1. Podcasts
  2. Open Circuit
  3. AI bubble fears are derailing energy IPOs
Open Circuit

27 Oct 2026 · 1h · 24 chapters

Episode artwork

AI bubble fears are derailing energy IPOs

In short

Clean energy IPOs are being delayed or repriced as the AI data-center buildout faces higher financing costs, slower project timelines, and local backlash against data centers. The episode argues the “AI wave” is breaking earlier than expected, pressuring nuclear, geothermal, and other pre-revenue energy developers.

Guests (backgrounds)

  1. Caroline Golan, chief growth and policy officer at NRG (utility/energy company; focuses on policy and growth).
  2. Jigar Shah, co-managing partner of Multiplier (investor/advisor on energy and climate infrastructure; discusses market/exit strategy).

Key claims

  • AI data-center owners must generate $8.5T by 2030 to cover spending/debt/returns; Gartner projects a ~$5T shortfall.
  • Higher interest rates (10-year Treasury yield up ~5% in September) raise borrowing costs and make pre-revenue energy valuations harder.
  • Data-center opposition is widespread (71% of Americans oppose data centers), stalling projects and slowing revenue realization.
  • Market scrutiny is returning: companies must show “demonstrative checkpoints,” not just LOIs or early progress.

Notable examples

  • IPO delays/shelving: Holtec, SB Energy, Form Energy.
  • Fervo geothermal IPO: down ~70% from first day.
  • Anthropic: planned ~$1.5T IPO drawing attention away from other deals.
  • Discussion of hyperscaler load delays and the need for capacity/flexibility; mentions Voltus-style VPP/load-flex as “no-regrets.”
  • Nuclear examples: X-energy not yet built a commercial NRC-approved reactor; Kairos takes a different private route.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Understanding Friction Maxing

Discussion on the concept of friction maxing and its implications.

“And as a result, there's no evidence of anything that I've ever said.”
2:27

Energy Market Dynamics

Exploring the implications of AI and energy company IPOs amidst economic challenges.

“Companies across the AI industry are seeing sharp stock price drops as investors worry about infrastructure spending.”
4:02

The $8.5 Trillion Challenge

AI data center owners face a massive revenue gap by 2030.

“Ben Brown is the CEO of Everyday Electric.”
4:15

Public Sentiment on Data Centers

Examining public opposition to data centers and its impact on the industry.

“We have to find ways in which to drive savings, both to households that are part of virtual power plants, because if you do that at scale, it actually drives savings for everyone.”
9:08

Market Sentiments and IPO Delays

Delving into the challenges faced by clean energy companies in the IPO market.

“Unfortunately, I'm not sure that the companies that are driving the demand here are being as judicious with the way they're placing capital.”
14:01

Market Sentiment and AI Impact on Energy IPOs

Explore the current state of the market and its effects on energy IPOs, driven by AI hype and course corrections.

“And I just think that it was a little bit of the dog that caught the car, you know, on the big AI build out.”
16:46

Dependency on Major Clients in AI Revenues

Discuss the reliance of AI companies on a small number of clients and potential risks involved.

“Yeah, and it may get there, but I just don't think it was going to get there in three years.”
19:49

Challenges in Data Center Development

Analyze the conflicting dynamics between large and small data center developments and market demands.

“And so they don't have the balance sheet to pivot.”
23:26

Environmental Concerns in Tech Infrastructure

Address the environmental implications of powering data centers and the industry's responsibility.

“sitting in the desert in Phoenix and run data centers off of it.”
27:37

Current Trends in Energy Development

Examine how certain companies are managing to thrive amidst delayed IPOs and market uncertainty.

“at the market and saying, this isn't the right time.”
Show all 24 chapters
28:00

Market Dynamics for Midsize Companies

Explore the current market situation and hesitations among midsize companies regarding IPOs.

“The electronics component suppliers that are developing the electrical architecture, this is still a really good market for a lot of the midsize companies along this industry.”
29:15

Cost Implications of Gas and Energy Infrastructure

Discuss the implications of rising costs in energy infrastructure and their impact on future planning.

“Because if the AI data center load growth doesn't show up, using the grid that we already have more efficiently doesn't lose money.”
31:08

Investor Scrutiny and IPO Readiness

Analyze how increased scrutiny affects companies' decisions to go public and their preparation.

“At what point do you say, huh, maybe the old way that we were doing things is not the right way to do it in the future, right?”
34:38

Technological Readiness and Market Expectations

Examine how companies' technological advancements influence investor confidence and market expectations.

“I don't think it means this industry is going away.”
37:19

Paths to Profitability and Market Strategy

Discuss different business paths companies can take toward profitability and the strategy behind them.

“And we've talked about some of those companies.”
42:00

The Dilemma of Wealth in Private Equity

The conversation explores the trade-offs between private equity and public offerings, highlighting how individuals navigate between comfort and wealth.

“Well, like, there's a bunch of people who are like, you know, I'm very filthy comfortable, right?”
44:32

Political Challenges in Clean Energy

Discussion on how political dynamics are influencing the clean energy sector and shaping capital investment opportunities.

“And so you said something that we haven't really brought in which I think is interesting that we haven't brought in which is that all of these companies started and we'll put the IRA money on the side for a second.”
45:54

Market Sentiment on Independent Power Producers

Insight into the current market conditions affecting independent power producers and their strategies amidst fluctuating prices.

“we've always known on the renewable side or the clean energy side, that it's all about regulatory and policy alignment.”
48:20

Energy Market Structures and Future Legislation

Exploration of the challenges in energy market structures and the potential for future legislative changes to address these issues.

“that's what your stock is going to be down.”
51:08

AI and Cybersecurity Concerns

Dialogue about the implications of AI on cybersecurity and its potential effects on the financial market landscape.

“And I think that, I will say it now, but I think there will be legislation in Texas next year that asks this, like, is the market today, you know, what we need going forward?”
53:05

Debating Data Center Necessity

A critical examination of whether infrastructure investments in data centers are essential for future AI integration in the economy.

“I think the wild card is going to be the narrative around China being months behind us goes away.”
56:05

The Future of AI and Edge Infrastructure

Exploring the integration of AI in the economy and the role of edge infrastructure.

“The current models that they're training right now still are less than one gigawatt.”
58:08

Challenges of Large Centralized Power Plants

Discussing the complexities and investment challenges in building centralized power plants.

“Because that's where the trade comes, right?”
1:00:00

Market Correction Insights

Understanding the market correction driven by the challenges in energy infrastructure.

“Well, if Stephen knew, he would not be hosting this podcast.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Open Circuit, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Latitude Media, covering the new frontiers of the energy transition. I've been seeing this term everywhere, friction maxing. Have you guys heard of this? It's my life. That's what I do. To be honest, I only heard of it once you told me that's how friction I am, because I don't even know that there are phrases like this, Stephen. So go buy groceries at the store instead of using Instacart. Go borrow books from the library. Host friends at your house instead of eating out. Use a physical map. Are these things that you're already doing anyway? These are all things that I do regularly. These are all things that I do.

0:34Even the physical map? Even physical maps. And people get really mad at me. Like, when I call people on the phone, they're like, Jigger, why do you call people? Why don't you text? And I was like, because I don't text. I call. That's what I do. And as a result, there's no evidence of anything that I've ever said. Pause on the friction maxing for a second. I think maybe the younger generation has lost the art of pleading the fifth and not having a paper trail. I don't know what you guys are hiding. Well, I mean. I am hiding nothing at all because none of it is in emails or texts. Exactly. All of it is in the ether.

1:14And now that I've said it, it was not recorded and it has moved on. Which is why I also have people over to my house for dinner. To yell at them. And do the other things. Right. No. Sorry? Yes. If I'm going to be mean and nasty, I'm going to do it to your face. I'm not going to do it over text and email. I have a library down the street. We're at the library. I like to go to the store for groceries. I don't use a physical map, but I got lots of friction in my life, but I will never give up the text message. I hate talking on the phone. I talk for a living, but I cannot stand talking on the phone.

1:45And so those transcribed messages are a godsend. I also spend less than$300 a year on Amazon. I mean, I just like, I go to the store and I buy stuff and I bring it back in my car. I'm an Amazon user, but what I do is like over time, I compile things in my cart. Like, oh, I might need that. And then I, like, make this month-long list in my cart. And then at the end of the month, I go in and say, like, okay, what do I actually really need? And then I whittle it down to a few things that I might really need. And you just described hyperscaler energy shopping in two minutes.

2:21This was supposed to be the year clean energy rode the AI wave onto Wall Street. Instead, the wave might be breaking sooner than expected. Companies across the AI industry are seeing sharp stock price drops as investors worry about infrastructure spending. And it's hitting energy companies. Holtec, the nuclear company, SB Energy, and Form Energy have all shelved plans to go public. And Fervo, this year's breakout geothermal listing, is down 70 % from its first day of trading. What is happening? Three numbers tell the story. $8.5 trillion. That's how much revenue AI data center owners need to bring in by 2030 to cover their spending, their debt, and a reasonable return.

3:00Gartner says they're going to come up nearly$5 trillion short. Then, 5%. That's the level the 10-year treasury yield broke in September, the highest in three years. That makes every dollar of the AI build-out more expensive to borrow and every pre-revenue energy company harder to value. And finally, 71%. That's the share of Americans who oppose data centers in their communities, according to Gallup. The backlash is stalling projects and forcing investors to rethink how fast the company's serving data centers can grow. So if the AI boom is getting more expensive and less popular, what happens to the energy companies that bet on it?

3:35That's coming up on Open Circuit from Latitude Media.

3:43Open Circuit is brought to you by Everyday Electric, formerly known as Renew Home. Utilities are investing$1.5 trillion in the grid over the next three years to meet soaring demand. And Americans are asking, how will it benefit me? Growth and demand can be a great thing for actually reducing rates for everyone, but only if the system becomes more efficient. Ben Brown is the CEO of Everyday Electric. With six gigawatts of flexible capacity, Everyday Electric empowers customers to take part in that transition and helps the grid grow responsibly. So yes, you need to build infrastructure, but you have to increase utilization of the system we have.

4:19We have to find ways in which to drive savings, both to households that are part of virtual power plants, because if you do that at scale, it actually drives savings for everyone. From batteries to thermostats to electric vehicles, homes around the country already have the energy products that could save them money while providing more capacity to the grid. Since its founding, Everyday Electric has been working toward a more affordable, more reliable system for everyone. Now that we are reaching scale, there's just these amazing moments in time that we can unlock 50 megawatts or 100 megawatts of resource across every major climate region, every major utility.

4:55Later in the show, Ben explains how VPPs can meet utility growth while driving down rates for everyone. To learn more, visit everydayelectric.com. Giving Tuesday is December 1st. Time to put climate giving on your year-end checklist and apply the same due diligence you would with any investment. That's what Giving Green does. Giving Green researches the strategies and nonprofits best positioned to unlock the next big climate breakthrough and sends 100 % of every dollar donated to the Giving Green Fund directly to them. Maximize your impact per dollar. No cuts or guesswork. Make your first gift before 2027, and it's matched up to$1 ,000.

5:33Go to givinggreen.earth. OpenCircuit is brought to you by Energy Hub. Energy Hub's DERMS platform gives utilities flexible capacity they can stake their grid planning on, coordinating batteries, EVs, thermostats, and commercial and industrial sites through a single system. Utilities unlock a partner ecosystem that covers more than 90 % of connected DERs in the market and integrates seamlessly into existing infrastructure. The scale is proven. More than 230 utilities across North America trust Energy Hub to manage over 3.5 gigawatts of flexible capacity. Learn more at energyhub.com.

6:15Welcome to the show. I'm Stephen Lacey, the executive editor of Latitude Media. Caroline Golan is with us. She's the chief growth and policy officer at NRG. Hi, Caroline. Hello, hello. Glad to be back. Jigar Shah is the co-managing partner of Multiplier. Did you have fun in Austin, Jigar, when I saw you at Flex Summit? Did you do any two-stepping? I mean, I crushed it. You and I went to the same dinner. That was a very long table. I, you know, sometimes have a hard time. I did not think that the structure of that dinner was good. I found that I was able to speak with the three people next to me and nobody else.

6:50Maybe good for everybody else. I don't know. They did that on purpose. I get it. All right. So it's a big week. Let's get into the public markets, which are seeing shifting headwinds for clean energy companies looking to IPO. We have this combination of high interest rates, skepticism over AI revenues, slower than expected development due to local resistance, and worries over the debt load now driving development. It's all making investors wary. And we're seeing this play out across the market. So many companies that are serving or in close proximity to AI are seeing big hits in their stock prices.

7:25And at the same time, we have Anthropic, which has a planned$1.5 trillion IPO that's sucking up all the attention away from other companies that are planning to go public. So as a result, there are a bunch of companies in this space that were expected to benefit from all this activity. They're delaying IPOs. They're reportedly getting signals from investors that their appetites have diminished. And the list is Holtec, Nuclear Company, SB Energy, and Form Energy. So what is going on here? Caroline, what's your read on how the narrative in the market has shifted? Yeah, I mean, I think it's pretty straightforward, but it's interesting that it's happening right now.

8:01And I will be interested to see if it shifts after midterms. I think that the market gave the AI race a really, really long leash, maybe a longer leash than it should have. Right. And they were investing and they were valuing based on potential. And they were really comfortable with companies being fairly well leveraged, you know. And now the politics have kicked up. Capital costs have gotten higher. Turns out it's hard to build power plants. Takes longer than you think. And some of them are burning out and people are breaking things left and right. And so you have to be able to demonstrate an actual return and you have to be able to demonstrate more than just, I think, early stage progress to get the wins that I think people were able to get maybe a year, year and a half ago, you know, based on an LOI or based on, you know, some type of potential partnership.

9:06I just think the leash has gotten tighter, and I think it should, frankly. Unfortunately, I'm not sure that the companies that are driving the demand here are being as judicious with the way they're placing capital. So we'll see. But I am interested how the midterms will change. I think a lot of people are waiting to see if the politics will get worse, it'll get better. And I personally don't think they've changed irrespective of whether there's a blue wave or not. Yeah. Yeah, Jigar, what's at the other end of that leash tugging? Is it interest rates? Is it earnings to spend ratio? Is it, you know, companies, pre-revenue companies having a harder time in the market?

9:54Like, what do you think it is? Well, it's all of those things, right? I mean, for those of us who have been on this open circuit journey, I think we have told everybody to short these stocks for like over a year. And, you know, and folks were like, you're an idiot. Wait, short what stocks? Are you talking about energy stocks or the data center? Well, I think it depends, right? Each one of the names has a different story, right? But I just think that, you know, for a long time, people are like, oh, no, Jigar, it's going to be so easy to run data centers off grid. I mean, there's still dumb people out there who think that they can run data centers off-grid, right?

10:31And so those people who sold technology into those projects are still trying to convince people that you can run data centers off-grid. I still don't think we've won that argument. But if those stock prices went up, and now all of those projects are delayed, like crazy delayed. It's like not just six months delayed, it's a year delayed. And now they're trucking in natural gas to those projects because the pipelines are delayed. And now, like, when you think about just how laughable it is, like, I feel like I'm literally watching a Charlie Brown show with a football and people are like, oh, that was not predictable at all.

11:08I don't think that anyone thought that we could see that coming, right? So now that it's happened, they're like, what should we do with the stock price? Well, obviously, if the compute's not online, well, then you can't make money off of it. That's how this works, right? You can lie to yourself as much as you want. But at some point, if the compute is not generating tokens and you're not getting revenue for those tokens, then there are consequences to that, right? And so that's what's happening on those sets of stocks. Then when you think about the Fervos of the world, look, I'm not going to badmouth Fervo or anybody else.

11:48The whole thing that I wanted Fervo to do was to raise$2.2 billion. They succeeded at doing that. Now they've got four years to prove whether they can use that$2.2 billion to make sure that all of their technology works and it can be replicated to five more projects and all these other things. I don't care what their stock price does because they've already raised$2.2 billion and now they're going to have a chance to succeed. I can't say the same thing for some of the other names. Like if you look at a lot of the other geothermal names, they didn't go out and go public. they don't have$2.2 billion.

12:24They have maybe$200 million. So we'll see when they run out of cash and whether the markets are open and are willing to give them more runway when they run out of cash. When you go to the Holtec side of things, Holtec has not yet turned on Palisades, right? Although it's supposed to be turning on any day now, and I'm hopeful and I'm super excited for when that occurs. And then you're going to have to build a 300-megawatt reactor there, right? They filed for two new Holtec 300s at that site, right? And, you know, we'll see where that goes. But I think that there was some trepidation when the week was that they were going to go public that folks were going to buy into the story that the hyperscalers were going to pay 15 cents a kilowatt hour for all that power.

13:13And so, you know, we'll see where, you know, the contracts land. Yeah, I mean, I think on Furvo, like, I don't think the lower valuation is something to freak out about. I mean, I think that across the entire industry, stocks are down. And that's largely because you have to show more durable checkpoints on construction and on meeting your milestones. And I don't think that's a bad thing. I look at Burble and I'm like, okay, if you can do what you said you were going to do, I think that will probably drive more investment in the company. But I think there was a race and an excitement. And I think the other thing that's happening here is that we had a flood of new entrants on the nuclear side, right?

14:00And there was a lot of political support, still is, on the nuclear side. And I just think that it was a little bit of the dog that caught the car, you know, on the big AI build out. And so there was a lot of interest. And we've talked about this before. And then there was a bit of a course correction because there's also a bit of sanity going on now, right? And I think you see this all the time in markets. I just don't think you see it with such demonstrative impact of capital that's on the line, right? Everyone gets spun up about something. You get smaller companies that get pulled along for the ride.

14:42Oh, you have a deal with one of the five companies that's 50 % of the overall market right now? Okay, you're good to go. But now there's just a little more sanity on it. And there should be. should be. I mean, I don't, I think there's a lot of nuance in some of the stuff around like SpaceX and Amazon and everything that's going on there, but, and Anthropic. But generally speaking, I think lower valuation is a result of three things. Market prices are low across the country. So there's that. Hitting your construction timeline is people are slipping because of politics and because of supply chain, which we all knew, but no one could guarantee, right?

15:25And so there's that. And the last one is, is that, like, I actually, we don't talk about this as much, but, you know, there's some general skepticism that the demand for the chips that are sitting on barges in ports. Yeah, in warehouses. You're right. In warehouses at Amazon. It's there. And I think that the narrative has always been, well, they're sitting there because there isn't enough power. But I think there is some recognition that power is part of it, but also demand is potentially not the hockey stick that everyone wants at. And so this is a course correction. And I actually, I think, sort of, I'm glad to see it because if it didn't happen, then I think we do run the risk of some, like, massive crash in volatility.

16:16Yeah. Yeah. And I would add one to that last point, which is, if you look at Anthropics S1, the bulk of their revenue relies on two customers. Two percent, right? If you look at AI, no, two main customers. Yeah, I forgot the percentage of revenue, but they're heavily dependent on two big customers. Right. And then if you look at the bulk of AI revenues across the industry, you have a very small number of companies that represent the bulk of AI spend. And so it's extremely concentrated, and there's not really the proof yet that this is durable in terms of revenue across a wide spectrum of industries.

16:50Yeah, and it may get there, but I just don't think it was going to get there in three years. Like, that's the thing is, you know, everyone's like, oh, the world is going to change. Caroline, this time was supposed to be different. Yeah. What was the last time? Yeah, what was the last time? Well, the last time was like telecom fiber. And the time before that was something else. Like, I'm just saying that like every news article was like, we read all that history and this time is different. Because this is such a game-changing technology. And it's going to put everyone out of a job in four weeks.

17:24Well, it is a game-changing technology, but I just think that it also requires, and I'm going to say something maybe a little controversial, it requires a literacy around the technology and a use case around the technology that wasn't pre-built before it disrupted. Right? Yeah. There's that. Coming from the corporate side, it's like you actually have to take time to figure out where this is going to be best used. And that can slow integration in a way that maybe I don't think people anticipated. Yeah. And I would push back on that a little bit, Jigar. I mean, I think there's a question about how companies can fill this revenue gap.

18:04But there's demand for the computing inside these data centers. I mean, it's not like the railroads, these small companies in the railroad era that just like built railroads to nowhere. These are the most highly capitalized companies in the world that are building data centers to meet actual demand. So there's, you know, definitely a different dynamic. I mean, potato, potato, right? I mean, all I'm saying is that on this side of the fence, you've got people who want to build only 1 ,000 megawatt data centers, which are literally building the city of Cincinnati in every single place. And then on this side, you have people that want to build five megawatt data centers at substations.

18:46Utilities are saying, here's where we have excess capacity. We would love for you to fill it because then we could reduce costs for everybody. And the data center companies are saying, we hate you. We would like to build the city of Cincinnati in every place and make your life a living hell. So if it was so hard for them to get compute, why wouldn't they work with the utility companies and say, yeah, we'll take those five megawatt sites and actually put compute in all those long lines so that we can actually increase utilization? And maybe they are. NVIDIA made that big announcement this week and Crusoe made a big announcement on their five megawatt unit, et cetera.

19:22But I'm just saying we are in a situation right now where it is very obvious that on the one hand, tokens are going up in price, to your point, because we're short compute. And on the other hand, there are people saying, here's some really great solutions. And the folks who are buying it are saying, no, we know better than you. We are so much smarter than you. And the stock market is implying that they actually are. I mean, they've also sunk billions of dollars into what they thought was better, right? And so they don't have the balance sheet to pivot. Yeah, without any knowledge whatsoever by which to say that it's better.

19:55Right? Just with their pure masculine energy. Masculine. So I don't care. Like, they could lose half their stock price and I would cheer. Because I'm so sick and tired of them. But you should care. Because, like, if they do— Why should I care about the masculine energy? Because then the whole market comes down. Well, so let's get— I'm fine with the feminine energy coming back. This is why I still love you. Let it loose. Let it loose. But there is, like, nuance. But there is no. So, like, you look at SpaceX, right? Still revenues, positive, still lots of deployment in AI. Market price is down. Stock price is down.

20:32They reduced their CapEx. They're the first company to actually reduce CapEx. They restated and reduced their CapEx, right? But that shows discipline, does it not, or no? I mean, that shows that they're finally starting to listen to the non-masculine energy. I just think that at some point, you have to look at the data and say, for these companies who are the most profitable companies in history to have negative cash flows, at some point, you're like, what are you doing, man? Like, seriously. Meta just announced that they went into negative cash flows, right? I mean, even Tesla, the only reason they made money really this last quarter was because they had a one-time increase in tariff refunds of$700 million.

21:15Yeah, but their revenue has slowed as well. Their revenue slowed. But it's across the board. Like, it is across the board in the energy space. Yeah. Cash flow revenue is down. Who's most exposed? I mean, so obviously the neoclouds are the ones that are taking the biggest hit. Like, who else do you think is most exposed here right now? On which side of the aisle? On the data center infrastructure side. I think, I mean, I tend to agree with Jigar on this. I think the development companies that went all in on the gigafactories are probably most exposed. Interesting. And then what about the energy side?

21:54Well, on the energy side, anyone who didn't take a DOE loan, probably. Why is that? Well, it was a joke. Well, kind of not a joke. I mean, I think everyone's exposed. I mean, look at PJM, look at ERCOT, look at KIA. I mean, market prices are down. Places that were sure bets are paused, right? I mean, everyone's exposed. I think the companies, and I think what you're seeing is that everyone is saying, okay, like, how do we affect discipline then, right? We all got a little crazy. We all went to the party. We all drank the AI Kool-Aid. But I think a lot of energy companies, and, you know, I talked to a lot of the supplier community and even sort of like, you know, the smaller IPP space are all recognizing we'd like to be here for 30, 50 more years, you know?

22:54So how much of our balance sheet are we willing to leverage to do this? And I think a lot of investors are saying, please don't leverage a lot of your balance sheet to do that, you know? And I was drinking N.A. beer, to be clear. Not Kool-Aid. I was not drinking Kool-Aid. I just think that this was so obvious in coming, right? And all of the people who were like, I'm going to take old ship engines and power a data center with it. I'm going to rip off these engines off of old airplanes sitting in the desert in Phoenix and run data centers off of it. Good riddance to all of them. But they're still doing that, aren't they?

23:35I don't think that's totally gone away. Yeah, they are. But good riddance to their investors, good riddance to everybody who thought that basically destroying the planet to be able to power AI data centers faster by two seconds was a good idea. I hope they all lose their shirt. Well, folks, that's it. No, but I'm just saying, look, I mean, there could have been, I get the fact that people were talking too much about climate change, right? And then the Trump administration came in and said, all of you guys were talking about climate change too much, right? But it's not like the IPCC didn't just come out and say that, you know, we're definitely way past 1.5 degrees.

24:14Now we're at 2.8 probably. We're going to have to look at geoengineering. And then on this side, the guy's like, oh, let me take the dirtiest possible power plant and figure out how to run a data center off-grid in the middle of Utah. And now they've got to, like, truck in natural gas because the pipeline didn't come in on time. And like, I'm sorry, I'm not crying for you.

24:41Earlier, we introduced you to Ben Brown, CEO of Everyday Electric. Ben has been pioneering smart home technologies and virtual power plants for 20 years. With electricity prices rising fast, those flexible resources, solar, batteries, EV chargers, smart thermostats, are more important than ever before. It's really important to understand that, yes, we are in an energy affordability crisis, But I also think that because of that, we have so much energy and so much focus going into how we can dig ourselves out of this. And a new study from the Brattle Group backs this up. It finds that residential VPPs could cut expected electricity bill increases in half over five years.

25:19There's just a massive amount of value that can be brought to homes when you increase the efficiency of the system, the utilization of the resources on the system. And not just for people that are part of those virtual power plants, but their neighbors, the communities around them. That can mean$4 to$7 billion of savings per year for Americans. Everyday Electric already coordinates the largest residential VPP in the country, and it's working with device manufacturers to make participation effortless, unlocking more savings and more flexibility for the grid. It's really important to think about that cross-orchestration and think about that whole home energy fabric, being able to think about unlocking savings across every component of our home.

25:56Making electricity more affordable isn't just about what we build next. It's about getting more from what we've already built. Learn more at everydayelectric.com. Giving Tuesday is December 1st. Time to put climate giving on your year-end checklist and apply the same due diligence you would with any investment. That's what Giving Green does. Giving Green researches the strategies and non-profits best positioned to unlock the next climate breakthrough. Climate impact is difficult to quantify, but Giving Green's research suggests a donation to one of their top climate non-profits is roughly 10 times more effective than a high-quality carbon offset.

26:32And the Giving Green Fund sends 100 % of every dollar straight to them. Maximized impact per dollar. No cuts or guesswork. Make your first gift before 2027, and it's matched up to$1 ,000. Go to givinggreen.earth slash circuit to claim it. Utilities don't just hope flexible capacity performs. They need to be able to stake grid planning on it day in, day out. Energy Hub's DERM's platform is trained on over a decade of real event data from 2.6 million connected DERs. That means utilities can forecast available capacity with accuracy, optimize dispatch across any DER type or ownership model, and maintain visibility across their entire system.

27:14The platform integrates across more than 80 OEM and aggregator partners, giving utilities the reach they need as markets and regulations change. Consistent, verifiable, affordable. Energy Hub is the flexibility platform for the modern grid. Learn more at energyhub.com.

27:35I want to talk about some of the delayed IPOs, and so many of these companies are just looking at the market and saying, this isn't the right time. But there's a whole range of companies that are benefiting from the development. Hundreds of billions of dollars in development are getting frozen, but there's still a lot of development happening. And that's really good for companies like Voltus, which is seeing gigawatt scale demand now for VPPs. It's great for the battery suppliers. They're just in a crazy amount of batteries. The electronics component suppliers that are developing the electrical architecture, this is still a really good market for a lot of the midsize companies along this industry.

28:12Yeah. I mean, I completely agree with that. We're being more disciplined. And frankly, so I think that a lot of the companies that have hesitated to go public, I think there is also nuance there. I mean, some of them are hesitating to go public because they realize they can't meet the scrutiny that exists today that didn't exist a year ago. That's not necessarily a bad thing for the market, right? And I think some of them are not going public because there is a general sort of damned if you do, damned if you don't, if you're attached to specific hyperscaler load in this moment, right? And so I think that the former is good.

28:59I think the latter could play itself. People are banking on it playing itself out within the next couple of months. And I'm not sure that that's going to happen. Yeah, I think when you look at the Voltus-type deals, right, this is a no-regrets approach, right? Because if the AI data center load growth doesn't show up, using the grid that we already have more efficiently doesn't lose money. Being able to flex load with the same level of dexterity that we flex supply still makes the whole grid operate better. That's a no-regrets approach. And so, yes, the ideas that are no-regrets approach is like battery storage or like load flex and all that stuff.

29:45Yeah, they should keep going regardless of what happens because it just makes everything run better. But my point is that when you look at the filings at NIPSCO in Indiana this week, and they're now trying to rate base$3 ,500 a KW. To put that in perspective, that's$400 ,000 a megawatt year for the capacity. The PJM at the rate cap is at$140 ,000 a megawatt year. So they are overpaying for gas by 3x, right? And for what purpose? That's going to get rate-based for 30 years, right? And if the AI data center load doesn't show up, then what? Microsoft or somebody else pays for 80 % of their capacity payment for a turbine that doesn't run?

30:34I mean, what kind of like, this is the height of insanity in terms of how people think about what we should do as we move towards a decarbonized grid. I don't think the PJM cap or the market is reflective of what it costs to build new gas, though. Okay, but then give me a number, right? Because four years earlier, Nipsco and their IRP put in$1 ,100 a KW for that same exact gas plant. Same thing's true for Duke. Duke's at$3 ,000 a KW now. They were at$850 a KW four years ago, right? At what point do you say, huh, maybe the old way that we were doing things is not the right way to do it in the future, right?

31:19I just think that the reason people are so pissed off, right, and you look at poll number after poll number and how governors have to be anti-utility to even get elected these days, is because I just think that people are just sort of like vibing it right now. And I was like, there is math that you can do around what the easiest way is to be able to meet this moment. And for you to do the exact opposite should get the vitriol that I'm spewing. So you laid out some buckets of reasons there, Caroline. Do you want to apply that to any of the companies? I mean, so SP Energy seems like the kind of company that's facing – this is a renewable developer that is now doing integrated data center development, these mega campuses.

32:03They reportedly got pushback on the$50 billion valuation they were seeking. Form Energy felt like the market was not going to support its price goal. How would you bucketize some of these different companies? Yeah, I mean, so part of, I think some of the other nuance that's going on here is that similar to the cost of building new natural gas, the cost of raising capital and the cost of meeting projections from a year ago today went up by 20 % across the board, right? So if you were preparing an IPO, say, a year ago to go public this year, what's actually going to bake the cake is higher than it was.

32:46And it's gone up dramatically. So, and I think if you haven't within that year shown demonstrative checkpoints in your advancement, then like you're sort of caught in between these two bookends. And that makes, and that would make me question whether to go public or not. I think that there are a lot of factors here that are, and not all of them are working at the same time on every single company, on every single issue. And so I do think you can be a phenomenal technology and you can still have very successful development and perhaps need to be a little more conservative in the way you think about going public or what you need to show.

33:36And I'm not sure that that's a bad thing. Do I think because people are waiting to go public that that means they're going to go bankrupt? No, not at all. I just think that it means they're going to have to show more due diligence on what they've done. And they just have to be able to show a little more feasibility in their construction. And that's okay. I mean, the reality is that is the scrutiny we held this market to for decades. And then we lost it for a little while. And, you know, I've said this before on the podcast, like we, there were times at Google where I was like, we are kind of making and breaking things just on LOIs.

34:13And I'm not sure that's the right way to invest, you know? So I think we are returning to the level of scrutiny that was there. The other thing, of course, that's happening across all of this is, you know, IRA dollars disappeared. And so if you've been planning this for years, right, and then you've got all these different forces working against you. And I just think it's a higher level of scrutiny. I don't think it means this industry is going away. I don't think it means it's a bad investment. I don't think it means these technologies won't win out. I just think they're having to be a little more conservative.

34:48And perhaps them being more conservative is going to force the overall, what were you drinking? I was drinking Kool-Aid. I don't know. You were drinking... Non-alcoholic beer. NA beer. What the hell? A non-alcoholic beer? To Carolyn's point... Oh, I was thinking PBRs. I mean, to Carolyn's point, I think some of these companies have not hit their milestones, right? Like, I love Form Energy, but they do not have a very large project up and running at scale that's collecting data. It's just what it is. And I'm not bad-mouthing them. I'm not saying that they're going to fail. No, I think they're great.

35:23But they need to have one of those up and running. and the one at GRE is not yet up and running, right? And so, but I also think that a lot of the investors in Furvo stock, you know, should know what they're getting themselves into, right? I mean, it is a new way of making geothermal. I think it is well studied and DOE and others have put a lot of money into it, but now they have to get all of their techniques right, right? And so if you don't want that risk profile, you shouldn't own the stock, right? Like it's not a guarantee. They haven't had profitable quarters for the last five years before they went public.

35:57They represented themselves exactly the way they should represent themselves, which I think is fine. On the nuclear front, same thing, right? Like, look, I love me X Energy, but they still haven't built their first reactor yet, right? I mean, they've got a partnership with Dow. They've got a couple of other partnerships with Amazon. They're trying to get stuff done, right? And so, you know, like they're public. It's going to be a very volatile stock because they haven't built their first reactor that's commercial, that's NRC-approved, right? Kairos obviously has taken a different route where they've got a partnership with Google, but they haven't gone public, and they've been trying to raise money from private sources different direction on their part.

36:39And I wouldn't say that, again, I think that the more conservative nature is not reflective of an overall erosion and power demand. I think it's more reflective of a very excited investment community that woke up to the realities of building power in this country. I still think it's going to get built. I still think these technologies, you know, are all of them going to win? No, of course not. And they shouldn't. But should they be held to a bar that ensures that they are durable? Yes. And frankly, the bar of durability sort of slipped for a little while. And we've talked about some of those companies.

37:25And Jigar had to apologize to them for what he said afterwards. Did I? I think you did. But, you know, that bar slipped. Depends on who we're talking about. That bar slipped. Now the bar is going back up. I don't think that that's a bad thing. Yeah, that all feels right to me. Jigar, part of what you do with Multiplier is to help companies think about their exit strategy. What are you telling companies about the pathway to going public? Well, last year, I told them the market is fully open. And if you want to go into the public markets, you have a short window by which to do it, right? And that window's closed?

38:00I think that window is on pause for sure. You never know whether something's closed or open until you look through the rearview mirror. But right now, it certainly looks paused. And I think it depends on the company, right? And what the characteristics are. But I do think that, as Carolyn suggested, we still need more power on the grid. And so for those folks, if Voltus is able to meet this Google contract in the next 12 months, which I suspect they can, then they'll be given a chance to quadruple that contract again, or 10x that contract again, because we are short capacity. Every one of the hyperscalers is short 10 ,000 megawatts of capacity.

38:45Right? Like, you know, contracts they signed are not coming through on time and are getting indefinitely delayed. And so they need capacity and Voltus is one of the solutions for that capacity. But they're doing deals like one commercial customer at a time. And so a lot of the hyperskillers are nervous and are saying, how many of those commercial customers exist? Can you really get 10 ,000 megawatts of flexibility or only 1 ,000 megawatts? They got to prove themselves, right? So they now have the chance to do that, right? And so I think that's true across the board, right? Whether it's residential battery suppliers, whether it's thermostat people like Everyday Electric now, or whether it's other folks, everyone is going to get their chance to prove themselves.

39:30All of the nuclear companies that got grant funding from the U.S. military for a five-army basis also will have a chance to prove themselves, and they're going to get paid cash to build those reactors. and now they're going to have to deliver or not deliver. And, you know, it's in their hands. I think one of the other aspects here that I don't have an answer to and I actually think about, maybe we can bring it back on another show, is that, you know, in the past two years, you've also seen the movement and the consolidation with the private equity platforms, right? And so that has presented a different approach to the way that some of the deal-making happens, right?

40:19And the way that we think about debt, the way we think about, you know, consolidating these supply issues, right? And I don't know how much that has changed the way that even smaller companies think about their trajectory. You know, like, if I am, you know, a mid-sized development company, is my goal exit? Is my goal to get onto one of these platforms? You know, it's a very different space than we were in a handful of years ago. I mean, you know, between KKR and BlackRock and Blackstone, I mean, now they're consolidating these huge development platforms and they're picking the different pieces.

41:08And I think it's probably the way a lot of it gets done moving forward. And so now there's another path to it, right? And you can go public and then go there. You could not, right? And so I think that there is, I mean, you saw this Invenergy, you know,$3 billion stake in Invenergy from private equity, right? Invenergy is not public. They didn't go public. They did that instead. So I think that there are more paths towards profitability. And I think that there should be more scrutiny on going public, considering how much the market is determined by a handful of companies right now. Well, I mean, you know, Charles Schwab has that ad campaign that they have now that's called Filthy Comfortable.

41:54I don't know. I don't watch television. And, you know, that's what that represents, right? What is it? Tell us the ad. Well, like, there's a bunch of people who are like, you know, I'm very filthy comfortable, right? And it's basically like, if you try to go public or you try to have these big exits, then, you know, you're trying to become filthy rich. If you go to private equity, like, no one becomes rich. That's not how private equity works, right? They become rich. They become rich, right. That's right. You work for them. You get a decent salary and decent bonuses and a bunch of promises that they never keep on the back end.

42:31And that's what it is, right? But you get unlimited capital by which to do your core business, right? And that's fun. And it's useful because you get to do a lot of great stuff, right? But you never become filthy rich. You get filthy comfortable. Yeah, but on the flip side, if your stock is dropping and your investors are pissed, similar handcuffs. Oh, I'm not suggesting otherwise, but I'm simply saying that that's what a lot of people are deciding between when they think about what to do with their platform. Because, you know, like a lot of the private equity guys also, like to them, these are all ones and zeros on a page.

43:11It's not clear that they actually really even care about these businesses that are underlying there, right? When you look at like what's happened to the renewable natural gas space and a lot of the consolidation there, right? And so I think that one of the big challenges that we have is on the one hand, we're talking about technologies and areas that follow the law of capitalism. They save customers money, the customers want to sign contracts, they deliver solutions, etc. And then on the other hand, we're talking about technologies that are on that bridge to bankability. They have not yet proven themselves and they are in need of a lot of capital to be able to get to the other side.

43:52and be able to prove that it works, and they can get their costs down, and they can be mass manufactured, and all of those things, right? And the question that we're asking ourselves is, now that the IRA is effectively dead, and the loan programs office is not really leaning in to more difficult names, what is the right pathway for these folks to succeed? Fervo has taken the public offering pathway, right? Others tried to copy them. we're talking about private equity but I'm not sure that private equity is going to give a lot of money to companies that lose money systematically and need another five years to prove whether they're going to be successful.

44:31No. And so you said something that we haven't really brought in which I think is interesting that we haven't brought in which is that all of these companies started and we'll put the IRA money on the side for a second. So whether you're clean tech or not but all of these companies started with a general belief in open markets and innovation, the opportunity in this country to succeed in sort of a capitalist system. And within the past year and a half, we've become more populous as a country than we've probably been in a hundred years. And so that, when I call my friends in this space and I say, what's the biggest challenge?

45:20Politics. Yep. It doesn't matter if you're a constellation or if you're Fervo or if you're Tesla. I mean, it's politics. And I do think if that hadn't emerged, I question whether the discipline in the market and the conservatism would have transpired. So in many ways, and we can see the silver lining here, is that like the Democracy is working in some way in course correcting. And so I just think that we, those of us who work in the business of power, even though we've always known on the renewable side or the clean energy side, that it's all about regulatory and policy alignment. I think generally the power industry underestimated the strength of the populist pushback.

46:18I don't think the clean tech space ever thought that building a power plant would mean that you are synonymous with the evil overlords of AI, right? And I think that that emergence is probably a far more weighted variable in this than we're giving it credit for. I agree with that assessment entirely. Let's hit one more angle to this, which is the IPPs. So NRG, Vistra, Talon, Constellation are all down on the year. I think there's a combination of things happening here. It's because I joined. I mean, we've got like a bunch of shifting market rules and PJM. low power prices in Texas, making it hard to build new power.

47:05These companies are also seen as AI derivative companies. What is the market telling us about IPPs right now, Caroline? I mean, market prices are soft. Most of the investor bases in the IPP space, I think, are generally split. There's some investors, and this is broadly, I'm not just speaking for energy. I think there are investors who want the IPPs to go after the golden ticket. But I think a lot of investors are like, no, we don't want you to. We want you to just stay steady at ease so you can, I mean, the IPP space, for what it's worth, has been sort of a plug and play investment community for decades, right?

47:46And you ride the weather. Prices are up. You make money. Prices are down. You don't make money. Now there's this new layer of like signing a bilateral and getting durable cash that way. Okay, how much of your balance sheet are you willing to leverage? Consto's deal with Google was a direct signal that, you know, which is a great deal. I'm very supportive of it. But like, it was a direct signal that those up rates were not going to clear the market. They weren't going to clear the market. And so they needed an offtake to do it. But that's true for all of these technologies. Right, right, exactly, exactly.

48:20But if you are an industry that is 90 % merchant and market, that's what your stock is going to be down. I mean, prices are low in Texas. The cap in PJM is lower than it would need to be for a lot of the IPPs to develop anything new. We have to separate some of this stuff, right? Like, I think if you're talking about new assets, right? The IPPs, broadly speaking, were started by, let's say, AES back in the 80s, right? And they were using PURPA to bring on technologies. Yes. Like if you're building new natural gas right now, new nuclear up rates, like none of those things pencil without a long-term off-tick agreement from a hyperscaler that's guaranteeing you a return on investment at a price that pencils, right?

49:10So I think that makes total sense. That's the story, right? I don't think there's anything particularly interesting. It's not the whole story, right? So then if you look at Texas, I'd say that, I mean, you tell me, but I don't think that the vast majority of batteries were deployed by the traditional IPPs. No. I think there were a lot of new companies that had a new business model with new metrics around. Well, I think the business model was, I think the business model was there was a six-year window to capitalize on. And if you look at returns in ERCOT for storage, it's decreasing, right? Because essentially it's going to run out of its ability to chase the margin from peak.

50:01And that's a natural occurrence with a technology like storage, unless you start pairing it and start integrating it and blending it in different ways. But no, that's absolutely right. And so prices are down and prices are soft. The other thing, though, in ERCOT and PJM is that it's interesting. I was actually talking about this with a friend the other day, which is that PJM is looking at ERCOT and going, man, that's the way we should have done it. There's no capacity market there. The capacity market is what's killing us. And then ERCOT's looking at PJM and would never admit this. But there's a number of entities within ERCOT are going like, without a capacity signal, we're going to erode plants.

50:43like power plants are going to go offline, right? If prices continue to drop, that's just economics, right? And so there's this interesting interplay between the two. Neither of them, I think, have it right. And I think the truth is, and Jigar, you've said it a million times, it is time to have a very different view of what market structures need to look like moving forward. And I don't think there is a perfect market out there. And I think that, I will say it now, but I think there will be legislation in Texas next year that asks this, like, is the market today, you know, what we need going forward?

51:21And I'm hopeful that there are people with interesting views. All right. So let's speculate to end here. What are your wildcards going forward? So I think we can see data center resistance as a wildcard. I don't think anybody two years ago saw just how powerful the resistance would become. Right now, a lot of people are sitting here freaking out about the cybersecurity threats of agents. Banks now have agents swimming around in their systems making transactions. They don't know which ones are malicious. You have people who don't know much about hacking now able to use open weight models to send teams of hackers out.

51:58You know, I don't know how this is going to affect markets, but you can see a world in which AI companies like take a hit if there's this massive cyber event that wreaks havoc on like the financial system. So this has like downstream consequences. I'm kind of curious about what's in the back of your mind. What are the crazy things that could happen that actually might not be that crazy at all? Jigger buys a tweet vest. That's the craziest thing. Yes. A buckaroo jacket. A buckaroo jacket. A buckaroo jacket. You go. I'm staying away from the cowboy boots. You go. Like if you think of all the wild scenarios that people are worried about right now, do any of them feel like they are material enough?

52:35Here's the truth on some of this. Like this whole like agent thing or – I actually – and I will leave my personal opinions out of this. I actually think what you will see happen if something like that happens is the narrative that the only thing that can tackle AI terrorism is AI. Ah, so it makes the AI labs more powerful? Yes. And concentrated? Yes. Yeah, I buy that. So I don't know that that does anything to, I mean, it does more for political unrest. I think the wild card is going to be the narrative around China being months behind us goes away. And they're no longer months. They are ahead of us.

53:16Yeah. Yeah. And then the question becomes, well, do you need to host all this infrastructure to benefit from the integration into the economy? And I think that is not the wild card. I think that is the card that plays out within the next year, year and a half. Yeah. And at some point, the systems are so powerful, like being months behind, does it really even matter? Like that they're going to be so capable. Right. Or there's just so much differentiation and optionality in which type of framework or large language model you choose. Yeah. Yeah. All right, Jigar, what's your wild scenario? I mean, I think I go back to Carolyn's point on politics, right?

53:56I mean, part of the reason why the markets are so uneasy is because they don't understand who the sheriff is in town, right? So whether it's on the AI side or whether it's on all of these CFTC oil trades that didn't get prosecuted. I mean, today, people no longer believe that Brent, the oil price at Brent actually represents the cost of oil. Just think about what that means. When you have an actual metric that you're basing billions of dollars of contracts against, and you're like, I don't even know what that number means anymore, right? And so when you think about all of these things, it leads you to this populist approach, which I don't think people have fathomed what the pathway is to AOC becoming president.

54:51Well, it's not even AOC. I mean, like, if you have Vance and Warren and AOC sort of all saying the same thing, like, what does that mean, right? And I don't know. I do think a lot of the moratorium concerns are really more about a pause because I think governors are getting wise to the fact like, oh, this is a negotiation. This is more than just maybe tax. This is more like, what do I want out of this? I mean, this is certainly what Jennifer Granholm has been saying. But I would suggest to you it's a little bit different than that. I hear you. But I think this is more about, you know, do we need large data centers?

55:40Yeah, that's my thing on the, like, is it worth it? Is the infrastructure worth it? Right. I mean, the companies are saying, yes, they do, right? But the companies have so many perimeters. Right, but these models are so much bigger. There are so many parameters. They're not. Yes, they are. They're not. Oh, my God. Yes, they are. Epoch AI has debunked it and said basically that because all of the data is now behind anti-fetching approaches, they're never going to get to the weighted models that they need to use four gigawatts of compute. The current models that they're training right now still are less than one gigawatt.

56:19We're going to have to pause on that one and hold. I will, because I don't necessarily agree with that. But I think the question is still, can you become a leader in the next version of the global economy, integrating AI without hosting all the damn data centers? And I think a year ago, we told everyone, you can't. And I just don't know if that's true. Well, but you said something differently earlier, Carolyn, which I think is worth talking about, which is that— We're still talking? All right. That ultimately, this is about integration of the tool. Right. Right? It's really like what Red Hat did to Linux, right?

57:09Linux was powerful, but no one knew how to use it, and Red Hat figured out how to make it usable for people, right? And so, I mean, yes, the models matter, but what matters more is this layer where people can help train people around how to really unlock productivity. And to me, that layer of value creation doesn't require 1 ,000 megawatt data centers. And the reason it matters to me is, just to be clear, is not about whether I win this argument. It's about if you're a populist, right, and you have a building that needs a million dollars worth of upgrades, putting a 500 kilowatt data center in the basement of that building and getting them to pay for the million dollars of upgrades is a pretty easy trade.

57:59And I think you're going to see that all day long. Okay, so what you're really arguing is that it's all going to happen. It's just going to happen in a more edge infrastructure. Because that's where the trade comes, right? Because that's where the negotiation can be. That's where you can actually get something out. And the communities aren't getting anything out of the bigger ones. Yeah, we just talked about the delta between transmission and distribution. There are so many buildings right now that are office buildings that are 50 % empty. They have 3 ,000 amps of unused service, right? So you can put a data center there, and what the mayors want in return is that they meet their energy efficiency standards and the water efficiency standards, and they get upgraded, right?

58:45Because a lot of these buildings are in disrepair. I just think that there's a level of political efficiency here that people are not seeing because they're just so obsessed with going bigger and bigger and bigger. I totally agree, and I think this is where China has a leg up. They actually have a strategy to make AI useful throughout the economy, throughout provinces, so that local leaders figure out how to adopt it inside government, make it useful for people. So does the Middle East, frankly. Yeah, and I absolutely think that that is a huge advantage for China and for the Middle East. But I think you can – I think you still need a lot of these centralized data centers for the kind of training that we're talking about.

59:26Like, I don't know how many. I don't know the exact translation between the trillions and trillions and trillions of parameters and the amount of gigawatts you need. That, to me, is still a very open question. But, like, these models are getting absolutely enormous. And, like, there is going to be a need for these large megacampuses. We just can't deny that. Which we have 36 of them already, to be clear. Yeah. So are you suggesting we need another 36 of these large campuses? No, I mean, I don't really know, right? I don't know. But you should know because it's destroying the stock market. Well, if Stephen knew, he would not be hosting this podcast.

1:00:03Yeah, exactly. Right, right. No, but I'm just saying the reason— I'd be an operations officer at OpenAI or something. No, you would— Well, no, but there are a lot of operations officers in OpenAI, and they don't get listened to either, right? Because I've talked to many of them, and they agree that inference can be small. The reason I bring this up, Stephen, is not to be pedantic about it, but just because, like, the fact that this is— whatever it is, like, you know, a trillion dollars of infrastructure per year, and no one has the answers to this most basic question, right, like, means that, like, people are investing capital without understanding very basic things that they should know.

1:00:40I just really think that investment and developers underestimated how hard it is to build large centralized power plants. And everything goes from there. Everything just goes from there. And whether they pivot, and maybe they should, or whether they just lose a ton of money beating their head against the wall, we'll see. But I think at the end of the day, it was just people thought that if they had a contract for turbines, then the turbines would get built. That is such a good place to close it. And I think that is what is driving this market correction. People are figuring out just how difficult this stuff is.

1:01:17So well said, a fun conversation. Caroline Golan, so good to see you. Always a treat. Thank you, Stephen. Jigar, great to see you. Your sweater just made my day, made me feel cozy New England. Well, you know, it is a fantastic fall.

1:01:40Good to see you both. Such a joy seeing you. Open Circuit is produced by Latitude Media. The show is edited by me, Sean Marquand, and Anne Bailey provide production support. You can find all of our episodes anywhere you get your podcasts, Apple, Spotify, elsewhere. Transcripts are at LatitudeMedia.com. And while you're there, check out our newsletters. We're covering all the stuff that we talk about on this show. And of course, if you like to watch podcasts, go to Latitude Media's YouTube channel and you can subscribe and see Open Circuit and Catalyst. And we hope to see you there. Thanks so much for being here.

1:02:15I'm Stephen Lacey. We'll catch you next week.

1:02:20Thank you.

From the publisher

This was supposed to be the year when clean energy rode the AI wave onto Wall Street. Instead, the pipeline for energy IPOs is dwindling. What happened?

A combination of high interest rates, uncertain AI revenue growth, investor concerns over capital expenditures, and local friction slowing projects are all putting pressure on AI companies — and the energy providers serving them.

Companies that planned to go public this year — Holtec, The Nuclear Company, SB Energy, and Form Energy — have all shelved their plans. This year’s breakout geothermal listing, Fervo, has seen its stock price drop 70% since May. And IPPs have taken big hits to their valuations.

This week, we dig into what the uneasy market means for power development.

We’ll look at shifting market conditions for the AI trade, the reasons for delayed IPOs, alternative pathways for exits, and who may come out ahead. We’ll end with a look at some “wild cards” that may shift the picture, including China’s AI strategy, the role of distributed data centers, and power pricing.

Open Circuit is brought to you by EnergyHub. EnergyHub works with more than 230 utilities to coordinate over 2.6 million DERs and more than 3.6 gigawatts of dispatchable flexibility through a single platform designed to perform when it counts most. See what that looks like at EnergyHub.com. 

Open Circuit is brought to you by Giving Green. Giving Green researches the climate nonprofits best positioned for the next big climate win, and sends 100% of every dollar donated to the Giving Green Fund to them. Make your first gift before 2027, and it’s matched up to $500. Go to GivingGreen.earth/Circuit or select Open Circuit at checkout.

Open Circuit is brought to you by Everyday Electric. Everyday Electric simplifies savings at home, helping support a more reliable, affordable grid. Operating the country’s largest residential VPP, it coordinates 6+ GW of capacity across connected products. Learn more at everydayelectric.com

More from Open Circuit

All episodes