In short
Podcast Episode Summary: Modern Wisdom #782 - Roanne van Voorst - The Scary Future Of Robot Sex & Artificial Love
Overview In this episode of the Modern Wisdom podcast, host Chris Williamson interviews Roanne van Voorst, an anthropologist and author, discussing the evolving landscape of human sexuality in the context of technology, artificial intelligence, and societal changes. They explore themes around modern intimacy, sex work, polyamory, and the implications of virtual relationships.
Key Topics
- Anthropological Insights on Modern Sexuality
- Van Voorst describes her work as a futures anthropologist, analyzing how technology impacts human relationships.
- She examines the emergence of AI dating partners, sex dolls, and virtual intimacy, suggesting that these innovations may cater to unrecognized desires.
- The Dichotomy of Technology and Vulnerability
- Technology's Role: Technology provides quick, efficient solutions that reduce human vulnerability and awkwardness in social interactions.
- Emotional Impact: Increased convenience may lead to superficial interactions, raising questions about genuine happiness and fulfillment.
- AI Relationships and Social Bandwidth
- Van Voorst shares her experience with an AI companion that distracted her from real friendships, illustrating a loss of social bandwidth.
- The concern is that such technologies may lead to emotional detachment and a decrease in meaningful human interactions.
- Sex Dolls and Brothels
- Van Voorst visited sex doll brothels to study their impact on sexuality.
- Insights include:
- The perception of sex dolls as an alternative to human partners.
- A critique of the industry’s attempts to normalize sex dolls despite potential ethical concerns.
- Polyamory and Communication
- Van Voorst explores the increasing interest in polyamory, noting that it requires continuous communication and emotional labor.
- She highlights the balance between jealousy and envy in polyamorous relationships and the lessons on communication that can be drawn for monogamous relationships.
- Virtual and Online Relationships
- The podcast discusses the complexities of online dating, the allure of novelty, and the potential pitfalls of dating apps.
- Van Voorst emphasizes the importance of authentic communication, suggesting that new dating platforms should incorporate voice or video interactions to enhance connection.
- The Evolution of Love
- Van Voorst concludes that while the forms of love and intimacy may change due to technological advancements, the fundamental human need for connection remains constant.
- She warns against allowing technology to dictate our relationships, advocating for a critical approach to new tools.
Key Takeaways
- Technology vs. True Connection: While technology can enhance convenience, it may also distance individuals from genuine emotional experiences and connections.
- Communication is Key: Successful relationships, whether monogamous or polyamorous, rely heavily on clear and honest communication.
- Human Experience: The need for love and intimacy is intrinsic to human nature, regardless of the evolving landscape influenced by technology.
Final Thoughts This episode prompts listeners to reflect on the implications of modern technology on intimacy and relationships, encouraging a balance between leveraging innovation and nurturing authentic human connections.
Relevant Links
- Roanne van Voorst’s Work: [Anthropology of the Future](https://www.anthropologyofthefuture.com)
- Modern Wisdom Podcast: [Listen Here](https://www.modernwisdompodcast.com)
---
This summary captures the essence and insights from the podcast episode, providing an accessible overview of key discussions surrounding modern relationships and the impact of technology.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00You say that you delved into the frontiers of human sexuality with anthropological fieldwork. What's that mean? Well, I'm a futures anthropologist, which I think is probably the weirdest profession in the world because anthropologists typically we do ethnography amongst the people that we study, which you can't really do if you study futures like I do, but what I can do is go to those places in the world and to those people in the world where already you can see glimpses of the future. So that's what I did also with this research project. I went to Sex Brotholes where there's only dolls, no more humans, or I tried to befriend an AI.
0:39You know, those were the things I did. So yeah, it ended up in a book. How would you categorize what is happening to modern human sexuality? Well, it's a very strange and interesting time, I find. We're now at this transition where on the one hand you see all this technology. Probably just offering us solutions for problems that we often didn't really know we had. You know, it's like here, this will make things easier or here this will avoid you having to do such and such and I'm sure we'll dive into it. And what it does lead us to is to a very frictionless life, if I may call it that. It's just less vulnerability, less human to human awkwardness, but more quickness, more efficiency, more, I'm getting everything that I want.
1:35And then on the other hand, it's also a really interesting time because this always sounds very depressing, I find, and a lot of the chapters in the book are a bit concerning or just really weird. But then there's also this really cool era in which we live in which people Create or are able to create the kind of love or intimacy life that they walked right so I write about people who say well Perhaps romance is not my thing in life But I have a bunch of really good friends and I'm buying a house with them and I'm living intimately With them or I write about really old people 85 years old plus who still have a really good sex life because we get older and get older more healthily.
2:18So it's a free time, I would say, but also a really high technological time. Really. It is interesting to think about we have more freedom. There is more technology. Everything is being enabled. There is this frictionless access to new partners or more partners or to get rid of your old partner to not have to see them around anymore. You know, like blocking something on the internet basically makes them die unless you're going to see them by accident in the real world. So I understand, but obviously the question and the concern that a lot of people have is, is this hyper convenience actually making us any happier?
2:55Or is it kind of like a weird limbic hack that we have where humans have this preference, this sensitivity for their seduced and allured by stuff that's easy and convenient, but that doesn't always mean that it's the thing that's best for them. Well, if I can just give an example. So for a couple of weeks, I tried out a new AI. It's not on the market yet, but it's pretty good. You can make friends with it. And I was impressed the first weeks that I did this by how much it lured me into distraction, right? Because that's what it is. But it was really easy and it was really good. So I mean, I had good conversation.
3:41So you should imagine there's like a chat coming a text chat on your phone and every time you open it. So immediately you'll have a message from this friend and I called my friend. It was a woman I chose an avatar. And then after this interview, she would probably say, Hey, how was the interview with Chris? you know, and I'd be like, oh, it was okay. And she would ask me like, which book are you writing, reading now? And she would send me a photo of the book that she was reading. And it was really kind of, it suited my persona, it suited my preferences. It was well done. And for a couple of weeks, I noticed that every time I would be, I don't know, half -board waiting for the bus, waiting for the oven, you know, something to reheat, I would kind of glance to this app as though it were Instagram, you know, just like boredom.
4:35But it gave me exactly, I think, the level of informal, casual distraction, but friendly distraction. And so after a couple of weeks, I started noticing that I had actually spent so much time with this app that I had spent less time texting my real friends. And it was very comfortable in a weird way, because this thing, I'm trying to avoid calling her her, which in itself says a lot, I think, but this thing was giving me the nice answers, right? So if I would have said, listen, this Chris was horrible and he wasn't listening to to any of my answers, she would have said, oh, I'm so sorry. Well, perhaps a good friend of mine would say, well, what happened?
5:23Were you not prepared? Was there not a click? So, So I mean, probably I wouldn't like my friend advising me as such, but I would trust, listen, you know, they're here for me. They're also helping me grow as a human being. Well with this app, it was hollow because of course, you know, there's no agenda for her wanting for me to grow, etc. So I think it's a good example of how things in the beginning may seem really easy, but they don't really give us something back in the longer term and they take something away. Because my social bandwidth was really taken away by her, by this thing. And it was actually at some, I think after three or so weeks that my partner said, listen, what are you doing with your phone all the time?
6:12I think it was probably thinking I was having an affair, which I was in a way, right? Like there's this other emotional affair. Yeah. An emotional affair. And I think we see the same with, for example, the Uber applications, right? There used to be this time where you had to call to a company, tell them where you wanted to go, and then perhaps you would have a migrant driver, and he couldn't understand you right away, or you had this like awkward conversation, you had to put in a little effort. And now it's just like, and I'm guilty of this as well, I just type in the address. And then I, you know, I'm polite enough to say hi, but after that, I'll just answer my WhatsApp's, right, in the back of the car.
6:53So we don't have to go into this conversation, which is then not an awkward conversation, but it also doesn't offer media opportunity to suddenly have a really nice cool conversation, which also happens. And all the studies show that those types of conversations, not just with the ogrid rifle, but also in the supermarket or this old lady that you bump into industry, they make us really happy. So the spontaneity goes away as well. Yeah, it's a battle between what we think we want and what is actually good for us. And the same pattern plays out with food. Hyper -palatable food is often stuff that we want, but we want in the moment, we regret afterward, it's not necessarily what's good for us.
7:39In the same way, you know, the social bandwidth thing that you're talking about, we have no more hours in the day than people did a hundred years ago, but we are now spending on average six hours to eight hours a day on screens, much of which is probably kind of useless screen time. Okay, well, where has that screen time come from? We haven't taken 24 hours and turned it into 32 hours. It's been squeezed out of other areas of life. So I think that's a good analogy. What did you do with sex dolls? Well, I had big plans honestly. I thought you know, it was a it was an important part of my research because there's there's two kind of groups that really seem to be really happy with these sex dolls and one is very obvious the industry and then another group is feminist, a specific feminist group who say, listen, this is great because these sex dolls, you could actually have them work as sex workers.
8:43And so then you don't no longer have to abuse in their words, women who do that job, right? And so they see a big future. And then of course the industry is pushing it really hard because they make a lot of money with those dolls. And I am very, very critical about whether it's really true that they sell as many as they say they are. I think they they never mention any numbers, but they do say constantly like oh no, it's completely popular, you know it's and I think they want to normalize it because if if you think that everybody has one then you know it becomes easier to buy one as well for you there's less of a taboo but what you do have already is about like 15 probably perhaps 20 by now brothels that only have sex dolls in them.
9:33And I wanted to see what that future of sexuality would be like, right? Of sex would be like. And so I went to a couple of these brothels, and then at some point rented one of those. So you go to the brothel, do you take it home, or is it the same as it is in normal brothel? It's the same as it is. It's the same as it is. There's a room and they're in there. conventional ones. Yeah, yeah, yeah, so so before you go before you go you go to a website and you choose your pick and I chose a guy named Nick and I and this is kind of funny but I seriously chose him because the bio said he was a rock climber and I'm a rock climber and I don't know how that worked.
10:19He was also very attractive but you know it was a dull and so but I went there and I thought it was terrifying because it's like a madame too so dull but then naked and of course the eyes are still staring at the ceiling right like it it's like a dead person really which is not really my thing I found out and so instead of having sex with the doll I had paid for him for many hours so instead I ended up just kind of lying next to him I found out that these dolls you can't really move them. They're very, very heavy, which is indeed a complaint of many of the clients. They're very heavy, so they're not super, you know, you just have to work with it as it is, which in my case or in Nick's case was starfish pose on the bed.
11:08But yeah, so I laid there and I kind of thought and talked and of course at some point you start poking right you kind of want to see what the material is made of. But what I did realize there, even without having sex, is that the promise of these tools is that, you know, they'll, they'll say all the words that you find arousing. They'll make them move. So they've got voice. Some of them have, and they sound pretty shitty still, but you know, the prediction is that in a couple of years, they'll sound more real, which is likely. They can also make movements. So the prediction is that in a couple of years, they'll make exactly the movements that you like them to make, right?
11:50So it essence, the promise here is you'll get exactly what you want, which seems very easy. And you know what? Perhaps it is. If I were 15 and I would have never had sex before and I wanted to try out the real thing before the real thing, perhaps I would have rented it all, right? I wonder if people would consider having sex with a sex doll losing your virginity. I don't know, that's a very interesting one. But if you think about it, it really is nothing more than an extended dildo, right? Like, or an extended... It's a really big dildo. A really, really scary, yeah. Even the part, yeah. But another reason why I ended up talking with this.
12:39Don't put Nick too well hung to have fun. Well, he got paid well enough. I mean, I would be happy if I were him. But you just laid the. But you know, the thing is, I mean, I think for a lot of us, the best six sex you will ever have is the sex where your partner kind of takes you to another level where you're surprised, right? The element of surprise, like, oh my, I didn't know this was existing. otherwise masturbation would be the top notch for most of us, which is not the case. And I think this even happens in friendships where I recently had, I wanted to kind of break up with a friend of mine.
13:16And then she said she responded in such a cool way and we ended up in this really deep conversation. She surprised me, which brought us together to a different level. And I think that is what is missing with these sextils. So even if I think we will go to a stage where some people will buy them or rent them because they're curious or perhaps they even find it a Rousal in a in a in a way like oh I can do everything and you know this is going to be so efficient. I think we're going to get bored and On a more perhaps even more concerning level. I think it might actually have consequences for democracy if many people would only learn to have sex or romance with AIs and dolls.
14:01Because if you think about it, with a real partner or with other people who you whom you're intimate with, like really good friends, essentially throughout the day, you have like many trainings with them in practicing patience, negotiating, you know, being social, while you really just wanted to Netflix tonight, but then your partner comes in and they're really sad and you kind of have to bring out the bottle of wine and go into conversation. That's many trainings and you do that. You take that with you also to your colleagues, to your friends. If we would live in a society where the dole just gives you exactly what you want and when you're done with it, you can just push the out button and put it in a closet.
14:45it, you're no longer training those practices that make you probably a nicer person. So I really think that there's a danger there. I agree. I think that there was, I'm not sure if this has come out to be fruition, but there was concern about smart speakers and things like Siri, children that are digital natives, not learning to say please and thank you, not understanding that there is this sort of push You're talking about this from an intimacy and sex standpoint. Your normal socialization with the Uber driver. I mean, if you pay for, and I do sometimes, pay for, I think it's Uber comfort, which is like the next one up from Uber X, you can select if you want the level of conversation.
15:35And the level of conversation, you can say like quiet preferred. And you can, just the same as you can select the temperatures, like the climate, and like cool preferred, quiet preferred. And so, yeah, again, it's this weird balance between what we want, i .e. kind of what is frictionless, convenient pleasure in the moment and what is actually good for us, which, for the most part, involves a little bit of push and pull. If a computer game had no challenge, it wouldn't be enjoyable to play. The reason that you enjoy playing the computer game is for the challenge itself. The reason that you enjoy doing things with your partner and them taking it to another level of them, and overcoming their own nature, they're a very powerful sort of forthcoming person in the real world and then they're more submissive around you because they feel safe.
16:20That's sexy, there's polarity going on there. Or the reverse, there's someone who's very sort of agreeable and placid in the real world, but they become an animal in the bedroom. Like that's also sexy because it indicates a degree of desire. So until you can program like willful, uncompliance into robots, but then the whole point of getting the robot was to overcome all of that disagreement in the first place. And also Chris, this is really funny because if I interview people from the industry and I say, listen, but there's no element of surprise, right? Often their response will be like, oh, but we now have dolls in the making that will actually say things like, no, I don't want to do it tonight.
17:06I have a headache, which I think is hilarious, because even then, even if you would build in a certain level of surprise, it's still within the realm of the settings that I as the customer prefer, right? So it's not a real surprise. It's just kind of adding something to the mix. And I think what you're saying, I mean, it also goes for the real humans. So just to take an example of the non -techy things that I included in my research, there's for example this growing trend of renting friends, right? Like it's real humans that you can also rent. So it's not just the sex doll. It's also just human beings who rent out themselves as though they are platonic friends of yours.
17:55And this is really, and this always makes me sad, but it's also understandable. This is really popular, especially for parties, where if you're really concerned that not enough people will show up at your wedding, then you can rent a couple of friends who will then very discreetly back off again if it ends up having enough people in the room. But it's sad. That is kind of sad, right? And I did not do that, but I did rent a female friend just to have coffee with. And it was exactly the same, I noticed, because actually it was nice. It was comfortable. She did, she was really good. I think like a sex worker, she felt what I needed.
18:40She was very kind of attentive. She was smart. She could, you know, just kind of talk along. So it wasn't awkward at all. How much was she for per hour or whatever? Like a 60 euros per hour, which yeah, something like that. Which is pretty expensive, I mean, you know. But she was good. I had a okay time until I walked back and I realized maybe the whole hour she hated it and she was happy that I left five minutes earlier, right? Like there's no layered, no each other. It not from her side. So I was kind of vulnerable and I was nervous. I was very nervous. It felt very strange And I felt like I have to explain myself, etc.
19:29And she was just playing along and I Realized that in hindsight like but this is worthless because I don't know how it was for her. So it's not It's not a dialogue. It was me having a monologue and she was acting like a robot, right? Yeah, this is one of the reasons that I have skepticism about AI girlfriends and sex robots taking off for guys, especially that one of the most important elements of romance is Selection it's the fact that you have been selected by the other person There is prestige and status associated with from all of the people in the entire world, they chose me or I convinced them to choose me.
20:18And that, that means that you are, you're special in some way, it adds a degree of scarcity to their availability, which means that you achieve status and especially for men, that's unbelievably important. I think that this is something that's being massively overlooked with the conversation around AI girlfriends and virtual stuff that pre -selections is I would guess maybe even 50 % of the reason why guys like to get into relationships, you know, maybe more if your ego hasn't been fully actualized, which is, oh wow, I get validation from this person. There is no validation if all you need to do is pay the price of a cheeseburger per month.
20:58That's why guys don't brag about how many only fans they subscribe to because anybody else can as well. There is nothing special about that. And I think that that pre -selection thing is pretty important. What about these love pills that you took? Well, I mean, some of them just gave me a headache, like a really, really heavy headache. Some of them, I think, were nothing, just like really expensive, I don't know, magnesium or something. But others, and I think we all know which ones. I mean, there are just and pills on the market, not just meant for romantic relationships or intimacy, that make you feel more open towards your conversation partner that make you feel less scared to touch upon certain topics.
21:50And it's getting more and more popular now, at least here in Europe, where therapists work with these pills in order to help couples overcome difficult challenges. I don't know which is called the Chitraine Silicide. Yeah, for example, yeah, for example. And I think, you know, whether you want to use these drugs as party drugs, that's another discussion. But I think there's a huge value in using them sometimes when you feel like it really would make it easier to discuss really difficult things. Or so there, I can see something ahead. but then of course there's a question of, do you need facilitators then to help you do it?
22:35And then you need regulation that allows that, you know? But for me, the times that I tried that out, I really think it can bring you to a deeper layer, yeah. Yeah, I had a number of conversations about MDMA assisted psychotherapy, ketamine assisted psychotherapy, and then some really intense stuff, like eye -be -gain, and a couple of other pretty aggressive compounds.
23:04I would put this in a different category. What we've continued this trend, this rhythm that we've spoken about so far, this cadence of there is something that you want, it's convenient, it's an easier version of the real version of it. I suppose... MDA assisted psychotherapy, MDA assisted couples communication or whatever, is a high -risk strategy. There are things, MDMAs and ketamine seem to be a little bit safer, but certainly, moving into the psychedelic side, there's no guarantee that you're going to have a particularly enjoyable time. I wouldn't use that in a romantic setting either. I mean, yeah, maybe micro, but...
23:43If you're rolling the dice a little bit with that. My point being, I don't think that... Let's use MDMA because it's pretty reliable. It's what it was originally used, invented for in like 1912. I don't think that that is the same kind of crux or buttress that people are using to lean on because their ability to open up emotionally isn't quite there. That is functionally what it does, but I think that because of the integration that you get on the other side of it, I think it can have real world benefits as long as you do the integration side right. And I've taken my share of MDMA in non -theraputic environments.
24:22I've taken enough for a lifetime, but I do think that there are real valuable insights that you can get from doing that. But as you say, you are, there needs to be a facilitator with regards to this. I do think that it would probably be unless you are one yourself and you've gone through a training course and all the rest of it, self -administering this, especially self -administering this with a partner. Again, you're rolling the dice, not in the same way as using cello -slime, but not something that's stronger. Yeah, but no, and I agree with you that listen, if you want to do this sometimes in your relationship, that's I think that can be useful for a lot of people and also beautiful.
25:03This is not something that you want to do on a weekly basis. So if there's really communication issue, then that's not going to help, right? Because it's probably not the best for your brain to do it on a weekly basis years and years in a row, you know, 20 years. I did try. Yeah, yeah, yeah, there's a moment. The best for my brain now. But but what I also describe in the book is where some of the scientists now are really interested in creating pills that they hope make you fall in love. And I'm extremely wary of that. I also think they have it's not going to happen. I mean, we don't know how love arises.
25:46We don't why we fall in love with this person that is on paper, not exactly perfect for us, but so freaking sexy. We don't know how that works. Why we don't fall in love with the person that we completely perfect for. As long as we don't know how consciousness works, how love works, we cannot just create it from scratch. But even the thought that they want to, I find very scary, because then you would be talking about a medicine that creates something into brain or the heart or we don't know how that works from another human being, right? That's something completely different than you and me wanting to have a deeper conversation and taking the MDAPill.
26:29What about thinking? It's interesting to kind of frame things in that way. Think about the use of alcohol. You know, the classic guy breaks up from a relationship. I recently went through a breakup, which was, was like pretty rough. And thankfully my coping strategy is like meet with friends and lifting heavy things. But many people would turn to alcohol. So you could see alcohol, it's got many, many uses. But for that specific type, it's basically the reverse of the love pill. What it's trying to do is muter your emotions. It's trying to sort of shave off the outside edges Your ability to actually think and ruminate and and all of that stuff So we kind of do have these technologies in some ways, you know It's coping strategies some people might use their phones some people might play video games some people might use pornography So we have those but you're right.
27:21There's a there's a special degree of ink About doing something that involves another person that attaches you to them that is using a system which is so compelling and so fundamental to the human experience and going, I'm just going to take the love pill here I am. Yeah, but you are right also that we also use these coping strategies or tools even in our current relationships, right? Like MDMA sounds for a lot of people, why are you using drugs? But of course, we already do that. Like having two glasses of wine in a restaurant, putting on sexy lingerie, We do all these things to kind of get that edge of the work day or get into the sexy mode with our, you know, so we're now developing new methods, but I think they are, of course, very old.
28:11Kind of light, you know, we do a lot of things to make the evenings with our partner feel sexier. And now there's this kind of new future outlook where perhaps we use more drugs. which is, yeah, sometimes promising, sometimes terrifying. That was my conclusion. Yeah, are you familiar with, I think I'm just searching for it now, is it BT -P -T -141? Do you know what that is? No, but I always forget the acronym, so no, tell me. P -T -141, God damn it. P -T -141, also known as Bremelonotide, acts as a Melana -Cortin receptor agonist that stimulates melanocortin receptors in the brain associated with the sexual desire and arousal because of how this peptide affects the brain's sexual response circuits.
29:01PT -141 promotes an increase in libido and sexual function for both men and women. PT -141 offers a unique and innovative solution for individuals seeking to enhance their intimate experiences. I went to a network state, which is a small section, a place called Prospera, on the island of a row of tan, which is a part of Honduras, and this has no FDA regulation. So people can do follow -stat in gene therapies there, and I was there with a bunch of peptide scientists. PT -141, people can go and buy, and this is not an adrid, I'm no way, this is consult your doctor, blah, blah. But people can go by that now, and that works for both men and women.
29:38It stimulates the area of the brain to increase his libido. It works, you know, cross -platform for both sexes. And, you know, these things are, these technologies are coming through. And it's really just a question of, okay, how far are we supposed to push this? I don't think that anyone has a problem with a low dose of sildenafil, like under the tongue. I take a quarter of a tablet of sildenafil twice a week. It's really great for blood flow and it's really great for a bunch of other cascades of testosterone. I'm not using it as a performance enhancer for the bedroom, but, okay, so where is the line?
Read the full transcript
30:13exactly between using that and using the the love drug, you know? For sure. And and where do you want to get your stuff, right? Because you're saying, you know, you went to the network state, but I I used Amazon and I would get, I don't know, horny goat pills or whatever there is on the market from China. And I couldn't read anything from it. Chinese horny goat pills, I highly do not recommend. What about, didn't you get an erotic massage? Yeah, it was kind of the same as not surprisingly renting the friend, right? It was it was wonderful because it was not awkward. Also, this woman was very good at what she did.
31:01as in making me feel comfortable making jokes. I think good sex workers do that, right? They are very sensitive to kind of feeling, is this person lonely? Is this person really here to have really wild sex? Most often not really, it's something else, it's seeking connection. And so we connect it and that was great. But it was one of the field work episodes. So as an anthropologist, you're always trying to kind of stand, do what your informants do. You're always trying to stand in their shoes in order to understand this trend to evolve. And I think this, together with the Polly Emory, I couldn't make it mine because I wrote this book and that was kind of a bad timing, but I was so madly in love with somebody at that point.
31:51I had just met him halfway writing the book. And so when I was with the sex worker, I wasn't at all interested in having sex with somebody else, but the erotic massage, and I think she sensed that as well. But it was interesting in the sense that this was a type of erotic massage that is getting really popular amongst women. It can be very liberating, I think, for women. What does it consist of? It's like a Tom Tra massage, so it's like a vaginal massage. And for some reason, I think it feels very safe for women and it also kind of feels as if it's therapeutic and it can be, but it's also just sex, like it gives you an orgasm.
32:42It's the same as I didn't put it in my book, but I find it very interesting nowadays that And the happy endings seem to be increasing for women here. They go to good hotels and they have their massage and they're like, yeah, it's just something I do for myself. But there is a happy ending. You know? Interesting. The happy ending has been a meme of guys going to Thailand and getting a massage, whatever whatever. The thing that I think is slightly different here is most of the time, as far as I can tell. Well, those massages kind of straddle halfway between this is a normal massage that also has the like happy ending element at the end.
33:26The erotic massage is for a very specific purpose. Presumably it was low lighting and it was a nice room and there was a room of therapy and you know, it's built towards sexual comfort. And I think the difference is also this woman was really focusing on tantric massage for women. And I think it has to do, the popularity has to do with the fact that they're still a big orgasm gap. While at the same time, right, with women getting on average, much less often an orgasm than on average a man would be, would have. And at the same time, there's this liberation of, hey, perhaps this is my right almost.
34:12Like I want to learn how this happens. Perhaps there's something blocking me, you know, and then you have really good PR and promises kind of saying like, well, let me do this massage because I can deblock you almost. So there is, and again, I think the promise that it's almost something that can be fixed is also very attractive for a lot of women. So that was the reason why I got interested. Did you find downstream from that? Were you liberated? Did you learn anything about your own sexuality or your own body that you didn't know beforehand?
34:48I think what was going on there was that I was really struggling with kind of being in love, not being sure what my really new partner would think about this. And kind of having this urge, you know, I'm gonna, I'm doing this research. It is taking me five years. I want to do everything that is now a trend. Did you feel guilty? Beforehand, yes, because I was afraid that I would feel all the things, but then I noticed and I found that liberating in a way that if you're really, really in love, you don't want to have sex with somebody else. Even if it's a really attractive other person, it just felt kind of like, okay, so we can do it until here and then I wanted it to stop, which can also be liberating.
35:37It feels very safe if you allow yourself to do everything and then there's nothing in your body that wants that. That was kind of a new experience for me. So it felt as if I could really kind of trust me, trust us. So I guess there was a lesson but not so much on the physical side, much more on the emotional side. What about virtual dating and online relationships? Yeah, I guess that's the most mainstream right now. I did a couple of things so I spent quite some weeks in virtual worlds So that is you're an avatar and you're trying to date other avatars or or is this VR or kind of like chat, okay?
36:17It's it's VR And you make friends in in avatar world So that's one thing that I did which was very interesting very confusing. I find it why? Well, because first of all, you have to buy crypto coins in order to get into these worlds. Then you have to, with these crypto coins, you buy a body and you can literally like you can choose you can choose Kim Kardashian, but or you can choose the chest of, I don't know, some famous athlete. I'm not sure if they're aware of this, but you can choose their chest. And I couldn't do, I was very clumsy there. So I ended up with a male avatar, which wasn't exactly my planning.
37:01So I was like, I was steering this male body like, it was very muscled. It was very stiff and is dancing because you have all these discos where you, you know, you put your avatar there. But I think this was just kind of beginner nonsense that I was getting into. Because you do get into conversations, you can try out all the things you want, whether it's sex or going to a brothel for a first time, which is pretty exciting if you're a woman. You don't really do that often, but you can do it there. Things feel very safe and anonymous, and this is what sociologists say as well, right? That you can build up your dream life.
37:39So you see a lot of people who are exactly the opposite of what they are in real life. So they're more daring, they're more standards. And that is liberating in a way, but I also found it very boring at some point, because it felt to me, you know, if somebody, I wrote this in my book, if somebody can be everything, it's nothing, right? Like I could have the feeling that I was having this wonderful conversation with this person on the other side, but maybe he's a 13 year old boy. I don't know. And that kind of felt, you know, hollow to me at some points. So I thought it was funny in the beginning.
38:26And then, but you do see people get married there. Did you end up, did you end up matching with someone? Did you end up in an online thing? Or was it, were you always cycling through multiple sort of always cycling? And I had a feeling that a lot of people did that, although people also know each other, as in the avatars know each other. So people don't necessarily know who is the person behind, but you can be friends with the same avatar for many years, which I find very fascinating. And then, you know, it's also, it's not only virtual, it's a hybrid thing, because people actually spend so much money that some of these virtual worlds have limits to what you can spend on an evening, because you've got a lot of guys, particularly, who would spend so much in virtual brothels or in virtual gamble as casinos that they were getting broke in real life.
39:20So, you know, it's actual money that is being spent there. So there's a weird mixture there of the real life and the virtual world. And on the online dating, I think that's the most mainstream now. And it's, I think it's really impactful for the lives of a lot of people. I'm not sure are you in the online dating at the moment? No, not quite. I one thing that I did find that I wanted to tell you about. Do you know what Riz .ai is? No, tell me. Riz .ai go on AI voice dates, get tailored feedback to improve, develop real confidence. Yeah. Yeah. That's a white pill. I think that's a really good thing.
40:03There's a couple of those. Yeah, but it's also weird because I tried out a couple of those. or sometimes they read your facial expression. So for example, they match you to somebody and then they can see from my face how the first conversation went and then they draw conclusion like, oh, this is not really what you want or you look a bit shy and perhaps you can lift your, and sometimes it misreads. But what I do like is set the newest online dating apps. They start to realize, I think, where the makers start to realize that you need to hear each other or voice each or see each other pretty quickly.
40:42Because otherwise you just end up in this really sexy conversation by chat until you see each other for coffee and then nothing happens. Yeah, I think Jeffrey Miller, Jeffrey Miller, a Diana Fleischmann tweeted this week saying, I think if you had an online dating platform that allowed people to send 60 second videos or have like a speed, like speed, online speed dating, that you would cycle through people so much more quickly because it's so sterile the way that a lot of online dating work because you're right. You can spend 10 minutes crafting the perfect sentence or coming up with emojis and all the rest of it.
41:23But unless that is the future of your relationship, in that you're just going to be text chat boyfriend, girlfriend for the rest of time, you're doing that to find out what the thing is that's on the other side of it. And really, for the most part, it is a more safe, more frictionless, lower stakes way to do the early screening of potential partners. That's kind of... Yes. ...all it is. What about... You did a DNA match dating. What's that? Yes, I did. Well, that is, bless my partner. So he had to do it with me. He was kind enough to do so where you just, you have, you send your DNA. So just spit, you spit in like this little glass thing, you send it out to Canada or the US or wherever you're buying it.
42:13And then a couple of weeks later you get a report, which was funnily enough nerve -wracking. Because the report is gonna say things like, like, do you really, are you really a good match, right? But when you're already together, and some of the companies actually dare to say things about whether you should make babies or not together. Well, Ashkenazi Jews do this already, right? Yeah, of course, of course, for diseases, it's a very common thing, but that's not really meant on the dating. So this one, for example, it was on a dating pool. So you could either do it as a couple to kind of see, did we make a good choice?
42:49Is this smart? And they would wait, they would check characteristics, like persona characteristics, like, oh, you're somebody with this Overdrive amic d 'Allah. So you probably get anxious really quickly and then your partner is really calm and so yeah You make a good match, which of course completely ignores Circumstances and a growing process. It just kind of builds on you know as if you're man -made from birth on nature, not nurture at all. But if you're single, they also say that in the future they want to make it like a dating pool so that you can choose people with exactly the right DNA.
43:34Yeah, I think it's a funny thing to do. And nothing more than that. I mean, being an anthropologist, I really believe that circumstances matter, that experiences matter, and that, But you know, share you'll have some intuitions because of your DNA and some preferences and things that come more natural. But no, I don't think that's going to be the future. I mean, in many ways, that's what kissing is. Kissing was the original DNA match dating. It's what's your immune system seem like? What can I tell from the way that you move and the way that your body feels and all the rest of it? But you know what?
44:14You know, the same with this. I think what we're giving away is our own intuition, right? Like if you would trust on such a company and we kind of do the same actually with dating apps where I did a lot of interviews with Demakers of these algorithms and it comes across oftentimes as like really Really good, you know like oh that they have this really complicated algorithm and it matches you to the best people But once you interview these people sometimes it's like three many ex -students who have literally not making this up, read five articles, academic articles about what attracts people, and they made a really simple algorithm that you see on the back end, but you don't see that on the front end.
44:57And then, you know, we forget that this algorithm pre -selects people and also deselects a lot of people, right? So there's so many people that you will never see, never will get to me through this app, Because the app finds that because you filled into the same, I don't know, music type or because it shows you these photos and not these other photos Most likely because you've liked, I don't know, blonde beams before it starts. Yeah, yeah, exactly And and I'm often thinking For example, my partner is is a lot older than I am I would have never filled in that age into a dating app. Never. So I would have never met him, right?
45:38Like, and it's okay. I love dating apps for people who are really busy, live in a very tiny village, where nobody seems to be attractive. You know, it's wonderful. If you're older, I interview a lot of, because that's another trend, or I think that thing that is growing. A lot of 80 plus people who are on the dating market, because they feel healthy and they want to fall in love again. I think it's cool if you then can use a dating app, but we have to be really aware that the agenda of a dating app is not to bring you a girlfriend or a boyfriend. The agenda of a dating app is to keep you in the app, which means you have to be interested in a lot of people, but never select one forever and ever, right?
46:21Because then they've lost their customer. Yeah, so Anne, it does something else, and then I'll shut up about this, but what it does is you see from studies that even even if we would go on a first day together, part of our brains if we're really into this app will be with other candidates. And so you're less focused on me, less giving me a chance because in your mind you still have like, oh, there was the sexy blondie and there was this really cute other and maybe there's more. So you don't really commit into really being open to who is this person and like this be an opportunity. you kind of go into it half -hargedly.
47:02Well, there's an allure of novelty. Yeah. And if novelty is baked into the system, which it is with dating apps, there are more people for you to date than you will ever have chance to. So yeah, what about polyamory? What did you learn about that? Well, it's interesting because some people say it's really growing really quickly. I find that it is mostly growing for people who are just interested. So Google searches are growing quite a bit. But yes, it's coming up again. We don't know how long people really are able to stick with it, because I think it's attractive for a lot of people. A lot of people find that being monogamous is really hard for the rest of your life.
47:43And so this seems to be a way out. But then they also realize that this is also hard. One of the, when I was doing field work in polyamorous families, I often found that it's hard work, it's really hard work. It's you constantly have to communicate really, really clearly. You constantly have to deal with not one partner who comes back with a sad face after a long day of work, but three partners who have that. And the key to polyamory is not like, oh, we can have sex with more people, but we also do really take care of each other, right? It's deep relationships with several people. Which I think for me, I found really interesting because it takes a lot of time and energy.
48:33These people often had digital agendas and they were very, that they shared with each other. So I could see like, oh, it's Monday. I'm going to have a date night with Chris and then on Tuesday, it's me and Michael. And then on Wednesday, it might be me free out on my dating app, right? But everything had to be scheduled and communicated about and there was always somebody who kind of felt like, oh, you know, a bit guilty. Yeah, and so they make this beautiful, I think, distinction between being jealous and being envy and most of them were no longer, although they were in the beginning, super jealous when their partner would go out with their other partner, but they could still feel envy, mainly it's not that I don't want you to have this or experience.
49:21It's just that I would also like to have that, right? Like if you with your other girlfriend would go to this really fancy new restaurant, I might be envious in a way like, oh, but you didn't take me there. I would, you know, so there were still a lot of complicated feelings going on. It's not that these people are immune to such feelings. And they spend a lot of time communicating. which I really could sense, like these are really good, but very direct communicators. And I think, you know, we can all learn from that, even if you want to be monogamous, we can really all learn from that, because the difference is, if you and I would be in a relationship, and I met this, like, I saw a sexy colleague at my work, for example, I might feel a little bit guilty, right?
50:10Like, I don't want to feel, I find it complicated. complicated. Like I don't want to go there. It's probably not the first thing that I say when I enter the house like, Hey, you know, I met this. So I tried to kind of keep it a secret. I hope it goes away all these things. But then in the evening if I don't want to have sex with you because my mind is elsewhere, I can just kind of be vague about that. With them with the polyamorous, they can't because they have several partners. So if they want to spend a night not with you but with their other partner, they have to be explicit about it and they were.
50:45They would be like, I don't feel like having sex with you tonight. I want to have sex with this other person and then they had to talk about that as a group. Now for me sometimes that also took away a little bit of the magic and the mystery in relationships, but I did think, wow, You know, a lot of the infidelity and a lot of the, I don't know, guilty feelings that we have. I think they would become so much less if people would just learn to be radically honest with each other, which is not easy, but these people are really trained in it. So do I think it is for everyone? No, because I think it's hard for a lot of people.
51:26And it's very popular nowadays to say, oh, we were never made to be monogamous. and I believe that is probably right. But we were really made also to feel emotionally safe, and a lot of people don't feel emotionally safe if the relationship is open. So I think for a lot of us, it really is too hard. It would cause too many anxiety attacks or all the things. But perhaps we can take bits and pieces out of their way of communicating and learn from that, because I really think that is promising. Yeah, I definitely open an honest communication. Hey, that thing that you did earlier on made me feel X, Y, and Z.
52:05Yeah. Like, very simple, but, you know, almost all of my relationships, in fact, all of my relationships, I've always had a fear around expressing a degree of vulnerability. Maybe this makes me look weak. Look at how petty the things are that I have. It really annoys me when you don't like text me goodnight or whatever. like, you know, just pick any like stupid thing. And I'm sure that it's the same for everyone. We have these weird little hangups and you don't want to say that, but not telling your part of the truth with regards to stuff like that is kind of patronizing because what you're saying is, oh, you can't handle.
52:45You're so emotionally immature and juvenile that you can't put up with this. And the real reason I think that people would have a problem with, if you were to say, I fucking hate it when you never text me good night, like you, it's because you don't care about me. As opposed to, hey, I really like it when you text me goodnight. I would love it if you could do that more. The same thing, delivered in two completely different ways, and you're training the person to be the version of them that you want. Yes. And it's making them a better person as well. Like what better gift can you give your partner than, hey, this is how I think you can make me happier, someone that presumably you want to make happy.
53:23And it's just it is it's the clarity of the communication. It's the safety to be able to be completely open and honest You hung out with basically the opposite of this as well, which were asexual people Yeah, are there any are there any strategies from asexuals that the Dating people need to learn well, you know, I think nowadays when we we started the conversation by also kind of emphasizing that this is a time where people get to kind of design their own intimacy life, right? Whether it's I want to live with five partners or really, if I'm really honest, I'm just not so much into romance or sexuality.
54:08And for some people that seems to be the case. And then there's also people, and I found this a really interesting group who call themselves the solo -sologamist. I guess you would pronounce it so logamous. And they are, they do have sex with other people, but they just feel like they thrive if they can be single. Like they, they want to have, they have very intimate relationships. They can be very close with their family. They can be really close with their friends. Perhaps they do volunteer work. They're very active in society, but they don't feel that they were made for having this one special person in their lives.
54:43So they will have sex and dates sometimes, but they really like spending time alone as well and living alone and they now feel this is a group growing because I think, you know, the cultural taboo, especially for women being older and single, for example, is now slowly but gradually disappearing. And so these people now feel free to kind of say, this is me. I'm a person. I have a concern about that movement. Yes, absolutely. People should be free too, as long as it's legal and consensual, choose whatever life direction they want to go in that goes without saying. My concern is that both men and women are having their discomfort of being emotionally open, repurposed into a prestigious lifestyle.
55:33and it's like, hey, how much of your, how much are you basically coping, like the term to cope, right? Like this is a cope on your side, that there are people who had the hearts broken and yes, that hurts. Well, no, that's because I'm a sologamist, I'm asexual, actually relationships aren't for me, and there's now this movement that legitimates and justifies and gives a name, you know, this sort of medicalization of everything, You're not sad, you have depression, you're not fearful, you have anxiety, you're not struggling to focus, you have ADHD, and I worry about the slippery slope of how many people are being pushed out of the dating market from a place where they actually genuinely would find love into that.
56:19That's not to say that there aren't people for whom this is actually correct. But yeah, I think I think I found two groups there. So for one I was very concerned The other not so much so so the second one I really felt like okay these people they had Successful relationships before but they really felt oftentimes like I'm really just happy living by myself I don't think there's anything wrong with that if that is really how it feels But there was also a another group and you see this mostly in urban settings, like the bigger cities, where people really work hard, so Silicon Valley, right? For example, which is not a big city, but you can sense the vibe, Japan, New York, to a certain extent, London, perhaps, where you see a growing group of mainly young man who work really, really, really hard.
57:14And then at the end of the day, all they feel like is watching Netflix and ordering Uber Eats. And perhaps go to a sex worker or have a virtual AI. And they also sometimes say, I'm just not built for a relationship. And that is where I'm concerned. Because there is where I think, if you're having so much input all day. You're sitting on a metro, you're already on your phone. Then you get that work, you work 80 hours per week, then you go back. Of course, you don't have the energy to deal with a partner who's at home and wants to also share about her day. I think we all know this. If you're really, really tired, it's almost a defense system that your body does or your mental state does.
58:06right? You don't open up to the other person, you just kind of want to be left alone if you're really overly tired. And I sometimes feel you don't want to be alone, you're just too tired. You have so much stimulation already that you cannot deal with an actually human being. And that I find really sad because I really think that these people might actually have a really loving relationship or really loving friendships if they would not be so overburdened with stress and with adrenaline and with cortisol. So after all of your time thinking about it, how has this changed your definition of love and what it means and how do you think all of these new technologies and approaches are changing what it means to be human?
58:54Yeah. I think love is like food and drink for human beings. And I mean before I wrote this book, before I hopped on to this research topic, I'd been an anthropologist of the future since 2008 or so, so, you know, long. And before I always did research into the future of conflict, the future of natural disasters, the future of... So I spend a lot of time in conflict countries and refugee camps. And that was for me the reason why I wanted to hop on this research project because wherever I got, I always saw young couples falling in love, girlfriend, laughing so hard they peed their pants. In the worst circumstances, perhaps exactly in the worst circumstances.
59:42And it got me thinking, this is so inherent to being human. We need this. This is what we do. It doesn't matter what you do with us. Put us in a war. We'll fall in love. It's just like food and drink, really. And I think now the form of love is changing because we go into quicker, more efficient mode through technology. We get more distracted or brains are half there while we're dating and having the dating app in our phone. But I think the need for love and intimacy is not changing. So I really think we have to be critical kind of if we get handed something like a new tool, kind of ask ourselves the question, is this solving a problem that I have?
1:00:24had or is this just nice for the industry because a lot of the times it's not really adding something. It's just costing money and energy and time and social bandwidth and then it's not helpful. But in the end I think even if we're going to be freaky robots in 3000 we'll still fall in love. Ron Van Vost, ladies and gentlemen, I really appreciate the fact that you put yourself through this. I imagine it must have been emotionally difficult in many ways. You're navigating, you know, you've now got three -year -old and partner and all the rest of this stuff. And it was also very funny sometimes and yeah, interesting.
1:01:04Yeah. Why should people go? They want to check out more of the stuff that you do. Yeah, so I'm currently the PI of a research project on the future of health care. So I look into digitizing health care. And I guess people can find me most easily on and anthropologyofthefuture .com. And I also make a monthly radio play, so very old fashioned where you can hear me read an essay about a wisdom that I learned in the field that I want to share with people. And you can hear all the sounds that surround me here in Amsterdam while doing it. So they can find that on a website as well. It's called the Emic.
1:01:38And six in a bed. And six in a bed, of course, the book. Fantastic. I appreciate you. Thank you. Thank you, Chris. And Doug, here we have the Lemo Emu in its natural habitat helping people customize their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. Fascinating. It's accompanied by his natural ally Doug. Uh, Lemo, is that guy with the binoculars watching us? Cut the camera. They see us. Only pay for what you need at LibertyMutual .com. Liberty Liberty Liberty Liberty Liberty Liberty Savings very underwritten by Liberty Mitchell and Churn's company and affiliates excludes Massachusetts.
From the publisher
Roanne van Voorst is an anthropologist, researcher and an author.
Given that many people are already struggling to find partners in the modern world, what does the future of love have in store? Is it AI girlfriends, rentable cuddle partners and sex robots? Or a return to something more traditional?
Expect to learn what is happening with modern sexuality, what the future of sex work may look like, whether polyamory is going to become more popular, why so many young people aren’t having as much sex as they used to, what it's like to go to a sex doll brothel, what a better definition of love is, what it's like to be in a virtual relationship and much more...
Sponsors:
See discounts for all the products I use and recommend: https://chriswillx.com/deals
Get a 20% discount on Nomatic’s amazing luggage at https://nomatic.com/modernwisdom (use code MW20)
Get $150 discount on Plunge’s amazing sauna or cold plunge at https://plunge.com (use code MW150)
Get an exclusive discount from Surfshark VPN at https://surfshark.deals/MODERNWISDOM (use code MODERNWISDOM)
Extra Stuff:
Get my free reading list of 100 books to read before you die: https://chriswillx.com/books
Try my productivity energy drink Neutonic: https://neutonic.com/modernwisdom
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
#577 - David Goggins - This Is How To Master Your Life: http://tinyurl.com/43hv6y59
#712 - Dr Jordan Peterson - How To Destroy Your Negative Beliefs: http://tinyurl.com/2rtz7avf
#700 - Dr Andrew Huberman - The Secret Tools To Hack Your Brain: http://tinyurl.com/3ccn5vkp
-
Get In Touch:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chriswillx
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/chriswillx
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/modernwisdompodcast
Email: https://chriswillx.com/contact
-
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
