In short
Screen Talk (IndieWire) hosts Anne Thompson and Ryan Latanzio discuss recent New York Film Festival picks and trailers, then interview Roofman producer Jamie Patricof (Jamie Patrykhoff).
Topic
Reviews and festival talk about Bradley Cooper’s Is This Thing On? (Searchlight; Dec. 19) and Josh Safdie’s secret NYFF screening Marty Supreme, plus Sundance trailer Rebuilding (Josh O’Connor). They also cover documentary/awards buzz (Laura Poitras’ Seymour Hersh cover-up, Orwell, 2,000 Meters to Andrivka, Alabama Solution, Perfect Neighbor).
Key claims
Is This Thing On? is not an Oscar contender but could play commercially; Marty Supreme is a frenetic Oscar-ready crowd-pleaser; Rebuilding is “sweet” and magnetically watchable despite sadness.
Notable examples
Will Arnett’s therapeutic standup setup with Laura Dern; Marty Supreme’s ping-pong training and grifter behavior; Roofman’s true-story elements (McDonald’s roof break-in, hiding in Toys R Us).
Guests
Jamie Patricof/Patrykhoff—longtime producer via Hunting Lane Films; produced Half Nelson (introduced Ryan Gosling), Blue Valentine, The Place Beyond the Pines, Mississippi Grind; longtime collaborator with director Derek Cianfrance.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VONYFF Highlights and New Films
0:54 to 2:15
Discussion of films seen at the New York Film Festival, including 'Is This Thing On?' and 'Marty Supreme'.
“And I'm Ryan Latanzio, still in New York as ever.”
Rebuilding: A Sundance Film
2:15 to 3:38
Review of 'Rebuilding' and the performance of Josh O'Connor in the film.
“is especially magnetically watchable and especially sad in this movie, which is written and directed by Max Silverman Walker.”
Exploring 'Is This Thing On?'
3:38 to 5:22
In-depth analysis of Bradley Cooper's 'Is This Thing On?' and its themes.
“And I particularly, I like him when he's being, we've talked about this.”
Will Arnett's Performance
5:22 to 7:38
Discussion of Will Arnett's role in 'Is This Thing On?' and his character's journey.
“But for people who've been married and know the challenges of marriage, you know, I think it's something you can relate to.”
Expectations vs. Reality in Film
7:38 to 9:26
Conversation about audience expectations and the film's marketing strategies.
“And I think the screenplay is excellent.”
Delight in 'Marty Supreme'
9:26 to 12:23
Excited review of 'Marty Supreme', its themes, and Timothee Chalamet's role.
“Well, it finds their way back, not necessarily to the marriage, but to themselves, to their own identity, who they really, really are.”
The Pulse of 'Marty Supreme'
12:23 to 14:00
Analysis of the film's pacing, character motivations, and potential awards buzz.
“It's going to be at the AFI Fest, so I'll catch it when I get back.”
Marty Supreme and Timothée Chalamet's Performance
14:00 to 16:55
Discussion about Timothée Chalamet's performance in 'Marty Supreme' and its Oscar potential.
“In this case, Timothee Chalamet is right in his zone.”
Impact of the Safdie Brothers' Aesthetic
16:55 to 19:36
Exploration of the anxiety-driven aesthetic in Safdie Brothers' films and its influence on 'Marty Supreme'.
“And I think that Timmy, Timmy, now we're on Timmy terms, Timothy, Timothée, whatever you want to say, Timothy Chalamet is going to win the Oscar this time.”
Film Festival Reactions
19:36 to 23:19
Reflections on audience reactions to various films shown at the New York Film Festival.
“I caught up with a number of things I needed to see, so it was very useful for me.”
Show all 23 chapters
Documentary Highlights and Themes
23:19 to 25:04
Discussing key documentaries from the festival, including their themes and impact.
“It doesn't consider anyone who's a criminal, not human.”
Collaboration with Derek Cianfrance
25:39 to 28:00
Jamie Patricof shares his long-standing collaboration with director Derek Cianfrance.
“No, no, we're excited to talk to you about Roofman, which just opened this weekend.”
The Journey of Collaboration with Derek Cianfrance
28:00 to 29:03
Learn about the long creative partnership between Jamie Patricof and filmmaker Derek Cianfrance, exploring their unique collaborative process.
“But unfortunately, or fortunately, you can't really put Derek C.”
Challenges in Developing Roofman
29:03 to 30:01
Discover the hurdles faced in getting the film Roofman greenlit by studios and the unique characteristics of its lead character.
“That's part of what we talked about with him.”
The Unconventional Nature of Roofman
30:01 to 31:12
Explore how Roofman blends traditional studio film elements with offbeat storytelling, featuring a unique lead character.
“And, you know, this is definitely a different type of film for him.”
Casting and Character Dynamics
31:12 to 32:58
Learn about the casting choices for Roofman and how actors contributed to shaping their characters.
“So, you know, the development process is challenging always.”
The Intersection of Comedy and Tragedy
32:58 to 34:18
Delve into the film's exploration of comedy and tragedy, and how these elements shape the protagonist's journey.
“And I think a lot of that has to do with having Kirsten as his screen partner, who is someone who is used to working in really naturalistic registers.”
Staying True to the True Story
34:18 to 35:58
Understand how the filmmakers maintained the authenticity of the true story behind Roofman while adapting it for film.
“and his wife, Shannon, is an accomplished filmmaker in her own right, and she's the comedian of the family, but much more dramatic at home.”
The Allure of Derek Cianfrance's Direction
35:58 to 37:51
Examine the reasons why actors are eager to work with Derek Cianfrance and the creative freedom he offers.
“use a fair number of the people who actually participated in jeff's life during that time whether it was somebody from the McDonald's, the prison guards, the captain.”
Anticipating Audience Reception
37:51 to 39:51
Discuss the anticipated audience for Roofman and the filmmakers' strategies for reaching a wider demographic.
“Like, who would the audience be for this movie?”
Reflections on Filmmaking and Podcasting
39:51 to 42:00
Explore the connection between filmmaking and podcasting through Jamie Patricof's experiences and insights.
“So you're hoping that it will have a good word of mouth over the, after an$8 million weekend.”
Exploring Jamie's Podcast Journey
42:00 to 45:38
Discover how Jamie's passion for conversation evolved into a podcast and newsletter.
“And it's like we're beyond proud of what the final product was.”
Upcoming Film Projects
45:38 to 46:50
Jamie discusses future film projects and the creative process behind them.
“Derek has a couple of projects that we're working on that we're hoping one that took us 18 years already may be coming next year.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:02That's the sound of zero sugar, 200 milligrams of caffeine and the power to burn body fat. Storm, energy for life. Storm Energy Blend helps boost metabolism, which in combination with exercise and a healthy diet helps burn fat. This product alone does not produce weight loss. Individual results may vary.
0:20Ryan Lattanzio:On the evening of March 31st, 1943, legendary lyricist Lawrence Hart confronts his shattered self-confidence in Sardi's bar as his former collaborator Richard Rogers celebrates the opening night of his groundbreaking hit musical, Oklahoma. From Richard Linklater, Blue Moon, starring Ethan Hawke, Margaret Qualley, Bobby Carnevale, and Andrew Scott, now playing in New York and Los Angeles nationwide October 24th. Welcome to Screen Talk, IndieWire's weekly podcast, bringing you up to speed on what's going on in Hollywood. I'm Anne Thompson. I'm still in New York. And I'm Ryan Latanzio, still in New York as ever.
1:00Ryan Lattanzio:Obviously, the New York Film Festival is over, but there are a couple of movies we've seen since we last met in person when we had Film at Lincoln Center director Daniel Batsik on. And that includes the closing night film, which is Bradley Cooper's third feature as a director, Is This Thing On? And we also saw the secret screening, which turned out to be, as many guessed, Josh Safdie's Marty Supreme. Oh, that's right. We get to talk about that. That'll be fun. Later on in the podcast, please stay tuned for our interview with producer Jamie Patrickoff, who also has a great sub stack called Lunch with Jamie.
1:38He is going to talk about Roofman, which is opening, has just opened this weekend. And we're going to talk about a lot of other things too. I also caught up with a Sundance movie that released its trailer this week, Josh O 'Connor's Rebuilding, a movie I was skeptical about because, you know, one of my favorite plummy British actors is playing a Colorado rancher who has lost his house in a fire. The movie shares some elements of Nomadland in the sense that this lonely, sad, bereft guy finds community with a group of others who have lost their homes. But I have to say O 'Connor is excellent. He seems to have perfected the art of being sad in such films as La Camara and The History of Sound.
2:22But he's always magnetically watchable. What do you think, Ryan? This was at Sundance.
2:26Ryan Lattanzio:is especially magnetically watchable and especially sad in this movie, which is written and directed by Max Silverman Walker. And it's shot on location in Colorado, where many locals were also invited to participate in the production. And this movie in which Josh O 'Connor's character is, as the title suggests, rebuilding his life after a wildfire has ravaged his home and his ranch. It's reconnecting with his ex-wife, who's played by Megan Fahey, and is connecting with other people who've been afflicted by wildfires, which also includes Callie Reese, who we liked a lot in The True Detective most recent season.
3:04Ryan Lattanzio:But this was a movie that a lot of people went to at Sundance. I mean, I don't know if they were trepidatious about it or anything because it hit especially close to home, right? Because this was a Sundance that was happening on the fields of Alcadena and Palisades fires. And this movie is very much about our modern world and vulnerability to such things. And this is a really nice, sweet movie that I enjoyed very much. And it's another, I mean, he's not given a bad performance, Josh O 'Connor. No, he hasn't. No, he hasn't. And I particularly, I like him when he's being, we've talked about this.
3:43I liked him a lot in Challengers. You know, that's the sweet spot where he gets to be kind, you know, at the same time, a little messed up, You know, not a perfect guy, but very sexy. You know, so I like it when he gets to channel some of those parts of his personality.
4:03Ryan Lattanzio:Those are like a lot of his other parts, such as God's Own Country. Remember the movie they work out in? Repressed gay guy, also messed up, also sexy. You could say that is similarly the case to, well, I wouldn't know, but I'm not sure about the Knives Out movie if sexy would apply to him in this case. I still haven't seen that. I'm going to catch up with that in Middleburg when I go, which is where I'm going after this. Let's do Bradley Cooper. Okay, so you went to see it in the morning and then you reviewed it. So I actually saw what your review was right around the time that I was getting out of the nighttime premiere movie.
4:40So I got to see it with the big audience at Alice Tully Hall, where it played very well. It was clearly working for the room. but what the question is is what kind of movie is this is this a movie that's going to be in the oscar race no it's not that kind of movie is it a movie that might play for audiences yes i think it might it might actually work um and it's entertaining and it's fun and as a woman who's been married and and broken up with her husband and someone who never divorced him um and someone
5:16Ryan Lattanzio:Stay connected to your husband. I stayed connected to him. So that's whatever. But for people who've been married and know the challenges of marriage, you know, I think it's something you can relate to. And the big discovery for me is Will Arnett. This guy is very, very good in this and very hunky and sad. He's another sad guy. but he comes into his own by going to talk about his troubles, his breakup with Laura Dern. His wife is Laura Dern at a comedy club in the village. So he has a day job. He's like a finance guy, but he goes and he, he's not good at standup. It's not like he's hilariously funny.
6:01That's clearly a decision they made not to try to make him hilariously funny, but to let him work through his troubles in a sort of therapeutic way in front of the audience. And I thought that worked. And then there's this great moment where Laura Dern herself on a date herself shows up and sees him. And then the movie takes an interesting turn at that point.
6:25Ryan Lattanzio:that's when the movie picked up for me the the first hour is almost interminably boring for a number of reasons uh part of this has to do with the fact that okay matthew libatique who actually cameos in the movie as a stand-up comic at the olive tree cafe wherever it is it's a real place that will ernett's character goes to where bradley cooper does the camera operating duties for the first time which lead to these long close-ups on characters faces that are meant to seem sort of verite or probing or even Cassavetian, but they actually look kind of clumsy. And at 124 minutes, this movie is way too long and could have used more editorial discipline, which is the case for a lot of auteurs these days.
7:08It was interesting to me during the Q &A that Bradley Cooper... What happens in these Q &As is that everyone inevitably defers to the director, right? It doesn't matter if it's Jim Jarmusch or anyone else. They're going to tell the audience, oh, he's so talented. He's so gifted. He can do anything.
7:32Ryan Lattanzio:That was the same in the press Q &A of just everyone congratulating each other and patting each other on the back. So I would say that Will Arnett worked with Bradley and their close friends on the screenplay. And I think the screenplay is excellent. I actually like this story. What I had trouble, I had a little trouble with some of the camera work also. There's another place where he has a terrible kind of miserable, angry rant. And literally the camera like shoves around in some kind of chaotic way behind his head that really is ridiculous because it's too on the nose. And then you picture Bradley Cooper smushed into their faces holding this camera, which adds another dimension of hilarity to it.
8:19Ryan Lattanzio:Well, they didn't talk about that. They talked about having to talk to him. I mean, he's one of those directors who said, say this, say that, do this, do that. He's one of those directors. So those actors had to, who are, but what I have to say is they're very good actors. And Laura Dern is very good, too. And I actually loved the way that it's sort of a fantasy. It's a fantasy of, you know, will mom and dad get back together? You know, it's it's something it has a little bit of a Richard Curtis feel at the end, maybe too much so. But again, I think it works. That that Will Arnett's so Will Arnett's character is based on an actual comedian, this British guy who kind of went through this whole story himself.
9:01But in this movie and that comedian, sorry, was working as a pharmaceutical rep when this happened, whereas this movie doesn't reveal what Will Arnett's character's job is. about being in finance at one point.
9:13Ryan Lattanzio:Yeah, but I didn't get that from the movie. And actually somebody, finally someone in the press conference asked that question, which is when the press conference picked up and stopped just being self-congratulations and congratulations to each other. I think that the idea to not reveal really what his professional life was beyond the events of the movie is to keep the focus not on stand-up comedy, but instead about someone who finds their way back to their marriage using it as a therapeutic tool. Yeah. Well, it finds their way back, not necessarily to the marriage, but to themselves, to their own identity, who they really, really are.
9:51That whole aspect of it worked for me. All of the relationship stuff, the idea that he found himself to a degree, that she found herself to a degree, she had to go back to reclaiming her role in the athletic world that she had had before. that all made sense to me. And I thought it was really, the trick with this movie is one of expectations. If you're looking for the next great, you know, Oscar contender, forget about it. That's not what it is. But I would like to think that this could actually play with audiences. You know who it played for? At the after party I was hanging out with these sort of bridge and tunnel guys, you know, men, older men, bros, they loved it.
10:33They thought it was great. So I could see a lot of people relating to Will Arnett and respond. Because a lot of people, the other idea is that, is it possible to have a movie that's just about relationships, just about people sort of, you know, conflicting with each other and not about something else? There's nothing sci-fi. There's nothing fantastic. There's nothing action. Could this work commercially? I'd like to think that it could.
10:59Ryan Lattanzio:Well, it's very possible because I watch movies like this every week, but that is not to say that those are necessarily commercial. You're right. I mean, you shouldn't be looking to this movie as the next great Oscar contender, but it is closing the New York Film Festival. It is premiering in December. So it does come with award season gravitas. Oh, they're going to make it. They're going to make a try for it. But part of what I've been watching this year, and I think it's really true, is that there are a number of movies that are putting themselves into that conversation. They're going to milk it for all the press they can get and hopefully amplify their openings.
11:37It doesn't mean they're going to get there, but it's a strategy, a marketing strategy, a publicity strategy for making a movie bigger than it would otherwise be.
11:46Ryan Lattanzio:Well, another end game of it being a Searchlight film is that it'll probably do well on Hulu. There you go. I can see it doing very well. Yeah. Yeah. Like I'll tell my mom to stream this movie when it when it comes out. Obviously, Searchlight doesn't have a ton of contenders this season. The other one, which we talked about recently, is, you know, they bought Ann Lee. They're also releasing that on Christmas a week after they release. Is this thing on which is coming out December 19th? And it does feel like when you get to have you had the chance to see Ann Lee yet? No, they haven't. They've invited me in LA and I'm not there.
12:22So I've missed it. It's going to be at the AFI Fest, so I'll catch it when I get back.
12:26Ryan Lattanzio:We'll talk about that one when you get back. But obviously the other movie that we haven't had a chance to touch base on is Marty Supreme, which was the secret screening at New York Film Festival last Monday. I was just delighted by Marty Supreme. And I have to say that I hadn't read that much about it. So beyond knowing the kind of movies that Josh and his brother Benny Safdie make, and Uncut Gems would be the last one to look at, I wasn't surprised to find an adrenaline rush movie that never stops, never lets up, and has a main character played by Timothee Chalamet, who is driven to be a competitive ping pong player who wins in the end, the ultimate championship.
13:17He's not going to let that go. And in the process of pursuing that dream, he walks all over everyone in his life. He's really bad. He's a grifter. He's really bad. He's a con man, too. Yeah, you're right. And so the feat that Timothee Chalamet performs in this movie, which I really, really credit him for. Obviously, his director is in it with him. But Josh, Josh Safdie, the one who comes out ahead in the Safdie Wars in this case, because Smashing Machine didn't do well. Smashing Machine was a disappointment. And in that case, the trick of trying to turn Dwayne The Rock Johnson into some kind of crossover star didn't work.
14:09In this case, Timothee Chalamet is right in his zone. This is an Oscar contender. This is a movie that's going to play really well for audiences, I think very similar to Uncut Gems on a bigger scale, but or one battle after another. It has a feel that's the same, this kind of, you know, don't stop, don't take a breath, just keep going until you run out of breath. But what Chalamet does, back to the point, he calibrates it in such a way that he gives you little dollops of humanity. Even as he's doing these egregious things, especially to the woman in his life, he saves it. And the ending actually works.
14:51Ryan Lattanzio:And the ending we won't talk about now, but you could also read the ending completely cynically, I feel. Really? Yeah, yeah. And the other thing I'll say is that with this film, you do realize where this anxiety-driven aesthetic of the Safdie Brothers movies, when they're working as a duo, like on Good Time or Uncut Gems, where that comes from, which is Josh. Because also, Marty Supreme is so - This is more frenetic than the other one. Yeah. And this is co-written by Ronald Bronstein, whose wife, Mary Bronstein, wrote and directed the very anxiety-driven A24 movie, If I Had Likes, I'd Kick You, showing that they are kind of all breathing the same air.
15:29Ryan Lattanzio:And then when you look at Benny as the Smashing Machine and the Curse Proved, he is the depressive side of the coin where Josh is the anxiety and Benny is the more voyeuristic of the two who obviously they split creatively two years ago and haven't worked from since, but they are making very different kind of movies. so what was interesting about we talked about this a little bit last week smashing machine shows the the directorial skills of benny but it doesn't um achieve the kind of audience pleasing pleasures that marty supreme does josh has a better sense of what the audience wants i don't get that sense from benny benny made a movie he wanted to make i don't know what do you think No, I agree.
16:19Ryan Lattanzio:And there is an audience for the Benny projects, including that Showtime series of The Curse, which I liked. And I don't know that it was not an audience pleasing. Of course not. But it there is a there is a fraction. Me, high and dry. I totally get that. There is a fraction of the audience that these projects pleases, whereas Josh is going for more quadrants and a broader reach. Yeah, interesting. Interesting. Yeah. I really am curious to see how Marty Supreme does. I think it will be a hit. Oh, absolutely. And I think that Timmy, Timmy, now we're on Timmy terms, Timothy, Timothée, whatever you want to say, Timothy Chalamet is going to win the Oscar this time.
17:06That's what's going to happen.
17:07Ryan Lattanzio:Absolutely. He's going to be 30, old enough to win, and he's earned it now. This is the one where they all go, okay, okay, you've earned it now. Leo's won twice. I mean, Leo's won once. Leo's won once. And Timothy spent six years learning ping pong for the movie all in other countries while filming Dune Part II and Willy Wonka. And he's fashion. He's sporting a bit of a unibrow in this movie. These are not the reasons that make the Thornis crazy. He also has weird skin. Did you notice the weird skin? Yeah. Yeah. I think I don't. They did something in makeup to make it. They did something in makeup to make his skin look a little bit pockmarked or discolored.
17:50And it was it wasn't enough to to make him not attractive. He was very attractive, nonetheless. That's what's so amazing about him. There's a scene where he takes his clothes off and he's running down a hallway and he is this scrawny little guy still. And he's still sexy as hell. I keep talking about how sexy everybody is on this podcast.
18:11Ryan Lattanzio:But he's sketchy looking in this one, and he has to be. And he's got a sort of skeevy, nervous quality that he didn't exude in these other performances. That's true. It's true. Yeah. The opening scene sort of tells you everything. He's working as a shoe salesman. He's obviously, and he figures out that this woman has come in. She's got an issue. She has to replace her shoe. And he says, come back into the storeroom with me and we'll find it. You know, it's lost in the storeroom. So, of course, he gets the other guy to fill in for him. And he schtups her in the back room. And it's very fun, you know.
18:49Ryan Lattanzio:And knocks her up in the process. Indeed. And this woman's played by Odessa Dazion, who is a breakout in this movie for sure. And she's also in an upcoming HBO series called I Love L.A. She's done a lot of other things that I'm not as familiar with. She's no picnic either. On some level, they deserve each other. Yeah. There's a couple of things that she does that are extremely questionable. But there's some scary stuff. There's some action stuff. The ping pong is amazing. I used to play ping pong in college, so I was very aware that he was really playing his own ping pong. He was doing it. It's impressive.
19:30Ryan Lattanzio:Yeah, I'm excited to see this one again and in a non-New York Film Festival audience. So let's look. The film festival's over. It's done. I caught up with a number of things I needed to see, so it was very useful for me. And I talked to people. I talked to people about what they liked and what they didn't like. Like I learned, for example, that House of Dynamite did not play as well at this festival as it did perhaps in Venice. But the Jarmusch did play as well as it did in Venice. At least that was my perception from talking to people. And that's been played a little better here than it did in Venice, if you like.
20:13Ryan Lattanzio:but some uh whatever when i say i'm polling mass audiences meaning i'm talking to my friends that are seeing these movies in theater they were not crazy about house of dynamite and they were not crazy about after the hunt and this is me talking to a group of like 10 people i know in new york and la who aren't in the industry but it's always revealing yeah i i'm what i'm missing is how it's playing for Academy audiences in L.A., but there's plenty of time to catch up with that, and I will get there. I would say the hit of the festival for me, Beyond the Jarmusch, which was extraordinary, was the Laura Poitras documentary about Seymour Hersh cover-up, and I just didn't realize that he was such a rock star, Seymour Hersh.
20:59I really was very taken with that one.
21:02Ryan Lattanzio:Yeah, that one seems primed to win. Best Documentary Oscar at this point. Well, it'll be nominated. She's won before, as you know. The trick with this, the other one, today they announced the Critics' Choice documentary nominees, and there's a list of movies that are likely to keep showing up on a lot of these documentary lists, and obviously cover up is one of those, how you build. This is how you build up to those nominations in the end. So cover-up is one. The other one seems to be the movie that I keep missing, which is Orwell. Did you see that one? You got to see that one because it has seven nominations.
21:46Ryan Lattanzio:So let's make a point to see that one before we connect. Yeah, I have our link for it. So we'll talk about that next week. Yeah, because that's a shameful admission on my part. Might as well. But I still haven't seen the Chernoff movie, which also showed up on their list. It's what, 2 ,000 Leagues? 2 ,000 Meters to Andrivka, which I've seen. Extremely intense movie. Did you see this? You did? Yeah, extremely intense. Well, so was the last one. This one even more so because it's all first-person cameras affixed to Ukraine soldiers in the battlefield. So he won for 20 days in Mariupol. So he's established.
Read the full transcript
22:29That's the thing. Part of the doc and the other one that's on that list is the Alabama solution from Jarecki. It's an extraordinary movie, which I highly recommend. It's on HBO already. You can see it. it's terribly upsetting to see this particular state has allowed certain conditions to exist in the prisons. And the reasons they exist in all the prisons in the whole state, the reasons that they allow these, they beat up the inmates, they put them in horrible solitary with rats, they drag them around having been beaten up with blood, you know, on the floor. Or the reason we know about it is because they took a lot of coverage of it with their own phones and shared it with the filmmaker.
23:17But also, the state regards them as less than human. It doesn't consider anyone who's a criminal, not human. So they can do whatever they want. That's a bad situation.
23:32Ryan Lattanzio:Yeah, I saw that one at Sundance. It's an extremely harrowing look at life in maximum security prisons and also works very well as an archival piece in terms of all of this contraband cell phone footage that he's able to compile. It's amazing. It's amazing. So those are, you know, then the one that's also showing up is Perfect Neighbor, which everybody, and that's a similar thing where the woman who is the director had been an editor and understood when she saw all of the police cam footage that was documenting the buildup to this murder in Florida from one neighbor to another. A white woman killed a black woman.
24:12And it was over, you know, just incredibly long buildup of perceived egregious behavior on the part of the children running around the neighborhood. I mean, it was really upsetting to watch, but she figured out that she could edit all that footage together and make it into a movie.
24:32Ryan Lattanzio:And there's catharsis at the end of that one because the woman actually is convicted, which is rare. When we see these kind of documentaries, that's not often the end of the story. It was interesting. When I interviewed the woman, I'm going to write a story about this. When I interviewed her, because it's about to open, I said to Gita Gumbier, the filmmaker, that I thought the police behaved relatively well, considering what we think about police in southern states like Florida. She disagreed with me completely. It was an interesting interchange. So you'll see. If you read my story, you'll see that discussion.
25:04Ryan Lattanzio:Well, on that note, we should sag into the next part of our podcast, which is that we have a special guest this week to talk about the movie Roofman, which is producer Jamie Patrickoff. He has been around for a long time. I remember he produced Half Nelson, which introduced Ryan Gosling. And he's worked with Derek Cienfranc, the director of Roofman, for quite some time. But you will get that introduction when you meet him shortly. Welcome to Screen Talk, Jamie Patrykhoff. Please meet my co-host, Ryan Latanzio. Hi, Jamie. Hi, guys. It's really nice to see you, and I'm really excited to be here, so thank you very much.
25:44No, no, we're excited to talk to you about Roofman, which just opened this weekend. And we are both fans of the movie, but there's questions. There's lots to discuss. But before, let me just introduce you a little bit. You're best known as a producer of movies big and small. With your Hunting Lane Films banner, you produced Hatton Nelson, which basically introduced Ryan Gosling to the world. Blue Valentine, Derek C. in France, and The Place Beyond the Pines, as well as such cool indies as Mississippi Ryan. That's a favorite of mine, actually, with Ben Mendelsohn and Ryan Reynolds.
26:22Ryan Lattanzio:so jamie to start to start off uh we'd love to know how you got to know derek c in france who's i think all of his features and his tv series i know this much is true you produced as well we actually had him on screen talk live during the new york film festival last year and he talked about roof man which is your new movie with channing tatum and kirsten dunst which just opened this past weekend. And he talked specifically about the true story that it's based on, which seeing this movie, it seems almost unbelievable, credulity straining. But then you realize most of it is very true. And he starts by breaking into McDonald's from the roof and eventually hides out in a Toys R Us after he escapes from prison.
27:08Ryan Lattanzio:But yes, tell us how you came to know Derek. Yeah, Derek and my collaboration goes back actually almost 25 years at this point. We were both working out of the radical media offices for a guy that many people know named John Kamen. We were both sort of there doing sort of our own projects. I wound up doing a project for VH1 that was actually a half-hour special on Ludacris. And Derek loves to tell this because he first was hired to be the director, Then he got hired to be the camera operator. And then the director and I sat him down and told him that he was being too creative with his camera shots.
27:52And we were going to demote him to third camera. So that was our first project. But I like to, that's all true. He did get sort of put in a box. But unfortunately, or fortunately, you can't really put Derek C. and France in a box. And the show to this day has one of the greatest opening minutes of a show that I've seen. And it was this extraordinary scene that he captured on his own with a camera off to the side doing his own thing. And I think in many ways that sort of began what I saw in him as such a unique and special filmmaker. It was a few years later that our Blue Valentine collaboration started.
28:32I went off and made Half Nelson and then felt that, you know, I was capable to come on and be helpful in that project. And, you know, and we've been working together ever since. And it's been an amazing collaboration. And, you know, Blue Valentine was the start of a lot of our kind of creative collaborations, which is really exciting. All of our HODs came back on Roofman from that movie as well, and it's been this long, 16-year collaboration on feature since then. So talk about Roofman and the development of it and how long. That's part of what we talked about with him. It took so long. What did you have to do to score a green light from a studio like Paramount?
29:16What were the hurdles along the way? It strikes me as an unusual commercial venture in the usual sense. You know, the lead is sort of a loser, right? Yeah. The ability for him to resolve his issues is a challenge, you know? Yeah. You know, it's funny you say this as long. You know, we have one project that Derek and I have been working on for almost 18 years now. Blue Valentine took 12 years for Derek. I was involved with it for probably six or seven before it got made. So this was under five from hearing about it to getting to the screen. So this feels like a sprint. But, you know, it's like everything that a Derek does, it's slightly off center.
30:08And, you know, this is definitely a different type of film for him. uh i think you know on the one hand i think there's a lot of elements that make it a very traditional kind of more studio film because you have the action element you have the comedic elements um but the same you have the romance yeah well said um a beautiful romance uh but um but you know today in today's world you sort of don't have those genres you mix them all up a bit and that's really what you do with this one. So, you know, for this, it was a combination. Obviously, everybody loves Derek as a filmmaker. People get excited when you talk about his name, both with the actors and with studios.
30:51And I think, you know, this had the makings always of something that was going to be a studio film. But it took getting Channing Tatum and Kirsten Dunn to talk about being really smart with the budget. you know this was a 19 million dollar film which you know for a studio that is a modest budget yeah i mean it's you know very small i mean you know i think if you uh so you know and we had to stretch every dollar because derrick you know his way of of making movies although uh you know when you look at him on kind of one-off basis a lot of them are you know he doesn't think about big things and big cranes and big effects and volume stages and all this stuff but he likes to give his actors time he likes to create real worlds uh he likes to shoot on film when he thinks it's the best medium for something um you know he likes to shoot in the real locations if possible so you know you could have gone to south africa shot on digital recreated the toys r us in a in a sound stage and probably cut this budget in half um or you could have done it you know in a more traditional studio manner and probably increased at times four at the same time.
32:07So, you know, the development process is challenging always. It is for everybody. I mean, you know, but we got it there in, for us, a shorter amount of time, ironically. Well, it's a triumph to get a green light from a studio. It's a triumph to get anything made at Detroit, especially something as idiosyncratic as this. So I congratulate you on that. I know Ryan really loves this movie. He saw it last night.
32:35Ryan Lattanzio:Yeah. So I finally saw it yesterday. I bought a ticket and went to the AMC Times Square. And I just thought it was so delightful and extremely moving, especially with the chemistry between Kirsten Dunst and Channing Tatum, who is both a movie star and an actor. Not everyone is both of them. And this movie showed a new kind of range for him. And I think a lot of that has to do with having Kirsten as his screen partner, who is someone who is used to working in really naturalistic registers. And being in this audience screening, I could feel something I find interesting about the movie is the kind of tension between the indie movie and the studio movie.
33:19Ryan Lattanzio:And I know that Derek has talked about wanting this to resemble a kind of studio movie from the aughts. And so I'm in the screening and I'm laughing at things like him apologizing to the dentist for having 14 cavities or whatever it is, because he is one of those people who wakes up and sort of starts apologizing for himself at the beginning of the day. But then other people in the audience are laughing at the slapstick material, like him naked and running from Peter Dinklage in the Toys R Us. Yeah, 100 percent. I mean, it's first of all, Ryan, I'm going to push back. You didn't laugh at the naked scene in the Toys R Us.
33:53Of course I was laughing, definitely.
33:56Ryan Lattanzio:But that got a real laugh out of all the people in the room. Yeah, I mean, Derek talks about the sort of how similar comedy and tragedy are, which I think is really an important aspect to think of this film and this lens of this film. He likes to say how funny he is in his regular life, but in his filmmaking, he's a much more dramatic filmmaker. and his wife, Shannon, is an accomplished filmmaker in her own right, and she's the comedian of the family, but much more dramatic at home. And, you know, he looks at comedy and tragedy as kind of two sides of a coin and really depends on where it lands.
34:38Like slipping on a banana peel, right? Which is, you know, inherently funny, but also hurts. And so I think that was some of the guiding principles of this film was really, you know, looking at all aspects of, you know, the tragedy and the comedy of Jeff and the scenes he's in and the fact that he's trying to do good but just can't get out of his own way and just doesn't realize the things that he's doing that ultimately either can cause pain or can be seen as just, you know, just the opposite way you would do something. And ironically, I mean, the true story that the true elements that we left out of this film are so unbelievable.
35:20You know, it's one of those moments where truth is stranger than fiction. I mean, Jeff, the stuff that he did and does and that was one of the bigger challenges is how do you make it so this is a believable character?
35:34Ryan Lattanzio:Well, I read that he moved to a different location even at some point like it wasn't only at the Toys R Us. yeah exactly i mean that you know so yeah and and we did a derry i think did a great job of weaving in the the true story and the and keeping the elements and the heart of it true and at this point now some of jeff's family's seen it and people who are part of the story you know that was one of the amazing things and why it was so critical to shoot in charlotte is we were able to use a fair number of the people who actually participated in jeff's life during that time whether it was somebody from the McDonald's, the prison guards, the captain.
36:14And it was very, they've all seen it now and all agreed that it really did capture the true story. So how did you manage to get this hefty cast? I mean, it's an amazing, how did you get Ben Mendelsohn to play this little tiny part? I guess he likes to sing. Yeah, who knew? I'd like to say it was all because of me. But, you know, it is every actors want to work with Derek. I mean, Channing talks about Channing said last night, you know, I would have played cop number two. You know, Kirsten the same way. You know, we he he was very deliberate in his casting. And to be honest, it really wasn't. I mean, Derek's not about how do I get the most famous person for something?
37:01And to be true, to be fair to the studio and to, you know, John Glickman and Miramax, they, they weren't saying, hey, you need more and more names. I mean, we sort of, Derek wanted the, Bonnie Timmerman is an awesome casting director. She keeps coming up with just wonderful ideas. And he just really wanted the perfect people for each role of, you know, and, and the amazing thing about these actors and then work, getting the chance to work with Derek is Derek gives them a lot of freedom. So, you know, he had a great script that he and Kirk Gunn wrote to start this movie. But as the actors come in, the script begins to take shape based on their storylines and what they come to.
37:43And to be honest, you know, Juno Temple, who ultimately shot for one day on the movie, which is just wild. um you know that backstory of her being a hairdresser and her you know wanting to she wanted to open a salon with with uh you know in the movie and all he had she brought all this stuff to it and that same thing that does it you know same thing with Uzo Adubo and her singing in the original script she wasn't even this that character wasn't even a singer and we just got Uzo came in had such an extraordinary voice it was like we have to use her as a singer um so So what did you think the box office appeal of this movie would be?
38:25Like, who would the audience be for this movie? What was your idea? You know, it's interesting. You know, in many ways, and this was maybe sound a little delusional, it's like it kind of is a four-quadrant film, but at the same time it's a film for an audience that wants a movie that's a little deeper and has got a little more thought to it and a little more substance in it. And there was times when we had talked about, okay, can this be a PG-13 film? When you go through it, there were really minimal things, but we made the decision that it wasn't worth cutting what we would have needed to cut.
39:10We are going to our grave saying it's a Christmas film, just like Die Hard, the Christmas film. Um, you know, it's a family film. I mean, I've talked to a lot of people that, um, you know, uh, who are, you know, come out of, you know, um, in religious groups and church groups who really love this film and, you know, appreciated the messages behind it. So, uh, you know, it's one of these films that I think everybody can get something from it. And, you know, it is are, but I do, I have two teenage daughters and I genuinely think, you know, that there's, you know, that it's a film that a family can see.
39:49And I think there's something for everybody. Yeah. So you're hoping that it will have a good word of mouth over the, after an$8 million weekend. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, listen, we were really happy with the box office. I mean, you think about in a challenging time and box office in general, we, you know, we basically made back almost half our budget in North America on opening weekend. And, you know, not, you know, it's challenging to make any money at box office right now. And you had other films coming out this weekend that had a really tough time. And, you know, you look at some of these other films, like One Battle After Another, which is an amazing film, you know, with a significantly higher price tag, and they're going to have a much harder time getting back to their budget.
40:34So we'll, you know, we'll do fine at the box office in the end. And I think we're going to have a long life for this film. I think you are, too. I bet the word of mouth is good. I bet the fall off is is is light. I bet you hold really well.
40:47Ryan Lattanzio:Yeah, it's interesting about what we ran an interview with Derek yesterday and he said he had considered shooting the movie in SD, which obviously the movie is in 35 millimeter and very much has that C in France look to it. But when you think about what the indie version of this movie would be, I guess the SD one would perhaps be that. That certainly I don't think that that would come to pass in a movie of this level. Yeah, I mean, yeah, I mean, it definitely there are a lot of different versions of this film. And I and it's interesting. I asked Derek Scott, great long term editor collaborators and all of his creative HOD user club.
41:26Ron Patane and Jim Helton, Jimmy and you from film school, and we were on a panel, Ralph Alpelbaum series at SVA, and I said to Ron and Jim, I said, I said, Derek shoots so much and shoots every scene in so many different ways. How many different versions of this movie do you think really exist? And they said, there's only one, the one you see. And that really is the case. I mean, there's, you know, I mean, somebody else could have made a different version, but shooting on film and shooting in Charlotte and shooting with the real people and shooting with these actors from Channing Tatum to Jimmy O.
42:03Yang and everybody else in between. That was the only version of this film. And it's like we're beyond proud of what the final product was. Well, I want to talk about your podcast. I think of it as a podcast, your substack. I want to think about the subs. I just am fascinated by how much time it must take to do that and put in all the time. I mean, when you interview someone like Kara Swisher or James Carville, you really do your homework and, you know, you hold your own with them. You talk about food. You talk about politics. You talk about Hollywood. Talk about the evolution of the this is Lunch with Jamie, of course.
42:44Yes. Yes. Thank you. Yeah. You know, it started really it was a it was a covid baby. It was something where it started just as a Zoom conversation I did for friends and friends of friends because we had a little time on our hands. And I personally am just a very curious person, both in the world of politics, but also, you know, in all different areas. And, you know, so I did it. It was it was again, it was really just for a small group of people. And then about a year ago, I started saying to myself, well, this is, you know, my goal is really just to find interesting people, talk to them and share what I learned with as many people as possible.
43:21So why not make it open to a wider audience? And it's been really fun. I mean, it does take a lot of work. I think the, you know, the, I'm lucky because I get to prepare for these things and just get to learn more about topics and people that are interesting. So whether I'm interviewing Jonathan Haidt or I'm interviewing Kara Swisher or I'm interviewing Richie Torres next week, it just gets to a point where I get to really get under the hood of who they are and listen to their podcast that they've been on and read either their book or – yeah. And that's – so I'm really spoiled in that sense. I love doing it.
43:59It's so fun. I tied it into my newsletter, which is Jamie's List, which – and that started originally as a food focus. You shared your food preferences. I got on there somehow at some point. Yeah, exactly. I sort of, I put a bunch, I just kept putting friends on it because I didn't really have a sign-up process. And then one day I was like, you know what? What goes together better than food, politics, and culture? And I sort of put it all together. So now I have the podcast, Lunch with Jamie. I have the newsletter, Jamie's List. And it's a lot of work. It definitely is. I've hired two people now to help me with that.
44:38but it's so much fun and it's really inspiring. So if I ever wanted to do this, is it remunerative? You know, listen, it's, it's, it's challenging, but it, it definitely can get there. And if you, again, like anything, if you put the time and effort into it, it is, but it just takes out of work. The paid subscribers, right? It's paid subscribers. That's really what it is. Yeah. I think I pay. You give away a lot for free, though, which is nice. I do. I, you know, the funny thing is I, I, I really, my goal is to charge so that I can just bring more, more interesting, unique content and tools to people.
45:24That's really the goal. I mean, I, you know, it is not my full-time job. My full-time job is producing movies and TV. But I do, the more I can make off it, the more I can add, the more value I can add to the community. And that's really what it is. It's great. You know, I started doing live events as well last year, which was so much fun and and bringing people together in a community i think that's so important right now that's why going to a theater to see roofman or anything else is so important because getting people together being out talking to people in real life is is just the is is what was so critical in this time especially people from different walks of life and different backgrounds and um so i love it so ryan and i both want to know what's what's in your pipeline What's coming up?
46:10Derek has a couple of projects that we're working on that we're hoping one that took us 18 years already may be coming next year. That's probably the closest thing. I have another filmmaker named Elgin James that I work with that we have a project that we're working on that could happen next year. But at the same time, you never know. I mean, I'll tell you, the one that Derek and I started 18 years ago, we didn't think was going to take us 18 years. Can you say what it is? I can't really talk about it. It's a TV project, though. Well, thank you for coming on. It was a pleasure. I will continue to enjoy your Substack and your movies, both.
46:54Thank you very much. I appreciate it. You're welcome. Thank you. I'm on my way to the London Film Festival premiere right now. So very excited to share this with the London audience. Have fun. Thank you. Okay. Bye. Bye-bye.
47:13You want to get your backyard summer ready, but you don't want to break the bank? Wayfair gets it. Planning on dining al fresco or relaxing poolside? Wayfair has everything you need to prep your space. Shop now and save up to 70 % off during Wayfair's 4th of July clearance. Score huge deals on outdoor furniture, area rugs, and more. We're talking thousands of products for every style and budget. Plus, surprise flash deals July 6th. Don't wait. Shop Wayfair's 4th of July clearance now through July 6th at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home.
From the publisher
Anne and Ryan break down two of the fall’s buzziest films, Marty Supreme and Is This Thing On, and only one is desined for the Oscar race.The duo also recap highlights from the New York Film Festival and welcome producer Jamie Patricof, who joins to discuss his new film Roofman and reuniting with Blue Valentine director Derek Cianfrance.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
