1. Podcasts
  2. NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast
  3. HMO, PPO or High-Deductible Plan? Navigate Open Enrollment as Health Care Costs Rise
NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast

2 Nov 2026 · 32m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

HMO, PPO or High-Deductible Plan? Navigate Open Enrollment as Health Care Costs Rise

In short

Open enrollment for 2026 health insurance—key deadlines, how rising costs affect plan choices, and how to compare HMOs, PPOs, and high-deductible plans (including HSA/FSA).

Guests

Kate Ashford, health insurance pro (NerdWallet “friend of the pod”). Backgrounds: Ashford is a benefits expert who advises on plan selection, drug coverage, networks, and tax-advantaged accounts (HSA/FSA).

Key claims

Open enrollment isn’t autopilot—check doctors, prescriptions, networks, and affordability. Health benefit costs are projected to rise 8%+ next year. For 2027, maximum out-of-pocket may reach $8,700 (individual) and $17,400 (family). HMOs are cheaper but less flexible; PPOs cost more but offer more specialist/out-of-network options; high-deductible plans can be cheaper but require cash for deductibles.

Notable examples

Hosts discuss being “middle ground” (high deductible but heavy use) as financially painful; one host’s urgent care stitches cost about $200 out of pocket; another negotiated a bill down and argued about PT pricing variability. ACA marketplace notes: insurers may leave markets; subsidies and eligibility rules for non-citizens change.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:26

Introduction to Open Enrollment

Hosts introduce the topic of open enrollment and its importance.

“Are you happy with your health insurance?”
1:49

Health Insurance Dates and Deadlines

Kate Ashford outlines key enrollment dates for various health insurance options.

“This episode, we're kicking off a not one, but two part series all about open enrollment 2026.”
2:25

Understanding Open Enrollment Importance

Discussion on the significance of open enrollment decisions and rising health costs.

“So let's start by laying out some important dates because there is a set window of time when open enrollment happens.”
4:38

Premiums vs. Deductibles Explained

Explanation of premiums and deductibles and their impact on health insurance choices.

“So what else should folks be aware of that's different in 2026.”
5:45

Personal Experiences with Health Plans

Hosts share their personal experiences with health insurance and its costs.

“And they have a kind of seesaw relationship, right?”
8:01

Choosing Between Health Plan Types

Kate discusses different types of health plans: HMOs, PPOs, and High Deductible Plans.

“Well, I will say we are high deductible plan users and we are heavy health care users.”
11:58

Evaluating Health Care Needs

Considerations for selecting the right health care plan based on individual needs.

“So I really look at that number and I take it very seriously.”
14:03

Navigating Health Care Choices

Understanding how individual health care needs affect plan choices.

“It also speaks to how different one health care office can be from the next.”
14:31

Evaluating Health Care Needs

Considerations for selecting the right health care plan based on individual needs.

“OK, well, more about open enrollment in a moment.”
17:46

Estimating Health Care Costs

Strategies for estimating health care expenses during open enrollment.

“Do you have any rules of thumb that can make this easier and also less overwhelming?”
Show all 19 chapters
18:50

Understanding Health Care Usage

Factors influencing health care decisions based on past usage.

“But at the same time, if you're a light health care user, it might also make sense for you because, of course, you're paying less for premiums and then also less for care.”
20:18

Health Savings Accounts Explained

Benefits of HSAs and their role in long-term health care savings.

“Because pregnancy is a heavy health care sort of situation.”
23:11

Flexible Spending Accounts Overview

Differences and rules regarding FSAs compared to HSAs.

“So you can save, as you are proving, a lot in your HSA that adds up over time.”
24:57

Child Care and FSAs

How to utilize FSAs for child care expenses and planning.

“But there are so many things you can spend this money on.”
26:58

Navigating ACA Plans

What to consider for ACA plans during open enrollment.

“Let's talk about the Affordable Care Act plans, Kate, sometimes called Obamacare plans.”
28:00

Changes to Emigrant Coverage for ACA

Learn about the new requirements for ACA coverage for non-citizens and state-specific changes.

“There are substantial changes to emigrant coverage.”
28:44

The Importance of Reviewing Health Insurance

Understand why it's crucial to review your health insurance annually and the impact of changes.

“All right, Kate, we have run through so very much this episode around health care and everything around open enrollment.”
29:26

Personal Healthcare Stories and Insights

Listen to personal stories about unusual healthcare experiences, including billing surprises.

“So I had a little medical emergency and I went to an urgent care, should have gone to an ER.”
30:43

Negotiating Healthcare Bills

Discover tips on how to negotiate healthcare bills and the variability in costs.

“And then I think I paid like$500 once for glue, like the glue to put together instead of stitches.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Elizabeth Ayoola: The following is a paid sponsorship, not an endorsement by NerdWallet's editorial team. Today's episode is sponsored by Bilt.

0:08Sean Pyles: You don't need me to tell you that rent and mortgage prices aren't dropping. That's why Bilt created three credit cards designed to offer the richest rewards on rent, mortgage, and everything else you spend on.

0:18Elizabeth Ayoola: Whether you rent or own, you can earn up to 1.25x points on every eligible housing payment with no transaction fee, regardless of the servicer or the lender. Points can be redeemed for flights, hotels, lift rides, a future housing payment, and so much more.

0:33Sean Pyles: Turn one of the most unavoidable payments in your life into the most rewarding. Find the card that's right for you and apply at joinbuilt.com slash smartmoney. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash smartmoney. Use our link so they know we sent you.

0:48Elizabeth Ayoola: Terms apply. Subject to approval and eligibility. Built cards are issued by Column N.A., member FDIC, pursuant to license from MasterCard International Incorporated. UKG is the workforce operating platform with unified HR, payroll and workforce management. Built to solve the unique challenges of frontline work. Powered by People First AI and decades of labor data, UKG turns workforce intelligence into real-time decisions around staffing, pay, compliance and productivity. Enabling every worker to confidently take action as work happens. Because when work works, everything works. Learn more at ukg.com slash work.

1:26Elizabeth Ayoola: UKG, HR, pay, and workforce management.

1:29Sean Pyles: Are you happy with your health insurance? What about your employee benefits? Well, now's the time to do something about it. That's right. We're talking about open enrollment. This episode, we're going deep. Welcome to NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast, where you send us your money questions and we answer them with the help of our genius nerds. I'm Sean Piles.

1:49Elizabeth Ayoola: And I'm Elizabeth. This episode, we're kicking off a not one, but two part series all about open enrollment 2026. It is that special and not so fun time of the year where we try to predict the future and select the health insurance and other benefits, of course, that will suit us best for next year. Can you believe it's almost 2027, guys?

2:09Sean Pyles: I know. I feel like I'm already planning for next summer and time is just slip slipping away. But we got to stay in the present and focus on open enrollment because it's a big decision we have to make this time of year. And to help us sort all of this out, we have friend of the pod and health insurance pro, Kate Ashford. Kate, welcome back to Smart Money. Happy to be here, Sean. So let's start by laying out some important dates because there is a set window of time when open enrollment happens. And which window applies to you depends on which kind of health insurance and health care you're navigating.

2:38Sean Pyles: Can you lay out these dates for us, please? So if people are looking for individual insurance on the marketplace, federal marketplace dates run from November 1 to January 15th of next year, although that is state-specific. Some states have different schedules, so you can Google yours. To have coverage that starts on January 1, you will need to enroll by December 15th. So that's something to keep in mind if you sign up after December 15th. You're looking at coverage that's going to start February 1st. If people are on Medicare, open enrollment started October 15th and will go through December 7th.

3:09People signing up for federal benefits, federal government employees, that open enrollment period goes from November 9th to December 14th. And if you have employer-sponsored insurance, which is many people, it's going to depend on your workplace. Usually it's a couple of weeks in the fall. We just heard yesterday about NerdWallet's own enrollment season. It's a couple of weeks in November. So keep an eye on your company and communication.

3:32Elizabeth Ayoola: So many dates, so many deadlines, Kate. But a good reminder that everyone needs to be engaging in open enrollment in some type of way. So it's not just for workplace health care, right? Because I think some people assume it's only about that. No, this is for everyone. This is basically your chance to make sure that you're set up for the next year. Check in with your coverage. Make sure that your drugs are still covered. Your doctors are still in network, that your prices are where you think they are. You can still afford your policy. Your policy will still exist next year. So it's not something that should be on autopilot.

4:04Sean Pyles: Open enrollment is some sort of like tedious, unpleasant holiday that comes around but once a year. And each holiday of open enrollment seems to be kind of worse than the last where we're seeing health care costs go up and we see a lot of employers pulling back benefits they offered in years past. And I actually was looking into this ahead of this recording and Marsh, a health benefits consultancy, found that health benefit costs are expected to jump over 8 % next year. And that is the biggest jump since 2003. So there are a lot of changes that do happen each year with this wretched little holiday.

4:38Sean Pyles: So what else should folks be aware of that's different in 2026. Sean, as you mentioned, health costs are predicted to go up. So you have to pay attention to what your employer is bringing you. That means everything. You should be looking at the deductible, the premiums, the out-of-pocket limit, because all of those can and will affect your bottom line if you are using health care. Contribution limits are going to go up for health savings accounts if you're using one. And they might also go up for flexible spending accounts, although as of the time that we're taping this, we don't know yet what that looks like for 2027.

5:06and you have to set pre-tax money aside. Now you have to decide on that amount of money during open enrollment. So you do have to think about what you want to put aside. Also, check your drug coverage. For people who have a GLP-1 who have employer coverage for it, some companies are choosing to drop that coverage to cut costs next year. So check in on that.

5:25Sean Pyles: And I know I was just ragging on open enrollment pretty hard, but it is a very important time that you should focus on and do this the right way. Set aside maybe an hour or two to make sure you're getting the right benefits for you. And there are some upsides, like the amount you can put into an HSA going up next year. So, hey, it's not all bad news.

5:40Elizabeth Ayoola: Well, Kate, as people are thinking about their health care options, they're likely going to be reviewing the D and P word, deductibles and premiums. And they have a kind of seesaw relationship, right? Because higher premiums can mean lower deductibles and vice versa. Now, as a refresher for people who have forgotten over the past year or maybe just never really understood, can you tell us what premiums and deductibles really are? Absolutely. So the premium is essentially the price tag for your insurance. It's what you pay each month. And it may not feel like something that you see very much if you're getting workplace insurance because generally that comes out of your paychecks.

6:17So you aren't actually writing a check for that, but it is something that you're paying.

6:22Sean Pyles: It is on your pay stub. So look at that number. The deductible is what you're paying out of pocket for covered care before your insurance starts paying for care. So if your policy has a deductible of$1 ,000, you would pay for the first$1 ,000 in covered health care that you get. And then your insurance will cover things after that. Although things like your annual physical and well woman visits, those are usually covered before the deductible.

6:46Elizabeth Ayoola: What do you guys do? Well, I'm all in your business, but I'll say mine first. So I prefer lower premiums because I'm relatively healthy and only really go for a checkup once a year. But I have higher deductibles.

6:57Sean Pyles: That's what I've done historically. I've had a high deductible health care plan for the past few years. And I think we'll talk about this a little bit later as we get into health savings accounts and HGHPs. But there's this sort of tricky middle ground where if you use a lot of your health insurance or you go to the doctor a lot in a certain year and you have one of these plans, you end up paying a lot out of pocket before your insurance kicks in. And that was me this year. I've been talking about this for years on Smart Money. And Kate, you've talked to us about this too. And I had issues with my sinuses.

7:27Sean Pyles: I was going to physical therapists for all of the running that I was doing. And I was forking out hundreds of dollars for each appointment. And I was like, man, I almost wish I had made a different choice for my health insurance this year. But yet having access to the HSA, which you're only allowed access to through a high deductible health care plan is still kind of worth it for me. But it's It's a very tough decision because like we always talk about, you never know what you're going to need in the coming year health insurance wise, even though you can try to kind of look back. It's never a perfect estimate of what you might have in the coming year.

7:58Sean Pyles: But I don't know. It's just it's been an expensive year for me health care wise. That's all I'm going to say. Well, I will say we are high deductible plan users and we are heavy health care users. And Sean, I will say that for us, the high deductible plan has always been the cheapest, even coming out of pocket for the full deductible, because the premiums, the premiums are so much less. And there is an employer contribution to our HSA. So it's helpful. It is cheaper. It feels worse. Yes, because you're forking out cash. Because you're paying so much out of pocket. But people forget about those premiums coming out of their paycheck for the more expensive plan.

8:33Sean Pyles: Kate, your experience really underlies how high deductible health care plans can be best for those who use very little like Elizabeth or a lot like you. And I was in that bad, not right middle of having to pay a lot out of pocket. Middle ground is tough for those decisions. It's anti-Goldilocks here. Being in the middle is not where you want to be.

8:50Elizabeth Ayoola: No. Well, how should people be considering premiums and deductibles as they shop around this year, Kate? We've kind of given our own examples, but what should people think about? So these are things that I think you said earlier. They kind of are a seesaw. They move in opposite directions. So for a plan with a high deductible, which means you're paying more out of pocket kind of as you get care, the premiums tend to be lower because you are paying more out of pocket before insurance kicks in. But if you want a lower deductible, those plans usually have higher premiums. And so you're going to pay more upfront for the benefit of just having a smaller copay when you go see the doctor.

9:27So people have feelings about how they like to get health coverage. Some people really like paying a bigger premium than just having a copay. So some of this is personal preference.

9:36Sean Pyles: I would encourage people, again, to go back to their pay stubs if they haven't thought about how much they are paying each month or each paycheck for their premiums because it can be pretty easy to ignore that number and that is real money that you're paying. Kate, given the rising cost of healthcare that we mentioned earlier, many might be looking to sign up for a high deductible healthcare plan, which we discussed a little before, where premiums are lower, but they could also be facing a maximum out-of-pocket of$8 ,700 for an individual and a whopping$17 ,400 for families in 2027. So that actually really can change the calculation for a lot of people if you can't afford that.

10:12Sean Pyles: So knowing which kind of health care plan to choose, an HGHP, a PPO, or HMO is a really complex decision. Where should people begin? There's a lot to this. And some of this is going to depend on your budget. Some is going to depend on how you use health care. So it's complicated, but here are some things to think about. First, HMOs are usually your cheapest options. They are also the least flexible, which makes sense because you're paying less for them. You usually have to go through your primary care physician if you want to see a specialist. You're usually restricted to in-network doctors and facilities, so you have care within a small bubble.

10:49PPOs are more expensive but also more flexible, so you can usually see a specialist without having to go through your primary doctor, and you may have access to some out-of-network coverage, which is important to some people. And high deductible health plans come in both forms, HMOs or PPOs. Overall, they do tend to be lower cost because there's that large upfront deductible, but it comes in all sorts of forms.

11:17Elizabeth Ayoola: What should people be asking themselves, Kate, as they weigh out these options? You want to be thinking about, do you want to be able to see out-of-network doctors? Is that important to you? You know, like for my parents, it was important that they'd be able to see someone in another state. So that sort of ad-for-network care was important to them. Would you rather pay more each month upfront so your medical co-pays are a little less? In general, how much are you able to pay per month for a plan? And that includes, you know, what's coming out of your paycheck for an employer-sponsored premium.

11:49And you have to look at that maximum out-of-pocket number because if you're a high healthcare user like me, can you afford to hit that? We almost always hit that. So I really look at that number and I take it very seriously. And if you're looking at that high deductible plan, and I cannot stress this enough, and Sean, you're living it this year, do you have enough cash on hand to cover that deductible? which you mentioned sort of the maximum, Sean, but there's also there's a minimum of$1 ,750 for individual coverage and$3 ,500 for family coverage in 2027. But that deductible can be much higher.

12:25And it does feel jarring to have to come out of pocket for that care. Even if you're paying less for premiums, it's still cash out of your bank account and it feels it feels really unpleasant. It can still be cheaper, but it doesn't work if you don't have that money available to pay for it.

12:40Sean Pyles: Kate, can I ask how your family manages that expense if you are paying so much each year? Do you have a designated savings account? Are you still able to actually put money into the HSA beyond maybe what our employer puts in, just given how expensive it all is? We put money into our HSA. And the nice thing about an HSA is that actually you can contribute to it even after open enrollment. Your FSA, you do have to choose an amount during open enrollment. You're stuck with that. Your HSA, you can contribute more later in the year if you want to. So we do keep a cushion because we want to make sure that when these bills come in, and they do at the beginning of the year, generally through July or August when we tend to hit our deductible amount, we have that cash on hand to pay for it.

13:23Elizabeth Ayoola: What about people with existing health conditions, Kate? I know when I was going through my own health care options, one of the reasons I lean towards HMOs is because, like I said, I don't frequent the doctor and it actually didn't impact me much if I had to go to a specialist because I don't usually. But someone who maybe needs lots of referrals may be better off with a PPO plan. Is that correct? It kind of depends on your patience for administrative work because you are going to have to go through your doctor for referrals. How accessible are they? Is it easy? Can you send them an email through the portal and it's quick?

13:55Or do you have to go see them every time you want a referral to a specialist? It kind of depends on your primary care doctor and your relationship with them. If you don't have to see a specialist very often, it might be just fine to have a primary care doctor who's managing your sort of situation. So it really is individual.

14:11Sean Pyles: It also speaks to how different one health care office can be from the next. Managing that administrative burden can be a big deterrent even using your health care, even if it is covered. I know I have left doctors because their offices were not user friendly. They didn't return calls. You couldn't get through to people. So it really just depends on who you're dealing with. OK, well, more about open enrollment in a moment. Stay with us.

14:36Elizabeth Ayoola: The following is a paid sponsorship, not an endorsement by NerdWallet's editorial team. Today's episode is sponsored by Simplify. You worked hard to build a nest egg that will fund your retirement. Now you may be looking for ways to put it to work in an effort to generate income. Stop waiting for your nest egg to hatch and start enjoying your life. You've earned it. Meet the Simplify Target 15 distribution ETF, ticker XV. XV was designed for income-seeking investors looking for the potential for higher income than traditional fixed income investments using a defined downside barrier option strategy that allows investors to make a more quantifiable risk assessment.

15:19Elizabeth Ayoola: The fund seeks higher income potential than traditional bonds, seeks to reduce downside risk compared with stocks, and targets a 15 % annualized distribution rate paid monthly. That means XV offers investors the potential for regular monthly cash flow. But a target is not a guarantee. Distributions may vary, may include a return of capital, and a distribution rate is not the same as investment return. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. You've built your nest egg. Now see how XV could help you put it to work. Carefully consider the fund's investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses before investing.

16:00Elizabeth Ayoola: The prospectus contains this and other information. Visit simplify.us slash nestegg to learn more. Please read the prospectus carefully before you invest. Distributed by Foresight Financial Services, LLC.

16:14Sean Pyles: Today's episode is supported by Quince.

16:16Elizabeth Ayoola: If you know Quince for their cashmere and elevated essentials, you might not know that they also have luggage that's earned a bit of a cult following. And with the holidays coming up, it might just be the most useful gift you can give or treat yourself to before all that holiday travel.

16:30Sean Pyles: There's a reason Quince luggage keeps selling out. It's obsessively engineered with durable polycarbonate shelves, smooth 360-degree spinner wheels, and a built-in compression system so you can pack more, stress less, and focus on where you're going.

16:43Elizabeth Ayoola: And travel isn't just one bag. Quince has hard shell suitcases in a range of sizes, plus nylon weekenders, totes, backpacks, and travel accessories, so you can build your perfect travel setup.

16:56Sean Pyles: Elizabeth, I know you have a Quince suitcase, right? How's that working for you?

17:00Elizabeth Ayoola: I do have a carry-on suitcase. I needed a new one because my last one cracked. And actually, it's been working great. It's very lightweight. It's stylish. I love the color. And also, it fits a lot of things. And I travel with lots of things.

17:12Sean Pyles: Yeah, last year, I picked up some luggage tags and a passport holder from Quince. They're the nice Italian leather. They're matching in red. It looks very chic. I feel very sophisticated whenever I travel with them.

17:22Elizabeth Ayoola: I might have to add that to my list of things to buy.

17:24Sean Pyles: These things also make great gifts. So give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to Quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was smart money. It's the best way to support the show.

17:46Elizabeth Ayoola: Now, Kate, even with all this information, there is still a certain amount of guesswork that you have to do and almost crystal ball gazing. Do you have any rules of thumb that can make this easier and also less overwhelming? I mean, it really is about doing the guesstimating and maybe some spreadsheet math. I will say there's spreadsheet math that happens at my house. And you just have to understand where you are as a health care consumer. And if you are a person that has heavy needs year to year, that's easier maybe to estimate than someone who isn't sure. And, of course, things pop up that are unexpected.

18:17And you might not know that next year will be a heavy health care use year for you. But I would mention that it's so worth taking all the numbers and putting them together because it could be that that high deductible plan, even with the high deductible, is less overall, even if you hit the deductible because maybe your employer gives you a contribution and you're paying less overall for premiums versus a higher PPO plan with heavy premiums. Maybe you're paying thousands of dollars in premiums before you even pay a dollar for care. So you have to keep that kind of thing in mind. But at the same time, if you're a light health care user, it might also make sense for you because, of course, you're paying less for premiums and then also less for care.

18:57It is that middle ground that gets really tricky and it is just sort of guessing. I would say NerdMallet does have a helpful explainer on how to choose health insurance, and we can link that in the show notes.

19:07Sean Pyles: Kate, I know that our listeners are a bunch of spreadsheet nerds, so I want to hear about your spreadsheet math. What does that look like? Sean, in my house, that's mainly my husband. He is a spreadsheet nerd. He loves a good pivot table and he is mapping out the premiums, the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum. We really are thinking about how much we would spend out of pocket in all the scenarios available to us. And so far for the last several years, I say at least a decade, maybe even the last 15, we've been on high deductible plans because they've worked out better for us. So in your case, Kate, it almost seems like what would be helpful for you and for other people listening is maybe looking back at the past year's health care expenses and seeing, OK, do you think you'll have these next year?

19:50Sean Pyles: Why or why not? So for me, like I mentioned, I had a bunch of unusual expenses this year. I don't anticipate having the same health care expenses next year, knocking on wood as I'm saying this. And so in that case, I'll probably be better off with my HGHP decision going into 2027 than I was going into this current year. Past behavior is somewhat a determinant of future behavior, depending on whether that was an ongoing problem or something that popped up unexpectedly. But there are also things to think about, like, are you thinking of starting a family? Because pregnancy is a heavy health care sort of situation.

20:24Kids can be heavy health care users, depending on what's going on with them. And frankly, like, I have a kid getting braces, so I'm looking at dental care options. And it's all tough to think about.

20:34Sean Pyles: Elizabeth, how does IO factor into your decision around health care?

20:38Elizabeth Ayoola: Good question. I was just going to say, as we're talking about this, long-time listeners may know that I am a fan of high deductible health care plans and health savings accounts. I have had one for five years, like you all, and it works for me and Io. We both have very similar health situations. He goes once a year so far for the past couple of years for a checkup, and we just basically go for maintenance. I do not spend much out of pocket for health care expenses. So it just works for us. So that's how I think about it. Yeah. Unless something changes, knock on wood.

21:07Sean Pyles: I always assumed that having a little boy in the house is like a healthcare nightmare. So I'm glad I haven't been the case for you. Wait, wait, let me tell y 'all something.

21:14Elizabeth Ayoola: No, I have a story. I have a story. I always have a story. Please, please, please. I had a flashback. I had like a medical emergency earlier this year. The school called me because he fell over in the playground and gushed his head. So he had a gash in his head. Yeah, terrible thing. No parent wants to hear that. So rushed there. I ended up taking him to, you guys help me as a Brit, not the emergency room what's the other one thank you so i took us with urgent care and actually i did have to pay some money out of pocket but it wasn't that much and don't ask me why because health care is so complicated but i feel like i only paid 200 bucks for that out of my own pocket and it should have been a lot more he had stitches so i would assume with our expensive health care system i'd be paying thousands and i didn't end up paying that much but aside from That's early.

22:00Elizabeth Ayoola: One off. Yeah. We're never in the hospital, so I hope it stays that way.

22:05Sean Pyles: Me too. Knock on wood for you.

22:06Elizabeth Ayoola: Well, I think that's a good segue, actually, to talking about health savings accounts, because one of the benefits for me, luckily, because my health care expenses are low, is I get to invest a lot of that money. And this is me telling too much of my business again, but I started with$0 four years ago, and just investing all of that extra income has gotten me to over$30K.

22:25Sean Pyles: In your HSA?

22:26Elizabeth Ayoola: Yes. Congratulations. I try to max it out each year. Thank you. That's phenomenal. I couldn't even believe the numbers myself. I said, well, how did that happen? I guess consistently saving. So but it just, you know, is money that can go towards future health care expenses. But Kate, what should people know about these accounts? Planners love these accounts. They really have so many advantages. They are triple tax advantage, people like to say, because the money you put in is pre-tax. You can invest that money often, and those earnings, anything you earn is pre-tax. And if you spend the money on eligible medical expenses, that money is pre-tax.

22:57So all kinds of pre-tax things happening here. Planners like to think about this as almost another retirement account, because the money you save in it, You can keep long after you've had this job. You can keep into retirement. Certainly there will be health care expenses in retirement you can use it for. So you can save, as you are proving, a lot in your HSA that adds up over time. The catch being that you do have to have a high deductible health plan in order to save to an HSA.

23:25Sean Pyles: Right. That said, if you have an HSA, you've been contributing because you had an HDHP, and then the next year maybe you change into a different plan that's not a high deductible plan, you can still keep that HSA, and it can be growing, investing in the background, but you just can't contribute to it. Exactly. Yes, you can keep it and use it in the future.

23:42Elizabeth Ayoola: I opened my first FSA this year. I have been struggling because the year is coming to an end because you have to do some guesswork with the FSA, right, which Kate, you'll tell us about. But I'm struggling to spend down the money because in most cases, not all, it's use it or lose it. So now this is going to make me do some different calculations for next year, trying to anticipate my child care costs. But anyway, Kate, tell us about how the FSA is different from the HSA and also how it works. So the FSA, what you're talking about is a flexible spending account. And it is like an HSA sort of cousin, sort of.

24:16Less flexible cousin. Less flexible cousin.

24:19Sean Pyles: FSA is such a misnomer. You think it would be flexible, but it's actually pretty rigid. It's a similar concept. You're putting in pre-tax money. During open enrollment, you decide how much. So that is kind of fortune telling. And as long as you spend the money on eligible medical expenses, you don't pay any taxes on it. However, as you mentioned, it is kind of a use it or lose it account. you do not get to take this money forward. There is a certain amount that your employer can choose to roll over from year to year. It's not a ton. I think it was$680 this year. I think it's$700 next year, but they don't have to.

24:50It's optional for them. And if you don't spend it all, you do just lose it. It's gone. I believe it goes back to your employer. But there are so many things you can spend this money on. I mean, you can buy over-the-counter meds. You can buy menstrual products. You can buy eyeglasses, sunscreen. You can buy pimple patches, a variety of skincare products. And I'm here to tell you, I'm sure that my two teenagers could come up with a lot of things skincare-wise that we could spend this money on, given the choice. But you do have to decide during open enrollment what you're going to set aside. So you have to think about what your upcoming expenses might be.

25:25Sean Pyles: What's nice is that there are a couple of flavors of FSAs. There's the regular FSA that seems to be more for things like the pimple patches and healthcare care expenses. There's also the dependent care FSA. And Elizabeth, is that what you had for Ayo?

25:39Elizabeth Ayoola: Exactly. So I was just about to say, I can use my dependent care FSA funds on pimple patches. So I wanted to clarify, yes, I'm talking about the dependent care FSA that I'm trying to spend down. Yes, yes. And that's generally, we've aged out of that because I think it's 13 or under or under 13. You can spend money on care that's required while you're working. It does include a lot of child care, but not all, but a good amount of it.

26:03Sean Pyles: Elizabeth, every year you are hit by this big financial bomb of IO summer camp expenses. And I hope your FSA covered that this year.

26:11Elizabeth Ayoola: A relief. Let me tell you one less thing to worry about. It was amazing. I will be using the FSA again next year. It just helped me to plan out my expenses so I didn't have to pull anything out my emergency savings. I know it's my money, but it almost felt like I got free child care. It's not mental accounting here. But because the money was allocated to something else and I had already saved the money, it just took a lot of stress off of me. But I did overestimate how much I was going to spend. So I have some money that I need to spend down. But I also realize you can use it, like you said, for child care expenses while you're working.

26:43Elizabeth Ayoola: They're very strict about that. But, yes, it's been very helpful this year. I miss being able to use my Dependent Care FSA because there are still child expenses, by the way. But they're too old. They're too old to qualify for Dependent Care FSA funds. Aren't there always expenses for these kids? Okay. Let's talk about the Affordable Care Act plans, Kate, sometimes called Obamacare plans. We saw the loss of subsidies for these plans send prices for this kind of insurance even higher earlier this year. What should people know about ACA plans heading into this open enrollment season? If you're shopping for an ACA plan next year, definitely pay attention to what's happening with your plan because some insurers are entering or leaving certain markets around the country.

27:22So it could be that your plan is ending and you will get notice about that, but you do have to be paying attention to your mail, your email, so that you catch that notice when it comes by. And you'll want to compare options and choose something new because otherwise you could be auto-renewed into a plan chosen by an algorithm and that might not be the best one for you. So keep an eye out. Unfortunately, prices are going up even more here than sort of across the board. The median proposed price hike on the ACA is 15 % for 2027, which means half of plans have a lower price hike, but half of plans have a higher price hike.

27:57So keep an eye out for what your premiums are going to look like next year. There are substantial changes to emigrant coverage. So next year, qualifying for marketplace subsidies, you must be a lawful permanent resident, a Cuban-Haitian entrant, or a compact of free association migrant. And there are about 17 other immigration statuses, so you'll want to look into that closely if you're a non-citizen looking for ACA coverage. And then for state plans, because this is state by state, I just wanted to know that Oregon is moving to a state-run marketplace system rather than the federal system. And Virginia and Rhode Island are both adding state-funded subsidies to help people pay for health care.

28:37So that's good news for those states.

28:38Sean Pyles: So do your homework on what your local area is offering HealthGrowRise because it varies so much across the country. All right, Kate, we have run through so very much this episode around health care and everything around open enrollment. Any final words of wisdom to leave folks with? It's so easy to tune out the advice to look closely at your health insurance. It is tedious. It's kind of boring. It's hard to understand. It's not fun. However, it affects you greatly and things change from year to year. Your drug coverage could change. Your doctor could leave your network. Your hospital could leave your network.

29:12And if you get into 2027 and you've chosen a plan that doesn't include something you think it should include, you are stuck unless you have a special enrollment period due to a life event like getting married or getting divorced or having a baby. So make sure you take a look because once you've chosen your coverage, you've chosen your coverage for next year.

29:31Elizabeth Ayoola: Wait, guys, one more thing. Oh, my gosh. Wait, I have one more story for you. I think that was last year. How about how I got free healthcare? So I had a little medical emergency and I went to an urgent care, should have gone to an ER. And I'm not gonna give you the details because a little gory, but I was in excruciating pain. I needed a mini operation. They had no utensils. They had no tools. So they kept me waiting and they had to go and get tools. They really didn't know what they were doing. So I was waiting there for ages. And at the end, they refused to let me go home after I gave them my insurance.

30:07Elizabeth Ayoola: And they were like, no, we need to wait. We need to run your insurance. So now I was stuck there for like an extra hour. And they felt so bad that they said, don't worry about the cost. Maybe I missed money. Maybe I could have sued and got some money out of that. Maybe that's why they said just go because there was medical negligence there. I don't know.

30:22Sean Pyles: Yeah, you paid with your time, I guess.

30:24Elizabeth Ayoola: That is unusual. Right? Bizarre.

30:28Sean Pyles: This makes me a little worried about the treatment that you got.

30:30Elizabeth Ayoola: But I got free health care. A year later, I'm fine, you know, well, for now. But anyways, I don't know what the story in that is, except, hey, if people mess up, maybe you'll get some free health care. But still get your coverage, though. I'm going to tell the opposite story. And then I think I paid like$500 once for glue, like the glue to put together instead of stitches. And I called and argued with them. I was like, can we both acknowledge that this is glue? $500 glue? I did actually manage to argue that bill down, believe it or not. So you can call and negotiate. It doesn't always work. Sometimes it does not work.

31:06But it did in that instance. I didn't get a ton off, but I got some off.

31:09Sean Pyles: Both of your stories show how weirdly malleable the health care system is. Sometimes you're totally overpaying for something ridiculous. Sometimes you are underpaying for being like weirdly neglected by your health care provider. And regardless, I think people should be negotiating their health care bills and scrutinizing them because sometimes people are being charged crazy amounts for things like ibuprofen. And this whole system is so wackadoo and it relies on us being kind of exhausted and not arguing for these things. But similarly, this past year, I was going to PT a lot. Each bill for each appointment varied by like$20.

31:44Sean Pyles: And each appointment they were getting like$20 more expensive. And I was getting effectively the same service. I was just picking this guy's brain about how I can help my legs not hurt when I run so much. And I wasn't really able to get a clear answer about why it costs different each time.

32:00Elizabeth Ayoola: Because they feel like they can.

32:02Sean Pyles: Yeah, and they're counting on me not calling. And they said they weren't able to change the amount. And again, by that point, I was so exhausted. I was just like, whatever, it's 20 bucks. But if you have the time and the energy and like to pick a fight, your health care bills are a good place to start. It is. It is a frustrating fight, but is one worth fighting? I have a friend who called to pay a bill in full recently, and they offered her a discount. Just out of the blue. Wow. Oh, you're paying in full, so you get 20 % off. And she's like, why was this not advertised up front? And also, I have done that many times.

32:30No one has ever offered me 20 % off, but - Same.

32:32Sean Pyles: They found that office manager on a good day.

32:35Elizabeth Ayoola: There are no rules. They make them up as they go along. There are no rules.

32:39Sean Pyles: Yeah. But the one rule is, choose your open enrollment plan by the deadline. Yes. Yes, please. Yes. Okay. Don't miss it. Kate, thank you so much for talking with us today. Thank you for having me, guys. That's all we've got for this episode, folks. Remember, send us your money questions. You can leave us a voicemail or text us on the nerd hotline at 901-730-6373. It's 901-730-NERD or email us at podcast at nerdballot.com. As always, you can drop us a comment on Spotify or YouTube.

33:05Elizabeth Ayoola: Join us next time for part two of our open enrollment series. And that one is going to be special. Not that this wasn't because Sean and I are going to be in Chicago recording that together. We're going to go deep into other types of benefits and coverage during that episode. But until then, follow Smart Money on your favorite podcast app, Spotify, Apple Podcasts. We've said it so many times. You know the rest. You can automatically download new episodes on whatever platform you use. We're also on YouTube.

33:31Sean Pyles: And here is our brief disclaimer. We are not your financial or investment or healthcare advisors. This nerdy info is provided for general educational and entertainment purposes and may not apply to your specific circumstances. Some companies mentioned in this episode may be NerdWallet partners, but does not influence how we talk about them.

33:49Elizabeth Ayoola: And with that said, until next time, turn to the nerd.

33:57Elizabeth Ayoola: UKG is the workforce operating platform with unified HR, payroll, and workforce management built to solve the unique challenges of frontline work. Powered by People First AI and decades of labor data, UKG turns workforce intelligence into real-time decisions around staffing, pay, compliance, and productivity, enabling every worker to confidently take action as work happens. Because when work works, everything works. Learn more at ukg.com slash work. UKG, HR, pay, and workforce management.

From the publisher

Learn how to compare health insurance plans, HSAs and FSAs before open enrollment deadlines arrive.

How do you pick the right health plan when costs keep climbing? Hosts Sean Pyles, CFP®, and Elizabeth Ayoola kick off a two-part open enrollment series with NerdWallet lead writer Kate Ashford, starting with the key enrollment dates for marketplace, Medicare, federal and employer-sponsored coverage. They discuss why employer health benefit costs are expected to jump next year, how premiums and deductibles work like a seesaw, the tradeoffs between HMOs, PPOs and high-deductible health plans, and why being a middle-of-the-road health care user could make the choice especially tricky. You’ll also hear how to weigh your out-of-pocket maximum, whether you have enough cash on hand to cover a high deductible, and how last year’s medical bills could help you estimate next year’s.

How can you get the most out of a health savings account or flexible spending account? Sean, Elizabeth and Kate explain the triple tax advantage of HSAs and why some planners treat them like another retirement account, how use-it-or-lose-it rules and rollover limits work for FSAs, and what a dependent care FSA could cover. They also dig into what’s changing for Affordable Care Act plans in 2027, including higher proposed premiums, insurers entering and leaving markets, new subsidy eligibility rules for some immigrants and state-level changes, plus why it could be worth trying to negotiate a medical bill.

Compare plans, premiums and out-of-pocket costs with NerdWallet’s guide:

How to Choose Health Insurance: Your Step-by-Step Guide: https://www.nerdwallet.com/insurance/health/learn/choose-health-insurance

Want us to review your budget? Fill out this form — completely anonymously if you want — and we might feature your budget in a future segment! https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScK53yAufsc4v5UpghhVfxtk2MoyooHzlSIRBnRxUPl3hKBig/viewform?usp=header

To send the Nerds your money questions, call or text the Nerd hotline at 901-730-6373 or email [email protected].

Like what you hear? Please leave us a review and tell a friend.

The show notes were created with the assistance of AI. They have been reviewed by our editorial team for accuracy and quality.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast

All episodes