Will Google's SGE AI Ruin Web Traffic?, Elon Musk's AI Chatbot Grok, and The Dangers of Too Many AI Tools (AI Corner Dec 2023 Week 3)

0:00All right. So we are going to talk about AI Corner. So we've got a lot of cool bells and whistles here to talk about. And I'm going to start off with this one over here. So Neil, have you seen this Wall Street? You definitely haven't, but I'm going to act like you did see it. So there's this Wall Street Journal article that came out, and the headline here says, News Publishers See Google's AI Search Tool as a Traffic-Destroying Nightmare. Okay? So let me share my screen over here. And you know how publishers always complain. And I think it's good for everyone to understand that there's always been a fragile kind of like agreement between Google and publishers, right?

0:36And a publisher is someone that might be like a Wall Street Journal. They're publishing content or a business insider. Now, that tentative agreement has always been, hey, Google will send you traffic. And the publishers, the agreement from their side is we will supply you content. And now, so what's happening now with the search generative experience is that Google scraping a lot of the web and just giving you an AI answer, right? Which by default means that it's taking away clicks, which means it's taking away traffic, which means that Google is taking away revenue from a lot of these publishers.

1:05Okay. So when you look at the Atlantic, which is a publisher that's been around since 166 years, Steve Jobs' wife, you know, she ended up buying it. But they think that 75 % of the time, the AI powered search would likely provide a full answer to a user's query and the Atlantic site would miss out on a traffic it otherwise would have gone. So that's one number over there. Now, the other thing here is publishers have seen enough to estimate that they will lose between 20 % and 40 % of their Google-generated traffic if anything resembling recent iterations roll out widely. Google has said it's giving priority to sending traffic to publishers, which, of course, it's going to say, right?

1:48The last thing I'm going to call out here before we react to this, Neil, is this is Liz Reed, Google Vice President. So here's what she said. she said basically any attempts to estimate the traffic impact of our SGA experiment are entirely speculative at this stage. And we continue, as we continue to rapidly evolve the user experience and design, including how links are displayed. And we closely monitor internal data from our tests, which is a typical Google answer when it comes to this stuff. So let's talk about this. I agree with that because, you know, I've talked about this in the past and I'm actually pulling up the data right now and I'll share it on my screen once I have it.

2:29But everyone's like, oh, SEO is dead, SGE. Well, first off, Google doesn't even know what they're going to end up doing with SGE and all the changes. It's so early. It's not something that's going to end up rolling out in a matter of, I don't know, like weeks. If they screw publishers over, they don't have a business. Yes. And you got it right. Because one, they need it for content. Without that, they really are screwed. And two, SEO, more so Google AdSense, really drives a lot of revenue. So check this out. I'm going to share my screen right now. I just got the stats. People talk about SEO being dead or they don't want to drive traffic to publishing websites.

3:09All right, so Google made$32.78 billion in revenue from their partner network, aka AdSense. And this is in 2022. And if you had to guess how those sites get their traffic, it pretty much is SEO. If you're making money from AdSense, AdSense is people buying traffic from Google Ads. You yourself cannot buy ads on Google and then send it to AdSense and make it profitable. You will lose money. Some people try to do it with Yahoo. Some people try to do it with Bing or Facebook and then send it to Google AdSense. Those days are long gone. It's very, very, very few people who are able to do that profitably.

3:48Those businesses don't last long and it's hard to do it at scale. It's hard to arbitrage from one ad network to another. But on the flip side, the way you get your traffic is organic social and organic SEO. Organic social doesn't give you consistent traffic. Organic, I mean, organic social doesn't get you consistent traffic. Organic SEO does. If they just killed SEO, they're going to kill a lot of their revenue. Now, am I saying that Google isn't willing to crush 30 something million dollars in revenue? I'm not saying that. I'm saying they're not willing to crush it and, you know, bank on AI until they know how to make up that revenue difference through something else.

4:32and they'll run a ton of experiments, which is a Google way, until they figure out what produces a better ROI. And they're very, very careful to do it with a fraction of a percent of their traffic or 1 % does good. Then they'll start opening up to maybe 5 % or a region and then 10%, then 20, then 50, and then boom, they'll just roll it out. Once they know it's going to make them a killing. They're not going to do something that's just going to crush their stock price. They're really smart and sophisticated. I just think, look, the people that are complaining, like Barry Diller, who's Expedia, Zillow, and all that, All the publishers that are complaining, the majority of their traffic comes from organic.

5:05And so, yes, what happens is you start to complain because when the golden goose starts to disappear where you feel like it's at risk, you start to panic, right? So what is the counter to this? The counter is to take an omni-channel approach. We talked about podcasting, YouTubing, all these other channels becoming bigger and bigger. It's time to diversify and not rely so much on Google. And Google has been good. Like Neil and I come from Google, right? We come from SEO. We love it, but we also know that we can't rely on it because then otherwise we'd be panicking right now. Yep. Speaking of AI, another thing that we've been testing out a lot is the different platforms.

5:41So ChadGPT, of course, Bart, of course. Eric, have you played with Grok a lot? Well, I need to wait one more day because I was too cheap. Anyway, I didn't want to pay. No, no. The iOS, there's a 30 % tax on it because Elon doesn't want to – so he makes the users take it. So I'm like, oh, I'm going to pay for Grok. But it's like, oh, no, you have to upgrade to the iOS version. I was like, I don't want to pay for it. So the support's like you need to wait until the 20th. And so tomorrow I can finally pay for it. You can just upgrade on your computer and you don't have to pay the 30th. It doesn't let me because my thing expires.

6:11My iOS expires on the 20th. And then I can finally say, okay, I'm going to sign up for the web. And then I can pay$16 instead of$22. Oh, okay. That's not too bad. of it. So what we found with Grok is, you know, chat GPT by default ends up posting, creating shorter content than Grok. So we kind of like that. Bard actually creates more in-depth content than even Grok. But from length perspective, we think Bard does it best, then Grok, then chat GPT. What we're also seeing is Grok has a lot less rules. Like if you ask Grok to use, you know, profan or if you ask it to be vulgar when it's creating something, it'll be vulgar.

6:53If you ask ChatGPT to, it will not be vulgar at all. You know, it'll be blocked out. Now, what we found is Grok also creates content with more emotions. It does a really good job at storytelling. Bard does too. ChatGPT is not bad as well. But with ChatGPT, we found that to get some of the things that you're getting from Grok and Bard, you can get, but you have to be more descriptive with your prompts, right? Well, with Grok and Bard, you don't have to be as descriptive with your prompts. And a lot of times you can get at least marketing content that's sufficient. Yep. Yeah, I'm keen to try it out.

7:35I think there's a lot you can do with it. I think they have a very unique data set. So X does. And I think they're going to be able to build a lot of interesting products from in the future. So I'm excited to see what happens there. Next thing over here is we wanted to talk about more identity layering ideas. So I've talked about how you can use tools like retention.com or customer.ai or warmly. There's a lot of these out there where you can de-anonymize the IP addresses that visit your site. But for example, when I look at a report, I get a daily export from retention.com. And I will see the director of marketing from Shopify visit.

8:10I will also get their LinkedIn. in. I'll get their email address as well. I'll also get their estimated revenue, number of employees. I will also see when they first visited, the first page they visited, and the other pages that they visited. And so now I have a lot of contextual data I can go after. And so let's say Neil visits my website. I might say, okay, he visited a page on SEO services. I might say, hey, Neil, thanks for visiting our site in regards to SEO. Have you looked into programmatic SEO or something like that? Or have you looked into this content over here? This might be helpful to you.

8:39My point of saying all this is that with this data that you have coming in, you can leverage the power of AI to find the right people, add them on LinkedIn, send them a message that's contextual based on whatever it is that they were interested in, what they visited. And then you can send them more content that's relevant to that, and you can build a relationship there, right? You can add them to your email list. You can retarget these people. But the other thing, too, is most people don't think about identity layering from, hey, what if you're looking to recruit people? There's plenty of people you're going to see on your list that are visiting your website, right?

9:09What if you're looking to acquire more companies? You might have people that might be potential acquirees visiting your website. So there's just a lot you can do from a recruiting, a marketing, sales standpoint, an acquisition standpoint with this stuff. And layering on AI, you can use clay.com to do it. I'm just throwing a lot at you right now. I'm just saying go look into this stuff. And I think this is a lot that we're going to be focusing on in 2024. Cool. So what's the last one you want to be covering on AI? uh well don't you know what i want to talk about don't not overloading on ai tools right like let's let's start with that i think you have a point of view here go with this right now everyone tells me about their latest and greatest tool it used to be like jasper and they're like oh you got to focus on chat gpt you got to focus on this tool they're doing some crazy stuff with their api and the way i look at it is there's too many tools coming out too many of them are features, they're not actually solving a big problem.

10:05They're just doing one little piece of the puzzle. And what my belief is, is focus on most of the major platforms, you know, Bard, ChadGPT, if you want to throw in a third, maybe Grok, but it's not necessarily needed, but focus on ChadGPT and Bard because it can do most things for you. And then from there, wait, no joke, six months to a year, and then see what's out there that still sticks. Because most things will just go away and people like oh you know you can do this with your podcasting or images well eventually chat gpt and bard will do all that kind of stuff for you anyway so why would you need to go pay for all these tools um and chat gpt and bard are probably going to do a better job i'm not saying that because you know they're the smartest people in the room or anything like that that's not the reason why i'm saying it because they have the most capital right when you're spending$2 billion,$3 billion,$5 billion on whatever it is to make these tools amazing, you bet that money is going to go a really long way and they can afford to pay more for better engineers, which is required for a lot of this stuff, than the competition.

11:11Even if you're venture funded and you have$500 million, it's a drop in the bucket compared to what some of these other guys are spending. No joke. That's why I think you should just mainly stick with chat GPT and barred and not worry about the hundred other tools that are out there. I think it gets to be so bad and overloaded that it's a time suck. And you spend so much time working on these tools that are features. You got to then spend a lot of time to clean up the mess that they're creating. And then you're like, Oh wait, I could have just done this manually faster. If you've ever built a website, you know how tough it can be to keep a strong design while ensuring site performance is fast.

11:41That's where Framer comes in and it totally changes the game. Framer is the design first no code website builder that lets anyone ship a production ready site in minutes. I recently built a custom landing page in just a few hours. Animations, fast load times, responsive layouts, all without writing a single line of code. It was easy to use and the end result was polished enough to look like a developer spent days on it. One of my favorite things is that Framers AI handles translations with a single click. So your site can be up and running in multiple languages almost instantly. And with real-time collaboration, your whole team can jump in and work together.

12:14No issues with versions or miscommunication, whether you're starting from scratch or using one of their templates, Framer lets you focus on design while handling the technical side for you. Animations, responsive layouts, search optimization, and all the things that matter. Ready to build a site that looks hand-coded without hiring a developer? Launch your site for free at framer.com and use code MS to get your first month of pro on the house. That's framer.com, promo code MS, framer.com, promo code MS. Rules and restrictions may apply. When I first started my business, the overwhelm was real.

12:45I didn't have the tools to help me scale. If only I had Shopify from the start to handle all the behind the scenes work. Shopify is the platform behind millions of businesses globally from huge names like Mattel and Gymshark to the smallest brands just getting started. The best part about it, it has everything you could need. Say you're ready to launch your own design studio. Shopify has hundreds of templates to create a beautiful store that matches your brand style. Or if you need help with content creation, Shopify has got AI tools that write your product descriptions, craft page headlines, and even enhance your product photos.

13:17Shopify lets you easily create email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they are, whether they're scrolling or strolling. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Turn your big business idea into with Shopify on your side. Sign up for your$1 per month trial and start selling today at shopify.com slash marketing school. Go to shopify.com slash marketing school, Shopify.com slash marketing school. Yep. Look, I also think a lot of the AI tools out there being built are just crap. They're not defensible, and they're going to be commoditized very quickly. And what's going to happen is, yes.

13:55Jasper is a prime example. That company will be worth very little to nothing. Mark my words. Maybe you'll disagree with me, but you don't need it to create content. You can just create it with Chad, GPT, or Bard. Skip the paying money. Yeah, look, I like the guys at Jasper a lot. I do think it's a tough situation. I remember when they first when ChatGPT first came out, I believe the founder, the founder, Dave, he reached out to Sam Altman. He's like, hey, like, you know, hey, I think it was something along the lines of, hey, like, would have been nice to have like a heads up around this or something like that.

14:26Right. Right. But when I look at not even Jasper, I think looking at other tools too, it's like, to me, they're like, they're basically helping you prompt engineer a little bit. And there it's nothing proprietary. And what is proprietary at the end of the day? One, yes, focus on your business, focus on what's actually going to drive high leverage. But if you want to play in this AI space, if you really want to have a tool, I think the people that are going to win at the end of the day are the people that have their own proprietary data sets and the ones that like when you layer on your own data set in, in addition to like a bard or a chat GPT, for example, that's where you're going to get amazing insights that are going to be able to, that's going to be able to move your business forward.

15:06Right. Um, that's where I think the money is. And that's where I think you can make the biggest impact because I hear about a lot of people right now. It's like, Hey, what I've done, I produced 4 ,000 more pieces of content or whatever. And it's like, dude, you use like 20 different tools and like all 4 ,000 pieces of content that you produce are all garbage. And so like, sure, you're producing it. But at the end of the day, what results are you getting? And more importantly, how much time are you wasting doing this? Dude, I'm with you. Well, that's it for today's episode. Make sure you rate review this podcast five stars.

15:36We really appreciate it. And we look forward to talking to you and seeing you tomorrow. And check out this next video over here. Goodbye.