1. Podcasts
  2. Making Money
  3. Are You Saving Too Much For Retirement?
Making Money

9 Nov 2026 · 1h 17m · 28 chapters

Episode artwork

Are You Saving Too Much For Retirement?

In short

Explains the “4% rule” for retirement withdrawals, why it’s often misunderstood, and whether it’s too cautious. Focuses on inflation, sequence-of-returns risk, and how to adjust spending flexibly rather than follow a fixed percentage.

Guest

Abraham Okusanya. Background: over a decade researching retirement withdrawal rates; wrote Beyond the 4% Rule; founded Timeline, software used by financial planners for retirement planning for tens of thousands of people.

Key claims

  • The 4% rule originated with Bill Bengen’s US historical research using a 50/50 US equities/government bonds portfolio and rolling 30-year periods; the “4%” is a rounded approximation of about 4.15%.
  • Sustainability depends more on the order of returns (“sequence risk”) and early retirement inflation than on average returns.
  • People shouldn’t follow it blindly; strategies can allow spending above the baseline.
  • Inflation matters most in the first decade; he’s cautious when inflation exceeds ~5%.
  • Global diversification and higher equity allocations can support withdrawal rates around/above 4% (he says <50% equities is a bad fit for long retirements).

Notable examples

  • Withdrawal math: start with £4,000 (4% of £100k), then increase each year by inflation (e.g., 5% inflation → £4,200; 3% → £4,326).
  • “Twin evil” scenario: high early inflation plus poor early returns.
  • Historical events baked into data: Panic of 1907, World Wars, Great Depression, and 1960s–70s inflation.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:39

Understanding the 4% Rule

Explaining the origins and calculations behind the 4% rule for retirement withdrawals.

“The 4 % rule is one of the most popular ways to think about that problem.”
3:00

The Mechanics of the 4% Rule

Detailed breakdown of how the 4% rule works in practice, including inflation adjustments.

“So if you started with a portfolio of$100 ,000, you could have taken 4%, which would have been$4 ,000 in year one.”
6:12

Sequence of Returns Risk

Discussion on the importance of the order of returns in retirement and its impact on outcomes.

“because it's one of the biggest dangers that you are confronting in retirement.”
8:16

Critique of the 4% Rule

Exploring the limitations of the 4% rule and suggestions for more flexible withdrawal strategies.

“where you would look at, you know, two 30-year scenarios and the average return during the period is the same.”
11:19

Variability in Withdrawal Rates

Discussion on different perspectives and research findings regarding sustainable withdrawal rates.

“So they find a worse number, a lower number.”
14:00

Understanding Withdrawal Rates

Explore the variations in retirement withdrawal rates and their implications.

“credible people as well, that throw up all different numbers.”
19:10

Investment Strategies for Retirement

Discussion on the importance of equity allocation in retirement portfolios.

24:21

Spending Patterns in Retirement

Examine how individuals spend during different phases of retirement.

“So I want to get into the individual of this now.”
28:00

Understanding Retirement Spending Patterns

Explore how to think about spending patterns during retirement, including potential spikes in care costs.

“So 5 % of your withdrawal in the first decade of retirement, then you slow down and you probably be about 4 % of what you have now adjusted for inflation.”
29:53

The Risks of the 4% Withdrawal Rule

Discuss the risks associated with the 4% withdrawal rule and how to manage potential pitfalls.

“One is you need to have poor returns in the first decade of retirement.”
Show all 28 chapters
31:09

The Importance of Financial Planning

Learn about the significance of having a robust financial plan for retirement withdrawals.

“So I will go into retirement with a plan to enjoy the money, especially when you can.”
34:35

Adjusting Withdrawal Rates and Inflation

Understand how to adjust withdrawal rates based on market conditions and inflation.

“How do people look at that, do you think?”
39:48

Flexible Withdrawal Strategies for Shorter Horizons

Explore withdrawal strategies for shorter retirement periods and their implications.

“And I think it gives a lot of peace of mind in an uncertainty because what people crave is certainty and no one can give it to them because they don't know the unknowns of the market and inflation.”
42:00

Understanding the 4% Rule and Market Reality

Exploring the stability of investments over a 10-year period and the implications for retirees.

“So what you're asking is like in 90, 92 % of 10 year rolling period in historical records ended up with, you know, higher positive return.”
43:08

FIRE Community and Withdrawal Rates

Discussing the Financial Independence, Retire Early (FIRE) movement and its challenges with the 4% rule.

“What I was going to say, I mean, they're talking like 50 years, some of them.”
44:35

Adjusting Withdrawal Rates for Longevity

Analyzing the need for adjusted withdrawal rates for longer retirement periods.

“You need more, yeah, if you have a 40-year retirement, you need more equity.”
46:02

Assumptions Behind the 4% Rule

Understanding the assumptions of the 4% rule concerning property and taxation.

“chances of running out of money at all with a 100%, 80 % equity portfolio, even in the worst case scenario, is pretty minimal.”
47:17

Evaluating the Cash Buffer Strategy

Debating the effectiveness of having cash reserves during retirement.

“He just says, well, you know, take X amount of money from your portfolio, add it to any other income that you might have and go figure out how much taxes you have to pay.”
48:55

The Cost of Panic Selling vs. Cash Buffers

Discussing the financial implications of panic selling and the role of cash buffers in investment portfolios.

“He said it was a placebo and that he thinks it wouldn't work.”
55:04

Investing in Companies vs. Stocks

Highlighting the philosophical approach to investing and the importance of understanding market dynamics.

“So, you know, from your research, 100 % equities throughout retirement would be the best mathematical approach to produce the best outcomes.”
56:00

Understanding the Human Element in Investing

Explore the impact of human behavior on investment decisions during crises.

“20%, 30 % less than they did the day before.”
58:52

Equity Investment Strategies for Young Investors

Learn how young investors can effectively plan for retirement using equity investments.

“That is what the evidence tells us that actually is more likely to support, you know, a higher withdrawal rate, you know, in retirement.”
1:01:18

Retirement Planning for Different Age Groups

Discover tailored strategies for retirement planning based on your age group.

“And what is the level of contribution that I need to make, assuming 8 % return, if I'm investing in equity, I've seen 8 % return at this phase of return, at this phase that you're in, that kind of simple maths work.”
1:07:08

Maximizing Your Pension and Investment Returns

Understand how to optimize your pension contributions and investments for better returns.

“Am I in the right sort of asset allocation?”
1:10:07

Navigating Retirement Savings in Your 40s

Learn the importance of maximizing pension contributions and understanding equity allocation for retirement savings.

1:12:02

Gaining Financial Peace of Mind

Discover how to adjust withdrawal rates and feel more secure about financial independence.

1:13:12

Insights from a Financial Expert

Hear reflections on key takeaways from a guest expert discussing retirement planning.

“I have incredible respect for you and the contribution that you're making.”
1:14:29

Recap of Previous Conversations

Review memorable discussions from past episodes relating to finance and personal experiences.

“rules around it yeah i loved it we talked about ben felix in that episode um the 2.7 thing we'll I believe Ben Felix's episode here, because I think we have a really, that's another really impactful conversation.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Making Money, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Our sponsor today is Take The Next Step, invest. Inflation is a funny concept. It can be really difficult to really internalise because it normally happens in small enough increments that we don't really notice it. The price of something in a supermarket goes up by 15p. But inflation is one of the most corrosive forces in finance. It's been bought home by the cost of living crisis in recent years because the price jumps have been so drastic. The best lever that most people have to outrun inflation is investing. So if you have solid savings and money you won't need for the next five years, then think about it.

0:36Take the next step, invest. How much can you actually spend in retirement without running out of money? The 4 % rule is one of the most popular ways to think about that problem. Today's guest, Abraham Okusanya, has spent over a decade researching this very question. He's written a book called Beyond the 4 % Rule and founded Timeline, which is software used by financial planners to help tens of thousands of people plan their retirement. So for people who've heard about the 4 % rule but they don't really understand what it means, could you please explain it in a very easy to understand way?

1:06Abraham Okusanya: Yeah, so the 4 % rule was actually designed, originally created by a guy called Bill Bengen. And a little bit of a background about Bill. Bill was originally trained to become an astronaut, studied to become an astronaut, but he wasn't accepted into the US space program. So he did the next best thing, which was to become a financial advisor. You know, several years later, he's still taking people to the moon. The fundamental thing was that Bill began this research to essentially come up with a framework to help his client think about retirement. And essentially what he did was very simple. He, you know, conducted a research using extensive historical data, U.S.

1:59Abraham Okusanya: market data. So he created an hypothetical portfolio that had 50 % U.S. equities and 50 % U.S. bond, U.S. government bond. And he basically ran a rolling 30-year period. So he said, well, assuming that someone started their retirement in January 1929, what was the journey that that portfolio went through for the subsequent 30 year period? Then he ran the next one. He was actually using quarterly data at the time. But say you started in March 1929. What was the subsequent 30 year period? What was that journey like? And then he applied different withdrawal rates to the portfolio. And essentially, what he came up with is that the worst case scenario in US historical record would have sustained a 4 % initial withdrawal rate.

3:03Abraham Okusanya: So if you started with a portfolio of$100 ,000, you could have taken 4%, which would have been$4 ,000 in year one. then you adjusted that withdrawal rate for inflation, CPI, every single year. So you took a higher withdrawal in nominal terms every single year for 30 years. The worst case scenario would have sustained a 4 % initial withdrawal rate. Of course, all of the other scenarios will sustain a higher withdrawal rate. And so this is where the 4 % rule came from. It wasn't intended to be the Newton fifth law of motion that we've now made it in financial services. Was it 4.15 % as well? Is that correct?

4:05That's correct, yes.

4:06Abraham Okusanya: A journalist actually approximated, I mean, 4.15 % wasn't going to roll off the tongue or stick. a journalist actually essentially rounded it up to the 4 % rule. How important is the 0.15 %? Well, it depends on the size of your portfolio. I think as far as finance goes, it's a good approximation. If you had a million pound portfolio, not 0.15%, maybe a little bit more money than if you had, say, 100 ,000. can we break this down in numbers just because sometimes it gets a little bit confusing the four percent i find anyway so you start with 100 100 grand for example first you take out 4 000 then the next year do you take out how much would you take out in year two whatever inflation was yeah add that on to increase the amount so this is a key thing yeah i think most people when they say four percent think you take four percent of the pot every year right then you take four percent the initial and adjust for inflation absolutely absolutely spot on you forget the four percent at the end of the first year because it's no longer relevant.

5:12Abraham Okusanya: So say you take£4 ,000 in the first year of retirement and inflation at the end of that year is 5%. The second year, you take£4 ,200 because you've digested for inflation. And then in the following year, let's say inflation has been 3%, you take£4 ,326. So you just increase the withdrawal in line with inflation. And this is important because if you do not adjust your withdrawal for inflation, you lose your spending power during the retirement period. So at an average, you know, inflation rate of, say, 3%, if you started with£4 ,000 of income, you will end your retirement with something like, you know, £1 ,000 in real terms,£1 ,500 in real terms.

6:08Abraham Okusanya: So the concept of adjusting for inflation is an important point because it's one of the biggest dangers that you are confronting in retirement. So the two drivers there of the sustainability are market performance and the rate of inflation. Did Bill look at poor market performance and poor inflation at the same time? You know, like periods like, say, the Great Depression, but then the inflation of the 70s. Because what happens when inflation is 10%, 11 %? Absolutely. So this is the crux of Bill's research. I will almost actually just set the 4%, the rule itself, to one side. Because, as maybe we'll get into this, it varies, right?

6:52Abraham Okusanya: But the crux of Bill's research is to say what happens in the worst case scenario, which would have been a scenario with very high inflation in the first decade of retirement and very poor returns as well. So this is what the industry knows as sequence risk. So the order of return is far more important than the average return in retirement. So if you break your retirement into, say, three decades, for instance, the first decade of retirement has a disproportional effect on the overall outcome. So the way I put this in English language is to say, like, if you had good returns in the first decade of retirement and poor returns show or high inflation show up later on in your retirement, you're OK.

7:50Abraham Okusanya: if you had poor returns in the first decade of retirement and then good returns show up later on, well, the technical term is buggered. Even though both individuals could have averaged 7 % at the same rate of return. It's when those returns are. Absolutely. And this is, you know, this is a scenario. There are historical scenarios, you know, in my book that I put out because I replicated research for the UK where you would look at, you know, two 30-year scenarios and the average return during the period is the same. But the retiree ends up with radically different outcome. It essentially comes down to the sequence of returns.

8:37Abraham Okusanya: So Bengen's research is to say, I want to create a portfolio and a withdrawal framework that lasts me, not just for the good years, not just for the average scenarios, but also the bad scenarios. And the data that we now have today to run this scenario will look at things like, you know, the panic of 1907. You know, there is 120 years of, you know, data for capital markets and inflation around the world. You can look at, you know, the panic of 1907. You can look at World War I. You can look at Great Depression, World War II, aggressive inflationary environment of 1960s and 70s. All of that is baked into the data.

9:24Abraham Okusanya: And that forms the basis of trying to create a withdrawal rate framework that will last. How likely is it that an individual encounters a bad market with bad inflation at point of retirement? Is the 4 % rule kind of a little bit negative or too cautious in its approach? And the majority of people then end up kind of underspending as a result? Absolutely. So the 4 % rule in its purest form is designed for that really bad scenario, really aggressive inflation and poor returns in the first decade of retirement. Call them the twin evil of retirement planning. So, but you are not supposed to, in my view, just, you know, follow it blindly.

10:21Abraham Okusanya: it creates a baseline and and you know there are strategies that i that i covered in my book that enables you to spend more than uh you know that baseline withdrawal you are absolutely right it's it's very cautious and you know what happens in the average scenario in like a typical scenario if you just follow the four percent rule blindly you end up with at the end of a 30-year retirement with twice more money than you actually started. So the average person who follows the 4 % will have twice their retirement portfolio by the point of death. Otherwise known as being the richest person in the group.

11:04Abraham Okusanya: Yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah, I don't think that that's amplified enough because a lot of people, when they speak about the 4 % rule, maybe like the FIRE community enough, they hang it up as like, this is how you work out how much you need. What you're telling me there is they will have. It gets even worse. I have seen people going down, you know, the rabbit hole of saying things like, oh, the 4 % rule is no longer sustainable. So they find a worse number, a lower number. You mentioned that there were different frameworks and you also just mentioned this is US data based on. A lot of us invest in global index funds and not as many, well, I don't know, but some people not S &P 500 global index funds.

11:45Does this make a difference in the 4 % rule?

11:47Abraham Okusanya: uh he he does uh so global returns historically is slightly lower than the u.s um you know u.s returns but again keep in mind that the the four percent rule was based on like the worst case scenario so broadly speaking um when you have a globally diversified portfolio it tends to fare slightly better than the US worst case scenarios. So the worst case scenario for global equity tends to be worse. They tend to be better than US worst case scenario. So I would say for a globally diversified investor, actually the 4 % rule is a good enough framework to work with. And remember that Bengen had his research was based on 50-50 equity bond portfolio, the more equities you have in your portfolio, the better.

12:51Abraham Okusanya: So you could construct a withdrawal rate that starts with, say, 4%. 4.5%, for instance, if you had more equities in your portfolio, if you had a 70, 80, maybe 100 % equity, like I do in your portfolio, you could start with a higher initial withdrawal rate If you encounter, you know, bad sequence of return in the first 10 years of retirement, maybe skip inflation adjustment, you know, for a few years. There are rules that you can put in place around it. But by all means, if you do experience more positive return in the first decade of retirement, you could have a framework that sees you spending way more than the 4 % rule dictates.

13:47I would like to get really into the numbers in a minute. Yes. Because you wrote the book, Beyond the 4 % Rule, and I know you've thought about this quite deeply. So we're going to go into all of that if we can. But I just do want to come back to, you said there's lots of people, credible people as well, that throw up all different numbers. We interviewed Ben Felix here. He said 2.7%. He did say people wanted a number, so I gave him a number, but I actually said a variable rate was better. But then other people, I think Bill Bengans came out and said, oh, no, I think 5%. Why is there such a variance in this number?

14:18Abraham Okusanya: Well, first is it comes down to how people are approaching this model. Bill's research was based on pure undiluted US historical data. There's been attempts to overlay market valuation into this. So, you know, people would say, if you are starting your retirement in an environment where CAP ratio, you know, you know. Okay. Cyclically adjusted price to earnings. Right.

15:02Abraham Okusanya: What are you guys talking about? Yeah. The Shiller CAP ratio. Robert Shiller. Are you going to explain anything about my goods? You could do it. I'm sorry. I just keep, I just want to show off. Select Cumble Flex. Yeah, you explain it. Well, yes. Cyclical adjusted price earning ratio was designed by Professor Schiller. And basically it says, it's a measure of how, quote unquote, overvalued the stock market is relative to their earnings, relative to the profit of these public companies. and basically says if this ratio is above the historical high, sorry, the historical average, which is about 17 times earnings for, you know, the S &P 500, then the market's overvalue and apparently is about to crash.

16:01Abraham Okusanya: I don't believe this, by the way. It's been over that for a long time now. It's been like that for a long time. And the CAPE ratio, I mean, I haven't looked in a while. there are times that this thing was uh you know 30 times um it's been right once which is the great financial crisis but apart from that um anyway so so people say people use the care ratio and they say oh because uh of where we are in the cycle right now um the four we have to adjust the the initial withdrawal rate down and this is where they get to for the most part we've looked at this i have looked at this um you know using using uk and global data um my friend michael kitsis looked at this uh even bill had gone back to look at this again and broadly speaking the correlation between the cape ratio itself just on its own and sustainability of withdrawal rate is is pretty low um it's low and when you go outside of the u.s environment you look at uk and indeed global environment is even less relevant the more important thing is inflation in the first decade of retirement so i will be cautious in an environment where you have say more than five percent inflation and and of course the returns the the returns that you get in that period i will pay less attention to to caper issue as a determinant of my my withdrawal rate when i if you know when i'm starting out in a retirement journey more than five percent inflation five percent inflation is quite a high rate of inflation this is more than double the bank of england's target and if we you know like how are they doing against that target yeah yeah yeah yeah but i mean what i'm saying is that or what i want to ask again just to clarify if it's five percent or below you would say that people don't need to be too concerned that they that's an okay and manageable within the four percent rule environment absolutely okay so there's quite a lot of headway there we'd be okay right now we wouldn't have in 2020 we wouldn't have been 2020 and again one of the rules so we'll come back to the rules but one of the rules that i talked about in in my book is uh you know one that says how am i going to adjust my withdrawal for inflation in bad market environment so if i started taking four percent of 4.5 percent of my initial portfolio and then i adjust that in line with inflation i can set a cap on that inflationary adjustment and says in years where inflation is higher than 5%, I'm not going to increase my withdrawal more than 5%.

18:58Abraham Okusanya: You can set a double, you know, two angles to that rule that says if returns are lower in the prior year and inflation is higher than X, then i'm not going to adjust so there there are things that you can do i would but but but starting withdrawals uh you know from from my portfolio with 2.7 percent initial withdrawal rate unless you are unless you have less than 50 allocation to equities in your portfolio i would not do that and if you have less than 50 allocation to your portfolio going into a into retirement or into drawdown well don't talk to me i was i was so glad you just said that because i was i was about to ask do you have to have a minimum for the four percent would you have to have a minimum of 50 percent equities or is there like a level where the four percent will doesn't work i mean yeah yeah absolutely so it's got to be at least 50 i would yes i would say there is no point you know if you're going to be going into a 30-year retirement or 20-year retirement the more equities the better research all around around the world's shown that i know you've had professor errol dimson on the podcast who's collated 125 years of global global return we've used this data to model scenarios uh professor wade fow in the u.s has done a lot of modeling if you are going to have less than 50 allocations to allocation to equities in your portfolio don't talk to you don't talk to us you know do something else with your life no it's okay it's okay so what i want to say the higher exposure to equities makes you more susceptible to short-term declines though so when we're talking about the sequence of return risks 100 equity at point of retirement surely has a higher likelihood of encountering a bad sequence of returns well it does have higher volatility and you need to pay attention to it but across nearly all countries i'm trying to exclude uh probably you know markets like russia or china again i'm thinking historical uh scenarios where these total losses yeah total permanent loss where the the i want to say the socialist took over and confiscated uh you know private assets or whatever phrase you're going to use but across you know developed markets using historical data around the you know over the last 125 years you will still end up with your portfolio lasting longer in the worst case scenarios with more equities in your portfolio than with less.

22:05I suddenly feel a lot richer because of speaking to you in terms of like, I've always got a figure in my head of like what I need to get to and speaking to you, I just feel much more encouraged. So T, how often do you think about your energy bills? 24 seven, like I'm literally running around the house turning off lights that my missus leaves on. At night time, I turn off my Wi-Fi. I'm trying to save money however I can. Every night, I turn off the Wi-Fi. That's wild, mate. We're now living in a time where there can be a personal finance case for moving to solar energy, which is why we're happy to be partnering with YouSwitch.

22:37Their customers save about£1 ,000 a year from switching. But they have to spend about£8 ,000 to£10 ,000 initially for the battery and the setup. That's the average, though. And for a third of people, the payoff is much quicker. Plus, there are financing options, which means some people are cash flow positive on their loan from month one. Clearly, there's a few things to consider. But the good thing about U-Switch is that they let you see whether solar power might be better for you with just a few clicks. You enter a few details, things like where you live, a bit of information about your house.

23:04And in a minute or so, you can see how much you can save each month. U-Switch also offers deals and discounts you can't get elsewhere. So, if you want a clear view on how much you can save from switching to solar, then check out the calculator in the description. We don't know yet who the winners and losers of AI are going to be. but we know that AI is probably here to stay. And that's going to have massive implications on businesses. As AI adoption grows, so do the security risks and the requirements for your company. New frameworks, audits, and needing to prove that you're compliant with standards.

23:36Protocols like GDPR, SOC 2, and ISO 27001. Keeping up with that is a massive pain, which is why we love Vanta. Most security compliance tools promise to automate your work away, but you still end up doing most of it by hand. and then you have this big panic when the audit comes round. Vanta's different because it's built to scale with you, not slow you down. They have over 1 ,400 automated tests across more than 400 integrations, which cuts your audit prep by 82%. Plus you can access Vanta's agent wherever you work, like Claude or Cursor. Over 16 ,000 of the best companies in the world use Vanta.

24:10If you're interested, you can learn more at vanta.com slash making money. That's V-A-N-T-A dot com slash making money. So I want to get into the individual of this now. What I want to say is that I think the reason we debate this so much is because the question that everybody wants to know is, have I got enough? You know, what should I spend? How much can I spend? From your observations of individuals who have crossed that threshold and enter retirement, how do they spend in retirement?

24:42Abraham Okusanya: That's a very, very good question. So observation is one thing. So we have data of more than 60 ,000 individuals or households in terms of how they're planning their retirement. But there is also a lot of research has been done by the International Longevity Center in London and some in the US and Australia. and broadly speaking again i'm generalizing here broadly speaking you can you can divide retirement journey again into three faces so there is the go go face the go slow face and the no go you know that i mean i know you're looking younger than me when he walked out he's looking good no but but so so generally people to spend more in the early phase of retirement when they're traveling or they still have the fiscal ability and the interest to do so and then they spend less uh you know uh in the in the second phase of retirement and then even less later on in life when maybe mobility is an issue.

26:02Abraham Okusanya: There's a lot of talk, and you see that in the US data, about expenses rising later in life. Like care costs. Yeah, care costs as a result of that. They call it a smile. A smile. A smile. So the actual spending doesn't follow a smile. the change in the rate of spending it's all complicated the the change in the rate of spending does follow a smile so in other words um you start spending more incrementally from when you start your retirement in that la phase and then it declines in the second phase and then it does rise you know in the last phase of retirement but the actual amount that you're spending relative to where you started is still less.

26:58It's like a side smile. Right. It's a side smile if you put it that way.

27:02Abraham Okusanya: So that's the framework. It's less so in the UK. People are worried about care costs in the UK and the government needs to sort out these kind of issues with between health care and, you know, you know, social care in the UK. You know, we just have people stuck in hospital who should be at home or whatever, need other kind of, but we, so therefore the data doesn't show a massive rise um on average in uh you know care cost in in later life of course if you now start to break it out for households that are wealthier with with assets you do see a jump average person spends uh you know about two years in care later in life you know in later life um and and more than 70 percent of people who go into care do spend um broadly speaking less than four years so i tend to think of care costs later in life as a one-off expense that happens over a four five-year period rather than rather than like sustained spending uh you know over the last decade of retirement okay yeah um and and first of all do you do you encourage people to think about their spending in that way would you say that's the right way to approach i'm going to spend lots of money in my early years i'm probably going to chill out in my 70s and there might be a spike towards the end in the 80s but i'm unlikely to gone going to be having consumption-based spending absolutely this is the right way this is the way i would think about it you know you you might think about it as a 5, 4, 3 plus X.

28:58Abraham Okusanya: So 5 % of your withdrawal in the first decade of retirement, then you slow down and you probably be about 4 % of what you have now adjusted for inflation. And then later on in life, you would have lower baseline regular spend, but expect that there will be a couple of one-off costs related to care in in later life and it may well come from your portfolio but uh many people uh you know you you have the house i mean many people spend the house or you know we don't tend to consider the house it tends to be like um i mean property assets it tends to be like a sacred they want to leave it to the kids or whatever but you but actually you could increase your spending in your early years and live your life if you have the mindset of if i incur that one-off cost i don't know if i will i will just sell the house and pay for it that way absolutely the greatest tragedy that i am seeing that i worry could happen with this uh you know four percent rule and if we don't think about them carefully enough is that people end up dying with too much money You know, basically, three things need to happen for that framework to fail.

30:23One is you need to have poor returns in the first decade of retirement.

30:30Abraham Okusanya: You need to have aggressive inflation in the first decade of retirement. And more importantly, you do nothing about it. so you don't adjust your withdrawal the the the you know the the the bengen's archetype bill bengen's archetype of retiree according to the model is one that keeps spending their portfolio and adjusting for inflation in spite of the knowledge that um uh you know their portfolio isn't doing well and inflation is aggressive nobody behaves like that in the real world So I will go into retirement with a plan to enjoy the money, especially when you can. Remember that go-go face trade?

31:19Abraham Okusanya: Knowing full well that you're probably going to slow down. You know, Timay, am I not slow down? I was just thinking, what if you don't slow down? Because I'm go-go-go for the whole 30 years. Maybe you don't slow down, but then a lot will be driven by the, you know, what's happened in the... you would have the knowledge of what's happened in the first year. So if your health and, you know, financial, sorry, if your health and physical circumstances is still in a position where you can continue at the same rate, then you have a second question, is my portfolio at that phase where I can? So have we enjoyed a relatively good first sequence, you know, first decade as far as returns concerned if the answer to those two things are true then yes you can keep going if if they're not then you have a constraint that you have to deal with is it not like a bit of a contradiction or an issue here that in the go-go phase is also the period where the sequence of returns risk is the highest yeah so that might be the period where the person has to not go go like how how do you square that circle so it's a contradiction absolutely this is why this requires proper management and understanding of the challenges that you're dealing with and and i highly recommend having uh you know ideally a good financial plan a good financial plan yes that models this kind of scenarios you know have a plan uh model this kind of scenario and i've talked uh you know both in in the within the industry uh about what i tend to see as deterministic tools so these are tools that like would assume returns with five percent in the first you know every single year of retirement of four percent average on every single year of retirement i don't believe or inflation will be three percent for on average for retirement i don't believe that these things are uh robust enough uh you know for people facing facing you know retirement so how often should people change their uh withdrawal rate and like rebalance their not rebalance their portfolio but how often should you make changes well let's let's go let's go step back first like if you don't mind to let's say someone's retiring and they've got 300 000 pounds in assets and they've got a state pension like year one what should they what should they do at that moment like you know they don't know the returns yet yeah what's this conversation they have with themselves at that point okay so so the conversation you want to have is first of all what's the asset allocation in the portfolio 100 % equities they they've been hanging out with you i mean i mean let's okay let's say there's a 60-40, there's an 80-20, there's a 100.

34:15I don't want you to get too well down in the maths. I just want you to kind of give people a way of thinking about it.

34:20Abraham Okusanya: So asset allocation, yeah, but it's an important driver. So if you, you know, asset allocation is an important driver. And then the question they need to be asking themselves is, what level of withdrawals from my portfolio would I take that will last me a lifetime that this portfolio will last me a lifetime even if returns and the markets and inflation turn against me and you look at that the only objective way to think about that is to think about that in the context of historical scenarios. How do people look at that, do you think? How would a normal person do that? Yes. Yeah, it's a very good question.

35:11Abraham Okusanya: Look, there are tools out there. There are software tools out there that you can plug this in. Again, I don't want to oversell the value of a good financial planner. I would go to a financial planner to help me work this out if you can. But there are software tools. Like cash flow modeling software tools. Yes. Yes, I hesitate to say, use one that isn't just assuming a straight line inflation. And yes, so that is the tool that I will use to work that out, to say, what is the level of withdrawal that I can take from this portfolio that will survive, you know, even in the worst case scenario. So in the case of a 100 % equity, I would probably feel comfortable to start with something closer to 5 % of the initial withdrawal.

36:04Abraham Okusanya: Now, again, there are fees that you need to think about in this, you know, in that 5 % picture, the OCF of the fund. Is that, is it, is the 5 %? Sorry, what's an OCF? Ongoing charging figure. It's just the fund that you pay for your S &P 500 fund. 0.2%. Yeah, yeah, yeah. 0.2%. Yeah. So is the 5 % withdrawal including fees? So the fee is part of the amount? No, you're very good. You're asking very good questions. I'm sorry, it got a little bit complicated. It's not complicated. But the broad framework, what you should do is deduct 50 basis points as a 0.5 % for every 1 % fee that you're paying.

36:55Abraham Okusanya: So if your fee from that 5 % figure, do you? You half the fee. So if the fee is 1%, you take off 45%. Correct. So if you're paying, again, this is the total fee, including platform fee and all that. If the total fee comes out to be 0.3%, I will reduce that initial withdrawal rate by 0.15%. Well, that's the 0.15 % that we missed off. No, we missed off. You didn't have that. You didn't have that. So my point is, but the point, the broad point stance is to say, if I'm, if I have low, higher equity in my portfolio, I would tend towards more towards 5%. If it's more like a 60-40 portfolio, maybe, you know, a 4.2 % initial withdrawal rate, something like that.

37:48And then depending on whatever equity content you have, you stay within that bound.

37:54Abraham Okusanya: And then to your point, you just look at this once every year. Once every year, you say, OK, we have knowledge that we didn't have at the start of this journey. What's my portfolio done in the first year of retirement? And what's inflation done in that period? one thing i would say is just set yourself a broad framework a rule that you agree with yourself if inflation runs ahead of itself i more than five percent a year i'm going to cap my adjustment for inflation and and secondly i would say in years where and you would in years where my portfolio return is negative i less than zero i'm actually not going to increase my withdrawal with inflation at all you would have that broadly speaking based on historical scenario one every five years so once every five years you would have a you would have a scenario where you know equity returns are negative um and once in turn you should expect you should plan for a scenario where equity returns are in bear market territory.

39:07Abraham Okusanya: That's historical data. That's historical records. What do you do in years where the stock market, say, produces a 20 % return? I love this question. I mean, what's inflation done in that scenario? In that scenario, I'll be more comfortable with you giving yourself a pay rise. So this is working with realities as they present themselves, rather than it's not. if there's anything that should be clear to us, this is not a set and forget framework or thing that people make it out to be. Would you call this a flexible withdrawal rate? Absolutely. Is that what you would name it? And you just, I think I just want to - Beyond the 4%.

39:49Abraham Okusanya: Yeah, Beyond the 4%. It's an excellent book. And I think it gives a lot of peace of mind in an uncertainty because what people crave is certainty and no one can give it to them because they don't know the unknowns of the market and inflation. But what your research does is say, if this happens, do this. If that happens, do that. And, you know, if you have a good year, spend a bit more money. Live your life. Yeah. What about, so I'm going to be a little bit selfish here. What about, say, you want a pot of money to last a period of time? So rather than an uncertain goal of 30 plus years retirement, I say I want to stop at 50 and I have a stocks and shares ISA that I want to last 10 years until I can access my pension.

40:31What kind of withdrawal rates could you look at over short periods of time? You know, where it's like 10 years, five years?

40:39Abraham Okusanya: So very good question. So again, the 4 % rule was meant for a longer retirement period, i.e. 30 years or more. If you have shorter time horizon, then of course you have uh you know greater flexibility in in sorry greater flexibility but but you you have higher initial withdrawal rate if the period is is shorter than five years i tend to support equities for horizon that are you know longer than than five years so if you have a 10-year period, I will be more than comfortable with 8 % withdrawal rate from that portfolio because you only need that for a defined period. But my framework will still be similar in terms of adjustments and looking at the portfolio, reviewing the portfolio once a year to make adjustments if if you have flexibility in the spending in what you use the money for you could start with 10 uh but just keep in mind that there might be scenarios where you just adjust that a little bit not aggressive um uh in terms of may maybe reduce the withdrawal uh if yeah market turns against yeah and and is there a reality that at the end of the 10 years, you've got loads more, loads of money still left in that pot as well, that it's unlikely to have gone to zero.

42:16Abraham Okusanya: Absolutely. So what you're asking is like in 90, 92 % of 10 year rolling period in historical records ended up with, you know, higher positive return. there's there's only one one in every 10 historical 10 year period that you would expect to have less okay so so so yes there is a chance if you're starting in a 10 year journey and you'll say taking 8 % of the portfolio in average scenario you will still end up with more money than you started with in nominal terms Wow. The other way then, the FIRE community, which is the financial independence retiree, they really bought into the 4 % rule. And they have that right at the center.

43:09Abraham Okusanya: It wasn't designed for them. No, no. What I was going to say, I mean, they're talking like 50 years, some of them. And the 4 % rule was designed for a 30-year retirement period. There's a high chance that a lot of retirees might live longer than 30 years, first of all. But if someone's saying, I want to retire in my 40s and I want to go to the end, what kind of withdrawal rates should they be considering, do you think? Can I be a little cheeky? Why? why i mean don't ask me i don't i don't sorry i don't get back to work not just that not just that so so so you're you know as an entrepreneur and and indeed you know someone who wants to contribute to life and to society why would you say uh at 40 i don't want to work now i get the value of making work optional but that's not the same to me as saying i'm not gonna work i'm gonna rely on my portfolio but who am i to judge i mean some people just don't some people don't like working right some some people are not and you know a lot of people just hate their jobs yeah and a lot of people aren't as passionate about what they do as you are you know and and all have the privilege of doing the work that we do but i know what you're saying and And I do think a lot of people in the FIRE community would say, actually, forget the RE, it's just the FIRE.

44:25It's the financial independence that they create. Right, right, and I get that. Yeah, and they probably would still be productive. But, you know, is it the case of, if it was 40, 50 years, you do have to bring that withdrawal rate down a lot.

44:37Abraham Okusanya: You need more, yeah, if you have a 40-year retirement, you need more equity. The case for equity is even stronger, and you would have to contend with lower, you know, initial withdrawal rate. So for that audience, your 3%, you know, figure, you know, for a 80%, 100 % equity portfolio is a great starting point. That's kind of where I would lean. There is a, I haven't run this, you know, I haven't run this model in a while. But there is a level of withdrawal rate where, of course, the portfolio never runs out of money. Like 1 % or something. But like, it's no fun. No. It's on bread and beans and toast.

45:30It's okay if you're like Jeff Bezos or something. You've got billions and you're like, well, it's still a lot of money. But for the average person, they're going to have to amass so much in assets, millions to live a life.

45:41Abraham Okusanya: You are going to have like a concentrated period of either earning aggressively high or living on rising beans. You know, so there is a figure, I haven't looked at it in a while, where, you know, I would imagine if you're taking 2.5 % of your portfolio, chances of running out of money at all with a 100%, 80 % equity portfolio, even in the worst case scenario, is pretty minimal. But who wants to live like this? Since Damar asked a selfish question, I'll ask a selfish question too. Just a quick one. Are there any assumptions with the 4 % rules? So for example, does this assume you own your property in retirement or is that not included?

46:33Abraham Okusanya: it it's not really a it's not really an explicit assumption all the four percent rule cares about is like how much money can you withdraw from your portfolio in your earlier example uh damien you would then layer on your state pension on top of that and that's it how you spend that money whether it's to pay a mortgage later on in in in mortgage you know your mortgage in retirement or rent in retirement or whatever it doesn't really it doesn't really it doesn't really matter um at the but the the things that are not uh the assumptions that he made that the four percent rule also one sorry another assumption that the four percent rule also makes is like that exists outside of tax uh you know our tax framework so he broadly ignores the tax wrapper whether the money is in an isa or a gia or or in a pension it ignores um um you know income tax and how that is, you know, calculated.

47:48Abraham Okusanya: He just says, well, you know, take X amount of money from your portfolio, add it to any other income that you might have and go figure out how much taxes you have to pay. Thank you. In a way, all it's answering is how much you can take from the portfolio. Whether that's enough for you to live, it doesn't care. It's not really answering that question. And this is why I say to people, you always have to go back to your original question, which is what kind of life do I want to live? What kind of income do I have? You know, and, you know, how much income do I need to support that life? And how much of that needs to come out of my portfolio?

48:32So we interviewed Moshe Molesky on here. Yeah, I know Moshe Molesky.

48:37Abraham Okusanya: Yeah, I met him a few years ago. Yeah, he's a great guy. We talked about like one method of managing sequence of return risk of having cash, maybe like two, three years worth of cash in pots on the side that you draw from. And if the market performs poorly, you basically whittle away this cash and hope it recovers. He said it was a placebo and that he thinks it wouldn't work. I know you've done a little bit of work around this. I mean, would you agree? It is an absolute placebo. Oh, damn it. it's very but yeah so moshi's looked at this several years ago another guy called avia estrada at the ic business school looked at this there are there are papers in the um in the journal financial planning that have looked at this i have looked at it my uh you know my colleagues um i've we've just gone back and look at it and say is there something that we're missing you know so this cash buffer is what you're calling so the idea of putting two three years or out of cash uh doesn't really from a from a mathematical portfolio longevity point of view doesn't do anything except i'll come back to it doesn't do anything um there is a behavioral uh effect if you like that has been claimed again nobody's been able to substantiate this but the idea that if you have three years or two years of your spending of your income in cash there you're less likely to panic and sell out of the market like a behavioral thing is a behavioral thing yeah so so um so there is that behavioral benefit but ultimately it comes at a cost you know so generally if you have i say generally historical data says if you have two options one is i'm going to invest 100 of my portfolio in 100 equities um and i'm going to spend down equities on a monthly basis or an annual basis just to pay for my spending many people might dread that option but versus i'm going to keep um in this example 90 percent uh of my money in equities and then 10 percent two and a half years of withdrawal or whatever two years of withdrawal in cash um um the 100 equity would do better than you know the cash it gets worse because then you need to top up this cash from time to time you know so in other words uh ever so often you if you're spending down the cash then at some point in six month time you end up with 18 months of withdrawal what do you do then you know then you end up with 12 months 12 months of withdrawal what do you do then so so in most cases it doesn't really add anything it just comes at the the complexity if you just look at it from a mathematical term the final thing i would say is that then you have to think about the cost of panic selling out of the market so so my my colleague um uh judges boswanis has done some work on trying to quantify the cost of someone panic panicking and selling out of the market even in a sensible way so if you said uh i'm going to set a simple rule if the market drops by 10 % or more.

52:23Abraham Okusanya: I'm going to sell all to cash. And then I'm going to wait until the market recovers by 10%. And then I'm going to go back in. That has a very, very high cost. So for a 100 % equity portfolio, if you started with a million pound portfolio, chances are you would lose 300 ,000 even if you've just followed that kind of relatively sensible rule relative to somebody who stays invested in the market. So you have to compare the cost of what we're trying to present, i.e. panicking out of the portfolio and panic selling the portfolio against the cost that comes with using this cash buffer framework. Our conclusion is that to the extent that you don't have any other way to prevent this panic selling from happening, it does make sense to keep this buffer because it stops you panicking.

53:38Abraham Okusanya: um we we estimate broadly speaking the cost of the buffer especially when you read the buffer fails when you need it most i in mark in scenarios with high inflation and poor return it fails in those scenarios and the cost on a million pound portfolio is around a hundred thousand so you would you will lose out broadly speaking on two years of income uh in terms of the return that the market can give over a 30-year period if that's the only alternative to panic selling and bailing out on your portfolio by all means pay that cost if there are other ways as i happen to believe um i you have a good financial planner who can talk sense to you or talk you off the ledge or you have a financial plan that you truly believe in and that's stress test uh for for market you know various market condition or you listen to damien and tim especially when the market goes completely bonkers uh we'll talk some sense to you you can achieve that objective in in far less expensive way.

54:56Abraham Okusanya: But if that's the only thing, the only thing that you truly believe that can, you know, keep you invested, by all means pay the cost. So, you know, from your research, 100 % equities throughout retirement would be the best mathematical approach to produce the best outcomes. Mathematical approach, yes. Again, is it the most emotional? We're all human, you know, And there are scenarios that even I have thought, is Trump going to blow up the world? Is the world going to go back? You know the Mike Tyson quote, everyone's got a plan until they get punched in the mouth. Absolutely. But the thing I always go back to that you have to always remember is this.

55:42Abraham Okusanya: We invest in companies, not stocks. So if you are a globally diversified investor, you what you are doing is investing in the best and the brightest companies in the world who with millions of people going out every single day especially in crisis scenario to make things to find ways to make life better for all of us and so it's implicit in that assumption that when you look at historical record and when you look at history of, you know, capitalism over the last century or more is that it is by far the best asset for, you know, most of us to achieve what we're trying to achieve with our retirement outcome.

56:47Abraham Okusanya: and so yeah that that that is where what the numbers tell us that's what the research tells us um but we shouldn't forget that human element um you know there are behavioral issues and i think actually that is the biggest risk that most people face i mean go back to lockdown you know the equity market tanked by 30 percent does any one of us really believe at that point that, you know, the greatest, the brightest companies of the world, you know, Apple. Google lost 20%. Google, all of them. But do we believe that they were what? 20%, 30 % less than they did the day before. They were worth more because everyone was stuck on them.

57:32Abraham Okusanya: Right. But at that point, when we're all stuck at home, I remember thanking the Tesco driver who came to deliver, you know, our groceries, saying to this gentleman, thank you for putting yourself at risk. We were all scared. You know, there are questions about whether we're going to return to life on the planet as we knew it before. In those really critical moments, and then you could go back to, let's say, the great financial crisis when we saw people coming out of buildings in New York with their boxes, you know, in those sort of critical, oh, you could go back even further to like, you know, dot-com bubble, you know, so there are these like critical periods, not just for capitalism, but for human existence or life as we know it, you know, that unless you have a proper framework in place, makes equity investing just incredibly difficult for you know even the the best of us you know so that is the qualification that's like a long-winded qualification of my equity you know all-in equity view um if you like and and again i'm talking about globally diversified uh low cost um we can get into active management all that stuff but you know Globally diversify, holding a basket of the best and brightest companies in the world, not trying to time the market or anything like that.

59:19Abraham Okusanya: That is what the evidence tells us that actually is more likely to support, you know, a higher withdrawal rate, you know, in retirement. 80-20 is good enough for most people. 60-40, I'll still be talking to you. below that level i don't know don't waste my time i mean buy an annuity do other things you know like if you are if you are not prepared to stomach that kind of volatility and not prepared to be constantly engaged listening to you know to me and and damien yammer on about investing and if you're not prepared for that then yeah there are there are other products other things to do don't worry about say i actually said this in my book right i said i you know said like there are other things if you're not prepared for the work and the volatility and some uncertainty that comes with you know this point of view of investing so sorry uh you know like we categorize we put this two into two categories like that's the safety first principle like if what you're looking for is safety and comfort and guarantee don't bother with this you know probability based equity supporting you know framework to to to retirement yeah but if you like it spicy come get in the arena come come do puto in this water yeah yeah um i just like to bring it uh bring some practical things for our audience so most of us our audience us are not retired yet but like me we want to know if we're on track and what we should be doing how can someone in their 20s 30s 40s how can they use what you've talked about today to make some changes i think that the the incredible work about what you guys do is reaching um an audience that many in our profession can't reach you know so financial advisors and wealth managers and all the things so so it's it's an incredible work that you're doing what i would say to uh you know you know to people in the in this audience is that um if you are you know targeting a level of income in retirement broadly speaking i you know you wouldn't go far wrong to multiply that level of income that you need your portfolio to provide outside of you know um you know state pension or other kind of income you wouldn't go far wrong by just saying if i am if i am uh you know if i'm targeting you know 50 50 50 000 pounds of annual income again before tax from my portfolio i need a million pound portfolio to support that that's a good start then you say how much do i have now uh you know answer that question let's say I'm going to make up a number, say you have 100 ,000 now, and then say, well, how long do I have to get to this figure?

1:02:52Abraham Okusanya: And what is the level of contribution that I need to make, assuming 8 % return, if I'm investing in equity, I've seen 8 % return at this phase of return, at this phase that you're in, that kind of simple maths work. The thing to keep in mind is, if you need a million pounds today so you need a million pounds in 30 years time today actually you need 2.5 million when you get there because to maintain what costs you one pound today is going to cost you three pound you know two and a half pounds in 30 years time so you need to factor that into your thinking but i wouldn't complicate it i wouldn't overcomplicate the mat I think I will work with that simple framework 20 times what you need let's go the the great thing you have on your side is the power of compounding in terms of time and equities compound aggressively you will you will not believe it you know uh you know it compounds incredibly well And so it's probably the most important instrument, again, globally diversified, low cost tool for meeting your objective.

1:04:18Abraham Okusanya: The best thing you have today is time. Don't waste it. To follow up, first of all, some of our audience are older. So if they're in their 40s or 50s and they're kind of starting out, how would they approach it? And then secondly, I wanted to ask on the inflation point, could someone just strip out the average inflation rate off the 8 %? So could they just work out the return on 5 %? And that would give them their figure. Yeah, that might work. Yes. So they're shooting in the right place because otherwise they're going to look and hit a million quid quite quickly. Oh, I'm done. But then you say 30 years of compound inflation does a dirty on them.

1:04:55Yeah.

1:04:56Abraham Okusanya: So, yeah, you can strip out the inflation rates and just walk on 5 % return, real return. The other thing to keep in mind is that, you know, just because you start today saving 500 pounds a month or whatever, doesn't mean that you are going to that you're going to just stick to that figure. this rule that we said this framework that we said for retirement about trying to adjust your withdrawal with inflation i will do it actually in the in the accumulation phase as well so i want to adjust my contribution in increase my contribution in line with inflation to give myself a better chance i would do one better you know adjust with pay rises you know so every time your pay goes up or your income goes up um you should adjust your contribution pay yourself first i'm sure you guys are i've dealt with that that sort of well you've talked about that framework so that is important we can go down the rabbit hole of like what proportion of my income now should i be saving or investing you know there are frame you know frameworks say something along the lines of 15 to 20 percent is a good start uh you know good start it's a good start yeah your pension gets you there a lot because you're eight percent yeah so you're just through being in your work pension you're getting half of that your work pensions already got eight percent i do think that's too low by the way eight percent is too low and then you need to cover the gap which is like you know seven seven percent outside of your eyes isn't that you get there you talked about people in their 40s or 50s you know someone starting later if you're in your 50s get your ass to a financial advisor a good one who can because you are now i'm assuming if you're in your 50s and you want to retire at 60 65 the last decade is so critical you need the plan you need more certainty i say more certainty more precision around the plan am i saving enough am i investing enough?

1:07:10Abraham Okusanya: Am I in the right sort of asset allocation? Am I maximizing? This will become more and more important. Am I maximizing the mix between pension, ISAs, and, you know, general investment accounts, maybe other tax wrappers properly? Because this will become more important in retirement. Pensions are, you know, are heavily taxed in retirement. And, you know, because they They get tax relief when you contribute to them. So they are less flexible when you start to draw money out of them. It gets even more complicated when you throw a spouse into the equation. So one of the stats that just came out, I think last week, is that we now have over a million people paying higher rates of tax in retirement.

1:08:06Abraham Okusanya: and one particular area where it's difficult to if you don't plan this at least a decade earlier is when you have one member of the spouse say the wife earning a lot of money and maybe the husband isn't when you and so let's say the wife in this equation contributes a lot into their pension and all that stuff let's say less so for for the husband when they get into retirement you could end up in an environment where one spouse is paying a higher rate of tax on their income and the other isn't using their annual allowance so so in your 50s it becomes really critical yes investment return and asset allocation is important but taxes become a more dominant force that needs to be thought through and planned.

1:08:59Abraham Okusanya: And it is, I'm afraid, more complicated than it needs to be. I didn't make that. You didn't make that. You know, whoever wrote the tax code did. So that's, if you're in your 50s, I would highly encourage that. In the 40s, I'm in my 40s. I don't think you need to do, if you've done the numbers that we talked about in your 30s, and you invested heavily in globally diversified equities, as you should,

1:09:34Abraham Okusanya: look at your workplace pension. I saw my sister, I think it was two years ago, three years ago, I just went, and she said to me in her early 40s, and she said to me, can you look at my, just look at my pension? I look at this. She's in her 40s, early 40s or late 30s even at the time. she's not going to touch this money legally until she's at least 60 and this thing is invested in a you know 50 50 equity or 60 40 equity the amount of return that she is going to sacrifice between over the next 25 years is insane it should be a crime but you know what our laws our employer framework you know i employ 100 people i should know creates this default scheme that we're putting people into that is broadly speaking in most cases 50 50 equity i think it's wrong so so so if you're in your 40s you want to be looking at the equity bond allocation within your workplace pension are you contributing enough are there are there ways that you can maximize your contribution through salary sacrifice and you need to do that like math that we've we've talked about this is planning this is financial planning and is there enough time for someone in their 40s who might be absolutely yes what do you mean are you trying to say no if they haven't i mean the thing about people in their 40s is they cut they are part of a generation where they might not have been in auto enrollment so they haven't had that forced savings and now they might just be waking up to life in terms of oh retirement is coming I haven't saved much I've had kids I've prioritized my house you know have I got enough time now to build a good retirement yes if you're in your 40s and let's say you're following the classical you know retirement period you know of 60 65 you have 20 years you have 20 years of compounding you will be amazed by the power of compounding that happens i i entered my 40s with actually not a lot of money in my pensions and then of course income change all these things uh you know gets you to a point where you aggressively contribute and the the equity market has been incredible over the last decade i mean it's always been incredible even with the occasional decline you know it'll give you a boost so it is absolutely not too not too early to so not too late to start absolutely you should thank you so much uh not only was it interesting funny but you gave a lot of practical advice and a lot of hope for people like me in our late 30s if 40 is not too late then 38 ain't too late you're a spring chicken i'm a spring chicken but i think it was really practical and you you cleared a lot cleared up a lot of things and even things that we talk about occasionally like 50 50 in the pension as a default you brought up so many good points and things we'd never talked about before so i really appreciate it thank you yeah i loved it you made me feel i mean i live and breathe this all day long and i am probably i save a lot more than the average person but I still think oh have I got enough have I not and I think you've just kind of given me a lot of peace of mind because I'm pursuing financial independence just because job unsecured like my job is a bit insecure full-time content creator it can all disappear and now I feel like you know my withdrawal rates can be adjusted and the numbers will come down quite a lot all right no but thank you I mean thanks for having me the work that you guys do I have incredible respect for you and the contribution that you're making.

1:13:20Abraham Okusanya: You know, let's get as many people investing. This thing shouldn't be as daunting as nearly as, you know, the industry has made it. So thank you for making it less daunting and bringing clarity to people. Thank you. Our pleasure. Thank you. You're the man. I liked Abraham. I've never been so entertained talking about the 4%. Well, he was funny. He was like knowledgeable. Don't talk to me. If you've got less than 50 % equities, I'm not interested. As academics go, he's one of my favorites we've ever spoken to. He just came with such a good energy. Yeah, he was lovely. And I thought he was really clear and really actionable.

1:13:58He made me feel really good. I know things about withdrawal rates. I've heard it all, but I don't know, to hear it from him just made me feel a lot more financially secure in my position. I definitely learned some new things from him that we haven't talked about before on the podcast, which is hard because we talk about a lot. but yeah he definitely brought some new ideas forward and just that kind of you know how do you definitively answer the question around have i got enough and the answer is what you need to more do is go how do i make sure that what i've got lasts and that i can deal with every situation and the key drivers of that are the inflation and the market returns and you just have those rules around it yeah i loved it we talked about ben felix in that episode um the 2.7 thing we'll I believe Ben Felix's episode here, because I think we have a really, that's another really impactful conversation.

1:14:45I think we had, that's probably one of my favorite ever episodes. We talked about everything. We talked about the markets, all the latest research, but then we talked about like happiness, ill health, basketball. Overcoming cancer. These nuts. These nuts. Yeah, that is just such a good episode. This episode was sponsored by Take the Next Step, Invest. People often think that investing is only done by professionals, but it's something normal people can do, and consistently investing can transform lives over the long term. So if you have solid savings and money you don't need for the next five years, then think about it.

1:15:26Take the Next Step, Invest. Before you go, it's really important to remember that nothing we said there was financial advice. The reason it's not financial advice is because it's not tailored to you. If you want advice that's tailored to you, it's worth speaking to a financial advisor. As with everything financial, please do your own research. We really encourage that because no one cares more about your money than you. I'm Damo. I'm T. Jack and Ben from Flowspire, film and edit for us. Ruth's our producer and Will is the co-founder at most. See you next week.

From the publisher

How much can you actually spend in retirement without running out of money? The 4% rule is one of the most popular ways to think about that problem. Abraham Okusanya has spent over a decade researching this very question. He's written a book called Beyond the 4% Rule and founded Timeline, software used by financial planners to help tens of thousands of people plan their retirement.

🎉 Sponsors:

Uswitch - See if you can save by switching to solar: ⁠https://makingmoney.email/uswitch

Vanta - Get your company secure and compliant: ⁠https://vanta.com/makingmoney

–

If you purchase a product or service using one of the links above, we may receive a commission. There will be no additional charge for you. Remember investments can fall and rise - and past performance is no guarantee of future results. Other fees may apply. Your money is at risk.

This is not financial advice. The reason it’s not financial advice is because it’s not tailored to you. We explain the principles of building wealth but if you want personalised advice, it’s worth speaking to a financial advisor. As with everything financial, please do your own research. We really encourage that because no one cares more about your money than you and if you learn the basics then it will change your life.

—-------------

Listen to our episode with Ben felix here: https://pod.link/1674547187/episode/ZDgxZTUzOTQtZWVlNS0xMWYwLWI0YjYtNmYxM2E2OGYxMzFi&nbsp;

More from Making Money

All episodes