In short
NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast: Episode Summary
Episode Title
Split-Expense Planning for Couples and the Winter Homebuying Advantage
Hosts
Sean Pyles, CFP®, Elizabeth Ayoola
Episode Description
The episode discusses the implications of shared housing expenses for couples, particularly when they have differing timelines for financial goals like retirement. The hosts explore the advantages of winter homebuying and how couples can equitably manage their finances.
---
Key Topics Discussed
Winter Homebuying
- Advantages of Winter Buying:
- Less competition among buyers, leading to potentially better deals.
- Average home prices can be 16% lower compared to peak spring prices.
- Homes tend to stay on the market longer, increasing negotiation power for buyers.
- Considerations:
- Winter conditions like snow and ice can obscure property issues during inspections.
- Motivated sellers may be more willing to negotiate on repairs or prices.
Managing Finances as a Couple
- Listener Segment: Claire and Robbie share their experience navigating shared living expenses with a 16-year age gap.
- Current Arrangements:
- Claire pays a flat rent to Robbie, who owns the house. They aim for equitable expense sharing despite a significant age difference.
- Discussions on Retirement:
- Concerns arise regarding different retirement timelines. Claire wishes to retire early, while Robbie is contemplating a longer work life.
- Financial strategies discussed include:
- Saving aggressively to facilitate early retirement.
- Exploring semi-retirement options such as "barista FIRE."
Key Financial Tools & Concepts
- Retirement Calculators: Recommended for projecting savings needs to align with different retirement timelines.
- Life Insurance & Estate Planning: Importance of life insurance and estate planning documents for couples, especially for those with a significant age difference.
---
Key Takeaways
- Winter Homebuying Advantages: It's an opportune time to buy due to reduced competition and lower prices.
- Equitable Expense Sharing: Couples should regularly communicate about finances to ensure fairness in shared expenses, especially when one partner owns the home.
- Retirement Planning: It's crucial to align financial goals and timelines. Strategies like semi-retirement can help bridge the gap in retirement timelines, and thorough planning can mitigate risks.
- Proactive Financial Management: Engaging in regular financial discussions and planning not only secures individual interests but also reinforces the partnership.
---
Additional Resources
- Homebuying Calculator: To assess home buying budgets, visit [NerdWallet's calculator](https://www.nerdwallet.com/mortgages/calculators/how-much-house-can-i-afford).
- Feedback and Questions: Listeners are encouraged to reach out with their money questions via voicemail at 901-730-6373 or email at podcast@nerdwallet.com.
---
Conclusion This episode emphasizes the importance of open financial discussions in relationships while providing valuable insights into homebuying strategies and retirement planning. The hosts encourage couples to evaluate their shared goals and financial arrangements to foster a healthy financial partnership.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOWinter Homebuying Market Overview
1:56 to 3:09
Explore the dynamics of home buying and selling during winter months.
“Later on this episode, we're going to be helping a couple work through how to manage their expenses, and we'll be doing that live.”
Buyers' Advantages in Winter Real Estate
3:09 to 4:12
Learn about the benefits and challenges for buyers in the winter housing market.
“So often people who list their homes in winter are doing it because they have to, not necessarily because they want to.”
Impact of Federal Reserve on Mortgage Rates
4:12 to 7:16
Understand how Federal Reserve actions influence mortgage rates and what that means for buyers.
“There's no buyer on the planet who's going to complain about less competition and lower prices.”
Spring Market Predictions and Homebuying Tips
7:16 to 11:20
Prepare for the spring housing market with insights on mortgage rates and buying strategies.
“Markets, including bond markets, tend to move ahead of the Fed.”
Listener Engagement and Future Questions
11:20 to 11:49
Hosts encourage listeners to send in their financial questions for future episodes.
“Still, you know, more homes for sale hopefully means bidding wars are a little less soul crushing.”
Couples' Financial Dynamics
15:26 to 16:43
Claire and Robbie share their financial arrangements and living situation.
“I'm so excited to have a couple here today, and we are excited to dig into your finances and answer your questions.”
Age Gap and Financial Discussions
16:43 to 17:44
The impact of Claire and Robbie's age difference on their financial planning.
“about how to equitably share this expense and we'll get to that in a little bit.”
Exploring Future Plans and Marriage
17:44 to 20:08
Discussion about potential marriage and long-term financial plans.
“Otherwise, I don't think we think about it much.”
Retirement Savings and Goals
20:08 to 21:47
Claire and Robbie discuss their retirement savings and aspirations.
“because we're thinking kind of down the line.”
Navigating Different Timelines for Retirement
21:47 to 22:46
Addressing concerns about retirement timing due to their age gap.
“Well, speaking of retirement, I know one of your main questions was how to think about retirement, given your age gap and your planning.”
Show all 20 chapters
Retirement Strategies for Claire and Robbie
22:46 to 24:00
Exploring options for Claire and Robbie to align their retirement goals.
“or maybe some of the pitfalls of early retirement if that was the option.”
Considering Financial Independence and Early Retirement
24:00 to 25:55
Discussion on the FIRE movement and its applicability to their situation.
“So that was something we also discussed whenever we were trying to figure out, okay, how do we make this fair?”
Planning for Post-Retirement Life
25:55 to 27:54
Exploring aspirations for activities and lifestyle in retirement.
“I think that that actually leads into some good planning that you guys could do.”
Retirement Aspirations and Financial Goals
28:00 to 28:30
Exploring retirement goals and the importance of financial stability.
“What are some other things aside from traveling that you envision yourself doing during retirement?”
Balancing Mortgage Payments and Retirement Savings
28:30 to 30:08
Discussing the trade-offs between prioritizing mortgage payments and retirement savings.
“But one of my big goals is to pay that off in the next 10 to 15 years so that if I do potentially retire within that same time frame, that's an additional expense that we don't necessarily have to worry about.”
Equitable Expense Contributions for Couples
30:08 to 31:04
How to ensure fair contributions towards shared expenses like a mortgage.
“It's also what helps you feel better about your money.”
Navigating Finances with Different Income Levels
31:04 to 33:08
Addressing how varying incomes affect financial responsibilities and contributions.
“or especially given kind of longer term goals, we're in a unique position.”
Planning for Future Financial Changes
33:08 to 35:15
Discussing future employment changes and their impact on financial planning.
“a bit more fair because you're able to maybe save more towards retirement than you would have if you were still renting your apartment?”
Importance of Life Insurance and Estate Planning
35:15 to 37:58
The need for life insurance and estate planning for couples to secure their future.
“been a struggle i would say for claire from an employment standpoint and and like the comfort level there.”
Creating a Financially Secure Relationship
37:58 to 41:09
How discussing finances can strengthen a relationship and ensure security.
“Something else I want to mention here is life insurance.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Sean Pyles:These days, I'm all about quality over quantity, especially in my closet. If it's not well-made and versatile, it's just not worth it to me. That's honestly why I love Quince. The fabrics feel elevated, the cuts are thoughtful, and the pricing actually makes sense.
0:14Elizabeth Ayoola:Quince makes high-quality wardrobe staples using premium fabrics like 100 % European linen, 100 % silk, and organic cotton poplin.
0:24Sean Pyles:Quince works directly with safe, ethical factories and cuts out the middlemen. You're not paying for brand markup or fancy retail stores. Just quality clothing.
0:32Elizabeth Ayoola:The Quince linen pants don't wrinkle like every other linen I've owned, and they look put together without trying too hard.
0:38Sean Pyles:Stop waiting to build the wardrobe you actually want. You don't need a closet full of options. You need pieces that work.
0:43Elizabeth Ayoola:Right now, go to Quince.com slash smart money for free shipping and 365 day returns. That's a full year to wear it and love it. And you will. now available in Canada too.
0:55Sean Pyles:Don't keep settling for clothes that don't last. Go to quince.com slash smartmoney for free shipping and 365-day returns. quince.com slash smartmoney.
1:07Anna Helhoski:When you want your spring break to feel like... And your kid's pool day to feel like...
1:16Abby Badach Doy:And your hotel bed to feel like... Ooh, and room service to feel like... Because at Hilton, hospitality feels like...
1:26Sean Pyles:Your cabana's ready. Would you like fresh towels?
1:28Abby Badach Doy:It matters where you stay. Book now at Hilton.com. Hilton, for this day.
1:37Sean Pyles:Managing your finances as a couple can be complicated. Add an age gap and hopes of an early retirement into that mix, and things get even more difficult to navigate. Welcome to NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast, where you send us your money questions and we answer them with the help of our genius nerds. I'm Sean Piles.
1:56Elizabeth Ayoola:And I'm Elizabeth Ayola. Later on this episode, we're going to be helping a couple work through how to manage their expenses, and we'll be doing that live. But first, our weekly money news roundup where we break down the latest in the world of finance to help you be smarter with your money. Our newest colleague, Ana Helhoske, is back. Hello, hello, hello, Ana. Hey, Elizabeth and Sean.
2:17Abby Badach Doy:So today we're going to be joined by mortgage writers, Abby Badek-Doyle and Kate Wood to reflect on home buying and selling during the winter and what they're keeping an eye on in February. That's the month when the market comes out of winter hibernation. Welcome back to both of you. Oh, thank you for having us. Thanks. Good to be back. So let's zoom out for a second. December through February is usually the slowest time of the year for home buying and selling. And I know I slow down in winter, but why does the market slow down too? A lot of it is just human behavior. Winter is hibernation season and, you know, we have the holidays.
2:50Abby Badach Doy:And then in January, you might need time to recover from the holidays. And just in general, people don't love moving when it's dark and cold and possibly snowing. Parents tend to avoid pulling their kids out of school mid middle of the year. And all of that kind of leads to a general sense of like, well, if we've made it this far, like we might as well just wait till spring. Yeah, the winter market has fewer buyers, but it also has fewer sellers, which does mean lower inventory. So often people who list their homes in winter are doing it because they have to, not necessarily because they want to.
3:23Abby Badach Doy:So winter sellers who list in the winter are often dealing with a big life change, could be a death in the family, a divorce, maybe relocating for their career. So if there's fewer buyers and fewer sellers, who has the upper hand? I'd say buyers tend to benefit the most from less competition. That's a big advantage. And there might be fewer homes for sale, but they tend to stay on the market longer in the winter. So in the winter, buyers have a better shot when they want to make an offer. Like in peak season, you might be competing with a handful of offers. But in the winter, you might be one of two offers or maybe even the only one.
3:59Abby Badach Doy:Exactly. Average home prices tend to drop in the winter, too. So seasonally, December through February, prices are about 16 % lower than when the market's at its peak in June. That's according to numbers from the National Association of Realtors. There's no buyer on the planet who's going to complain about less competition and lower prices. But is there some kind of catch? What should buyers be cautious about? In the winter, you really have to do your due diligence at the walkthrough and at the home inspection. Snow and ice can hide a lot of major issues. For a recent NerdWallet story, I interviewed a real estate broker from Valdez, Alaska.
4:35Abby Badach Doy:And she tells her buyers, when the snow melts, am I going to find an old car hiding out there in the woods? Your surprise reveal might not be that dramatic, but even a little bit of snow can hide major problems with the property. Things like roof or siding damage, cracks in the driveway or in the sidewalks, drainage problems in the yard, or even septic system issues. So you can use that winter weather to your advantage, though, since after all, you're going to be living in the place year round, so long as it's not your second home. So you really do want to know how the home feels in winter. Honestly, my last house, I closed in September.
5:11Abby Badach Doy:And if I had toured it in winter, I don't know if I would have bought it. It was beautiful, but it really, really felt like a cabin. So this is the time where you're going to know like, wow, the heating really isn't that great. Or are we getting enough natural light? Or, you know, does it feel like you're in a cave? Stuff that you wouldn't be able to tell if you were touring the home in warmer weather. Yes to the vibe check. And if you do spot a major issue, remember that sellers who list in the winter are often pretty eager to sell. So if you get an estimate saying this will be a$10 ,000 repair, a motivated seller might be willing to negotiate with you on the asking price or even offer to cover the cost of that repair.
5:52Abby Badach Doy:So during the winter, buyers may be getting a break on affordability, which is always nice. But a big chunk of your monthly bill comes from the mortgage rate. And that's not something you can really control. Abby, where are the rates sitting right now? Things are pretty stable right now, Ana. As of the end of January, the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate was right around 6%. And that's about a full percentage point lower than the average rate in January 2025. And generally speaking, that's about the lowest that we've seen mortgage rates in three years. I'm going to be asking both of you a crystal ball question in a minute, which I know everybody loves.
6:27Abby Badach Doy:But first, how much do the Fed's moves actually affect mortgage rates? They kept the federal funds rates steady at their meeting last month. But is that going to actually mean anything for buyers? So it might not mean as much as buyers might hope it would. The Fed does not set mortgage rates, but a lot of people think it does. The Federal Reserve sets the funds rate, which you just mentioned. That's a key short-term borrowing rate. That change ripples out to other interest rates. Those changes, however, don't directly affect mortgage rates. What you're really seeing moving when you're seeing mortgage rates moving, you are seeing the markets moving.
7:02Abby Badach Doy:So they're responding not even necessarily to the Fed's decisions, but to the Fed's plans, right? So it's less about, oh, what did they just decide to do? And what did they say right after in that press conference? Where did they say that they're heading? Markets, including bond markets, tend to move ahead of the Fed. So they're either reacting to rate cuts or rate hikes before they're made. So mortgage rates tend to move along with 10-year Treasury bills because mortgage-backed securities and those 10-year T-bills tend to appeal to similar investors. So this is one reason why you'll often see mortgage rates get to where the Fed is going before the central bankers get there.
7:40Abby Badach Doy:So that means folks that are waiting for the Fed to cut rates because they think it will lower mortgage rates are often disappointed because if the Fed is about to make a cut, that often means mortgage rates have already dropped. Right now, like Anna mentioned, the Fed chose to hold the FEMS rate steady. They're kind of in wait and see mode. For now, that's a signal that the economy is stable enough. The central bankers don't feel like they need to intervene too much. There are some folks out there who are more anxious about the job market and think the Fed should cut further. But, you know, until we see dramatically different data, we're likely to see the central bankers kind of chill for a while.
8:17Abby Badach Doy:There's also been a lot of Fed-related news lately, like way more than is ever normal. But these big changes that people are talking about, like a new Federal Reserve chair this spring, those are not going to have an immediate effect on mortgage rates. Okay, so looking ahead to spring, do you have any sense of where mortgage rates might be going? So pending any major surprises from the market, and I never can count that out. I've had them ruin too many forecasts to not count them out. But most economists, most forecasters are expecting mortgage rates to remain in that low 6 % range for the near future.
8:53Abby Badach Doy:Because things are pretty steady right now, it's a great opportunity for buyers to jump in, shop around for a mortgage pre-approval, and then lock in your rate before the spring rush. Yeah, and spring will be here before we know it. And that's what I keep telling myself while piles of snow are so frozen on the ground here in New York. So when will we see more homes actually hit the market? Well, people tend to think of springtime as the traditional home buying season, right? Growth, rebirth, homes on the market, everything's coming back. So it is true that peak buying season in terms of homes going under contract, that's April through June.
9:25Abby Badach Doy:But in terms of inventory coming on the market, that begins a little earlier than that, usually in February, right after the Super Bowl. So good news, you might already be seeing more open houses and new listings starting to pop up. And every local market is different. February might feel early, but don't sleep on house hunting as early as right now. You want to have your finances in order so that you can move fast when a good listing pops up. Yes, absolutely. If you are in that stage where you're just getting started and trying to figure out the money stuff, check out NerdWallet's How Much House Can I Afford Calculator.
9:59Abby Badach Doy:It's a great place to get started. Yeah, we'll link to it in the show notes. So a little February story from my own experience. Two years ago, my husband and I started our house hunt in the month of February. And by the end of the month, there was the most adorable little starter home that popped up in our top ranked neighborhood. And we put in our bid, a little bit over asking, thinking that we were being competitive. and then our buyer's agent told us that we were one of 22 offers. Wow, are you sure that was two years ago? Because that really sounds like 2021. I know. It was the highest amount of offers that our buyer's agent had ever seen.
10:36Abby Badach Doy:And we didn't get the house. Candidly, I think someone probably overpaid for it. But for weeks afterward, it was all that anybody in the neighborhood was talking about. every open house that we went to at a similar price point in a similar area after that, the agent or the other buyers would say, were you also part of that bidding war on such and such street? And we're like, yeah, we're in the loser's club. It just goes to show that real estate is really local. So something that you're hearing about the entire country might not apply where you live. Nationally, we've seen a lot more inventory coming onto the market in the past two years, but how much more and what people are paying for it is really going to vary depending on where you live or where you're trying to move to.
11:20Abby Badach Doy:Still, you know, more homes for sale hopefully means bidding wars are a little less soul crushing. Yeah, here's hoping. So again, every local market is going to be different. But for our listeners, the TLDR is that seasonally speaking, the housing market heats up sooner than you think. So if you want to buy this year, now is the time to get your finances in order, link up with a buyer's agent and get that pre-approval. And that way you'll have all of your ducks in a row when a good listing comes along. Right. Even if it's sub-zero temperatures and there's still snow on the ground. I mean, you just have to think ahead to how good summer is going to be, right?
11:57Abby Badach Doy:Once you're in your new home. Oh, here's hoping. Abby and Kate, thank you so much for joining us today.
12:02Elizabeth Ayoola:Thanks for having us. Thank you. And thank you, Anna. I feel a little bit inspired. I think I'm going to have a new hobby during the springtime, just going to look at houses just because I'm not buying, but I just want to go look because why not?
12:14Sean Pyles:One of these days you're just going to jump into buying a house. I know it.
12:17Elizabeth Ayoola:That's what you think. Listen, let me tell you, I am having nostalgia thinking about that 3 % interest rate during the pandemic. I almost bought a house, almost, but I didn't want to be house poor. And you guys are breaking my heart by telling me it's not coming back, that we're hovering around 6%. So until then, I'll be window shopping.
12:32Sean Pyles:Hey, you can just live vicariously through me. My interest rate's about that low.
12:39Sean Pyles:Anyway, moving on. Up next, we answer a listener's question about how to manage expenses and saving for retirement as a couple. But first, listeners, you know the drill. This is a show that runs on your money questions, so send them our way. We're also working on a special episode all about tax season 2026. So whatever you're wondering about around your taxes, send your questions to us, the nerds.
12:58Elizabeth Ayoola:You can leave us a voicemail. You can text us on the nerd hotline. The number is 901-730-6373. Again, that's 901-730-NERD. You can also pop us an email at podcast at nerdwallet.com.
13:13Sean Pyles:In a moment, this episode's money question. Stay with us.
13:21Elizabeth Ayoola:Today's episode is sponsored by Spectrum Business.
13:24Sean Pyles:Picture this. You're running a business and the internet drops during business hours. Your to-do list instantly becomes one, panic. Two, stare at the router like you're negotiating with it.
13:34Elizabeth Ayoola:And three, start offering customers a brief moment of mindfulness while the checkout screen loads.
Read the full transcript
13:39Sean Pyles:For business owners, being connected isn't a perk. It's how you take payments, talk to clients, and keep things moving.
13:45Elizabeth Ayoola:Spectrum Business keeps businesses connected seamlessly with fast, reliable internet and advanced Wi-Fi. Plus, phone, TV, and mobile services if you need them.
13:55Sean Pyles:And Spectrum Business offers 100 % U.S.-based customer support 24-7 to help you stay up and running. That means you get actual help not submit a ticket and hope for the best.
14:05Elizabeth Ayoola:Our colleague, Kari, is a Spectrum customer. Shout out to our social media team. And she told us that she chose Spectrum because people online kept recommending it as a reliable and affordable option for internet and phone service.
14:17Sean Pyles:Kari told us she was actually a little hesitant to switch at first because she'd been using a different service for a while. But after a year with Spectrum, she's had a really good experience. Her phone gets strong, reliable service and it automatically connects to Spectrum Wi-Fi everywhere.
14:29Elizabeth Ayoola:Join the millions who rely on Spectrum business. Visit spectrum.com slash business to learn more. One more time, that's spectrum.com slash business.
14:38Sean Pyles:Restrictions apply. Services not available in all areas.
14:42Abby Badach Doy:This episode is brought to you by Indeed. Stop waiting around for the perfect candidate. Instead, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs to find the right people with the right skills fast. It's a simple way to make sure your listing is the first candidate C. According to Indeed data, Sponsored Jobs have four times more applicants than non-sponsored jobs. So go build your dream team today with Indeed. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply.
15:10Sean Pyles:We're back and answering your money questions to help you make smarter financial decisions. This episode, we're joined by two listeners, Claire and Robbie, who have some questions about how to equitably manage their finances and plan for their retirement as a couple.
15:23Elizabeth Ayoola:Claire and Robbie, welcome to Smart Money. Thanks for having us.
15:27Sean Pyles:Thanks.
15:27Elizabeth Ayoola:I'm so excited to have a couple here today, and we are excited to dig into your finances and answer your questions.
15:33Sean Pyles:Can we start by hearing a little more about your relationship and how you've managed money together so far? We've been dating a little over a year, and Claire just moved in about three months ago.
15:46Anna Helhoski:So we kind of came to an agreement before she moved in that she would help essentially like pay rent because we currently live together in a house I purchased last year. So she essentially just pays like a flat fee every month. And then I pay the mortgage and the utilities and everything that everything else that goes along with it. Okay.
16:15Sean Pyles:And how did you decide what that rent amount is going to be?
16:18Anna Helhoski:So prior to her moving into the house, she was obviously at her own place and was living in an apartment. And I felt that it shouldn't be the same as what she's paying for her apartment. And we kind of talked about it and both agreed on the specific number that she's currently paying.
16:42Sean Pyles:Well, I know you have some questions for us about how to equitably share this expense and we'll get to that in a little bit. But one thing you mentioned when you wrote to us, Claire, was that you two have a pretty notable age gap. So talk with us about that and whether it's affected the way you guys relate to each other and have managed your finances as you've been together.
17:02Abby Badach Doy:Yeah, we are 16 years apart. We personally never think about it really. We met at a run club. Our interests are very similar, like both live an active lifestyle. But I do think that financially it's come up just in that something that attracted us to each other is that we're both very open about our finances and very interested in how to kind of optimize what we're doing. And I think even before I moved in, we were already talking about retirement and not only what we do, but how that could potentially create issues, especially in terms of retirement. So yeah, I think that's where it's come up most for us.
17:44Abby Badach Doy:Otherwise, I don't think we think about it much.
17:48Elizabeth Ayoola:okay and then what do you guys do for work i know that you wrote to us and said that you
17:52Abby Badach Doy:have similar income so what do you guys do so i work as an analyst in tech and robbie works in salesforce something
18:03Elizabeth Ayoola:you gotta love how i wrote some people ask me like oh what does your friend do or sister do for work and i'm like something around something you just never never sticks right like i don't
18:13Abby Badach Doy:I only have a loose understanding. Yes.
18:15Sean Pyles:You're focused on other things that are more important, perhaps.
18:19Anna Helhoski:The technical version is I'm a software consultant in tech as well.
18:25Sean Pyles:Tech something something. Yes. Yes. And how much do you each make?
18:29Abby Badach Doy:It's around$130.
18:31Sean Pyles:Okay. So you guys are making about the same.
18:33Abby Badach Doy:Okay.
18:33Sean Pyles:Yes. Okay. With that, do you find that you feel really compelled to share things 50-50? because a lot of times we get questions in couples where they think, oh, one person makes a lot more than the other. How should we actually divvy up our expenses? What's your conversation about that like?
18:47Anna Helhoski:We haven't had a lot of conversations about it other than just what she would potentially pay whenever she moved in. I will say for going out and entertainment and traveling and stuff like that, we try to just split it down the middle. but as far as like the household stuff she pays her part in uh rent and then i pretty much pay
19:15Elizabeth Ayoola:everything else and do you guys have any plans um or have you talked about potentially pulling your money together or you plan to keep your finances separate um for the most part yeah
19:24Anna Helhoski:that hasn't been a discussion of like pulling pulling things together okay you don't have to
19:30Sean Pyles:i mean i'm married to my husband and we don't have any shared finances we just cover things on our own and we'll Venmo each other often, which is maybe inefficient, but it works for us. But speaking of being married, you guys have been together for a year, as you said. Are you planning to get married? Because you guys have some pretty long-term plans or aspirations here. Has that come into the picture at all? Yeah. Sorry to put you on the spot here. I don't know if you guys have talked about it.
19:55Abby Badach Doy:Yeah. We've talked about like kind of what the timeline might look like for that, which would be like maybe in two years time or something. So yeah, it's definitely on our minds of, or clearly both planners because we're thinking kind of down the line. Yeah, it definitely is something we've talked about.
20:13Anna Helhoski:Yeah, we've definitely discussed it. We currently don't have like hard set plans or anything like that. So, but it has been something that's come up.
20:22Elizabeth Ayoola:All right, so we want to know, since you guys are long-term planners and thinking about the future, I love that. What are your thoughts around retirement? How much do you have saved so far? And then what are your goals?
20:31Anna Helhoski:I have about 900 saved across multiple different accounts, like a rollover IRA, a Roth IRA, 401k, HSA, standard savings and brokerage.
20:45Sean Pyles:Congratulations. That's an accomplishment.
20:46Anna Helhoski:Thank you. About 150 of that is in a Roth or a Roth version because I do have the option in my 401k to contribute to a Roth portion. So that's where I stand.
21:05Abby Badach Doy:And then what about you, Claire? I kind of had to reset into my retirement savings because I've been living abroad before we met for six years and kind of put retirement savings on pause during that time. That said, I have a little over 200K in retirement savings right now. So the bulk of that is in an account with Vanguard. So a target savings fund for 2060. I've got a rollover IRA. I am contributing or maxing out my Roth. So in the last two years, I've done that. And then I have a 401k that's about 30k. So I'm maxing that out, given the kind of limit for 2026 as well.
21:45Elizabeth Ayoola:You guys are so financially savvy. I love to hear it.
21:48Sean Pyles:Thank you. Well, speaking of retirement, I know one of your main questions was how to think about retirement, given your age gap and your planning. So what are your main questions or concerns there?
21:59Abby Badach Doy:We're on different timelines. You know, I was already a little behind because I took six years out of saving. You know, if I were to retire at 65, I'd retire really well, but neither of us wants to work forever. we'd like to retire at or before kind of normal retirement age but we'd also like to spend as much of retirement together and I think that kind of inevitably means that I would need to retire early and I think we haven't quite circled that square of how to do that or what options we have as far as being able to do that. So I think we're very curious to hear kind of what our options are or maybe some of the pitfalls of early retirement if that was the option.
22:50Sean Pyles:Have you guys played around with our retirement calculator at NerdWallet much?
22:55Abby Badach Doy:I have heard of it. My parents are a big fan.
22:57Sean Pyles:I really recommend using that just so you can get an understanding of some numbers here because that will help you understand how much you might need to save because you guys will have a longer overall retirement timeline than most couples, right? Because Claire, you're hoping to retire earlier. So you might have a retirement if this goes according to how you would like, it could be 30, 40 plus years, if you are hoping to retire around when Robbie is going to. So there are a few different options. One, Claire, you could retire early, which seems like the goal. Another one is that Robbie, you could work longer, even part time until Claire can retire, although that seems like the least desirable option for you guys.
23:36Sean Pyles:And then you could also even temporarily have a split household where maybe Robbie is retired and Claire, you're still working to catch up the difference of those years where you weren't saving for retirement. Additionally, you could kind of split the difference between your saving and work timelines where Claire saves more aggressively now and Robbie might work a little bit longer than he wants to. So does any of that resonate with you? Yeah, you want to retire as soon as you can.
24:03Anna Helhoski:And going back to the discussion about expenses, one of the reasons we came up with the figure that we did is I wanted it to be lower than what she was paying for rent so that she would have the ability to save even more in her retirement account. So that was something we also discussed whenever we were trying to figure out, okay, how do we make this fair?
24:29Elizabeth Ayoola:Well, one thing I want to bring up that comes to mind that you could potentially do, Claire, you guys are financially savvy. So I'm going to assume that you've heard about FIRE, Financial Independence Retire Early, have you? So is that something you guys have thought about or discussed? I don't think we use her.
24:44Abby Badach Doy:I personally haven't engaged with FIRE specifically, but I'm familiar with the concept.
24:48Elizabeth Ayoola:So it's essentially Financial Independence Retire Early and there are different types of FIRE. But for you guys, the situation, what comes to mind for me is potentially doing barista FIRE. and that is when you semi-retire. So you save enough whereas you can semi-retire and then you take a part-time job so that you're not doing maybe your demanding career job and that way you guys have more time to spend on the beach together and get lunch and Netflix and chill while you're still earning enough money to do things like cover healthcare expenses and also fund fund money. And I know healthcare can be a big thing when you retire early since you wouldn't be eligible for Medicare yet if you do that before the age of 65.
25:24Elizabeth Ayoola:But if you semi-retire, you can still get those healthcare benefits while also having some freedom.
25:29Anna Helhoski:That is my vision of retirement. If I need to work some sort of, you know, part-time gig, I could, but I want to have the, essentially the choice because if we think about it, we have a lot of time or we spend a lot of time working. And I feel like a lot of people don't think about, okay, what are you going to do to fill all that damn time? Mm hmm. Yeah. That's something I've I've spent a lot of time thinking about of, OK, let's say I didn't have to work anymore. What am I going to do?
26:03Sean Pyles:What? What, Robbie? What did you pick up a hobby? You can volunteer somewhere. I think that that actually leads into some good planning that you guys could do. One thing that's really key with FIRE is that in these years where you're working as hard as you can, saving as much as you can, you'll want to be tucking away between 50 % and 70 % of your income. That is a core tenant of FIRE to make those many years of retirement feasible. So you'll have to sacrifice some of those vacations or maybe dining out now just to put as much as you can in your 401ks. is great to hear that you're maxing that out, Claire, but also things like a taxable brokerage account, which you would be able to access earlier than something like a 401k without penalties.
26:40Sean Pyles:Meanwhile, as you think about your jobs and how you could maybe have a more flexible working schedule in your semi-retirement, is there a way where you can begin to position yourself to be almost a consultant so you can have part-time work, but on your schedule?
26:54Anna Helhoski:Yeah. And that's definitely something I need to think about or look into. But But in that same vein, like Claire kind of has a part time gig already that she does. So she could continue doing something like that to help offset like the health care costs that we've talked about.
27:13Elizabeth Ayoola:That's right. That's right.
27:15Sean Pyles:What is your part time gig, Claire?
27:17Elizabeth Ayoola:I dog sit. Oh, that's good. Sean has a dog. Sean, are you going to talk about your dog now?
27:22Sean Pyles:My dog is napping right next to me in the chair.
27:25Abby Badach Doy:Yeah, it's nice. I do it primarily because I love dogs, but we also love travel. So I think it's kind of best of both worlds that I get that dog time, but then kind of none of the bad parts.
27:37Sean Pyles:Yeah, you don't have to look for a dog sitter of your own because yeah, you can just travel when you want to. That's great.
27:41Abby Badach Doy:And I like to put that money or so far I've been putting that money in a sunny day fund. So I have 12 months of expenses in a rainy day fund. But then I put all the dog sitting money into a sunny day fund to potentially pay for a honeymoon or whatever that ends up being.
27:59Sean Pyles:That is a great term that I haven't heard before. A sunny day fund. I love the optimism of that.
28:05Elizabeth Ayoola:What are some other things aside from traveling that you envision yourself doing during retirement? And also because you want to retire together, what are some things you want to do together?
28:14Abby Badach Doy:I think the big thing we've talked about is keeping our place in Austin as a home base and then doing, you know, one month stints abroad or in other places in the U.S.
28:25Anna Helhoski:We haven't discussed like the house and mortgage and all that adulting stuff. But one of my big goals is to pay that off in the next 10 to 15 years so that if I do potentially retire within that same time frame, that's an additional expense that we don't necessarily have to worry about. And that other than her vehicle is the only debt that we have. So we don't have school loans or credit card debt or any of that fun stuff. So that's something that we've kind of discussed is, you know, like we don't have a lot of expenses that a lot of other adults have, like kids or, you know, debt or anything like that.
29:14Anna Helhoski:So we're very lucky to be in that situation. But that's like one less thing that we don't have to worry about.
29:20Sean Pyles:Yeah. One thing I'm thinking about there is you might have to sacrifice either your retirement savings or your mortgage payment to hit either of those goals. So which one would maybe be a greater priority to you? This is where calculators can be really handy to help you see how much further your money would go if you're stuffing as much as you can into different types of investment and retirement accounts versus putting extra toward your mortgage. I understand and really see the appeal of not wanting to have a mortgage payment in your retirement, but there's a chance that you might be better served by putting all that money into your investments now so it can grow and you might get a better return based on what you're paying for your mortgage and your interest rate there.
29:59Anna Helhoski:Yeah, it's just making the best decision or whatever personal decision suits you best. Yeah.
30:08Sean Pyles:That's right. It's not just about the numbers too. It's also what helps you feel better about your money. And sometimes that's paying down your mortgage.
30:15Anna Helhoski:Yeah. You made the comment about you have to choose between one or the other. Claire, her saving percentage is pretty close to 40. We're both pretty close to 40%. Wow. And I'm essentially taking like the extra money that or the money that she pays every month. And I just put that towards the mortgage. So there's a little wiggle room either way if we want to make adjustments there.
30:44Elizabeth Ayoola:All right. Well, speaking of mortgage, you also sent us a question around how to make it fair, considering that Claire is contributing towards the mortgage. And sometimes couples have a concern that if they break up, one person has helped the other pay down their mortgage and they leave having to go and pay rent somewhere again. So what kind of questions did you guys have around that?
31:03Abby Badach Doy:Kind of what our options are as far as splitting that expense or especially given kind of longer term goals, we're in a unique position. And so it's hard to ask other couples kind of what they're doing. You know, they'll have kids or they'll have different things going on. Find out if we have other options we might want to consider about how to split that expense. If I remember correctly, it's 50 % of the mortgage payment. So again, kind of it goes back to that we are in the same as is where that number kind of came from as well. But especially given wanting to retire together, that at all also comes in the consideration of maybe that payment being different to maximize retirement savings or whatever that might look like.
31:47Sean Pyles:I actually am in a kind of similar situation with my husband where we live in his house in Portland, I have a house in Washington that I rent out and I pay him rent and I pay him a flat amount that is it's like a thousand dollars so it's a little less than half of the mortgage and we account for the difference because he is getting the equity in this house and I don't cover any utilities in this house because I'm paying for maintenance on my own house so if something needs to be repaired he'll pay for that but then sometimes if there's a cosmetic change that I want to make like last year I wanted all new light fixtures in the house.
32:24Sean Pyles:And after coming back from my honeymoon in Japan, I needed to have a bidet in my bathroom and I'm paying for that. So it's a little bit squishy here and there, but it feels very equitable. And that's the key thing I want to emphasize is that it feels like you have a right balance for your incomes. And it sounds like you're doing that. We haven't touched on maintenance a lot. Robbie, are you covering that? Is that my understanding?
32:46Anna Helhoski:There's not a lot of that, but yeah, anything household related would fall under my umbrella. I guess.
32:54Elizabeth Ayoola:Okay. And then Robbie, I know that you mentioned earlier that when you guys were deciding how much rent Claire would pay, you did factor in her being able to save more for retirement. So maybe you adjusted that number to accommodate that. So Claire, do you feel like that feels a bit more fair because you're able to maybe save more towards retirement than you would have if you were still renting your apartment?
33:13Abby Badach Doy:Oh, definitely. So I think that and kind of framing it in terms of maybe not paying for utilities is kind of the way of adjusting for building his equity kind of is a nice reframing for me.
33:28Sean Pyles:Is there anything else that could make it feel more fair for either of you?
33:32Abby Badach Doy:Like we said, we're still having some conversations in that area. I think this podcast has brought some up. So even last night, we talked about when we go out, making sure that that's more 50 50, that that's probably geared more towards Robbie covering it than feels fair. And so I think that was a nice reminder that we need to check in on this. Like the podcast has prompted those conversations, but that maybe every couple of months, it's good to just check in that everybody feels like it's being fairly distributed.
34:02Sean Pyles:Just so I'm clear on that when you guys are going out to dinner, Robbie, you're the one putting down your card more often. Is that right?
34:07Anna Helhoski:Yeah, that's kind of what we discussed last night. But there's some variables around that. So that's the overall theme, I guess.
34:18Elizabeth Ayoola:And I'm curious about I know everyone has different values around how to split finances, but have both of you always been 50 50 people? And like, why do you decide that you want to do 50 50?
34:29Abby Badach Doy:We don't have traditional roles. might be a way of phrasing it. We like the idea that we're both kind of equal partners. And I think, again, definitely the fact that we make the same money has just kind of inspired wanting to split things 50-50. I think, yeah, it's only the difference in timeline that has maybe prompted some thoughts into switching that up a little bit.
34:53Sean Pyles:Yeah, I think you guys are in a situation where because of the numbers you're working with, you're able to really live your values around being 50-50 in this way. there could be a future state where one of you is making significantly more than the other how would you change this dynamic in that case would you try to have it be an equitable representative split based on income or would you still like to have 50 50 the last six months has
35:16Anna Helhoski:been a struggle i would say for claire from an employment standpoint and and like the comfort level there. So it's, I guess it's probably been something in the back of our minds. So, you know, if she were to lose her job, I don't, I don't personally, I don't feel like it would be fair for her to still have to like pay rent or whatever, but that that's something we would have to discuss. I think if unfortunately that were to happen.
35:50Abby Badach Doy:And it's definitely part of why I bolstered the rainy day fund because I work in tech and there's just kind of a constant threat of layoffs. I just felt like six months maybe didn't feel secure enough that I wanted to make sure there was a little bit more in there.
36:04Sean Pyles:With the way the job market is at this current moment, it's taking people quite a while to find jobs. So typically we would say you actually might not want more than six months in your emergency fund, given that you guys are both gainfully employed. But I think it's actually pretty smart to be conservative given where we are right now.
36:21Elizabeth Ayoola:We have discussed so many different topics. Do you guys have any other questions?
36:24Abby Badach Doy:You know, we're trying to plan for the ideal scenario where everything works out, but it has crossed my mind. And it's something we've talked about that in the event that this wasn't to work out long term, I want to make sure that I am not, you know, risking my comfortable retirement in order to coordinate our savings. So I'm wondering if there's anything I might consider or as far as, you know, maybe when I stop saving or exit the workforce to make sure that, you know, I'm not retiring earlier than I would necessary while still, you know, making sure that we spend as much time together in retirement as possible if it were to work out.
37:10Sean Pyles:To me, the solution would be keeping one, maybe two coals in the fire employment wise. So that way you can have a steady stream of income. Maybe you're doing 10, 15, 20 hours a week, depending on what you feel like you want to do and how much you enjoy the work. But you're giving yourself the flexibility to not have to be checking into a job nine to five Monday through Friday. And then you could actually maybe pivot more into doing different hours if you end up needing that income at some point. So just keeping your options open was a smart thing to do.
37:40Elizabeth Ayoola:And also maybe factoring in individually. I know you're planning retirement together, but your own retirement number and what number you would be comfortable stopping at so that if things didn't work out, knock on wood, because we want y 'all to be together forever. But, you know, so that you would have a comfortable nest egg for yourself if you happen to be single. Creep.
37:58Sean Pyles:Something else I want to mention here is life insurance. Do you guys have life insurance? No.
38:04Anna Helhoski:I do through work. I believe it's three times my salary. So, okay.
38:10Sean Pyles:I mentioned this because it's very important for couples in your situation with your age gap to have life insurance because Claire, you're likely going to live longer than Robbie. Sorry to bring up death in this conversation, but that's just the fact of life, right? So you want to ensure that Claire, you would have enough resources to help you through the years where you might not have Robbie around, which, you know, it's sad to think about, but also it's great to be prepared and have that base covered.
38:38Anna Helhoski:That's part of why we wanted to have this conversation because she's going to have a much longer time retired. So we need to work together to get to a point where we feel comfortable to where we potentially both can retire.
38:53Sean Pyles:Yeah. And something like a term life insurance policy probably wouldn't be that expensive for either of you to have and you could structure it. So maybe cover the rest of your mortgage, Robbie?
39:03Elizabeth Ayoola:Another thing I want to bring up relating to life insurance is estate planning. Have you thought about estate planning documents? And I think something that people sometimes confuse is they think that you have to be married to kind of plan these things with your partner, but you don't. So estate planning usually contains many different documents, but some of the most important are will. Some people may do a trust to help you avoid probate. You also have your, you know, power of attorneys. All these documents just ensure, you know, heavens forbid one of you is incapacitated and cannot make financial or healthcare decisions, the other person can do it on your behalf.
39:39Elizabeth Ayoola:And since you guys are already planning your finances together, I think that would be something really important to consider. And I know nobody wants to think about, you know, getting sick or dying, but it also can be such a loving thing to do so that if you are in that situation, your partner is not scrambling and trying to think about what to do. And also so that you guys have the power to make decisions on each other's behalf, if that does happen.
39:59Anna Helhoski:Yeah, that's a good reminder because I'm I am going to live much longer than her.
40:05Elizabeth Ayoola:I love it. Competing for who's going to live the longest.
40:07Sean Pyles:Hey, you guys are runners, so you're going to be healthy. I'm a runner, too, so I get it. We'll be living forever. One quick thing I will recommend, and it's much easier than actually getting an estate plan in place, which you should still do, is if you want to making each other beneficiaries of your accounts, like your investment accounts, your bank accounts. That way, if something does happen, you don't even have to go through probate. Your assets are just going to one another. It's really simple. You log into your account portals, you set your beneficiary. It can take 10 minutes to do.
40:35Elizabeth Ayoola:I just want to take a moment out to commend you guys on the mature conversation that you are having and the detail that you're going into the vulnerability, especially after dating for a year. Like it's just very commendable how transparent you guys are with one another and that you're able to come and talk about all these things. Yeah.
40:54Sean Pyles:Thank you so much. It's been clear in talking to you guys that you love each other a lot and you want the best for each other and for your life together. And having all of your finances sorted out is it's a kind of technical, but sort of romantic gift to give each other too, because you're making it so you can have the life you want together. It all comes back to having your finances sorted. Great. Well, Robbie, Claire, thank you so much for coming on and talking with us today.
41:16Elizabeth Ayoola:Thanks for having us. And please, please, please keep us updated. We would love to hear from you. Tell us what happens a year from now. If you get married, invite us, you know, all the things.
41:25Sean Pyles:Yes, we would love to attend. I mean, Elizabeth is just down the road, so.
41:29Elizabeth Ayoola:I am.
41:31Sean Pyles:Well, Robbie and Claire, let's have you guys take us out.
41:33Anna Helhoski:All right. If you want the nerds to answer your money question, call or text the nerd hotline at 901-730-6373. That's 901-730-NERD
41:48Abby Badach Doy:Or you could email your question like I did to podcast at nerdwallet.com or leave a comment on Spotify or YouTube.
41:55Elizabeth Ayoola:We want you to follow Smart Money on your favorite podcast app that might be iHeartRadio, Spotify, Apple Podcasts to automatically download new episodes.
42:04Sean Pyles:Here's our brief disclaimer. We are not your financial or investment advisors. This nerdy info is provided for general educational and entertainment purposes and may not apply to your specific circumstances.
42:14Elizabeth Ayoola:And this episode was produced by the best team ever. We have Tess Vigland, Hillary Georgie, who helped with editing, Nick Karisimi, and Eve Krogman mixed our audio and video. And we want to give a huge thank you to NerdWallet's editors for all the ways they help us.
42:29Sean Pyles:And with that said, until next time, turn to the nerds.
From the publisher
Find out the best time to go home shopping and whether shared housing bills can affect your plans to retire together.
Should you buy a house in the winter or wait for spring? How can you split housing costs and plan for retirement when you and your partner are on different timelines? Hosts Sean Pyles and Elizabeth Ayoola discuss equitable money management for couples to help you understand how to plan a shared future without losing sight of your own financial security. But first, Anna Helhoski joins Sean and Elizabeth to discuss winter homebuying and selling with mortgage Nerds Abby Badach Doyle and Kate Wood. They discuss why winter can mean less competition for buyers, what snow and cold weather can hide during a walkthrough or inspection, and why February can be the moment to get preapproved before the spring rush.
Then, listeners Claire and Robbie join Sean and Elizabeth to discuss how to share expenses when one partner owns the house, and how to aim for retirement at the same time despite a 16-year age gap. They discuss ways to rethink “50-50” so it feels fair, what semi-retirement options like barista FIRE can look like when health insurance is a concern, and how life insurance and basic estate planning can protect both partners if life takes an unexpected turn.
Use NerdWallet’s free calculator to see how far your homebuying budget could take you: https://www.nerdwallet.com/mortgages/calculators/how-much-house-can-i-afford
Want us to review your budget? Fill out this form — completely anonymously if you want — and we might feature your budget in a future segment! https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScK53yAufsc4v5UpghhVfxtk2MoyooHzlSIRBnRxUPl3hKBig/viewform?usp=header
To send the Nerds your money questions, call or text the Nerd hotline at 901-730-6373 or email podcast@nerdwallet.com.
Like what you hear? Please leave us a review and tell a friend.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

