

Whether “AI swarms” and fast-moving cyber vulnerabilities (“Black October”) could disrupt critical infrastructure and the power grid, plus how energy affordability and data centers are shaping U.S. elections.
Jonathan Monken, senior partner at Converge Strategies; former senior director of system resilience at PJM; specializes in energy resilience for utilities, the military, and large commercial customers; 25-year Army career with combat deployments and prior cyber operations. Other hosts: Stephen Lacey (Latitude Media) and Caroline Golan (NRG), plus Jigar Shah (discussing energy politics).
The risk is “real and significantly elevated,” with a dangerous window because AI can identify vulnerabilities faster than patches can be developed (example: vulnerability found 4 days before patch). Grid risk concentrates on “edges” (small utilities) and shared vulnerabilities exploited at scale. “Fortress” (90-day base isolation) isn’t proof of imminent grid collapse; it’s a resilience mentality, but implementation is hard due to interconnected dependencies. Data centers may become a major near-term grid stressor.
PHP vulnerability affecting ~70% of websites; Tampa water system hack; U.S. military planning for 90 days of blackouts; Russia/Iran/Ukraine energy targeting; Pentagon “Fortress” initiative; VPP savings discussion (Brattle Group).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Conversation about societal collapse fears and prepping for disruptions.
“I'm the executive editor at Latitude Media.”
Exploration of the risks associated with AI and its implications for the power grid.
“And the algorithm has somehow hooked me and it's a very anxiety-inducing place to be.”
Learn how AI is changing the cybersecurity landscape and increasing vulnerability.
“which is what we've done now is we've lowered the barrier to entry dramatically to bring enhanced cyber capabilities to that offensive capability against critical infrastructure.”
Discover the implications of unpatched software and vulnerabilities in critical systems.
“Like, do you think that we're in a time period of particularly high vulnerability?”
Explore the need for better planning and coordination in the face of new threats.
“certainly you have the scale issue when you talk about big companies.”
Understand the difficulties in responding to large-scale cyber attacks and infrastructure failures.
“So I think you failed at the assignment.”
Explore the challenges of responding to large-scale infrastructure failures.
“Because I'm not – I'll scare you in this regard.”
Delve into the military's Fortress plan and its implications for national security.
“to isolate bases in the event of a civilian power grid collapse.”
Discuss the risks posed by data centers to critical infrastructure and the grid.
“It's not integrated as part of IRPs that are being submitted by utilities.”
Analyze whether the industry is prepared to meet new threats to the grid.
“We've talked about rogue agents attacking the bulk power system.”
Exploring how energy costs are affecting political narratives and voter concerns.
“All 36 governors running for election this fall are beefing up on who's to blame for higher electricity costs.”
Discussing the need for local energy policies and the role of decarbonization.
“Well, it's hard to, I mean, I think Trump is still trying very hard to explain our engagement in South America, in Central America, in the Middle East, in Greenland as an energy dominant narrative.”
Examining the struggles of governors and lawmakers in managing energy issues.
“It's not just batteries, but it's a big part of it.”
Analyzing public sentiment regarding power grid management and accountability.
“So if we don't pass permitting reform, it will all be blamed on the electric utilities.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Open Circuit, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:02Latitude Media, covering the new frontiers of the energy transition. So, Caroline, you're the only person who has shown up dressed up for Halloween. This episode is going to come out after Halloween. What are you talking about? What? I'm not dressed up. This is the latest trendy look, but I'm a walrus every year. And so I will have a Tito wig with my walrus costume on. You're one of the lazy ones who wears the same costume every year. I know. That's lazy? That's what you call frugal. Every year as a family, we go, you know, as a theme. We've done Lord of the Rings. We've done Wizard of Oz. We've done Alice in Wonderland.
0:46We've done Greek Gods. When AI swarms bring down society and we're all stuck in our homes, you're going to have plenty of costumes to play with. Maybe you can be like a traveling troop to go to collapsed town after collapsed town to give people some entertainment. Yeah. Life is better with a polyester wig on your head.
1:09The prepping vibes are very high right now. Spend any amount of time on X and you'll be inundated with warnings about coming societal collapse driven by the collapse of the grid and list upon list of how to prepare. And if you're paying any attention to the news, there's a reason people are anxious. The U.S. military is preparing for at least 90 days of blackouts of the civilian power grid. Governments around the world are telling people to prepare for multiple days of disruption. And cybersecurity experts are warning about the flood of malicious AI bots that could compromise the fabric of the internet.
1:41Some security experts are calling the AI threat Black October. It's pretty clear that we're at an inflection point for cybersecurity. So how worried should we actually be? And how worried should we be about the power grid? This week, we're joined by someone who's designed resilience and cybersecurity protocols for power markets, and he's going to help us understand where the grid is vulnerable and how seriously we should take all this prepping advice. Then a reflection on the most energy-centric election in modern history. What does it tell us about how energy, climate, and data centers will play into the presidential election?
2:13That's right here on Open Circuit from Latitude Media.
2:23Open Circuit is brought to you by Everyday Electric, formerly known as Renew Home. Utilities are investing$1.5 trillion in the grid over the next three years to meet soaring demand. And Americans are asking, how will it benefit me? Growth and demand can be a great thing for actually reducing rates for everyone, but only if the system becomes more efficient. Ben Brown is the CEO of Everyday Electric. With six gigawatts of flexible capacity, Everyday Electric empowers customers to take part in that transition and helps the grid grow responsibly. So yes, you need to build infrastructure, but you have to increase utilization of the system we have.
3:00We have to find ways in which to drive savings, both to households that are part of virtual power plants, because if you do that at scale, it actually drives savings for everyone. From batteries to thermostats to electric vehicles, homes around the country already have the energy products that could save them money while providing more capacity to the grid. Since its founding, Everyday Electric has been working toward a more affordable, more reliable system for everyone. Now that we are reaching scale, there's just these amazing moments in time that we can unlock 50 megawatts or 100 megawatts of resource across every major climate region, every major utility.
3:35Later in the show, Ben explains how VPPs can meet utility growth while driving down rates for everyone. To learn more, visit everydayelectric.com. Giving Tuesday is December 1st. Time to put climate giving on your year-end checklist and apply the same due diligence you would with any investment. That's what Giving Green does. Giving Green researches the strategies and non-profits best positioned to unlock the next big climate breakthrough and sends 100 % of every dollar donated to the Giving Green Fund directly to them. Maximize your impact per dollar. No cuts or guesswork. Make your first gift before 2027, and it's matched up to$1 ,000.
4:13Go to givinggreen.earth. Open Circuit is brought to you by Energy Hub. Energy Hub's DERMs platform gives utilities flexible capacity they can stake their grid planning on, coordinating batteries, EVs, thermostats, and commercial and industrial sites through a single system. Utilities unlock a partner ecosystem that covers more than 90 % of connected DERs in the market and integrates seamlessly into existing infrastructure. The scale is proven. More than 230 utilities across North America trust Energy Hub to manage over 3.5 gigawatts of flexible capacity. Learn more at energyhub.com.
4:55Welcome to the show. I'm Stephen Lacey. I'm the executive editor at Latitude Media. Caroline Golan is the chief growth and policy officer at NRG and wearing the most wonderful hat. you've dressed up. Yeah. I didn't realize we were doing this but I'm delighted to see you. Y 'all are lame. That's all. I thought you were Ted Lasso.
5:18If you had told us we could have coordinated. I mean, but part of it is like channeling who you really are at this time, you know? And her reminding us how much better she is. Yeah. There's also that. Just whenever I can. Do you have your 72-hour stockpile of food and supplies, Caroline? Yeah. I got chickens. I got garden beds. I probably don't have all the other things that we don't think about, you know, that, like, scared us in COVID. We should make a list. We should release a list after this to our listeners. I've got it all. Hand sanitizer, hand crank radio, solar-powered flashlights, tons of toilet paper and paper towels.
6:02I've got it all. candles. You just use candles. I've got tons of candles. Yeah. What about you, Jigger? I mean, I have been going to 25 years of solar conferences. You don't think I have all this stuff? I have a solar-powered hand crank radio. I have a solar - powered hand crank flashlight. I have every single solar-powered gadget and gizmo someone could possibly have. Prepper swag. You got the pepper swag. I want to make sure that you have your custom Nikes and Hawaiian shirts in that prepping kit. I do. I do. I do. It is like, I am ready to host a house full of unprepared people. So why are we talking about all this prepping?
6:54Well, let's bring in our guest for more. There are a bunch of storylines coming together at once, and it's freaking people out. So over the last month or so, we've seen a rapid increase in cyber attacks from swarms of AI agents. And the pace of events is picking up and it's leading some to call it Black October. More and more cybersecurity experts are warning that AI is getting so good, it is far outpacing our ability to find and fix security flaws. And they're telling people, make preparations for real world disruptions. This story is colliding with a couple of others. In late September, the Pentagon unveiled its fortress initiative to prepare bases for 90 days of blackouts on the civilian power grid.
7:35And numerous countries in the last few weeks, all roughly at the same time, have encouraged citizens to prepare for multiple days of outages to basic services. So some of this is guidance that governments have been saying for a long time. But the convergence of these stories is creating a swirl of conspiracy theories that we are on the verge of catastrophe. And if you spend any time on X, you'll be flooded with prepping lists and think pieces on survival skills. And the algorithm has somehow hooked me and it's a very anxiety-inducing place to be. So how do we actually distinguish the real threats to critical infrastructure and more specifically, the power grid?
8:15And we have with us Jonathan Monken. He is gonna help us sort through it. He's a senior partner at Converge Strategies. He's the former senior director of system resilience at PJM. And he specializes in energy resilience for utilities, the military, and large commercial customers. Jonathan, welcome. Thanks so much for being here. Stephen, thanks so much for having me. Looking forward to the chat. So we need to start with the question we've all been ruminating on here is, do you have a prepping strategy? Well, absolutely. I invested heavily in beef jerky early, so I should be fine. I think I'm going to be able to survive almost indefinitely, really.
8:49So honestly, it's funny. I used to be the director of the Illinois Emergency Management Agency, so I'm an emergency manager by trade. and prep was always part of the job. It's just foundational to what I do just in general. And so I have an emergency kit at home. I have 72 hours worth of supplies. That's just something that's just kind of part of what I've always done. But interestingly enough, even when I designed my house, I put in a 17 kilowatt solar system with a full battery backup for the full house just because I knew that it's something that is, you know, there's economics to it. It's clean energy for the house, but it's also something that the house could run independent of the grid for 24 hours or longer if it had to, because I think preparedness is just one of those things that's foundational to where hopefully people go when they, you know, understand what the potential risks are.
9:38I mean, if you love your family, Jonathan, you'll get a 17 kilowatt system with a full home backup. Thank you. Exactly. That's what love really means. So Jigar finally said the quiet part out loud, and now my kids understand how much I value them. What do you think is going on here with so many governments now issuing these 72-hour preparedness notices? There's a bunch of stories coming together at once, and I want to sort through each of them individually. But why now? Why are we getting these alerts from so many governments? Definitely part of this is just, I would frankly say, coincidence about the timing of when some of these comments come out.
10:15I mean, anybody that's working government now, Jigar, you can disagree with me. But if you didn't know this, government policy moves slowly. So a lot of times, like, these messages are being developed over time. You know, they're trying to reinforce some of these things. But I also think it's worth acknowledging the fact that these kind of timelines that are being set, like, what does 72 hours mean? Why are people choosing these specific time horizons? It's really just an understanding of you need to – the government needs to buy 72 hours of time so that they don't have to replicate or replace these critical infrastructure systems that are sustaining basic life functions.
10:51So whether you're talking about electricity or water, wastewater, communications, they need you to be able to sustain yourself for as long as possible so that they can actually set up a proper response. So I think we're going to continue to see this type of message just in general, but I also think that there's just a more open acknowledgement of the degree to which people are generally at risk when we look at these types of power disruptions or severe weather events and the types of things that governments understand that they have a responsibility for. I feel like it's worse than that, though, Jonathan.
11:22Like, I think that when you think about what's happening with Ukraine and Russia, right, and the Ukrainians going after a bot farm in Russia, and, you know, what's happening between the U.S. and Israel and Iran, there really is real kinetic warfare happening in the world. And there really is a desire by different kinetic players to actually disrupt infrastructure in each other's countries. Energy specifically, yeah. Yeah, and so I do think that people are like, hey, the probability of this happening has gone up a little bit. Yep. And this is a good time to remind people that, you know, we've always been asking you to be safe.
12:07but be extra safe this time around because it's actually more likely to occur. Well, it's also new threats, right? And in that new sort of world of AI warfare, are we up to speed yet in that defense or are they going to take a few hiccups? No joke, I was in a meeting with lawyers and they were talking about bots against bots and my head just sort of exploded and I wanted it to be 1995 again. I think that's a good transition into one of the questions I have for Jonathan, which is thinking about what this Black October means, right? This is a loose label for all these cybersecurity incidents related to AI.
12:49I'm curious about how you read the increasing security vulnerabilities and the ability for hackers, pretty unsophisticated hackers, to use swarms of AI to perhaps penetrate physical systems. Like, how are you thinking about this moment? Yeah, I think the risk is very real and it is significantly elevated. So I think Caroline's term was correct. Like, are we up to speed on this? I think is the right word. And then also to Jigar's point, like the increasing attacks that are focused on critical infrastructure, some of them are kinetic in nature, and that includes the United States targeting energy infrastructure and Iran.
13:25Iran targeting a lot of critical infrastructure, specifically energy in the Middle East, and then certainly Russia's ongoing focus on the bulk power system within Ukraine. These are all examples of things where we're just in a different era right now, where critical infrastructure in that regard used to be generally off the table, just in terms of what modern workers look like. It's illegal to go after critical infrastructure. Absolutely, without a doubt it is. And I think the gray space has been on the cyber side of things where you're not seeing bombs and missiles hit grid infrastructure because it's more of a clandestine function.
13:59And Steven, your question I think is very appropriate, which is what we've done now is we've lowered the barrier to entry dramatically to bring enhanced cyber capabilities to that offensive capability against critical infrastructure. It used to be that there were only a handful of nation state actors in the world that had the scale and sophistication, the manpower to actually focus on critical infrastructure. So Russia, Iran, and China were really the only countries that had enough people to spend enough time to focus on critical infrastructure. Now, you really don't have to be that sophisticated.
14:35You can use off-the-shelf tools from an AI standpoint and do what it used to take an entire cyber brigade to be able to execute, which is frankly not great. I think it totally changes the risk environment. It's like nuclear deterrence again, except AI. Yeah, and the bots versus bots conversation is really complicated for a number of reasons, not the least of which is, you know, there's a lot of open source AI capability that's there that is our AI better than your AI? Is it working faster than your AI is? Are we focusing it in the right places? There's a lot of questions about the sophistication of both the user and the tool, and you have to have the combination of the two in order to be successful.
15:16I want to hang on the bots on bots question for a second because my understanding is that we're in a pretty vulnerable place and that huge swaths of the internet and the software that guides companies, etc. are in its human made software with lots of security vulnerabilities that have never been uncovered. And suddenly we have these AI swarms that are relentless and confined vulnerabilities that have never been uncovered. And we just saw this recently with the discovery of a gap in PHP software, which guides like 70 % of websites on the internet. And that folks are worried that there's this time period, like a year or so, when our AI defenses are not good enough or that we have this legacy human crafted software internet that like is vulnerable to the offensive AI hackers.
16:13Like, do you think that we're in a time period of particularly high vulnerability? Yeah, I mean, I think before the defensive tools catch up to the degree that they need to, we're in a very, very dangerous window in that regard of the pacing at which vulnerabilities are both discovered and then addressed and patched. we've frankly gotten used to something that's typically measured in weeks or longer when we say, okay, there's a slower pace to vulnerability assessments that are happening or vulnerabilities that are being actively hunted by humans. And then the timeline of when a company develops a patch for an identified vulnerability, pushes it out to their customers, those customers go through their sandboxing and testing, and then they ultimately put the security patch out there.
16:57That's a timeline typically of weeks. So the difference now is if the vulnerabilities can be identified in real time, if it's happening immediately. And there was an example in Black October of the vulnerability was identified four days before the patch could even be developed and then sent out. And you've got this four-day window now where you say, this is an open door. This is frankly just an open door. if it's going to be happening at that pace, the patches necessarily can't be developed as quickly as the vulnerabilities can be identified. It's like anything else. It's a lot harder to build the patch than it is to just poke a hole in something and figure out that there's a gap there.
17:36I'm still like reeling from the fact that Black October doesn't mean I get cheaper stuff. It might. I mean, it could. It could. I'm pretty sure Amazon's doing that. So, I mean, part of what I'm trying to understand, Jonathan— You could buy this hat. Not really. This was not cheap.
17:56I know you, Caroline. Nothing you do is cheap. That's true. But, I mean, I guess what I'm trying to understand is that, like, as somebody who is a Luddite by nature, so all of this stuff happens, right? Like, these guys get disrupted, and those guys get disrupted, and Binance gets, like, hacked, and this guy gets hacked. Like, where does this all lead us? Like, it feels like it just leads us into a massive recession. Like, is that basically what happens? Like, I'm just trying to understand what I'm prepping for exactly. Like, give me the actual, like, what is it that I need to do in my list? Because the solar and battery storage I already got done.
18:39Like, that's working. And I am, like, laughing at everyone who doesn't have one. So, like, you know, everyone needs to get one. But, and then the water and that, I'm just trying to understand like which systems are going to get disrupted first, right? Like what does that negative consequence look like? Yeah. Great question. Yeah, I mean, yeah, I like the question for a number of reasons because I know that you like to identify which stocks to short early. So I'm trying to just get as much insight. I need to know what your top five stock picks are. Glad you understand why we do this podcast now.
19:14Right. I got the assignment. Don't worry. I got this locked in. So I think the biggest challenge is certainly you have the scale issue when you talk about big companies. So you talked about Amazon or you talked about, I mean, you could pick a large utility. You can talk about these companies. These are companies that have resources. But as you know, there are more than 3 ,000 electric utilities out there and they don't all have access financially or operationally or technically to the same tools. The same is certainly true when you talk about water utilities. in an example. If you think 3 ,000 is a lot for electricity, there's over 250 ,000 water utilities out there.
19:49And a lot of them are just very small scale players. When we talk about where the risk shows up on the grid, it's really at the edges. So when we talk about smaller utilities, less sophisticated tools, still have those vulnerabilities that haven't been patched. The PHP example was a vulnerability that was there for 20 years. So these vulnerabilities exist out there. It's just that you can scan so many more things simultaneously on all these edges of the system. So when we talk about what should you be most concerned with, I think really where we see the most concern is those kind of lower level sophistication, smaller scale systems, they're hiding and kind of hanging out on the edges of the larger system.
20:29And what that ultimately translates to is if you can really expose those vulnerabilities and then take advantage of them at scale, individually, it might not be a big deal. I'm sure you guys remember when like the Tampa water system was hacked like three years ago, very small scale. So it was handleable, if that's a word, you know, so you can kind of wrap your arms around it and you say this is like a finite footprint. Well, if you're talking about dozens or hundreds of utilities simultaneously because they have a shared vulnerability that can be exploited at scale, that's when you start getting into that threshold event of saying, well, it's not geographically isolated.
21:04It's not infrastructure specific. It's multiple companies in multiple geographic areas. And now what you're doing is you're immediately exceeding the collective ability to respond and sustain people that are having disruptions to those electric services, communication services, water services. That's the game right there. You've been doing this a long time. You've run a lot of different scenarios. You've developed emergency response and resiliency plans. When you think about the new threat of AI swarms, what is different? Are there new risks that are imminent? Like how should utilities be planning for this?
21:44Just explain like how different the threat is today versus, you know, in the past. Yeah, I mean, I think we have to treat this as a foundational shift in how we approach security. This is not like a, okay, well, this is an interesting intellectual problem that we can consider for a little while and we'll take our time and get there. There has to be a lot more intentionality about how we do it. There also needs to be much better public-private coordination when we talk about the ways in which the government is able to specifically support utilities and what they're doing from a cyber defense standpoint.
22:20I mean, there's certainly, you know, anytime you ask, you're like, oh, absolutely, we work very closely together and the government's a great partner. But we have to get way past the lip service stage of this. So there are not joint cyber defense capabilities that are mature enough to make sure that the tools that are necessary in order to handle this AI-enabled cyber attack vector, we're not set up for it the way that we need to be. So I think there has to be a much stronger consideration for government has access to AI tools, private sector has access to AI tools. What does the crossover look like and how are we being much more coordinated in making sure that we're more proactively addressing the speed at which these vulnerabilities are exposed and then the speed at which the actual patching is done so that we can address those vulnerabilities.
23:11So different era.
23:18Earlier, we introduced you to Ben Brown, CEO of Everyday Electric. Ben has been pioneering smart home technologies and virtual power plants for 20 years. With electricity prices rising fast, those flexible resources, solar, batteries, EV chargers, smart thermostats, are more important than ever before. It's really important to understand that, yes, we are in an energy affordability crisis, but I also think that because of that, we have so much energy and so much focus going into how we can dig ourselves out of this. And a new study from the Brattle Group backs this up. It finds that residential VPPs could cut expected electricity bill increases in half over five years.
23:55There's just a massive amount of value that can be brought to homes when you increase the efficiency of the system, the utilization of the resources on the system, and not just for people that are part of those virtual power plants, but their neighbors, the communities around them. That can mean$4 to$7 billion of savings per year for Americans. Everyday Electric already coordinates the largest residential VPP in the country, and it's working with device manufacturers to make participation effortless, unlocking more savings and more flexibility for the grid. It's really important to think about that cross-registration and think about that whole home energy fabric, being able to think about unlocking savings across every component of our home.
24:33Making electricity more affordable isn't just about what we build next. It's about getting more from what we've already built. Learn more at everydayelectric.com Giving Tuesday is December 1st. Time to put climate giving on your year-end checklist and apply the same due diligence you would with any investment. That's what Giving Green does. Giving Green researches the strategies and non-profits best positioned to unlock the next climate breakthrough. Climate impact is difficult to quantify, but Giving Green's research suggests a donation to one of their top climate non-profits is roughly 10 times more effective than a high-quality carbon offset.
25:09And the Giving Green Fund sends 100 % of every dollar straight to them. Maximized impact per dollar. No cuts or guesswork. Make your first gift before 2027, and it's matched up to$1 ,000. Go to givinggreen.earth slash circuit to claim it. Utilities don't just hope flexible capacity performs. They need to be able to stake grid planning on it day in, day out. Energy Hub's DERM's platform is trained on over a decade of real event data from 2.6 million connected DERs. That means utilities can forecast available capacity with accuracy, optimize dispatch across any DER type or ownership model, and maintain visibility across their entire system.
25:50The platform integrates across more than 80 OEM and aggregator partners, giving utilities the reach they need as markets and regulations change. Consistent, verifiable, affordable. Energy Hub is the flexibility platform for the modern grid. Learn more at energyhub.com.
26:13So I think you failed at the assignment. Me or? Tomorrow is Halloween. At shorting the stock? That's the assignment. I mean, tomorrow is Halloween and I am not scared at all. Yeah. And so I think that, like, you need to do a better job of scaring the crap out of our listeners. And so, like, Tom Fanning, like, to be clear, left Southern Company and joined an organization in D.C. And his whole thing was that, like, these cyber attacks, he thinks, can shut down the entire country. and that we need a Black Start manual on how to restart the economy, right? So his nonprofit was like, we need to figure out how to restart the entire economy, right, with like this Black Start capability.
27:04I got kind of scared after talking to Tom Fanning. Yeah, yeah. You're like, you're not scared. Can I add one other thing here? We don't have enough first responders to deal with the climate events that are going to come our way in this country, right? So the way we've always dealt with this is, okay, something's blown up, something's bad. National Guard goes in. Maybe you get power back. Maybe the water gets back. But we have these sort of reserve, literally, troops that come in. We don't have enough for that for even climate. So if you layer on top of this, we're just banking on the fact that there's going to be some really smart software engineers that are going to figure this out.
27:50I guess my question is, scare me in, how do you fix it in real time? You're like, 72 hours. Who's actually fixing it in those 72 hours? Because I'm not – I'll scare you in this regard. Yeah. Okay, yeah, because I am actually freaked out, and I'm just curious how freaked out you are. Yeah. All I can tell, so I spent, I just finished a 24-year career in the Army. I did eight years as domestic operations officer in the National Guard, so all disaster response. And the last 13 years as a cyber operations officer. Thank you. Thank you for your service. You're welcome. There we go. You're welcome. Let's start with that.
28:26Okay. So we can't fix it. we are not capable in that 72 hours of actually fixing the problem of the scale that we're describing. So doing complex catastrophe analysis and exercise design. So like Jigar, I do grid X, right? And I was in the room with Tom Fanning when he was talking about restarting the economy in the context of that exercise. And the challenge here is we are not capable of handling an event to that scale full stop. We can't. So what we had to plan for when we talk about complex catastrophic planning is what we call a mass migration event. If you disrupt critical infrastructure systems to the degree that we're describing right now, it's a mass migration event because there are insufficient resources, even in the aggregate, National Guard, reserves, government responders.
29:20I mean, FEMA's fundamentally gutted right now. If you talk about what we have available to replace, even on a temporary basis, these infrastructure systems, it's not possible. It's a mass migration event. So we're in a can't fail environment right now. I think what we're seeing in the deployment of this technology is the potential for being able to disrupt at a scale that exceeds what our threshold is to respond to it. Like that's the space that we're playing in right now is the potential is too high and we don't have what we need in order to sustain ourselves. I really wanna ask you about this fortress plan.
29:58This is the military's preparation for 90 days to isolate bases in the event of a civilian power grid collapse. There are a lot of conspiracy theorists out there right now that are seizing on this. I mean, Dan Bongino, the former deputy director of the FBI, Glenn Beck, they're all out there saying that this is proof that the government expects imminent blackouts. I know this has been going on for a long time. What is Fortress? How long has it been in the works? And what does it really tell us about military preparedness? Yeah, I mean, Fortress, I think, is really a mentality that you're saying, you know, the military has to protect itself.
30:35And that's the only way that they're going to be able to make it through what comes next. So the idea that you're going to create, there's about 500 major military installations in the continental United States. And the idea of creating 500 islands that are independently functioning is, I think, the intent behind the program. I think the implementation of it is, frankly, impossible. It's kind of like, I would put it in the same category as how Jigar describes the idea of an off-grid data center. Like, that's just not a thing. You warm my heart, Jonathan. That's what I was thinking. That's exactly what I was thinking.
31:09See, exactly. And I think it fails to appreciate some really key variables here, which is you could light up the installation like a Christmas tree, but if the defense community is not energized, they're part of the mission capability of the installation. So, and also if you lose the other infrastructure systems that the base depends on, you're still not functional. And if you lose the defense industrial base at the next layer out that is providing the materials, the munitions, everything else that's necessary to make missions go, So you're just missing the picture. So the idea of creating 500 islands, which is really what Fortress is all about, it doesn't mean that you can't take preparatory activities on the base, like adding generation there, increasing the capability and sophistication of technical systems related to transmission and distribution on installations.
31:55Great. I think it's a great idea. I think trying to understand, though, the interconnected nature of these systems is what's being missed right now in this conversation. And Fortress came up as a very, very quickly, frankly. Like it's been a conversation within the department for years about bringing more generation on the base, about hardening infrastructure. The pace of action is, in my opinion, way too slow. Like we have to do a lot more in this area to try and sustain national defense capabilities because we're just not intentional about it. It's not part of grid planning. Straight up. It doesn't matter what utility you're talking about.
32:29It is not a formal part of grid planning. It's happening on an ad hoc basis, on a customer basis between the installation and the servicing utility. It's not integrated as part of transmission planning at any ISO and RTO. It's not integrated as part of IRPs that are being submitted by utilities. It's just not a formal part of the process. So there are ways to improve. But in this particular instance, 90 days as a threshold, the idea that a base could sustain itself with nothing else from the outside for 90 days is to say it's a tall order is a gross understatement. Like the idea of being able to - Stephen, can I just say that Jonathan is my favorite guest of all time and he needs to come on every month to make me look better.
33:17Oh, dear God. I don't know what you said, Jonathan, to get that reaction, but - I'm just saying the fact that he's saying that since the Obama administration, this has been policy, right? The fact that like every military base could actually generate its own power and figure out a way to be a little bit more resilient, etc. The utilities never took it seriously, never integrated it into their integrated resource plans, never thought, oh, this is an opportunity for us to test out new technology or do cool stuff. Like, is a cultural problem, right? And it took basically a meathead as the head of the Department of Defense just randomly announcing the Fortress Initiative for anyone to take this damn thing seriously.
34:03What the hell? It's a full circle of that. I can't believe it's happening now. Just to address this head on, just because there is so much chatter right now about what the military is preparing for with this fortress plan, this is not an indication that the military thinks the grid is going to collapse, right? I think so. I think it's an acknowledgement of the fact that it can, which honestly - But like imminently. Is the problem, yeah, I mean, I think I don't. Well. They could say that, but I mean, they can't implement what they're describing in a timeline that would align with, if they thought the grid was gonna fail tomorrow, if they genuinely believe that it was gonna fail tomorrow.
34:44This is, even if everybody, if the culture problem gets solved and we say we're actually gonna be intentional about it, we're in a decades long timeline of trying to implement what they're talking about if we don't fundamentally change how we plan infrastructure. We have to be able to do that. Wait, I have a doomsday bingo card order for you, okay? Oh, nice. Climate change, severe weather, rogue AI terrorist attack, massive data centers tripping the system and bringing down the grid. Which one happens first and which one should we actually be talking about politically? I think we'll probably get to the data center challenge very quickly.
35:27I think, let's put it this way. Number one, I would say rogue AI cyber attack. You're putting very deadly weapons in the hands of children is basically what's happening right now. People that don't have the intellectual capability to understand the implications of what they're doing and the human cost of executing that. I think second is the data center problem. And I say that because the Department of Defense has been the single largest rate-paying customer in the United States and actually in the world since World War II for the last 70 years. That will not be the case in the next 12 months.
36:01They won't even be in the top three anymore. Data center companies are going to have more aggregated IT and energy load than all of those military bases combined in the next 12 months. That impact on the grid cannot be ignored, and it will be felt soon. And then I think the climate component of it is going to continue to worsen, and I think that timeline is longer, which unfortunately means people are going to find excuses to continue to ignore it. We've talked about rogue agents attacking the bulk power system. Now we have this new part of the bulk power system, which is essentially being built out in real scale and in real time to service training, service compute, of which more and more of our greater economy is relying on.
36:49At what point do you just start targeting massive compute data centers? And does that become more disruptive in the longer term? You see what I'm saying? In the longer term? Absolutely. Because everyone's running their banking, they're doing their online travel. Everything is run by this. Wait, Carolyn, are you saying that we should be building only 20 megawatt and below? Okay, okay, yes. Digger's brilliant. We're all in it. Oh my God, so much winning. So much winning. But to your point, Carolyn, I just absolutely feel like a real serious threat. Yeah, how do you see that threat, Jonathan? Yeah, I mean, I think that's what we have to be very, very aware of.
37:35You can – look, data centers, they don't segment the IT load inside the facility based on the individual customer except in very unique circumstances. That's right. So, when you talk about an ability to affect multiple infrastructure systems simultaneously, you focus on that. So you don't even, I mean, even from an adversarial standpoint, they may not even know the full impact of if they do that, if they focus their attacks on that data center disruption, they basically just get to sit back and watch all the ripples on the pond and find out just how many things are going to be immediately affected by the loss of compute that is enabling so many of these different systems.
38:12The difference here is understanding that is a point of vulnerability that is not currently baked into how we understand critical infrastructure. Last question for you. Is the industry changing fast enough to meet this threat? I mean, I'm guessing not, but like, are you seeing an acceleration of preparation and planning in a way that leads you to believe that the industry, grid operators, utilities, et cetera, are really taking this new threat seriously? I think they're taking it seriously, and I don't think that they can move fast enough right now. I think we're in a window of time that I think you articulated well earlier of we have not caught up from a defensive standpoint to try and fully address what we're seeing in terms of new offensive capabilities.
38:58We're unfortunately in like that between zone that we have not been able to understand how that needs our defensive capabilities need to be leveraged to address this threat. We're not there yet. And we I think it's always the defender that's at the disadvantage. It takes more time to develop the mitigation than it does to develop the vulnerability. And so we're in that window. I would say that the last question I have is, if I have a frozen Connie's pizza in the freezer with Gio De Niro peppers, would that cause you and your family to want to bunker at my house? Any chance to get close to Chicago deep dish pizza, I will come to your house immediately under any circumstances.
39:39Okay, to be clear, I have a dozen chickens, seven garden beds, and of like three solar-powered freezers stocked full of stuff. I love where we're at right now. I've got options. That's what I need. I need redundancy. Thank you both. I also have four children you have to deal with, though. Okay, now I'm kind of leaning on Jigar right now. That's a workforce, Caroline. That's a workforce. Well, whoever Jonathan and his family decides to hunker down with, you are definitely coming back on the podcast. It's a time of high anxiety, and I really appreciate you walking us through this. So thank you so much.
40:14It's my pleasure. Thanks so much for having me. I enjoyed it. Jonathan Monken is a senior partner at Converge Strategies. He has a 25-year career in the Army. He's had multiple combat deployments. And before joining Converge Strategies, he was the senior director of system resilience at PJM. What a good conversation. We'll catch you later, Jonathan. Sounds great. All right, let's turn to the election. We are recording this a couple days before the midterms, and it will come out just as Americans head to the polls. And of course, gasoline, diesel, power prices, data centers were all top issues in the year leading up to the elections.
40:52High energy prices have historically been a Republican weapon, but this time Democrats have largely controlled the message. And people are just mad about high costs and the backlash is so severe that Nate Silver is calling it the possible end of the Trump era if the outcome predicted by the polls comes to pass. So if Dems win in red states, I think we can make a case that energy was one of the most important factors that derailed the president's coalition. And at the same time, it was a massive turning point for how we don't talk about climate, for how Democrats think about messaging on climate, and mostly by just not talking about it at all.
41:33So I guess first question for you, do you agree with the premise that this is the most energy-centric election in the U.S.? Obviously, we have the 1980— Since the Iran contract, yeah, probably. The 1980 presidential election when Reagan beat Jimmy Carter after the oil shocks, that was a big one. But where do you guys think this stacks up? Jigar? I mean, we have an entire series on Energy Empire called Energy on the Ballot. So I think you know exactly where I sit here. I mean, I have found it amazing. All 36 governors running for election this fall are beefing up on who's to blame for higher electricity costs.
42:13I think the big difference, though, is that gasoline has been on the ballot before. Yeah, for sure. But electricity bills have almost never been on the ballot, and they are most firmly on the ballot this fall. Absolutely. Yeah, it's interesting to me how disproportionate energy is compared to just the overall rising cost of the economy on many critical goods. And you think about the rising cost of groceries, right? I mean, it's insane how the cost of groceries compared to where it was, you know, three or four years ago. Rising costs of health care, you know, rising costs of other durable goods.
42:52I mean, everything has gone up. And we all know the reasons why it's gone up, but everything has gone up. It's interesting how much more electricity gets a play. Because I don't think proportionally electricity has gone up as much as some of these other sort of what we would see like critical public goods. but it's getting the biggest vitriol. And I think we've talked about that before. It's because, you know, it's driven by this like spooky AI actor that, you know, we can't wrap our hands around. But that's the most interesting part to me is the disproportion there, but absolutely striving it.
43:31So as affordability took over, it feels like energy dominance stopped working as a political message. Do you think that that's the case? Any thoughts? Well, it's hard to, I mean, I think Trump is still trying very hard to explain our engagement in South America, in Central America, in the Middle East, in Greenland as an energy dominant narrative. I just don't know how well it's working. It doesn't seem to be working. It doesn't seem to be working. So I was looking at a bunch of polling data, and it was pretty shocking that only 10 % of Americans have even heard of energy dominance. So it's not even a term that most American voters has heard.
44:23And what most American voters care about is local. Resilience, local, how do I protect my family? How do I protect my community? How do I protect my county? And so when you look at like Spanberger in Virginia has been talking about how the state becomes more self-reliant because, you know, Virginia is the worst run state in the country in terms of electricity. They import more electricity than any other state in the country. And that message has resonated way more than even like energy dominance, decarbonization, any of that stuff. It's really about local. Do you think voters should trust Dems on this?
45:03Like, are they going to, what do they need to do to not screw this up if they are going to come in? And I'm talking about both the federal level and the state level. Like, how do they not screw this up? What are the real energy affordability priorities that they need to tackle right away? I mean, Jigar has said it a million times, but like, we have to incentivize distribution level generation. We have to incentivize a market that values that. We have to create policies that put resilience in the hands of homeowners. And we have to free up the bulk power system. I mean, we know how to do it. It's not just storage, even though, Jigar, go ahead and say it.
45:48Batteries. Okay, there you go. Batteries, batteries, batteries. Is this like Beetlejuice? Batteries, batteries, batteries. It's not just batteries, but it's a big part of it. And I actually, what I find interesting is that there is a lot of rhetoric and there is a lot of questioning about whether, you know, moratoriums or posturing will just sort of die out after the midterms, right? Like this is sort of just a political jockeying stick. I actually don't think that it will. I think that some of the moratoriums are really just like a pause and they're trying to figure things out and that will probably alleviate.
46:28But I do generally think that there are a lot of governors out there who are looking for the authority to solve these problems. And some are overstepping their historical authority. And, you know, and this is this is the political environment by which overstepping your political authority like wins you a gold star. Right. And so I think that there I think that the Dems are going to have to if they win. but I think that they actually want to this time and and to be fair I think the Republicans want to as well like I don't think that it's just the Democrats that want to fix this problem I think both sides desperately want to fix this problem and and I actually don't even see a moral authority on either side in this I think they both feel very stuck between you know an antiquated system from a, you know, administration that hasn't keyed in with rural America well enough.
47:35And the realities of this AI, like, monster load growth. Yeah, I think that Carolyn's exactly right, which is that this is— Wait, one more time. One more time. Oh, wait. Carolyn's exactly right. There you go. This is really about change. It's not about Dems versus ours. Yeah. And like if you look at the permitting bill, if the permitting bill dies, everyone in Washington believes that it will be the electric utilities that killed it. So if we don't pass permitting reform, it will all be blamed on the electric utilities. And remember, the National Energy Dominance Council is who wants the permitting bill to pass because they want the Clean Water Act amendments for the natural gas pipelines, right?
48:23I think when you think about what's happening in each one of these states, if we don't get a handle on figuring out how data centers pay for all of the incremental costs that they're creating for the grid, then those governors have failed. And every one of those governors, 36 of them on the ballot this fall, have basically said that they are going to do business differently. That is what Abbott had to say in order to get elected in Texas, is that he was more suspect of data centers now and more suspect of the utility decision-making process. If he didn't clear those two bars, then the voters of Texas would not re-elect him into office, right?
49:08And so that has been the litmus test that every single governor and every single senator has had to go through to be able to be elected this cycle. Any thoughts on how this is going to shape the 2028 election wrapping up? Like, are data centers going to be the thing? Are energy prices and data centers going to be the main driver? Are we going to see anti-data center candidate? Oh, I mean, I think we're going to see a blue weight. I mean, I think, yeah, I think we're going to see massive turnover. But it's not as if the Dems are the only ones thinking about this or trying to fix this, right? And so it's like, there's turnover because people are angry, right?
49:48And I think there's going to be, the accountability would be the same, I think, whether or not there's a turnover. I think the accountability is here to stay, which is great. I'm here for it. I think I've said it before. Like, if these, you know, irresponsible, you know, build-outs are the thing that brings the right and the left together and reinvest them in their community, then, like, bring it on. Let's do it. I think people feel like the oligarchs in the United States have taken away their power. Their agency. Right? Yeah. Like when you think about the fact that Elon took it upon himself to come on the side of Russia over Ukraine, that's a problem.
50:37That should be decided by the U.S. military and the U.S. Congress, not by Elon Musk, right? When you think about some of the stories around how we're going to build out the power grid, how we give people permission as to whether they can run their house off of their vehicle, which General Motors and Tesla now allow you to do, right? When you think about all of these things that people want access to, they want to know that their elected officials are actually in charge of whatever it is that they're supposed to be in charge of and not some trillionaire or billionaire that's like pulling the puppet strings.
51:21And so we are entering a phase where people call it socialism, people call it all sorts of things. But what it is, is that these collective decisions that we make, whether it's about the electric power grid or drinking water or figuring out some of our national security priorities, etc., they want to know that our elected officials are in charge and not a bunch of campaign contributors. Well, we're going to have to close it there. Jigar, you have an election watch party that you're hosting. Is that right? I do. In D.C. at Hook Hall. And so we're excited to see everybody. And I think, look, I think whoever you're voting for, I think everyone should vote.
52:08Just vote. And I totally agree with Carolyn, which is that, like, you know, the solutions have to come from the community. Well, I'm going to be listening to the results on my hand crank radio, eating my can of beans. surrounded by my 30 days of supplies. So I won't either. You chickens. I'll at least be protected. Caroline, good to see you. Thanks for showing up in costume. Have a great Halloween. Enjoy your party. Thank you.
52:43Open Circuit is produced by Latitude Media. It's edited by me, Sean Markwand, and Bailey. You can find all our audio episodes anywhere you listen to podcasts and transcripts are at LatitudeMedia.com. All of our industry coverage is there, so make sure to sign up to our newsletters and go to YouTube to watch our episodes. Subscribe to Latitude Media's channel for episodes of Open Circuit and Catalyst. And if you like the show, give us a rating and review anywhere you listen to us. Thanks a lot for being here. I'm Stephen Lacey. We'll catch you all next week. Thank you.
The prepping vibes online are very high right now. Spend any time on X, and you’ll get inundated with warnings about AI hacking, possible grid collapse, and stockpile checklists.
There’s a reason people are anxious. Security experts are sounding the alarm about AI agent swarms that are targeting infrastructure. Governments around the world are telling people to prepare for at least 72 hours of disruption. And the Pentagon recently unveiled a plan to operate bases for 90 days in the event of widespread blackouts.
So, how worried should we be about threats to the power grid?
This week, Jonathon Monken, a senior partner at Converge Strategies, joins the show to assess the state of grid security. Jonathon is a 24-year Army veteran, the former senior director of system resilience at PJM, and a former director of the Illinois emergency management agency. He says the risk is real and significantly elevated.
We’ll talk with him about where the grid is most exposed, why data centers are becoming an attractive target, and why the military’s 90-day blackout plan is very difficult to execute.
We’ll wrap up the show with a look at the energy storylines driving the midterm elections. Did “energy dominance” stop working as a political message? And can Democrats actually live up to their promises to drop energy prices?
Open Circuit is brought to you by EnergyHub. EnergyHub works with more than 230 utilities to coordinate over 2.6 million DERs and more than 3.6 gigawatts of dispatchable flexibility through a single platform designed to perform when it counts most. See what that looks like at EnergyHub.com.
Open Circuit is brought to you by Giving Green. Giving Green researches the climate nonprofits best positioned for the next big climate win, and sends 100% of every dollar donated to the Giving Green Fund to them. Make your first gift before 2027, and it’s matched up to $500. Go to GivingGreen.earth/Circuit or select Open Circuit at checkout.
Open Circuit is brought to you by Everyday Electric. Everyday Electric simplifies savings at home, helping support a more reliable, affordable grid. Operating the country’s largest residential VPP, it coordinates 6+ GW of capacity across connected products. Learn more at everydayelectric.com.