he was betraying them.

37:55So they came after his son, Edgar. Yeah, he was gunned down outside a shopping mall a month after being released from prison himself. But despite all the deaths, despite all the bloodshed, the money is still rolling in. So by 2009, it's thought that Mexico makes more money moving drugs than exporting oil, which is its biggest legitimate foreign currency earner. And this is recognised by the folks at Forbes who compile the rich list. And they put El Chapo onto his list controversially for the first time that year. They estimate his wealth in 2009 to be$1 billion. That put him at number 701 on their list of the world's richest people.

38:36And according to the DEA, he becomes the leading drug trafficker of all time. He's said to have imported more drugs into America than anyone else. And so it's official. In 2009, El Chapo is a billionaire. And I understand there were baseball hats with like 701 written on it to celebrate the fact that he came in at 701 on the Forbes Rich List. So he's a celebrity. In many ways, he's a kind of gruesome celebrity. He is. And, you know, he's gotten rich by cutting a trail of murder and devastation and, you know, probably addiction. Yeah.

39:19His biggest fear is the US. Those are the authorities he fears the most. And in 2011, after Osama bin Laden died, he becomes the USA's most wanted person. Right. Five million dollars for valuable information leading to his capture. That's a lot of money on the table. And when he is eventually tried in the US, El Chapo claims he paid a 100 million dollar bribe to the new president, President Nieto, when he took office during this period. allegations that Mr Nieto strenuously denies. Still, it's going to take another three years until El Chapo is recaptured. And in 2014, he's arrested in Sinaloa by the Mexican Navy in collaboration with the DEA.

39:59And he's returned back to his old home into the Altiplano Penitentiary and put into solitary confinement while the US continues to build its case and pushes for extradition. So he hatches, and this is the part that is the truly crazy bit about his story, He hatches his most audacious plan for escape. In 2015, I'm just like setting it up in my head here. He walks over to his little cell. He kind of like moves behind this little partition wall that separates the security camera from the shower bit. And then he just disappears. Yeah, he doesn't appear for 25 minutes. Guards go to check on him. They discover he's escaped through, guess what?

40:38It's a tunnel. Yes. The entrance of the tunnel is a one and a half foot gap in the shower floor and beneath that there's a 32 foot ladder into a tunnel which is a mile long. It's only just a little bit taller than El Chapo himself but you know it's got lights, it's got a ventilation system, it's even got a motorbike on a little rail to quickly transport him so you can just sit on the motorbike and zoom off. How do you build a one mile tunnel and a 32 foot hole right down without everyone in the prison knowing about it? So apparently the prisoners in the jail had complained about all this racket of the tunnel being built to prison officials, but they were all being paid off to look the other way.

41:21I can just imagine the guards going, what, I can't hear anything, what, what, what? Something's wrong with your hearing, mate. It strains credulity at this point, which is in a way, I think, why we're so fascinated by these stories. And of course, this Robin Hood image, it's a bit like getting away from the Sheriff of Nottingham again. It enhances that whole image he's got. That story of the prison escape alone, I think that was what made him world famous. Yeah. And he sometimes calls a sort of narco saint, sort of a folk hero rather than the sort of brutal criminal that we know he is. And we'll have to say, you know, his criminal enterprises did provide money for a lot of the people in these remote areas.

41:58You know, they make a living producing poppies and marijuana for his cartel. And bizarrely, in an interview that he conducted with Sean Penn for some reason while he was on the lam after this motorcycle escape, that's what his defence was for getting into the drug trade. There's no other job to do when you're born into a position like I was in the middle of nowhere with no money. This is what I had to do to stay alive. Yeah. And that interview in Rolling Stone was very controversial. I saw Marco Rubio was in the presidential race. He said, you might think this kind of thing sells magazines, whatever.

42:29I find it grotesque, the fact that they did this interview. And also, if you can still watch it on Rolling Stone, it's a very odd interview. I highly recommend looking it up. So he's on the run. He's possibly the most famous fugitive anywhere in the world. He's appearing in Rolling Stone magazine. But in January 2016, the Mexican Marines, with help from the US Marshals Service and the DEA, they recapture him in a violent standoff during a raid at a roadside motel back in Sinaloa, back in his hometown, which left five people dead. And a year later, Mexico finally extradites El Chapo to the US and he faces 11 counts of drug trafficking and is locked up in a high security prison in New York, presumably away from the nearest tunnel.

43:11Yeah, and as they were picking a jury to try him, some jurors were excused because they were, I think, quite understandably afraid. I mean, you know, would you want to be in that jury? Oh, absolutely not. I was like, I'm burning every single piece of correspondence that has ever asked me to be on this jury. Yeah, well, the lawyers start making their opening statements in November 2018. The trial gets underway. And when people start to testify, this is when people really start to see the measure of this man, because the stuff that people have to say about El Chapo is just grim. Yeah, his bodyguard tells the court he personally witnessed El Chapo brutally beat and torture three members of a rival drug cartel before murdering them.

43:50Another witness said that El Chapo buried a man alive. Another said a rival drug lord who refused to shake El Chapo's hand paid with his life for that insult. And, you know, the court papers also accused him of drugging and raping girls who were as young as 13. Apparently he called them his vitamins. Gross. Anyway, he has found guilty of 10 counts of drug trafficking. At sentencing later that year, he's given life plus 30 years. And he's also ordered to pay back over$12 billion, which the prosecutors say he has earned from his criminal activity. So we've got a pretty precise number there. The prosecutors have told us exactly how much money they think he made.

44:29Yep. But it doesn't put an end to the drug war. So when he's convicted, that year is the most bloody yet in Mexico. It launches this latest phase of the so-called war on drugs. There were 33 ,341 killings, which was 33 % more than 2017. So he may be gone, he may be banged up, but the violence and the mayhem continues. I mean, in many ways, this is going to be one of the easiest things we've had to judge. Exactly. So, well, let's judge our chapel.

45:07We always start with wealth. This one is actually pretty hard to pin down. The US prosecutors reckon it was$12 billion, but like I say, it's not the kind of thing that you can look up in the annual report. But if you go by Forbes' list, right, 701 is not particularly high up in the list of billionaires. So in drug terms, he's a kingpin. In the world of billionaires, he's kind of small fry. On the other hand, he does wear his wealth very extravagantly. I mean, he's not sending off drug traffickers into space, but, you know, he did buy a zoo. Yeah, the thing about the zoo and having a ranch in every state and having four aeroplanes, I secretly suspect he's got more money than Forbes actually estimated, although things are a bit cheaper in Mexico.

45:48So, yeah, I mean, he wears it well. He wears it, I mean, when it comes to ostentatious displays of wealth, he's every bit the bling drug dealer. Oh, yeah. I actually read something somewhere that said that he had a pistol that was encrusted with diamonds in his initials. Yeah, I can well believe that. OK, for wealth, I'm going to give him a four. Well, I mean, the diamond pistol makes me think. Diamond pistol? OK. Six out of ten for me. OK, four for me, six for you. Rags to riches. I mean, it's quite a journey. And it's a well-trodden one in Mexico. coming from what I assume is a very poor underdeveloped village in a mountain range in the middle of nowhere in Mexico to you know federal prison and I mean it's it's a stuff of biopics really yeah it's a rather tragic kind of rags to riches story in a way isn't it it's not an aspirational one it's almost the opposite of that I'm sure at its high points he must have felt on top of the world yeah no one forced him to become the most wanted person in the world right But the point is that if you wanted to make money, there were very few routes available for you to do that in Mexico.

46:57I think I would give him, and this is not to condone the way he made his money, I would give him an 8 out of 10. OK. I'll give him an 8 as well. So he's got a great story, but what about the villainy aspect? This is where we have to compare notes with our previous billionaires, right? So we gave Victor Boot a 10 on Villainy. And we should have probably given him a 9 because we knew El Chapo was coming up. So, I mean, can we go for 11? Can we dial it up to 11, Spinal Tap Style? I think Spinal Tap Style. We'll have to give him an 11. For 11, I mean, there's so many shocking accounts of his violence.

47:39You know, a former weapons smuggler said he had a murder room in his mansion on the US border. The room had white tiles, was soundproof, so no noise could come out. A drain on the floor to clean up after slayings. In that house, no one comes out. And this is just gruesome. Yeah. You know, Victor Boots sold weapons to warlords and dictators that probably, I don't know, killed hundreds of thousands of people. But as far as we know, he never directly killed anyone. Right. So, yeah. I mean, this is 11. And probably worth making the point as well is that, you know, the people who made him rich ultimately are the people who took the drugs that he exported.

48:18So, you know, perhaps we should not be able to sort of wash our hands of his villainy in some ways. Oh, definitely. I think it says a lot that the illegal drugs market in America is almost as much as to market for legal, legitimate alcohol. I mean, you know, like you say, a lot of the people in our podcast got rich by giving people what they wanted. But having said that, the drugs that he was selling, especially fentanyl, caused a lot of damage. And it's still causing a lot of damage in the US. You know, fentanyl deaths are soaring. In 2019, it accounted for 51 % of overdose deaths. And then by 2021, it's 66%.

48:56Yeah. So in many ways, some of his customers are also his victims. Exactly. And don't forget, fentanyl is up to 50 times stronger than heroin. So it's addictive stuff. Yeah. So sorry, Victor, we're demoting you to a nine and El Chapo, you're getting an 11, spinal tap style. Yeah. Let's come to the category that might, well, I mean, El Chapo would probably like to think that this rehabilitates his image, but the philanthropy he did, what did he actually do? Well, we know that he would dish out money left, right and centre. He was a folk hero who seemed to give employment to people. He had this Robin Hood kind of image, but no one's actually been able to find any kind of school or hospital or anything with El Chapo's name on it.

49:38Yeah. And actually, the mayor of where El Chappell was born told journalists that he couldn't see a single building producing jobs, a single piece of public works, a soccer field, a sewer, a school, etc. Not a single one that you can say was built by drug traffickers or their money. So that's pretty damning. OK. So if philanthropy means the love of humans, wanton death and destruction is probably, you know, what he traded in. Yeah, I mean, he himself claims to have killed over 2 ,000 people. That's a lot of people to have killed. I would give him a zero. I would say that given how many people have died either violently through the trade or in overdoses or in pitch gun battles or what have you, I think there's a strong case that he comes in with a negative number for philanthropy.

50:26I don't know if I can do negatives on this. The scale is expanding. The scale is expanding. I'm going to give him minus 10. I mean, if our chap was listening, and I hope he isn't. Oh, God, don't say that. I'm going to give him minus. Oh, my God, I'm going to be looking over my shoulder on the way home from this. OK, now, power. Interesting one. If the difficulties in catching him and incarcerating him and keeping him there are anything to go by, he seemed to live almost above the law. He was able to buy off anyone he wanted. I mean, he operated a criminal organisation for decades that brought in tons of money.

51:08Whether or not it's true, the audaciousness in claiming you tried to bribe the Mexican president, that's a lot of power that you think you have. Yeah, I think within Mexico, he was very feared and fear is a form of power. So I think he's quite a powerful person. Yeah. At the height of his power, I would probably give him an 8 out of 10. OK, I'm going to agree. 8 out of 10 for power. So then we come to legacy. So assuming El Chapo never leaves prison, will live out the rest of his life and die behind bars, how are we going to regard his legacy? He's not the only famous drug dealer, is he? And you've had Pablo Escobar, there are other ones as well.

51:45And you do suspect that it's a trade by its very nature that once he's locked up, it continues. The trade goes on without him. He's notorious and he became famous because he came out of the shadows. but the trade won't miss him, that's what I'm saying. Yeah, someone else will always rise up to take his place like he did with Gallardo. Yeah, exactly. So there'll always be somebody else. I think one thing he has done, both him and Escobar have created a mythology around this which has been richly mined for TV and film and what have you. His legacy in a way is sustained through films and stereotypes of this kind of behaviour.

52:26Right. And even music, because in Mexico you have these songs called Narco Corridos, which are songs celebrating and talking about these drug traffickers. And, you know, Billboard magazine even has like a top 10 list of Narco Corridos written about El Chapo. So his legacy is one of death and fear, his notorious acts of escapology more than as much as anything else. His innovations to drug trafficking, maybe those things will be remembered. So for legacy, I'm going to give him a six. Yeah, I'm going to give him a six. I feel like he'll pass into pop culture mythology more because of his escapes.

53:02But when you hear about what he actually did, I mean, oh. Okay, so final judgment. Good. This is so easy. Good, bad, or just another billionaire. This is one bad hombre, isn't it? This is a very, very bad man. So I hope you're not listening, but I'm afraid El Chapo, we judge you as a bad billionaire. Do they get podcasts in prison? I really hope not. I hope to God they don't.

53:31Who's our next billionaire? We've got a big hitter, not just in media, but also on the world stage. It's Rupert Murdoch. Yeah, I really hope you've enjoyed this. It's been absolutely fascinating to make. We've covered everything from luxury to rap to drugs to the legal arms trade. There's something for everyone in this. I hope you enjoy it. And if you do, tell a friend. Thanks for listening to Good Bad Billionaire. This podcast is produced by Hannah Hufford and Mark Ward. James Cook is our editor and it's a BBC audio production.

From the publisher

The story of Mexican drug lord Joaquín Archivaldo Guzmán Loera, better known as El Chapo, the leader of one of the world’s most prolific, violent and powerful drug cartels.

BBC business editor Simon Jack and journalist Zing Tsjeng follow El Chapo from childhood in the Mexican mountain region of Sinaloa to the very top of the drug business, and into the New York prison cell where he now resides.

Simon and Zing reveal how El Chapo innovated with tunnels along the US-Mexican border, escaped prison twice, and used extreme violence to gain power. Then they are given the simple task of deciding if he's good, bad, or just another billionaire.

We’d love to hear your feedback. Email goodbadbillionaire@bbc.com or drop us a text or WhatsApp to +1 (917) 686-1176.

To find out more about the show and read our privacy notice, visit www.bbcworldservice.com/goodbadbillionaire

More from Good Bad Billionaire

All 110 episodes
El Chapo: Cocaine kingpinGood Bad Billionaire · 51 min
Listen in VO