What Home Sellers Can Legally Hide and How to Master Irregular Bills

16 Oct 2025 · 34 min · 22 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Home-sale disclosure rules for paranormal activity and non-natural deaths, plus how to budget for irregular expenses (annual/quarterly/fluctuating bills) using tracking, averages, cushions, and automated savings.

Guests

Holden Lewis and Kate Wood, NerdWallet housing reporters (“housing nerds”) who discuss home buying/selling and disclosure law. They share personal stories about rumored haunted houses (1744 home near a cemetery; “spooky cabinet” with names; Toledo “Suicide Flats” row house basement; childhood ghost-like sighting later explained as a shirt on a door).

Key claims

Most states don’t require sellers to disclose ghosts/paranormal activity; Massachusetts requires disclosure only for alleged supernatural phenomena if it’s a “material fact,” and Minnesota has zero disclosures on this topic. Murder/suicide disclosure varies: Alaska requires disclosure for deaths in the last year; California for deaths in the last three years; South Dakota for suicides/homicides during ownership; some places require answering direct questions. A California court case held a seller had a duty to inform when a property was “notorious” in the community (quintuple murder).

Notable examples

“Spooky cabinet” with lists of names; “Suicide Flats” basement; advice to search addresses/news and ask neighbors; budgeting examples include a $2,000 annual oil bill, fluctuating quarterly water, and unpredictable “easy pass” charges.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Weekly Money News Roundup

0:07 to 1:07

Hosts discuss the latest news in the world of home buying and selling.

“As of 2026, renters and homeowners can also earn up to 1.25x points on their housing payments.”

Weekly Money News Roundup

1:26 to 1:44

Hosts discuss the latest news in the world of home buying and selling.

“It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks.”

Weekly Money News Roundup

2:15 to 2:25

Hosts discuss the latest news in the world of home buying and selling.

“We're joined this episode by housing nerds Holden Lewis and Kate Wood.”

Haunted Houses and Personal Stories

2:25 to 4:31

Hosts share personal stories about living in homes with spooky histories.

“So what's news in the world of home buying and selling right now?”

Disclosure Laws for Haunted Homes

4:31 to 12:19

Exploration of legal obligations for sellers to disclose paranormal activity or deaths.

“And so he was now like 10 feet from his former property line, which was like cool for him.”

Finding Out About a Home's History

12:19 to 14:01

Advice on how to research a home's history and uncover potential issues before buying.

“There's a bunch of different states, different rules.”

Spooky Insights on Home Buying

14:01 to 14:24

Learn how to uncover hidden issues in potential home purchases.

“But these days, we can just go on the web and search the address and see what shows up.”

Listener Engagement and Money Questions

14:24 to 14:57

Discover how to reach out with your money questions for guidance.

“Up next, Elizabeth and I answer a listener's question about how to budget when your expenses aren't always the same week to week or month to month.”

Listener Engagement and Money Questions

16:32 to 17:34

Discover how to reach out with your money questions for guidance.

“Comfortable, versatile, and somehow right for almost every occasion.”

Listener Engagement and Money Questions

17:41 to 17:53

Discover how to reach out with your money questions for guidance.

“That's quince.com slash smartmoney for free shipping and 365-day returns.”
Show all 22 chapters

Listener's Budgeting Dilemma

17:53 to 18:54

Explore Alyssa's budgeting challenges with irregular expenses.

“This episode's question comes from Alyssa, who sent us an email.”

Identifying Irregular Expenses

18:54 to 19:24

Understand common irregular expenses that can disrupt budgeting.

“Let's start by talking about some common irregular expenses.”

Assessing Annual Expense Totals

19:24 to 20:56

Learn how to calculate annual costs for better budgeting.

“Not so much my thing, but probably yours, Elizabeth.”

Tracking Irregular Expenses

20:56 to 21:34

Strategies for managing unpredictable expenses effectively.

“Probably around the amount that I was projecting, Sean, which was$5 ,000.”

Planning for Fluctuating Costs

21:34 to 23:55

Get tips on planning budgets for expenses that vary in amount.

“They can look backwards at what they have been spending their money on for the past few months.”

The Importance of Expense Tracking

23:55 to 25:28

Uncover the significance of closely monitoring spending habits.

“And I think your budgeting system is going to determine how you manage those irregular expenses.”

Lifestyle Creep and Budget Management

25:28 to 27:30

Understand lifestyle creep and how to manage it within your budget.

“I had a moment like that between the end of last year and earlier this year where I was like wait a minute Where's all my money going?”

Making Thoughtful Financial Choices

27:30 to 28:00

Learn how to make responsible spending decisions while budgeting.

“So once they get a feel for that, then they might want to try a budgeting method that is kind of relaxed because it seems like they don't want to be micromanaging their finances on a regular basis.”

Understanding Lifestyle Creep

28:00 to 29:44

Explore the concept of lifestyle creep and its implications on personal finance.

“So Sean, I want to know, have you experienced any type of lifestyle creep?”

Savings Strategies and Irregular Expenses

29:44 to 31:35

Learn about effective savings strategies and handling irregular expenses.

“I feel like I talk about Uber Eats a lot.”

Automating Your Savings

31:35 to 34:10

Discover methods to automate savings for easier financial management.

“And I have a little bit of my paycheck every single pay period going into each one of these accounts based on percentages.”

Accountability in Financial Goals

34:10 to 35:32

Understand the importance of accountability in achieving financial goals.

“Because I understand that you don't have nine checking and savings accounts.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Sean Pyles:The following is a paid sponsorship, not an endorsement by NerdWallet's editorial team. Today's episode is sponsored by Bilt.

0:06Elizabeth Ayoola:You've heard me talk about Bilt as the loyalty program that lets you earn points on rent wherever you live, and they just leveled up even more. As of 2026, renters and homeowners can also earn up to 1.25x points on their housing payments.

0:23Sean Pyles:This is thanks to Bilt's three new credit cards, the Palladium Card, Obsidian Card, and Blue Card. All three can turn your housing payments, rent, or mortgage into flexible rewards. So you can choose the card that fits your lifestyle without missing out on points and exclusive benefits.

0:38Elizabeth Ayoola:Built points can be redeemed at top airlines and hotels, Amazon.com purchases, future rent payments, and so much more. Built points have also been ranked by top publications as the industry's most valuable point currency.

0:52Sean Pyles:Your housing payment is most likely your biggest expense. Make it your most rewarding. Find the card that fits your lifestyle and apply today at joinbuilt.com slash smartmoney. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash smartmoney. Make sure to use our URL so they know we sent you. Terms and limitations apply.

1:11Elizabeth Ayoola:Subject to approval and eligibility, Built cards are issued by Column N-A, member FDIC pursuant to license from MasterCard International Incorporated. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+.

1:48Sean Pyles:Here's something spooky for your finances. Irregular expenses. They can make it tough to budget, but today will help smooth it all out so it's not such a scary proposition.

2:03Sean Pyles:Welcome to NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast, where you send us your money questions and we answer them with the help of our genius nerds. I'm Sean Piles. Later this episode, we'll be talking with a listener about how to budget for irregular expenses. But first, our weekly money news roundup, where we break down the latest in the world of finance to help you be smarter with your money. We're joined this episode by housing nerds Holden Lewis and Kate Wood. Welcome back, you two. Hello. Thanks for having us. So what's news in the world of home buying and selling right now? All right, Kate, Sean, Halloween is coming up.

2:35And that just makes me want to ask this haunting question, which is, has either one of you lived in a house that was haunted or there were rumors that it was a haunted house?

2:50Sean Pyles:I'm so glad you asked this question, Holden. It reminds me of one time I was probably about five or six years old. I woke up in the middle of the night and I look over at my door to my bedroom and there is a white mass just floating at the door. And I am terrified being a child, seeing this glowing thing that clearly is a ghost to me. So I'm staring it down for what felt like hours and hours. I eventually mustered the courage to get up and check it out, turn on the light switch, which was, of course, right next to the door. And it was a shirt on a hanger on my doorknob. So that's the closest I've ever gotten to a ghost in my house.

3:27Sean Pyles:Beyond that, no, I kind of wish I did, but nothing that I've currently, presently, personally experienced. Okay, you were like the bravest five-year-old, though. I would have just waited that out. Okay, you lived in a super old house. I'm sure you probably have something, right? Yes, so like sort of, but probably not as cool as you'd think. But I don't know. It's kind of cool. You guys be the judge. If you really listen to this podcast a lot, you might remember I owned a house that dated to 1744. It was also next door to a cemetery, which was this huge selling point for me because those are the least problematic neighbors you will ever have in your life, right?

4:07Sean Pyles:Unless they're coming back from the dead. No, I mean, okay, unless it's a living dead situation, then everything changes, right? All bets are off. But in terms of like, are they going to cause noise? Are they going to encroach on like your land? Are they going to build something? Nah, you're super safe. these people have been dead, or at least these specific people had been dead for a long time. So one of the house's previous owners was actually buried there. He died in like the 1850s or 1860s. And so he was now like 10 feet from his former property line, which was like cool for him. So the house itself was not haunted, but it did have this one area where I was like, I'm not messing with this.

4:44So I called it, and you're going to, this is going to make your hair stand on it. I call this the spooky cabinet. So it was a cabinet above one of the fireplaces. The house had three fireplaces, Colonial, Central, Chimney. And there's actually like no real agreement from historians on why Colonial era homes have these fireplace cabinets or like what the point would have been. It's just a cabinet that's above the mantle. So I bought this house empty, empty. It hadn't been lived in for over a year. I opened the cabinet just because like, you know you're moving and you're opening things all that's in there is a tarnished silver spoon and a bible and it's not like a really old bible but like it's a bible yeah but these are clearly cursed items cursed items or it's protection right like these are like protective so i was like i'm not gonna touch these items whatsoever so i was just kind of like noped on out of there and tried to close it, but this cabinet refused to stay closed.

5:42So that was a whole other thing. Spooky cabinet won't close. So one time my brother's visiting and I was just like, hey, while you're here, can you install a latch on this cabinet to hold it closed? Because again, I was like, I don't really want to touch it. I don't want to mess with it. So he's looking at it and he's like, what do you think all the writing is? And I was like, what writing? Okay. Like, I don't know how tall I sound, but in real life I'm short. And so I had not even seen this writing. We can hear that, actually. Yeah, no. Okay, well, my brother is like six feet, and he's just looking at it.

6:13So on the inside of the cabinet door, and it was somehow like faded into the woods, the writing was kind of lighter than the wood. There was what looked like a long, jumbled list of names, like three columns covering it. And then there was a second, shorter list in pen, also in decipherable names over the first column. So long story short. Terrifying. We shut that cabinet. I hung a piece of art over it. I never touched it again.

6:36Sean Pyles:That's a good call because I'm just going to venture a guess that those are people who may well have died on the property over the course of those several hundred years. Yeah, I don't. Yeah. Wow. My experiences have been a lot less broad, I guess you could say. When I lived in Toledo, I rented an apartment right on the edge of downtown. And it was a row house and the building was called Suicide Flats because back in the 70s and 80s, it had been a shooting gallery, you know, a drug den and, you know, a lot of overdoses there. And so every once in a while, I would go down into the unfinished basement of this row house.

7:11Oh, my gosh. You know, I just kind of felt a presence, especially because since it was unfinished, it was like dirt floors, you know. And I would go, whoa, I wonder if something's buried down here. But, you know, I don't know. Didn't really. You never dug it up just to check? No. Oh, my gosh. He was renting, Sean. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I mean, I kind of wonder if people's things disappeared because, you know, we would store things down there. And then right after that, bought a house there in Toledo from a widow. And her husband had died of natural causes in the house. And I knew exactly where that bed was where he died.

7:48Like, it was in the second bedroom. And I just knew it, partly because I felt a presence, but partly because that was the most obvious place to put a bed. And it is where we ended up putting our baby's crib. Wow. That sounds like the premise of a horror movie. It really does. It does. And nothing horrible happened. But I would think about it at least a couple of times a week. Like, was that a wise thing to do to bark that? Is my baby going to be possessed by an old man who died here? Yeah, exactly. Is my infant son developing the personality of like an octogenarian Ohioan? Will he be a fireman?

8:25Just like him?

8:27Sean Pyles:is your son a fireman, just like that guy. And he is not. He is a social worker. So, okay, I got to ask you guys, do you believe in paranormal activity? You know, whether or not you do, like, would you be willing to live in a house where either there were rumors of ghosts or something terrible had happened there and people knew it? Much like Mulder from the X-Files, I want to believe, but I've never seen a ghost besides that shirt hanging on my door that wasn't actually a ghost. I'm open to it. But yeah, waiting for evidence. Yeah, same. I feel like I'm ghost agnostic. And like in the scheme of things, supernatural.

9:05I feel like I'd be probably okay with living in the house. Crime house? Like I'd really rather not. But at the same time, I recognize that like I'm in New England. It's still a really hot market here. I feel like if the price was right, you just kind of have to be like, well, there were a bunch of murders here. I'm going to burn a lot of sage.

9:25Sean Pyles:Yeah, I think I would need like a deep vibe cleanse of a house that I knew something horrific had happened in. But I wouldn't have it be my first choice because I just think that things like that leave an imprint in a space. But if you do want to buy a house where something horrible happened, do you have to be told about that? Like, is there disclosure laws around like ghosts or horrible acts of murder or anything like that? So depending on where you're buying, whether you have a right to know is going to vary. So seller's disclosures are always a normal part of the home sale process, but what the seller actually has to reveal is going to vary depending on where you live.

10:05fun fact turns out in most states the home seller does not have to disclose the presence of ghosts or other paranormal activity most states know some states yes massachusetts for example you sell a house in massachusetts it's not considered a quote-unquote material fact if the home has been the site of again we're quoting here an alleged parapsychological or supernatural phenomenon on the other hand if the buyer asks you about it you can't lie opposite end of the spectrum Minnesota. Zero disclosures on this topic, as well as non-supernatural deaths. When I sold my house, I'm in Connecticut. I don't have to disclose it, but because it was such an old house and I figured people would make assumptions or want to know, I did kind of summarize things for my agent and I was just like, look, I don't think this house is haunted because I was mostly here by myself.

10:56The staircases are so steep. If some kind of malevolent spirit had wanted to mess with me, I was just like easy pickings. Yeah.

11:05Sean Pyles:Also, are those stairs up to code? No, no. That's another question. Oh, no. These are colonial home stairs are like snowflakes. No two are the same, you know? Yeah. They're perilous. That's almost scarier than a ghost in the house. It definitely was for my boyfriend at the time. All right. So we're talking about ghosts and that leaves a murder-sized hole. or should I say murder-sized hole in this discussion, which is, are there disclosures having to do with murders, suicides? I mean, from what I understand, in most states, the seller can just keep their mouth shut about it. An exception is Alaska.

11:44If you're aware that a murder or suicide happened in the house in the last year, you have to disclose it and you have to tell the buyer up front. Other states have these only ifs, like California. You have to disclose a death in the house in the last three years. In South Dakota, you have to disclose if a suicide or homicide happened while you own the property. And in Kentucky and I don't know, a few other places, you actually have to honestly answer a direct question about like a haunting, a death, suicide, a murder, but you don't have to tell the buyer if they don't ask. I don't know. There's a bunch of different states, different rules.

12:21And a lot of places, if you're selling and someone asks you a question like that, you can say, I do not care to answer that question and then leave it at that.

12:30Sean Pyles:I think that that tells you all you need to know if that is the answer to that question. Yeah, that feels very, I'm pleading the fifth. Don't worry about it. With these disclosures, there are basic laws, but there is room for nuance. These things can evolve. So there was a court case 42 years ago in California. This woman had bought a house from a guy and he just never mentioned, And by the way, this was the site of a quintuple murder that had happened like 10 years prior. Also, no, like this is not like Charles Manson related. It's not the Sharon Tate house. So anyway, the buyer sues the seller and she argues that the neighbor is like, look, everyone knows what happened in this house.

13:08Right. And that that history really probably makes the house less valuable than what she paid. She won. The court said that the seller had a duty to inform the buyer because the house was notorious in that community. And so, yeah, that quintuple murder had a negative effect on the property value, and she shouldn't have paid that much.

13:27Sean Pyles:That's kind of wild. What I'm taking from this is that when I buy any future house, I'm going to ask, did any sort of crazy, spooky, haunty, murdery things happen here? Yeah, and maybe go around asking neighbors, too. All right, so what if you're not a goth, and you don't want to live in a house that is supposedly haunted or someone died but not of natural causes? What can you do? Again, the answer kind of varies by state in terms of, does the seller have to disclose this? Can you force the seller to disclose it in some way? These days, obviously, this is something our like 42 years ago woman couldn't have done.

14:01But these days, we can just go on the web and search the address and see what shows up. Are there news articles letting you know that something horrifying happened there? Or that neighbors always smell like a mysterious scent or feel cold when they walk by the house, right? You could also just ask the neighbors. They will probably tell you.

14:18Sean Pyles:Well, Kate Holden, thank you for coming on and sharing your spooky home buying insights with us today. Thank you for having us. It was my spooky pleasure. Up next, Elizabeth and I answer a listener's question about how to budget when your expenses aren't always the same week to week or month to month. But before we get into that, a reminder listener to send us your money questions. Maybe you're wondering if the time of year when the veil is thinnest between the living and the dead is a good time to buy a house. or maybe even how to save up for a down payment on a house. Whatever your money question, leave us a voicemail or text us on the nerd hotline at 901-730-6373.

14:52Sean Pyles:That's 901-730-NERD. Or email us at podcast at nerdwallet.com. In a moment, this episode's money question. Stay with us.

15:04Sean Pyles:Today's episode is sponsored by Rula. Finding a therapist is hard enough. But finding one that actually takes your insurance, that's where most online therapy platforms fall short. Many don't work with insurance at all, which means you're stuck paying the full cost out of pocket or paying for an expensive monthly subscription.

15:21Elizabeth Ayoola:Rula does things differently. They partner with over 100 insurance plans, making the average copay just$15 per session. That's real therapy from licensed professionals at a price that actually makes sense. Think about it. You use your insurance benefits to maintain your physical health, So why wouldn't you do the same for your mental health?

15:41Sean Pyles:Rula isn't just affordable. The experience is tailored around you. Other online therapy platforms might match you with the first available provider, whether or not they're the right fit. Rula considers your goals, preferences, and background to provide you a curated list of licensed in-network therapists who are actually aligned with what you need, because they know that finding the right therapist can make all the difference. Go to rula.com slash smart money to get started today. That's R-U-L-A dot com slash smart money for quality therapy that's covered by insurance.

16:10Elizabeth Ayoola:Thousands of people are already using Rula to get affordable, high quality therapy that's actually covered by insurance. Visit Rula dot com slash smart money to get started. That's R-U-L-A dot com slash smart money. You deserve mental health care that works with you, not against your budget. Today's episode is sponsored by Quince.

16:31Sean Pyles:The best summer pieces are the ones that you keep ending up wearing on repeat. Comfortable, versatile, and somehow right for almost every occasion.

16:38Elizabeth Ayoola:And that's exactly why I love Quince. They make elevated essentials and they use premium materials like European linen, organic cotton, and washable silk without the traditional retail markup.

16:49Sean Pyles:Quince's 100 % European linen pants, dresses, and tops are the pieces that you'll reach for all summer long. They're lightweight, effortless to style, and start at just$32.

Read the full transcript

16:58Elizabeth Ayoola:And if you like denim, their denim is soft and comfortable, and their organic cotton sweaters are perfect for layering when evenings start to cool down.

17:06Sean Pyles:I recently got some European linen sheets for my bedroom, and they are so cozy, and they really do get softer every time I wash them.

17:13Elizabeth Ayoola:It's summertime. Of course, it has been blazing hot, so I've been spending time by the pool, and I have been rocking the bathing suit that I got from Quince. It is so washable, the fabric is so light, and it feels like such good quality.

17:23Sean Pyles:With Quince, it's not just the apparel. Quince also offers elevated essentials for your home, from bedding, like I mentioned, and bath, to kitchen essentials and furniture.

17:32Elizabeth Ayoola:Make your summer wardrobe feel easier. Go to quince.com slash smartmoney for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. It's now available in Canada, too.

17:42Sean Pyles:That's quince.com slash smartmoney for free shipping and 365-day returns. quince.com slash smartmoney. We're back and answering your money questions to help you make smarter financial decisions. This episode's question comes from Alyssa, who sent us an email. Here it is. Hi, Elizabeth and Sean. I love your podcast, and I've been learning a lot from it. I have a budgeting question for our family. My spouse and I make good salaries, around$180 ,000 to$200 ,000 per year, and we don't spend extravagantly, but our budget always feels tighter than it should. I've been working to better track our expenses, and one thing that consistently confuses me is how to plan for irregular bills.

18:21Sean Pyles:For example, we have an annual$2 ,000 oil bill, a quarterly water bill that fluctuates, and an easy pass charge that pops up unpredictably. We'd really prefer a set-it-and-forget-it approach rather than daily expense tracking, something that keeps us organized, helps us plan for a regular cost, and allows us to consistently save for bigger goals like a home addition. Right now, our savings just keeps getting eaten up. Do you have advice for how to budget for regular expenses in a way that smooths things out month-to-month and makes it easier to build savings with confidence? Thank you for considering my question.

18:52Sean Pyles:I'd love to hear your take. Alyssa.

18:53Elizabeth Ayoola:And this episode, Sean and I are taking on Alyssa's questions ourselves. Are you ready to dive in, Sean?

19:00Sean Pyles:Let's do it. Let's start by talking about some common irregular expenses. A lot come to mind, actually, because I face these every single year, it seems, and they're always annoying and throw me off. So car registration is one that I just paid. Maybe premium credit card annual fees. I know, Elizabeth, you and I were just talking about this and how expensive it can get. But also pet insurance, magazine subscriptions, oil changes, back to school supplies. Not so much my thing, but probably yours, Elizabeth. Also neighborhood dues, home maintenance. There are so many. Do any other come to mind for you?

19:32Elizabeth Ayoola:Definitely some that you have brought up. You called me out and told my business. Maybe I told my business already on this podcast. But premium card annual fees are definitely one for me. I have four too many of those. Definitely back to school supplies. An interesting one for me actually is because I'm a single mom of when I want to go out or even just when I want to travel on a trip without my son, I have to pay babysitter fees, which can get really expensive. And I don't always necessarily plan for car maintenance, beauty products, because a girl has to girl.

20:01Sean Pyles:Yeah, but you run out of a product and you have to replace it and you don't know exactly when that's going to happen, right?

20:06Elizabeth Ayoola:Yeah, and then it just so strangely happens that they all run out around the same time and then it becomes this big expense bill. Like I need eyeliner and face wash and shampoo and just all the things at once and it can cost quite a bit.

20:17Sean Pyles:So I looked into my own irregular expenses ahead of this recording. Do you want to guess how much I spend on an annual basis?

20:25Elizabeth Ayoola:I'm going to say$5 ,000.

20:28Sean Pyles:Not quite. I spend a little over$3 ,500 a year on annual expenses. And that's a lot more than I was expecting it to be. Although admittedly, most of this expense comes from my pet insurance, which is around like$2 ,200 a year. So yeah, I just wasn't expecting to have that number. I thought it would be maybe closer to$1 ,000, but all of those things that we just listed out really add up over time. Do you have a number for how much you're spending on your irregular expenses annually, Elizabeth?

20:56Elizabeth Ayoola:Probably around the amount that I was projecting, Sean, which was$5 ,000. So I was putting that on you, but it was really on me.

21:03Sean Pyles:Yeah, that's a lot. I'm guessing a good chunk of that is coming from your credit card annual fees.

21:07Elizabeth Ayoola:Yep, credit card annual fees. And then a lot honestly goes to child care.

21:10Sean Pyles:Well, I think it's telling, too, that you don't have a precise number and that I didn't before I looked into it to answer this listener's question because these things do pop up. We don't think about them on a regular basis until all of a sudden that charge hits our account and we're like, oh, crap, I have to scramble and move some money around to cover this bill. So we should talk about how you can account for these expenses given that they can be kind of unpredictable or they seem like they can be unpredictable. I think to start, the best place for people to look is just their spending. They can look backwards at what they have been spending their money on for the past few months.

21:42Sean Pyles:As you're looking through your charges, flag anything that seems, quote unquote, irregular. And I'm saying, quote unquote, because at the end of the day, there isn't actually a big difference between an irregular expense or a regular expense. An irregular expense is just one that popped up unexpectedly that you maybe forgot or you weren't totally planning for. Although if you have foresight and you look at your expenses closely enough, we should all be able to plan for these things. We know they're coming, right?

22:06Elizabeth Ayoola:Absolutely. And actually, this reminds me of a regular expense dilemma that I was having with my small business, which is that I had those kind of unexpected fees coming up as well. So something I did was I created a spreadsheet. It was easier to look through because my business credit card expenses are not as much as my personal one. So I was able to kind of highlight each of those quote unquote irregular expenses and pop them in a spreadsheet and also put the date next to it of what time of the year they come around so that I can anticipate them. So maybe that's something people can consider as well.

22:37Sean Pyles:That's really smart. I think people can either track them either through a spreadsheet or a note on their notes app on their phone. Something so that if and when these expenses do pop up, you can just keep track of it in that moment. And then hopefully next time this expense comes around, you know to anticipate it because you have it written down somewhere. And also you flagging your business expense makes me think about how next year I'm going to be facing a bunch of irregular expenses with my business and my CFP certification. And that stuff is not cheap. So I'm going to start saving for that probably today.

23:06Elizabeth Ayoola:Yeah, even just the annual business registration fee, not to get too much into business stuff. But my website domain comes up, you know, every year and then you're like, whoa, another bill.

23:14Sean Pyles:Well, one thing that's hard to figure out as well is how you can track irregular expenses when the price can fluctuate. Like a water bill might not be the same every month or every quarter, depending on how frequently you're billed. So in that case, it's a good idea to try to get an average for how much you might be spending. So look back at your last three or four bills, see what you're typically spending. Also see if you might be getting a price increase coming up because we're getting that for our water bills here in Portland. Get some sort of grasp on what you might have to spend. That way you can plan for it, even if you don't know exactly how much it's going to cost you.

23:47Sean Pyles:And I I would also suggest putting in a cushion in your budget to save maybe more than you might expect so that you don't end up not having enough set aside for it.

23:54Elizabeth Ayoola:And I think that's a good segue, Sean, because everyone has a different budgeting system, right? And I think your budgeting system is going to determine how you manage those irregular expenses. So someone like you who has five million different accounts, you might have an account for each bill or whatever it looks like. But for someone like me who has only two checking accounts and one savings account, I find my approach is, like you said, having enough money in my account, knowing roughly how much my monthly expenses are, and then having that extra cushion, right, for those unexpected bills so that I'm not robbing Peter to pay Paul.

24:25Yeah.

24:26Sean Pyles:And for something like Alyssa's$2 ,000 oil bill, I would probably put it in my home maintenance fund. And then they can break that up on a monthly basis and see what amount they might need to put aside into that account so that it's all covered. That's just one easy way. And that's probably, again, how I would do it. But one thing that I'm thinking about is how Alyssa mentioned that their budget always feels tighter than it should while they're making between$180 ,000 to$200 ,000 a year. And we don't know a lot about their household finances. We don't know where they live, what their mortgage costs, all of this.

24:58Sean Pyles:But I am willing to bet that they probably aren't tracking their expenses as closely as they might think they are. And this is kind of a open secret in the financial planning and personal finance world, which is that most people, when they're living a pretty comfortable middle class life, aren't really budgeting that closely at all. And that's okay because you have enough money to get by. But then when you're facing a cash crunch like they are facing, it's time to look into what's really going on and track your expenses more closely.

25:27Elizabeth Ayoola:I agree. I had a moment like that between the end of last year and earlier this year where I was like wait a minute Where's all my money going? Because I got so comfortable kind of like, you know, this couple is and it was a daunting and also Freeing freeing experience to really sit down and I did something which is track my expenses for a month and see exactly What I was spending I started checking every single week to see how many uber eats I was doing how many instacarts And I was like girl you're doing too much So that can help you see where, and I was like, I do have enough money because I started to feel like, oh, I need more money.

25:59Elizabeth Ayoola:No, I just needed to manage the money I had better. So I think tracking the expenses really closely to see where it's going is a good place to start.

26:06Sean Pyles:How exactly was that freeing? Because it sounds kind of tedious, to be honest.

26:10Elizabeth Ayoola:It was tedious, but how it was freeing is first of all, I was stressed out because I didn't know where my money was going and I was avoiding checking where my money was going. And it was also freeing because I had all this pressure on myself because I was feeling guilty because I didn't know where my money was going and because I knew that I was possibly overspending. But being able to track and see where all that was going helped me to feel free from all of that stress and all of that guilt because now I know where my money is going and what I need to fix and I have a clear path forward.

26:35Sean Pyles:It's like you had this budget boogeyman in your life. And once you confronted it head on, you were able to take more control over your finances.

26:43Elizabeth Ayoola:Exactly. Exactly.

26:44Sean Pyles:Okay. And so how did you change the way you're tracking your money? Are you still looking at it on a kind of close basis like you were for that month? Or have you gone back to a kind of more relaxed pattern?

26:53Elizabeth Ayoola:Oh, no, we're not going all the way that way relaxed. So now I check weekly, actually. I see exactly what I'm spending weekly. And then intuitively, I'm able to say, hey, maybe I'm going to spend less next week. Or this is kind of my budget for the rest of the month.

27:06Sean Pyles:And that's a good idea. So with Alyssa, they could track every expense for a month, see what's coming in, see what's going out, just get a really clear picture on where they might be succumbing to some kind of lifestyle creep like all the Uber Eats or shopping for clothes, whatever it might be. We all have our own little lifestyle creeps that are not necessarily bad, but they can become troublesome when it prevents us from not being able to save how we want to or cover our expenses in Alyssa's case. So once they get a feel for that, then they might want to try a budgeting method that is kind of relaxed because it seems like they don't want to be micromanaging their finances on a regular basis.

27:40Sean Pyles:In that case, you know, I like to recommend the 50-30-20 budget framework, which we talk about a lot for a good reason. If you have your 50-30-20 budget where half of your income is going to cover your needs, 30 % is going to wants, 20 % is going towards additional debt payments and savings, this is a way where you can ensure that you have some kind of financial and budgeting balance. And if your money is fitting into these categories neatly, then you can kind of set it and forget it, have your money going to your different expenses and not have to worry about every single thing that you're spending money on.

28:10Elizabeth Ayoola:Yeah, because it can be time consuming. So Sean, I want to know, have you experienced any type of lifestyle creep? What was that like for you if you have?

28:18Sean Pyles:I kind of love lifestyle creep in a responsible way. That's why when I bought a car in 2020, I bought myself a very affordable BMW because I drove crappy cars my entire life. In high school, I had a Honda Civic where the muffler was rusted out and dragging on the ground behind me. It was Oh, dear. A mess. Yeah, it was really bad. So I said, okay, I have a big boy job. I'm earning some money. I can fit this luxurious car into my lifestyle and my budget. And, you know, it was affordable for me. My monthly payment was like$350 a month, which is nothing for a car. Yeah. Exactly. So I'm all about having thoughtful lifestyle creep.

28:54Sean Pyles:So think about where your priorities are. For me, I wanted a nice car. I also like buying some nice clothes. I don't have a child that's taking up my money or a really big housing payment. So I have the freedom in my finances to allocate things to where I want to indulge a little bit. And that can be a nice vacation every once in a while, too. So, yes, I like lifestyle creep, but I think you need to be really considerate about how you're doing it.

29:17Elizabeth Ayoola:I like that framing. So it's almost like you're using lifestyle creep as a way to say, hey, I can enjoy a bit more of my money now that I have more money.

29:25Sean Pyles:One thing I go back to a lot in personal finance is that it's important to plan for tomorrow, but also live for today, too, because there is no promise of tomorrow. But you want to, of course, cover all your bases. So enjoy things while you can. Go out to that nice meal. Treat your partner to a nice evening out. Whatever is important to you, but just make sure it fits into everything else you need to do with your finances. That's right. What about you, Elizabeth? What's your big indulgence? Is it the Uber Eats?

29:50Elizabeth Ayoola:I feel like I talk about Uber Eats a lot. Do I sound like a greedy girl? We are not sponsored by Uber Eats, by the way.

29:57Sean Pyles:She's organic.

29:59Elizabeth Ayoola:Honestly, I would say my biggest lifestyle creep was no, just escaped from my vocabulary suddenly. Hey, wanna go out to eat? No. Hey, wanna go on vacation? I mean, yes, yes, yes, there were no no's. I was saying yes to everything and not checking with my budget first because I was like, I think I have enough money to do all of these things. And maybe I didn't have enough money that month to do all of the things.

30:21Sean Pyles:Right, and that's where the lifestyle creep becomes problematic. So again, Alyssa, we don't know what your household finances are like, but I suspect there might be some kind of lifestyle creep going on. Think about where you can cut back and find some extra money in your budget to cover all of these unexpected irregular expenses. Okay, well, something else that Alyssa mentioned is wanting to have a set it and forget it approach to savings. And I am the master of doing this because as you said earlier, Elizabeth, I have about 20 ,000 savings accounts at the moment. No, I really only have nine that I'm currently using.

30:55Sean Pyles:And that might sound extreme, but let me just list them out. I don't think it'll sound as wild as you might initially think. So going in order, I have my emergency fund. I have my wedding fund, which is being quickly depleted as I spend more and more ahead of my wedding in less than two months now. I have my house maintenance fund. I have a student loan fund. I have a fund for taxes. I have one for my car, for car maintenance and for my future car. I have one that's just fun money. I also have a checking account at a credit union. That's kind of my day-to-day spending. I also have an old checking account from high school that I pretty much just used to pay my mom my part of the cell phone bill.

31:33Sean Pyles:And that's it. That's where my money is going. And I have a little bit of my paycheck every single pay period going into each one of these accounts based on percentages.

31:42Elizabeth Ayoola:You can add nine?

31:43Sean Pyles:Yes, actually. So with NerdWallet system, they say you can add 10. But guess what? I did that one time and I broke the system. So you can't do 10. But you can do nine. This way, I have just different percentages of my paycheck going into all of these different areas. And I don't even have to think about it. It's happening in the background on autopilot. Super easy.

32:01Elizabeth Ayoola:Well, I do have one question for you. Do you ever find that you end up co-mingling? Because this is a common issue I hear for people who are having budgeting issues, which is like, I didn't have enough in my check-in. Then I had to take it from my savings or I had to take it from that account and put it in this account. So do you ever have that issue?

32:15Sean Pyles:I have had that issue, especially with some of these irregular expenses. Like this past August, my annual pet insurance bill came and I just pay it all at one time. And it was, again, like$2 ,200 or something. And so I didn't have enough money in my checking account to cover that. So I pulled it from my house maintenance fund because my pets are part of my house. That's how I girl math justified it to myself. But I'm thinking that in general, I want to get better about having my irregular expenses accounted for because Alyssa's question was kind of a wake-up call for me too. So in the future, I'll probably put that into my emergency fund account and just pull it from there, even though it's not technically an emergency.

33:00Sean Pyles:But it's a place where I have a pot of money that I know has a designated purpose outside of typical day-to-day spending.

33:06Elizabeth Ayoola:And something I will say further for anyone who's thinking about adopting Sean's wild idea is that you may want to budget again. You're going to have to go through, but you're going to have to, I think, budget for each of these expenses. And then maybe you automatically save, I don't know, if you want to put$50 for your pet bill. I'm sorry I made that up. I have fish. Maybe that applies to me. Maybe you're putting$5. I know, right? Maybe you're putting$5 into that account a month in order to meet that bill. So you're going to have to time it properly and also plan your savings.

33:35Sean Pyles:So with this, there's a little bit of admin work on the front end, understanding where you need your money to go to cover all of your expenses, and then setting up the direct deposit if your employer graciously allows you to do so like NerdWallet does. Thank you, NerdWallet. But if they don't allow you to do that, you could also just do automated transfers from your checking into a different savings account each pay period. This is really the pay yourself first method of savings where before the money is even available for you to spend it, you have it just quickly shot into whatever savings account that you want and you just ensure that savings is going on in the background.

34:07Sean Pyles:And that's just what I do personally. Elizabeth, how do you handle this? Because I understand that you don't have nine checking and savings accounts.

34:13Elizabeth Ayoola:I do not. So I am a lump sum girl. I love to see big sums of money going somewhere, usually into my savings. So I save quite a chunk, maybe around, let's say, a thousand dollars a month into a general savings account. And then when I need to use it, I just pull it out. So I just save large amounts and use it whenever it's needed. Okay.

34:33Sean Pyles:But you're not sweating, oh, I'm pulling this a couple hundred bucks for my son's expense from my lump sum. some and you're not worried about that getting in the way of saving for another goal that you have like a vacation or something.

34:44Elizabeth Ayoola:No. Okay.

34:46Sean Pyles:That's fine because you know where your money is going. So if you are a little bit, I don't want to say loosey-goosey, but a little bit more flexible than my potentially more rigid way of saving, that's okay to each their own, right?

34:56Elizabeth Ayoola:Exactly. Exactly. And then on months, so if I'm planning for a vacation, for example, I will plan a couple of months ahead for that and then I'll budget like, hey, maybe I need to put aside a little extra money into my savings for that so that when it's time to pay for it, I have enough.

35:09Sean Pyles:All right. Well, Alyssa and all other listeners who struggle with irregular expenses, Elizabeth and I included in this. I hope this has been helpful. Let us know what you end up doing with your finances because it's something that we all struggle with.

35:20Elizabeth Ayoola:That's right. So I'll be taking some tips from what we learned today or what we taught y 'all today, and I'll be using them in my personal finances too.

35:27Sean Pyles:And keep us posted, Elizabeth.

35:29Elizabeth Ayoola:You too, Sean. We're holding each other accountable here.

35:31Sean Pyles:Yes, exactly. Accountability partners here. Well, that's all we have for this episode, remember, listener, that we are here to answer your money questions. So turn to the nerds and call or text us your questions at 901-730-6373. That's 901-730-NERD. You can also email us at podcast at nerdball.com.

35:49Elizabeth Ayoola:Join us next time to hear about how much life insurance you might need. You can follow Smart Money on your favorite podcast app that includes Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and iHeartRadio to automatically download new episodes.

36:01Sean Pyles:Here's our brief disclaimer. We are not your financial or investment advisors, this nerdy info is provided for general educational and entertainment purposes and may not apply to your specific circumstances.

36:11Elizabeth Ayoola:This episode is produced by Tess Viglin and Anna Howalski, Hillary Georgie helps with editing, Nick Kersmey mixed our audio, and a big thank you to NerdWallet's editors for their help.

36:20Sean Pyles:And with that said, until next time, turn to the nerds.

36:41Toast.

From the publisher

Learn how to plan for surprise bills and what to ask about a home’s past so your budget and buying feel stress free.

Do sellers have to disclose deaths, crimes or “hauntings” in a home? How can you budget for irregular expenses without daily tracking? Hosts Sean Pyles and Elizabeth Ayoola open a spooky episode with housing Nerds Holden Lewis and Kate Wood to break down which states require sellers to reveal a home’s dark history, when they don’t, and how to protect yourself as a buyer. They unpack how to check local laws, research an address, and talk with neighbors so you can make confident choices — and avoid creepy surprises.

Then, Sean and Elizabeth answer listener Alyssa’s question about managing expenses that change (or don’t come up at all) from month to month. They share practical ways to plan ahead for costs like home maintenance, credit card fees, childcare, pet care, and car repairs — without tracking every penny. Learn how to build flexible savings buckets, automate deposits, and keep lifestyle creep in check so your budget finally feels steady.

Want us to review your budget? Fill out this form — completely anonymously if you want — and we might feature your budget in a future segment! https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScK53yAufsc4v5UpghhVfxtk2MoyooHzlSIRBnRxUPl3hKBig/viewform?usp=header

In their conversation, the Nerds discuss: haunted house disclosure laws, seller disclosure death in house, stigmatized property, California real estate law, Alaska disclosure rules, Massachusetts disclosure requirements, Minnesota property laws, South Dakota home sale rules, Kentucky real estate disclosure, house history search, property value and crime, neighborhood research before buying, state disclosure differences, how to check a home’s history, due diligence when buying a home, buyer protection strategies, homebuyer checklist, surprise home costs, unpredictable expenses, annual fees planning, sinking funds, budgeting system, flexible savings account, automated transfers, pay yourself first, lifestyle creep management, household budget balance, high income budgeting, financial organization, saving for irregular costs, long-term financial planning, and how to do a monthly money check-in.

To send the Nerds your money questions, call or text the Nerd hotline at 901-730-6373 or email podcast@nerdwallet.com.

Like what you hear? Please leave us a review and tell a friend.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast

All 131 episodes
What Home Sellers Can Legally Hide and How to Master Irregular BillsNerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast · 34 min
Listen in VO